TRANSCRIPCIÓN 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.220 --> 00:00:05.750
All events just are. They're unchangeable. They're immutable. So the
2
00:00:05.830 --> 00:00:07.049
events can't change.
3
00:00:07.150 --> 00:00:09.130
And you simply, if you go back to the past,
4
00:00:09.210 --> 00:00:12.490
are fulfilling the precise set of events that allowed you
5
00:00:12.609 --> 00:00:14.589
to exist and to go on that journey in the
6
00:00:14.630 --> 00:00:15.009
first place.
7
00:00:19.620 --> 00:00:24.920
This is StarTalk Cosmic Queries Edition. And today we're going
8
00:00:24.940 --> 00:00:29.559
to be talking about time travel, inspired by Dickens' classic novel,
9
00:00:30.120 --> 00:00:32.590
A Christmas Carol. Chuck, love to have you on this.
10
00:00:33.270 --> 00:00:37.710
Always a pleasure to be here. Although I'm not actually here.
11
00:00:38.429 --> 00:00:40.729
I'm coming to you from the future. You should just
12
00:00:40.770 --> 00:00:42.799
know that.
13
00:00:43.140 --> 00:00:46.280
Thanks for that heads up. In case that matters.
14
00:00:46.320 --> 00:00:49.079
Let me say it this way. Neil, it's your kids.
15
00:00:49.200 --> 00:00:50.500
It's your kids.
16
00:00:53.899 --> 00:01:03.619
Thank you, Doc Brown. Realize when they, they went into
17
00:01:03.740 --> 00:01:06.140
the year 2015, just thought I'd remind you of that.
18
00:01:06.760 --> 00:01:09.400
Wow. Wow.
19
00:01:09.579 --> 00:01:09.879
Yeah.
20
00:01:09.939 --> 00:01:10.200
Yeah.
21
00:01:10.280 --> 00:01:12.640
Yeah. We'll, we'll get back to that. So I, well,
22
00:01:12.719 --> 00:01:14.620
I know a little bit about time travel. I don't
23
00:01:14.659 --> 00:01:17.519
know nearly as much as our guest, which is why
24
00:01:17.560 --> 00:01:20.230
we brought him on a good friend and colleague. From
25
00:01:20.349 --> 00:01:23.849
up the street at Columbia University, Brian Greene. Brian, dude.
26
00:01:24.409 --> 00:01:25.890
Our returning champion.
27
00:01:26.609 --> 00:01:28.219
Returning champion.
28
00:01:28.239 --> 00:01:31.819
Our returning champion, Brian Greene, ladies and gentlemen.
29
00:01:33.340 --> 00:01:37.439
He's professor of physics and math. Is that right? Both
30
00:01:37.459 --> 00:01:37.700
of those?
31
00:01:37.719 --> 00:01:38.780
Yeah, that's right. That's right.
32
00:01:39.390 --> 00:01:43.950
Dang. Wait, as a layperson, isn't that redundant?
33
00:01:44.750 --> 00:01:47.469
It does sound redundant. Yeah, but I don't touch equipment.
34
00:01:47.510 --> 00:01:49.290
That's what it emphasizes.
35
00:01:49.390 --> 00:01:51.450
Oh, yeah. It's like, get the hell out of the lab.
36
00:01:51.489 --> 00:01:55.250
You're one of those theorists. Yeah. So Brian is a
37
00:01:55.310 --> 00:02:00.840
theoretical physicist and a longtime friend. And it's just a
38
00:02:00.879 --> 00:02:04.379
delight with bestselling books. And let me get the title
39
00:02:04.459 --> 00:02:08.639
correct of his latest book, because this title leaves nothing out.
40
00:02:08.719 --> 00:02:13.020
Load full transcript
Here it is. Until the End of Time, Mind Matters.
41
00:02:13.400 --> 00:02:16.879
And our search for meaning in an evolving universe came
42
00:02:16.939 --> 00:02:20.039
out last year. Brian, that's a, that title doesn't leave
43
00:02:20.139 --> 00:02:21.419
anything untouched.
44
00:02:21.740 --> 00:02:27.189
You need, you need all the good search words so that, yeah.
45
00:02:29.069 --> 00:02:31.650
That's great. Who's the publisher of that?
46
00:02:32.210 --> 00:02:32.669
Canoff.
47
00:02:33.030 --> 00:02:36.289
Yeah. Canoff. Very nice. Very nice. And of course, many
48
00:02:36.330 --> 00:02:40.210
people know you or know of you through being co-founder
49
00:02:40.229 --> 00:02:42.659
of I think with your wife, is that correct? Of
50
00:02:42.689 --> 00:02:46.289
the World Science Festival? Yeah, Tracy Day. I met Tracy
51
00:02:46.310 --> 00:02:48.650
Day before I knew you when she was a news reporter.
52
00:02:48.990 --> 00:02:51.289
Was it for NBC? Is that right?
53
00:02:51.349 --> 00:02:52.150
ABC, yeah.
54
00:02:52.449 --> 00:02:54.530
ABC. Yeah, yeah. She did an interview with me.
55
00:02:54.550 --> 00:02:57.729
Oh, I didn't know that. She never mentioned it.
56
00:02:57.830 --> 00:03:05.509
Yeah, we go way back. So let's put some context
57
00:03:05.569 --> 00:03:09.500
on the table. So Charles Dickens, which is, you know,
58
00:03:09.539 --> 00:03:12.509
he wrote Oliver. He wrote a tale of two cities.
59
00:03:13.090 --> 00:03:15.349
He wrote a Christmas. I mean, he wrote a bunch
60
00:03:15.370 --> 00:03:18.490
of stuff. And I think he wrote a tale of
61
00:03:18.509 --> 00:03:19.689
two cities. Yeah. Yeah, of course.
62
00:03:20.310 --> 00:03:21.949
And it was the best of times.
63
00:03:22.349 --> 00:03:24.810
And the worst of times. Right now we're, we're in
64
00:03:24.830 --> 00:03:26.210
the second part of that right now.
65
00:03:26.349 --> 00:03:26.629
Yes, exactly.
66
00:03:26.659 --> 00:03:28.030
We're going to get out.
67
00:03:28.039 --> 00:03:28.120
Yeah.
68
00:03:28.139 --> 00:03:29.240
So written long time.
69
00:03:29.060 --> 00:03:39.610
Ago, 1843. And by some measures, it may be the
70
00:03:39.750 --> 00:03:45.430
first sort of modern literary example of time travel or
71
00:03:45.469 --> 00:03:49.289
the implications of time travel. And so that's well before,
72
00:03:49.349 --> 00:03:52.710
like a half a century before H.G. Wells' The Time Machine.
73
00:03:53.270 --> 00:03:57.979
So itself quite a remarkable step to take in storytelling.
74
00:03:58.439 --> 00:04:06.960
So Brian, before we had Einstein's relativity, How did anybody
75
00:04:07.039 --> 00:04:08.439
think about time travel?
76
00:04:09.060 --> 00:04:10.069
Yeah, it's a good question.
77
00:04:10.250 --> 00:04:15.069
What was it missing? Let me say that differently. What
78
00:04:15.110 --> 00:04:18.269
do we in our enlightened modern times with the benefit
79
00:04:18.310 --> 00:04:21.500
of relativity get to say about time travel that they
80
00:04:21.639 --> 00:04:28.939
couldn't say before Einstein, before the 1905 special relativity paper
81
00:04:29.040 --> 00:04:31.500
and the 1960s? General relativity.
82
00:04:31.560 --> 00:04:33.459
Yeah, well, I mean, you know, I look at us
83
00:04:33.600 --> 00:04:36.379
as the unique species on the planet that's able to
84
00:04:36.939 --> 00:04:40.879
lift ourselves up above the timeline and think about the
85
00:04:40.920 --> 00:04:43.560
past and future. So that immediately gives us at least
86
00:04:43.620 --> 00:04:47.939
the imaginative capacity to travel to the past.
87
00:04:47.740 --> 00:04:50.220
And the future. But of course, you're going beyond that.
88
00:04:50.259 --> 00:04:52.879
You want to know about real time travel.
89
00:04:52.980 --> 00:04:57.339
The way that they could back then is that time
90
00:04:57.360 --> 00:05:02.170
is much more individualistic. than anybody would have ever thought.
91
00:05:02.250 --> 00:05:05.029
The common view of time was it's universal. It's the
92
00:05:05.050 --> 00:05:07.529
same for me, for you, for anyone else, regardless of
93
00:05:07.569 --> 00:05:10.709
what we're doing, what we're experiencing, how we're moving. And
94
00:05:10.750 --> 00:05:16.100
that Einstein shattered by showing that time elapses at different rates,
95
00:05:16.180 --> 00:05:17.759
depending on all those qualities.
96
00:05:18.100 --> 00:05:18.660
How do you move?
97
00:05:18.879 --> 00:05:21.040
Gravity of experience. That's the main new feature here.
98
00:05:21.930 --> 00:05:22.269
Awesome.
99
00:05:22.350 --> 00:05:22.970
Interesting.
100
00:05:23.050 --> 00:05:26.670
That is amazing. So now that you said that, because please,
101
00:05:26.769 --> 00:05:33.589
one of you, either one of you, I'm filthy with
102
00:05:33.829 --> 00:05:39.300
physicists right now. You just, you just, it's raining physicists.
103
00:05:40.120 --> 00:05:41.060
Raining physicists.
104
00:05:41.180 --> 00:05:43.560
I have an embarrassment of physicists.
105
00:05:43.600 --> 00:05:45.139
Riches. So.
106
00:05:47.920 --> 00:05:51.870
This is just wonderful every time I think about it.
107
00:05:52.019 --> 00:05:57.459
But if something is, let's say, let's go as close
108
00:05:57.500 --> 00:06:00.759
as geosynchronous orbit, like a satellite, and it's traveling at
109
00:06:00.810 --> 00:06:06.730
this speed, and they have to adjust the clocks because...
110
00:06:06.819 --> 00:06:11.500
time is ticking differently for that thing up there than
111
00:06:11.550 --> 00:06:15.050
it is for us down here. And can you please
112
00:06:15.509 --> 00:06:19.329
just speak to that? And can you speak to is
113
00:06:19.449 --> 00:06:25.980
it a literal elapsed difference? Like running clock, running clock,
114
00:06:26.160 --> 00:06:29.519
or is it something that causes it to seem like
115
00:06:30.000 --> 00:06:31.199
an elapsed difference?
116
00:06:31.220 --> 00:06:33.319
I shouldn't jump in. Maybe Neil wants to take this,
117
00:06:33.540 --> 00:06:34.579
but it's real.
118
00:06:34.620 --> 00:06:37.810
I'll just start with 1905. and you pick us up
119
00:06:37.889 --> 00:06:41.810
at 1916, okay? So what we learn with 1905 special
120
00:06:41.850 --> 00:06:45.240
relativity is that the faster you go, all right, you
121
00:06:45.250 --> 00:06:52.000
will perceive events around you as, well, okay. If you
122
00:06:52.060 --> 00:06:56.300
watch someone go fast, you will perceive their ticking clock
123
00:06:56.779 --> 00:06:59.620
to move more slowly than yourself. And we call this
124
00:06:59.639 --> 00:07:03.480
special theory of relativity because it only involved motion that
125
00:07:03.519 --> 00:07:07.240
did not accelerate. It was very sort of... basic case
126
00:07:07.300 --> 00:07:10.339
of motion and so once you got used to that
127
00:07:10.540 --> 00:07:13.920
then then 10 years later he throws in a whole
128
00:07:14.079 --> 00:07:17.779
other fact and brian pick it up from there.
129
00:07:18.199 --> 00:07:21.160
Yeah the new fact that neil's referring to is that
130
00:07:21.319 --> 00:07:24.899
gravity also affects the passage of time so chuck an
131
00:07:24.939 --> 00:07:26.850
example that you gave if you have a clock on
132
00:07:26.910 --> 00:07:31.189
planet and a clock that's hovering above the earth some
133
00:07:31.250 --> 00:07:34.730
number of miles up there those clocks will really tick
134
00:07:34.769 --> 00:07:38.329
off time at different rates because they are experiencing different
135
00:07:38.370 --> 00:07:41.709
forces of gravity. The stronger the pull of gravity, the
136
00:07:41.769 --> 00:07:45.110
slower the clock ticks. So the clock on Earth truly
137
00:07:45.149 --> 00:07:47.800
is ticking off time at a slower rate than the
138
00:07:47.829 --> 00:07:49.500
clock that's floating up there in space.
139
00:07:50.839 --> 00:07:53.879
Well, so what's interesting there is that the geosynchronous satellites,
140
00:07:54.160 --> 00:07:56.439
because Chuck, you started this by saying they have whatever
141
00:07:56.500 --> 00:08:00.160
is their orbital speed, which has some significance, right? It's
142
00:08:00.660 --> 00:08:03.730
a few miles per second, really. and up at sort
143
00:08:03.750 --> 00:08:06.930
of middle, you know, Brian, every time I talk about,
144
00:08:07.310 --> 00:08:10.389
you know, there's Leo, low Earth orbit, and Geo, but
145
00:08:10.709 --> 00:08:13.629
middle Earth orbit, you know, Mio, every time I say
146
00:08:13.670 --> 00:08:16.300
middle Earth, people are thinking Lord of the Rings, you know?
147
00:08:17.480 --> 00:08:24.180
Oh, don't worry, Mr. Frodo. We've got this. We'll get
148
00:08:24.220 --> 00:08:26.660
that traffic satellite fixed, sir. We'll do it.
149
00:08:28.189 --> 00:08:31.689
So, Brian, have you done the math yet, since you
150
00:08:31.709 --> 00:08:35.129
are a professor of freaking mathematics, on the geosynchronous satellites?
151
00:08:35.429 --> 00:08:41.250
They're moving fast relative to us, so we should see
152
00:08:41.350 --> 00:08:46.669
their time slow down, but they're farther away from Earth's gravity,
153
00:08:47.490 --> 00:08:49.929
so we should see their time speed up. So there's
154
00:08:49.980 --> 00:08:51.299
some contest between the two.
155
00:08:51.720 --> 00:08:54.320
There is, and I don't know the exact numbers in
156
00:08:54.379 --> 00:08:58.250
that particular case, but I do know that when... They
157
00:08:58.330 --> 00:09:02.129
tested these ideas on a Pan Am jet in the 1970s,
158
00:09:02.149 --> 00:09:05.779
where they had the atomic clock that they left on
159
00:09:05.799 --> 00:09:08.960
the tarmac, and the other they strapped into the passenger seat,
160
00:09:09.000 --> 00:09:10.399
maybe his first class, I don't know.
161
00:09:10.440 --> 00:09:11.379
On this Pan Am jet.
162
00:09:12.539 --> 00:09:16.080
In that particular case, it is the speeding up of
163
00:09:16.179 --> 00:09:20.960
time from the gravitational difference that wins out.
164
00:09:22.750 --> 00:09:24.990
Whenever I teach this, I'm always careful with.
165
00:09:24.929 --> 00:09:28.139
My language because you would think that clock should tick
166
00:09:28.179 --> 00:09:31.240
off time more slowly because it's in motion. But when
167
00:09:31.279 --> 00:09:34.500
you take the competition into effect, in the end, the
168
00:09:34.879 --> 00:09:37.019
net change is not what you would have anticipated.
169
00:09:37.039 --> 00:09:38.340
But none of that really matters.
170
00:09:38.620 --> 00:09:41.139
What really matters is when you take all the effects
171
00:09:41.200 --> 00:09:45.990
into account, motion and gravity that Einstein delineated, the prediction
172
00:09:46.019 --> 00:09:48.289
agrees with the observation spot on.
173
00:09:48.990 --> 00:09:51.070
And so these effects are truly real.
174
00:09:51.799 --> 00:09:54.820
So I didn't know about that experiment. And Brian, please
175
00:09:54.899 --> 00:09:55.940
tell everyone.
176
00:09:56.039 --> 00:09:59.090
Haefel and Keating were the two scientists.
177
00:09:59.269 --> 00:10:00.860
Tell everyone what... Pan Am is.
178
00:10:01.100 --> 00:10:04.220
I'm just.
179
00:10:04.919 --> 00:10:05.259
Saying.
180
00:10:05.580 --> 00:10:07.480
That was the Southwest of its day.
181
00:10:09.879 --> 00:10:14.340
Yeah, kids. Pan Am actually was also the space shuttle
182
00:10:14.960 --> 00:10:17.679
in 2001, A Space Odyssey. It was a Pan Am
183
00:10:17.700 --> 00:10:20.480
space shuttle. Oh, really? Yeah, yeah, going up to the
184
00:10:20.500 --> 00:10:22.779
space station where there was an AT & T phone
185
00:10:23.059 --> 00:10:25.700
and a Howard Johnson's hotel.
186
00:10:26.039 --> 00:10:29.299
It's super cool. That's very cool.
187
00:10:29.360 --> 00:10:31.720
So it turns out– so I didn't know that about
188
00:10:31.740 --> 00:10:34.460
the Pan Am. That's excellent. That remains true even for
189
00:10:34.480 --> 00:10:37.769
the geosynchronous
satellites. So the fact that they're higher above
190
00:10:37.830 --> 00:10:41.769
Earth wins over the fact that they're moving fast. And
191
00:10:41.870 --> 00:10:45.330
so when the geosynchronous satellites hand us our times to
192
00:10:45.370 --> 00:10:49.620
our cell phones, they have to be pre-corrected knowing– that
193
00:10:49.799 --> 00:10:53.539
Einstein's ideas are correct, which is just fricking mind blowing.
194
00:10:54.220 --> 00:10:58.799
Einstein can say it in his armchair, right? And it
195
00:10:58.840 --> 00:11:01.669
can happen in a physics paper, but to actually measure
196
00:11:01.710 --> 00:11:02.970
the stuff is a whole other thing.
197
00:11:03.070 --> 00:11:04.409
It's totally insane. It's totally nuts.
198
00:11:04.429 --> 00:11:06.690
And just one other thing, Chuck, for your question, even
199
00:11:06.710 --> 00:11:09.190
if you take gravity out of the story, you take
200
00:11:09.289 --> 00:11:12.750
two clocks and you send one into space and it
201
00:11:12.789 --> 00:11:15.259
turns around and it comes back and you literally compare
202
00:11:15.279 --> 00:11:18.250
the clock side by side, they will show different amounts
203
00:11:18.309 --> 00:11:19.429
of elapsed time.
204
00:11:19.730 --> 00:11:20.970
So it's real.
205
00:11:21.289 --> 00:11:23.690
The clock on earth in that particular case will have
206
00:11:23.710 --> 00:11:27.350
ticked off than the clock that went on that round
207
00:11:27.649 --> 00:11:30.409
trip journey. So in a sense, the person carrying the
208
00:11:30.470 --> 00:11:33.519
clock on the round trip journey has traveled into the future.
209
00:11:33.759 --> 00:11:36.960
They're seeing the earth time than their own watch would
210
00:11:36.980 --> 00:11:37.960
suggest it should be.
211
00:11:38.480 --> 00:11:38.960
Wow.
212
00:11:40.080 --> 00:11:46.879
And one last point about Ebenezer Scrooge. He was observing
213
00:11:47.980 --> 00:11:53.120
different Christmases, but the big issue for any storyteller is
214
00:11:53.159 --> 00:11:56.320
whether you can interact either with the past or with
215
00:11:56.360 --> 00:11:59.779
the present that you then have access to. And so
216
00:11:59.830 --> 00:12:01.169
what does Einstein say about that?
217
00:12:01.870 --> 00:12:05.509
Well, he doesn't say a whole lot about travel to
218
00:12:05.529 --> 00:12:09.220
the past. because everything that he was doing, if you
219
00:12:09.259 --> 00:12:12.220
actually follow it through, you can move in such a
220
00:12:12.259 --> 00:12:14.519
way or experience a gravitational field that allows you to
221
00:12:14.559 --> 00:12:16.860
go into the future. And if you're in the future,
222
00:12:16.879 --> 00:12:19.779
he said, sure, you interact with anything that you want
223
00:12:19.799 --> 00:12:21.720
to interact with. It's just that you are at a
224
00:12:21.759 --> 00:12:25.580
later time than your own clock would suggest. But when
225
00:12:25.600 --> 00:12:28.360
it comes to the past, I haven't read anything that
226
00:12:28.419 --> 00:12:30.740
he wrote, but it's a real conundrum that, you know,
227
00:12:30.799 --> 00:12:32.960
back to the future popularized, right?
228
00:12:33.470 --> 00:12:34.129
If you go to the.
229
00:12:34.090 --> 00:12:37.100
Past, can you change things in such a way that
230
00:12:37.149 --> 00:12:39.679
might prevent your own birth? And then you're in a
231
00:12:39.700 --> 00:12:43.399
logical paradox. How could that ever happen? And people have
232
00:12:43.460 --> 00:12:47.000
struggled with that. And we can talk about the solutions
233
00:12:47.419 --> 00:12:49.210
if it's relevant to the topic here.
234
00:12:49.279 --> 00:12:51.889
But yeah, in one of those solutions, you can interact,
235
00:12:51.909 --> 00:12:52.750
but you're constrained.
236
00:12:53.350 --> 00:12:55.049
You don't have the freedom that you would have thought
237
00:12:55.190 --> 00:12:57.210
you would have had to mess things up.
238
00:12:57.669 --> 00:13:02.549
Now, wait, is that constriction Forced upon you, like, for instance,
239
00:13:02.750 --> 00:13:06.230
if I were trying to get rid of my own self.
240
00:13:06.809 --> 00:13:11.779
So I'm going to commit suicide via time travel.
241
00:13:12.299 --> 00:13:13.570
Right? Oh, okay.
242
00:13:13.610 --> 00:13:17.090
Do aside via time travel. So those constrictions, since I'm
243
00:13:17.190 --> 00:13:20.870
coming from a place that is already set, okay? I
244
00:13:20.889 --> 00:13:24.330
go back at my origin, before my origin, I'm sorry.
245
00:13:24.870 --> 00:13:28.470
And then I, let's just say, you know, I caused
246
00:13:28.509 --> 00:13:30.889
my parents to hate each other. I'm doing the reverse
247
00:13:31.090 --> 00:13:34.960
of the movie, right? and they end up hating each other.
248
00:13:34.980 --> 00:13:39.100
Because you can do this without bloodshed, right? Yeah, without bloodshed.
249
00:13:39.240 --> 00:13:41.279
Put your parents in an argument at a time they
250
00:13:41.320 --> 00:13:43.759
might have made love. And then you're not conceived in
251
00:13:43.779 --> 00:13:44.840
that moment. Exactly.
252
00:13:45.379 --> 00:13:48.539
Or I just do something really nasty, but not, you know,
253
00:13:48.580 --> 00:13:51.179
like hit on my mom. And she's just like, you
254
00:13:51.240 --> 00:13:53.879
are adorable. And I'm like, yeah, don't ever talk to
255
00:13:53.919 --> 00:13:59.370
that guy. And before this.
256
00:13:59.250 --> 00:14:05.679
Gets too far out of hand, I wasn't going to
257
00:14:05.700 --> 00:14:06.220
be further.
258
00:14:07.299 --> 00:14:09.639
Slow down, Chuck. Slow down. Slow down.
259
00:14:09.740 --> 00:14:13.919
Let me just ask this. So are, would then kind
260
00:14:13.980 --> 00:14:19.320
of like the box of time force those events to
261
00:14:19.419 --> 00:14:24.259
happen anyway in a different circumstance, even though I just
262
00:14:24.320 --> 00:14:27.779
screwed up the circumstance under which I came into being?
263
00:14:28.259 --> 00:14:29.610
No, I wouldn't frame it that way.
264
00:14:29.620 --> 00:14:30.350
Okay.
265
00:14:30.950 --> 00:14:33.529
The answer that I would give on that is that
266
00:14:33.750 --> 00:14:36.809
if you travel back to an earlier moment in time
267
00:14:36.850 --> 00:14:42.860
before your own birth, then you were always at that moment.
268
00:14:43.580 --> 00:14:46.000
There are two versions of a given moment in time.
269
00:14:47.200 --> 00:14:50.940
A moment in time can't change because what would be
270
00:14:51.340 --> 00:14:53.940
the parameter through which that change would occur? It'd have
271
00:14:53.980 --> 00:14:56.899
to be time, but we're talking about individual moments. So
272
00:14:56.919 --> 00:14:59.320
if you go to the past, you were always part
273
00:14:59.340 --> 00:15:02.480
of that moment and therefore you were always part of
274
00:15:02.529 --> 00:15:05.740
the causal chain of events that resulted in your own birth.
275
00:15:06.460 --> 00:15:09.440
So you are- Okay, so wait, wait.
276
00:15:09.460 --> 00:15:12.480
So Brian, wait, wait. Damn. Brian, in the time machine,
277
00:15:13.799 --> 00:15:18.970
the character has a love interest and then she crosses
278
00:15:18.990 --> 00:15:22.139
the street and is hit by a, you know, by
279
00:15:22.179 --> 00:15:23.940
a horse and buggy back then, I guess that was
280
00:15:23.980 --> 00:15:26.120
a deadly thing. And then she says, no, wait, I
281
00:15:26.139 --> 00:15:28.659
can fix that. He goes back in time and like
282
00:15:28.700 --> 00:15:31.059
prevents her from crossing the street, leaves her. Then she
283
00:15:31.100 --> 00:15:34.320
gets mugged and dies from a mugging. And then she, he,
284
00:15:34.659 --> 00:15:37.139
he prevents the mugging in a third time. And then
285
00:15:37.159 --> 00:15:39.279
she dies some other way. And he figures out that
286
00:15:39.340 --> 00:15:42.659
her death was something inherent in the timeline. And there's
287
00:15:42.710 --> 00:15:43.769
nothing he can do to change it.
288
00:15:44.000 --> 00:15:46.679
Brian, what you're saying is what's inherent in that timeline
289
00:15:46.950 --> 00:15:50.470
is you. You're not an X factor. You are part
290
00:15:50.509 --> 00:15:52.330
of that equation all the time.
291
00:15:52.870 --> 00:15:57.809
That's correct. All events just are. They're unchangeable. They're immutable.
292
00:15:58.389 --> 00:16:00.330
So the events can't change.
293
00:16:00.429 --> 00:16:02.409
And you simply, if you go back to the past,
294
00:16:02.490 --> 00:16:06.070
are fulfilling the precise set of events that allowed you
295
00:16:06.190 --> 00:16:08.169
to exist and to go on that journey in the
296
00:16:08.210 --> 00:16:10.190
first place. Now, look, I'm not saying this is the
297
00:16:10.370 --> 00:16:13.700
only resolution to these ideas. Because Neil, the example that
298
00:16:13.740 --> 00:16:19.299
you gave brings to mind another proposal, which is this
299
00:16:19.360 --> 00:16:21.720
idea of a multiverse.
300
00:16:22.730 --> 00:16:25.570
Let's pause there. We're going to take a quick break
301
00:16:25.590 --> 00:16:27.169
and we're going to come back and we're going to
302
00:16:27.190 --> 00:16:32.070
find out what kinds of time travel are theoretically allowed.
303
00:16:32.929 --> 00:16:35.230
And I like the one where Chuck going back in
304
00:16:35.269 --> 00:16:39.299
time preordained the fact that he would be born even
305
00:16:39.360 --> 00:16:44.639
if his intentions were otherwise nefarious or even suicidal. We'll
306
00:16:44.679 --> 00:16:48.919
be right back. Cosmic Queries Time Travel Edition with Brian Green.
307
00:16:50.940 --> 00:16:56.019
We're back. Cosmic Queries Time Travel Edition, inspired by Charles Dickens,
308
00:16:57.259 --> 00:17:01.139
the ghost of Christmas past, present, and future. Brian Green,
309
00:17:01.860 --> 00:17:03.740
we got the best person in the world to have
310
00:17:03.779 --> 00:17:06.839
this conversation with, Chuck, and you know it. Yes, absolutely.
311
00:17:07.299 --> 00:17:13.500
So Brian, in the case where Chuck's going back in
312
00:17:13.579 --> 00:17:16.779
time was part of the equation that led to his
313
00:17:16.819 --> 00:17:18.900
birth in the first place, even if he only just
314
00:17:18.940 --> 00:17:22.019
realized that. Let me give an example that I've given before,
315
00:17:22.059 --> 00:17:24.930
but it seems to be consistent with that, okay? So
316
00:17:25.170 --> 00:17:28.829
I see, so let's say we can use tachyons, which
317
00:17:28.890 --> 00:17:32.630
travel backwards in time, and I can send texts via tachyons.
318
00:17:33.069 --> 00:17:35.380
And I watch you walk down the corridor and you
319
00:17:35.430 --> 00:17:38.119
slip on a banana peel. And I say to myself,
320
00:17:38.720 --> 00:17:41.500
Brian's my friend, I don't want him to bust his ass,
321
00:17:41.859 --> 00:17:43.799
slipping on a banana peel, I'm going to text him.
322
00:17:44.200 --> 00:17:47.420
So I text you via tachyons, you get the message
323
00:17:47.950 --> 00:17:51.549
before you slipped on the banana peel, and you look
324
00:17:51.609 --> 00:17:54.869
down to the message, and by looking down, you don't
325
00:17:55.049 --> 00:17:57.490
see the banana peel, and you slip on the banana peel.
326
00:17:58.150 --> 00:18:00.589
So I ended up causing you to slip on the
327
00:18:00.630 --> 00:18:03.549
banana peel. Is that the same case that you just
328
00:18:03.589 --> 00:18:04.890
described with Chuck?
329
00:18:05.309 --> 00:18:09.220
Yeah, it's a self-consistent, immutable set of events.
330
00:18:10.059 --> 00:18:15.069
And And the text, inexplicably from your perception, is what
331
00:18:15.170 --> 00:18:18.890
actually causes the event that you wanted it to prevent.
332
00:18:19.019 --> 00:18:21.980
But it's part of that causal fabric.
333
00:18:22.460 --> 00:18:25.799
And that, in this approach, is the immutable quality of
334
00:18:25.839 --> 00:18:26.480
the timeline.
335
00:18:27.240 --> 00:18:28.140
Wow. Cool.
336
00:18:28.400 --> 00:18:30.839
Very cool. So it's reverse destiny.
337
00:18:33.980 --> 00:18:37.029
Well, it's timeless destiny.
338
00:18:37.410 --> 00:18:41.049
So all the events of reality just exist out there.
339
00:18:41.529 --> 00:18:44.670
And it perhaps is human perception that orders them into
340
00:18:44.710 --> 00:18:48.170
this causal set, but they're just all out there, just
341
00:18:48.210 --> 00:18:50.119
like all the spaces out there. And this way of
342
00:18:50.180 --> 00:18:53.140
thinking about things all of time may be out there too.
343
00:18:53.759 --> 00:18:56.079
And so there's nothing that can ever be changed.
344
00:18:56.920 --> 00:19:04.049
So in Kurt Vonnegut's Slaughterhouse-Five, that time travel scenario is
345
00:19:04.089 --> 00:19:07.819
what you're describing, right? And because in it, His entire time,
346
00:19:07.920 --> 00:19:11.569
he's picked up by aliens and he lives in a cage,
347
00:19:12.130 --> 00:19:14.470
all right, an alien zoo. But it doesn't matter to
348
00:19:14.529 --> 00:19:17.509
him because he still has access to his entire life's timeline.
349
00:19:17.789 --> 00:19:20.190
And when he's describing this, well, they describe it to him.
350
00:19:20.410 --> 00:19:22.710
So when will I die? You're always dying. When was
351
00:19:22.769 --> 00:19:24.900
I born? You're always being born. When did I go
352
00:19:24.940 --> 00:19:27.359
to college? You're always going to college. And so the
353
00:19:27.420 --> 00:19:30.359
preexisting timeline, he could just rejoin it at any point.
354
00:19:30.759 --> 00:19:33.779
But the destiny is already preordained.
355
00:19:34.430 --> 00:19:34.650
Yeah.
356
00:19:34.730 --> 00:19:37.619
And there's something comforting. There's something comforting about that, right?
357
00:19:37.730 --> 00:19:41.559
Because even those of us who've lost parents or loved ones,
358
00:19:41.619 --> 00:19:44.200
in some sense, they still exist at the moment of
359
00:19:44.299 --> 00:19:46.029
time that they occupied.
360
00:19:46.269 --> 00:19:48.710
And that is an eternal, unchanging statement.
361
00:19:49.029 --> 00:19:50.809
But Brian, it takes away. free will.
362
00:19:53.130 --> 00:19:56.950
So yes, this is a version of negating free will,
363
00:19:57.230 --> 00:19:59.430
but I am one of those people who doesn't believe
364
00:19:59.470 --> 00:20:03.259
in any variety of free will of the traditional sort.
365
00:20:03.630 --> 00:20:06.440
So this doesn't run afoul of my intuition at all.
366
00:20:06.660 --> 00:20:08.400
Okay, Brian, now, okay.
367
00:20:08.740 --> 00:20:10.539
See, I know we got queries. Wait, wait, Chuck, we
368
00:20:10.579 --> 00:20:13.839
got to get to questions. This is a cosmic queries. Go, go.
369
00:20:14.099 --> 00:20:18.380
Brian, stop tempting us. Brian, stop tempting us. Shut up, Brian.
370
00:20:18.460 --> 00:20:20.569
Let's act like we don't have an audience.
371
00:20:24.150 --> 00:20:29.710
Brian, stop being so damn interesting. And let us get
372
00:20:29.750 --> 00:20:32.279
to our Cosmic Queries. Oh, man. Okay.
373
00:20:32.480 --> 00:20:34.940
All right. Let me get to the queries. I'll put
374
00:20:35.000 --> 00:20:38.490
my stuff on the back burner. Here we go. Hey,
375
00:20:38.549 --> 00:20:40.910
this is Jay Salmon who says, or Salmon. I mean,
376
00:20:40.950 --> 00:20:45.490
it's Salmon, but Salmon, maybe. He says, hello, Dr. Green,
377
00:20:45.589 --> 00:20:50.150
because a photon of light has no mass, theoretically, can't
378
00:20:50.309 --> 00:20:54.019
it travel both forward and backward in time?
379
00:20:54.819 --> 00:20:59.160
Well, I love that. Speaking of gravity. No, wait a minute.
380
00:20:59.180 --> 00:21:01.740
So it moves the speed of light. And if time
381
00:21:01.779 --> 00:21:04.839
goes slower for you, the faster you go, then photons
382
00:21:04.880 --> 00:21:05.980
have no time at all.
383
00:21:06.059 --> 00:21:06.200
Yeah.
384
00:21:06.559 --> 00:21:07.910
I think that's good. So if they have no time,
385
00:21:08.019 --> 00:21:09.980
why don't, who cares whether they move forwards or backwards?
386
00:21:10.000 --> 00:21:10.680
It doesn't make a difference.
387
00:21:10.940 --> 00:21:11.160
Right.
388
00:21:11.259 --> 00:21:12.640
There is no forward and backwards.
389
00:21:13.140 --> 00:21:16.839
There's two ways of answering this question. I think both
390
00:21:16.940 --> 00:21:17.839
are really important.
391
00:21:18.079 --> 00:21:22.180
One is from our perception watching the photon. And from
392
00:21:22.339 --> 00:21:24.980
our perception, you fire a photon and it travels through
393
00:21:25.019 --> 00:21:29.460
space as time elapses. It goes forward in time. But
394
00:21:29.500 --> 00:21:32.839
then you say, what about from the photon's perspective? It's
395
00:21:32.900 --> 00:21:35.160
traveling at the speed of light. And from what Neil
396
00:21:35.180 --> 00:21:38.809
described earlier, when the photon looks out at the world,
397
00:21:39.289 --> 00:21:41.710
everything should be going infinitely slowly.
398
00:21:42.650 --> 00:21:47.470
And therefore, in some sense, time is stopping. Now, that's
399
00:21:47.579 --> 00:21:48.700
poetically fine.
400
00:21:49.099 --> 00:21:51.980
The problem I have with taking that too seriously is,
401
00:21:52.559 --> 00:21:55.160
and this may seem like a footnote, but it's not,
402
00:21:55.859 --> 00:21:59.680
you're ascribing some kind of experience to a photon. And
403
00:21:59.700 --> 00:22:02.420
a photon doesn't have experience. It doesn't have consciousness. It
404
00:22:02.480 --> 00:22:04.960
doesn't look out at the world, even though the poetic
405
00:22:05.029 --> 00:22:09.630
language is useful to invoke. And so to imagine that
406
00:22:09.750 --> 00:22:12.309
we could travel at the speed of light and therefore
407
00:22:12.369 --> 00:22:14.529
there'd be no time and time
would stop is a
408
00:22:14.569 --> 00:22:17.670
step too far. So when we look at the photon,
409
00:22:17.819 --> 00:22:20.019
it's like any other particle. It travels through space. It
410
00:22:20.039 --> 00:22:22.660
goes forward in time. If you put yourself into the
411
00:22:22.720 --> 00:22:26.160
shoes of the photon, whatever that means, Then poetically, yes,
412
00:22:26.240 --> 00:22:29.259
time would stop. There's no notion of the elapsing of time.
413
00:22:29.480 --> 00:22:33.920
There's no notion of aging from the photon's perspective, whatever
414
00:22:33.960 --> 00:22:34.900
that actually means.
415
00:22:36.119 --> 00:22:40.619
But, okay, so Chuck, you heard that. Brian cast shade
416
00:22:40.680 --> 00:22:45.009
on the photon. He said it has no emotions, no feelings. Basically.
417
00:22:45.029 --> 00:22:51.470
Brian thinks photons are stupid. Okay.
418
00:22:52.130 --> 00:22:52.809
That's Brian.
419
00:22:52.990 --> 00:22:53.430
All right.
420
00:22:53.630 --> 00:22:57.150
All right, Brian. We know where you're coming from. All right.
421
00:22:57.789 --> 00:22:59.049
Keep going, Chuck. Here we go.
422
00:22:59.069 --> 00:23:04.440
This is, I like this. Let's a little more philosophical.
423
00:23:04.539 --> 00:23:08.720
This is Tyler J. Tyler says, how might time travel
424
00:23:08.839 --> 00:23:17.910
be policed? or regulated if it were able to happen. Yeah,
425
00:23:17.930 --> 00:23:19.569
because I mean, think about it. If we could all-
426
00:23:19.630 --> 00:23:22.130
If you have bad actors going through, right. Yeah.
427
00:23:22.369 --> 00:23:26.359
Well, again, I'm less fearful of time travel because of
428
00:23:26.380 --> 00:23:29.259
the view that I hold that you couldn't actually change anything.
429
00:23:29.279 --> 00:23:31.220
If you could, then yeah, we'd have to have the
430
00:23:31.259 --> 00:23:34.720
time police around here to avoid things happening that we
431
00:23:34.740 --> 00:23:35.799
didn't want to have happen.
432
00:23:36.440 --> 00:23:39.430
Is that the same thing as Hawking's time travel conjecture?
433
00:23:41.069 --> 00:23:48.190
Um, well, uh, he's got a few conjectures, so exactly
434
00:23:48.230 --> 00:23:50.700
which one, but, but I think Hawking.
435
00:23:50.440 --> 00:23:52.480
Has said chronology.
436
00:23:52.019 --> 00:23:55.440
Protection, chronology protection, that you can't travel to the past
437
00:23:55.619 --> 00:23:59.140
because it keeps history safe for historians, right? Because, you know,
438
00:23:59.180 --> 00:24:01.839
if you could travel, you could change things. And it's
439
00:24:01.900 --> 00:24:04.740
also his explanation for why we're not overwhelmed with tourists
440
00:24:04.769 --> 00:24:06.890
from the future. If you could travel to the past,
441
00:24:07.170 --> 00:24:09.690
wouldn't everybody from the future come and visit us and
442
00:24:09.730 --> 00:24:12.450
be gawking at what life was like in the 21st century?
443
00:24:13.589 --> 00:24:17.019
But again, they could be here looking at us right now.
444
00:24:17.720 --> 00:24:21.519
Or another explanation, which is more plausible, is in almost
445
00:24:21.779 --> 00:24:25.599
any time travel scenario that has been dreamt up, you
446
00:24:25.640 --> 00:24:29.490
can never travel to a moment in time prior to
447
00:24:29.509 --> 00:24:31.849
the construction of the first time machine.
448
00:24:33.109 --> 00:24:34.569
And so if the.
449
00:24:34.509 --> 00:24:37.430
First-time machine is yet to be constructed, that would also
450
00:24:37.470 --> 00:24:40.039
explain why no one's come back here, because they can't
451
00:24:40.099 --> 00:24:42.119
come back here because the machine's yet to be built.
452
00:24:43.119 --> 00:24:46.140
So that's another very straightforward way of explaining why we're
453
00:24:46.180 --> 00:24:47.920
not overrun with tourists from the future.
454
00:24:48.180 --> 00:24:49.099
I like that one.
455
00:24:49.160 --> 00:24:49.980
Wow.
456
00:24:50.000 --> 00:24:51.759
All right, Chuck, keep going. What do you have?
457
00:24:52.160 --> 00:24:54.740
All right. Let's have some fun with this one. This
458
00:24:54.799 --> 00:24:58.420
is Kevin DeSommelier, who's... Oh, we love Kevin the Sommelier. Yeah,
459
00:24:58.440 --> 00:25:00.299
we love Kevin the Sommelier. Never sends us wine.
460
00:25:00.319 --> 00:25:03.059
He needs to give wine recommendations. Never gives wine instructions.
461
00:25:03.079 --> 00:25:04.279
Never sends us a bottle.
462
00:25:04.720 --> 00:25:05.099
Well, no.
463
00:25:05.220 --> 00:25:10.369
Never sends Chuck wine. Neil doesn't need any wine. I've
464
00:25:10.400 --> 00:25:12.609
been to Neil's cellar. He don't need no wine. Chuck
465
00:25:12.650 --> 00:25:13.250
needs wine.
466
00:25:13.730 --> 00:25:17.109
Okay. All right.
467
00:25:17.369 --> 00:25:17.609
All right.
468
00:25:17.970 --> 00:25:23.650
Kevin the Sommelier says, Dr. Green, what Hollywood film depicts
469
00:25:23.799 --> 00:25:29.390
time travel best in your estimation? And then he says,
470
00:25:30.099 --> 00:25:33.980
is it frequency? I don't know why he says that, but.
471
00:25:34.559 --> 00:25:36.400
Well, yeah, I had a brief moment in frequency.
472
00:25:36.779 --> 00:25:39.960
I tried to convince the filmmakers on how the end
473
00:25:40.299 --> 00:25:40.990
should be done, but.
474
00:25:42.410 --> 00:25:43.150
It could have been more.
475
00:25:43.170 --> 00:25:44.839
Frequency is a film. I had never seen it or
476
00:25:44.859 --> 00:25:45.680
heard of it.
477
00:25:46.619 --> 00:25:49.000
There's a time travel element where a father and a
478
00:25:49.140 --> 00:25:55.019
son are able to communicate across 30 years. He's a firefighter.
479
00:25:55.059 --> 00:25:55.839
He died in a fire.
480
00:25:55.900 --> 00:25:59.420
So the son tries to tell the father, go left,
481
00:25:59.460 --> 00:26:02.569
not right in that burning building when it happens tomorrow.
482
00:26:02.589 --> 00:26:06.240
And he
actually actually saves him. So they do change
483
00:26:06.299 --> 00:26:09.430
the future in that particular case. So yeah, there's a
484
00:26:09.450 --> 00:26:11.059
multiverse way of thinking about it.
485
00:26:11.410 --> 00:26:13.069
But back to the- But they called you for advice
486
00:26:13.150 --> 00:26:13.430
on that?
487
00:26:14.009 --> 00:26:15.369
They called me for advice and then they asked me
488
00:26:15.430 --> 00:26:17.690
if I would be in it. And I'm like, interview
489
00:26:17.970 --> 00:26:22.059
Dick Cavett. Dick Cavett in two different timeframes. And they
490
00:26:22.220 --> 00:26:25.200
aged me to make me look old and one. And
491
00:26:25.220 --> 00:26:27.839
it was the scariest thing, really. I thought it would
492
00:26:27.859 --> 00:26:29.200
be so simple, but I don't know if you've ever
493
00:26:29.240 --> 00:26:31.059
done this. And they put the plaster on your face
494
00:26:31.160 --> 00:26:33.720
to mold so that they can get jowls and things
495
00:26:33.880 --> 00:26:34.200
on you.
496
00:26:35.200 --> 00:26:36.400
Feels like being buried alive.
497
00:26:36.720 --> 00:26:39.440
But- Excuse me, Brian. Black don't crack, so that wouldn't
498
00:26:39.599 --> 00:26:40.180
be necessary.
499
00:26:40.329 --> 00:26:42.950
That's true. I'm 87. I'm 87 years old, Brian.
500
00:26:46.799 --> 00:26:48.960
Wait, wait, so Brian, were you in the movie? Brian,
501
00:26:49.029 --> 00:26:49.720
were you in the movie?
502
00:26:49.890 --> 00:26:51.029
I missed it. Okay, I gotta go.
503
00:26:51.109 --> 00:26:54.190
I'm in a television set being interviewed in the past
504
00:26:54.309 --> 00:26:56.430
and another television set in the future to like set
505
00:26:56.589 --> 00:26:57.650
up this time warpy thing.
506
00:26:58.250 --> 00:26:59.470
Oh, cool.
507
00:26:59.630 --> 00:27:02.900
Damn. Chuck, that's not his first movie. He was in
508
00:27:02.920 --> 00:27:04.559
the Mimsy movie. What's the name of that movie?
509
00:27:05.119 --> 00:27:07.200
The Last Mimsy, yeah.
510
00:27:07.240 --> 00:27:09.420
He was in The Last Mimsy. Yeah, yeah. My boy
511
00:27:09.440 --> 00:27:13.119
was in The Last Mimsy. Interviewed as Brian Greene. We
512
00:27:13.339 --> 00:27:18.039
need expertise on this one. You were great in it. Like,
513
00:27:18.140 --> 00:27:19.390
total natural. I loved it.
514
00:27:19.640 --> 00:27:21.960
Well, thank you. I appreciate that.
515
00:27:22.039 --> 00:27:24.140
Okay, so what's the best movie? What's the best movie?
516
00:27:24.160 --> 00:27:29.029
I would say that Interstellar is probably the best one
517
00:27:29.140 --> 00:27:32.769
where you have a massive economy going near a black hole.
518
00:27:33.230 --> 00:27:35.980
Time slows down. When it goes back to the ship,
519
00:27:36.299 --> 00:27:39.210
the fellow left on the ship is 23 years older,
520
00:27:39.250 --> 00:27:42.009
even though McConaughey is only like an hour older. And
521
00:27:42.029 --> 00:27:45.269
then Matthew McConaughey, I can't remember his name, his character.
522
00:27:44.970 --> 00:27:45.230
In the movie.
523
00:27:45.250 --> 00:27:48.509
Just to be clear, 23 years older, not 23 years older.
524
00:27:48.529 --> 00:27:49.519
So the guy's gray.
525
00:27:49.779 --> 00:27:50.859
Yeah, right.
526
00:27:51.200 --> 00:27:54.119
Yeah, it's sort of a very crazy scene, but it's accurate.
527
00:27:54.259 --> 00:27:56.359
You know, you go down near a black hole and
528
00:27:56.380 --> 00:27:59.180
you come back and your crew members have aged decades
529
00:27:59.480 --> 00:28:02.960
and you've aged an hour. But then in a very
530
00:28:03.069 --> 00:28:07.200
poignant moment, the character sees his own daughter much older
531
00:28:07.240 --> 00:28:07.829
than he is.
532
00:28:08.190 --> 00:28:08.490
Right.
533
00:28:08.970 --> 00:28:11.170
And she's in her bed, as you may recall, and
534
00:28:11.190 --> 00:28:12.569
he kind of comes into that room.
535
00:28:12.630 --> 00:28:18.069
So those are accurate features of Einstein's general theory of relativity.
536
00:28:18.150 --> 00:28:20.450
And it's not just because you're buds with Kip Thorne,
537
00:28:20.470 --> 00:28:23.380
who was co-executive producer on that movie, who was a
538
00:28:23.400 --> 00:28:26.259
professor of physics at Caltech. It's not just because you're
539
00:28:26.279 --> 00:28:26.740
friends with him.
540
00:28:26.960 --> 00:28:30.079
That's Not because I'm friends, but no doubt it was
541
00:28:30.119 --> 00:28:33.579
his expertise that kept the film on track, on scientific track,
542
00:28:33.619 --> 00:28:34.819
which is kind of a beautiful thing.
543
00:28:34.859 --> 00:28:38.210
It's a great movie. Chuck, did you see Interstellar? Oh God, yes.
544
00:28:38.269 --> 00:28:41.089
I love it. It's one of my favorite sci-fi movies.
545
00:28:41.230 --> 00:28:43.769
Did you see the name of the robot?
546
00:28:44.630 --> 00:28:44.710
Um.
547
00:28:45.789 --> 00:28:48.029
It's the big square robot. I forget his name, though.
548
00:28:48.089 --> 00:28:49.390
Yeah, the big rectangular robot.
549
00:28:49.490 --> 00:28:52.119
Which, by the way, was the best, I think, depiction
550
00:28:52.140 --> 00:28:55.400
of a robot in a movie. It's just a block.
551
00:28:55.460 --> 00:28:58.900
It's just a block? Everybody's like, I am a robot. No,
552
00:28:59.019 --> 00:29:03.349
it's just a block. You're like, here's a square that
553
00:29:03.369 --> 00:29:05.369
has appendages when it wants.
554
00:29:05.650 --> 00:29:07.829
I forget his name, though. Do you remember the name
555
00:29:07.849 --> 00:29:08.329
of the robot?
556
00:29:09.470 --> 00:29:09.630
No.
557
00:29:09.809 --> 00:29:10.250
I do not.
558
00:29:11.150 --> 00:29:12.390
Brian, do you remember the name of the robot?
559
00:29:13.019 --> 00:29:15.519
I'm embarrassed to say I can't even remember the robot,
560
00:29:15.579 --> 00:29:16.299
so I'm out of it.
561
00:29:16.319 --> 00:29:20.660
Okay. Okay. The robot's name was
Kip.
562
00:29:21.109 --> 00:29:21.410
Kip.
563
00:29:22.170 --> 00:29:22.309
Oh.
564
00:29:22.450 --> 00:29:22.690
Yes.
565
00:29:22.710 --> 00:29:23.230
There you go.
566
00:29:23.269 --> 00:29:25.150
Just thought I'd tell you. Kip Thorne.
567
00:29:25.170 --> 00:29:25.430
Very nice.
568
00:29:25.450 --> 00:29:28.509
By the way, Kip Thorne, of course, helped pioneer LIGO,
569
00:29:28.890 --> 00:29:34.450
Laser Interferometry Gravitational Wave Observatory, but received the Nobel Prize,
570
00:29:35.769 --> 00:29:38.430
was the co-recipient of it a few years ago, and
571
00:29:38.470 --> 00:29:40.960
he did the movie, so we got some good people
572
00:29:41.019 --> 00:29:44.700
out there nice trying to raise science literacy of the
573
00:29:44.759 --> 00:29:47.579
world a few notches yeah so all right there it
574
00:29:47.599 --> 00:29:50.079
goes so good calculations there on the time so that's
575
00:29:50.119 --> 00:29:55.579
just that's just straightforward gravitational einsteinian physics yeah.
576
00:29:55.700 --> 00:30:01.390
That's all that is yeah Okay, so with respect, very quickly,
577
00:30:03.410 --> 00:30:06.990
is actually, okay, do we have any.
578
00:30:07.069 --> 00:30:09.039
Are you a Patreon member? It sounds like you're asking
579
00:30:09.059 --> 00:30:09.680
your own question.
580
00:30:09.759 --> 00:30:18.890
I paid this month. You a liar. That's how to,
581
00:30:19.170 --> 00:30:21.910
that's what liars sound like. That is exactly what liars
582
00:30:21.950 --> 00:30:24.529
sound like. And that is why I'm a terrible liar.
583
00:30:24.670 --> 00:30:26.509
Cause that's exactly what I sound like.
584
00:30:26.849 --> 00:30:27.970
I paid, I paid.
585
00:30:28.069 --> 00:30:34.589
All right. So wait real, very quickly. Do we have
586
00:30:34.710 --> 00:30:40.130
any information on the aging of cells that, at the
587
00:30:40.250 --> 00:30:45.730
speed of light or in gravitational situations that we might
588
00:30:45.769 --> 00:30:47.230
be able to attribute to time travel?
589
00:30:47.849 --> 00:30:50.180
Yeah, well, everything that we're talking about in terms of
590
00:30:50.200 --> 00:30:53.819
the time slowing down or speeding up, it's truly time.
591
00:30:54.279 --> 00:30:58.059
So any physical process, whether it's the motion of atoms
592
00:30:58.140 --> 00:31:01.019
or the motion of particles in a cell or motion
593
00:31:01.079 --> 00:31:03.740
of aspects of proteins.
594
00:31:03.349 --> 00:31:05.630
Carrying out instructions given to them by DNA.
595
00:31:05.650 --> 00:31:09.470
It all is happens at a rate dictated by how
596
00:31:09.509 --> 00:31:13.910
time elapses. So when we talk about time slowing, it's
597
00:31:13.990 --> 00:31:14.730
everything slowing.
598
00:31:15.529 --> 00:31:17.809
Amazing. Brian, just to be clear, because there's a point
599
00:31:17.829 --> 00:31:21.250
of ambiguity here, unless we say it explicitly, it's not
600
00:31:21.309 --> 00:31:25.950
that being in stronger gravity has some effect on your
601
00:31:26.039 --> 00:31:31.299
physiology that makes you age more slowly. It's an actual
602
00:31:31.380 --> 00:31:35.359
change in the ticking clock that's on your wall. It's
603
00:31:35.539 --> 00:31:39.329
everything around you And has nothing to do with the
604
00:31:40.089 --> 00:31:44.019
effect of gravity, the strength of the gravity on your
605
00:31:44.119 --> 00:31:48.440
metabolism or anything. It has to do with the space-time,
606
00:31:49.519 --> 00:31:51.740
the fabric of the space-time that you're embedded in. Is
607
00:31:51.759 --> 00:31:52.920
that a fair way to say it?
608
00:31:52.940 --> 00:31:53.460
Totally fair.
609
00:31:53.519 --> 00:31:56.660
And so much so that even your thoughts would slow
610
00:31:56.700 --> 00:31:59.869
down in a traditional field. And that's why you wouldn't
611
00:31:59.940 --> 00:32:03.789
even notice in your local environment that anything had changed.
612
00:32:04.269 --> 00:32:07.869
Everything slows down, even your thoughts, so there's no obvious
613
00:32:08.069 --> 00:32:11.230
evidence of it. It's only when you compare time elapsing
614
00:32:11.269 --> 00:32:14.349
for you with time elapsing for somebody far away in
615
00:32:14.369 --> 00:32:18.059
a different circumstance that you recognize things have elapsed.
616
00:32:18.079 --> 00:32:20.480
Now, of course, strong gravity might still kill your ass,
617
00:32:20.900 --> 00:32:23.380
but that has nothing to do with the time that's taken.
618
00:32:23.700 --> 00:32:27.440
That's right. Amazing. Amazing. Amazing. All right, Chuck, keep going.
619
00:32:27.539 --> 00:32:34.019
Okay, here we go. This is Logan Kent, and Logan says... Hello,
620
00:32:34.160 --> 00:32:39.680
beloved science professors and happy holidays from Kansas cities. Uh,
621
00:32:40.019 --> 00:32:42.180
I'm already giddy waiting for the episode where we get
622
00:32:42.200 --> 00:32:44.720
to hear about the knowledge and theories on the topic
623
00:32:45.119 --> 00:32:47.230
of time travel. Okay. Well, we're in it.
624
00:32:47.609 --> 00:32:52.569
And he's hailing from both Kansas cities, Casey Moe and Casey, uh, Kansas,
625
00:32:52.769 --> 00:32:53.049
I guess.
626
00:32:53.250 --> 00:32:53.630
Okay.
627
00:32:53.670 --> 00:32:54.509
That's the plural there.
628
00:32:54.670 --> 00:32:54.890
Yeah.
629
00:32:54.910 --> 00:32:55.069
Right.
630
00:32:55.170 --> 00:32:59.680
Very good. He says, uh, If controlled backwards time travel
631
00:32:59.700 --> 00:33:02.920
was possible today, where do you think your matter or
632
00:33:03.089 --> 00:33:07.009
information would travel? And no, I'm not talking about what
633
00:33:07.089 --> 00:33:09.589
time do you want to travel, though the answers are,
634
00:33:10.670 --> 00:33:14.160
but rather if you were in a third person position
635
00:33:14.279 --> 00:33:17.980
observing someone travel back in time, what do you think
636
00:33:18.240 --> 00:33:22.970
it would look like? So the
time travel itself, if
637
00:33:23.089 --> 00:33:26.529
you were the observer, what would you see if you
638
00:33:26.569 --> 00:33:29.569
were able to observe the timeline itself?
639
00:33:30.630 --> 00:33:33.740
So I like that. But also just slipped in there, Brian,
640
00:33:33.779 --> 00:33:36.220
was some mention about information.
641
00:33:36.579 --> 00:33:37.200
Yes.
642
00:33:37.519 --> 00:33:40.200
And that links to entropy, I presume. So if you
643
00:33:40.220 --> 00:33:42.880
can tackle both of those. In the next 90 seconds
644
00:33:42.960 --> 00:33:44.039
before we go to break.
645
00:33:44.059 --> 00:33:46.420
Yeah, so look, I think the.
646
00:33:46.319 --> 00:33:48.460
Only real way to answer that question is to commit
647
00:33:48.599 --> 00:33:51.670
to a version of time travel to the past. And
648
00:33:51.710 --> 00:33:55.890
the version that I find most convincing involves wormholes. And
649
00:33:55.930 --> 00:33:58.309
the idea of a wormhole, I think many people know
650
00:33:58.390 --> 00:34:01.049
this idea, it's a tunnel from one location in space
651
00:34:01.130 --> 00:34:03.910
to another location in space, a kind of shortcut. And
652
00:34:03.950 --> 00:34:07.099
if you move those openings relative to each other, you
653
00:34:07.140 --> 00:34:09.280
put one near a black hole, again, there'll be a
654
00:34:09.320 --> 00:34:11.119
time difference between the two openings.
655
00:34:11.570 --> 00:34:14.710
So now one opening is ahead, one opening is behind.
656
00:34:15.010 --> 00:34:16.829
So you go through the tunnel one direction, you go
657
00:34:16.849 --> 00:34:18.949
to the future, you go through the tunnel the other direction,
658
00:34:18.989 --> 00:34:19.650
you go to the past.
659
00:34:19.690 --> 00:34:21.469
So what would going to the past look like?
660
00:34:22.130 --> 00:34:25.590
Somebody would enter the opening of a wormhole and they
661
00:34:25.639 --> 00:34:28.840
would disappear and they'd pop out the other opening of
662
00:34:28.900 --> 00:34:31.500
the wormhole at a different place at a different time.
663
00:34:32.300 --> 00:34:33.699
So in the.
664
00:34:33.679 --> 00:34:36.579
Marvel universe where you have Doctor Strange opening these portals,
665
00:34:36.980 --> 00:34:40.719
he's only moving through space. He's not actually moving through time.
666
00:34:41.280 --> 00:34:44.599
So that's a lost storytelling element there that they could
667
00:34:44.739 --> 00:34:47.539
totally do interesting things with, it seems to me.
668
00:34:47.980 --> 00:34:52.119
Yeah, I mean, the richness of Wormholes really arises when
669
00:34:52.159 --> 00:34:54.510
you have a time difference between the two openings. I mean,
670
00:34:54.530 --> 00:34:57.070
it's fun to have a tunnel through space, but it
671
00:34:57.230 --> 00:34:59.449
is mind-blowing to have a tunnel through time.
672
00:34:59.750 --> 00:35:04.630
Yeah. And also, I would add that, I think I
673
00:35:04.650 --> 00:35:09.579
can add
correctly, Brian, that as portrayed in the movie Contact,
674
00:35:09.719 --> 00:35:13.050
where Jodie Foster... goes through this, we presume is a wormhole,
675
00:35:13.409 --> 00:35:16.010
to get to visit the aliens, and then she returns.
676
00:35:16.650 --> 00:35:19.429
We like the idea that it's like a water slide.
677
00:35:19.690 --> 00:35:21.949
You know, you're in this tunnel, you're in this tube,
678
00:35:22.030 --> 00:35:27.820
and you're sliding, but it's really just a simple hole.
679
00:35:28.079 --> 00:35:31.199
You step through it, right? It's not some journey. Isn't
680
00:35:31.219 --> 00:35:34.239
that correct? Because they're basically in the same place.
681
00:35:35.519 --> 00:35:38.519
They can be, but you can also have situations where
682
00:35:38.980 --> 00:35:42.349
the throat of the wormhole has some length to it.
683
00:35:42.780 --> 00:35:45.690
And then again, it would just be traveling through space.
684
00:35:45.769 --> 00:35:48.250
It wouldn't be some kind of, like you say, water
685
00:35:48.269 --> 00:35:50.909
slide or some kind of weird thing that was happening.
686
00:35:51.289 --> 00:35:52.829
But you're right.
687
00:35:52.969 --> 00:35:56.050
Okay. So if you're going to do this, at least
688
00:35:56.130 --> 00:35:58.750
and report on it, if you're in a wormhole and
689
00:35:58.789 --> 00:36:03.000
it's propped up nicely and it's safe for you, then you...
690
00:36:04.260 --> 00:36:07.920
You're just moving through space backwards in time if the
691
00:36:08.039 --> 00:36:11.739
opening of that wormhole is near a black hole where
692
00:36:11.780 --> 00:36:13.610
time is ticking more slowly than where you came from.
693
00:36:14.349 --> 00:36:16.030
Or if it was there for a while.
694
00:36:16.269 --> 00:36:18.769
Once you set the time difference between the two openings,
695
00:36:18.789 --> 00:36:21.250
you can then move away from the black hole because
696
00:36:21.650 --> 00:36:23.510
the time difference will then persist.
697
00:36:24.989 --> 00:36:25.349
Wow.
698
00:36:25.989 --> 00:36:26.639
Jesus.
699
00:36:29.769 --> 00:36:32.110
That is insane. So Chuck, in this one broadcast, you've
700
00:36:32.130 --> 00:36:36.219
mentioned God and Jesus together. Yeah. This must be a
701
00:36:36.260 --> 00:36:38.320
very significant force operating on your brain.
702
00:36:38.659 --> 00:36:40.840
Instead, I should have said, Father time.
703
00:36:45.780 --> 00:36:47.400
Why don't you give us one more question before we
704
00:36:47.420 --> 00:36:49.920
hit the break? All righty. Here we go.
705
00:36:49.960 --> 00:36:54.289
This is Jim Kelly. And Jim Kelly says, hi, Dr. Tyson, Dr. Green, Dr.
706
00:36:54.329 --> 00:36:54.929
Comedy.
707
00:36:55.170 --> 00:36:58.130
Why do physicists assume that all time travelers are murderous,
708
00:36:58.190 --> 00:37:04.949
patricidal maniacs? Just kidding. Just kidding. But how does a
709
00:37:04.969 --> 00:37:10.400
hypothetical paradox preclude the existence of
time travel? All right.
710
00:37:10.519 --> 00:37:13.539
Let's take a quick break because I want a good
711
00:37:13.599 --> 00:37:15.949
answer from Brian out of that. So, Brian, we're going
712
00:37:15.969 --> 00:37:21.500
to discuss the paradoxes and how they're circumvented when we
713
00:37:21.539 --> 00:37:25.699
come back on StarTalk Cosmic Queries Time Travel Edition, fully
714
00:37:25.739 --> 00:37:29.000
inspired by Charles Dickens, who kind of went there first
715
00:37:29.639 --> 00:37:35.360
before other novelists, thinking about the Christmas past, present, and future. Ah, humbug.
716
00:37:37.699 --> 00:37:40.659
We're back, Cosmic Queries Time Travel Edition, with none other
717
00:37:41.260 --> 00:37:45.809
than Brian Greene, whose most recent book, I got to
718
00:37:46.130 --> 00:37:50.610
read this title because it's so inclusive. Until the end
719
00:37:50.650 --> 00:37:54.369
of time, mind, matter, and our search for meaning in
720
00:37:54.409 --> 00:37:57.539
an evolving universe. And you just confessed that you put
721
00:37:57.699 --> 00:38:01.820
every Google search keyword in there so that no matter
722
00:38:01.840 --> 00:38:04.079
what anyone is searching for in the universe, they land
723
00:38:04.139 --> 00:38:09.190
on your book. That's brilliant. Published by Knopf in 2021.
724
00:38:09.190 --> 00:38:11.650
And Chuck, how do we find you on social media?
725
00:38:12.309 --> 00:38:14.190
Chuck, nice comic everywhere, people.
726
00:38:14.719 --> 00:38:18.150
Nice. Leave off the everywhere, just Chuck Nice comic. Thank you. Yeah,
727
00:38:18.170 --> 00:38:21.789
you're right. Chuck Nice comic. You can find me everywhere. Brian,
728
00:38:21.809 --> 00:38:23.349
tell us about your social media footprint.
729
00:38:23.969 --> 00:38:28.469
It's really only on Twitter, and it's at Bgreen. At Bgreen.
730
00:38:29.250 --> 00:38:31.010
Bgreen. Okay.
731
00:38:31.050 --> 00:38:31.269
Nice.
732
00:38:31.309 --> 00:38:31.929
You can do that.
733
00:38:31.949 --> 00:38:33.909
Without a checkmark. Without a blue checkmark.
734
00:38:34.940 --> 00:38:36.500
Oh, right, there you go.
735
00:38:36.699 --> 00:38:39.179
Never had one and now I never will, I suspect.
736
00:38:43.550 --> 00:38:46.260
I heard that after Elon took over and the check
737
00:38:46.300 --> 00:38:49.710
mark thing, that Jesus got a blue check for paying
738
00:38:49.730 --> 00:38:52.590
the anthology. Yeah, finally. So Chuck, we left off with
739
00:38:52.630 --> 00:38:54.090
a question. Just give us the highlights of it. What
740
00:38:54.110 --> 00:38:54.630
was it?
741
00:38:54.670 --> 00:38:57.530
Jim Kelly, who basically says this, how does a hypothetical
742
00:38:57.570 --> 00:38:59.869
paradox preclude the existence of time travel?
743
00:39:01.449 --> 00:39:03.250
Yeah, I mean, I don't think it does.
744
00:39:04.110 --> 00:39:08.420
So the hypothetical paradoxes are you change the past in
745
00:39:08.460 --> 00:39:10.699
a way that, say, prevents your own existence. And we
746
00:39:10.719 --> 00:39:13.500
already discussed how it may be you can't do that.
747
00:39:14.099 --> 00:39:16.880
But the other idea that we made brief mention of
748
00:39:17.039 --> 00:39:20.619
is if instead of traveling to the past in your
749
00:39:20.800 --> 00:39:23.849
own universe, the laws of physics demand that you go
750
00:39:23.889 --> 00:39:27.070
to the past in a parallel universe. Well, if you
751
00:39:27.489 --> 00:39:29.909
prevent your own birth in that universe, there's no paradoxes.
752
00:39:30.599 --> 00:39:32.679
Where were you born? In a different universe.
753
00:39:33.199 --> 00:39:36.199
And so that's another way in which you can have
754
00:39:36.219 --> 00:39:38.719
the freedom to make changes to the past, but not
755
00:39:38.739 --> 00:39:40.429
the past of your own world.
756
00:39:40.849 --> 00:39:41.550
The past of both worlds.
757
00:39:41.570 --> 00:39:44.769
And that's what the Marvel universe persistently does. That's how
758
00:39:44.809 --> 00:39:48.349
Spider-Man can have multiple origin stories, for example. We're actually
759
00:39:48.469 --> 00:39:52.679
accessing a different universe where similar things are happening, but
760
00:39:52.760 --> 00:39:57.329
not so different that we don't recognize the story. That's crazy.
761
00:39:57.530 --> 00:40:01.710
So Brian, what about information? Because information, I don't think
762
00:40:01.730 --> 00:40:05.530
it has mass, does it? Does it travel? Information is
763
00:40:05.590 --> 00:40:09.889
this intangible thing. And I always hear physicists arguing about
764
00:40:09.929 --> 00:40:12.619
whether we lose or gain information every time you do
765
00:40:12.659 --> 00:40:13.500
something with a black hole.
766
00:40:13.940 --> 00:40:16.260
Yeah, I mean, I like to think of information as
767
00:40:16.599 --> 00:40:20.820
more concrete than that description might suggest, because information is
768
00:40:21.079 --> 00:40:26.090
always carried by particles. You can have an abstract measure
769
00:40:26.250 --> 00:40:28.150
of information, but if you want to look at the
770
00:40:28.250 --> 00:40:31.190
motion of information, it's got to be the motion of
771
00:40:31.289 --> 00:40:34.610
stuff that carries that information. And to me, that makes
772
00:40:34.630 --> 00:40:37.679
it much more clear what's going on. So with black holes,
773
00:40:37.780 --> 00:40:40.980
the whole question was, as radiation comes out of a
774
00:40:41.019 --> 00:40:44.230
black hole, which Hawking, Stephen Hawking told us will happen,
775
00:40:44.969 --> 00:40:45.250
are the.
776
00:40:45.429 --> 00:40:49.699
Particles- Instead of Louis Hawking- You mean Stephen Hawking? That's right.
777
00:40:49.719 --> 00:40:52.059
They always get those news.
778
00:40:52.079 --> 00:40:55.099
Think of specifying, Brian, which Hawking you're referring to.
779
00:40:55.199 --> 00:41:00.449
It was the universe where Louis Hawking actually was
responsible.
780
00:41:00.530 --> 00:41:03.949
So as the radiation comes out, hey, serious guys, serious guys,
781
00:41:03.969 --> 00:41:07.969
the question is, do the particles have a relationship among
782
00:41:08.050 --> 00:41:11.409
each other that carries the information of what fell in?
783
00:41:11.889 --> 00:41:15.150
So it's really concrete when you think about it as
784
00:41:15.210 --> 00:41:16.690
information carried by stuff.
785
00:41:18.349 --> 00:41:21.869
Okay, because, right, because otherwise there's no information without stuff
786
00:41:21.889 --> 00:41:22.369
to carry it.
787
00:41:22.510 --> 00:41:27.469
It's hard to follow the information without that commitment.
788
00:41:27.670 --> 00:41:31.760
So when it comes to, like, for those of us
789
00:41:31.820 --> 00:41:35.840
who are listening that may not be so familiar with
790
00:41:35.880 --> 00:41:38.659
what you're talking about. So when you go into a
791
00:41:38.699 --> 00:41:41.199
black hole, I'm a chair, I go into a black hole.
792
00:41:41.780 --> 00:41:43.880
I get broken down into just particles.
793
00:41:44.179 --> 00:41:44.579
Okay.
794
00:41:44.760 --> 00:41:47.050
That's all because the gravity is so strong. Now, just
795
00:41:47.090 --> 00:41:50.469
the string of particles. I come out during the evaporation.
796
00:41:51.389 --> 00:41:53.789
Would I be able to be a chair again?
797
00:41:53.809 --> 00:41:58.309
Okay. That is the question. That is the deep question.
798
00:41:58.590 --> 00:42:01.869
And for a while Hawking said, no, that your particles
799
00:42:01.909 --> 00:42:04.670
would come out and they'd have no memory of their
800
00:42:04.769 --> 00:42:08.239
earlier configuration. The information that they carried would be lost.
801
00:42:08.980 --> 00:42:12.400
But he was ultimately convinced by string theorists and others
802
00:42:13.039 --> 00:42:16.849
that that was wrong. The particles come out and they
803
00:42:16.929 --> 00:42:19.630
do carry the imprint of the fact that they were
804
00:42:19.710 --> 00:42:23.150
once a chair. And if you measure the particles appropriately,
805
00:42:23.449 --> 00:42:26.550
you could reconstruct the chair when those particles come out.
806
00:42:26.929 --> 00:42:29.849
Damn. That's amazing.
807
00:42:30.210 --> 00:42:32.690
But the chair itself doesn't come out. You have to
808
00:42:32.730 --> 00:42:35.739
still make the chair. That sounds like a cop-out. It's
809
00:42:35.800 --> 00:42:42.780
now an Ikea chair. Ikea is in black holes. Chuck,
810
00:42:42.900 --> 00:42:45.360
I love that new theory. All right, Brian, I want
811
00:42:45.400 --> 00:42:48.539
a new research paper on that.
812
00:42:48.579 --> 00:42:51.599
Black holes.
813
00:42:51.619 --> 00:42:53.719
I want it on my desk in the morning, Brian.
814
00:42:53.760 --> 00:42:55.190
The Ikea hypothesis.
815
00:42:56.690 --> 00:42:57.969
Wow, that's amazing.
816
00:42:57.989 --> 00:42:58.989
All right, Chuck, keep them coming.
817
00:42:59.190 --> 00:43:03.269
Okay, let's keep it going. This is from Y Cos.
818
00:43:03.869 --> 00:43:05.949
And Y says, hello, Brian. Hello, Neil.
819
00:43:05.969 --> 00:43:06.170
Hello, Neil.
820
00:43:06.409 --> 00:43:08.909
And then he puts in parentheses with a question mark.
821
00:43:09.429 --> 00:43:09.800
Chuck?
822
00:43:10.820 --> 00:43:12.639
Okay.
823
00:43:12.679 --> 00:43:16.460
That ain't right. We've been Lord Chuck. We've been King Chuck.
824
00:43:17.179 --> 00:43:17.840
All right.
825
00:43:18.000 --> 00:43:21.300
Okay. He says, is it possible to calculate precisely where
826
00:43:21.440 --> 00:43:26.610
in the universe Earth was in a moment to make
827
00:43:26.710 --> 00:43:30.849
sure that we find ourselves on Earth's surface and not
828
00:43:30.949 --> 00:43:35.159
in the position that Earth was in before? When we
829
00:43:35.219 --> 00:43:39.360
are time traveling, how would you compensate for the... Oh, wait.
830
00:43:39.840 --> 00:43:41.679
Wait a minute now. This is where he gets... This
831
00:43:41.699 --> 00:43:45.059
is when you know that why Kaz was either thinking
832
00:43:45.179 --> 00:43:48.960
too much or maybe might have been smoking a little something.
833
00:43:49.400 --> 00:43:49.909
Then he goes.
834
00:43:50.010 --> 00:43:53.309
Okay. Then he goes like this. How would you also
835
00:43:53.809 --> 00:43:59.170
compensate for the expansion of the universe when calculating that trajectory?
836
00:43:59.550 --> 00:44:01.510
So he's getting it all in.
837
00:44:01.969 --> 00:44:06.940
He's all... He's all in. So let me toss to
838
00:44:06.960 --> 00:44:10.280
Brian here after I say something. So in Back to
839
00:44:10.300 --> 00:44:14.920
the Future, they kind of, in the original, they kind
840
00:44:15.099 --> 00:44:21.789
of avoided that problem because when Marty went back in time,
841
00:44:22.010 --> 00:44:25.150
he went back in time in a precise whole number
842
00:44:25.190 --> 00:44:30.010
of years. Okay? And so Earth would be back where
843
00:44:30.050 --> 00:44:33.139
it is when he goes back in time. in its,
844
00:44:33.320 --> 00:44:35.880
in its orbit, you know, enough for the plot line.
845
00:44:36.409 --> 00:44:38.989
But if he went back a week or even an hour,
846
00:44:39.349 --> 00:44:42.789
he's not in that parking lot anymore at all. So,
847
00:44:42.829 --> 00:44:45.809
so Brian, tell me about all this time travel mechanisms
848
00:44:46.230 --> 00:44:49.130
when in fact the universe is changing. So you can't
849
00:44:49.150 --> 00:44:52.590
just show up in the same place and expect to, to, to,
850
00:44:53.010 --> 00:44:54.409
you know, to be home again.
851
00:44:54.750 --> 00:44:55.389
Exactly right.
852
00:44:55.550 --> 00:44:58.800
And so when you time travel, you also need to
853
00:44:58.840 --> 00:45:01.840
space travel. It's really space time travel, right? You have
854
00:45:01.880 --> 00:45:05.289
to pick the location in time and the location in space.
855
00:45:05.329 --> 00:45:07.860
And typically in these films, they only talk about the
856
00:45:07.909 --> 00:45:10.940
time part of things. And to make it concrete, if
857
00:45:10.960 --> 00:45:15.440
you're using the wormhole version of time travel, the opening
858
00:45:15.820 --> 00:45:18.880
of the wormhole that you're going to exit from, it's
859
00:45:18.960 --> 00:45:21.619
at some position in space at some moment in time
860
00:45:21.639 --> 00:45:24.340
when you exit. You better be certain that you have
861
00:45:24.699 --> 00:45:28.460
somehow maneuvered that opening to be, say, on planet Earth
862
00:45:28.719 --> 00:45:30.500
if when you exit, you want to still be on
863
00:45:30.539 --> 00:45:34.250
planet Earth. Otherwise, you could exit back in time, but
864
00:45:34.289 --> 00:45:37.510
near the Andromeda Galaxy or just an empty space. So
865
00:45:37.590 --> 00:45:41.139
you do need to dial both in in order to
866
00:45:41.559 --> 00:45:43.960
get to where you are intending.
867
00:45:44.820 --> 00:45:45.340
Okay.
868
00:45:45.380 --> 00:45:45.719
Interesting.
869
00:45:45.780 --> 00:45:49.960
I bet they don't know that, but we accept it anyway, right? Sure.
870
00:45:50.000 --> 00:45:54.619
It's implicit. It's implicit, I guess, is what that is. Mm-hmm. Chuck,
871
00:45:54.639 --> 00:45:55.119
keep them coming.
872
00:45:55.179 --> 00:45:59.550
All right, let's go. I want to find this young person.
873
00:45:59.639 --> 00:46:02.869
The way you described that previous question, it sounds like
874
00:46:02.909 --> 00:46:06.190
we should have a Cosmic Queries only if the people
875
00:46:06.309 --> 00:46:09.269
were on weed when they wrote the question. Oh, man.
876
00:46:09.289 --> 00:46:11.510
Let me tell you something. That's a great show.
877
00:46:15.739 --> 00:46:17.329
Just legal weed, not illegal weed.
878
00:46:17.389 --> 00:46:20.309
It will either be our best show or our worst show.
879
00:46:20.389 --> 00:46:23.449
Or the worst. No, no. While we're doing it, we'll
880
00:46:23.510 --> 00:46:25.929
think it's the best. Right. And then afterwards, we'll know
881
00:46:25.989 --> 00:46:26.429
it's the worst.
882
00:46:26.550 --> 00:46:28.570
And that is kind of how that goes. All right.
883
00:46:29.269 --> 00:46:35.960
This is Savage162. And Savage162 says, in the frontier of science,
884
00:46:36.639 --> 00:46:40.500
is there any idea on how to try and detect
885
00:46:40.599 --> 00:46:44.659
the theorized tachyon particle? Ooh.
886
00:46:45.480 --> 00:46:46.900
Remind us what a tachyon is, Brian.
887
00:46:47.219 --> 00:46:49.619
Yeah, so it's what you had mentioned earlier, Neil, this
888
00:46:49.699 --> 00:46:51.780
idea of a particle that can go faster than the
889
00:46:51.820 --> 00:46:55.989
speed of light. And when a particle can go hypothetical,
890
00:46:56.030 --> 00:46:57.869
I should say, a particle goes faster than the speed
891
00:46:57.909 --> 00:47:01.769
of light, there are observers watching that particle who will
892
00:47:01.809 --> 00:47:05.650
see it reach its target before it was emitted by
893
00:47:05.710 --> 00:47:09.559
the source. Reaches target before it was emitted by the source.
894
00:47:09.800 --> 00:47:14.239
So cause and effect become flipped. for the observers who
895
00:47:14.489 --> 00:47:18.809
are witnessing the motion of a tachyon. So the question is,
896
00:47:18.840 --> 00:47:25.619
how would you ever detect these things? First of all,
897
00:47:26.179 --> 00:47:28.559
to measure something going faster than the speed of light,
898
00:47:28.800 --> 00:47:32.960
that's actually not that hard. You start with a particle
899
00:47:33.000 --> 00:47:35.760
at one location and you fire it and you simply
900
00:47:36.059 --> 00:47:39.300
calculate or you measure, I should say, how long it
901
00:47:39.340 --> 00:47:41.440
took to get to the target. Did it beat a
902
00:47:41.480 --> 00:47:42.559
light beam or not?
903
00:47:43.090 --> 00:47:43.650
And that's it.
904
00:47:44.210 --> 00:47:48.550
So that's pretty straightforward. And indeed, you may recall, I
905
00:47:48.570 --> 00:47:50.070
don't know, some 10 years ago.
906
00:47:50.130 --> 00:47:53.130
That neutrino thing in Italy, right?
907
00:47:53.510 --> 00:47:56.150
Yeah, in Italy, there was a claim that these neutrinos
908
00:47:56.190 --> 00:47:59.550
had gone from the source to the target and beaten
909
00:47:59.849 --> 00:48:02.710
a beam of light. They'd gotten there earlier than a
910
00:48:03.170 --> 00:48:05.650
beam of light would. Now, some of us knew that.
911
00:48:05.690 --> 00:48:07.969
So Brian, you know the joke about that, the Euro joke,
912
00:48:07.989 --> 00:48:10.940
because Europeans like joking about each other. They said, that
913
00:48:10.960 --> 00:48:13.559
would have been the first time Italy arrived anywhere early.
914
00:48:13.579 --> 00:48:14.400
Yeah, that's right.
915
00:48:14.440 --> 00:48:14.619
Right.
916
00:48:14.659 --> 00:48:15.840
That's, that's exactly right.
917
00:48:15.880 --> 00:48:17.940
So that, that was, that was the key tip off
918
00:48:18.000 --> 00:48:23.789
immediately that nothing gets, but, but, but scientifically fascinating.
919
00:48:23.809 --> 00:48:25.050
It would have been fascinating. It would have been an
920
00:48:25.110 --> 00:48:26.929
example of something that would fascinate the speed of light.
921
00:48:27.480 --> 00:48:30.079
And so people looked really intently at the data and
922
00:48:30.219 --> 00:48:34.000
ultimately realized that there was some kind of loose wire
923
00:48:34.039 --> 00:48:36.039
or fiber optic cable or something.
924
00:48:36.070 --> 00:48:37.219
I can't remember the details.
925
00:48:37.489 --> 00:48:40.369
And when that was repaired, the particles did not go
926
00:48:40.429 --> 00:48:41.489
faster than the speed of light.
927
00:48:41.650 --> 00:48:42.369
But in principle.
928
00:48:42.409 --> 00:48:44.130
But let me add, Brian, because you might not go
929
00:48:44.170 --> 00:48:47.309
there for the benefit of Chuck, that in my field,
930
00:48:47.389 --> 00:48:49.809
and it surely happens in your field, somebody gets a
931
00:48:49.829 --> 00:48:54.179
cockamamie observation, which would later be shown to be wrong.
932
00:48:54.500 --> 00:48:57.400
But if it's right... It's amazing. And you have these
933
00:48:57.820 --> 00:49:01.539
ambulance chasing theorists coming up with an explanation of, of course,
934
00:49:01.619 --> 00:49:04.019
why that must be so. Did that happen in the
935
00:49:04.059 --> 00:49:05.920
case of the neutrinos? Oh, gosh.
936
00:49:06.079 --> 00:49:07.619
I'm not completely sure.
937
00:49:07.639 --> 00:49:10.320
There must have been a few papers because nobody could
938
00:49:10.340 --> 00:49:13.800
have fully resisted it within the confines of the entire field.
939
00:49:14.179 --> 00:49:18.360
But 99% of the people who encountered that result that
940
00:49:18.480 --> 00:49:19.980
I spoke to were like, it can't be true.
941
00:49:20.199 --> 00:49:22.019
It just can't be true. And it wasn't true.
942
00:49:22.360 --> 00:49:22.739
Here we go.
943
00:49:23.079 --> 00:49:26.179
Ryan, this is just Ryan. He's like Cher, just Ryan.
944
00:49:26.570 --> 00:49:31.269
He says, hello, doctors. If we developed a way to
945
00:49:31.510 --> 00:49:36.710
time travel backwards, could we travel to a time before
946
00:49:36.730 --> 00:49:40.449
the Big Bang? Or would we just break science altogether?
947
00:49:40.469 --> 00:49:45.250
I love it. Brian?
948
00:49:45.590 --> 00:49:48.389
Yeah, well, the whole question of before the Big Bang
949
00:49:48.849 --> 00:49:52.090
is a deep one. And it could simply be that
950
00:49:52.139 --> 00:49:54.579
there's no notion of before when it comes to the
951
00:49:54.619 --> 00:49:58.159
Big Bang, because the Big Bang could be the origin
952
00:49:58.179 --> 00:50:01.300
of time itself. And so the notion of before makes
953
00:50:01.340 --> 00:50:05.760
sense when you're talking about you know, 1800s or 2000 B.C.
954
00:50:05.780 --> 00:50:07.960
or whatever, but when you get to the beginning of
955
00:50:08.019 --> 00:50:11.889
time itself, there's simply no conception of before. And so
956
00:50:11.949 --> 00:50:15.050
there may not even be a realm of reality that
957
00:50:15.110 --> 00:50:17.750
we could delineate as before the Big Bang.
958
00:50:17.769 --> 00:50:21.309
It's just the same, I think, I've heard Hawking, this
959
00:50:21.329 --> 00:50:27.010
is what Louis Hawking told me, that going before the
960
00:50:27.030 --> 00:50:29.010
Big Bang might be like asking what's north of the
961
00:50:29.050 --> 00:50:29.550
North Pole.
962
00:50:29.750 --> 00:50:31.409
The whole grid.
963
00:50:31.130 --> 00:50:35.039
System is defined there And you can't, once you're as
964
00:50:35.079 --> 00:50:36.760
far north as you can go, you can't go farther north.
965
00:50:37.099 --> 00:50:38.960
Once you're as far back in time at the beginning,
966
00:50:38.980 --> 00:50:40.199
you can't go further back.
967
00:50:40.340 --> 00:50:42.739
Yeah, but I should say that that's only one idea.
968
00:50:42.760 --> 00:50:45.090
It's an interesting and provocative one, but there are other
969
00:50:45.250 --> 00:50:47.710
approaches which suggest that there is a realm before the
970
00:50:47.750 --> 00:50:48.250
Big Bang.
971
00:50:48.269 --> 00:50:50.409
There may be many Big.
972
00:50:50.110 --> 00:50:53.710
Bangs giving rise to many universes, and our Bang may
973
00:50:53.750 --> 00:50:55.530
not have been in any sense the first.
974
00:50:56.309 --> 00:50:57.670
And so there may be a realm.
975
00:50:58.050 --> 00:51:00.289
So you'd have to pass out of our sort of
976
00:51:00.349 --> 00:51:04.519
space-time realm. structure and enter somebody else's space time. If
977
00:51:04.539 --> 00:51:06.579
you want to go before what happened with the big bang.
978
00:51:06.619 --> 00:51:07.280
Yeah, that's right.
979
00:51:07.480 --> 00:51:10.880
It's like a subway line. You reach the end of
980
00:51:11.019 --> 00:51:14.260
one line. I mean, you can't go any further. That's it.
981
00:51:14.599 --> 00:51:17.960
But you can switch to another subway and then you
982
00:51:17.980 --> 00:51:19.820
can go on from there, but you're in a different
983
00:51:19.840 --> 00:51:21.139
thing at that point, different train.
984
00:51:21.159 --> 00:51:21.760
You're a different thing.
985
00:51:21.780 --> 00:51:26.449
You're going to have to pay another fare in this version.
986
00:51:26.610 --> 00:51:28.230
And Chuck, the laws of physics might be a little
987
00:51:28.289 --> 00:51:31.719
different so that your body would Fall into a pile
988
00:51:31.739 --> 00:51:32.139
of goo.
989
00:51:33.099 --> 00:51:36.420
That's what you get for a jump of the turnstile.
990
00:51:37.619 --> 00:51:41.340
Oh, Brian, just close this out if you could. What
991
00:51:41.539 --> 00:51:45.880
kind of time travel did, in all of your variants,
992
00:51:46.539 --> 00:51:50.190
did Charles Dickens invoke? for Christmas past and future?
993
00:51:50.429 --> 00:51:54.210
It sort of feels like a wormhole-y version where they're
994
00:51:54.250 --> 00:51:56.769
traveling through a wormhole to the past, and maybe they're
995
00:51:56.789 --> 00:52:00.050
just hovering at the edge of the wormhole, not actually
996
00:52:00.269 --> 00:52:01.550
entering that reality.
997
00:52:01.570 --> 00:52:03.469
And therefore not interacting with it.
998
00:52:03.610 --> 00:52:06.030
Yeah, therefore they're sort of more of an observer status
999
00:52:06.070 --> 00:52:09.650
as opposed to a participant status. It kind of resonates
1000
00:52:09.829 --> 00:52:11.389
with that, but, you know.
1001
00:52:11.630 --> 00:52:13.670
But don't you need a different universe now? Because there
1002
00:52:13.690 --> 00:52:17.199
were some different outcomes, right? So now there's... That's right.
1003
00:52:18.139 --> 00:52:20.199
And so this would be an example where the wormhole
1004
00:52:20.219 --> 00:52:24.030
stretches from one universe to another, as opposed to from
1005
00:52:24.170 --> 00:52:25.590
one universe to the same universe.
1006
00:52:25.789 --> 00:52:31.110
Yeah, but the different outcomes were not directly attributable to
1007
00:52:31.130 --> 00:52:35.800
the time travel. The different outcomes were because of his
1008
00:52:35.940 --> 00:52:39.820
change of actions in the present, which affected the future.
1009
00:52:40.449 --> 00:52:40.829
That's right.
1010
00:52:41.130 --> 00:52:42.750
So the past never changed.
1011
00:52:43.190 --> 00:52:45.369
Yeah, I think Chuck is more current on that.
1012
00:52:45.409 --> 00:52:47.449
The past never changed. He changed.
1013
00:52:47.469 --> 00:52:49.199
The past was, oh my gosh, is that what the
1014
00:52:49.239 --> 00:52:50.760
future is going to be? No, it's not. Right. Because
1015
00:52:50.780 --> 00:52:52.179
I'm going to change myself in the present.
1016
00:52:52.300 --> 00:52:54.079
Yeah, exactly.
1017
00:52:54.559 --> 00:52:57.480
Yeah, so the basic idea is imagine three or some
1018
00:52:57.500 --> 00:53:00.820
number of tunnels emanating from this realm to these other
1019
00:53:00.900 --> 00:53:04.610
parallel universes, sort of like slices of bread in a
1020
00:53:04.780 --> 00:53:07.500
grand cosmic reality where each slice of bread is its
1021
00:53:07.579 --> 00:53:10.860
own universe you just have these tunnels connecting us to
1022
00:53:10.900 --> 00:53:13.239
them allowing you to witness what would happen in a
1023
00:53:13.280 --> 00:53:17.400
world where things were different wow damn.
1024
00:53:18.090 --> 00:53:20.349
It's amazing all right we gotta let's we gotta land
1025
00:53:20.369 --> 00:53:23.170
that plane right there brian it's been a delight to
1026
00:53:23.210 --> 00:53:26.670
have you back on star talk um always a pleasure
1027
00:53:27.769 --> 00:53:29.630
it's really you're just up the street we should have
1028
00:53:29.670 --> 00:53:33.260
you on even we should be like a regular brian feature, right?
1029
00:53:35.039 --> 00:53:37.280
Give Brian his own minute. A minute from Brian.
1030
00:53:37.679 --> 00:53:39.699
Make it two minutes.
1031
00:53:40.139 --> 00:53:42.039
Make it whatever you want to call Brian time.
1032
00:53:42.300 --> 00:53:44.880
Brian time!
1033
00:53:45.699 --> 00:53:47.219
Near the speed of light.
1034
00:53:47.260 --> 00:53:50.559
Near the speed of light. Oh, yeah. You got it. Guys,
1035
00:53:50.659 --> 00:53:52.420
great to have you. Chuck, always good to have you there.
1036
00:53:52.559 --> 00:53:53.239
Always a pleasure.
1037
00:53:53.260 --> 00:53:56.900
For these cosmic queries. I am Neil deGrasse Tyson. You're
1038
00:53:56.920 --> 00:53:59.619
a personal astrophysicist. As always, I bid you to keep
1039
00:53:59.639 --> 00:54:01.079
looking up.