TRANSCRIPCIÓN 🔗
1
00:00:00,900 --> 00:00:02,635
Welcome to News in Context.
2
00:00:02,635 --> 00:00:03,970
I'm Gina Baleria.
3
00:00:03,970 --> 00:00:06,172
This is Civity Week on News In Context.
4
00:00:06,172 --> 00:00:09,743
Civity is a culture of deliberately
engaging in relationships
5
00:00:09,743 --> 00:00:12,746
of respect and empathy with others
who are different,
6
00:00:12,746 --> 00:00:16,282
moving people from us versus them to
we all belong.
7
00:00:16,383 --> 00:00:18,385
To learn more, go to civity.org.
8
00:00:18,385 --> 00:00:22,489
In this episode, we explore how othering
has led to increased
9
00:00:22,489 --> 00:00:25,725
marginalization and vilification of people
who are unhoused
10
00:00:25,892 --> 00:00:28,862
and how Civity can help counter
this trend by helping
11
00:00:28,862 --> 00:00:32,699
people who are housed
see the humanity of those without housing.
12
00:00:32,766 --> 00:00:37,137
My guest is Eric Tars, legal director
of the National Homelessness Law Center,
13
00:00:37,303 --> 00:00:41,274
who reminds us that housing is a human
right and hopes that helping people
14
00:00:41,274 --> 00:00:46,880
see each other's
humanity can bring this back into focus.
15
00:00:46,980 --> 00:00:50,383
What is the work
you're doing with relation to housing?
16
00:00:50,383 --> 00:00:54,421
Civic dialog
around issues of housing and homelessness,
17
00:00:54,421 --> 00:01:00,527
and the real divides that we find
in our communities around these issues,
18
00:01:00,627 --> 00:01:03,730
Because I think housing is such
19
00:01:03,730 --> 00:01:08,301
a fundamental issue on Maslow's
hierarchy of needs.
20
00:01:08,401 --> 00:01:10,503
It's one of our most fundamental.
21
00:01:10,503 --> 00:01:14,374
So when people are threatened
22
00:01:14,574 --> 00:01:18,445
without having housing, either
because they actually don't have it
23
00:01:18,445 --> 00:01:23,683
or because they have to confront
that concept that others in the community
24
00:01:23,683 --> 00:01:27,454
don't have it,
and that it might in turn be them.
25
00:01:27,520 --> 00:01:31,524
It can reach right down
into that reptilian brain
26
00:01:31,591 --> 00:01:35,695
and trigger
some really powerful emotional responses.
27
00:01:35,795 --> 00:01:39,032
That's why we need civic dialog
28
00:01:39,099 --> 00:01:44,270
in a respectful and understanding
and empathetic tone
29
00:01:44,370 --> 00:01:49,476
to be able to get us out of that fear
response
30
00:01:49,542 --> 00:01:53,313
triggered response and into actual dialog
31
00:01:53,313 --> 00:01:57,283
where we can talk about the fact that you
32
00:01:57,383 --> 00:02:02,689
yes, homelessness is bad and it's bad
for everybody in the community
33
00:02:02,789 --> 00:02:08,561
and the solution is not a law enforcement
based one
34
00:02:08,628 --> 00:02:12,165
that's only actually going
to make things worse that might erase
35
00:02:12,265 --> 00:02:15,168
the problem
from your particular street corner,
36
00:02:15,168 --> 00:02:17,137
Load full transcript
but it's just going to put it
on somebody else's.
37
00:02:17,137 --> 00:02:21,441
And then you know, that person
who's had to go through that traumatic
38
00:02:21,541 --> 00:02:24,344
law enforcement
experience is going to have an arrest
39
00:02:24,344 --> 00:02:28,348
record, is going to have fines and fees
they can't pay as a barrier
40
00:02:28,348 --> 00:02:30,083
before
they can actually get out of homelessness.
41
00:02:30,083 --> 00:02:34,254
So it's actually prolonging homelessness
and making it worse in your community,
42
00:02:34,254 --> 00:02:37,590
even if you can't see it on your street
corner anymore.
43
00:02:37,657 --> 00:02:40,627
And so instead, we need to be focusing
44
00:02:40,627 --> 00:02:45,732
on actual systemic solutions to address
the underlying causes of homelessness.
45
00:02:45,798 --> 00:02:48,801
But it's hard to get to that
46
00:02:48,868 --> 00:02:52,305
that meaningful conversation
if you can get to that conversation
47
00:02:52,305 --> 00:02:56,643
on the merits,
the constructive solutions win every time,
48
00:02:56,709 --> 00:03:01,214
but you can't get there
if you're just stuck in that fear
49
00:03:01,214 --> 00:03:04,450
based response,
which is where some politicians
50
00:03:04,651 --> 00:03:10,023
wait to keep you, then you don't get to
the actual evidence based responses
51
00:03:10,023 --> 00:03:13,760
that are going to solve things
and things that will end up getting worse.
52
00:03:13,860 --> 00:03:16,863
I want to ask you so many things,
but I want to start with this whole
53
00:03:16,930 --> 00:03:21,601
reptilian brain, emotional response,
fear based response versus
54
00:03:21,668 --> 00:03:23,870
I'm paraphrasing,
but you said solutions that,
55
00:03:23,870 --> 00:03:26,973
you know, that solve the problem, win
every time, right?
56
00:03:27,006 --> 00:03:30,743
Like solutions that actually address
the issue of homelessness, win every time.
57
00:03:30,977 --> 00:03:34,147
And yet these trigger responses
58
00:03:34,180 --> 00:03:38,218
keep winning
and they keep driving the issue forward.
59
00:03:38,284 --> 00:03:41,754
Why do you think it is that that emotional
60
00:03:41,821 --> 00:03:44,324
fear based trigger response
61
00:03:44,324 --> 00:03:49,429
wins the day here and and that the stuff
that really solves the problem?
62
00:03:49,429 --> 00:03:53,466
It doesn't seem to be gaining traction
in a lot of cases, unfortunately.
63
00:03:53,533 --> 00:03:57,337
You know,
we are now kind of operating in this post
64
00:03:57,403 --> 00:04:02,709
truth society where truthiness
is more important than truth
65
00:04:02,775 --> 00:04:06,446
and the Dunning
Kruger effect convinces people,
66
00:04:06,479 --> 00:04:10,783
you know, the less they know, the more
they're convinced they know everything.
67
00:04:10,883 --> 00:04:17,657
And so you get stuck in these reactions
when you hear the actual truth.
68
00:04:17,657 --> 00:04:19,726
If it doesn't fit into the frame
69
00:04:19,726 --> 00:04:23,329
that you've convinced yourself is
the correct frame, then it doesn't mesh.
70
00:04:23,329 --> 00:04:27,066
And so it makes the preexisting narratives
71
00:04:27,066 --> 00:04:30,970
and prejudices and stereotypes
so much more effective.
72
00:04:31,170 --> 00:04:34,874
So in America, we have this narrative
73
00:04:34,874 --> 00:04:39,445
of the American work ethic,
and if you work hard, then you get ahead.
74
00:04:39,512 --> 00:04:43,149
And the corollary is therefore,
if you haven't gotten ahead,
75
00:04:43,216 --> 00:04:45,251
if you're out there on the streets,
76
00:04:45,251 --> 00:04:47,787
then it must be because you haven't worked
hard.
77
00:04:47,787 --> 00:04:49,922
It's not the systemic issues.
78
00:04:49,922 --> 00:04:51,991
Rents have gone up.
79
00:04:51,991 --> 00:04:54,661
Wages have remained flat for decades.
80
00:04:54,661 --> 00:04:56,629
But it must be something that you've done.
81
00:04:56,629 --> 00:04:58,731
And therefore it's fine to blame you.
82
00:04:58,731 --> 00:05:02,168
And, you know, you just kind of keep on
going down that road.
83
00:05:02,235 --> 00:05:05,238
And if you're a wealthy individual,
84
00:05:05,405 --> 00:05:10,109
then you might not wake that reminder
that poverty exists in your community.
85
00:05:10,343 --> 00:05:14,414
And then you have to confront
is the inequality
86
00:05:14,514 --> 00:05:18,117
that I'm benefiting from actually fair.
87
00:05:18,184 --> 00:05:23,723
And if you're a poor person, then you can
see that person out there on the street.
88
00:05:23,823 --> 00:05:28,494
One, you get this triggered fear response
there, but for the grace of God, go I.
89
00:05:28,561 --> 00:05:31,898
And rather than that, creating empathy,
90
00:05:31,964 --> 00:05:36,602
it creates that I don't want to think
about this kind of effect.
91
00:05:36,669 --> 00:05:40,173
There's also that Why should that person
92
00:05:40,239 --> 00:05:44,210
get free housing if I have to work
two jobs to pay the rent?
93
00:05:44,310 --> 00:05:48,247
Instead of questioning, why do I have
to work two jobs to pay the rent?
94
00:05:48,314 --> 00:05:52,118
And seeing that we're all on the same side
here and we're confronting
95
00:05:52,118 --> 00:05:55,121
the same issues of lack of affordable
housing in our communities.
96
00:05:55,288 --> 00:06:00,493
And this person is just somebody who,
you know, wasn't able to keep working that
97
00:06:00,493 --> 00:06:05,431
second job or is actually working two jobs
but still wasn't able to pay the rent.
98
00:06:05,498 --> 00:06:08,868
And so it's that combination of the fear
based
99
00:06:08,868 --> 00:06:13,005
response mixed with the judgment
100
00:06:13,106 --> 00:06:16,042
that fits into the narrative
that kind of keeps it in that
101
00:06:16,042 --> 00:06:19,812
individual analysis,
rather than getting to
102
00:06:19,912 --> 00:06:24,317
look at the systemic problems
that are actually creating homelessness.
103
00:06:24,317 --> 00:06:27,487
As you
know, in
so many areas of policy in the U.S.
104
00:06:27,487 --> 00:06:31,391
or issues in the U.S., we do tend to
105
00:06:31,491 --> 00:06:33,693
look at each other
rather than looking at the system, rather
106
00:06:33,693 --> 00:06:37,630
than looking at the people who sort of
are the gatekeepers of the system.
107
00:06:37,830 --> 00:06:42,435
And that does keep us, I think, in a lot
of cases from really solving the problem.
108
00:06:42,668 --> 00:06:46,472
So you're doing work
now that you're trying to connect people
109
00:06:46,539 --> 00:06:49,375
on various sides of the housing issue,
110
00:06:49,375 --> 00:06:52,779
to be in relationship with each other
so that they can make
111
00:06:52,779 --> 00:06:56,516
these connections
and work from a different frame
112
00:06:56,516 --> 00:06:58,818
or a different angle
to try to solve this problem.
113
00:06:58,818 --> 00:07:02,655
Talk to me a little bit
about how you got to this place where you
114
00:07:02,755 --> 00:07:08,528
identified the idea that building
relationships across some of these housing
115
00:07:08,594 --> 00:07:11,030
silos was something
you thought might be effective.
116
00:07:11,030 --> 00:07:12,398
So the underlying problem
117
00:07:12,398 --> 00:07:15,401
is that we don't have enough affordable
housing in our community
118
00:07:15,601 --> 00:07:18,571
and we need people to be engaged to engage
119
00:07:18,571 --> 00:07:23,176
with their elected officials
to help them make that happen.
120
00:07:23,276 --> 00:07:27,713
But in many cases,
even when you get approval for funding
121
00:07:27,780 --> 00:07:31,584
or for a private developer
applying for somewhere
122
00:07:31,584 --> 00:07:35,888
to put it, the community itself
says, Nope, not in my backyard.
123
00:07:35,955 --> 00:07:38,825
It's a great idea,
but it should always be somewhere else.
124
00:07:38,825 --> 00:07:43,196
So we need to be able to
to talk to people and emphasize
125
00:07:43,262 --> 00:07:46,766
that we are all in this together,
in this housing.
126
00:07:46,933 --> 00:07:48,868
Everybody needs it in the community.
127
00:07:48,868 --> 00:07:53,473
And if you don't have it,
then everybody in the community suffers.
128
00:07:53,573 --> 00:07:56,843
One of our cases in San Diego
129
00:07:56,943 --> 00:08:01,080
around vehicle residency
in many cases is disabled
130
00:08:01,080 --> 00:08:06,185
and elderly people
who can't access regular shelters.
131
00:08:06,185 --> 00:08:07,920
Even there's not enough shelter.
132
00:08:07,920 --> 00:08:12,692
But even that
that exists isn't disabled accessible.
133
00:08:12,758 --> 00:08:16,429
And so the best place
that they can actually live is in vehicle.
134
00:08:16,462 --> 00:08:22,034
They can't afford the rent on their
Social Security or pension income.
135
00:08:22,134 --> 00:08:25,771
But you get these neighborhood groups
136
00:08:25,838 --> 00:08:30,910
who take pictures of trash
outside of some of these homes.
137
00:08:31,010 --> 00:08:37,183
Are these vans that people are living
in, pictures of poop on the sidewalk
138
00:08:37,250 --> 00:08:40,887
and they're sending them to their elected
officials, like generating
139
00:08:40,887 --> 00:08:45,491
all this energy in these neighborhood
next door type groups.
140
00:08:45,591 --> 00:08:50,630
In this case,
we actually got the judge to agree
141
00:08:50,630 --> 00:08:54,166
that enforcing
these laws was unconstitutional, unfair.
142
00:08:54,267 --> 00:08:56,736
The city repealed the ordinance.
143
00:08:56,736 --> 00:09:01,941
But within days, the folks
and those next dawn networks
144
00:09:02,041 --> 00:09:06,012
were sending those pictures and saying,
this is what's happening
145
00:09:06,012 --> 00:09:07,480
in my neighborhood,
you need to do something about it.
146
00:09:07,480 --> 00:09:10,383
And they reinstituted
they just tweaked the wording a little
147
00:09:10,383 --> 00:09:12,919
and they put that ordinance
right back into effect
148
00:09:12,919 --> 00:09:17,890
and all the legal work to be done
basically went out the window.
149
00:09:17,957 --> 00:09:21,294
You know, I just had this vision where
150
00:09:21,360 --> 00:09:27,233
there's so much energy in those groups
and if it could only be turned
151
00:09:27,333 --> 00:09:32,004
to constructive solutions,
if there was just one person in that group
152
00:09:32,071 --> 00:09:35,074
who said, look, I agree with you,
153
00:09:35,141 --> 00:09:39,612
those people should not be
living in vans on our streets.
154
00:09:39,679 --> 00:09:42,648
They should be in housing,
making it illegal to park on the streets
155
00:09:42,648 --> 00:09:45,985
so that their vehicles get towed,
their homes get taken
156
00:09:45,985 --> 00:09:49,755
away, is only going to put them
literally out on the streets.
157
00:09:49,755 --> 00:09:54,026
And you're going to like that a lot
less than them living in their vehicles.
158
00:09:54,093 --> 00:09:57,563
And these are mostly, as I said
earlier, would be disabled people.
159
00:09:57,630 --> 00:10:00,066
Wait,
is that how we want to treat each other?
160
00:10:00,066 --> 00:10:06,172
If you just get that one voice
in each one of these next door network,
161
00:10:06,272 --> 00:10:09,241
then you could take all that energy
162
00:10:09,475 --> 00:10:12,345
that says we need a solution
to this problem and really make it
163
00:10:12,345 --> 00:10:15,448
a solution
that works for everybody in the community
164
00:10:15,648 --> 00:10:19,251
rather than just the House people,
even the elected officials.
165
00:10:19,352 --> 00:10:23,522
It doesn't make it easier for them
to criminalize homelessness.
166
00:10:23,522 --> 00:10:27,393
It's just the most politically expedient
thing for them to do because they know
167
00:10:27,460 --> 00:10:32,565
that if they don't act
in response to the community,
168
00:10:32,665 --> 00:10:36,369
if they aren't seen acting,
if they try to get a new housing
169
00:10:36,369 --> 00:10:40,373
bond
approved so that there's funding
for affordable housing,
170
00:10:40,473 --> 00:10:44,677
it's going to be, you know, three,
five years before ground is even broken.
171
00:10:44,677 --> 00:10:46,912
By that point,
they've been voted out of office
172
00:10:46,912 --> 00:10:49,048
because they weren't responsive
to the community,
173
00:10:49,048 --> 00:10:51,684
telling them
that homelessness was a priority.
174
00:10:51,684 --> 00:10:55,888
And so the easiest thing for them to do
is always just criminalize it,
175
00:10:55,955 --> 00:10:58,924
make it disappear from the people
who are complaining about it
176
00:10:58,924 --> 00:11:01,927
streets and say, I did something.
177
00:11:02,094 --> 00:11:04,764
But if you can get the people
of that community
178
00:11:04,764 --> 00:11:08,968
saying, look, we will support you
in making that long term
179
00:11:09,035 --> 00:11:12,638
investment, that's actually
going to solve this problem for all of us.
180
00:11:12,705 --> 00:11:15,708
It frees them up
really to do the right thing
181
00:11:15,808 --> 00:11:17,543
rather than just the expedient thing.
182
00:11:17,543 --> 00:11:19,912
I think you've identified the problem
so well.
183
00:11:19,912 --> 00:11:21,180
And as far as what to do about it,
184
00:11:21,180 --> 00:11:24,817
I think that's where civic
we can come into play.
185
00:11:25,051 --> 00:11:27,953
So cities borrows from us versus them to
we all belong.
186
00:11:27,953 --> 00:11:29,422
And you said moving from
187
00:11:29,422 --> 00:11:32,658
we need to get rid of these people to
we need to help our neighbors.
188
00:11:32,758 --> 00:11:35,027
And to me,
that's exactly from us versus them, too.
189
00:11:35,027 --> 00:11:37,129
We all belong.
I mean, that is city at its core.
190
00:11:37,129 --> 00:11:40,199
And there's great research out there
that once you begin
191
00:11:40,199 --> 00:11:43,369
to see someone's humanity, it's
really difficult to backtrack on that.
192
00:11:43,536 --> 00:11:48,207
I feel like activity kind of nudges
people, you know, in that direction.
193
00:11:48,240 --> 00:11:52,812
That's why you have folks like
194
00:11:52,912 --> 00:11:55,047
me and former President Trump
195
00:11:55,047 --> 00:11:58,684
who are fearmongering around these issues
196
00:11:58,684 --> 00:12:02,755
and using that same kind of rapists
and murderers language
197
00:12:02,755 --> 00:12:06,659
that you used about people
coming over the border.
198
00:12:06,826 --> 00:12:09,695
He's now using about people
experiencing homelessness,
199
00:12:09,695 --> 00:12:12,932
trying to make people afraid
so that they don't make that connection.
200
00:12:12,932 --> 00:12:14,633
They're afraid to even go
201
00:12:14,633 --> 00:12:18,170
into that homeless encampment
where it's just our neighbors
202
00:12:18,270 --> 00:12:22,475
who don't have homes, who are suffering
and who could use that connection.
203
00:12:22,475 --> 00:12:26,078
But if you're too afraid to even go there,
then then
you don't make that connection
204
00:12:26,078 --> 00:12:27,113
in the first place.
205
00:12:27,113 --> 00:12:30,616
That's one of the kind of
really insidious things that we see
206
00:12:30,716 --> 00:12:32,418
happening a lot more now.
207
00:12:32,418 --> 00:12:38,023
This national push to criminalize
and demonize this population and lock them
208
00:12:38,023 --> 00:12:42,027
up, move them into internment
camps under the threat of arrest.
209
00:12:42,061 --> 00:12:46,065
It really is kind of this creeping
fascism,
210
00:12:46,165 --> 00:12:49,201
the antithesis of democracy and civility
211
00:12:49,201 --> 00:12:52,404
and civic dialog that others don't belong.
212
00:12:52,471 --> 00:12:55,174
And we need to get them
out of the community.
213
00:12:55,174 --> 00:12:55,674
You're right.
214
00:12:55,674 --> 00:12:56,842
It is insidious.
215
00:12:56,842 --> 00:13:01,647
And I wish more people would recognize it
because it's very scary
216
00:13:01,647 --> 00:13:03,115
and it's so effective.
217
00:13:03,115 --> 00:13:06,185
So to me, the work you're doing
and hopefully the work Civic is doing is
218
00:13:06,185 --> 00:13:09,255
is needed now more than ever.
219
00:13:09,255 --> 00:13:12,792
I think that jump to you know,
we all belong like
220
00:13:12,992 --> 00:13:16,462
we saw the potential of it in the pandemic
221
00:13:16,562 --> 00:13:19,932
when we did realize
we were all in it together.
222
00:13:19,999 --> 00:13:24,470
You know, that the threats of tens
of millions
223
00:13:24,470 --> 00:13:28,340
of Americans losing their housing
because they were out of work
224
00:13:28,440 --> 00:13:31,644
actually got the resources that we needed
225
00:13:31,710 --> 00:13:36,448
to keep them in their housing
through emergency rental assistance.
226
00:13:36,515 --> 00:13:39,585
For once,
we had that that bipartisan consensus
227
00:13:39,585 --> 00:13:43,122
that we have to keep people in their homes
or it's going to make this pandemic
228
00:13:43,189 --> 00:13:47,326
so much worse and have lasting
impacts for so many people
229
00:13:47,426 --> 00:13:49,728
and for the people on the streets.
230
00:13:49,728 --> 00:13:53,499
We got the CDC to come out with guidance
that said,
231
00:13:53,566 --> 00:13:56,302
if you move people out of encampments
without providing them
232
00:13:56,302 --> 00:13:59,371
with individual housing,
if you put them into congregate shelters
233
00:13:59,371 --> 00:14:01,240
or into jails, even worse,
234
00:14:01,240 --> 00:14:04,243
like that's going to be the worst thing
that we could do for the pandemic.
235
00:14:04,410 --> 00:14:08,514
And if you want that ICU bed available
236
00:14:08,581 --> 00:14:11,383
for when you need it
or your grandmother needs it,
237
00:14:11,383 --> 00:14:14,286
then you've got to make sure
it's not already filled up
238
00:14:14,286 --> 00:14:17,656
with a medically vulnerable person
who's been living on the streets,
239
00:14:17,756 --> 00:14:23,028
who is thrown into a homeless shelter
and then suddenly all 100 people in
240
00:14:23,028 --> 00:14:26,532
there are sharing the same air
and all getting COVID.
241
00:14:26,599 --> 00:14:30,469
So they said, you know, no evictions
without individual housing.
242
00:14:30,703 --> 00:14:35,107
And then FEMA actually supported
communities in getting those individual
243
00:14:35,107 --> 00:14:40,112
housing units, providing hotel rooms
for people experiencing homelessness.
244
00:14:40,179 --> 00:14:43,515
And we saw that a lot of this myth
245
00:14:43,582 --> 00:14:48,120
of service resistance,
quote unquote, service resistance was just
246
00:14:48,120 --> 00:14:51,991
that was a myth when you are offering
somebody only a congregate shelter
247
00:14:51,991 --> 00:14:55,761
bed in a facility
that doesn't actually meet their needs.
248
00:14:55,861 --> 00:14:57,229
Sure, they're going to refuse that.
249
00:14:57,229 --> 00:15:00,633
But when you offer them a dignified space,
the same as you would want
250
00:15:00,633 --> 00:15:06,639
for yourself or anybody else
in your family with its own locking door
251
00:15:06,805 --> 00:15:12,544
with its own bathroom, then they took it
95% plus at the time, you know.
252
00:15:12,544 --> 00:15:13,712
So it's not that
253
00:15:13,712 --> 00:15:17,449
their service was this and it's
that the services are people are resistant
254
00:15:17,549 --> 00:15:21,086
and all of that really helped
255
00:15:21,153 --> 00:15:24,523
to keep the pandemic from getting worse.
256
00:15:24,590 --> 00:15:29,295
And so we had this this moment,
these models of what we can do
257
00:15:29,295 --> 00:15:34,300
when we realize we're all in it together,
you know, even the Congress can work.
258
00:15:34,400 --> 00:15:39,104
And unfortunately, that's kind of all
faded and we're back to business as usual.
259
00:15:39,204 --> 00:15:42,408
It shows the potential of that
when we have that dialog,
260
00:15:42,408 --> 00:15:43,442
when we respect each other
261
00:15:43,442 --> 00:15:47,813
as human beings, when we understand
that we're all part of the same community,
262
00:15:47,880 --> 00:15:53,018
then we can actually get the solutions
that everybody benefits from.
263
00:15:53,052 --> 00:15:56,221
You're listening to News In Context,
I'm Gina Baleria.
264
00:15:56,388 --> 00:15:58,357
We're talking about housing as a human
right
265
00:15:58,357 --> 00:16:02,294
with Eric Tars, legal director
of the National Homelessness Law Center.
266
00:16:02,328 --> 00:16:03,595
What are some of the legal issues
267
00:16:03,595 --> 00:16:06,966
that you find yourself dealing
with as you navigate this issue?
268
00:16:06,999 --> 00:16:12,705
We are working to defend the rights
of people who are living on the streets
269
00:16:12,705 --> 00:16:17,142
and it is not our goal in this
to defend the right of somebody
270
00:16:17,142 --> 00:16:19,345
to sleep on the street.
So that's not a win for us.
271
00:16:19,345 --> 00:16:20,713
It's not a win for them.
272
00:16:20,713 --> 00:16:22,781
It's not a win for the community.
273
00:16:22,781 --> 00:16:27,186
But the reason that we do this
is that we take
274
00:16:27,252 --> 00:16:31,890
that most politically expedient option
of we'll just criminalize
275
00:16:31,890 --> 00:16:36,729
everybody and push them out of public
sight off the table with one of our cases.
276
00:16:36,795 --> 00:16:40,899
Martin de Boise,
in which the Ninth Circuit recognized
277
00:16:40,899 --> 00:16:44,336
that it's cruel and unusual punishment
under the Eighth Amendment
278
00:16:44,403 --> 00:16:49,375
to punish somebody for unavoidable, life
sustaining conduct
279
00:16:49,408 --> 00:16:53,479
like needing to sleep, needing
to shelter yourself from the elements
280
00:16:53,579 --> 00:16:56,181
in the absence of any alternatives.
281
00:16:56,181 --> 00:16:58,817
And so many communities
282
00:16:58,817 --> 00:17:02,721
signed on to amicus briefs and protested
and said like,
283
00:17:02,855 --> 00:17:08,594
this takes away tools from law enforcement
to deal with homelessness.
284
00:17:08,694 --> 00:17:11,597
It takes away tools from our community
to deal with homelessness.
285
00:17:11,597 --> 00:17:12,431
No, it doesn't.
286
00:17:12,431 --> 00:17:15,067
Law enforcement
shouldn't be dealing with homelessness.
287
00:17:15,067 --> 00:17:16,702
It's exactly the opposite.
288
00:17:16,702 --> 00:17:20,739
We are giving them tools
when those constituents come in to them
289
00:17:20,739 --> 00:17:23,742
and say, There's this encampment
on my corner, I want it gone.
290
00:17:23,809 --> 00:17:25,677
They can say, well, look,
291
00:17:25,677 --> 00:17:30,616
the courts have told us
we can't just simply push those people off
292
00:17:30,616 --> 00:17:33,619
that corner unless we give them some place
better to go.
293
00:17:33,619 --> 00:17:36,789
So let's work together
to find those constructive solutions.
294
00:17:36,789 --> 00:17:42,161
It opens up the ability for dialog
rather than getting the elected officials
295
00:17:42,161 --> 00:17:46,031
and the as a whole siphoned off into this
296
00:17:46,098 --> 00:17:50,202
this negative spiral,
which is where we always seem to end up.
297
00:17:50,302 --> 00:17:53,572
So that's the reason that we bring
these cases.
298
00:17:53,672 --> 00:17:56,608
It's not the end in itself.
299
00:17:56,608 --> 00:18:00,746
It's a tool that we're trying to leverage
300
00:18:00,813 --> 00:18:04,716
in order to have the broader policy dialog
that we need to have.
301
00:18:04,950 --> 00:18:06,418
In some places it's worked.
302
00:18:06,418 --> 00:18:09,621
It's helped to generate
that shift in approach.
303
00:18:09,721 --> 00:18:13,025
In too many other places
like what happened in San Diego,
304
00:18:13,025 --> 00:18:16,261
they just tweaked the words
a little bit here, their lawyers,
305
00:18:16,261 --> 00:18:19,631
lots of money
that could be going to homelessness.
306
00:18:19,698 --> 00:18:24,303
And instead, you know, just try and
find
the constitutional loophole
307
00:18:24,303 --> 00:18:28,173
rather than like
what would actually help in the community.
308
00:18:28,207 --> 00:18:29,441
Yeah, that always fascinates me.
309
00:18:29,441 --> 00:18:33,912
Like so much money is spent to defend
and I'm like, But take that money.
310
00:18:33,946 --> 00:18:36,181
My God, we could just fix it. Yeah.
311
00:18:36,181 --> 00:18:37,015
That always fascinates me.
312
00:18:37,015 --> 00:18:42,521
In Los Angeles one year,
they had a report that out of $100 million
313
00:18:42,654 --> 00:18:47,626
spent to address homelessness,
87 million of it was for law enforcement.
314
00:18:47,626 --> 00:18:49,995
Only 13 million was for the services.
315
00:18:49,995 --> 00:18:54,233
If you flip that, then you actually solve
homeless right in the community.
316
00:18:54,233 --> 00:18:56,301
But they don't. Because?
317
00:18:56,301 --> 00:19:00,072
Because you can hide the costs
of homelessness
318
00:19:00,172 --> 00:19:02,941
in that police budget,
you don't have to acknowledge it.
319
00:19:02,941 --> 00:19:05,777
Whereas for the housing and the services,
320
00:19:05,777 --> 00:19:08,480
you almost always have to acknowledge it
upfront.
321
00:19:08,480 --> 00:19:11,350
We need to bring those costs out
322
00:19:11,350 --> 00:19:14,686
because that's what enables
the true civic dialog to take place.
323
00:19:14,720 --> 00:19:19,358
When you don't have that transparency,
then you are able to have the conversation
324
00:19:19,358 --> 00:19:20,192
that you actually need.
325
00:19:20,192 --> 00:19:22,394
Your San Diego
example, there's the idea of,
326
00:19:22,394 --> 00:19:26,098
you know, the federal government
or the state government will pass a law,
327
00:19:26,165 --> 00:19:30,602
but local agencies are responsible
for implementing it,
328
00:19:30,802 --> 00:19:34,373
and that can be very different right now
in California,
329
00:19:34,373 --> 00:19:35,741
there are two bills
330
00:19:35,741 --> 00:19:39,678
that have been introduced that would
criminalize homelessness statewide,
331
00:19:39,778 --> 00:19:42,514
and they both don't have
332
00:19:42,514 --> 00:19:45,517
any fiscal component to them.
333
00:19:45,517 --> 00:19:47,619
And so often this is what we see.
334
00:19:47,619 --> 00:19:48,887
They'll pass the law.
335
00:19:48,887 --> 00:19:51,990
And in many communities
they have these fiscal sunshine
336
00:19:51,990 --> 00:19:55,260
provisions that say if you need to make
a budget allocation for it
337
00:19:55,327 --> 00:19:58,330
and they all check the box,
no fiscal impact,
338
00:19:58,397 --> 00:20:00,132
nothing could be further from the truth.
339
00:20:00,132 --> 00:20:04,169
It's going to cost 2 to 3 times
more than providing housing would.
340
00:20:04,236 --> 00:20:05,771
But you get to hide that fact.
341
00:20:05,771 --> 00:20:08,307
And that's
why it's so easy to pass these laws.
342
00:20:08,307 --> 00:20:12,211
We talked about earlier the the reptilian
brain and the emotion and the fear.
343
00:20:12,311 --> 00:20:15,781
People who live in the communities
where the house, people
344
00:20:15,781 --> 00:20:16,949
are looking at the house people.
345
00:20:16,949 --> 00:20:19,518
And that perception is real to them,
right?
346
00:20:19,518 --> 00:20:24,056
Like they're not trying to be mean
or whatever they might be scared
347
00:20:24,056 --> 00:20:27,426
that something would happen
no matter how borne out that is or,
348
00:20:27,693 --> 00:20:29,795
you know, factual or not factual,
that may be.
349
00:20:29,795 --> 00:20:33,765
So when people sort of engage
in what used to be called NIMBYism
350
00:20:33,765 --> 00:20:34,933
and now I guess it's,
351
00:20:34,933 --> 00:20:36,635
oh, I want to preserve the character
of my community
352
00:20:36,635 --> 00:20:39,705
or I'm concerned about
crime or whatever it is.
353
00:20:39,805 --> 00:20:41,473
Do you have a response to them?
354
00:20:41,473 --> 00:20:45,477
How do you reframe that narrative
to both address
355
00:20:45,477 --> 00:20:48,747
and acknowledge their concerns
but help bring them along?
356
00:20:48,780 --> 00:20:52,618
What I always read with is we all agree
357
00:20:52,684 --> 00:20:54,987
that people shouldn't be living on
the streets.
358
00:20:54,987 --> 00:20:59,291
It's not safe or healthy
for anybody in the community.
359
00:20:59,324 --> 00:21:03,795
Again, trying to build that sense of
we are all in this
360
00:21:03,895 --> 00:21:07,065
and reframe it as this is about all of us.
361
00:21:07,165 --> 00:21:10,235
We agree that public safety is suffering,
362
00:21:10,235 --> 00:21:13,905
but public safety is not served
363
00:21:14,006 --> 00:21:18,110
by criminalizing people
who are just trying to survive
364
00:21:18,210 --> 00:21:22,014
by compelling law enforcement officers
365
00:21:22,080 --> 00:21:27,219
who aren't trained for crisis intervention
like a social worker
366
00:21:27,219 --> 00:21:32,524
would be to have to go with a sidearm
367
00:21:32,524 --> 00:21:37,296
on their head to threaten to take away is
368
00:21:37,362 --> 00:21:37,896
tense.
369
00:21:37,896 --> 00:21:38,830
They're very shelter.
370
00:21:38,830 --> 00:21:43,035
Again, that base level of your Maslow's
hierarchy, of course,
371
00:21:43,135 --> 00:21:46,905
people are going to react to that threat
to their very survival.
372
00:21:47,005 --> 00:21:52,244
And it's setting the police up for,
you know, the next viral video incident.
373
00:21:52,344 --> 00:21:56,748
And they don't want to be in that position
in Los Angeles with some of these bills
374
00:21:56,748 --> 00:21:57,416
that they're suggesting.
375
00:21:57,416 --> 00:22:00,419
They're saying we don't want to be
in that role.
376
00:22:00,485 --> 00:22:04,323
Stop putting us as the front line
responders to homelessness.
377
00:22:04,323 --> 00:22:08,927
It should be trained outreach workers
who are there
378
00:22:09,027 --> 00:22:12,798
not with sidearm,
but with offers of
services and housing
379
00:22:12,798 --> 00:22:16,768
that people actually need,
building relationships with people.
380
00:22:16,768 --> 00:22:18,704
And that's going to get a way better
response.
381
00:22:18,704 --> 00:22:23,041
And that's, again,
evidence borne out in the communities
382
00:22:23,041 --> 00:22:26,445
that have actually ended
chronic homelessness in this country.
383
00:22:26,545 --> 00:22:29,348
There's dozens of communities
that have ended veterans homelessness
384
00:22:29,348 --> 00:22:31,750
in this country
because they've been provided
385
00:22:31,750 --> 00:22:34,753
with those resources
and with those outreach workers.
386
00:22:34,753 --> 00:22:35,721
We can do this.
387
00:22:35,721 --> 00:22:40,392
We know it's not the homeless services
that are failing to end homelessness.
388
00:22:40,425 --> 00:22:41,993
They know what they're doing.
389
00:22:41,993 --> 00:22:44,363
It's the failure
to give them the resources they need.
390
00:22:44,363 --> 00:22:49,067
And so if we can shift those resources
and say
391
00:22:49,167 --> 00:22:53,038
public safety is not just served
by law enforcement,
392
00:22:53,071 --> 00:22:56,074
public safety is served by
393
00:22:56,208 --> 00:23:00,112
housing people,
it's actually going to cost less.
394
00:23:00,212 --> 00:23:00,645
Public
395
00:23:00,645 --> 00:23:04,049
health, if you're concerned
about the feces on the sidewalk, you know,
396
00:23:04,082 --> 00:23:09,321
nobody waits to see that and nobody likes
to have to go to the bathroom.
397
00:23:09,321 --> 00:23:10,956
But it's incredibly demeaning.
398
00:23:10,956 --> 00:23:13,725
Like we are the wealthiest country
in the world.
399
00:23:13,725 --> 00:23:16,294
We should not have that problem.
400
00:23:16,294 --> 00:23:20,632
So if public health officials
thought that criminalizing people
401
00:23:20,732 --> 00:23:22,534
was the answer,
they would say that. But no.
402
00:23:22,534 --> 00:23:25,537
The American Public Health
Association has said criminalization
403
00:23:25,670 --> 00:23:27,172
is the worst approach.
404
00:23:27,172 --> 00:23:30,809
The public health approach
is, you know, you provide
405
00:23:30,876 --> 00:23:34,446
public bathrooms in place
or you get people into housing.
406
00:23:34,546 --> 00:23:36,782
But one other point on public safety.
407
00:23:36,782 --> 00:23:40,685
There are other studies
that show that in communities
408
00:23:40,685 --> 00:23:46,925
that take this really forceful approach
to enforcement of low level crimes,
409
00:23:46,992 --> 00:23:49,861
the rates of prosecution
410
00:23:49,861 --> 00:23:52,531
of violent crimes actually go down.
411
00:23:52,531 --> 00:23:55,767
So there are fewer
violent criminals being prosecuted
412
00:23:55,767 --> 00:23:59,037
because the courts
and the police are too busy.
413
00:23:59,237 --> 00:24:01,273
So you're not even making the community
safer.
414
00:24:01,273 --> 00:24:08,246
You're making it less safe by focusing on
people just
trying to survive outside.
415
00:24:08,380 --> 00:24:14,486
Like I said, if we can get to the merits
based conversation with people,
416
00:24:14,553 --> 00:24:19,991
then whether you look at it from a fiscal,
a public health or public safety
417
00:24:20,058 --> 00:24:24,463
approach, these constructive approaches
win every time.
418
00:24:24,529 --> 00:24:28,834
But we just have to get
to that conversation in the first place.
419
00:24:28,834 --> 00:24:32,137
Before you came to this work,
you did a lot of international work.
420
00:24:32,137 --> 00:24:36,875
There's any aspect of your international
experience that informs your approaches
421
00:24:36,875 --> 00:24:37,943
and your perspectives.
422
00:24:37,943 --> 00:24:42,180
I came to this work from the international
human rights perspective that housing is
423
00:24:42,180 --> 00:24:46,952
a basic human right, has been working
at the center for the past
424
00:24:47,018 --> 00:24:52,457
1516 years towards that end
and for probably a decade of that
425
00:24:52,457 --> 00:24:56,361
felt like I was banging my head
against a brick wall, but doing a lot of
426
00:24:56,361 --> 00:24:59,664
really great base building work
at the grassroots level went.
427
00:24:59,698 --> 00:25:04,503
I mean, if you talk to a person
experiencing homelessness or somebody
428
00:25:04,569 --> 00:25:09,074
who can't afford their rent
and you tell them housing is your basic
429
00:25:09,074 --> 00:25:14,946
human right as part inherent
in your essential human dignity,
430
00:25:15,013 --> 00:25:17,015
that resonates.
431
00:25:17,015 --> 00:25:21,586
And it changes the perspective from
432
00:25:21,753 --> 00:25:26,191
we need to beg for charity for these basic
human needs to.
433
00:25:26,191 --> 00:25:29,327
We are demanding our rights
from our government
434
00:25:29,327 --> 00:25:32,964
that has a duty to us,
and it is failing in that duty.
435
00:25:32,964 --> 00:25:38,503
It is violating its own obligations
to provide for us, its citizens.
436
00:25:38,737 --> 00:25:40,472
How do you see activity
informing your work?
437
00:25:40,472 --> 00:25:45,577
I think it all has to start
from that very neighborhood level.
438
00:25:45,644 --> 00:25:49,514
We need that sense
that we are all in this together,
439
00:25:49,614 --> 00:25:52,050
that these are our unhoused neighbors.
440
00:25:52,050 --> 00:25:55,587
There was a camp up in Walla Walla,
Washington,
441
00:25:55,654 --> 00:25:58,390
in this kind of city square.
442
00:25:58,390 --> 00:26:01,660
There is a lot more kind of downtown
activity happening,
443
00:26:01,726 --> 00:26:05,163
and they didn't want the people
experiencing homelessness there.
444
00:26:05,163 --> 00:26:08,667
They assumed
they were all transients, nomads,
445
00:26:08,700 --> 00:26:11,703
out-of-towners,
and they just wanted them gone.
446
00:26:11,736 --> 00:26:16,808
But when they did a survey and found out
that 90% of them had lived in Walla
447
00:26:16,808 --> 00:26:22,781
Walla prior to becoming homeless
and 75% of them were actually born there,
448
00:26:22,881 --> 00:26:27,285
it changed the dialog
and they said these aren't,
449
00:26:27,385 --> 00:26:31,323
you know, strangers, these aren't other,
these are us.
450
00:26:31,556 --> 00:26:34,292
These are our people who we have failed.
451
00:26:34,292 --> 00:26:39,864
And so let's look for alternate solutions
other than just locking up our neighbors.
452
00:26:39,931 --> 00:26:42,667
That's where it all has to starts.
453
00:26:42,667 --> 00:26:46,571
And we have to be able to have that dialog
454
00:26:46,638 --> 00:26:49,407
get beyond those fear based responses.
455
00:26:49,407 --> 00:26:51,276
Is there anything else
you want to say that
456
00:26:51,276 --> 00:26:53,211
I didn't ask you
that you think it's important for people
457
00:26:53,211 --> 00:26:58,350
to know the racially disparate impact
of all these policies, whether it's
458
00:26:58,350 --> 00:27:02,320
the lack of affordable housing
or the criminalization of homelessness,
459
00:27:02,387 --> 00:27:05,023
we are all harmed by these things.
460
00:27:05,023 --> 00:27:08,727
But there are some communities
that are harmed more than others.
461
00:27:08,793 --> 00:27:12,631
In some communities,
half the people who are in jail
462
00:27:12,631 --> 00:27:16,101
on any given night
are there because of homelessness.
463
00:27:16,201 --> 00:27:19,571
In San Francisco, there's study done.
464
00:27:19,638 --> 00:27:23,808
African-American homeless
people are ten times more likely
465
00:27:23,808 --> 00:27:27,045
to be charged for these low level
466
00:27:27,145 --> 00:27:30,348
quality of life offenses
than white people.
467
00:27:30,348 --> 00:27:34,452
So each one of those arrests, each
one of those tickets
468
00:27:34,686 --> 00:27:37,856
is an opportunity for police violence.
469
00:27:37,856 --> 00:27:44,229
And so if your issue is police brutality,
if your issue is mass incarceration,
470
00:27:44,295 --> 00:27:48,366
your issue is homelessness
and the criminalization of homelessness.
471
00:27:48,433 --> 00:27:51,236
And the solution to all of this
is housing.
472
00:27:51,236 --> 00:27:55,040
It's true on the racial front,
but also for people
473
00:27:55,140 --> 00:27:58,543
with disabilities,
for the LGBTQ community.
474
00:27:58,710 --> 00:28:01,713
All of these are already marginalized
communities.
475
00:28:01,913 --> 00:28:04,916
That marginalization intersects
with homelessness.
476
00:28:05,150 --> 00:28:08,953
It makes people even more vulnerable
to police violence,
477
00:28:08,953 --> 00:28:14,526
to vigilante violence,
which we see a lot in growing communities.
478
00:28:14,592 --> 00:28:18,396
There's an article that just came out
last week that showed the rate of murder
479
00:28:18,630 --> 00:28:22,667
of people experiencing homelessness
has gone way up over the past few years.
480
00:28:22,667 --> 00:28:27,372
And if we are working towards
a more equitable world,
481
00:28:27,472 --> 00:28:30,041
this has to be part of the conversation.
482
00:28:30,041 --> 00:28:31,109
Thank you to my guest,
483
00:28:31,109 --> 00:28:34,879
Eric Tars, legal director
of the National Homelessness Law Center.
484
00:28:34,979 --> 00:28:37,115
For more information, go to Homeless Law.
485
00:28:37,115 --> 00:28:38,616
Dawg.
486
00:28:38,616 --> 00:28:40,952
This is Civil Week on using context.
487
00:28:40,952 --> 00:28:44,322
Passivity is a culture of deliberately
engaging in relationships
488
00:28:44,322 --> 00:28:47,325
of respect
and empathy with others who are different
489
00:28:47,358 --> 00:28:50,895
moving people from us versus them to
we all belong.
490
00:28:50,995 --> 00:28:54,265
To learn more, go to City Hall
491
00:28:54,332 --> 00:28:55,400
Music in this episode
492
00:28:55,400 --> 00:28:59,270
includes Spring Fling by Track Tribe
and the Heist by Silent Partner.
493
00:28:59,504 --> 00:29:02,941
In addition to hearing News In Context
every Friday at 8:30 a.m.
494
00:29:02,941 --> 00:29:04,008
and 6:30 p.m.
495
00:29:04,008 --> 00:29:07,011
on KSFP 102.5 in San Francisco.
496
00:29:07,245 --> 00:29:10,548
You can hear it on Spotify,
Stitcher, Apple Podcasts.
497
00:29:10,782 --> 00:29:13,017
Iheartmedia Google Play.
498
00:29:13,017 --> 00:29:16,721
Google Podcasts
Pod Bean, YouTube and Pyrex.
499
00:29:16,788 --> 00:29:20,558
We're also on Facebook
and Twitter @newsincontextSF and
500
00:29:20,625 --> 00:29:23,094
on Instagram @newsincontext.
501
00:29:23,094 --> 00:29:26,998
And you can find links to all of that
at newsincontext.net.
502
00:29:27,065 --> 00:29:29,334
I'm Gina Baleria, thank you for listening.