TRANSCRIPCIÓN 🔗
Chris Sarkonak Master Riverside MONO: Orbeyond Grades is supported by Gott Learning. GutLearning is a new type of classroom platform designed to help schools, teachers, and students provide ongoing feedback, facilitate formative assessment, personalize learning, and show growth over time. Students and teachers can send and receive feedback, post video reflections, and scan non-digital learning evidence directly into their learning conversations. Find out more at Gottlearning.com. Quite often in my math classes, I felt good because kids needed me. I felt like I had connection because they kept coming back to me. But the best thing that I could actually do for my students, and I didn't realize this until I saw it, is if I've outlived my usefulness to them. Welcome to the Grow Beyond Grades Podcast. I'm Arthur Caravelli. Today I'm joined by Chris Sarkinek. A physics and mathematics teacher from Manitoba, whose chapter asks a deceptively simple question: what does a grade look like? Chris has spent years experimenting with traditional grading, standards-based grading, portfolios, conferencing, co-constructed criteria, and other approaches designed to give students greater voice in ownership and assessment. Along the way, he began noticing a troubling contradiction. Qualities we say make good scientists. Curiosity, creativity, collaboration, risk-taking, and a willingness to learn from mistakes are often the very qualities our grading systems discourage. Chris's work has recently been recognized with the Prime Minister's Award for Teaching Excellence in STEM and the Robert E. Yeager Foundation Excellence and Teaching Award from the National Science Teaching Association. Here's our conversation. Welcome, Chris. We're excited to have you. Thanks. It's great to be here. looking forward to our conversations. Great to see you again. Your chapter centers on this deceptively simple question: what does a grade look like? When you ask students that question for the first time, what does a grade look like? Or what does an A look like? Or what does this or that grade look like? What do they usually say at first? There's a lot of buildup to it. I think. Students often have this misconception of what grades are that revolves around, you know, this thing that's that's kind of ambiguous. It's kind of gatekeeping their futures a little bit. It they're not really sure where it comes from. you know, and but they they have this innate sense of it too at the same time. Like what should it take to pass? What should it take to do really well in a course? but to build up to that, you know, we I run students through some different exercises and we talk about things like, you know, for the first few days we we do these exercises looking at the nature of science and what science itself is really all about. Then we I get them doing activities. I I don't worry about a course outline on day one. I I want to establish this feel of of this is what learning should be about. And then
Load full transcript
we we develop these scientific skills and scientific ideas and and ways of thinking. And after about a week or so, I get students to turn that on their experiences in education. And so I start asking, well, what is learning? Right? What what are we doing? What are we what are we getting out of courses that are more traditional in different ways? you know, what when you go ahead and you sit down for a a course and and you think about, okay, you're taking a a grade 11, say physics or a grade nine science. what are you hoping to get out of that? Well, what should it be in the real world? And if you look back at courses that you've taken over the years, what are you getting out of those? And so I lead students along this train of thought where, you know, we look at, okay, well, what makes somebody good at science? Right? Like you can you can dream up, you know, a a friend who's really good, or or if you look up to a certain teacher, or if you want it to be like Bill Nye or Neil deGrasse Tyson or whoever comes to mind, right? But somebody you can definitively say is is really good at it, and you can just recognize it, you can see it, you can you can feel it. and so I want students to have that perception in their mind of of what it can look like to be that person who's so engaged and so passionate and so in love with their discipline, and and say, well, what. What makes them that way? What makes them successful in what they're doing? And and students will always come up with things like, you know, passion, curiosity, willing to take risks, you know, all these different things that that I think are are really powerful across all disciplines, right? I I think it doesn't matter if you've got an English classroom, you want the curious and creative kid. You or if you've got the the the phys ed classroom and and you want them to experiment with sport and and stuff like that. those are still tremendous skills that they need to be successful. And and beyond the school system, I mean that's how that's how you make a difference in this world, I think. Right. you know, and I want to foster and encourage that and and get them to realize that that's what they should be getting out of their out of their educations. I love that you're sort of anchoring it in that what are those Mindsets or dispositions that allow scientists to be so successful at what they do? It's it's not timidity. It's not always trying to have the right answer. Yeah. And until you really define what what you want to get out of the course, how do you determine what grades should actually be, what they should look like? And how do you also go ahead and have for me, one of the big things became Has the has the teacher, has the instructor, how do I go ahead and foster these different things in in a way that students can do them safely and not be punished for them the rest of their lives? You know, like I I go ahead and I think back to my early days, you know, over over a 17-year career, I've I've always known something was wrong and I've tried so many different things over the years before I finally, you know, settled onto something that. That really felt right for my students over these last few years. And so, you know, I I remember going ahead and seeing the kid in my math class who went ahead and and was afraid to try something. Yes. And, you know, or or got into their own head because, they they had one bad test and now there's so much pressure to do better on the next one, and so much pressure to do better on the next one that that they get such a tremendous level of anxiety that, you know, they can't. Process when the next test is put in front of them anymore. So then are you getting any sort of real evaluation of their learning anymore? Yeah, there's this fragility. I love what you bring up there, just in terms of even success. Yeah. Creates this, this brittle mindset that I now I just need to keep this up, you know, indefinitely. Yeah. I I think a lot of it actually goes back quite far in my own life to when I was a student. And I I went ahead and and I had the good fortune that, you know, my brain, as I was developing, wired itself in a way I could remember stuff easy. And that often went ahead and resulted in in good grades in school. you know, a lot of stuff that that when we we don't focus on the pedagogy in the right ways, it ends up being that okay, we're we're constantly just checking for knowledge, checking for knowledge. We're not checking to see what we can actually do with that knowledge. and so my own schooling, I was a benefactor of that because I could remember what the my teacher said. I I could close my eyes and reenvision the lesson when I'm sitting there on a test day and I could go ahead and get a really good score on a on a test. and I didn't have to work for it. And and I knew that through that process, I wasn't really getting out of it what I should. And I also knew that what it was creating was it was creating, you know. All these people around me, and I don't think that anyone ever means anything negative by it, but people would call me smart. And I think people only ever mean it as a compliment. But with constantly being called smart, you you start to attach your own identity to that label. And it starts to almost consume your life where you so desperately want to hold on to that label that you do almost anything. And so this pressure starts to mount and you start to to define yourself by it. And and all of a sudden, irrational things start to take over, where you know, a 95 or a 96 is like a slap in the face because it's you're focusing on well, what was that five percent that I did wrong? Rather than wow, that was an amazing accomplishment. And so you start to irrationally build this identity around. Okay, well, anything less than perfection means I'm dumb. And perfection itself is the only way I can maintain that label of smart. And it became deeply unhealthy. And so I I think when it came to the
classroom, you know, I still had pieces of that when I started where, okay, well, if I accepted too much responsibility for for what I was st seeing with student results, well, that would make me. failure. That would make me something that would shatter my self-perception. And so I I tried to develop this this this rationalization to protect myself of okay, well it's just the kids, right? It's not me. I'm a I'm a great teacher. I it's it's the kids. Either they are buying in then they're doing great or they're not buying in and they're doing poor. It's not my fault. And and so you protect yourself, right? Said you were a beneficiary of this. I think at this point, you're not you're not a beneficiary. You never really were a beneficiary of this. Yeah. It really hindered you. Yes. Yeah. And that's what I started to see with my students. And I started to recognize that if I was leading them down the same path that I went down, I wasn't giving them what they needed to actually be successful in life. And at the end of the day, I think that's one of the biggest things that we can give our students is it's not the To be successful in the classroom. I mean, the the the classroom ends at some point for everyone. Yeah. It it's how do you go ahead and help help people become successful in every aspect of their lives for the rest of it? And so when I have these conversations developing this, what does a grade look like at the beginning of the course? And we start talking about learning and what that means, you know, I I ask students, like, okay, well, well, who here typically does well in school? And, you know, You know what? A good handful put up their hands and say, Yeah, okay. And then I say, Okay, well, well, how do you do it? And they'll say, Well, okay, well, you work hard. You study, you do your homework, right? And I say, Okay, well, great. Well, well, how do you study? How do you, how do you prepare? And they say, Okay, well, you know, I'll the day before the test, I'll reread stuff over and over again. Or I'll I'll do practice questions over and over again. Okay, great. And what does that get you? Okay, well, well, I hopefully remember memorize most of it. Okay, great. And then what you how much do you remember the the day of the actual test? And and the kids who taught consider themselves to be these high achievers and do really well at school, you know, they'll put up their hands and say, Yeah, like 90, 95%, like we're good to go, right? And the kids who don't feel that, okay, well, all of a sudden they're like, Well, I'm happy if I could remember half, right? Or hopefully it's the half that's actually on the test. you know, and it starts to they start to realize it's this game of being school savvy and and trying to predict what that teacher's gonna put on to that assessment, more than actually learning the material itself. And and so then the conversation switches over to okay, I I asked them, all right. Well, if I cold called you three weeks later, the exact same test, exact same questions, exact same numbers, how are you all gonna do? And all of a sudden. Most of those high achievers are like, yeah, well, I would have already purged it from my brain by that point. I'd get I'd be lucky to pass. And I say It's part of the mental strategy. Exactly. So then I say, okay, so what have you gotten out of those courses for the last 10, 11, 12 years of your lives? Well, you learn how to take a test. Did did you learn what the intent of the course ever was? Did you learn the skills that are going to last you in the long term? Did you learn how to learn? And And all of a sudden, every student starts to recognize that, okay, well, we we've spent 10, 11, 12 years learning how to take tests, not how to actually be successful in life. And so then I talked to them about how do we rebuild a a program, how do we rebuild our our course in a way that we actually value the things that matter, we focus on the learning, we focus on the risk taking, all those things that You would make a the next Neil deGrasse Tyson or or whoever, how do we go ahead and actually infuse that into the classroom and make the classroom revolve around that goal? I'm wondering as you, you know, experience maybe these slightly more alternative settings, did you run across a student who, when you invited them into this more, I guess you could say, humane? assessment system that valued some of the values of of scientists, like being able to learn from mistakes that you saw them really thrive within this and maybe thrive a little bit more quickly than the students who were used to the traditional approach. Yeah, absolutely. I I mean it's it was something that I started to see success with pretty pretty quickly where where students I still remember during COVID and I was just on the edge of putting these pieces together. And, you know, I was a physics teacher. I'm like, hey, COVID, you know what? In your face, let's go ahead and we can still do physics at home. Dig out your old Hot Wheels. Like, let's let's roll them down a ramp or or whatever. Like, let's figure out a way to still do, still do science around you, right? I didn't, I I didn't want Just go ahead and turn physics into something that I didn't recognize anymore. So I started doing these conferences with students and having these meetings one on one. And and I mean, you know, we didn't go out until mid March or so. And so, you know, we'd already had a a month and a half with with our classes, and and at that time I was still doing quite traditional. And so I'd already had a couple tests and stuff like that. And I remember having a conversation with a student that had a, know, a 90 or 95 in my class. And it was really clear within a couple of minutes that they had learned absolutely nothing about the physics. And they they couldn't piece together the most basic ideas. And and I was like, Well, like, how are you at the grade that you're at right now? And he said, and we we
had the do no h no harm grading where grades couldn't go down because of COVID. So so he was quite emboldened to just go ahead and say, Well, I just memorize whatever you give me and and spit it out on the test and forget it the day after. So I collect my 95 and move on with life. I'm like, okay. I'm like, okay, well, that's that's kind of an interesting way to look at things. and But I remember having this other student who he had about a 60 or 65, I forget. And with COVID, I went ahead and I wanted them doing the science in their home, but I also gave them opportunities to infuse like their passions. And so this one student started to build like this this context-rich problem that was like, you know, you take like four or five different ideas, you blend them together, has almost like clues to lead to a bigger conclusion on this. On this bigger picture problem, right? And and to put that together successfully, you really have to dig in, you really have to understand it. I, it takes a lot of work. And he was also infusing, he had this passion for graphic design that he was bringing into it all as well. And he was trying to make these wonderful visuals for everything. And and he could hold these amazing conversations with me. And I'm like, you know, this inside and out. How are you only at a 60, right? And He went ahead and he just said, Yeah, when a test is put in front of me, I jam up and and I just forget everything. And I'm it it just kind of hit me like a like a punch to the gut. And I'm like, my gosh, like these kids are getting the exact opposite grades of what they should be. you know, and and that kind of dawning realization was was okay, well. Let's flip this around. And so then we started to see more success. And I still remember, like I I've had students that have had severe anxiety issues all of a sudden considered physics classrooms of all places to be their safe space because they felt that they could make mistakes and learn from them. You know, I I physics usually has this quite notorious reputation of of often being the opposite. and so over the years I've taken quite a bit of pride in the fact that that my classroom has been seen as a safe space and more students are going ahead and trying it and aren't afraid to. And I've had English language learners go ahead and tell me that, you know, they've learned more English in my physics classroom than they do in in their language learning classes because they feel like they can take those risks. They can feel like like people aren't gonna judge them. They can feel like they can They can safely put themselves out there. I've had kids with tremendous anxiety that have gone ahead and said that they they don't have it as much in my classroom anymore. I I had a couple of kids who went ahead and they wrote the AP physics exam last last year. And you know what? For them, it was a huge win to sit there for that three hour grueling exam and make it from start to finish. Of your journey that you
describe in the chapter is standards-based grading. Yeah. What did standards-based grading help you see and where did it fall short for you? For me, it's one of those things that I don't regret doing, but with where I'm at now, I would never go back to. Yes. I I went ahead and and it was a tremendous improvement over traditional approaches. And I I think the first time that I went ahead and took a real crack at it, I think was my fourth year as a teacher. And I was teaching some trades maths. And and students there, like the their traditional testing and stuff like that really was not working. It was just it was burying 75% of the class. And it it wasn't giving those kids what they needed at all. And I could have these conversations with them and knew that they were capable of so much more. And so standards-based grading became my first venture into that. And so I started to look at, okay, well, well, how are you outcome by outcome? And so that was really good in giving students clear targets. But it also didn't stop students from gaming that system in that. They could just keep trying to hit those targets over and over and over and over again on repeat until eventually, you know, there were there was a a significant proportion of them in those classes that it it was just fluking into it. They it wasn't repeatable, right? And so they would they would do it over and over, try and look for a pattern or or whatever. And and so I could see that that was happening with the students and I wasn't terribly happy with that, which is why I think I always kept reverting back to traditional and and never really stuck with the the standards based grading. I think I've done it about three or four different times throughout my career. Like I said, like there was still something that the students could gain. On my end, making these repeated assessments over and over again occupied a lot of my time. Marking them over and over again occupied a lot of my time. I I was creating something that for me wasn't sustainable. When it came to the grade, I mean, we still have to go ahead and come up with a a singular number grade in in our province. And we're not allowed a way around that. So, how do you go ahead and take this collection of outcome scores and still turn that into a single thing? So a f a few years ago, when I was looking at at making this shift coming out of COVID. One of the things I had to break down in my own head was was this conception of the grade, right? And how it's almost, you know, this this sank or sank thing that you can't dare touch because there's a calculation going on behind the scenes. masquer it masquerades as this kind of scientific precision. And and as a scientist, you know that that there's There there are a lot of very subjective decisions that are being made in terms of how this gets calculated. Absolutely. And so one of the things that I encountered was I was on our school division's Power School leadership team when that was the LMS
that we were bringing in. And so I got to work with a lot of my colleagues and see how they entered grades into their grade books. And so I created like this mock student that, you know, traditional system, assignments, quizzes, tests, and across a series of chapters and I went ahead and I plunked in some numbers and played around with, okay, well, I remember this teacher had their grade book set up this way. So what would what grade would this kid get? And I remember this teacher had their grade book set up this way and I set up mine this way. So what happens in each of these different classes for this one kid without changing the scores that they got, which which I mean there's over a hundred years of research. I I think you can go back to what is it? Starch and Elliot there back in 1912 talking about how there's no consistency from from one teacher to the next in terms of an individual assessment. But but let's assume that 120 years of research doesn't support that for whatever reason, and and assume that the individual pieces are accurate or at least agreed upon. If two teachers have the exact same course and agree on everything else, how they're gonna mark individual pieces, how they're gonna go ahead and and lay out their course, how they're gonna teach everything pedagogy wise, how they're gonna assess everything, but they don't actually talk about how they enter stuff into their grade books. Well, I I found that you can go ahead and create like a a thirty, thirty five percent spread just based on how the teacher enters it. Yeah. And and I tried that again. Very precise. No, not at all. that's nothing to do with the kid at that point. That is just two different teachers entering in two different ways. And I could take a kid and I think one of the most extremes that I could get without going to like really crazy arbitrary numbers, but like something still realistic, was I could have a kid go from a forty-seven and fail a course all the way up to a seventy-three. And and be you know a little bit shy of honor role. and just based on how the teacher entered the grades. I actually made the mistake of doing that experiment with a class of students once. And my gosh, that did not go well. They yes, they did not like that at all. Let's start getting into the nuts and bolts of your actual system. Can you walk us through what that class period looks like on a on a daily or weekly basis? What what are those structures and how do they function in your class? I would actually recommend that almost no one try to carbon copy me. Like you've got to find your own path and you've got to talk to your students. And that's the part that I believe is is repeatable from one discipline to the next, from one teacher to the next, one school to the next is talk to kids, listen to what they have to say. Actually go ahead and involve them in this process of building something new. use some of what I do to get them on, you know, that right train of thought and and what
it can look like and tear down these old structures, but rebuild it together with them and then be the person that carries their voice forward. students went ahead and said, well, if we're not doing tests, we still need feedback and and we need feedback that we don't just focus on the grade. So ungraded feedback. Okay. Well, if it's in the form of a test, the most common thing that students told me was it's too late. Tests are usually every two to three weeks, sometimes every month. Well, great. That's that's far too long of a time period between when you actually learned it and can do something about it. So it's a postmortem, essentially. It's how do we intervene at the right points in time? And so we have a a quick little weekly assessment piece that it it starts off in grade eleven. It it's very similar to what we've talked about in the course. There's a there's definitely you know, a a bit of comparison to it. But as the program goes on for through grade eleven and grade twelve, it's about okay, by by grade twelve, I'm asking you questions that you've never seen before that maybe take in not just that topic that we've talked about this week, but maybe the previous two or three and blends them into something new. So then you've got something worth solving. You've got real, real problems to tackle, right? But you have to create that scaffolding again throughout the program. And so that weekly piece gives me the opportunity to give them feedback on how their problem-solving approach is going. And it's not all about did they get the right answer? It's about how do they think through that? That's what I'm really trying to go after. It is pieces like that of. How do we get kids to be those problem solvers, be those deep thinkers and risk takers that we want them to be? And so it's all about creating that progression and and that continuum. And so, you know, on a day-to-day basis, you know, in grade 11 at the beginning, it looks very different than by the time they reach grade 12 for me, because they've evolved. So grade 11, yeah, we got some confirmatory guided labs. Yeah, we have weekly check-ins that are. still initially a little bit mimicky at times, but we gotta build that foundation. We start gotta start building something to be able to deviate away from to get them on that right path. by the time they're in grade 12, it's I I give some almost flippant remark about, hey, this would be cool to find an answer to. The funny thing is, is I I get quite often teaching my grade 12s, I get bored because for the most part, they don't need me anymore. And and that's the that's the thing that's been the greatest shift in my thinking as an educator is that the best thing that I could do for them. Quite often in my math classes, you know, I felt good because kids needed me. I felt like I had connection because they kept coming back to me. Right. But the best thing that I could actually do for my students, and I didn't realize this until I saw it, the best thing I can do for them. is if I've outlived my usefulness to them. Because then they are truly ready for whatever they do next. If by the end of my time with them in grade twelve, they don't need me anymore. And I I've hardly had to do any lectures or talking or things like that. I just facilitate labs or facilitate conversations or or give them a little bit of feedback on a weekly check-in. And they know how to rely on each other. They know how to communicate with other people, share ideas, how to accept feedback, how to learn about their own learning and what they need for them to be successful. And they're not relying on me for every little piece of validation. And they're not relying on a grade to tell them whether they're smart enough. Then I've done something right for them. Chris, thank you. So much again for joining me today. Thank you for being part of the book. Really enjoy your chapter and your journey and sharing that with us. Thank you. I appreciate the opportunity. And I'm so excited to see what's next. And I look forward to talking to you again. Is a nonprofit supported by people who believe in this work. Please consider making a one-time or monthly donation through our website. Your support helps us keep these conversations and gatherings going. Thanks for listening. We hope you'll join us for the next episode of Grow Beyond Grades.