TRANSCRIPCIÓN 🔗
Friedemann: I love point and click adventure games. I love Thimbleweed Park, that's probably my favorite for its puzzle design, Monkey Island for being so incredibly hard. I love Grimfandango for the world that it creates, and I love Broken Sword for its story. and machinarium, that's another great one for its humor. as with everything that I do, if I do it a lot, I'll start seeing patterns. I start analyzing how something is made. I get excited about how it's been created and I want to create something like it myself. so it's only natural that the same thing would happen with point and click adventure games. so this is the story of how I designed my point and click adventure game series, Cantaloop, and how it became a best-selling board game that spawned four sequels in total. Is it four? So that's one and two and three and four and multiple smaller versions. That I think it was three or four smaller versions that you can also find online. but more important, I achieved a accomplished a dream of mine, which was to see one of my products being displayed publicly in stores. And I have since seen Cantaloop lying around at a lot of board game stores, at a lot of stores. Talia here in Germany has them lying around, and it just always makes me excited to see them. the story of Cantaloop actually dates back to my university days. back then, I first came up with this as a video game. we had to figure out a project for what we wanted to do. Back then, I was a film and video games music major. So I thought, you know what, I'm gonna make a game myself. I wanna see how the sausage is made. I'm going to lead the production of a video game. And I came up with a story. I wrote the characters and all the lines and all the puzzles and all that stuff. I did basically did all the game design, also did all the music, did all the sound effects, did all the voiceover. So I recorded thousands of lines of dialogue with different actors that I hired, students like me, you know. all people who were just excited to be part of a cool project. And eventually had a a team of about 20 people working under me, all of them for free, all of them just for the excitement of the cause. Unfortunately. It didn't work out. The reason it didn't end up working was because at some point excitement wears off, and it is a long process to make something like this. We've been working on this for three years. And people realized, yes, it's gonna be like this for another three years, probably. Anyway, at some point I was just tired of asking people to stick to their deadlines. And so I canceled the project with the intent of, well, maybe later I'm going to come back to this and finish it. and I got the opportunity a couple of years later when I played the Exit series from Cosmos, which is a very hugely popular series that has won the Spiel des Jahris, right? The biggest board game award in the world. and the Unlock series in particular, which I really loved. but when I played the games, I also
Load full transcript
had a sense of this could really be done better. I'd played a lot of point and clicks at this point. And I'd seen a lot of puzzle games like this, and I could tell that this could be done better. And what I was particularly missing was the non-linearity. These games here are very linear. Now they got better over time, I think, but in the beginning at least, it was always clear which pieces belonged to a puzzle. And so it was always kind of you always had just had to pe put the pieces together, and it was just very clear puzzles that you had to solve sequentially in order to progress. What I love in games is when they just give me a whole bunch of stuff from different puzzles, and I have to figure out which of them I have to solve first, and then I have to find I have to assemble my own pieces myself, and then I have to figure out how do I use that to progress. That is how I experience creativity myself. It's not somebody gives you the pieces and you just have to assemble them. No, the pieces are lying everywhere, and you have to go and find the pieces that match what you're trying to do and assemble them into something meaningful. The other major criticism I had was that I didn't care about the story at all. Like unlocked did it better, I think, but exit? I even stopped reading the texts after a while. I was just reading blah blah blah blah blah blah because I just wanted to finish the game as fast as possible. I love story, right? I love reading good writing. But here it didn't grab me at all. It was just boring cliched stuff of like this crazy scientist locks you in there, whatever. And I don't really give a shit. So I remember sitting on our couch, I don't remember what I was doing at the time, but I thought, exit is this is so cool. I I love this principle. And then I thought back to Cantaloupe And so in what can only be described as a Eureka moment, I only had two of those in my entire life where I really had like everything just I knew exactly what I had to do. I combined those two ideas of, well, let's make this better or more how I want it. And let's take Cantaloop, this old idea that I still have lying around, that's basically finished, and turn that into a finished product. And within seconds, I knew exactly how I was going to do it all. I knew that it was going to be exactly like this. I knew it was going to be. A location on one side, right? And texts on the other. And you would interact with different things on this side with cards. So there's cards in the in the front here, right? the cards are your items, and you hold those against the things in the location. that gives you a code, and then with like a red foil, you would look over here what that gives you, right? That's basically how you progress through the game. And through that you might find another item. That will help you in a different place, or you might be able to s talk to a person that you weren't able to talk to before. That's kind of what I figured, like and it was all there in seconds. I had a meeting with a publisher lined up for another board game that I was working on at the time. And I thought, well, if I'm gonna meet them anyway, let's make a prototype and show it to them and see if they like it. my goal creating this game was to make a nostalgic feeling point and click adventure game that you could play on the train by yourself if you wanted to. some of the things that make it really nostalgic, I think, for point-and-click fans is first of all, there's no rules in the beginning. Usually board games have rules. This one doesn't have rules, it has a tutorial. So you're actually already playing the game, and it's the game is being explained to you. As you go through this little mini story at the beginning. The other thing is, on top of unlocking locations, as you would in any game, you also have dialogues at the end of the book. So whenever you're meeting somebody in one of those locations you just saw, you skip to a dialogue scene at the end of the book and you read through that. So you have these crazy characters. And then the final thing, and this is the big thing I want to be talking about here, which really was the core of my puzzle design. You have a puzzle tree. So Ron Gilbert, who's the godfather of all adventure games, in my opinion at least, he talks about puzzle trees a lot, dependency trees. here's one. this is one of my tattoos here. This is how important it is to me. and that's basically what I talk what I want to talk about in this video, how I designed Cantaloop and how I made it fun. for story driven games, there are essentially four approaches. There is the linear approach, which I'm sure you know from a lot of video games, like say Last of Us, where you have one story and you follow that story in strict order. Exit is a very clear case for this, as is Unlock. Then we have the rubber band idea, which was, I think, first popularized by a game called Heavy Rain. You might also know it from Detroit Become Human. which is the idea that you follow something in strict order, but you get to make some decisions that pull the story a little bit in one direction or another, but the story still follows largely the same beats. And then the third approach is my favorite, which is the nonlinear story. And this is where this puzzle tree comes in. That's what I did for Cantaloop. The fourth one, by the way, is the open world puzzle game, which I don't think exists in board games yet. but there are video games that have done it. blueprints being my absolute favorite. Maybe I should make another video about that at some point, because I do love blueprints. It is just absolutely brilliant. but let's talk about this idea of nonlinear puzzle design and how I how it helped me create this game and make sure that it stays fun, fair, and solvable at all times. So let's explain a little bit more what nonlinear means. Again, linear means you start somewhere and you end somewhere and you solve puzzles in between
to get to the next node. Nonlinear means you have an endpoint that you need to arrive at, but in order to get there, you have to solve a whole bunch of puzzles, and you can essentially solve them in whatever order you want. The tricky part now becomes making sure that all of those puzzles still fit into a coherent story so that all of that still makes sense, even though you might experience it in a completely different order than I might. And so the way you do that is you build a tree like this. This is your puzzle tree, your dependency tree. And so you start with the end goal in mind. You figure out what is going to be the big overarching goal the player is trying to achieve in this game. To give you an example, for the Cantaloupe series, part one is about assembling your crew, part two is about making a plan, and part three is about actually carrying out the heist. From there, you go back one step to the penultimate step and figure out what is the thing that needs to happen or what are the things that need to happen for this to become true. And ideally, you want those to be independent of one another. In book one, for example, you need to find two crew members. So you are playing this guy here, this crook called Hook, and you are trying to get this jazz singer, Alice, and this hacker guy called Fly on board. And both of them, are separate strands, separate paths on this dependency tree. so if this last box here was get a team together, these boxes right before that would be get a hacker and get a woman in red. And from here, you figure out the complications. You ask yourself questions like, well, why can't Alice just join my team? Why can't Fly? Well, because our hacker, Fly, is actually in prison. And our decoy is currently performing on stage and you can't talk to her. So the challenge becomes we have to get the hacker out of prison and we have to get the singer off the stage. And so going back one more step from those intermediate goals, you now arrive at smaller goals. Well, how do you break into prison without the guards noticing? How do you smuggle something in without the guards noticing? How do you get the person out of prison, right? All of those questions that you now have to answer, and all of those are potential puzzles. You wanna block progress behind puzzles. So you don't wanna give a player a chainsaw. That's boring, they can immediately use it to break stuff. You wanna give them an empty chainsaw and they have to figure out where to find fuel. Much more interesting. And what's great about the dependency tree is you can be sure that the player has solved all of your puzzles in order to finish the game. another great thing about the dependency tree is that we can see linearity very quickly. Here, for example, we have two linear puzzles, and it would be great if we could have some more branches coming off of that, some more conditions to fulfill this puzzle right here. ultimately what we're trying to do is build a puzzle world, a world that is filled with puzzles where everything is a potential clue. If you take a look at the second book right here at this location, for example, this is filled with puzzles. This window, this dog, this dead body, this door. This this homeless person over here, this money on the floor, even this graffiti over here, it is all puzzles. Everything is important to solving the game as a whole. And what I love about this is it is completely free form. this has an arrow with a 03. That means you can go from here to the front of the supermarket and continue from here. And you here you can go back to where you just came from, or you go inside, or you just take the map and go somewhere completely different. It is completely up to you where you want to go, and you have access to pretty much everything almost from the start. And that's one of the most fun things for me. It's pure creativity, right? You find something over here and you realize, I know where I can fit this key essentially. And you go back to the other location and you find the door. and of course we don't want to have puzzles like that all the time. Key meets lock is an inherently boring and obvious puzzle. That's what a lot of real world escape rooms do. And I think it's incredibly boring. so I thought a lot about how can I make these puzzles fit into the world of this game. Now it has a cartoony style, but I wanted to make the puzzles semi-realistic. So it is something that could be potentially done in the real world. That's what makes the world believable to the player. I distinguished between two types of puzzles, explicit and implicit puzzles. Explicit puzzles are very straightforward. It's you need to break this person out of prison. How are you going to do it? Right. It's a very clear puzzle. You need to open this door. Where is the key? Or how do you break it open? An implied puzzle might be something where you see something that is interesting. And the question is more it might be interesting to do X. Can you do it? Is there a way to do it? Can you figure out a way to get to this object, for example? So you might come across, you know, a brook, and on the other side is a hammer, and you're thinking, don't. probably want to get that hammer. That seems like a really useful thing to have. Is there a way that I can get to it? I don't actually have to explicitly tell you you need the hammer. No character ever has to tell you that. You can figure that out just from it being there. It probably wouldn't be there if you couldn't somehow get to it. Goal, as I said, is to create a rich world that feels like a normal world. But if you take a closer look, every single thing you can interact with somehow has a meaning, a larger meaning in itself, like a coin, a dog. They can mean different things for this game. And you can use them to unlock new areas and to unlock new cards and items and maybe other things as well. And that to me is the most exciting thing about it is. That's the message I'm
trying to give people with games like that. I think that's what's so excited about Pointed Clicks is that they make you look at the world in a different light. You look at objects, and an object isn't just the thing that it's intended for. It could be used in a number of different ways. You might have heard about that exercise that they give to preschool kids. what are, you know, can you come up with as many uses as you can for a paper clip? And grown-ups think about like, you could staple things together, you could unwind it, you could, you know, clean your teeth with it or whatever. And kids are incredibly good at coming up with uses for paperclips because they think, well, could it be 200 feet tall or whatever? could it be made of gummy bears or whatever it might be, right? And they think more outside the box and they come up with more interesting applications for it. And I think that's what point-of-click adventure games do, is they give you a bunch of objects that seemingly wouldn't ever be used by somebody trying to break into a prison. And they give you the question. How could you use those things in a creative manner to get ahead, to progress in the game? In a way, what you learn with these games is to be a more creative person because you're given these useless things and your goal is to solve problems with them and to see them in a different light in order to solve a problem. that's what creativity is to me. It's solving complex problems with the objects that are in your immediate vicinity. the world around you is filled with puzzles and is filled with wonder that's waiting for you to explore it. That is kind of my message that I want to give people with this board game. What's so amazing about the puzzle tree is that it means you don't just have one note that you have to progress through. to get to the next node. Suddenly you have five nodes open. You can do whichever puzzle you want in whatever order you want. And if you're stuck on one puzzle, that's not a problem because there's four other puzzles you could be solving at any given time. And in the real game, by the way, it's not just this many puzzles, it's more like 50 different puzzles. And the tree is much bigger and much more dense. And that creates a real world that feels very lived in, where you can decide in which order you want to tackle things. And you just continue with whatever is right in front of you and what makes the most sense to you. But it's the basic idea where there's always something to do. If you get stuck, not a problem. what I find wonderful as a designer is I don't even have to tell you what you're supposed to do next. Exit, because of its game design has to tell the player, you're trying to open this door, right? I never have to do that. I just say, here's what you're trying to do at the end. Now go and explore. There's so many puzzles, you'll find something to work on without even knowing sometimes why you're doing something in particular. But the thing will later turn out, okay, I did this because it gave me this, and with this, now I have a new tool that I can use with all the other things in my environment. And maybe I can use it to break open this box, which will allow me to get this, and now with this, I can get on top of this building and whatever it might be. The truly wonderful thing about building a puzzle world like that is that I can basically just drop the player into it. It's a live world. It feels like it's rich with people and actual locations that you can visit. And I can basically just say, go out and explore. You figure out how to solve these problems at the end. It is just like the real world. Nobody's gonna give you very many dis directions. You have to figure out how you're gonna accomplish all of this. And if you go out into the world, In the game or in the real world, right? And you start looking at things as though they might be meaningful and as though they might help you to solve some problems in your life. I think it changes the way you look at the world. And that's what's wonderful about this. In the beginning, it feels very open. You don't really know what you're doing, but slowly but surely you're starting to piece things together. I've seen this over here. I need to pull this nail out of the wall because I need the nail for whatever. I saw the hammer over there on the other side of the brook. Well, how could I get to the? So maybe I'll leave the nail for later and I'll first focus on the hammer, right? And so that's that might be one player, and another player has already found an inflatable raft and they're still trying to figure out how they know they need to get over the river. They haven't figured out what the hammer is for, but they are still trying to figure out how to inflate their raft, right? So everybody goes through this world in a slightly different way. Everybody will eventually solve the same puzzles and get to the same endpoint. but it is a world where players get to explore freely and figure things out at their own pace. One of the great things about working with a physical medium is that it allows you to do a bunch more puzzle types that you wouldn't be able to do on a computer. And so I really tried to go above and beyond with it. exploring that and using the actual medium to to force me to come up with new puzzles. Now, if all of this sounds interesting to you, I would love to do a playthrough of the first Cantaloop game, maybe of the first hour or so, and do a kind of running commentary and explain why I made certain decisions in the game and show you how this works out in practice. if that's something you would like to see, please leave a comment below. And if you learned anything from this, maybe not even for game design, but for something in music or in any other art form, please leave that below as well. I'm always reading your comments and responding. Thank you for watching. Take care.