Breaking Down the Media Statements: Kimmel, Trump, Tylenols Counterpunch

WEBVTT
00:00:00.119 --> 00:00:05.108
Two big stories dropped this week and they both happened at the same time.
00:00:05.108 --> 00:00:11.009
Monday late afternoon 3.44 pm, eastern Daylight Time.
00:00:11.009 --> 00:00:11.771
Just in.
00:00:11.771 --> 00:00:15.762
Jimmy Kimmel to be reinstated after suspension following Charlie Kirk's comments.
00:00:15.762 --> 00:00:18.045
Abc says 3.49,.
00:00:18.045 --> 00:00:22.370
Abc ends Jimmy Kimmel's suspension and his show will return Tuesday.
00:00:22.370 --> 00:00:24.373
4.51 pm.
00:00:24.373 --> 00:00:26.935
Trump's autism announcement is underway.
00:00:26.935 --> 00:00:29.263
4.56, just in.
00:00:29.263 --> 00:00:36.905
Trump suggests Tylenol during pregnancy can contribute to higher autism risk A link experts say is unproven.
00:00:36.905 --> 00:00:41.914
5.01, trump announces FDA recommendations on Tylenol use.
00:00:41.914 --> 00:00:43.323
5.02.
00:00:43.323 --> 00:00:47.142
Maternal Fetal Medicine Group says it's safe to use Tylenol in pregnancy.
00:00:47.142 --> 00:00:54.353
Oh, my goodness, that is whiplash of news stories.
00:00:55.075 --> 00:00:57.165
Hey there, welcome to the PR Breakdown Podcast.
00:00:57.165 --> 00:01:02.381
I'm your host, molly McPherson, and I'm a little unprepared for this podcast.
00:01:02.381 --> 00:01:03.966
I already had something in the can.
00:01:03.966 --> 00:01:08.256
Then the announcement comes from the Walt Disney Company that Jimmy Kimmel is coming back.
00:01:08.256 --> 00:01:13.608
I hopped on social media right away, knowing full well I had to record this podcast.
00:01:13.608 --> 00:01:21.974
And just as I'm recording, I get another notification from the New York Times about what was happening at the White House.
00:01:21.974 --> 00:01:27.361
What was happening at the White House?
00:01:27.361 --> 00:01:30.628
That Donald Trump was making an announcement, with RFK Jr and Dr Oz on either side.
00:01:30.628 --> 00:01:31.790
Is that by design?
00:01:31.790 --> 00:01:34.941
Well, we don't know, but let's look at the evidence.
00:01:34.941 --> 00:01:39.272
Story one the Walt Disney Company and Jimmy Kimmel.
00:01:39.272 --> 00:01:43.251
So let's start with the Disney statement on bringing Kimmel back.
00:01:43.251 --> 00:01:46.822
As you know, quick rewind Last Monday, jimmy Kimmel Live.
00:01:46.822 --> 00:01:50.230
Kimmel reacted to the assassination of a conservative activist, charlie Kirk.
00:01:50.560 --> 00:02:02.546
He had some new lows over the weekend with the MAGA gang desperately trying to characterize this kid who murdered Charlie Kirk as anything other than one of them and doing everything they can to score political points from it.
00:02:02.546 --> 00:02:05.533
You can see how hard the president is taking this.
00:02:06.221 --> 00:02:08.306
My condolences on the loss of your friend Charlie Kirk.
00:02:08.306 --> 00:02:12.448
May I ask sir, personally, how are you holding up over the last day and a half, sir?
00:02:12.448 --> 00:02:13.449
I think very good.
00:02:13.449 --> 00:02:15.804
And by the way, right there you see all the trucks.
00:02:15.804 --> 00:02:19.001
They've just started construction of the new ballroom for the.
00:02:19.020 --> 00:02:19.542
White House.
00:02:19.542 --> 00:02:28.622
Yes, he's at the fourth stage of grief construction he's at the fourth stage of grief construction.
00:02:28.641 --> 00:02:34.213
That clip set everything off because by Wednesday, fcc chair Brendan Carr was publicly threatening ABC's affiliate licenses, nextar and Sinclair.
00:02:34.213 --> 00:02:44.164
Two massive station groups said they'd preempt the show and Disney, abc's parent company, decided to suspend Kimmel indefinitely.
00:02:44.164 --> 00:02:50.788
No surprise, it lit off a firestorm which was leading into the weekend.
00:02:50.788 --> 00:03:10.867
Rhetoric, strong rhetoric against the progressives, the left, liberals, democrats.
00:03:10.867 --> 00:03:15.010
This was a lot of posturing from a political point of view.
00:03:15.010 --> 00:03:26.409
But now we have, on Monday afternoon, disney puts out a statement where it is a complete backtrack on what they did with Jimmy Kimmel.
00:03:26.409 --> 00:03:32.251
Now, before I read the statement, I want to mention that last Friday I did a live on Substack.
00:03:32.251 --> 00:03:40.316
I tend to go on once a week minimum, usually on Fridays sometime in the morning between 9 am and noon, breaking down the big story of the week.
00:03:40.316 --> 00:03:41.046
It's a live chat.
00:03:41.046 --> 00:03:43.557
I want to get other people's opinion on it as well.
00:03:43.557 --> 00:03:46.848
We broke down what was happening with the whole Jimmy Kimmel situation.
00:03:47.368 --> 00:03:55.250
Fcc chair Brendan Carr appeared on another right wing conservative who actually had more subscribers Benny Johnson than Charlie Kirk.
00:03:55.250 --> 00:04:11.389
You could look at his appearance on there and he was, I mean, essentially pressuring these station groups where they own a bunch of affiliates Now the next stars and the Sinclaircasting Companies of the world was trying to acquire Tango, which is another media group.
00:04:11.389 --> 00:04:13.091
So we have business there.
00:04:13.091 --> 00:04:16.252
We have money, which I always say about crisis, it always comes down to money.
00:04:16.252 --> 00:04:41.259
What he had to say with the pressure to these groups, brendan Carr replied back with a gif from the office of Steve Carell and Rainn Wilson's character, kind of like putting their hands up in the air.
00:04:41.259 --> 00:04:45.096
I mean, what a bizarre thing for an FCC chair to write back.
00:04:45.096 --> 00:04:51.706
But the outcry was strong to write back.
00:04:51.706 --> 00:04:58.892
But the outcry was strong and in this live we talked about there's going to be now boycotts against Disney, against Hulu, which was really hard because there's only murders in the building is on, and I love it this season, it's so good.
00:04:59.052 --> 00:05:03.172
But I started reading some of the statements and one of the statements that I read I thought was so good.
00:05:03.172 --> 00:05:04.716
Let me pull a part of it.
00:05:04.716 --> 00:05:10.733
It's from the Writers Guild of America West and the Writers Guild of America East, one of the things that I mentioned.
00:05:10.733 --> 00:05:22.827
I didn't really see it anywhere in commentary or in the news so I could be off base on it, but it feeds into this kind of boycott-itis.
00:05:22.827 --> 00:05:23.209
That's out there.
00:05:23.209 --> 00:05:26.353
What happens when you trigger unions, when you trigger other groups?
00:05:26.353 --> 00:05:32.540
They mobilize and they mobilize together and that pressure builds up and people do things.
00:05:32.540 --> 00:05:34.509
And what do people do now?
00:05:34.509 --> 00:05:42.211
When they boycott and they want to make a stand, they tend to punch where it hurts and that's usually finances.
00:05:42.211 --> 00:05:45.795
So I think finances had something to do with Disney's decision.
00:05:45.795 --> 00:05:49.975
But this is part of the statement by both of these writer guilds.
00:05:50.365 --> 00:05:59.778
Quote as a guild, we stand united in opposition to anyone who uses their power and influence to silence the voices of writers or anyone who speaks in dissent.
00:05:59.778 --> 00:06:06.572
If free speech applied only to ideas we like, we needn't have bothered to write it into the Constitution.
00:06:06.572 --> 00:06:14.872
What we have signed on to, painful as it may seem, painful as it may be at times, is the freeing agreement to disagree.
00:06:14.872 --> 00:06:18.158
Wow, I stated on that live.
00:06:18.158 --> 00:06:20.209
That's an excellent statement.
00:06:20.209 --> 00:06:25.610
It was so good and it's not surprising because it's from the Writers Guild, it's from writers.
00:06:25.930 --> 00:06:33.596
But day by day, the buildup started happening on social media and I think the Walt Disney Company started to feel the pressure.
00:06:33.596 --> 00:06:38.899
Big names out there started to speak out against it as well.
00:06:38.899 --> 00:06:42.997
So now that leads us to the Walt Disney.
00:06:42.997 --> 00:06:46.312
When the notification appeared on my computer that ABC made this statement.
00:06:46.312 --> 00:06:48.098
I immediately looked for the statement.
00:06:48.098 --> 00:06:55.149
I wanted to read it right away and then hop on social media, because that first reading is where I get the gist of the statement.
00:06:55.149 --> 00:06:57.074
You can get the intent behind the statement.
00:06:57.074 --> 00:07:00.971
So I didn't want to read it or analyze it before I went on social media.
00:07:00.971 --> 00:07:04.165
So my social media response was really like a real response.
00:07:04.165 --> 00:07:14.040
I'm going to quickly read the statement and then let's look at some of the words that they used to see if that can help us discern what's really going on behind the scenes.
00:07:14.040 --> 00:07:20.797
So this statement was released by the Walt Disney Company late on Monday, september 22nd.
00:07:20.817 --> 00:07:30.646
In the afternoon Last Wednesday we made the decision to suspend production on the show to avoid further inflaming a tense situation at an emotional moment for our country.
00:07:30.646 --> 00:07:36.108
It is a decision we made because we felt some of the comments were ill-timed and thus insensitive.
00:07:36.108 --> 00:07:45.517
We have spent the last days having thoughtful conversations with Jimmy and after those conversations we reached the decision to return the show on Tuesday.
00:07:45.517 --> 00:08:06.872
Now Disney did not say whether all ABC affiliates were going to bring back the show, because some of them balked about carrying Jimmy Kimmel live last week Sinclair that is, the broadcast group came out and said that they were going to air the Charlie Kirk memorial special on Friday and they flip-flopped and aired Celebrity Family Feud instead.
00:08:06.872 --> 00:08:12.461
So, in the theme of flip-flopping, let's break down this statement.
00:08:12.461 --> 00:08:22.435
So let's start with what they wrote at the beginning Quote to avoid further inflaming a tense situation at an emotional moment for our country that's deflection.
00:08:22.755 --> 00:08:27.552
The problem wasn't Jimmy's words, they're saying, it was the national mood.
00:08:27.552 --> 00:08:30.538
The responsibility was spread outward.
00:08:30.538 --> 00:08:32.369
So don't look inward to us.
00:08:32.369 --> 00:08:33.914
We didn't do anything wrong.
00:08:33.914 --> 00:08:35.380
We didn't make a decision.
00:08:35.380 --> 00:08:42.518
We were just reacting to what was happening in the country, to the mood, and the mood, my dear listener, was created by you.
00:08:42.518 --> 00:08:44.206
It's their way of saying.
00:08:44.206 --> 00:08:45.509
It's your fault.
00:08:45.509 --> 00:08:47.471
You are part of the problem.
00:08:47.712 --> 00:08:52.980
Another part of the statement we felt some of the comments were ill-timed and thus insensitive.
00:08:52.980 --> 00:09:01.293
Notice the hedging Not wrong, not misleading, not blasphemous, just ill-timed.
00:09:01.293 --> 00:09:07.827
Wow, that's minimizing, shrinking the offense down to optics.
00:09:07.827 --> 00:09:14.326
Ill-timed makes it sound like it was a calendar mistake or when we ran it on the show.
00:09:14.326 --> 00:09:16.889
And what is the right time?
00:09:16.889 --> 00:09:22.139
Like would Jimmy Kimmel be okay if he did it on Tuesday night or Wednesday night?
00:09:22.139 --> 00:09:24.409
And then to call it only insensitive?
00:09:24.409 --> 00:09:25.412
Their choice.
00:09:25.852 --> 00:09:29.669
Abc, disney's choice to pull Kimmel created a firestorm.
00:09:29.669 --> 00:09:38.047
A firestorm is created over something that was just quote insensitive from late night television Wow, wow.
00:09:38.047 --> 00:09:50.254
Then, once they suspended him and they bring him back in under a week and this took place due to quote thoughtful conversations Can you imagine what those thoughtful conversations were like?
00:09:50.254 --> 00:09:52.895
I can imagine that, jimmy Kimmel.
00:09:52.895 --> 00:10:04.621
I saw Howard Stern make a comment on the air saying that he did not speak to Jimmy Kimmel about any of this, but he gave his opinion where he said I immediately canceled Disney Plus in support of Jimmy Kimmel.
00:10:04.621 --> 00:10:06.846
He and Jimmy Kimmel are really, really tight.
00:10:06.846 --> 00:10:09.577
So Howard Stern is going to defend Jimmy Kimmel.
00:10:09.577 --> 00:10:18.729
But also, howard Stern was speaking from a place where he had pressure over the years, not so much recently, but back in his heyday, back in the 90s.
00:10:18.729 --> 00:10:20.674
He was at war with the FCC.
00:10:20.674 --> 00:10:27.509
So he's the perfect foil for the government to come out and speak out again.
00:10:27.528 --> 00:10:33.139
But this statement is really a wishy-washy, deflection, flip-flop statement.
00:10:33.139 --> 00:10:37.376
Either the suspension was an overreaction or the reinstatement was a retreat.
00:10:37.376 --> 00:10:38.951
Both can't be true.
00:10:38.951 --> 00:10:42.072
And Disney used we again and again.
00:10:42.072 --> 00:10:43.466
We made the decision.
00:10:43.466 --> 00:10:46.110
We felt we reached a decision.
00:10:46.110 --> 00:10:48.075
That's corporate fog.
00:10:48.075 --> 00:10:51.186
It hides who actually made the decision.
00:10:51.186 --> 00:10:56.258
There's no name attached to this statement from the Walt Disney Company.
00:10:56.258 --> 00:11:01.768
The only name mentioned is Kimmel, and not even Jimmy Kimmel or Jimmy Kimmel Live.
00:11:01.768 --> 00:11:02.969
They just say Jimmy.
00:11:02.969 --> 00:11:05.210
So this Kimmel statement wasn't about clarity.
00:11:05.210 --> 00:11:15.657
It was about optics, buying time and protecting the brand under political fire and also under financial pressure.
00:11:15.657 --> 00:11:17.398
Trump and Tylenol.
00:11:17.398 --> 00:11:20.539
Donald Trump speaking in the Roosevelt Room of the White House.
00:11:20.539 --> 00:11:32.599
He was flanked by Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F Kennedy Jr and Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services Administrator, dr Mehmet Oz, to make this announcement.
00:11:32.804 --> 00:11:56.937
First, effective immediately, the FDA will be notifying physicians that the use of acetaminophen, which is basically commonly known as Tylenol, during pregnancy can be associated with a very increased risk of autism.
00:11:56.937 --> 00:11:59.671
So taking Tylenol is not good.
00:11:59.671 --> 00:12:01.556
I'll say it it's not good.
00:12:01.556 --> 00:12:02.037
Did you notice how?
00:12:02.057 --> 00:12:02.518
he struggled there.
00:12:02.518 --> 00:12:03.299
That's why I think he defaulted.
00:12:03.299 --> 00:12:04.121
Taking Tylenol is not good.
00:12:04.121 --> 00:12:05.164
All right, I'll say it, it's not good.
00:12:05.164 --> 00:12:06.866
Did you notice how he struggled there?
00:12:06.866 --> 00:12:07.808
That's why I think he defaulted to Tylenol.
00:12:07.808 --> 00:12:15.394
It's a lot easier for him to say but that's alarmist framing Strong words, very increased risk, not good with no scientific consensus backing it up.
00:12:15.835 --> 00:12:16.736
He even admitted.
00:12:16.736 --> 00:12:19.970
You know, I'm just making these statements for me, I'm not making them from these doctors.
00:12:20.370 --> 00:12:22.774
That's not careful public health messaging.
00:12:22.774 --> 00:12:26.419
That's a politician freelancing with people's medical choices.
00:12:26.419 --> 00:12:32.802
And then he pivoted into vaccines, of course because RFK Jr standing there calling for smaller doses over the years.
00:12:32.802 --> 00:12:35.043
Again, no evidence cited.
00:12:35.043 --> 00:12:36.350
It's a rhetorical move.
00:12:36.350 --> 00:12:44.251
Stoke fear connected to a broader narrative and let the soundbite live online where it goes in direct contrast.
00:12:44.251 --> 00:12:49.528
And it's fighting for airtime and headline space with the Jimmy Kimmel announcement.
00:12:49.528 --> 00:13:02.759
He wants it to cover the Kimmel announcement, the effect Panic among expecting mothers, confusion in the medical community and dangerous undermining of trust in safe medications.
00:13:03.206 --> 00:13:07.761
And personally I don't like this fear-mongering around a diagnosis of autism.
00:13:07.761 --> 00:13:10.208
There are plenty of people living with autism.
00:13:10.208 --> 00:13:11.953
There are plenty of people on the spectrum.
00:13:11.953 --> 00:13:15.331
There are plenty of places on the spectrum where autism lies.
00:13:15.331 --> 00:13:21.591
We're labeling it as a problem and we're labeling people with autism, kids with autism.
00:13:21.591 --> 00:13:24.490
Why are we painting them as such problems?
00:13:24.490 --> 00:13:26.215
I mean, yes, it's understandable.
00:13:26.215 --> 00:13:28.246
It's something that we want to understand more.
00:13:28.246 --> 00:13:31.173
We want to get closer to how we can work with it.
00:13:31.173 --> 00:13:33.886
So babies aren't born with this challenge.
00:13:33.886 --> 00:13:36.773
So we understand what's behind autism.
00:13:36.773 --> 00:13:41.673
But it's so dangerous when we make it seem like it's just this awful, awful thing.
00:13:41.673 --> 00:13:43.249
I have a nephew who has autism.
00:13:43.249 --> 00:13:55.289
But if I were a parent right now with a child with autism, I would be picking up the phone and calling them and talking to them and telling them that you're perfect, you're perfect, there is nothing wrong with you.
00:13:55.289 --> 00:14:01.535
There is no reason why we needed a statement from the Roosevelt Room about something that you deal with in your life.
00:14:01.535 --> 00:14:04.815
I don't like it, but that's my take, that's my Molly take.
00:14:04.815 --> 00:14:07.815
But then here's the third response Tylenol.
00:14:08.205 --> 00:14:10.913
The parent company Kenview, responded quickly.
00:14:10.913 --> 00:14:17.217
Quote independent sound science clearly shows that taking acetaminophen does not cause autism.
00:14:17.217 --> 00:14:20.416
We strongly disagree with any suggestion otherwise.
00:14:20.416 --> 00:14:26.573
Woof, that's the corporate counterpunch Straightforward denial grounded in scientific consensus.
00:14:26.573 --> 00:14:28.138
They went further.
00:14:28.138 --> 00:14:31.736
Acetamiophen is the safest pain reliever for pregnant women.
00:14:31.736 --> 00:14:38.052
Without it, women face dangerous choices, suffer through fever or use riskier alternatives.
00:14:38.413 --> 00:14:42.200
Bam, this is what Disney's statement lacked directness.
00:14:42.200 --> 00:14:47.692
Tylenol acknowledged the stakes, emphasized evidence and outlined the risks of ignoring science.
00:14:47.692 --> 00:14:55.073
It's not perfect PR After all, they are protecting their product, of course but it's anchored in data and clarity.
00:14:55.073 --> 00:14:56.770
Now, they knew this was coming.
00:14:56.770 --> 00:15:04.195
There was an announcement this morning that President Trump would be making a statement, so I think he was just waiting for it to be timed.
00:15:04.195 --> 00:15:07.288
But this was a statement that came with a punch.
00:15:07.788 --> 00:15:09.874
Now, if we line them up and compare them.
00:15:09.874 --> 00:15:16.130
The Disney statement it's very vague, defensive, hiding between we Trump.
00:15:16.130 --> 00:15:25.107
Trump statement alarmistist, unsourced, emotional, designed for headlines, not accuracy, designed for distraction.
00:15:25.107 --> 00:15:31.427
And Tylenol Firm, evidence-based, corrective, anchored in research and patient safety.
00:15:31.427 --> 00:15:33.813
What do they have in common?
00:15:33.813 --> 00:15:38.585
All three are less about truth than about control.
00:15:38.585 --> 00:15:41.173
Some of the statements have truth in there.
00:15:41.173 --> 00:15:49.217
Tylenol was backing it with data, but they needed to control the messaging because their stock plunged.
00:15:49.217 --> 00:15:55.136
So, yes, kimmel is back and, yes, tylenol is fighting to defend itself against presidential claims.
00:15:55.136 --> 00:15:56.769
But here's the real through line.
00:15:56.769 --> 00:15:58.375
We're watching a test in credibility.
00:15:58.375 --> 00:15:58.777
Who do you believe?
00:15:58.777 --> 00:15:59.259
Do you believe networks?
00:15:59.259 --> 00:16:00.484
Do you believe you believe?
00:16:00.484 --> 00:16:01.485
Do you believe networks?
00:16:01.485 --> 00:16:02.548
Do you believe the president?
00:16:02.548 --> 00:16:03.832
Do you believe scientists?
00:16:03.832 --> 00:16:08.890
Because in all the story, the stakes are the same Trust.
00:16:08.890 --> 00:16:11.235
That's all for this week on the podcast.
00:16:11.235 --> 00:16:12.948
Thanks so much for listening.
00:16:12.948 --> 00:16:14.235
Does your head hurt?
00:16:14.235 --> 00:16:15.120
Mine does.
00:16:15.120 --> 00:16:16.288
Bye, for now.