BBC Best Bits | Ep 7 | What We Get Wrong About Leaders

We keep throwing people into leadership roles and hoping they figure it out. Unfortunately, they often don't.

In this best-bits episode of Building Better Cultures we look back to Episodes 48 and 49. We hear from Jamie Heaslip about the leadership gap, and how we still promote people without equipping them. And we hear from Zoe Routh about the craft of asking versus commanding.

Jamie Heaslip starts with the unglamorous fundamentals: what actually forms a team is trust, accountability, healthy conflict and a shared view of results, and none of it works without psychological safety. His point is that safety and accountability aren't opposites. You need people safe enough to try things and fall short, and then honest enough to own the outcome on Monday morning. He's good on the contrast between sport and business too. In rugby the scoreboard arrives every weekend and the review follows immediately, while in business the equivalent feedback can be a quarter away, which is precisely why the best leaders don't wait for it. They're checking in weekly, agreeing what the shared goal is, and making it safe to say something didn't work. He finishes with a story about an injection moulding company making parts for defibrillators, and the question that reframes an ordinary job: think about the lives potentially saved because you did your work well, or the lives lost if you hadn't.

Zoe Routh picks up what happens to people at the moment of promotion. You go from autonomy and expertise, where you knew exactly what good looked like, to a role where people start knocking on your door, and the sheer volume of interruption feels like it's getting in the way of the job. So people retreat to the tools, back to the craft they're good at. Her correction is the heart of the episode: the people stuff isn't what's stopping you doing the real work, it is the real work. Coaching people to higher levels and helping them become leaders themselves is the job description now. And she names the structural problem behind all of it, that we hand out leadership roles on the basis of seniority and years served rather than fit, because most organisations still don't offer a credible specialist track alongside a people-leader track. She closes on the consequence: a genuine crisis of trust in leadership, where institutions are rarely seen as both competent and ethical at the same time.

The common thread? Being brilliant at the job is not the same as being ready to lead people doing it, and nobody is served by pretending otherwise.

• Trust, accountability, healthy conflict and results are the fundamentals. They sound obvious, which is exactly why they get skipped.

• Psychological safety and accountability go together. People need to feel safe enough to try something and get it wrong, and grown-up enough to own the outcome afterwards.

• Sport gets a scoreboard every week, business often doesn't. That's an argument for checking in more often, not for waiting until the quarter closes.

• Good leaders agree the shared goal out loud. If everyone can name what we're going after together, challenging each other stops feeling personal.

• Pace matters across a season. You can't have your foot to the floor all year, so decide deliberately where the peaks are.

• Twenty or thirty goals means no goals. Direction comes from a small number of things and a clear sense of purpose behind them.

• Purpose is usually hiding in plain sight. Even a component in a factory can be the difference between a life saved and a life lost, if someone connects the work to the outcome.

• The interruptions are the job now. The instinct to retreat to the tools you're expert in is understandable, and it's the thing that stops people becoming leaders.

• The real work of leadership is growing other people. Coaching your team to higher levels, and to lead themselves, is the priority, not the thing you fit around the priority.

• We promote on seniority and service, not readiness. People end up in leadership roles because they've been there longest, rather than because it suits them or they've been equipped for it.

• Organisations need two credible career tracks. Without a specialist route that's genuinely recognised and rewarded, becoming a people leader is the only way to progress, and that serves nobody.

• Trust in leadership is the thing actually in crisis. Being seen as competent and being seen as ethical are different tests, and institutions rarely pass both.

00:00 – Introduction: we throw people into leadership roles and hope 00:29 – Jamie Heaslip: the fundamentals of what forms a team 01:15 – Accountability when the scoreboard arrives every weekend 01:35 – Psychological safety, and making it safe to try things 01:55 – Pacing a season, and choosing where the peaks are 02:55 – Why the best business leaders don't wait for quarterly results 03:15 – Shared goals, challenging each other, and learning when it doesn't work 04:35 – Why thirty goals means no goals 05:29 – Defibrillator parts, and finding the purpose in the work 06:04 – Zoe Routh: when the people stuff feels like it's getting in the way 06:24 – The shock of the door starting to knock 06:44 – Retreating to the tools you're good at 07:04 – The people stuff is the real work of leadership 09:16 – Why we throw people into leadership roles 09:36 – The missing specialist career track 11:12 – The crisis of trust in leadership 12:14 – Competent or ethical, and why institutions rarely manage both 12:49 – Wrap-up

EP048 – Jamie Heaslip: 48 | Tips on leadership and purpose from an Irish rugby legend | Podcasts EP049 – Zoe Routh: 49 | How to help your teams work better together | Podcasts

LinkedIn | YouTube | Instagram

Connect with Scott McInnes: LinkedIn

leadership, leadership development, first time managers, promotion, career paths, coaching, psychological safety, accountability, trust, high performance, teams, workplace culture, sport and business, purpose, employee engagement, internal communications, Jamie Heaslip, Zoe Routh, Scott McInnes, Building Better Cultures, Inspiring Change, best bits, podcast compilation