WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.180 --> 00:00:11.860
Geek Out with Matt Navara is sponsored by Pinterest. Inspire your audience and grow your company on Pinterest with a free business account. Learn more at business.pinterest.com. It's time to Geek Out.
2
00:00:12.139 --> 00:00:27.860
[upbeat music] Hello, and welcome to Geek Out with Matt Navara, sponsored by Pinterest. I am Matt Navara. And I'm Martin SFP Bryant.
3
00:00:28.100 --> 00:00:38.560
Now, one of the platforms we talk about most on this show is Instagram. So this week, we're delighted to be joined by someone who's better placed than most to give us an insider's view. That is right. I'm very excited.
4
00:00:38.600 --> 00:00:47.640
It's Vishal Shah, who's Instagram's head of product, and we've got loads of questions to put to him shortly, and I think there's even some from people who've listened to last week's show knowing he was coming on.
5
00:00:48.060 --> 00:00:58.860
So don't forget, you can always get in touch with us on Twitter. You can find me there as @MattNavara. And I'm @MartinSFP. So Matt, what have you been up to this week? It's been a weird week this week.
6
00:00:58.920 --> 00:01:03.820
It's a funny, funny one. [laughs] Um, so I've started off the week with a sim- my kids wanted me to get an Xbox.
7
00:01:03.840 --> 00:01:09.910
They've been pestering me for ages, and I was, like, resisting 'cause I'm conscious that the Xbox is now at the end of its life cycle, and- Mm...
8
00:01:09.940 --> 00:01:15.650
they're gonna replace it shortly, and I thought, "This is not a good tech investment." I was too geeky about it. I wasn't thinking- [laughs]... kid.
9
00:01:15.680 --> 00:01:23.950
So I, uh, I gave in, and I got myself, uh, uh, one of the Xboxes, and, uh, it's been good. So that's great. I also started watching Mr. Robot finally. It was, um- Mm...
10
00:01:23.980 --> 00:01:32.080
something that I remember when I was at South By, um, a good few years ago, and they had an activation going on when they launched the show, and I thought it might be my cup of tea.
11
00:01:32.100 --> 00:01:40.120
But somehow, for two years or however long it's been out, I haven't managed to get down to doing that, to watching. Yeah, that was freaky, wasn't it? A few years ago, I think th- they had, like, a big Mr.
12
00:01:40.180 --> 00:01:41.460
Robot fairground, didn't they?
13
00:01:41.500 --> 00:01:54.000
The year before, it might have been, um, when they first were launching the first season, they had these weird guys in black hoodies walking around the streets of Austin, uh, with that, with very little explanation, and that, that was real- [laughs] That was a bit freaky, that.
14
00:01:54.110 --> 00:02:00.520
It was. Well, I, I keep on meaning to watch it, and someone suggested it to me last week that, you know, "Have you watched it yet?" And I thought, "Oh, yes, I'm gonna watch it."
15
00:02:00.540 --> 00:02:07.300
And I've watched the first two or three episodes of season one, so I'm way behind the world on this, um, and very much enjoying it. So that was good.
16
00:02:07.420 --> 00:02:18.000
Uh, and then I did some tweets this week that kinda went nuts 'cause I tweeted about the change in the, or the, the feature that might be coming soon that we discussed in the last episode of the podcast for Twitter, where they're looking at controlling...
17
00:02:18.040 --> 00:02:22.640
You can set controls over who can see your tweets and who can reply, sorry, who can reply to your tweets.
18
00:02:23.100 --> 00:02:32.790
Um, and that tweet ended up going out and getting sort of tens of thousands of likes and comments and things, so it's destroyed my Twitter notifications thread. It still doesn't work with the ability to- [laughs]...
19
00:02:32.790 --> 00:02:42.040
filter verified. It didn't help at all. Oh, the pains of being popular. [laughs] I know. Well, I, I wish I had more of those tweets 'cause they're fun, but they also destroy your, your notifications box.
20
00:02:42.060 --> 00:02:48.740
But, um, in terms of another weird thing, Mark Zuckerberg replied to me, which was, uh, a curious one. Ooh. So I say Mark Zuckerberg.
21
00:02:48.840 --> 00:02:56.200
I think we all, um, in the geek circle know that it's not probably him that's doing this. His team have been responding on behalf of him on his account.
22
00:02:56.540 --> 00:03:20.280
But I, uh, I was asking him about his thread that he, or post he did last week, uh, around the future of, of Facebook and its responsibilities and his plans for the next year and things, and I sort of suggested how could he be thinking about the future and dealing with the future stuff that they want to develop and innovate when they've still got a lot of problems that are existing from tech that they've released in the previous 10 years that they've yet to find solutions to, or they're still causing problems.
23
00:03:20.680 --> 00:03:29.700
So he responded, and then of course, Facebook was then, uh, pretty much unusable for notifications anyway for a good three or four days. But, um- [laughs]... yeah, it was a busy week. How about you?
24
00:03:30.400 --> 00:03:37.700
Uh, well, uh, uh, the couple of things that were probably most, uh, interesting, uh, and fun were, um, I did a bit of media interview work.
25
00:03:37.780 --> 00:03:47.020
So I, I was on BBC Breakfast talking about, uh, Windows 7 and Microsoft ending support for that. So if you've got Windows 7, uh, you're out of luck if, uh, you get any bugs or anything.
26
00:03:47.080 --> 00:03:48.900
And, uh, so I was doing an explainer on that.
27
00:03:48.940 --> 00:03:57.740
And normally, if you're on a breakfast TV, you have to wait in the morning for a taxi at, uh, an ungodly hour of the morning, and then, uh, you, you get in there early, and they put makeup on.
28
00:03:57.900 --> 00:04:05.500
Um, and, uh, you go and do it live. And then for the rest of the day, you've got this lovely sheen of makeup on your face, and, um, [laughs] it, it's actually really, really nice.
29
00:04:05.640 --> 00:04:10.070
It's, it helps you feel a bit more confident about the day. Um, but- I tell you what. On, on that point, quick, funny story. Yeah?
30
00:04:10.080 --> 00:04:18.860
I ha- I should say, I did exactly the same as you did with a BBC Breakfast thing where it was in Manchester up in your neck of the woods, and, uh, I got into the... First time I'd ever done it.
31
00:04:18.940 --> 00:04:23.620
They did all the whole hair and makeup thing, so it was all quite fun and exciting but at the same time, a bit kind of weird.
32
00:04:24.010 --> 00:04:36.160
And then I got straight out of the studio, and I had to get back on the train to come back here to Bristol and Cardiff area, and, and throughout my train journey, three or four different people I'd never met just s- stopped me and just said, "You've got amazing eyes.
33
00:04:36.190 --> 00:04:42.300
You've got really lovely eyes. You look-" [laughs] And I was like, "Oh, thank you very much." Yeah, I thought this train, the northerners really are very friendly.
34
00:04:42.670 --> 00:04:47.440
[laughs] And then suddenly, um, I went through, and I went to the bathroom on the train, and I looked in the mirror. I was like, "Oh."
35
00:04:47.560 --> 00:04:57.160
And I looked like I had so much makeup on, but you could still look like my eyes were just popping with- [laughs]... the color of the blue against the sheen color of the makeup. So- Oh... that was my makeup story.
36
00:04:57.220 --> 00:05:05.870
But, uh, so it's much more convenient to do what I did this week, which is go in in the afternoon and pre-record an interview, which was really nice and, uh, civilized, except they don't put makeup on. Ah.
37
00:05:05.920 --> 00:05:13.000
So I, I, I saw myself on [laughs] TV. This is very vain, but I saw myself on TV, and I thought, "I look really rough", but, uh- [laughs]... there we go.
38
00:05:13.400 --> 00:05:24.140
Um, uh, and I did actually encourage, uh, somebody who saw it, who was on Windows Vista still, in a Windows Vista computer. Jesus. I managed to convince them to, uh, to get a, a Chromebook actually, so there you go.
39
00:05:24.320 --> 00:05:38.290
Um, and, uh, and then the other thing I did was I went and did a radio interview where I think I probably ac- accidentally set off a load of, uh, Amazon Echos by giving an Alexa command as an example on the radio after I said, "I'm not going to do this 'cause it will set off all your Alexas".
40
00:05:38.540 --> 00:05:45.360
I then completely accidentally set off an Alexa com- uh, uh, command, um, and, uh, who knows what happened, but, uh, hopefully nothing. [laughs] You should've gone rogue.
41
00:05:45.420 --> 00:05:53.170
You should've gone rogue and done something like, "Alexa, find me", and then something really X-rated- [laughs]... and then people with children would be going like, "No, stop, Alexa. Stop, stop." Um, but anyway.
42
00:05:53.170 --> 00:06:01.780
We're gonna have to edit this because you just said, "Find me something X-rated", and, uh, who knows what, uh, what people's Echos will do if, uh, if they're listening to the podcast. [laughs] Oh, damn.
43
00:06:01.880 --> 00:06:07.540
Oh, sorry about that. So what's been going on in the news this week, Martin? What have you got for us? Okay.
44
00:06:07.620 --> 00:06:17.480
Well, uh, our first story might sound familiar because it's a story that is as old as the oldest social media news story you can imagine.
45
00:06:17.820 --> 00:06:22.340
Um, Twitter's Jack Dorsey on the edit button, "We'll probably never do it", he says.
46
00:06:22.540 --> 00:06:31.560
Yes, he's done a video Q&A with Wired, and, uh, one of the questions he was asked was inevitably about the edit button, and he was talking about it, and he basically said, "We'll never do it."
47
00:06:31.760 --> 00:06:42.060
But he was, "Uh, we'll probably never do it." So there's still, if you're an edit button fan, there's still a chance. He said probably, not certainly, but to me it just feels like, make your mind up.
48
00:06:42.320 --> 00:06:44.000
[laughs] Don't you think? Yeah.
49
00:06:44.060 --> 00:06:53.840
Well, they're just- they're leaving that little door open partly for fun, I guess, but also 'cause, you know, they never wanna say anything concrete about something that could change, of course, like that, which, um, y- you know, they may change their minds on it.
50
00:06:53.860 --> 00:07:05.600
But for me, I'm, overall I'm pretty happy with that because I don't particularly like the idea of having a full-scale edit tweet button. I could probably tolerate and understand the value of a, a typo correction thing.
51
00:07:06.060 --> 00:07:13.780
Um, but I'm- but I did take great glee yesterday when tweeting out that it was basically dead and it's, it's never gonna happen. [laughs] That was, that was one of my favorite moments this week.
52
00:07:14.210 --> 00:07:25.560
Uh, what else is happening? Uh, so TikTok, uh, has, uh, s- something that, uh, might change the feel of the app a little bit. They're exploring the idea of a curated content feed, uh, to lure advertisers.
53
00:07:25.590 --> 00:07:27.870
So this was a, uh, a story from the Financial Times.
54
00:07:28.370 --> 00:07:45.100
Uh, so, uh, basically the, the higher quality stuff from creators, but also stuff from brands would have its own dedicated feed, with the idea being that if you're an advertiser, you don't want to be in the, the main algorithmic feed of TikTok because you don't know what you might end up advertising next to.
55
00:07:45.500 --> 00:07:55.860
So if you're in a, a high quality, this is the, uh, the, the handpicked stuff kind of feed, then you're more likely to want to spend big bucks with, uh, TikTok. Do you think this is a good idea, Matt?
56
00:07:56.160 --> 00:07:57.540
Um, I think it's a natural progression.
57
00:07:57.600 --> 00:08:08.560
I, I can imagine that's where it would think it would, it would go or wants to go, and, and why the people would assume that's the way it would go, um, given that, you know, Snapchat has gone through that life cycle and explored that as well.
58
00:08:08.680 --> 00:08:13.800
And, and it, it, it makes sense in so many ways that I, I can't see it not happening really.
59
00:08:14.200 --> 00:08:20.780
Um, and, uh, it's just a case really it's gonna have like t- little mini shows that they're gonna produce or they're gonna outsource it to others.
60
00:08:20.880 --> 00:08:29.440
Um, how much, you know, cut they're gonna give on those, and then all the questions about what sort of content will actually be handpicked and some of it will it be using the algorithm combined with some curation.
61
00:08:29.500 --> 00:08:37.020
Who knows? But, um, but yeah, no, very interesting one, but one that I think is a, a natural progression that was inevitable. Yeah. TikTok growing up a little bit, I think there.
62
00:08:37.080 --> 00:08:44.040
We, uh, also heard the news this week of a, uh, Facebook bug that exposed the anonymous admins of pages.
63
00:08:44.300 --> 00:08:57.200
So this was, uh, a bug that was discovered, and, uh, it was, uh, being shared around on, a lot on places like, uh, 4chan, where people had discovered that you could, uh, find out who was the admin, the anonymous admin, uh, of a page.
64
00:08:57.240 --> 00:09:00.460
And so that meant that you could see who the admin was for, say, celebrities' pages.
65
00:09:00.720 --> 00:09:15.750
But there was also potentially problems around maybe more, uh, you know, where, where there were maybe admins of groups, uh, of pages where, you know, they, they didn't want any, any kind of publicity for maybe safety reasons, and, uh, they were maybe getting exposed.
66
00:09:15.990 --> 00:09:19.020
Uh, it was, it was fixed quickly, but, uh, what did you make of this, Matt?
67
00:09:19.060 --> 00:09:31.380
Well, I was, when I saw the list of names of, uh, accounts that had gone round 4chan and, uh, so say, revealing the, some of the page admins, um, the first name that stuck out to me, being from Bristol myself was, was Banksy, and I was thinking, "Oh, is there something in there?
68
00:09:31.400 --> 00:09:36.580
It's not gonna be him, but maybe there's something in there that's kind of like leads us to the mystery of, of Banksy."
69
00:09:36.680 --> 00:09:46.400
But, uh, no, it was some guy with a very, um, normal, regular name that I have no idea that was in New York, so it doesn't really have much- Oh... not unless we think- If only, if only it was 3D from Massive Attack.
70
00:09:46.520 --> 00:09:51.500
[laughs] Oh. Yeah, I mean- That theory would be proven at last. [laughs] I, I just think all this sort of stuff, you know, it, it could have been worse.
71
00:09:51.560 --> 00:09:56.340
It could have been a lot worse given what Facebook's, um, been up to over the years and what they've been accused of and what they have been doing.
72
00:09:56.440 --> 00:10:09.700
Um, but at the same time, i- i- in all seriousness, yeah, that could have, um, been a problem for, for certain people, and I'm sure the people that's had, um, themselves in the news, I think Greta Thunberg was one of them, uh, can't, uh, appreciate Facebook's efforts here at all, really.
73
00:10:09.780 --> 00:10:24.100
Yeah. Well, I, I think it's a reminder that anything on the internet is, uh, liable to being, uh, exposed unexpectedly, and, uh, anything private we put up online, uh, has that risk attached to it. Exactly. Good words.
74
00:10:24.500 --> 00:10:34.680
We'll be speaking to Instagram's head of product, Vishal Shah, in just a moment, but first... Geek Out with Matt Navara is sponsored by Pinterest, and each week we share tips to help you make the most of the platform.
75
00:10:34.690 --> 00:10:43.140
Now, Pinterest has launched Pinterest Academy, a series of free online courses covering topics like creative strategy, campaign optimization, and more.
76
00:10:43.160 --> 00:10:51.640
For example, when it comes to creative strategy, Pinterest is a visual platform, so design plays a significant role in the success of content from brands, publishers, and creators.
77
00:10:52.000 --> 00:11:03.480
The first step in creating successful pins is to make sure they stand out. Here are three tips to get the most out of your organic and promoted content on Pinterest. Number one, use compelling eye-catching imagery.
78
00:11:03.540 --> 00:11:14.380
Lifestyle images are often more effective than product shots. Two, make your pins vertical. 85% of Pinterest's users are on mobile, meaning that your content should be optimized for mobile space.
79
00:11:14.840 --> 00:11:24.840
And three, think beyond static imagery. Video and story pins are new formats on Pinterest that are great for how-tos, storytelling, and showcasing a product in use.
80
00:11:25.140 --> 00:11:36.680
So if you want to find success on Pinterest and grow your brand, Pinterest Academy has nine courses with more information for you to explore. Head to pinterestacademy.com to create the perfect lesson plan for your goals.
81
00:11:37.370 --> 00:11:50.400
So our guest this week is in charge of a product that is many people's favorite social media tool and product, so it's, his job must be fascinating, full of interesting challenges, and I'm very, uh, excited to be able to introduce, uh, Vishal Shah, Instagram's head of product.
82
00:11:50.920 --> 00:11:56.680
Uh, thank you so much for having me. It's a pleasure to be here. No worries. We've, we've been trying to, um, get somebody from Instagram to come on.
83
00:11:56.740 --> 00:12:05.520
We've had so many questions, uh, through, uh, the Facebook group about it and, uh, and other places, so it's great now to finally be able to chat to you a bit about what you do and, and how you do it.
84
00:12:05.800 --> 00:12:12.620
And I think the, the first question is probably most useful to our audience is what is a head of product, and what does it do at, at Instagram anyway?
85
00:12:13.100 --> 00:12:18.772
Well, that's a, that's a really good question, uh, 'cause I think that, that- job has really evolved as the platform has evolved.
86
00:12:18.852 --> 00:12:27.132
So I actually joined Instagram about five years ago, uh, to help build the ads business, uh, on the product side. So I have a background in, in programmatic advertising.
87
00:12:27.212 --> 00:12:31.392
I spent 10 years, uh, at a startup, mostly on the engineering side before coming here.
88
00:12:31.472 --> 00:12:51.372
And I, I came to Instagram to think about how to build an ads business that put people first and advertisers second, and to think about if we took a longer term view in what it meant to value what we're, value we're creating for advertisers, but really thinking about the experience that people are having, could we build a better, uh, online advertising platform?
89
00:12:51.552 --> 00:13:02.492
And by using the infrastructure that we had here at Facebook and thinking about all the leverage we get there, uh, but thinking about how that applies to the Instagram ecosystem was a really interesting opportunity kind of to think about.
90
00:13:02.572 --> 00:13:08.712
But at the time, we were, you know, less than, uh, a couple hundred people, uh, at Instagram. The product team was relatively small.
91
00:13:09.252 --> 00:13:12.572
Uh, and so really it was about making sure we're making those individual day-to-day decisions.
92
00:13:12.732 --> 00:13:46.071
Uh, now, you know, at, at our scale of a billion plus people using Instagram, thinking about how we keep the app simple while we build, uh, while we think about how to empower engineers and product designers and researchers and data scientists to think about how best to do their job, my role now is to think about how to best set the organization up for success to make the decisions that stays true to our values of simplicity and craft and putting people first, uh, but not actually being involved in every single product decision because that, uh, simply wouldn't scale, uh, at the, at the scale we are today.
93
00:13:46.392 --> 00:13:46.892
I can imagine.
94
00:13:46.912 --> 00:13:58.602
And I, and I guess what, what would be interesting for me as well is, is how does that role fit in with where, where Adam, who's, you know, in charge of Instagram, Adam Mosery, where does that sort of fit and how, what, what's your kind of interaction on a kind of day-to-day, week-to-week basis with him?
95
00:13:59.072 --> 00:14:05.532
Well, we certainly, uh, have to work very closely together. Adam, uh, you know, his responsibility is to think about Instagram as a whole.
96
00:14:05.572 --> 00:14:21.592
Now, we are a product-driven organization, so much of what we talk about and discuss are things about product and strategy, but Adam also thinks about, uh, the business holistically and our teams internationally and the work we do, uh, to support the ecosystem even outside of the product.
97
00:14:21.612 --> 00:14:37.312
And so, uh, while certainly we have to be very aligned on the type of product strategic investments that we're going to be making, some of our bigger bets and where they might be heading, uh, he also relies on me to help think about the direction of the product to execute on it, but also think about the health of the team.
98
00:14:37.872 --> 00:14:55.142
Uh, and I think so much of running an organization at scale is, uh, ensuring people are getting the support they need, both from a career and mentorship perspective, but also thinking about new opportunities for people, maybe even in different locations as we expand, you know, outside of just California from a development perspective, which we can, we can certainly talk about.
99
00:14:55.192 --> 00:15:00.332
Uh, so it's about thinking about the organization, the health of the organization in addition to the, the strategy around the product. Got you.
100
00:15:00.352 --> 00:15:07.512
And I guess more importantly, who does the best Instagram stories, you or Adam? Who's, who's winning on that front at the moment? I mean, you know, it's really not a comparison.
101
00:15:07.582 --> 00:15:15.652
[laughs] Adam tries his best, but, uh, I have to say I have the upper hand on that one. You do. Uh, yeah, you know, Adam's getting good though. His game's going good at the moment, so, uh, he's pretty cool.
102
00:15:15.692 --> 00:15:25.382
Um- Yeah, it's fun. It's fun [laughs] Yeah. So we're at, we're at the start of a, a new year, and, uh, what are your product priorities for the year ahead? It's, it's a, a good time to reflect.
103
00:15:25.452 --> 00:15:33.032
You know, at the beginning of the year, it's thinking about what happened the previous year. I think it was a big year of change for Instagram, uh, for a variety of reasons.
104
00:15:33.042 --> 00:15:41.052
N- new leadership team, thinking about, you know, scale at which we're operating, uh, how we think about the responsibilities we have in terms of building for a community of a billion.
105
00:15:41.432 --> 00:15:49.932
Uh, so we have four priority areas, and I'll give you a quick, um, synopsis of each of them, uh, and then we're happy to go into any more detail, uh, as, as it makes sense.
106
00:15:49.992 --> 00:16:01.972
So first and foremost, we think about how we can keep the platform a place that is safe for people, where they feel supported, where they feel safe to express themselves, because we believe the heart of ex- of Instagram is expression.
107
00:16:02.472 --> 00:16:08.652
And if people cannot express themselves in a comfortable, safe way, uh, then the, the sort of core of the platform is really at risk.
108
00:16:08.692 --> 00:16:29.632
And so, so much of the work we do is both on the sort of, let's call it defensive side, which is making sure we keep, uh, you know, content that is against our policies, for example, off the platform, but also thinking about the, the more, um, uh, offensive work that we're doing, for example, to, to fight online bullying and to think about the mental health of, of people using our platform.
109
00:16:29.712 --> 00:16:37.852
So there's a lot of work there around safety and, and wellbeing. Uh, the second area for us is, uh, helping people connect with the people that they love.
110
00:16:38.032 --> 00:16:49.672
And so if the heart of Instagram is expression, you would love when you come to Instagram, the reason you open the platform on a regular basis is because you wanna know what your closest friends are up to, what your family is up to.
111
00:16:49.712 --> 00:16:56.852
And you know, that evolves with your age group. Maybe when you're a little bit younger, it's about your friends at school, it's the people you spend time with at school.
112
00:16:56.972 --> 00:17:03.912
Um, but maybe as you get older, it's your, it's your family, it's the people you live with. And so that, there's an evolution there certainly in terms of the people that people care the most about.
113
00:17:03.952 --> 00:17:12.201
But if you come to Instagram and you aren't able to really deeply understand and, and feel connected to the people you care about, then the product is not as retentive.
114
00:17:12.722 --> 00:17:19.772
Um, but once we do have people coming to Instagram for that core use case, they stay, uh, to connect with their interests.
115
00:17:19.962 --> 00:17:33.362
And that's really, uh, the third area of priority for us, which is, you know, how do you, uh, connect with that business or that creator, or how do you shop from them, or how do you think about the, the long form video that they're creating?
116
00:17:33.362 --> 00:17:43.412
And so a lot of the more recent experiences that we've built, not just in our, in our new investments, uh, but even in things like s- uh, search and explore, really thinking about going deep with, with your interests across Instagram.
117
00:17:43.422 --> 00:17:49.552
And as a platform that's visual in nature, um, and has an asymmetric follow graph, you know, that's a really natural place for interests to live.
118
00:17:49.592 --> 00:17:58.632
And we're seeing that not only something that we need to invest in more, but really a, a, a cornerstone of how people think of, of the platform. Uh, and the last one, uh, is really about helping
119
00:17:59.732 --> 00:18:06.592
people turn their passion or their hobby or their interest into a business, and to make a living, uh, on the platform.
120
00:18:06.612 --> 00:18:33.592
And I, I call that out as a specific priority because it's not just the business that we're building, uh, in terms of what we're doing in, in ads, but helping small businesses, helping creators, you know, really embracing the secular shift that we're seeing from big organizations with lots of, of tools at their disposal to the individual, you know, hobbyist in their garage who has a, a thing that they care about and can turn that passion, turn that excitement, uh, into, into a living for themselves.
121
00:18:34.284 --> 00:18:39.164
It's such a, such a complicated product. Not in a, not in a bad way, but it's such a, an involved product now.
122
00:18:39.204 --> 00:18:48.644
If you think about back to the, uh, the days of a simple photo sharing app, uh, uh, 10 years ago, and now you've got this, uh, uh, this, this enormously well-developed platform.
123
00:18:48.674 --> 00:18:58.284
And sometimes I think it's, it's, it's, it's easy to forget just how much there is packed into that app. Yeah. That is a, that is a really good observation, but also a bit by design.
124
00:18:58.384 --> 00:19:04.784
So I mentioned earlier our values and, and I'll come back to them as we talk because it's so central to how we build.
125
00:19:04.844 --> 00:19:10.444
So one of those values is, um, simplicity, and there's a couple of different ways to look at simplicity.
126
00:19:10.544 --> 00:19:32.684
One is we believe very strongly that Instagram should feel like one product, not a series of products stitched together into a container, which means that we will often make product decisions that are actually suboptimal for any one product, but the right decision for Instagram as a whole because we value how the whole thing feels, uh, whether that's from a design systems perspective or even from a feature perspective.
127
00:19:32.764 --> 00:19:36.924
So there's a lot of thought that goes into making sure the, the whole app feels cohesive.
128
00:19:37.464 --> 00:19:44.124
Um, but the second is as we're adding new use cases, new reasons for people to use Instagram, uh, we have to stay true to the core.
129
00:19:44.524 --> 00:19:54.444
And as I mentioned before, the core's expression, it's about connecting with the people you care the most about, and we will make sure that that stays front and center in the experience, whether that's in, in feed, or in stories, or in some of the sharing flows.
130
00:19:54.904 --> 00:19:57.764
Uh, that has to be at the center of, of what people do.
131
00:19:58.344 --> 00:20:17.464
But then if the additional experience that people then come to Instagram for, whether that's video, or shopping, or interests, um, are things that they would like to opt into, we would want to make that easy for them to get to, but we don't want that to dominate the experience if that's not what they want, which I know is a very subtle, uh, kind of line that we're trying to, to weave.
132
00:20:17.604 --> 00:20:20.664
Um, but it's a really important part of how we think about building the app as a whole.
133
00:20:20.864 --> 00:20:37.564
And how, how do you make the decision on what, what stays as, as part of the app, as the main part of the, the core Inst- Instagram experience and what you siphon off it into its own separate app, that decision of whether you have a pr- you know, um, just a messaging app, which I know you've experimented with and withdrawn, and now you're experimenting it in, in direct, uh, messages and things on, on the web.
134
00:20:37.904 --> 00:20:44.544
You know, how do you choose to keep it in the app or to, to create a new one? Well, so I think there's two different, uh, two different considerations.
135
00:20:44.704 --> 00:20:53.554
One is inside the main app, how do you think about the core experience, the thing that people spend the majority of their time, uh, using because it is what the app opens to, right?
136
00:20:53.584 --> 00:21:04.964
The fact that it opens to your home experience, which is feed and stories, sort of sets the tone for what the app is for. And then where do we think about things that go into the explore tab or into search?
137
00:21:05.284 --> 00:21:13.084
You know, there's a, there's some considerations there about simplicity and making sure that that feels really easy, but we wanna make sure that that core home experience feels, um, really cohesive.
138
00:21:13.724 --> 00:21:31.684
Then there's the question of, as you mentioned, separate apps, which I think, um, uh, it's kind of this interesting evolution, I think, for how people think about apps, where, you know, apps are very much like spaces and people associate jobs, use cases, things that they do with a space.
139
00:21:31.764 --> 00:21:43.494
You know, you go to an office, you go to a restaurant, you go to a bar, and there's a set of norms associated with those spaces. There's the mental kind of, uh, expectation of what you get when you go into that space.
140
00:21:44.024 --> 00:21:49.644
Um, and so that's like the, the sort of physical equivalent, but there's also the, the physics of a separate app on your phone.
141
00:21:50.144 --> 00:21:58.044
Uh, if you're sending a lot of push notifications, uh, from one app, that is now maybe in contrast with how people tend to think about that app, for example, with messaging.
142
00:21:58.444 --> 00:22:03.484
You really wanna make sure that you can reach someone, and so me- push messaging and push notifications are incredibly important.
143
00:22:04.064 --> 00:22:09.404
Um, but if you take something like Threads, which is our, our standalone app that, uh, we are, we are testing for messaging,
144
00:22:10.324 --> 00:22:15.984
you know that when you get a push notification from Threads, it is going to be from one of your close friends.
145
00:22:16.304 --> 00:22:22.584
And so you know when you see that push notification that it is from someone that you have determined is important to you.
146
00:22:22.704 --> 00:22:28.244
And it's actually, if you think about it from that perspective, the only messaging app that you get to decide who gets to reach you.
147
00:22:28.624 --> 00:22:45.464
Because it sits on top of the Instagram network, all of the reachability and findability behavior exists in the core app, but the sh- the sort of siphoned off messaging experience that's limited to your close friends gets to play in this very separate space, which when you go back to the, the space analogy, means that when you open it, you kind of know what you're gonna get.
148
00:22:45.964 --> 00:22:53.913
And, and how is Threads doing? And what can you tell us about that at the moment? 'Cause I, I think people know, or some people know that it's out there, and it's being tested, and the, um, the basics of how it works.
149
00:22:53.983 --> 00:23:02.924
But, uh, can you give us any update on that? It's, it's going well in the sense that, you know, we put apps out there sometimes to learn about how people use them and, and we take different approaches.
150
00:23:02.964 --> 00:23:09.964
In some cases, we will market them very heavily and, and want to get as many people using it as possible 'cause that's what matters. Uh, with Threads, we actually took a different approach.
151
00:23:10.024 --> 00:23:21.644
We, we haven't done a lot of, uh, proactive marketing or, or even, um, you know, upsells inside the product to get people to try it, and we're really trying to understand for the people who do find it, who do use it, how they're using it.
152
00:23:22.024 --> 00:23:32.204
Uh, and so while it's a little bit too early to give any definitive, uh, you know, data on that, uh, we're pleased to see where things are, are going because it, because it's really focused on these three areas that we were trying to differentiate Threads on.
153
00:23:32.344 --> 00:23:37.384
One of which I just talked about around close friends and having that sense of control over who shows up in that space.
154
00:23:37.904 --> 00:23:46.964
Um, the other is around, um, really fast and quick performance and the idea of the app being very simple, that it is, is very, um, kind of devoid of clutter.
155
00:23:47.384 --> 00:23:50.804
Uh, not just from an experience perspective, but even from an app performance perspective.
156
00:23:50.844 --> 00:24:00.564
We want it to, to open very quickly, to get to the camera very quickly, and the team actually spent a lot of time, uh, working on the underlying infrastructure for the camera to make sure that it can open as, as quickly as possible.
157
00:24:01.164 --> 00:24:10.324
Uh, and the third is an, a kind of a newer area that we're exploring, which is how do you think about if it's a place for your closest friends, what are the types of things that would inspire a conversation?
158
00:24:10.744 --> 00:24:25.444
Uh, and that's where you've seen some of the work we've done in Status, which is, uh, is it helpful to know that a friend of yours is traveling or, or even outside of their home, or that their phone is, is charging and so you might know that they're not reachable right now because they're probably not with their device?
159
00:24:25.484 --> 00:24:34.844
There's like things like that that we're trying to understand, you know, what are ways in which, again, because it's limited to your closest friends, what are the types of things that are a bit more asynchronous but would inspire a conversation?
160
00:24:34.864 --> 00:24:38.284
Those are the types of things that we're, that we're really excited about to learn more about how people use in Threads.
161
00:24:39.360 --> 00:24:51.240
I got this vision of, uh, and of you guys in a room and having all the data and all the things about what people's been testing and what things you've been trying out to see what works, and having you on one side of the table and a team of other people battling it and saying, "That one's dead.
162
00:24:51.300 --> 00:24:59.360
We're gonna kill that feature." W- it, does it come to it in the end where you kind of, there is kind of some tough decisions and is about kind of getting a m- a majority consensus?
163
00:24:59.420 --> 00:25:04.290
How do you kind of come to that final decision? Yeah, I think there's no sort of set rule for that.
164
00:25:04.400 --> 00:25:14.310
Certainly, there are conversations around, uh, you know, what, what is in and what's out, and some of it, frankly, you know, is subjective. There is this, this sense of what it means to make a call on something.
165
00:25:14.340 --> 00:25:23.600
And maybe you don't have perfect data. If you have perfect data, then maybe you waited too long to make a decision. Um, but also just where, you know, strategically we- we're heading. I... Here's the fun thing. I,
166
00:25:24.540 --> 00:25:30.770
I feel like, and you, you sort of started the podcast with, you know, how, how interesting could this job be thinking about Instagram as a whole.
167
00:25:31.170 --> 00:25:40.440
And I feel very lucky to have surrounded myself with really incredible product thinkers who get to explore in these spaces and, and ensure that we are building towards value for people.
168
00:25:40.490 --> 00:25:48.760
And we might make decisions to, you know, shut something down, not because, um, it wasn't useful, but actually is, is detracting from a, a value perspective.
169
00:25:48.840 --> 00:26:03.840
So, you know, we've been really diligent in this last year about kicking off something that I call, um, unship, uh, which is very counterintuitive, especially for, for people who, who are, you know, used to technology companies just always shipping new things.
170
00:26:03.860 --> 00:26:12.680
It's very easy for an engineer or for a product manager or for a designer to celebrate shipping a product into a, into the world. It is not very common to celebrate unshipping something.
171
00:26:13.180 --> 00:26:23.280
And knowing that by removing a, a feature or a product, you're actually making the overall experience better, and we're trying to set a culture where that is celebrated just as much as shipping the thing in the first place.
172
00:26:23.380 --> 00:26:28.340
Um, and again, back to the idea of keeping Instagram really simple, and, and we've done a few of those, you know, this year.
173
00:26:28.400 --> 00:26:37.600
But I wanted to sort of make sure that that was clear, is the reason we do that is because we value the simplicity of the product so much that we want to celebrate unship just as much as shipping in the first place.
174
00:26:37.740 --> 00:26:46.100
And d- d- does it make any difference if there's millions of your users that are out there saying that they really want something changed on Instagram, it's driving them nuts, and they're really fed up with it and stuff?
175
00:26:46.160 --> 00:26:49.109
Does that kind of sway on any of your decision-making in this process?
176
00:26:49.480 --> 00:26:58.320
Well, I mean, I'd be, you know, I think I'd be lying if I said that we don't listen to all kinds of feedback, whether that's, uh, individual research that we do with people. I mean, we certainly read the media.
177
00:26:58.360 --> 00:27:06.880
I've, I've listened to your podcast, and I know you guys have chatted about Instagram a, a fair amount, and that's important input into the process. But, uh, that's just one of the factors that we think about.
178
00:27:06.940 --> 00:27:17.820
So as an example, uh, we recently sh- unshipped, uh, the Following tab inside the Activity feed. I know you guys actually discussed this on the podcast a couple of months ago. Mm. Um, and we did that for a few reasons.
179
00:27:18.180 --> 00:27:25.100
One, uh, it was, while it was used by, you know, an... It was not an insignificant percentage of, of our pro- of the, of the user base.
180
00:27:25.480 --> 00:27:35.889
The, the research we had done and the reason people were using it was for two reasons. One was to discover new accounts and to find new places, uh, of Instagram that they maybe didn't know about.
181
00:27:36.310 --> 00:27:50.360
And given that the Following tab was launched almost nine years ago, there's a lot of work that we've done to improve that use case in places like Search and Explore and in some of our rec- recommendation surfaces that we think are far more personalized and do a better job of account discovery.
182
00:27:51.080 --> 00:27:59.660
But the second is that people were using it to sort of see what their friends were up to or doing, or even if the people they didn't know directly, but the, you know, the creators and the public figures that they followed.
183
00:28:00.120 --> 00:28:08.120
And, and lots of people didn't know that their consumption behavior, their likes, their comments, their follows were being surfaced in this way.
184
00:28:08.660 --> 00:28:27.920
And so it was both a simplicity win to remove something that was not used by a lot of people, but also, uh, aligned with the, the safety and, and kinda comfort that we want to make sure that people on Instagram have, where it doesn't feel like your behavior is always on display and that you have to worry about liking something and that someone coming and figuring out what you, what you've liked.
185
00:28:27.960 --> 00:28:30.280
And so there's a lot of different drivers here.
186
00:28:30.360 --> 00:28:40.280
Um, you know, we, we try to keep a balance between what we hear, but also know that sometimes what you hear is what people want you to hear, not necessarily what their underlying kind of core motivation is.
187
00:28:40.820 --> 00:28:47.940
Uh, and, and [laughs] I'm sure you have some examples of, of questions like that that we can also talk about. Yeah, I will do. I'm, I'm, I've got a couple of things at the end that I'll come back to.
188
00:28:47.960 --> 00:28:52.380
We've got some audience, uh, listeners who've wanted to ask you some things, so we'll, we'll jump into some of those.
189
00:28:52.460 --> 00:29:07.360
But, but talking about removing things, it, uh, one of the things that everyone's been talking about in the last few months with Instagram or about Instagram is the removal of the like counter, um, and, uh, and how that's been played out in terms of it's, you know, been tested in various countries, and it's still being tested.
190
00:29:07.400 --> 00:29:21.380
And I think I saw a, an Instagram story from, from Adam saying something along the lines of, uh, that it, you know, you're hoping later this year to, to roll it out, which is, or something along those lines, which suggested maybe that it's, it seems likely that it will be rolled out permanently globally.
191
00:29:21.800 --> 00:29:27.760
Um, can you give us an update on where it is and, and what that's, what's it changed about how people are using the app? Yeah, ab- absolutely.
192
00:29:27.780 --> 00:29:32.260
And, and, you know, I'm personally very excited about this work, and I, I know Adam is, too.
193
00:29:32.580 --> 00:29:44.240
A- actually, interestingly, the origin story of this entire, um, effort is, is also great because a lot of times these efforts are a more tops-down decision, you know, a decision that Adam has made or something that I've made.
194
00:29:44.300 --> 00:29:50.360
But actually, this one came from the team that works on, uh, interactions in feed.
195
00:29:50.420 --> 00:30:07.740
So this team is, is incentivized to try to drive, uh, more likes, more comments, but in all of their user research, they heard so loud and clear that people felt like the public like count was a very high area of pressure for them when they produced content on Instagram.
196
00:30:08.240 --> 00:30:23.820
And if you think of the, the core of the platform being about expression and getting people to share with the people they care the most about, the art or the sort of the act of expression itself is what we cared about, not the validation or perceived validation that a public like count gets people.
197
00:30:24.560 --> 00:30:34.900
Now, in 2010, when we launched, it made sense from a norms perspective to say, when you put something out there, the way you know that people are seeing it is through something like a, like a like count.
198
00:30:35.360 --> 00:30:45.600
Uh, that was sort of the norm at the time. But what we've seen since 2016 with, with Stories is that these public, uh, kind of engagement metrics that are shared are, are not the things that drive behavior.
199
00:30:45.620 --> 00:30:54.640
It's about, you know, private interactions. It's about conversations in Direct. It's about the act of sharing in and of itself. And so we learned a lot from that, uh, inside of Stories.
200
00:30:54.660 --> 00:31:07.864
And then also said if, if People were deleting the stuff that they posted to feed because they felt like they were competing with themselves, they were competing with public figures and celebrities and influencers that they felt they could never be on a, an evil, even playing field.
201
00:31:08.364 --> 00:31:14.754
We thought this was a, one of the most effective ways to, to even that playing field and to remove some of that pressure of, of performing.
202
00:31:15.364 --> 00:31:21.244
Um, and the reason that this is taking us some time to ship broadly is this is a big change.
203
00:31:21.264 --> 00:31:28.474
It's probably the biggest, uh, sort of, uh, you know, smallest number of pixels to biggest ecosystem change that I think you could, you could probably think about.
204
00:31:28.484 --> 00:31:40.324
And so we wanna make sure we're doing it right and we understand the, the, not just the short-term, but the long-term implications, understanding, uh, the sentiment that people have as they, as they use this product, and we have it out in, in many countries to, to really do that.
205
00:31:40.784 --> 00:31:43.044
Um, but to also make sure we're doing, we're doing it responsibly.
206
00:31:43.444 --> 00:31:59.244
But I, I wanna end that section by saying we know, we knew going into this that we would likely have to trade off some amount of engagement to do this work, and we are very comfortable doing that if at the end it makes people more comfortable, you know, expressing themselves and sharing on Instagram.
207
00:31:59.524 --> 00:32:04.744
And can we, can we, can we expect to see that, uh, rolling out globally, or is that still not really a decision that's been made yet, do you think?
208
00:32:05.124 --> 00:32:13.204
You know, it's not a decision that's explicitly been made yet, but you know, we are working very hard to, to get this out and to really understand the implications.
209
00:32:13.244 --> 00:32:22.624
And as I mentioned, Adam and I are both very excited about what this could mean for the platform, and the research and the anecdotes that we've heard, uh, sort of support why we, the motivations behind why we built it.
210
00:32:22.684 --> 00:32:33.084
So, uh, I, I wish I could commit to you on, on, today on a, on a timeframe, but, um, know that we're excited about it, know that we continue to, to push on it because we think it's really important. Okay. Martin. Yeah.
211
00:32:33.144 --> 00:32:43.624
How do you, if we look at something like hiding like counts, how do you significantly change a platform like that without killing the soul of the platform, if you get what I mean?
212
00:32:43.664 --> 00:32:57.304
Uh, 'cause users are very sensitive to changes, and if the l- feel of the app is changed even just slightly, it can really have an impact on how people use the app, how they enjoy it. Uh, how do you go about that?
213
00:32:57.644 --> 00:33:06.024
Look, I would argue that the soul of Instagram is about expression and sharing, uh, not about the, the public validation that a like might give you.
214
00:33:06.374 --> 00:33:14.904
That being said, the reason we are taking our time to understand the implications of this is you don't run a test for a month and figure out what the effects of, of something like this are.
215
00:33:15.264 --> 00:33:20.364
Uh, you do have to run this for a longer period of time to really understand, uh, not just what happens in the short term.
216
00:33:20.424 --> 00:33:29.084
Like most product changes that you make, you'll get some change in, in behavior in the very short term. Sometimes it will regress back to where it was before. Sometimes it will actually reverse.
217
00:33:29.584 --> 00:33:33.244
Um, but oftentimes you really wanna understand the, the longer implications for some time.
218
00:33:33.264 --> 00:33:41.344
And so it takes a, a while for an individual to have this, uh, you know, feature in their hand for the, for their behaviors to actually change, um, in, in one way or the other.
219
00:33:41.384 --> 00:33:48.654
So that's one of the reasons it just takes that, the amount of time to, to do it. Um, but I think the, the, the deeper question that you've asked there is
220
00:33:49.924 --> 00:33:58.314
just because a product has worked a certain way for a period of time doesn't mean we shouldn't ask ourselves whether that's the right behavior now.
221
00:33:59.064 --> 00:34:02.384
And, you know, there's been a series of those things over the course of Instagram's history.
222
00:34:02.424 --> 00:34:11.184
You know, when I first got here in 2015, uh, one of the very first things we worked on was changing the, uh, restriction on square photos.
223
00:34:11.784 --> 00:34:21.964
And if you ask someone in 2000, even, even in early 2015 if, if you can imagine Instagram without square photos, they would say, "That's so core to the identity of what the platform is. How could you change that?"
224
00:34:22.504 --> 00:34:29.534
Um, but in reality, um, more than 20% of media uploaded to Instagram had some form of manual letterboxing that people were doing.
225
00:34:30.024 --> 00:34:40.204
And so they were already getting around this constraint when really they wanted to express a moment, and if they had, uh, something that they wanted to share that was wider or taller, they were figuring out a way to make that fit in the square.
226
00:34:40.264 --> 00:34:44.603
That didn't feel like it was staying true to the soul of the platform, which was about expression.
227
00:34:45.024 --> 00:34:52.084
And so there's a series of things I think over the course of our history that is maybe some would call sacred cows that we've gone back and revisited, and we're not afraid.
228
00:34:52.384 --> 00:35:01.544
I'm very proud of the fact that we're not afraid to revisit some of those really what feel like core things if they're the right decisions going forward. So DMs coming to the web.
229
00:35:01.664 --> 00:35:12.844
So this is something that's come out this week that, uh, Instagram is going to be testing it with a small subset of users, the ability to, uh, use the messaging features and functionality on, on desktop version of Instagram.
230
00:35:13.304 --> 00:35:15.004
Um, why now?
231
00:35:15.384 --> 00:35:24.884
This is one of those, um, you know, I wish we could do everything as quickly as we wanted to, but we have, you know, we have to prioritize some of the, the work that we do, and this is something that's been on our radar for, for a little while.
232
00:35:24.904 --> 00:35:37.304
I think two things to say here. One is I don't consider the desktop version of Instagram to be the primary way that people will use Instagram. I think the primary job of Instagram is about expression.
233
00:35:37.344 --> 00:35:44.224
It's about personal expression, which means it's, it's mobile, it's very personal. It's about when you're out and about, but also when you're home and you have something to share.
234
00:35:44.784 --> 00:36:06.284
Um, and so I think of the desktop experience as a secondary interface for Instagram, which is sometimes there are some things that just get, that are just easier done, um, on a desktop, which for example, when you're messaging and you're typing a, a decent amount, and I know, uh, for, for those of us that use the product a lot, uh, it's a, it's a, you know, sometimes a, a difficult thing to have to switch to your phone when you're typing, you know, quite a bit.
235
00:36:06.304 --> 00:36:21.124
And so we think of this as it's not necessarily going to be the primary way that everyone uses, uh, direct messaging, but there's enough, um, you know, whether it's, you call it a power user behavior or people who use direct messaging a lot, uh, where I think this could be very helpful, uh, for people who, who use the platform.
236
00:36:21.144 --> 00:36:24.384
And our, and our desktop experience over time has gotten, gotten more feature rich.
237
00:36:24.844 --> 00:36:39.624
Um, and by no means do I expect it to be a replacement for mobile, but I do think it, it solves some needs, um, for reporters, for journalists, for, um, businesses, for creators, and I think it, it can be very, very valuable when you, when you have the volume of messaging that, that you do on, on a platform like ours.
238
00:36:40.224 --> 00:36:53.104
So Mark Zuckerberg has stated his aim of integrating the backend of all of Facebook's owned messaging pod- um, products, and it wants to make it possible for users to message a friend on WhatsApp from within Instagram and vice versa, and, and many other benefits, uh, is outlined.
239
00:36:53.464 --> 00:37:00.444
And, uh, it enables Facebook also, I guess, to compete more with, uh, rivals such as iMessages as well with it, which is much more kind of like that.
240
00:37:00.784 --> 00:37:10.884
And so, um, you know, how is that project progressing, and, and what can users expect to see, um, visually when they're, like when you're using these messaging apps in, in the year ahead when this is completed? Yeah.
241
00:37:10.944 --> 00:37:17.204
I think it's important here to start in the, in the motivations and what we're trying to achieve and, and, and why we kicked this off in the first place.
242
00:37:17.244 --> 00:37:40.538
So, um, maybe think to your, your own experience, and so I can ex- describe a bit of mine, um, as an example, but- You know, I have, you know, the exact same kind of group messaging thread, uh, with a couple of friends on Instagram Direct, on WhatsApp, on Messenger, and we sometimes have the conversations in individual places based on, you know, a piece of content that we found, and so the message might go there.
243
00:37:41.028 --> 00:37:54.208
Uh, but then I think back to the, the, you know, one-on-one thread that I have with my wife, and while we predominantly use a, a given, you know, space, recently when she traveled to India, uh, all of those conversations kind of moved to WhatsApp, and then she came back, and then we were back on Instagram.
244
00:37:54.378 --> 00:37:59.648
And if I ever wanted to go back and reference any of that conversation, it was splintered, and we didn't exactly know where to go back and look at it.
245
00:37:59.668 --> 00:38:08.148
And if you think about that use case of talking to an individual, the fact that that splintered across multiple apps is actually quite challenging.
246
00:38:08.728 --> 00:38:12.308
Um, that being said, there are other use cases that maybe don't make as much sense.
247
00:38:12.328 --> 00:38:34.188
So if you are running, you know, multiple accounts, uh, for Instagram and you have a very specific account that is an Instagram account that is not on Facebook or not on WhatsApp, we think that you can continue and should continue to use, you know, the messaging app of choice, especially when you aren't feeling the sort of splintering o- of the conversation where it's not about the individual across multiple surfaces, but really about, um, kind of the app experience in and of itself.
248
00:38:34.728 --> 00:38:43.428
So as you can imagine, a, a project like this is, uh, incredibly complicated, both from a technical infrastructure perspective, but also from a product, uh, experience perspective.
249
00:38:43.468 --> 00:38:55.368
And so, um, we're working through both of those in parallel to understand, you know, A, uh, for whom will this, would this be most useful, and how do we make sure that they find value in it and, and they can, and opt into it?
250
00:38:55.808 --> 00:39:04.718
Uh, how does that experience then feel cohesive, uh, for them when they have opted into it? Uh, how does the back end work? Uh, how do we transition people from, from the current world into this world?
251
00:39:05.158 --> 00:39:09.248
Uh, and you know, there have been some open questions even on encryption that we're working through.
252
00:39:09.288 --> 00:39:16.798
And the reason we announced this product as early as we did, uh, was to make sure we could have some of that public dialogue about how we would, um, solve some of these issues.
253
00:39:17.268 --> 00:39:23.318
Uh, normally I think our product development process is much more, you know, we do a lot of this behind the scenes and then kinda talk about it when it's ready.
254
00:39:23.318 --> 00:39:41.888
Uh, but knowing how important of a change this was, it was a different philosophy in terms of talking about it earlier and getting feedback and engaging with not just consumers, but, um, you know, uh, advocacy groups and safety groups and kind of thinking about the implications not just of the, of the interoperability between the platforms, but what it means to move to a, to an encrypted space.
255
00:39:42.488 --> 00:39:48.488
And there's, and one last question on that one really is, i- is it, is it on track in terms of what you had set yourself to achieve by this point?
256
00:39:48.528 --> 00:39:52.798
Is it kind of where you want it to be, or is, uh, is it become s- more challenging than you thought? Where, where is that?
257
00:39:53.508 --> 00:40:04.048
Uh, these things are, these kinds of projects are always fun because the things that you thought were really complicated up front sometimes are, are less complicated than you thought, and the things that you thought were really simple and straightforward are sometimes much more complicated than you realized.
258
00:40:04.068 --> 00:40:04.968
And so I think we have a bit of both.
259
00:40:04.988 --> 00:40:18.568
And so generally I feel like we're, we're making good progress, but it's, it's such a, um, kind of complicated set of systems that we're working through that, uh, I think it's gonna take us some time to make sure we really, uh, feel confident in, in any kind of dates or any kind of announcements.
260
00:40:18.708 --> 00:40:26.148
But, um, but I'm, I'm, I'm excited about the, the teams working on some of the hardest problems. And again, back to the point of not
261
00:40:27.268 --> 00:40:36.788
shying away from the core of the product or from the hardest problems, I think as a, as a company, we're very good at when we decide that this is the right experience and we think it's important for people, that we will take the time to, to get that work right.
262
00:40:36.908 --> 00:40:48.348
Okay. Martin. We talked about safety and privacy earlier, and this is, uh, something that's become, uh, such a, a hot s- product, uh, topic around, uh, Silicon Valley i- in, uh, i- in, in recent times.
263
00:40:48.408 --> 00:40:55.488
You just look this week at, uh, Google removing third-party cookies from Chrome. You know, it's, uh, it would've sounded unthinkable, um, a couple of years ago.
264
00:40:56.038 --> 00:41:01.508
Um, if we look at Threads, for example, um, you were talking about the contextual things that happen there in the, in the background.
265
00:41:01.717 --> 00:41:05.157
It, it tells your friends when you're moving or, uh, charging your phone, things like that.
266
00:41:05.628 --> 00:41:15.618
Um, and one thing that struck me when I u- used Threads for the first time was I had to share my real-time location with Instagram, ergo Facebook, in order to get that to work.
267
00:41:15.728 --> 00:41:22.508
So there's obviously a clear ad tech benefit for, for Facebook there, which is un- understandable. Facebook is an advertising company.
268
00:41:22.908 --> 00:41:33.528
Um, but there's also the benefit for me as a user in that kind of contextual information being shared, and we, we get, uh, something from that. Do you think that this kind of, there's sort of give and take there.
269
00:41:33.648 --> 00:41:45.868
Do you think that give and take, that kind of, um, w- we give you this, but you have to give up that, that kind of transaction is going to have to become a bit more transparent in this more privacy-minded age?
270
00:41:46.288 --> 00:41:50.128
Uh, no question. Uh, I think there are a, a bunch of factors here.
271
00:41:50.188 --> 00:42:05.608
One is sort of general awareness, uh, from a consumer perspective of how platforms work and how the, the systems that they use use, uh, data, use, um, uh, you know, algorithms and, and information to help make decisions and make recommendations.
272
00:42:06.138 --> 00:42:15.448
Um, but I think it hasn't always been clear to people, uh, exactly what data is being used and how it's being used and why it's helpful or, or in their minds, not helpful for the way they use the platform.
273
00:42:15.468 --> 00:42:25.408
So I think as an industry, we have to get to a place where we have to be super transparent about what data we're using, uh, why w- why it's being used, and, and what it could be used for.
274
00:42:25.428 --> 00:42:33.448
But people also need to know the benefit that they get by sharing that information, and if they opt out of it, what the implications of opting out may actually be.
275
00:42:33.868 --> 00:42:49.068
And I think that is not really well established yet in terms of, I mean, you can make a statement that, okay, if you opt out of, of da- tracking for ads targeting, your ads might become less relevant, uh, which I think is actually a real, people really, uh, have a negative, uh, reaction to that when they actually live with it.
276
00:42:49.448 --> 00:42:53.228
Um, but we don't do a very good job of explaining that to people in the moment when they're making that decision.
277
00:42:53.728 --> 00:43:04.888
Uh, or, you know, how good the recommendations would be even outside of ads, uh, just for content that they might see, for example, in Explore on Instagram and what their experience might, might do and might change if, if the data was being used differently.
278
00:43:05.328 --> 00:43:12.404
And so I think the Uh, you know, you guys have talked on this podcast a lot about sort of patterns for, for products and for design.
279
00:43:12.444 --> 00:43:24.004
I think we'll see a lot in the next, let's call it five to 10 years, about how best we can not only be transparent about what data's being collected and how it's being used, but how that information then affects the experience that people are having.
280
00:43:24.524 --> 00:43:33.244
Uh, and some of it comes down to the business model in terms of a free product being advertising supported. Some of it comes down to the level of personalization that people can get with using a product like ours.
281
00:43:33.704 --> 00:43:38.464
Um, but then also being clear that if you don't wanna provide that then maybe you have an experience that you're not as excited about.
282
00:43:38.524 --> 00:43:47.024
But people just need to know, uh, what they're getting or what they're not when they're making some of these choices. So how do you see Instagram looking three to five years from now?
283
00:43:47.124 --> 00:43:54.894
So that's kind of a not too far away it's unrealistic and crazy, but also separate to that, what do you think it might look like in 10 years from now?
284
00:43:55.004 --> 00:44:04.354
So really kind of blue sky thinking especially with the concepts of things to do with the Oculus and what they're doing with AR and AR stuff, now AR glasses have been talked about at, uh, many different places.
285
00:44:04.404 --> 00:44:12.124
Uh, what's your thoughts there? Yeah. I think in the three to five-year timeframe, uh, you know, we'll continue to be focused in, in, I believe in the four areas that I mentioned.
286
00:44:12.243 --> 00:44:21.324
Maybe specifics within them might, might evolve over time. So as an example, and I, I don't believe we will ever go away from the core of people expressing and sharing.
287
00:44:21.384 --> 00:44:31.084
Uh, now how they share and to whom they share I think will continuously evolve. We've seen a shift from, you know, broadcast sharing into a feed, uh, evolving into Stories.
288
00:44:31.104 --> 00:44:37.104
We're seeing more communication, more pri- uh, sharing happening in private groups, uh, whether it's a group of people or even individually.
289
00:44:37.124 --> 00:44:45.204
So I think the, the audience and what people are comfortable sharing and to whom is, is changing. Uh, the way in which they capture and they, and they share is a- also evolving.
290
00:44:45.244 --> 00:44:53.554
The cameras certainly on phones have gotten, gotten much better. Technology from a, um, you know, augmented reality kind of effects perspective have, have continuously gotten better.
291
00:44:53.624 --> 00:45:12.584
I've been incredibly proud of the, the work that we've been seeing out of the, the platform work that we've done on AR on Instagram where, you know, over the holidays, I don't know if this was as big, um, in the UK, uh, but we had a lot of filters, uh, uh, face effects on, you know, what Disney character are you or, or you know, what celebrity are you that didn't come from Instagram.
292
00:45:12.624 --> 00:45:21.944
It came from the community and that was an incredibly inspiring to see some of those things, you know, really find traction. And so the ways in which those things, um, evolve will, will...
293
00:45:21.984 --> 00:45:25.824
Or the, the ways in which people share will evolve, and we need to make sure we're setting the right guardrails.
294
00:45:25.844 --> 00:45:34.544
And so as we opened up that platform early last year, one of the things that we were looking at really actively was what kinds of effects we would allow versus not allow from a policy perspective.
295
00:45:34.564 --> 00:45:45.803
And we made a decision, you know, last year to say things that were explicitly about, you know, plastic surgery or facial, um, uh, things that made it look like you, you were having, you know, explicit plastic surgery were things we did not want on the platform.
296
00:45:46.114 --> 00:45:53.124
And that's a call that we'd have to make along the way, and I think we as platforms need to think about those things as we're making calls. What is allowed or not allowed in, in Live?
297
00:45:53.204 --> 00:45:56.424
What is allowed or not allowed in, in things like effects?
298
00:45:56.464 --> 00:46:04.104
And this is a challenging question when you talk about a global platform because norms are, are certainly quite different, you know, country by country and, and region by region.
299
00:46:04.604 --> 00:46:09.504
And so I, I think those are challenges that we're gonna have to continue to, to face and think through as, as we launch them.
300
00:46:09.544 --> 00:46:19.804
But, uh, the core of the product I think will really will stay, uh, you know, centered on, on sharing an expression. But I do think you'll see, start to see more from us, um, on these different interest verticals.
301
00:46:20.004 --> 00:46:31.773
Uh, so you've seen some of that already, uh, with IGTV as a place for, for Instagram creators to tell a longer, deeper story than what they could do on Feed or in Stories, uh, uh, pun intended.
302
00:46:32.284 --> 00:46:44.384
Um, or in, in Shopping, uh, where people are opting in to follow brands, to follow stylists and bloggers, and to see the latest trends and to understand, uh, what a product might be that they could, they could purchase.
303
00:46:44.844 --> 00:46:55.354
Um, so I think we have some ideas like that, um, in other verticals. Things like travel and music, uh, and gaming that I think you can, you'll start to see us, you know, work on more in the years to come.
304
00:46:55.764 --> 00:47:03.944
We do try to be very, um, deliberate about how many of those things we're doing at any one point in time, back to the point on simplicity. So, um, we're gonna have to wrap up.
305
00:47:03.984 --> 00:47:08.354
I think our time is coming close to an end with you 'cause I know you're busy and you've got some more meetings you've gotta jump into.
306
00:47:08.534 --> 00:47:20.204
So, um, we had a ton of people ask us questions, um, that they wanted me to ask you about various things. Um, they're all pretty decently interesting questions that I would've wanted to answer mys- uh, answers to myself.
307
00:47:20.284 --> 00:47:24.904
So, uh, if you don't mind, we're gonna jump through in probably, like, 30 seconds on each is fine and see what, see what we can come up with.
308
00:47:25.604 --> 00:47:33.164
Um, so, uh, can you give us a teaser about what cool new Instagram stickers for Stories you're testing or thinking about developing? And that's from me.
309
00:47:33.484 --> 00:47:37.044
[laughs] That's the first one, and then the rest of them everyone else can have. Well, so I, I...
310
00:47:37.064 --> 00:47:44.504
Let me instead of a specific sticker, I'll tell you sort of the thematically how we're thinking about the, the creative tools in, in a place like Stories. So we're looking at two different things.
311
00:47:44.684 --> 00:47:55.444
One is what are, are the types of stickers or, or effects that give you a reason to share, not just about augmenting something you've already decided to share. So it's a, a reason to share in the first place. That's one.
312
00:47:55.904 --> 00:48:03.744
Uh, and the second is how to make, uh, Stories even more interactive. And so you saw that with the polling sticker. You saw that with the questions and answer sticker and the emoji slider.
313
00:48:04.164 --> 00:48:14.854
There's something about, um, making the space really interactive, which I think is amazing for, for people, but also really amazing for businesses, uh, to be able to connect with their fans and their audiences, uh, in, in ways that we're exploring.
314
00:48:15.344 --> 00:48:22.704
Got you. Right. Well, we've got a bunch of questions about one particular topic which is, uh, "When will IGTV get monetization features?" Says David Orrego.
315
00:48:22.944 --> 00:48:32.964
And also someone else, "Any plans for improving IGTV search features?" Says At Not Nap. And there was also a question about just generally where, where it is at for IGTV.
316
00:48:33.064 --> 00:48:40.184
Um, have you got anything you can share with us today? Yeah. You know, there's a, there's a few things on IGTV that are worth calling out. I'll try to keep things brief so we can get to some more questions.
317
00:48:40.244 --> 00:48:58.044
So one is, you know, we've really seen the adoption of the core creator segment that we're going after, which is the Instagram native creator who has built an audience, who is telling stories in Feed and in, in Stories, but really needed a place to tell a longer form story that today they had to go to a different platform, uh, to do.
318
00:48:58.084 --> 00:49:13.484
Now, we understand that- Creating longer form video is more expensive from a time and resource perspective for creators, and so we set the expectation that we wanted to bring monetization to IGTV even outside of, of some of the branded content and, and work that we've, we've done to date.
319
00:49:13.564 --> 00:49:20.924
Um, so no specific plans, uh, to announce, but know that that is still an important priority for us, and, and you will certainly hear more from us, uh, about that.
320
00:49:20.964 --> 00:49:35.744
Now, the second thing I wanted to mention is that, you know, like any product, uh, organization, we're constantly evolving and learning, and so one of the things that we learned, uh, about how IGTV was being used were people were confused about how they should best upload video on Instagram.
321
00:49:35.784 --> 00:49:43.894
Should they first go to the IGTV tab? Should they first go to, you know, kind of the, the plus icon in the bottom of, of the, of the main screen to upload something?
322
00:49:43.934 --> 00:49:56.314
And so for the purpose of simplifying, uh, the way people upload video, uh, we're actually going to allow people to upload video for both feed and for IGTV from that main kind of feed upload plus icon, uh, inside of, of the platform.
323
00:49:56.724 --> 00:50:08.884
And for the purpose of simplification and to make sure that there is not a lot of competing, uh, attention for when people get to the, to the, to the, uh, platform, we're actually going to be removing the IGTV icon from the home screen.
324
00:50:09.204 --> 00:50:24.434
I think back to our very early point on having the diligence and feeling like you can unship and celebrating that just as much as shipping something in the first place, I'm proud of the team for, for really, uh, thinking about the simplicity of Instagram as a whole and simplifying the, the video upload flow when they're making a change like this.
325
00:50:24.644 --> 00:50:28.324
Got you. I'm gonna rattle through some of these now 'cause we've got so- I've got three minutes, I think, so let's go for it.
326
00:50:28.364 --> 00:50:37.384
So are there any plans to allow people to edit published stories, says Vaselina Filipidi, I think. I've got that right. No, no. There are no plans for that.
327
00:50:37.444 --> 00:50:47.404
We believe once the, um, the, the story's out there and people have seen it and responded, we wanna make sure that, that stays consistent in the same way that, you know, in a stor- in a feed post, you know, we keep the image pretty much consistent.
328
00:50:47.444 --> 00:50:54.904
So people can certainly delete them and, and re-upload them if they've made a mistake, but we think it's important for once that, that thing has been published, uh, for it to stay pretty consistent.
329
00:50:55.164 --> 00:51:00.704
Uh, adding links to feed posts, is it ever gonna happen, says- No... Payvee Kalska. No. It is, it is not.
330
00:51:00.824 --> 00:51:08.143
Uh, and I know there was a question that you had, you had, we had talked about earlier about even reshares in feed. That is also not coming. Uh, and those two changes are really important.
331
00:51:08.184 --> 00:51:12.884
The reason we don't do links or reshares in feed is it would change the incentive for why people post.
332
00:51:13.344 --> 00:51:26.604
Uh, if you have a link to share and that's why you post versus just sharing a moment, that changes why you post, and if you can reshare, when you come across content from someone that you follow and it's not something they originally created, it changes the reason why you see something in your feed.
333
00:51:26.664 --> 00:51:30.844
So for simplicity and for the sense of control, uh, we explicitly are not going to make those changes.
334
00:51:31.124 --> 00:51:38.683
Is Instagram Checkout going to allow you to buy, um, services as well as physical goods within Instagram, says Jonathan Pollinger.
335
00:51:39.484 --> 00:51:48.623
It's possible over time, although our area of focus is very much on specific products and launching that more broadly in, in the US where we are now, but then thinking about how we, we scale that internationally.
336
00:51:48.684 --> 00:51:53.244
Tons of questions on why doesn't my country have music sticker yet. When will those countries get it if they haven't got it yet?
337
00:51:54.204 --> 00:52:07.683
M- so music stickers, uh, we would love to take it everywhere, but we have to work with the music rights holders in all the different markets, and so the reason they're not everywhere is because we don't have rights for music in those markets, and it's really important to us to abide by the rights that these rights holders have.
338
00:52:08.024 --> 00:52:14.884
Got you. And then finally, and one that I was just curious about, does, does it affect you hearing criticism from, from people about a specific product?
339
00:52:14.933 --> 00:52:22.184
And, uh, what somebody said to me a few months back, and I wrote saying that, um, that IGTV was the recycle bin for YouTube right now.
340
00:52:22.624 --> 00:52:30.564
And I thought about that, and I thought it made me smile and laugh, but then at the same time I was thinking, God, what, what would happen with the, uh, the people in the product teams who are developing these products and they hear some of these things.
341
00:52:30.884 --> 00:52:41.584
How does, how does that affect you? Oh, it certainly affects, uh, affects you. I, I think as, as a, as a human, you, you are affected by the things that you hear and you think about, um, w- people's perceptions.
342
00:52:41.624 --> 00:52:53.564
At the same time, I think we have the, the discipline as a product organization to know that that's one perspective and doesn't really think about the longer term implications of what we're trying to achieve, but also the things that we might be working on that people don't know about.
343
00:52:53.594 --> 00:52:54.984
And so I think it's, uh...
344
00:52:55.064 --> 00:53:07.544
I think it would be impossible to say you, you don't hear those things, but also it wouldn't be the only reason to act on something or to make a change, and it's just part of the discipline of, of being a product owner and product thinker to think even, even beyond the, the short-term criticism.
345
00:53:08.024 --> 00:53:08.404
Got you.
346
00:53:08.444 --> 00:53:17.044
Well, I think we've made it exactly to the time, so I just wanna wrap it up and say that we've had a great time chatting to you, and I think there's a lot of questions and answers that are in there that people will enjoy listening back to.
347
00:53:17.404 --> 00:53:25.264
And so thank you, Vishal, for joining us, and, uh, hope you've had a good time as well. Thanks to both of you. Really enjoyed the chat, and, uh, and, uh, best of luck on the rest of the season. Thank you.
348
00:53:25.904 --> 00:53:37.204
It's time now for quick hits. Here's Matt with tests and updates from social media companies that amaze your eyes, electrify your ears, and bedazzle your brain. They get cheesier every week. [laughs] They seriously do.
349
00:53:37.224 --> 00:53:42.794
Like, what is going on with you? Okay. So yes, there's a co- there's about five or six this week, so we'll, uh, rattle through them.
350
00:53:42.864 --> 00:53:50.064
Let's start with the one that I just spotted before recording today, and that is LinkedIn has got three new features that it's gonna be rolling out to company pages.
351
00:53:50.124 --> 00:53:59.884
Now, I say new 'cause lots of people have already come back to me and said, "This is not new. This has been around for ages." These are ones that have been out for some people for a little while, probably being tested.
352
00:54:00.204 --> 00:54:04.184
Others haven't had them. So this is a global rollout, I believe, and that is LinkedIn Live.
353
00:54:04.324 --> 00:54:13.624
So the live streaming video stuff is gonna come out to more company pages or all of them in due course, uh, in the next few weeks, I think, and there's also act as a page or a profile.
354
00:54:13.744 --> 00:54:22.864
So if you're familiar with Facebook where you can choose whether you wanna respond to comments as your page or as your profile, that is being brought to LinkedIn as well, something that they're playing catch up with there.
355
00:54:23.324 --> 00:54:35.774
And the invite connections to follow your page, so you can choose some of your first, um, order connections on LinkedIn to invite them to your page, but there is a 50, uh, limit, a limit of 50 profiles that you can invite as follow, to follow your page.
356
00:54:36.404 --> 00:54:46.304
And also they've got some con- um, control settings that you can set, say you don't want to receive such, uh, invitations from other people if it gets a bit spammy. The next thing was Bing Pages.
357
00:54:46.404 --> 00:54:49.944
Now I saw Bing Pages, and I just thought Google+ 2.0.
358
00:54:50.144 --> 00:55:08.144
You know, it just ringed of a company that's not really sure what it's doing but wants to have some sort of socially type feature, and Bing Pages seems to be Microsoft's version of that, which is basically a profile page which pulls together all of your kind of feeds and streams and the posts you put out, and you can have a kind of page profile there within Bing as well.
359
00:55:08.264 --> 00:55:13.552
So for those who get excited by Google+, this may be one for you to check out. Twitter tipping feature.
360
00:55:13.642 --> 00:55:23.952
So this gen- generated a lot of interest, a lot of talk, um, in the last few days when I tweeted about it, and it was in, uh, within a, a video or a vide- another article which was talking about other things that Twitter is doing.
361
00:55:24.352 --> 00:55:34.012
So it's the idea of you being able to, uh, say that people can tip you some money for whatever reason, I guess, you justify they should tip you, or people just choose organically to.
362
00:55:34.072 --> 00:55:44.222
So this is, uh, something that I think is an interesting idea, but I'm not sure how it will work in, in practical terms, and there's plenty of ways it could probably be abused, or it could, uh, change the kind of vibe of Twitter.
363
00:55:44.292 --> 00:55:59.872
But, um, they did say that although it was, it was in an article for the information, this, uh, this story, they did say that afterwards that they're not actively working on it at this time, which is one of those, it's kind of there, but we might not get to it, so we'll- Oh, you'd get so many people begging for money through Twitter then, wouldn't you?
364
00:56:00.042 --> 00:56:08.212
It, uh- Yeah. I think it would get a bit, yeah. It could be. So we'll see if that one ever comes to fruition. Also, Instagram Boomerang has got an update for stories.
365
00:56:08.292 --> 00:56:17.822
So Boomerang, you know, you're playing around with video, nice kind of jumpy, kind of repeat video stuff you can do, and they've got some new features. Um, so slow mo, uh, which is self-explanatory.
366
00:56:18.232 --> 00:56:28.712
Echo, which gives it kind of like a, a double kind of vision, kind of echoey effect, and then you've got duo, which kind of adds a slow and fast speed at the same time to give it a bit more texture in the, in the video.
367
00:56:29.022 --> 00:56:33.852
And there's also a new trimming feature for, for your boomerangs, which is something that it should have had at the beginning, to be honest.
368
00:56:33.992 --> 00:56:47.192
Uh, Twitter lists, so they're becoming, um, a popular thing again, and I'm glad they are 'cause they're very useful, and Twitter lists now, I noticed the other day, suggest to me what other accounts I should add to my existing list or a new list I was creating.
369
00:56:47.592 --> 00:56:55.732
So it was, I had a list for new tech news, and it started suggesting some really useful accounts to add, in fact. So that's gonna be a, a great, uh, addition to lists.
370
00:56:55.752 --> 00:57:01.612
And finally, a small one really, a small one that's a big one. LinkedIn has kind of supersized its buttons.
371
00:57:01.972 --> 00:57:14.662
So now along, when you kind of tap the button to l- to like a post or whatever, it's got a real bigger sized kind of selection of buttons at the bottom to choose from, and one of them's got repost, which is a nice kind of prompt to kind of re-share something.
372
00:57:14.792 --> 00:57:22.592
Uh, it's kind of cool that it's done it 'cause it, before it was a bit plain and small, but now it's, yeah, supersized buttons on LinkedIn. Good stuff, and that's it for today.
373
00:57:22.992 --> 00:57:34.672
Now, last week, you might remember Taylor Lorenz told us how influencers are shifting away from advertising and endorsements to wider forms of content creation, and next week we'll be talking to an influencer who is all about content.
374
00:57:34.952 --> 00:57:40.212
She's a creator, blogging mentor, and podcast host, and she'll be great to speak to. That's Vix Meldrew.
375
00:57:40.732 --> 00:57:48.672
Yes, I'm really looking forward to that one as well, so make sure you do hit subscribe in your podcast app of choice so that you're notified as soon as the next episode is available.
376
00:57:48.912 --> 00:58:01.072
Geek Out with Matt Navarra is a Big Revolution production. Find out more at bigrevolution.net/podcasts. You can find me on Twitter as @martinsfp. And I'm @mattnavarra on Twitter.
377
00:58:01.192 --> 00:58:07.972
So don't forget to tell all your friends about the podcast, and also join the Facebook group. We have a Facebook group called the Social Media Geek Out.
378
00:58:08.172 --> 00:58:17.572
Uh, you can find it by searching exactly for that within Facebook, and you'll find us there for more of the same as what's in this podcast and even other weird and wonderful things to do with social. Indeed.
379
00:58:17.652 --> 00:58:20.272
We'll see you soon. Goodbye, geeks. [upbeat music]
1
00:00:00.180 --> 00:00:11.860
Geek Out with Matt Navara is sponsored by Pinterest. Inspire your audience and grow your company on Pinterest with a free business account. Learn more at business.pinterest.com. It's time to Geek Out.
2
00:00:12.139 --> 00:00:27.860
[upbeat music] Hello, and welcome to Geek Out with Matt Navara, sponsored by Pinterest. I am Matt Navara. And I'm Martin SFP Bryant.
3
00:00:28.100 --> 00:00:38.560
Now, one of the platforms we talk about most on this show is Instagram. So this week, we're delighted to be joined by someone who's better placed than most to give us an insider's view. That is right. I'm very excited.
4
00:00:38.600 --> 00:00:47.640
It's Vishal Shah, who's Instagram's head of product, and we've got loads of questions to put to him shortly, and I think there's even some from people who've listened to last week's show knowing he was coming on.
5
00:00:48.060 --> 00:00:58.860
So don't forget, you can always get in touch with us on Twitter. You can find me there as @MattNavara. And I'm @MartinSFP. So Matt, what have you been up to this week? It's been a weird week this week.
6
00:00:58.920 --> 00:01:03.820
It's a funny, funny one. [laughs] Um, so I've started off the week with a sim- my kids wanted me to get an Xbox.
7
00:01:03.840 --> 00:01:09.910
They've been pestering me for ages, and I was, like, resisting 'cause I'm conscious that the Xbox is now at the end of its life cycle, and- Mm...
8
00:01:09.940 --> 00:01:15.650
they're gonna replace it shortly, and I thought, "This is not a good tech investment." I was too geeky about it. I wasn't thinking- [laughs]... kid.
9
00:01:15.680 --> 00:01:23.950
So I, uh, I gave in, and I got myself, uh, uh, one of the Xboxes, and, uh, it's been good. So that's great. I also started watching Mr. Robot finally. It was, um- Mm...
10
00:01:23.980 --> 00:01:32.080
something that I remember when I was at South By, um, a good few years ago, and they had an activation going on when they launched the show, and I thought it might be my cup of tea.
11
00:01:32.100 --> 00:01:40.120
But somehow, for two years or however long it's been out, I haven't managed to get down to doing that, to watching. Yeah, that was freaky, wasn't it? A few years ago, I think th- they had, like, a big Mr.
12
00:01:40.180 --> 00:01:41.460
Robot fairground, didn't they?
13
00:01:41.500 --> 00:01:54.000
The year before, it might have been, um, when they first were launching the first season, they had these weird guys in black hoodies walking around the streets of Austin, uh, with that, with very little explanation, and that, that was real- [laughs] That was a bit freaky, that.
14
00:01:54.110 --> 00:02:00.520
It was. Well, I, I keep on meaning to watch it, and someone suggested it to me last week that, you know, "Have you watched it yet?" And I thought, "Oh, yes, I'm gonna watch it."
15
00:02:00.540 --> 00:02:07.300
And I've watched the first two or three episodes of season one, so I'm way behind the world on this, um, and very much enjoying it. So that was good.
16
00:02:07.420 --> 00:02:18.000
Uh, and then I did some tweets this week that kinda went nuts 'cause I tweeted about the change in the, or the, the feature that might be coming soon that we discussed in the last episode of the podcast for Twitter, where they're looking at controlling...
17
00:02:18.040 --> 00:02:22.640
You can set controls over who can see your tweets and who can reply, sorry, who can reply to your tweets.
18
00:02:23.100 --> 00:02:32.790
Um, and that tweet ended up going out and getting sort of tens of thousands of likes and comments and things, so it's destroyed my Twitter notifications thread. It still doesn't work with the ability to- [laughs]...
19
00:02:32.790 --> 00:02:42.040
filter verified. It didn't help at all. Oh, the pains of being popular. [laughs] I know. Well, I, I wish I had more of those tweets 'cause they're fun, but they also destroy your, your notifications box.
20
00:02:42.060 --> 00:02:48.740
But, um, in terms of another weird thing, Mark Zuckerberg replied to me, which was, uh, a curious one. Ooh. So I say Mark Zuckerberg.
21
00:02:48.840 --> 00:02:56.200
I think we all, um, in the geek circle know that it's not probably him that's doing this. His team have been responding on behalf of him on his account.
22
00:02:56.540 --> 00:03:20.280
But I, uh, I was asking him about his thread that he, or post he did last week, uh, around the future of, of Facebook and its responsibilities and his plans for the next year and things, and I sort of suggested how could he be thinking about the future and dealing with the future stuff that they want to develop and innovate when they've still got a lot of problems that are existing from tech that they've released in the previous 10 years that they've yet to find solutions to, or they're still causing problems.
23
00:03:20.680 --> 00:03:29.700
So he responded, and then of course, Facebook was then, uh, pretty much unusable for notifications anyway for a good three or four days. But, um- [laughs]... yeah, it was a busy week. How about you?
24
00:03:30.400 --> 00:03:37.700
Uh, well, uh, uh, the couple of things that were probably most, uh, interesting, uh, and fun were, um, I did a bit of media interview work.
25
00:03:37.780 --> 00:03:47.020
So I, I was on BBC Breakfast talking about, uh, Windows 7 and Microsoft ending support for that. So if you've got Windows 7, uh, you're out of luck if, uh, you get any bugs or anything.
26
00:03:47.080 --> 00:03:48.900
And, uh, so I was doing an explainer on that.
27
00:03:48.940 --> 00:03:57.740
And normally, if you're on a breakfast TV, you have to wait in the morning for a taxi at, uh, an ungodly hour of the morning, and then, uh, you, you get in there early, and they put makeup on.
28
00:03:57.900 --> 00:04:05.500
Um, and, uh, you go and do it live. And then for the rest of the day, you've got this lovely sheen of makeup on your face, and, um, [laughs] it, it's actually really, really nice.
29
00:04:05.640 --> 00:04:10.070
It's, it helps you feel a bit more confident about the day. Um, but- I tell you what. On, on that point, quick, funny story. Yeah?
30
00:04:10.080 --> 00:04:18.860
I ha- I should say, I did exactly the same as you did with a BBC Breakfast thing where it was in Manchester up in your neck of the woods, and, uh, I got into the... First time I'd ever done it.
31
00:04:18.940 --> 00:04:23.620
They did all the whole hair and makeup thing, so it was all quite fun and exciting but at the same time, a bit kind of weird.
32
00:04:24.010 --> 00:04:36.160
And then I got straight out of the studio, and I had to get back on the train to come back here to Bristol and Cardiff area, and, and throughout my train journey, three or four different people I'd never met just s- stopped me and just said, "You've got amazing eyes.
33
00:04:36.190 --> 00:04:42.300
You've got really lovely eyes. You look-" [laughs] And I was like, "Oh, thank you very much." Yeah, I thought this train, the northerners really are very friendly.
34
00:04:42.670 --> 00:04:47.440
[laughs] And then suddenly, um, I went through, and I went to the bathroom on the train, and I looked in the mirror. I was like, "Oh."
35
00:04:47.560 --> 00:04:57.160
And I looked like I had so much makeup on, but you could still look like my eyes were just popping with- [laughs]... the color of the blue against the sheen color of the makeup. So- Oh... that was my makeup story.
36
00:04:57.220 --> 00:05:05.870
But, uh, so it's much more convenient to do what I did this week, which is go in in the afternoon and pre-record an interview, which was really nice and, uh, civilized, except they don't put makeup on. Ah.
37
00:05:05.920 --> 00:05:13.000
So I, I, I saw myself on [laughs] TV. This is very vain, but I saw myself on TV, and I thought, "I look really rough", but, uh- [laughs]... there we go.
38
00:05:13.400 --> 00:05:24.140
Um, uh, and I did actually encourage, uh, somebody who saw it, who was on Windows Vista still, in a Windows Vista computer. Jesus. I managed to convince them to, uh, to get a, a Chromebook actually, so there you go.
39
00:05:24.320 --> 00:05:38.290
Um, and, uh, and then the other thing I did was I went and did a radio interview where I think I probably ac- accidentally set off a load of, uh, Amazon Echos by giving an Alexa command as an example on the radio after I said, "I'm not going to do this 'cause it will set off all your Alexas".
40
00:05:38.540 --> 00:05:45.360
I then completely accidentally set off an Alexa com- uh, uh, command, um, and, uh, who knows what happened, but, uh, hopefully nothing. [laughs] You should've gone rogue.
41
00:05:45.420 --> 00:05:53.170
You should've gone rogue and done something like, "Alexa, find me", and then something really X-rated- [laughs]... and then people with children would be going like, "No, stop, Alexa. Stop, stop." Um, but anyway.
42
00:05:53.170 --> 00:06:01.780
We're gonna have to edit this because you just said, "Find me something X-rated", and, uh, who knows what, uh, what people's Echos will do if, uh, if they're listening to the podcast. [laughs] Oh, damn.
43
00:06:01.880 --> 00:06:07.540
Oh, sorry about that. So what's been going on in the news this week, Martin? What have you got for us? Okay.
44
00:06:07.620 --> 00:06:17.480
Well, uh, our first story might sound familiar because it's a story that is as old as the oldest social media news story you can imagine.
45
00:06:17.820 --> 00:06:22.340
Um, Twitter's Jack Dorsey on the edit button, "We'll probably never do it", he says.
46
00:06:22.540 --> 00:06:31.560
Yes, he's done a video Q&A with Wired, and, uh, one of the questions he was asked was inevitably about the edit button, and he was talking about it, and he basically said, "We'll never do it."
47
00:06:31.760 --> 00:06:42.060
But he was, "Uh, we'll probably never do it." So there's still, if you're an edit button fan, there's still a chance. He said probably, not certainly, but to me it just feels like, make your mind up.
48
00:06:42.320 --> 00:06:44.000
[laughs] Don't you think? Yeah.
49
00:06:44.060 --> 00:06:53.840
Well, they're just- they're leaving that little door open partly for fun, I guess, but also 'cause, you know, they never wanna say anything concrete about something that could change, of course, like that, which, um, y- you know, they may change their minds on it.
50
00:06:53.860 --> 00:07:05.600
But for me, I'm, overall I'm pretty happy with that because I don't particularly like the idea of having a full-scale edit tweet button. I could probably tolerate and understand the value of a, a typo correction thing.
51
00:07:06.060 --> 00:07:13.780
Um, but I'm- but I did take great glee yesterday when tweeting out that it was basically dead and it's, it's never gonna happen. [laughs] That was, that was one of my favorite moments this week.
52
00:07:14.210 --> 00:07:25.560
Uh, what else is happening? Uh, so TikTok, uh, has, uh, s- something that, uh, might change the feel of the app a little bit. They're exploring the idea of a curated content feed, uh, to lure advertisers.
53
00:07:25.590 --> 00:07:27.870
So this was a, uh, a story from the Financial Times.
54
00:07:28.370 --> 00:07:45.100
Uh, so, uh, basically the, the higher quality stuff from creators, but also stuff from brands would have its own dedicated feed, with the idea being that if you're an advertiser, you don't want to be in the, the main algorithmic feed of TikTok because you don't know what you might end up advertising next to.
55
00:07:45.500 --> 00:07:55.860
So if you're in a, a high quality, this is the, uh, the, the handpicked stuff kind of feed, then you're more likely to want to spend big bucks with, uh, TikTok. Do you think this is a good idea, Matt?
56
00:07:56.160 --> 00:07:57.540
Um, I think it's a natural progression.
57
00:07:57.600 --> 00:08:08.560
I, I can imagine that's where it would think it would, it would go or wants to go, and, and why the people would assume that's the way it would go, um, given that, you know, Snapchat has gone through that life cycle and explored that as well.
58
00:08:08.680 --> 00:08:13.800
And, and it, it, it makes sense in so many ways that I, I can't see it not happening really.
59
00:08:14.200 --> 00:08:20.780
Um, and, uh, it's just a case really it's gonna have like t- little mini shows that they're gonna produce or they're gonna outsource it to others.
60
00:08:20.880 --> 00:08:29.440
Um, how much, you know, cut they're gonna give on those, and then all the questions about what sort of content will actually be handpicked and some of it will it be using the algorithm combined with some curation.
61
00:08:29.500 --> 00:08:37.020
Who knows? But, um, but yeah, no, very interesting one, but one that I think is a, a natural progression that was inevitable. Yeah. TikTok growing up a little bit, I think there.
62
00:08:37.080 --> 00:08:44.040
We, uh, also heard the news this week of a, uh, Facebook bug that exposed the anonymous admins of pages.
63
00:08:44.300 --> 00:08:57.200
So this was, uh, a bug that was discovered, and, uh, it was, uh, being shared around on, a lot on places like, uh, 4chan, where people had discovered that you could, uh, find out who was the admin, the anonymous admin, uh, of a page.
64
00:08:57.240 --> 00:09:00.460
And so that meant that you could see who the admin was for, say, celebrities' pages.
65
00:09:00.720 --> 00:09:15.750
But there was also potentially problems around maybe more, uh, you know, where, where there were maybe admins of groups, uh, of pages where, you know, they, they didn't want any, any kind of publicity for maybe safety reasons, and, uh, they were maybe getting exposed.
66
00:09:15.990 --> 00:09:19.020
Uh, it was, it was fixed quickly, but, uh, what did you make of this, Matt?
67
00:09:19.060 --> 00:09:31.380
Well, I was, when I saw the list of names of, uh, accounts that had gone round 4chan and, uh, so say, revealing the, some of the page admins, um, the first name that stuck out to me, being from Bristol myself was, was Banksy, and I was thinking, "Oh, is there something in there?
68
00:09:31.400 --> 00:09:36.580
It's not gonna be him, but maybe there's something in there that's kind of like leads us to the mystery of, of Banksy."
69
00:09:36.680 --> 00:09:46.400
But, uh, no, it was some guy with a very, um, normal, regular name that I have no idea that was in New York, so it doesn't really have much- Oh... not unless we think- If only, if only it was 3D from Massive Attack.
70
00:09:46.520 --> 00:09:51.500
[laughs] Oh. Yeah, I mean- That theory would be proven at last. [laughs] I, I just think all this sort of stuff, you know, it, it could have been worse.
71
00:09:51.560 --> 00:09:56.340
It could have been a lot worse given what Facebook's, um, been up to over the years and what they've been accused of and what they have been doing.
72
00:09:56.440 --> 00:10:09.700
Um, but at the same time, i- i- in all seriousness, yeah, that could have, um, been a problem for, for certain people, and I'm sure the people that's had, um, themselves in the news, I think Greta Thunberg was one of them, uh, can't, uh, appreciate Facebook's efforts here at all, really.
73
00:10:09.780 --> 00:10:24.100
Yeah. Well, I, I think it's a reminder that anything on the internet is, uh, liable to being, uh, exposed unexpectedly, and, uh, anything private we put up online, uh, has that risk attached to it. Exactly. Good words.
74
00:10:24.500 --> 00:10:34.680
We'll be speaking to Instagram's head of product, Vishal Shah, in just a moment, but first... Geek Out with Matt Navara is sponsored by Pinterest, and each week we share tips to help you make the most of the platform.
75
00:10:34.690 --> 00:10:43.140
Now, Pinterest has launched Pinterest Academy, a series of free online courses covering topics like creative strategy, campaign optimization, and more.
76
00:10:43.160 --> 00:10:51.640
For example, when it comes to creative strategy, Pinterest is a visual platform, so design plays a significant role in the success of content from brands, publishers, and creators.
77
00:10:52.000 --> 00:11:03.480
The first step in creating successful pins is to make sure they stand out. Here are three tips to get the most out of your organic and promoted content on Pinterest. Number one, use compelling eye-catching imagery.
78
00:11:03.540 --> 00:11:14.380
Lifestyle images are often more effective than product shots. Two, make your pins vertical. 85% of Pinterest's users are on mobile, meaning that your content should be optimized for mobile space.
79
00:11:14.840 --> 00:11:24.840
And three, think beyond static imagery. Video and story pins are new formats on Pinterest that are great for how-tos, storytelling, and showcasing a product in use.
80
00:11:25.140 --> 00:11:36.680
So if you want to find success on Pinterest and grow your brand, Pinterest Academy has nine courses with more information for you to explore. Head to pinterestacademy.com to create the perfect lesson plan for your goals.
81
00:11:37.370 --> 00:11:50.400
So our guest this week is in charge of a product that is many people's favorite social media tool and product, so it's, his job must be fascinating, full of interesting challenges, and I'm very, uh, excited to be able to introduce, uh, Vishal Shah, Instagram's head of product.
82
00:11:50.920 --> 00:11:56.680
Uh, thank you so much for having me. It's a pleasure to be here. No worries. We've, we've been trying to, um, get somebody from Instagram to come on.
83
00:11:56.740 --> 00:12:05.520
We've had so many questions, uh, through, uh, the Facebook group about it and, uh, and other places, so it's great now to finally be able to chat to you a bit about what you do and, and how you do it.
84
00:12:05.800 --> 00:12:12.620
And I think the, the first question is probably most useful to our audience is what is a head of product, and what does it do at, at Instagram anyway?
85
00:12:13.100 --> 00:12:18.772
Well, that's a, that's a really good question, uh, 'cause I think that, that- job has really evolved as the platform has evolved.
86
00:12:18.852 --> 00:12:27.132
So I actually joined Instagram about five years ago, uh, to help build the ads business, uh, on the product side. So I have a background in, in programmatic advertising.
87
00:12:27.212 --> 00:12:31.392
I spent 10 years, uh, at a startup, mostly on the engineering side before coming here.
88
00:12:31.472 --> 00:12:51.372
And I, I came to Instagram to think about how to build an ads business that put people first and advertisers second, and to think about if we took a longer term view in what it meant to value what we're, value we're creating for advertisers, but really thinking about the experience that people are having, could we build a better, uh, online advertising platform?
89
00:12:51.552 --> 00:13:02.492
And by using the infrastructure that we had here at Facebook and thinking about all the leverage we get there, uh, but thinking about how that applies to the Instagram ecosystem was a really interesting opportunity kind of to think about.
90
00:13:02.572 --> 00:13:08.712
But at the time, we were, you know, less than, uh, a couple hundred people, uh, at Instagram. The product team was relatively small.
91
00:13:09.252 --> 00:13:12.572
Uh, and so really it was about making sure we're making those individual day-to-day decisions.
92
00:13:12.732 --> 00:13:46.071
Uh, now, you know, at, at our scale of a billion plus people using Instagram, thinking about how we keep the app simple while we build, uh, while we think about how to empower engineers and product designers and researchers and data scientists to think about how best to do their job, my role now is to think about how to best set the organization up for success to make the decisions that stays true to our values of simplicity and craft and putting people first, uh, but not actually being involved in every single product decision because that, uh, simply wouldn't scale, uh, at the, at the scale we are today.
93
00:13:46.392 --> 00:13:46.892
I can imagine.
94
00:13:46.912 --> 00:13:58.602
And I, and I guess what, what would be interesting for me as well is, is how does that role fit in with where, where Adam, who's, you know, in charge of Instagram, Adam Mosery, where does that sort of fit and how, what, what's your kind of interaction on a kind of day-to-day, week-to-week basis with him?
95
00:13:59.072 --> 00:14:05.532
Well, we certainly, uh, have to work very closely together. Adam, uh, you know, his responsibility is to think about Instagram as a whole.
96
00:14:05.572 --> 00:14:21.592
Now, we are a product-driven organization, so much of what we talk about and discuss are things about product and strategy, but Adam also thinks about, uh, the business holistically and our teams internationally and the work we do, uh, to support the ecosystem even outside of the product.
97
00:14:21.612 --> 00:14:37.312
And so, uh, while certainly we have to be very aligned on the type of product strategic investments that we're going to be making, some of our bigger bets and where they might be heading, uh, he also relies on me to help think about the direction of the product to execute on it, but also think about the health of the team.
98
00:14:37.872 --> 00:14:55.142
Uh, and I think so much of running an organization at scale is, uh, ensuring people are getting the support they need, both from a career and mentorship perspective, but also thinking about new opportunities for people, maybe even in different locations as we expand, you know, outside of just California from a development perspective, which we can, we can certainly talk about.
99
00:14:55.192 --> 00:15:00.332
Uh, so it's about thinking about the organization, the health of the organization in addition to the, the strategy around the product. Got you.
100
00:15:00.352 --> 00:15:07.512
And I guess more importantly, who does the best Instagram stories, you or Adam? Who's, who's winning on that front at the moment? I mean, you know, it's really not a comparison.
101
00:15:07.582 --> 00:15:15.652
[laughs] Adam tries his best, but, uh, I have to say I have the upper hand on that one. You do. Uh, yeah, you know, Adam's getting good though. His game's going good at the moment, so, uh, he's pretty cool.
102
00:15:15.692 --> 00:15:25.382
Um- Yeah, it's fun. It's fun [laughs] Yeah. So we're at, we're at the start of a, a new year, and, uh, what are your product priorities for the year ahead? It's, it's a, a good time to reflect.
103
00:15:25.452 --> 00:15:33.032
You know, at the beginning of the year, it's thinking about what happened the previous year. I think it was a big year of change for Instagram, uh, for a variety of reasons.
104
00:15:33.042 --> 00:15:41.052
N- new leadership team, thinking about, you know, scale at which we're operating, uh, how we think about the responsibilities we have in terms of building for a community of a billion.
105
00:15:41.432 --> 00:15:49.932
Uh, so we have four priority areas, and I'll give you a quick, um, synopsis of each of them, uh, and then we're happy to go into any more detail, uh, as, as it makes sense.
106
00:15:49.992 --> 00:16:01.972
So first and foremost, we think about how we can keep the platform a place that is safe for people, where they feel supported, where they feel safe to express themselves, because we believe the heart of ex- of Instagram is expression.
107
00:16:02.472 --> 00:16:08.652
And if people cannot express themselves in a comfortable, safe way, uh, then the, the sort of core of the platform is really at risk.
108
00:16:08.692 --> 00:16:29.632
And so, so much of the work we do is both on the sort of, let's call it defensive side, which is making sure we keep, uh, you know, content that is against our policies, for example, off the platform, but also thinking about the, the more, um, uh, offensive work that we're doing, for example, to, to fight online bullying and to think about the mental health of, of people using our platform.
109
00:16:29.712 --> 00:16:37.852
So there's a lot of work there around safety and, and wellbeing. Uh, the second area for us is, uh, helping people connect with the people that they love.
110
00:16:38.032 --> 00:16:49.672
And so if the heart of Instagram is expression, you would love when you come to Instagram, the reason you open the platform on a regular basis is because you wanna know what your closest friends are up to, what your family is up to.
111
00:16:49.712 --> 00:16:56.852
And you know, that evolves with your age group. Maybe when you're a little bit younger, it's about your friends at school, it's the people you spend time with at school.
112
00:16:56.972 --> 00:17:03.912
Um, but maybe as you get older, it's your, it's your family, it's the people you live with. And so that, there's an evolution there certainly in terms of the people that people care the most about.
113
00:17:03.952 --> 00:17:12.201
But if you come to Instagram and you aren't able to really deeply understand and, and feel connected to the people you care about, then the product is not as retentive.
114
00:17:12.722 --> 00:17:19.772
Um, but once we do have people coming to Instagram for that core use case, they stay, uh, to connect with their interests.
115
00:17:19.962 --> 00:17:33.362
And that's really, uh, the third area of priority for us, which is, you know, how do you, uh, connect with that business or that creator, or how do you shop from them, or how do you think about the, the long form video that they're creating?
116
00:17:33.362 --> 00:17:43.412
And so a lot of the more recent experiences that we've built, not just in our, in our new investments, uh, but even in things like s- uh, search and explore, really thinking about going deep with, with your interests across Instagram.
117
00:17:43.422 --> 00:17:49.552
And as a platform that's visual in nature, um, and has an asymmetric follow graph, you know, that's a really natural place for interests to live.
118
00:17:49.592 --> 00:17:58.632
And we're seeing that not only something that we need to invest in more, but really a, a, a cornerstone of how people think of, of the platform. Uh, and the last one, uh, is really about helping
119
00:17:59.732 --> 00:18:06.592
people turn their passion or their hobby or their interest into a business, and to make a living, uh, on the platform.
120
00:18:06.612 --> 00:18:33.592
And I, I call that out as a specific priority because it's not just the business that we're building, uh, in terms of what we're doing in, in ads, but helping small businesses, helping creators, you know, really embracing the secular shift that we're seeing from big organizations with lots of, of tools at their disposal to the individual, you know, hobbyist in their garage who has a, a thing that they care about and can turn that passion, turn that excitement, uh, into, into a living for themselves.
121
00:18:34.284 --> 00:18:39.164
It's such a, such a complicated product. Not in a, not in a bad way, but it's such a, an involved product now.
122
00:18:39.204 --> 00:18:48.644
If you think about back to the, uh, the days of a simple photo sharing app, uh, uh, 10 years ago, and now you've got this, uh, uh, this, this enormously well-developed platform.
123
00:18:48.674 --> 00:18:58.284
And sometimes I think it's, it's, it's, it's easy to forget just how much there is packed into that app. Yeah. That is a, that is a really good observation, but also a bit by design.
124
00:18:58.384 --> 00:19:04.784
So I mentioned earlier our values and, and I'll come back to them as we talk because it's so central to how we build.
125
00:19:04.844 --> 00:19:10.444
So one of those values is, um, simplicity, and there's a couple of different ways to look at simplicity.
126
00:19:10.544 --> 00:19:32.684
One is we believe very strongly that Instagram should feel like one product, not a series of products stitched together into a container, which means that we will often make product decisions that are actually suboptimal for any one product, but the right decision for Instagram as a whole because we value how the whole thing feels, uh, whether that's from a design systems perspective or even from a feature perspective.
127
00:19:32.764 --> 00:19:36.924
So there's a lot of thought that goes into making sure the, the whole app feels cohesive.
128
00:19:37.464 --> 00:19:44.124
Um, but the second is as we're adding new use cases, new reasons for people to use Instagram, uh, we have to stay true to the core.
129
00:19:44.524 --> 00:19:54.444
And as I mentioned before, the core's expression, it's about connecting with the people you care the most about, and we will make sure that that stays front and center in the experience, whether that's in, in feed, or in stories, or in some of the sharing flows.
130
00:19:54.904 --> 00:19:57.764
Uh, that has to be at the center of, of what people do.
131
00:19:58.344 --> 00:20:17.464
But then if the additional experience that people then come to Instagram for, whether that's video, or shopping, or interests, um, are things that they would like to opt into, we would want to make that easy for them to get to, but we don't want that to dominate the experience if that's not what they want, which I know is a very subtle, uh, kind of line that we're trying to, to weave.
132
00:20:17.604 --> 00:20:20.664
Um, but it's a really important part of how we think about building the app as a whole.
133
00:20:20.864 --> 00:20:37.564
And how, how do you make the decision on what, what stays as, as part of the app, as the main part of the, the core Inst- Instagram experience and what you siphon off it into its own separate app, that decision of whether you have a pr- you know, um, just a messaging app, which I know you've experimented with and withdrawn, and now you're experimenting it in, in direct, uh, messages and things on, on the web.
134
00:20:37.904 --> 00:20:44.544
You know, how do you choose to keep it in the app or to, to create a new one? Well, so I think there's two different, uh, two different considerations.
135
00:20:44.704 --> 00:20:53.554
One is inside the main app, how do you think about the core experience, the thing that people spend the majority of their time, uh, using because it is what the app opens to, right?
136
00:20:53.584 --> 00:21:04.964
The fact that it opens to your home experience, which is feed and stories, sort of sets the tone for what the app is for. And then where do we think about things that go into the explore tab or into search?
137
00:21:05.284 --> 00:21:13.084
You know, there's a, there's some considerations there about simplicity and making sure that that feels really easy, but we wanna make sure that that core home experience feels, um, really cohesive.
138
00:21:13.724 --> 00:21:31.684
Then there's the question of, as you mentioned, separate apps, which I think, um, uh, it's kind of this interesting evolution, I think, for how people think about apps, where, you know, apps are very much like spaces and people associate jobs, use cases, things that they do with a space.
139
00:21:31.764 --> 00:21:43.494
You know, you go to an office, you go to a restaurant, you go to a bar, and there's a set of norms associated with those spaces. There's the mental kind of, uh, expectation of what you get when you go into that space.
140
00:21:44.024 --> 00:21:49.644
Um, and so that's like the, the sort of physical equivalent, but there's also the, the physics of a separate app on your phone.
141
00:21:50.144 --> 00:21:58.044
Uh, if you're sending a lot of push notifications, uh, from one app, that is now maybe in contrast with how people tend to think about that app, for example, with messaging.
142
00:21:58.444 --> 00:22:03.484
You really wanna make sure that you can reach someone, and so me- push messaging and push notifications are incredibly important.
143
00:22:04.064 --> 00:22:09.404
Um, but if you take something like Threads, which is our, our standalone app that, uh, we are, we are testing for messaging,
144
00:22:10.324 --> 00:22:15.984
you know that when you get a push notification from Threads, it is going to be from one of your close friends.
145
00:22:16.304 --> 00:22:22.584
And so you know when you see that push notification that it is from someone that you have determined is important to you.
146
00:22:22.704 --> 00:22:28.244
And it's actually, if you think about it from that perspective, the only messaging app that you get to decide who gets to reach you.
147
00:22:28.624 --> 00:22:45.464
Because it sits on top of the Instagram network, all of the reachability and findability behavior exists in the core app, but the sh- the sort of siphoned off messaging experience that's limited to your close friends gets to play in this very separate space, which when you go back to the, the space analogy, means that when you open it, you kind of know what you're gonna get.
148
00:22:45.964 --> 00:22:53.913
And, and how is Threads doing? And what can you tell us about that at the moment? 'Cause I, I think people know, or some people know that it's out there, and it's being tested, and the, um, the basics of how it works.
149
00:22:53.983 --> 00:23:02.924
But, uh, can you give us any update on that? It's, it's going well in the sense that, you know, we put apps out there sometimes to learn about how people use them and, and we take different approaches.
150
00:23:02.964 --> 00:23:09.964
In some cases, we will market them very heavily and, and want to get as many people using it as possible 'cause that's what matters. Uh, with Threads, we actually took a different approach.
151
00:23:10.024 --> 00:23:21.644
We, we haven't done a lot of, uh, proactive marketing or, or even, um, you know, upsells inside the product to get people to try it, and we're really trying to understand for the people who do find it, who do use it, how they're using it.
152
00:23:22.024 --> 00:23:32.204
Uh, and so while it's a little bit too early to give any definitive, uh, you know, data on that, uh, we're pleased to see where things are, are going because it, because it's really focused on these three areas that we were trying to differentiate Threads on.
153
00:23:32.344 --> 00:23:37.384
One of which I just talked about around close friends and having that sense of control over who shows up in that space.
154
00:23:37.904 --> 00:23:46.964
Um, the other is around, um, really fast and quick performance and the idea of the app being very simple, that it is, is very, um, kind of devoid of clutter.
155
00:23:47.384 --> 00:23:50.804
Uh, not just from an experience perspective, but even from an app performance perspective.
156
00:23:50.844 --> 00:24:00.564
We want it to, to open very quickly, to get to the camera very quickly, and the team actually spent a lot of time, uh, working on the underlying infrastructure for the camera to make sure that it can open as, as quickly as possible.
157
00:24:01.164 --> 00:24:10.324
Uh, and the third is an, a kind of a newer area that we're exploring, which is how do you think about if it's a place for your closest friends, what are the types of things that would inspire a conversation?
158
00:24:10.744 --> 00:24:25.444
Uh, and that's where you've seen some of the work we've done in Status, which is, uh, is it helpful to know that a friend of yours is traveling or, or even outside of their home, or that their phone is, is charging and so you might know that they're not reachable right now because they're probably not with their device?
159
00:24:25.484 --> 00:24:34.844
There's like things like that that we're trying to understand, you know, what are ways in which, again, because it's limited to your closest friends, what are the types of things that are a bit more asynchronous but would inspire a conversation?
160
00:24:34.864 --> 00:24:38.284
Those are the types of things that we're, that we're really excited about to learn more about how people use in Threads.
161
00:24:39.360 --> 00:24:51.240
I got this vision of, uh, and of you guys in a room and having all the data and all the things about what people's been testing and what things you've been trying out to see what works, and having you on one side of the table and a team of other people battling it and saying, "That one's dead.
162
00:24:51.300 --> 00:24:59.360
We're gonna kill that feature." W- it, does it come to it in the end where you kind of, there is kind of some tough decisions and is about kind of getting a m- a majority consensus?
163
00:24:59.420 --> 00:25:04.290
How do you kind of come to that final decision? Yeah, I think there's no sort of set rule for that.
164
00:25:04.400 --> 00:25:14.310
Certainly, there are conversations around, uh, you know, what, what is in and what's out, and some of it, frankly, you know, is subjective. There is this, this sense of what it means to make a call on something.
165
00:25:14.340 --> 00:25:23.600
And maybe you don't have perfect data. If you have perfect data, then maybe you waited too long to make a decision. Um, but also just where, you know, strategically we- we're heading. I... Here's the fun thing. I,
166
00:25:24.540 --> 00:25:30.770
I feel like, and you, you sort of started the podcast with, you know, how, how interesting could this job be thinking about Instagram as a whole.
167
00:25:31.170 --> 00:25:40.440
And I feel very lucky to have surrounded myself with really incredible product thinkers who get to explore in these spaces and, and ensure that we are building towards value for people.
168
00:25:40.490 --> 00:25:48.760
And we might make decisions to, you know, shut something down, not because, um, it wasn't useful, but actually is, is detracting from a, a value perspective.
169
00:25:48.840 --> 00:26:03.840
So, you know, we've been really diligent in this last year about kicking off something that I call, um, unship, uh, which is very counterintuitive, especially for, for people who, who are, you know, used to technology companies just always shipping new things.
170
00:26:03.860 --> 00:26:12.680
It's very easy for an engineer or for a product manager or for a designer to celebrate shipping a product into a, into the world. It is not very common to celebrate unshipping something.
171
00:26:13.180 --> 00:26:23.280
And knowing that by removing a, a feature or a product, you're actually making the overall experience better, and we're trying to set a culture where that is celebrated just as much as shipping the thing in the first place.
172
00:26:23.380 --> 00:26:28.340
Um, and again, back to the idea of keeping Instagram really simple, and, and we've done a few of those, you know, this year.
173
00:26:28.400 --> 00:26:37.600
But I wanted to sort of make sure that that was clear, is the reason we do that is because we value the simplicity of the product so much that we want to celebrate unship just as much as shipping in the first place.
174
00:26:37.740 --> 00:26:46.100
And d- d- does it make any difference if there's millions of your users that are out there saying that they really want something changed on Instagram, it's driving them nuts, and they're really fed up with it and stuff?
175
00:26:46.160 --> 00:26:49.109
Does that kind of sway on any of your decision-making in this process?
176
00:26:49.480 --> 00:26:58.320
Well, I mean, I'd be, you know, I think I'd be lying if I said that we don't listen to all kinds of feedback, whether that's, uh, individual research that we do with people. I mean, we certainly read the media.
177
00:26:58.360 --> 00:27:06.880
I've, I've listened to your podcast, and I know you guys have chatted about Instagram a, a fair amount, and that's important input into the process. But, uh, that's just one of the factors that we think about.
178
00:27:06.940 --> 00:27:17.820
So as an example, uh, we recently sh- unshipped, uh, the Following tab inside the Activity feed. I know you guys actually discussed this on the podcast a couple of months ago. Mm. Um, and we did that for a few reasons.
179
00:27:18.180 --> 00:27:25.100
One, uh, it was, while it was used by, you know, an... It was not an insignificant percentage of, of our pro- of the, of the user base.
180
00:27:25.480 --> 00:27:35.889
The, the research we had done and the reason people were using it was for two reasons. One was to discover new accounts and to find new places, uh, of Instagram that they maybe didn't know about.
181
00:27:36.310 --> 00:27:50.360
And given that the Following tab was launched almost nine years ago, there's a lot of work that we've done to improve that use case in places like Search and Explore and in some of our rec- recommendation surfaces that we think are far more personalized and do a better job of account discovery.
182
00:27:51.080 --> 00:27:59.660
But the second is that people were using it to sort of see what their friends were up to or doing, or even if the people they didn't know directly, but the, you know, the creators and the public figures that they followed.
183
00:28:00.120 --> 00:28:08.120
And, and lots of people didn't know that their consumption behavior, their likes, their comments, their follows were being surfaced in this way.
184
00:28:08.660 --> 00:28:27.920
And so it was both a simplicity win to remove something that was not used by a lot of people, but also, uh, aligned with the, the safety and, and kinda comfort that we want to make sure that people on Instagram have, where it doesn't feel like your behavior is always on display and that you have to worry about liking something and that someone coming and figuring out what you, what you've liked.
185
00:28:27.960 --> 00:28:30.280
And so there's a lot of different drivers here.
186
00:28:30.360 --> 00:28:40.280
Um, you know, we, we try to keep a balance between what we hear, but also know that sometimes what you hear is what people want you to hear, not necessarily what their underlying kind of core motivation is.
187
00:28:40.820 --> 00:28:47.940
Uh, and, and [laughs] I'm sure you have some examples of, of questions like that that we can also talk about. Yeah, I will do. I'm, I'm, I've got a couple of things at the end that I'll come back to.
188
00:28:47.960 --> 00:28:52.380
We've got some audience, uh, listeners who've wanted to ask you some things, so we'll, we'll jump into some of those.
189
00:28:52.460 --> 00:29:07.360
But, but talking about removing things, it, uh, one of the things that everyone's been talking about in the last few months with Instagram or about Instagram is the removal of the like counter, um, and, uh, and how that's been played out in terms of it's, you know, been tested in various countries, and it's still being tested.
190
00:29:07.400 --> 00:29:21.380
And I think I saw a, an Instagram story from, from Adam saying something along the lines of, uh, that it, you know, you're hoping later this year to, to roll it out, which is, or something along those lines, which suggested maybe that it's, it seems likely that it will be rolled out permanently globally.
191
00:29:21.800 --> 00:29:27.760
Um, can you give us an update on where it is and, and what that's, what's it changed about how people are using the app? Yeah, ab- absolutely.
192
00:29:27.780 --> 00:29:32.260
And, and, you know, I'm personally very excited about this work, and I, I know Adam is, too.
193
00:29:32.580 --> 00:29:44.240
A- actually, interestingly, the origin story of this entire, um, effort is, is also great because a lot of times these efforts are a more tops-down decision, you know, a decision that Adam has made or something that I've made.
194
00:29:44.300 --> 00:29:50.360
But actually, this one came from the team that works on, uh, interactions in feed.
195
00:29:50.420 --> 00:30:07.740
So this team is, is incentivized to try to drive, uh, more likes, more comments, but in all of their user research, they heard so loud and clear that people felt like the public like count was a very high area of pressure for them when they produced content on Instagram.
196
00:30:08.240 --> 00:30:23.820
And if you think of the, the core of the platform being about expression and getting people to share with the people they care the most about, the art or the sort of the act of expression itself is what we cared about, not the validation or perceived validation that a public like count gets people.
197
00:30:24.560 --> 00:30:34.900
Now, in 2010, when we launched, it made sense from a norms perspective to say, when you put something out there, the way you know that people are seeing it is through something like a, like a like count.
198
00:30:35.360 --> 00:30:45.600
Uh, that was sort of the norm at the time. But what we've seen since 2016 with, with Stories is that these public, uh, kind of engagement metrics that are shared are, are not the things that drive behavior.
199
00:30:45.620 --> 00:30:54.640
It's about, you know, private interactions. It's about conversations in Direct. It's about the act of sharing in and of itself. And so we learned a lot from that, uh, inside of Stories.
200
00:30:54.660 --> 00:31:07.864
And then also said if, if People were deleting the stuff that they posted to feed because they felt like they were competing with themselves, they were competing with public figures and celebrities and influencers that they felt they could never be on a, an evil, even playing field.
201
00:31:08.364 --> 00:31:14.754
We thought this was a, one of the most effective ways to, to even that playing field and to remove some of that pressure of, of performing.
202
00:31:15.364 --> 00:31:21.244
Um, and the reason that this is taking us some time to ship broadly is this is a big change.
203
00:31:21.264 --> 00:31:28.474
It's probably the biggest, uh, sort of, uh, you know, smallest number of pixels to biggest ecosystem change that I think you could, you could probably think about.
204
00:31:28.484 --> 00:31:40.324
And so we wanna make sure we're doing it right and we understand the, the, not just the short-term, but the long-term implications, understanding, uh, the sentiment that people have as they, as they use this product, and we have it out in, in many countries to, to really do that.
205
00:31:40.784 --> 00:31:43.044
Um, but to also make sure we're doing, we're doing it responsibly.
206
00:31:43.444 --> 00:31:59.244
But I, I wanna end that section by saying we know, we knew going into this that we would likely have to trade off some amount of engagement to do this work, and we are very comfortable doing that if at the end it makes people more comfortable, you know, expressing themselves and sharing on Instagram.
207
00:31:59.524 --> 00:32:04.744
And can we, can we, can we expect to see that, uh, rolling out globally, or is that still not really a decision that's been made yet, do you think?
208
00:32:05.124 --> 00:32:13.204
You know, it's not a decision that's explicitly been made yet, but you know, we are working very hard to, to get this out and to really understand the implications.
209
00:32:13.244 --> 00:32:22.624
And as I mentioned, Adam and I are both very excited about what this could mean for the platform, and the research and the anecdotes that we've heard, uh, sort of support why we, the motivations behind why we built it.
210
00:32:22.684 --> 00:32:33.084
So, uh, I, I wish I could commit to you on, on, today on a, on a timeframe, but, um, know that we're excited about it, know that we continue to, to push on it because we think it's really important. Okay. Martin. Yeah.
211
00:32:33.144 --> 00:32:43.624
How do you, if we look at something like hiding like counts, how do you significantly change a platform like that without killing the soul of the platform, if you get what I mean?
212
00:32:43.664 --> 00:32:57.304
Uh, 'cause users are very sensitive to changes, and if the l- feel of the app is changed even just slightly, it can really have an impact on how people use the app, how they enjoy it. Uh, how do you go about that?
213
00:32:57.644 --> 00:33:06.024
Look, I would argue that the soul of Instagram is about expression and sharing, uh, not about the, the public validation that a like might give you.
214
00:33:06.374 --> 00:33:14.904
That being said, the reason we are taking our time to understand the implications of this is you don't run a test for a month and figure out what the effects of, of something like this are.
215
00:33:15.264 --> 00:33:20.364
Uh, you do have to run this for a longer period of time to really understand, uh, not just what happens in the short term.
216
00:33:20.424 --> 00:33:29.084
Like most product changes that you make, you'll get some change in, in behavior in the very short term. Sometimes it will regress back to where it was before. Sometimes it will actually reverse.
217
00:33:29.584 --> 00:33:33.244
Um, but oftentimes you really wanna understand the, the longer implications for some time.
218
00:33:33.264 --> 00:33:41.344
And so it takes a, a while for an individual to have this, uh, you know, feature in their hand for the, for their behaviors to actually change, um, in, in one way or the other.
219
00:33:41.384 --> 00:33:48.654
So that's one of the reasons it just takes that, the amount of time to, to do it. Um, but I think the, the, the deeper question that you've asked there is
220
00:33:49.924 --> 00:33:58.314
just because a product has worked a certain way for a period of time doesn't mean we shouldn't ask ourselves whether that's the right behavior now.
221
00:33:59.064 --> 00:34:02.384
And, you know, there's been a series of those things over the course of Instagram's history.
222
00:34:02.424 --> 00:34:11.184
You know, when I first got here in 2015, uh, one of the very first things we worked on was changing the, uh, restriction on square photos.
223
00:34:11.784 --> 00:34:21.964
And if you ask someone in 2000, even, even in early 2015 if, if you can imagine Instagram without square photos, they would say, "That's so core to the identity of what the platform is. How could you change that?"
224
00:34:22.504 --> 00:34:29.534
Um, but in reality, um, more than 20% of media uploaded to Instagram had some form of manual letterboxing that people were doing.
225
00:34:30.024 --> 00:34:40.204
And so they were already getting around this constraint when really they wanted to express a moment, and if they had, uh, something that they wanted to share that was wider or taller, they were figuring out a way to make that fit in the square.
226
00:34:40.264 --> 00:34:44.603
That didn't feel like it was staying true to the soul of the platform, which was about expression.
227
00:34:45.024 --> 00:34:52.084
And so there's a series of things I think over the course of our history that is maybe some would call sacred cows that we've gone back and revisited, and we're not afraid.
228
00:34:52.384 --> 00:35:01.544
I'm very proud of the fact that we're not afraid to revisit some of those really what feel like core things if they're the right decisions going forward. So DMs coming to the web.
229
00:35:01.664 --> 00:35:12.844
So this is something that's come out this week that, uh, Instagram is going to be testing it with a small subset of users, the ability to, uh, use the messaging features and functionality on, on desktop version of Instagram.
230
00:35:13.304 --> 00:35:15.004
Um, why now?
231
00:35:15.384 --> 00:35:24.884
This is one of those, um, you know, I wish we could do everything as quickly as we wanted to, but we have, you know, we have to prioritize some of the, the work that we do, and this is something that's been on our radar for, for a little while.
232
00:35:24.904 --> 00:35:37.304
I think two things to say here. One is I don't consider the desktop version of Instagram to be the primary way that people will use Instagram. I think the primary job of Instagram is about expression.
233
00:35:37.344 --> 00:35:44.224
It's about personal expression, which means it's, it's mobile, it's very personal. It's about when you're out and about, but also when you're home and you have something to share.
234
00:35:44.784 --> 00:36:06.284
Um, and so I think of the desktop experience as a secondary interface for Instagram, which is sometimes there are some things that just get, that are just easier done, um, on a desktop, which for example, when you're messaging and you're typing a, a decent amount, and I know, uh, for, for those of us that use the product a lot, uh, it's a, it's a, you know, sometimes a, a difficult thing to have to switch to your phone when you're typing, you know, quite a bit.
235
00:36:06.304 --> 00:36:21.124
And so we think of this as it's not necessarily going to be the primary way that everyone uses, uh, direct messaging, but there's enough, um, you know, whether it's, you call it a power user behavior or people who use direct messaging a lot, uh, where I think this could be very helpful, uh, for people who, who use the platform.
236
00:36:21.144 --> 00:36:24.384
And our, and our desktop experience over time has gotten, gotten more feature rich.
237
00:36:24.844 --> 00:36:39.624
Um, and by no means do I expect it to be a replacement for mobile, but I do think it, it solves some needs, um, for reporters, for journalists, for, um, businesses, for creators, and I think it, it can be very, very valuable when you, when you have the volume of messaging that, that you do on, on a platform like ours.
238
00:36:40.224 --> 00:36:53.104
So Mark Zuckerberg has stated his aim of integrating the backend of all of Facebook's owned messaging pod- um, products, and it wants to make it possible for users to message a friend on WhatsApp from within Instagram and vice versa, and, and many other benefits, uh, is outlined.
239
00:36:53.464 --> 00:37:00.444
And, uh, it enables Facebook also, I guess, to compete more with, uh, rivals such as iMessages as well with it, which is much more kind of like that.
240
00:37:00.784 --> 00:37:10.884
And so, um, you know, how is that project progressing, and, and what can users expect to see, um, visually when they're, like when you're using these messaging apps in, in the year ahead when this is completed? Yeah.
241
00:37:10.944 --> 00:37:17.204
I think it's important here to start in the, in the motivations and what we're trying to achieve and, and, and why we kicked this off in the first place.
242
00:37:17.244 --> 00:37:40.538
So, um, maybe think to your, your own experience, and so I can ex- describe a bit of mine, um, as an example, but- You know, I have, you know, the exact same kind of group messaging thread, uh, with a couple of friends on Instagram Direct, on WhatsApp, on Messenger, and we sometimes have the conversations in individual places based on, you know, a piece of content that we found, and so the message might go there.
243
00:37:41.028 --> 00:37:54.208
Uh, but then I think back to the, the, you know, one-on-one thread that I have with my wife, and while we predominantly use a, a given, you know, space, recently when she traveled to India, uh, all of those conversations kind of moved to WhatsApp, and then she came back, and then we were back on Instagram.
244
00:37:54.378 --> 00:37:59.648
And if I ever wanted to go back and reference any of that conversation, it was splintered, and we didn't exactly know where to go back and look at it.
245
00:37:59.668 --> 00:38:08.148
And if you think about that use case of talking to an individual, the fact that that splintered across multiple apps is actually quite challenging.
246
00:38:08.728 --> 00:38:12.308
Um, that being said, there are other use cases that maybe don't make as much sense.
247
00:38:12.328 --> 00:38:34.188
So if you are running, you know, multiple accounts, uh, for Instagram and you have a very specific account that is an Instagram account that is not on Facebook or not on WhatsApp, we think that you can continue and should continue to use, you know, the messaging app of choice, especially when you aren't feeling the sort of splintering o- of the conversation where it's not about the individual across multiple surfaces, but really about, um, kind of the app experience in and of itself.
248
00:38:34.728 --> 00:38:43.428
So as you can imagine, a, a project like this is, uh, incredibly complicated, both from a technical infrastructure perspective, but also from a product, uh, experience perspective.
249
00:38:43.468 --> 00:38:55.368
And so, um, we're working through both of those in parallel to understand, you know, A, uh, for whom will this, would this be most useful, and how do we make sure that they find value in it and, and they can, and opt into it?
250
00:38:55.808 --> 00:39:04.718
Uh, how does that experience then feel cohesive, uh, for them when they have opted into it? Uh, how does the back end work? Uh, how do we transition people from, from the current world into this world?
251
00:39:05.158 --> 00:39:09.248
Uh, and you know, there have been some open questions even on encryption that we're working through.
252
00:39:09.288 --> 00:39:16.798
And the reason we announced this product as early as we did, uh, was to make sure we could have some of that public dialogue about how we would, um, solve some of these issues.
253
00:39:17.268 --> 00:39:23.318
Uh, normally I think our product development process is much more, you know, we do a lot of this behind the scenes and then kinda talk about it when it's ready.
254
00:39:23.318 --> 00:39:41.888
Uh, but knowing how important of a change this was, it was a different philosophy in terms of talking about it earlier and getting feedback and engaging with not just consumers, but, um, you know, uh, advocacy groups and safety groups and kind of thinking about the implications not just of the, of the interoperability between the platforms, but what it means to move to a, to an encrypted space.
255
00:39:42.488 --> 00:39:48.488
And there's, and one last question on that one really is, i- is it, is it on track in terms of what you had set yourself to achieve by this point?
256
00:39:48.528 --> 00:39:52.798
Is it kind of where you want it to be, or is, uh, is it become s- more challenging than you thought? Where, where is that?
257
00:39:53.508 --> 00:40:04.048
Uh, these things are, these kinds of projects are always fun because the things that you thought were really complicated up front sometimes are, are less complicated than you thought, and the things that you thought were really simple and straightforward are sometimes much more complicated than you realized.
258
00:40:04.068 --> 00:40:04.968
And so I think we have a bit of both.
259
00:40:04.988 --> 00:40:18.568
And so generally I feel like we're, we're making good progress, but it's, it's such a, um, kind of complicated set of systems that we're working through that, uh, I think it's gonna take us some time to make sure we really, uh, feel confident in, in any kind of dates or any kind of announcements.
260
00:40:18.708 --> 00:40:26.148
But, um, but I'm, I'm, I'm excited about the, the teams working on some of the hardest problems. And again, back to the point of not
261
00:40:27.268 --> 00:40:36.788
shying away from the core of the product or from the hardest problems, I think as a, as a company, we're very good at when we decide that this is the right experience and we think it's important for people, that we will take the time to, to get that work right.
262
00:40:36.908 --> 00:40:48.348
Okay. Martin. We talked about safety and privacy earlier, and this is, uh, something that's become, uh, such a, a hot s- product, uh, topic around, uh, Silicon Valley i- in, uh, i- in, in recent times.
263
00:40:48.408 --> 00:40:55.488
You just look this week at, uh, Google removing third-party cookies from Chrome. You know, it's, uh, it would've sounded unthinkable, um, a couple of years ago.
264
00:40:56.038 --> 00:41:01.508
Um, if we look at Threads, for example, um, you were talking about the contextual things that happen there in the, in the background.
265
00:41:01.717 --> 00:41:05.157
It, it tells your friends when you're moving or, uh, charging your phone, things like that.
266
00:41:05.628 --> 00:41:15.618
Um, and one thing that struck me when I u- used Threads for the first time was I had to share my real-time location with Instagram, ergo Facebook, in order to get that to work.
267
00:41:15.728 --> 00:41:22.508
So there's obviously a clear ad tech benefit for, for Facebook there, which is un- understandable. Facebook is an advertising company.
268
00:41:22.908 --> 00:41:33.528
Um, but there's also the benefit for me as a user in that kind of contextual information being shared, and we, we get, uh, something from that. Do you think that this kind of, there's sort of give and take there.
269
00:41:33.648 --> 00:41:45.868
Do you think that give and take, that kind of, um, w- we give you this, but you have to give up that, that kind of transaction is going to have to become a bit more transparent in this more privacy-minded age?
270
00:41:46.288 --> 00:41:50.128
Uh, no question. Uh, I think there are a, a bunch of factors here.
271
00:41:50.188 --> 00:42:05.608
One is sort of general awareness, uh, from a consumer perspective of how platforms work and how the, the systems that they use use, uh, data, use, um, uh, you know, algorithms and, and information to help make decisions and make recommendations.
272
00:42:06.138 --> 00:42:15.448
Um, but I think it hasn't always been clear to people, uh, exactly what data is being used and how it's being used and why it's helpful or, or in their minds, not helpful for the way they use the platform.
273
00:42:15.468 --> 00:42:25.408
So I think as an industry, we have to get to a place where we have to be super transparent about what data we're using, uh, why w- why it's being used, and, and what it could be used for.
274
00:42:25.428 --> 00:42:33.448
But people also need to know the benefit that they get by sharing that information, and if they opt out of it, what the implications of opting out may actually be.
275
00:42:33.868 --> 00:42:49.068
And I think that is not really well established yet in terms of, I mean, you can make a statement that, okay, if you opt out of, of da- tracking for ads targeting, your ads might become less relevant, uh, which I think is actually a real, people really, uh, have a negative, uh, reaction to that when they actually live with it.
276
00:42:49.448 --> 00:42:53.228
Um, but we don't do a very good job of explaining that to people in the moment when they're making that decision.
277
00:42:53.728 --> 00:43:04.888
Uh, or, you know, how good the recommendations would be even outside of ads, uh, just for content that they might see, for example, in Explore on Instagram and what their experience might, might do and might change if, if the data was being used differently.
278
00:43:05.328 --> 00:43:12.404
And so I think the Uh, you know, you guys have talked on this podcast a lot about sort of patterns for, for products and for design.
279
00:43:12.444 --> 00:43:24.004
I think we'll see a lot in the next, let's call it five to 10 years, about how best we can not only be transparent about what data's being collected and how it's being used, but how that information then affects the experience that people are having.
280
00:43:24.524 --> 00:43:33.244
Uh, and some of it comes down to the business model in terms of a free product being advertising supported. Some of it comes down to the level of personalization that people can get with using a product like ours.
281
00:43:33.704 --> 00:43:38.464
Um, but then also being clear that if you don't wanna provide that then maybe you have an experience that you're not as excited about.
282
00:43:38.524 --> 00:43:47.024
But people just need to know, uh, what they're getting or what they're not when they're making some of these choices. So how do you see Instagram looking three to five years from now?
283
00:43:47.124 --> 00:43:54.894
So that's kind of a not too far away it's unrealistic and crazy, but also separate to that, what do you think it might look like in 10 years from now?
284
00:43:55.004 --> 00:44:04.354
So really kind of blue sky thinking especially with the concepts of things to do with the Oculus and what they're doing with AR and AR stuff, now AR glasses have been talked about at, uh, many different places.
285
00:44:04.404 --> 00:44:12.124
Uh, what's your thoughts there? Yeah. I think in the three to five-year timeframe, uh, you know, we'll continue to be focused in, in, I believe in the four areas that I mentioned.
286
00:44:12.243 --> 00:44:21.324
Maybe specifics within them might, might evolve over time. So as an example, and I, I don't believe we will ever go away from the core of people expressing and sharing.
287
00:44:21.384 --> 00:44:31.084
Uh, now how they share and to whom they share I think will continuously evolve. We've seen a shift from, you know, broadcast sharing into a feed, uh, evolving into Stories.
288
00:44:31.104 --> 00:44:37.104
We're seeing more communication, more pri- uh, sharing happening in private groups, uh, whether it's a group of people or even individually.
289
00:44:37.124 --> 00:44:45.204
So I think the, the audience and what people are comfortable sharing and to whom is, is changing. Uh, the way in which they capture and they, and they share is a- also evolving.
290
00:44:45.244 --> 00:44:53.554
The cameras certainly on phones have gotten, gotten much better. Technology from a, um, you know, augmented reality kind of effects perspective have, have continuously gotten better.
291
00:44:53.624 --> 00:45:12.584
I've been incredibly proud of the, the work that we've been seeing out of the, the platform work that we've done on AR on Instagram where, you know, over the holidays, I don't know if this was as big, um, in the UK, uh, but we had a lot of filters, uh, uh, face effects on, you know, what Disney character are you or, or you know, what celebrity are you that didn't come from Instagram.
292
00:45:12.624 --> 00:45:21.944
It came from the community and that was an incredibly inspiring to see some of those things, you know, really find traction. And so the ways in which those things, um, evolve will, will...
293
00:45:21.984 --> 00:45:25.824
Or the, the ways in which people share will evolve, and we need to make sure we're setting the right guardrails.
294
00:45:25.844 --> 00:45:34.544
And so as we opened up that platform early last year, one of the things that we were looking at really actively was what kinds of effects we would allow versus not allow from a policy perspective.
295
00:45:34.564 --> 00:45:45.803
And we made a decision, you know, last year to say things that were explicitly about, you know, plastic surgery or facial, um, uh, things that made it look like you, you were having, you know, explicit plastic surgery were things we did not want on the platform.
296
00:45:46.114 --> 00:45:53.124
And that's a call that we'd have to make along the way, and I think we as platforms need to think about those things as we're making calls. What is allowed or not allowed in, in Live?
297
00:45:53.204 --> 00:45:56.424
What is allowed or not allowed in, in things like effects?
298
00:45:56.464 --> 00:46:04.104
And this is a challenging question when you talk about a global platform because norms are, are certainly quite different, you know, country by country and, and region by region.
299
00:46:04.604 --> 00:46:09.504
And so I, I think those are challenges that we're gonna have to continue to, to face and think through as, as we launch them.
300
00:46:09.544 --> 00:46:19.804
But, uh, the core of the product I think will really will stay, uh, you know, centered on, on sharing an expression. But I do think you'll see, start to see more from us, um, on these different interest verticals.
301
00:46:20.004 --> 00:46:31.773
Uh, so you've seen some of that already, uh, with IGTV as a place for, for Instagram creators to tell a longer, deeper story than what they could do on Feed or in Stories, uh, uh, pun intended.
302
00:46:32.284 --> 00:46:44.384
Um, or in, in Shopping, uh, where people are opting in to follow brands, to follow stylists and bloggers, and to see the latest trends and to understand, uh, what a product might be that they could, they could purchase.
303
00:46:44.844 --> 00:46:55.354
Um, so I think we have some ideas like that, um, in other verticals. Things like travel and music, uh, and gaming that I think you can, you'll start to see us, you know, work on more in the years to come.
304
00:46:55.764 --> 00:47:03.944
We do try to be very, um, deliberate about how many of those things we're doing at any one point in time, back to the point on simplicity. So, um, we're gonna have to wrap up.
305
00:47:03.984 --> 00:47:08.354
I think our time is coming close to an end with you 'cause I know you're busy and you've got some more meetings you've gotta jump into.
306
00:47:08.534 --> 00:47:20.204
So, um, we had a ton of people ask us questions, um, that they wanted me to ask you about various things. Um, they're all pretty decently interesting questions that I would've wanted to answer mys- uh, answers to myself.
307
00:47:20.284 --> 00:47:24.904
So, uh, if you don't mind, we're gonna jump through in probably, like, 30 seconds on each is fine and see what, see what we can come up with.
308
00:47:25.604 --> 00:47:33.164
Um, so, uh, can you give us a teaser about what cool new Instagram stickers for Stories you're testing or thinking about developing? And that's from me.
309
00:47:33.484 --> 00:47:37.044
[laughs] That's the first one, and then the rest of them everyone else can have. Well, so I, I...
310
00:47:37.064 --> 00:47:44.504
Let me instead of a specific sticker, I'll tell you sort of the thematically how we're thinking about the, the creative tools in, in a place like Stories. So we're looking at two different things.
311
00:47:44.684 --> 00:47:55.444
One is what are, are the types of stickers or, or effects that give you a reason to share, not just about augmenting something you've already decided to share. So it's a, a reason to share in the first place. That's one.
312
00:47:55.904 --> 00:48:03.744
Uh, and the second is how to make, uh, Stories even more interactive. And so you saw that with the polling sticker. You saw that with the questions and answer sticker and the emoji slider.
313
00:48:04.164 --> 00:48:14.854
There's something about, um, making the space really interactive, which I think is amazing for, for people, but also really amazing for businesses, uh, to be able to connect with their fans and their audiences, uh, in, in ways that we're exploring.
314
00:48:15.344 --> 00:48:22.704
Got you. Right. Well, we've got a bunch of questions about one particular topic which is, uh, "When will IGTV get monetization features?" Says David Orrego.
315
00:48:22.944 --> 00:48:32.964
And also someone else, "Any plans for improving IGTV search features?" Says At Not Nap. And there was also a question about just generally where, where it is at for IGTV.
316
00:48:33.064 --> 00:48:40.184
Um, have you got anything you can share with us today? Yeah. You know, there's a, there's a few things on IGTV that are worth calling out. I'll try to keep things brief so we can get to some more questions.
317
00:48:40.244 --> 00:48:58.044
So one is, you know, we've really seen the adoption of the core creator segment that we're going after, which is the Instagram native creator who has built an audience, who is telling stories in Feed and in, in Stories, but really needed a place to tell a longer form story that today they had to go to a different platform, uh, to do.
318
00:48:58.084 --> 00:49:13.484
Now, we understand that- Creating longer form video is more expensive from a time and resource perspective for creators, and so we set the expectation that we wanted to bring monetization to IGTV even outside of, of some of the branded content and, and work that we've, we've done to date.
319
00:49:13.564 --> 00:49:20.924
Um, so no specific plans, uh, to announce, but know that that is still an important priority for us, and, and you will certainly hear more from us, uh, about that.
320
00:49:20.964 --> 00:49:35.744
Now, the second thing I wanted to mention is that, you know, like any product, uh, organization, we're constantly evolving and learning, and so one of the things that we learned, uh, about how IGTV was being used were people were confused about how they should best upload video on Instagram.
321
00:49:35.784 --> 00:49:43.894
Should they first go to the IGTV tab? Should they first go to, you know, kind of the, the plus icon in the bottom of, of the, of the main screen to upload something?
322
00:49:43.934 --> 00:49:56.314
And so for the purpose of simplifying, uh, the way people upload video, uh, we're actually going to allow people to upload video for both feed and for IGTV from that main kind of feed upload plus icon, uh, inside of, of the platform.
323
00:49:56.724 --> 00:50:08.884
And for the purpose of simplification and to make sure that there is not a lot of competing, uh, attention for when people get to the, to the, to the, uh, platform, we're actually going to be removing the IGTV icon from the home screen.
324
00:50:09.204 --> 00:50:24.434
I think back to our very early point on having the diligence and feeling like you can unship and celebrating that just as much as shipping something in the first place, I'm proud of the team for, for really, uh, thinking about the simplicity of Instagram as a whole and simplifying the, the video upload flow when they're making a change like this.
325
00:50:24.644 --> 00:50:28.324
Got you. I'm gonna rattle through some of these now 'cause we've got so- I've got three minutes, I think, so let's go for it.
326
00:50:28.364 --> 00:50:37.384
So are there any plans to allow people to edit published stories, says Vaselina Filipidi, I think. I've got that right. No, no. There are no plans for that.
327
00:50:37.444 --> 00:50:47.404
We believe once the, um, the, the story's out there and people have seen it and responded, we wanna make sure that, that stays consistent in the same way that, you know, in a stor- in a feed post, you know, we keep the image pretty much consistent.
328
00:50:47.444 --> 00:50:54.904
So people can certainly delete them and, and re-upload them if they've made a mistake, but we think it's important for once that, that thing has been published, uh, for it to stay pretty consistent.
329
00:50:55.164 --> 00:51:00.704
Uh, adding links to feed posts, is it ever gonna happen, says- No... Payvee Kalska. No. It is, it is not.
330
00:51:00.824 --> 00:51:08.143
Uh, and I know there was a question that you had, you had, we had talked about earlier about even reshares in feed. That is also not coming. Uh, and those two changes are really important.
331
00:51:08.184 --> 00:51:12.884
The reason we don't do links or reshares in feed is it would change the incentive for why people post.
332
00:51:13.344 --> 00:51:26.604
Uh, if you have a link to share and that's why you post versus just sharing a moment, that changes why you post, and if you can reshare, when you come across content from someone that you follow and it's not something they originally created, it changes the reason why you see something in your feed.
333
00:51:26.664 --> 00:51:30.844
So for simplicity and for the sense of control, uh, we explicitly are not going to make those changes.
334
00:51:31.124 --> 00:51:38.683
Is Instagram Checkout going to allow you to buy, um, services as well as physical goods within Instagram, says Jonathan Pollinger.
335
00:51:39.484 --> 00:51:48.623
It's possible over time, although our area of focus is very much on specific products and launching that more broadly in, in the US where we are now, but then thinking about how we, we scale that internationally.
336
00:51:48.684 --> 00:51:53.244
Tons of questions on why doesn't my country have music sticker yet. When will those countries get it if they haven't got it yet?
337
00:51:54.204 --> 00:52:07.683
M- so music stickers, uh, we would love to take it everywhere, but we have to work with the music rights holders in all the different markets, and so the reason they're not everywhere is because we don't have rights for music in those markets, and it's really important to us to abide by the rights that these rights holders have.
338
00:52:08.024 --> 00:52:14.884
Got you. And then finally, and one that I was just curious about, does, does it affect you hearing criticism from, from people about a specific product?
339
00:52:14.933 --> 00:52:22.184
And, uh, what somebody said to me a few months back, and I wrote saying that, um, that IGTV was the recycle bin for YouTube right now.
340
00:52:22.624 --> 00:52:30.564
And I thought about that, and I thought it made me smile and laugh, but then at the same time I was thinking, God, what, what would happen with the, uh, the people in the product teams who are developing these products and they hear some of these things.
341
00:52:30.884 --> 00:52:41.584
How does, how does that affect you? Oh, it certainly affects, uh, affects you. I, I think as, as a, as a human, you, you are affected by the things that you hear and you think about, um, w- people's perceptions.
342
00:52:41.624 --> 00:52:53.564
At the same time, I think we have the, the discipline as a product organization to know that that's one perspective and doesn't really think about the longer term implications of what we're trying to achieve, but also the things that we might be working on that people don't know about.
343
00:52:53.594 --> 00:52:54.984
And so I think it's, uh...
344
00:52:55.064 --> 00:53:07.544
I think it would be impossible to say you, you don't hear those things, but also it wouldn't be the only reason to act on something or to make a change, and it's just part of the discipline of, of being a product owner and product thinker to think even, even beyond the, the short-term criticism.
345
00:53:08.024 --> 00:53:08.404
Got you.
346
00:53:08.444 --> 00:53:17.044
Well, I think we've made it exactly to the time, so I just wanna wrap it up and say that we've had a great time chatting to you, and I think there's a lot of questions and answers that are in there that people will enjoy listening back to.
347
00:53:17.404 --> 00:53:25.264
And so thank you, Vishal, for joining us, and, uh, hope you've had a good time as well. Thanks to both of you. Really enjoyed the chat, and, uh, and, uh, best of luck on the rest of the season. Thank you.
348
00:53:25.904 --> 00:53:37.204
It's time now for quick hits. Here's Matt with tests and updates from social media companies that amaze your eyes, electrify your ears, and bedazzle your brain. They get cheesier every week. [laughs] They seriously do.
349
00:53:37.224 --> 00:53:42.794
Like, what is going on with you? Okay. So yes, there's a co- there's about five or six this week, so we'll, uh, rattle through them.
350
00:53:42.864 --> 00:53:50.064
Let's start with the one that I just spotted before recording today, and that is LinkedIn has got three new features that it's gonna be rolling out to company pages.
351
00:53:50.124 --> 00:53:59.884
Now, I say new 'cause lots of people have already come back to me and said, "This is not new. This has been around for ages." These are ones that have been out for some people for a little while, probably being tested.
352
00:54:00.204 --> 00:54:04.184
Others haven't had them. So this is a global rollout, I believe, and that is LinkedIn Live.
353
00:54:04.324 --> 00:54:13.624
So the live streaming video stuff is gonna come out to more company pages or all of them in due course, uh, in the next few weeks, I think, and there's also act as a page or a profile.
354
00:54:13.744 --> 00:54:22.864
So if you're familiar with Facebook where you can choose whether you wanna respond to comments as your page or as your profile, that is being brought to LinkedIn as well, something that they're playing catch up with there.
355
00:54:23.324 --> 00:54:35.774
And the invite connections to follow your page, so you can choose some of your first, um, order connections on LinkedIn to invite them to your page, but there is a 50, uh, limit, a limit of 50 profiles that you can invite as follow, to follow your page.
356
00:54:36.404 --> 00:54:46.304
And also they've got some con- um, control settings that you can set, say you don't want to receive such, uh, invitations from other people if it gets a bit spammy. The next thing was Bing Pages.
357
00:54:46.404 --> 00:54:49.944
Now I saw Bing Pages, and I just thought Google+ 2.0.
358
00:54:50.144 --> 00:55:08.144
You know, it just ringed of a company that's not really sure what it's doing but wants to have some sort of socially type feature, and Bing Pages seems to be Microsoft's version of that, which is basically a profile page which pulls together all of your kind of feeds and streams and the posts you put out, and you can have a kind of page profile there within Bing as well.
359
00:55:08.264 --> 00:55:13.552
So for those who get excited by Google+, this may be one for you to check out. Twitter tipping feature.
360
00:55:13.642 --> 00:55:23.952
So this gen- generated a lot of interest, a lot of talk, um, in the last few days when I tweeted about it, and it was in, uh, within a, a video or a vide- another article which was talking about other things that Twitter is doing.
361
00:55:24.352 --> 00:55:34.012
So it's the idea of you being able to, uh, say that people can tip you some money for whatever reason, I guess, you justify they should tip you, or people just choose organically to.
362
00:55:34.072 --> 00:55:44.222
So this is, uh, something that I think is an interesting idea, but I'm not sure how it will work in, in practical terms, and there's plenty of ways it could probably be abused, or it could, uh, change the kind of vibe of Twitter.
363
00:55:44.292 --> 00:55:59.872
But, um, they did say that although it was, it was in an article for the information, this, uh, this story, they did say that afterwards that they're not actively working on it at this time, which is one of those, it's kind of there, but we might not get to it, so we'll- Oh, you'd get so many people begging for money through Twitter then, wouldn't you?
364
00:56:00.042 --> 00:56:08.212
It, uh- Yeah. I think it would get a bit, yeah. It could be. So we'll see if that one ever comes to fruition. Also, Instagram Boomerang has got an update for stories.
365
00:56:08.292 --> 00:56:17.822
So Boomerang, you know, you're playing around with video, nice kind of jumpy, kind of repeat video stuff you can do, and they've got some new features. Um, so slow mo, uh, which is self-explanatory.
366
00:56:18.232 --> 00:56:28.712
Echo, which gives it kind of like a, a double kind of vision, kind of echoey effect, and then you've got duo, which kind of adds a slow and fast speed at the same time to give it a bit more texture in the, in the video.
367
00:56:29.022 --> 00:56:33.852
And there's also a new trimming feature for, for your boomerangs, which is something that it should have had at the beginning, to be honest.
368
00:56:33.992 --> 00:56:47.192
Uh, Twitter lists, so they're becoming, um, a popular thing again, and I'm glad they are 'cause they're very useful, and Twitter lists now, I noticed the other day, suggest to me what other accounts I should add to my existing list or a new list I was creating.
369
00:56:47.592 --> 00:56:55.732
So it was, I had a list for new tech news, and it started suggesting some really useful accounts to add, in fact. So that's gonna be a, a great, uh, addition to lists.
370
00:56:55.752 --> 00:57:01.612
And finally, a small one really, a small one that's a big one. LinkedIn has kind of supersized its buttons.
371
00:57:01.972 --> 00:57:14.662
So now along, when you kind of tap the button to l- to like a post or whatever, it's got a real bigger sized kind of selection of buttons at the bottom to choose from, and one of them's got repost, which is a nice kind of prompt to kind of re-share something.
372
00:57:14.792 --> 00:57:22.592
Uh, it's kind of cool that it's done it 'cause it, before it was a bit plain and small, but now it's, yeah, supersized buttons on LinkedIn. Good stuff, and that's it for today.
373
00:57:22.992 --> 00:57:34.672
Now, last week, you might remember Taylor Lorenz told us how influencers are shifting away from advertising and endorsements to wider forms of content creation, and next week we'll be talking to an influencer who is all about content.
374
00:57:34.952 --> 00:57:40.212
She's a creator, blogging mentor, and podcast host, and she'll be great to speak to. That's Vix Meldrew.
375
00:57:40.732 --> 00:57:48.672
Yes, I'm really looking forward to that one as well, so make sure you do hit subscribe in your podcast app of choice so that you're notified as soon as the next episode is available.
376
00:57:48.912 --> 00:58:01.072
Geek Out with Matt Navarra is a Big Revolution production. Find out more at bigrevolution.net/podcasts. You can find me on Twitter as @martinsfp. And I'm @mattnavarra on Twitter.
377
00:58:01.192 --> 00:58:07.972
So don't forget to tell all your friends about the podcast, and also join the Facebook group. We have a Facebook group called the Social Media Geek Out.
378
00:58:08.172 --> 00:58:17.572
Uh, you can find it by searching exactly for that within Facebook, and you'll find us there for more of the same as what's in this podcast and even other weird and wonderful things to do with social. Indeed.
379
00:58:17.652 --> 00:58:20.272
We'll see you soon. Goodbye, geeks. [upbeat music]
