WEBVTT
00:00:01.217 --> 00:00:22.420
Welcome to the latest episode of Inside Out, the only true and living podcast upon the face of the earth, speaking collectively and not individually.
00:00:23.222 --> 00:00:29.528
My name is Ian Wilkes, and as always, I'm here with my partner, the indisputable Mr.
00:00:29.789 --> 00:00:30.750
Jim Bennett.
00:00:31.138 --> 00:00:32.360
There's no disputing it.
00:00:32.401 --> 00:00:33.101
That's me.
00:00:34.183 --> 00:00:47.572
And every time you say that, when you say that this is the only true podcast collectively and not individually, I have to recognize that there are only two individuals who are in this podcast on a regular basis.
00:00:48.293 --> 00:00:52.021
So one of us may or may not be true.
00:00:52.353 --> 00:00:54.735
But if I'm indisputable, that may be you.
00:00:54.957 --> 00:00:57.118
That may be a problem you have to wrestle with here.
00:00:57.838 --> 00:00:57.939
It's
00:00:57.960 --> 00:01:00.462
something that I have to wrap my thinking around.
00:01:00.521 --> 00:01:03.844
Yeah, I think you're the truest person on the truest podcasts.
00:01:04.365 --> 00:01:05.106
Well, there we go.
00:01:05.126 --> 00:01:06.287
There we go.
00:01:06.748 --> 00:01:15.156
And so today, Jim, we have a very special guest indeed, and someone that is very dear to me and very special to me.
00:01:15.197 --> 00:01:19.361
We have here today Marcus Hooper, all the way from...
00:01:20.706 --> 00:01:21.085
England.
00:01:21.427 --> 00:01:22.227
Marcus, welcome.
00:01:23.650 --> 00:01:23.909
Hiya.
00:01:26.873 --> 00:01:30.018
That's a very good response.
00:01:30.058 --> 00:01:30.397
That's fine.
00:01:30.438 --> 00:01:33.762
You can keep that response like that.
00:01:33.843 --> 00:01:35.123
I think that's great.
00:01:35.704 --> 00:01:38.567
And so, Marcus, I don't know you.
00:01:38.629 --> 00:01:45.918
When I speak to you and when I communicate with you, I don't automatically, immediately think of you as Marcus.
00:01:46.177 --> 00:01:47.939
To me, you are Elder Hutber.
00:01:49.001 --> 00:01:54.540
And My relationship with you is very unique and very distinct and very precious to me.
00:01:54.682 --> 00:02:18.198
So I know Elder Hutbert because back in the 80s, Elder Hutbert was the missionary, along with Elder Southwick, I think it was, who found me and tracked me up as a full-time missionary serving in the England Leads Mission from, what, 82 to 83, I think it was, or thereabouts.
00:02:19.746 --> 00:02:22.250
Yeah, for me, it was 81 to 83, Ian.
00:02:22.310 --> 00:02:22.931
That's right,
00:02:23.230 --> 00:02:23.311
yeah.
00:02:23.330 --> 00:02:23.872
Okay, okay.
00:02:24.372 --> 00:02:31.342
And so this was a council house estate, which I'd spoken to about earlier on the podcast.
00:02:32.223 --> 00:02:34.186
An interesting place for sure.
00:02:34.347 --> 00:02:45.042
And Marcus, Elder Hubbert and Elder Southwick, tracked me up and actually taught me the discussions back in the early 80s.
00:02:46.022 --> 00:02:47.725
And so that was a very...
00:02:48.066 --> 00:02:50.248
in my life, very significant time in my life.
00:02:51.050 --> 00:02:56.899
And Marcus shaped my life and informed my thinking significantly back then.
00:02:56.938 --> 00:03:01.626
And he's somebody that I have a great deal of love and respect for.
00:03:02.167 --> 00:03:05.031
And I've spoken a little bit about this on the podcast.
00:03:05.551 --> 00:03:08.036
So our relationship, Marcus, goes back a long way.
00:03:08.075 --> 00:03:16.707
And I think it would be appropriate if you could share your thoughts a little bit about that experience.
00:03:16.788 --> 00:03:25.341
And then after that, if you can give us a little bit of a broader, more general introduction about yourself, maybe your family, if you're comfortable, and a little bit about your background in the church.
00:03:25.401 --> 00:03:27.364
I think you were raised in the church, you grew up in the church.
00:03:27.965 --> 00:03:31.751
And a little bit about your, just kind of your overall experience in the gospel and in the church.
00:03:32.431 --> 00:03:43.808
And I think a key event in your life, of course, certainly from my perspective, but a key event in your life, period in your life, was obviously serving as a full-time missionary in England Leeds Mission.
00:03:44.330 --> 00:03:46.013
So if you can speak a little bit about that.
00:03:47.169 --> 00:04:09.550
without sharing too much about how, uh, notorious I was, uh, and cheeky I was back then, you know, as a, as a teenager, um, as a disclaimer, what I did back then, I was, you know, a teenager and I didn't, I didn't know all the rules, but if you can speak about that experience and then give it, move into an introduction, that would be great.
00:04:10.712 --> 00:04:11.272
Yeah, sure.
00:04:11.854 --> 00:04:15.437
Ian, you were always a very, very intelligent kid, very much so.
00:04:15.576 --> 00:04:17.499
And, um, Flying Spuds.
00:04:17.839 --> 00:04:29.677
When I first met you, mate, I was actually leaning over to tie up my shoelaces and a very large D-sized battery comes whizzing past my head on the left-hand side.
00:04:30.699 --> 00:04:36.026
And I look up and there's this kid grinning at me and I think, I got to talk to this kid.
00:04:36.067 --> 00:04:37.288
This is kind of interesting.
00:04:37.949 --> 00:04:38.951
So, wow.
00:04:39.552 --> 00:04:42.896
Now, I've listened to your podcast and I've listened to them with great interest.
00:04:42.956 --> 00:04:43.858
I really have, guys.
00:04:43.937 --> 00:04:47.511
I've listened to them and they're very varied and they're very They're very fascinating.
00:04:48.312 --> 00:04:54.279
Some of them are a little bit different, but some of the people I listen to are a little bit different than I expected, which is, again, interesting.
00:04:54.940 --> 00:04:57.564
But I've listened to them, and they have been fascinating.
00:04:58.125 --> 00:05:05.954
Now, going through it, you bring up all sorts of topics which are really curious.
00:05:06.656 --> 00:05:11.622
Now, you were a smart young chap.
00:05:12.161 --> 00:05:17.350
And I don't remember the girl that you came along to see when we were teaching you.
00:05:17.389 --> 00:05:22.177
I don't actually remember teaching that girl, but it must have been the girl because that's why you came.
00:05:22.197 --> 00:05:23.360
So that was kind of curious.
00:05:23.841 --> 00:05:27.487
But anyway, what I do remember is I do remember the baptismal challenge, Ian.
00:05:27.526 --> 00:05:43.538
Now, that baptismal challenge actually became quite infamous because it was my turn and I actually gave the baptismal challenge and I gave it to you And you sat there, and you looked a little bit perplexed, and I was kind of interested.
00:05:43.579 --> 00:05:45.843
And you didn't say something for a while.
00:05:45.862 --> 00:05:48.766
And out of self, it was about to say something.
00:05:48.807 --> 00:05:51.411
And I looked over him, and I kind of gave him a bit of a stare.
00:05:51.851 --> 00:05:52.773
So he backed off.
00:05:53.394 --> 00:05:56.639
And then I looked back at you, and it was happening.
00:05:56.678 --> 00:05:59.523
And I was thinking, okay, what's the reply?
00:05:59.543 --> 00:06:00.363
It's either yes or no.
00:06:00.403 --> 00:06:01.887
Come on, just tell us what it is.
00:06:01.966 --> 00:06:02.668
It's probably going to be no.
00:06:02.687 --> 00:06:03.189
It doesn't matter.
00:06:03.228 --> 00:06:04.009
Let's just have it.
00:06:04.810 --> 00:06:06.613
And then you still didn't reply.
00:06:07.362 --> 00:06:12.086
And it went on for a while, and it went on for a while, and it went on for a while, and it kept going.
00:06:12.166 --> 00:06:16.711
And at the end, when you finally said yes, I thought, you can't say yes.
00:06:16.771 --> 00:06:17.612
That's not how it goes.
00:06:17.653 --> 00:06:18.293
You've been so long.
00:06:18.314 --> 00:06:19.274
You've got to say no.
00:06:19.295 --> 00:06:21.958
And they've got to give you loads of reasons why it's no.
00:06:21.997 --> 00:06:23.519
How can it be yes?
00:06:23.560 --> 00:06:24.641
That's just crazy.
00:06:24.680 --> 00:06:30.528
So I'm thinking, and I looked at Southwick, and Southwick just kind of gave a blank expression.
00:06:30.567 --> 00:06:32.709
And we're thinking, this is crazy.
00:06:32.730 --> 00:06:42.502
And then what happened is it went around the mission that Hutpa, had given a three-hour baptismal challenge and hadn't said anything for three hours.
00:06:42.543 --> 00:06:45.387
We could use, you know, all these things become kind of inflated.
00:06:45.987 --> 00:07:01.509
But I do remember going to Eva, to your mum, and saying to her, look, you know, we're kind of teaching your son and he's a really decent chap and we'd like to...
00:07:03.394 --> 00:07:04.995
We'd like to baptize him.
00:07:05.076 --> 00:07:09.341
And I can remember your mum actually being not very keen on the idea.
00:07:09.401 --> 00:07:15.290
So I said, well, look, you know, look, Eva, this is just going to improve his life.
00:07:15.310 --> 00:07:16.271
It's just going to help him.
00:07:16.310 --> 00:07:22.680
He'll learn stuff from here, which will enable him to do all sorts of things in life.
00:07:22.759 --> 00:07:24.221
It will be really good for him.
00:07:24.322 --> 00:07:29.629
And so she said to me, came back a couple of times.
00:07:29.730 --> 00:07:35.172
And then when we came back, she finally said that, that she would give permission.
00:07:35.211 --> 00:07:41.440
Now, what I didn't know, Ian, at the time, was that she would turf you out of the house.
00:07:41.761 --> 00:07:46.266
And when I heard Flying Spuds, I thought, what the Flying Spuds is going down here?
00:07:46.286 --> 00:07:52.334
And then Linda Cavell was fantastic, and Jenny Johnson were fantastic, and they really helped you.
00:07:52.355 --> 00:07:56.060
And then the bishop, I think, in Wakefield, wasn't it, who really helped you?
00:07:56.940 --> 00:08:00.245
Just to the light, Ian, it was just a pleasure.
00:08:00.286 --> 00:08:06.605
And then I watched you over the years, oh, what you've achieved and what you've done is just fantastic.
00:08:07.805 --> 00:08:10.249
You know, you've done so much and it's just a pleasure.
00:08:10.269 --> 00:08:13.552
And all those certificates on your wall there, they're just great.
00:08:13.593 --> 00:08:14.553
That just sums you up.
00:08:14.613 --> 00:08:19.819
And it's just so much, it's just been such a pleasure to watch your life develop.
00:08:19.858 --> 00:08:28.968
Now, what was kind of curious was that I actually was posted up to Durham and I think it was around Sacristo I was tracked in.
00:08:29.569 --> 00:08:31.711
Yours, yeah.
00:08:31.891 --> 00:08:32.033
Yeah.
00:08:32.472 --> 00:08:35.106
And I heard, And there was some kids around.
00:08:35.148 --> 00:08:36.349
I think it's me and Elder Daniels.
00:08:36.389 --> 00:08:37.269
And there was some kids around.
00:08:37.289 --> 00:08:39.312
And I heard the voice, Mark has called out.
00:08:39.812 --> 00:08:41.413
Now, when you're on a mission, it's just Elder.
00:08:41.474 --> 00:08:42.414
Everybody's called Elder.
00:08:42.475 --> 00:08:43.336
And people say, well, hold on.
00:08:43.395 --> 00:08:44.576
Why have you all got the same Christian name?
00:08:44.616 --> 00:08:48.260
But anyway, I said to Elder Daniels, hold on.
00:08:48.321 --> 00:08:51.624
One of these kids has got my Christian name.
00:08:51.683 --> 00:08:52.585
And I heard the name again.
00:08:52.605 --> 00:08:54.647
I heard someone call out my name.
00:08:54.726 --> 00:08:56.149
And I thought, hold on, Ed.
00:08:56.168 --> 00:08:57.649
One of these kids really has got my name.
00:08:57.669 --> 00:08:59.091
And I thought, this is unusual.
00:08:59.172 --> 00:09:03.897
And then when it happened the third time, I thought, hold on, I've got to look around.
00:09:03.996 --> 00:09:12.967
So I looked around and there was Eva, your mum, standing in her front door looking at me and just grinning.
00:09:13.008 --> 00:09:21.758
And I walked up and she said, look, you never told me about your church.
00:09:22.519 --> 00:09:28.105
I'd like to hear what you've got to say, but let me make it absolutely crystal clear.
00:09:28.145 --> 00:09:31.070
I'm not joining and neither is Michael.
00:09:31.682 --> 00:09:33.943
And then a few weeks later they were baptized.
00:09:34.004 --> 00:09:38.548
So, yeah, just your mum was, I never had a problem with her.
00:09:38.668 --> 00:09:43.953
I knew that she was very feisty, but my mum was quite feisty as well.
00:09:44.374 --> 00:09:51.961
In fact, I was six when the mysteries came around to my house and my mother was quite feisty.
00:09:52.000 --> 00:09:55.083
So we kind of share that, but they were both really well-meaning.
00:09:55.144 --> 00:09:58.927
So I never had a problem with your mum because my mum was exactly the same.
00:10:00.229 --> 00:10:07.538
And in fact, I have, On Thursday nights, I have a family home evening with the two guys who taught me the gospel and baptized me every Thursday.
00:10:07.578 --> 00:10:08.541
So that's a pleasure.
00:10:08.600 --> 00:10:10.062
One of them lives in...
00:10:11.826 --> 00:10:17.914
He's just moved down from Payson in Utah, and he lives in Overton in Nevada.
00:10:18.316 --> 00:10:19.256
And the other chap lives in St.
00:10:19.298 --> 00:10:19.697
George.
00:10:20.479 --> 00:10:23.384
A couple of totally really excellent chaps.
00:10:23.904 --> 00:10:27.750
But when I was young, I actually had loads of questions.
00:10:27.951 --> 00:10:29.633
That's why I really enjoy...
00:10:30.145 --> 00:10:34.429
listen to your podcast because they actually raise loads of questions.
00:10:35.530 --> 00:10:37.493
And I used to read books.
00:10:37.552 --> 00:10:41.557
I used to read things like Science of Modernism, Coming of the Lord, Book of Jasher.
00:10:41.596 --> 00:10:43.197
Book of Jasher is a fantastic book.
00:10:43.678 --> 00:10:45.159
Tempting Cosmos by Nibley.
00:10:45.681 --> 00:10:47.022
Just love these books.
00:10:47.863 --> 00:10:53.668
And I got to wondering about stuff and I actually was curious.
00:10:53.727 --> 00:11:07.528
I mean, for me, guys, the Big Bang is a nice idea, but it doesn't actually give any answers because If the Big Bang is actually just sitting and expanding, what sits outside the Big Bang?
00:11:08.990 --> 00:11:09.431
A void?
00:11:11.072 --> 00:11:14.337
But Billy Smith says that where there is space, there is matter.
00:11:14.658 --> 00:11:20.306
You look in D&C 8837 and 131.7, it talks about where there is matter in every kingdom.
00:11:21.067 --> 00:11:28.758
And so for me, that idea that you have an extension of dimensions continuing forever is really curious.
00:11:29.090 --> 00:11:30.672
And I really love that idea.
00:11:30.692 --> 00:11:34.697
And so for me, the big bang is just postponing the question.
00:11:34.899 --> 00:11:36.400
It's not given an answer at all.
00:11:37.241 --> 00:11:47.397
Now, what I love is I love the idea that, in fact, you have dark matter, which is 95% of the universe, and you have gravitational matter, which is 5% of the universe.
00:11:48.217 --> 00:11:55.970
And so for me, that fits really lovely, in a really lovely way, where the celestial and terrestrial kingdoms are encompassed by dark matter.
00:11:57.091 --> 00:11:58.533
Sorry, they are dark matter.
00:11:59.649 --> 00:12:06.177
5% of the universe is the telestial kingdom, which is the gravitational matter, and it fits really nicely.
00:12:06.298 --> 00:12:26.663
Now, I actually wonder how dimensions can actually sit on top of each other, and for me, I always looked at physics, was fascinated by it, because in physics, if my house was the nucleus of an atom, the electron which bounds the atom would be over in Winchester, which is quite a distance away.
00:12:27.384 --> 00:12:29.265
So, for me, matter...
00:12:29.666 --> 00:12:34.251
most of matter is empty space, which means that dimensions can sit on top of each other.
00:12:34.812 --> 00:12:37.895
So therefore, we know that the spirit world is around us.
00:12:38.596 --> 00:12:40.278
We know that from near-death experiences.
00:12:40.339 --> 00:12:43.302
And Ian, I loved your near-death experience that you described.
00:12:43.942 --> 00:12:53.355
And as you described your near-death experience, Ian, you actually related, are these just neurons firing off?
00:12:54.076 --> 00:12:57.921
Are these just chemical reactions that I'm actually having here?
00:12:57.961 --> 00:13:02.110
And then a little way later, A bit later, you say, no, I actually experienced that.
00:13:02.731 --> 00:13:09.722
Now, this is a bit of an aside here, but for me, guys, there are list A and list B experiences.
00:13:09.783 --> 00:13:17.996
List B experiences, I've got 400 of them that I've collected, and over 16 years on the high count, so I went around to different wards, and I'd actually give list B experience.
00:13:18.037 --> 00:13:19.057
What's a list B experience?
00:13:19.097 --> 00:13:22.624
List B experience is one that you have to have faith to...
00:13:26.690 --> 00:13:29.232
understand it or to actually go along with it.
00:13:29.293 --> 00:13:30.793
Let me give you a little experience.
00:13:30.813 --> 00:13:38.763
So I came home one day and my wife said, my engagement ring lost the diamond in it.
00:13:39.323 --> 00:13:41.024
Oh, that's not really good, dear.
00:13:41.446 --> 00:13:44.109
She said, yeah, but you're going to find it.
00:13:44.269 --> 00:13:44.769
Goodbye.
00:13:44.809 --> 00:13:45.309
I'm off.
00:13:45.389 --> 00:13:46.530
And she ran off upstairs.
00:13:46.991 --> 00:13:47.613
I thought, what?
00:13:48.994 --> 00:13:49.554
No, I'm not.
00:13:49.615 --> 00:13:50.475
That's ridiculous.
00:13:50.716 --> 00:13:52.658
Anyway, she called down from the stairs.
00:13:52.717 --> 00:13:53.298
Yes, you are.
00:13:53.418 --> 00:13:54.019
Pray about it.
00:13:54.120 --> 00:13:54.620
Goodbye.
00:13:54.779 --> 00:13:55.421
Slammed the door.
00:13:55.760 --> 00:13:56.302
I thought, what?
00:13:56.833 --> 00:14:00.558
So I thought, all right, then I'll do the religious bin.
00:14:00.620 --> 00:14:01.581
I'll do the prayer bit.
00:14:02.282 --> 00:14:04.926
And I said, okay, you know, give the hand.
00:14:04.946 --> 00:14:06.248
Well, your hand's put me a bit of a spot.
00:14:06.307 --> 00:14:07.429
Could you give me a bit of a hand?
00:14:07.450 --> 00:14:09.432
So I had the feeling, go through the rubbish bin.
00:14:09.452 --> 00:14:11.034
Go through the rubbish bin?
00:14:11.095 --> 00:14:12.437
What do you mean go through the rubbish bin?
00:14:12.517 --> 00:14:15.000
All right, fine, I'll go through the rubbish bin.
00:14:15.020 --> 00:14:17.403
I couldn't find any gloves, so I shoved my hand in the rubbish bin.
00:14:17.443 --> 00:14:18.125
I'm going through it.
00:14:18.666 --> 00:14:23.592
I pulled it out three times and emptied it, put it back in again, and my hands were absolutely filthy.
00:14:23.633 --> 00:14:27.934
And when I put it in the last time, I had the feeling, It's not in here.
00:14:27.955 --> 00:14:29.456
I thought, what do you mean?
00:14:29.576 --> 00:14:30.678
What do you mean it's not in here?
00:14:30.719 --> 00:14:31.679
Don't be ridiculous.
00:14:31.740 --> 00:14:33.142
I just got through the rubbish bin.
00:14:33.542 --> 00:14:38.248
And in fact, my son, who'd actually been listening to all this, had the same feeling.
00:14:38.307 --> 00:14:40.870
And he actually refused to go through the rubbish bin with me.
00:14:42.373 --> 00:14:45.716
So I thought, right, I'm not listening to any more promptings at all.
00:14:45.756 --> 00:14:46.197
I had enough.
00:14:46.477 --> 00:14:46.857
I'm off.
00:14:47.077 --> 00:14:50.322
And I actually shoved off to the downstairs toilet.
00:14:50.543 --> 00:14:56.470
And there, underneath the sink, as I'm about to wash my hands, is the diamond to Helen's ring.
00:14:56.833 --> 00:15:01.000
Can you imagine a guy on the other side here having fun with Hutba, this idiot Hutba?
00:15:01.200 --> 00:15:04.524
How can we get this moron to actually go to the sink and wash his hands?
00:15:04.705 --> 00:15:06.366
I'd have to get him to go through the rubbish bin.
00:15:06.967 --> 00:15:17.542
So look, but this requires faith because when I told this story to a relative, and I won't mention my sister's name, but when I said it to her, she said, oh, it's just coincidence.
00:15:17.601 --> 00:15:20.947
And I thought, okay, I won't bother telling any more stories then, fair enough.
00:15:20.986 --> 00:15:27.221
So list B experiences require faith, but list A experiences require don't.
00:15:29.125 --> 00:15:31.206
Yeah, go on, Ian.
00:15:31.888 --> 00:15:32.087
Sorry,
00:15:32.128 --> 00:15:32.488
go ahead.
00:15:32.509 --> 00:15:32.889
You continue.
00:15:32.908 --> 00:15:33.789
I have a question, but go ahead.
00:15:33.830 --> 00:15:34.169
Continue.
00:15:38.095 --> 00:15:42.799
All I was going to say was that list A experiences do not require faith.
00:15:42.921 --> 00:15:44.842
And I've had probably four or five of those.
00:15:44.863 --> 00:15:48.346
And list A experiences I will not discuss.
00:15:49.548 --> 00:15:57.174
Experiences I will say from the pulpit or from anywhere, but I would happily discuss Any of the 400 lists that be experienced I've had.
00:15:57.375 --> 00:15:58.035
Sorry, what were you going to say?
00:15:58.657 --> 00:16:01.221
Yeah, no, this is, this is, uh, this is interesting.
00:16:01.903 --> 00:16:11.000
Um, and a really important segue into a topic that Jim and I have explored quite a bit, uh, to some extent.
00:16:11.500 --> 00:16:18.192
And I remember having a conversation with Hans Mattson on the podcast with Jim, and I think you've listened to that podcast.
00:16:18.977 --> 00:16:32.298
And we spoke to Hans Massen on that podcast about his perspective on revelation and the concept or the principle of the Lord intervening in very personal ways.
00:16:32.879 --> 00:16:45.179
I mean, I think that the point I'm trying to get to is that the Lord and the Spirit was involved in your prayers and your faith to find a lost diamond.
00:16:45.220 --> 00:16:46.461
So very personal.
00:16:47.105 --> 00:17:45.803
personal very involved in that you know and specifically telling you not to look in in a place because it was somewhere else etc so the lord intervening in that process and then the the questions that we get and we talked about this with hans mattson is does that principle apply to other things far more important than finding a lost diamond does the lord get involved in other more serious it's a question that I've been asked many times in the church and not in the church now but post church about where and when and how does the Lord intervene and the different responses where people say well you know why did the Lord allow my child to die or why didn't the Lord respond to my faith and prayers when you know I was sick or someone passed away we had a blessing And they passed away.
00:17:46.143 --> 00:17:49.909
And where was the Lord in those losses, in those experiences?
00:17:50.549 --> 00:17:54.096
And then the response that they often get is, well, that's what the Lord intended.
00:17:54.135 --> 00:17:58.643
That was the plan all along, that the Lord hadn't planned to save the individual.
00:17:59.203 --> 00:18:06.815
Or maybe they felt that the Lord wasn't involved in the same way that he was involved in finding a lost diamond.
00:18:07.676 --> 00:18:17.162
When you hear that, and again, I'm sharing this Feedback I've had on a personal level as I've been a leader in the church and also people come to me as a friend.
00:18:17.521 --> 00:18:30.779
How do you reconcile the principle of the Lord intervening with you, for example, finding a lost diamond versus people feeling that the Lord hasn't intervened or feel at times forsaken from him?
00:18:30.839 --> 00:18:35.185
Because the brethren have talked about this in conference, you know, about having faith, et cetera.
00:18:35.426 --> 00:18:38.851
How do you reconcile the two points there?
00:18:38.891 --> 00:18:40.673
Something really serious, like a life...
00:18:41.442 --> 00:18:51.615
law doesn't intervene or doesn't appear to intervene from people's experiences versus the intervention to find the lost diamond
00:18:53.176 --> 00:19:15.116
okay okay it's a really good question and I really appreciate it okay I've got to be careful here because I might lose it so I've got to be really careful here but in the position where I am right now is where my wife died And it was the right time for her.
00:19:15.176 --> 00:19:15.917
She had a blessing.
00:19:17.319 --> 00:19:21.246
And in fact, she had the blessing in the position where I am right now.
00:19:21.266 --> 00:19:23.628
I've got us a tea here, but there was a bed here.
00:19:23.648 --> 00:19:33.063
And the blessing said that in the pre-existence, that we agreed as a family that she would go at this time.
00:19:33.083 --> 00:19:35.426
At that time, not this time, obviously.
00:19:37.108 --> 00:19:37.369
So...
00:19:41.089 --> 00:19:42.171
Let me share something else.
00:19:43.451 --> 00:19:47.215
She actually talked to a guy who was an atheist.
00:19:48.096 --> 00:19:50.960
And I met this chap a little while after Helen had passed.
00:19:52.080 --> 00:20:02.351
And he said to me, as Helen was dying, she would have known that there was no afterlife and she would have realized that she was dying, that she was going into oblivion.
00:20:02.391 --> 00:20:08.798
And I was thinking, I was thinking all sorts of things that I might do.
00:20:09.250 --> 00:20:11.093
but I didn't, and I withheld myself.
00:20:11.713 --> 00:20:13.195
Now, let me tell you what really happened.
00:20:14.618 --> 00:20:20.587
Helen had been in a coma for two weeks, and she hadn't moved.
00:20:24.595 --> 00:20:30.403
And then she moved her arm, and I thought, wow, hold on here.
00:20:31.025 --> 00:20:34.130
This is kind of incredible.
00:20:35.298 --> 00:20:37.840
And she'd always wanted to talk to me.
00:20:37.881 --> 00:20:40.904
I'd been out for a walk to take the dogs out.
00:20:41.144 --> 00:20:45.250
And when I was out for 20 minutes and she phoned me four times because she needed to speak to me.
00:20:46.010 --> 00:20:50.436
Anyway, so I looked at her and I said, are you in pain, dear?
00:20:50.737 --> 00:20:53.500
And she didn't acknowledge me whatsoever.
00:20:53.520 --> 00:20:54.602
This was just before she died.
00:20:54.642 --> 00:20:57.566
She died on the 25th of November at 1.42, 2017.
00:20:59.307 --> 00:21:04.233
And she looked...
00:21:05.506 --> 00:21:11.154
passed me over to the mantelpiece that I'm actually looking at now.
00:21:12.297 --> 00:21:14.539
And she scanned her eyes from left to right.
00:21:14.700 --> 00:21:16.502
It was about a six to eight foot area.
00:21:17.644 --> 00:21:19.207
Left to right, right to left.
00:21:19.488 --> 00:21:21.550
And she did that two minutes.
00:21:22.432 --> 00:21:29.103
And her breathing went down from once every 10 seconds, once every 20 seconds, once every 30 seconds.
00:21:30.786 --> 00:21:42.759
And she didn't hear me or actually hear acknowledged me, although she always wanted to talk to me, and then she gave a last breath and she passed.
00:21:42.940 --> 00:21:44.020
She was looking at something.
00:21:44.761 --> 00:21:50.568
Now, I don't know what she was looking at, but I'm sorry, that atheist was wrong.
00:21:51.750 --> 00:21:54.051
She saw something when she was going.
00:21:55.854 --> 00:22:00.900
Now, I'm not going to share with you my list of experiences, but I will tell you this.
00:22:01.941 --> 00:22:04.208
I know there is another dimension.
00:22:05.409 --> 00:22:06.391
I don't have to have fate.
00:22:06.590 --> 00:22:08.313
I know there is another dimension.
00:22:10.195 --> 00:22:15.303
And what I know is very specific to me and it is my list A experiences.
00:22:16.625 --> 00:22:21.652
And I know that there are people in another dimension who interact with this dimension, guys.
00:22:23.855 --> 00:22:28.221
So in answer to your question, why do people go?
00:22:28.320 --> 00:22:30.683
Because basically it's their time.
00:22:30.703 --> 00:22:31.925
It was Helen's time.
00:22:32.481 --> 00:22:34.344
Why do bad things happen to people?
00:22:35.005 --> 00:22:38.469
Because it's not Heavenly Father doing it.
00:22:38.789 --> 00:22:41.031
It's basically it's chance doing it.
00:22:41.512 --> 00:22:45.116
Heavenly Father had the chance to actually save people from really bad things.
00:22:46.219 --> 00:22:47.861
And he has the opportunity not to.
00:22:47.901 --> 00:22:50.063
And if he actually decides, well, look, this guy's had enough.
00:22:50.463 --> 00:22:51.605
He's been through enough pain.
00:22:51.644 --> 00:22:53.207
He's been through enough hassle in his life.
00:22:54.048 --> 00:22:57.251
He's been politically assassinated.
00:22:57.913 --> 00:23:00.556
So everybody actually goes through different things.
00:23:00.615 --> 00:23:01.636
We all have different things.
00:23:03.201 --> 00:23:07.326
So when people have had enough, Heavenly Father says, okay, let's bring them back.
00:23:07.606 --> 00:23:08.126
They've had enough.
00:23:08.188 --> 00:23:08.928
Let's bring them back.
00:23:09.388 --> 00:23:12.772
So he doesn't stop certain things happening.
00:23:13.353 --> 00:23:15.075
He actually intervenes when it's necessary.
00:23:15.194 --> 00:23:17.116
He doesn't intervene when it's not necessary.
00:23:17.718 --> 00:23:22.343
So an answer to your question is Heavenly Father allows chance to take its course.
00:23:22.784 --> 00:23:26.127
But when he decides that something needs changing, he'll change that course.
00:23:26.748 --> 00:23:27.409
That's how he does.
00:23:28.109 --> 00:23:28.349
Yeah.
00:23:29.089 --> 00:23:30.250
Yeah, no, I appreciate that.
00:23:30.330 --> 00:23:31.472
I want to bring Jim in here.
00:23:31.772 --> 00:23:40.844
And then just going forward, we've got a few questions that we're going to ask you in terms of doctrine and want to talk about some of those topics that you and I shared back and forward, if you may.
00:23:40.884 --> 00:23:48.373
But Jim, when you hear that, you know, because that's such a very significant part of, you know, a religious and spiritual experience, right?
00:23:48.472 --> 00:23:49.994
They're very different experiences.
00:23:50.474 --> 00:23:53.337
What are your thoughts on that, listening to Marcus?
00:23:53.398 --> 00:23:56.382
What's your perspective on that?
00:23:56.834 --> 00:24:03.804
on that dimension, but also how the Lord, based on that, how he intervenes and doesn't intervene?
00:24:05.366 --> 00:24:12.457
Oh, that's a question that has bedeviled philosophers for millennia.
00:24:12.478 --> 00:24:16.303
This is the theodicy question.
00:24:16.343 --> 00:24:18.046
Why do bad things happen to good people?
00:24:19.106 --> 00:24:21.371
Why doesn't the Lord intervene in certain spots?
00:24:21.691 --> 00:24:29.531
We've had instances in our family where there was a time after my daughter was injured.
00:24:29.813 --> 00:24:37.762
My daughter was injured at the age of 14 in a skiing accident that left her paralyzed from the waist down, at least partially paralyzed from the waist down.
00:24:39.044 --> 00:24:49.778
And I used to just get enraged, really, when I would hear these sort of miraculous healing stories.
00:24:50.849 --> 00:24:54.534
that were, see, isn't God good and isn't God wonderful?
00:24:54.614 --> 00:24:57.195
He's healed my child.
00:24:57.296 --> 00:24:58.436
He's healed my wife.
00:24:58.557 --> 00:24:59.898
He's healed somebody else.
00:25:00.980 --> 00:25:05.604
And I'd say, well, so am I just not righteous enough that God hasn't intervened?
00:25:05.984 --> 00:25:10.709
And as time has gone on, my daughter has made a great life for herself.
00:25:10.788 --> 00:25:15.433
She's currently a medical doctor in her first year of residency.
00:25:15.534 --> 00:25:23.218
She's when I raised that with some people to say, well, see, it was all for the best.
00:25:23.438 --> 00:25:33.712
This was, you know, and, and I, you know, and I, I've had discussions with my wife about that, where she's just said that just drives me crazy.
00:25:33.813 --> 00:25:46.911
I mean, yes, we've seen so many blessings and so many wonderful people who've come in and helped as a result of that, but I'd be willing to throw them away to make my daughter whole again.
00:25:46.931 --> 00:25:53.423
You know, they're not, they're, That kind of reasoning gets very frustrating.
00:25:53.723 --> 00:26:13.170
So I've sort of reached the point where I believe that we are the intervention, that we are the body of Christ, that we are the ones that have the inspiration to reach out to our neighbors, to reach out to people in need.
00:26:14.392 --> 00:26:33.308
And I think the kinds of intervention that My daughter takes a wrong turn down a mountain and somehow the hand of God reaches out and just nudges her away from the obstacle that causes the injury.
00:26:33.328 --> 00:26:40.919
I don't think that mortality is designed for experiences like that.
00:26:41.400 --> 00:26:46.026
I'm with Marcus in that he lets chance take its course.
00:26:46.817 --> 00:26:51.962
And I'm also with Marcus in this idea that we signed up for this.
00:26:52.983 --> 00:27:08.258
I don't know if I can go all the way to say we knew exactly when we were going to die or exactly what was going to befall us when we came here, but we knew what we would be subject to.
00:27:08.298 --> 00:27:21.894
We knew what the risks were, and we were willing to accept those risks because mortality and death That kind of experience with opposition is the only way to learn and to grow.
00:27:21.934 --> 00:27:40.634
So I no longer really believe that, you know, the closest I've had to the finding the diamond experience is finding, there was one year at Christmas, my wife makes homemade stockings.
00:27:41.394 --> 00:27:45.057
She's made these stockings for all of our kids and we'd lost one of them.
00:27:46.145 --> 00:27:50.190
And we prayed and we prayed and we prayed and we prayed, and I found them.
00:27:50.710 --> 00:27:51.191
I found it.
00:27:51.411 --> 00:27:53.593
And I thought, whoa, isn't this a great answer to prayer?
00:27:55.074 --> 00:28:10.548
But the older I get, the more I think, jeez, if we can't deal with some sort of lost item, then mortality probably is too big a stretch for us.
00:28:12.451 --> 00:28:15.232
That's not what the mortal experience is supposed to be.
00:28:16.417 --> 00:28:38.924
I don't take any issue with anything that Marcus has said, and I actually was reminded, Ian, of your near-death experience when we talk about it on this podcast, and also not just the near-death experience, but the death of your brother, when you talked about that that was just an undeniable moment where you recognized there was something beyond this life.
00:28:40.145 --> 00:28:45.227
And I, too, have had, we want to call them column A experiences.
00:28:45.247 --> 00:28:51.413
I have had column A experiences that I don't think are necessarily appropriate for public consumption.
00:28:52.334 --> 00:28:58.740
But I think that kind of worldview, I can understand it.
00:28:58.759 --> 00:29:00.642
I share it to some degree.
00:29:00.682 --> 00:29:02.123
I don't share it to another degree.
00:29:02.884 --> 00:29:13.574
But I think these are the great questions that keep all of us talking and that keep all of us up at night as we try to figure out what it is that we're doing here and where we've come from and where we're going.
00:29:14.210 --> 00:29:15.310
Yeah, thank you for that.
00:29:15.612 --> 00:29:17.374
I think we all agree, and I agree with you, Marcus.
00:29:17.394 --> 00:29:23.643
I know, like you, Marcus, there is another dimension for sure, based on my own experiences.
00:29:24.463 --> 00:29:27.047
I really appreciate you both providing your insight.
00:29:28.628 --> 00:29:39.364
What I'd like to do, if I can, is go into the next stage of our conversation, and we've been sharing and communicating this part of the conversation with Marcus.
00:29:40.305 --> 00:29:43.128
There's at least two things I know about you, Marcus, amongst many things.
00:29:44.162 --> 00:29:53.958
The two things are, from my experience, having known you for so long now, is your commitment to the church and the gospel is just extraordinary.
00:29:54.219 --> 00:29:55.520
I want you to know that.
00:29:55.580 --> 00:29:57.384
That's how I see you.
00:29:57.403 --> 00:29:58.826
You're incredibly committed.
00:29:58.846 --> 00:30:05.297
And the other thing, amongst other things, of course, there's lots of other things, is your knowledge of the gospel and the church.
00:30:06.018 --> 00:30:23.115
And so when you and I were back and forward and I was trying to keep Jim aligned and up to date on some of your questions, there was a few topics that we wanted to get into with you, if we can, to get your insights and your experience and your knowledge and thoughts on this.
00:30:23.194 --> 00:30:25.336
And I think this will be very interesting for many of our listeners.
00:30:25.958 --> 00:30:27.318
And so maybe we could...
00:30:28.420 --> 00:30:32.904
So if we can, in the interest of time, ask
00:30:32.984 --> 00:30:33.125
some
00:30:33.766 --> 00:30:34.205
very...
00:30:34.369 --> 00:30:37.394
Well, before we do that, can I jump in just very quickly?
00:30:37.434 --> 00:30:58.390
Because this has been such a lovely conversation and I would hope it would stay a lovely conversation because I know that behind the scenes, Marcus, some of your objections to some of the things that we've said on this podcast, I think have the potential to get very heated and get very contentious.
00:30:59.233 --> 00:31:08.085
And I would hope that one of the hallmarks of this podcast, when we have people on, is we say, we absolutely want you to feel comfortable.
00:31:09.026 --> 00:31:13.351
And we want this to be a safe place for people to talk, for people to tell their stories.
00:31:14.511 --> 00:31:17.395
And I know of Ian's affection for you, Marcus.
00:31:18.336 --> 00:31:22.882
And I just met you today, but you seem like a very pleasant, lovely human being.
00:31:23.222 --> 00:31:43.213
And I would just hope that as we discuss things that may become somewhat difficult, some topics that may be somewhat loaded topics, that we can do so with civility, with kindness, and that this doesn't go off the rails into something else.
00:31:44.596 --> 00:31:45.017
Is that all
00:31:45.037 --> 00:31:45.237
right?
00:31:46.338 --> 00:31:51.788
Can you note that Jim's actually said some really good things about me, and I'd like that posted and actually put on the Facebook.
00:31:52.569 --> 00:31:54.192
Oh, that's excellent.
00:31:54.573 --> 00:31:54.973
Oh, well.
00:31:55.713 --> 00:31:57.757
No, I think that's a really important point.
00:31:57.777 --> 00:32:02.705
You know, our feedback we got from people who've been on to the podcast is that it feels safe and comfortable.
00:32:03.066 --> 00:32:14.184
But at the same time, we are, you know, we're really interested in having a very robust conversation because I think we can get some really interesting, you know, points in here.
00:32:14.365 --> 00:32:18.111
But I appreciate and value, obviously, what Jim said, and I concur with that.
00:32:18.632 --> 00:32:19.773
So if you're okay...
00:32:19.970 --> 00:32:47.108
Marcus if you're comfortable if we could just get into some of the topics uh that we talk as I think your insights are going to be uh fascinating um we've talked for example some of the big topics are like race and the priesthood polygamy you know these are some of the big ones right um you know the Book of Mormon translation process I think you've even talked about a little about evolution uh you know these are some of the the big the big topics there and so if you're comfortable getting to some of these questions.
00:32:47.869 --> 00:32:49.731
And we can start at any one of these.
00:32:50.452 --> 00:32:52.736
Maybe I'll just ask one question here.
00:32:52.776 --> 00:32:54.637
And again, I'll keep it brief.
00:32:57.541 --> 00:33:01.807
What's your perspective on race in the priesthood, for example?
00:33:03.308 --> 00:33:16.215
When Brigham Young introduced the restrictions on Black people accessing priesthood authority and temple blessings, Was he right to do so?
00:33:16.276 --> 00:33:17.277
Was he wrong?
00:33:17.317 --> 00:33:18.459
Did he make a mistake?
00:33:19.079 --> 00:33:25.707
And this speaks to an area that Jim's fascinated in, which is prophetic infallibility.
00:33:25.968 --> 00:33:28.289
Are the prophets wrong?
00:33:28.390 --> 00:33:29.010
Are they right?
00:33:29.612 --> 00:33:30.712
Are they speaking as a man?
00:33:30.772 --> 00:33:31.753
Are they speaking as a prophet?
00:33:32.134 --> 00:33:41.705
But was Brigham Young right or wrong to introduce restrictions on black people holding the priesthood and accessing the temple of blessings?
00:33:43.490 --> 00:33:44.030
Okay.
00:33:44.411 --> 00:33:50.518
I mean, I think it's really important that anybody in the gospel is actually open to questions.
00:33:50.657 --> 00:33:54.622
And anybody who fails to answer questions, I think, is missing the point.
00:33:54.761 --> 00:34:08.597
I think it is very important that we're all able to interact with each other very clearly and openly and happily, and that you do create a very comfortable environment and are very much appreciative of that fact.
00:34:09.157 --> 00:34:13.021
I think there are tenets that the gospel offers.
00:34:13.217 --> 00:34:49.728
lays down and I think those tenets are important to define the tenet for blacks and the priesthood is basically that there was no racism there has been no racism and that there was no pre-existent sin that black people committed to not receive the priesthood now my son My youngest son, I've got four kids, my youngest son is actually engaged to a really fun and exciting and vibrant black girl from South Africa.
00:34:49.768 --> 00:34:52.431
And they're engaged and they'll get married quite soon.
00:34:53.373 --> 00:34:54.994
So I think this is a really relevant question.
00:34:55.936 --> 00:35:06.849
My take, having thought about this for a long time, is that between 1852 and 1978, you have a geographical region which was restricted only to Africa.
00:35:07.425 --> 00:35:13.411
whereby people couldn't receive the priesthood if they were actually born within that geographical location.
00:35:14.311 --> 00:35:21.358
I can remember teaching a black family, the Browns, and they were just delightful.
00:35:22.920 --> 00:35:30.447
But I can easily see and completely see and totally understand why someone would not wish to be a judge in Israel.
00:35:31.068 --> 00:35:34.670
Now, I've been on quite a few disciplinary councils.
00:35:34.731 --> 00:35:36.313
I was on the High Council for 16 years.
00:35:37.666 --> 00:35:39.989
That was a continuous stretch when I really enjoyed it.
00:35:40.009 --> 00:35:40.429
I loved it.
00:35:40.949 --> 00:35:45.534
But I didn't enjoy going into disciplinaries so much.
00:35:45.614 --> 00:35:53.063
When I was actually asked to speak for the, to uphold the good name of the church, I always used to find myself swapping sides.
00:35:53.682 --> 00:35:58.548
And I would actually just put up mitigating circumstances for the guy in the chair.
00:35:58.588 --> 00:36:02.072
And some of the guys in the high council would give me a little bit of a funny look.
00:36:02.132 --> 00:36:02.833
I didn't care.
00:36:02.853 --> 00:36:06.016
I just wanted to continue to put the mitigating circumstances.
00:36:06.077 --> 00:36:10.378
So guys, I get it why some people would not want to do that.
00:36:10.398 --> 00:36:17.789
And I personally never wanted to be in that position because I saw the great angst that I had.
00:36:17.949 --> 00:36:19.351
I was with three state presidents.
00:36:19.371 --> 00:36:24.197
I saw the great angst that they went through in making decisions and also certain bishops.
00:36:25.259 --> 00:36:32.329
And I only kept what I say here, but not all leaders are actually fantastic.
00:36:32.429 --> 00:36:34.512
And I've heard your podcast and I agree with you.
00:36:35.233 --> 00:36:38.885
Some of them, Yeah, not that brilliant, but that's as far as I'll go with that.
00:36:39.465 --> 00:36:55.304
But guys, for me, the blacks not receiving the priesthood was a voluntary thing of not wanting to have been compelled to be a judge in Israel because it's not something that I'm comfortable with that idea.
00:36:56.005 --> 00:36:57.327
Some bishops are fantastic.
00:36:57.927 --> 00:37:00.030
So for me, it was a voluntary decision.
00:37:00.353 --> 00:37:07.181
just the same way that it was a voluntary decision that Helen left at the time that she did, not one that I kind of thought I was clever and agreeing to, but anyway.
00:37:07.880 --> 00:37:21.175
But so for me, that group of people between 1852 and 1978 didn't want to be judged in Israel, but once they die, they can have the opportunity of actually receiving the priesthood after mortality.
00:37:21.574 --> 00:37:30.172
And after 1978, all that group had gone through mortality, so it wasn't something which needed to be in place anymore, and it wasn't.
00:37:30.211 --> 00:37:30.833
It was removed.
00:37:31.293 --> 00:37:32.617
So for me, it was a voluntary action.
00:37:32.657 --> 00:37:34.760
It's got nothing to do with racism whatsoever.
00:37:35.320 --> 00:37:41.030
And I cannot agree that a prophet would be racist.
00:37:41.853 --> 00:37:46.922
And whilst men are fallible, as long as Christ is talking to a prophet, he's not fallible.
00:37:47.282 --> 00:37:51.769
The second he actually doesn't have Christ chatting to him, then he can make mistakes.
00:37:51.809 --> 00:37:54.887
But all the time that Christ is talking to him, He's not making mistakes.
00:37:54.927 --> 00:37:58.833
He's got the guy in the big cheese in the middle actually saying, look, do it like this, guys.
00:37:59.514 --> 00:38:00.835
Dissemination of information.
00:38:01.958 --> 00:38:11.873
So there's a big disparate view here between what guys muck up, and there's plenty of local leaders who do some really stupid things.
00:38:13.376 --> 00:38:24.318
But when the Savior is chatting to the prophet, it's not a problem, and there is nothing to be scared of in terms of listening to to what the prophet is saying.
00:38:24.900 --> 00:38:31.286
Now, I know that we all have different prophets that we like, and I really like President Nelson.
00:38:31.445 --> 00:38:31.947
I really do.
00:38:32.387 --> 00:38:34.909
I really like President Monson, the way he can twitch his ears.
00:38:34.989 --> 00:38:38.452
But, you know, other guys, I didn't warm to.
00:38:38.693 --> 00:38:40.394
But those two, I do.
00:38:40.474 --> 00:38:41.215
I really like them.
00:38:41.815 --> 00:38:42.657
So that's my answer.
00:38:42.697 --> 00:38:44.739
I appreciate that.
00:38:44.778 --> 00:38:47.702
And I want to get Jim's response here as well.
00:38:47.722 --> 00:38:58.925
But if I understand you, my interpretation of that is that The decision not to accept the priesthood was from the black people at the time, again, so correctly if I'm wrong.
00:39:00.248 --> 00:39:03.532
You're nodding your head, agreeing to that, I think.
00:39:03.692 --> 00:39:07.878
And secondly, Brigham Young didn't get it wrong as the prophet.
00:39:08.398 --> 00:39:11.422
He was in the Lord's prophet seat there.
00:39:11.442 --> 00:39:13.023
He didn't get it wrong.
00:39:13.565 --> 00:39:17.829
His decision to prohibit, restrict black from the priesthood was correct, if that's what you're saying.
00:39:18.630 --> 00:39:23.257
And he wasn't racist.
00:39:24.920 --> 00:39:31.630
His decision behind that wasn't based on his discriminating against black people.
00:39:31.690 --> 00:39:32.733
Is that correct?
00:39:33.373 --> 00:39:34.014
Did I understand that?
00:39:37.981 --> 00:39:40.266
Jim, any thoughts, comments on that from your perspective?
00:39:41.827 --> 00:39:42.509
Well, many.
00:39:44.733 --> 00:39:47.677
I'm just trying to figure out the best way to go at it.
00:39:48.193 --> 00:39:56.862
Because I think without that, I don't, I've cut you off there, but I think you and I talk about our perspective is somewhat different to that, but go ahead.
00:39:57.762 --> 00:39:59.204
Well, okay.
00:40:01.005 --> 00:40:02.967
Two things jump out at me from your answer.
00:40:03.889 --> 00:40:08.833
The first being that somehow this is a voluntary decision by black people.
00:40:08.914 --> 00:40:34.126
You initially said this is, these are people that are confined to a certain geographical area when in fact, you know, This affected people far beyond that geographical area, as in a global society, people of African descent can be found in pretty much any nation in the world, and they could be found in any nation in the world prior to the priesthood restrictions being lifted.
00:40:35.449 --> 00:40:53.858
But I want to drill down on this idea that this was somehow voluntary, that they somehow chose to not to have the priesthood because I've had conversations with Darius Gray, who was one of the first men who received the priesthood after restriction was lifted.
00:40:53.918 --> 00:40:56.222
He was one of the founders of the Genesis Group.
00:40:56.442 --> 00:40:58.585
Are you familiar with the Genesis Group, Marcus?
00:41:00.847 --> 00:41:03.731
You give your response and I'll come back with a riposte afterwards, okay?
00:41:04.431 --> 00:41:04.853
Oh, okay.
00:41:06.574 --> 00:41:18.746
The Genesis Group was a group of Black Latter-day Saints prior to the priesthood restriction, and they interacted directly with President Kimball.
00:41:19.788 --> 00:41:28.701
Darius Gray tells the story of his baptism, that he had received a testimony that he was to be baptized and then discovered that he couldn't get the priesthood.
00:41:30.063 --> 00:41:53.014
And the idea that Darius Gray or anybody else who had joined the church prior to 1978 didn't want the priesthood or, or chose or volunteered not to have the priesthood, uh, flies in the face of, of the, of any kind.
00:41:53.715 --> 00:41:59.663
I have not yet met a person who would say that, no, we just didn't want it.
00:41:59.822 --> 00:42:00.664
We just didn't want it.
00:42:01.085 --> 00:42:03.907
So I'm presuming that you are talking about that.
00:42:03.947 --> 00:42:20.226
This was a volunteer sort of thing that happened before this life, which is a sort of an explanation that the church has explicitly disavowed in the race and the priesthood essay.
00:42:20.266 --> 00:43:07.664
The idea that somehow they're less valiant, that somehow something in their pre-earth life determined that they would not be able to have the priesthood and you attach the word voluntary to that as if this which actually I can sort of understand why you would want to because then it no longer says okay well they were less valiant it was okay well they just chose to not have the priesthood and so that sort of softens the blow but it doesn't remove the sort of underlying assumption of inferiority that comes with that.
00:43:08.266 --> 00:43:21.545
So, so, so, I mean, I, that's my first foray into this and I'm happy to get to the other part about, um, uh, whether or not Brigham Young made mistakes or whether or not prophets can make mistakes.
00:43:21.585 --> 00:43:30.594
Cause I think that's a larger discussion, but, uh, That's my response to that, and I'd be interested to hear your thoughts in reply.
00:43:30.635 --> 00:43:32.135
Fantastic.
00:43:32.155 --> 00:43:32.576
I'd love to.
00:43:32.677 --> 00:43:32.876
Right.
00:43:32.936 --> 00:43:40.925
First of all, in terms of the passage of people out from Africa, it doesn't make any difference.
00:43:41.005 --> 00:43:50.813
If people actually were born in Africa, then basically the Heavenly Father made that possible that they were born in Africa, so therefore that was their choice from the preexistence.
00:43:51.175 --> 00:43:52.635
So that's sort of fair comment, Jim.
00:43:52.695 --> 00:43:54.117
But nice try, but it doesn't work.
00:43:54.594 --> 00:44:00.201
The other idea that it's actually connected with valiance, we know that it's not connected with valiance from the essays.
00:44:00.501 --> 00:44:04.565
That's got nothing whatsoever to do with the fact that it was a free choice.
00:44:04.646 --> 00:44:11.333
Valiance and free will, and Heavenly Father is very keen on free will, are completely and utterly separate.
00:44:11.353 --> 00:44:14.297
So it's not a case of dumbing down the blow.
00:44:14.338 --> 00:44:16.380
It's a case of they're not connected whatsoever.
00:44:16.420 --> 00:44:23.789
So it doesn't actually impact the idea that people in the preexistence made that as a free will choice.
00:44:24.193 --> 00:44:27.197
So it's a nice try, mate, but it doesn't actually stack up logically.
00:44:27.277 --> 00:44:28.858
Okay.
00:44:28.878 --> 00:44:31.322
I just want to set some boundaries here a little bit.
00:44:31.481 --> 00:44:32.443
I mean, nice try.
00:44:32.463 --> 00:44:34.144
I'm just trying to have a discussion with you.
00:44:34.224 --> 00:44:35.206
I'm not debating you.
00:44:36.086 --> 00:44:37.688
I'm not criticizing you.
00:44:37.768 --> 00:44:38.771
I'm not attacking you.
00:44:39.851 --> 00:44:42.233
I'm trying to have an exchange of ideas.
00:44:42.474 --> 00:44:48.061
So when you say things like, well, nice try or this, it's not about me being right or wrong.
00:44:48.161 --> 00:44:50.563
It's about me trying to understand your position.
00:44:51.724 --> 00:44:52.445
And I was appalled, John.
00:44:52.802 --> 00:45:18.418
When you start talking about it's voluntary in the pre-existence, I mean, the geography, well, I mean, the geography, I guess that doesn't matter because people born in the United States for generations, there are people who have been born in the United States for hundreds of years and born in the UK and born throughout the world who haven't ever been to Africa.
00:45:18.657 --> 00:45:25.949
I guess their genetic ancestry is rooted in Africa, but I guess maybe that's a distinction without a difference.
00:45:26.789 --> 00:45:37.226
But when I raised Darius Gray, for instance, Darius Gray would have told you in 1977 that he very much wanted the priesthood.
00:45:38.608 --> 00:45:52.639
And based on the way you are framing this, you would have told him, well, you made a decision before this life where you didn't want the priesthood, and that decision should take precedence over your 1977 decision.
00:45:53.440 --> 00:45:54.621
Is that an accurate framing?
00:45:56.304 --> 00:45:58.186
Well, I apologize for saying nice try.
00:45:58.246 --> 00:46:03.309
What I'm used to is actually talking like this as a scientist, and I actually debate regularly with other scientists.
00:46:03.351 --> 00:46:05.472
I'm not trying to be rude, and I really apologize.
00:46:05.753 --> 00:46:07.153
That's not what I'm trying to do, Jim.
00:46:07.454 --> 00:46:11.838
I'm actually just coming back, and I'm used to people actually coming back at me and saying nice try.
00:46:11.878 --> 00:46:15.422
This is the kind of banter that we use, and it's not meant to be offensive.
00:46:15.905 --> 00:46:17.007
I really apologize for that.
00:46:17.068 --> 00:46:26.181
But bottom line is that the pre-existent choice was something that people will make, just in the same way that I made a choice about Helen, apparently.
00:46:26.822 --> 00:46:31.210
And that then has to actually remain in force until you pass through mortality.
00:46:31.510 --> 00:46:38.422
So it doesn't matter what you actually choose or what decisions you try to change once you're in mortality.
00:46:38.442 --> 00:46:40.003
Once you're on the...
00:46:41.250 --> 00:46:46.155
the crazy ride on Fort Park, you're on there until the end of the ride.
00:46:46.195 --> 00:46:48.219
And once you get off the ride, then that's fine.
00:46:48.298 --> 00:46:50.402
Once you die, then that's a different story.
00:46:50.641 --> 00:46:52.403
But you can't change your mind halfway through.
00:46:52.423 --> 00:46:53.505
It doesn't work like that.
00:46:54.206 --> 00:46:57.331
Well, doesn't that sort of defeat the entire purpose of mortality?
00:46:57.590 --> 00:47:05.701
Isn't the purpose of coming here the willingness to make decisions, to make choices, to learn from our decisions, to learn from our choices?
00:47:05.780 --> 00:47:11.623
And if we're bound solely by the choices we made before this life, Why do we bother coming here in the first place?
00:47:12.684 --> 00:47:27.300
Because we all have to actually have preconditions set in, and actually those preconditions determine where we were born, how we were born, to what families we were born, and therefore we have a partial judgment when we die.
00:47:27.320 --> 00:47:29.603
All the things that we do have consequences.
00:47:30.103 --> 00:47:39.193
So when we actually have different choices to make, we make them at the time and we live with them until we get a circumstance where those conditions are changed.
00:47:39.554 --> 00:47:50.070
So it's not a problem, Jim, in actually deciding, look, I don't want to be a judge in Israel, but I certainly want to go down to mortality and to actually participate.
00:47:50.871 --> 00:47:56.079
I don't want to go with Lucifer's crowd because that's crazy, but I also don't want to be a judge in Israel.
00:47:56.099 --> 00:47:57.201
There's nothing wrong with doing that.
00:47:58.463 --> 00:48:01.708
Marcus, can I just drill down on this because I think this is fascinating.
00:48:04.773 --> 00:48:05.514
Is it your...
00:48:05.858 --> 00:48:34.396
perspective that you know you talk about choice and preconditions before people came to the earth that we individuals some individuals chose to go to Africa for example it chose to go to a certain geography that there were certain decisions that they made under free agency to go to a be born in a certain place in that situation or those conditions in those geographies, et cetera, you know, outside the United States, for example, or UK or whatever.
00:48:35.117 --> 00:48:36.780
And that those are the series of choices.
00:48:37.300 --> 00:48:44.751
Was that based on any type or form of faithfulness or balance on their part?
00:48:44.811 --> 00:48:51.961
For example, when I was investigating the church, certainly just after I was baptized, I learned pretty quickly early on that.
00:48:52.963 --> 00:48:54.045
And this was in seminary.
00:48:54.284 --> 00:49:14.909
We talked about this on the podcast briefly where I was taught that that black people weren't allowed to receive the priesthood at that time because they were, quote, less valiant, end quote, before the world was, and that they were restricted to certain geographies, weren't born in white, middle-class Utah, for example.
00:49:14.969 --> 00:49:16.030
They went to Africa.
00:49:16.371 --> 00:49:20.675
That was, to your point, their choice based on their agency.
00:49:20.715 --> 00:49:27.561
But is there a correlation there with those individuals' faithfulness and valiance, which is what I...
00:49:27.938 --> 00:49:30.280
was taught when I first joined the church.
00:49:30.340 --> 00:49:31.041
Could you speak to that?
00:49:33.063 --> 00:49:35.726
Yeah, I think that's a really important point, Ian.
00:49:36.146 --> 00:49:41.992
And sometimes I think that local guys actually just get it wrong.
00:49:42.351 --> 00:49:42.932
I really do.
00:49:43.373 --> 00:49:44.614
And this is really important.
00:49:44.773 --> 00:49:51.141
And what's really stark for me here is as soon as you start speaking, Ian, I'm automatically wanting to agree with you.
00:49:51.201 --> 00:49:58.380
As soon as Jim starts speaking, because I don't know him so well, I automatically want to actually joust with him.
00:49:58.940 --> 00:50:00.061
So it's crazy.
00:50:00.202 --> 00:50:02.726
I don't want to do that, but it's just my natural reaction.
00:50:02.766 --> 00:50:09.153
So automatically I'm thinking, yeah, how can I actually completely find common ground with Ian?
00:50:09.215 --> 00:50:13.740
And I'm thinking, how can I get in there and give Jim a good blow before he blows me?
00:50:13.760 --> 00:50:15.443
I mean, that's just how it goes.
00:50:15.503 --> 00:50:16.164
That's where we are.
00:50:16.204 --> 00:50:17.646
We guys is what we want to do.
00:50:18.027 --> 00:50:23.253
So completely, Ian, some local leaders just basically talk utter drivel.
00:50:23.793 --> 00:50:25.597
And I don't mean that to be rude.
00:50:25.637 --> 00:50:30.722
It's just But other guys are just a delight to listen to.
00:50:30.802 --> 00:50:32.224
In the Winchester Ward, it's a pleasure.
00:50:32.284 --> 00:50:37.349
So I completely and totally disagree with the idea about valiance and the preexistence.
00:50:37.449 --> 00:50:38.469
I'm completely with you.
00:50:38.891 --> 00:50:40.391
I think that's completely 100%.
00:50:40.693 --> 00:50:48.561
It's got nothing to do with people from black ethnicity at all.
00:50:49.382 --> 00:50:51.885
And I think your point you make is very good, Ian.
00:50:51.905 --> 00:50:52.905
100%, mate.
00:50:52.965 --> 00:50:53.126
Yep.
00:50:54.722 --> 00:51:06.840
Well, I want to dive into this idea that the prophets couldn't have been wrong and the idea that they've got Christ whispering in their ear and so they can't be wrong.
00:51:07.920 --> 00:51:10.445
So this is going to be sort of a two-pronged question.
00:51:10.485 --> 00:51:16.914
The first, I want to read a statement by Brigham Young made on March 8th, 1863.
00:51:17.916 --> 00:51:22.021
Shall I tell you the law of God in regard to the African race?
00:51:22.849 --> 00:51:31.639
If the white man who belongs to the chosen seed mixes his blood with the seed of Cain, the penalty under the law of God is death on the spot.
00:51:32.340 --> 00:51:34.563
This will always be so.
00:51:34.603 --> 00:51:41.610
Now, you, Marcus, you told us you've got a son that is marrying a lovely woman of African descent.
00:51:42.771 --> 00:51:53.963
And based on the law of God that will always be so, as enunciated by Brigham Young, the punishment, the penalty under the law of God is death on the spot.
00:51:54.664 --> 00:51:55.927
Do you agree with Brigham Young?
00:51:56.067 --> 00:52:07.961
And if you don't agree with Brigham Young, because I'm assuming you don't want that punishment for your son and his fiance, how do you reconcile that and say Brigham Young wasn't wrong?
00:52:09.603 --> 00:52:11.967
Okay, here's my riposte.
00:52:12.606 --> 00:52:13.849
Very easily indeed.
00:52:13.869 --> 00:52:20.661
I was politically assassinated and I actually saw things printed in the press and I know were fabricated.
00:52:21.802 --> 00:52:29.333
My daughter is a reporter and she's a very accurate reporter and very objective in her articles that she writes.
00:52:30.054 --> 00:52:39.246
Some reporters, or shall I say, it is the nature and disposition of nearly all men, not only to exercise unrighteous dominion, but also to tell complete big porky pies.
00:52:40.161 --> 00:52:43.447
actually report in a way which I don't trust as far as I can throw it.
00:52:43.807 --> 00:52:48.293
So I'm not interested in what someone reported about something that Brigham Young may or may not have said.
00:52:48.635 --> 00:52:51.559
When I get into the next dimension, I'll ask him myself.
00:52:52.019 --> 00:52:52.880
And he can tell me.
00:52:52.922 --> 00:52:59.090
When I get into the next dimension and I see Joseph Smith, if he's got multiple wives, that's fine by me because it would be real.
00:52:59.110 --> 00:53:01.014
If he hasn't, I don't care.
00:53:01.034 --> 00:53:04.338
I don't care what somebody actually reports about Brigham Young.
00:53:04.699 --> 00:53:08.726
I'm not interested in third parties because I've seen all sorts of drivel made up about me.
00:53:09.090 --> 00:53:10.992
And I know that it's completely fabricated.
00:53:11.594 --> 00:53:14.418
So I'm getting animated here because I've experienced it.
00:53:14.478 --> 00:53:20.789
So in answer to your question, Jim, I'm not interested in third-party reports, and I think they're a completely utter fabricated drivel.
00:53:21.650 --> 00:53:27.579
So you don't think Brigham Young is wrong because you deny that Brigham Young ever said anything like this?
00:53:28.880 --> 00:53:35.070
I don't trust people's third-party reports having had that experience.
00:53:35.831 --> 00:53:36.393
Okay, well...
00:53:37.153 --> 00:53:43.199
I've had a number of experiences with the press as well, and I recognize the press is capable of getting things wrong.
00:53:43.239 --> 00:53:49.005
Would that this were an isolated sort of statement on the part of Brigham Young.
00:53:49.746 --> 00:54:02.938
We have his address recorded to the territorial legislature in 1852, which is the first time that the priesthood and temple ban became sort of codified into Latter-day Saint policy.
00:54:02.998 --> 00:54:11.659
It had been sort of enforced sporadically prior to that, Joseph Smith ordained several men of African descent to the priesthood.
00:54:12.661 --> 00:54:25.014
But it was in that 1852 address to the territorial legislature that Brigham Young outlined specifically that black people are the descendants of Cain, which we now disavow.
00:54:25.054 --> 00:54:30.780
The black people were in fact less valiant and less righteous, which we now disavow.
00:54:30.820 --> 00:54:44.599
And all the kinds of things that we taught prior to 1978, have their origins in that 1852 address, which was well-recorded and which was firsthand.
00:54:44.978 --> 00:54:49.684
I don't know how you reconcile historical sources.
00:54:49.724 --> 00:55:01.474
If the game is, okay, we just disregard any kind of historical record that makes a prophet look bad, then this is going to be a fairly unproductive conversation.
00:55:02.436 --> 00:55:28.608
But the church has readily admitted that Brigham Young taught those things, that Brigham Young taught the inferiority of the black race, the cursed nature of the black race, and whether or not this individual statement that I had read to you is in fact accurate, it is in many ways consistent with the large body of what Brigham Young had to teach on the subject of race.
00:55:29.429 --> 00:55:30.891
And it isn't just Brigham Young.
00:55:31.152 --> 00:55:45.202
As it goes down, The idea the black people are the cursed descendants of Cain is something that was taught by every prophet since Brigham Young up to Spencer W.
00:55:45.242 --> 00:55:47.143
Kimball, who finally lifted the ban.
00:55:47.445 --> 00:55:59.936
And the idea that they are not cursed did not come into parlance in our theological discussions until essentially 2013.
00:56:01.313 --> 00:56:09.708
with the publication of the race and priesthood essay, which explicitly disavows all of those things that the prophets had said prior to that.
00:56:09.748 --> 00:56:42.523
Now, if you're going to say every single prophet is, was misquoted or misunderstood or misheard when they talked about the inferiority of the black race and the cursed nature of the black race, uh, I don't know where we can take this conversation in a productive direction because I think it's undeniable that that's something that was taught at the highest levels of this church for well over a century.
00:56:42.563 --> 00:56:52.878
And I don't know how you can look at that and then say, well, prophets can't make mistakes.
00:56:54.753 --> 00:56:55.434
Okay, right.
00:56:55.896 --> 00:56:58.239
Okay, my response to that would be twofold.
00:56:58.498 --> 00:57:09.193
One is that I don't think Brigham Young is stupid enough to actually believe that Cain was the source of the cursing because black people came from Egypt as the wife of Ham.
00:57:09.833 --> 00:57:24.233
Secondly, I've actually listened to your podcast, Jim, where you actually talk about 2 Nephi 5.21, where you talk about the idea that the Lamanites were cursed with a dark skin.
00:57:24.802 --> 00:57:26.844
That's not my understanding at all whatsoever.
00:57:26.903 --> 00:57:28.967
The Lamanites threw off their clothes and got tanned.
00:57:28.987 --> 00:57:41.800
When my father was actually in Iraq in the hockey team, they were lining up and they said, we thought that you were actually just only going to have British soldiers, British RAF guys.
00:57:43.543 --> 00:57:44.784
You can't have that guy over there.
00:57:44.824 --> 00:57:46.867
And they said, well, what do you mean?
00:57:46.887 --> 00:57:50.391
He said, well, he's not Caucasian.
00:57:50.791 --> 00:57:51.751
He's a black guy.
00:57:51.791 --> 00:57:53.213
That was my father.
00:57:53.889 --> 00:58:01.601
When people actually chuck off their clothes, they get self-cursing because they get carcinomas and they get a really deep tan.
00:58:01.961 --> 00:58:13.639
So your explanation for 2 Nephi 521, I'm sorry, doesn't actually sit level with me because some of the things that you're quoting, some of these guys can be interpreted in different ways.
00:58:13.739 --> 00:58:15.902
Justin, we could come on to the Pearl of Great Price.
00:58:15.943 --> 00:58:17.905
That's another one where we get different interpretations.
00:58:18.365 --> 00:58:23.998
So whilst you can actually roll out these quotes, Jim, My understanding of them is completely different to yours, I'm afraid.
00:58:24.018 --> 00:58:29.608
And every time I read one of these quotes that you pull up, I'm actually reading it in a completely different way.
00:58:29.628 --> 00:58:29.668
So
00:58:31.271 --> 00:58:34.795
I'm trying to find out what way you're reading them.
00:58:35.657 --> 00:58:42.809
I mean, do you deny that the prophets taught that black people bore the curse of Cain?
00:58:44.652 --> 00:58:45.634
It's got nothing to do with Cain.
00:58:45.653 --> 00:58:47.557
It's to do with Ham and Egyptus.
00:58:48.001 --> 00:58:50.306
Well, Ham and Egyptus were descendants.
00:58:50.445 --> 00:58:54.012
Egyptus was scripturally a descendant of Cain.
00:58:56.177 --> 00:59:01.887
I mean, Brigham Young, and again, I've given you the 1852 reference, the territorial legislature speech.
00:59:02.867 --> 00:59:10.442
And I can give you the 1949 first presidency statement where they reiterate that black people bear the curse of Cain.
00:59:11.242 --> 00:59:12.565
That's George Albert Smith.
00:59:13.313 --> 00:59:15.597
I can find several other statements of it.
00:59:16.018 --> 00:59:27.713
And when you say, well, you interpret them in a different way, and then you go to 2 Nephi 5.21, which is a different discussion, because 2 Nephi 5.21 was never used to deny anybody priesthood or temple blessings.
00:59:28.875 --> 00:59:31.858
But the idea of the curse of Cain absolutely was.
00:59:31.900 --> 00:59:36.565
And so I'm trying to get...
00:59:36.606 --> 00:59:39.389
See, so from my perspective...
00:59:40.257 --> 00:59:58.820
The idea of prophetic infallibility, the idea that prophets cannot make mistakes, never make mistakes, they've got Jesus whispering in their ear 24 hours a day, and everything they say is always right and always reliable, that absolutely flies in the face.
00:59:59.969 --> 01:00:21.264
of the fundamental principle of mortality, which is agency, which is the idea that we chose to come to this earth in order to learn and grow by encountering opposition and learning from our mistakes and knowing that sin and wickedness and mistakes would keep us from living with our heavenly father.
01:00:21.284 --> 01:00:26.413
We were given a savior in order to be able to pay for that education, if you will.
01:00:27.106 --> 01:00:39.878
But the idea, it's always interesting to me when people talk about church leaders, and Marcus, you talk about, okay, you're willing to concede that there are local leaders that are lousy.
01:00:41.039 --> 01:00:51.889
And I commend you for not mentioning them by name, because I do think we are under a covenantal obligation not to speak evil of people who have been given callings by the Lord.
01:00:51.929 --> 01:00:56.173
But I'm curious that...
01:00:56.673 --> 01:01:01.137
My mission president after Ian left the mission was Joseph Fielding McConkie.
01:01:01.177 --> 01:01:05.402
And he was often asked about prophetic infallibility.
01:01:05.442 --> 01:01:08.105
And he wrote a book called Answers to Gospel Questions.
01:01:08.485 --> 01:01:13.409
And he wrote a lengthy thing where he said, at what point does infallibility begin?
01:01:14.251 --> 01:01:16.572
Because we don't expect infallible Sunday school teachers.
01:01:17.273 --> 01:01:18.735
We don't expect infallible bishops.
01:01:19.476 --> 01:01:22.539
So at what point do we expect infallible 70s?
01:01:23.358 --> 01:01:25.802
Does infallibility kick in when you become an apostle?
01:01:26.465 --> 01:01:34.494
Or is it reserved solely for the person who sits in the big chair at general conference in the center of the first presidency?
01:01:34.635 --> 01:01:37.797
Is it only the prophet that can't make mistakes?
01:01:38.358 --> 01:01:50.012
Because the reality is that for a prophet to be infallible, for a prophet to not make mistakes, they need to have their agency extracted from them.
01:01:50.472 --> 01:01:57.242
They no longer have can have the freedom to choose wrong if all they can do is right.
01:01:58.244 --> 01:02:01.710
And so that defeats the entire purpose of mortality.
01:02:01.730 --> 01:02:13.989
It flies in the face of every scriptural example we know about prophets, and everything we know, and the prophets themselves tell us that they are not infallible, and yet we refuse to believe them.
01:02:14.570 --> 01:02:53.489
And so with that if you say, okay, well, a prophet has never made mistakes, they are infallible, and I've given you, I can give you as long as your arm citations and references of prophets saying extraordinarily racist things, not just that black people bear the curse of Cain, but all sorts of justifications that we now completely and totally disavow as being the truth, and yet we're not And yet somehow we try to reconcile that reality with this idea, well, no, they were never wrong to begin with.
01:02:54.231 --> 01:03:04.021
If you're just going to say they were misquoted by the press for 100 years, it's just an absolutely ridiculous sort of defense for an undeniable reality.
01:03:05.923 --> 01:03:06.264
Okay.
01:03:06.525 --> 01:03:08.827
My repost to that, Jim, will be twofold.
01:03:09.128 --> 01:03:27.068
One is that if you look in the Polygraph Price, you actually hear that Pharaoh actually had a cursing And we know that Pharaoh came from the line of black ancestry, but it does not connect the cursing to a black skin.
01:03:28.851 --> 01:03:35.800
My second point will be that when Christ is talking to the prophet, I will always listen.
01:03:36.121 --> 01:03:44.452
We know that some apostles have actually fallen away, so I'll always listen with interest, but I'll actually focus my interest on the prophet when he speaks.
01:03:47.137 --> 01:03:55.547
actually looking at quotes and saying, we can look at each individual specific quotes, if you like, and actually interpret each one individually.
01:03:55.586 --> 01:04:03.173
But I'm sorry, every time I listen to your podcast, I go to the reference and I read it and I read it a different way.
01:04:03.213 --> 01:04:10.202
And it's not good enough just to say there are many quotes and there are many apostles and there are many prophets who have actually been wrong.
01:04:10.242 --> 01:04:21.132
You have to look at every individual case on its merits and actually interpret dissect that particular case and actually see whether those quotes are saying what you're alluding to.
01:04:21.152 --> 01:04:35.833
And my argument is that what you're alluding to isn't in fact what you're purporting, that in fact they're disparate, and that my actual reading of the same quotes and the same scriptures isn't the same as yours.
01:04:36.545 --> 01:04:37.708
It's fascinating.
01:04:37.967 --> 01:04:44.016
It's interesting to hear both of your different interpretations and perspectives.
01:04:44.215 --> 01:04:46.179
So I just want to kind of bring it to a bit of a higher level.
01:04:46.860 --> 01:04:52.467
So do you, Marcus, believe that prophets don't get it wrong?
01:04:52.748 --> 01:04:53.568
They don't make mistakes?
01:04:53.949 --> 01:04:54.789
Is that fair?
01:04:56.112 --> 01:05:00.478
I think there was a time where, for example, Joseph Smith said that men wouldn't get to the moon.
01:05:00.657 --> 01:05:01.920
That was clearly incorrect.
01:05:02.360 --> 01:05:06.206
When he actually publishes something in the Doctrine and Covenants, it's not wrong.
01:05:06.753 --> 01:05:07.355
Go
01:05:07.514 --> 01:05:09.177
ahead.
01:05:10.958 --> 01:05:18.447
I've had some business authorities who've come down, and I'm not prepared to mention their names, but they've said things which I thought were completely wrong.
01:05:18.467 --> 01:05:21.891
And I've actually gone up to them and had discussions afterwards.
01:05:21.972 --> 01:05:27.998
Now, I won't actually broadcast what I think about their ideas because I think they were completely and utterly wrong.
01:05:28.880 --> 01:05:39.541
But do I actually think that President Nelson would make a mistake in terms of some key doctrinal points, key tenets of our religion, the answer is categorically no.
01:05:39.581 --> 01:05:45.471
And when I have a doubt, I will actually shelve that doubt until I find out the answer.
01:05:45.510 --> 01:05:55.005
For example, I actually couldn't figure out whether bristlecone pine really was, as dendrochronology says, which is basically predating the flood.
01:05:55.565 --> 01:05:57.829
And I tried for two years to figure it out.
01:05:58.389 --> 01:06:01.233
And I sat and I sat and I sat and I couldn't figure it out.
01:06:01.634 --> 01:06:06.420
So after two years, I finally said to Emily, I said, okay, come on and give me an idea because I haven't got a clue.
01:06:06.920 --> 01:06:09.503
So the idea came to me, where is bristlecone pine?
01:06:09.543 --> 01:06:10.605
Tops of the mountains.
01:06:11.184 --> 01:06:14.068
What's the last thing that gets uncovered?
01:06:14.289 --> 01:06:15.230
Tops of the mountains.
01:06:15.329 --> 01:06:16.871
What's the first thing that gets uncovered?
01:06:17.271 --> 01:06:18.313
Tops of the mountains.
01:06:18.813 --> 01:06:21.036
Can plants survive a little while underwater?
01:06:21.117 --> 01:06:21.797
Yes, they can.
01:06:21.838 --> 01:06:28.746
I'm thinking, oh my goodness, I've had an idea within 30 seconds that it's taken me two years that I couldn't figure out.
01:06:29.057 --> 01:06:32.061
So the bottom line is, if there's a will, there's a way.
01:06:32.101 --> 01:06:39.288
And we shouldn't be looking for problems and more questions and moaning and being negative about church stuff.
01:06:39.648 --> 01:06:41.108
We should be looking for answers.
01:06:41.168 --> 01:06:42.990
And I've got two pages of stuff here.
01:06:43.030 --> 01:06:45.713
And we've gone on to one subject, Flax on the Priesthood.
01:06:46.014 --> 01:06:48.536
And I've got two pages of things that we could discuss.
01:06:48.635 --> 01:06:51.039
I could go through loads of different points.
01:06:51.179 --> 01:06:52.659
Evolution's a fascinating one.
01:06:53.260 --> 01:06:58.626
When I actually had a TV, we watched the Sharks series.
01:06:59.074 --> 01:07:03.099
and the Sharp series, basically, was coming to a brick-ground conclusion.
01:07:03.260 --> 01:07:08.067
And as it was coming to a conclusion, we were all getting excited, Helen and I, and then the TV stopped working.
01:07:08.106 --> 01:07:09.148
I thought, you've got to be kidding.
01:07:09.208 --> 01:07:12.452
I picked up the TV and shoved it outside the door, hoping someone would pick it up.
01:07:12.853 --> 01:07:20.605
We went to a TV store down the road, and there in the back of the store was my TV, looking fantastic and new.
01:07:21.286 --> 01:07:23.668
But the TV didn't become a radio.
01:07:23.688 --> 01:07:25.291
It was still a TV.
01:07:26.152 --> 01:07:26.813
So therefore...
01:07:27.969 --> 01:07:35.400
On evolution, as it talks about in the scriptures, species replicates after their own kind.
01:07:35.701 --> 01:07:43.072
When we get a problem, we have to go to the scriptures and actually try and find an answer, not try and find another problem and moan about what we can't understand.
01:07:43.552 --> 01:07:46.257
We've got to try and find answers to these problems.
01:07:46.757 --> 01:07:48.981
And so, no, I won't be negative about the church.
01:07:49.201 --> 01:07:54.309
I'll spend my life studying and trying to find answers to gospel questions.
01:07:54.708 --> 01:07:57.634
And that's why I published the book called Evolution Theorem.
01:07:58.210 --> 01:08:03.679
with two pseudonyms because I didn't want to highlight the fact that I was politically assassinated, and I put it up on Amazon.
01:08:04.101 --> 01:08:16.345
One, to let my kids know basically what Helen was like, and two, to answer gospel questions that they could pull off at four quid and basically print it off and get answers that they won't get from places which is super negative about the church.
01:08:16.805 --> 01:08:30.501
So my answer is yes, I will continue to actually oppose any of his specific quotes about blacks in the priesthood, and we can actually look at them and actually dissect them one by one by one, because that's what I've done my whole life.
01:08:31.381 --> 01:08:32.783
I appreciate you bringing this back to the back,
01:08:32.963 --> 01:08:35.167
because I want to talk about President Nelson.
01:08:35.287 --> 01:08:50.855
I want to do a sort of, we're at an hour and eight minutes, and Marcus, you've said you could go on forever, and I actually would like to go on, so I'm wondering, Ian, if we could I don't know what your schedule is like right now, but I'm happy to go on.
01:08:50.877 --> 01:08:54.725
And if we have to sort of split this into more than one episode, I'm happy to do that too.
01:08:56.307 --> 01:08:57.430
What are your schedules like?
01:08:57.511 --> 01:09:00.957
Is there a drop dead moment where we have, you guys have to go on?
01:09:01.250 --> 01:09:03.131
I have to go in like 10 minutes.
01:09:03.332 --> 01:09:09.840
I think this is a fascinating conversation and I would love to get Marcus back on if you're interested, Marcus, because I really would love to get into some of the topics.
01:09:10.581 --> 01:09:12.943
And so I appreciate that intervention there.
01:09:12.983 --> 01:09:23.836
So I do have a hard stop at about 10, 15 minutes max, which is coming up to, you know, where we usually drop off on these, you know, where we end that conversation on the podcast.
01:09:24.317 --> 01:09:25.377
But so...
01:09:25.729 --> 01:09:30.256
We've got probably 10, I've only got 10, 15 minutes, but Marcus would love to get you back on if you're interested.
01:09:31.038 --> 01:09:35.445
And so just going back to the topic of race in the priesthood, which is fascinating.
01:09:36.927 --> 01:09:42.617
What I'm hearing is that if they're going correctly from wrong, Brigham Young didn't make, did not make a mistake.
01:09:43.362 --> 01:09:53.896
he was speaking for the Lord, his ban on black soldiers and the priesthood, et cetera, of African descent, whether they were in Africa or not, et cetera, which is their choice, which they made before they came to it.
01:09:54.497 --> 01:09:55.899
Brigham Young didn't make a mistake.
01:09:56.020 --> 01:09:57.021
He didn't get it wrong.
01:09:57.202 --> 01:09:58.283
He was right at the time.
01:09:58.342 --> 01:10:02.789
Again, correct me if I'm wrong in any part of that, if I misunderstood you or misinterpreted.
01:10:03.270 --> 01:10:07.837
And also you mentioned something very interesting where the Lamanites were not black.
01:10:08.518 --> 01:10:09.520
They were suntanned.
01:10:10.661 --> 01:10:46.458
Does that, thinking extend to uh other people who are non-white are they is your perspective that black people are suntanned and not black uh naturally um you know because my understanding that the lebanites were black uh i've never heard uh the idea that they were suntanned until now so you and i are talking so could you just have two things there on this subject um Before we move on, and if we have time, I'd like to talk briefly a bit about President Nelson.
01:10:47.180 --> 01:10:52.208
We'll see where this goes in terms of a decision on the LGTBQ decisions that were made there.
01:10:52.529 --> 01:10:53.751
We may not have time to get into that.
01:10:54.131 --> 01:10:56.534
But was Brigham Young right then, essentially?
01:10:56.796 --> 01:10:58.478
It didn't make a mistake on that.
01:10:59.059 --> 01:11:03.987
And secondly, do you hold that black people are suntanned?
01:11:04.908 --> 01:11:05.729
Can you clarify that?
01:11:06.850 --> 01:11:07.511
Okay, sure.
01:11:08.332 --> 01:11:15.641
I think there's a distinction here, Ian, between people who actually came from Ham or came from Japheth.
01:11:15.662 --> 01:11:17.203
So you've got Shem, Ham and Japheth.
01:11:17.243 --> 01:11:23.311
Shem is Caucasians, Japheth is Asian, and Ham is the black race.
01:11:23.752 --> 01:11:30.001
In terms of Suntans, the Lamanites weren't Negroes, no, in that sense.
01:11:30.622 --> 01:11:35.051
And that's a historic term, by the way, when I say It's not a term we use now.
01:11:35.091 --> 01:11:36.193
I mean blacks by that.
01:11:36.313 --> 01:11:40.637
And don't forget, my daughter-in-law will be a black girl.
01:11:40.658 --> 01:11:45.184
I'm just looking at the phraseology that was used at the time.
01:11:46.586 --> 01:11:47.327
So, no.
01:11:49.829 --> 01:11:59.601
For me, the Lamanites were suntanned, but they were not from black ethnicity.
01:12:00.162 --> 01:12:04.268
So no, the two are distinct and separate.
01:12:04.747 --> 01:12:05.949
So they weren't cursed.
01:12:06.029 --> 01:12:07.492
They weren't cursed with a black skin.
01:12:07.532 --> 01:12:08.153
That's what you're saying.
01:12:09.675 --> 01:12:20.650
I'm saying that they were self-cursed by actually discarding clothing, but I'm saying that they were cursed in the same way that we have factions now.
01:12:20.690 --> 01:12:25.096
We actually have extremist groups that people will stay away from.
01:12:25.117 --> 01:12:35.998
So when when Heavenly Father says, don't mix and intermarry, it's something natural in the sense that people look at cults and they don't want to be a part of it and so they keep away from them.
01:12:36.840 --> 01:12:46.252
In the same way, Heavenly Father said to the Nephites, look, don't mix with this bunch of, this group of people because they're not being, they're not acting in a righteous way.
01:12:46.351 --> 01:12:50.037
So in that sense, that's only something which is sensible.
01:12:50.617 --> 01:12:54.301
In terms of a self, in terms of a cursing, it was a self-cursing, Ian, yeah?
01:12:54.497 --> 01:12:58.222
by just chucking the clothes off and getting deeply tanned like my father was deeply tanned.
01:12:59.204 --> 01:12:59.284
Yeah.
01:12:59.305 --> 01:13:12.864
So the self-curse was, again, if I get it right, understand it correctly, was by that group of people taking their clothes off, they were self-cursed by getting a suntan.
01:13:13.765 --> 01:13:31.137
And that means then I think that when the Lord in the Book of Mormon said that he placed the curse upon this group in terms of their skin color, That curse was a self-curse, not one that was placed by the Lord, which is what the Book of Mormon taught.
01:13:32.219 --> 01:13:43.753
You know, I've got the Book of Mormon that you gave to me when I was investigating the church, and it says, white and delightsome, not pure and delightsome as it says now, but the 1981 version talks about white and delightsome.
01:13:43.993 --> 01:13:52.145
But you're saying the Lamanites were of darker skin because of a suntan and not cursed by the Lord.
01:13:52.185 --> 01:13:53.086
Is that correct?
01:13:54.242 --> 01:14:01.030
Okay, so the cursing is not associated at any point in the scriptures with a change of skin color.
01:14:01.070 --> 01:14:01.771
They're separate.
01:14:02.353 --> 01:14:06.779
The Lord said that he cursed them, or he said that a curse was placed upon them, i.e.
01:14:06.798 --> 01:14:12.686
it was self-cursing, but there is no connection between the change of the color of the skin and the cursing.
01:14:12.726 --> 01:14:14.048
They are separate and distinct.
01:14:14.989 --> 01:14:20.457
So therefore, if people choose to throw off their clothes and get carcinomas, that's up to them.
01:14:21.826 --> 01:14:22.286
Interesting.
01:14:22.627 --> 01:14:27.471
We probably haven't got enough time to get into another big topic because we so much explore on this one.
01:14:27.851 --> 01:14:30.014
You know, we talked about polygamy, LGBTQ.
01:14:30.555 --> 01:14:32.417
I'm fascinated about your position on evolution.
01:14:32.796 --> 01:14:34.399
And we're coming up to the end of the podcast.
01:14:34.878 --> 01:14:37.322
We probably may only have time to stay on this particular topic.
01:14:37.362 --> 01:14:39.623
And there's so much more to even talk about this.
01:14:40.204 --> 01:14:42.087
Jim, what's your perspective on...
01:14:42.207 --> 01:14:45.449
What's your response to Marcus's answers to those questions?
01:14:47.212 --> 01:14:47.731
Well, I...
01:14:50.242 --> 01:14:56.029
I'm looking at it from a larger perspective here in that Marcus is the way you frame this.
01:14:56.671 --> 01:15:10.248
You said, look, I'm not going to say anything bad about the church, meaning that when we highlight the fact that church leaders have made mistakes, we are somehow attacking the church or we are somehow saying something bad about the church.
01:15:11.350 --> 01:15:27.154
Because one of the things that I've discovered as I've entered this sort of space that the people who are on the borders of the church, inside out, where they're on the edge of the inside or on the edge of the outside.
01:15:28.895 --> 01:15:40.048
You're seeing people who are leaving the church in large numbers, largely because they encounter error in our history.
01:15:40.069 --> 01:15:43.733
And then we have absolutely no tools to be able to deal with it.
01:15:44.274 --> 01:16:16.301
We look at some kind of statement and say, Most people look at these statements and take them at face value, and again, I think it's really difficult to say that every single racist statement that was made by a church leader up before 1978 has some sort of magical explanation, or didn't really happen, or can somehow be interpreted to not be racist, when the reality is, as President Uchtdorf told us in General Conference, sometimes church leaders have simply made mistakes.
01:16:16.770 --> 01:16:19.292
He did say that in October 2013.
01:16:19.893 --> 01:16:20.474
He said that.
01:16:20.713 --> 01:16:21.715
You're shaking your head.
01:16:21.734 --> 01:16:23.376
He asked...
01:16:25.819 --> 01:16:26.819
Misreading that again.
01:16:26.859 --> 01:16:32.284
President Uchtdorf said that people in leadership positions make mistakes, i.e.
01:16:32.585 --> 01:16:34.046
local leaders can make mistakes.
01:16:34.167 --> 01:16:39.391
He's not saying that the apostles or the prophets made mistakes.
01:16:39.511 --> 01:16:44.596
He's specifically saying that some leaders can make mistakes.
01:16:44.617 --> 01:16:45.457
You have to actually...
01:16:46.018 --> 01:16:50.684
make sure that what you're thinking is the same thing that he's actually tried to convey.
01:16:51.484 --> 01:16:51.864
Okay.
01:16:52.125 --> 01:16:54.528
So, again, we get to this sort of workaround.
01:16:54.568 --> 01:16:57.051
It's not a workaround.
01:16:57.192 --> 01:17:02.677
I mean, to try to take the plain meaning of what somebody says and then try to find some other definition of it.
01:17:03.158 --> 01:17:22.637
So, Marcus, before we go, I want to ask you a series of essentially yes or no questions because we don't have a lot of time and I would love to have you back because I would love to discuss evolution with you, the idea that We have to be young earth creationists, which I am not, which my great-grandfather David O.
01:17:22.658 --> 01:17:23.578
McKay was not.
01:17:24.560 --> 01:17:26.824
Sitting just a few feet away from me is David O.
01:17:26.845 --> 01:17:33.837
McKay's personal copy of Man, His Origin and Destiny, which was written by Joseph Fielding Smith, which is a screed against evolution.
01:17:34.719 --> 01:17:35.439
And David O.
01:17:35.460 --> 01:17:38.845
McKay has all kinds of marginalia there.
01:17:39.042 --> 01:17:41.323
talking about how much he disagreed with them.
01:17:41.425 --> 01:17:48.972
Because even church leaders, I mean, to say that they never make mistakes, you then have to get into the fact that they don't always agree.
01:17:49.713 --> 01:17:53.358
So they can't both be right, so one of them has to be mistaken.
01:17:53.978 --> 01:17:57.381
I mean, this is just sort of fundamentally the way human nature works.
01:17:57.481 --> 01:18:10.212
But the questions I want to ask you, yes or no, did church leaders prior to 1978 teach that black skinned, was the result of a curse.
01:18:12.413 --> 01:18:15.938
Okay, we can get into things like ecruhim, non-ecruhim, models.
01:18:16.097 --> 01:18:17.319
It's a yes or no question.
01:18:18.060 --> 01:18:19.141
It's a yes or no question.
01:18:19.743 --> 01:18:26.050
Did church leaders prior to 1978 teach that black skin was the sign of a curse?
01:18:27.211 --> 01:18:29.373
Okay, Jim, are you going to let me answer or are you going to answer for me?
01:18:30.435 --> 01:18:33.018
We can get into the answer, but it's a yes or no question.
01:18:34.145 --> 01:18:37.168
Jim, you can't tell me how to speak and I'll never be told how to speak.
01:18:37.488 --> 01:18:42.673
We can get into such things as equilibrium, non-equilibrium models, uranium, thorium, lead decay.
01:18:42.694 --> 01:18:44.695
We can get into dendrochronology.
01:18:45.077 --> 01:18:50.322
We can actually get into population bottlenecks in terms of mitochondrial DNA.
01:18:50.341 --> 01:18:57.809
I'm very happy to do that, Jim, because I have a science background and that would do just music for me to actually get into that.
01:18:58.850 --> 01:19:00.591
But I won't be told how to speak, Jim.
01:19:00.671 --> 01:19:09.872
I appreciate that you challenge me in terms of in terms of the quotes from authorities, well, I'll challenge you back and say, give me a quote and I'll interpret it.
01:19:10.193 --> 01:19:17.167
Don't actually say as a generic cause that everything that they say will be a racist
01:19:23.592 --> 01:19:44.690
comment, bring out specific quotes and we'll look at them individually.
01:19:45.391 --> 01:19:46.634
the sky is blue.
01:19:47.395 --> 01:19:49.436
Would you be able to answer that yes or no?
01:19:49.457 --> 01:19:51.800
Is the sky blue?
01:19:54.703 --> 01:19:57.167
Jim, I'll talk in the way that I wish to answer.
01:19:57.347 --> 01:19:57.948
That's fine.
01:19:58.448 --> 01:19:59.369
Is the sky blue?
01:20:00.251 --> 01:20:03.615
Because here's the reason why I'm trying to ask.
01:20:03.636 --> 01:20:11.265
The difficulty that I'm having here is that you and I do not seem to share a common set of facts.
01:20:12.289 --> 01:20:19.538
As a scientist, I'm sure you recognize how necessary it is to have an agreed upon set of facts.
01:20:19.599 --> 01:20:37.420
So if you're sitting there dealing with some kind of rational scientific thesis, and you've got somebody who comes in and says, well, I don't believe gravity is real, you all of a sudden go, well, then we can't really have a discussion because we don't share a common set of facts.
01:20:38.081 --> 01:21:03.033
And so what I'm trying to establish here is that I think it is factually undeniable that prior to 1978 and even after 1978, church materials, church leaders, and yes, presidents of the church, prophets, as well as scriptures, describe black skin as being a sign of a curse.
01:21:03.614 --> 01:21:34.029
And this was taught largely universally, and if you want to say, well, I need to look at every single one so I can figure out some way to work around it, if you don't believe, I'm not going to tell you how to speak because you don't seem to be willing to answer yes or no questions, but if you do not believe that church leaders prior to 1978 taught that black skin was a sign of a curse, then you and I do not share a common set of facts.
01:21:36.354 --> 01:21:36.935
Could you read with
01:21:37.117 --> 01:21:37.217
that?
01:21:38.421 --> 01:21:39.728
Let me answer you again.
01:21:39.747 --> 01:21:41.395
I've already said it previously.
01:21:41.414 --> 01:21:46.033
The cursings and the black skin were not connected.
01:21:46.497 --> 01:21:47.618
That's what you say.
01:21:47.640 --> 01:21:52.826
That is not what church leaders said up until 1978 and even afterward.
01:21:52.865 --> 01:22:04.542
What I'm trying to get you to recognize and acknowledge is a common set of facts, a common reality that this was, in fact, something that the church taught.
01:22:05.143 --> 01:22:16.318
And since you insist that the church leaders never teach anything wrong, you have to find some way to reinterpret plain language.
01:22:17.090 --> 01:22:21.175
in a way that flies in the face of the meaning of the words.
01:22:22.055 --> 01:22:38.198
And once again, it becomes, all right, if you want to talk about some fictional church that did not teach that black skin was the sign of a curse prior to 1978, I'm not the person to talk to because I'd never belonged to that church.
01:22:38.417 --> 01:22:44.466
I grew up in a church where I was taught personally that black people bore the curse of Cain.
01:22:45.185 --> 01:22:49.412
And I was taught that, and I was taught that it was a result of black skin.
01:22:49.492 --> 01:23:06.917
And if you want to pin that on whatever bishop told me that or whatever else told me that, I can come back and tell you that that was taught in my family for generations, a family led by a president of the church who believed that.
01:23:07.394 --> 01:23:16.046
and taught that and signed a statement in 1949 when he was a member of the first presidency that reiterated that.
01:23:16.646 --> 01:23:29.466
So if you're not willing to accept that and then you come back and say, well, I won't talk bad about the church, you're not defending the church when you are trying to create a new church.
01:23:30.082 --> 01:23:38.774
to replace the real one that taught things that we now disavow because we now acknowledge they were wrong.
01:23:38.815 --> 01:23:47.970
And so for you to say you will never criticize the church, you are refusing to stand with the church today.
01:23:48.609 --> 01:24:07.317
When the church disavows explicitly that we taught that black skin was the sign of a curse, that we taught that black people bore the curse of Cain, and if you're not willing to accept that, then maybe we don't have you back because we don't share a common set of facts.
01:24:09.154 --> 01:24:10.936
Jim, it's down to you guys.
01:24:11.037 --> 01:24:13.502
If Ian wants to be back or whatever, that's fine.
01:24:13.921 --> 01:24:15.564
It's an impasse here, Jim.
01:24:15.604 --> 01:24:17.729
At the end of the day, it's not about workarounds.
01:24:17.809 --> 01:24:18.990
We see things differently.
01:24:19.011 --> 01:24:20.774
I disagree with what you're saying.
01:24:20.793 --> 01:24:24.199
I disagree with your rationales and I disagree with your citations.
01:24:25.506 --> 01:24:26.106
But it's
01:24:26.287 --> 01:24:27.889
not a difference of opinion, Marcus.
01:24:28.009 --> 01:24:29.189
It's a difference of fact.
01:24:29.329 --> 01:24:35.438
If you say the sky is green and I say the sky is blue, one of us is right and one of us is wrong.
01:24:35.537 --> 01:24:37.840
It's not an agree to disagree situation.
01:24:38.301 --> 01:24:39.162
The sky is blue.
01:24:39.181 --> 01:24:44.328
And if you don't agree the sky is blue, we can't have a conversation about the sky.
01:24:44.368 --> 01:24:51.115
And if you don't agree that the church taught that black skin was a sign of a curse, you are wrong.
01:24:51.136 --> 01:24:52.858
And I am right.
01:24:53.377 --> 01:24:55.060
And it's not a matter of opinion.
01:24:55.079 --> 01:24:58.685
It is a matter of fundamental fact and reality.
01:24:59.926 --> 01:25:02.570
If you talk over me, Jim, it's not a conversation anymore.
01:25:02.610 --> 01:25:04.654
It's just a monologue, mate, yeah?
01:25:05.095 --> 01:25:05.836
All right, yeah.
01:25:06.896 --> 01:25:13.065
At the end of the day, I appreciate that you see things differently, and I get it, and that your background is different, but...
01:25:13.386 --> 01:25:16.010
I'm done, Ian.
01:25:17.032 --> 01:25:18.033
You can take it from me here.
01:25:18.154 --> 01:25:23.268
I'm still frustrated with the fact that that you're trying to dismiss.
01:25:24.007 --> 01:25:28.313
I mean, you can't look at the sky.
01:25:28.332 --> 01:25:30.595
I keep using the sky because it's the simplest thing.
01:25:31.154 --> 01:25:34.198
But you can't look at saying something, well, agree to disagree.
01:25:34.217 --> 01:25:35.219
I think it's green.
01:25:35.279 --> 01:25:36.000
You think it's blue.
01:25:36.039 --> 01:25:37.421
You come from a different background.
01:25:37.921 --> 01:25:38.682
One of us is right.
01:25:38.882 --> 01:25:39.684
One of us is wrong.
01:25:40.323 --> 01:25:43.927
I'm probably getting heated, and so I probably need to step back.
01:25:44.729 --> 01:25:46.770
So I'll let you finish this up, Ian.
01:25:47.131 --> 01:25:48.551
Thanks very much, Marcus, for your time.
01:25:49.913 --> 01:25:50.333
All right, Jim.
01:25:50.561 --> 01:25:57.296
do you want to just any final comments on this before we close the podcast
01:25:58.399 --> 01:26:15.063
my final comments it's been really interesting and up to the last point there where Jim is getting a bit frustrated I enjoy interacting with him but the bottom line is that is that we have to just continue to discuss things because that's the only way we'll actually make progress is my thoughts.
01:26:15.122 --> 01:26:17.445
And I really like chatting to you, mate, and it's a pleasure.
01:26:17.765 --> 01:26:19.569
And I really enjoy your questions, Ian.
01:26:19.609 --> 01:26:20.730
They're just excellent.
01:26:22.693 --> 01:26:28.701
Just to clarify, you don't, again, for the sake of our listeners, and I appreciate those last comments, I really do.
01:26:30.023 --> 01:26:33.006
You disagree entirely, it sounds like, with what Jim said.
01:26:34.909 --> 01:26:44.412
I disagree with the fact that he's trying to say the church is wrong in certain areas, and I...
01:26:45.113 --> 01:26:49.097
In this area, where the blacks were cursed, you don't accept that?
01:26:50.479 --> 01:26:51.220
Not at all, no.
01:26:51.440 --> 01:26:57.046
No, I don't agree that the black skin was actually apportioned to a person.
01:26:57.447 --> 01:26:59.789
I believe that they are distinct and separate.
01:27:00.270 --> 01:27:02.993
And it's actually very clear in the scriptures that they were, yeah.
01:27:03.713 --> 01:27:04.014
And any
01:27:04.095 --> 01:27:06.917
evidence that suggests otherwise, you just don't accept that?
01:27:07.713 --> 01:27:08.375
from any source.
01:27:09.476 --> 01:27:10.899
Somebody wants to present it to me.
01:27:10.918 --> 01:27:12.320
I'm happy to look at any evidence.
01:27:12.421 --> 01:27:14.725
I always do and have done my whole life.
01:27:14.805 --> 01:27:18.510
And science is something which I'll always re-examine again and again and again.
01:27:18.529 --> 01:27:19.712
I'm happy to see it.
01:27:20.073 --> 01:27:21.494
But Jim's got to be specific.
01:27:21.534 --> 01:27:24.659
He can't just get frustrated and say, I'm not listening.
01:27:24.699 --> 01:27:25.461
But I am listening.
01:27:26.402 --> 01:27:36.811
Yeah, what he was trying to do, and again, I'm trying to be the middle guy here between this conversation, is just ask me some yes or no questions.
01:27:36.851 --> 01:27:38.253
And we couldn't get past that.
01:27:38.554 --> 01:27:42.578
You mentioned, and we'll close here in a minute, you mentioned Elder Uchtdorf's talk in 2013.
01:27:42.597 --> 01:27:46.662
And for me personally, that was a very significant talk.
01:27:46.981 --> 01:27:55.994
When I listened to that in conference, Elder Uchtdorf, and he talked about past leaders who made mistakes, I, like you, thought he was talking about And I've shared this on the podcast.
01:27:56.055 --> 01:28:04.204
I thought he was talking about some rogue local leader, a bishop or state president who made mistakes, as they do, of course.
01:28:04.225 --> 01:28:04.865
You know that.
01:28:04.905 --> 01:28:05.447
I know that.
01:28:05.806 --> 01:28:10.573
I didn't for one second think he extended that to prophets.
01:28:10.993 --> 01:28:29.347
But in my follow-up research and conversations, what I got back from general authorities, I was on the state presence at the time, that that talk did extend to past apostles and prophets, that they made mistakes.
01:28:30.248 --> 01:28:44.988
And so, you know, I believe that prophets can, you don't believe prophets can make mistakes, I think, that they're not allowed to make mistakes or the agency is taken away and they are dictated to or told exactly what they should or shouldn't say.
01:28:45.029 --> 01:28:50.136
You know, they don't make mistakes, especially on this magnitude, like, you know, raising the priesthood, et cetera.
01:28:50.155 --> 01:29:52.458
I, you know, I don't, agree with that or believe that we have a different perspective on that but i think um you know i think this has been uh fascinating i don't think we're going to agree on you know i think if you cover our different topics like you know evolution like you talk about the earth was created 6 000 years ago and the scientific conversation around that i'm environmental sciences so i'd love to have that conversation with you the position of the church on you know lgdb GDPQ etc and the changes that has been happening around that you know the Book of Mormon translation process I'd be fascinated to you know have a conversation with you about that obviously I need to have this conversation with Jim and seeing if that we can go forward but I you know have to you know my position is and I'm saying this not to come down on anyone's side here but I like to look at the spiritual side of things, obviously, but I also like to look at the facts and what do the facts say.
01:29:52.498 --> 01:30:01.751
And I try to get this balanced approach in order to arrive at a conclusion or a position or understanding of things.
01:30:01.850 --> 01:30:05.935
I agree with you that I think this requires further discussion.
01:30:06.516 --> 01:30:16.400
But Jim and I, we've got a perspective on things and we wanted to get some clarity around these topics.
01:30:16.461 --> 01:30:24.113
And I appreciate you've got the scientific approach, but the facts, I don't think we're going to agree on some of the facts.
01:30:24.394 --> 01:30:28.239
And that's just the way it is.
01:30:28.900 --> 01:30:35.250
So I'll speak to Jim about whether or not we want to have another conversation with you and then come back to you.
01:30:35.270 --> 01:30:38.494
But I really appreciate you coming on and talking about these things.
01:30:39.256 --> 01:30:40.198
I think it's fascinating.
01:30:40.609 --> 01:30:45.698
Um, on a personal note, I want to express my love and appreciation to you.
01:30:46.340 --> 01:30:50.306
You know, you came into my life at a time when I was very unhappy.
01:30:50.327 --> 01:31:08.507
I was desperately unhappy and I felt alone and, and, um, very vulnerable, uh, young teenager and your, uh, um, influence in my life and Ellis Arthur was profound and continues to be profound.
01:31:08.768 --> 01:31:10.449
The church saved my life.
01:31:10.569 --> 01:31:17.356
I've talked about it on the podcast and I'm deeply grateful for my experience in the church and it influences my life even now.
01:31:18.037 --> 01:31:27.948
So on a personal note, I just want to say how grateful I am to you for who you are and the commitment and service that you've given and dedicated to the Lord and to the church.
01:31:29.314 --> 01:31:38.284
I think, you know, doctrinally, historically, policy-wise, I think we're going to have a, it'd be fascinating to get your perspective on those things for sure.
01:31:40.247 --> 01:31:41.788
So I just want to thank you for that.
01:31:41.889 --> 01:31:44.112
Any final thoughts or comments before we close?
01:31:45.993 --> 01:31:51.240
Yeah, Ian, you're a really good guy and I've liked listening to your podcast and I think Jim is a good guy.
01:31:51.280 --> 01:31:54.465
I think he's got lots of potential to explore different areas.
01:31:55.786 --> 01:31:58.649
I actually prefer your style because I think you're a lot calmer.
01:31:59.137 --> 01:32:03.002
And so I understand that Jim gets frustrated at times.
01:32:03.082 --> 01:32:06.284
And that's like, we're all a little bit different.
01:32:07.447 --> 01:32:10.729
I think we could go in all sorts of directions and have really good conversations.
01:32:11.371 --> 01:32:15.014
But at the end of the day, we have to realize that sometimes there are impasses.
01:32:15.054 --> 01:32:17.856
And when you reach an impasse, you just need to move on to a different
01:32:17.936 --> 01:32:18.318
topic.
01:32:19.319 --> 01:32:20.720
And I think that's a valid point.
01:32:20.739 --> 01:32:21.541
I think we're going to do here.
01:32:22.042 --> 01:32:23.483
So Marcus, thank you again.
01:32:23.523 --> 01:32:24.864
It's so great to see you.
01:32:24.925 --> 01:32:26.086
Give my love to your family.
01:32:26.753 --> 01:32:28.536
It's wonderful to connect with you.
01:32:28.555 --> 01:32:30.478
I hope we can keep connecting.
01:32:30.618 --> 01:32:34.101
And then when I come over to the UK, maybe we can get together.
01:32:34.122 --> 01:32:34.962
It'd be great to see you.
01:32:35.524 --> 01:32:39.127
It's been a long time since you and I worked together in person.
01:32:39.148 --> 01:32:39.747
I would love that.
01:32:40.488 --> 01:32:41.831
I plan to come over in the summertime.
01:32:41.970 --> 01:32:46.555
But thank you again for taking the time to be with us today.
01:32:48.318 --> 01:32:48.939
Jim, thank you.
01:32:48.979 --> 01:32:50.500
You've just left us there.
01:32:50.881 --> 01:32:51.962
Thank you for your contribution.
01:32:52.462 --> 01:32:55.426
And to our listeners, thank you for being here with us.
01:32:56.033 --> 01:33:01.324
and for your interest in the Inside Out podcast.
01:33:01.465 --> 01:33:04.371
Until next time, we wish you all well.
01:33:04.771 --> 01:33:08.921
And Marcus, thank you again for this very lively and robust conversation.
01:33:09.081 --> 01:33:09.381
Thank you.
01:33:10.744 --> 01:33:13.310
Cheers, matey.
00:00:01.217 --> 00:00:22.420
Welcome to the latest episode of Inside Out, the only true and living podcast upon the face of the earth, speaking collectively and not individually.
00:00:23.222 --> 00:00:29.528
My name is Ian Wilkes, and as always, I'm here with my partner, the indisputable Mr.
00:00:29.789 --> 00:00:30.750
Jim Bennett.
00:00:31.138 --> 00:00:32.360
There's no disputing it.
00:00:32.401 --> 00:00:33.101
That's me.
00:00:34.183 --> 00:00:47.572
And every time you say that, when you say that this is the only true podcast collectively and not individually, I have to recognize that there are only two individuals who are in this podcast on a regular basis.
00:00:48.293 --> 00:00:52.021
So one of us may or may not be true.
00:00:52.353 --> 00:00:54.735
But if I'm indisputable, that may be you.
00:00:54.957 --> 00:00:57.118
That may be a problem you have to wrestle with here.
00:00:57.838 --> 00:00:57.939
It's
00:00:57.960 --> 00:01:00.462
something that I have to wrap my thinking around.
00:01:00.521 --> 00:01:03.844
Yeah, I think you're the truest person on the truest podcasts.
00:01:04.365 --> 00:01:05.106
Well, there we go.
00:01:05.126 --> 00:01:06.287
There we go.
00:01:06.748 --> 00:01:15.156
And so today, Jim, we have a very special guest indeed, and someone that is very dear to me and very special to me.
00:01:15.197 --> 00:01:19.361
We have here today Marcus Hooper, all the way from...
00:01:20.706 --> 00:01:21.085
England.
00:01:21.427 --> 00:01:22.227
Marcus, welcome.
00:01:23.650 --> 00:01:23.909
Hiya.
00:01:26.873 --> 00:01:30.018
That's a very good response.
00:01:30.058 --> 00:01:30.397
That's fine.
00:01:30.438 --> 00:01:33.762
You can keep that response like that.
00:01:33.843 --> 00:01:35.123
I think that's great.
00:01:35.704 --> 00:01:38.567
And so, Marcus, I don't know you.
00:01:38.629 --> 00:01:45.918
When I speak to you and when I communicate with you, I don't automatically, immediately think of you as Marcus.
00:01:46.177 --> 00:01:47.939
To me, you are Elder Hutber.
00:01:49.001 --> 00:01:54.540
And My relationship with you is very unique and very distinct and very precious to me.
00:01:54.682 --> 00:02:18.198
So I know Elder Hutbert because back in the 80s, Elder Hutbert was the missionary, along with Elder Southwick, I think it was, who found me and tracked me up as a full-time missionary serving in the England Leads Mission from, what, 82 to 83, I think it was, or thereabouts.
00:02:19.746 --> 00:02:22.250
Yeah, for me, it was 81 to 83, Ian.
00:02:22.310 --> 00:02:22.931
That's right,
00:02:23.230 --> 00:02:23.311
yeah.
00:02:23.330 --> 00:02:23.872
Okay, okay.
00:02:24.372 --> 00:02:31.342
And so this was a council house estate, which I'd spoken to about earlier on the podcast.
00:02:32.223 --> 00:02:34.186
An interesting place for sure.
00:02:34.347 --> 00:02:45.042
And Marcus, Elder Hubbert and Elder Southwick, tracked me up and actually taught me the discussions back in the early 80s.
00:02:46.022 --> 00:02:47.725
And so that was a very...
00:02:48.066 --> 00:02:50.248
in my life, very significant time in my life.
00:02:51.050 --> 00:02:56.899
And Marcus shaped my life and informed my thinking significantly back then.
00:02:56.938 --> 00:03:01.626
And he's somebody that I have a great deal of love and respect for.
00:03:02.167 --> 00:03:05.031
And I've spoken a little bit about this on the podcast.
00:03:05.551 --> 00:03:08.036
So our relationship, Marcus, goes back a long way.
00:03:08.075 --> 00:03:16.707
And I think it would be appropriate if you could share your thoughts a little bit about that experience.
00:03:16.788 --> 00:03:25.341
And then after that, if you can give us a little bit of a broader, more general introduction about yourself, maybe your family, if you're comfortable, and a little bit about your background in the church.
00:03:25.401 --> 00:03:27.364
I think you were raised in the church, you grew up in the church.
00:03:27.965 --> 00:03:31.751
And a little bit about your, just kind of your overall experience in the gospel and in the church.
00:03:32.431 --> 00:03:43.808
And I think a key event in your life, of course, certainly from my perspective, but a key event in your life, period in your life, was obviously serving as a full-time missionary in England Leeds Mission.
00:03:44.330 --> 00:03:46.013
So if you can speak a little bit about that.
00:03:47.169 --> 00:04:09.550
without sharing too much about how, uh, notorious I was, uh, and cheeky I was back then, you know, as a, as a teenager, um, as a disclaimer, what I did back then, I was, you know, a teenager and I didn't, I didn't know all the rules, but if you can speak about that experience and then give it, move into an introduction, that would be great.
00:04:10.712 --> 00:04:11.272
Yeah, sure.
00:04:11.854 --> 00:04:15.437
Ian, you were always a very, very intelligent kid, very much so.
00:04:15.576 --> 00:04:17.499
And, um, Flying Spuds.
00:04:17.839 --> 00:04:29.677
When I first met you, mate, I was actually leaning over to tie up my shoelaces and a very large D-sized battery comes whizzing past my head on the left-hand side.
00:04:30.699 --> 00:04:36.026
And I look up and there's this kid grinning at me and I think, I got to talk to this kid.
00:04:36.067 --> 00:04:37.288
This is kind of interesting.
00:04:37.949 --> 00:04:38.951
So, wow.
00:04:39.552 --> 00:04:42.896
Now, I've listened to your podcast and I've listened to them with great interest.
00:04:42.956 --> 00:04:43.858
I really have, guys.
00:04:43.937 --> 00:04:47.511
I've listened to them and they're very varied and they're very They're very fascinating.
00:04:48.312 --> 00:04:54.279
Some of them are a little bit different, but some of the people I listen to are a little bit different than I expected, which is, again, interesting.
00:04:54.940 --> 00:04:57.564
But I've listened to them, and they have been fascinating.
00:04:58.125 --> 00:05:05.954
Now, going through it, you bring up all sorts of topics which are really curious.
00:05:06.656 --> 00:05:11.622
Now, you were a smart young chap.
00:05:12.161 --> 00:05:17.350
And I don't remember the girl that you came along to see when we were teaching you.
00:05:17.389 --> 00:05:22.177
I don't actually remember teaching that girl, but it must have been the girl because that's why you came.
00:05:22.197 --> 00:05:23.360
So that was kind of curious.
00:05:23.841 --> 00:05:27.487
But anyway, what I do remember is I do remember the baptismal challenge, Ian.
00:05:27.526 --> 00:05:43.538
Now, that baptismal challenge actually became quite infamous because it was my turn and I actually gave the baptismal challenge and I gave it to you And you sat there, and you looked a little bit perplexed, and I was kind of interested.
00:05:43.579 --> 00:05:45.843
And you didn't say something for a while.
00:05:45.862 --> 00:05:48.766
And out of self, it was about to say something.
00:05:48.807 --> 00:05:51.411
And I looked over him, and I kind of gave him a bit of a stare.
00:05:51.851 --> 00:05:52.773
So he backed off.
00:05:53.394 --> 00:05:56.639
And then I looked back at you, and it was happening.
00:05:56.678 --> 00:05:59.523
And I was thinking, okay, what's the reply?
00:05:59.543 --> 00:06:00.363
It's either yes or no.
00:06:00.403 --> 00:06:01.887
Come on, just tell us what it is.
00:06:01.966 --> 00:06:02.668
It's probably going to be no.
00:06:02.687 --> 00:06:03.189
It doesn't matter.
00:06:03.228 --> 00:06:04.009
Let's just have it.
00:06:04.810 --> 00:06:06.613
And then you still didn't reply.
00:06:07.362 --> 00:06:12.086
And it went on for a while, and it went on for a while, and it went on for a while, and it kept going.
00:06:12.166 --> 00:06:16.711
And at the end, when you finally said yes, I thought, you can't say yes.
00:06:16.771 --> 00:06:17.612
That's not how it goes.
00:06:17.653 --> 00:06:18.293
You've been so long.
00:06:18.314 --> 00:06:19.274
You've got to say no.
00:06:19.295 --> 00:06:21.958
And they've got to give you loads of reasons why it's no.
00:06:21.997 --> 00:06:23.519
How can it be yes?
00:06:23.560 --> 00:06:24.641
That's just crazy.
00:06:24.680 --> 00:06:30.528
So I'm thinking, and I looked at Southwick, and Southwick just kind of gave a blank expression.
00:06:30.567 --> 00:06:32.709
And we're thinking, this is crazy.
00:06:32.730 --> 00:06:42.502
And then what happened is it went around the mission that Hutpa, had given a three-hour baptismal challenge and hadn't said anything for three hours.
00:06:42.543 --> 00:06:45.387
We could use, you know, all these things become kind of inflated.
00:06:45.987 --> 00:07:01.509
But I do remember going to Eva, to your mum, and saying to her, look, you know, we're kind of teaching your son and he's a really decent chap and we'd like to...
00:07:03.394 --> 00:07:04.995
We'd like to baptize him.
00:07:05.076 --> 00:07:09.341
And I can remember your mum actually being not very keen on the idea.
00:07:09.401 --> 00:07:15.290
So I said, well, look, you know, look, Eva, this is just going to improve his life.
00:07:15.310 --> 00:07:16.271
It's just going to help him.
00:07:16.310 --> 00:07:22.680
He'll learn stuff from here, which will enable him to do all sorts of things in life.
00:07:22.759 --> 00:07:24.221
It will be really good for him.
00:07:24.322 --> 00:07:29.629
And so she said to me, came back a couple of times.
00:07:29.730 --> 00:07:35.172
And then when we came back, she finally said that, that she would give permission.
00:07:35.211 --> 00:07:41.440
Now, what I didn't know, Ian, at the time, was that she would turf you out of the house.
00:07:41.761 --> 00:07:46.266
And when I heard Flying Spuds, I thought, what the Flying Spuds is going down here?
00:07:46.286 --> 00:07:52.334
And then Linda Cavell was fantastic, and Jenny Johnson were fantastic, and they really helped you.
00:07:52.355 --> 00:07:56.060
And then the bishop, I think, in Wakefield, wasn't it, who really helped you?
00:07:56.940 --> 00:08:00.245
Just to the light, Ian, it was just a pleasure.
00:08:00.286 --> 00:08:06.605
And then I watched you over the years, oh, what you've achieved and what you've done is just fantastic.
00:08:07.805 --> 00:08:10.249
You know, you've done so much and it's just a pleasure.
00:08:10.269 --> 00:08:13.552
And all those certificates on your wall there, they're just great.
00:08:13.593 --> 00:08:14.553
That just sums you up.
00:08:14.613 --> 00:08:19.819
And it's just so much, it's just been such a pleasure to watch your life develop.
00:08:19.858 --> 00:08:28.968
Now, what was kind of curious was that I actually was posted up to Durham and I think it was around Sacristo I was tracked in.
00:08:29.569 --> 00:08:31.711
Yours, yeah.
00:08:31.891 --> 00:08:32.033
Yeah.
00:08:32.472 --> 00:08:35.106
And I heard, And there was some kids around.
00:08:35.148 --> 00:08:36.349
I think it's me and Elder Daniels.
00:08:36.389 --> 00:08:37.269
And there was some kids around.
00:08:37.289 --> 00:08:39.312
And I heard the voice, Mark has called out.
00:08:39.812 --> 00:08:41.413
Now, when you're on a mission, it's just Elder.
00:08:41.474 --> 00:08:42.414
Everybody's called Elder.
00:08:42.475 --> 00:08:43.336
And people say, well, hold on.
00:08:43.395 --> 00:08:44.576
Why have you all got the same Christian name?
00:08:44.616 --> 00:08:48.260
But anyway, I said to Elder Daniels, hold on.
00:08:48.321 --> 00:08:51.624
One of these kids has got my Christian name.
00:08:51.683 --> 00:08:52.585
And I heard the name again.
00:08:52.605 --> 00:08:54.647
I heard someone call out my name.
00:08:54.726 --> 00:08:56.149
And I thought, hold on, Ed.
00:08:56.168 --> 00:08:57.649
One of these kids really has got my name.
00:08:57.669 --> 00:08:59.091
And I thought, this is unusual.
00:08:59.172 --> 00:09:03.897
And then when it happened the third time, I thought, hold on, I've got to look around.
00:09:03.996 --> 00:09:12.967
So I looked around and there was Eva, your mum, standing in her front door looking at me and just grinning.
00:09:13.008 --> 00:09:21.758
And I walked up and she said, look, you never told me about your church.
00:09:22.519 --> 00:09:28.105
I'd like to hear what you've got to say, but let me make it absolutely crystal clear.
00:09:28.145 --> 00:09:31.070
I'm not joining and neither is Michael.
00:09:31.682 --> 00:09:33.943
And then a few weeks later they were baptized.
00:09:34.004 --> 00:09:38.548
So, yeah, just your mum was, I never had a problem with her.
00:09:38.668 --> 00:09:43.953
I knew that she was very feisty, but my mum was quite feisty as well.
00:09:44.374 --> 00:09:51.961
In fact, I was six when the mysteries came around to my house and my mother was quite feisty.
00:09:52.000 --> 00:09:55.083
So we kind of share that, but they were both really well-meaning.
00:09:55.144 --> 00:09:58.927
So I never had a problem with your mum because my mum was exactly the same.
00:10:00.229 --> 00:10:07.538
And in fact, I have, On Thursday nights, I have a family home evening with the two guys who taught me the gospel and baptized me every Thursday.
00:10:07.578 --> 00:10:08.541
So that's a pleasure.
00:10:08.600 --> 00:10:10.062
One of them lives in...
00:10:11.826 --> 00:10:17.914
He's just moved down from Payson in Utah, and he lives in Overton in Nevada.
00:10:18.316 --> 00:10:19.256
And the other chap lives in St.
00:10:19.298 --> 00:10:19.697
George.
00:10:20.479 --> 00:10:23.384
A couple of totally really excellent chaps.
00:10:23.904 --> 00:10:27.750
But when I was young, I actually had loads of questions.
00:10:27.951 --> 00:10:29.633
That's why I really enjoy...
00:10:30.145 --> 00:10:34.429
listen to your podcast because they actually raise loads of questions.
00:10:35.530 --> 00:10:37.493
And I used to read books.
00:10:37.552 --> 00:10:41.557
I used to read things like Science of Modernism, Coming of the Lord, Book of Jasher.
00:10:41.596 --> 00:10:43.197
Book of Jasher is a fantastic book.
00:10:43.678 --> 00:10:45.159
Tempting Cosmos by Nibley.
00:10:45.681 --> 00:10:47.022
Just love these books.
00:10:47.863 --> 00:10:53.668
And I got to wondering about stuff and I actually was curious.
00:10:53.727 --> 00:11:07.528
I mean, for me, guys, the Big Bang is a nice idea, but it doesn't actually give any answers because If the Big Bang is actually just sitting and expanding, what sits outside the Big Bang?
00:11:08.990 --> 00:11:09.431
A void?
00:11:11.072 --> 00:11:14.337
But Billy Smith says that where there is space, there is matter.
00:11:14.658 --> 00:11:20.306
You look in D&C 8837 and 131.7, it talks about where there is matter in every kingdom.
00:11:21.067 --> 00:11:28.758
And so for me, that idea that you have an extension of dimensions continuing forever is really curious.
00:11:29.090 --> 00:11:30.672
And I really love that idea.
00:11:30.692 --> 00:11:34.697
And so for me, the big bang is just postponing the question.
00:11:34.899 --> 00:11:36.400
It's not given an answer at all.
00:11:37.241 --> 00:11:47.397
Now, what I love is I love the idea that, in fact, you have dark matter, which is 95% of the universe, and you have gravitational matter, which is 5% of the universe.
00:11:48.217 --> 00:11:55.970
And so for me, that fits really lovely, in a really lovely way, where the celestial and terrestrial kingdoms are encompassed by dark matter.
00:11:57.091 --> 00:11:58.533
Sorry, they are dark matter.
00:11:59.649 --> 00:12:06.177
5% of the universe is the telestial kingdom, which is the gravitational matter, and it fits really nicely.
00:12:06.298 --> 00:12:26.663
Now, I actually wonder how dimensions can actually sit on top of each other, and for me, I always looked at physics, was fascinated by it, because in physics, if my house was the nucleus of an atom, the electron which bounds the atom would be over in Winchester, which is quite a distance away.
00:12:27.384 --> 00:12:29.265
So, for me, matter...
00:12:29.666 --> 00:12:34.251
most of matter is empty space, which means that dimensions can sit on top of each other.
00:12:34.812 --> 00:12:37.895
So therefore, we know that the spirit world is around us.
00:12:38.596 --> 00:12:40.278
We know that from near-death experiences.
00:12:40.339 --> 00:12:43.302
And Ian, I loved your near-death experience that you described.
00:12:43.942 --> 00:12:53.355
And as you described your near-death experience, Ian, you actually related, are these just neurons firing off?
00:12:54.076 --> 00:12:57.921
Are these just chemical reactions that I'm actually having here?
00:12:57.961 --> 00:13:02.110
And then a little way later, A bit later, you say, no, I actually experienced that.
00:13:02.731 --> 00:13:09.722
Now, this is a bit of an aside here, but for me, guys, there are list A and list B experiences.
00:13:09.783 --> 00:13:17.996
List B experiences, I've got 400 of them that I've collected, and over 16 years on the high count, so I went around to different wards, and I'd actually give list B experience.
00:13:18.037 --> 00:13:19.057
What's a list B experience?
00:13:19.097 --> 00:13:22.624
List B experience is one that you have to have faith to...
00:13:26.690 --> 00:13:29.232
understand it or to actually go along with it.
00:13:29.293 --> 00:13:30.793
Let me give you a little experience.
00:13:30.813 --> 00:13:38.763
So I came home one day and my wife said, my engagement ring lost the diamond in it.
00:13:39.323 --> 00:13:41.024
Oh, that's not really good, dear.
00:13:41.446 --> 00:13:44.109
She said, yeah, but you're going to find it.
00:13:44.269 --> 00:13:44.769
Goodbye.
00:13:44.809 --> 00:13:45.309
I'm off.
00:13:45.389 --> 00:13:46.530
And she ran off upstairs.
00:13:46.991 --> 00:13:47.613
I thought, what?
00:13:48.994 --> 00:13:49.554
No, I'm not.
00:13:49.615 --> 00:13:50.475
That's ridiculous.
00:13:50.716 --> 00:13:52.658
Anyway, she called down from the stairs.
00:13:52.717 --> 00:13:53.298
Yes, you are.
00:13:53.418 --> 00:13:54.019
Pray about it.
00:13:54.120 --> 00:13:54.620
Goodbye.
00:13:54.779 --> 00:13:55.421
Slammed the door.
00:13:55.760 --> 00:13:56.302
I thought, what?
00:13:56.833 --> 00:14:00.558
So I thought, all right, then I'll do the religious bin.
00:14:00.620 --> 00:14:01.581
I'll do the prayer bit.
00:14:02.282 --> 00:14:04.926
And I said, okay, you know, give the hand.
00:14:04.946 --> 00:14:06.248
Well, your hand's put me a bit of a spot.
00:14:06.307 --> 00:14:07.429
Could you give me a bit of a hand?
00:14:07.450 --> 00:14:09.432
So I had the feeling, go through the rubbish bin.
00:14:09.452 --> 00:14:11.034
Go through the rubbish bin?
00:14:11.095 --> 00:14:12.437
What do you mean go through the rubbish bin?
00:14:12.517 --> 00:14:15.000
All right, fine, I'll go through the rubbish bin.
00:14:15.020 --> 00:14:17.403
I couldn't find any gloves, so I shoved my hand in the rubbish bin.
00:14:17.443 --> 00:14:18.125
I'm going through it.
00:14:18.666 --> 00:14:23.592
I pulled it out three times and emptied it, put it back in again, and my hands were absolutely filthy.
00:14:23.633 --> 00:14:27.934
And when I put it in the last time, I had the feeling, It's not in here.
00:14:27.955 --> 00:14:29.456
I thought, what do you mean?
00:14:29.576 --> 00:14:30.678
What do you mean it's not in here?
00:14:30.719 --> 00:14:31.679
Don't be ridiculous.
00:14:31.740 --> 00:14:33.142
I just got through the rubbish bin.
00:14:33.542 --> 00:14:38.248
And in fact, my son, who'd actually been listening to all this, had the same feeling.
00:14:38.307 --> 00:14:40.870
And he actually refused to go through the rubbish bin with me.
00:14:42.373 --> 00:14:45.716
So I thought, right, I'm not listening to any more promptings at all.
00:14:45.756 --> 00:14:46.197
I had enough.
00:14:46.477 --> 00:14:46.857
I'm off.
00:14:47.077 --> 00:14:50.322
And I actually shoved off to the downstairs toilet.
00:14:50.543 --> 00:14:56.470
And there, underneath the sink, as I'm about to wash my hands, is the diamond to Helen's ring.
00:14:56.833 --> 00:15:01.000
Can you imagine a guy on the other side here having fun with Hutba, this idiot Hutba?
00:15:01.200 --> 00:15:04.524
How can we get this moron to actually go to the sink and wash his hands?
00:15:04.705 --> 00:15:06.366
I'd have to get him to go through the rubbish bin.
00:15:06.967 --> 00:15:17.542
So look, but this requires faith because when I told this story to a relative, and I won't mention my sister's name, but when I said it to her, she said, oh, it's just coincidence.
00:15:17.601 --> 00:15:20.947
And I thought, okay, I won't bother telling any more stories then, fair enough.
00:15:20.986 --> 00:15:27.221
So list B experiences require faith, but list A experiences require don't.
00:15:29.125 --> 00:15:31.206
Yeah, go on, Ian.
00:15:31.888 --> 00:15:32.087
Sorry,
00:15:32.128 --> 00:15:32.488
go ahead.
00:15:32.509 --> 00:15:32.889
You continue.
00:15:32.908 --> 00:15:33.789
I have a question, but go ahead.
00:15:33.830 --> 00:15:34.169
Continue.
00:15:38.095 --> 00:15:42.799
All I was going to say was that list A experiences do not require faith.
00:15:42.921 --> 00:15:44.842
And I've had probably four or five of those.
00:15:44.863 --> 00:15:48.346
And list A experiences I will not discuss.
00:15:49.548 --> 00:15:57.174
Experiences I will say from the pulpit or from anywhere, but I would happily discuss Any of the 400 lists that be experienced I've had.
00:15:57.375 --> 00:15:58.035
Sorry, what were you going to say?
00:15:58.657 --> 00:16:01.221
Yeah, no, this is, this is, uh, this is interesting.
00:16:01.903 --> 00:16:11.000
Um, and a really important segue into a topic that Jim and I have explored quite a bit, uh, to some extent.
00:16:11.500 --> 00:16:18.192
And I remember having a conversation with Hans Mattson on the podcast with Jim, and I think you've listened to that podcast.
00:16:18.977 --> 00:16:32.298
And we spoke to Hans Massen on that podcast about his perspective on revelation and the concept or the principle of the Lord intervening in very personal ways.
00:16:32.879 --> 00:16:45.179
I mean, I think that the point I'm trying to get to is that the Lord and the Spirit was involved in your prayers and your faith to find a lost diamond.
00:16:45.220 --> 00:16:46.461
So very personal.
00:16:47.105 --> 00:17:45.803
personal very involved in that you know and specifically telling you not to look in in a place because it was somewhere else etc so the lord intervening in that process and then the the questions that we get and we talked about this with hans mattson is does that principle apply to other things far more important than finding a lost diamond does the lord get involved in other more serious it's a question that I've been asked many times in the church and not in the church now but post church about where and when and how does the Lord intervene and the different responses where people say well you know why did the Lord allow my child to die or why didn't the Lord respond to my faith and prayers when you know I was sick or someone passed away we had a blessing And they passed away.
00:17:46.143 --> 00:17:49.909
And where was the Lord in those losses, in those experiences?
00:17:50.549 --> 00:17:54.096
And then the response that they often get is, well, that's what the Lord intended.
00:17:54.135 --> 00:17:58.643
That was the plan all along, that the Lord hadn't planned to save the individual.
00:17:59.203 --> 00:18:06.815
Or maybe they felt that the Lord wasn't involved in the same way that he was involved in finding a lost diamond.
00:18:07.676 --> 00:18:17.162
When you hear that, and again, I'm sharing this Feedback I've had on a personal level as I've been a leader in the church and also people come to me as a friend.
00:18:17.521 --> 00:18:30.779
How do you reconcile the principle of the Lord intervening with you, for example, finding a lost diamond versus people feeling that the Lord hasn't intervened or feel at times forsaken from him?
00:18:30.839 --> 00:18:35.185
Because the brethren have talked about this in conference, you know, about having faith, et cetera.
00:18:35.426 --> 00:18:38.851
How do you reconcile the two points there?
00:18:38.891 --> 00:18:40.673
Something really serious, like a life...
00:18:41.442 --> 00:18:51.615
law doesn't intervene or doesn't appear to intervene from people's experiences versus the intervention to find the lost diamond
00:18:53.176 --> 00:19:15.116
okay okay it's a really good question and I really appreciate it okay I've got to be careful here because I might lose it so I've got to be really careful here but in the position where I am right now is where my wife died And it was the right time for her.
00:19:15.176 --> 00:19:15.917
She had a blessing.
00:19:17.319 --> 00:19:21.246
And in fact, she had the blessing in the position where I am right now.
00:19:21.266 --> 00:19:23.628
I've got us a tea here, but there was a bed here.
00:19:23.648 --> 00:19:33.063
And the blessing said that in the pre-existence, that we agreed as a family that she would go at this time.
00:19:33.083 --> 00:19:35.426
At that time, not this time, obviously.
00:19:37.108 --> 00:19:37.369
So...
00:19:41.089 --> 00:19:42.171
Let me share something else.
00:19:43.451 --> 00:19:47.215
She actually talked to a guy who was an atheist.
00:19:48.096 --> 00:19:50.960
And I met this chap a little while after Helen had passed.
00:19:52.080 --> 00:20:02.351
And he said to me, as Helen was dying, she would have known that there was no afterlife and she would have realized that she was dying, that she was going into oblivion.
00:20:02.391 --> 00:20:08.798
And I was thinking, I was thinking all sorts of things that I might do.
00:20:09.250 --> 00:20:11.093
but I didn't, and I withheld myself.
00:20:11.713 --> 00:20:13.195
Now, let me tell you what really happened.
00:20:14.618 --> 00:20:20.587
Helen had been in a coma for two weeks, and she hadn't moved.
00:20:24.595 --> 00:20:30.403
And then she moved her arm, and I thought, wow, hold on here.
00:20:31.025 --> 00:20:34.130
This is kind of incredible.
00:20:35.298 --> 00:20:37.840
And she'd always wanted to talk to me.
00:20:37.881 --> 00:20:40.904
I'd been out for a walk to take the dogs out.
00:20:41.144 --> 00:20:45.250
And when I was out for 20 minutes and she phoned me four times because she needed to speak to me.
00:20:46.010 --> 00:20:50.436
Anyway, so I looked at her and I said, are you in pain, dear?
00:20:50.737 --> 00:20:53.500
And she didn't acknowledge me whatsoever.
00:20:53.520 --> 00:20:54.602
This was just before she died.
00:20:54.642 --> 00:20:57.566
She died on the 25th of November at 1.42, 2017.
00:20:59.307 --> 00:21:04.233
And she looked...
00:21:05.506 --> 00:21:11.154
passed me over to the mantelpiece that I'm actually looking at now.
00:21:12.297 --> 00:21:14.539
And she scanned her eyes from left to right.
00:21:14.700 --> 00:21:16.502
It was about a six to eight foot area.
00:21:17.644 --> 00:21:19.207
Left to right, right to left.
00:21:19.488 --> 00:21:21.550
And she did that two minutes.
00:21:22.432 --> 00:21:29.103
And her breathing went down from once every 10 seconds, once every 20 seconds, once every 30 seconds.
00:21:30.786 --> 00:21:42.759
And she didn't hear me or actually hear acknowledged me, although she always wanted to talk to me, and then she gave a last breath and she passed.
00:21:42.940 --> 00:21:44.020
She was looking at something.
00:21:44.761 --> 00:21:50.568
Now, I don't know what she was looking at, but I'm sorry, that atheist was wrong.
00:21:51.750 --> 00:21:54.051
She saw something when she was going.
00:21:55.854 --> 00:22:00.900
Now, I'm not going to share with you my list of experiences, but I will tell you this.
00:22:01.941 --> 00:22:04.208
I know there is another dimension.
00:22:05.409 --> 00:22:06.391
I don't have to have fate.
00:22:06.590 --> 00:22:08.313
I know there is another dimension.
00:22:10.195 --> 00:22:15.303
And what I know is very specific to me and it is my list A experiences.
00:22:16.625 --> 00:22:21.652
And I know that there are people in another dimension who interact with this dimension, guys.
00:22:23.855 --> 00:22:28.221
So in answer to your question, why do people go?
00:22:28.320 --> 00:22:30.683
Because basically it's their time.
00:22:30.703 --> 00:22:31.925
It was Helen's time.
00:22:32.481 --> 00:22:34.344
Why do bad things happen to people?
00:22:35.005 --> 00:22:38.469
Because it's not Heavenly Father doing it.
00:22:38.789 --> 00:22:41.031
It's basically it's chance doing it.
00:22:41.512 --> 00:22:45.116
Heavenly Father had the chance to actually save people from really bad things.
00:22:46.219 --> 00:22:47.861
And he has the opportunity not to.
00:22:47.901 --> 00:22:50.063
And if he actually decides, well, look, this guy's had enough.
00:22:50.463 --> 00:22:51.605
He's been through enough pain.
00:22:51.644 --> 00:22:53.207
He's been through enough hassle in his life.
00:22:54.048 --> 00:22:57.251
He's been politically assassinated.
00:22:57.913 --> 00:23:00.556
So everybody actually goes through different things.
00:23:00.615 --> 00:23:01.636
We all have different things.
00:23:03.201 --> 00:23:07.326
So when people have had enough, Heavenly Father says, okay, let's bring them back.
00:23:07.606 --> 00:23:08.126
They've had enough.
00:23:08.188 --> 00:23:08.928
Let's bring them back.
00:23:09.388 --> 00:23:12.772
So he doesn't stop certain things happening.
00:23:13.353 --> 00:23:15.075
He actually intervenes when it's necessary.
00:23:15.194 --> 00:23:17.116
He doesn't intervene when it's not necessary.
00:23:17.718 --> 00:23:22.343
So an answer to your question is Heavenly Father allows chance to take its course.
00:23:22.784 --> 00:23:26.127
But when he decides that something needs changing, he'll change that course.
00:23:26.748 --> 00:23:27.409
That's how he does.
00:23:28.109 --> 00:23:28.349
Yeah.
00:23:29.089 --> 00:23:30.250
Yeah, no, I appreciate that.
00:23:30.330 --> 00:23:31.472
I want to bring Jim in here.
00:23:31.772 --> 00:23:40.844
And then just going forward, we've got a few questions that we're going to ask you in terms of doctrine and want to talk about some of those topics that you and I shared back and forward, if you may.
00:23:40.884 --> 00:23:48.373
But Jim, when you hear that, you know, because that's such a very significant part of, you know, a religious and spiritual experience, right?
00:23:48.472 --> 00:23:49.994
They're very different experiences.
00:23:50.474 --> 00:23:53.337
What are your thoughts on that, listening to Marcus?
00:23:53.398 --> 00:23:56.382
What's your perspective on that?
00:23:56.834 --> 00:24:03.804
on that dimension, but also how the Lord, based on that, how he intervenes and doesn't intervene?
00:24:05.366 --> 00:24:12.457
Oh, that's a question that has bedeviled philosophers for millennia.
00:24:12.478 --> 00:24:16.303
This is the theodicy question.
00:24:16.343 --> 00:24:18.046
Why do bad things happen to good people?
00:24:19.106 --> 00:24:21.371
Why doesn't the Lord intervene in certain spots?
00:24:21.691 --> 00:24:29.531
We've had instances in our family where there was a time after my daughter was injured.
00:24:29.813 --> 00:24:37.762
My daughter was injured at the age of 14 in a skiing accident that left her paralyzed from the waist down, at least partially paralyzed from the waist down.
00:24:39.044 --> 00:24:49.778
And I used to just get enraged, really, when I would hear these sort of miraculous healing stories.
00:24:50.849 --> 00:24:54.534
that were, see, isn't God good and isn't God wonderful?
00:24:54.614 --> 00:24:57.195
He's healed my child.
00:24:57.296 --> 00:24:58.436
He's healed my wife.
00:24:58.557 --> 00:24:59.898
He's healed somebody else.
00:25:00.980 --> 00:25:05.604
And I'd say, well, so am I just not righteous enough that God hasn't intervened?
00:25:05.984 --> 00:25:10.709
And as time has gone on, my daughter has made a great life for herself.
00:25:10.788 --> 00:25:15.433
She's currently a medical doctor in her first year of residency.
00:25:15.534 --> 00:25:23.218
She's when I raised that with some people to say, well, see, it was all for the best.
00:25:23.438 --> 00:25:33.712
This was, you know, and, and I, you know, and I, I've had discussions with my wife about that, where she's just said that just drives me crazy.
00:25:33.813 --> 00:25:46.911
I mean, yes, we've seen so many blessings and so many wonderful people who've come in and helped as a result of that, but I'd be willing to throw them away to make my daughter whole again.
00:25:46.931 --> 00:25:53.423
You know, they're not, they're, That kind of reasoning gets very frustrating.
00:25:53.723 --> 00:26:13.170
So I've sort of reached the point where I believe that we are the intervention, that we are the body of Christ, that we are the ones that have the inspiration to reach out to our neighbors, to reach out to people in need.
00:26:14.392 --> 00:26:33.308
And I think the kinds of intervention that My daughter takes a wrong turn down a mountain and somehow the hand of God reaches out and just nudges her away from the obstacle that causes the injury.
00:26:33.328 --> 00:26:40.919
I don't think that mortality is designed for experiences like that.
00:26:41.400 --> 00:26:46.026
I'm with Marcus in that he lets chance take its course.
00:26:46.817 --> 00:26:51.962
And I'm also with Marcus in this idea that we signed up for this.
00:26:52.983 --> 00:27:08.258
I don't know if I can go all the way to say we knew exactly when we were going to die or exactly what was going to befall us when we came here, but we knew what we would be subject to.
00:27:08.298 --> 00:27:21.894
We knew what the risks were, and we were willing to accept those risks because mortality and death That kind of experience with opposition is the only way to learn and to grow.
00:27:21.934 --> 00:27:40.634
So I no longer really believe that, you know, the closest I've had to the finding the diamond experience is finding, there was one year at Christmas, my wife makes homemade stockings.
00:27:41.394 --> 00:27:45.057
She's made these stockings for all of our kids and we'd lost one of them.
00:27:46.145 --> 00:27:50.190
And we prayed and we prayed and we prayed and we prayed, and I found them.
00:27:50.710 --> 00:27:51.191
I found it.
00:27:51.411 --> 00:27:53.593
And I thought, whoa, isn't this a great answer to prayer?
00:27:55.074 --> 00:28:10.548
But the older I get, the more I think, jeez, if we can't deal with some sort of lost item, then mortality probably is too big a stretch for us.
00:28:12.451 --> 00:28:15.232
That's not what the mortal experience is supposed to be.
00:28:16.417 --> 00:28:38.924
I don't take any issue with anything that Marcus has said, and I actually was reminded, Ian, of your near-death experience when we talk about it on this podcast, and also not just the near-death experience, but the death of your brother, when you talked about that that was just an undeniable moment where you recognized there was something beyond this life.
00:28:40.145 --> 00:28:45.227
And I, too, have had, we want to call them column A experiences.
00:28:45.247 --> 00:28:51.413
I have had column A experiences that I don't think are necessarily appropriate for public consumption.
00:28:52.334 --> 00:28:58.740
But I think that kind of worldview, I can understand it.
00:28:58.759 --> 00:29:00.642
I share it to some degree.
00:29:00.682 --> 00:29:02.123
I don't share it to another degree.
00:29:02.884 --> 00:29:13.574
But I think these are the great questions that keep all of us talking and that keep all of us up at night as we try to figure out what it is that we're doing here and where we've come from and where we're going.
00:29:14.210 --> 00:29:15.310
Yeah, thank you for that.
00:29:15.612 --> 00:29:17.374
I think we all agree, and I agree with you, Marcus.
00:29:17.394 --> 00:29:23.643
I know, like you, Marcus, there is another dimension for sure, based on my own experiences.
00:29:24.463 --> 00:29:27.047
I really appreciate you both providing your insight.
00:29:28.628 --> 00:29:39.364
What I'd like to do, if I can, is go into the next stage of our conversation, and we've been sharing and communicating this part of the conversation with Marcus.
00:29:40.305 --> 00:29:43.128
There's at least two things I know about you, Marcus, amongst many things.
00:29:44.162 --> 00:29:53.958
The two things are, from my experience, having known you for so long now, is your commitment to the church and the gospel is just extraordinary.
00:29:54.219 --> 00:29:55.520
I want you to know that.
00:29:55.580 --> 00:29:57.384
That's how I see you.
00:29:57.403 --> 00:29:58.826
You're incredibly committed.
00:29:58.846 --> 00:30:05.297
And the other thing, amongst other things, of course, there's lots of other things, is your knowledge of the gospel and the church.
00:30:06.018 --> 00:30:23.115
And so when you and I were back and forward and I was trying to keep Jim aligned and up to date on some of your questions, there was a few topics that we wanted to get into with you, if we can, to get your insights and your experience and your knowledge and thoughts on this.
00:30:23.194 --> 00:30:25.336
And I think this will be very interesting for many of our listeners.
00:30:25.958 --> 00:30:27.318
And so maybe we could...
00:30:28.420 --> 00:30:32.904
So if we can, in the interest of time, ask
00:30:32.984 --> 00:30:33.125
some
00:30:33.766 --> 00:30:34.205
very...
00:30:34.369 --> 00:30:37.394
Well, before we do that, can I jump in just very quickly?
00:30:37.434 --> 00:30:58.390
Because this has been such a lovely conversation and I would hope it would stay a lovely conversation because I know that behind the scenes, Marcus, some of your objections to some of the things that we've said on this podcast, I think have the potential to get very heated and get very contentious.
00:30:59.233 --> 00:31:08.085
And I would hope that one of the hallmarks of this podcast, when we have people on, is we say, we absolutely want you to feel comfortable.
00:31:09.026 --> 00:31:13.351
And we want this to be a safe place for people to talk, for people to tell their stories.
00:31:14.511 --> 00:31:17.395
And I know of Ian's affection for you, Marcus.
00:31:18.336 --> 00:31:22.882
And I just met you today, but you seem like a very pleasant, lovely human being.
00:31:23.222 --> 00:31:43.213
And I would just hope that as we discuss things that may become somewhat difficult, some topics that may be somewhat loaded topics, that we can do so with civility, with kindness, and that this doesn't go off the rails into something else.
00:31:44.596 --> 00:31:45.017
Is that all
00:31:45.037 --> 00:31:45.237
right?
00:31:46.338 --> 00:31:51.788
Can you note that Jim's actually said some really good things about me, and I'd like that posted and actually put on the Facebook.
00:31:52.569 --> 00:31:54.192
Oh, that's excellent.
00:31:54.573 --> 00:31:54.973
Oh, well.
00:31:55.713 --> 00:31:57.757
No, I think that's a really important point.
00:31:57.777 --> 00:32:02.705
You know, our feedback we got from people who've been on to the podcast is that it feels safe and comfortable.
00:32:03.066 --> 00:32:14.184
But at the same time, we are, you know, we're really interested in having a very robust conversation because I think we can get some really interesting, you know, points in here.
00:32:14.365 --> 00:32:18.111
But I appreciate and value, obviously, what Jim said, and I concur with that.
00:32:18.632 --> 00:32:19.773
So if you're okay...
00:32:19.970 --> 00:32:47.108
Marcus if you're comfortable if we could just get into some of the topics uh that we talk as I think your insights are going to be uh fascinating um we've talked for example some of the big topics are like race and the priesthood polygamy you know these are some of the big ones right um you know the Book of Mormon translation process I think you've even talked about a little about evolution uh you know these are some of the the big the big topics there and so if you're comfortable getting to some of these questions.
00:32:47.869 --> 00:32:49.731
And we can start at any one of these.
00:32:50.452 --> 00:32:52.736
Maybe I'll just ask one question here.
00:32:52.776 --> 00:32:54.637
And again, I'll keep it brief.
00:32:57.541 --> 00:33:01.807
What's your perspective on race in the priesthood, for example?
00:33:03.308 --> 00:33:16.215
When Brigham Young introduced the restrictions on Black people accessing priesthood authority and temple blessings, Was he right to do so?
00:33:16.276 --> 00:33:17.277
Was he wrong?
00:33:17.317 --> 00:33:18.459
Did he make a mistake?
00:33:19.079 --> 00:33:25.707
And this speaks to an area that Jim's fascinated in, which is prophetic infallibility.
00:33:25.968 --> 00:33:28.289
Are the prophets wrong?
00:33:28.390 --> 00:33:29.010
Are they right?
00:33:29.612 --> 00:33:30.712
Are they speaking as a man?
00:33:30.772 --> 00:33:31.753
Are they speaking as a prophet?
00:33:32.134 --> 00:33:41.705
But was Brigham Young right or wrong to introduce restrictions on black people holding the priesthood and accessing the temple of blessings?
00:33:43.490 --> 00:33:44.030
Okay.
00:33:44.411 --> 00:33:50.518
I mean, I think it's really important that anybody in the gospel is actually open to questions.
00:33:50.657 --> 00:33:54.622
And anybody who fails to answer questions, I think, is missing the point.
00:33:54.761 --> 00:34:08.597
I think it is very important that we're all able to interact with each other very clearly and openly and happily, and that you do create a very comfortable environment and are very much appreciative of that fact.
00:34:09.157 --> 00:34:13.021
I think there are tenets that the gospel offers.
00:34:13.217 --> 00:34:49.728
lays down and I think those tenets are important to define the tenet for blacks and the priesthood is basically that there was no racism there has been no racism and that there was no pre-existent sin that black people committed to not receive the priesthood now my son My youngest son, I've got four kids, my youngest son is actually engaged to a really fun and exciting and vibrant black girl from South Africa.
00:34:49.768 --> 00:34:52.431
And they're engaged and they'll get married quite soon.
00:34:53.373 --> 00:34:54.994
So I think this is a really relevant question.
00:34:55.936 --> 00:35:06.849
My take, having thought about this for a long time, is that between 1852 and 1978, you have a geographical region which was restricted only to Africa.
00:35:07.425 --> 00:35:13.411
whereby people couldn't receive the priesthood if they were actually born within that geographical location.
00:35:14.311 --> 00:35:21.358
I can remember teaching a black family, the Browns, and they were just delightful.
00:35:22.920 --> 00:35:30.447
But I can easily see and completely see and totally understand why someone would not wish to be a judge in Israel.
00:35:31.068 --> 00:35:34.670
Now, I've been on quite a few disciplinary councils.
00:35:34.731 --> 00:35:36.313
I was on the High Council for 16 years.
00:35:37.666 --> 00:35:39.989
That was a continuous stretch when I really enjoyed it.
00:35:40.009 --> 00:35:40.429
I loved it.
00:35:40.949 --> 00:35:45.534
But I didn't enjoy going into disciplinaries so much.
00:35:45.614 --> 00:35:53.063
When I was actually asked to speak for the, to uphold the good name of the church, I always used to find myself swapping sides.
00:35:53.682 --> 00:35:58.548
And I would actually just put up mitigating circumstances for the guy in the chair.
00:35:58.588 --> 00:36:02.072
And some of the guys in the high council would give me a little bit of a funny look.
00:36:02.132 --> 00:36:02.833
I didn't care.
00:36:02.853 --> 00:36:06.016
I just wanted to continue to put the mitigating circumstances.
00:36:06.077 --> 00:36:10.378
So guys, I get it why some people would not want to do that.
00:36:10.398 --> 00:36:17.789
And I personally never wanted to be in that position because I saw the great angst that I had.
00:36:17.949 --> 00:36:19.351
I was with three state presidents.
00:36:19.371 --> 00:36:24.197
I saw the great angst that they went through in making decisions and also certain bishops.
00:36:25.259 --> 00:36:32.329
And I only kept what I say here, but not all leaders are actually fantastic.
00:36:32.429 --> 00:36:34.512
And I've heard your podcast and I agree with you.
00:36:35.233 --> 00:36:38.885
Some of them, Yeah, not that brilliant, but that's as far as I'll go with that.
00:36:39.465 --> 00:36:55.304
But guys, for me, the blacks not receiving the priesthood was a voluntary thing of not wanting to have been compelled to be a judge in Israel because it's not something that I'm comfortable with that idea.
00:36:56.005 --> 00:36:57.327
Some bishops are fantastic.
00:36:57.927 --> 00:37:00.030
So for me, it was a voluntary decision.
00:37:00.353 --> 00:37:07.181
just the same way that it was a voluntary decision that Helen left at the time that she did, not one that I kind of thought I was clever and agreeing to, but anyway.
00:37:07.880 --> 00:37:21.175
But so for me, that group of people between 1852 and 1978 didn't want to be judged in Israel, but once they die, they can have the opportunity of actually receiving the priesthood after mortality.
00:37:21.574 --> 00:37:30.172
And after 1978, all that group had gone through mortality, so it wasn't something which needed to be in place anymore, and it wasn't.
00:37:30.211 --> 00:37:30.833
It was removed.
00:37:31.293 --> 00:37:32.617
So for me, it was a voluntary action.
00:37:32.657 --> 00:37:34.760
It's got nothing to do with racism whatsoever.
00:37:35.320 --> 00:37:41.030
And I cannot agree that a prophet would be racist.
00:37:41.853 --> 00:37:46.922
And whilst men are fallible, as long as Christ is talking to a prophet, he's not fallible.
00:37:47.282 --> 00:37:51.769
The second he actually doesn't have Christ chatting to him, then he can make mistakes.
00:37:51.809 --> 00:37:54.887
But all the time that Christ is talking to him, He's not making mistakes.
00:37:54.927 --> 00:37:58.833
He's got the guy in the big cheese in the middle actually saying, look, do it like this, guys.
00:37:59.514 --> 00:38:00.835
Dissemination of information.
00:38:01.958 --> 00:38:11.873
So there's a big disparate view here between what guys muck up, and there's plenty of local leaders who do some really stupid things.
00:38:13.376 --> 00:38:24.318
But when the Savior is chatting to the prophet, it's not a problem, and there is nothing to be scared of in terms of listening to to what the prophet is saying.
00:38:24.900 --> 00:38:31.286
Now, I know that we all have different prophets that we like, and I really like President Nelson.
00:38:31.445 --> 00:38:31.947
I really do.
00:38:32.387 --> 00:38:34.909
I really like President Monson, the way he can twitch his ears.
00:38:34.989 --> 00:38:38.452
But, you know, other guys, I didn't warm to.
00:38:38.693 --> 00:38:40.394
But those two, I do.
00:38:40.474 --> 00:38:41.215
I really like them.
00:38:41.815 --> 00:38:42.657
So that's my answer.
00:38:42.697 --> 00:38:44.739
I appreciate that.
00:38:44.778 --> 00:38:47.702
And I want to get Jim's response here as well.
00:38:47.722 --> 00:38:58.925
But if I understand you, my interpretation of that is that The decision not to accept the priesthood was from the black people at the time, again, so correctly if I'm wrong.
00:39:00.248 --> 00:39:03.532
You're nodding your head, agreeing to that, I think.
00:39:03.692 --> 00:39:07.878
And secondly, Brigham Young didn't get it wrong as the prophet.
00:39:08.398 --> 00:39:11.422
He was in the Lord's prophet seat there.
00:39:11.442 --> 00:39:13.023
He didn't get it wrong.
00:39:13.565 --> 00:39:17.829
His decision to prohibit, restrict black from the priesthood was correct, if that's what you're saying.
00:39:18.630 --> 00:39:23.257
And he wasn't racist.
00:39:24.920 --> 00:39:31.630
His decision behind that wasn't based on his discriminating against black people.
00:39:31.690 --> 00:39:32.733
Is that correct?
00:39:33.373 --> 00:39:34.014
Did I understand that?
00:39:37.981 --> 00:39:40.266
Jim, any thoughts, comments on that from your perspective?
00:39:41.827 --> 00:39:42.509
Well, many.
00:39:44.733 --> 00:39:47.677
I'm just trying to figure out the best way to go at it.
00:39:48.193 --> 00:39:56.862
Because I think without that, I don't, I've cut you off there, but I think you and I talk about our perspective is somewhat different to that, but go ahead.
00:39:57.762 --> 00:39:59.204
Well, okay.
00:40:01.005 --> 00:40:02.967
Two things jump out at me from your answer.
00:40:03.889 --> 00:40:08.833
The first being that somehow this is a voluntary decision by black people.
00:40:08.914 --> 00:40:34.126
You initially said this is, these are people that are confined to a certain geographical area when in fact, you know, This affected people far beyond that geographical area, as in a global society, people of African descent can be found in pretty much any nation in the world, and they could be found in any nation in the world prior to the priesthood restrictions being lifted.
00:40:35.449 --> 00:40:53.858
But I want to drill down on this idea that this was somehow voluntary, that they somehow chose to not to have the priesthood because I've had conversations with Darius Gray, who was one of the first men who received the priesthood after restriction was lifted.
00:40:53.918 --> 00:40:56.222
He was one of the founders of the Genesis Group.
00:40:56.442 --> 00:40:58.585
Are you familiar with the Genesis Group, Marcus?
00:41:00.847 --> 00:41:03.731
You give your response and I'll come back with a riposte afterwards, okay?
00:41:04.431 --> 00:41:04.853
Oh, okay.
00:41:06.574 --> 00:41:18.746
The Genesis Group was a group of Black Latter-day Saints prior to the priesthood restriction, and they interacted directly with President Kimball.
00:41:19.788 --> 00:41:28.701
Darius Gray tells the story of his baptism, that he had received a testimony that he was to be baptized and then discovered that he couldn't get the priesthood.
00:41:30.063 --> 00:41:53.014
And the idea that Darius Gray or anybody else who had joined the church prior to 1978 didn't want the priesthood or, or chose or volunteered not to have the priesthood, uh, flies in the face of, of the, of any kind.
00:41:53.715 --> 00:41:59.663
I have not yet met a person who would say that, no, we just didn't want it.
00:41:59.822 --> 00:42:00.664
We just didn't want it.
00:42:01.085 --> 00:42:03.907
So I'm presuming that you are talking about that.
00:42:03.947 --> 00:42:20.226
This was a volunteer sort of thing that happened before this life, which is a sort of an explanation that the church has explicitly disavowed in the race and the priesthood essay.
00:42:20.266 --> 00:43:07.664
The idea that somehow they're less valiant, that somehow something in their pre-earth life determined that they would not be able to have the priesthood and you attach the word voluntary to that as if this which actually I can sort of understand why you would want to because then it no longer says okay well they were less valiant it was okay well they just chose to not have the priesthood and so that sort of softens the blow but it doesn't remove the sort of underlying assumption of inferiority that comes with that.
00:43:08.266 --> 00:43:21.545
So, so, so, I mean, I, that's my first foray into this and I'm happy to get to the other part about, um, uh, whether or not Brigham Young made mistakes or whether or not prophets can make mistakes.
00:43:21.585 --> 00:43:30.594
Cause I think that's a larger discussion, but, uh, That's my response to that, and I'd be interested to hear your thoughts in reply.
00:43:30.635 --> 00:43:32.135
Fantastic.
00:43:32.155 --> 00:43:32.576
I'd love to.
00:43:32.677 --> 00:43:32.876
Right.
00:43:32.936 --> 00:43:40.925
First of all, in terms of the passage of people out from Africa, it doesn't make any difference.
00:43:41.005 --> 00:43:50.813
If people actually were born in Africa, then basically the Heavenly Father made that possible that they were born in Africa, so therefore that was their choice from the preexistence.
00:43:51.175 --> 00:43:52.635
So that's sort of fair comment, Jim.
00:43:52.695 --> 00:43:54.117
But nice try, but it doesn't work.
00:43:54.594 --> 00:44:00.201
The other idea that it's actually connected with valiance, we know that it's not connected with valiance from the essays.
00:44:00.501 --> 00:44:04.565
That's got nothing whatsoever to do with the fact that it was a free choice.
00:44:04.646 --> 00:44:11.333
Valiance and free will, and Heavenly Father is very keen on free will, are completely and utterly separate.
00:44:11.353 --> 00:44:14.297
So it's not a case of dumbing down the blow.
00:44:14.338 --> 00:44:16.380
It's a case of they're not connected whatsoever.
00:44:16.420 --> 00:44:23.789
So it doesn't actually impact the idea that people in the preexistence made that as a free will choice.
00:44:24.193 --> 00:44:27.197
So it's a nice try, mate, but it doesn't actually stack up logically.
00:44:27.277 --> 00:44:28.858
Okay.
00:44:28.878 --> 00:44:31.322
I just want to set some boundaries here a little bit.
00:44:31.481 --> 00:44:32.443
I mean, nice try.
00:44:32.463 --> 00:44:34.144
I'm just trying to have a discussion with you.
00:44:34.224 --> 00:44:35.206
I'm not debating you.
00:44:36.086 --> 00:44:37.688
I'm not criticizing you.
00:44:37.768 --> 00:44:38.771
I'm not attacking you.
00:44:39.851 --> 00:44:42.233
I'm trying to have an exchange of ideas.
00:44:42.474 --> 00:44:48.061
So when you say things like, well, nice try or this, it's not about me being right or wrong.
00:44:48.161 --> 00:44:50.563
It's about me trying to understand your position.
00:44:51.724 --> 00:44:52.445
And I was appalled, John.
00:44:52.802 --> 00:45:18.418
When you start talking about it's voluntary in the pre-existence, I mean, the geography, well, I mean, the geography, I guess that doesn't matter because people born in the United States for generations, there are people who have been born in the United States for hundreds of years and born in the UK and born throughout the world who haven't ever been to Africa.
00:45:18.657 --> 00:45:25.949
I guess their genetic ancestry is rooted in Africa, but I guess maybe that's a distinction without a difference.
00:45:26.789 --> 00:45:37.226
But when I raised Darius Gray, for instance, Darius Gray would have told you in 1977 that he very much wanted the priesthood.
00:45:38.608 --> 00:45:52.639
And based on the way you are framing this, you would have told him, well, you made a decision before this life where you didn't want the priesthood, and that decision should take precedence over your 1977 decision.
00:45:53.440 --> 00:45:54.621
Is that an accurate framing?
00:45:56.304 --> 00:45:58.186
Well, I apologize for saying nice try.
00:45:58.246 --> 00:46:03.309
What I'm used to is actually talking like this as a scientist, and I actually debate regularly with other scientists.
00:46:03.351 --> 00:46:05.472
I'm not trying to be rude, and I really apologize.
00:46:05.753 --> 00:46:07.153
That's not what I'm trying to do, Jim.
00:46:07.454 --> 00:46:11.838
I'm actually just coming back, and I'm used to people actually coming back at me and saying nice try.
00:46:11.878 --> 00:46:15.422
This is the kind of banter that we use, and it's not meant to be offensive.
00:46:15.905 --> 00:46:17.007
I really apologize for that.
00:46:17.068 --> 00:46:26.181
But bottom line is that the pre-existent choice was something that people will make, just in the same way that I made a choice about Helen, apparently.
00:46:26.822 --> 00:46:31.210
And that then has to actually remain in force until you pass through mortality.
00:46:31.510 --> 00:46:38.422
So it doesn't matter what you actually choose or what decisions you try to change once you're in mortality.
00:46:38.442 --> 00:46:40.003
Once you're on the...
00:46:41.250 --> 00:46:46.155
the crazy ride on Fort Park, you're on there until the end of the ride.
00:46:46.195 --> 00:46:48.219
And once you get off the ride, then that's fine.
00:46:48.298 --> 00:46:50.402
Once you die, then that's a different story.
00:46:50.641 --> 00:46:52.403
But you can't change your mind halfway through.
00:46:52.423 --> 00:46:53.505
It doesn't work like that.
00:46:54.206 --> 00:46:57.331
Well, doesn't that sort of defeat the entire purpose of mortality?
00:46:57.590 --> 00:47:05.701
Isn't the purpose of coming here the willingness to make decisions, to make choices, to learn from our decisions, to learn from our choices?
00:47:05.780 --> 00:47:11.623
And if we're bound solely by the choices we made before this life, Why do we bother coming here in the first place?
00:47:12.684 --> 00:47:27.300
Because we all have to actually have preconditions set in, and actually those preconditions determine where we were born, how we were born, to what families we were born, and therefore we have a partial judgment when we die.
00:47:27.320 --> 00:47:29.603
All the things that we do have consequences.
00:47:30.103 --> 00:47:39.193
So when we actually have different choices to make, we make them at the time and we live with them until we get a circumstance where those conditions are changed.
00:47:39.554 --> 00:47:50.070
So it's not a problem, Jim, in actually deciding, look, I don't want to be a judge in Israel, but I certainly want to go down to mortality and to actually participate.
00:47:50.871 --> 00:47:56.079
I don't want to go with Lucifer's crowd because that's crazy, but I also don't want to be a judge in Israel.
00:47:56.099 --> 00:47:57.201
There's nothing wrong with doing that.
00:47:58.463 --> 00:48:01.708
Marcus, can I just drill down on this because I think this is fascinating.
00:48:04.773 --> 00:48:05.514
Is it your...
00:48:05.858 --> 00:48:34.396
perspective that you know you talk about choice and preconditions before people came to the earth that we individuals some individuals chose to go to Africa for example it chose to go to a certain geography that there were certain decisions that they made under free agency to go to a be born in a certain place in that situation or those conditions in those geographies, et cetera, you know, outside the United States, for example, or UK or whatever.
00:48:35.117 --> 00:48:36.780
And that those are the series of choices.
00:48:37.300 --> 00:48:44.751
Was that based on any type or form of faithfulness or balance on their part?
00:48:44.811 --> 00:48:51.961
For example, when I was investigating the church, certainly just after I was baptized, I learned pretty quickly early on that.
00:48:52.963 --> 00:48:54.045
And this was in seminary.
00:48:54.284 --> 00:49:14.909
We talked about this on the podcast briefly where I was taught that that black people weren't allowed to receive the priesthood at that time because they were, quote, less valiant, end quote, before the world was, and that they were restricted to certain geographies, weren't born in white, middle-class Utah, for example.
00:49:14.969 --> 00:49:16.030
They went to Africa.
00:49:16.371 --> 00:49:20.675
That was, to your point, their choice based on their agency.
00:49:20.715 --> 00:49:27.561
But is there a correlation there with those individuals' faithfulness and valiance, which is what I...
00:49:27.938 --> 00:49:30.280
was taught when I first joined the church.
00:49:30.340 --> 00:49:31.041
Could you speak to that?
00:49:33.063 --> 00:49:35.726
Yeah, I think that's a really important point, Ian.
00:49:36.146 --> 00:49:41.992
And sometimes I think that local guys actually just get it wrong.
00:49:42.351 --> 00:49:42.932
I really do.
00:49:43.373 --> 00:49:44.614
And this is really important.
00:49:44.773 --> 00:49:51.141
And what's really stark for me here is as soon as you start speaking, Ian, I'm automatically wanting to agree with you.
00:49:51.201 --> 00:49:58.380
As soon as Jim starts speaking, because I don't know him so well, I automatically want to actually joust with him.
00:49:58.940 --> 00:50:00.061
So it's crazy.
00:50:00.202 --> 00:50:02.726
I don't want to do that, but it's just my natural reaction.
00:50:02.766 --> 00:50:09.153
So automatically I'm thinking, yeah, how can I actually completely find common ground with Ian?
00:50:09.215 --> 00:50:13.740
And I'm thinking, how can I get in there and give Jim a good blow before he blows me?
00:50:13.760 --> 00:50:15.443
I mean, that's just how it goes.
00:50:15.503 --> 00:50:16.164
That's where we are.
00:50:16.204 --> 00:50:17.646
We guys is what we want to do.
00:50:18.027 --> 00:50:23.253
So completely, Ian, some local leaders just basically talk utter drivel.
00:50:23.793 --> 00:50:25.597
And I don't mean that to be rude.
00:50:25.637 --> 00:50:30.722
It's just But other guys are just a delight to listen to.
00:50:30.802 --> 00:50:32.224
In the Winchester Ward, it's a pleasure.
00:50:32.284 --> 00:50:37.349
So I completely and totally disagree with the idea about valiance and the preexistence.
00:50:37.449 --> 00:50:38.469
I'm completely with you.
00:50:38.891 --> 00:50:40.391
I think that's completely 100%.
00:50:40.693 --> 00:50:48.561
It's got nothing to do with people from black ethnicity at all.
00:50:49.382 --> 00:50:51.885
And I think your point you make is very good, Ian.
00:50:51.905 --> 00:50:52.905
100%, mate.
00:50:52.965 --> 00:50:53.126
Yep.
00:50:54.722 --> 00:51:06.840
Well, I want to dive into this idea that the prophets couldn't have been wrong and the idea that they've got Christ whispering in their ear and so they can't be wrong.
00:51:07.920 --> 00:51:10.445
So this is going to be sort of a two-pronged question.
00:51:10.485 --> 00:51:16.914
The first, I want to read a statement by Brigham Young made on March 8th, 1863.
00:51:17.916 --> 00:51:22.021
Shall I tell you the law of God in regard to the African race?
00:51:22.849 --> 00:51:31.639
If the white man who belongs to the chosen seed mixes his blood with the seed of Cain, the penalty under the law of God is death on the spot.
00:51:32.340 --> 00:51:34.563
This will always be so.
00:51:34.603 --> 00:51:41.610
Now, you, Marcus, you told us you've got a son that is marrying a lovely woman of African descent.
00:51:42.771 --> 00:51:53.963
And based on the law of God that will always be so, as enunciated by Brigham Young, the punishment, the penalty under the law of God is death on the spot.
00:51:54.664 --> 00:51:55.927
Do you agree with Brigham Young?
00:51:56.067 --> 00:52:07.961
And if you don't agree with Brigham Young, because I'm assuming you don't want that punishment for your son and his fiance, how do you reconcile that and say Brigham Young wasn't wrong?
00:52:09.603 --> 00:52:11.967
Okay, here's my riposte.
00:52:12.606 --> 00:52:13.849
Very easily indeed.
00:52:13.869 --> 00:52:20.661
I was politically assassinated and I actually saw things printed in the press and I know were fabricated.
00:52:21.802 --> 00:52:29.333
My daughter is a reporter and she's a very accurate reporter and very objective in her articles that she writes.
00:52:30.054 --> 00:52:39.246
Some reporters, or shall I say, it is the nature and disposition of nearly all men, not only to exercise unrighteous dominion, but also to tell complete big porky pies.
00:52:40.161 --> 00:52:43.447
actually report in a way which I don't trust as far as I can throw it.
00:52:43.807 --> 00:52:48.293
So I'm not interested in what someone reported about something that Brigham Young may or may not have said.
00:52:48.635 --> 00:52:51.559
When I get into the next dimension, I'll ask him myself.
00:52:52.019 --> 00:52:52.880
And he can tell me.
00:52:52.922 --> 00:52:59.090
When I get into the next dimension and I see Joseph Smith, if he's got multiple wives, that's fine by me because it would be real.
00:52:59.110 --> 00:53:01.014
If he hasn't, I don't care.
00:53:01.034 --> 00:53:04.338
I don't care what somebody actually reports about Brigham Young.
00:53:04.699 --> 00:53:08.726
I'm not interested in third parties because I've seen all sorts of drivel made up about me.
00:53:09.090 --> 00:53:10.992
And I know that it's completely fabricated.
00:53:11.594 --> 00:53:14.418
So I'm getting animated here because I've experienced it.
00:53:14.478 --> 00:53:20.789
So in answer to your question, Jim, I'm not interested in third-party reports, and I think they're a completely utter fabricated drivel.
00:53:21.650 --> 00:53:27.579
So you don't think Brigham Young is wrong because you deny that Brigham Young ever said anything like this?
00:53:28.880 --> 00:53:35.070
I don't trust people's third-party reports having had that experience.
00:53:35.831 --> 00:53:36.393
Okay, well...
00:53:37.153 --> 00:53:43.199
I've had a number of experiences with the press as well, and I recognize the press is capable of getting things wrong.
00:53:43.239 --> 00:53:49.005
Would that this were an isolated sort of statement on the part of Brigham Young.
00:53:49.746 --> 00:54:02.938
We have his address recorded to the territorial legislature in 1852, which is the first time that the priesthood and temple ban became sort of codified into Latter-day Saint policy.
00:54:02.998 --> 00:54:11.659
It had been sort of enforced sporadically prior to that, Joseph Smith ordained several men of African descent to the priesthood.
00:54:12.661 --> 00:54:25.014
But it was in that 1852 address to the territorial legislature that Brigham Young outlined specifically that black people are the descendants of Cain, which we now disavow.
00:54:25.054 --> 00:54:30.780
The black people were in fact less valiant and less righteous, which we now disavow.
00:54:30.820 --> 00:54:44.599
And all the kinds of things that we taught prior to 1978, have their origins in that 1852 address, which was well-recorded and which was firsthand.
00:54:44.978 --> 00:54:49.684
I don't know how you reconcile historical sources.
00:54:49.724 --> 00:55:01.474
If the game is, okay, we just disregard any kind of historical record that makes a prophet look bad, then this is going to be a fairly unproductive conversation.
00:55:02.436 --> 00:55:28.608
But the church has readily admitted that Brigham Young taught those things, that Brigham Young taught the inferiority of the black race, the cursed nature of the black race, and whether or not this individual statement that I had read to you is in fact accurate, it is in many ways consistent with the large body of what Brigham Young had to teach on the subject of race.
00:55:29.429 --> 00:55:30.891
And it isn't just Brigham Young.
00:55:31.152 --> 00:55:45.202
As it goes down, The idea the black people are the cursed descendants of Cain is something that was taught by every prophet since Brigham Young up to Spencer W.
00:55:45.242 --> 00:55:47.143
Kimball, who finally lifted the ban.
00:55:47.445 --> 00:55:59.936
And the idea that they are not cursed did not come into parlance in our theological discussions until essentially 2013.
00:56:01.313 --> 00:56:09.708
with the publication of the race and priesthood essay, which explicitly disavows all of those things that the prophets had said prior to that.
00:56:09.748 --> 00:56:42.523
Now, if you're going to say every single prophet is, was misquoted or misunderstood or misheard when they talked about the inferiority of the black race and the cursed nature of the black race, uh, I don't know where we can take this conversation in a productive direction because I think it's undeniable that that's something that was taught at the highest levels of this church for well over a century.
00:56:42.563 --> 00:56:52.878
And I don't know how you can look at that and then say, well, prophets can't make mistakes.
00:56:54.753 --> 00:56:55.434
Okay, right.
00:56:55.896 --> 00:56:58.239
Okay, my response to that would be twofold.
00:56:58.498 --> 00:57:09.193
One is that I don't think Brigham Young is stupid enough to actually believe that Cain was the source of the cursing because black people came from Egypt as the wife of Ham.
00:57:09.833 --> 00:57:24.233
Secondly, I've actually listened to your podcast, Jim, where you actually talk about 2 Nephi 5.21, where you talk about the idea that the Lamanites were cursed with a dark skin.
00:57:24.802 --> 00:57:26.844
That's not my understanding at all whatsoever.
00:57:26.903 --> 00:57:28.967
The Lamanites threw off their clothes and got tanned.
00:57:28.987 --> 00:57:41.800
When my father was actually in Iraq in the hockey team, they were lining up and they said, we thought that you were actually just only going to have British soldiers, British RAF guys.
00:57:43.543 --> 00:57:44.784
You can't have that guy over there.
00:57:44.824 --> 00:57:46.867
And they said, well, what do you mean?
00:57:46.887 --> 00:57:50.391
He said, well, he's not Caucasian.
00:57:50.791 --> 00:57:51.751
He's a black guy.
00:57:51.791 --> 00:57:53.213
That was my father.
00:57:53.889 --> 00:58:01.601
When people actually chuck off their clothes, they get self-cursing because they get carcinomas and they get a really deep tan.
00:58:01.961 --> 00:58:13.639
So your explanation for 2 Nephi 521, I'm sorry, doesn't actually sit level with me because some of the things that you're quoting, some of these guys can be interpreted in different ways.
00:58:13.739 --> 00:58:15.902
Justin, we could come on to the Pearl of Great Price.
00:58:15.943 --> 00:58:17.905
That's another one where we get different interpretations.
00:58:18.365 --> 00:58:23.998
So whilst you can actually roll out these quotes, Jim, My understanding of them is completely different to yours, I'm afraid.
00:58:24.018 --> 00:58:29.608
And every time I read one of these quotes that you pull up, I'm actually reading it in a completely different way.
00:58:29.628 --> 00:58:29.668
So
00:58:31.271 --> 00:58:34.795
I'm trying to find out what way you're reading them.
00:58:35.657 --> 00:58:42.809
I mean, do you deny that the prophets taught that black people bore the curse of Cain?
00:58:44.652 --> 00:58:45.634
It's got nothing to do with Cain.
00:58:45.653 --> 00:58:47.557
It's to do with Ham and Egyptus.
00:58:48.001 --> 00:58:50.306
Well, Ham and Egyptus were descendants.
00:58:50.445 --> 00:58:54.012
Egyptus was scripturally a descendant of Cain.
00:58:56.177 --> 00:59:01.887
I mean, Brigham Young, and again, I've given you the 1852 reference, the territorial legislature speech.
00:59:02.867 --> 00:59:10.442
And I can give you the 1949 first presidency statement where they reiterate that black people bear the curse of Cain.
00:59:11.242 --> 00:59:12.565
That's George Albert Smith.
00:59:13.313 --> 00:59:15.597
I can find several other statements of it.
00:59:16.018 --> 00:59:27.713
And when you say, well, you interpret them in a different way, and then you go to 2 Nephi 5.21, which is a different discussion, because 2 Nephi 5.21 was never used to deny anybody priesthood or temple blessings.
00:59:28.875 --> 00:59:31.858
But the idea of the curse of Cain absolutely was.
00:59:31.900 --> 00:59:36.565
And so I'm trying to get...
00:59:36.606 --> 00:59:39.389
See, so from my perspective...
00:59:40.257 --> 00:59:58.820
The idea of prophetic infallibility, the idea that prophets cannot make mistakes, never make mistakes, they've got Jesus whispering in their ear 24 hours a day, and everything they say is always right and always reliable, that absolutely flies in the face.
00:59:59.969 --> 01:00:21.264
of the fundamental principle of mortality, which is agency, which is the idea that we chose to come to this earth in order to learn and grow by encountering opposition and learning from our mistakes and knowing that sin and wickedness and mistakes would keep us from living with our heavenly father.
01:00:21.284 --> 01:00:26.413
We were given a savior in order to be able to pay for that education, if you will.
01:00:27.106 --> 01:00:39.878
But the idea, it's always interesting to me when people talk about church leaders, and Marcus, you talk about, okay, you're willing to concede that there are local leaders that are lousy.
01:00:41.039 --> 01:00:51.889
And I commend you for not mentioning them by name, because I do think we are under a covenantal obligation not to speak evil of people who have been given callings by the Lord.
01:00:51.929 --> 01:00:56.173
But I'm curious that...
01:00:56.673 --> 01:01:01.137
My mission president after Ian left the mission was Joseph Fielding McConkie.
01:01:01.177 --> 01:01:05.402
And he was often asked about prophetic infallibility.
01:01:05.442 --> 01:01:08.105
And he wrote a book called Answers to Gospel Questions.
01:01:08.485 --> 01:01:13.409
And he wrote a lengthy thing where he said, at what point does infallibility begin?
01:01:14.251 --> 01:01:16.572
Because we don't expect infallible Sunday school teachers.
01:01:17.273 --> 01:01:18.735
We don't expect infallible bishops.
01:01:19.476 --> 01:01:22.539
So at what point do we expect infallible 70s?
01:01:23.358 --> 01:01:25.802
Does infallibility kick in when you become an apostle?
01:01:26.465 --> 01:01:34.494
Or is it reserved solely for the person who sits in the big chair at general conference in the center of the first presidency?
01:01:34.635 --> 01:01:37.797
Is it only the prophet that can't make mistakes?
01:01:38.358 --> 01:01:50.012
Because the reality is that for a prophet to be infallible, for a prophet to not make mistakes, they need to have their agency extracted from them.
01:01:50.472 --> 01:01:57.242
They no longer have can have the freedom to choose wrong if all they can do is right.
01:01:58.244 --> 01:02:01.710
And so that defeats the entire purpose of mortality.
01:02:01.730 --> 01:02:13.989
It flies in the face of every scriptural example we know about prophets, and everything we know, and the prophets themselves tell us that they are not infallible, and yet we refuse to believe them.
01:02:14.570 --> 01:02:53.489
And so with that if you say, okay, well, a prophet has never made mistakes, they are infallible, and I've given you, I can give you as long as your arm citations and references of prophets saying extraordinarily racist things, not just that black people bear the curse of Cain, but all sorts of justifications that we now completely and totally disavow as being the truth, and yet we're not And yet somehow we try to reconcile that reality with this idea, well, no, they were never wrong to begin with.
01:02:54.231 --> 01:03:04.021
If you're just going to say they were misquoted by the press for 100 years, it's just an absolutely ridiculous sort of defense for an undeniable reality.
01:03:05.923 --> 01:03:06.264
Okay.
01:03:06.525 --> 01:03:08.827
My repost to that, Jim, will be twofold.
01:03:09.128 --> 01:03:27.068
One is that if you look in the Polygraph Price, you actually hear that Pharaoh actually had a cursing And we know that Pharaoh came from the line of black ancestry, but it does not connect the cursing to a black skin.
01:03:28.851 --> 01:03:35.800
My second point will be that when Christ is talking to the prophet, I will always listen.
01:03:36.121 --> 01:03:44.452
We know that some apostles have actually fallen away, so I'll always listen with interest, but I'll actually focus my interest on the prophet when he speaks.
01:03:47.137 --> 01:03:55.547
actually looking at quotes and saying, we can look at each individual specific quotes, if you like, and actually interpret each one individually.
01:03:55.586 --> 01:04:03.173
But I'm sorry, every time I listen to your podcast, I go to the reference and I read it and I read it a different way.
01:04:03.213 --> 01:04:10.202
And it's not good enough just to say there are many quotes and there are many apostles and there are many prophets who have actually been wrong.
01:04:10.242 --> 01:04:21.132
You have to look at every individual case on its merits and actually interpret dissect that particular case and actually see whether those quotes are saying what you're alluding to.
01:04:21.152 --> 01:04:35.833
And my argument is that what you're alluding to isn't in fact what you're purporting, that in fact they're disparate, and that my actual reading of the same quotes and the same scriptures isn't the same as yours.
01:04:36.545 --> 01:04:37.708
It's fascinating.
01:04:37.967 --> 01:04:44.016
It's interesting to hear both of your different interpretations and perspectives.
01:04:44.215 --> 01:04:46.179
So I just want to kind of bring it to a bit of a higher level.
01:04:46.860 --> 01:04:52.467
So do you, Marcus, believe that prophets don't get it wrong?
01:04:52.748 --> 01:04:53.568
They don't make mistakes?
01:04:53.949 --> 01:04:54.789
Is that fair?
01:04:56.112 --> 01:05:00.478
I think there was a time where, for example, Joseph Smith said that men wouldn't get to the moon.
01:05:00.657 --> 01:05:01.920
That was clearly incorrect.
01:05:02.360 --> 01:05:06.206
When he actually publishes something in the Doctrine and Covenants, it's not wrong.
01:05:06.753 --> 01:05:07.355
Go
01:05:07.514 --> 01:05:09.177
ahead.
01:05:10.958 --> 01:05:18.447
I've had some business authorities who've come down, and I'm not prepared to mention their names, but they've said things which I thought were completely wrong.
01:05:18.467 --> 01:05:21.891
And I've actually gone up to them and had discussions afterwards.
01:05:21.972 --> 01:05:27.998
Now, I won't actually broadcast what I think about their ideas because I think they were completely and utterly wrong.
01:05:28.880 --> 01:05:39.541
But do I actually think that President Nelson would make a mistake in terms of some key doctrinal points, key tenets of our religion, the answer is categorically no.
01:05:39.581 --> 01:05:45.471
And when I have a doubt, I will actually shelve that doubt until I find out the answer.
01:05:45.510 --> 01:05:55.005
For example, I actually couldn't figure out whether bristlecone pine really was, as dendrochronology says, which is basically predating the flood.
01:05:55.565 --> 01:05:57.829
And I tried for two years to figure it out.
01:05:58.389 --> 01:06:01.233
And I sat and I sat and I sat and I couldn't figure it out.
01:06:01.634 --> 01:06:06.420
So after two years, I finally said to Emily, I said, okay, come on and give me an idea because I haven't got a clue.
01:06:06.920 --> 01:06:09.503
So the idea came to me, where is bristlecone pine?
01:06:09.543 --> 01:06:10.605
Tops of the mountains.
01:06:11.184 --> 01:06:14.068
What's the last thing that gets uncovered?
01:06:14.289 --> 01:06:15.230
Tops of the mountains.
01:06:15.329 --> 01:06:16.871
What's the first thing that gets uncovered?
01:06:17.271 --> 01:06:18.313
Tops of the mountains.
01:06:18.813 --> 01:06:21.036
Can plants survive a little while underwater?
01:06:21.117 --> 01:06:21.797
Yes, they can.
01:06:21.838 --> 01:06:28.746
I'm thinking, oh my goodness, I've had an idea within 30 seconds that it's taken me two years that I couldn't figure out.
01:06:29.057 --> 01:06:32.061
So the bottom line is, if there's a will, there's a way.
01:06:32.101 --> 01:06:39.288
And we shouldn't be looking for problems and more questions and moaning and being negative about church stuff.
01:06:39.648 --> 01:06:41.108
We should be looking for answers.
01:06:41.168 --> 01:06:42.990
And I've got two pages of stuff here.
01:06:43.030 --> 01:06:45.713
And we've gone on to one subject, Flax on the Priesthood.
01:06:46.014 --> 01:06:48.536
And I've got two pages of things that we could discuss.
01:06:48.635 --> 01:06:51.039
I could go through loads of different points.
01:06:51.179 --> 01:06:52.659
Evolution's a fascinating one.
01:06:53.260 --> 01:06:58.626
When I actually had a TV, we watched the Sharks series.
01:06:59.074 --> 01:07:03.099
and the Sharp series, basically, was coming to a brick-ground conclusion.
01:07:03.260 --> 01:07:08.067
And as it was coming to a conclusion, we were all getting excited, Helen and I, and then the TV stopped working.
01:07:08.106 --> 01:07:09.148
I thought, you've got to be kidding.
01:07:09.208 --> 01:07:12.452
I picked up the TV and shoved it outside the door, hoping someone would pick it up.
01:07:12.853 --> 01:07:20.605
We went to a TV store down the road, and there in the back of the store was my TV, looking fantastic and new.
01:07:21.286 --> 01:07:23.668
But the TV didn't become a radio.
01:07:23.688 --> 01:07:25.291
It was still a TV.
01:07:26.152 --> 01:07:26.813
So therefore...
01:07:27.969 --> 01:07:35.400
On evolution, as it talks about in the scriptures, species replicates after their own kind.
01:07:35.701 --> 01:07:43.072
When we get a problem, we have to go to the scriptures and actually try and find an answer, not try and find another problem and moan about what we can't understand.
01:07:43.552 --> 01:07:46.257
We've got to try and find answers to these problems.
01:07:46.757 --> 01:07:48.981
And so, no, I won't be negative about the church.
01:07:49.201 --> 01:07:54.309
I'll spend my life studying and trying to find answers to gospel questions.
01:07:54.708 --> 01:07:57.634
And that's why I published the book called Evolution Theorem.
01:07:58.210 --> 01:08:03.679
with two pseudonyms because I didn't want to highlight the fact that I was politically assassinated, and I put it up on Amazon.
01:08:04.101 --> 01:08:16.345
One, to let my kids know basically what Helen was like, and two, to answer gospel questions that they could pull off at four quid and basically print it off and get answers that they won't get from places which is super negative about the church.
01:08:16.805 --> 01:08:30.501
So my answer is yes, I will continue to actually oppose any of his specific quotes about blacks in the priesthood, and we can actually look at them and actually dissect them one by one by one, because that's what I've done my whole life.
01:08:31.381 --> 01:08:32.783
I appreciate you bringing this back to the back,
01:08:32.963 --> 01:08:35.167
because I want to talk about President Nelson.
01:08:35.287 --> 01:08:50.855
I want to do a sort of, we're at an hour and eight minutes, and Marcus, you've said you could go on forever, and I actually would like to go on, so I'm wondering, Ian, if we could I don't know what your schedule is like right now, but I'm happy to go on.
01:08:50.877 --> 01:08:54.725
And if we have to sort of split this into more than one episode, I'm happy to do that too.
01:08:56.307 --> 01:08:57.430
What are your schedules like?
01:08:57.511 --> 01:09:00.957
Is there a drop dead moment where we have, you guys have to go on?
01:09:01.250 --> 01:09:03.131
I have to go in like 10 minutes.
01:09:03.332 --> 01:09:09.840
I think this is a fascinating conversation and I would love to get Marcus back on if you're interested, Marcus, because I really would love to get into some of the topics.
01:09:10.581 --> 01:09:12.943
And so I appreciate that intervention there.
01:09:12.983 --> 01:09:23.836
So I do have a hard stop at about 10, 15 minutes max, which is coming up to, you know, where we usually drop off on these, you know, where we end that conversation on the podcast.
01:09:24.317 --> 01:09:25.377
But so...
01:09:25.729 --> 01:09:30.256
We've got probably 10, I've only got 10, 15 minutes, but Marcus would love to get you back on if you're interested.
01:09:31.038 --> 01:09:35.445
And so just going back to the topic of race in the priesthood, which is fascinating.
01:09:36.927 --> 01:09:42.617
What I'm hearing is that if they're going correctly from wrong, Brigham Young didn't make, did not make a mistake.
01:09:43.362 --> 01:09:53.896
he was speaking for the Lord, his ban on black soldiers and the priesthood, et cetera, of African descent, whether they were in Africa or not, et cetera, which is their choice, which they made before they came to it.
01:09:54.497 --> 01:09:55.899
Brigham Young didn't make a mistake.
01:09:56.020 --> 01:09:57.021
He didn't get it wrong.
01:09:57.202 --> 01:09:58.283
He was right at the time.
01:09:58.342 --> 01:10:02.789
Again, correct me if I'm wrong in any part of that, if I misunderstood you or misinterpreted.
01:10:03.270 --> 01:10:07.837
And also you mentioned something very interesting where the Lamanites were not black.
01:10:08.518 --> 01:10:09.520
They were suntanned.
01:10:10.661 --> 01:10:46.458
Does that, thinking extend to uh other people who are non-white are they is your perspective that black people are suntanned and not black uh naturally um you know because my understanding that the lebanites were black uh i've never heard uh the idea that they were suntanned until now so you and i are talking so could you just have two things there on this subject um Before we move on, and if we have time, I'd like to talk briefly a bit about President Nelson.
01:10:47.180 --> 01:10:52.208
We'll see where this goes in terms of a decision on the LGTBQ decisions that were made there.
01:10:52.529 --> 01:10:53.751
We may not have time to get into that.
01:10:54.131 --> 01:10:56.534
But was Brigham Young right then, essentially?
01:10:56.796 --> 01:10:58.478
It didn't make a mistake on that.
01:10:59.059 --> 01:11:03.987
And secondly, do you hold that black people are suntanned?
01:11:04.908 --> 01:11:05.729
Can you clarify that?
01:11:06.850 --> 01:11:07.511
Okay, sure.
01:11:08.332 --> 01:11:15.641
I think there's a distinction here, Ian, between people who actually came from Ham or came from Japheth.
01:11:15.662 --> 01:11:17.203
So you've got Shem, Ham and Japheth.
01:11:17.243 --> 01:11:23.311
Shem is Caucasians, Japheth is Asian, and Ham is the black race.
01:11:23.752 --> 01:11:30.001
In terms of Suntans, the Lamanites weren't Negroes, no, in that sense.
01:11:30.622 --> 01:11:35.051
And that's a historic term, by the way, when I say It's not a term we use now.
01:11:35.091 --> 01:11:36.193
I mean blacks by that.
01:11:36.313 --> 01:11:40.637
And don't forget, my daughter-in-law will be a black girl.
01:11:40.658 --> 01:11:45.184
I'm just looking at the phraseology that was used at the time.
01:11:46.586 --> 01:11:47.327
So, no.
01:11:49.829 --> 01:11:59.601
For me, the Lamanites were suntanned, but they were not from black ethnicity.
01:12:00.162 --> 01:12:04.268
So no, the two are distinct and separate.
01:12:04.747 --> 01:12:05.949
So they weren't cursed.
01:12:06.029 --> 01:12:07.492
They weren't cursed with a black skin.
01:12:07.532 --> 01:12:08.153
That's what you're saying.
01:12:09.675 --> 01:12:20.650
I'm saying that they were self-cursed by actually discarding clothing, but I'm saying that they were cursed in the same way that we have factions now.
01:12:20.690 --> 01:12:25.096
We actually have extremist groups that people will stay away from.
01:12:25.117 --> 01:12:35.998
So when when Heavenly Father says, don't mix and intermarry, it's something natural in the sense that people look at cults and they don't want to be a part of it and so they keep away from them.
01:12:36.840 --> 01:12:46.252
In the same way, Heavenly Father said to the Nephites, look, don't mix with this bunch of, this group of people because they're not being, they're not acting in a righteous way.
01:12:46.351 --> 01:12:50.037
So in that sense, that's only something which is sensible.
01:12:50.617 --> 01:12:54.301
In terms of a self, in terms of a cursing, it was a self-cursing, Ian, yeah?
01:12:54.497 --> 01:12:58.222
by just chucking the clothes off and getting deeply tanned like my father was deeply tanned.
01:12:59.204 --> 01:12:59.284
Yeah.
01:12:59.305 --> 01:13:12.864
So the self-curse was, again, if I get it right, understand it correctly, was by that group of people taking their clothes off, they were self-cursed by getting a suntan.
01:13:13.765 --> 01:13:31.137
And that means then I think that when the Lord in the Book of Mormon said that he placed the curse upon this group in terms of their skin color, That curse was a self-curse, not one that was placed by the Lord, which is what the Book of Mormon taught.
01:13:32.219 --> 01:13:43.753
You know, I've got the Book of Mormon that you gave to me when I was investigating the church, and it says, white and delightsome, not pure and delightsome as it says now, but the 1981 version talks about white and delightsome.
01:13:43.993 --> 01:13:52.145
But you're saying the Lamanites were of darker skin because of a suntan and not cursed by the Lord.
01:13:52.185 --> 01:13:53.086
Is that correct?
01:13:54.242 --> 01:14:01.030
Okay, so the cursing is not associated at any point in the scriptures with a change of skin color.
01:14:01.070 --> 01:14:01.771
They're separate.
01:14:02.353 --> 01:14:06.779
The Lord said that he cursed them, or he said that a curse was placed upon them, i.e.
01:14:06.798 --> 01:14:12.686
it was self-cursing, but there is no connection between the change of the color of the skin and the cursing.
01:14:12.726 --> 01:14:14.048
They are separate and distinct.
01:14:14.989 --> 01:14:20.457
So therefore, if people choose to throw off their clothes and get carcinomas, that's up to them.
01:14:21.826 --> 01:14:22.286
Interesting.
01:14:22.627 --> 01:14:27.471
We probably haven't got enough time to get into another big topic because we so much explore on this one.
01:14:27.851 --> 01:14:30.014
You know, we talked about polygamy, LGBTQ.
01:14:30.555 --> 01:14:32.417
I'm fascinated about your position on evolution.
01:14:32.796 --> 01:14:34.399
And we're coming up to the end of the podcast.
01:14:34.878 --> 01:14:37.322
We probably may only have time to stay on this particular topic.
01:14:37.362 --> 01:14:39.623
And there's so much more to even talk about this.
01:14:40.204 --> 01:14:42.087
Jim, what's your perspective on...
01:14:42.207 --> 01:14:45.449
What's your response to Marcus's answers to those questions?
01:14:47.212 --> 01:14:47.731
Well, I...
01:14:50.242 --> 01:14:56.029
I'm looking at it from a larger perspective here in that Marcus is the way you frame this.
01:14:56.671 --> 01:15:10.248
You said, look, I'm not going to say anything bad about the church, meaning that when we highlight the fact that church leaders have made mistakes, we are somehow attacking the church or we are somehow saying something bad about the church.
01:15:11.350 --> 01:15:27.154
Because one of the things that I've discovered as I've entered this sort of space that the people who are on the borders of the church, inside out, where they're on the edge of the inside or on the edge of the outside.
01:15:28.895 --> 01:15:40.048
You're seeing people who are leaving the church in large numbers, largely because they encounter error in our history.
01:15:40.069 --> 01:15:43.733
And then we have absolutely no tools to be able to deal with it.
01:15:44.274 --> 01:16:16.301
We look at some kind of statement and say, Most people look at these statements and take them at face value, and again, I think it's really difficult to say that every single racist statement that was made by a church leader up before 1978 has some sort of magical explanation, or didn't really happen, or can somehow be interpreted to not be racist, when the reality is, as President Uchtdorf told us in General Conference, sometimes church leaders have simply made mistakes.
01:16:16.770 --> 01:16:19.292
He did say that in October 2013.
01:16:19.893 --> 01:16:20.474
He said that.
01:16:20.713 --> 01:16:21.715
You're shaking your head.
01:16:21.734 --> 01:16:23.376
He asked...
01:16:25.819 --> 01:16:26.819
Misreading that again.
01:16:26.859 --> 01:16:32.284
President Uchtdorf said that people in leadership positions make mistakes, i.e.
01:16:32.585 --> 01:16:34.046
local leaders can make mistakes.
01:16:34.167 --> 01:16:39.391
He's not saying that the apostles or the prophets made mistakes.
01:16:39.511 --> 01:16:44.596
He's specifically saying that some leaders can make mistakes.
01:16:44.617 --> 01:16:45.457
You have to actually...
01:16:46.018 --> 01:16:50.684
make sure that what you're thinking is the same thing that he's actually tried to convey.
01:16:51.484 --> 01:16:51.864
Okay.
01:16:52.125 --> 01:16:54.528
So, again, we get to this sort of workaround.
01:16:54.568 --> 01:16:57.051
It's not a workaround.
01:16:57.192 --> 01:17:02.677
I mean, to try to take the plain meaning of what somebody says and then try to find some other definition of it.
01:17:03.158 --> 01:17:22.637
So, Marcus, before we go, I want to ask you a series of essentially yes or no questions because we don't have a lot of time and I would love to have you back because I would love to discuss evolution with you, the idea that We have to be young earth creationists, which I am not, which my great-grandfather David O.
01:17:22.658 --> 01:17:23.578
McKay was not.
01:17:24.560 --> 01:17:26.824
Sitting just a few feet away from me is David O.
01:17:26.845 --> 01:17:33.837
McKay's personal copy of Man, His Origin and Destiny, which was written by Joseph Fielding Smith, which is a screed against evolution.
01:17:34.719 --> 01:17:35.439
And David O.
01:17:35.460 --> 01:17:38.845
McKay has all kinds of marginalia there.
01:17:39.042 --> 01:17:41.323
talking about how much he disagreed with them.
01:17:41.425 --> 01:17:48.972
Because even church leaders, I mean, to say that they never make mistakes, you then have to get into the fact that they don't always agree.
01:17:49.713 --> 01:17:53.358
So they can't both be right, so one of them has to be mistaken.
01:17:53.978 --> 01:17:57.381
I mean, this is just sort of fundamentally the way human nature works.
01:17:57.481 --> 01:18:10.212
But the questions I want to ask you, yes or no, did church leaders prior to 1978 teach that black skinned, was the result of a curse.
01:18:12.413 --> 01:18:15.938
Okay, we can get into things like ecruhim, non-ecruhim, models.
01:18:16.097 --> 01:18:17.319
It's a yes or no question.
01:18:18.060 --> 01:18:19.141
It's a yes or no question.
01:18:19.743 --> 01:18:26.050
Did church leaders prior to 1978 teach that black skin was the sign of a curse?
01:18:27.211 --> 01:18:29.373
Okay, Jim, are you going to let me answer or are you going to answer for me?
01:18:30.435 --> 01:18:33.018
We can get into the answer, but it's a yes or no question.
01:18:34.145 --> 01:18:37.168
Jim, you can't tell me how to speak and I'll never be told how to speak.
01:18:37.488 --> 01:18:42.673
We can get into such things as equilibrium, non-equilibrium models, uranium, thorium, lead decay.
01:18:42.694 --> 01:18:44.695
We can get into dendrochronology.
01:18:45.077 --> 01:18:50.322
We can actually get into population bottlenecks in terms of mitochondrial DNA.
01:18:50.341 --> 01:18:57.809
I'm very happy to do that, Jim, because I have a science background and that would do just music for me to actually get into that.
01:18:58.850 --> 01:19:00.591
But I won't be told how to speak, Jim.
01:19:00.671 --> 01:19:09.872
I appreciate that you challenge me in terms of in terms of the quotes from authorities, well, I'll challenge you back and say, give me a quote and I'll interpret it.
01:19:10.193 --> 01:19:17.167
Don't actually say as a generic cause that everything that they say will be a racist
01:19:23.592 --> 01:19:44.690
comment, bring out specific quotes and we'll look at them individually.
01:19:45.391 --> 01:19:46.634
the sky is blue.
01:19:47.395 --> 01:19:49.436
Would you be able to answer that yes or no?
01:19:49.457 --> 01:19:51.800
Is the sky blue?
01:19:54.703 --> 01:19:57.167
Jim, I'll talk in the way that I wish to answer.
01:19:57.347 --> 01:19:57.948
That's fine.
01:19:58.448 --> 01:19:59.369
Is the sky blue?
01:20:00.251 --> 01:20:03.615
Because here's the reason why I'm trying to ask.
01:20:03.636 --> 01:20:11.265
The difficulty that I'm having here is that you and I do not seem to share a common set of facts.
01:20:12.289 --> 01:20:19.538
As a scientist, I'm sure you recognize how necessary it is to have an agreed upon set of facts.
01:20:19.599 --> 01:20:37.420
So if you're sitting there dealing with some kind of rational scientific thesis, and you've got somebody who comes in and says, well, I don't believe gravity is real, you all of a sudden go, well, then we can't really have a discussion because we don't share a common set of facts.
01:20:38.081 --> 01:21:03.033
And so what I'm trying to establish here is that I think it is factually undeniable that prior to 1978 and even after 1978, church materials, church leaders, and yes, presidents of the church, prophets, as well as scriptures, describe black skin as being a sign of a curse.
01:21:03.614 --> 01:21:34.029
And this was taught largely universally, and if you want to say, well, I need to look at every single one so I can figure out some way to work around it, if you don't believe, I'm not going to tell you how to speak because you don't seem to be willing to answer yes or no questions, but if you do not believe that church leaders prior to 1978 taught that black skin was a sign of a curse, then you and I do not share a common set of facts.
01:21:36.354 --> 01:21:36.935
Could you read with
01:21:37.117 --> 01:21:37.217
that?
01:21:38.421 --> 01:21:39.728
Let me answer you again.
01:21:39.747 --> 01:21:41.395
I've already said it previously.
01:21:41.414 --> 01:21:46.033
The cursings and the black skin were not connected.
01:21:46.497 --> 01:21:47.618
That's what you say.
01:21:47.640 --> 01:21:52.826
That is not what church leaders said up until 1978 and even afterward.
01:21:52.865 --> 01:22:04.542
What I'm trying to get you to recognize and acknowledge is a common set of facts, a common reality that this was, in fact, something that the church taught.
01:22:05.143 --> 01:22:16.318
And since you insist that the church leaders never teach anything wrong, you have to find some way to reinterpret plain language.
01:22:17.090 --> 01:22:21.175
in a way that flies in the face of the meaning of the words.
01:22:22.055 --> 01:22:38.198
And once again, it becomes, all right, if you want to talk about some fictional church that did not teach that black skin was the sign of a curse prior to 1978, I'm not the person to talk to because I'd never belonged to that church.
01:22:38.417 --> 01:22:44.466
I grew up in a church where I was taught personally that black people bore the curse of Cain.
01:22:45.185 --> 01:22:49.412
And I was taught that, and I was taught that it was a result of black skin.
01:22:49.492 --> 01:23:06.917
And if you want to pin that on whatever bishop told me that or whatever else told me that, I can come back and tell you that that was taught in my family for generations, a family led by a president of the church who believed that.
01:23:07.394 --> 01:23:16.046
and taught that and signed a statement in 1949 when he was a member of the first presidency that reiterated that.
01:23:16.646 --> 01:23:29.466
So if you're not willing to accept that and then you come back and say, well, I won't talk bad about the church, you're not defending the church when you are trying to create a new church.
01:23:30.082 --> 01:23:38.774
to replace the real one that taught things that we now disavow because we now acknowledge they were wrong.
01:23:38.815 --> 01:23:47.970
And so for you to say you will never criticize the church, you are refusing to stand with the church today.
01:23:48.609 --> 01:24:07.317
When the church disavows explicitly that we taught that black skin was the sign of a curse, that we taught that black people bore the curse of Cain, and if you're not willing to accept that, then maybe we don't have you back because we don't share a common set of facts.
01:24:09.154 --> 01:24:10.936
Jim, it's down to you guys.
01:24:11.037 --> 01:24:13.502
If Ian wants to be back or whatever, that's fine.
01:24:13.921 --> 01:24:15.564
It's an impasse here, Jim.
01:24:15.604 --> 01:24:17.729
At the end of the day, it's not about workarounds.
01:24:17.809 --> 01:24:18.990
We see things differently.
01:24:19.011 --> 01:24:20.774
I disagree with what you're saying.
01:24:20.793 --> 01:24:24.199
I disagree with your rationales and I disagree with your citations.
01:24:25.506 --> 01:24:26.106
But it's
01:24:26.287 --> 01:24:27.889
not a difference of opinion, Marcus.
01:24:28.009 --> 01:24:29.189
It's a difference of fact.
01:24:29.329 --> 01:24:35.438
If you say the sky is green and I say the sky is blue, one of us is right and one of us is wrong.
01:24:35.537 --> 01:24:37.840
It's not an agree to disagree situation.
01:24:38.301 --> 01:24:39.162
The sky is blue.
01:24:39.181 --> 01:24:44.328
And if you don't agree the sky is blue, we can't have a conversation about the sky.
01:24:44.368 --> 01:24:51.115
And if you don't agree that the church taught that black skin was a sign of a curse, you are wrong.
01:24:51.136 --> 01:24:52.858
And I am right.
01:24:53.377 --> 01:24:55.060
And it's not a matter of opinion.
01:24:55.079 --> 01:24:58.685
It is a matter of fundamental fact and reality.
01:24:59.926 --> 01:25:02.570
If you talk over me, Jim, it's not a conversation anymore.
01:25:02.610 --> 01:25:04.654
It's just a monologue, mate, yeah?
01:25:05.095 --> 01:25:05.836
All right, yeah.
01:25:06.896 --> 01:25:13.065
At the end of the day, I appreciate that you see things differently, and I get it, and that your background is different, but...
01:25:13.386 --> 01:25:16.010
I'm done, Ian.
01:25:17.032 --> 01:25:18.033
You can take it from me here.
01:25:18.154 --> 01:25:23.268
I'm still frustrated with the fact that that you're trying to dismiss.
01:25:24.007 --> 01:25:28.313
I mean, you can't look at the sky.
01:25:28.332 --> 01:25:30.595
I keep using the sky because it's the simplest thing.
01:25:31.154 --> 01:25:34.198
But you can't look at saying something, well, agree to disagree.
01:25:34.217 --> 01:25:35.219
I think it's green.
01:25:35.279 --> 01:25:36.000
You think it's blue.
01:25:36.039 --> 01:25:37.421
You come from a different background.
01:25:37.921 --> 01:25:38.682
One of us is right.
01:25:38.882 --> 01:25:39.684
One of us is wrong.
01:25:40.323 --> 01:25:43.927
I'm probably getting heated, and so I probably need to step back.
01:25:44.729 --> 01:25:46.770
So I'll let you finish this up, Ian.
01:25:47.131 --> 01:25:48.551
Thanks very much, Marcus, for your time.
01:25:49.913 --> 01:25:50.333
All right, Jim.
01:25:50.561 --> 01:25:57.296
do you want to just any final comments on this before we close the podcast
01:25:58.399 --> 01:26:15.063
my final comments it's been really interesting and up to the last point there where Jim is getting a bit frustrated I enjoy interacting with him but the bottom line is that is that we have to just continue to discuss things because that's the only way we'll actually make progress is my thoughts.
01:26:15.122 --> 01:26:17.445
And I really like chatting to you, mate, and it's a pleasure.
01:26:17.765 --> 01:26:19.569
And I really enjoy your questions, Ian.
01:26:19.609 --> 01:26:20.730
They're just excellent.
01:26:22.693 --> 01:26:28.701
Just to clarify, you don't, again, for the sake of our listeners, and I appreciate those last comments, I really do.
01:26:30.023 --> 01:26:33.006
You disagree entirely, it sounds like, with what Jim said.
01:26:34.909 --> 01:26:44.412
I disagree with the fact that he's trying to say the church is wrong in certain areas, and I...
01:26:45.113 --> 01:26:49.097
In this area, where the blacks were cursed, you don't accept that?
01:26:50.479 --> 01:26:51.220
Not at all, no.
01:26:51.440 --> 01:26:57.046
No, I don't agree that the black skin was actually apportioned to a person.
01:26:57.447 --> 01:26:59.789
I believe that they are distinct and separate.
01:27:00.270 --> 01:27:02.993
And it's actually very clear in the scriptures that they were, yeah.
01:27:03.713 --> 01:27:04.014
And any
01:27:04.095 --> 01:27:06.917
evidence that suggests otherwise, you just don't accept that?
01:27:07.713 --> 01:27:08.375
from any source.
01:27:09.476 --> 01:27:10.899
Somebody wants to present it to me.
01:27:10.918 --> 01:27:12.320
I'm happy to look at any evidence.
01:27:12.421 --> 01:27:14.725
I always do and have done my whole life.
01:27:14.805 --> 01:27:18.510
And science is something which I'll always re-examine again and again and again.
01:27:18.529 --> 01:27:19.712
I'm happy to see it.
01:27:20.073 --> 01:27:21.494
But Jim's got to be specific.
01:27:21.534 --> 01:27:24.659
He can't just get frustrated and say, I'm not listening.
01:27:24.699 --> 01:27:25.461
But I am listening.
01:27:26.402 --> 01:27:36.811
Yeah, what he was trying to do, and again, I'm trying to be the middle guy here between this conversation, is just ask me some yes or no questions.
01:27:36.851 --> 01:27:38.253
And we couldn't get past that.
01:27:38.554 --> 01:27:42.578
You mentioned, and we'll close here in a minute, you mentioned Elder Uchtdorf's talk in 2013.
01:27:42.597 --> 01:27:46.662
And for me personally, that was a very significant talk.
01:27:46.981 --> 01:27:55.994
When I listened to that in conference, Elder Uchtdorf, and he talked about past leaders who made mistakes, I, like you, thought he was talking about And I've shared this on the podcast.
01:27:56.055 --> 01:28:04.204
I thought he was talking about some rogue local leader, a bishop or state president who made mistakes, as they do, of course.
01:28:04.225 --> 01:28:04.865
You know that.
01:28:04.905 --> 01:28:05.447
I know that.
01:28:05.806 --> 01:28:10.573
I didn't for one second think he extended that to prophets.
01:28:10.993 --> 01:28:29.347
But in my follow-up research and conversations, what I got back from general authorities, I was on the state presence at the time, that that talk did extend to past apostles and prophets, that they made mistakes.
01:28:30.248 --> 01:28:44.988
And so, you know, I believe that prophets can, you don't believe prophets can make mistakes, I think, that they're not allowed to make mistakes or the agency is taken away and they are dictated to or told exactly what they should or shouldn't say.
01:28:45.029 --> 01:28:50.136
You know, they don't make mistakes, especially on this magnitude, like, you know, raising the priesthood, et cetera.
01:28:50.155 --> 01:29:52.458
I, you know, I don't, agree with that or believe that we have a different perspective on that but i think um you know i think this has been uh fascinating i don't think we're going to agree on you know i think if you cover our different topics like you know evolution like you talk about the earth was created 6 000 years ago and the scientific conversation around that i'm environmental sciences so i'd love to have that conversation with you the position of the church on you know lgdb GDPQ etc and the changes that has been happening around that you know the Book of Mormon translation process I'd be fascinated to you know have a conversation with you about that obviously I need to have this conversation with Jim and seeing if that we can go forward but I you know have to you know my position is and I'm saying this not to come down on anyone's side here but I like to look at the spiritual side of things, obviously, but I also like to look at the facts and what do the facts say.
01:29:52.498 --> 01:30:01.751
And I try to get this balanced approach in order to arrive at a conclusion or a position or understanding of things.
01:30:01.850 --> 01:30:05.935
I agree with you that I think this requires further discussion.
01:30:06.516 --> 01:30:16.400
But Jim and I, we've got a perspective on things and we wanted to get some clarity around these topics.
01:30:16.461 --> 01:30:24.113
And I appreciate you've got the scientific approach, but the facts, I don't think we're going to agree on some of the facts.
01:30:24.394 --> 01:30:28.239
And that's just the way it is.
01:30:28.900 --> 01:30:35.250
So I'll speak to Jim about whether or not we want to have another conversation with you and then come back to you.
01:30:35.270 --> 01:30:38.494
But I really appreciate you coming on and talking about these things.
01:30:39.256 --> 01:30:40.198
I think it's fascinating.
01:30:40.609 --> 01:30:45.698
Um, on a personal note, I want to express my love and appreciation to you.
01:30:46.340 --> 01:30:50.306
You know, you came into my life at a time when I was very unhappy.
01:30:50.327 --> 01:31:08.507
I was desperately unhappy and I felt alone and, and, um, very vulnerable, uh, young teenager and your, uh, um, influence in my life and Ellis Arthur was profound and continues to be profound.
01:31:08.768 --> 01:31:10.449
The church saved my life.
01:31:10.569 --> 01:31:17.356
I've talked about it on the podcast and I'm deeply grateful for my experience in the church and it influences my life even now.
01:31:18.037 --> 01:31:27.948
So on a personal note, I just want to say how grateful I am to you for who you are and the commitment and service that you've given and dedicated to the Lord and to the church.
01:31:29.314 --> 01:31:38.284
I think, you know, doctrinally, historically, policy-wise, I think we're going to have a, it'd be fascinating to get your perspective on those things for sure.
01:31:40.247 --> 01:31:41.788
So I just want to thank you for that.
01:31:41.889 --> 01:31:44.112
Any final thoughts or comments before we close?
01:31:45.993 --> 01:31:51.240
Yeah, Ian, you're a really good guy and I've liked listening to your podcast and I think Jim is a good guy.
01:31:51.280 --> 01:31:54.465
I think he's got lots of potential to explore different areas.
01:31:55.786 --> 01:31:58.649
I actually prefer your style because I think you're a lot calmer.
01:31:59.137 --> 01:32:03.002
And so I understand that Jim gets frustrated at times.
01:32:03.082 --> 01:32:06.284
And that's like, we're all a little bit different.
01:32:07.447 --> 01:32:10.729
I think we could go in all sorts of directions and have really good conversations.
01:32:11.371 --> 01:32:15.014
But at the end of the day, we have to realize that sometimes there are impasses.
01:32:15.054 --> 01:32:17.856
And when you reach an impasse, you just need to move on to a different
01:32:17.936 --> 01:32:18.318
topic.
01:32:19.319 --> 01:32:20.720
And I think that's a valid point.
01:32:20.739 --> 01:32:21.541
I think we're going to do here.
01:32:22.042 --> 01:32:23.483
So Marcus, thank you again.
01:32:23.523 --> 01:32:24.864
It's so great to see you.
01:32:24.925 --> 01:32:26.086
Give my love to your family.
01:32:26.753 --> 01:32:28.536
It's wonderful to connect with you.
01:32:28.555 --> 01:32:30.478
I hope we can keep connecting.
01:32:30.618 --> 01:32:34.101
And then when I come over to the UK, maybe we can get together.
01:32:34.122 --> 01:32:34.962
It'd be great to see you.
01:32:35.524 --> 01:32:39.127
It's been a long time since you and I worked together in person.
01:32:39.148 --> 01:32:39.747
I would love that.
01:32:40.488 --> 01:32:41.831
I plan to come over in the summertime.
01:32:41.970 --> 01:32:46.555
But thank you again for taking the time to be with us today.
01:32:48.318 --> 01:32:48.939
Jim, thank you.
01:32:48.979 --> 01:32:50.500
You've just left us there.
01:32:50.881 --> 01:32:51.962
Thank you for your contribution.
01:32:52.462 --> 01:32:55.426
And to our listeners, thank you for being here with us.
01:32:56.033 --> 01:33:01.324
and for your interest in the Inside Out podcast.
01:33:01.465 --> 01:33:04.371
Until next time, we wish you all well.
01:33:04.771 --> 01:33:08.921
And Marcus, thank you again for this very lively and robust conversation.
01:33:09.081 --> 01:33:09.381
Thank you.
01:33:10.744 --> 01:33:13.310
Cheers, matey.
