TRANSKRIPT 🔗
[0:05] Welcome to Trial Talk, Insights from Experience New York Trial Attorney, Michael Joseph.
[0:13] Hello everyone and welcome to Trial Talk, Insights from Legal Expert, Michael Joseph.
[0:19] Today we're joined by guest John Tate, an associate attorney with the firm who focuses
[0:24] on civil litigation including personal injury, product liability, construction, and premises
[0:30] liability cases.
[0:32] John has an extensive experience handling cases involving defective equipment, consumer
[0:36] products, and complex injury claims in both state and federal courts.
[0:40] My name's Sean O'Connor, and today we're talking about defective products and when
[0:45] manufacturers or companies can be held responsible when something goes wrong.
[0:51] John, how are you?
[0:52] Good to see you.
[0:53] Good to see you Sean.
[0:54] Thanks for having me on.
[0:56] You bet.
[0:57] So, when someone is injured by a product, what do they have to show for that situation to become
[1:03] a legal claim?
[1:04] Well, Sean, in New York, a party injured as a result of a defective product may seek relief
[1:09] against the product manufacturer or others in the distribution chain, if the defect was
[1:15] a substantial factor in causing the injury.
[1:18] A product may be defective when it is defectively designed, contains a manufacturing flaw, or
[1:24] is not accompanied by adequate warning for the use of the product.
[1:28] These are not required to prove the specific defect and proof of necessary facts and may
[1:34] be circumstantial.
[1:35] I'm playing if it needs to show that the product did not perform as intended and exclude all
[1:42] other causes for the product's failure that are not attributable to the defendant.
[1:47] Similarly, when someone is injured by a product, they may also have an implied warranty claim.
[1:53] It's not just strict liability product defect.
[1:57] To show an implied warranty claim, the plaintiff must prove that a product is not minimally
[2:02] safe.
[2:03] They must show that a product was defective, or not fit for its ordinary purpose when it
[2:08] left the defendant's possession, is being used in the purpose and the manner intended, and
[2:13] of course, the defect was a proximate cause of the plaintiff's accident.
[2:18] That's kind of key, because to show proximate causation, the plaintiff must show that the
[2:25] incident that harmed the plaintiff was a kind that ordinarily occurs as a result of
[2:30] a defective product.
[2:31] And it was not solely a result of causes other than the product defect as it existed at the
[2:38] time of sale or distribution.
[2:41] Got it.
[2:42] Are there main ways a product can be considered defective under the New York law?
[2:49] Yes.
[2:50] It's pretty universal throughout the United States.
[2:52] As federal law as well, there are three main product defect cases.
[2:56] Those are the manufacturing defect cases, the design defect cases, and of course, the failure
[3:03] to warn.
[3:04] A manufacturing defect is, when the product does not live up to the expectations or the designs
[3:12] of the manufacturer, it's predicated on a defect within the manufacturing of the product
[3:19] itself.
[3:20] The plaintiff must show that the product did not perform as intended, and that the defect
[3:25] was there when it was purchased by the plaintiff.
[3:30] As explained by the New York course, manufacturing defects by definition are imperfections that
[3:36] just inevitably occur in a very small percentage of products given the design and the result
[3:43] of the fallibility of the manufacturing process.
[3:47] We expect for every product made that one or two will flip to the cracks and there will
[3:51] be a defect.
[3:54] Defectively manufactured product does not conform in some significant aspect to the intended
[3:59] design.
[4:00] That's also okay because every product can come off the line slightly different.
[4:04] That doesn't make it a manufacturing defect.
[4:07] It has to be significant to the intended design.
[4:12] The second one I mentioned, of course, was the design defect.
[4:15] That's when a manufacturer is responsible for the purposeful design choices.
[4:22] Any design that presents an unreasonable danger to the user can open that manufacturer
[4:27] and others up to a design defect claim.
[4:31] That responsibility derives from the manufacturer's superior position to anticipate the reasonable
[4:36] uses of its products and its obligations to design a product that is not harmful when
[4:42] used in the manner intended.
[4:44] For a player to show that, you must show that the product was not reasonably safe.
[4:50] If a reasonable person would conclude that the utility of the product did not outweigh
[4:55] the risk inherent in marketing a product designed in that manner.
[5:00] This is kind of key issues.
[5:01] You see here the word reasonable a lot and it's up to a jury.
[5:05] Is it reasonably safe?
[5:07] If a reasonable person would conclude the utility does not outweigh the risk.
[5:13] All products have risks, all products have utilities.
[5:16] It's a balancing factor that's done by the finder of fact.
[5:21] The third category we talked about, or I mentioned I should say, is a failure to warn.
[5:25] Under New York law, failure to warn claim arises when a manufacturer or seller fails to provide
[5:31] adequate warnings or instructions about the foreseeable risks associated with a product's
[5:37] use.
[5:38] The warning must be clearly visible, understandable, and adequately described the risks.
[5:43] You can't just list what the risks may be.
[5:46] You have to describe them so a person of reasonable intelligence could understand the implications
[5:52] of those risks.
[5:53] This can apply to any number of products, machineries, tools, sports equipment, medicines and chemicals
[6:01] we all know.
[6:02] Even food at a grocery store requires adequate warnings.
[6:11] And of course, it's strict
Load full transcript
liability theory, so the plaintiff must have proved the product
[6:14] was not reasonably safe because of missing or inadequate warnings.
[6:19] So when we talk about liability and who can be held responsible for in a defective product
[6:27] case, I mean, of course, it's like, well, the manufacturer would be held responsible.
[6:32] Are there other parties who could be held responsible for in this kind of a case?
[6:36] Absolutely.
[6:37] Absolutely.
[6:38] Anyone in the line of distribution.
[6:40] So as you mentioned, it's manufacturers and even component part manufacturers.
[6:46] Many products will have various parts made up by different manufacturers.
[6:52] So even component part manufacturers, the wholesaler, the distributor, the retailer where
[6:58] you go and you purchase it from, they're all on the hook for a product defect.
[7:03] New York legislature, they put the burden of a defective product, not on the consumer,
[7:09] but rather on those best to absorb the societal cost of defective products.
[7:14] And those with the ability to best prevent a defective product from entering the market in
[7:18] the first place.
[7:19] In this case, that's literally everyone from soup to nuts, from part manufacturer to manufacturer
[7:26] all the way up to the guy in the deli selling you the product.
[7:30] Yeah.
[7:31] Yeah, the chain of possession there.
[7:33] Exactly.
[7:34] You mentioned, John, a few, you know, several different categories of products.
[7:40] I'm guessing that there might be certain products that you see most often lead to these kinds
[7:46] of serious injury claims.
[7:48] You know, it's so varied.
[7:50] There is no one type of product that leads to injury claims.
[7:56] Most of my career was doing product liability, you know, work in the firearm industry and people
[8:02] would think, well, firearms, you know, you would think there'd be a lot of defects and it's
[8:05] not.
[8:06] People get injured, but it's not because of a defective product.
[8:10] The serious injuries can come from anything.
[8:12] It could be coming from heavy industry machinery, which is often what we think of someone losing
[8:16] an arm and a trash compactor motor vehicles, of course, right, defect in a motor vehicle.
[8:23] We can see easily how that would cause serious injuries, but it can be household appliances.
[8:29] And even like as I said earlier, even food products purchased at your supermarket, people
[8:33] don't realize if there's something wrong in that food or, you know, has ingredients, not
[8:38] as is labels, people can be seriously injured if they have allergic reactions.
[8:41] And we see that as well.
[8:42] It's really, there's no one product that drives, you know, the legal jurisdiction of product
[8:51] defect in New York.
[8:52] Got it.
[8:53] Got it.
[8:54] So, from a, I don't know, sort of a trying the case, kind of a practical perspective, I'm
[9:00] wondering, you know, the sort of challenges they're going to come up,
you know, when you're
[9:05] trying to prove something, you know, and provide, you know, proponderance of evidence, whatever
[9:09] the standard might be.
[9:10] You know, what kinds of evidence are most important when you're building this kind of product
[9:16] liability case?
[9:17] Because I imagine you're up against some pretty well-funded opponents.
[9:22] Yeah, well-funded and well-experienced certainly the defense bar has their, you know, their
[9:28] firms that specialize in product liability defense and a lot of them are associated with
[9:32] the products.
[9:33] Like Ford has their guys and, you know, Toyota has their guys and girls and they're out there
[9:38] fighting every day.
[9:39] These issues, yeah, there's a lot of challenges and basically the first thing you have to do
[9:45] to address the challenges is determine what type of defect it is, right?
[9:49] Is it a manufacturing defect?
[9:51] Is it a design defect?
[9:52] Oftentimes it's both.
[9:54] When the design calls for, let's say, an aluminum piece that shouldn't be in there because
[10:00] of the stress on it, well, the piece failed so it's manufacturing, it's also a design because
[10:06] it shouldn't have been in there begin with.
[10:08] From there, you have to begin building your case.
[10:10] Once you kind of figure out where the defect is and that's performing product testing and
[10:15] retaining and engaging with experts, causation is always an important issue, particularly
[10:21] where a finished product may have a number of components from different manufacturers and
[10:27] where the defect itself may be a piece of the product but not the entire product or the
[10:33] overall design of the product in the way the parts are integrated may be the cause of
[10:38] the defect.
[10:39] So you've got to figure out the causation.
[10:41] Another challenge is when the product changed hands after it's original sale.
[10:45] Platinum flush show that the product was defective at the time of sale and not from any changes
[10:50] after the sale or any modifications after the sale and you may use a car and you bring it
[10:55] to your mechanic and he does this and she does that and suddenly it's maybe a challenge
[11:01] to show that that part was the original part and of course one of the things people forget
[11:07] is there usually a lot of defendants with cross claims against each other.
[11:11] Everyone in the distribution chain is responsible and where the product is complex and there
[11:15] are usually a number of part manufacturers involved in the final product.
[11:20] So you get a lot of finger pointing amongst the defendants.
[11:24] As an experienced product liability attorney, you've got to work your way through those
[11:28] and go down all those rabbit holes and really uncover what the truth is.
[11:33] These lawsuits have often last many years and it really takes and experience product liability
[11:39] attorney to uncover the different part manufacturers,
the distributions, particularly when you
[11:45] have international distributions and you've got to work through those competing claims.
[11:49] Those are some of the challenges you see with a product liability case that you don't
[11:53] see in other cases.
[11:55] Yeah, that makes it pretty complex.
[11:58] What about, I mean, even doing this for years, have you seen situations where product appeared
[12:02] to be safe but later turned down to have a serious defect and I think this is probably separate
[12:07] from manufacturer recalls, which are obviously publicized and then taking the right steps.
[12:15] Sure, of course, when a consumer purchases a product, they don't usually see a defect.
[12:25] And as you mentioned with the vehicle recalls, I'll take you on that, you'll see if you have
[12:29] a vehicle, you know, you get these recall notices two or three years after the fact they
[12:33] say, come in, you know, we need to change this part.
[12:36] It might not be a danger.
[12:37] It might be a leak here.
[12:38] It might be that and that's something that they've only discovered years later after millions
[12:42] of cars have been sold.
[12:45] And so yeah, these defects do appear later.
[12:48] Or maybe, I mean, they may have discovered that the recall may have been initiated because
[12:55] of all of the claims against them.
[12:57] Is that a scenario where it's like, oh, we've got
[13:00] a defect problem here, we've got to get ahead of it.
[13:04] It absolutely does, of course, of course.
[13:06] And that's, you know, the risk adverse and there's a money involved in defending these
[13:10] and when they lose, they're going to say, hey, what's it cost to replace a 30 cent part?
[13:15] Even if it's only affected 10% of the cars, let's go ahead and do that.
[13:18] We're going to save money in the long run, you know, and, you know, it used to be where
[13:23] you get to recall the car companies.
[13:25] You brought that up, they felt that as a negative.
[13:27] They would think, oh, it's recalled and they lose their value, although the industry
[13:33] or really the consumer industry has kind of changed our perceptions of that.
[13:37] I guess they got so used to, you know, computer programs upgrading and updating every, they
[13:43] kind of accepted the fact that cars, you buy your car now, it's going to need to be updated
[13:48] just like you're, you know, you know, you know, man, a brand new car today is basically
[13:53] a computer on wheels.
[13:55] Oh, it really is.
[13:57] You know, let's talk damages with, you know, at the time we have, what types of damages
[14:01] can someone pursue after being injured by a defective product?
[14:05] All right.
[14:05] So in New York, if a product is found effective and approximately caused the injury, then plans
[14:10] can see compensation for economic and non-economic damages.
[14:15] And, you know, economic damages is the money out of your pocket, right?
[14:19] Whether you had medical bills, you had to pay, whether it's, you know, money you had to
[14:23] spend those are your economic damages.
[14:25] If you lost wages because you're at work, those are economic damages.
[14:29] Those are, we call them blackboard numbers.
[14:32] When you're in front of a jury, you like to put down the blackboard numbers, juries understand
[14:36] blackboard numbers, they can see the number, they can come to a conclusion.
[14:40] The other, other portion damages you can recover are non-economic losses.
[14:45] What we call pain and suffering and, you know, and that's, that's a whole other procedure
[14:51] trying to convince a jury and to explain to them what your pain and suffering is, is, and
[14:56] then for them to put that into a dollar figure.
[14:59] So you get your economic damages and you get your, your, your non-economic damages.
[15:03] Now in New York, punitive damages for product defects can be awarded.
[15:09] It's very rare.
[15:11] They are awarded only when a defendant's conduct is found to be reckless, wanton, willful,
[15:18] or that the defendant showed a conscious disregard for public safety.
[15:23] Yeah, these damages, they go beyond just compensating the victim.
[15:28] You know, they're designed for punishment, punish the manufacturers for their acts.
[15:32] They're rare, but they are available.
[15:35] Mm-hmm.
[15:36] I see.
[15:37] You know, with the time we have left, let's, I want to, you know, take it down to more of a,
[15:40] I don't know, it's like practical level, but in a way, right?
[15:43] We've got people listening out there and, you know, maybe they've been, maybe they believe
[15:48] they've been injured, you know, as a result of, of a product they've used or purchased.
[15:55] What should they do early on to protect their rights?
[15:57] You know, I talk to attorneys that deal in personal injury and, you know, automotive accidents
[16:02] and there's, you know, there's a list of like, do this, do this, do this, don't do that,
[16:06] don't do this, don't do that.
[16:07] What would your list be, short list, you know, for someone listening that thinks they might
[16:12] have a, a claim?
[16:13] Yeah, there's no real short list.
[16:15] One is, I'm going to say probably what every attorney has told you, it's a quality experience
[16:19] product liability attorney because they can understand, you know, right off the bat what you need
[16:25] to do, what the product is, I have products that need refrigeration.
[16:29] We get them stored.
[16:30] I, you know, a lot of times we can go and get, you know, pre-trial work, pre-trial subpoenas
[16:35] to secure evidence.
[16:37] If it's a product you have in your house, you want to obviously preserve that product in
[16:41] the same condition that it was when it caused the injury.
[16:45] Don't take it apart, don't try to, you know, take your screwdriver and figure out what went
[16:49] wrong.
[16:50] Don't touch it, preserve it, you know, take any photos or documentation that you have, preserve
[16:56] those.
[16:57] But really, you want representation right away because that evidence is critical.
[17:03] If you change the evidence before the other side has noticed and the ability to inspect
[17:10] it, then there's not much you can do after that.
[17:13] Got it.
[17:14] Yeah, you want to, like we see on TV, you want to, you want to make sure that the evidence
[17:19] can't be impeached for, you know, well, they took it apart, maybe they caused the, it's
[17:24] like a crime scene.
[17:25] Don't touch it.
[17:27] Listen, great to talk to you, John, we're pretty much out of time here.
[17:31] So we'll wrap it up, but I know we'll talk again in the, in the near future.
[17:35] All right.
[17:36] Looking forward to it.
[17:37] All right.
[17:38] So for today's episode of trial talk insights from legal expert Michael Joseph, if you are
[17:44] someone you know has been injured by an effective product, visit the website New York trial lawyers.org
[17:52] to learn more about your legal options and connect with the team, including John.
[17:56] Thanks for listening and don't forget to subscribe, share, maybe leave a review so more people
[18:01] can find the information they need.
[18:03] Have a great day.
[18:11] Thanks for watching.
[18:12] Be sure to hit that like and subscribe button and leave us a review in the comments.