TRANSKRIPT 🔗
00:00:10
Speaker 1: Welcome to the Therapy for Black Girls podcast, a weekly conversation about mental health, personal development, and all the small decisions we can make to become the best possible versions of ourselves. I'm your host, Dr. Joy Harden-Bradford, a licensed psychologist in Atlanta, Georgia. For more information or to find a therapist in your area, visit our website at therapyforblackgirls.com. While I hope you love listening to and learning from the podcast, it is not meant to be a substitute for a relationship with a licensed mental health professional. Hey, y'all. Thanks so much for joining me for session 490 of the Therapy for Black Girls podcast. Today, I'm sitting down with Dr. Shaniqua Borns to talk about religious psychosis. We'll get right into our conversation after a word from our sponsors. If you've spent any time on social media lately, you've probably seen the term religious psychosis, used to describe everything from extreme religious beliefs to spiritual abuse. But what does it actually mean? Today, we're exploring the growing conversation around the term sitting at the cross section of faith spirituality, and mental health. How do we distinguish between deeply held religious beliefs and symptoms of a mental health condition? To help us unpack this from a clinical perspective, I'm joined by Dr. Shaniqua Borns, a scholar, theologian, and clinical psychologist whose work explores the intersections of psychology, theology, and healing. In our conversation, Dr. Borns helps us understand the ways religion can serve as a protective factor for our mental health while also examining how certain beliefs within faith communities can become harmful. We discuss spiritual bypassing, the importance of cultural competency when treating people whose experiences are rooted in faith, and why therapists and clergy need to work together more intentionally. If you've ever struggled to reconcile your mental health needs with your spiritual beliefs, this conversation offers some important perspective. Press play and let's get into the conversation. Thank you so much for joining me today, Dr. Shaniqua.
00:02:37
Speaker 2: Yeah, I'm glad to be here. Thanks for the invitation.
00:02:40
Speaker 1: Yeah, I'm very excited to chat with you. So this is a conversation we've been wanting to have for some time because I am sure you have seen this. There is a lot of use of the term religious psychosis online. Like you're seeing it everywhere and people are using it to describe everything from like extreme religiosity to spiritual abuse. So from a clinical perspective, what are we talking about when we talk about psychosis?
00:03:03
Speaker 2: So psychosis usually has to do with beliefs like delusions, hallucinations, things that people experience that other people don't experience. And then with religious psychosis, those delusions and hallucinations have like religious or spiritual themes. So it can be like hearing voices. It can be believing that
Load full transcript
you're a prophet, right? Believing that you are maybe like the reincarnation of Jesus or something like that. That's the examples of what we're talking about.
00:03:33
Speaker 1: Got it. And is there anything that's concerning to you about the way the term is being used online?
00:03:39
Speaker 2: Yes. I mean, I think there's concerns about the ways that a lot of people use psychological terms online, right? There's a way in which people hear terms and then try to weaponize them against other people. And I think that's part of what's happening. I think the conversation is around religious psychosis is important, but people are often using it in ways that is really not about religious psychosis. It's about harmful religious beliefs. It's about their own ideas about religion broadly, and not necessarily about somebody who really is suffering from a psychological disorder.
00:04:15
Speaker 1: So something else I'd love to hear your thoughts about, and I know you write a lot about this, is the protective ways that spirituality can kind of show up in our mental health, but also the ways that Christianity and other spiritual practices may be harmful. Can you talk about the ways that it is both protective and sometimes harmful?
00:04:33
Speaker 2: Yeah. I mean, there's a large body of research showing that people who are religious and who are involved So they attend church or synagogue, a mosque, a temple, a sangha, whatever, that people tend to have deeper social relationships. They tend to have greater levels of happiness and life satisfaction. And actually, religion has been linked with social mobility, right, that there's a way in which it helps people to do better in life. Not all the time, obviously, but in general, those are the trends. So there are a lot of ways in which religion provides a sense of meaning. It provides social support. It provides a sense of community. It can help people to make sense of and cope with difficult life circumstances for many people of color. I think about the descendants of enslaved Africans, for example, that religious beliefs were a way that people managed to survive. really horrific circumstances, right? But then on the other hand, there are ways in which religion can interfere with our mental health. Sometimes people who are religious are less likely to acknowledge symptoms of psychological disturbance, right? Depression, right? Anxiety. So things can kind of get dismissed as that's not really a problem. You just need to pray. more. It becomes a barrier to treatment sometimes. Sometimes people have religious beliefs that may or may not be part of the core doctrine of a religion that end up interfering their life. The idea that everything is outside of their control, that they have to be passive and wait for things to happen to them, that they have to put up with abuse or other types of mistreatment because it is sort of God's will for their life. Those are some of the ways in which religion can, on the one hand, be protective, and on the other hand, it can sometimes be harmful.
00:06:42
Speaker 1: Yeah, you know, and I'm curious, Dr. Shaniko, because there's been lots of conversations around how specifically the Black church has changed kind of historically, right? And in some ways that may be positive, but also some things that I think people feel like they've lost, right? So thinking about how the Black church is often historically has been seen as like the center of the community. And like, that's where political messaging got sent out. And it's where like kids learn how to manage social anxiety because you were given Easter speeches and all of these things that I think were very protective and like helpful for the community. But it doesn't feel like the church necessarily exists in that same way. Can you talk about like the impact that that has had maybe on mental health?
00:07:21
Speaker 2: Yeah, I think about this from a real personal perspective. I grew up in church and I'm a minister and but I'm in many ways a pastor without a congregation. I have not been in church for a number of years since my last leadership position. And my son has grown up largely outside of the church. Many of the kids in my family in his generation are growing up outside of the church or they're sort of church adjacent. They go to some stuff sometimes, right? And I've noticed what I feel like is a sense of lack. One is that One of the things that the church did was that it gave us a sense of a community and a support network outside of our family, right? It helped us belong to a community that was bigger than our people. And that did a lot in terms of our social skill development, in terms of our ability to be able to form relationships with other people. We had role models in other people. The first psychologist I ever saw was in my church.
00:08:19
Speaker 1: Right?
00:08:20
Speaker 2: And it was like a really big deal. It was like, here's a Black woman who's a psychologist. And I was like, ooh, I want to be like her when I grow up, right? And so it gave me role models. There were those things that some of us might look back now as, oh, we hated that. But those Easter speeches, the being in a choir, being in a Sunday school class where we were on the spot and we had to answer questions, we were actually getting public speaking training, right? We were getting training in how to serve. Maybe you were on the junior usher board or you're in the choir or something like that, and you've got a leadership position, right? We were actually learning a lot of things through that. And then the church was a place of organizing, political organization, political education, health education. The number of churches who would bring people in to talk to us about different health issues or that will have a health fair. So there are a lot of things that the Black church has done and really continues to do in some ways that I think we lose out on when the church sort of loses its
power in the world. So yeah, those are some of the things that I know personally, I feel a sense of loss as the number of younger generations, I think really Gen X and younger, are drifting further and further away from the church and often for good reason, but there's still a loss that comes with that.
00:09:45
Speaker 1: So I want to hear more about maybe how this psychologist that you saw in your church kind of shaped your career, because I mean, that kind of feels like what you've done, right? Like blending the worlds of clinical care and faith. So what drew you to that beyond maybe this experience? with the role model in your church?
00:10:02
Speaker 2: Yeah. So I don't know when I decided that I wanted to be a psychologist. My mom traces it back to when I was in middle or high school. I think it came out of, in part, from my church. I learned. So I went to a historically Black Baptist church that was very much involved in the community very much politically savvy, right? When you think of kind of the, you know, people talk about in the civil rights movement, there was really only a small number of churches or pastors that were involved in the movement. Well, my pastor was one of those. And so I was used to this idea that one of the responsibilities of Christians is to give back to the community and it is to help people who might be less fortunate. And that was in a church that was primarily a working class community. There was some sense of that part of our responsibility was to go out and help people and make the world a better place than we found it. And I, in particular, had a real passion for children who were hurting. And I don't know how I thought of a therapist as something that I decided I wanted to be. But I do believe it was the fact that Dr. Margaret Weaver was. was part of my church. And I would see this woman, and she may have been the first PhD in our congregation. And so she was often lifted up. And even in a church that didn't believe in women in ordained leadership, there was something about the way my pastor talked about Dr. Weaver, the way that he deeply respected her. And I would just watch her and be like, yeah, that's I want to do that. Right. I think psychology is the thing I want to do. And so, yeah, I went to college sort of knowing that I wanted to feel this call to help people. And then psychology was the way that I thought I could do that. And that was all because I came from a church that told me that was my responsibility in life.
00:12:03
Speaker 1: And how has the profession maybe kind of supported you in the blending? Because it doesn't always, right? Like sometimes seen as a very niche kind of thing to like blend spirituality and faith with science and psychology. So how do you feel like you've been supported by the field to blend these things?
00:12:20
Speaker 2: You know, I think it's getting better, but honestly, it's something I've had to do on my own. Psychology has often been hostile towards religions. And in my graduate program, when I went to graduate school, my advisor was an atheist. He never tried to belittle my religious beliefs, but there was also a way in which I could not talk about my religious beliefs in the context of my training. So we often talk about the stigma that churches have against mental health and the ways that churches can be barriers to mental health. But there's also the stigma that the therapy professions often have about religion. And so like many therapists, what I learned was that religion was something that we should respect by keeping a distance from it, right? Just like hold it out there. We're not really going to talk about that. If people brought it up, we were supposed to be like, nod respectfully and then move on, right? I remember having... brown bag like seminars and graduate programs, both as a student and then in the early part of my career when I was teaching in psychology. And people would talk about clients who wanted their therapist to be a Christian or a person from the same faith as them. And they would challenge that and say, why is that important to you? And that shouldn't be important to you. What's important is my skill. And I remember thinking we wouldn't really do that with any other form of identity if a person said, I really feel like I need a female therapist, or I really feel like I need an African-American therapist. We actually generally try to respect that, right? But then when it comes to religion, there's this sense of that's not important. So a lot of the work that I've had to do of integrating the two, I really had to figure out on my own. After a few years as a psychology professor, I ended up leaving and going back to school, to seminary. And then from then on, I've been a seminary professor teaching pastoral care, which is a sort of blending of psychology and theology. But I was making it up as I was going along. And I really think for the first few years in my career as a seminary professor, I was really functioning more like a psychologist, like I was just kind of playing a theologian. And then over time, it became more natural to me as I figured out ways incorporating it. But yeah, a lot of us really figure it out on our own. We don't feel really supported by either psychology or theology as feels when we try to do this integrative work.
00:14:59
Speaker 1: More from our conversation after the break. Our conversations here are just the start. Therapy for Black Girls also connects you to care in your own community. As the year winds down, a lot of us start thinking about what we want to feel in the new year. If finding a therapist is on your list, start at the Therapy for Black Girls directory, where over 5,000 Black women practitioners are ready to connect. Search at therapyforblackgirls.com. And therapists, this is a great time to make sure you're listed and your profile is ready for the new year. Join us at therapyforblackgirls.com slash start hyphen here.
Something that you mentioned earlier, Dr. Shiniko, is that sometimes like the psychosis shows up because people will hold beliefs that are like beyond the core tenets of a religion. So it feels like there could be a fine line, right? Like, well, how do we distinguish between something that is a religious belief versus psychosis?
00:15:58
Speaker 2: Yeah, that's so tricky because the reality is Every religion probably has something of the fantastical, the unbelievable, something that stretches the beliefs or the logic, particularly of people who are outside of that, right? So there are things we say in Christianity that on the surface of it probably sound mad, right? Outside of Christianity. So part of it is you have to judge religious psychosis from the standpoint of of the belief system, like within the belief system. And this is in the case of a sort of accepted, right, belief system. So the tricky thing about religion is like, there's also a fine line between a religion and a cult, right? It's a very fine line. And so trying to figure out what is actually normal belief within this religion, is the religion itself widespread? Because sometimes a matter of a delusion is how many people believe it. There are some religions, Christianity is one of them, that at the beginning, the followers would have been seen as really delusional, right? And then it became mainstream. And so now it's okay, right? And so sometimes it can be very difficult to judge what is a matter of psychosis versus what is normal belief. But part of it is understanding What is the accepted doctrine within not just the religion as a whole, but within the particular faith community that that person came from, right? Do the other people in their congregation believe this? Is this what they've been taught? Now, people could have been taught this in their congregation and it could still be psychosis, right? We're actually living in a time now where a lot of people have beliefs that seem really crazy to us, right? And there are like millions of people that are adopting a worldview that seems really steeped in some delusional, illogical thinking. And many of the rest of us are watching this feeling helpless. It makes it even muddier to figure out, but part of it is understanding what's the tradition, what's the history of the tradition, how has this evolved? What is the particular tradition congregation that this person came up in, the particular faith community that this person came up in, what were they taught there? How do their beliefs coincide with what they were taught and how much do their beliefs and their behaviors go beyond what is taught? And then of course, the big one for us as psychologists is how is it affecting them in the They can't function well in terms of their relationships, in terms of their work, in terms of their schooling, their health. Then we begin to say, OK, this is a problem.
00:19:03
Speaker 1: And so it feels like this kind of is an overlap of what you just talked about in terms of, you know, like clients coming in saying, I want a clinician of a particular faith background. it feels like this is a conversation around like cultural competency, right? Because if I have a client who comes to me with these kinds of concerns and maybe I don't share this faith background, how will I know if this is something that is kind of standard practice for the faith group or is this beyond that, right? And so can you talk about like maybe what like a treatment team might look like where like a therapist has to bring in maybe like a faith leader or a psychiatrist, like what does maybe a treatment team look like when you're maybe trying to make an assessment about Is this actually something that is like clinical concern or is this like a faith doctrine kind of thing?
00:19:47
Speaker 2: Yeah. And sometimes there's an overlap sometimes. the faith doctrine becomes the clinical concern, right? That you can't, it's hard to tease them apart. You actually can't treat the person without addressing the religious beliefs, right? So I think about a couple of cases, some that are mine, some that aren't, but like cases I've trained on. I remember an internship, There was a case where a person had an issue of paralysis. There was no medical reason for the paralysis. But the person was from the Caribbean, I think Haitian in particular. And they said essentially somebody put a root on me. Right. They were like, I pissed somebody off and somebody put a root on me. And that's why they were paralyzed. And they brought in all kinds of mental health professionals. trying to convince this person that they were fine, right? There's nothing wrong with you. You can move. You just kind of let this go. And that didn't work. And there turned out to be a Haitian psychiatrist on staff. And he said, oh, I know what to do, right? And he goes into the community and he finds a spiritual leader within the community, a Haitian spiritual leader who essentially, you know, he said, I went and found a witch doctor. And I brought that person into the hospital and I said, help him, right? He said that person performed a ceremony and the guy got up and walked, right? So we can label that a lot of things, but it worked, right? So within that person's belief system, that ended up being the effective treatment. And so you have to let, at that point, you just say, okay, you do what works. So you have to have somebody who understands the community. Sometimes it's more like the assessment part, right? It's about knowing that, Again, that fine line. And I think you need people who have both the psychological and the spiritual aspect, right? I've had students, I once had a student who had been diagnosed as schizophrenic. And some of the things that he would say in class, I would say, no, that doesn't sound like what the rest of us are talking about, right? That is not healthy. And in that person's case, I didn't actually think it was healthy for him to be in
seminary. Right. Because it didn't seem like his schizophrenia was well managed or I couldn't even tell if he was under the care of a mental health team and that they knew he was in seminary and that they could help him discern like the distinctions between when are we using religious language in a way that is symbolic or figurative? And what does he take literally? When we're talking about the body and blood of Christ, what is he hearing versus what am I hearing? There were some things like that that really bothered me. So I think you really have to have on your team somebody who knows both. They understand what delusions, hallucinations are. They understand the seriousness of symptoms. They're not tempted to do spiritual bypassing. They see it and they're like, wait a minute, I see something going on. We need to take this seriously. And then they have enough skillfulness and knowledge in the religious realm that they can say, this is normal within that worldview. This is not, right? This was within the range of belief. It's consistent. Like I can even tell you what denominations think this way and teach this way versus this is not consistent with any denomination that that person has been affiliated with. And so you need someone who really can do both.
00:23:27
Speaker 1: So you brought up another term that I feel like I've seen lots of people talk about online, spiritual bypassing. So what does that mean? And like, how is this a part of the conversation?
00:23:36
Speaker 2: Yeah. So spiritual bypassing is a way in which people use spirituality to dismiss, minimize behaviors, right? Or problematic behaviors in particular. So sort of a classic spiritual bypass in the Christian world is God still working on me, right? Like when someone tries to like hold somebody accountable and they're like, well, God knows my heart, right? Like rather than owning up to it, they just kind of say, well, nobody's perfect, right? Or we've heard it recently in the whole conversation with Cheyenne Bryant and being like, I only have to answer to God. So spiritual bypassing is often used as a way to avoid accountability for one's behavior, right? Is I'm going to throw this off on God. I'm going to excuse this away by somehow putting this on the divine, right? That's in a nutshell, kind of what spiritual bypassing is. So very often people will do that around mental health, right? They'll say, well, really that person needs to pray more that that could be a form of of spiritual bypassing that it prevents people from getting the treatment that they need. But you can also sort of over-spiritualize what are really mental health issues to say, well, you know, that person, their relationship with God isn't right, or if only they would do this more, or it's okay if they have destroyed all their relationships because God is still working on them or those types of things, or it's okay if I harmed you. Because it was really, it wasn't me that did it, right? There must have been some force within me that made me do that to you. And so it wasn't really me. A lot of those are examples of the bypassing is about bypassing responsibility and accountability and using spirituality to do it. So what does it look.
00:25:37
Speaker 1: Like to work with a client then who comes in with those kinds of beliefs, right? I mean, because as therapists, like a lot of our training is to be respectful of like what clients bring in, right? Especially as it relates to faith and spirituality. So what does it look like to be able to challenge some of those things that may actually be harming people's mental health?
00:25:54
Speaker 2: Yeah. So I know in my experience, what I found is that often what will happen is people will kind of do spiritual bypassing and they will use certain scriptures to support what they're doing, right? And one way that you can challenge that is, again, working within the religion. So sometimes it's been saying, oh, okay, so we're talking about this particular scripture. Did you actually understand in the context? Let's look at it. It actually means this, right? And so where they are using the scripture in ways that aren't consistent with what it means, right? What we talk about as being good exegesis, like reading the text in its context, in its historical context as well, in cultural context. So you try to figure out if there's a way there. Sometimes though, because some of our belief systems, particularly Christianity, have things in it that are contradictory, right? And so this can actually be helpful because somebody can bring up one scripture and they may be evoking a scripture that their interpretation is actually leading to their suffering, right? It's actually helping you to suffer. And so then it's like, you know what? That is a scripture. Here's another one, right? There's this other scripture over here that says something very different. Now, which one do you feel like helps you more? Can you find, or can you think of another scripture that, That actually contradicts the one you just used that has you locked into this really unhealthy way of being. Is there something else that you might see? Is there a figure in scripture that helps you to think about your freedom, your liberation, your happiness, your thriving as being something that God wants for you, right? Is there something you can see where somebody actually leaves a bad relationship in scripture, right? Can we find examples of that too? So that's one of the ways where, again, it helps to know the tradition because then you can acknowledge, you're right. It does say that about divorce. And then it also says this, right? And so how are you going to work with that? What does that mean to you? What does it mean for you to hear that there are other possibilities with their scripture and other ways of interpreting the scriptures in a way that help your flourishing? So those are some of the ways that you can challenge those beliefs.
00:28:24
Speaker 1: I
want to hear more, Dr. Chenico, because I know a lot of your writing especially is kind of geared towards Black women. And there are often a lot of messages, I think, in Christianity that kind of reinforces kind of long-suffering woman beliefs.
00:28:38
Speaker 2: Kind of thing.
00:28:38
Speaker 1: Can you talk maybe about some of the messages in Christianity that do what you're talking about, right? That can kind of reinforce this idea of suffering and like not taking care of yourself or not prioritizing yourself.
00:28:49
Speaker 2: Yeah. So this is something that women, I think, especially Black women get handed a lot. There are certain terms. I won't even call them scriptures because they're not really often, but there are certain phrases that I only hear from Black women. And a good one is God won't give you more than you can bear. Or another, if he brought you to it, he'll bring you through it, right? A lot of those are sayings that are meant to explain suffering, but also meant in a way to help us to be okay with suffering, right? And so very often I'll see, I've seen women who've been in jobs that were really unhealthy for them. Like categorically, unhealthy psychologically, physically, in every way, but then they would say things like, well, God hasn't told me to leave. Right. I have to stay here because God hasn't told.
00:29:47
Speaker 1: Me to leave.
00:29:48
Speaker 2: And, you know, and the way I often challenge that is what exactly are you looking for from God? Right. Because your blood pressure is telling you to leave. right? Your chronic pain is telling you to leave, right? There are other things that are telling you to leave. What exactly are you looking for? And why do you think that God wants that much control over your life, right? And I find it really interesting because I've noticed I never ever hear men say that, right? Even male pastors, they won't be like, well, I have this other opportunity over here, but I can't take it because God hasn't told me to leave. They'll be like, I got another opportunity over here. Bigger church, bigger salary. I'm going. Like there's no sense of I cannot make a move unless it is directed.
00:30:38
Speaker 1: Right.
00:30:38
Speaker 2: So there's a way in which a lot of black women have been taught that God is a micromanager, that God doesn't actually want our freedom. But what God wants from us is to control every aspect of our lives and that we don't have the wisdom to. the right or the authority to make decisions on our own behalf. And usually who that ends up benefiting are sort of patriarchal powers, racist powers, right? You stay in a job that doesn't treat Black women well because you're waiting for God to tell you to leave, but you already had the freedom to leave, right? So we've been steeped in these religious beliefs that God wants our suffering, and that keeps more Black women suffering.
00:31:26
Speaker 1: It also feels like there is a large role for shame in Christianity. And really, can you talk about the role shame has and how that impacts our mental health?
00:31:34
Speaker 2: Yeah, there's so much shame and fear-based control that happens in a lot of churches, which often has less to do with the religion and more to do with the people who benefit from shame. So if we can shame you into thinking that something's wrong with your body, then we get to control how you look, right? If we can shame you into thinking that you're supposed to give your all to the church, then we get to benefit from your free labor for us, right? So there are a lot of ways that shame is used. And again, it's really targeted towards Black women in the church in order to make Black women really sacrifice themselves on behalf of other people. And it's not just the church. It happens. It's shame around mothering. I once met a woman who was literally in prison. I was working as a prison chaplain because of maternal shame, because something had happened to one of her kids. And she was like, oh, if I'm a good mother, I would do the thing he needs me to do in order to be a good mother. Well, the thing he needed her to do was illegal. Right. But she was like, but I got to be a good mom. So here's this really good church going woman. who ends up doing something really, like just horrible, right? And I'm like, but why would you do that? She was like, because I learned that's what mothers do. You do whatever your child needs you to do. And I thought, oh, wow, you literally gave up your freedom. It didn't help him. Like he's still in jail and now you're in jail too. So yeah, so there are things like that, that we often learn that what a good Christian girl does That leads us into so many negative relationships and behaviors, all because we're trying to avoid the weight of shame.
00:33:35
Speaker 1: Hmm. Something you mentioned earlier that I want to go back to, you talked about a case that you were trained on. I think it might have been a student who you realized kind of like that seminary was actually kind of making the delusions more significant and more. I hadn't thought about like this could be kind of a gateway for people whose mental health is not like well managed, that you could see some concerning things, especially with the age, right? That most people are probably in seminary is when we first see these psychotic breaks and those kinds of things. Yeah. So can you talk more about like what kinds of things maybe need to be assessed maybe before like somebody embarks on a seminary program? Because it is a special kind of training that could maybe, I think that some may make the case that grad school is bad for our mental health kind of generally. But I think this is a special kind of training that could open up some doors that you might not see if you were training to be like an engineer.
00:34:25
Speaker 2: Yeah. I mean, the reality is churches, because of their emphasis on particularly forgiveness, because of the stigma, against mental health or
mental illness. And this sort of, that's not our place to judge. It's funny because churches are really judgy in some ways, but when it comes to mental health, sometimes they're not judgy enough, right? And so they can let in students and, you know, and I've seen this a few times. I've been teaching at seminaries for almost 20 years now where I'll look at somebody and I'll be like, what are they doing here? Like, wait, why are they here? Right? And a lot of them, it's like, to me as a psychologist, the mental health issues will be screaming at me, right? I see it passing by them in the hall. I'm like, something's off here, right? But the reality is that seminaries and churches are often places of refuge. And so they tend to attract people who are trying to figure themselves out, right? In the same way, when I was a psychology professor for our graduate programs, You know, psychology programs, all the counseling programs really usually require an interview for admission. And one of the reasons is that faculty know that a lot of people who apply to these programs are applying because they're trying to figure out their own stuff. Right. And we need to figure out who is psychologically healthy enough to be in this program. And we try to weed through some of that in the interview process. I actually think seminaries need to be doing more of that work. And a lot of seminaries will say, well, it's not up to us to determine who God calls. And I'm like, actually, it kind of is. That is a communal discernment process. We have a responsibility to protect the public. I actually think seminaries have as much responsibility to protect the public as therapy training programs do, as medical schools do, right? We should be trying to say, wait a minute, does this person seem to have the character where they want to home, right? If we know that this person is in school and maybe they do seem to be having hallucinations or delusions, that doesn't mean that they can't be here, but it does mean that they have to take getting that treated seriously, right? Like what's your plan for keeping this under control? What's your accountability? Like who is it that gets to sort of look at you and that, you know, can say, wait a minute, you're functioning now, makes you not safe to be in leadership. We need you to take a break. Who helps you to to do that? What's the plan for that? How do you know when your symptoms are no longer well, well controlled, right? Those are the types of things that we need to help people to figure out what is it that is drawing you to this place and how much of that is rooted in your own pain. There's so many times I've seen people that say, well, God told me to do such and such. And I'll be sitting there thinking like, I don't know if that was God talking to you. I think That might be something else. That might've been them issues. You need to go work with a therapist all. And then after you've worked that and you've gotten to a place to help, now let's see what's God saying to you once you're healthy, right? And so I think if we could help people to do that more, so it doesn't even have to be psychosis. It can be you've got bipolar, right? And how do you know when you're in a manic episode, right? Versus you're excited about something in a way that is more a healthy thing. and stabilizing. Those are some of the things that we need to do right now. There aren't a lot of gatekeeping around mental health in the religious world, other than to pretend it doesn't exist, which doesn't, it doesn't help anyone. It doesn't help the person suffering and it doesn't help the people that they might end up serving.
00:38:16
Speaker 1: Yeah. And, you know, as you're talking and I think there again have been so many conversations around like licensure and credentialing and, you know, kind of happening recently and, But there is not necessarily a comparable process for people who just open up a church, right? Like, of course, there are some denominations where you have to be ordained and like there are like bodies that you report to. But anybody really could say like, oh, I'm the pastor of this thing. And so it does feel like it becomes a public health issue when people, you know, are attracting congregations and espousing these different kinds of things that can really be harmful, I think, in particular ways to mental health that often go overlooked.
00:38:53
Speaker 2: Yeah. I mean, the reality is in America, because of separation of church and state, anybody can claim to be a pastor, right? And anyone can open a church, open something that they call a church and often say, well, these are our beliefs and those won't necessarily be rooted in any sort of larger tradition, any sort of larger spiritual tradition. And sometimes folks don't know that. And that becomes, it's also the case where people use the term Christian counselor. There are no rules around who gets to call themselves a Christian. counselor. Like you can't just go out and call yourself a psychologist. I mean, obviously people do, but you're not supposed to. Like legally, you're not supposed to. You're really not supposed to just go out and call yourself a licensed professional counselor, unless you actually have that designation, but anybody can call themselves a minister. Anybody can call themselves a pastor and they can set up a church and they can set up beliefs and doctrines and they can say, well, this is what we do. And this is what is normative. And sometimes people can come up in these settings, not knowing that what they were in was not necessarily part of sort of mainstream religion, or it's not within the larger fold of a religion, but there are really very few checks and balances. Again, there are within denominations, certain denominations, but in the United States, anybody can say, well, I'm going to form a church that's outside of the denominational structures, right? So I'm going to form a non-denominational church and I
don't answer to anybody. And yeah, so there's a lot of room for really unhealthy people to end up in positions of leadership So, yeah, it's sometimes you have to kind of balance like the not you don't necessarily want state control over religion. But at the same time, people in religious authority have a lot of capacity to influence people in ways that could be negative. Right. Could be harmful. Yeah.
00:41:09
Speaker 1: More from our conversation after the break. What would you like to see more in terms of like collaboration or, you know, engagement with faith and spirituality communities in terms of incorporating more mental health?
00:41:30
Speaker 2: Yeah. I'm always encouraging my seminary students to become knowledgeable enough about mental health, right? Knowledgeable enough in the sense that they can begin to recognize what is sort of within the normal functional environment. an adaptive spectrum of belief and behavior? What are the things that maybe are just at the edge that maybe they can handle? And then what's that big group that like, no, this is outside my competence. Like I know enough about this to know I should not be doing anything here. I need to refer, right? I wish more clergy were in relationships with therapists, were in like, first of all, your personal relationship with a therapist, that I was more clergy would actually have therapists so that they not only address their issues, but we kind of need people to hold us in check as clergy. There's a bit of ego and narcissism of anybody who thinks God called you to serve somebody like that. That's just kind of an occupational hazard. So it's helpful to have a therapist who Who can pull you by the coattails and be like, I need to see behind that mask. What's really going on with you right now? So I think people need to be in therapy, but also clergy need to understand what therapy is like so that we can refer people from a standpoint of knowledge and experience, right? So that we can begin to understand why is it hard to find a therapist? What is it like to try to find a therapist? So that we can begin to tell people, hey, the first couple of sessions, you're filling somebody out, right? And then we need relationships with therapists professionally. So I wish more clergy had relationships with therapists where they had a list of people they could make referrals to. That they're like, I got somebody who needs a therapist for a child. Well, I know somebody who works with kids and who takes their insurance or that I could refer them to. I wish more clergy would have more of a network of therapists. I wish therapists would learn more about not just learn more about spirituality. I'm finding the more that I talk to therapists and I talk about spirituality, there are a lot more therapists who are deeply spiritual and religious people, but they have learned to separate it from their professional world. And so they're part of a faith community. It's a big part of their life. They will
never talk about it. They won't talk about it in their training. They won't talk about it with their clients, right? They don't even know how to talk about it, right? That was my experience when I first started doing this work. I didn't know how to address issues of faith because my training hadn't taught me how to do it. Like I knew what I had learned in church, but in the psychology world, they didn't tell me what to do when somebody came with what sounded like religious psychosis, right? Or like, I don't know, is this psychosis or not? What do I do with this, right? Was this a real spirit with this person? What is happening here, right? I didn't know how to judge that. And so I wish therapists were taught more about spirituality, about what its role is, how it functions, what are the ways that it's helpful to people, and then how do we mitigate its potential harm? What do we need to look out for in terms of harm? And how do we help redirect people so that they can hold on to the best of their spiritual traditions while letting go or reinterpreting those that are not aiding and they're flourishing?
00:45:09
Speaker 1: I agree with you. Like there does need to be more conversations, more, you know, like webinars and like bringing the like Dr. Weaver in to be a guest speaker on the, you know, Sundays and those kinds of things. But you often hear this idea that if I am talking with a therapist, it means that I'm abandoning my faith, right? Like this idea that those can't coexist. What would you say to somebody who might be struggling with that idea?
00:45:30
Speaker 2: Yeah, I think it's no different than when you go to a doctor because you have diabetes. right? That doesn't mean that you don't believe in God or that your faith is somehow weak because your body is not holding up. There are people who will say stuff like that too. It's what we would call bad theology, right? That actually isn't helpful to you. And so I think for us to recognize that mental illness is real, psychological suffering is real. And also I like to believe As a therapist, I like to believe that I am being an agent of healing for people, right? That I am helping them in ways that hopefully get them closer to the life that God wants them to have, right? And so I think that therapists, we can look at therapists as agents of God's healing. So if you are a person who believes that God is a God of healing, then why can't a therapist be an agent of that healing, right? in the same way that a doctor, a medical doctor could be, in the same way that a chiropractor could be, right? We just work with what's in the mind as opposed to what is the muscles or other tissue. So that's one way that I've looked at it and have often talked about it to particularly my students and to people in the church. And that usually helps them say, oh yeah, right? If I think about it as very similar to this, The difference is with therapy, very often we have to do a lot of work. You can't just turn it over to the therapist and they just say a few things and that fixes it. We have to put in a lot of work as well. And so, yeah, it's like we are, again, to use the language of faith, that's when I would say we're being co-creators with God. And what we are creating together is our mental health, right? We and the therapist are working together together. With God and invoking God in that place so that we can achieve what we think is the health that God wants all of humanity to have.
00:47:35
Speaker 1: Something else that has often come up in these conversations, and you even talked about it earlier, being like without a congregation, since your last leadership position. And oftentimes people are making that decision because of like some kind of spiritual trauma or some kind of church hurt. or something that has happened, what would you say to people who still want to have like a faith relationship, but maybe have experienced like a religious trauma or some church hurt, but are still longing for like some community or a connection to their spirituality?
00:48:01
Speaker 2: Yeah. I would say, first of all, the degree to which this has happened and how common it is also speaks to the need for mental health treatment for people in churches, right? I think if we could normalize treatment more we might end up having less church hurt happening because churches are often places where the unwell gather, right? Because it's a place where you can't. So for those who are dealing with church hurt, I would say one thing is to recognize that it's not your fault, right? It's not your fault. I think sometimes there can be so much shame around it. And the church is one of the places, one of the few places that we actually do try to shame people into an abusive relationship. Like in other places in the world, in our world, we've learned to say, oh no, you don't have to stay in that relationship. It's bad for you. If that job is bad for you, you don't have to stay there. If that romantic relationship is bad for you, you should leave, sis. But then with church, we're like, well, you know, I know they hurt you, but you should go back, right? So first of all, you don't have to go back, right? Even when it comes to the church, God does not require us to suffer. We are not required to suffer. We are especially not required to suffer. at the hands of those who are supposed to be our spiritual family. And so I think first is for people to know that. And the second is to know that the pain is real. The harm can be very real. The damage can be very real. And sometimes we can work through that on our own, but sometimes we need help. Sometimes it's actual trauma that people have experienced in their spiritual communities, and it has disrupted their sense of who God is. It has disrupted their sense of relational and spiritual safety in the world, their sense of psychological safety in the world. And often they do need help. from someone who can help them to restore that sense of
connection for them to begin to make meaning in different ways. And so I think to know that it's not your fault and that you may need help with it and that spiritual trauma is a very real thing, that it can be just as real and just as damaging as other forms of trauma. And so it's okay to get help for that.
00:50:29
Speaker 1: Is that a conversation, Dr. Shaniqua, that you have been hearing like your colleagues who are pastors having, right, like about like encouraging one another to go to therapy? And as I'm asking you this question, I'm very aware that I hear a lot of Black women have this conversation, right? Like you, Dr. Nita Phillips, I feel like Sarah Jakes Roberts has talked about like her own experiences with therapy. I don't know that I've heard any of the male pastors talk. which may be kind of emblematic of a part of the concern. But is that a conversation happening among faith professionals? Like, hey, this is really something we need to be doing. And like you mentioned, like this is an occupational hazard. So we got to kind of keep a check on this.
00:51:06
Speaker 2: Yeah. Every once in a while, I feel like there are signs of progress and then something will happen. And I'll be like, we're still back there. Right. I thought we had gotten better. So I'm hearing more faith leaders talk about therapy more openly. Still not nearly enough. It seems to be a small segment of people. There are some, I can think of like, I can't even say a handful, maybe like two male pastors that I'm guessing have talked pretty openly about therapy and their therapy experiences. I think part of it is that Black men are often really socialized not to talk about their sufferings. and to keep it hidden and not to seek help for it. And that even when they do seek help for it, they're not likely to talk about it in the way that say Sarah Jakes Roberts, real, right? In this really more transparent way. So yeah, I would love to see more men, more black men talking about healing, right? We desperately need it. The ones I see talking about it in the faith world are often not pastors, right? Right. And I don't know if that's because churches reject pastors. Well, I actually do know. Yeah. I can think of a former male pastor who one of my mentors, it was essentially kicked out of his church. Right. And because he had begun talking very openly about his experiences of child sexual abuse and started talking about the suffering and the trauma he experienced and the ways it was impacting him. And he was in therapy. Right. But he was seen by his congregation as being weak. Now something's wrong with you because you're talking about these things. And if you were abused, what does that mean about you? If you were sexually abused, and we also know that you're not homophobic, that you're affirming of LGBTQIA people, then that tells us something about your sexuality. So there were all these aspersions kind of cast on this pastor. So I think in a lot of ways, we still, as a world, are not really ready for Black men's vulnerabilities. including that of pastors. And I would love for us to see that change so that we can encourage that more. I think Black women have made more progress along those lines, but I think it is still harder for Black men. So that even when they're in therapy, they're not talking about it. I know plenty of them who are in therapy. They won't talk about it though. They won't tell people about it. But the people really do need to hear. That's part of how we normalize. And I tell my students all the time, I tell them, first of all, you need a therapist. And second, you need to tell people that you've had a therapist, right? So that it helps your people to say, Oh, wait, if pastor did this, I could do this too. It's no different than the pastors who have AIDS testing in their congregations. They have HIV testing. And I've known multiple pastors who will be the first person in line to get tested because they want to communicate to their congregation that it's okay. We need to do the same with mental health treatment. Communicate to the people that it's okay. Yeah, yeah.
00:54:16
Speaker 1: So Dr. Shaniko, for people who may be hearing about you and learning from you for the first time, where should they start with your books if they want to kind of learn more about the kinds of things you talk about?
00:54:26
Speaker 2: Yeah. So my first book is called Too Heavy a Yolk. It is about the burden of the strong Black woman. So this myth of the strong Black woman and the ways it impacts the lives of Black women. It's in some ways the story, the beginning of my story of getting free. from that. So I often write from my experience and in ways that are related to my healing. And then my latest book is Sacred Self-Care. And it is a devotional, which uses, it blends both psychology and spirituality to talk about what self-care is and ways that are not about going out and spending money, but really are about trying to be our best, healthiest self that we can be. So yeah, those are some of my books. And then in my, I have a sub stack a weekly Substack called No Trifling Matter that I write about every Sunday. And it's usually having to do with issues of faith and healing and justice. So that's where folks can find me. And that's drshaniqua.substack.com.
00:55:26
Speaker 1: Perfect. Is there anywhere else we can find you online? Are you on any of the social media channels?
00:55:31
Speaker 2: I have this really sort of conflictual relationship with social media. So there are times where I'll be like, I'm going to get on it. I'm going to do better. And so right now I'm on threads and Instagram. And then at some point I'll be like, I'm tired of this. I'm not doing it anymore.
00:55:45
Speaker 1: Understood. So for the time that you are there, where can people find you with your handle?
00:55:51
Speaker 2: But you can find me at Dr. Shaniqua, both on Instagram and on threads. That's my handle at Dr. Shaniqua.
00:55:58
Speaker 1: Perfect. We'll be sure to include that in our show notes. Thank you so much for spending some time with us today. I really appreciate it.
00:56:03
Speaker 2: Thank you.
00:56:08
Speaker 1: I'm so glad Dr. Barnes was able to join me for this conversation. To learn more about her and her work, be sure to visit the show notes at therapyforblackgirls.com slash session 490. And don't forget to text this episode to two of your girls right now and tell them to check it out. Did you know that you could leave us a voicemail with your questions or suggestions for the podcast? If you have movies or books you'd like us to review, drop us a message at memo.fm slash therapyforblackgirls and let us know what's on your mind. We just might feature it on a podcast episode. If you're looking for a therapist in your area, visit our therapist directory at therapyforblackgirls.com slash directory. Don't forget to follow us on Instagram at therapyforblackgirls and come on over and join us in our Patreon community for exclusive updates, behind the scenes content, and much more. We can't wait to see you inside. You can join us at community.therapyforblackgirls.com. This episode was produced by Elise Ellis, Nde Chubu, and Bria Mosley. Editing was done by Denison Bradford. Thank y'all so much for joining me again this week. I look forward to continuing this conversation with you all real soon. Take good care.