TRANSKRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:01.828 --> 00:00:04.940
you got too many people that are in positions of decision-making
2
00:00:05.236 --> 00:00:07.189
that are strategically lazy.
3
00:00:07.490 --> 00:00:11.658
That's Brendan Witcher, Global VP of Product and Content at
4
00:00:11.659 --> 00:00:14.167
ShopTalk, live with me at ShopTalk Fall.
5
00:00:14.505 --> 00:00:17.499
"Strategically lazy." I mean, that's a bold thing to say
6
00:00:17.499 --> 00:00:19.623
at Shop Talk, and frankly, out loud
7
00:00:20.049 --> 00:00:21.691
And he's got numbers too.
8
00:00:22.081 --> 00:00:26.783
Amazon owns 76% of retail media, Walmart 6%.
9
00:00:27.132 --> 00:00:28.496
Everyone else fights over the rest.
10
00:00:28.593 --> 00:00:30.584
We talk about what retailers should be doing.
11
00:00:30.895 --> 00:00:34.033
Plus why the tech companies building AI agents
12
00:00:34.041 --> 00:00:36.431
worry him more than shoppers do.
13
00:00:36.808 --> 00:00:41.374
His fix is three words: think it through
14
00:00:41.802 --> 00:00:42.619
I love this man.
15
00:00:43.218 --> 00:00:47.576
This is Retail Transformers recorded live from Shop Talk Fall in Nashville
16
00:00:57.082 --> 00:00:59.084
Welcome to Retail Transformers, candid
17
00:00:59.085 --> 00:01:02.519
conversations with the visionaries shaping the future of commerce.
18
00:01:02.601 --> 00:01:03.639
I'm Ricardo Belmar.
19
00:01:03.920 --> 00:01:04.934
And I'm Casey Golden.
20
00:01:04.935 --> 00:01:06.627
Welcome back, Retail Razor fans.
21
00:01:06.653 --> 00:01:09.628
This is the podcast where we cut through the clutter to bring you
22
00:01:09.640 --> 00:01:13.810
the sharpest insights from the leaders redefining retail, careers,
23
00:01:13.810 --> 00:01:15.269
and the future of retailing.
24
00:01:15.687 --> 00:01:19.196
And Ricardo, I'm feeling, one, completely under the weather, so
25
00:01:19.196 --> 00:01:21.954
if you're watching us on YouTube, I'll take a little grace right now.
26
00:01:22.684 --> 00:01:23.669
and the FOMO.
27
00:01:23.846 --> 00:01:24.220
Mm-hmm.
28
00:01:24.712 --> 00:01:29.901
And just a bit upset that you went to Shoptalk Fall without me!
29
00:01:30.119 --> 00:01:31.281
I did, I did.
30
00:01:31.281 --> 00:01:32.011
But you were missed.
31
00:01:32.038 --> 00:01:33.216
You were definitely missed.
32
00:01:33.763 --> 00:01:37.090
But I did come back with four really good episodes for us though, all
33
00:01:37.091 --> 00:01:40.756
recorded live, in person, in the Rethink Retail Creator Studio.
34
00:01:41.258 --> 00:01:42.848
And today's episode's a good one.
35
00:01:42.951 --> 00:01:47.276
It's with Brendan Witcher, Global VP of Product and Content at Shoptalk,
36
00:01:47.286 --> 00:01:51.404
and of course famously known as a top Forrester retail analyst prior
37
00:01:51.405 --> 00:01:55.032
to that for, oh gosh, gotta be at least over a decade, maybe more.
38
00:01:55.032 --> 00:01:55.826
I've lost track.
39
00:01:55.834 --> 00:01:59.351
I mean, I know that's how long ago Brendan and I met that many years ago
40
00:01:59.656 --> 00:02:00.280
What are you talking about?
41
00:02:00.280 --> 00:02:01.368
We're all 20
42
00:02:02.133 --> 00:02:03.927
Well, we were all kids when we started in this industry.
43
00:02:03.927 --> 00:02:04.610
I mean, it's retail, right?
44
00:02:04.610 --> 00:02:05.985
Everybody starts when they're young.
45
00:02:07.842 --> 00:02:11.394
So now he's the person shaping the content at Shop
46
00:02:11.398 --> 00:02:13.540
Talk and Grocery Shop also, right?
47
00:02:14.411 --> 00:02:14.818
Okay.
48
00:02:14.818 --> 00:02:20.801
What big ideas did he say that I need to hear, our audience needs to hear.
49
00:02:21.242 --> 00:02:21.842
What's up?
50
00:02:22.390 --> 00:02:25.247
Well, for starters, he thinks a lot of retail
51
00:02:25.251 --> 00:02:28.368
leaders are strategically lazy.
52
00:02:28.862 --> 00:02:32.247
They grab a stat that says what they already wanted to hear
53
00:02:32.266 --> 00:02:33.505
and then call it a strategy.
54
00:02:33.800 --> 00:02:34.193
Ouch.
55
00:02:34.817 --> 00:02:38.246
I mean, I've sat in that meeting probably more times than I'd like to admit,
56
00:02:38.503 --> 00:02:39.203
Haven't we all?
57
00:02:39.953 --> 00:02:41.082
with people I adore
58
00:02:41.176 --> 00:02:41.931
Exactly, right?
59
00:02:41.931 --> 00:02:42.182
Yeah.
60
00:02:42.207 --> 00:02:45.788
I mean, his, his example is retail media, which I admit hurts a little bit.
61
00:02:45.952 --> 00:02:50.925
But, yeah, he pointed out, rightfully so, Amazon has, like, 76% of it.
62
00:02:50.937 --> 00:02:53.441
Walmart has the next 6% or 8%.
63
00:02:54.000 --> 00:02:56.812
, So before you jump in, if you're new in retail media just because everybody's
64
00:02:56.812 --> 00:03:00.437
talking about it, you do the math on what's left for you, and then what?
65
00:03:00.876 --> 00:03:01.291
Fair.
66
00:03:01.384 --> 00:03:01.708
Fair.
67
00:03:01.851 --> 00:03:02.086
Yeah.
68
00:03:02.404 --> 00:03:02.824
What else?
69
00:03:03.236 --> 00:03:06.191
Well, he gave me a line that I told him I am absolutely gonna
70
00:03:06.192 --> 00:03:07.807
keep stealing because I love this.
71
00:03:07.824 --> 00:03:10.694
He said, "Knowledge is the absence of questions."
72
00:03:11.487 --> 00:03:12.136
Ouch.
73
00:03:13.682 --> 00:03:16.679
I think I'm gonna, I'm gonna need to sit with that for a second
74
00:03:16.751 --> 00:03:17.031
Yeah.
75
00:03:17.739 --> 00:03:18.929
I'm probably gonna steal
76
00:03:19.012 --> 00:03:19.262
Yeah
77
00:03:20.263 --> 00:03:24.129
I'm guessing AI agents came up with it because, you know,
78
00:03:24.140 --> 00:03:30.758
Shoptalk retail conference, is anybody talking about anything other than agents?
79
00:03:31.569 --> 00:03:33.891
Well, it was tough to find that, but so yeah, obviously
80
00:03:33.891 --> 00:03:36.210
agents came up, in the conversation.
81
00:03:36.250 --> 00:03:39.092
Interestingly, some interesting comments you'll hear from Brendan,
82
00:03:39.357
Load full transcript
--> 00:03:42.701
he thinks that shopper behavior's actually pretty predictable, despite how
83
00:03:42.702 --> 00:03:46.654
everybody seems to be so focused on the shopper side of, of agentic commerce.
84
00:03:46.654 --> 00:03:49.471
But what worries him more is what he calls the middle layer.
85
00:03:49.471 --> 00:03:52.354
It's the tech companies building the agents and what they're gonna
86
00:03:52.364 --> 00:03:55.184
do with your emails and content before a shopper ever even sees it
87
00:03:55.538 --> 00:03:56.311
Yeah, I agree.
88
00:03:56.311 --> 00:03:57.658
I'm not worried about shoppers.
89
00:03:57.689 --> 00:03:59.965
Like, we're creature-- people are creatures of habits
90
00:04:00.113 --> 00:04:00.413
Yeah
91
00:04:01.078 --> 00:04:04.584
We, we all wanna feel like the same way
92
00:04:04.729 --> 00:04:05.201
Mm-hmm.
93
00:04:05.631 --> 00:04:06.026
Right.
94
00:04:06.073 --> 00:04:06.499
out here
95
00:04:06.541 --> 00:04:06.846
Right.
96
00:04:06.864 --> 00:04:08.748
for like some miracle,
97
00:04:09.098 --> 00:04:09.626
exactly.
98
00:04:09.655 --> 00:04:09.911
Yeah.
99
00:04:09.945 --> 00:04:11.303
like stop screwing up,
100
00:04:11.312 --> 00:04:11.781
Yeah.
101
00:04:12.862 --> 00:04:13.186
Yeah.
102
00:04:13.223 --> 00:04:14.558
Like, just screw up less.
103
00:04:15.007 --> 00:04:15.465
okay.
104
00:04:15.475 --> 00:04:19.172
So I'm, really sorry that I missed it.
105
00:04:19.771 --> 00:04:22.120
I'll have to make sure… I'll be at the next Shop Talk
106
00:04:22.184 --> 00:04:22.674
There you go
107
00:04:23.201 --> 00:04:27.205
Before we get into this conversation, Ricardo, why don't you
108
00:04:27.206 --> 00:04:30.802
tell everyone about the next event
109
00:04:32.471 --> 00:04:32.502
Hmm.
110
00:04:32.502 --> 00:04:34.302
The Retail Razor Show is gonna be joining?
111
00:04:34.518 --> 00:04:35.456
Why, I'd love to.
112
00:04:35.461 --> 00:04:35.939
Thank you.
113
00:04:37.087 --> 00:04:40.852
I'm excited to share with everyone that next month we'll be joining
114
00:04:40.902 --> 00:04:45.304
Retail Agent Con, along with over 500 of your retail peers.
115
00:04:45.580 --> 00:04:49.966
We're gonna take an honest look at where the industry stands across merchandising,
116
00:04:49.978 --> 00:04:54.486
order management, inventory control, store operations, and specifically what agents
117
00:04:54.486 --> 00:04:56.217
are doing today in each of these areas.
118
00:04:56.217 --> 00:04:57.547
Where are the real wins?
119
00:04:57.998 --> 00:05:01.634
And what has to change in your org chart to really make sure those results hold?
120
00:05:01.887 --> 00:05:07.588
So it's going to be a live virtual event on November 17th from 11:00 AM to 3:00
121
00:05:07.588 --> 00:05:12.167
PM Eastern, and it's produced by our good friends at IHL Group with ClearSight AI.
122
00:05:12.702 --> 00:05:16.024
You'll hear from retail leaders like Glenn Allison of Tractor Supply,
123
00:05:16.037 --> 00:05:20.845
Scot Sager of David's Bridal, Justin Ewig of Artisant Lane Furniture, Dr.
124
00:05:20.940 --> 00:05:24.645
Janet Sherlock will talk about the organizational changes needed for
125
00:05:24.667 --> 00:05:26.422
agents and humans to work together.
126
00:05:26.851 --> 00:05:30.827
And analysts like Greg Buzek and Jerry Sheldon of IHL Group, and me, I'll be
127
00:05:30.828 --> 00:05:35.048
there too, for practical conversations about, you guessed it, AI agents.
128
00:05:35.677 --> 00:05:37.118
Retailers attend free.
129
00:05:37.386 --> 00:05:41.962
Sponsorships and individual tickets are available as well for solution providers.
130
00:05:41.991 --> 00:05:46.286
You can learn more at www.retailagentcon.com.
131
00:05:46.720 --> 00:05:48.835
Don't miss it, and register today.
132
00:05:49.236 --> 00:05:49.572
Okay.
133
00:05:49.636 --> 00:05:51.142
I'm super stoked for that one.
134
00:05:51.987 --> 00:05:55.257
if you're watching us on YouTube and you saw me disappear off screen, my
135
00:05:55.289 --> 00:05:58.444
puppy is dreaming underneath my chair.
136
00:05:58.509 --> 00:05:59.398
He's, like,
137
00:06:00.505 --> 00:06:02.029
It's too cute.
138
00:06:05.540 --> 00:06:08.543
So now let's go to our conversation with Brendan
139
00:06:08.543 --> 00:06:13.724
Witcher, recorded live and in person at Shoptalk Fall in Nashville.
140
00:06:20.963 --> 00:06:21.705
Now welcome everybody.
141
00:06:21.709 --> 00:06:26.168
Thanks for joining us We are live in person at Shoptalk Fall, and I
142
00:06:26.169 --> 00:06:31.187
am pleased to be joined this time with Brendan Witcher, VP of, Content
143
00:06:31.192 --> 00:06:33.130
and Product, right, at Shoptalk.
144
00:06:33.662 --> 00:06:36.323
And well, I think what this is… This has been, like, a long time
145
00:06:36.323 --> 00:06:39.203
in, in planning that we've been wanting to get you on the show.
146
00:06:39.764 --> 00:06:39.795
Yes.
147
00:06:39.795 --> 00:06:42.643
'Cause al- always love every conversation we have.
148
00:06:42.651 --> 00:06:45.878
There's always… I learn a lot, and you always have a fantastic take-
149
00:06:46.112 --> 00:06:46.306
Thank you
150
00:06:46.306 --> 00:06:46.720
… Ricardo Belmar: on things.
151
00:06:46.744 --> 00:06:47.121
Thank you.
152
00:06:47.240 --> 00:06:50.574
so maybe a good place to start, let me… I mean, how, how are
153
00:06:50.574 --> 00:06:52.439
you feeling about Shoptalk Fall?
154
00:06:52.440 --> 00:06:56.781
I, I know when we've talked before, you- you've talked about, how to do things
155
00:06:56.783 --> 00:07:01.395
differently to really serve different parts of the audience that shows up.
156
00:07:01.395 --> 00:07:01.409
Right.
157
00:07:01.641 --> 00:07:04.209
So how are you feeling about the show as we're… We're only at day one.
158
00:07:04.490 --> 00:07:04.771
Yeah.
159
00:07:04.775 --> 00:07:06.598
I, I, I feel r- really, really good about it.
160
00:07:06.599 --> 00:07:09.077
I mean, to be quite honest with you, I think it's really important
161
00:07:09.080 --> 00:07:13.338
to understand that as an event company, we have two choices.
162
00:07:13.396 --> 00:07:16.421
We can be the kind of company that just focuses on number of sessions- Yeah
163
00:07:16.421 --> 00:07:20.366
number of speakers- Mm … number of topics covered, or, which is what our
164
00:07:20.366 --> 00:07:24.531
approach is, and what we're changing more towards even more in the future, is this
165
00:07:24.531 --> 00:07:28.906
idea of, how are we enabling the ecosystem of relationships- Mm … at shows?
166
00:07:28.958 --> 00:07:29.293
Okay.
167
00:07:29.394 --> 00:07:29.666
Right?
168
00:07:29.722 --> 00:07:32.776
How are we thinking- Yeah … about the brands who wanna talk to retailers,
169
00:07:32.776 --> 00:07:35.635
the retailers that wanna talk to technology people, the peers that
170
00:07:35.635 --> 00:07:39.019
wanna talk to other peers in their industry- Mm-hmm right, sort of thing.
171
00:07:39.306 --> 00:07:43.236
So the, the content we're creating, the products we're creating, which is why
172
00:07:43.236 --> 00:07:45.458
product is in my title as well as content-
173
00:07:45.657 --> 00:07:45.667
Mm-hmm.
174
00:07:45.667 --> 00:07:50.583
Yeah … is really about how are we enabling, not just hoping they happen,
175
00:07:50.810 --> 00:07:54.479
but enabling these conversations and these sort of connections to happen
176
00:07:54.722 --> 00:07:57.572
where people can come to the show and be productive on a number of levels.
177
00:07:57.846 --> 00:08:01.499
I think the old, traditional way of looking at a show and saying, "I'm
178
00:08:01.499 --> 00:08:04.623
gonna go find out what the tech vendors are- Yeah … and I'm gonna go and
179
00:08:04.625 --> 00:08:06.209
find out what people say on stage-"
180
00:08:06.264 --> 00:08:06.554
Yeah
181
00:08:06.635 --> 00:08:08.237
… Brendan Witcher: that's, those are table stakes.
182
00:08:08.251 --> 00:08:09.101
Like, everybody's- Yeah … doing those
183
00:08:09.101 --> 00:08:09.756
Everybody does that,
184
00:08:09.807 --> 00:08:10.000
right.
185
00:08:10.000 --> 00:08:10.082
You know?
186
00:08:10.086 --> 00:08:10.727
You can do that anywhere.
187
00:08:10.727 --> 00:08:13.185
Hopefully I don't- Yeah … lose my new job by saying this.
188
00:08:13.421 --> 00:08:13.768
Right?
189
00:08:13.838 --> 00:08:16.010
But you can go to any show and get that.
190
00:08:16.013 --> 00:08:16.023
Yeah.
191
00:08:16.115 --> 00:08:16.504
Right.
192
00:08:16.589 --> 00:08:20.353
But the reality is, is- There are very few shows that are
193
00:08:20.365 --> 00:08:25.670
out there that are thinking about did the person walk away maximizing the
194
00:08:25.670 --> 00:08:30.984
opportunities to go back and become the best professional of what they are?
195
00:08:31.192 --> 00:08:31.310
Yeah.
196
00:08:31.310 --> 00:08:35.294
And that includes whether I'm an email marketer or a- Mm-hmm … CEO of a big box
197
00:08:35.295 --> 00:08:40.029
retailer, or a vendor at a small company- Yeah …
startup, or a vendor at a giant
198
00:08:40.030 --> 00:08:43.873
conglomerate, or a media person that works for- Yeah … the Wall Street Journal-
199
00:08:44.034 --> 00:08:46.486
Mm-hmm … or someone that just works for Modern Retail, like a smaller- Yeah
200
00:08:46.486 --> 00:08:47.889
sort of, you know, outlet.
201
00:08:47.923 --> 00:08:49.983
Like, there's all sorts of attendees.
202
00:08:50.008 --> 00:08:50.352
Right.
203
00:08:50.352 --> 00:08:50.362
Right.
204
00:08:50.540 --> 00:08:51.817
And there's all sorts of people.
205
00:08:51.838 --> 00:08:52.740
Yeah, with different needs and
206
00:08:52.740 --> 00:08:54.326
d- And each of them- And, and different requirements.
207
00:08:54.345 --> 00:08:54.638
Yeah.
208
00:08:54.687 --> 00:08:54.967
Yeah.
209
00:08:55.125 --> 00:08:58.286
As a podcaster, you have- Yeah … needs and requirements.
210
00:08:58.286 --> 00:08:58.298
Right.
211
00:08:58.298 --> 00:09:00.530
Your audience has needs and requirements just listening
212
00:09:00.530 --> 00:09:01.304
to this, and they want- Yeah
213
00:09:01.304 --> 00:09:02.638
certain things out of it, right?
214
00:09:02.638 --> 00:09:02.648
Right.
215
00:09:02.890 --> 00:09:07.014
So I'm really looking at the whole ecosystem and saying, "Are we doing
216
00:09:07.014 --> 00:09:12.974
the kinds of things at our show that make someone go," maybe not can see the
217
00:09:12.975 --> 00:09:14.532
difference, but can feel the difference.
218
00:09:14.548 --> 00:09:14.813
Yeah.
219
00:09:15.296 --> 00:09:15.477
Yeah.
220
00:09:15.484 --> 00:09:16.914
Like, that to me is really important.
221
00:09:16.950 --> 00:09:20.354
I, I like the way you put that because the You, when, when
222
00:09:20.361 --> 00:09:22.463
everyone who leaves an event, right?
223
00:09:22.463 --> 00:09:24.623
Usually what they're thinking is, you know, it, part of it is, "Well, what am
224
00:09:24.624 --> 00:09:28.243
I gonna remember from the event?" But I think it's very similar what i- in general
225
00:09:28.247 --> 00:09:29.616
we, we always tell retailers, right?
226
00:09:29.616 --> 00:09:31.352
Is that you're trying to create a feeling.
227
00:09:31.701 --> 00:09:35.288
An emotional response, because that response that people feel,
228
00:09:35.292 --> 00:09:36.263
that's what they're gonna remember.
229
00:09:36.459 --> 00:09:36.745
Yeah.
230
00:09:36.877 --> 00:09:37.153
Right?
231
00:09:37.341 --> 00:09:37.610
Yeah.
232
00:09:37.984 --> 00:09:40.735
And the journey we're on right now, and I, we're not there yet,
233
00:09:40.737 --> 00:09:41.950
I mean, we're, it's a cycle-
234
00:09:42.073 --> 00:09:42.199
Mm-hmm
235
00:09:42.228 --> 00:09:42.569
… Brendan Witcher: for us.
236
00:09:42.600 --> 00:09:44.180
I mean, we started this at the beginning of the year.
237
00:09:44.296 --> 00:09:44.529
Yeah.
238
00:09:44.569 --> 00:09:46.537
this is the year where we are testing and
239
00:09:46.537 --> 00:09:47.968
learning but doing more of.
240
00:09:47.970 --> 00:09:48.045
Mm-hmm.
241
00:09:48.300 --> 00:09:53.380
This idea of creating, a feeling within people that I really call the, the,
242
00:09:53.414 --> 00:09:57.373
the four-prong sort of like stool of this, four, four-legged stool of this.
243
00:09:57.708 --> 00:10:00.011
Which is, do people feel inspired?
244
00:10:00.150 --> 00:10:00.430
Yeah.
245
00:10:00.499 --> 00:10:02.744
Now that's, you know, you can just, I can just put
246
00:10:02.790 --> 00:10:04.579
Tony Robbins on stage and be done.
247
00:10:04.810 --> 00:10:05.173
Right?
248
00:10:05.209 --> 00:10:05.523
Right, right.
249
00:10:05.523 --> 00:10:05.703
Yeah.
250
00:10:05.724 --> 00:10:06.182
Like, okay.
251
00:10:06.182 --> 00:10:06.192
Okay.
252
00:10:06.196 --> 00:10:07.113
I'm inspired.
253
00:10:07.113 --> 00:10:07.123
Sure.
254
00:10:07.148 --> 00:10:07.377
Right?
255
00:10:07.377 --> 00:10:07.973
Yeah, yeah.
256
00:10:07.975 --> 00:10:09.231
Does that mean I'm better at my job?
257
00:10:09.540 --> 00:10:10.946
So let's, we need to combine that.
258
00:10:10.970 --> 00:10:11.161
Yeah.
259
00:10:11.163 --> 00:10:11.445
Right?
260
00:10:11.485 --> 00:10:11.776
Right.
261
00:10:11.776 --> 00:10:13.584
With, I feel capable.
262
00:10:13.780 --> 00:10:14.147
Mm-hmm.
263
00:10:14.374 --> 00:10:17.955
Again, I could put Tony Robbins up there with the CEO of Walmart-
264
00:10:18.012 --> 00:10:18.302
Yeah
265
00:10:18.332 --> 00:10:20.984
… Brendan Witcher: who could talk about like, "We have the budget
266
00:10:21.004 --> 00:10:23.461
balance sheet of a small country, and so we do all these things."
267
00:10:23.461 --> 00:10:23.777
Right.
268
00:10:23.777 --> 00:10:23.787
Right.
269
00:10:23.827 --> 00:10:25.752
And 99% of the audience would be like, "Well, we know." I
270
00:10:25.754 --> 00:10:26.341
can't do that.
271
00:10:26.362 --> 00:10:26.574
Yeah.
272
00:10:27.026 --> 00:10:27.149
Right?
273
00:10:27.149 --> 00:10:28.207
I can't do any of those things.
274
00:10:28.218 --> 00:10:29.958
So those two things are not enough.
275
00:10:30.033 --> 00:10:30.295
Yeah.
276
00:10:30.314 --> 00:10:30.699
Right?
277
00:10:30.722 --> 00:10:32.955
So I feel inspired, I feel capable.
278
00:10:33.023 --> 00:10:33.282
Yeah.
279
00:10:33.431 --> 00:10:34.633
I feel knowledgeable.
280
00:10:34.913 --> 00:10:38.361
Like, this is another thing- Hmm … that I find that event
281
00:10:38.548 --> 00:10:40.388
companies don't do really well.
282
00:10:40.484 --> 00:10:40.775
Uh-huh.
283
00:10:40.797 --> 00:10:44.735
Is they don't get people to talk to the level that they
284
00:10:44.735 --> 00:10:48.867
need to talk to, so someone could go, "I feel like I don't have so many
285
00:10:48.869 --> 00:10:50.432
questions that I can't get started."
286
00:10:51.166 --> 00:10:51.938
Okay, yeah.
287
00:10:51.957 --> 00:10:52.414
You know what I mean?
288
00:10:52.415 --> 00:10:52.702
Yeah.
289
00:10:53.108 --> 00:10:54.970
Like, there's those sort of like- Right … intro-
290
00:10:54.994 --> 00:10:55.285
Right
291
00:10:55.332 --> 00:10:57.535
… Brendan Witcher: like you're never gonna learn to change out
292
00:10:57.537 --> 00:10:59.579
a carburetor from a TikTok video.
293
00:10:59.702 --> 00:10:59.917
Right.
294
00:11:01.531 --> 00:11:01.833
Yeah.
295
00:11:01.833 --> 00:11:03.491
Sometimes you just gotta go to YouTube- Right.
296
00:11:03.491 --> 00:11:03.773
That's
297
00:11:03.773 --> 00:11:05.474
right, yeah … and watch the 10-minute video.
298
00:11:05.474 --> 00:11:06.072
The 10-minute version,
299
00:11:06.073 --> 00:11:06.207
yeah.
300
00:11:06.207 --> 00:11:06.376
Not
301
00:11:06.376 --> 00:11:07.025
the 30-second version.
302
00:11:07.025 --> 00:11:09.858
You know, not that I know anything about carburetors- … or changing
303
00:11:09.861 --> 00:11:10.320
them out.
304
00:11:10.351 --> 00:11:10.477
I- Yeah.
305
00:11:10.477 --> 00:11:11.812
Well, I guess it's the, it's the difference between- I'm
306
00:11:11.813 --> 00:11:12.783
hoping I'm right, but- Yeah.
307
00:11:12.783 --> 00:11:16.172
You can go to a session and hear about what someone did,
308
00:11:16.520 --> 00:11:17.532
or what an organization did.
309
00:11:17.532 --> 00:11:17.999
Right.
310
00:11:18.160 --> 00:11:20.322
But that doesn't mean that when you leave that
311
00:11:20.322 --> 00:11:22.245
session you know how to replicate it.
312
00:11:22.299 --> 00:11:22.716
Correct.
313
00:11:22.718 --> 00:11:22.976
Right?
314
00:11:23.109 --> 00:11:23.417
Right.
315
00:11:23.646 --> 00:11:26.725
Inspired, capable- Yeah … knowledgeable.
316
00:11:26.751 --> 00:11:27.029
Right.
317
00:11:27.060 --> 00:11:29.573
And knowledge is really the absence of questions.
318
00:11:29.633 --> 00:11:29.954
Yeah.
319
00:11:30.206 --> 00:11:30.454
Okay.
320
00:11:30.454 --> 00:11:30.736
Right?
321
00:11:30.736 --> 00:11:30.746
Right.
322
00:11:30.803 --> 00:11:32.800
That's what I would say- Right … on that point, right?
323
00:11:32.800 --> 00:11:32.810
Yeah.
324
00:11:32.834 --> 00:11:33.132
Last.
325
00:11:33.185 --> 00:11:33.737
Yeah, good point.
326
00:11:33.781 --> 00:11:36.985
And then the last one I would say is empowered.
327
00:11:37.228 --> 00:11:37.555
Okay.
328
00:11:37.745 --> 00:11:39.795
Because at the end of the day, a lot of these people,
329
00:11:39.795 --> 00:11:43.241
whether, if, unless you're a CEO and no one challenges you because you
330
00:11:43.244 --> 00:11:44.687
have a bunch of sycophants around you-
331
00:11:45.091 --> 00:11:48.894
I think that you're in a position very often where you leave a
332
00:11:48.896 --> 00:11:50.251
session and be like, "That's great."
333
00:11:50.537 --> 00:11:50.702
Mm-hmm.
334
00:11:50.726 --> 00:11:53.766
" Brendan Witcher: But I gotta convince a whole organization of this." Right.
335
00:11:53.987 --> 00:11:54.294
To do this,
336
00:11:54.294 --> 00:11:54.304
yeah.
337
00:11:54.304 --> 00:11:55.451
They didn't attend the show.
338
00:11:55.460 --> 00:11:55.747
Right.
339
00:11:55.782 --> 00:11:55.926
They
340
00:11:55.958 --> 00:11:56.538
didn't hear any of that.
341
00:11:56.540 --> 00:11:57.644
I'm the only one that heard all this.
342
00:11:57.656 --> 00:11:57.946
Right.
343
00:11:58.181 --> 00:12:00.494
And I gotta somehow go back and feel like I-
344
00:12:00.494 --> 00:12:01.311
And be convincing
345
00:12:02.033 --> 00:12:03.486
I can speak to this- Yeah.
346
00:12:03.486 --> 00:12:05.933
Right … in a way that people go, "Brilliant."
347
00:12:05.953 --> 00:12:06.266
Brilliant.
348
00:12:06.294 --> 00:12:06.944
That makes sense.
349
00:12:06.954 --> 00:12:07.388
Let's do it.
350
00:12:07.388 --> 00:12:07.730
That makes sense.
351
00:12:07.737 --> 00:12:07.970
Yeah.
352
00:12:08.354 --> 00:12:08.626
Yeah.
353
00:12:08.708 --> 00:12:10.748
You clearly understand this.
354
00:12:10.769 --> 00:12:11.125
Right.
355
00:12:11.384 --> 00:12:13.486
Help us- Right … lead this change, right?
356
00:12:13.486 --> 00:12:13.496
Right.
357
00:12:13.519 --> 00:12:16.785
So, like, those are the four things that I really- Yeah … think.
358
00:12:17.163 --> 00:12:22.444
Again, trying not to be an event company, trying to be a value-based company- Mm-hmm
359
00:12:22.444 --> 00:12:24.173
and a relationship- Yeah … building company-
360
00:12:24.193 --> 00:12:24.440
Yeah
361
00:12:24.442 --> 00:12:26.265
… Brendan Witcher: I think puts you in a different spot of
362
00:12:26.265 --> 00:12:27.617
what you really focus on.
363
00:12:27.671 --> 00:12:27.940
Yeah.
364
00:12:27.982 --> 00:12:30.147
And as you notice, those four things I mentioned had
365
00:12:30.150 --> 00:12:31.532
nothing to do with session counts.
366
00:12:31.568 --> 00:12:31.915
Right.
367
00:12:31.950 --> 00:12:31.970
That's right.
368
00:12:31.970 --> 00:12:32.077
They
369
00:12:32.077 --> 00:12:33.176
had nothing to do with attendees.
370
00:12:33.176 --> 00:12:33.196
That's right.
371
00:12:33.296 --> 00:12:34.190
They had nothing to do with the- Right
372
00:12:34.190 --> 00:12:36.095
level of the speakers, whether they're the CEOs- Right,
373
00:12:36.587 --> 00:12:36.907
right
374
00:12:36.907 --> 00:12:37.804
… Brendan Witcher: or the whatevers, right?
375
00:12:37.805 --> 00:12:37.966
Right.
376
00:12:37.998 --> 00:12:41.827
Because you can learn from everybody- Yeah … if the people that are doing things great.
377
00:12:42.127 --> 00:12:46.869
so to me, this is just something that in my way, in my own little way, I
378
00:12:46.869 --> 00:12:51.745
feel like we're trying to bring, you know, the eco- we're trying to level
379
00:12:51.745 --> 00:12:53.317
up the entire ecosystem together-
380
00:12:53.521 --> 00:12:53.664
Mm-hmm
381
00:12:53.664 --> 00:12:54.472
at one time.
382
00:12:54.508 --> 00:12:54.739
Yeah.
383
00:12:54.751 --> 00:12:57.202
Rather than trying to just be parts of that story.
384
00:12:57.237 --> 00:12:57.525
Yeah.
385
00:12:57.595 --> 00:12:59.117
' Brendan Witcher: Cause very often those won't work if
386
00:12:59.118 --> 00:13:00.162
other parts aren't fulfilled.
387
00:13:00.397
--> 00:13:00.667
Yeah.
388
00:13:01.146 --> 00:13:03.067
No, I think that makes a lot of sense a- actually.
389
00:13:03.068 --> 00:13:05.239
And it's, it'll be good to see how, how things- I try to once in a
390
00:13:05.239 --> 00:13:05.620
while
391
00:13:05.718 --> 00:13:06.040
… Ricardo Belmar: evolve.
392
00:13:06.046 --> 00:13:06.303
Yeah.
393
00:13:06.303 --> 00:13:06.343
Make a little sense.
394
00:13:06.343 --> 00:13:06.874
I know, yeah.
395
00:13:07.055 --> 00:13:08.207
Once in a while or- And you're really, you're good at making sense.
396
00:13:08.207 --> 00:13:08.455
You know.
397
00:13:08.482 --> 00:13:09.846
That's why I like these conversations.
398
00:13:11.196 --> 00:13:11.965
Once in a while.
399
00:13:12.010 --> 00:13:12.335
So, yeah.
400
00:13:12.581 --> 00:13:15.890
So okay, so let's t- talk about another, a thing that I, y- you
401
00:13:15.891 --> 00:13:17.762
know, would be good to make sense of.
402
00:13:17.800 --> 00:13:18.126
All right.
403
00:13:18.444 --> 00:13:21.661
I find a lot of times when you read… When, when,
404
00:13:21.666 --> 00:13:25.208
you know, people are reading what's published or written, documented, what
405
00:13:25.220 --> 00:13:30.082
have you, about what's happening in retail, there's always seems to be a
406
00:13:30.082 --> 00:13:32.657
tendency to overgeneralize, I think.
407
00:13:32.723 --> 00:13:32.975
Oh.
408
00:13:33.307 --> 00:13:36.355
You know, where, w- when… As soon as you hear the phrase, "In
409
00:13:36.355 --> 00:13:38.362
retail, we're doing this," right?
410
00:13:38.538 --> 00:13:41.996
But when you say that, well, retail makes up a lot of different segments or a lot
411
00:13:41.997 --> 00:13:43.549
of different pockets and industries.
412
00:13:43.549 --> 00:13:46.933
There's size, there's scale, there's, you know, grocery's not the same
413
00:13:46.934 --> 00:13:48.817
as selling luxury watches, right?
414
00:13:49.122 --> 00:13:51.572
There, there's all kinds of variations and things.
415
00:13:51.588 --> 00:13:55.328
And it, there's multiple things that kinda come from that that I- I
416
00:13:55.362 --> 00:13:58.156
think about that I don't see a lot of people necessarily talk about.
417
00:13:58.158 --> 00:14:00.599
But I think you, I'm sure you have a, a, a take on this.
418
00:14:01.167 --> 00:14:03.773
That on the one hand, there are things that, you know, one
419
00:14:03.773 --> 00:14:05.165
segment can learn from another.
420
00:14:05.389 --> 00:14:05.636
Yeah.
421
00:14:05.765 --> 00:14:06.048
Right?
422
00:14:06.049 --> 00:14:08.269
Where- Of course … because the challenge may be the same, even if
423
00:14:08.269 --> 00:14:10.192
the way it's implemented might vary.
424
00:14:10.287 --> 00:14:10.531
Yeah.
425
00:14:10.561 --> 00:14:10.742
Right?
426
00:14:10.745 --> 00:14:13.280
Or, or if the target customer may be a little different.
427
00:14:13.711 --> 00:14:17.255
but there are also a lot of things that are not the same, and that when
428
00:14:17.256
--> 00:14:20.687
you overgeneralize it, you end up completely missing the mark, right?
429
00:14:20.742 --> 00:14:23.883
I, I, I'm thinking, like an example I can think of is, the
430
00:14:23.884 --> 00:14:25.134
larger the format of a store.
431
00:14:25.139 --> 00:14:25.163
Yeah.
432
00:14:25.163 --> 00:14:27.090
Like the, you know… Take a department store.
433
00:14:27.093 --> 00:14:29.534
it's, it's, e- al- it's alwa- everyone likes to pick on department
434
00:14:29.534 --> 00:14:33.301
stores from that perspective, like because what's a department, right?
435
00:14:33.301 --> 00:14:36.394
Department really is something different than the next, i- in my view.
436
00:14:36.406 --> 00:14:36.668
Yeah, yeah.
437
00:14:36.821 --> 00:14:39.870
And so what works in one department might not work in another department.
438
00:14:39.870 --> 00:14:40.286
Very true.
439
00:14:40.440 --> 00:14:40.757
Right?
440
00:14:41.120 --> 00:14:46.306
And so if I'm, for example, someone, and I said I'm a department store person,
441
00:14:46.306 --> 00:14:50.002
I'm trying to better understand how I'm gonna engage a customer in a department.
442
00:14:50.079 --> 00:14:52.513
It's not necessarily the same if the department is apparel
443
00:14:52.523 --> 00:14:53.970
versus housewares- Yeah
444
00:14:53.970 --> 00:14:58.225
versus, you know, whatever else or… And, and I think even, even I, I, I
445
00:14:58.226 --> 00:14:59.753
would almost argue even in grocery.
446
00:14:59.767 --> 00:15:03.929
I mean, if I'm a grocer in a part and I have a, a wine section versus, you
447
00:15:03.929 --> 00:15:07.620
know, shelf stable milk, I mean, it, the engagement is a little different
448
00:15:07.962 --> 00:15:09.494
for the customer in question.
449
00:15:10.015 --> 00:15:12.228
But I think technology vendors do this a lot.
450
00:15:12.228 --> 00:15:14.869
They generalize and say, you, you know, talk to any retailer,
451
00:15:14.869 --> 00:15:16.434
well, do this for your customers.
452
00:15:16.773 --> 00:15:19.003
But you haven't really qualified, well, which kind of customer?
453
00:15:19.158 --> 00:15:19.452
Right.
454
00:15:19.456 --> 00:15:19.602
Right?
455
00:15:19.604 --> 00:15:20.399
Or which segment.
456
00:15:20.405 --> 00:15:22.304
So how do you look at that?
457
00:15:22.341 --> 00:15:25.163
And you know, when you're talking to retailers and you're answering questions
458
00:15:25.163 --> 00:15:28.896
about this, and I, I'm sure you've done this in your background as an analyst-
459
00:15:29.022 --> 00:15:29.311
Yeah
460
00:15:29.419 --> 00:15:30.857
where you see people making that mistake.
461
00:15:30.857 --> 00:15:30.884
Yes.
462
00:15:30.884 --> 00:15:32.188
Where they're overgeneralizing.
463
00:15:32.747 --> 00:15:33.189
Yeah.
464
00:15:33.431 --> 00:15:38.203
I, I would say, Everything that you wrapped up there, everything you
465
00:15:38.210 --> 00:15:41.923
said right there- Mm-hmm … I would classify in one way as being, you know,
466
00:15:41.925 --> 00:15:46.672
the, the biggest, the biggest problem today is that, if I can be blunt-
467
00:15:46.759 --> 00:15:47.048
Mm-hmm
468
00:15:47.067 --> 00:15:48.668
is you got too many people that are in
469
00:15:48.670 --> 00:15:52.533
positions of decision-making that are strategically lazy.
470
00:15:52.692 --> 00:15:53.087
Okay.
471
00:15:53.173 --> 00:15:54.603
I wouldn't call it anything but that.
472
00:15:54.794 --> 00:15:55.011
Yeah.
473
00:15:55.011 --> 00:15:56.398
It's just strategic laziness.
474
00:15:56.398 --> 00:15:56.408
Yeah.
475
00:15:57.000 --> 00:15:58.272
And I don't know why they do it.
476
00:15:58.272 --> 00:16:00.510
They may do it 'cause they make a lot of money, and so they feel
477
00:16:00.510 --> 00:16:01.861
like, "I've earned this spot."
478
00:16:02.043 --> 00:16:02.067
Mm-hmm.
479
00:16:02.067 --> 00:16:03.438
"I've been doing it for 30 years." Yeah.
480
00:16:03.438 --> 00:16:05.255
"I don't need to think about this 'cause I know."
481
00:16:05.568 --> 00:16:05.783
Right.
482
00:16:05.784 --> 00:16:06.034
You know?
483
00:16:06.035 --> 00:16:06.417
I already know.
484
00:16:06.417 --> 00:16:06.825
Sort of thing.
485
00:16:06.832 --> 00:16:06.882
Yeah.
486
00:16:06.893 --> 00:16:07.537
I already know.
487
00:16:07.586 --> 00:16:07.849
Yeah.
488
00:16:07.889 --> 00:16:09.608
But it's strategically lazy.
489
00:16:09.908 --> 00:16:14.954
And, and it's, and it's strategically lazy to say, you know, I saw a data
490
00:16:14.955 --> 00:16:19.221
point that said, you know, 98% of people care about sustainability-
491
00:16:19.323 --> 00:16:19.586
Yeah
492
00:16:19.878 --> 00:16:22.491
and then say, "We should focus on sustainability."
493
00:16:22.508 --> 00:16:22.745
Right.
494
00:16:22.775 --> 00:16:24.684
That's a strategically lazy statement.
495
00:16:24.711 --> 00:16:24.887
Yeah.
496
00:16:24.887 --> 00:16:28.466
'Cause at the end of the day, all… Like, the un-lazy thing to do is to
497
00:16:28.468 --> 00:16:32.053
go look at the data- Yeah … and see how many people visit our
498
00:16:32.153 --> 00:16:34.189
corporate sustainability policy page-
499
00:16:34.189 --> 00:16:34.470
Right
500
00:16:34.492 --> 00:16:35.884
… Brendan Witcher: before they make- Right … a purchase.
501
00:16:35.930 --> 00:16:36.512
Right, yeah.
502
00:16:36.999 --> 00:16:38.944
And is anyone even measuring that, ever?
503
00:16:39.658 --> 00:16:41.909
Usually the volume of people visiting that page- … isn't,
504
00:16:41.991 --> 00:16:44.870
enough to create a rounding error- … on your, on your reporting.
505
00:16:45.479 --> 00:16:48.760
So, like, you know, I'm not saying… Like, I'm not against sustainability
506
00:16:48.760 --> 00:16:49.764
as an example- Yeah … right?
507
00:16:49.764 --> 00:16:50.000
Yeah.
508
00:16:50.054 --> 00:16:50.834
I think it's important.
509
00:16:50.853 --> 00:16:53.269
If you find it important, then do it for the reasons.
510
00:16:53.274 --> 00:16:53.287
Mm-hmm.
511
00:16:53.474 -->
00:16:54.810
But don't justify it-
512
00:16:54.931 --> 00:16:55.237
Yeah
513
00:16:55.401 --> 00:16:57.579
… Brendan Witcher: with a data point that just leans into what
514
00:16:57.579 --> 00:16:58.927
you want- Right … to say.
515
00:16:58.947 --> 00:16:59.318
Right.
516
00:16:59.372 --> 00:16:59.686
Right?
517
00:16:59.722 --> 00:16:59.843
Right.
518
00:16:59.845 --> 00:17:01.396
That's strategically lazy.
519
00:17:01.414 --> 00:17:01.749
Yeah.
520
00:17:01.875 --> 00:17:03.765
It is also- Yeah … strategically lazy to be
521
00:17:03.766 --> 00:17:07.063
like, "Okay, everyone's talking about retail media. We should be
522
00:17:07.066 --> 00:17:08.915
focusing- Mm … on retail media." All right, we should do retail media.
523
00:17:08.938 --> 00:17:09.099
"We should do-" Yeah.
524
00:17:09.099 --> 00:17:09.687
"… we should do retail media." Yeah.
525
00:17:09.692 --> 00:17:13.474
"Retail media, retail media." It's like, yeah, it's a, it's an interesting topic.
526
00:17:13.565 --> 00:17:13.689
Mm-hmm.
527
00:17:13.730 --> 00:17:17.915
But when you dig into it, you start to realize there are things that
528
00:17:17.916 --> 00:17:20.684
retail media works for, and there are things that just simply do not.
529
00:17:20.763 --> 00:17:21.055
Yeah.
530
00:17:21.146 --> 00:17:21.449
Right?
531
00:17:21.600 --> 00:17:21.883
Right.
532
00:17:21.954 --> 00:17:24.766
And, and I guess maybe that's probably a topic I'm gonna…
533
00:17:24.910 --> 00:17:27.566
Let me shift over to something that has been around a little
534
00:17:27.566 --> 00:17:28.926
bit longer because I think-
535
00:17:28.951 --> 00:17:29.247
Mm-hmm
536
00:17:30.159 --> 00:17:32.528
… Brendan Witcher: it's more comfortable for more people to hear it like this.
537
00:17:32.903 --> 00:17:33.983
So shoppable video.
538
00:17:34.146 --> 00:17:34.169
Yeah.
539
00:17:34.169 --> 00:17:35.180
Been around a long time.
540
00:17:35.183 --> 00:17:35.619
Oh, yeah.
541
00:17:35.708 --> 00:17:35.902
Right.
542
00:17:35.909 --> 00:17:36.168
Right?
543
00:17:36.266 --> 00:17:36.557
Right.
544
00:17:36.606 --> 00:17:37.226
Long time.
545
00:17:37.248 --> 00:17:39.046
I wrote a report on it many years ago.
546
00:17:40.619 --> 00:17:44.824
And one of the things that I think is really important to understand about
547
00:17:44.833 --> 00:17:49.518
shoppable video is shoppable video makes sense in certain scenarios-
548
00:17:49.521 --> 00:17:49.802
Mm-hmm
549
00:17:50.230 --> 00:17:52.121
and doesn't make sense in other scenarios.
550
00:17:52.143 --> 00:17:52.528
Sure, yeah.
551
00:17:52.528 --> 00:17:54.602
If I'm gonna buy a SodaStream device-
552
00:17:54.676 --> 00:17:55.020
Mm-hmm
553
00:17:55.062 --> 00:17:56.864
… Brendan Witcher: and you don't know what a SodaStream is- Yeah … where
554
00:17:56.865 --> 00:18:00.194
you're making, like, shoppable video makes sense because- Sure,
555
00:18:00.197 --> 00:18:00.481
yeah
556
00:18:00.669 --> 00:18:01.695
… Brendan Witcher: I need to see how- Just open it, gives you an
557
00:18:01.695 --> 00:18:03.391
understanding, you explain … how does this thing work, right?
558
00:18:03.391 --> 00:18:03.401
Right,
559
00:18:03.509 --> 00:18:03.844
right.
560
00:18:03.917 --> 00:18:06.516
Do I need shoppable video to buy Advil?
561
00:18:07.137 --> 00:18:07.700
No.
562
00:18:07.779 --> 00:18:08.054
No.
563
00:18:08.057 --> 00:18:10.021
It, there's no story behind Advil.
564
00:18:10.021 --> 00:18:10.051
There's no story,
565
00:18:10.128 --> 00:18:10.377
yeah.
566
00:18:10.391 --> 00:18:10.677
Right?
567
00:18:10.679 --> 00:18:10.898
You know?
568
00:18:10.898 --> 00:18:10.908
Yeah.
569
00:18:10.908 --> 00:18:12.286
It's like, I know what Advil is.
570
00:18:12.286 --> 00:18:12.458
You know what
571
00:18:12.458 --> 00:18:12.762
it is.
572
00:18:12.820 --> 00:18:15.052
I pop two pills, 20 minutes later, hopefully-
573
00:18:15.052 --> 00:18:15.690
Right … I feel better.
574
00:18:15.852 --> 00:18:16.033
Right.
575
00:18:16.049 --> 00:18:16.767
Call it a day.
576
00:18:16.928 --> 00:18:17.248
Right.
577
00:18:17.402 --> 00:18:20.095
But this is what happens, this is that strategic laziness
578
00:18:20.106 --> 00:18:21.681
that usually works itself over time.
579
00:18:21.928 --> 00:18:22.138
Mm-hmm.
580
00:18:22.183 --> 00:18:22.497
Right?
581
00:18:22.764 --> 00:18:26.235
But when you get something new, strategic laziness is at an all-time high.
582
00:18:26.746 --> 00:18:27.055
Right?
583
00:18:27.153 --> 00:18:31.028
It's like people want to, c- and again, it could be a little bit of the things we've
584
00:18:31.028 --> 00:18:34.063
talked about, could be- Yeah … American culture of being like- Mm-hmm … you
585
00:18:34.065 --> 00:18:36.158
know, we need to get this solved.
586
00:18:36.509 --> 00:18:36.659
Yeah.
587
00:18:36.717 --> 00:18:39.259
I mean, I think you asked your question in the amount of time most
588
00:18:39.260 --> 00:18:41.051
people take in a strategy meeting-
589
00:18:41.071 --> 00:18:43.467
just to talk about strategy, right?
590
00:18:43.468 --> 00:18:43.478
Right.
591
00:18:43.478 --> 00:18:46.610
Like, you just asked questions and you took up 15 minutes, right?
592
00:18:46.610 --> 00:18:47.384
Or whatever it was.
593
00:18:47.432 --> 00:18:47.687
Right, right.
594
00:18:47.711 --> 00:18:49.557
And I think most people are like, "We only have 15 minutes
595
00:18:49.558 --> 00:18:50.560
to solve this problem." Yeah.
596
00:18:50.560 --> 00:18:53.563
It's like, no- Yeah … that's an American culture way of- Right,
597
00:18:53.678 --> 00:18:54.057
right … thinking about it.
598
00:18:54.057 --> 00:18:56.615
It's okay to walk away from a meeting and say, "We don't know yet." We
599
00:18:56.616 --> 00:18:57.430
don't know yet, yeah.
600
00:18:57.509 --> 00:18:57.840
Right?
601
00:18:57.840 --> 00:18:57.850
Right,
602
00:18:57.850 --> 00:18:58.113
right.
603
00:18:58.134 --> 00:19:01.089
So that's that, I think the aggregate of information-
604
00:19:01.089 -->
00:19:01.349
Yeah
605
00:19:01.349 --> 00:19:04.140
… Brendan Witcher: the, the strategic laziness that's going on.
606
00:19:04.389 --> 00:19:06.702
I think you just have too many people that aren't thinking
607
00:19:06.704 --> 00:19:08.357
deeply enough about strategy.
608
00:19:08.430 --> 00:19:08.613
yeah.
609
00:19:08.613 --> 00:19:10.462
They're thinking about solving problems.
610
00:19:10.506 --> 00:19:10.820
Right.
611
00:19:10.820 --> 00:19:15.742
And unfortunately, they're taking ideas and calling them strategy.
612
00:19:15.914 --> 00:19:17.202
There's a big d- That's, there's a big difference … there's,
613
00:19:17.202 --> 00:19:18.456
everyone's got ideas.
614
00:19:18.456 --> 00:19:18.466
Right,
615
00:19:18.698 --> 00:19:18.986
right.
616
00:19:19.005 --> 00:19:19.834
I got an idea right now.
617
00:19:19.925 --> 00:19:20.093
Right.
618
00:19:20.093 --> 00:19:20.844
Everyone's got ideas.
619
00:19:20.848 --> 00:19:20.971
Yeah.
620
00:19:20.971 --> 00:19:21.644
You got an idea right now.
621
00:19:21.718 --> 00:19:21.849
Yeah.
622
00:19:21.849 --> 00:19:22.435
Everyone's got them,
623
00:19:22.473 --> 00:19:22.797
right?
624
00:19:22.877 --> 00:19:23.206
Right.
625
00:19:23.333 --> 00:19:25.408
The difference between an idea and a strategy is a strategy's
626
00:19:25.409 --> 00:19:27.060
actually been worked out and vetted.
627
00:19:27.233 --> 00:19:27.540
Yeah.
628
00:19:27.903 --> 00:19:30.912
There's some, some sort of- foresight
629
00:19:30.913 --> 00:19:32.459
that's trying to be hindsight-
630
00:19:32.725 --> 00:19:33.055
Right
631
00:19:33.137 --> 00:19:35.586
… Brendan Witcher: in calculating the possibility of this-
632
00:19:35.586 --> 00:19:36.694
Yeah … and if there's variables.
633
00:19:36.694 --> 00:19:37.414
Right, right.
634
00:19:37.414 --> 00:19:37.424
Right?
635
00:19:37.692 --> 00:19:41.960
Go back, going back to retail media, there's a reason that Amazon owns
636
00:19:41.967 --> 00:19:45.242
76%- of the retail media space.
637
00:19:45.273 --> 00:19:45.591
Yeah,
638
00:19:45.591 --> 00:19:45.601
yeah.
639
00:19:45.660 --> 00:19:50.413
And Walmart, the second number one- Right … second person, owns- Right … 6%.
640
00:19:50.477 --> 00:19:50.864
Right.
641
00:19:51.338 --> 00:19:54.073
Like, that in and of itself is one thing to consider.
642
00:19:54.073 --> 00:19:54.396
Right,
643
00:19:54.482 --> 00:19:54.621
yeah.
644
00:19:54.621 --> 00:19:55.584
That's 82%.
645
00:19:55.584 --> 00:19:55.826
Yeah.
646
00:19:55.901 --> 00:19:58.537
That leaves 18% for the rest of the people to-
647
00:19:58.780 --> 00:19:59.496
Right … the whole industry-
648
00:19:59.496 --> 00:19:59.999
For everyone else,
649
00:19:59.999 --> 00:20:01.052
right … to scrap over.
650
00:20:01.075 --> 00:20:02.069
Right, right.
651
00:20:02.069 --> 00:20:04.735
So then you start to say to yourself, "If everyone's
652
00:20:04.737 --> 00:20:07.272
talking about retail media, we should focus on retail media." Yeah.
653
00:20:07.272 --> 00:20:11.296
But if you say, "But there's only 14% of that $44 billion that's
654
00:20:11.297 --> 00:20:12.901
gonna spread over everybody-" Yeah,
655
00:20:13.089 --> 00:20:13.351
yeah
656
00:20:13.355 --> 00:20:14.619
… Brendan Witcher: maybe it isn't worth it.
657
00:20:14.625 --> 00:20:14.642
Yeah.
658
00:20:14.660 --> 00:20:17.806
That's the un-strategic, that's the un-lazy way of thinking about
659
00:20:17.808 --> 00:20:17.836
something.
660
00:20:17.836 --> 00:20:19.150
Well, it requires more analysis, right?
661
00:20:19.151 --> 00:20:22.497
You have to think it through, and I, I feel like it- it ties back to,
662
00:20:22.498 --> 00:20:25.841
you know, it- an idea doesn't have an execution plan attached to it-
663
00:20:25.845 --> 00:20:26.160
Yeah
664
00:20:26.231 --> 00:20:26.432
… Ricardo Belmar: right?
665
00:20:26.432 --> 00:20:27.290
But a strategy should.
666
00:20:27.354 --> 00:20:27.690
Yeah.
667
00:20:28.007 --> 00:20:28.114
Right?
668
00:20:28.117 --> 00:20:30.963
It's one of those things where you, if you think-- I think every parent
669
00:20:30.969 --> 00:20:33.899
should at some point look at their children and go, "Think it through."
670
00:20:34.389 --> 00:20:34.970
That's right.
671
00:20:35.206 --> 00:20:36.209
Who hasn't had that mo- Think it through.
672
00:20:36.209 --> 00:20:36.857
What parent hasn't
673
00:20:36.857 --> 00:20:37.041
had
674
00:20:37.042 --> 00:20:37.372
that moment?
675
00:20:37.385 --> 00:20:40.440
And I think more leaders need to do that to themselves- Yeah, let's
676
00:20:40.441 --> 00:20:41.170
think this through … and to their team.
677
00:20:41.170 --> 00:20:42.802
It's like- Let's think this through … just, just those words.
678
00:20:42.908 --> 00:20:43.112
Yeah.
679
00:20:43.132 --> 00:20:44.332
Three words, and then leave it.
680
00:20:44.415 --> 00:20:44.554
Yeah.
681
00:20:44.554 --> 00:20:45.064
Just leave silence.
682
00:20:45.064 --> 00:20:45.753
And let it sit, yeah.
683
00:20:45.754 --> 00:20:46.802
Like, think it through.
684
00:20:46.802 --> 00:20:47.688
It's like, you know-
685
00:20:47.731 --> 00:20:47.862
Yeah
686
00:20:47.864 --> 00:20:50.279
… Brendan Witcher: on Friends when Joey would, like- Right … say something
687
00:20:50.279 --> 00:20:51.937
and be like- … "You'll get it."
688
00:20:51.941 --> 00:20:52.316
Okay.
689
00:20:52.317 --> 00:20:52.638
Right?
690
00:20:52.638 --> 00:20:52.648
Right.
691
00:20:52.669 --> 00:20:54.414
It's like- Yeah … think it through.
692
00:20:54.452 --> 00:20:54.673
Right.
693
00:20:54.678 --> 00:20:54.968
Right?
694
00:20:55.057 --> 00:20:55.279
Right.
695
00:20:55.280 --> 00:20:57.256
And I think there's not enough of that going on.
696
00:20:57.282 --> 00:20:57.461
Yeah.
697
00:20:57.461 --> 00:20:58.988
And like, we laugh about it-
698
00:20:59.055 --> 00:20:59.300
Yeah
699
00:20:59.313 --> 00:21:03.704
… Brendan Witcher: but at the end of the day, I have to say with all honesty, and
700
00:21:03.705 --> 00:21:07.901
I really hope
that, like- People know I'm not trying to, like, rip on anybody.
701
00:21:07.995 --> 00:21:08.202
Yeah.
702
00:21:08.213 --> 00:21:10.675
But I'm trying to speak truth here, where like that's why
703
00:21:10.675 --> 00:21:11.829
your strategies are failing.
704
00:21:11.909 --> 00:21:13.446
It's not 'cause you have bad ideas.
705
00:21:13.447 --> 00:21:15.855
It's not- Yeah … 'cause the tech isn't available- Right … certainly.
706
00:21:15.888 --> 00:21:16.218
Right.
707
00:21:16.303 --> 00:21:16.653
Right?
708
00:21:16.696 --> 00:21:17.065
Exactly.
709
00:21:17.072 --> 00:21:19.118
It isn't because you don't have the right talent.
710
00:21:19.292 --> 00:21:19.302
Mm-hmm.
711
00:21:19.302 --> 00:21:21.969
It's because you haven't thought about the strategy you need-
712
00:21:22.099 --> 00:21:22.408
Yeah
713
00:21:22.705 --> 00:21:25.272
in light of the tal- te- te- tech that's out there.
714
00:21:25.272 --> 00:21:25.282
Right.
715
00:21:25.327 --> 00:21:26.918
In light of the talent that you have.
716
00:21:26.918 --> 00:21:26.928
Right.
717
00:21:27.130 --> 00:21:29.873
In light of the amount of ideas- Mm … you're trying to work on.
718
00:21:29.876 --> 00:21:29.960
Yeah.
719
00:21:29.965 --> 00:21:30.223
Right?
720
00:21:30.498 --> 00:21:30.659
Yeah.
721
00:21:30.665 --> 00:21:33.882
The context of those things- … are what makes strategy work.
722
00:21:33.932 --> 00:21:34.262
Right.
723
00:21:34.337 --> 00:21:36.232
And there's just not enough of that going on.
724
00:21:36.233 --> 00:21:36.490
Yeah.
725
00:21:36.911 --> 00:21:37.377
Period.
726
00:21:37.377 --> 00:21:37.394
Yeah,
727
00:21:37.408 --> 00:21:37.912
exactly.
728
00:21:37.936 --> 00:21:38.211
Yeah.
729
00:21:38.289 --> 00:21:39.747
' Brendan Witcher: Cause if you can't get that, the rest
730
00:21:39.748 --> 00:21:40.847
of it really doesn't matter.
731
00:21:40.889 --> 00:21:42.869
All those pieces combined are, are, are what's
732
00:21:42.870 --> 00:21:44.837
gonna actually lead to success.
733
00:21:44.892 --> 00:21:45.054
Yeah.
734
00:21:45.054 --> 00:21:46.744
If you don't- if you leave one of those pieces out, it's gonna fall apart.
735
00:21:46.756 --> 00:21:46.854
Yeah.
736
00:21:46.855 --> 00:21:48.093
It's not sexy and fun.
737
00:21:48.180 --> 00:21:48.422
Yeah.
738
00:21:48.441 --> 00:21:49.058
It's very- It's the
739
00:21:49.058 --> 00:21:49.412
hard work
740
00:21:49.417 --> 00:21:49.783
unsexy and
741
00:21:49.859 --> 00:21:50.103
hard work.
742
00:21:50.103 --> 00:21:50.515
It's the hard work part.
743
00:21:50.532 --> 00:21:50.755
Yeah.
744
00:21:50.755 --> 00:21:50.765
Right?
745
00:21:50.765 --> 00:21:52.883
It's the hard work- Right … that has to get done to make it,
746
00:21:53.491 --> 00:21:54.495
to make a positive result.
747
00:21:54.523 --> 00:21:54.765
Yeah.
748
00:21:54.765 --> 00:21:54.775
Yeah.
749
00:21:54.916 --> 00:21:55.791
Period, end of story.
750
00:21:55.795 --> 00:21:56.053
Yeah.
751
00:21:56.250 --> 00:21:58.337
You know, and that's
not gonna make it into CNBC's, you
752
00:21:58.338 --> 00:21:59.638
know, headlines- … or anything, right?
753
00:21:59.695 --> 00:21:59.940
No,
754
00:21:59.940 --> 00:21:59.950
no.
755
00:21:59.950 --> 00:22:01.126
'Cause it's not a fun headline.
756
00:22:01.141 --> 00:22:01.414
Right.
757
00:22:01.434 --> 00:22:01.748
No, it's not.
758
00:22:01.748 --> 00:22:01.758
You
759
00:22:01.758 --> 00:22:03.743
know, retailers and brands need to think more and
760
00:22:03.743 --> 00:22:04.311
work harder.
761
00:22:05.492 --> 00:22:05.981
Need to think it through.
762
00:22:05.981 --> 00:22:06.110
They need to think it through.
763
00:22:06.110 --> 00:22:06.196
Right.
764
00:22:06.279 --> 00:22:07.208
That's definitely gonna be a headline.
765
00:22:07.208 --> 00:22:07.404
You know?
766
00:22:07.406 --> 00:22:07.686
Yeah.
767
00:22:07.826 --> 00:22:09.121
One of you out there- Yeah … one of my
768
00:22:09.121 --> 00:22:10.636
friends in the media, please-
769
00:22:10.636 --> 00:22:10.944
Right
770
00:22:11.202 --> 00:22:11.905
… Brendan Witcher: write that.
771
00:22:11.981 --> 00:22:12.592
Write that down.
772
00:22:12.604 --> 00:22:12.897
Think it through.
773
00:22:12.897 --> 00:22:12.951
You
774
00:22:12.951 --> 00:22:13.223
know?
775
00:22:13.269 --> 00:22:14.181
it'd be a great article.
776
00:22:14.196 --> 00:22:17.591
So, well, so I'm thinking, so in, in light of thinking
777
00:22:17.591 --> 00:22:20.738
it through- Yeah … here's one that I'm, I'm personally struggling to
778
00:22:20.741 --> 00:22:21.987
think this one through a little bit.
779
00:22:22.448 --> 00:22:27.207
But on the consumer side, we're in the midst right now of these personal
780
00:22:27.212 --> 00:22:28.395
agents I'll, I'll call, right,- Yeah
781
00:22:28.395 --> 00:22:29.192
that are coming out, right?
782
00:22:29.194 --> 00:22:29.991
Meta's Muse.
783
00:22:29.991 --> 00:22:30.804
There's Insight.
784
00:22:30.804 --> 00:22:30.814
Yeah.
785
00:22:31.140 --> 00:22:32.118
And, and I'm sure there's others.
786
00:22:32.118 --> 00:22:34.151
I'm not even remembering the name- Sure … and, and thinking of,
787
00:22:34.549 --> 00:22:38.782
where they're being billed as- Connect it to all your information,
788
00:22:38.782 --> 00:22:41.722
to your life, and the agent can do anything for you, just about, right?
789
00:22:41.735 --> 00:22:44.841
Set it off, have it do your shopping for you, have it buy your travel,
790
00:22:44.842 --> 00:22:47.571
make your travel plans, buy your airline tickets, do whatever.
791
00:22:48.342 --> 00:22:52.435
And I struggle with this one because when I think it through, I think through
792
00:22:52.436 --> 00:22:56.282
of how much of this information do I really want these people to have,
793
00:22:57.127 --> 00:23:00.562
regardless of whatever they claim or, or, you know, the claims they make
794
00:23:00.568 --> 00:23:04.183
about how they're not gonna misuse this information or not use it.
795
00:23:04.183 --> 00:23:06.996
But I'm, I'm
curious what you think of these.
796
00:23:07.336 --> 00:23:09.063
And, and I don't know, have you tried any of these, by the way?
797
00:23:09.112 --> 00:23:09.390
Oh, yeah,
798
00:23:09.390 --> 00:23:09.653
yeah.
799
00:23:09.715 --> 00:23:10.017
Okay.
800
00:23:10.208 --> 00:23:13.494
So, so what are, what are your, what are your thoughts on, on consumers,
801
00:23:13.518 --> 00:23:17.007
you know, relying on these agents and, and use them and, and I don't
802
00:23:17.007 --> 00:23:19.380
know, what, what are, what's a retailer supposed to think about this?
803
00:23:19.428 --> 00:23:22.369
I, I, I don't think that that is a exercise
804
00:23:22.690 --> 00:23:24.138
in a lot of brain power.
805
00:23:24.156 --> 00:23:24.171
Mm-hmm.
806
00:23:24.172 --> 00:23:27.298
Like, that que- like, the, the, the answer to that question doesn't
807
00:23:27.298 --> 00:23:28.106
require a lot of brain power.
808
00:23:28.108 --> 00:23:28.356
Yeah.
809
00:23:28.380 --> 00:23:29.363
I don't, I don't think that's hard.
810
00:23:29.363 --> 00:23:32.314
Because I think consumers are fairly simple creatures.
811
00:23:32.352 --> 00:23:32.691
Mm-hmm.
812
00:23:32.726 --> 00:23:35.768
We will do the things, like most of… Like, if you look
813
00:23:35.769 --> 00:23:39.052
at the numbers, you'll probably find that, I'm guessing here, but like 60%
814
00:23:39.053 --> 00:23:41.503
of people will put their own names into ChatGPT and see what it says.
815
00:23:41.503 --> 00:23:41.727
Yeah.
816
00:23:41.760 --> 00:23:42.343
Like, we're gonna-
817
00:23:42.415 --> 00:23:42.649
Right.
818
00:23:42.659 --> 00:23:42.679
Yeah, yeah
819
00:23:42.679 --> 00:23:44.198
… Brendan Witcher: like, we kind of know how consumers- Yeah … are
820
00:23:44.199 --> 00:23:45.180
gonna use these things.
821
00:23:45.200 --> 00:23:45.434
Right.
822
00:23:45.434 --> 00:23:45.717
Right?
823
00:23:45.748 --> 00:23:47.392
Like- Right … and there's gonna be a mix.
824
00:23:47.422 --> 00:23:48.397
Of course, there's gonna be a mix.
825
00:23:48.397 --> 00:23:48.422
Mm-hmm.
826
00:23:48.422 --> 00:23:50.758
There's not gonna be one way, getting back- Right … to our earlier question.
827
00:23:50.758 --> 00:23:50.990
Yeah.
828
00:23:51.233 --> 00:23:53.279
There's not gonna be one way people use these tools.
829
00:23:53.279 --> 00:23:53.671
Right.
830
00:23:53.671 --> 00:23:56.464
They're gonna use it in all sorts of crazy ways and learn certain things, right?
831
00:23:56.683 --> 00:23:59.579
So I don't think we're at the stage yet where we have to worry
832
00:23:59.579 --> 00:24:00.760
about that, 'cause I think-
833
00:24:00.760 --> 00:24:01.008
Yeah
834
00:24:01.199 --> 00:24:03.841
… Brendan Witcher: we can make some assumptions, and we'd probably be right.
835
00:24:03.843 --> 00:24:03.974
Yeah.
836
00:24:03.974 --> 00:24:05.163
Consumers are easy.
837
00:24:05.320 --> 00:24:05.643
Yeah.
838
00:24:06.224 --> 00:24:09.042
The harder question to answer, which is probably the more
839
00:24:09.043 --> 00:24:12.640
important one, and the one that really will define what the industry turns
840
00:24:12.640 --> 00:24:15.527
into, is what will the tech companies do-
841
00:24:15.539 --> 00:24:17.301
to enable these agents to do things?
842
00:24:17.338 --> 00:24:17.638
Yeah.
843
00:24:17.687 --> 00:24:19.866
I'll give you an example of what I mean- Yeah … and
844
00:24:19.873 --> 00:24:23.409
just how disruptive that factor is- Okay … versus what consumers do.
845
00:24:23.409 --> 00:24:23.419
Yeah.
846
00:24:23.959 --> 00:24:27.504
A consumer could build an a- I think you and I would agree that there will be
847
00:24:27.504 --> 00:24:32.100
at least one human being out there that will build an agent, summarize my emails.
848
00:24:32.716 --> 00:24:32.851
Right.
849
00:24:34.005 --> 00:24:34.207
Yeah.
850
00:24:34.210 --> 00:24:34.402
Right?
851
00:24:34.466 --> 00:24:34.733
Yeah.
852
00:24:34.757 --> 00:24:35.183
For sure.
853
00:24:35.225 --> 00:24:35.340
No
854
00:24:35.340 --> 00:24:35.394
doubt.
855
00:24:35.394 --> 00:24:38.271
I'll bet dollars to donuts- Yeah … with any human being out there- Yep,
856
00:24:38.271 --> 00:24:38.534
that's a safe bet.
857
00:24:38.686 --> 00:24:40.528
Yeah … that there will be someone to do that.
858
00:24:40.529 --> 00:24:40.545
Yeah.
859
00:24:41.145 --> 00:24:42.221
That's not the problem.
860
00:24:42.361 --> 00:24:42.736
Mm-hmm.
861
00:24:42.820 --> 00:24:43.634
That's not the question.
862
00:24:43.721 --> 00:24:44.875
That's an easy one to answer.
863
00:24:44.937 --> 00:24:45.645
That's gonna happen.
864
00:24:45.654 --> 00:24:45.664
Yeah.
865
00:24:45.782 --> 00:24:46.472
Period, end of story.
866
00:24:47.302 --> 00:24:51.661
The question will be, what does the tech company who builds that agent or who
867
00:24:51.663 --> 00:24:57.634
enables that agent do with the kinds of emails it could put out as a summary?
868
00:24:57.750 --> 00:25:01.307
There's a lot of emails that are, are written very loosely.
869
00:25:01.410 --> 00:25:01.711
Yeah.
870
00:25:01.820 --> 00:25:04.186
There's a lot of emails that are written very formally.
871
00:25:04.292 --> 00:25:04.465
Right, right.
872
00:25:04.466 --> 00:25:06.621
There's emails that are mostly imagery.
873
00:25:06.704 --> 00:25:07.274
Right, yeah.
874
00:25:07.327 --> 00:25:07.615
Exactly, yeah.
875
00:25:07.623 --> 00:25:09.852
There's, there's- Yeah … there's emails that have
876
00:25:09.866 --> 00:25:13.069
alt text as the- Mm … primary thing that an AI is gonna read.
877
00:25:13.069 --> 00:25:13.413
Right,
878
00:25:13.572 --> 00:25:13.908
right.
879
00:25:13.908 --> 00:25:13.918
Right?
880
00:25:13.951 --> 00:25:14.215
Right.
881
00:25:14.215 --> 00:25:16.699
You know, graphic 5.2.6- Yeah.
882
00:25:16.699 --> 00:25:17.711
… is behind this image.
883
00:25:17.713 --> 00:25:18.025
Right.
884
00:25:18.335 --> 00:25:18.742
Right?
885
00:25:18.812 --> 00:25:19.018
Right.
886
00:25:19.019 --> 00:25:20.967
That's what the AI's
gonna think it's copying.
887
00:25:20.967 --> 00:25:21.303
That's what it's gonna see.
888
00:25:21.318 --> 00:25:22.109
Exactly, yeah.
889
00:25:22.207 --> 00:25:22.446
Right?
890
00:25:22.446 --> 00:25:22.640
Yeah.
891
00:25:22.843 --> 00:25:25.430
And then suddenly they're gonna start to say, "Well, do I need to look at
892
00:25:25.430 --> 00:25:28.907
the subject line?" Well, God forbid, because we know that marketers often
893
00:25:28.909 --> 00:25:31.560
put very misleading subject lines.
894
00:25:31.560 --> 00:25:31.807
Right,
895
00:25:31.847 --> 00:25:32.085
right.
896
00:25:32.085 --> 00:25:32.237
Yeah, yeah.
897
00:25:32.237 --> 00:25:33.663
You know, like, "You've won a car."
898
00:25:33.667 --> 00:25:33.940
Yeah.
899
00:25:34.296 --> 00:25:36.373
But really- Yeah … I'm talking to you about a timeshare.
900
00:25:36.373 --> 00:25:36.529
Right.
901
00:25:36.529 --> 00:25:36.751
Right?
902
00:25:36.751 --> 00:25:41.003
Like- Yeah … there's, there's so much that I think, like, we need to
903
00:25:41.003 --> 00:25:42.727
worry about from the middle layer.
904
00:25:42.772 --> 00:25:43.062
Yeah.
905
00:25:43.083 --> 00:25:45.131
That's where it's really gonna be- Right … the change.
906
00:25:45.164 --> 00:25:45.849
That's the challenge.
907
00:25:45.849 --> 00:25:46.293
Yeah.
908
00:25:46.293 --> 00:25:47.882
The s- the, the consumer part of it's easy.
909
00:25:47.887 --> 00:25:48.192
Yeah.
910
00:25:48.455 --> 00:25:49.988
Like, we can imagine the scenarios.
911
00:25:49.988 --> 00:25:50.264
Right.
912
00:25:50.406 --> 00:25:53.554
The challenge is gonna be what are they g- what
913
00:25:53.554 --> 00:25:54.988
are they gonna do is the question.
914
00:25:55.253 --> 00:25:55.368
Mm-hmm.
915
00:25:55.386 --> 00:26:02.358
The challenge is are we prepared to stay abreast of all the things they're doing-
916
00:26:02.770 --> 00:26:03.045
Right
917
00:26:03.064 --> 00:26:06.307
… Brendan Witcher: test these engines on a regular basis- Right … run our
918
00:26:06.307 --> 00:26:08.636
emails through there, who looks at it-
919
00:26:08.727 --> 00:26:09.044
Right
920
00:26:09.049 --> 00:26:10.300
… Brendan Witcher: who makes sure it's right?
921
00:26:10.300 --> 00:26:10.310
Right.
922
00:26:10.522 --> 00:26:13.221
Like, and how many- Yeah … different engines do we need to test
923
00:26:13.245 --> 00:26:14.858
this on and blah, blah, blah.
924
00:26:14.860 --> 00:26:14.870
Yeah.
925
00:26:14.870 --> 00:26:15.501
Right, right.
926
00:26:15.539 --> 00:26:18.391
And, and if it comes out wrong, who's gonna
927
00:26:18.395 --> 00:26:19.303
fix it- Who's gonna do that?
928
00:26:19.303 --> 00:26:20.414
Right … before we need to resend it?
929
00:26:20.414 --> 00:26:20.424
Yeah.
930
00:26:20.484 --> 00:26:20.736
Right?
931
00:26:20.736 --> 00:26:20.756
Before we
932
00:26:20.756 --> 00:26:21.237
try again.
933
00:26:21.237 --> 00:26:22.119
Like, and then- Yeah … who's gonna run
934
00:26:22.119 --> 00:26:22.991
through that whole process again-
935
00:26:22.991 --> 00:26:24.086
The whole process again, right
936
00:26:24.095 --> 00:26:24.326
… Brendan Witcher: on version two?
937
00:26:24.326 --> 00:26:25.350
And reevaluate.
938
00:26:25.406 --> 00:26:25.695
Yeah.
939
00:26:25.797 --> 00:26:29.466
So, like, that to me is really what we're coming- Mm up against.
940
00:26:29.466 --> 00:26:29.476
Yeah.
941
00:26:29.671 --> 00:26:31.003
It isn't the consumer behavior.
942
00:26:31.026 --> 00:26:31.342
Yeah.
943
00:26:31.464 --> 00:26:34.869
Like- Interesting, yeah … I think it's, it's, I think it's saying
944
00:26:34.879 --> 00:26:39.291
in a world where AI is being enabled by so many players in the space- Yeah
945
00:26:39.291 --> 00:26:43.714
… and so many layers in the ecosystem-
946
00:26:43.771 --> 00:26:44.140
Mm-hmm
947
00:26:44.410 --> 00:26:49.213
… Brendan Witcher: that exists, how are we going to operate as a business where
948
00:26:49.520 --> 00:26:54.392
what the customer sees or experiences isn't exactly what they thought-
949
00:26:54.449 --> 00:26:55.863
Right … they would see- Right … or experience?
950
00:26:55.890 --> 00:26:56.179
Yeah.
951
00:26:56.216 --> 00:26:57.589
' Brendan Witcher: Cause that's- Yeah … the nature of an agent.
952
00:26:57.691 --> 00:26:57.928
Right.
953
00:26:57.928 --> 00:27:00.206
An agent is- … me telling you something-
954
00:27:00.206 --> 00:27:00.438
That's right
955
00:27:00.484 --> 00:27:01.729
… Brendan Witcher: and then you telling this guy- Yeah … in the
956
00:27:01.729 --> 00:27:02.897
cool hat over there something.
957
00:27:02.900 --> 00:27:03.259
Yeah.
958
00:27:03.259 --> 00:27:03.269
Right,
959
00:27:03.306 --> 00:27:03.587
right.
960
00:27:03.617 --> 00:27:06.395
Like, that's what we're really- Yeah … talking about here.
961
00:27:06.395 --> 00:27:06.821
Yeah, exactly.
962
00:27:06.821 --> 00:27:06.831
Exactly.
963
00:27:06.834 --> 00:27:08.438
You're the, you're the variable.
964
00:27:08.448 --> 00:27:08.729
Right.
965
00:27:09.973 --> 00:27:10.139
Yeah.
966
00:27:10.257 --> 00:27:11.822
You know- Yeah … they're gonna hear what they hear.
967
00:27:12.305 --> 00:27:12.318
Right.
968
00:27:12.318 --> 00:27:13.279
I'm gonna say what I say.
969
00:27:13.310 --> 00:27:13.650
Right.
970
00:27:13.893 --> 00:27:16.374
But you are a independent- Yeah … and someone else is
971
00:27:16.383 --> 00:27:19.008
paying your, like, through advertising- Right, right … you're getting
972
00:27:19.162 --> 00:27:19.505
paid- Through ad- yeah, through the
973
00:27:19.508 --> 00:27:19.944
advertising.
974
00:27:19.944 --> 00:27:21.447
Right, exactly … to do a certain thing a certain way.
975
00:27:21.498 --> 00:27:21.755
Yeah, yeah.
976
00:27:21.800 --> 00:27:24.965
And your technologists have views- Yeah … on things, so at the end of the day, I
977
00:27:24.966 --> 00:27:26.280
think that that's what becomes important.
978
00:27:26.287 --> 00:27:26.531
Yeah.
979
00:27:26.965 --> 00:27:28.861
Yeah, so that, that's a, a great take.
980
00:27:28.862 --> 00:27:29.601
I l- I love that.
981
00:27:29.613 --> 00:27:30.940
The, And you're right, it's interesting, but that's not
982
00:27:30.940 --> 00:27:31.745
what anybody's thinking about.
983
00:27:32.209 --> 00:27:33.447
That's not the part anyone's worrying about.
984
00:27:33.447 --> 00:27:35.076
Everyone's worried about the consumer- Process … adoption right now.
985
00:27:35.076 --> 00:27:35.335
Right, 'cause
986
00:27:35.338 --> 00:27:36.103
that's the sexy topic.
987
00:27:36.122 --> 00:27:37.718
Exactly, 'cause that's the one that gets the headlines.
988
00:27:37.718 --> 00:27:38.275
Right, right.
989
00:27:38.461 --> 00:27:40.299
That's like, "Well, what are all the cool things we
990
00:27:40.597 --> 00:27:41.779
can think of- Right, right … the consumer's gonna do?" Exactly, yeah.
991
00:27:41.781 --> 00:27:42.053
Like-
992
00:27:42.086 --> 00:27:42.848
Yeah … all right.
993
00:27:42.917 --> 00:27:43.200
Right.
994
00:27:43.200 --> 00:27:43.847
But that's not the problem.
995
00:27:43.856 --> 00:27:46.059
But that's not the actual challenge that- That's not the
996
00:27:46.059 --> 00:27:48.139
problem … impacts your retail business and how you, that you have to respond to.
997
00:27:48.181 --> 00:27:48.436
No.
998
00:27:48.436 --> 00:27:48.446
No.
999
00:27:48.446 --> 00:27:49.066
Right, right.
1000
00:27:49.083 --> 00:27:49.692
Absolutely.
1001
00:27:49.694 --> 00:27:49.724
That
1002
00:27:49.725 --> 00:27:50.257
was a great take.
1003
00:27:50.257 --> 00:27:52.038
Well, Brendan, I appreciate this.
1004
00:27:52.038 --> 00:27:54.132
This was a super fun conversation.
1005
00:27:54.168 --> 00:27:55.420
I, I always love when we do this.
1006
00:27:55.635 --> 00:27:57.187
We're, we have to have you come back and do this again.
1007
00:27:57.252 --> 00:27:57.614
Anytime.
1008
00:27:57.863 --> 00:27:58.073
Okay.
1009
00:27:58.089 --> 00:27:58.512
Thank you.
1010
00:27:58.559 --> 00:27:59.044
So thanks.
1011
00:27:59.323 --> 00:28:01.330
And that's it for us from Shop Talk Fall.
1012
00:28:08.052 --> 00:28:09.636
Admit it, you loved this episode.
1013
00:28:09.651 --> 00:28:10.394
I know you did.
1014
00:28:10.405 --> 00:28:14.910
Drop us a five-star rating and review on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or Goodpods.
1015
00:28:15.325 --> 00:28:18.635
And if you're watching on YouTube, like and subscribe before you go.
1016
00:28:18.691 --> 00:28:19.695
I'm Casey Golden.
1017
00:28:20.024 --> 00:28:22.884
Follow us on LinkedIn, Bluesky, Threads, and Instagram,
1018
00:28:22.905 --> 00:28:26.022
and subscribe to our Substack for highlights and bonus content.
1019
00:28:26.287 --> 00:28:29.614
For transcripts and guest info, visit retailrazor.com.
1020
00:28:29.887 --> 00:28:30.873
I'm Ricardo Belmar.
1021
00:28:31.149 --> 00:28:34.436
Thanks for joining us on Retail Transformers, part of
1022
00:28:34.436 --> 00:28:36.240
the Retail Razor podcast network
1023
00:28:36.370 --> 00:28:38.465
Until next time, stay sharp, be bold,
1024
00:28:38.465 --> 00:28:40.122
and keep transforming retail.
1025
00:28:40.166 --> 00:28:42.829
This is the Retail Razor: Retail Transformers.