TRANSKRIPT 🔗
Chris Vance: Welcome and thank you for joining us for another episode of the Republican Legacy Podcast, the official podcast of our Republican Legacy. We are a group of Republican activists across the country working to restore our party to core traditional conservative principles, focused very heavily on the election of 2028. we're going to talk about that. First, I want to introduce Meryl Matthews, our Texas chair, regular columnist in the Hill. My name's Chris Vance. I'm a former Republican lawmaker, former chairman of the Washington State Republican Party, now ORL's executive director. Real quick, if you like what we're doing and you believe in our cause, you can go to our Republican Legacy dot com, join our national committee. You can make a donation if you're So inspired. And we're going to be having two very special events coming up from 9 30 to 10 30 Eastern on election night. We'll be right here with Lynn and Meryl and other guests reacting to the election results in the midterm as they come in. And then on November 11th, in the early evening, we're going to be holding a national committee meeting on Zoom, and other platforms, again with ORL messengers and leaders again talking about the results of the midterm. And this episode is all about the midterms, which are less than three weeks away now. We're very lucky to have with us Wit Ayres, North Star Opinion Research, one of the really outstanding Republican pollsters out there. if you're a regular here, you've seen him here before. Wit's a good friend of our Republican legacy. Wit, we're three weeks out. Thanks for joining us. How is this election looking to you? Big picture.
Whit Ayres: Chris, it's good to be with you once again. it is a very, very critical midterm election, obviously. All the tide is flowing toward the Democrats' direction right now. I think if the election were held today, the Democrats would take not only the House but also the Senate. But we still have three weeks ago and tens of millions of dollars yet to be spent. And we know that that can affect the outcome of elections. So I think even with the tens of millions, the Democrats are likely to take the House. The real question there is the margin, and the Senate is still very much up in the air, depending upon how the next three weeks go.
Chris Vance: Great. Well I know you have some data to show us, so let you get that up there. I know that the first thing we want to talk about is the president's approval rating, which is always the mean driver in midterms.
Whit Ayres: Alrighty, Donald Trump did not start off as a particularly popular president. In fact, he started off as the second most unpopular president in 2025 when he was inaugurated, surpassed only by Donald Trump's first term, where he was a little less popular. But he has steadily declined. And he's currently somewhere around 37 to 38 percent job approval, based on an average of recent polls, with about sixty percent job disapproval. his strong disapproval
Load full transcript
is more than twice his strong approval, which goes to show just how intense
Merrill Matthews: Mm.
Whit Ayres: the opposition is to the Trump administration. about two-thirds of Americans say the Trump administration has made the economy worse, including three-fourths of independents and one-fourth of Republicans. This is a major problem for the administration because Donald Trump was re-elected in 2024 to do four things: to bring down inflation, to juice the economy, to stop illegal immigration, and to get away from woke culture. So on the top issues for which he was re-elected. It is a real problem, say when sixty-three percent of the registered voters say he's made the economy worse rather than better, including virtually unanimous Democrats. But when three-quarters of independents say he's made the economy worse, that's a real problem for Republican candidates this year. Donald Trump retains almost unanimous favorable ratings among MAGA Republicans. They're the mirror image of the Democrats. 90 to 4 favorable, unfavorable for among MAGA GOP, 4 to 93 among Democrats.
Merrill Matthews: Mm.
Whit Ayres: But it's interesting that the non-MAGA portion of the GOP, more traditional Republicans, are still saying of 59% approval, but 40% disapproval or unfavorable rating, which is pretty significant. It's also, as we saw the last slide with three-quarters of independents saying, The Trump administration has made the economy worse. Three quarters of independents have an unfavorable view of Donald Trump.
Chris Vance: Let's pause there for just a moment 'cause I know we have questions. on the economy again. Is it too simplistic to say that if gas didn't cost five, six, seven dollars a gallon, these numbers might look very different?
Whit Ayres: I think so, although inflation is broader than gas prices. food is up because of the cost of fuel, the cost of fertilizer, because of the tariffs. but the most visible and immediate example of inflation worsening is the price of gas at the pump. So it would certainly make it better, Chris, but it wouldn't totally change these numbers.
Merrill Matthews: Witt, one of the things that Republicans are trying to say, and especially President Trump, is trust us the economy is going to get better. He's saying at right after the election, gas prices will go down. He thinks Iran will sort of cave then at some point. do Republicans actually have a chance of persuading voters that things are gonna get much better after the election?
Whit Ayres: It's gonna be real tough, Meryl. It's gonna be real tough because Donald Trump has said so many things that turned out not to be true. Whether
Merrill Matthews: Mm-hmm.
Whit Ayres: it's Mexico's gonna pay for the wall or he's gonna end the war in Ukraine in twenty four hours and on and on and on. I don't know that he has a lot of credibility in forecasting what's gonna happen in the future. Moreover, the main driver of the inflation that people are concerned about is the war in Iran. We've had some Republicans say that we just need to end the war in Iran, but I don't know what that means. Does that mean we really
Chris Vance: Mm-hmm.
Whit Ayres: should just walk away and leave the Iranians in control of the Strait of Hormuz and the Houthis in control of the Red Sea? I don't think they mean that. So it's very difficult to say what's going to bring these prices down when we can't see an end to the war in Iran.
Chris Vance: Yeah, and you know, I have a degree in political science, not economics, but I think I understand the basics and we here at ORL have been screaming at the top of our lungs that the big government Republican policies that the Trump administration has enacted, including massive tariffs, which are taxes on things people want to buy, which drives up prices, and adding another trillion or two trillion to the debt, which keeps interest rates high, all of that, along with the war, is just really spiking inflation, which is costing him middle class, non college educated voters. voters and I wonder if that message is sinking in. I mean I don't know if you have any data on this, but I wonder if Republican voters, especially non-MAGA Republican voters, are starting to understand that tariffs and debt are a bad thing.
Whit Ayres: As a general rule, Americans oppose the tariffs because they sort of get the fact that they're paid by American consumers rather than by foreign countries.
Merrill Matthews: one thing, Whit, I just a wanna ask you the question. You said of the four things that Trump ran on, he actually has done a good job on the border and ending sort of the woke cultural issues. Those are sort of in the past, but those don't seem to be resonating with people even though those were two of his key focus points.
Whit Ayres: They're not resonating because they're being overwhelmed by the concern about the economy and inflation.
Chris Vance: Yeah. And then on another really interesting point right there, the split within Republican voters MAGA and non magga. And that's really of course interesting say a little more about that if you could, 'cause it's I think that's the of course the main thing that's gonna matter in twenty twenty eight,
Whit Ayres: Well, the MIGA voters are going to support whatever Donald Trump does, even if it's a hundred and eighty degrees different from what he did yesterday or said he would do
Chris Vance: Mm-hmm.
Whit Ayres: four years ago. They are going to support Donald Trump and they want their Republican elected officials to support him no matter what it is. The non-MAGA GOP is a little bit less in lockstep. They believe a lot of the things the Trump administration has done are good and good for the country. But they also have real reservations about the president's demeanor and character and language. And they also are having increasing reservations about some of the policies, particularly the war in Iran and tariffs.
Merrill Matthews: You know, w one of the things that's happened here
in Texas is Angela Paxton, who is a state senator, has run an ad essentially because she's separated from her husband right now. There are issues there, but she ran an ad saying when you come to a general election, it's about the team, not the individual. And so we want you to vote for the team. And what they're trying to do, it seems to me, is to get these non MAGA republicans on board. because they I think they feel like there's this real enthusiasm gap there. And then with seventy four percent of the independents, we often say independents sort of decide the election. If you've got seventy four percent unfavorable, can you actually win an election with that high of independence unfavorable?
Whit Ayres: It would be very difficult if that indeed is what's happens in Texas as well as other swing states. I think Ms. Paxton may be laying the groundwork for her own political career with that ad, by the way.
Chris Vance: do you have any idea what percentage of the party is maga versus non maga, based on the latest polling there?
Whit Ayres: Chris, it varies a lot depending upon Donald Trump's standing. When Donald Trump is riding high, it's more like sixty percent maga, forty percent non. On the other hand, once he starts sliding, that number starts changing. So now we're looking at somewhere around fifty percent being non-MAGA, forty percent being MAGA, and the rest say both or I'm not sure.
Chris Vance: That is so exciting for me to hear again because as much as we care about these midterms, what this organization's focusing on is the next election. And the idea that we're going to continue to be a MAGA party is not inevitable. I think you'd agree with that.
Whit Ayres: I think that's right. And I think that proportion of MAGA and non-MAGA is going to be affected by the outcome of the midterm elections. You know, if Republicans lose the House and the Senate and a bunch of governorships and down ballot races, I think the enthusiasm for the MAGA approach is going to be substantially less.
Chris Vance: Okay. We interrupted you. Keep going.
Whit Ayres: All righty. Majority of Americans, including a plurality of non-MAGA Republicans, think the war in Iran was the wrong decision. these are pretty tough numbers. Overall, only about a quarter of Americans think it's the right decision. A substantial majority think it's wrong. 21% of Republicans say it's wrong, but that's driven by the non-MAGA Republicans, a plurality of whom say it's wrong. Percent say it's wrong, only 30 percent right. As I was saying, the MAGA Republicans are going to support whatever Donald Trump wants to do. So you have 69% of MAGA Republicans saying the war in Iran was the right decision, Democrats overwhelmingly unanimously opposed almost, and 62% of independents say it was the wrong decision. So this is a real problem for the administration and for other Republicans, frankly. Now, I've got four reasons why Republicans are more enthusiastic. or at least not as unenthusiastic about the upcoming election. We only elect a third of the Senate every cycle, and in this cycle the states that are up The Senate seats that are up are overwhelmingly in states Donald
Merrill Matthews: Mm-hmm.
Whit Ayres: Trump carried in 2024, often by double digits. There are 23 states won by Trump in 2024, only 12 are in states won by Kamala Harris. Second reason is the Republican committees and super PACs have far more money than the Democrats. Just look at some of those numbers. Congressional Leadership Fund versus House Majority, this is the House funds, 44 million Republican, 22 million Democrat. The same on the side for the Senate, $71 million for Republicans versus 61 for Democrats. But look at the numbers for the two party committees. 130 million for the RNCs, only 16 million for the DNC. And that's not even counting the $400 million in the MAGA Trump controlled super PAC. So there is a Boatload of money that could be spent over the course of the next three weeks to affect the outcome of these elections. The mid-decade redistricting has helped the GOP. It's hard to know exactly how many seats. The best estimate of the Cook Political Report is five to ten more congressional seats. That's not enough to keep control of the House, but it may be enough to hold down the Democratic gains in the House. The Democrats, on the other hand, lead on the generic congressional ballot by about nine percentage points. Now, there's a certain Republican bias in this number because Republicans are spread more widely than Democrats who tend to be concentrated in cities. But a nine-point lead is a substantial generic lead for Democrats. So control of the Senate depends on the outcome of a dozen key races. These are Democratic held seats to watch. in Georgia I think Osof really has that one pretty well sewn up.
Merrill Matthews: Mm-hmm.
Whit Ayres: The popular Georgia governor Brian Kemp might have run, but he refused to go along with Donald Trump's efforts to overturn the election in Georgia. and so he took a pass and it has a much weaker MAGA candidate. Asof is going to win that one. Michigan is really interesting. Abdul Al-Said is a far left-wing Democrat who refuses to say that Israel has a right to exist as a Jewish state. He's doing far less well in Michigan than other Democrats who have come before him. Mike Rogers is a very credible Republican candidate with a lot of experience in the intelligence committees. So I can easily see Mike Rogers pulling off an upset there, although you'd have to say El Said is still the favorite. Minnesota's very interesting. She was a sideline reporter for the NFL.
Chris Vance: Hmm.
Whit Ayres: So lot of people know her face. That's an interesting race. And in New Hampshire, the Sununu name is Golden, and Chris Pappas and Sununu are in a tight race there. So if Republicans flip any of these seats, it's going to make it far more difficult for the Democrats to take control of the Senate. On the other hand, here are eight
Republican-held seats. that all of which are really close. Mary Patola in Alaska has already been elected statewide to Congress there. She and Sullivan are in a tight race. Turek and Hinson are neck and neck in Iowa. Kansas? How did Kansas get on this list? Roger Marshall is the Republican incumbent in a state that Donald Trump carried by double digits. But Adam Hamilton started the largest Methodist church in the entire state. Kind of hard to paint as a left-wing wacko. And that's now a nip and tuck race. In Maine, the Democrats have been going after Susan Collins for years. They had to get rid of their first nominee with his Nazi tattoo. So they have a relatively inexperienced nominee. My bet is that Susan Collins Collins pulls that out. She's always run ahead of her polling numbers, but we'll see. Nebraska, the Democrats nominated somebody whom they got to drop out and get behind Dan Osborne running as an independent against incumbent Pete Ricketts. In North Carolina, well, Tom Tillis was a mainstream Republican senator. but he wasn't Trumpy enough for Trump, so Trump threatened to primary him, so he dropped out. And now you've got a guy who's never been elected to any public office in North Carolina carrying the Republican banner. Roy Cooper is a very popular former centrist Democratic governor. Cooper's gonna win that seat, and you see Republicans pulling money out of North Carolina for these other races. in Ohio, Sherrod Brown, former senator, it's in blue-collar. A cred against John Housted, the appointed senator for J.D. Vance's seat. that don't be surprised if if Brown pulls that one out. Now
Merrill Matthews: Mm-hmm.
Whit Ayres: we get to Texas. Well
Chris Vance: Mm-hmm.
Whit Ayres: John Cornyn was a mainstream, very conservative Republican senator. He voted with 99% for Trump in his voting record. That wasn't enough for the president. So the president jumped in the primary at the last minute, endorsed Ken Paxton. And now we have a very serious race. Ken Paxton, who is so corrupt, his own Republican legislature impeached him.
Merrill Matthews: Mm-hmm.
Whit Ayres: And now an awful lot of donors are looking at the president going, Buddy, you bought it, you own it. And if you don't believe that, look at the the fundraiser that former president George Bush held with John Cornyn for Republican Senate candidates around the country. Guess who wasn't invited to the fundraiser in Texas? The Texas Republican nominee Ken Paxton. Tallerico's not exactly your cowboy boot wearer and manly man, but don't be surprised if he pulls off that race because a lot of non-MAGA Republicans just can't stomach Ken Paxton. So the bottom line: Democrats are likely to hold the House, margin we don't know. If the election were held today, Democrats would likely control the Senate, but with all that money to be spent. I wouldn't bet a whole lot of money on that outcome yet. and as we saw with swing states in the presidential race, close states don't split evenly but often go disproportionately to one side or the other. When a tide gets going, the tide tends to go the same way in all of these
Chris Vance: Hm.
Whit Ayres: various states.
Chris Vance: you mentioned tides and I've lived through them on both sides, but the the biggest
Whit Ayres: We all have.
Chris Vance: one yeah. I'm wondering how big this tide could end up being. There's races you did not mention that some people are talking about. South Carolina. The independent running in Idaho. there's even some people thinking that that the Mississippi Senate race is in play. There are house races that no one thought were in nineteen ninety-four, I had just left the state legislature to go to the King County Council. I looked back, when I left we had thirty-two seats in the state house. After the nineteen ninety-four election, we had sixty-two. Th
Whit Ayres: Wow.
Chris Vance: there were Republicans across the country in nineteen ninety-four who got elected who didn't even campaign. Nobody
Whit Ayres: Ha ha ha.
Chris Vance: I mean t no, quite literally. Absolutely. Just just the t the wave was that big. when I see this right now, this wave almost seems like it could be nineteen ninety four in reverse. am I being crazy?
Whit Ayres: Well, i we are far, far more polarized today than we were in nineteen ninety-four. And there were far more seats in the House that were in play. Far fewer seats then that were locked into the Democrats or Republicans. So I think it's kind of fanciful to think about a nineteen ninety-four interverse, but This election has a lot of similarities to 2006, when President Bush had an exactly the same job approval, 37-38%, that Donald Trump has now. We had an unpopular war in the Middle East, and in that year, Republicans lost 30 seats in the House and six in the Senate. So if you're looking for an analogy or a comparable election in earlier times, I think 2006. is a better match than nineteen ninety-four. but as we said, we still have a lot of polarization that could ameliorate those outcomes.
Chris Vance: Let me ask one more along those lines. I'm I'm sure you're probably polling internally for some clients, and internal polls are the most accurate, not media polls. so you know things that we don't know, and you can't tell us because your clients own that data. but you can see what's happening by how campaigns are reacting. You move money and stuff based on what's happening. And I am seeing the D triple C putting money into house races, including Washington Five in my state, which is spoken. for God's sake, that all of a sudden they think are in play. I see the Republicans moving money into South Carolina Senate race. So internally it looks like this wave right now looks like it could be pretty darn big.
Whit Ayres: Well, it's hard to argue against that, Chris. this feels like the kind of year where we will wake up the morning after the election and go, Who lost? Really?
Chris Vance: Mm-hmm.
Whit Ayres: we're gonna be shocked by the
outcome of an election or two that's not on anybody's radar screen, at least not very visibly right now.
Chris Vance: Mm-hmm. Merrill, go ahead.
Merrill Matthews: So with two questions. Number one, I've heard pollsters say that polling tends to favor Democrats a little bit compared to the actual election. Do you agree with that? Why would that be the case? And the second question is: Chris has said several times that internal polling tends to be more accurate than the public polling. And I'm wondering what makes internal polling more accurate
Chris Vance: Hmm.
Merrill Matthews: than the public polling?
Whit Ayres: Because internal polling is done to help guide strategy, not to get clicks or get attention. and that means that our reputations, my firm's reputation, is totally dependent on the accuracy of our numbers. you can have a media poll that, wow, looks really off, but it gets a lot of attention. and that helps a media poll. But that doesn't help an internal poll for people like me who are relied on to give an accurate information. As far as a Democrat bias for polls goes, we've seen in the past that some MAGA Republicans are simply reluctant to talk to us. They're anti-establishment, they're anti expertise, and they simply don't want to play ball with pollsters. And that's one of the reasons why Donald Trump tended to run ahead of his. polling in the past. we'll see if that applies when Donald Trump's not on the ballot. But that certainly was a phenomenon in the past with Donald Trump on the ballot.
Chris Vance: I'm not a pollster, but I'm the guy who's hired a lot of pollsters and commission polls and sat through briefings with people like you with about and how this works. And the thing is a campaign or a party committee will spend the money to hire someone like you to do it right.
Whit Ayres: Exactly.
Chris Vance: where a media firm will just like do, you know, random digit dialing and, you know, push one if you're voting for so and so. That's just inherently not as accurate. we're also in the season where every little thing you see on Twitter freaks people out. And the freak out this week was there was some polling or some pollster who said that in the Midwest they're getting a hard time getting rural voters to respond. And that led a whole bunch of Democrats were just waiting for the roof to cave in, to get all freaked out that that it's happening again, what you just said, that rural voters, Trump voters are not responding to polls but they'll turn out. did you see all that and what'd you think about that?
Whit Ayres: Well, I think everybody who is really into politics overreacts to any event that just happened. and it's important to keep a long term view and to keep these things in perspective. and that's where those of us who've done this for many, many years have an advantage over some of the people who are relatively new to the game.
Chris Vance: Yeah.
Merrill Matthews: Witt, let me ask you a question. You talked about money in politics so far. a new mentioned by Carl Rove of a Rob Pyer, I believe it is, the data scientist, says by his estimate, Republicans have spent six hundred and forty-three million on the Senate and 165 million on the House. Democrats 235 million in the Senate, 125 million in the House. And so my question is a lot of money's going here. Can money sway the election and Can it offset some of the negatives that Trump and his policies have had? Where's the role of money in this election, you think? 'Cause so much money's coming in.
Whit Ayres: Well, I'd rather have money than not have money, you'd rather have it than not have it. It gives you more flexibility. On the other hand, as the old Governor of Georgia, Zell Miller used to say, if the dogs don't like the dog food, they're just not gonna eat the dog food, no matter how
Chris Vance: Mm-hmm.
Whit Ayres: much money you spend advertising the dog food. And I've
Chris Vance: Right.
Whit Ayres: thought about that a lot. You know,
Merrill Matthews: Mm-hmm.
Whit Ayres: if the people don't like the candidate or don't like the outcome, you can spend all the money you want and you're not gonna get them to change their mind. I don't know. Merrill,
Chris Vance: Right.
Whit Ayres: you tell me who's gonna win the Senate race down there?
Merrill Matthews: my guess is right now Tallerica will probably win it. He's been running between two and six points ahead for since I think the beginning of August. But one of the things we're seeing, and this gets another question, so much money floods in here and it starts doing negative ads because a lot of it isn't from the candidates, it's from various other groups. can negative ads eventually sort of just turn people off
Whit Ayres: sure, sure. And that's what may very well happen in Texas to the non MAGA Republicans. You know, they may say, Listen, I can't stomach Talo Rico, but I'm not gonna vote for Ken Paxton. They may just stay home.
Chris Vance: the thing about running campaigns is If you've got a ton of money and it's a high profile race, you've already spent so much money, people have made up their minds. The overwhelming majority of voters, eighty-five, ninety-five percent, make up their minds before Labor Day, if they have the information, and certainly by mid-October. I don't think there's anything that anybody running for the US Senate can do right now with money, it's gonna change direction. This is just consultants making more money buying more and more ads to make the rubble bounce, you know, because they get big Commissions off of that. Now if you're running for the state legislature and you don't have high name ID, that's why you spend your money the last weekend because you know that's when you can afford to do a few mailings and people have not heard of you. But for US Senate candidates, this is baked in. It's now just about turnout. And which side right now has an enthusiasm advantage right now, with which side's more excited, Republicans or Democrats,
to come out to vote?
Whit Ayres: Democrat Democrats are far more excited. they're jacked up, they can't wait to go to the polls. We know that voting against something tends to be a stronger motivator than voting for something, and the Democrats can't wait to go and vote against Republicans and against Donald Trump and his allies. But I will say this, Merrill, if indeed Taller Rico pulls out a Senate victory for the Democrats in Texas, it will,
Merrill Matthews: Mm-hmm.
Whit Ayres: to use a soccer analogy, be the greatest only. Goal the Republican Party has ever scored in its history. They didn't need to do that.
Merrill Matthews: Hm.
Chris Vance: Yep. So yeah, and well and if the Democrats lose Minnesota, if they lose Michigan, those would be own goals on their side, you know? I mean th the basic rules of politics still apply. The
Whit Ayres: You're exactly right. Yep.
Chris Vance: center decides elections and whichever party loses that So we are coming to our end here. we are going to be very loud and as public as we can be the minute these ballots are cast saying twenty twenty eight begins now. Is there anything you can say right now about how all this portends for you know, within just a few months people are gonna be announcing for president. Maybe within a few weeks.
Merrill Matthews: Mm-hmm.
Chris Vance: any any thoughts?
Whit Ayres: well at this point, Republicans would like to have someone who's nominated in 2028 go the same direction as Donald Trump. but we'll see what they think if indeed this wave comes in and the Democrats take control. I'll just say this. At this point in the 2008 election cycle, no one thought a guy named Barack Hussein Obama was going to be the next nominee or president. And at this point in the 2016 cycle, no one thought that Donald Trump was going to be the Republican nominee, much less the elected Republican president. So I would caution all of us to be pretty circumspect about who we think could get the nomination. It may be somebody who's not even on our radar screen right now.
Chris Vance: Well, somebody on our radar screen is the outgoing Congressman from Nebraska two, Don Bacon, who was on our podcast a few weeks ago, said he's considering running for president. It's interesting a couple of things
Whit Ayres: Is he really interesting?
Chris Vance: yeah, couple of things interesting to me, you know, retired Air Force General. Pretty hard for MAGA to say he's not a patriot. And if you look at his district, which he carried five times, the Republicans are gonna lose it this election. you know, he's the kind of guy that can reach out to independence, I think, if he chooses to run.
Whit Ayres: And and and I've talked to some former governors who are giving serious consideration to running, whom both of you would like very much, I think.
Merrill Matthews: Wit, just one quick question. Does being tied to Donald Trump sort of hurt your chances to run for president in twenty twenty eight?
Whit Ayres: All depends on what happens in the midterms and what his reputation is following that.
Chris Vance: Witt, thank you. Fantastic.
Whit Ayres: My pleasure.
Chris Vance: We'll be talking again in the future. Merrill, always great. Ladies and gentlemen, thanks for joining us. If you enjoy this again, please go to ourRpublipublicanLegacy.com. You can join our national committee. You can make a donation if you're so motivated. And join us election night between 9 30 and 10 30 Eastern to take a look at how things have actually turned out. And on November 11th for our next national committee meeting. Thank you all again. We'll see you next week.