TRANSKRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.051 --> 00:00:05.154
Well, as I record today's episode, it's the beginning of August and we are in the thick of the dog days of summer.
2
00:00:06.014 --> 00:00:19.082
Yes, it's that liminal space that exists between the date when you pay for your kids next semester of school and the date when they actually leave all bright-eyed and bushy-tailed and blissfully unaware of the corporate hell that awaits them on the other side of the diploma.
3
00:00:20.243 --> 00:00:34.060
It's a pensive time filled with quiet contemplation and deep rumination about all sorts of big heady topics like do zombies get unlimited PTO or do transformers need to buy life insurance or auto insurance.
4
00:00:34.761 --> 00:00:37.485
You know, wrestling with the really big important stuff of life.
5
00:00:38.698 --> 00:00:42.000
Now I've also been doing a lot of thinking about the future of this channel.
6
00:00:42.820 --> 00:00:52.945
It's been up and running for a couple of years and I've got some great regular subscribers and despite some of the algorithmic stuff that YouTube likes to pull, it's still holding its own.
7
00:00:54.506 --> 00:00:59.809
So I wanna keep it going, but I also feel like I'm a little bit of a Debbie Downer.
8
00:01:02.970 --> 00:01:20.011
you know like i feel like everything i cover about the workforce or culture's impact on it tends to like arc towards the negative and that gets boring after a while right so you know i really wanted this first video the first one i've done in several weeks
9
00:01:20.932 --> 00:01:22.933
to come off a little different.
10
00:01:22.953 --> 00:01:34.461
So I've been trolling the news, looking for something, anything I can share that would put a little spring in your step if you're feeling the stress of looking for a job or the stress of being overworked at work.
11
00:01:35.402 --> 00:01:38.364
And, well, here's all the positive stuff that I found.
12
00:01:44.048 --> 00:01:46.269
Look, I am sorry, guys.
13
00:01:46.850 --> 00:01:47.370
I'm trying.
14
00:01:47.791 --> 00:01:49.932
I'm really, really trying.
15
00:01:51.290 --> 00:02:03.883
But it looks like it's going to be yet another episode of stark sympathy and maybe a bit of a glimpse behind the curtain of the world of work and the shenanigans that make things way, way harder than it should be.
16
00:02:04.644 --> 00:02:12.032
So sit back, put your feet up, and pour yourself a good stiff drink to dull the pain because it's time for another episode of The Rational Workplace.
17
00:02:18.115 --> 00:02:18.936
Hey folks, Mark here.
18
00:02:18.976 --> 00:02:21.178
Thanks so much for tuning in to another episode.
19
00:02:21.699 --> 00:02:28.246
I hope you are having an amazing summer so far and giving yourself some slack and relaxing a bit.
20
00:02:28.806 --> 00:02:29.166
You need it.
21
00:02:30.107 --> 00:02:38.516
Now, we're going to mix things up a little bit today as I present a selection, a variety, a charc... charcute, char... charc...
22
Load full transcript
00:02:40.574 --> 00:02:46.457
I present one of those big plates of ham and cheese and stuff of a variety of workforce related news items.
23
00:02:47.258 --> 00:02:47.678
Here we go.
24
00:02:48.859 --> 00:02:56.303
So first off, let's take a look at that perennial source of good news and sunshine, the Wall Street Journal and see what they have to say.
25
00:02:56.992 --> 00:03:02.717
Now, in late July, they dropped an article that on the surface seemed like it was good news about the labor market, right?
26
00:03:02.737 --> 00:03:04.158
That things were starting to turn a corner.
27
00:03:04.899 --> 00:03:08.001
By most of the usual metrics, things were looking up.
28
00:03:08.181 --> 00:03:10.303
The economy added jobs for four straight months.
29
00:03:10.924 --> 00:03:13.406
Unemployment dipped to around 4.2%.
30
00:03:13.426 --> 00:03:15.187
And that's all nice and happy news, right?
31
00:03:16.048 --> 00:03:24.055
Well, sit tight before you start popping those soft landing corks, my friend, because Sir Mix-A-Lot isn't the only one who feels compelled to talk about some big old butts.
32
00:03:24.990 --> 00:03:34.133
Yeah, Wall Street Journal also reported that although unemployment is improving, the share of people who have been out of work for six months or longer hit 27.3% in June.
33
00:03:34.213 --> 00:03:34.473
27.3%.
34
00:03:41.980 --> 00:03:45.761
Now that's hovering right near the highest level we've seen since late 2021.
35
00:03:46.841 --> 00:03:48.341
You remember 2021, right?
36
00:03:48.401 --> 00:03:57.143
That was the era when we were in the thick of that post-pandemic, come get your COVID jab and free order of fries at participating pharmacies era of life.
37
00:03:57.223 --> 00:04:00.144
Did you say free fries when you get vaccinated?
38
00:04:01.384 --> 00:04:03.085
Um, I got vaccinated.
39
00:04:04.225 --> 00:04:04.965
Man, that was a weird one.
40
00:04:06.010 --> 00:04:13.216
Now, to hang an absolute number on it, we're talking that nearly two million people have been stuck on the sidelines for half a year or more.
41
00:04:14.157 --> 00:04:19.401
And according to the Labor Department, it's hitting white collar workers and people in their prime earning years the hardest.
42
00:04:19.942 --> 00:04:22.704
That's namely the 25 to 54 graph.
43
00:04:23.905 --> 00:04:33.293
And although it seems that the mass firing events may have taken a little bit of a summer holiday, hiring as a share of employment has barely moved in two years.
44
00:04:34.451 --> 00:04:45.380
So in other words, we're kind of stuck in this low hire, low fire doldrums that are making the short term unemployment numbers look somewhat well behaved, but they're also not hiring much either.
45
00:04:46.641 --> 00:04:47.622
Look, let me put this simply.
46
00:04:48.303 --> 00:04:52.886
If you lose your job or if you're a recent grad trying to get your first one.
47
00:04:54.728 --> 00:04:55.929
Then may the odds be.
48
00:04:59.251 --> 00:05:07.696
Now on the upside, if you're one of the folks who are going insane looking for a gig and have been at it for quite some time, the journal points out that at least you're not alone.
49
00:05:08.532 --> 00:05:10.393
Now they cite a couple of folks in the article.
50
00:05:10.513 --> 00:05:17.137
One was this 38 year old accountant in California who's been looking for a year and a half and he put it pretty clearly.
51
00:05:17.797 --> 00:05:20.198
I go through lots of screening calls and they go nowhere.
52
00:05:20.819 --> 00:05:25.801
He's actually now considering becoming a locksmith or a watchmaker, I'm not kidding.
53
00:05:25.821 --> 00:05:28.963
Cool jobs, kind of a far cry from what he was doing before though, right?
54
00:05:29.823 --> 00:05:34.626
Now another job seeker in the article, a former Amazon recruiter who was laid off in January of 2023.
55
00:05:36.867 --> 00:05:39.208
is still looking more than three years later.
56
00:05:40.109 --> 00:05:46.252
He said his wife has been carrying the family and said that the market for what he does is virtually impossible today.
57
00:05:47.612 --> 00:05:57.397
And then on the other end of the spectrum, we have a 23-year-old digital media grad who got her diploma last summer and is still sending out applications and collecting rejection emails.
58
00:05:58.418 --> 00:06:01.959
She put up mildly and said, it can definitely take a toll on you mentally.
59
00:06:02.900 --> 00:06:03.580
Boy, is she right.
60
00:06:04.662 --> 00:06:20.212
Now, I know that a lot of folks who are going through it right now, a lot of folks who are out on the market looking for gigs and kind of wrestling with all the challenges there, one of the risks is you might be spending a little too much time online, which, I mean, most job seekers tend to do, right?
61
00:06:21.093 --> 00:06:24.115
But depending on where you're hanging out, it can only make things worse.
62
00:06:25.077 --> 00:06:41.723
Now, I appreciate that the journal talked about people who are having a very different experience from what the official numbers are saying, but there are plenty of folks, especially online, and especially on platforms like LinkedIn, who are maybe putting a less charitable view out there.
63
00:06:43.112 --> 00:06:53.278
There, you're going to be bombarded by everything from snake oil salesmen promising to land you your dream job tomorrow to people that are shouting from the rooftops about their new gig or promotion or certification.
64
00:06:54.098 --> 00:06:57.961
And it can all get to be a little, well, a little over the top.
65
00:06:58.981 --> 00:07:07.226
So if you're in the thick of a job search or if you've been on the hunt for a while, take a little bit of a digital detox every now and then because it'll do wonders for your mental health.
66
00:07:08.641 --> 00:07:19.305
But if you're plugging away and you're still out there and you're lucky enough to land that coveted Cal and Lee invite for an interview with the recruiter, the
next thing you need to do is pray that the interview actually happens.
67
00:07:19.765 --> 00:07:20.965
That leads us to our next story.
68
00:07:21.245 --> 00:07:25.447
This is a ghost story.
69
00:07:26.688 --> 00:07:34.958
According to a live career survey of more than 1,000 workers, 45% say they've already been ghosted by a company after they were in the hiring process.
70
00:07:35.639 --> 00:07:44.530
Not after submitting an application, not after they got a kind Dear John letter, but after they've actually already started talking to someone.
71
00:07:46.025 --> 00:07:57.157
22% said they got ghosted after one or more interviews, and an astounding 13% got ghosted after being told that an offer letter or whatever next steps in the process were going to be coming around the corner.
72
00:07:58.258 --> 00:08:00.080
Now, let that one sink in for a second.
73
00:08:00.981 --> 00:08:04.384
They told you next steps were coming, and then vanished.
74
00:08:04.564 --> 00:08:04.784
Poof.
75
00:08:05.045 --> 00:08:05.165
Gone.
76
00:08:05.185 --> 00:08:05.285
Gone.
77
00:08:06.516 --> 00:08:15.078
Nearly half of the people who experienced this say they will never apply to that company again, and 42% say they trust the company less.
78
00:08:15.118 --> 00:08:26.761
Most of the candidates who were ghosted believed the silence was intentional, that the company either picked someone else or simply didn't feel like delivering bad news to a fully functioning adult.
79
00:08:27.782 --> 00:08:32.643
And this is before we even talk about the even more cynical cousin of interview ghosting,
80
00:08:33.775 --> 00:08:34.456
Ghost jobs.
81
00:08:35.116 --> 00:08:40.402
You know, the ones, the postings that sit there for months, always open yet somehow never get filled.
82
00:08:41.222 --> 00:08:57.538
The ones that exist mainly so a company can look like it's growing or maybe they're just harvesting resumes for a rainy day or maybe they're just trying to satisfy some internal policy that says that they have to post the role externally even though they've already decided who's going to get it internally.
83
00:08:58.784 --> 00:09:02.669
Now, we've all seen it, we've all heard about it, but how pervasive is the problem?
84
00:09:03.430 --> 00:09:07.755
Some research shows that as many as one in three job postings aren't even real.
85
00:09:07.775 --> 00:09:09.137
They're just cast points.
86
00:09:10.047 --> 00:09:24.916
Now, if you're an employer or a hiring manager in HR, I implore you to put yourself in the shoes of someone who's already been out of work for six months or a year or a year and a half and just imagine what it must feel like to be on the receiving end of that behavior.
87
00:09:25.917 --> 00:09:28.238
People are already watching their savings shrink.
88
00:09:28.258 --> 00:09:31.740
They're already second guessing every line in their resume and cover letter.
89
00:09:32.260 --> 00:09:37.504
They're already dealing with all the practical and psychological challenges that ride along with long-term unemployment.
90
00:09:38.164 --> 00:09:47.149
And then they finally score an interview, they prep, they show up or they log on if it's virtual, they do the whole song and dance, and then nothing.
91
00:09:48.190 --> 00:09:59.857
Radio silence, no rejection, no feedback, just the digital equivalent of being left on read by a company that spent the last two years posting about how much they value people and appreciate transparency.
92
00:10:01.087 --> 00:10:03.889
It's not just rude, it's corrosive.
93
00:10:04.630 --> 00:10:15.538
And the companies doing it seem completely unaware or completely unconcerned that they're training an entire generation of candidates to assume the worst about every employer they encounter.
94
00:10:16.439 --> 00:10:24.846
All of this short-term convenience for the hiring team is creating long-term damage to your talent pipeline and potentially permanent damage to your brand.
95
00:10:25.346 --> 00:10:26.947
Just stop doing it.
96
00:10:28.088 --> 00:10:38.962
All this makes me feel like the disconnect between employers and HR and the realities of what is out there for rank and file employees is pretty bad.
97
00:10:39.343 --> 00:10:41.526
Maybe worse than anyone even realizes.
98
00:10:43.116 --> 00:10:54.805
Look, in my day job, I run a marketing consultancy that focuses on B2B clients, and the bulk of my business and the bulk of my experience over the past 20 or so years is supporting HR tech companies.
99
00:10:55.485 --> 00:11:05.653
So although I'm not an HR professional and I never have been, I spend an awful lot of time in and around their orbit, and I'm kind of dying inside when I see what's happening out there.
100
00:11:06.566 --> 00:11:15.849
Because the gap between what companies think employees and candidates want and what people actually need right now has become the Grand Canyon.
101
00:11:16.489 --> 00:11:23.091
For the last several years, too many employers and the HR teams who support them have been obsessed with all the wrong things.
102
00:11:24.212 --> 00:11:32.655
Identity politics in the workplace and AI shoved into places that it has no business being and internal politics and status-seeking games.
103
00:11:33.915 --> 00:11:43.022
all of it kind of geared around making sure they can keep their hands on the strategic reins they were given to them during COVID, it's all just energy spent on the wrong things.
104
00:11:44.263 --> 00:12:00.915
Meanwhile, on the ground, employee engagement's in the toilet, nobody feels secure in their job anymore, mental health is in a free fall, trust is shot, the Canada experience is a dumpster fire, and long-term unemployed people are being treated like they're invisible and they're losing hope.
105
00:12:02.156 --> 00:12:08.582
Every single meaningful indicator of a healthy workplace and a decent hiring process is approaching DEFCON 1.
106
00:12:09.343 --> 00:12:12.085
The people who are actually suffering already know it.
107
00:12:12.926 --> 00:12:18.631
The ones that are still collecting paychecks and feeling the anxiety creep up every Sunday night, they know it.
108
00:12:19.412 --> 00:12:27.879
The ones that are sending out applications for a year or more, just chucking it into the void and not hearing anything back, trust me, they really know it.
109
00:12:28.860 --> 00:12:36.322
In fact, the only people who haven't fully absorbed the enormity of the problem are the ones who are still too busy protecting their own relevance.
110
00:12:37.442 --> 00:12:46.285
But once the noise finally dies down, once they stop attacking everything that doesn't reinforce their own worldview, they might finally see what's been happening right in front of them.
111
00:12:47.552 --> 00:12:53.097
They might listen to the people who are recording their soulless layoff Zoom calls and sharing it on social media.
112
00:12:53.977 --> 00:13:01.544
They might empathize with the person, pouring their heart into their 500th resume only to get ghosted by a recruiter for the umpteenth time.
113
00:13:02.324 --> 00:13:12.113
Or stressing because they now need to try and learn how to pay the mortgage, put their kids through school, keep food on the table, and do all of that while assembling a patchwork of...
114
00:13:13.013 --> 00:13:20.957
cashier gigs and Uber Eats driving to cover the same spread that their engineering job used to before they got laid off.
115
00:13:22.018 --> 00:13:31.843
I mean, I'm really hoping and praying that once they do tune into these stories, once the people empowered to make some changes might actually do something about it.
116
00:13:33.183 --> 00:13:34.464
But I'm also not holding my breath.