TRANSKRIPT 🔗
Welcome back to the Potter discussion. This is episode 94 and now today's episode, we will be discussing what would happen if Neville and a Harry swapped places. Let's do this.
Hello. Welcome back everyone. I'm glad you are joining me. Uh, today for this episode, I am very excited because it is the first episode in a series. This new series I've been cooking up and it's called flip the script where we swapped two characters to Elm, to the story, to whatever. To see how the store would be different today.
We are switching Harry and Neville. How would Neville perform as Harry? How would Harry perform as now? We don't know, but we will, after this episode, so stick around before we get started, I will remind you that the two links in the show notes below are still available for you to send me a topic, a question, a Christmas question, a joke, whatever you have.
Just send me that with those two links and description. I have a SpeakPipe page link and a Google form link. If you want to choose any of those. And if you don't want those, you can always send me an email. My email is the Potter discussion at g-mail dot com. That is the Potter discussion@gmo.com. And I haven't those in a while, but if you like what you're here, consider subscribing.
Oh, that'd be fun. So, because you have great episodes like this coming down the pipeline every single week. All right. Let's get into this. And coming in at number one. I don't think Neville would have won the tri wizard tournament. So I, sorry, Neville, but I do think that this is true. So Neville's strengths are, he's a good friend. He's very loyal, kind of like a half a, and he just has this knack for getting to know people. But magic really isn't in his skillset, which is unfortunate because Harry needs his magic as much as he does.
And he clearly in the story at every turn magic expel, the arm is, you know, expressed to Patrona him. Those are his go-to one most saviors. So for Neville to not have access to those spells and not have. Honestly, not have the power to cast them might be a problem. And now this is kind of my first thoughts when thinking of this episode is the child was a tournament because that's all about these quick spouses.
Quick reactions is complicated things learning spout to about to spell, which plays into Neville's weaknesses, not his strength. Neville doesn't have a very good memory. He is not very good at magic and he just, isn't very confident. So going into this school almost nationwide tournament to, to compete against other, very accomplished wizards and witches with an arsenal of spells that he had to remember after learning them.
I mean like it's built, so Neville will lose. And as much as Matt I moody slash party crutched junior might help novel. I still don't think he would stand a chance because although yes, he did get the clues. The clues were only half of it. If only, maybe even a quarter. Because it was the spells that you used and the magic that you learned that helped you through the actual will tasks.
For example, maybe I know Neville did help Harry with the water task and while Harry would help. No, of cause that's the story. But Neville would still not do very well because then he would have to find the base. He would have to no, no, to get his hostage and be, it would be Luna or Jenny or someone like that.
And he would have to really figure that out. And that's a lot of critical thinking and that's something that's novel. It isn't good. So he just, isn't a very good candidate for the, you know, intense spells, intense battles, memorizing a lot of things. And just thinking on your feet. That's not an very Neville thing to do.
I mean, if there's a competition to make friends or make cookies, oh, Neville would probably Excel and you might even win that competition. But the try was a tournament, just isn't a built for him. And it's unfortunate because I'm sure NEMA would have loved to win that after the trial was torment, but it just still doesn't seem like the very, you know, it, isn't a very good thing for Neville to do because it's dangerous.
And it's not built for your everyday, you know, slightly forgetful teenager, a 14 year old, especially if it's novel. I mean, for hair, like we can understand because he's a pretty accomplished was there and he knows some pretty intense and helpful spells, but Neville just isn't that kind of person. And although yes, he does get better.
That's very much a it's a lot longer after the was tournament. Novel. That's my first prediction for novel. He would not have won the tri wizard tournament. And the second item on my list is Neville would be even shyer in class because of his fame and attention. We can't forget the boy who lived is now no longer Harry, but it's now. And he has all the highs, all the attention, all the fame. Everyone's just looking at him all the time. And that's something that Neville is just very much not good at.
He's not good at the, you know, taking the fame and, you know, appreciating. You know what, whatever he did when he was young, that's just what Nemo does not do. It seems like Harry is the complete opposite of now, which is pretty unfortunate because the things that Harry doesn't a story are very much a built for Harry, not built for Neville.
Again, a travel tournament, pick spells, powerful spells things that never just isn't good at and taking the attention and the taunting and everything. Again, not something Neville could have done. And it's pretty weird to think about Neville as Harry. And it's something that I think pretty much everyone listening right now can agree on Neville would not have done very well at because she couldn't take what everyone was throwing at him.
We saw that just because he couldn't cast a couple of spells booze. It took a while. He got pretty down and that's not something you want to see with someone who's going to be under constant pressure and constant attention. And everyone constantly looking at
Load full transcript
him and whispering about him and saying mean things and spreading rumors.
So Neville just, isn't good at taking the. Bad side of life and understanding that there are people who are very neat and people who are doing it because he's the boy who lived, they can do it to him. And he can't do anything back that will even encourage some sliver ends or someone who would want to taunt.
Now I would encourage some people who don't have the option to, you know, do it to someone else because maybe they have a bad situation at home or something like that. And Neville is the perfect candidate because he can't take it. He cannot take it after only a couple of years. Malfoy could have gotten Neville, you know, into tears and running out of the room.
So Neville just, isn't good at taking it, taking the, you know, the harsh side of being Harry Potter, being the boy who lived, I mean, Neville Longbottom just doesn't have the same ring to it, but we can, you know, we can, we can move that aside just for now because although Neville, I'm sure it would be awesome.
Neville Longbottom in the source of stone, Neville long bottom of the chamber of secrets, man, those would just fly off the shelves. There was what a full lie off the shelves. I'm so glad that. It wasn't called that because that would probably would not be a very good, um, not be a very good title to read about.
And then when someone asks, well, what's your redone and you say, yeah, Neville Longbottom and the chamber of secrets. And that's, those are just two senses that don't go together. Neville Longbottom, since we got keynote kids, comedy, and then we have, and the chamber of secrets. And intense mystery, you know, so it Neville Longbottom and the chamber of secrets.
That's just, it just sounds ridiculous. I mean, it just sounds horrible. Like, why would you, why would you buy something? That's, you know, a, a kid's comedy and an adult mystery all in one. I don't know, but Harry Potter just sounds more, you know, You know, I'm a valley into warrior. Yeah. You know, I dunno if that is, it means just me, but it just seems like that Harry Potter is a little more heroic than Neville Longbottom.
I'm I'm pretty sure that's what J K Rowling intended. When, you know, putting in those names and making sure all the different titles and spells and stuff, but that's just such a strange thing to call the book series. If Neville was Harry, you know, in Harry's shoes, but this was a, this was a big rant because I mean, I'm, this is, this is something that I'm adamant about.
The steer should not have been called Neville Longbottom. If Neville wasn't Harry shoes, maybe they just like switched places. Maybe they still have the same parents and maybe, you know, it was named the same thing. I dunno. Ah, this was just a strange, strange segment, but I've got one coming up next. Let's take a look at that one.
Ruby has Hagrid is a very large part of hairy success at Hogwarts Haggard was the one that told Harry who he was and how would it also one that protected Harry through his years and showed him the right people and showed him the right way. But Hagrid took a very specific liking to Harry. And the question is here, would Hagrid take a very specific liking to.
To that. I think the answer is unfortunately, no. So just think about it this way. Hagrid is a very cheerful, happy, you know, loyal, you know, I don't know a Hufflepuff and a Griffendor were kind of combined. And even though Hagrid was really friendly with Harry, he didn't know Harry beforehand and it was Dumbledore that said, Hey Agra, can you go pick up Harry in a little hybrid and expect this to happen?
Hagrid was still, you know, he didn't really have a good impression of who Harry was. Yes. He was really sad to see Harry go as a baby, but that's just because, uh, you know, the boy who lived the Harry Potter, you, you don't just leave them on a doorstep and just walk away. It was a really tough thing for Haggart to see.
I mean, and also like leaving a baby on doorstep. I mean, anyone would cry, so that's kind of a Haggard thing to do, but Harry was still a very, very specific kind of person that had great actually liked that hybrid stuck with Harry throughout his years. And even though, I mean, we know Haggard, isn't a very good actor, but even though, um, Dumbledore ordered him to, you know, pick up.
I still think that hybrid took a specific liking to him. So even though Hagrid is a, you know, someone who was kind of forced to be there, he still wanted to go to meet Harry. But with Neville Neville, isn't the kind of person that high grid would know befriend and take a liking to. Now I see that because Neville is someone who's keeps to himself.
He's very, you know, reserved and he's very nice. He's very, self-conscious about himself and that's just his number long bottle, but as never long got on the boy you live nearby never longer when I'm on the neighbors never would still be. Someone who was even more shy and more self-conscious about himself, because he was under all that pressure, all under all that attention as Harry Potter, you don't that doesn't just go on notice you can't just continue on with your life as if it never happened.
You have to embrace who you are, and that will just can't do that. He can't accept that he is the most important person to have ever lived in the last hundred years. So it's very difficult for Neville to make friends reach out, you know, do something like that. The point is Neville. Longbottom is all about the shyness, keeping to yourself, not interacting with others.
And Hagrid is all about the, I wanna make friends with you and we are going to be best friends for life kind of thing. So not the best mix as you can probably tell and not the best.
With Harry Potter, the boy who lived or Neville Longbottom, when the chamber of secrets, the boy who lived comes the trio. So with Harry, it was Harry Ron in her mind, the iconic golden three, the trio, they were to
concrete, evil together, hand in hand wound won. Um, what's another thing I can use, um, for input that's.
Okay. That's it. Anyway, Neville zone Neville has to have his own trio too, because that's just who the boy who lived his, you have to have your true, your group, your gang, your, your, your people, your peeps, people you view around you. Like. So who was that? Who was that for? Neville? Who does Neville choose to be around?
As I mentioned before, there were two possible people who probably could have been his try wizard person, who we had to retrieve from the lake. And that was Luna or Jeanette. And that's definitely who I think the trio would be Luna and Jenny, because if you think about it, it doesn't really have any major friends besides, you know, Harry and I don't know, maybe someone like Luna or Jenny, but maybe Luna and Jenny, but still Neville just doesn't have the same.
Thing is hair, you know, and that one doesn't have the same, you know, look on life as Harry and never wouldn't choose the same people. And he doesn't, he, he doesn't choose Ron and Heidi. No. And of course, Harry doesn't choose and Neville, but Jenna and I should say Luna and Jenny at the same time, Jenna, um, Ginny and Lou.
Are pretty much lean, all kind of nettles, perfect people because they're also, you know, just a little bit different and they all kind of have the same, you know, goals. So Neville, I mean, being the leader of the group, she would kind of be, you know, the person who would. Kind of lead the charge and be the face of the organization.
Luna would be the, like the strategist, the person who could, you know, look into a situation, just see it differently than everyone else. And then Jenny would eat like the hermana and ate the person who was just, you know, really great at magic. The person who was you let you know Luna and, and Naval copy their homework.
Um, so. That's kind of how I see that group of people. And it does make sense that Neville would choose people like that because he is a very, you know, person who doesn't have much besides being the leader. If he was the boy who lived, he would have to have smart people, strategic people, you know, logic people behind him in order to really thrive in that arena.
Defeating the dark Lord and, you know, going on to fight all these dark creatures and death, theaters and snatchers. So it's difficult for Neville to figure out his own team. And it was just be his friends kind of like Dumbledore, sorry, Harry didn't really choose that. But it was people who were naturally around Harry hearing about it.
And who wanted to, you know, learn about dementia cause they're soccer. Umbrage wasn't teaching them. And it kind of same thing with Neville Luna, and Jenny want to be with Neville as in the feeding, the dark Lord and fighting the dark side, which is something that the whole, you know, light side wants to do.
But as we know, Harry was. Rather Neville was, Harry never would have even more of a drive. And we saw even with Harry, Harry had much more of a drive to do those things. And then anyone else, I mean maybe, maybe besides, you know, Dumbledore or maybe in Snape, but Neville would want people who could figure, you know, the difficult situations out by his side, like Jenny and like limp.
Which is perfect for on their friends. They work together. They have every element of a good team and they would definitely work together. One of Harry's strengths is his power with magic. Harry can remember spells practice them and a master them to use to his own advantage. But as mentioned before, that's not a very Neville thing to do. So what would Neville. Well, I don't think he would go through life with a magic focused skill set.
That's what we're going to be talking about right now. So magic is a big part of how Harry succeeds. That's how Harry goes through life. And that's what, that's the edge he has. He has something to fight for and use his knowledge for good, but Neville doesn't have the knowledge that Harry. So how would Neville improve upon how, what he, and what, and how we already is and go through life without a magic focus skills?
Well, no, no. If you had to choose something that he was good at, it would be his determination, bravery and just social, you know, prowess general. I don't know. It just mentioned he was really shy and stuff like that, but he started out shy, but in the seventh book, When Voldemort and his death eaters were there in the entirety of Hogwarts, Neville stepped forward and he's, he made a speech.
He made us speak for the whole school district show, how much he is growing and he's grown so much. So if Neville could just do that, if Neville could, you know, just grow socially. Be more confident. That's what he would use. He would use it, he would use his, you know, speech and he would use his, you know, whatever to empower everyone else, which is something that Harry does a ton and something that never would do even better because Neville that's the only thing.
The Nemo really. And that's not the only thing. What does a, that's something that Neville is just generally good at, which is important because if Neville didn't have, you know, the social aspect and didn't have the magic aspect, he wasn't really anything, which is kind of not one, not really a good boy.
Person. So I'm kind of like the thing that being a social character or being a big social person, he would really grow into the role of the face of the light, you know, the good side, because that's something that never would really be good at if he took up the mantle. And if you willingly stepped forward as the face of good, never would be very, very good at being.
Person who would give this speeches? Who inspired everyone else who fought the last person that who never is if he became Harry and that's, whenever would be good at even if she wasn't, even if nimble didn't have that social confidence, he would have want. Be the person that he would always need to,
he would need to be the speech person.
He would need to be the person who gave you the chocolate frog when you were sad. So if Neville didn't develop the social confidence, he did. I doubt he would have been anywhere near as effective as Harry while he did. And he is If we have Harry, and if we have Neville. What are the family figures in the situation more specifically who would be serious with Harry? It is sororities block, of course, but with Neville, who would the serious figure be and what would happen? To that person. That is the question for this segment, what is the serious figure and what would have happened to them?
So let's just for speculate, who would the serious figure have to be and what traits would he or her have to have? Him or her RO um, well, we have to think that serious in Harry's terms as someone that they don't really recognize as a father figure, as you know, Sirius is Harry's father figure because he doesn't have a father and serious just the person who takes care of him, his guardian and Neville has his grandmother and his parents had a similar fate to Harry.
So in devil's position, move into Harry's position. Who would that serious figure be? Well, I don't think we can say, can we say Octavia? I know Augusta that's her name? Not Octavia. Augusta. Augusta is Neville's grandmother who he grows up with. Can we say her? I don't think so because that's who we live with.
But ah, I'm like thinking of this on the spot, but it, Harry is Neville is Harry. Then his parents died and he moved in with his aunt and uncle, which we don't know who that is, but his grandmother would be pretty much out of the picture. Right. I mean, I don't know. I dunno. It's it's that is out of the picture.
I don't know idea, but, but if parents are dead, he loses on an uncle who we don't know, they aren't really important, but who the serious figure be? I mean, maybe his dad's friend, maybe someone like I don't, I'm thinking a member of the order. Definitely. Who had a personal connection to France. I don't know someone like that.
I think that's what we can say is the. The serious person for this, the someone who was in the order who had a personal connection with Frank along bottom, that is a safe bet for who is the serious person, but now we have the serious person. So who is the serious who what happens to serious? Well, I think I can pretty much assume that this serious would have gotten the dementors kids.
It's unfortunate. What, going back to novels, social, I don't know skills. He doesn't have many magical skills and he couldn't have cast that go back, you know, you know, the famous line, but maybe even if he couldn't have done that, then she wouldn't have, and he knew that he couldn't. So he was. You can figure that out.
So the dementors would have swooped in and they probably would have given serious the dementors kiss and never thinking, well, wouldn't they have given the Demento SKUs to Neville to know, because you know, the dementors only give to the dementors cause to the fugitives, not the students. So, you know, Sirius would have gone to the mentor's kiss and then Neville would have been like, ah, and then collapsed.
So, so I do think serious, the serious figure would have gone with the D mentors kissed because Neville's skills are very social, not magical, as we said before, and just standing up and casting a very difficult spell against hundreds of dementors.
I dunno. I dunno how Neville built that is. Do. The do all of that. You cast a very difficult spot that most accomplished, which is Missouri's, can't even produce a core pauriol, Patronis an actual animal from his Metronic and Neville couldn't even do it in his fifth. His fifth year and he, I don't doubt he could do it in his third year too.
He couldn't do it. Fifth. Definitely cannot do it. Third. So serious would have gone the dementors kiss and Neville would have been very, very distraught.
Part of being the boy who live is in, during all of the taunting and scheming to get you in trouble behind your back. And that is something that Neville has to endure to. How, how could he have done that? How could he have stood up to the bullies? I bet he would have been bullied and more in this scenario because Neville has to take on all of that blame and he has to take on blame, but he has shown just like lush.
Let's look scrap that. Let's just think about it. The boy who lived, we have the Malfoy, we have the crab, the Goel, the pansy Parkinson, the blaze. We have the, everyone, the snake who is being really mean to Neville and bullying him. And then, then we have never. You know, not very confident self. And then, then we have him plus that.
And it's almost like multiplication a it's a, it's an exponential growth from being bullied, to being bullied even more. And on top of that, Doubt Neville would have fought back. Maybe he would have been annoyed. Maybe he would have been, you know, secretly and internally just, you know, feeling very powerless and sad that this was happening, but I don't think he would've fought back.
And I think it would have, he would have been bullied even more because Neville being like the shy person he is, I don't know if you know. If you could have stood up to the mouth voice to the snips, to the people who were being, you know, cold and just menacing to him, I use the word menacing and that's something that Neville just isn't built for.
He isn't that kind of person, he, isn't the kind of person to stand up and say, okay, stop. Thanks. And he definitely isn't the person who needs to be held back. If Malfoy goes, Hey, there, Hey, head air. And then, then we'll like, we're going to tax him. I'm sorry for that noise. But that was my best impression of a map of Tom Felton's Patacca so thank you for that.
Um, thank you for enduring that noise, but back to the point, never would have not fought back being bullied even more than Harry was because they would see that Harry was kind of having a very, very serious reaction and yes, that may would have the, maybe whatever. Proud of them more to be even more cruel to Harry.
I don't know. It still seems like they would have been scared of what Harry would do to them because Malfoy, he knows what he's saying is real mean and not nice in the slightest. So for Malfoy to be saying those things to Neville and knowing that he would not get a response, but just eggs Malfoy on more, just to see if he can get a response to see how good Malfoy is tans and jokes and main things in salts are about Neville.
And he would have to work very hard to find the best, you know, insults and Neville couldn't even. Stand up to that. Neville couldn't even think of the, you know, she couldn't endure what was being thrown at him, which is unfortunate, but it's true. And I think that's a, it's a pretty, pretty solid place to wrap up this episode.
So thank you for listening. I am very happy that you stuck around me, that you stuck around with me to the end of this first episode of flip the script. You will be hearing more episodes like this one in the future. So definitely stay tuned for that. You've got a Quizmaster company. Coming up. We've got applause episode coming up ton of good stuff.
I hope you were looking forward to it. Uh, so thanks for listening. Uh, definitely send me an email. My email is the part of discussion@gmo.com. That is the part of discussion@gmail.com. Um, and why not? I, I would love to hear what you have to say. What do you think Neville would have done and what do you think never would have been good at to send me an email?
The two links in the description are good for contacting and just go ahead and subscribe to hear some awesome episodes coming up. Uh, thanks for listening as always use information to our advantage, and I will see you later.