TRANSKRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.151 --> 00:00:09.757
But as a military strategist and a military defence planner, I look at Australia, I'd want to be protecting Australia with 40 or 50 million people rather than 28.
2
00:00:10.612 --> 00:00:13.333
Do you think the concerns are more about the level or the mix?
3
00:00:13.853 --> 00:00:14.133
Level.
4
00:00:14.353 --> 00:00:15.653
Level much more so than mix.
5
00:00:16.013 --> 00:00:22.074
So that implies that prior to 2014, we were letting in tens of thousands of people that we wouldn't have wanted to?
6
00:00:22.394 --> 00:00:24.215
I think that's about the right order of magnitude.
7
00:00:24.455 --> 00:00:27.816
What do you think is the single best measure for the speed of acculturation?
8
00:00:28.156 --> 00:00:32.016
Intermarriage, language acquisition, second generation economic mobility?
9
00:00:32.216 --> 00:00:32.536
Sport.
10
00:00:33.417 --> 00:00:39.298
We've always taken a mix of national and cultural groups such that no one group has formed
11
00:00:40.158 --> 00:00:45.164
critical mass, the extent to which that has been a happy accident versus deliberate policy.
12
00:00:45.444 --> 00:00:49.109
Look, it's been driven by global population dynamics.
13
00:00:49.749 --> 00:00:50.570
Not deliberate planning?
14
00:00:50.610 --> 00:00:50.751
No.
15
00:00:51.051 --> 00:00:59.421
I can assure you we don't have officers sitting in the permanent program saying, what is the global distribution of Spanish-speaking people from Latin America?
16
00:00:59.859 --> 00:01:07.630
Do you think there's a way that selection criteria can filter out people like the father of the two Bondi terrorists?
17
00:01:08.051 --> 00:01:12.938
If we could go back to that application in 98, would you have made a different visa decision?
18
00:01:13.419 --> 00:01:14.501
I suspect the answer would be no.
19
00:01:15.992 --> 00:01:17.853
All right, so today I'm chatting with Mike Pizzullo.
20
00:01:18.193 --> 00:01:22.175
Mike was one of Australia's most senior and experienced public servants.
21
00:01:23.015 --> 00:01:44.485
Notably, he was deputy secretary in the Department of Defense, where he was the lead author of the 2009 Defense White Paper, a document that was prescient in the way it contemplated the military implications of China's rise, and which reputedly earned Mike a trip to Beijing, where senior CCP officials unsuccessfully demanded that he change the White Paper.
22
00:01:45.245 --> 00:01:52.208
But most relevant to today, Mike ran Australia's immigration and border protection apparatus for almost a decade.
23
00:01:52.228 --> 00:01:58.851
He was CEO of the Australian Customs and Border Protection Service from 2013, where he oversaw Operation Sovereign Borders.
24
00:01:59.472 --> 00:02:04.554
He was appointed Secretary of the Department of Immigration and Border Protection in 2014, run it all the way through to 2023, including through...
25
00:02:07.155 --> 00:02:10.618
the transition to the mega Department of Home Affairs in 2017.
26
00:02:10.998 --> 00:02:16.403
So today we're going to chat about acculturation, social cohesion, and the security dimensions of immigration.
27
00:02:16.423 --> 00:02:18.104
Mike, welcome to the podcast.
28
00:02:18.284 --> 00:02:18.865
Great to be here.
29
00:02:19.445 --> 00:02:28.312
So I think the question I most want to start with is, what does the process of selecting migrants to Australia look like concretely?
30
00:02:29.093 --> 00:02:34.398
So if I'm looking over the shoulder of an immigration officer at the department, what are they actually seeing and doing?
31
00:02:34.799 --> 00:02:37.321
Obviously, the process is going to look different depending on the visa.
32
00:02:37.341 --> 00:02:37.641
Yes.
33
00:02:38.582 --> 00:02:42.206
So maybe we could start just with the skilled permanent stream.
34
00:02:43.107 --> 00:02:45.129
Say I want to migrate to Australia under the points test.
35
00:02:45.549 --> 00:02:46.650
I check my eligibility.
36
00:02:46.690 --> 00:02:49.012
I check my occupations on the skilled occupation list.
37
00:02:49.613 --> 00:02:51.054
I submit an expression of interest.
38
00:02:51.975 --> 00:02:57.917
Sometime later, I get an invitation to apply, and then I submit my full visa application with all of my supporting documents.
39
00:02:57.957 --> 00:02:58.217
Yes.
40
00:02:58.778 --> 00:02:59.498
What happens next?
41
00:03:00.158 --> 00:03:16.705
Well, what happens next, and the department, and I've not been there for two and a half years now, so the extent to which they've progressed on this path is a bit of an open question, but certainly on the track that we were on when I left in late 23, increasingly that's going to look automated.
42
00:03:16.725 --> 00:03:17.125
Okay.
43
00:03:17.145 --> 00:03:17.285
Okay.
44
00:03:17.545 --> 00:03:26.932
So you're going to have that officer typically working with increasingly a suite of AI tools, applying their own personal judgment because these officers are deeply experienced.
45
00:03:26.952 --> 00:03:28.212
They know what they're looking for.
46
00:03:28.753 --> 00:03:34.957
They know almost intuitively because they've typically been doing it for 5, 10, 15, sometimes more, 20 plus years.
47
00:03:34.997 --> 00:03:36.118
They know intuitively.
48
00:03:36.815 --> 00:03:42.281
what an objective points criteria translates into as a real human.
49
00:03:42.821 --> 00:03:52.331
Whether you're looking for people with skills in nursing or welding or production, agricultural labour and the like.
50
00:03:52.991 --> 00:03:58.437
Over time, though, that will increasingly become, simply because of the volume of applications and also the...
51
00:04:00.097 --> 00:04:08.340
And we'll get to this, but the more rigorous checks that we're going to want to do, increasingly you'll have AI tools sitting beside the officer, assisting the officer.
52
00:04:08.360 --> 00:04:19.164
We were talking before off camera about the change in the AI world where you're
Load full transcript
increasingly moving from a chat function to an agent-like function.
53
00:04:19.524 --> 00:04:20.664
That inevitably will come in.
54
00:04:20.784 --> 00:04:27.927
There were some early versions of that starting to come into the department, both as Immigration and Border Protection, but then Home Affairs and...
55
00:04:28.627 --> 00:04:31.610
subsequent to 2017, which subsumed the immigration function.
56
00:04:32.151 --> 00:04:39.558
And what you're looking for is you're not obligated by law to deal with each application in the sequence in which they arrived.
57
00:04:40.018 --> 00:04:42.040
You're just required to give them due consideration.
58
00:04:42.321 --> 00:04:49.688
You can move applications around on different piles, depending on regions or states that might be expressing an interest, because there's a lot
59
00:04:52.290 --> 00:04:58.014
nurses or doctors or people who are willing to go, for instance, into regional health and medical practices.
60
00:04:58.794 --> 00:05:10.362
Over time, and we didn't quite get there by the time I left at the end of 23, you're going to want a completely digital way of doing that because what you want to do is really calibrate the demand side.
61
00:05:10.702 --> 00:05:15.305
So, you know, doctors in regional and rural Victoria are
62
00:05:15.987 --> 00:05:17.048
against your applications.
63
00:05:17.249 --> 00:05:31.985
And then what we're doing largely at the moment still with human intelligence, but over time it'll be augmented with AI, is then going through all the applications, say for medical practitioners who have expressed a desire to go into rural or regional Victoria, okay, here are the top...
64
00:05:33.827 --> 00:05:39.532
candidates based on academic qualifications, their points, and so on and so forth.
65
00:05:40.593 --> 00:05:45.737
So it's a transition from a human-based system to what will ultimately be a human and machine-based system.
66
00:05:46.177 --> 00:05:51.142
That's going to involve a challenge, which every large enterprise is going through, of retraining your workforce.
67
00:05:51.162 --> 00:05:53.724
There's probably going to be some of the workforce will probably
68
00:05:54.304 --> 00:05:57.986
if you like, transition into retirement, not having to pick up too many of those skills.
69
00:05:58.466 --> 00:06:04.849
And at the other end of the pipeline, you're going to have younger officers coming through who are just completely digitally native.
70
00:06:04.889 --> 00:06:15.875
And so they'll be able to apply their educational qualifications, but also just their ease with technology, and then apply that to these tasks that I've been, as I've been describing them.
71
00:06:16.353 --> 00:06:18.395
And does that all happen in the ICSE?
72
00:06:18.415 --> 00:06:19.956
Yes.
73
00:06:20.497 --> 00:06:26.462
So for people wondering, that's the integrated client services environment, which is the department's main visa.
74
00:06:26.602 --> 00:06:28.704
Well, it certainly was when I left.
75
00:06:28.864 --> 00:06:31.966
Again, I'm two and a half years out of date.
76
00:06:32.087 --> 00:06:40.994
But that is an amalgam or was an amalgam because it was a steady build over time of, if you like, a digital layer, but still in some cases sitting on top of paper systems.
77
00:06:41.054 --> 00:06:41.315
Yeah.
78
00:06:42.015 --> 00:06:49.667
to ultimately, and this is a function of investment and just the take-up of tech across government, but over time you want to go to a fully digital system.
79
00:06:50.187 --> 00:06:50.388
Yeah.
80
00:06:50.868 --> 00:06:53.372
So say with the skilled permanent stream.
81
00:06:53.653 --> 00:06:53.793
Yep.
82
00:06:55.184 --> 00:07:00.486
When have ever applicants interviewed an immigration officer?
83
00:07:00.626 --> 00:07:02.487
It's reasonably late in the piece.
84
00:07:02.507 --> 00:07:13.210
So you go through a lot of this triaging that I've been describing and you're really getting a fair way down the process of what's called candidate selection before interviews are scheduled.
85
00:07:13.230 --> 00:07:16.771
Because you've got, to be honest, for Australia, Canada's in the same position.
86
00:07:17.312 --> 00:07:21.133
You've got a great number of candidates in terms of quantity.
87
00:07:21.713 --> 00:07:29.921
And so that triaging and that selection process happens up front, and then you start talking to people at a relatively mature part of that process.
88
00:07:30.062 --> 00:07:30.342
I see.
89
00:07:30.962 --> 00:07:32.064
So everyone gets an interview?
90
00:07:32.404 --> 00:07:33.625
Yes.
91
00:07:33.725 --> 00:07:34.086
Yeah.
92
00:07:34.246 --> 00:07:36.228
If they're coming under the permanent program.
93
00:07:36.388 --> 00:07:36.648
Yes.
94
00:07:36.888 --> 00:07:37.389
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
95
00:07:37.629 --> 00:07:52.122
So because we're going to focus on acculturation, I'm curious, when immigration officers select migrants in any visa class, do they consider how quickly the migrant is going to acculturate?
96
00:07:52.662 --> 00:07:54.804
And do they screen for values?
97
00:07:56.785 --> 00:08:00.727
Indirectly, there's what's called a security and character check.
98
00:08:01.047 --> 00:08:01.207
Yeah.
99
00:08:01.527 --> 00:08:04.268
And if you like, that's almost a negative filter.
100
00:08:04.548 --> 00:08:14.031
So are there any issues of security concern or character concern that have come up in the application, either through the objective data that we've got in our own data holdings?
101
00:08:14.111 --> 00:08:15.232
There might be, for instance...
102
00:08:15.992 --> 00:08:32.305
a reference that you find in one of your data holdings, which is adverse to that person, or perhaps suggests that further inquiries need to be made because maybe they come from a particular area or they've got associations with either criminal elements or terrorist elements that you want to interrogate.
103
00:08:33.266 --> 00:08:41.992
So that's when you do your data
checking and you're running names constantly through, I wouldn't call it a never expanding range of data sources, but certainly
104
00:08:42.753 --> 00:08:47.075
are more significantly a larger set of data holdings than we used to have.
105
00:08:47.315 --> 00:08:54.959
And we're just constantly coming to arrangements and agreements, not just with our Five Eyes partners, but with others to mutually access each other's data sets.
106
00:08:55.039 --> 00:08:56.540
So that's one set of criteria.
107
00:08:57.320 --> 00:09:03.943
Increasingly, not available for all candidates, but increasingly you can do social media scrapes.
108
00:09:04.443 --> 00:09:08.485
Not everyone's online, obviously, but you'd be surprised at the number of people who are online.
109
00:09:08.525 --> 00:09:11.027
So they've either got their own social media presence,
110
00:09:12.267 --> 00:09:13.348
They've posted things.
111
00:09:13.388 --> 00:09:14.868
They've posted things about themselves.
112
00:09:15.768 --> 00:09:29.773
In some cases, the officer will either be the beneficiary of an intelligence analyst in the separate part of home affairs that does immigration intelligence work who might prompt a query saying, look, we found a post that you might just want to think about or look into.
113
00:09:29.793 --> 00:09:31.814
There might be a post that is suggestive of...
114
00:09:32.835 --> 00:09:35.017
of a security or character concern.
115
00:09:35.919 --> 00:09:43.849
And then there's the interview process itself, and it might well be that matters come up through the interview process that give the officer cause for concern.
116
00:09:45.151 --> 00:09:49.537
So the better way to put it, and certainly when I was running the department, I was...
117
00:09:50.668 --> 00:10:00.770
I didn't want to particularly, this is going to sound counterintuitive, I didn't want a particularly fixed view of what Australian values or, if you like, the Australian character was.
118
00:10:00.930 --> 00:10:11.353
Because it seemed to me, and I know the formal documents call the Australian value statement, but if you look at the value statement, they're no different from what you would describe as liberal democratic values.
119
00:10:11.673 --> 00:10:12.975
small L values.
120
00:10:13.075 --> 00:10:16.358
I read the statement in preparation for our chart.
121
00:10:16.598 --> 00:10:16.798
Yes.
122
00:10:16.939 --> 00:10:19.441
With the exception of the section on the fair go.
123
00:10:19.621 --> 00:10:20.022
The fair go.
124
00:10:20.042 --> 00:10:24.106
I mean, it could be an American value statement or a British value statement.
125
00:10:24.126 --> 00:10:25.227
But you want it to be, right?
126
00:10:25.247 --> 00:10:31.534
So, I mean, is anyone seriously saying that an Italian or a Dane or a French person is
127
00:10:32.174 --> 00:10:45.958
is any more committed to pluralism, the rule of law, respect for the rule of law, democratic, whether it's a presidential system or a parliamentary system, some form of democratic system of resolving political difference.
128
00:10:45.978 --> 00:10:49.019
So I don't see those as being uniquely Australian values.
129
00:10:49.079 --> 00:10:53.860
I know for legal and probably for political purposes, we call them Australian values and
130
00:10:54.580 --> 00:11:00.848
And a fair go in other societies might be called egalitarianism.
131
00:11:01.449 --> 00:11:09.199
So most societies have also got a sense of balancing liberty on the one hand, freedom, with, if not equality, at least equity.
132
00:11:09.219 --> 00:11:09.619
Mm-hmm.
133
00:11:10.681 --> 00:11:34.282
So my view was always, and certainly in all the instructional materials we used to give our staff and what they were looking for, is look for, if you like, aberrations or look for people who aren't going to live in that pluralistic, liberal, democratic society rather than who are not going to fit into Australian society because you end up in the same place.
134
00:11:34.302 --> 00:11:35.063
Right, yeah.
135
00:11:35.223 --> 00:11:46.087
You end up in a place where you've got – and this has been our overwhelming migrant experience because typically if you're going to migrate permanently, you've already got a sense of the country that you're migrating to.
136
00:11:46.107 --> 00:11:49.968
There's a couple of exceptions that no doubt we'll come to in the course of our conversation.
137
00:11:50.708 --> 00:11:59.696
where there are particular religions or particular cultural backgrounds that might run up against not Australian-ness per se, but pluralism, tolerance.
138
00:11:59.937 --> 00:12:01.478
And no doubt we'll come to that.
139
00:12:01.498 --> 00:12:12.948
And I think there's a particular issue in relation to some of the harder interpretations of Islam, for instance, particularly with the sophistic jihadist interpretation.
140
00:12:12.968 --> 00:12:14.029
But we'll come to that in a moment.
141
00:12:14.790 --> 00:12:21.515
So whether you're migrating to Canada or whether you're migrating to New Zealand or whether you're migrating to Australia, the model is essentially the same.
142
00:12:21.575 --> 00:12:28.159
We use different systems points and different security and character testing algorithms and procedures and processes.
143
00:12:28.640 --> 00:12:35.665
But essentially, you're looking for the same thing, which is not so much to say, Joe, we want you to conform with a particular culture.
144
00:12:36.772 --> 00:12:36.972
No.
145
00:12:37.312 --> 00:12:41.335
What we're really asking you is to conform with a particular institutional system.
146
00:12:42.016 --> 00:12:43.477
This is how we run Australia.
147
00:12:44.078 --> 00:12:44.778
It's plural.
148
00:12:45.158 --> 00:12:45.999
It's democratic.
149
00:12:47.000 --> 00:12:48.081
Men and women are equal.
150
00:12:48.421 --> 00:12:49.822
There's equality of opportunity.
151
00:12:50.582 --> 00:12:52.244
The courts dispense justice.
152
00:12:52.284 -->
00:12:56.347
We don't have an extrajudicial way of dispensing justice.
153
00:12:56.867 --> 00:12:59.709
When a court decides something, even the government is bound.
154
00:13:00.190 --> 00:13:03.352
In other words, the courts can restrain the executive government from,
155
00:13:04.937 --> 00:13:20.405
If we believe that you as a candidate are able to live within those, if you like, institutional, and I describe them as institutional rather than cultural parameters, because our French and Australian culture is very different, but we're both democracies.
156
00:13:21.165 --> 00:13:31.589
It seems to me the common touch points in migration typically to at least Western nations are a commitment to the, if you like, the institutional values of that society.
157
00:13:32.149 --> 00:13:39.171
So when you do your security and character checks, you're looking for things like criminal behaviour, obviously, criminal associations.
158
00:13:39.611 --> 00:13:43.353
But you're also looking for things like extremist belief.
159
00:13:45.194 --> 00:13:49.038
Has the person come up in a database of extremists, for instance?
160
00:13:49.859 --> 00:13:54.864
Are they potentially associated with someone who might be in your extremist database?
161
00:13:55.725 --> 00:14:02.412
Is there anything that they said during interview or maybe that they've expressed through social media that might give you cause for concern about?
162
00:14:02.932 --> 00:14:05.573
in terms of extremist ideation.
163
00:14:06.114 --> 00:14:09.595
That's what you're looking for, rather than a more nebulous.
164
00:14:09.996 --> 00:14:13.177
And I understand why in the political debate we talk about Australian values.
165
00:14:13.297 --> 00:14:14.238
I absolutely get that.
166
00:14:14.718 --> 00:14:21.521
And I get why a politician, for instance, a minister or a senior member of the opposition would want to talk about the Australian way.
167
00:14:21.701 --> 00:14:22.542
I absolutely get that.
168
00:14:23.548 --> 00:14:44.078
But as an administrator, turning that into something that is, if you like, able to be delivered as a program where you can train your staff as to what to look for, you can train your decision makers as to how to make decisions, there are limits to what a fairly nebulous idea of Australia, there are limits to how you can apply that in a programmatic sense.
169
00:14:44.098 --> 00:14:50.401
You've got to turn that into some decision points that are able to be documented and where the thresholds are clear.
170
00:14:51.209 --> 00:15:00.356
What's an example of an interview question put by an immigration officer that might turn up whether someone has beliefs that are incompatible with liberal democratic values?
171
00:15:00.596 --> 00:15:13.887
If the officer's so-minded, or it might be that we're doing a particular campaign, or I shouldn't say we in the first person, but if they're doing a particular campaign through their questioning and they want to have a discussion
about men and women,
172
00:15:15.549 --> 00:15:15.969
Equality.
173
00:15:17.791 --> 00:15:22.955
The rights of women to work, the rights of women to live free of domestic violence, for instance.
174
00:15:22.975 --> 00:15:25.237
You might probe away at that.
175
00:15:25.717 --> 00:15:30.842
Now, you've also got to apply a bit of some judgment because it might be that the person...
176
00:15:31.502 --> 00:15:36.464
engaging with you and answering your questions as anticipated, the fact that you're going to ask that.
177
00:15:36.485 --> 00:15:45.349
So you're not necessarily getting to, if you like, deep ideation, but it might sit alongside other indicators that might cause you to be concerned.
178
00:15:46.009 --> 00:15:53.473
Yeah, because I mean, I can imagine people who are applying probably will have a pretty good idea of what the immigration officer wants to hear.
179
00:15:54.797 --> 00:16:01.214
Yes, and for the most part, there's a beautiful confluence of what the immigration wants to hear and what the person believes.
180
00:16:02.353 --> 00:16:10.678
In my experience, and it's very rare to find examples to the contrary, most people have got a positive idea of Australia.
181
00:16:11.338 --> 00:16:11.698
Of course.
182
00:16:12.819 --> 00:16:14.440
In a sense, it's a land of opportunity.
183
00:16:14.480 --> 00:16:15.561
It's a land of freedom.
184
00:16:16.481 --> 00:16:22.824
As long as you don't harm others or adversely affect others, you're basically a free to live as you want.
185
00:16:22.844 --> 00:16:23.005
Yeah.
186
00:16:23.525 --> 00:16:24.826
Most people express that.
187
00:16:25.786 --> 00:16:34.608
both in their application and through their enthusiasm during the whole candidacy process, through interviews and the rest of it.
188
00:16:35.288 --> 00:16:42.630
And the officers become very attuned to detecting that enthusiasm and that genuine desire.
189
00:16:42.950 --> 00:16:45.271
Now, can someone mask that?
190
00:16:45.351 --> 00:16:46.951
Of course, look, of course they can.
191
00:16:46.991 --> 00:16:52.273
Can someone, you know, create a legend which isn't what they really believe and...
192
00:16:53.185 --> 00:16:55.680
Yes, and the more skilled they are, the harder they are to detect.
193
00:16:55.700 --> 00:16:57.027
But then you're really almost starting to...
194
00:16:58.328 --> 00:17:02.109
getting to counter-espionage and trying to penetrate someone's legend.
195
00:17:02.169 --> 00:17:07.050
Typically, most people's beliefs are deeply held but lightly expressed.
196
00:17:07.070 --> 00:17:12.011
In other words, they'll say, yes, of course women should be able to dress as they choose.
197
00:17:12.052 --> 00:17:16.473
Of course women should have an equal opportunity to get a job.
198
00:17:16.533 --> 00:17:23.054
Most people, it's just like conversing with someone at a restaurant or in a pub, will express their view of life in basic terms.
199
00:17:23.114 --> 00:17:23.374
Yeah.
200
00:17:26.175 --> 00:17:35.945
So thinking back on your time as secretary of the department, are there any vignettes that stand out as particularly salient around how we select migrants?
201
00:17:36.386 --> 00:17:37.527
Any anecdotes?
202
00:17:38.138 --> 00:17:50.866
I've got to be a little bit careful because I don't want to give away the tradecraft of how particular intelligence operations are mounted or how particular what we call campaigns are mounted through the selection process.
203
00:17:51.266 --> 00:18:04.094
But I certainly recall at particular times, especially when we were dealing with that period, during that period from about 2013 onwards until about 2019 with the rise of the caliphate.
204
00:18:04.574 --> 00:18:05.996
Mm-hmm.
205
00:18:06.977 --> 00:18:11.622
And we should now go into the question of the more extremist versions of Islam.
206
00:18:11.642 --> 00:18:19.310
What was heartening during that time is both through candidate selection, which is what you're asking about, but also in the parallel question of
207
00:18:20.091 --> 00:18:37.292
the attitudes of second-generation migrants, so those who are the children of people, in this case with a Muslim or Islamic faith background, is the relatively small numbers relative to population size where we were concerned.
208
00:18:37.312 --> 00:18:37.392
Yes.
209
00:18:39.025 --> 00:18:44.969
Now, yes, it is the case that there's an over-representation.
210
00:18:45.470 --> 00:18:49.793
This is not so much on migrant selection, but it's really about the second generation, but it makes the same point.
211
00:18:51.034 --> 00:19:00.201
There's an over-representation, no question, and I can't discuss the numbers simply because it's really a matter for the head of ASIO to speak about this publicly, not me.
212
00:19:00.221 --> 00:19:01.622
But let's say for argument's sake...
213
00:19:03.015 --> 00:19:08.240
There's, let's say, several hundred, I won't be precise, but let's say several hundred hard targets that you're looking at.
214
00:19:08.280 --> 00:19:13.946
That is, people you're seriously concerned about who might take their ideation to the point of attack planning.
215
00:19:14.807 --> 00:19:15.988
Who are already in the country.
216
00:19:16.308 --> 00:19:16.448
Yeah.
217
00:19:16.588 --> 00:19:18.570
Either first or second generation, typically.
218
00:19:18.590 --> 00:19:21.053
We're not quite at the point where we're getting third generation yet.
219
00:19:21.193 --> 00:19:21.333
Yeah.
220
00:19:21.733 --> 00:19:26.979
And you might have several thousand who might be on the periphery of some of these more extremist preachers, for instance.
221
00:19:27.119 --> 00:19:27.299
Mm-hmm.
222
00:19:29.417 --> 00:19:39.348
So you've got an over-representation within the groups that are under investigation, the groups that are charged, and the groups that are brought before the courts are convicted.
223
00:19:39.548 --> 00:19:42.972
In other words, an over-representation typically of younger men
224
00:19:44.411 --> 00:19:57.545
of Muslim faith who have got a view that there's a somehow deeply existential conflict between the West, Judeo-Christian West, and the Christians and the Jews particularly, and Islam.
225
00:19:58.305 --> 00:20:02.209
And the only way to resolve that is to live in a caliphate.
226
00:20:02.750 --> 00:20:05.733
And we saw this, so we saw this play out for real, and we saw this,
227
00:20:05.853 --> 00:20:30.775
when the caliphate, which is a very different model from the al-Qaeda model, which is a very decentralised terrorist model, the caliphate of Islamic State, was, no, no, we're going to create a territorial unit, and we're going to invite people from all over the world, from the universal Islamic community, to come and live their true Islamic faith, where men are superior, women are in a subordinate position, your children are raised in the caliphate.
228
00:20:32.213 --> 00:20:35.616
What was hardening about that was the relatively small numbers.
229
00:20:36.437 --> 00:20:38.099
Yes, there was over-representation.
230
00:20:38.119 --> 00:20:52.073
So if you look at the people who have been charged and convicted since, say, 9-11, so that gives you a 25-year sample set, very much overly represented by young Muslim men.
231
00:20:52.989 --> 00:21:05.700
The good news is that within their community, which is now getting above 850,000, so last census was about 825,000 from memory, so about now it'd be 850,000.
232
00:21:05.760 --> 00:21:07.882
The largest non-Christian faith group in Australia.
233
00:21:07.962 --> 00:21:12.025
And rapidly growing for a series of reasons.
234
00:21:12.125 --> 00:21:16.889
One is source country immigration, humanitarian program, and birth rate.
235
00:21:17.110 --> 00:21:17.210
Yep.
236
00:21:17.230 --> 00:21:17.310
Yep.
237
00:21:17.710 --> 00:21:23.935
So at least for the moment in the second generation, high levels of fertility relative to other groups.
238
00:21:24.376 --> 00:21:25.697
So growing at quite a size.
239
00:21:26.437 --> 00:21:28.799
That to me is a remarkable achievement.
240
00:21:28.819 --> 00:21:30.080
The absolute numbers are small.
241
00:21:30.260 --> 00:21:30.721
Correct.
242
00:21:31.001 --> 00:21:36.105
So yes, you do get over-representation and there's no beating about the bush.
243
00:21:36.125 --> 00:21:38.347
You can't avoid making this statement.
244
00:21:38.787 --> 00:21:40.209
You have over-representation.
245
00:21:40.229 --> 00:21:43.952
I won't give you the numbers, A, because they're classified and B, I'm two and a half years out anyway.
246
00:21:44.552 --> 00:22:00.862
You have over-representation in the ASIO and AFP caseload ahead of the second group, which is actually Caucasian men, again, increasing, not at a startling rate, but increasing significantly enough, who are...
247
00:22:01.582 --> 00:22:05.783
following neo-Nazi type or white supremacist type ideation.
248
00:22:05.803 --> 00:22:08.403
So those are your two groups that you're most worried about.
249
00:22:08.463 --> 00:22:08.643
Yeah.
250
00:22:08.964 --> 00:22:10.384
And they kind of feed off each other as well.
251
00:22:10.404 --> 00:22:12.284
And they feed off each other to some extent.
252
00:22:12.304 --> 00:22:24.507
They've both got a very different view about the very thing we spoke about a moment ago, pluralistic, tolerant, equitable, cosmopolitan, multicultural Australia.
253
00:22:24.907 --> 00:22:29.988
They come from different vectors against that vision.
254
00:22:30.168 --> 00:22:30.348
Yeah.
255
00:22:31.312 --> 00:22:33.274
Absolute numbers are worrying enough.
256
00:22:33.314 --> 00:22:37.938
You don't want, you certainly wouldn't want thousands of targets, but let's say... Several hundred.
257
00:22:38.198 --> 00:22:39.079
Let's say several hundred.
258
00:22:39.119 --> 00:22:41.341
I'm not going to go beyond that.
259
00:22:41.721 --> 00:22:49.768
And let's say, and I'll just do a quick side note because we'll come back to this, I suspect, in the context of the Royal Commission that's currently underway.
260
00:22:50.369 --> 00:22:52.491
This is something that Virginia Bell, the commissioner...
261
00:22:53.031 --> 00:22:55.193
the former High Court justice is going to have to think about.
262
00:22:55.233 --> 00:23:10.146
Because one of the things that she's now confronted with, and regrettably, my good friend Dennis Richardson, as of the time that we're broadcasting this, has just recently announced he's not going to further assist in the process, which I think is a shame, but I respect Dennis's...
263
00:23:11.206 --> 00:23:12.728
motivations and reasons.
264
00:23:12.768 --> 00:23:38.808
But one of the things that Virginia Bell's now going to have to think about is for the likely growth in those two caseloads, or the, no, I won't say growth, for the likely quantum and the trajectory of those quantums, one with young Muslim men, typically, very few Muslim women, notwithstanding the discussion about ISIS brides who went to the caliphate, but the attack planning and attack execution is typically younger Muslim men.
265
00:23:40.257 --> 00:23:49.126
Although in the case of Bondi, he had the father as well, but the surviving suspect is in his 20s.
266
00:23:50.307 --> 00:23:55.171
And those Caucasian neo-Nazis and or white supremacists.
267
00:23:56.172 --> 00:24:03.499
One of the things that the judge will have to consider is what is the baseline of those two caseloads at the moment?
268
00:24:04.328 --> 00:24:22.526
Because in absolute numbers, because ASIO needs to think about absolute numbers rather than proportions, and then is the resourcing level set right for both extremist Islamist terrorism and white supremacy and or neo-Nazi terrorism?
269
00:24:22.546 --> 00:24:22.646
Okay.
270
00:24:23.542 --> 00:24:27.930
And she's going to have to come to a view, and she might well have to give public venting to those numbers.
271
00:24:29.453 --> 00:24:35.805
For the purpose of this
discussion, and I'm just focused at the moment, although I'm happy to talk about white supremacists if you wish, but...
272
00:24:36.766 --> 00:24:40.108
because they've got an integration issue as well in a perverse kind of way.
273
00:24:40.508 --> 00:24:54.696
But if we're just focused on those who follow the more extremist, Salafist, jihadi version of Sunni Islam, the numbers are actually quite small relative to...
274
00:24:55.516 --> 00:24:57.078
the Australian Muslim community.
275
00:24:57.418 --> 00:24:59.540
And I think we should be heartened by that.
276
00:24:59.680 --> 00:25:00.621
That's a good thing.
277
00:25:01.521 --> 00:25:06.606
As I said, based on the last census, that community is about 850,000.
278
00:25:06.906 --> 00:25:18.235
So those numbers, whilst worrying in absolute terms, including the numbers that have been bought before the courts and numbers prior to that who have been charged, you don't want to see an increase in those numbers, that's for sure.
279
00:25:18.255 --> 00:25:19.416
But...
280
00:25:20.397 --> 00:25:24.762
You're not talking about thousands and thousands of people who hate Australia.
281
00:25:24.983 --> 00:25:25.623
Yeah.
282
00:25:25.643 --> 00:25:26.484
So that's the good news.
283
00:25:26.544 --> 00:25:27.045
That's good news.
284
00:25:27.886 --> 00:25:29.248
So how did we get onto the- Oh, yeah.
285
00:25:29.268 --> 00:25:34.874
I was asking about whether you had any kind of vignettes or anecdotes about how we select migrants-
286
00:25:35.763 --> 00:25:47.934
Well, at that time, so just reverse engineering the answer, because we were concerned about the idea of the caliphate, extra attention and resources.
287
00:25:48.515 --> 00:25:55.622
And again, I'm going to be circumspect in describing the exact methodologies and the classified systems that are used.
288
00:25:56.062 --> 00:25:59.025
But at that time, there was extra checking done.
289
00:26:00.150 --> 00:26:09.601
on anyone who might come from countries where that Salafistic, jihadi version of Sunni Islam was prevalent.
290
00:26:09.801 --> 00:26:13.326
So parts of Somalia, parts of Iraq, Sudan, et cetera.
291
00:26:14.167 --> 00:26:16.129
And at the same time, about 2014, 2015,
292
00:26:18.411 --> 00:26:33.762
We achieved a number of breakthroughs in what was still the Immigration and Border Protection Department in terms of getting agreements with partners, both domestic and foreign, to link in digitally databases that had never been previously made available.
293
00:26:33.802 --> 00:26:35.783
So you could do some of that digital checking.
294
00:26:37.613 --> 00:26:57.251
Now, acknowledging that the technology was 12 years old, it was cutting edge at the time, but you could run your search parameters through larger data lakes, and you'd get flags that, frankly, might never have been flagged to immigration officers previously.
295
00:26:57.591 --> 00:26:59.072
So, for instance, one-
296
00:27:00.033 --> 00:27:02.295
And this is about the time of the caliphate.
297
00:27:02.315 --> 00:27:03.556
So really important reference point.
298
00:27:04.177 --> 00:27:11.203
We've got access, and I spoke about this at one of the Senate committee hearings, to a number of classified US databases.
299
00:27:11.403 --> 00:27:20.912
I'm not in a position to, you know, whether it's FBI or CIA or someone else, I'll let your imagination run wild.
300
00:27:20.932 --> 00:27:21.132
Right.
301
00:27:21.873 --> 00:27:47.115
where because the Immigration and Border Protection Department, as it then was, subsequently Home Affairs, was not a rated intelligence agency at that time, you might not have full access to all the biodata, but you might have enough of a hit just based on basic biodata, name, date of birth, aliases, where the host agency
302
00:27:48.136 --> 00:27:57.360
And it was done through a portal within Homeland Security, say in the American case, which we need to send this file to the Australians, which we might do through ASIO, right?
303
00:27:57.380 --> 00:28:05.543
So we're not going to send it to an immigration officer who doesn't have quite the high-level clearances required, but a flag's been hit.
304
00:28:06.724 --> 00:28:10.065
And in days of old, that immigration officer would have been none the wiser.
305
00:28:10.606 --> 00:28:10.746
Hmm.
306
00:28:11.626 --> 00:28:20.457
So then what happens is they get a call from ASIO saying, oh, you've sent a ping for Joe, biodata and an alias has come up.
307
00:28:21.359 --> 00:28:26.205
We're running that lead down with our partners, say, in the FBI, let's say.
308
00:28:27.908 --> 00:28:34.657
In that federated searching process, just that alone started to see an increase in our rejection rate.
309
00:28:36.038 --> 00:28:38.461
And I can't go into the numbers, but why?
310
00:28:38.802 --> 00:28:46.231
Because we were hitting databases, even just at the stripped down data layer, name, alias, state of birth, maybe...
311
00:28:47.332 --> 00:28:50.575
region of origin, town of origin, place of birth, maybe, at most.
312
00:28:51.176 --> 00:28:52.897
Well, you don't get the full FBI file.
313
00:28:52.917 --> 00:28:59.763
You don't get the full CIA file because they're highly classified and they're subject to different sharing arrangements.
314
00:29:00.403 --> 00:29:05.488
But it's just enough for the officer to be flagged to say, hey, we've sent a file to ASIO.
315
00:29:05.508 --> 00:29:07.489
You better talk to your colleagues over at ASIO.
316
00:29:07.630 --> 00:29:08.330
Yeah, interesting.
317
00:29:08.550 --> 00:29:12.774
And an ASIO who might have access to the deeper file saying, do not issue a visa.
318
00:29:12.962 --> 00:29:13.422
Yeah, wow.
319
00:29:14.242 --> 00:29:20.065
Which is interesting because it implies that prior to the 2010s, we were letting in a lot of people who... Before 2014.
320
00:29:20.605 --> 00:29:21.485
I can almost date it.
321
00:29:22.165 --> 00:29:24.666
So the... What was that?
322
00:29:24.686 --> 00:29:26.307
The Abbott government funded...
323
00:29:26.607 --> 00:29:31.869
There was some earlier work done to the credit of both the Rudd and Gillard governments where they started going down this path.
324
00:29:32.769 --> 00:29:40.012
But the investment in something called VRA, public program, not classified, although elements of it are classified...
325
00:29:40.652 --> 00:29:47.120
Visa Risk Assessment, VRA, was funded from memory in the 2014-2015 budget.
326
00:29:47.720 --> 00:29:55.570
So we've got quite a lot of money, I think, upwards of $100 million to create this federated search engine, classified search engine.
327
00:29:56.310 --> 00:30:13.500
We created for the first time, there were intelligence officers in the old immigration department going right back to 1945, typically retired military, retired police, sometimes retired ASIO, very good officers, but very much working with paper files.
328
00:30:14.281 --> 00:30:18.724
With VRA, we started to deploy digital tools.
329
00:30:19.644 --> 00:30:24.406
We created an intelligence cell, which ultimately became a division, a whole division.
330
00:30:24.446 --> 00:30:28.728
So in a bureaucratic hierarchy, you've got the department, which is run by the secretary.
331
00:30:29.148 --> 00:30:31.349
You've got groups that are run by deputy secretaries.
332
00:30:31.909 --> 00:30:35.251
And then you've got divisions that are run by first assistant secretaries.
333
00:30:35.551 --> 00:30:44.955
Roughly mimics the military system of an army, a corps, and a division, just in broad terms for those of your viewers who are military-minded.
334
00:30:45.015 --> 00:30:45.795
Military-minded.
335
00:30:46.375 --> 00:30:50.698
Yeah, so a two-star, a first assistant secretary, broadly equivalent to a two-star general.
336
00:30:51.018 --> 00:30:58.042
So we created a division under a two-star civilian equivalent, and they had top-secret code word clearances.
337
00:30:58.062 --> 00:31:05.107
So they could engage more openly on, if you like, the under-the-line text and other information.
338
00:31:05.487 --> 00:31:09.389
The immigration officer, who might have a lower-level clearance, might never see the full file.
339
00:31:09.409 --> 00:31:09.510
Yeah.
340
00:31:10.370 --> 00:31:23.023
But because he had this federated search capability, they were able to be advised, do not issue a visa or probe more deeply on these questions and factors before you come to a view and then come back to us.
341
00:31:23.663 --> 00:31:26.526
And so that loop that was created between the intelligence staff and...
342
00:31:27.407 --> 00:31:32.488
and the visa issuance staff was a first and subsequently built upon.
343
00:31:32.708 --> 00:31:35.689
There was further investment under the Turnbull government, as I recall.
344
00:31:36.589 --> 00:31:54.393
It's not quite to that fully digital selection machine that I spoke about at the top of this discussion, where ultimately you're going to have everything digitised, including down to having an AI agent who can not only look for those security flags and concerns, but can also say...
345
00:31:55.053 --> 00:31:57.335
You're looking for nurses in Tasmania.
346
00:31:57.555 --> 00:31:59.216
Here are your best 20 candidates.
347
00:31:59.256 --> 00:31:59.536
Yeah.
348
00:31:59.796 --> 00:32:01.378
I mean, ultimately, you want to get to that.
349
00:32:01.498 --> 00:32:02.438
Yeah.
350
00:32:02.518 --> 00:32:07.442
I don't know, unless there's been a dramatic lift in investment in the last couple of years.
351
00:32:07.502 --> 00:32:09.523
I don't know that they're close quite to that level.
352
00:32:09.903 --> 00:32:20.171
But that federated surface searching, at least, has been a feature of our visa risk assessment process for now 12 years.
353
00:32:20.291 --> 00:32:20.491
Hmm.
354
00:32:21.232 --> 00:32:28.461
So that increase in the rejection rate, I don't remember the exact increase, but I did read it in one of your opening statements to legal and constitutional affairs.
355
00:32:28.562 --> 00:32:30.304
I can put a link in the show notes.
356
00:32:30.825 --> 00:32:32.167
But that implies that-
357
00:32:35.498 --> 00:32:37.280
And I'd have to go back to my statements.
358
00:32:37.340 --> 00:32:43.785
I think we added something like a 1.5 percentage point lift in rejections.
359
00:32:43.925 --> 00:32:45.106
Yeah, that sounds about right.
360
00:32:45.567 --> 00:32:52.753
So that implies that prior to 2014, we were letting in like tens of thousands of people that we wouldn't have wanted to?
361
00:32:53.193 --> 00:32:54.816
Is that the right order of magnitude?
362
00:32:54.836 --> 00:32:56.538
I think that's about the right order of magnitude.
363
00:32:56.558 --> 00:33:08.756
We'll have to go back to the relevant... Because I did quite a lot of work on this in anticipation of one of the Senate estimate hearings, because there was a question about...
364
00:33:09.437 --> 00:33:21.801
There was a question about whether, if you like, we were checking, particularly after the Caliphate episode, whether we're checking deeply enough, thoroughly enough.
365
00:33:22.781 --> 00:33:36.325
I think from memory, and again, I'm going to have to be corrected and you can put a link, I think we got the rejection rate up by at least a whole percentage point, if not 1.5 or something, which in absolute numbers was in the thousands.
366
00:33:36.726 --> 00:33:36.966
Right.
367
00:33:37.366 --> 00:33:38.006
Yeah, interesting.
368
00:33:38.266 --> 00:33:42.010
Now, not all of that, I should be clear, was about terrorists.
369
00:33:42.330 --> 00:33:43.291
Sure, of course.
370
00:33:43.411 --> 00:33:58.826
In some cases, through these international checking channels, we picked up repeat applicants who have gone to different countries with maybe fraudulent academic qualifications.
371
00:33:58.846 --> 00:33:58.946
Yep.
372
00:33:58.966 --> 00:33:59.126
Yep.
373
00:34:00.007 --> 00:34:07.370
And so you'll
get a hit, say, in a Canadian database saying, no, no, we've seen that person before, and we look behind their application.
374
00:34:07.550 --> 00:34:09.151
They don't have that degree.
375
00:34:09.451 --> 00:34:10.151
Okay, thank you.
376
00:34:10.311 --> 00:34:10.931
Thanks, Canada.
377
00:34:11.492 --> 00:34:13.152
And we'll share our information with you.
378
00:34:13.192 --> 00:34:17.914
So some of the rejections were on security grounds.
379
00:34:18.234 --> 00:34:25.217
Other rejections would have been on character, and other rejections would have been on basically fraud, you know, fraudulent qualifications, for instance.
380
00:34:25.237 --> 00:34:26.237
And this is all under the VRA.
381
00:34:26.377 --> 00:34:26.517
Yep.
382
00:34:26.978 --> 00:34:27.138
Yep.
383
00:34:27.638 --> 00:34:27.778
Yep.
384
00:34:28.398 --> 00:34:29.979
What's your gut intuition?
385
00:34:29.999 --> 00:34:40.547
Do you think AI is going to net out in favour of bureaucrats using it to detect weak applications or in favour of weaker applicants trying to get around the system?
386
00:34:41.408 --> 00:34:52.095
I think in net terms, if you combine it with and keep building on these digital systems that I've been describing, more and more of these databases, right?
387
00:34:52.716 --> 00:34:56.418
So the visa officer has this force multiplier that,
388
00:34:57.417 --> 00:35:06.848
which they might not be aware of because it's coming through an intelligence portal, and they might be reliant on CIA, FBI, MI6, MI5 information that they'll never see.
389
00:35:07.809 --> 00:35:15.198
But as you force multiply, say we establish a relationship with the French intelligence services or the Belgian intelligence services,
390
00:35:16.557 --> 00:35:18.339
It's not just AI, but the feed.
391
00:35:18.939 --> 00:35:30.869
So the more data you're pushing in, you're scraping people's social media, you're hitting more and more databases, both at the bio data level, but also in terms of classified holdings,
392
00:35:31.830 --> 00:35:44.719
and you're moving to sort of an AI agent model that's helping the officer do the research, I think the balance of favour falls on the side of the officer.
393
00:35:45.119 --> 00:35:45.359
Okay.
394
00:35:45.940 --> 00:35:47.181
And the reason why I say that is...
395
00:35:49.502 --> 00:36:05.445
is because, a bit like crime, criminals will always be working new ways of importing drugs or conducting fraud, and if the defending organisation just stays on its own, they'll always be overwhelmed.
396
00:36:06.005 --> 00:36:18.087
But the more you federate, this is a point about law enforcement, but the same applies to immigration and border protection, the more you federate with like-minded jurisdictions and you just keep multiplying, multiplying, multiplying...
397
00:36:18.147 --> 00:36:19.528
Now, you've got to give as well, right?
398
00:36:19.548 --> 00:36:23.190
So if I get a French database, I've got to give them an Australian database.
399
00:36:23.770 --> 00:36:35.917
And the way you protect privacy is we say to the French, say, for instance, or the Belgians or others, we say, we're going to give you our headlines of all our key targets, and all you get is the name, the date of birth, place of birth.
400
00:36:35.997 --> 00:36:39.319
And if it pings, we'll then have a protocol to give you more.
401
00:36:39.859 --> 00:36:45.363
The more you do that, the more you suppress the opportunities to game the system.
402
00:36:45.383 --> 00:36:45.623
Right.
403
00:36:45.643 --> 00:36:45.783
Right.
404
00:36:46.272 --> 00:36:46.492
Hmm.
405
00:36:47.994 --> 00:36:53.158
So, at least with respect to immigration applications, AI will be defense biased.
406
00:36:53.358 --> 00:36:53.519
Yeah.
407
00:36:53.719 --> 00:36:53.899
Yeah.
408
00:36:54.720 --> 00:36:55.140
Interesting.
409
00:36:55.280 --> 00:36:55.781
I believe so.
410
00:36:56.021 --> 00:37:00.225
Again, collaboration always defeats the gamer.
411
00:37:00.505 --> 00:37:01.826
Yeah.
412
00:37:01.846 --> 00:37:02.046
Okay.
413
00:37:02.507 --> 00:37:02.647
So-
414
00:37:04.115 --> 00:37:07.017
I've been trying to get an answer to this next question for more than a year now.
415
00:37:07.217 --> 00:37:07.678
Right.
416
00:37:07.738 --> 00:37:14.323
It's come up in a lot of my conversations with people who've worked previously in the Department of Immigration.
417
00:37:14.343 --> 00:37:14.743
Mm-hmm.
418
00:37:15.383 --> 00:37:23.529
And I ask, you know, what are the reasons that historically Australia seems to have been so successful at acculturating migrants into the Australian mainstream?
419
00:37:23.549 --> 00:37:23.629
Yep.
420
00:37:23.890 --> 00:37:24.050
Yep.
421
00:37:24.590 --> 00:37:40.630
And one of the points I often hear is that we've always taken a mix of national and cultural groups such that no one group has formed critical mass sufficient to form a breakaway culture like the Quebisois in Canada or the Catalonians in Spain –
422
00:37:42.250 --> 00:37:57.275
And it is true that if you look at the spread of the 31.5% of Australians born overseas, 43 different countries account for at least 0.5% of that population each.
423
00:37:58.896 --> 00:38:08.359
In contrast, I think the US is much more top heavy in terms of its distribution, maybe like a quarter of their foreign born stock are from Mexico, for example.
424
00:38:08.579 --> 00:38:08.719
Yep.
425
00:38:10.731 --> 00:38:21.940
But what I don't understand is, like, A, the extent to which that has been a happy accident versus deliberate policy, and B, if it has been deliberate, exactly how it's been operationalized.
426
00:38:22.381 --> 00:38:27.185
Because obviously, since about 1973, we've had the principle of non-discrimination.
427
00:38:27.205 --> 00:38:27.285
Yes.
428
00:38:28.145 --> 00:38:39.955
I know that at various points in our history, governments have kind of consciously accepted refugees from particular regions with a view to kind of
like counterbalancing policies.
429
00:38:40.115 --> 00:38:46.818
certain diaspora already in Australia or expanding or building out the mix somewhat.
430
00:38:46.838 --> 00:38:54.721
So for example, I think in the 70s, the Whitlam government consciously took migrants from Latin America because we hadn't drawn migrants from there before.
431
00:38:55.242 --> 00:38:59.403
But since then, I haven't been able to find any other more recent examples.
432
00:38:59.463 --> 00:39:01.104
So yeah, I'm just going to put that out there.
433
00:39:01.784 --> 00:39:02.705
What do you know?
434
00:39:03.825 --> 00:39:07.347
It's been driven by global population dynamics.
435
00:39:08.387 --> 00:39:09.227
Not deliberate planning.
436
00:39:09.267 --> 00:39:09.427
No.
437
00:39:09.907 --> 00:39:10.228
Okay.
438
00:39:10.528 --> 00:39:15.029
And that's a function of the shift, the very welcome shift to non-discrimination.
439
00:39:15.289 --> 00:39:15.469
Yeah.
440
00:39:15.949 --> 00:39:17.409
However, and here's the however.
441
00:39:17.569 --> 00:39:17.769
Okay.
442
00:39:18.169 --> 00:39:26.551
Even if you're open to the world, in some cases, so India's a good example, and China to some extent, the world wasn't always traveling.
443
00:39:26.871 --> 00:39:27.051
Yeah.
444
00:39:27.311 --> 00:39:34.753
It's only been in recent years, probably from the 80s in China, in the case of China, 90s, even the 2000s in the case of India.
445
00:39:34.773 --> 00:39:34.873
Yeah.
446
00:39:35.453 --> 00:39:44.803
where you have the mass migration out that you saw previously in places like Italy or Greece or Ireland and the Baltic states, et cetera.
447
00:39:44.843 --> 00:39:51.730
In other words, these waves go through global history as a function of two factors.
448
00:39:52.410 --> 00:39:58.336
One, the openness of the receiving society, whether it's Australia or Canada or New Zealand, but also the...
449
00:39:58.977 --> 00:40:04.960
the temperament, if you like, or the attitude, or the sentiment, I should say, of the emigrant nation.
450
00:40:05.621 --> 00:40:12.884
So for a long time, people in India, for instance, didn't have the means to apply for the visa and to do the travel.
451
00:40:13.325 --> 00:40:13.765
Now they do.
452
00:40:14.585 --> 00:40:19.269
So you've had this dramatic rise in both.
453
00:40:19.349 --> 00:40:20.410
And that's a function of two things.
454
00:40:20.550 --> 00:40:22.552
One, you get temporary migration with students.
455
00:40:22.572 --> 00:40:24.934
They can stay for a post-study period.
456
00:40:24.954 --> 00:40:28.637
They sometimes form family attachments or they apply for the permanent stream.
457
00:40:29.257 --> 00:40:33.821
Applying for the permanent stream, just quickly going back to our earlier conversation from onshore,
458
00:40:34.461 --> 00:40:37.002
is as important today as applying offshore.
459
00:40:37.022 --> 00:40:39.463
In other words, you came here to do a four-year degree.
460
00:40:39.903 --> 00:40:44.344
You might have had a two- or four-year post-degree study and work period.
461
00:40:44.764 --> 00:40:48.205
You met someone, you fell in love, you decided, I want to stay in Australia.
462
00:40:48.766 --> 00:40:58.388
You switched to the permanent program, either off your own volition or through maybe a family, through a relationship, partner-sponsored visa.
463
00:40:58.709 --> 00:41:02.830
And what initially was a uni placement becomes a lifestyle choice.
464
00:41:02.850 --> 00:41:03.350
Mm-hmm.
465
00:41:05.242 --> 00:41:10.049
When people from India were not emigrating, our numbers were low.
466
00:41:10.069 --> 00:41:12.272
We didn't go out saying, let's get people from India.
467
00:41:12.312 --> 00:41:13.794
They just simply weren't emigrating.
468
00:41:14.415 --> 00:41:19.562
The great emigration from India started, I'll have to check my data on this, but probably...
469
00:41:20.263 --> 00:41:21.724
In the early 2000s, I'd say.
470
00:41:21.744 --> 00:41:22.204
Sounds right.
471
00:41:22.364 --> 00:41:22.544
Yeah.
472
00:41:22.564 --> 00:41:22.764
Yeah.
473
00:41:22.845 --> 00:41:23.905
China a little bit earlier.
474
00:41:24.065 --> 00:41:24.205
Yeah.
475
00:41:24.586 --> 00:41:33.691
And China, interestingly, more from Canton and the areas around Hong Kong, so southern China more so than northern China.
476
00:41:33.731 --> 00:41:35.652
That probably started in the 80s.
477
00:41:36.112 --> 00:41:42.876
So Sydney, for instance, a lot of people from Hong Kong, what used to be called Canton, they speak Cantonese, for instance.
478
00:41:43.136 --> 00:41:45.658
There's an over-representation relative to...
479
00:41:46.578 --> 00:41:48.240
the demographic breakdown of China.
480
00:41:48.821 --> 00:42:00.915
So it's when those waves are both attracted by the receiving country because of openness and non-discrimination in selection, but also those waves have to start.
481
00:42:01.616 --> 00:42:04.239
They ripple out from the source country.
482
00:42:04.659 --> 00:42:07.080
And then over time, in some cases, people stopped migrating.
483
00:42:07.100 --> 00:42:10.982
So there hasn't been an emigration wave from Ireland for decades.
484
00:42:11.582 --> 00:42:17.365
And if anything, people are sort of going back, particularly when Ireland became economically very successful.
485
00:42:18.646 --> 00:42:26.089
So these waves go for decades and then they either peter out or they transform or they become different.
486
00:42:26.785 --> 00:42:34.229
The thing that slightly operates at the margin of that is the refugee intake.
487
00:42:34.629 --> 00:42:35.690
Yeah.
488
00:42:35.710 --> 00:42:35.790
Why?
489
00:42:36.250 --> 00:42:44.115
The refugee intake typically, if your system for granting asylum to people with a well-founded fear of persecution...
490
00:42:44.955 --> 00:42:48.896
typically doesn't mirror waves of economic emigration.
491
00:42:50.337 --> 00:42:55.918
It's people fleeing from violence, torture, rape, political
oppression, etc.
492
00:42:56.559 --> 00:42:58.959
Discrimination on the base of gender, sexuality, etc.
493
00:42:59.920 --> 00:43:01.460
That's a different group again.
494
00:43:01.680 --> 00:43:07.142
And that's why in your refugee ranks after the Second World War,
495
00:43:07.933 --> 00:43:10.336
A lot of people from Eastern Europe, the Baltic states, etc.
496
00:43:10.396 --> 00:43:15.000
A lot of people fleeing communism, for instance, in the immediate aftermath of the Second World War.
497
00:43:15.701 --> 00:43:16.982
That changes dramatically.
498
00:43:17.042 --> 00:43:27.573
Vietnam, obviously, being the case in point in the 70s, Cambodia to some extent, and in more recent years, Syria, Sudan, and places, Somalia, places like that.
499
00:43:29.064 --> 00:43:55.737
Because we've also got a non-discriminatory policy in the refugee area, as we should, depending on the absolute size of your refugee program, you can get actually quite visible changes quickly because, say, for instance, you're taking a lot of people from Sudan, they normally wouldn't be migrating in the way, say, Italians migrated or Greeks migrated or the Irish before them or, more recently, people from China or India.
500
00:43:56.877 --> 00:43:57.418
They're fleeing.
501
00:43:57.438 --> 00:43:57.538
Yeah.
502
00:43:58.358 --> 00:44:10.890
And so nearly everyone that you see in Australia who's come, just from their physical appearance, you might think might have come from Sudan, is almost certainly here as a consequence of the humanitarian stream.
503
00:44:11.690 --> 00:44:21.980
So that is a sort of subset within your permanent program that's a function of drivers other than economic emigration.
504
00:44:22.000 --> 00:44:22.140
Right.
505
00:44:23.125 --> 00:44:40.684
It's kind of a remarkable fact about modern Australia that to the extent that the fact that the distribution of national groups in our foreign-born population is obviously far from perfectly uniform, but more uniform than it is for other Western democracies –
506
00:44:41.905 --> 00:44:51.688
That is just the result of us kind of hopscotching our way to the mix over these successive waves of emigrations.
507
00:44:51.728 --> 00:45:01.291
I can assure you, we don't have offices sitting in the permanent program saying, what is the global distribution of Spanish-speaking people from Latin America?
508
00:45:01.311 --> 00:45:03.552
And we filled up our quota here, so now we're going to get it.
509
00:45:03.572 --> 00:45:04.172
There's none of that.
510
00:45:04.212 --> 00:45:04.312
No.
511
00:45:05.353 --> 00:45:13.577
It largely mirrors the world with that exception around refugee, the refugee intake, which is probably disproportionate.
512
00:45:14.058 --> 00:45:19.601
So we would not, I suspect, I haven't looked at the data for a long time, but I don't think we've got...
513
00:45:20.292 --> 00:45:37.265
If you like the global distribution of people born in Sudan or people born of Sudanese parents in Australia, we've probably got a higher quotient or a higher proportion as a function of taking people who have got a well-founded fear of persecution and granting them asylum.
514
00:45:38.066 --> 00:45:59.975
But if you control for that variable, so people from Nepal or Bangladesh or India or Pakistan, and you go through with some oddities, but where there's perhaps over-representation relative to global demography, we basically mirror the world.
515
00:46:00.416 --> 00:46:03.457
Do you think we should have a deliberate policy with respect to...
516
00:46:04.624 --> 00:46:05.865
The mix or quotas?
517
00:46:06.205 --> 00:46:06.385
No.
518
00:46:06.665 --> 00:46:08.947
We should just kind of take what's there.
519
00:46:08.967 --> 00:46:12.789
No, I just think you take what's there based on those two factors.
520
00:46:13.129 --> 00:46:18.272
Openness of reception, subject to those character and security and other checks we spoke about earlier.
521
00:46:19.753 --> 00:46:23.655
And then you're basically, if you like, and Canada's similar...
522
00:46:24.515 --> 00:46:28.598
through the point system, you're basically a reflection of global mobility.
523
00:46:29.018 --> 00:46:31.799
So what was the time when people weren't emigrating from India?
524
00:46:32.119 --> 00:46:32.320
Yeah.
525
00:46:32.660 --> 00:46:35.061
There weren't a lot of Indians in Australia.
526
00:46:35.201 --> 00:46:35.381
Yeah.
527
00:46:36.302 --> 00:46:42.165
Once India started to open up, not open up, but once they started to emigrate,
528
00:46:43.251 --> 00:46:45.955
A lot of them either because family was here or they just knew about Australia.
529
00:46:45.975 --> 00:46:46.856
It was a Commonwealth country.
530
00:46:47.177 --> 00:46:48.399
Both play cricket, et cetera.
531
00:46:48.579 --> 00:46:49.320
Yeah.
532
00:46:49.440 --> 00:46:52.284
English, you know, they can get by very well with English.
533
00:46:52.525 --> 00:46:52.705
Yeah.
534
00:46:52.865 --> 00:46:54.928
Similar sort of common law justice systems.
535
00:46:55.549 --> 00:46:56.570
I want to go to Australia.
536
00:46:56.631 --> 00:46:57.592
Why schools are better?
537
00:46:57.993 --> 00:46:58.874
Better education.
538
00:46:59.795 --> 00:47:04.077
I still am devoted to my homeland, you know, celebrate national festivals.
539
00:47:04.997 --> 00:47:07.158
I'm a Hindu, as the case might be.
540
00:47:07.178 --> 00:47:11.220
I have freedom of religious observance in Australia.
541
00:47:11.240 --> 00:47:13.601
You know, I can go to the temple, et cetera.
542
00:47:14.282 --> 00:47:18.904
Australia is this wonderful land, but I'll make sure that my children understand their roots.
543
00:47:19.764 --> 00:47:23.025
And depending on our wealth over time, we'll travel back.
544
00:47:23.606 --> 00:47:28.548
And in some cases, it certainly has happened in the Italian community that I'm familiar with,
545
00:47:29.168 --> 00:47:36.350
Subsequent generations even buy property back in what is the ancestral
home and almost live a split life.
546
00:47:36.370 --> 00:47:43.213
I'm going back to Italy for three or four months, but my main house is in Australia.
547
00:47:43.593 --> 00:47:44.593
Indian people will do that.
548
00:47:44.633 --> 00:47:47.054
Chinese people, I suspect, will do that.
549
00:47:47.074 --> 00:47:50.455
We're second, third, and by the time you're fourth generation-
550
00:47:51.555 --> 00:47:55.337
They might well say, actually, I've opened up a business in India.
551
00:47:55.657 --> 00:47:56.597
My home is Australia.
552
00:47:56.617 --> 00:47:58.078
That's where my main residence is.
553
00:47:58.118 --> 00:48:00.939
My children all speak Australian.
554
00:48:01.439 --> 00:48:04.741
They want to play for the Australian cricket team, not the Indian cricket team.
555
00:48:05.241 --> 00:48:10.863
And when my children speak, they sound like little Australians, you know, in terms of the accent, for instance.
556
00:48:11.563 --> 00:48:12.744
But I also love India.
557
00:48:13.544 --> 00:48:15.165
and I've opened up a business there.
558
00:48:15.385 --> 00:48:15.585
Yeah.
559
00:48:15.886 --> 00:48:24.130
And you've seen this with Italians, you've seen it with Greeks, you've seen it with people from the former Yugoslavia, that you start to live in those two worlds, and that's a very healthy thing.
560
00:48:24.150 --> 00:48:24.370
Yeah.
561
00:48:24.790 --> 00:48:30.834
So, I mean, fundamentally what you're talking about there is acculturation, which is a very powerful and natural process.
562
00:48:31.174 --> 00:48:31.374
Yes.
563
00:48:31.534 --> 00:48:40.419
When I just – so people who might be listening are clear, when I say acculturation, like I basically mean what economists mean by assimilation or what people mean by integration –
564
00:48:41.520 --> 00:48:45.684
I avoid the word assimilation because in the Australian policy context, it's a very loaded word.
565
00:48:46.124 --> 00:48:50.489
But acculturation is a universal, natural, and powerful process.
566
00:48:50.509 --> 00:48:50.729
Yes.
567
00:48:51.069 --> 00:48:56.174
And it's a two-way street, and along different dimensions, the migrant culture might
568
00:48:56.995 --> 00:49:01.078
acculturate might converge more on the mainstream culture or vice versa.
569
00:49:01.118 --> 00:49:06.262
So like a classic example of the mainstream culture converging to the migrant culture is through cuisine.
570
00:49:07.222 --> 00:49:10.945
In the other direction, it's like language acquisition.
571
00:49:12.186 --> 00:49:21.773
And the definition of acculturation I like most is it's like the diminishing of ethnic or cultural difference over time.
572
00:49:22.073 --> 00:49:25.115
I like that definition because it permits the two-way street.
573
00:49:25.135 --> 00:49:26.436
It's about like a convergence.
574
00:49:27.233 --> 00:49:27.413
Hmm.
575
00:49:28.454 --> 00:49:37.983
So just so I'm clear, what you're saying is that we don't need to worry about or have a deliberate policy with respect to the mix because of this process of acculturation.
576
00:49:38.864 --> 00:49:48.513
But if it's true that the success of Australia's experience with acculturation is contingent on the fact that
577
00:49:49.334 --> 00:49:55.040
None of the groups have been sufficiently large that they can kind of sustain their own culture.
578
00:49:55.921 --> 00:50:02.708
And then you end up with, you know, like you travel to California and all the road signs are in both English and Spanish.
579
00:50:03.209 --> 00:50:04.490
We don't have that kind of situation.
580
00:50:04.510 --> 00:50:07.133
I mean, why shouldn't we be...
581
00:50:07.914 --> 00:50:09.334
deliberate about the mix?
582
00:50:09.354 --> 00:50:13.035
Just so I'm clear, why do you think we don't need to be deliberate about that?
583
00:50:13.596 --> 00:50:20.017
I think for the reason that we touched on earlier, that the mix doesn't matter as much as the allegiance does.
584
00:50:20.998 --> 00:50:28.960
It doesn't matter whether you're a Greek Australian, an Anglo-Australian, a Lebanese Australian, if you accept a number of basic precepts.
585
00:50:29.820 --> 00:50:32.223
We resolve our political differences through the parliament.
586
00:50:32.243 --> 00:50:34.885
You know, we have political parties and we have representation.
587
00:50:36.266 --> 00:50:39.549
The courts determine both civil and criminal penalties.
588
00:50:40.710 --> 00:50:43.392
There's equality of opportunity and equality of employment.
589
00:50:43.953 --> 00:50:46.295
Then your culture shouldn't matter.
590
00:50:46.856 --> 00:50:53.361
Where it does start to matter, and you're starting to see this in Britain to some extent, parts of Canada, where...
591
00:50:54.242 --> 00:51:05.571
either because the size of the group in objective terms is large enough or in political muscle it's large enough, you do start to see multilingual signs.
592
00:51:06.292 --> 00:51:16.320
You do start to see some experiments, and your viewers might be interested in looking up over the last 20 years some of the experiments that have been made, for instance, with Sharia.
593
00:51:17.040 --> 00:51:35.615
in both Canada about 20 years ago, I think it might have been Ontario from memory, and also there's a debate in Britain about having Sharia, as long as it's not inconsistent with the common law, to have a degree of being able to resolve disputes in a Sharia format.
594
00:51:35.975 --> 00:51:39.458
We should stand opposed to that, which is under no circumstances.
595
00:51:40.478 --> 00:51:41.820
We have a single justice system.
596
00:51:41.860 --> 00:51:45.963
It's based on the common law of England as modified by statute.
597
00:51:46.445 --> 00:51:46.767
That's it.
598
00:51:47.191 --> 00:51:48.522
We've just got one legal system.
599
00:51:49.147 --> 00:52:11.602
Now, to the extent that challenges you in terms of faith, well, then you either have to make a decision about living here, or you've got to
accommodate, whether it's in relation to marriage or sexuality or how we resolve financial or other disputes, we do it in a secular fashion through, in the case of the legal system, through the common law system.
600
00:52:12.502 --> 00:52:12.682
Yeah.
601
00:52:13.083 --> 00:52:15.164
We should just have no tolerance at all.
602
00:52:15.784 --> 00:52:16.465
So I wouldn't...
603
00:52:17.787 --> 00:52:20.549
My preference is not to go for mix.
604
00:52:20.829 --> 00:52:24.512
My preference is to go for, is it rigidity?
605
00:52:24.712 --> 00:52:31.757
Yeah, I'd say it's rigidity or at least principle, like really firm principles about that institutional design.
606
00:52:32.857 --> 00:52:33.778
This is Australia.
607
00:52:34.338 --> 00:52:39.362
Now, to your point, you made a passing comment, which I didn't pick up on at the time, but I will now.
608
00:52:40.002 --> 00:52:44.885
A simulation has got a particular connotation, which was...
609
00:52:45.806 --> 00:52:47.707
And I certainly saw the back end of it.
610
00:52:47.727 --> 00:52:52.350
I was born in 1964, second generation Italian.
611
00:52:52.370 --> 00:53:05.337
I saw the back end of this, as I remember, in the late 60s, early 70s, where a simulation was assumed to be you're assimilating to a culture, a monoculture, which is Anglo-Australian.
612
00:53:06.297 --> 00:53:19.743
So I grew up in a street, there was an old Federation, what used to be called Federation Housing in southern Sydney, which are all the houses that they built just after the First World War, principally for returned soldiers.
613
00:53:21.464 --> 00:53:24.485
By that stage, people have been living in the streets, say, for 50 years.
614
00:53:24.505 --> 00:53:26.726
They're quite elderly, World War I vets.
615
00:53:27.527 --> 00:53:30.108
There were only two families in the street, Italian.
616
00:53:30.348 --> 00:53:34.090
There was a Sicilian family down the street, and we were at the top end of the street,
617
00:53:35.450 --> 00:53:49.593
And we were accepted, but it was always accepted on the basis of, oh, I noticed the other day in the backyard you were making sausage or you were making tomato pasta sauce.
618
00:53:50.253 --> 00:53:51.514
I remember that during the war.
619
00:53:51.554 --> 00:53:52.694
I was in the Second World War.
620
00:53:53.974 --> 00:53:55.374
Unfortunately, we fought the Italians.
621
00:53:55.694 --> 00:53:56.635
They had great food.
622
00:53:56.915 --> 00:54:02.756
So you'd have that sort of discussion where you were kind of the oddity in the street, but accepted.
623
00:54:02.776 --> 00:54:03.496
Mm-hmm.
624
00:54:03.716 --> 00:54:05.376
But every Sunday was fascinating.
625
00:54:05.817 --> 00:54:12.618
You know, the two Italian families, because very few of us drive, some drive, but the churches were in walking distance.
626
00:54:12.638 --> 00:54:18.500
The Italian families would go to the Roman Catholic Church, and all of the Anglo-Australians would go to the Church of England.
627
00:54:18.980 --> 00:54:20.340
Not Anglican, Church of England.
628
00:54:21.141 --> 00:54:23.021
So Australia was a very different place.
629
00:54:23.261 --> 00:54:24.602
That Australia is very different.
630
00:54:24.702 --> 00:54:27.762
Like, I remember that Australia, largely Anglo.
631
00:54:28.563 --> 00:54:29.723
It hadn't yet been...
632
00:54:31.023 --> 00:54:33.664
if you like, affected by many migrant waves.
633
00:54:33.964 --> 00:54:37.125
By the 70s and 80s, there was more multiculturalism evident.
634
00:54:37.805 --> 00:54:39.965
The policies of the Whitlam government changed that.
635
00:54:40.485 --> 00:54:49.087
The creation of the Special Broadcasting Service, SBS under the Fraser government, you started to see in a multilingual public broadcasting, for instance, there's no internet.
636
00:54:49.888 --> 00:54:59.110
So for instance, for Italian Australians, you'd get the weekly newspaper, La Fiamma, that might have sporting scores or something from Italy.
637
00:54:59.950 --> 00:55:08.038
But all of my father, his brothers, so my uncles, they'd all become devout rugby league fans because you weren't –
638
00:55:08.937 --> 00:55:10.758
except for maybe the weekly highlight package.
639
00:55:10.778 --> 00:55:13.960
You weren't watching Italian soccer on TV.
640
00:55:13.980 --> 00:55:18.963
Now, it's changed again because the world has come closer through the internet.
641
00:55:18.983 --> 00:55:23.185
But in those days, no, they became, in my case, Southern Sydney, St George supporters.
642
00:55:23.205 --> 00:55:25.126
They were fierce St George supporters.
643
00:55:26.127 --> 00:55:27.287
That's a simulation.
644
00:55:28.148 --> 00:55:36.953
I think what's happened since the 70s is acculturation, as you described it, and Australia looks and feels more like its demography.
645
00:55:36.973 --> 00:55:37.393
Right.
646
00:55:37.873 --> 00:55:48.596
So whether it's Little India or Little Vietnam or you go to the place I grew up with in southern Sydney, a lot of Chinese people are in the suburbs of Hurstville and Congra.
647
00:55:48.616 --> 00:55:49.056
How do you know that?
648
00:55:49.076 --> 00:55:49.957
Because all the signs.
649
00:55:52.477 --> 00:56:01.280
But typically, and we know this for our children, second and third generation children, when they open their mouth or when they speak,
650
00:56:02.500 --> 00:56:03.080
They're Australian.
651
00:56:03.280 --> 00:56:03.781
Yeah.
652
00:56:04.461 --> 00:56:06.782
And I gauge that just by their accent.
653
00:56:06.802 --> 00:56:19.986
So I think that's a better model where you're saying we've got a certain fixed and non-negotiable rules about institutional design.
654
00:56:20.766 --> 00:56:24.408
And then the culture just evolves organically depending on demography.
655
00:56:24.608 --> 00:56:24.788
Yeah.
656
00:56:25.628 --> 00:56:27.809
That sort of creedal national identity.
657
00:56:28.789 --> 00:56:31.130
You mentioned Indian migration before.
658
00:56:33.370 --> 00:56:36.254
India is Australia's fastest growing migrant group.
659
00:56:36.374 --> 00:56:36.494
Yep.
660
00:56:36.514 --> 00:56:45.307
I think last year there were about 900,000 Indian born Australians and it's soon going to surpass the United Kingdom as Australia's largest- First time, yep.
661
00:56:45.507 --> 00:56:47.470
For the first time as Australia's largest source country.
662
00:56:47.530 --> 00:56:47.610
Yep.
663
00:56:47.850 --> 00:56:48.010
Yep.
664
00:56:48.831 --> 00:56:53.775
Putting aside the obvious stuff like cuisine, how at all do you think that will change Australian culture?
665
00:56:56.557 --> 00:57:12.930
You sometimes see in the discussion and in the policy discussion concerns expressed because a lot of first generation, less so second generation, are still tied to, say, the politics of home, right?
666
00:57:13.110 --> 00:57:15.612
So when Prime Minister Modi comes to Australia...
667
00:57:16.232 --> 00:57:22.536
A lot of Indian, not just temporary migrants, but permanent migrants, will turn out waving the Indian flag.
668
00:57:22.896 --> 00:57:23.577
I think that's fine.
669
00:57:24.397 --> 00:57:25.938
I've got no issue with that.
670
00:57:25.978 --> 00:57:29.420
They're proud of India's rising status as a great power.
671
00:57:30.461 --> 00:57:32.942
I don't see any clash of allegiance there.
672
00:57:34.824 --> 00:57:41.448
It's especially evident when there's a sporting tournament, when we're hosting particularly cricket,
673
00:57:42.188 --> 00:57:52.901
a World Cup, either the one-day international or the T20, the crowds that you get for an Australia-India game, or let's say an India-Pakistan game, are enormous.
674
00:57:54.182 --> 00:57:57.566
And it might be the MCG, and most of them are following India.
675
00:57:59.118 --> 00:58:00.079
No problems with that at all.
676
00:58:00.499 --> 00:58:07.587
I think the fact that they're waving the Indian flag, even if they're first-generation permanent residents, not a problem.
677
00:58:07.927 --> 00:58:10.790
I'd like their second-generation kids to play for our cricket team.
678
00:58:11.691 --> 00:58:17.757
So, you know, I'd like to have the next 10 Doolka playing for Australia and not thinking that they've got to pay for their homeland.
679
00:58:19.498 --> 00:58:19.859
I think...
680
00:58:21.733 --> 00:58:29.482
So long as none of the communal or political differences come here, the Prime Minister talks about the Australian Covenant.
681
00:58:29.502 --> 00:58:37.151
He's talked about this in the context of the Bondi atrocity, that he uses this phrase, the Australian Covenant, that you don't bring...
682
00:58:38.092 --> 00:58:49.856
Whoever you barrack for or whatever your culture is or whatever your sporting interest is or how you want to dress or your cuisine, you don't bring hatred or you don't bring differences here.
683
00:58:49.936 --> 00:58:54.997
I think he's onto something there because that's another strand of that acculturation that we spoke about.
684
00:58:55.017 --> 00:58:55.298
Yeah.
685
00:58:55.798 --> 00:58:55.998
That.
686
00:58:56.958 --> 00:59:09.053
If you've got a view about how India should be run, say, by a Hindu majority party, and Hindus should have special benefits over Muslims in India...
687
00:59:09.278 --> 00:59:13.740
Okay, if that's what you think, you go to India and prosecute that case.
688
00:59:14.220 --> 00:59:15.361
We don't live like that here.
689
00:59:15.561 --> 00:59:17.962
We don't have communal privileges here.
690
00:59:19.143 --> 00:59:25.245
So, and we saw this when Modi visited in 22 or 23, I can't quite remember the year.
691
00:59:25.926 --> 00:59:26.726
Rockstar welcome.
692
00:59:27.666 --> 00:59:32.709
And there were, you know, they had to get sporting stadiums because there were so many people...
693
00:59:33.831 --> 00:59:41.716
For me, that was an expression of pride, including by Indian Australians, in India's rise.
694
00:59:42.616 --> 00:59:45.338
I don't see any problems with that at all, whatsoever.
695
00:59:46.199 --> 00:59:50.922
Scaling a business is hard enough already, so you don't want to be bottlenecked on things like compliance.
696
00:59:51.222 --> 00:59:59.047
And while achieving compliance can help you win bigger deals, enter new markets, and deepen trust with customers, it can also cost a lot of time and money.
697
00:59:59.067 --> 00:59:59.587
Yeah.
698
00:59:59.667 --> 01:00:07.232
By automating up to 90% of work involved in SOC 2, ISO 27001 and more, Vanta gets you compliant quickly.
699
01:00:07.872 --> 01:00:08.753
It also saves you money.
700
01:00:09.113 --> 01:00:20.220
A recent white paper by the International Data Corporation found that Vanta customers achieve $535,000 per year in benefits, and the platform pays for itself in just three months.
701
01:00:20.800 --> 01:00:24.123
A startup I worked at used Vanta and I found it really reliable.
702
01:00:24.723 --> 01:00:33.070
Over 12,000 global companies like Atlassian, Replit and Cursor also use Vanta to manage risk and prove security in real time.
703
01:00:33.710 --> 01:00:39.795
My audience can get a special offer of $1,000 off Vanta at Vanta.com slash Joe.
704
01:00:40.315 --> 01:00:44.719
That's V-A-N-T-A dot com slash J-O-E for $1,000 off.
705
01:00:47.662 --> 01:00:55.071
Let me go out on a limb and test one potential unexpected positive benefit on you.
706
01:00:55.932 --> 01:01:01.459
So Australia has what I've been calling, I think Australia has what I've been calling a culture of acculturation.
707
01:01:01.479 --> 01:01:02.600
Yep.
708
01:01:02.821 --> 01:01:05.103
Which I think partly connects to the egalitarianism.
709
01:01:05.804 --> 01:01:05.964
Yep.
710
01:01:06.445 --> 01:01:06.865
And...
711
01:01:08.007 --> 01:01:10.991
I've been meaning to write something about this, which I will at some point this year, hopefully.
712
01:01:11.271 --> 01:01:21.324
But it's possible that the Indian diaspora kind of leans into
that and supercharges it because India is an incredibly multicultural country.
713
01:01:21.584 --> 01:01:25.829
And I think people evolve or adapt ways of...
714
01:01:26.610 --> 01:01:34.216
communicating and dealing with that difference in Indian society that maybe is quite resonant with Australia's culture of acculturation?
715
01:01:34.856 --> 01:01:36.217
I think... Total speculation.
716
01:01:36.317 --> 01:01:46.945
No, no, I think if... And all of us have got Indian friends, either temporary migrants or more typically increasingly Indian-Australian, permanent residents, ultimately citizens.
717
01:01:47.145 --> 01:01:49.187
Yeah.
718
01:01:49.847 --> 01:01:50.788
And this is a part of...
719
01:01:51.649 --> 01:01:55.071
I think it's to do with the Commonwealth and to some extent the British Empire.
720
01:01:55.211 --> 01:01:55.391
Yeah.
721
01:01:56.472 --> 01:02:01.895
Even just phrases, like we talked semi-seriously, but let's talk about it seriously, sport.
722
01:02:03.476 --> 01:02:15.343
If an Australian of Italian heritage, so let's say an Italian Australian and an Indian Australian are talking about fairness, we'll use the idiomatic phrase, it's just not cricket, as an example.
723
01:02:15.503 --> 01:02:17.364
And we both will know exactly what that means.
724
01:02:17.384 --> 01:02:18.225
Yeah.
725
01:02:18.765 --> 01:02:24.850
It's sort of distilled or derived to some extent from the empire, from the Commonwealth.
726
01:02:25.471 --> 01:02:30.214
Probably have to translate that idiom to a Chinese, Australian or someone from the Middle East.
727
01:02:30.234 --> 01:02:31.675
They probably wouldn't quite get it.
728
01:02:32.196 --> 01:02:47.568
But with someone from India, they have come from a polyglot country, multi-ethnic, multi-religious, multicultural, very tolerant with some outbreaks of just terrible violence, but largely tolerant.
729
01:02:49.058 --> 01:03:04.709
And they see Australia often as a better version of that because, you know, for all the tolerance of India, it's a remarkable achievement for just how tolerant and pluralistic it is for such a diverse country with so many different religions, subreligions, sects, etc.
730
01:03:05.749 --> 01:03:11.033
They do occasionally have horrific instances of communal violence happening.
731
01:03:12.376 --> 01:03:15.677
With Australia, you get all that multiculturalism without any of the communal violence.
732
01:03:16.078 --> 01:03:16.278
Yeah.
733
01:03:16.798 --> 01:03:21.060
You know, the sort of terrible violence you saw in 1947, for instance, at Partition.
734
01:03:21.460 --> 01:03:22.500
You don't have any of that here.
735
01:03:23.421 --> 01:03:39.048
So I think for certainly anyone who's come from a British tradition, the Commonwealth tradition, Australia, and I suspect Canada and New Zealand are in this category as well, are almost like an ideal type of...
736
01:03:39.908 --> 01:03:51.514
without all the class and all the privilege of Britain, of what that imperial heritage looks like when you overlay it with a fair go or egalitarianism or however you want to couch that.
737
01:03:52.594 --> 01:03:55.376
I think for others, though, they quickly come to appreciate that.
738
01:03:55.396 --> 01:04:07.842
If you're from Latin America or you're from Southeast Asia or you're from Africa, the Middle East, and we've all got friends in our broader friendship network or partners of our family members,
739
01:04:08.822 --> 01:04:15.266
They get that even though they don't have that deep British heritage because of that idea of the fair go.
740
01:04:15.606 --> 01:04:15.786
Yeah.
741
01:04:16.387 --> 01:04:27.214
Now, I said earlier, and you drew attention to this in the value statement, that the fair go is the one thing that doesn't kind of translate in Canada or France or elsewhere.
742
01:04:27.454 --> 01:04:30.176
They've got their own ways of expressing egalitarianism.
743
01:04:31.076 --> 01:04:33.738
But it seems to me that idea of the fair go
744
01:04:35.860 --> 01:04:40.722
let's call it egalitarianism or equality of opportunity, is a universal currency.
745
01:04:41.922 --> 01:05:00.829
So even if someone who's second-generation Chinese Australian, they might not have that deep background in the empire and cricket and all the rest of it in the way that an Indian Australian would, it's very easy to translate into as a core simple idea about how to live into a universal value.
746
01:05:00.909 --> 01:05:02.050
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
747
01:05:03.535 --> 01:05:11.979
Okay, so let's, I like to split what we might call acculturation policies into two separate categories.
748
01:05:12.859 --> 01:05:16.060
The first is selection policies, which we've just been talking about.
749
01:05:16.421 --> 01:05:21.683
And I think there are a couple of mechanisms by which selection can affect acculturation.
750
01:05:21.763 --> 01:05:24.544
One is just, as we were saying, sheer numbers.
751
01:05:24.644 --> 01:05:28.986
So a smaller group is going to acculturate more quickly than a larger group, all else equal.
752
01:05:29.006 --> 01:05:29.206
Yeah.
753
01:05:29.586 --> 01:05:33.789
And the second mechanism is just the selection criteria.
754
01:05:33.809 --> 01:05:43.156
So choosing migrants with traits that, you know, more consistent with the mainstream culture are going to make those migrants acculturate more quickly.
755
01:05:43.176 --> 01:05:47.999
And noting what I said, that that's largely done through a filtration process.
756
01:05:48.039 --> 01:05:50.120
So you're filtering on security and character.
757
01:05:50.140 --> 01:05:50.241
Yeah.
758
01:05:50.261 --> 01:05:50.401
Yeah.
759
01:05:50.961 --> 01:05:58.087
Because you're assuming that unless there's a derogatory holding against someone or some sort of adverse indicator, they're in.
760
01:05:58.367 --> 01:05:58.527
Yeah.
761
01:05:58.888 --> 01:06:03.231
So it's that filtration process rather than thinking, jailmaker, great Aussie.
762
01:06:03.551 --> 01:06:03.732
Yeah.
763
01:06:04.838 --> 01:06:11.100
And then once you've got those filters set right, it's then just an organic demographic outcome.
764
01:06:11.380 --> 01:06:11.600
Right.
765
01:06:11.720 --> 01:06:12.800
The weight of numbers.
766
01:06:13.000 --> 01:06:16.521
Yes, it's like a negative check or something.
767
01:06:17.541 --> 01:06:22.022
So that first stage or first category are selection policies.
768
01:06:22.042 --> 01:06:25.783
And then the second category or stage are...
769
01:06:26.683 --> 01:06:28.864
what we might call acculturation services.
770
01:06:29.004 --> 01:06:29.164
Yeah.
771
01:06:29.385 --> 01:06:30.665
So I want to talk about these now.
772
01:06:31.166 --> 01:06:35.668
And I just want to like, because these questions are quite sort of like factual or empirical.
773
01:06:35.908 --> 01:06:37.389
I'm just trying to learn as much as possible.
774
01:06:37.409 --> 01:06:37.509
Sure.
775
01:06:37.789 --> 01:06:39.370
So I'm just going to rapid fire.
776
01:06:39.390 --> 01:06:40.130
Yeah.
777
01:06:40.150 --> 01:06:52.477
So acculturation services, if I'm a skilled migrant, is it correct that there really aren't any government services that I can avail myself of to help me integrate into Australian society?
778
01:06:52.497 --> 01:06:52.737
Yeah.
779
01:06:53.097 --> 01:07:02.259
Largely not, unless there's a question about your English proficiency, in which case you've probably struggled to get selected in the first place for school migration.
780
01:07:02.399 --> 01:07:02.539
Yeah.
781
01:07:02.779 --> 01:07:08.040
But for other categories, there is adult migrant education, which is really about English proficiency.
782
01:07:08.060 --> 01:07:19.922
It's about ensuring that maybe a family member of someone who's come in, so they've got a visa as well, but they've come in on a skilled program, might be one of the family members is struggling with English, so they get into a funded program.
783
01:07:19.942 --> 01:07:20.042
Yeah.
784
01:07:21.002 --> 01:07:28.784
Look, it's nothing like, and this is a matter of regret, I think, it's nothing like the kind of programs that we had in the 50s and 60s.
785
01:07:29.084 --> 01:07:29.384
Yeah.
786
01:07:30.004 --> 01:07:30.944
Particularly under Menzies.
787
01:07:30.984 --> 01:07:38.005
Menzies was especially strong for all migrant groups, whether they didn't really have the sort of skilled family breakdown.
788
01:07:38.025 --> 01:07:39.546
It was basically all family.
789
01:07:40.106 --> 01:07:49.908
Like the program that my parents came in in the early 60s, they basically came as labourers or unskilled workers because Australia was looking for unskilled workers.
790
01:07:50.028 --> 01:07:50.228
Yeah.
791
01:07:52.510 --> 01:07:56.833
in the 50s especially, started to wind down into the 70s, there were neighbourhood groups.
792
01:07:56.853 --> 01:08:00.997
So there were committees of Australians, Anglo-Australians.
793
01:08:01.037 --> 01:08:01.998
The good neighbour councils.
794
01:08:02.338 --> 01:08:03.399
Good neighbour councils.
795
01:08:04.040 --> 01:08:06.221
Menti's was especially strong on that.
796
01:08:06.522 --> 01:08:14.529
Now, we've got a form of that in the refugee space, really, really good services that are both government-driven because...
797
01:08:15.552 --> 01:08:19.515
With refugees, special case, they're not really coming here to fill a skills gap.
798
01:08:19.535 --> 01:08:22.638
They're fleeing from the sorts of things we spoke about earlier.
799
01:08:23.158 --> 01:08:26.241
So there are government services about, okay, here's how you live in Australia.
800
01:08:26.261 --> 01:08:27.702
Here's some English language training.
801
01:08:29.063 --> 01:08:30.584
This is going to make your job ready.
802
01:08:30.604 --> 01:08:30.704
Yeah.
803
01:08:30.865 --> 01:08:31.065
Yeah.
804
01:08:31.565 --> 01:08:41.488
In those cases, through a combination of civil society groups that might be ethnically based, so Sudanese people helping Sudanese, Somali Australians helping Somalis, for instance.
805
01:08:41.828 --> 01:08:50.631
They're also a version of good neighbours who are settled Australians from different walks of life, different ethnicities.
806
01:08:51.311 --> 01:08:57.813
who form a committee or a group in regional Victoria or regional New South Wales to make people feel welcome.
807
01:08:58.173 --> 01:09:06.596
That in microcosm in the refugee space used to be done on a much more pervasive basis in the 50s and 60s.
808
01:09:06.936 --> 01:09:08.416
Including for non-refugees?
809
01:09:08.456 --> 01:09:08.977
Yeah.
810
01:09:09.057 --> 01:09:09.317
Okay.
811
01:09:09.597 --> 01:09:10.957
Yeah, because one of my questions...
812
01:09:10.997 --> 01:09:11.937
Absolutely.
813
01:09:11.957 --> 01:09:13.438
Sorry, more so in the 50s and 60s.
814
01:09:13.518 --> 01:09:16.199
It started to actually decline in the 70s.
815
01:09:16.639 --> 01:09:16.899
Right.
816
01:09:17.019 --> 01:09:19.900
Because I don't... See, as a child growing up... Yeah.
817
01:09:19.920 --> 01:09:20.020
Yeah.
818
01:09:20.620 --> 01:09:22.623
I remember very little by way of services.
819
01:09:22.663 --> 01:09:24.244
So I was born in 64.
820
01:09:24.284 --> 01:09:25.346
I went to school in 69.
821
01:09:25.646 --> 01:09:25.846
Yeah.
822
01:09:26.467 --> 01:09:33.355
There's virtually no, like I don't recall any kind of assistance from the Department of Immigration as it then was.
823
01:09:33.395 --> 01:09:34.076
Yeah, interesting.
824
01:09:34.276 --> 01:09:37.219
And I don't mind that because our family made its own way.
825
01:09:37.239 --> 01:09:37.359
Yeah.
826
01:09:37.600 --> 01:09:37.800
Yeah.
827
01:09:38.000 --> 01:09:47.147
Because our networks were my father and mother's relatives, typically some older siblings who'd come to Australia first.
828
01:09:47.767 --> 01:09:53.051
They helped them navigate through banking, the legal system, how to buy a house, basic
English.
829
01:09:54.252 --> 01:09:58.535
Certainly neither mum or dad did any kind of intensive English proficiency.
830
01:09:58.555 --> 01:10:01.137
And they came in 61.
831
01:10:01.157 --> 01:10:04.379
So even by then, it was starting to tail off.
832
01:10:04.699 --> 01:10:05.600
Yeah.
833
01:10:06.400 --> 01:10:06.921
And indeed...
834
01:10:07.561 --> 01:10:12.244
But what the government relied on was the second generation children as they grew up.
835
01:10:13.024 --> 01:10:23.150
So in my case, me, as the oldest child, eldest son typically, I actually helped my dad translate conveyancing documents.
836
01:10:23.870 --> 01:10:31.554
I remember as a 12 or 13 or 14 year old, help him read legal documents to do with conveyancing and the like.
837
01:10:31.574 --> 01:10:32.115
So you become...
838
01:10:32.895 --> 01:10:40.099
quite skilled, even at a young age, saying, okay, this is what a tax return looks like, because you're helping Dad fill out the tax return.
839
01:10:41.239 --> 01:10:54.306
But that idea in the 50s and probably early 60s of good neighbourhood, good neighbour councils, reception committees, I think a version of that would...
840
01:10:54.506 --> 01:11:01.069
It requires funding, and funding is always a problematic issue, but a version of that, I think, would be very welcome.
841
01:11:01.565 --> 01:11:14.923
Yeah, so one of my questions was going to be, to the extent that we now take a very laissez-faire approach to integration and acculturation, how much of that is just a function of the fact that
842
01:11:17.353 --> 01:11:24.943
In the immediate years or decade after World War II, most of the migrants we were taking were displaced persons.
843
01:11:25.324 --> 01:11:26.706
In other words, refugees.
844
01:11:27.647 --> 01:11:29.269
And we do provide- And largely Europeans.
845
01:11:29.449 --> 01:11:30.491
Largely Europeans.
846
01:11:30.791 --> 01:11:31.712
Largely Europeans.
847
01:11:32.513 --> 01:11:47.939
And we do provide those kind of integration services for refugees today, but it's just that from the 80s and then even more so, again, from the kind of mid-90s, there was this shift to focusing on skills and the sort of economic rationale for migration.
848
01:11:49.100 --> 01:11:53.762
Just like the balance shifted from refugees to skilled migrants.
849
01:11:54.082 --> 01:11:57.183
And skilled migrants don't need the same level of support.
850
01:11:57.743 --> 01:12:06.025
But even earlier than that, Joe, even in the 70s, because you said in the 70s, ministers in the Fraser government looked back at one point of regret.
851
01:12:06.225 --> 01:12:06.425
Yeah.
852
01:12:06.445 --> 01:12:07.925
So you talked to people like Philip Ruddock.
853
01:12:08.025 --> 01:12:08.265
Yeah.
854
01:12:08.785 --> 01:12:14.947
Was that the support wraparound for Vietnamese refugees, some of whom came initially by boat.
855
01:12:15.147 --> 01:12:15.967
Yeah.
856
01:12:16.067 --> 01:12:18.147
Very famously into Darwin port.
857
01:12:18.247 --> 01:12:19.007
Yeah.
858
01:12:19.087 --> 01:12:20.268
Malcolm Fraser allowed them in.
859
01:12:20.308 --> 01:12:26.689
And then ultimately there was the comprehensive action plan for displaced people from South Vietnam who were...
860
01:12:27.269 --> 01:12:30.231
probably never going to go back to a communist Vietnam.
861
01:12:30.251 --> 01:12:34.894
They're typically Catholic, religious people from South Vietnam.
862
01:12:35.334 --> 01:12:38.676
They were displaced persons who came in on a program.
863
01:12:39.877 --> 01:12:52.204
You talk to the remaining ministers from the Fraser days, they would say that the sort of Menzies-style approach probably should have been put in place in the 70s.
864
01:12:53.345 --> 01:13:05.752
Because those early years in places like Cabramatta in Western Sydney were difficult because it was assumed that, you know, the children would be supported through the school system.
865
01:13:06.572 --> 01:13:12.736
As long as the hospital or the GP had some Vietnamese language, mum or dad would kind of navigate that.
866
01:13:13.956 --> 01:13:15.137
the health system, for instance.
867
01:13:15.397 --> 01:13:16.298
Yeah.
868
01:13:16.998 --> 01:13:23.602
And you talk to anyone from the Vietnamese Australian community, they would say those years were tough,
869
01:13:25.070 --> 01:13:35.793
And now look at the wonderful, vibrant community we have, second and indeed third generation now because of having grandchildren, super successful business people.
870
01:13:36.673 --> 01:13:38.353
They trade back into Vietnam.
871
01:13:38.573 --> 01:13:41.214
It's great language capability that Australia has.
872
01:13:42.014 --> 01:13:51.616
But I think they would argue that unlike the support that we put in place, say, for people from Hungary, Poland, the Baltic states, et cetera,
873
01:13:55.117 --> 01:14:01.400
Even by the 70s, I think you'll find, if someone mapped the history of this, a diminution in those services.
874
01:14:01.440 --> 01:14:01.660
Yeah.
875
01:14:02.201 --> 01:14:03.561
And that's 50 years ago, right?
876
01:14:03.601 --> 01:14:04.362
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
877
01:14:04.502 --> 01:14:05.122
So it's been a while.
878
01:14:05.582 --> 01:14:05.803
Yeah.
879
01:14:06.443 --> 01:14:07.683
Okay, let me keep rapid firing.
880
01:14:07.703 --> 01:14:07.804
Sure.
881
01:14:07.824 --> 01:14:12.466
So if I'm a skilled migrant, I don't think I'm even eligible for the adult migrant English program.
882
01:14:12.626 --> 01:14:13.466
Yeah, not eligible.
883
01:14:13.706 --> 01:14:16.648
Because you wouldn't have got the visa proficiency.
884
01:14:17.048 --> 01:14:18.229
Your spouse might be.
885
01:14:18.249 --> 01:14:18.589
Yeah.
886
01:14:18.709 --> 01:14:20.150
Because your partner- Yeah.
887
01:14:21.210 --> 01:14:24.392
Unless you're both primary visa holders, right?
888
01:14:24.412 --> 01:14:26.333
So let's say you've got a couple.
889
01:14:26.633 --> 01:14:26.813
Yeah.
890
01:14:26.953 -->
01:14:29.955
They're both welders or both school teachers.
891
01:14:30.555 --> 01:14:40.721
It might be that the family, including the spouse, typically a woman, not always, maybe has got challenges with English proficiency.
892
01:14:40.821 --> 01:14:40.981
Yeah.
893
01:14:41.341 --> 01:14:47.284
Even though the primary holder has got good English because that was a condition of getting the visa.
894
01:14:47.425 --> 01:14:47.605
Yeah.
895
01:14:48.565 --> 01:14:52.551
So putting to one side the humanitarian program, i.e.
896
01:14:52.651 --> 01:14:58.598
refugees, and just to give people context about the numbers here, for 2025, 2026, I think the permanent program is capped at 185,000 places.
897
01:14:58.638 --> 01:14:59.900
That's right, yep.
898
01:15:03.985 --> 01:15:07.769
In comparison, the humanitarian program is just 20,000 places.
899
01:15:07.809 --> 01:15:17.218
So I think oftentimes in the public conversation, refugees get conflated with migrants, but the humanitarian program is really only about 11% the size of the permanent program.
900
01:15:17.258 --> 01:15:18.580
And at times it's been smaller.
901
01:15:19.135 --> 01:15:19.635
Absolutely.
902
01:15:19.795 --> 01:15:28.339
And the permanent program comprises the skilled stream, the family stream, predominantly partner visas, and then also a very small stream called special eligibility.
903
01:15:28.459 --> 01:15:28.680
Correct.
904
01:15:29.120 --> 01:15:31.401
And there's a slight misnomer with the skilled.
905
01:15:31.681 --> 01:15:35.223
That's roughly two thirds, one thirds split between skilled and family.
906
01:15:35.263 --> 01:15:35.543
Yeah.
907
01:15:35.783 --> 01:15:39.405
But within skilled, everyone in the family unit gets that visa.
908
01:15:39.985 --> 01:15:40.585
Oh, I didn't know that.
909
01:15:40.625 --> 01:15:40.845
Right.
910
01:15:40.865 --> 01:15:41.746
So it's not like...
911
01:15:42.855 --> 01:15:44.276
Let's say- I didn't know that.
912
01:15:44.737 --> 01:15:46.518
So let's say- So it's kind of inflated.
913
01:15:46.538 --> 01:15:48.140
The skilled numbers are kind of inflated.
914
01:15:48.180 --> 01:15:48.420
Correct.
915
01:15:48.480 --> 01:15:51.182
Because it's not just the skilled worker, it's their family as well.
916
01:15:51.202 --> 01:15:55.466
So let's say roughly the long run program is about 190,000 thereabouts.
917
01:15:55.666 --> 01:15:56.487
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
918
01:15:57.048 --> 01:16:01.532
Let's in round terms call it 180,000 just for the sake of this illustration.
919
01:16:01.632 --> 01:16:01.772
Yeah.
920
01:16:01.792 --> 01:16:01.892
Yeah.
921
01:16:02.292 --> 01:16:08.237
It's roughly two-thirds, one-third, 120,000, 60,000 split between skilled and family.
922
01:16:08.517 --> 01:16:08.757
Yeah.
923
01:16:08.957 --> 01:16:12.040
But within that 120,000, you're not getting 120,000 skilled workers.
924
01:16:12.200 --> 01:16:13.080
Oh, that's crazy.
925
01:16:13.120 --> 01:16:13.741
I did not know that.
926
01:16:13.761 -->
01:16:14.762
But you do get their kids.
927
01:16:15.162 --> 01:16:15.422
Yeah.
928
01:16:15.882 --> 01:16:21.046
So the idea is that the family unit comes, hopefully, and it's a slightly gendered thing.
929
01:16:21.086 --> 01:16:27.411
So typically the non-income or the non-primary income partner is the woman.
930
01:16:27.731 --> 01:16:27.872
Yeah.
931
01:16:27.912 --> 01:16:28.012
Yeah.
932
01:16:28.752 --> 01:16:52.520
Either she goes into part-time work, maybe has to get some assistance with English language, although that's not usually the case because typically in a skilled situation, not always gendered in this way, but typically, let's say the male in a conventional, let's say, traditional nuclear family, the male's got a uni degree, IT, speciality, university,
933
01:16:53.660 --> 01:16:55.481
The woman might well have some qualification.
934
01:16:56.822 --> 01:16:59.022
It's not always gendered in that way, but typically it is.
935
01:16:59.963 --> 01:17:11.608
But that family unit then, because they either come with small kids or they decide to have children, typically in that second generation, that family unit is, if you like, a professional family.
936
01:17:12.498 --> 01:17:20.201
So it might be that mum, dad, say two kids, that's four visas, but only dad is the IT specialist, say.
937
01:17:20.381 --> 01:17:20.561
Yeah.
938
01:17:21.182 --> 01:17:33.087
So with all that context, just like putting to one side the humanitarian stream and the skilled stream, I guess you're not left with, well, you're left with family visas and temporaries.
939
01:17:33.307 --> 01:17:33.407
Yeah.
940
01:17:33.427 --> 01:17:33.527
Yeah.
941
01:17:34.467 --> 01:17:41.371
For those people left, is the main sort of acculturation service available really the Adult Migrant English program?
942
01:17:41.791 --> 01:17:43.512
Would that be the one that stands out?
943
01:17:43.812 --> 01:17:43.952
Yes.
944
01:17:44.212 --> 01:17:45.113
Including for temporaries?
945
01:17:46.093 --> 01:17:46.353
No.
946
01:17:46.593 --> 01:17:54.818
No, because for temporaries, you're either here to study English, to study uni, but you have to have English proficiency.
947
01:17:54.838 --> 01:17:54.938
Yeah.
948
01:17:54.958 --> 01:17:55.218
Yeah.
949
01:17:56.238 --> 01:18:00.481
Or you're here in a working holiday, in which case you get by.
950
01:18:00.521 --> 01:18:05.965
We're not going to give backpackers English training.
951
01:18:05.985 --> 01:18:08.246
So you're not even eligible if you're a temporary.
952
01:18:08.627 --> 01:18:10.768
But you might be eligible if you're a temporary skilled.
953
01:18:10.968 --> 01:18:11.148
Yes.
954
01:18:11.348 --> 01:18:12.089
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
955
01:18:12.269 --> 01:18:18.633
But typically not the primary visa holder because that person would have had to have already demonstrated English proficiency.
956
01:18:18.653 --> 01:18:21.795
It's a question about whether their spouse has got English proficiency.
957
01:18:21.895 -->
01:18:22.395
Yeah, yeah.
958
01:18:22.616 --> 01:18:22.836
Okay.
959
01:18:23.256 --> 01:18:33.943
So a priori, the adult migrant English program seems really important because I think maybe, I don't know this for sure, but maybe the most important thing.
960
01:18:35.413 --> 01:18:42.955
lever for acculturation is language acquisition, because that kind of opens up your ability to participate in all other parts of the society.
961
01:18:44.396 --> 01:18:52.078
But the evaluations of the effectiveness of that program are pretty lackluster.
962
01:18:52.998 --> 01:19:06.044
Peter Shergold's 2019 report into settlement services for refugees mentions that only about 7% of participants in the adult migrant English program achieve functional English by the end of the program.
963
01:19:07.265 --> 01:19:18.130
I don't know whether actually that's not that bad internationally speaking or something, but yeah, I don't know if there's anything interesting to say on this, just how good is the AMAP?
964
01:19:19.230 --> 01:19:19.671
I...
965
01:19:21.825 --> 01:19:25.086
We had a number of runs at this, at trying to improve quality.
966
01:19:26.367 --> 01:19:39.912
Essentially, the problem was if you drive the standard too high and those scores even get lower, the problem typically is that you're starting to almost break up family units.
967
01:19:40.912 --> 01:19:41.592
Oh, I see.
968
01:19:41.692 --> 01:19:42.413
That's your problem.
969
01:19:42.593 --> 01:19:43.313
Okay.
970
01:19:43.333 --> 01:19:47.014
So take a skill migration we just spoke about.
971
01:19:47.034 --> 01:19:47.855
It might be that...
972
01:19:48.675 --> 01:19:58.219
Might be someone qualifies because they're here on a visa, but their English is not great, but it wasn't detrimental to gaining the visa because the primary visa holder had English proficiency.
973
01:19:58.439 --> 01:19:58.660
Yeah.
974
01:19:58.880 --> 01:20:05.443
You're not going to knock someone out and say, well, you either have to leave or improve your scores.
975
01:20:05.503 --> 01:20:05.623
Yeah.
976
01:20:08.785 --> 01:20:16.370
as a function of the AMAP requirement, because you get to a point where... And, you know, I look back on the experience of Italians and Greeks.
977
01:20:16.450 --> 01:20:24.576
I suspect my mother, who's a naturalised Australian, as a citizen, I suspect she probably... Now she's well into her 80s.
978
01:20:24.617 --> 01:20:25.857
If you tested her today...
979
01:20:26.778 --> 01:20:31.924
she's got enough English to get by in a shop, but I'm not sure that she'd achieve functionality.
980
01:20:32.165 --> 01:20:33.326
Sorry, mum.
981
01:20:34.027 --> 01:20:39.534
And she'd be okay with that because she just needs enough to get by in a shop, getting basic banking services.
982
01:20:39.554 --> 01:20:42.918
So I think in the end, we've always come to a pragmatic view that,
983
01:20:44.681 --> 01:20:50.262
Typically, as long as you can get by, get directions, go into a shop, understand
street signs.
984
01:20:50.282 --> 01:20:52.663
We're not going to have variable street signs.
985
01:20:54.183 --> 01:20:54.944
That's kind of good enough.
986
01:20:55.444 --> 01:20:56.124
Yeah.
987
01:20:56.324 --> 01:20:59.185
And that's a level slightly below functional.
988
01:20:59.445 --> 01:20:59.805
Yeah, yeah.
989
01:20:59.965 --> 01:21:04.346
I think the pragmatic view has always been you can spend a lot getting that...
990
01:21:05.146 --> 01:21:09.470
It's been a lot of resources getting to that next level for, frankly, very little return.
991
01:21:09.510 --> 01:21:10.030
Yeah, I see.
992
01:21:10.190 --> 01:21:10.490
I see.
993
01:21:11.671 --> 01:21:18.917
So turning to refugees, would it be accurate to say that they present the most challenges from the perspective of acculturation?
994
01:21:20.919 --> 01:21:23.280
Yes, by and large.
995
01:21:23.881 --> 01:21:28.685
Largely because... Let's need to step through this carefully.
996
01:21:28.845 --> 01:21:29.025
Yeah.
997
01:21:29.846 --> 01:21:33.629
Largely because the environments they're coming from are so...
998
01:21:35.592 --> 01:21:38.973
atypical or so different from Australia.
999
01:21:39.053 --> 01:21:40.314
It's almost like another planet.
1000
01:21:40.794 --> 01:22:04.683
So if you're coming from a place where there's been generation after generation after generation of communal violence, say Christians on Muslims, Muslims on Christians, Hindus and Muslims, whatever the case might be, or say the former Yugoslavia, Serbs and Croats, to take an example, in some cases that...
1001
01:22:05.903 --> 01:22:26.435
the violence that's built into the structure of your society also regrettably uh leads to attitudes where there's lower thresholds and more acceptance of violence simply because it's the character of the society and the culture you've grown up in yeah and trying to get that out of
1002
01:22:29.114 --> 01:22:32.937
a person's thinking is the work potentially of generations.
1003
01:22:33.278 --> 01:22:33.458
Yeah.
1004
01:22:33.958 --> 01:22:34.479
Potentially.
1005
01:22:34.759 --> 01:22:34.939
Yeah.
1006
01:22:35.319 --> 01:22:35.940
Good example.
1007
01:22:37.221 --> 01:22:44.507
We have very little, very little evidence in any of the security intelligence reports that I ever saw.
1008
01:22:44.527 --> 01:22:53.755
And again, I'm out of date, but there's virtually no communal schism any longer of a material nature between Serbs and Croats.
1009
01:22:54.216 --> 01:22:54.296
Mm.
1010
01:22:55.417 --> 01:22:56.137
But there was in the 70s.
1011
01:22:56.157 --> 01:22:56.237
Mm.
1012
01:22:58.365 --> 01:23:00.088
There was in the 70s the point of violence.
1013
01:23:00.569 --> 01:23:02.292
Yeah.
1014
01:23:02.612 --> 01:23:11.267
People coming from Sudan, because of the nature of the society there, the ongoing conflict, particularly between Christians and Muslims, and...
1015
01:23:13.555 --> 01:23:21.787
you've almost got to get people comfortable and almost
teach them through settlement services that, hey, Australia is a safe place.
1016
01:23:21.807 --> 01:23:29.638
We actually don't go around butchering each other based on religious, ethnic, cultural or indeed political differences.
1017
01:23:31.448 --> 01:23:33.530
And that's both a source of joy.
1018
01:23:33.550 --> 01:23:53.567
I mean, I remember when the Abbott government opened up out of Syria, something like 10,000 or was it 12,000 places principally for refugees from IS barbarity, most of whom ended up being Yazidi and various Christian minority sects.
1019
01:23:54.468 --> 01:23:57.010
They immediately embraced the idea of peace.
1020
01:23:57.151 --> 01:23:57.631
They said, yeah.
1021
01:23:59.593 --> 01:24:06.580
We're in a blessed country where you get up in the morning not fearing that by that evening you might be dead.
1022
01:24:08.021 --> 01:24:10.604
And this was when IS was at its most rampant.
1023
01:24:11.004 --> 01:24:14.547
They were going into villages, you know, putting people into the town square.
1024
01:24:15.708 --> 01:24:17.230
You've got to make that extra effort.
1025
01:24:18.782 --> 01:24:31.168
not because you're dealing with violent people, because typically they're people who are fleeing violence, but the norms, their sensibility, their understanding of society is so different from Australia.
1026
01:24:31.248 --> 01:24:34.229
It's almost got to be taught, to some extent at least.
1027
01:24:35.050 --> 01:24:37.070
In other cases, it's embraced.
1028
01:24:37.130 --> 01:24:41.833
I remember the Yazidi community out of Syria, Australia.
1029
01:24:43.593 --> 01:24:54.499
They settled in, I can't quite recall, it might have been Wagga or Albury or one of those large regional towns in New South Wales or Victoria.
1030
01:24:57.380 --> 01:25:05.865
They formed their own community associations, common language and the like, were embraced, almost like an organic, almost spontaneous version of that old Menzies community.
1031
01:25:06.585 --> 01:25:09.570
notion of good neighbour communities.
1032
01:25:10.191 --> 01:25:14.177
I remember Prime Minister Abbott, Minister Dutton, going to visit them and
1033
01:25:16.742 --> 01:25:31.207
And I remember one person saying to me, because I was just chatting in the margins of one of these political visits and meetings, and they said, you know what's different about, it might have been Albury or Wodonga, essentially Wagga, I can't quite remember now.
1034
01:25:31.607 --> 01:25:34.568
They said, you just smell the air in this piece.
1035
01:25:35.088 --> 01:25:41.570
Because you don't have the smell of acrid smoke, burning villages, gunfire.
1036
01:25:41.590 --> 01:25:41.690
Yeah.
1037
01:25:42.470 --> 01:25:45.192
They could smell peace in the air.
1038
01:25:45.992 --> 01:25:54.838
So the challenge you've always got with refugees, particularly in the most, who've come out of the most barbaric situations, is trauma.
1039
01:25:55.358 --> 01:25:55.759
Yeah.
1040
01:25:55.779 --> 01:25:57.180
That's what you're really dealing with.
1041
01:25:57.240 --> 01:25:57.400
Yeah.
1042
01:25:57.420 --> 01:25:57.740
Yeah.
1043
01:25:57.880 --> 01:26:04.086
Not typically, there's some exceptions, the Serb-Croat problem of the 70s being a case in point.
1044
01:26:04.626 --> 01:26:10.652
It's not typically any ongoing hatred or violence that they've carried with them.
1045
01:26:11.132 --> 01:26:14.075
It's normally adjusting to a place that's not violent.
1046
01:26:14.135 --> 01:26:14.736
Yeah, yeah.
1047
01:26:15.297 --> 01:26:28.013
I guess one other way to think about the difference might be, say for migrants through the skilled program, you're explicitly selecting on traits that correlate with rapid acculturation.
1048
01:26:28.033 --> 01:26:28.153
Yeah.
1049
01:26:28.173 --> 01:26:30.436
So things like English proficiency in education.
1050
01:26:30.456 --> 01:26:30.817
Yeah.
1051
01:26:31.097 --> 01:26:38.323
When it comes to refugees, I mean, quite rightly, you're really just randomly sampling from the home country's population.
1052
01:26:38.924 --> 01:26:40.625
And if that home country is- And hotspots.
1053
01:26:40.885 --> 01:26:41.466
And hotspots.
1054
01:26:41.686 --> 01:26:42.687
Global hotspots, right?
1055
01:26:42.707 --> 01:26:43.668
It's a function of that.
1056
01:26:43.808 --> 01:26:44.048
Yeah.
1057
01:26:44.088 --> 01:26:46.730
And I guess that comes to your trauma point.
1058
01:26:47.030 --> 01:26:54.437
But there's another point, which is that if you're just randomly sampling, then if that home country's-
1059
01:26:55.097 --> 01:27:02.701
culture happens to be more culturally distant to your countries, then they're naturally going to be slower to a culture, right?
1060
01:27:03.921 --> 01:27:04.121
Correct.
1061
01:27:04.261 --> 01:27:14.006
Because skilled migrants, even if they, say, come from more middle-income countries, so Latin America, parts of the Middle East, parts of South Asia, say middle-income, they are developing.
1062
01:27:14.026 --> 01:27:14.366
Yeah.
1063
01:27:14.706 --> 01:27:17.747
So you come here as an automotive mechanic.
1064
01:27:18.088 --> 01:27:26.811
You might have come from a poorer country, but you basically know what an urban motorized society looks like.
1065
01:27:27.272 --> 01:27:27.472
Why?
1066
01:27:27.492 --> 01:27:29.272
Because you're a mechanic.
1067
01:27:30.193 --> 01:27:34.975
And you might have come from Mexico, or you might have come from Chile, or you might have come from somewhere else.
1068
01:27:35.595 --> 01:27:39.837
That might not be per capita up there with Australia, so it's more middle income, but...
1069
01:27:40.577 --> 01:27:47.382
But you kind of get what an urbanised, motorised, automobile-heavy society looks like.
1070
01:27:47.482 --> 01:27:47.642
Yeah.
1071
01:27:47.982 --> 01:27:48.883
Well, that's not Somalia.
1072
01:27:48.903 --> 01:27:49.423
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
1073
01:27:49.443 --> 01:27:50.204
That's not Sudan.
1074
01:27:50.244 --> 01:27:50.424
Yeah.
1075
01:27:51.385 --> 01:27:55.868
And also, if you're educated, in some sense, you're part of a global culture.
1076
01:27:56.028 --> 01:27:56.128
Yes.
1077
01:27:56.188 --> 01:28:01.111
In that education downloads like a particular package of modes of thinking.
1078
01:28:01.371 --> 01:28:02.192
Yeah.
1079
01:28:02.392 --> 01:28:03.993
Mechanics are a great example, by the way.
1080
01:28:04.173 --> 01:28:05.334
So Audi, for instance.
1081
01:28:05.454 --> 01:28:05.794
Yeah.
1082
01:28:05.814 --> 01:28:06.915
A very well-known case.
1083
01:28:07.175 --> 01:28:07.556
Audi...
1084
01:28:08.296 --> 01:28:12.217
is heavily reliant on temporary skilled migrants.
1085
01:28:12.357 --> 01:28:12.537
Why?
1086
01:28:12.557 --> 01:28:17.659
Because they all come from the Audi Mechanics University or whatever it is in Germany.
1087
01:28:17.679 --> 01:28:18.039
Yeah.
1088
01:28:18.279 --> 01:28:35.203
And they come here and they train the local mechanics who then, and I know this case particularly simply because we've got an Audi in our family, the mechanic then sometimes goes to get their postgraduate qualification or their higher qualification back to the Audi school in Germany.
1089
01:28:35.303 --> 01:28:36.824
You know, you're part of a global...
1090
01:28:37.324 --> 01:28:42.286
network of people who work on increasingly sophisticated cars, right?
1091
01:28:42.446 --> 01:28:49.209
Most even middle-income countries have got fairly sophisticated cars that have got, you know, computer-assisted engines.
1092
01:28:49.649 --> 01:28:52.630
You typically don't have a lot of mechanical...
1093
01:28:53.230 --> 01:28:54.891
tinkering that you do under the hood anymore.
1094
01:28:54.911 --> 01:28:56.852
You just take it into the service dealership.
1095
01:28:57.252 --> 01:28:59.913
You've got a sat-nav in the car, et cetera.
1096
01:28:59.933 --> 01:29:01.033
You've got a sound system.
1097
01:29:01.693 --> 01:29:09.757
Well, you can be a mechanic who's able to deploy that skill to Australia or to Canada or to any European country where Audis are sold.
1098
01:29:10.317 --> 01:29:18.200
Well, again, that's so different from the experience of most typical refugee producing countries where very few people will drive an Audi, for instance.
1099
01:29:18.947 --> 01:29:19.568
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
1100
01:29:19.708 --> 01:29:20.128
Interesting.
1101
01:29:21.350 --> 01:29:25.655
Okay, so four final questions to rapid fire at you on this topic.
1102
01:29:25.675 --> 01:29:26.396
Yeah.
1103
01:29:26.416 --> 01:29:32.383
So for refugees, there's a raft of what are called settlement services available.
1104
01:29:33.004 --> 01:29:35.887
Should I basically think of those as like acculturation services?
1105
01:29:35.947 --> 01:29:36.428
Largely.
1106
01:29:36.448 --> 01:29:37.589
Yes, largely.
1107
01:29:37.629 --> 01:29:38.010
Some of them-
1108
01:29:39.991 --> 01:29:42.613
Some of you might not agree the label is applicable.
1109
01:29:42.734 --> 01:29:46.076
I happen to, but they're things like employment readiness services.
1110
01:29:46.136 --> 01:29:48.358
Now, is that part of acculturation?
1111
01:29:48.378 --> 01:29:54.203
Well, in a sense it is because work and employment, having stable employment, is part of our culture.
1112
01:29:54.243 --> 01:29:54.403
Yeah.
1113
01:29:54.703 --> 01:29:55.243
Yeah.
1114
01:29:55.283 --> 01:29:59.785
And also that's how you interact with other Australians.
1115
01:30:00.006 --> 01:30:02.867
A third of your waking day, you know, eight hours at work.
1116
01:30:03.007 --> 01:30:03.447
Yeah.
1117
01:30:03.707 --> 01:30:11.511
So getting employment ready, employment specialist, employment placement services, which also then marry up with the English language piece.
1118
01:30:12.071 --> 01:30:15.093
That is part of enculturing you to Australia.
1119
01:30:15.253 --> 01:30:15.433
Yeah.
1120
01:30:15.873 --> 01:30:22.616
Because, you know, apart from our family life, our second mode, if you like, of social interaction is our workplace.
1121
01:30:22.676 --> 01:30:22.856
Yeah.
1122
01:30:23.237 --> 01:30:23.437
Yeah.
1123
01:30:24.217 --> 01:30:30.464
So apart from the Adult Migrant English program, what are some of the other services available to refugees?
1124
01:30:30.524 --> 01:30:32.486
Especially the Migrant Employment Services.
1125
01:30:32.506 --> 01:30:33.707
That's a big one.
1126
01:30:33.747 --> 01:30:36.129
They'd be probably co-equal with English language.
1127
01:30:36.570 --> 01:30:37.270
The two biggest?
1128
01:30:37.310 --> 01:30:37.931
The two big ones.
1129
01:30:37.991 --> 01:30:38.372
Okay.
1130
01:30:38.472 --> 01:30:45.419
And the Migrant Employment Programs are all, as with job services for other Australians,
1131
01:30:46.880 --> 01:30:51.623
are delivered through a government-regulated system but privately delivered.
1132
01:30:51.643 --> 01:30:58.187
So you get these private service providers who, for instance, specialise in migrant employment services.
1133
01:30:58.207 --> 01:30:58.527
Okay.
1134
01:30:58.547 --> 01:30:58.707
Okay.
1135
01:30:59.947 --> 01:31:00.227
Got it.
1136
01:31:00.247 --> 01:31:04.789
So, well, that answers my penultimate question, which was going to be, you know, one of the most important ones.
1137
01:31:04.809 --> 01:31:06.069
So it'd be the adult migrant English program.
1138
01:31:06.089 --> 01:31:06.890
Language and employment.
1139
01:31:06.910 --> 01:31:07.570
And the employment.
1140
01:31:07.590 --> 01:31:08.810
Yeah.
1141
01:31:08.890 --> 01:31:18.274
And then just finally, it sounds like it would be true to say that on a per migrant basis, humanitarian entrants receive the most acculturation services.
1142
01:31:18.594 --> 01:31:18.714
Yes.
1143
01:31:18.954 --> 01:31:19.274
Yeah.
1144
01:31:19.414 --> 01:31:20.355
If you use that label.
1145
01:31:20.375 --> 01:31:20.475
Yeah.
1146
01:31:20.555 --> 01:31:20.715
Yeah.
1147
01:31:21.515 --> 01:31:30.920
Some people would argue because they either are uncomfortable with the term as you and I have been using it, and they say, no, no, no, no, that's language and employment.
1148
01:31:31.441 --> 01:31:37.124
I argue in a bigger sense, language and employment is central to culture.
1149
01:31:37.304 --> 01:31:37.464
Yeah.
1150
01:31:37.784 --> 01:31:37.924
Yeah.
1151
01:31:38.184 --> 01:31:38.645
Absolutely.
1152
01:31:38.845 --> 01:31:39.005
Yeah.
1153
01:31:39.045 --> 01:31:41.006
They're sort of like vehicles for culture, right?
1154
01:31:41.566 --> 01:31:42.067
Yeah.
1155
01:31:42.467 --> 01:31:42.927
Fantastic.
1156
01:31:42.987 --> 01:31:43.307
Okay.
1157
01:31:43.327 --> 01:31:46.449
So now we've got those kind of factual premises out of the way.
1158
01:31:46.469 --> 01:31:47.269
I want to-
1159
01:31:49.134 --> 01:31:52.097
Talk about whether we've been getting worse at acculturation.
1160
01:31:53.178 --> 01:32:01.927
So if you compare the success of the post-war migration program with today, has Australia gotten materially worse at acculturating migrants?
1161
01:32:02.007 --> 01:32:04.249
No, I genuinely do not believe that.
1162
01:32:04.409 --> 01:32:04.649
Great.
1163
01:32:04.829 --> 01:32:05.510
I do not believe that.
1164
01:32:05.570 --> 01:32:07.792
I think with that one exception- Yep.
1165
01:32:07.812 --> 01:32:07.872
...
1166
01:32:08.673 --> 01:32:27.581
And I spent a bit of time earlier in this discussion on adherents of Islam, not all Islam, but who have got a particular reading of Islam that is so, in some cases, to the detriment or so adverse to a secular plural rule of law...
1167
01:32:29.123 --> 01:32:30.864
community, with that exception.
1168
01:32:31.164 --> 01:32:36.006
And as I said, in proportionate terms, it's not as big a problem as you might imagine.
1169
01:32:36.506 --> 01:32:41.228
In absolute terms, it causes ASIO and AFP to have some concerns.
1170
01:32:41.248 --> 01:32:42.369
We can come back to that if you wish.
1171
01:32:43.049 --> 01:32:55.414
But other than that, we are incredibly successful, incredibly successful at blending together different demographies, ethnicities, religions, and cultures.
1172
01:32:55.734 --> 01:32:56.295
To this day.
1173
01:32:56.575 --> 01:32:56.735
Yes.
1174
01:32:57.635 --> 01:33:04.760
notwithstanding obviously the decline in acculturation services since the 60s or 70s.
1175
01:33:05.001 --> 01:33:05.441
Yes, correct.
1176
01:33:05.721 --> 01:33:06.382
Yes.
1177
01:33:06.922 --> 01:33:14.648
Is there a country in the world, to your knowledge, that's being intentional about how to acculturate migrants or a country that we should look to as a model?
1178
01:33:15.128 --> 01:33:15.809
Are we the model?
1179
01:33:15.829 --> 01:33:24.515
Look, I think we're the model for us, if that's not too much of a contradiction, because I think, and this is where some European countries have –
1180
01:33:26.997 --> 01:33:29.899
And I will actually give you one example.
1181
01:33:30.299 -->
01:33:33.201
I was originally contemplating not naming a country.
1182
01:33:33.581 --> 01:33:36.003
I think France has had a huge problem.
1183
01:33:36.283 --> 01:33:36.523
Yeah.
1184
01:33:37.403 --> 01:33:43.907
Because it precisely invested so heavily in a unitary version of the French identity.
1185
01:33:43.927 --> 01:33:44.147
Yeah.
1186
01:33:44.167 --> 01:33:44.348
Yeah.
1187
01:33:45.268 --> 01:33:48.432
Partly, largely from the imperial experience.
1188
01:33:48.792 --> 01:33:54.158
French imperialism was quite different from British imperialism.
1189
01:33:54.638 --> 01:33:56.700
When you were in a French colony, you were in France.
1190
01:33:57.381 --> 01:33:57.581
Yeah.
1191
01:33:57.821 --> 01:34:00.464
It was metropolitan France.
1192
01:34:00.484 --> 01:34:01.205
Yeah.
1193
01:34:01.445 --> 01:34:11.352
And what that resulted in was when migration then started, there was no need to in culture because you're already French because it was such a function of being a French speaker.
1194
01:34:11.512 --> 01:34:12.773
Yeah.
1195
01:34:12.953 --> 01:34:17.796
And that was largely the Francophone position.
1196
01:34:17.816 --> 01:34:19.597
So people like de Gaulle would talk about...
1197
01:34:20.898 --> 01:34:27.165
There is no need to in culture because you speak French and they put so much weight.
1198
01:34:28.246 --> 01:34:37.196
Language was carrying so much of the burden of identity that now, and the French themselves have recognised this.
1199
01:34:37.256 --> 01:34:42.122
I remember some of those intriguing discussions I used to have in government were with people
1200
01:34:42.442 --> 01:34:52.826
my counterparts in the French system who were fascinated in Australian multiculturalism, and indeed, for that matter, Canadian multiculturalism.
1201
01:34:52.846 --> 01:34:55.347
There was a separate issue because of the Quebec issue.
1202
01:34:55.367 --> 01:34:57.388
But they were fascinated in Australia because they said, but...
1203
01:34:58.108 --> 01:34:59.129
But you're kind of English.
1204
01:34:59.189 --> 01:35:01.811
And I said, well, no, our institutions are English.
1205
01:35:02.411 --> 01:35:21.506
Our culture has become an ever-evolving, and it'll evolve again as more people out of the Indian community, so Indian Australians or Chinese Australians, become more senior in academia, in commerce, in cultural life, et cetera.
1206
01:35:21.526 --> 01:35:21.806
Yeah.
1207
01:35:21.826 --> 01:35:22.007
Yeah.
1208
01:35:22.847 --> 01:35:26.229
Australia itself will gradually, through increments, change.
1209
01:35:26.889 --> 01:35:29.571
So we don't have a fixed idea of Australia.
1210
01:35:29.631 --> 01:35:33.773
You tend to have a very fixed idea of France, the grandeur of France.
1211
01:35:33.813 --> 01:35:38.535
A lot of it's invested in language because it's such a beautiful language.
1212
01:35:39.756 --> 01:35:49.381
And now you have the situation where by not having an approach to multiculturalism, which accepted that you were going to,
1213
01:35:50.121 --> 01:35:52.724
if you like, blend different ethnicities together.
1214
01:35:52.744 --> 01:35:53.124
Yeah.
1215
01:35:53.244 --> 01:36:01.172
You go to places like Paris, and we know this from some of the terrorist incidents, there are
1216
01:36:02.683 --> 01:36:08.245
areas of Paris, the greater Paris area, which are terrorism hotspots.
1217
01:36:09.185 --> 01:36:15.767
Because the idea of France, which is supposed to overcome all difference, has never really taken root.
1218
01:36:17.128 --> 01:36:31.433
Because, simply because someone, say, whose background might have been African, they speak French, but they don't necessarily accept the institutional design of France as a parliamentary democracy, which is plural, courts of law, etc., etc.
1219
01:36:32.513 --> 01:36:41.906
So we, in a perverse way, even though you might say, or some would argue that Australia's been monocultural, I don't fully accept that.
1220
01:36:43.008 --> 01:36:48.175
It's certainly British in antecedents, that's true, language, culture, sport, etc.,
1221
01:36:49.316 --> 01:37:05.376
But I think what we've done is we've evolved and we've, if you like, taken the best of different groups as they've come, but we're still recognizably Australian, Australia in an institutional sense.
1222
01:37:06.117 --> 01:37:14.563
I think France is potentially in a world of hurt, and that's why you have a much more extreme version of One Nation.
1223
01:37:14.623 --> 01:37:19.206
I mean, National Front is very different from One Nation.
1224
01:37:19.647 --> 01:37:26.992
It's basically proto-fascist because of the problem, as they would describe it, of these ghettos.
1225
01:37:27.152 --> 01:37:27.432
Yeah, yeah.
1226
01:37:27.552 --> 01:37:28.773
We have virtually none of that here.
1227
01:37:28.893 --> 01:37:29.133
Yeah, yeah.
1228
01:37:29.814 --> 01:37:30.594
This is so interesting.
1229
01:37:30.614 --> 01:37:32.395
I want to pick up on two threads here.
1230
01:37:32.415 --> 01:37:37.739
So firstly, I'm really glad you mentioned France because I think it's like a really instructive case study.
1231
01:37:38.720 --> 01:37:46.725
And a pen pal of mine, a guy called Mike Mudakrishna, who's an Aussie academic, he was at LSE, he might be at NYU now.
1232
01:37:47.005 --> 01:37:49.387
But Mike's an expert in the field of cultural evolution.
1233
01:37:50.227 --> 01:37:53.869
And he distinguishes four models of multiculturalism.
1234
01:37:54.449 --> 01:37:58.071
The first is called the umbrella model, which is closest to what Australia is.
1235
01:37:58.612 --> 01:38:01.533
Then there's the melting pot model, which is closest to what America is.
1236
01:38:01.933 --> 01:38:04.755
The mosaic model, which is closest to what Canada is.
1237
01:38:05.295 --> 01:38:08.317
And the no hyphen model, which is closest to what France is.
1238
01:38:08.337 --> 01:38:08.677
First France.
1239
01:38:08.977 --> 01:38:14.563
No hyphen meaning that
there's no such thing as a German French or an Ethiopian French or just French.
1240
01:38:14.884 --> 01:38:15.064
Yeah.
1241
01:38:15.184 --> 01:38:23.873
And it's a very rigid form of assimilationism where you have to, as you were saying, adopt the language, adopt the customs, and then you can be French.
1242
01:38:24.594 --> 01:38:26.536
And it's kind of counterintuitive because-
1243
01:38:27.437 --> 01:38:32.882
Compared with some other European countries, France has quite generous naturalization laws.
1244
01:38:33.082 --> 01:38:33.762
It does, yeah.
1245
01:38:33.822 --> 01:38:39.087
In a formal or legal sense, it's quite easy to become French, at least for the second or third generation.
1246
01:38:39.667 --> 01:38:47.994
But at a kind of social or cultural level, the French natives are very...
1247
01:38:50.556 --> 01:38:53.778
very like, very, how would you put it?
1248
01:38:54.619 --> 01:38:58.161
Very exclusive with respect to the French identity.
1249
01:38:58.221 --> 01:39:08.668
And I think this is, this is like partly rooted in the much less egalitarian, more hierarchical culture of France as distinct from Australia's sort of egalitarian.
1250
01:39:08.848 --> 01:39:11.770
Notwithstanding what the French revolution was meant to have achieved.
1251
01:39:11.790 --> 01:39:12.210
Of course.
1252
01:39:12.270 --> 01:39:12.511
Yeah.
1253
01:39:12.751 --> 01:39:15.993
I'm using egalitarian in the kind of John Hearst equality of manners sense.
1254
01:39:16.073 --> 01:39:16.473
And, yeah,
1255
01:39:19.895 --> 01:39:41.288
I think that is one of the main reasons why France has done quite poorly with integrating Muslim migrants, because there's a good book about this which talks about how there's been a kind of discriminatory equilibrium in France where the French natives mistrust Muslim migrants, which causes them to further separate, drives more mistrust.
1256
01:39:41.308 --> 01:39:41.488
Yeah.
1257
01:39:43.829 --> 01:39:51.091
radical versions of Islam feed off groups like the National Front and vice versa.
1258
01:39:51.171 --> 01:39:53.992
That was the first thing you reminded me of.
1259
01:39:54.232 --> 01:40:00.293
The second thing was, I'm curious, do you remember any of the kind of- What kind of questions did your French counterparts ask you about Australia?
1260
01:40:00.493 --> 01:40:02.194
Was it just stuff like, how did you do it?
1261
01:40:02.534 --> 01:40:04.174
Or anything more specific than that?
1262
01:40:04.234 --> 01:40:06.375
In part, it was how would you do it, but the big-
1263
01:40:07.915 --> 01:40:14.598
And this is where I was fascinated in the difference between how the French empire sort of broke up.
1264
01:40:15.578 --> 01:40:23.201
They still don't think they're broken up because they think there's still this sort of francophone world and the British empire broke up.
1265
01:40:23.821 --> 01:40:35.352
We had to constantly, or I found myself constantly in a sense of repartee with my French counterparts, saying we never assumed that there was ever an Australia abroad.
1266
01:40:36.012 --> 01:40:44.299
The difference between us is, for you, someone in New Mia, in New Caledonia, or French Polynesia in Tahiti,
1267
01:40:45.160 --> 01:40:47.861
is French because they speak French.
1268
01:40:48.281 --> 01:40:54.784
They might have locally adopted a dialect and accent, and they used to rib the people from Quebec.
1269
01:40:54.804 --> 01:40:56.645
They said, well, they don't really speak French.
1270
01:40:57.185 --> 01:40:58.206
They kind of do, but they don't.
1271
01:40:59.707 --> 01:41:10.351
So you had an assumption that anywhere in the world where you went, if you were tied in a Francophone sense back to the idea of France, you were the same.
1272
01:41:11.592 --> 01:41:13.653
The British rejected that a long time ago.
1273
01:41:15.030 --> 01:41:17.553
And Australia is sort of growing up within the...
1274
01:41:17.633 --> 01:41:19.496
Evolving within the British context.
1275
01:41:19.836 --> 01:41:20.076
Yeah.
1276
01:41:20.517 --> 01:41:24.642
Never had that from the start because, of course, we had a strong Irish quotient.
1277
01:41:24.962 --> 01:41:27.265
So you didn't have the class system.
1278
01:41:27.305 --> 01:41:31.550
You didn't have that sense of manners that John Hirst and others have talked about.
1279
01:41:32.271 --> 01:41:33.012
So that's why...
1280
01:41:33.953 --> 01:41:42.383
We might have been British in antecedents, in institutions, in our parliamentary democracy, in our common law, our jurisprudence, etc.
1281
01:41:43.344 --> 01:41:54.256
But very early, we, if you like, synthesised an Australian culture, in part irreverent and anti-hierarchical and all the rest of it.
1282
01:41:55.097 --> 01:41:56.598
which was never exported anywhere.
1283
01:41:57.138 --> 01:42:00.439
In other words, you only ever experienced it by being in Australia.
1284
01:42:00.619 --> 01:42:00.939
Yeah, yeah.
1285
01:42:01.359 --> 01:42:10.403
The difference with France is that the French, and they've got such a beautiful language, deep culture, extraordinary literature.
1286
01:42:10.643 --> 01:42:10.803
Yeah.
1287
01:42:10.863 --> 01:42:12.144
Of course you'd be proud of it.
1288
01:42:12.464 --> 01:42:12.644
Yeah.
1289
01:42:12.944 --> 01:42:20.707
But the problem is that they're, if I can say this respectfully, I hate to think what your French viewers are going to make of this.
1290
01:42:21.707 --> 01:42:25.588
are still caught in this 18th or 19th century of France abroad.
1291
01:42:25.888 --> 01:42:26.148
Yeah.
1292
01:42:26.828 --> 01:42:29.768
And that's where you get the difficulties with integration.
1293
01:42:29.808 --> 01:42:46.711
Instead of saying France might have been in West Africa for even a century, it probably didn't change the cultures of those countries, whether it was Senegal or anywhere else that was in the Francophone Empire.
1294
01:42:46.812 --> 01:42:49.352
They were in Morocco for a couple of
decades.
1295
01:42:50.930 --> 01:42:58.432
So why not accept that someone coming from Senegal or someone coming from Morocco is probably going to have deeper roots?
1296
01:42:58.452 --> 01:43:13.795
So go back generations and generations in their own customs, religious traditions, et cetera, and then say, that's fine, but in smaller France, true metropolitan France, here are the house rules.
1297
01:43:15.235 --> 01:43:20.478
And by not having that, the House rules idea, we talked about, you know, the Menzies period.
1298
01:43:20.818 --> 01:43:29.662
You came to Australia, you left all your hatreds behind, whether it was Serbs and Croats or, you know, later on, you know, Jews and Muslims or whatever the case might be.
1299
01:43:29.722 --> 01:43:32.724
Leave all those hatreds behind because we've got House rules.
1300
01:43:33.524 --> 01:43:34.865
I don't know that the French ever...
1301
01:43:36.304 --> 01:43:46.070
And Britain, ironically, also wasn't through the 70s and 80s with their immigration program, particularly from the former parts of the British Empire.
1302
01:43:46.651 --> 01:43:48.792
I don't think we're hard enough on house rules.
1303
01:43:49.953 --> 01:43:50.913
We have house rules here.
1304
01:43:50.973 --> 01:43:55.837
And it goes back to the very first thing we talked about, which was the deliberate institutional design.
1305
01:43:56.637 --> 01:43:58.118
And everyone's signing up to those rules.
1306
01:43:58.458 --> 01:43:58.639
Yeah.
1307
01:43:58.779 --> 01:44:02.021
Parliamentary democracy, courts of law, courts dispense justice.
1308
01:44:02.161 --> 01:44:07.505
We don't have any extrajudicial or extralegal way of resolving difference.
1309
01:44:07.725 --> 01:44:07.886
Yeah.
1310
01:44:07.966 --> 01:44:08.926
We have politics.
1311
01:44:09.247 --> 01:44:09.427
Yeah.
1312
01:44:09.707 --> 01:44:10.407
That's all we have.
1313
01:44:10.588 --> 01:44:10.748
Yeah.
1314
01:44:11.308 --> 01:44:18.874
That was intrinsic to Australia's design almost from the get-go, largely, in fact, largely because...
1315
01:44:20.672 --> 01:44:33.640
In the settler groups, leaving aside the soldiers and the officials, but in the settler groups, you had a mix of both Protestant, landed, and in some cases, wealthy groups, and you had the Irish.
1316
01:44:33.920 --> 01:44:34.080
Yeah.
1317
01:44:34.700 --> 01:44:45.186
So right from the get-go, even though there was sectarian differences and sensibilities, you know, Protestants tended to dominate in certain professions, for instance, Catholics in others...
1318
01:44:46.207 --> 01:45:01.758
When we then came to federate, and you see this in the constitutional protection for the freedom of religious expression that's embedded in our constitution, we were from the get-go not going to be a sectarian society and we were not going to be a stratified society.
1319
01:45:01.858 --> 01:45:04.120
I don't think you get that in former empires.
1320
01:45:04.340 --> 01:45:04.520
Yeah.
1321
01:45:04.760 --> 01:45:06.742
And I think that's one of the material differences.
1322
01:45:06.902 --> 01:45:07.983
Yeah, that's super interesting.
1323
01:45:08.403 --> 01:45:10.725
I hadn't thought about that connection to empire.
1324
01:45:10.745 --> 01:45:11.265
Mm-hmm.
1325
01:45:12.674 --> 01:45:16.075
Okay, super quickly, you can only pick one.
1326
01:45:16.095 --> 01:45:19.376
What do you think is the single best measure for the speed of acculturation?
1327
01:45:20.036 --> 01:45:23.858
Intermarriage, language acquisition, second generation economic mobility.
1328
01:45:23.878 --> 01:45:26.078
I can only pick one.
1329
01:45:26.258 --> 01:45:28.879
Yeah.
1330
01:45:29.339 --> 01:45:29.700
Sport.
1331
01:45:30.600 --> 01:45:30.840
Yeah.
1332
01:45:31.521 --> 01:45:43.432
If I can see in second generation, not first generation, if I can see in second generation either typical or indeed abnormal levels of participation.
1333
01:45:43.473 --> 01:45:51.961
So, for instance, in the way that you see Pacific Island and Lebanese Australians and other Middle East Australians.
1334
01:45:52.421 --> 01:45:52.602
Yeah.
1335
01:45:53.102 --> 01:45:55.463
in my hometown of Sydney or through rugby league.
1336
01:45:55.503 --> 01:45:57.824
They love their rugby league.
1337
01:45:58.325 --> 01:46:04.387
Similarly in cricket, we're seeing a lot of not just Indian Australians but South Asian Australian kids.
1338
01:46:04.828 --> 01:46:13.292
I jokingly said if we ever have a Sachin Tendulkar born here in Australia, I want them to play for Australia and not to migrate back to India.
1339
01:46:14.833 --> 01:46:16.574
It's an odd metric and maybe a bit quirky.
1340
01:46:16.594 --> 01:46:17.235
That's interesting.
1341
01:46:17.275 --> 01:46:18.435
But it's foundational.
1342
01:46:18.515 --> 01:46:31.625
If you have, well, I see myself as a second generation Australian with a largely, you know, broadly Australian accent, hopefully a degree of culture associated with it.
1343
01:46:32.105 --> 01:46:38.029
But I speak in the Italian, in the Australian idiom, the Italian, the Australian vernacular.
1344
01:46:38.170 --> 01:46:41.332
I understand my mother well enough to be able to converse with her, but my mother,
1345
01:46:41.912 --> 01:46:46.054
My mental language is Australian and my sporting preferences.
1346
01:46:46.134 --> 01:46:52.698
Now, this doesn't work for people who don't have sporting biases, so you're going to have to have an equivalent measure for culture or something.
1347
01:46:52.718 --> 01:46:56.540
But a lot of second-generation young kids are sporty.
1348
01:46:57.200 --> 01:46:57.820
Have a look at them.
1349
01:46:58.461 --> 01:47:09.106
In rugby league, so I'm less of an expert in AFL in Victoria, but certainly in Sydney, you have wonderful representation in,
1350
01:47:09.826 --> 01:47:29.182
in all of those rugby league clubs, and you look at their supporter base, you know, Canterbury, Bankstown particularly, a lot of Middle
East Australians because it's geographically coherent, West Tigers because of the Western suburbs, but also some of the inner Western suburbs.
1351
01:47:29.963 --> 01:47:32.965
Sport for me is a real indicator.
1352
01:47:33.192 --> 01:47:37.276
Yeah, I was not expecting that answer, but I can... And in cricket, Usman Khawaja.
1353
01:47:37.476 --> 01:47:38.577
Yeah, yeah.
1354
01:47:38.617 --> 01:47:41.299
Second generation Pakistani Australian.
1355
01:47:41.319 --> 01:47:41.519
Yeah.
1356
01:47:41.940 --> 01:47:47.665
And there's a plausible kind of mechanism there where it's almost like a microcosm for cooperation within a broader society.
1357
01:47:48.085 --> 01:47:48.986
What does it tell you, right?
1358
01:47:49.006 --> 01:47:50.347
So sport is every week.
1359
01:47:50.668 --> 01:47:50.768
Yeah.
1360
01:47:50.788 --> 01:47:50.908
Yeah.
1361
01:47:51.288 --> 01:47:58.954
Your parents associating as you get dropped off at training, whether it's cricket in summer or footy in the winter.
1362
01:47:59.354 --> 01:48:01.135
Every week you get taken to the ground.
1363
01:48:01.516 --> 01:48:01.676
Yeah.
1364
01:48:02.096 --> 01:48:04.078
You play, have a half-time break.
1365
01:48:04.118 --> 01:48:05.419
One of the parents does oranges.
1366
01:48:05.459 --> 01:48:07.440
Another parent does this or the other.
1367
01:48:07.460 --> 01:48:07.720
Yeah.
1368
01:48:07.740 --> 01:48:10.903
Another parent's running up and down the sideline, you know, officiating.
1369
01:48:10.923 --> 01:48:11.023
Yeah.
1370
01:48:11.683 --> 01:48:12.985
It's a social experience.
1371
01:48:13.005 --> 01:48:14.286
Yeah, yeah.
1372
01:48:14.526 --> 01:48:26.278
And how is that any different from the acculturation process for English and Irish Australians playing rugby league, rugby union, cricket, et cetera, back in the day?
1373
01:48:26.418 --> 01:48:27.159
Yeah, yeah.
1374
01:48:27.620 --> 01:48:28.120
So sport.
1375
01:48:28.641 --> 01:48:28.761
Yeah.
1376
01:48:29.061 --> 01:48:29.381
Love it.
1377
01:48:29.542 --> 01:48:30.683
Okay, so...
1378
01:48:30.803 --> 01:48:43.176
I should very quickly add, I went on the official visit to Islamabad, and it was the week when Khawaja had just made his debut test, and my counterpart said, oh, he's very good.
1379
01:48:43.236 --> 01:48:44.137
Can we have him back?
1380
01:48:44.317 --> 01:48:46.119
I said, no, no, he's ours.
1381
01:48:48.802 --> 01:48:49.383
That's great.
1382
01:48:51.458 --> 01:48:56.262
We haven't spoken too much about temporary migrants, and I've just got one question focused on temporaries.
1383
01:48:56.322 --> 01:49:04.969
And I went into this more with Martin Parkinson, but there was like, we didn't really get to the bottom of how do we solve this issue?
1384
01:49:04.989 --> 01:49:10.753
So let me kind of present my framing of the issue, and then I want to hear your thoughts on it.
1385
01:49:10.793 --> 01:49:15.037
So Australia's kind of stuck in this bind where on the one hand,
1386
01:49:16.237 --> 01:49:25.490
Every night, about 2 million people in Australia go to sleep who are not permanent residents, are not citizens, but they have work rights in the country.
1387
01:49:25.510 --> 01:49:25.650
True.
1388
01:49:25.910 --> 01:49:26.030
Yep.
1389
01:49:27.115 --> 01:49:28.235
That is the temporary migrants.
1390
01:49:28.275 --> 01:49:31.616
And we've kind of like- And that's in a population just shy of 28 million.
1391
01:49:31.876 --> 01:49:32.116
Yeah.
1392
01:49:32.136 --> 01:49:33.917
So it's a significant percentage.
1393
01:49:34.117 --> 01:49:43.259
And we've sort of drifted into this equilibrium where our society and our economy are now quite dependent on this class of permanent temporaries.
1394
01:49:43.959 --> 01:49:48.280
So for example, I think they make up about roughly 10 to 15% of the labor force.
1395
01:49:48.300 --> 01:49:48.660
Mm-hmm.
1396
01:49:49.200 --> 01:49:53.123
University funding models have become quite dependent on international students.
1397
01:49:53.623 --> 01:49:56.785
The horticultural industry is quite dependent on working holidaymakers.
1398
01:49:58.146 --> 01:49:59.667
So that's on the one hand.
1399
01:50:00.367 --> 01:50:08.052
On the other hand, being permanently temporary is surely suboptimal from an acculturation and social cohesion standpoint.
1400
01:50:08.592 --> 01:50:17.540
It kind of like violates the settler society paradigm of I'm coming to this country, I'm committing to the national project, I'm on a clear path to citizenship.
1401
01:50:17.620 --> 01:50:17.760
Yep.
1402
01:50:18.421 --> 01:50:23.064
So how do we resolve that bind and what should the new paradigm be?
1403
01:50:23.084 --> 01:50:23.185
Yeah.
1404
01:50:23.944 --> 01:50:27.185
Well, I think you need to be slightly careful with premise.
1405
01:50:27.305 --> 01:50:30.505
I'm familiar with the term permanent temporary.
1406
01:50:31.405 --> 01:50:37.146
It's not really a thing in legal terms because temporary is temporary, even if you get a number of extensions.
1407
01:50:37.826 --> 01:50:43.868
So four-year uni degree, you get a two-year or four-year, depending on whether it's two plus two or two extension.
1408
01:50:44.708 --> 01:50:45.648
We have work rights.
1409
01:50:45.908 --> 01:50:46.808
We get value out of that.
1410
01:50:46.848 --> 01:50:51.529
So you've come to Australia to do a four-year degree or a three-year degree, play computer science or whatever.
1411
01:50:52.149 --> 01:51:00.595
You get picked up during that three-year period or four-year period, depending on what your post-study entitlement is in your field, right?
1412
01:51:01.015 --> 01:51:03.417
Now, in the meantime, we don't want you loafing about.
1413
01:51:03.677 --> 01:51:08.981
So the idea of, oh, you know, this person came to do a uni degree and now they're driving Uber.
1414
01:51:09.541 --> 01:51:18.167
Well, A, that means that there's a demand for that Uber driver because they're only driving because people have got
the app and they're demanding car rides.
1415
01:51:18.948 --> 01:51:28.714
And typically, and I always have this conversation with my Uber drivers and the ones who are here saying I'm either about to finish my degree or I'm in my two or three or four year extension.
1416
01:51:28.734 --> 01:51:28.834
Yeah.
1417
01:51:29.055 --> 01:51:29.255
Yeah.
1418
01:51:29.755 --> 01:51:34.043
I'm desperately keen to get a job as a computer scientist or IT or whatever, whatever.
1419
01:51:34.344 --> 01:51:38.311
But in the meantime, because I want to get income, I want to be gainfully employed.
1420
01:51:38.792 --> 01:51:40.035
I'm packing shelves.
1421
01:51:40.215 --> 01:51:42.159
I'm an Uber driver.
1422
01:51:43.248 --> 01:51:45.790
Not a bad thing because those jobs need to be done.
1423
01:51:45.890 --> 01:51:46.150
Yes.
1424
01:51:46.711 --> 01:51:49.252
So why would you exclude that workforce?
1425
01:51:49.332 --> 01:51:53.355
So, you know, growing up as a kid, we've talked about my childhood a bit.
1426
01:51:54.456 --> 01:51:59.860
I can never remember in the equivalent of Coles and Woolies, we used to have a supermarket called Franklin's.
1427
01:52:00.781 --> 01:52:03.483
Typically, there were people stacking the shelves were not...
1428
01:52:05.527 --> 01:52:13.506
what we would consider to be non-Anglos, Anglo-Australians, typically older, unskilled, older Australians.
1429
01:52:13.975 --> 01:52:17.658
Now you go to Woolies, Coles, a lot of them are students.
1430
01:52:17.678 --> 01:52:23.983
A lot of them are exercising their work rights, depending on whether they've got 40 hours of a fortnight or whatever the work writing title is.
1431
01:52:25.004 --> 01:52:27.306
I get a service out of that.
1432
01:52:27.326 --> 01:52:28.467
The shelves are packed.
1433
01:52:29.007 --> 01:52:30.788
You know, produce is put into the...
1434
01:52:31.169 --> 01:52:32.009
They're getting income.
1435
01:52:32.390 --> 01:52:34.672
They're either studying their degree or they're here for...
1436
01:52:35.312 --> 01:52:37.293
That searching for employment.
1437
01:52:37.373 --> 01:52:38.494
Now, it's positive, son.
1438
01:52:39.534 --> 01:52:40.715
Absolutely positive, son.
1439
01:52:41.476 --> 01:52:51.962
The problem becomes, and there's a suggestion that I read recently that the coalition might be going down the path of revisiting something that we've looked at before.
1440
01:52:52.682 --> 01:52:57.024
that you get to a point where there's no more extensions onshore, you have to go back offshore.
1441
01:52:57.805 --> 01:53:01.286
I think we probably need to tighten up the departure rules.
1442
01:53:02.247 --> 01:53:18.655
So you might have a two-year with a hard break, but with a right to go offshore and extend or, you know, get a new visa to come back, right, either in your skilled area or, again, in a temporary situation where you're looking for employment.
1443
01:53:20.478 --> 01:53:45.031
I think if you get the departure piece right and deal
with the other problem, which is the not so much overstay problem, we've actually got a very small overstay issue in the sense that last time I saw the numbers, and I'm a couple of years out of date, between the sum of all persons who have arrived in Australia since the Second World War versus all those who have departed...
1444
01:53:45.731 --> 01:53:50.933
There's something like a discrepancy of around, don't hold me to the precise figure, but it's around 80,000.
1445
01:53:50.953 --> 01:53:55.294
Now, some of those people might have arrived decades ago and they've probably passed away.
1446
01:53:55.874 --> 01:53:57.215
They're dead.
1447
01:53:57.655 --> 01:53:59.696
So that's a very small amount.
1448
01:53:59.716 --> 01:54:04.017
Like compared to America with what's called the undocumented problem.
1449
01:54:04.037 --> 01:54:05.678
Which might be like 11 million or something.
1450
01:54:05.698 --> 01:54:06.158
About that.
1451
01:54:06.298 --> 01:54:12.620
So in undocumented terms where we can't reconcile an arrival with a departure.
1452
01:54:12.640 --> 01:54:13.140
Mm-hmm.
1453
01:54:13.500 --> 01:54:14.261
It's about 80,000.
1454
01:54:14.521 --> 01:54:18.864
It might have gone slightly above that in the time since I've been out.
1455
01:54:19.524 --> 01:54:20.545
Very small problem.
1456
01:54:21.425 --> 01:54:30.151
Where we do have what's sometimes described as an overstate problem is people on what are called bridging visas pending resolution of their status.
1457
01:54:30.792 --> 01:54:30.932
Right.
1458
01:54:31.032 --> 01:54:34.574
They've got to the end of their, say, four-year study period.
1459
01:54:34.975 --> 01:54:35.135
Yeah.
1460
01:54:35.615 --> 01:54:37.036
They put in an asylum application.
1461
01:54:37.076 --> 01:54:37.216
Yeah.
1462
01:54:38.617 --> 01:54:44.882
They didn't put it in at the start of the period, interestingly, but towards the end of their visa, okay, they put in an asylum claim.
1463
01:54:44.902 --> 01:54:46.463
It has to be judged on its merits.
1464
01:54:47.384 --> 01:54:56.991
They typically, unless the application is completely vexatious and without merit, it's typically considered, and you get bridged.
1465
01:54:57.852 --> 01:55:01.535
And there's different classes of bridging visas, A through to E and F from memory.
1466
01:55:02.816 --> 01:55:05.938
That bridging amount, or the bridging number,
1467
01:55:07.359 --> 01:55:12.840
sometimes in the media or in public policy discussion is described as overstays.
1468
01:55:12.860 --> 01:55:14.961
Well, they're technically not overstays because they've got a visa.
1469
01:55:15.181 --> 01:55:15.821
Yeah.
1470
01:55:15.921 --> 01:55:17.601
It's called a bridging visa.
1471
01:55:17.721 --> 01:55:17.901
Yeah.
1472
01:55:18.181 --> 01:55:19.442
Very truncated rights.
1473
01:55:20.922 --> 01:55:29.664
And that's a problem because if you don't have access to benefits and access to work rights and, you know, how are you going to survive and get by?
1474
01:55:29.684 --> 01:55:32.465
So we have to solve two problems essentially.
1475
01:55:32.505 --> 01:55:33.845
And then I think the question of...
1476
01:55:34.725 --> 01:55:38.306
mass migration or uncontrolled migration, such as it is, goes away.
1477
01:55:39.046 --> 01:55:42.588
One, we've probably got to have a harder back end, right?
1478
01:55:42.648 --> 01:55:47.869
You get one extension, say two years or three years after a degree of study, and then you have to go.
1479
01:55:48.570 --> 01:56:00.173
If you go to ground and try to do what happens in America and elsewhere, we try to disappear, well, one way or another we'll find you, because you've got to surface at some point for benefits or to go to the doctor or whatever.
1480
01:56:00.934 --> 01:56:01.214
So...
1481
01:56:02.734 --> 01:56:16.626
You certainly want to intervene well before you get to the American problem where they've got ICE agents deploying in paramilitary garb, you know, into major cities doing these incredible roundup operations, which at times become incredibly violent.
1482
01:56:16.666 --> 01:56:20.589
And as you know, people have been killed in those operations.
1483
01:56:20.609 --> 01:56:22.110
We have nothing close to that.
1484
01:56:22.931 --> 01:56:43.139
And then the other problem we've got, and this is a really hard problem to solve legally, is the rolling extension through the bridging process of reviews, of reviews, of reviews, whether it's an asylum application or you're contesting a visa cancellation.
1485
01:56:44.280 --> 01:56:51.903
The most radical suggestion, and this is breaking news, so I've never said this publicly, the most radical way to deal with that,
1486
01:56:52.803 --> 01:57:09.257
and you probably would need a constitutional amendment, but it's probably one that would win a lot of favour, is because you've got in the Constitution, and this holds a different discussion, take a whole podcast of just legal discussion to explain this, so I'll just give you the summary.
1487
01:57:09.277 --> 01:57:10.278
Sounds like a fun podcast.
1488
01:57:10.618 --> 01:57:11.939
I'll give you the summary version.
1489
01:57:12.440 --> 01:57:18.125
Because it's Section 75 of the Constitution, the High Court's got...
1490
01:57:19.446 --> 01:57:25.910
what's called original jurisdiction, it can issue a writ that were the old common law writs that were in existence in 1901 in any case.
1491
01:57:25.950 --> 01:57:32.634
So you can arrive at an airport, you've only been in Australia for 10 years, for 10 minutes rather, you get denied entry.
1492
01:57:33.114 --> 01:57:37.377
If you're smart enough and you've got the right lawyer, you can put an injunction into the High Court.
1493
01:57:38.644 --> 01:57:40.126
They've been in Australia for 10 minutes.
1494
01:57:40.947 --> 01:57:43.430
And the High Court probably wouldn't necessarily hear it.
1495
01:57:43.830 --> 01:57:48.776
And if you put it in at 2 a.m. in the morning, the judges might be a bit put out by being, you know, woken up.
1496
01:57:49.277 --> 01:57:54.202
So what typically has happened is that the Migration Act has taken that burden away from the High Court.
1497
01:57:54.222 --> 01:57:56.145
Some people aren't just screaming to the High Court all the time.
1498
01:57:56.665 --> 01:57:58.648
And allowed for applications to be made.
1499
01:57:59.428 --> 01:58:01.470
And then you have merits review within the department.
1500
01:58:01.490 --> 01:58:06.173
You have administrative rights reviews in the administrative review tribunal.
1501
01:58:06.193 --> 01:58:09.935
You have judicial review through to the federal court, and then you can get to the high court.
1502
01:58:10.356 --> 01:58:14.398
So we're not all bothering the high court at 2 a.m. in the morning with our applications.
1503
01:58:15.099 --> 01:58:20.402
If you wanted to choke that off, really choke that off and get to a point where, now hang on,
1504
01:58:21.583 --> 01:58:28.207
We will give you some review rights, but you can't just tie us up for years and years and years, including by getting to our highest court.
1505
01:58:29.067 --> 01:58:47.817
What you would have to do is you'd have to change the Constitution slightly to say that the High Court's reach or its ability to grant anyone an injunction, alien or not, the constitutional term is alien, so someone who's not a citizen, the High Court's ability to grant anyone an injunction.
1506
01:58:48.377 --> 01:58:52.738
even if they've just been here for 10 minutes, some form of injunctive relief is denied.
1507
01:58:53.918 --> 01:59:03.920
And what you do is you have a separate section of the Constitution that says aliens have got the legal rights such as Parliament has provided for in statute.
1508
01:59:05.341 --> 01:59:12.182
If you did that, what you then could do is have a statutory provision that says you get one go.
1509
01:59:12.202 --> 01:59:14.463
And it's a 30-day determination.
1510
01:59:14.623 --> 01:59:14.943
That's it.
1511
01:59:16.289 --> 01:59:20.531
So if you're being denied a visa, you can't take it all the way to the High Court.
1512
01:59:21.311 --> 01:59:30.395
Really radical idea, and it would offend some people, saying, hang on, but the High Court should be able to, if you like, interrogate any decision of government.
1513
01:59:30.735 --> 01:59:31.555
That's a fair view.
1514
01:59:32.075 --> 01:59:42.640
Or you might say, hang on, the High Court's rights, or the right of access, I should say, to the ultimate form of judicial review, which is a High Court injunction or throwing
1515
01:59:46.221 --> 01:59:47.722
is only available to citizens.
1516
01:59:47.882 --> 01:59:55.425
In other words, it's a special privilege of the membership rules of the club.
1517
01:59:55.445 --> 01:59:55.925
Yeah.
1518
01:59:56.526 --> 02:00:06.910
And if you're an alien, to use the constitutional term, not trying to be derogatory but just using the legal term, sorry, you can't tie us up in courts for
years.
1519
02:00:07.231 --> 02:00:09.672
That's the only way you could cut that knot.
1520
02:00:09.912 --> 02:00:10.252
Interesting.
1521
02:00:10.272 --> 02:00:11.833
Now, if you did that... Yeah.
1522
02:00:11.853 --> 02:00:11.953
Yeah.
1523
02:00:12.593 --> 02:00:17.297
What you could do is the parliament, and the parliament would then have to decide how many bites you could have of the cherry.
1524
02:00:17.718 --> 02:00:20.080
The parliament might say you get one review.
1525
02:00:20.100 --> 02:00:21.201
Yeah.
1526
02:00:21.241 --> 02:00:21.661
30 days.
1527
02:00:22.222 --> 02:00:22.522
That's it.
1528
02:00:22.822 --> 02:00:23.002
Yeah.
1529
02:00:23.323 --> 02:00:31.270
And if the original decision to deny you a visa or to cancel it or to deny an asylum application...
1530
02:00:32.807 --> 02:00:34.648
is upheld within 30 days, you have to leave.
1531
02:00:35.188 --> 02:00:35.388
Yeah.
1532
02:00:36.008 --> 02:00:39.129
And you become, you know, deportable at that time.
1533
02:00:39.349 --> 02:00:39.509
Yeah.
1534
02:00:39.789 --> 02:00:56.415
That's the only way you could... Because otherwise, because you can't cut the high court out of ultimately being the recipient of someone's injunction application, then you can theoretically, depending on how skilful your lawyers are, be here for months if not years.
1535
02:00:56.655 --> 02:00:57.035
I see.
1536
02:00:57.355 --> 02:00:58.856
So people sort of exploit that.
1537
02:00:58.876 --> 02:00:58.976
Yeah.
1538
02:01:00.276 --> 02:01:02.897
But this would require – changing this would require a referendum.
1539
02:01:03.177 --> 02:01:04.238
I think so, yeah.
1540
02:01:04.298 --> 02:01:12.422
It's not a question that – it should be clear for your viewers – it's not a question that's ever been examined formally as far as I'm aware by any government.
1541
02:01:12.742 --> 02:01:18.225
But just reading the Constitution on its plain text in Chapter 3, which sets out the powers of the judiciary –
1542
02:01:19.165 --> 02:01:23.808
Because the High Court's got this what's called original jurisdiction, it's written into our Constitution.
1543
02:01:23.888 --> 02:01:24.068
Yeah.
1544
02:01:24.128 --> 02:01:32.472
What that means is the High Court can issue an injunction against any executive officer of the Commonwealth on any matter.
1545
02:01:32.612 --> 02:01:32.792
Yeah.
1546
02:01:33.133 --> 02:01:36.955
Then logically what that means is that anyone, say, I've arrived at an airport.
1547
02:01:37.155 --> 02:01:37.495
Yeah.
1548
02:01:37.855 --> 02:01:39.096
I put my hand up for asylum.
1549
02:01:39.336 --> 02:01:40.897
They said, no, we're going to kick you out.
1550
02:01:42.017 --> 02:01:45.059
I happen to have a free lawyer because I phoned them or they were here.
1551
02:01:46.060 --> 02:01:47.460
They've filled out the paperwork.
1552
02:01:47.540 --> 02:01:49.682
They've gone into the High Court at 2 a.m. in the morning.
1553
02:01:50.122 --> 02:01:51.883
The High Court says, oh, okay, we better hear that.
1554
02:01:52.403 --> 02:01:56.565
Okay, we'll grant you two weeks or whatever, and we remit it to the department or whatever.
1555
02:01:56.926 --> 02:02:00.788
Now, you don't want a situation where the High Court's getting hundreds of thousands of these writs.
1556
02:02:01.468 --> 02:02:03.489
been lodged at all hours.
1557
02:02:03.589 --> 02:02:07.312
So what the act is designed to do is take that pressure off the high court.
1558
02:02:07.332 --> 02:02:18.278
So you go through that other conveyable that I mentioned earlier of internal departmental review, ART review, federal court review, and then if it gets standing, ultimately high court.
1559
02:02:18.579 --> 02:02:20.300
But that could in some cases take years.
1560
02:02:20.460 --> 02:02:21.240
Yeah, interesting.
1561
02:02:21.680 --> 02:02:25.623
So as far as you're aware, this hasn't been considered by a cabinet, but it's an idea that you've had...
1562
02:02:26.461 --> 02:02:27.902
We'll call it a Pezzolo special.
1563
02:02:28.062 --> 02:02:29.964
Okay.
1564
02:02:30.064 --> 02:02:30.684
Pez spesh.
1565
02:02:31.025 --> 02:02:32.886
A special.
1566
02:02:33.406 --> 02:02:42.572
And that's the function of having a written constitution that has that power explicitly enumerated in the powers of the high court.
1567
02:02:42.613 --> 02:02:43.553
Right, right, right, right.
1568
02:02:43.973 --> 02:02:47.496
Okay, so this would help with this problem of permanent temporaries.
1569
02:02:48.296 --> 02:02:51.618
Because what would happen is if you solve those two problems, right?
1570
02:02:51.638 --> 02:03:02.722
So the high court jurisdiction problem and the hard close on either bridging or renewals where you have to leave.
1571
02:03:03.283 --> 02:03:05.043
So go back a step.
1572
02:03:05.603 --> 02:03:07.784
We talked about the three or four year study visa.
1573
02:03:08.085 --> 02:03:09.525
You get two years to find a job.
1574
02:03:09.565 --> 02:03:12.126
If you haven't found a job within 24 hours, you have to leave.
1575
02:03:12.386 --> 02:03:14.287
You can apply again, but you have to leave.
1576
02:03:14.987 --> 02:03:15.908
So if you cut that...
1577
02:03:16.528 --> 02:03:29.407
If you put a hard close on the rights to get renewed and you put a hard close on review and appeal rights, then essentially the problem goes away.
1578
02:03:29.427 --> 02:03:29.567
Yeah.
1579
02:03:29.687 --> 02:03:29.947
Okay.
1580
02:03:30.188 --> 02:03:30.428
Yeah.
1581
02:03:30.468 --> 02:03:30.929
Interesting.
1582
02:03:31.890 --> 02:03:43.460
Okay, so when I was framing the problem a little bit earlier, I did it quite rhetorically and provocatively, and I'm glad that you corrected the premise that not all temporaries are permanently temporary.
1583
02:03:43.740 --> 02:03:45.782
There's maybe another premise that we could correct.
1584
02:03:45.882 --> 02:03:50.626
I think, sorry, I think when people use that term, they mean that there's a permanent part of the
Australian system.
1585
02:03:51.186 --> 02:03:55.149
demography or population and labour force, which is always temporary.
1586
02:03:55.189 --> 02:03:56.549
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
1587
02:03:56.569 --> 02:04:01.533
That is statistically right, but it's not right at the level of the individual.
1588
02:04:01.613 --> 02:04:01.793
Yeah.
1589
02:04:01.893 --> 02:04:03.654
It can't be right at the level of the individual.
1590
02:04:03.914 --> 02:04:10.118
Unless they abscond and they somehow kind of just disappear into Australia in the way that people have in America.
1591
02:04:10.316 --> 02:04:10.476
Yep.
1592
02:04:10.836 --> 02:04:11.017
Yep.
1593
02:04:11.237 --> 02:04:11.577
Gotcha.
1594
02:04:12.117 --> 02:04:20.624
I mean, there's also another premise that we could correct, which is that temporaries are actually suboptimal for acculturation.
1595
02:04:21.284 --> 02:04:27.028
Maybe there are actually benefits where you can sort of try before you buy, or if you don't like Australia, then you leave.
1596
02:04:28.309 --> 02:04:29.170
I've got the opposite view.
1597
02:04:29.230 --> 02:04:37.536
I think temporary is good for acculturation, partly because, as I said, there's increasing, or certainly there was, I'm two years out of date, but
1598
02:04:38.877 --> 02:04:43.738
The proportion of what are called onshore temporary, sorry, onshore permanent applications is increasing.
1599
02:04:44.118 --> 02:04:44.298
Yeah.
1600
02:04:44.758 --> 02:04:47.699
So you came here for a three-year degree or a four-year honours degree.
1601
02:04:48.019 --> 02:04:57.000
You've got two years at the back for post-study residence, sometimes four years, but typically two years.
1602
02:04:57.100 --> 02:04:59.421
So you've been here, say, for six years, right?
1603
02:04:59.761 --> 02:04:59.921
Yeah.
1604
02:05:00.161 --> 02:05:02.021
Through that period, you fall in love with Australia.
1605
02:05:02.141 --> 02:05:02.281
Yeah.
1606
02:05:02.321 --> 02:05:04.002
Or better still, you fall in love with someone.
1607
02:05:04.182 --> 02:05:04.342
Yeah.
1608
02:05:04.762 --> 02:05:06.022
I want to create a family unit.
1609
02:05:06.202 --> 02:05:06.362
Yeah.
1610
02:05:06.722 --> 02:05:20.381
If you're here during your either four years of honours, undergraduate plus honours, or your two-year bolt-on period, so within that six years, you can apply for permanent residency.
1611
02:05:21.343 --> 02:05:22.423
We know something about you.
1612
02:05:22.883 --> 02:05:23.784
You're paying taxes.
1613
02:05:23.824 --> 02:05:24.564
You're employed.
1614
02:05:25.224 --> 02:05:26.785
You may or may not have a police record.
1615
02:05:26.845 --> 02:05:29.465
Hopefully you don't because if you do, we probably won't accept you.
1616
02:05:30.406 --> 02:05:31.866
You've probably been on social media.
1617
02:05:31.886 --> 02:05:32.046
Yeah.
1618
02:05:32.686 --> 02:05:40.049
So a lot of that checking that I talked about earlier, we're at the very top of this conversation about security and character.
1619
02:05:40.529 --> 02:05:44.770
We can already start to screen based on live observation, right?
1620
02:05:45.391 --> 02:05:49.457
So because you've been here for the best part of six years, Joe, we know you, Joe.
1621
02:05:49.637 --> 02:05:49.797
Yeah.
1622
02:05:50.078 --> 02:05:55.145
We've checked all the databases, not just the foreign databases, but all the state and territory databases.
1623
02:05:55.405 --> 02:05:56.647
You haven't even got a speeding ticket.
1624
02:05:58.097 --> 02:06:02.740
We've looked at, you know, we've run, we've scraped with some AI your social media posts.
1625
02:06:03.441 --> 02:06:04.501
You're interested in sport.
1626
02:06:04.521 --> 02:06:06.863
You're interested in chess or, you know, origami.
1627
02:06:07.283 --> 02:06:11.946
You don't express, you don't envisage any or exhibit any interest in extremism.
1628
02:06:13.167 --> 02:06:17.030
That's a good, that actually adds to social cohesion.
1629
02:06:17.130 --> 02:06:18.011
Yeah, yeah.
1630
02:06:18.251 --> 02:06:22.654
And the quality of the candidacy for permanent consideration.
1631
02:06:22.734 --> 02:06:23.514
Yeah, it's like...
1632
02:06:23.634 --> 02:06:24.515
I'm a fan, actually.
1633
02:06:25.069 --> 02:06:25.891
Yeah, it's interesting.
1634
02:06:25.991 --> 02:06:29.838
I hadn't thought much about that, but it's almost like running like a trial.
1635
02:06:30.118 --> 02:06:30.659
And also...
1636
02:06:32.447 --> 02:06:34.308
I've got a greater concern.
1637
02:06:34.588 --> 02:06:50.919
As I said, there's two groups, socially and culturally, that I worry about, not in proportion terms, just absolute numbers, the second-generation Muslim men and some third, fourth, fifth-generation Caucasian white males.
1638
02:06:51.520 --> 02:06:54.301
They're my two groups that I actually worry about.
1639
02:06:55.102 --> 02:06:56.983
In absolute terms, too many.
1640
02:06:57.724 --> 02:07:00.466
In proportion terms, insignificant.
1641
02:07:00.486 --> 02:07:01.146
Yeah.
1642
02:07:01.646 --> 02:07:05.027
They're permanent residents, in some cases, many cases, citizens.
1643
02:07:05.867 --> 02:07:19.410
What I find with temporary, and simply because I was a secretary or sometimes people would recognize me, so you talk about, you get in a conversation at a checkout or in an Uber or taxi, nearly everyone who's temporary loves the place.
1644
02:07:19.450 --> 02:07:23.551
Let's say the freedom here, I don't want to go back, but I know I've got to go back.
1645
02:07:23.591 --> 02:07:29.893
And if they know who I was, they'd say, I'm going back, or I've, I'm,
1646
02:07:30.773 --> 02:07:32.854
I've started a romantic relationship.
1647
02:07:32.894 --> 02:07:34.374
You know, we'll see where that goes.
1648
02:07:34.514 --> 02:07:35.834
I'd love to have a family here.
1649
02:07:36.514 --> 02:07:42.936
I think a lot of temporary migrants are sort of, in their own mind at least, guest Aussies.
1650
02:07:43.636 -->
02:07:55.779
You know, they're starting to think of themselves like that with maybe the aspiration of, I love this country so much, white space, freedom, economic opportunity, that they're always starting to think of themselves as Australians.
1651
02:07:55.799 --> 02:07:55.979
Yeah.
1652
02:07:57.059 --> 02:08:06.806
So to finish some questions about social cohesion and security, when you were secretary of the department, you appeared before the Senate's legal and constitutional affairs committee about two or three times a year.
1653
02:08:07.487 --> 02:08:12.130
And I went back and read all 26 opening statements between 2014 and 2023.
1654
02:08:12.250 --> 02:08:21.377
And it struck me that across the 26 opening statements you gave, the word cohesion appears about 33 times.
1655
02:08:21.637 --> 02:08:25.479
And it's usually framed as a core objective of the department's work.
1656
02:08:26.480 --> 02:08:40.325
Whereas diversity or multiculturalism or their variants appear only about 15 times and never is like a positive value in their own right, but instrumentally or as the name of a division or a policy function.
1657
02:08:41.126 --> 02:08:42.006
Was that deliberate?
1658
02:08:42.026 --> 02:08:44.107
And what's the kind of Straussian reading of that?
1659
02:08:45.302 --> 02:08:49.345
Well, the numbers tell the tale.
1660
02:08:49.885 --> 02:09:13.681
When I was looking at the design of the functions of the department, I was given about six months from July of 2017 to set up the design, and Mr Turnbull gave us until December to be ready to make the change, which is pretty generous, so six months to do a lot of mapping, a lot of design work.
1661
02:09:14.321 --> 02:09:36.062
Looking at functions that were spread across a number of different departments, the Attorney General's Department, my own Department of Immigration and Border Protection, obviously I knew very well, settlement services and some of the social cohesion functions that traditionally had been clustered around multicultural Australia, they were in the Department of Social Services.
1662
02:09:36.082 --> 02:09:36.182
Yeah.
1663
02:09:36.887 --> 02:09:40.589
They were moved there in maybe 2013 or 2014 by Abbott.
1664
02:09:40.629 --> 02:09:41.529
By Tony Abbott, yep.
1665
02:09:41.709 --> 02:09:43.971
And previously they had been in the Department of Immigration.
1666
02:09:44.011 --> 02:09:44.311
Correct.
1667
02:09:44.571 --> 02:09:46.112
So they were coming back.
1668
02:09:46.152 --> 02:09:46.932
They were coming back.
1669
02:09:46.992 --> 02:09:55.536
So what had moved was some of the settlement services that we spoke about, so employment and English language, but also the multicultural function.
1670
02:09:55.656 --> 02:09:56.237
So the whole...
1671
02:09:56.937 --> 02:10:02.223
idea of multicultural Australia, the Office of Multicultural Affairs, things of that nature.
1672
02:10:02.243 --> 02:10:04.164
That was in social services.
1673
02:10:04.184 --> 02:10:15.356
Some of the functions were in the Attorney General's Department, I think I mentioned, the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet, and also the Department of Transport when it came to aviation security and the like.
1674
02:10:15.396 --> 02:10:20.000
And some of the functions were in the Department of Defence insofar as they related to cyber warfare.
1675
02:10:20.020 --> 02:10:20.221
So,
1676
02:10:20.861 --> 02:10:36.332
Quite an eclectic sort of grouping, and it struck me that we needed to think coherently, because otherwise we're just going to be a federation of tribes, all sort of doing functions that couldn't be moved around later on without any kind of unifying purpose.
1677
02:10:36.792 --> 02:10:45.197
So as I looked at the operating model, in the same way that the Department of Defence looks at how do you defend Australia, and the Treasury looks at how do you run the Australian economy...
1678
02:10:46.218 --> 02:10:53.143
It struck me that our job was to think about how we run Australian society in terms of protecting its sovereignty and its security short of war.
1679
02:10:53.423 --> 02:11:00.988
Obviously, the wartime function is led by our colleagues in defence, but everything else, the protection of our borders...
1680
02:11:01.808 --> 02:11:17.438
the control over who enters and who leaves or who is required to leave, the sovereignty and the security of our critical infrastructure, our ability to be resilient in the face of supply shocks and the rest of it.
1681
02:11:17.458 --> 02:11:23.262
So all of the things that, if you like, the security function of Australia entails outside of a war.
1682
02:11:24.462 --> 02:11:31.966
So when it came to social cohesion, it struck me that the positive value that mattered most was our cohesiveness.
1683
02:11:32.026 --> 02:11:47.353
In other words, our ability to come together, whether we're dealing with a pandemic, whether we're dealing with a major outage of our internet and cyber, whether, as we're seeing as we speak, loss of fuel supplies or potentially the loss of fuel supplies.
1684
02:11:53.788 --> 02:12:09.322
which can ration goods and services, which can prioritise essential services, which can face a common foe if it requires that, right up to, at the most extreme level, war, but short of that, dealing with terrorism.
1685
02:12:10.363 --> 02:12:28.857
So for me, the things that bind us together, the things that give us a common interest in defending our sovereignty, in defending our territory, in protecting our borders, that's far more important than the diversity of our faith, our culture, etc.
1686
02:12:28.877 --> 02:12:31.459
Because the latter can be managed organically.
1687
02:12:32.420 --> 02:12:40.403
We're not going to tell people what to believe or whether to believe in a supreme deity, in which case, and if so, which one.
1688
02:12:41.684 --> 02:12:43.204
Those things are matters for culture.
1689
02:12:44.185 --> 02:12:50.967
And my starting point was the less the
government has to do with culture, the better, because culture is sort of pre-governmental.
1690
02:12:51.027 --> 02:12:51.788
It's sort of deeper.
1691
02:12:52.708 --> 02:13:03.274
pre-governmental, and government should only get involved in culture to the extent that tensions arise or gaps in common understanding start to arise.
1692
02:13:03.394 --> 02:13:08.477
We talked earlier, for instance, about people wanting to live under Sharia law, for instance.
1693
02:13:08.617 --> 02:13:09.898
Well, no, we're not going to do that.
1694
02:13:09.958 --> 02:13:17.762
So even though that might be organically coming up through a particular culture, we're not going to translate that into the institutional design process.
1695
02:13:17.922 --> 02:13:18.642
of Australia.
1696
02:13:18.723 --> 02:13:43.377
So for me, cohesion trumped diversity simply because the function of government is more about cohesion and congruence and unity than if you like generating, affirming or managing difference, because the latter is done culturally and it should be done organically with frankly the least involvement or the least possible involvement by government.
1697
02:13:43.797 --> 02:13:43.957
And,
1698
02:13:45.938 --> 02:13:52.259
I'm heartened to hear that my Straussian reading was at least directionally correct.
1699
02:13:53.279 --> 02:14:07.022
The other reason I appreciate your emphasis of social cohesion over multiculturalism or diversity is that it's descriptively true that Australia is a diverse country and there are benefits to diversity.
1700
02:14:07.302 --> 02:14:13.683
Like, for example, there's an economics literature showing that diversity helps with some level of diversity helps with innovation.
1701
02:14:15.204 --> 02:14:20.928
But as a national identity, I don't think diversity is adequate.
1702
02:14:22.008 --> 02:14:27.292
I'm quite fond of and influenced by Fukuyama's work on identity.
1703
02:14:27.312 --> 02:14:35.858
I think a book by the same name talks about multiculturalism, just not being load-bearing enough as a national identity.
1704
02:14:35.958 --> 02:14:38.560
You do need that additional kind of identity.
1705
02:14:38.720 --> 02:14:44.686
creed around liberal democratic values and potentially also another layer of positive virtues.
1706
02:14:45.727 --> 02:14:57.598
So when you were secretary, to your knowledge, did the department have its own internal measure of social cohesion or did it just use the Scanlon index?
1707
02:14:57.958 --> 02:14:58.138
We-
1708
02:14:59.139 --> 02:15:05.623
We certainly used a lot of academic or open source indices, Scanlon being one.
1709
02:15:05.743 --> 02:15:06.503
Yeah.
1710
02:15:06.943 --> 02:15:14.967
We did – I wouldn't raise this to the level of sort of mathematical or quantitative – Yeah.
1711
02:15:15.748 --> 02:15:15.768
–
1712
02:15:18.167 --> 02:15:27.920
But we certainly did scrape across all of the available data to look for the problems, which goes back to the point I just made.
1713
02:15:27.980 --> 02:15:31.845
Cohesion is your starting point and what you're looking for is deviation.
1714
02:15:32.266 --> 02:15:32.466
Yeah.
1715
02:15:32.666 --> 02:15:44.977
So you are looking for, whether it's through your own focus groups and your own outreach through certain community associations, whether it's working with ASIO and going through their caseload, for instance.
1716
02:15:44.997 --> 02:15:47.439
So ASIO would share their caseload.
1717
02:15:48.720 --> 02:15:50.962
Typically, the most sensitive information was stripped off.
1718
02:15:51.402 --> 02:15:56.607
But even that's not quite the case because the head of our intelligence and
1719
02:15:57.247 --> 02:16:03.290
The senior people in our intelligence division and myself included in this would also see the most sensitive cases.
1720
02:16:04.031 --> 02:16:10.794
So we're able to run, if you like, at the macro scale, trends across their caseload, for instance.
1721
02:16:11.094 --> 02:16:18.938
And ASIO did their own quantitative work in terms of, okay, here's what we're saying in terms of demography, age, gender.
1722
02:16:20.039 --> 02:16:25.982
You know, as I said earlier, there's a particular group, you know, Caucasian, some, not many, Caucasian white men.
1723
02:16:26.862 --> 02:16:37.866
and some, not many, Muslim males, not many in proportional terms, but as we discussed earlier, significant enough in absolute numbers to be concerned.
1724
02:16:37.886 --> 02:16:38.746
Those are the two groups.
1725
02:16:39.586 --> 02:16:42.827
You wouldn't just rely on your academic sociological research for that.
1726
02:16:42.867 --> 02:16:47.169
You're also running a model of sorts, I suppose you'd call it.
1727
02:16:47.409 --> 02:16:53.431
You'd run models across caseloads that AFP and ASIO are seeing, for instance, and you'd come to a common view with them.
1728
02:16:53.551 --> 02:16:54.191
So we do...
1729
02:16:55.312 --> 02:17:09.912
classified, I won't go into too much detail here, but we certainly would do classified assessments saying, look, here's what we're seeing both in the academic literature over here, and you mesh that with learnings that we've received from the Institute of Criminology, the federal government body,
1730
02:17:10.872 --> 02:17:14.994
the AFP, ASIO, is what states and territories are seeing.
1731
02:17:15.674 --> 02:17:19.095
Here's what we're seeing through the Countering Violent Extremism program.
1732
02:17:19.115 --> 02:17:21.336
Here's what we're seeing, CVE.
1733
02:17:21.676 --> 02:17:25.978
Here's what we're seeing through the CVE engagement with states and territories.
1734
02:17:26.038 --> 02:17:37.122
So what are they seeing on the ground in terms of ethnic tensions, communal tensions, anti-Semitism, Islamophobia, you know, all of the...
1735
02:17:38.002 --> 02:17:49.206
All of the indicators, so you're looking for indicators of harm and you're essentially looking for indicators of deviation from unity because those things,
when you think about them, are the opposite of unity.
1736
02:17:50.406 --> 02:18:07.112
So if you allow culture to do most of the heavy lifting for most people in terms of living together, being tolerant, enjoying each other's culture, enjoying each other's cuisine, tolerating each other's national, you know,
1737
02:18:07.692 --> 02:18:11.533
origin stories and the rest of it, what government's focused on are the problems.
1738
02:18:12.474 --> 02:18:21.917
So that's why you flip the social cohesion discussion for early identification of those problems and remediation of those problems rather than...
1739
02:18:22.857 --> 02:18:29.100
frankly, the easier task, which is really what I call the 1970s model of multiculturalism.
1740
02:18:29.120 --> 02:18:37.705
So starting with the appointment of the first Minister for Effectively Multicultural Affairs, it wasn't actually in his title, but Grasby, Al Grasby.
1741
02:18:38.485 --> 02:18:49.733
And then later on, there were ministers with dedicated titles, typically, well, initially, actually, ethnic affairs was the nomenclature, and then it became multicultural affairs.
1742
02:18:50.713 --> 02:18:54.356
And that largely started under Fraser, Malcolm Fraser.
1743
02:18:55.216 --> 02:19:00.880
So from that period, also saw the establishment of SBS as a second public broadcaster, and
1744
02:19:02.062 --> 02:19:05.083
That probably had its role in place.
1745
02:19:05.724 --> 02:19:07.885
In fact, more than probably.
1746
02:19:07.985 --> 02:19:23.792
It certainly had its role in place in 1970s Australia, because I remember 1970s Australia, we talked about this earlier, as sort of coming out of that Anglo period and then sort of grappling with, okay, all these Southern Europeans have turned up and they're starting to have kids, so they're second generation.
1747
02:19:23.812 --> 02:19:25.573
Now we're having Vietnamese people.
1748
02:19:26.213 --> 02:19:27.994
people coming as a result of the war.
1749
02:19:28.134 --> 02:19:31.335
Okay, what is Australia going to look like, you know, going forward?
1750
02:19:31.355 --> 02:19:41.940
So Fraser, I think, was far-reaching or far-sighted in that sense, and Hawke built on that with, so, the Office of Multicultural Affairs in the 80s.
1751
02:19:41.980 --> 02:19:46.082
But then 40 years on, we've achieved that multicultural approach
1752
02:19:46.782 --> 02:19:51.432
polygot, multi-ethnic, multi-racial, multi-faith society.
1753
02:19:51.832 --> 02:19:53.436
So you need to keep celebrating that.
1754
02:19:54.257 --> 02:19:55.840
The grief celebration doesn't harm.
1755
02:19:58.995 --> 02:20:05.398
Or is that engagement with your different communities really about early indications of problems?
1756
02:20:05.918 --> 02:20:07.398
Like, what are you seeing in your community?
1757
02:20:07.438 --> 02:20:14.161
Well, actually, some of our young can't get employment or they're discriminated against or they feel that their culture is denigrated.
1758
02:20:14.241 --> 02:20:16.062
Okay, that's a really important insight.
1759
02:20:16.482 --> 02:20:19.383
So with the Muslim community or the Jewish community, okay.
1760
02:20:20.023 --> 02:20:22.865
talk to our state and territory colleagues, talk across the Commonwealth.
1761
02:20:23.526 --> 02:20:28.109
What can we do to sort of mitigate, push back into that?
1762
02:20:28.389 --> 02:20:44.541
Typically, the only groupings or the only sort of sociological elements that mean you go to further levels to actually mitigate against potential terrorism risk, those two that I've been identifying throughout this discussion.
1763
02:20:45.201 --> 02:20:46.942
Very small number of groups,
1764
02:20:47.943 --> 02:21:15.870
adherence of extreme Islamist ideology and more recently but it's in the sense an older strand fascist or or neo-nazi or white supremacist ideation very small numbers okay this is Jay Joe Jay works at Eucalyptus I was trying to work out when it was that you and I first connected online and I went back and checked our Twitter DMs and it was September 2020 that's crazy
1765
02:21:16.210 --> 02:21:21.453
You're one of the OG listeners, so probably back when there were about 2,000 listeners per episode on average or something.
1766
02:21:21.534 --> 02:21:21.974
Yeah, we are.
1767
02:21:22.034 --> 02:21:23.375
Back in the Jolly Swagman days.
1768
02:21:23.555 --> 02:21:24.676
Some would say the golden days.
1769
02:21:24.736 --> 02:21:26.897
Yeah, some may say the golden days.
1770
02:21:26.997 --> 02:21:29.739
We finally met in person at one of my live events.
1771
02:21:30.039 --> 02:21:33.141
And at that time, you were working in the think tank world.
1772
02:21:33.421 --> 02:21:35.563
You've been a policy researcher at various think tanks.
1773
02:21:36.123 --> 02:21:38.344
Now you're working in growth marketing at Eucalyptus.
1774
02:21:39.245 --> 02:21:39.846
Why the shift?
1775
02:21:40.046 --> 02:21:49.856
Really, it was more of shifting from optimizing for, frankly, intellectual status and loft towards a mindset around being a gun by 30.
1776
02:21:50.116 --> 02:21:56.202
I wanted to learn as many skills from the best in Australia as possible.
1777
02:21:56.222 --> 02:22:02.709
I was watching Tim doing a keynote speech at Sunrise, and then he mentioned offhandedly that he was currently trying to hire.
1778
02:22:03.269 --> 02:22:05.970
someone who'd written an essay online about taste.
1779
02:22:06.110 --> 02:22:08.150
And I thought, that's got to be Jay.
1780
02:22:08.510 --> 02:22:11.611
Am I right in thinking that that essay was what put you on Tim's radar?
1781
02:22:12.311 --> 02:22:12.671
It was.
1782
02:22:12.931 --> 02:22:21.373
It was a response to a sort of disassociating and insufferable discourse around taste and culture emanating from Silicon Valley tech types.
1783
02:22:21.533 --> 02:22:24.794
One weekend, I finally decided to just write the rant down and then...
1784
02:22:25.634 --> 02:22:26.614
shipped it on
Substack.
1785
02:22:26.814 --> 02:22:30.275
Tim saw it on LinkedIn, his favorite platform.
1786
02:22:30.595 --> 02:22:32.396
And then, yeah, he reached out from there.
1787
02:22:32.796 --> 02:22:36.037
Why do you think it is that Eucalyptus selects on writing ability?
1788
02:22:36.237 --> 02:22:39.538
The marker of like a good generalist today is your writing ability.
1789
02:22:39.718 --> 02:22:41.858
I think if you can write, you can think.
1790
02:22:42.258 --> 02:22:44.559
And then if you can think, you can do most jobs.
1791
02:22:44.599 --> 02:22:47.540
What would you say you've learned here that you wouldn't have learned in the think tank world?
1792
02:22:47.940 --> 02:22:54.849
Joining a startup is great to sort of see ambition realized with respect to speed and velocity and also autonomy.
1793
02:22:55.370 --> 02:22:56.371
That's super refreshing.
1794
02:22:56.632 --> 02:22:56.872
All right.
1795
02:22:57.152 --> 02:22:59.255
Jay, thanks for joining me on the podcast.
1796
02:22:59.736 --> 02:23:00.157
My pleasure.
1797
02:23:00.357 --> 02:23:03.341
This is where I see whether I can spell eucalyptus.
1798
02:23:04.437 --> 02:23:09.219
You can check out Eucalyptus' open roles at eucalyptus.health slash careers.
1799
02:23:09.419 --> 02:23:14.520
That's E-U-C-A-L-Y-P-T-U-S dot health slash careers.
1800
02:23:14.820 --> 02:23:15.041
Cool.
1801
02:23:15.441 --> 02:23:16.681
They call me One Take Walker.
1802
02:23:17.101 --> 02:23:17.581
Let's go.
1803
02:23:17.601 --> 02:23:19.142
My man can spell.
1804
02:23:21.039 --> 02:23:40.911
So it's interesting to hear that the department would combine the academic literature, so things like the Scanlon, I think it's actually the Scanlon Monash Index, with its own kind of internal data and case files from agencies to essentially keep your finger on the pulse of Australian social cohesion.
1805
02:23:41.311 --> 02:23:41.491
Yep.
1806
02:23:42.772 --> 02:23:55.881
Alas, I don't have access to those kind of confidential sources of data, but the main thing I've, or the only thing I've looked at is the Scanlon Monash Index, which is probably the kind of premier Australian index.
1807
02:23:55.921 --> 02:23:56.862
It's a flagship.
1808
02:23:57.122 --> 02:23:57.302
Yep.
1809
02:23:57.782 --> 02:23:59.484
So it's been running since 2007, and they have sort of-
1810
02:24:03.006 --> 02:24:06.549
Five different dimensions of social cohesion, and then they build an average.
1811
02:24:07.410 --> 02:24:12.795
So the index starts at 100 in 2007, and it's pretty steadily declined over the last couple of decades.
1812
02:24:12.815 --> 02:24:15.998
It now sits at 82, which is the lowest it's been on record.
1813
02:24:17.159 --> 02:24:28.750
Taking the index at face value, if you had to boil it down into a couple of sentences, what's your kind of general account of why Australian social cohesion seems to have declined over the last couple of decades?
1814
02:24:28.770 --> 02:24:28.950
Yeah.
1815
02:24:29.495 --> 02:24:34.958
Well, they're measuring, and they measure what they measure, and it's a long time series.
1816
02:24:35.298 --> 02:24:41.061
They measure social cohesion more through a lens of an appreciation of diversity.
1817
02:24:41.161 --> 02:24:55.069
So what they're tracking, what they say they're tracking at least, is, and you see this expressed in political discourse as well, Australia is starting to feel different because it's starting to look different.
1818
02:24:57.162 --> 02:25:06.347
That, to me, might well be a view that many people have, largely because changes in migration patterns.
1819
02:25:06.367 --> 02:25:14.412
We talked about that earlier, more from the Middle East, more people from India and South Asia, more people of Chinese heritage.
1820
02:25:17.165 --> 02:25:27.509
But from the point of view of the department, or certainly the government at large, but I think the department in terms of its more specialised work, social cohesion is actually a narrower subset of that.
1821
02:25:27.769 --> 02:25:29.010
Okay.
1822
02:25:29.690 --> 02:25:36.012
And social cohesion is less an attitudinal sense of what we feel about Australia.
1823
02:25:36.733 --> 02:25:42.075
So what Scanlon's tracking, which is a thing, right, because they've got rigorous methodology, which they've got...
1824
02:25:42.775 --> 02:25:49.659
extended over a longitudinal axis now of 20 years almost now.
1825
02:25:50.620 --> 02:26:03.927
So they've been measuring the same thing, is how people feel about Australia in terms of probably an idealised or a memory of Australia and to what extent it's starting to feel different.
1826
02:26:06.238 --> 02:26:08.961
I think it's possible that number will continue to decline.
1827
02:26:09.602 --> 02:26:10.363
But is that a problem?
1828
02:26:10.543 --> 02:26:10.743
No.
1829
02:26:11.063 --> 02:26:11.944
Okay, interesting.
1830
02:26:12.265 --> 02:26:24.438
It's only a problem when, and you're starting to see this in parts of Europe and elsewhere, but principally Europe, when that attitude about our cohesion breaking down,
1831
02:26:26.522 --> 02:26:34.965
And we're breaking off into different tribes that are antagonistic to one another, either because we live in ghettos or we use the example of Sharia law.
1832
02:26:35.545 --> 02:26:41.447
Some parts of my country are under a different legal system, whether formally or informally.
1833
02:26:41.467 --> 02:26:44.668
And we're a long way from that.
1834
02:26:45.168 --> 02:26:47.028
If you start getting into that territory and...
1835
02:26:50.349 --> 02:27:00.558
And the tell for that, the canary for that, is actually not the rise of parties like One Nation, but parties to the further right of One Nation.
1836
02:27:00.878 --> 02:27:01.058
Yeah.
1837
02:27:01.759 --> 02:27:04.181
People might think, well, but aren't they at the far right?
1838
02:27:04.221 --> 02:27:07.524
No, I think they're just at the right.
1839
02:27:08.344 --> 02:27:09.766
Populist right, call them whatever you want.
1840
02:27:10.306 --> 02:27:14.670
And you're starting to see this in- I mean, if Barnaby Joyce can be in One Nation, it might get-
1841
02:27:15.030 --> 02:27:16.451
It's pretty mainstream.
1842
02:27:16.591 --> 02:27:19.152
It's within the over-dome window.
1843
02:27:19.172 --> 02:27:20.392
It's very over-dome.
1844
02:27:20.772 --> 02:27:25.194
I don't want to get into political commentary here, but I don't think that's extreme.
1845
02:27:25.714 --> 02:27:37.079
What you're starting to see in Britain, though, for instance, where people are rebelling or reacting, if not rebelling, against things like council ordinances that say –
1846
02:27:38.079 --> 02:27:45.067
not so much the Union Jack even, but the flag of St George cannot be flown because it's offensive to some groups.
1847
02:27:45.207 --> 02:27:45.427
Right.
1848
02:27:45.868 --> 02:27:49.632
English Defence League say, hang on, what do you mean?
1849
02:27:49.732 --> 02:27:55.619
If they don't like the flag, whether it's the Union Jack or the flag of St George, they can leave.
1850
02:27:57.808 --> 02:28:04.036
And some people, there's some evidence there that people are starting to organise in militias of a certain variety.
1851
02:28:04.056 --> 02:28:06.719
In my mind...
1852
02:28:08.828 --> 02:28:27.659
that indicator where our social cohesion is breaking down to the point where it's starting to translate into an organic separation and almost getting ready for conflict or schisms at least, you'd see enormous numbers starting to flow into things like the National Socialist Network.
1853
02:28:28.660 --> 02:28:29.820
We're just not seeing that.
1854
02:28:31.001 --> 02:28:32.602
NSN, for instance, a whole lot of
1855
02:28:34.242 --> 02:28:48.914
frankly misguided young men who venerate, either venerate Hitler or venerate sort of a version of Nazism that they say should be rehabilitated from history because apparently there was good Nazism and it sort of went a bit off tracks.
1856
02:28:49.034 --> 02:28:51.956
No, no, it was just all Nazism was evil.
1857
02:28:53.638 --> 02:28:54.598
That's not One Nation.
1858
02:28:54.618 --> 02:28:55.059
One Nation.
1859
02:28:56.726 --> 02:28:58.468
And that's not even particularly large.
1860
02:28:58.548 --> 02:29:01.732
It's dangerous if you let it fester and grow.
1861
02:29:02.432 --> 02:29:09.880
But I just don't... And even the so-called mass anti-immigration rallies, you see there's an organic...
1862
02:29:10.781 --> 02:29:14.686
Particularly a few months ago, quite a few of them were being held...
1863
02:29:15.927 --> 02:29:19.471
March for Australia, I think the network is loosely called.
1864
02:29:21.353 --> 02:29:26.898
Yes, some neo-Nazis tried to platform themselves, and typically they were yelled down, typically.
1865
02:29:27.339 --> 02:29:36.128
So you've got people who might otherwise, say, be on the right of the political spectrum saying, too many migrants, too many migrants
from certain parts of the world.
1866
02:29:36.969 --> 02:29:40.776
I want to see less migration, certainly want to see less migration from certain parts of the world.
1867
02:29:42.379 --> 02:29:45.305
But no, I don't venerate Hitler and I hate the neo-Nazis.
1868
02:29:45.657 --> 02:29:45.837
Yeah.
1869
02:29:46.918 --> 02:29:57.026
If you reflect on the unprecedented support One Nation's enjoying at the moment, at least in opinion polls, and for the first time in its history, it's tied with a major party, namely the coalition.
1870
02:29:57.046 --> 02:30:01.049
I think it's pretty clear that that reflects concerns about immigration.
1871
02:30:01.249 --> 02:30:05.412
But just to narrow it down, do you think the concerns are more about the level or the mix?
1872
02:30:05.953 --> 02:30:06.233
Level.
1873
02:30:06.813 --> 02:30:07.033
Okay.
1874
02:30:07.154 --> 02:30:08.475
Level much more so than mix.
1875
02:30:08.695 --> 02:30:09.035
Interesting.
1876
02:30:09.075 --> 02:30:10.276
Level much more so than mix.
1877
02:30:11.304 --> 02:30:13.746
And what do you think is the biggest piece of evidence for that?
1878
02:30:14.246 --> 02:30:32.201
I think either quantitatively, so it's not just Scanlon, but a lot of the large reputable polling companies because they're obviously looking at major issues, cost of living, access to bulk billing, levels of migration, housing affordability.
1879
02:30:32.241 --> 02:30:36.765
They're in different sequence issues, one, two, three, four.
1880
02:30:37.325 --> 02:30:41.748
And they sort of move around, but largely it's cost of living, housing, immigration.
1881
02:30:41.768 --> 02:30:45.870
You know, I like to visit the GP, the bulk bill.
1882
02:30:45.890 --> 02:30:48.632
They're sort of roughly issues one, two, three, four.
1883
02:30:48.672 --> 02:30:50.353
So we've got a lot of quantitative data.
1884
02:30:50.853 --> 02:30:56.036
And so when the different polling companies are all the ones who do the political polls as well...
1885
02:30:56.828 --> 02:30:59.969
They then drill into the immigration question.
1886
02:31:00.409 --> 02:31:02.510
It's always about housing and congestion, always.
1887
02:31:02.630 --> 02:31:03.171
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
1888
02:31:03.511 --> 02:31:03.731
Yeah.
1889
02:31:04.251 --> 02:31:06.232
Which is never by definition about mix.
1890
02:31:06.292 --> 02:31:07.692
It's always about numbers.
1891
02:31:07.952 --> 02:31:08.112
Yep.
1892
02:31:08.593 --> 02:31:09.153
That makes sense.
1893
02:31:09.213 --> 02:31:09.373
Yeah.
1894
02:31:10.333 --> 02:31:14.297
And there's a very tight correlation with, I tried to get into the housing market.
1895
02:31:14.597 --> 02:31:29.771
Whether it's economically true or not, where there's a causality and using multifactorial analysis, some economists can sort of break that down and say, well, no, actually, it's because we're short of tradesmen or the building and construction industry can't keep up with demand.
1896
02:31:29.831 --> 02:31:32.874
It's not because there's more migrants, because the migrants typically, because we've got
1897
02:31:33.374 --> 02:31:37.882
such a biased system towards points and skills, they're actually coming to Australia with money.
1898
02:31:38.222 --> 02:31:38.623
Yeah, yeah.
1899
02:31:39.084 --> 02:31:41.488
So they're actually not a drain on our economy.
1900
02:31:41.748 --> 02:31:43.171
They're actually adding to our economy.
1901
02:31:43.191 --> 02:31:44.373
Yeah.
1902
02:31:45.940 --> 02:31:54.825
And even, you know, people talk about students typically, most of them live in student accommodation, typically not always, rather than houses or units.
1903
02:31:55.245 --> 02:31:55.965
Yeah.
1904
02:31:55.985 --> 02:32:11.633
So when the companies then drill into the impression that one has about migration, it's typically about too much congestion on the streets, traffic-wise, and can't break into the housing or rental market.
1905
02:32:11.741 --> 02:32:11.921
Yep.
1906
02:32:12.422 --> 02:32:15.085
It's a pretty classic pattern across time and place, right?
1907
02:32:15.966 --> 02:32:18.388
Stagnant or declining living standards, dot, dot, dot.
1908
02:32:18.628 --> 02:32:20.190
Zero-sum thinking, dot, dot, dot.
1909
02:32:20.971 --> 02:32:22.032
Blame migrants.
1910
02:32:22.232 --> 02:32:22.432
Yep.
1911
02:32:23.733 --> 02:32:25.575
And sorry, blame migrants sounds quite judgmental.
1912
02:32:25.735 --> 02:32:34.183
There's often quite a rational component to that because migrants are driving up the demand, but there's oftentimes an irrational kind of scapegoating component as well.
1913
02:32:35.344 --> 02:32:47.614
And what's interesting in that is when it comes to mix, because you've got 30% foreign born and what is it, 49% or call it 50% with at least one if not both parents, you've
1914
02:32:48.335 --> 02:32:53.257
Those attitudes themselves, those people themselves, are playing back into the question of mix.
1915
02:32:53.597 --> 02:33:02.542
So typically, it'd be highly unusual, I would have thought, but typically an Indian-Australian would not be concerned that there's too many Indian-Australians in Australia.
1916
02:33:02.582 --> 02:33:02.742
Yeah.
1917
02:33:03.862 --> 02:33:11.166
Or, you know, someone who gets polled and they're of Chinese heritage, they're not typically going to say, no, too many people coming from China.
1918
02:33:11.626 --> 02:33:12.247
Yeah.
1919
02:33:12.947 --> 02:33:22.552
So the tolerance for a more pluralistic or more multi-ethnic society itself has been built into the structure of the very society that's been polled.
1920
02:33:22.752 --> 02:33:22.932
Yeah.
1921
02:33:23.273 --> 02:33:24.393
Yeah.
1922
02:33:24.473 --> 02:33:25.594
That's a good point.
1923
02:33:25.694 --> 02:33:26.914
So this next question feels...
1924
02:33:28.415 --> 02:33:31.978
out of place, but I think it does connect to this conversation about social cohesion.
1925
02:33:33.200 --> 02:33:41.266
There's this
striking juxtaposition between the way we treat legal migrants and the way we treat illegal migrants, at least those who come by boat.
1926
02:33:42.107 --> 02:33:45.230
It's almost like putting Disneyland next to a gulag.
1927
02:33:46.010 --> 02:33:47.251
And there's a...
1928
02:33:47.992 --> 02:34:01.077
a view or like a shibboleth in Australian politics that the very harsh treatment of illegal migrants is necessary to sustain broad public support of the high levels of legal migration that we've had over the last couple of decades.
1929
02:34:01.897 --> 02:34:06.439
What's your impression of the empirical evidence for that connection?
1930
02:34:06.459 --> 02:34:15.262
Because it's taken as a truism, but I've never really had anyone explain to me whether it is actually true.
1931
02:34:15.522 --> 02:34:21.627
Well, in fact, Scanlon is one of the reputable time series on this.
1932
02:34:22.488 --> 02:34:35.018
There is a correlation between a sense of the management of our borders, so the degree to which border control is being effected, and confidence in migration levels.
1933
02:34:35.598 --> 02:34:41.083
So we're actually out of kilter at the moment because we've got high levels of confidence in border protection
1934
02:34:41.923 --> 02:34:43.684
because the boats have stopped by and large.
1935
02:34:44.424 --> 02:34:50.666
The crisis of 2009 through to about 2013 has passed into memory.
1936
02:34:50.966 --> 02:34:51.146
Yeah.
1937
02:34:52.067 --> 02:34:58.689
But there's different concerns that are driving immigration anxiety to do with levels and housing that we just spoke about.
1938
02:34:59.509 --> 02:35:09.793
But if you go back to that period, say the Rudd, Gillard-Rudd period and very early Abbott, including looking at Scanlon but also other reputable quantitative work done at the time,
1939
02:35:10.733 --> 02:35:15.077
People felt on the one hand, and there was a close correlation, we've lost control of our borders.
1940
02:35:16.498 --> 02:35:19.299
I'm anti-immigration or I want to see fewer migrants.
1941
02:35:19.639 --> 02:35:19.779
Yeah.
1942
02:35:19.979 --> 02:35:21.960
So there is a nexus.
1943
02:35:23.060 --> 02:35:28.582
And then as you regain border control, I would argue you use the adjective harsh.
1944
02:35:28.682 --> 02:35:31.543
I'd argue through robust measures.
1945
02:35:31.563 --> 02:35:41.307
I mean, we always ensured we're spending a lot of money on medical care, good catering, safe transport options to get people to regional processing and the like.
1946
02:35:41.347 --> 02:35:43.628
And we can talk a bit about that in a moment if you wish.
1947
02:35:44.528 --> 02:35:44.688
But,
1948
02:35:46.445 --> 02:35:51.149
That sense of there's only one way to come to Australia, and that's through the visa system.
1949
02:35:51.730 --> 02:35:53.291
You will not get any benefit.
1950
02:35:53.351 --> 02:36:09.346
And this is actually a Labor policy in the first instance, so Labor policy of 2013 adopted by the
Abbott opposition, that if you come by illegal means or unauthorized means, the nomenclature sometimes varies, you'll never be able to settle in Australia.
1951
02:36:10.506 --> 02:36:26.656
So July 2013, we're coming up to 13 years of that policy, enshrined in law, because if you arrive by illegal or unauthorised means, the two terms are interchangeable, it's just that the two parties prefer different terms.
1952
02:36:27.817 --> 02:36:34.621
Coalition tends to prefer illegal, Labor tends to prefer unauthorised, but the legal consequence is the same.
1953
02:36:35.662 --> 02:36:53.333
Effective, in fact, I can give you a precise date, the 19th of July 2013 when Mr Rudd and then Deputy Prime Minister Albanese announced it, you can only apply for a humanitarian visa if you come by boat seeking asylum by invitation.
1954
02:36:53.353 --> 02:36:53.693
Right.
1955
02:36:54.173 --> 02:36:55.874
You otherwise will never settle in Australia.
1956
02:36:55.934 --> 02:36:59.135
We've had that policy for 13 years.
1957
02:37:00.336 --> 02:37:03.937
The consequence of that is that you will be removed to regional processing.
1958
02:37:04.717 --> 02:37:10.820
We had two sites now, one, Manus Island in PNG, now closed, or Nauru.
1959
02:37:11.780 --> 02:37:12.740
That's gone global.
1960
02:37:12.800 --> 02:37:13.660
Like everyone knows that.
1961
02:37:13.700 --> 02:37:15.161
That is the Australian policy.
1962
02:37:15.521 --> 02:37:27.784
We know, and I'm not aware of the, obviously I'm not aware of the classified information, but we know from periodic public pronouncements that a couple, that some boats still come occasionally.
1963
02:37:28.444 --> 02:37:36.906
There seems to be, from questions taken on notice, maybe about 100 people on Nauru, we think.
1964
02:37:37.326 --> 02:37:38.246
Not entirely clear.
1965
02:37:38.266 --> 02:37:41.047
And I haven't been tracking the detail in any event.
1966
02:37:42.568 --> 02:37:45.049
but that is below the critical mass.
1967
02:37:45.129 --> 02:38:00.517
In other words, you don't have enough arrivals where people think, oh, if I get down to Malaysia or Indonesia or East Timor, there's enough cash flow going to the smugglers that they'll have another venture ready for me to go.
1968
02:38:00.557 --> 02:38:07.741
So in other words, at its peak, so when the Rudd government was returned in, or when Labor was returned, I should say,
1969
02:38:08.521 --> 02:38:15.505
In 07, they changed the law and some migration regulations in the middle part of 2008.
1970
02:38:15.725 --> 02:38:25.890
They cut the processing time, closed regional processing, cut the processing for humanitarian visas, I think, from memory down to 90 days.
1971
02:38:25.930 --> 02:38:28.491
That started to send a demand signal around the world.
1972
02:38:29.391 --> 02:38:32.452
which Labor subsequently accepted that that's what had happened.
1973
02:38:34.532 --> 02:38:51.017
Smugglers then had enough of a business case or a business proposition to actually start taking advance orders, starting the boats, the fuel, the rations, and saying, okay, you get yourself to Jakarta or you get yourself to Kuala Lumpur or you get yourself to wherever –
1974
02:38:51.937 --> 02:38:58.625
One of my people will meet you, will take you down through some back roads, maybe to southern Java, say.
1975
02:38:59.926 --> 02:39:03.831
And don't worry if you miss next week's boat, because there's enough of a throughput going.
1976
02:39:04.331 --> 02:39:05.513
I'll get you on in two weeks' time.
1977
02:39:06.788 --> 02:39:28.291
That loss of control that saw the 50,000 plus arrive from mid-08 to early-14, and that's the period where it sort of peaked and then was then gotten back under control through turnbacks, through regional processing, through temporary protection visas, and that's
1978
02:39:29.332 --> 02:39:41.805
And it saw conservatively around 1,600 people drown, we think, based on the information we had about likely departures versus what we know arrived, the numbers that arrived.
1979
02:39:41.825 --> 02:39:45.409
So we think about 1,600 people died.
1980
02:39:45.429 --> 02:39:46.610
Yeah.
1981
02:39:48.352 --> 02:39:50.974
That effectively, in the early part of 2014, stopped dying.
1982
02:39:52.738 --> 02:39:53.038
Why?
1983
02:39:53.058 --> 02:39:56.079
Because it was a global signal that that way is shut.
1984
02:39:56.579 --> 02:39:56.759
Yeah.
1985
02:39:57.399 --> 02:40:08.502
So people stopped making advanced bookings, cash starts to dry up, the smugglers aren't getting cash flow, they can't, it's not economic for them to run ventures.
1986
02:40:09.082 --> 02:40:12.423
Whereas at its peak, they were running a timetable.
1987
02:40:12.443 --> 02:40:16.504
They were saying, oh, look, you've missed tomorrow's boat, but I can get you on Thursday.
1988
02:40:16.524 --> 02:40:16.624
Wow.
1989
02:40:16.644 --> 02:40:16.784
Yeah.
1990
02:40:20.610 --> 02:40:28.534
So, in this chat, we've touched on the question of Muslim integration, but specifically the problem of radical Islam.
1991
02:40:29.014 --> 02:40:30.975
And I want to come to it explicitly now.
1992
02:40:30.995 --> 02:40:31.756
Yep.
1993
02:40:32.436 --> 02:40:37.619
So, I have some questions that kind of cover some issues that we haven't discussed so far.
1994
02:40:37.639 --> 02:40:38.939
Mm-hmm.
1995
02:40:38.959 --> 02:40:40.400
First one's a philosophical one.
1996
02:40:40.420 --> 02:40:40.700
Yep.
1997
02:40:41.580 --> 02:40:46.503
Should an open society exclude people who adhere to radical Islamic ideology?
1998
02:40:46.523 --> 02:40:46.743
Yeah.
1999
02:40:48.535 --> 02:40:55.122
it's not really a philosophical question because it's actually a matter of law and application of law.
2000
02:40:55.282 --> 02:41:03.349
I spoke earlier at some length about the visa risk assessment process, which is becoming increasingly digitised.
2001
02:41:04.090 --> 02:41:06.553
If your security and character checks are working,
2002
02:41:07.573 --> 02:41:13.214
You should, doesn't always happen, you should be able to detect that in your first generation migrants.
2003
02:41:13.795 --> 02:41:22.937
Now you've got an issue, I said earlier, candidly, that we've had an issue with second generation Australian born Australian citizens who went off to fight for the caliphate.
2004
02:41:23.977 --> 02:41:26.858
You wouldn't have got that through visa screening.
2005
02:41:28.218 --> 02:41:35.800
But more than philosophically, as a matter of law and as a matter of bureaucratic procedure, we attempt to do that.
2006
02:41:37.205 --> 02:41:48.591
Well, I guess the... And sorry, the logic being not because of your religion, but what the interpretation of your religion could lead you to do in action.
2007
02:41:48.832 --> 02:41:49.072
Right.
2008
02:41:49.712 --> 02:42:01.138
So if you're, whether you're an adherence of the teachings of the prophet or a Christian or any religious sensibility, if there's...
2009
02:42:02.279 --> 02:42:22.872
a possibility that we pick up through security and character intelligence checks, that you might translate that into extremist ideation and worse, intention of extremist action, ultimately building a bomb or engaging in a mass casualty attack against a synagogue or a church, for instance.
2010
02:42:25.373 --> 02:42:26.314
We want to keep you out.
2011
02:42:26.534 --> 02:42:26.734
Yeah.
2012
02:42:27.174 --> 02:42:27.594
Okay.
2013
02:42:27.654 --> 02:42:40.117
So here, just so we're clear, are we defining radical Islam, because these terms can be quite slippery, are we defining radical Islam as people who believe in taking up violent means to advance?
2014
02:42:41.238 --> 02:42:44.438
It's even more precise than that, or more particular than that.
2015
02:42:44.678 --> 02:42:45.579
Yeah.
2016
02:42:46.759 --> 02:42:52.820
Because, you know, different parts of history, you know, there have been Christian groups who have taken up arms.
2017
02:42:52.860 --> 02:42:55.161
I mean, the Crusades was about that.
2018
02:42:56.261 --> 02:43:08.550
There's a particular strain, Salafist jihadi thinking, that really emerged after the Second World War.
2019
02:43:09.110 --> 02:43:23.239
It traceable to the Muslim Brotherhood, some scholars and intellectuals in Egypt who started to promote the idea because of the discovery of oil in Saudi Arabia, as those societies were likely to become westernised.
2020
02:43:23.760 --> 02:43:24.840
So under the Ottomans,
2021
02:43:25.701 --> 02:43:27.502
There was high levels of tolerance.
2022
02:43:27.602 --> 02:43:36.588
If you wanted to practice as a Muslim, typically that was the majority throughout the Ottoman Empire, which of course went right down into Arabia.
2023
02:43:37.648 --> 02:43:43.292
But there was respect for and tolerance in Christian communities and Jewish communities.
2024
02:43:44.052 --> 02:43:49.476
These questions didn't really arise until you started to get the decolonization of...
2025
02:43:50.256 --> 02:44:16.675
after the Second World War, so states such as Egypt started to emerge, Jordan, Transjordan, as it was called, the question of Palestine, the advent of the state of Israel, that actually started to harden views, saying, oh, hang on, now that there's a United Nations, because the empires have all largely broken up, we talked earlier about the dissolution of the British and French empires, well, that saw the demarcation of Iraq and Syria, for instance, you know, with the geographical boundaries, right?
2026
02:44:16.835 --> 02:44:17.496
being drawn.
2027
02:44:18.176 --> 02:44:22.120
Saudi Arabia, incredibly important there because people knew that oil was going to be the future.
2028
02:44:22.140 --> 02:44:33.289
A lot of scholars, largely in Cairo, this movement intellectually started in Egypt, but it also took hold in places like Damascus.
2029
02:44:33.329 --> 02:44:39.014
They started to say, and this is where the Muslim Brotherhood idea started to emerge, that, hang on,
2030
02:44:40.725 --> 02:44:42.305
We're not going to be plural societies.
2031
02:44:42.345 --> 02:44:43.806
We're Islamic societies.
2032
02:44:44.206 --> 02:45:05.010
So, yes, we might want to do trade with or have investment and maybe even have Western businesses here, but we don't want to look like those countries, including in terms of religious instruction, schools, mosques, halal eating rules and all the rest of it.
2033
02:45:06.927 --> 02:45:32.197
By the 80s and 90s, and you saw this with Bin Laden particularly, Al-Qaeda was one of the early adopters of the idea that this schism between the view we have of the Islamic world and how Islam can be best protected and preserved in opposition to the West is existential.
2034
02:45:33.117 --> 02:45:34.498
They've got all the financial power.
2035
02:45:34.898 --> 02:45:36.158
They've got all the military power.
2036
02:45:36.798 --> 02:45:40.219
They can overwhelm us if they choose to.
2037
02:45:40.880 --> 02:45:44.181
So we have to take up asymmetric means.
2038
02:45:44.281 --> 02:45:46.001
And you saw that on 9-11.
2039
02:45:46.061 --> 02:45:52.784
You know, we're going to crash planes into the center of American capitalism and the center of American military power.
2040
02:45:53.124 --> 02:46:01.487
And it would seem that they were also looking to target the Congress to the center of American political power because it's an existential struggle to the death.
2041
02:46:02.827 --> 02:46:07.128
We don't have vast military force or financial power.
2042
02:46:07.168 --> 02:46:08.108
They have all the power.
2043
02:46:08.908 --> 02:46:12.469
We've got the deed.
2044
02:46:12.829 --> 02:46:24.232
We can carry out the deeds that will show to them that in this struggle we will prevail and we certainly will not surrender to your ways.
2045
02:46:25.430 --> 02:46:29.693
Now, Al-Qaeda then obviously was pulverised after 9-11.
2046
02:46:29.733 --> 02:46:32.395
They splintered off into, you know,
different parts of the world.
2047
02:46:33.135 --> 02:46:46.745
And as I said earlier, the Islamic State then emerged almost as a reaction to the defeat of Al-Qaeda on the battlefield, saying, hang on, sure, we've got to take the attack into their homelands, but the first thing we've got to do is secure our own base.
2048
02:46:48.146 --> 02:46:53.870
And these apostate countries that are compromising the
2049
02:46:54.590 --> 02:46:59.313
with the West, you know, including Jordan and countries like that.
2050
02:46:59.414 --> 02:47:13.323
No, we're going to take over territory, in this case, parts of Iraq and large parts of Syria, and start to run it in accordance with our belief system, which is the caliphate.
2051
02:47:17.443 --> 02:47:25.329
To the extent that that idea is indistinguishable, or inextinguishable, I should say, it's probably going to be with us for generations.
2052
02:47:26.770 --> 02:47:30.093
The good news is that a lot of Muslims themselves are...
2053
02:47:32.352 --> 02:47:34.033
are opposed to that way of thinking.
2054
02:47:34.053 --> 02:47:43.596
In fact, some of the hardest campaigns against these extremist groupings are actually to be found in Muslim-majority countries.
2055
02:47:43.776 --> 02:47:43.976
Right.
2056
02:47:44.636 --> 02:47:50.698
Saudi Arabia, Jordan, you've got a reformed al-Qaeda guy in charge of Syria now.
2057
02:47:51.258 --> 02:47:56.080
Egypt, they go after these cells...
2058
02:47:57.160 --> 02:48:01.383
Even, frankly, in a more tough and robust fashion than even we do.
2059
02:48:01.403 --> 02:48:01.823
Yeah.
2060
02:48:02.424 --> 02:48:13.011
So, because you said it wasn't so much a philosophical question for you, just so I'm clear on the claim, the claim would be that radical Islam as- Or Islamist.
2061
02:48:13.171 --> 02:48:19.835
I would say, I prefer not to use the term radical Islam because even though you're qualifying it with the adjective radical- I see.
2062
02:48:20.155 --> 02:48:21.776
You're still tying it to the religion.
2063
02:48:21.797 --> 02:48:21.897
Okay.
2064
02:48:21.917 --> 02:48:22.317
So radical.
2065
02:48:22.537 --> 02:48:23.157
Radical Islamism?
2066
02:48:23.197 --> 02:48:23.638
Islamist.
2067
02:48:23.918 --> 02:48:24.318
Yeah.
2068
02:48:24.378 --> 02:48:24.979
Yeah.
2069
02:48:25.359 --> 02:48:30.322
So radical Islamism is fundamentally incompatible with liberal democracy?
2070
02:48:30.762 --> 02:48:35.586
Well, on their own, just on a reading of their own belief system.
2071
02:48:35.786 --> 02:48:35.986
Okay.
2072
02:48:36.166 --> 02:48:37.967
No, that's good.
2073
02:48:38.528 --> 02:48:45.612
So therefore, we should want to exclude migrant applicants who adhere to those beliefs?
2074
02:48:46.173 --> 02:48:49.515
Which is where the rigor of your security and character checking comes in.
2075
02:48:49.715 --> 02:48:49.875
Yeah.
2076
02:48:50.135 --> 02:48:51.036
Okay, great.
2077
02:48:51.116 --> 02:48:59.561
So does the non-discrimination principle in Australian migration policy allow us to exclude migrants on that basis?
2078
02:48:59.661 --> 02:49:01.002
Yes, absolutely.
2079
02:49:01.042 --> 02:49:05.064
Because we're not discriminating against you in terms of your religious belief.
2080
02:49:05.585 --> 02:49:05.805
Yeah.
2081
02:49:06.944 --> 02:49:09.526
probably discriminating against you in terms of your political belief.
2082
02:49:09.866 --> 02:49:10.047
Yeah.
2083
02:49:10.347 --> 02:49:21.636
Because you're saying that your adherence to Islam, in your particular view of the world, because you've followed a particular scholar or a particular imam, leads you, for instance, to say that...
2084
02:49:23.217 --> 02:49:26.460
Jews and Christians and Muslims cannot live side by side.
2085
02:49:26.480 --> 02:49:27.421
It's the way of the sword.
2086
02:49:27.761 --> 02:49:27.921
Yeah.
2087
02:49:28.362 --> 02:49:40.993
Or in some of the more extreme hate preaching that's been the subject of discussion post-Bondi, you're going to place emphasis on parts of the Quran that are particularly violent in relation to Jews.
2088
02:49:41.174 --> 02:49:41.374
I see.
2089
02:49:41.394 --> 02:49:41.494
Yeah.
2090
02:49:41.914 --> 02:49:49.299
So are there particular grounds in the Migration Act that allow us to exclude anyone with extremist views?
2091
02:49:49.319 --> 02:49:54.523
Yes, all the provisions that are underpinned by the Act in relation to security and character.
2092
02:49:54.785 --> 02:49:58.548
Yeah, so good character and a good order or whatever.
2093
02:49:58.728 --> 02:50:12.077
Yeah, the phrase used in the Act, which ultimately can lead to a cancellation under section 501, and also denial of grant under other sections, is where your presence would not be compatible with the good order of Australia.
2094
02:50:12.257 --> 02:50:13.618
That's the wording, yeah.
2095
02:50:13.698 --> 02:50:18.183
And there's very strong jurisprudence in relation to that, very strong.
2096
02:50:18.323 --> 02:50:19.384
Like the TN case.
2097
02:50:20.105 --> 02:50:20.986
TN principally.
2098
02:50:21.106 --> 02:50:22.567
It was also affirmed in Djokovic.
2099
02:50:23.027 --> 02:50:23.868
Completely different issue.
2100
02:50:24.008 --> 02:50:24.129
Oh.
2101
02:50:24.569 --> 02:50:27.532
But the presence when Djokovic came, there was...
2102
02:50:28.492 --> 02:50:30.773
uncertainty about his vaccination status.
2103
02:50:30.933 --> 02:50:31.813
Yeah.
2104
02:50:32.313 --> 02:50:39.736
He wasn't then excluded or, in fact, deported from Australia because of his lack of having appropriate vaccine credentials.
2105
02:50:39.836 --> 02:50:40.016
Yeah.
2106
02:50:40.336 --> 02:50:52.700
But because anti-vax groups started to rebel or started to get incited and were surrounding the hotel he was being kept in, and so his presence here was not consistent with good order, and he was deported.
2107
02:50:53.220 --> 02:50:53.460
Right.
2108
02:50:54.181 --> 02:50:55.421
The world's number one tennis player.
2109
02:50:55.541 --> 02:50:55.761
Yeah.
2110
02:50:56.582 --> 02:51:04.006
Now, we didn't discriminate against Mr Djokovic on the basis of his religious belief, his ethnicity, his a Serbian.
2111
02:51:05.547 --> 02:51:10.890
His exclusion was in relation to his presence being contrary to good order.
2112
02:51:11.090 --> 02:51:11.290
Yeah.
2113
02:51:11.590 --> 02:51:11.911
Yeah, yeah.
2114
02:51:12.051 --> 02:51:12.551
Okay, got it.
2115
02:51:13.211 --> 02:51:13.432
Okay.
2116
02:51:13.772 --> 02:51:13.872
So-
2117
02:51:15.778 --> 02:51:23.300
Probably the ultimate instantiation of a failure to acculturate is when someone commits a terrorist attack in their new host country.
2118
02:51:23.320 --> 02:51:23.800
Yep.
2119
02:51:24.840 --> 02:51:36.643
Do you think there's a way that selection criteria can filter out people like the father of the two Bondi terrorists who first came to Australia on a student visa in 1998?
2120
02:51:37.183 --> 02:51:42.264
Or is it kind of too difficult to see inside their minds or what they might become and you've kind of got to leave those...
2121
02:51:43.024 --> 02:51:48.646
functions to other agencies like ASIO to pick up the work after the person arrives?
2122
02:51:49.326 --> 02:51:58.730
Look, this will, I think, be tested through the reports of the Royal Commission, the criminal trial, and any coronial.
2123
02:51:58.750 --> 02:52:00.571
So there's probably going to be three lenses put on this.
2124
02:52:00.831 --> 02:52:02.351
I suspect all of them will find.
2125
02:52:02.411 --> 02:52:03.392
I don't know for a fact.
2126
02:52:03.612 --> 02:52:03.792
Yeah.
2127
02:52:04.372 --> 02:52:11.115
And certainly, Akram, either senior or junior, didn't come to my attention when I was the secretary.
2128
02:52:11.135 --> 02:52:11.535
Mm-hmm.
2129
02:52:12.155 --> 02:52:26.201
And we know from what ASIO has said publicly that the younger Akram was on the periphery of a number of investigations they were conducting into street preachers and people associating with those street preachers that we just spoke about.
2130
02:52:27.301 --> 02:52:33.524
And he was looked at, I think, in 2019 for a period, I think, from memory of about six months, that Ed of ASIO has said.
2131
02:52:34.224 --> 02:52:35.905
This is the son, not the father.
2132
02:52:36.785 --> 02:52:39.527
And the case was effectively closed, wasn't it?
2133
02:52:40.587 --> 02:52:48.776
He was associating with people expressing those sorts of views about the caliphate, about the need for sharia, etc., all the things we've just spoken about.
2134
02:52:49.336 --> 02:52:59.587
Was listening, was engaged, young man, about 18 or so, impressionable, not deemed worthy of ongoing surveillance or scrutiny because you've got to triage, you've got to make case decisions.
2135
02:53:00.107 --> 02:53:03.430
prioritisation decisions, have you got enough resources to track everyone like that?
2136
02:53:03.650 --> 02:53:20.322
Or going back to what I said about the
caseload earlier, if there's a smaller, harder core group of potential attackers, do you throw all of your material resources to the likely attackers as opposed to people at the periphery?
2137
02:53:21.383 --> 02:53:27.691
This will be established through the Royal Commission and through other processes, the criminal and coronial processes, I suspect.
2138
02:53:28.372 --> 02:53:37.523
In relation to the deceased Akram senior, student visa, India, an Indian Muslim.
2139
02:53:41.246 --> 02:53:47.832
I suspect it's already been examined as part of the initial Royal Commission work.
2140
02:53:48.152 --> 02:53:49.674
Probably his application has been looked at.
2141
02:53:50.114 --> 02:53:53.858
Going back to what I said in this discussion, the digital tools were not quite...
2142
02:53:54.498 --> 02:53:57.259
what they should have been up until about 2014.
2143
02:53:57.319 --> 02:54:02.761
So you're talking about an application that probably would have been paper-based.
2144
02:54:04.061 --> 02:54:16.085
A student, I think, from memory, I can't remember, I can't quite recall reading the course of study that he came on, I think subsequently formed a relationship here and subsequently married here.
2145
02:54:17.105 --> 02:54:18.946
And moved to a partner visa.
2146
02:54:18.966 --> 02:54:24.927
Moved on to partner, and then that's how he got into the permanent stream from off student.
2147
02:54:24.947 --> 02:54:42.752
98, I would think, looking back, the systems would be almost prehistoric compared to the sorts of data sets that I spoke about that emerged in the 2014 period and thereafter with digital access to foreign databases.
2148
02:54:43.172 --> 02:54:44.192
But, and here's the but.
2149
02:54:46.006 --> 02:55:06.739
If you could conduct this mind or thought experiment, and I think Judge Bell should, knowing what we now know, that he was one of the terrorists, now deceased, won't be able to cross-examine at trial, obviously, although we'll learn something through cross-examination of his son.
2150
02:55:08.440 --> 02:55:10.341
If we could go back to that application in 1998,
2151
02:55:12.240 --> 02:55:18.008
and controlling for bias in terms of hindsight, would you have made a different visa decision?
2152
02:55:18.469 --> 02:55:19.631
I suspect the answer would be no.
2153
02:55:20.382 --> 02:55:20.602
Yeah.
2154
02:55:21.143 --> 02:55:22.804
Were there flags at the time?
2155
02:55:23.264 --> 02:55:25.706
It was almost certainly a paper application, I suspect.
2156
02:55:25.726 --> 02:55:39.675
It might have been in the old mainframe system, so maybe elements of it would have been digitised, but the actual, literally the file that would have been examined either in New Delhi, because a lot of the caseloads were distributed around the world.
2157
02:55:40.035 --> 02:55:40.315
Yeah.
2158
02:55:40.395 --> 02:55:42.977
So probably there would have been a visa officer in New Delhi.
2159
02:55:43.137 --> 02:55:43.317
Yeah.
2160
02:55:43.718 --> 02:55:49.482
One of the last posts simply because of the size of it where we retired the old trolleys that used to...
2161
02:55:50.162 --> 02:56:01.344
move files around to the different visa processing offices and literally were tied up with old British, the British pink imperial era bureaucratic ribbons, where the phrase red tape comes from.
2162
02:56:01.945 --> 02:56:05.605
There would have been a file, which would be somewhere in the Department of Home Affairs.
2163
02:56:05.785 --> 02:56:06.425
Here in Canberra?
2164
02:56:06.806 --> 02:56:07.686
Yeah, I suspect so.
2165
02:56:07.706 --> 02:56:13.127
The archive file might be actually in New Delhi because some of the archiving was done around the world.
2166
02:56:13.147 --> 02:56:13.687
Interesting.
2167
02:56:13.827 --> 02:56:16.068
Well, simply because of volume, you'd apply.
2168
02:56:16.088 --> 02:56:16.509
Yeah.
2169
02:56:16.749 --> 02:56:19.850
In India, you'd apply ultimately under... And we have an office there.
2170
02:56:19.890 --> 02:56:25.013
We'd have a big immigration team in New Delhi in the 90s.
2171
02:56:25.113 --> 02:56:39.121
They might have punched in some basic data into what passed as, you know, they didn't have sort of the computers we have today, but they would have had some desktops starting to emerge and they would have been networked back to a mainframe back here.
2172
02:56:39.141 --> 02:56:39.421
Yeah.
2173
02:56:39.441 --> 02:56:39.581
Yeah.
2174
02:56:40.021 --> 02:56:44.824
But the file, now I suspect the file's been called for and it's been carefully scrutinised.
2175
02:56:45.904 --> 02:56:48.206
But here's something the Royal Commission should do.
2176
02:56:48.266 --> 02:57:01.173
They should conduct that thought experiment and trying to eliminate for as much bias as possible, knowing that the guy ultimately, many years later, ended up being an assailant at Bondi Beach.
2177
02:57:01.973 --> 02:57:03.954
Would you make a different visa decision?
2178
02:57:03.974 --> 02:57:04.995
I doubt it.
2179
02:57:05.996 --> 02:57:06.416
I doubt it.
2180
02:57:09.919 --> 02:57:21.283
Even if you could time travel and have the sort of digital capability, the data checking capability that I mentioned earlier, would it have come up?
2181
02:57:22.383 --> 02:57:22.784
I doubt it.
2182
02:57:22.884 --> 02:57:23.084
Yeah.
2183
02:57:23.104 --> 02:57:32.567
I think this is a really important point for people to understand just what we can reasonably expect from our immigration system.
2184
02:57:34.105 --> 02:57:38.374
I guess it begs the question or raises the question, what is the...
2185
02:57:43.025 --> 02:57:46.947
Where, if anywhere, was the point of failure then?
2186
02:57:47.147 --> 02:57:49.028
Is it a failure of acculturation?
2187
02:57:49.088 --> 02:57:51.209
Is it a failure of intelligence?
2188
02:57:52.769 --> 02:58:04.995
It goes back to the point I've been making recurrently through this discussion on a small group, in absolute terms, large enough
to be concerned about it, in relative terms not, that...
2189
02:58:06.035 --> 02:58:16.103
of Muslim men who are alienated and dissatisfied slash disassociated from Western plural liberal norms.
2190
02:58:17.164 --> 02:58:20.386
So, again, I'm just going to have to speculate here because I just don't know.
2191
02:58:20.406 --> 02:58:20.506
Yeah.
2192
02:58:21.467 --> 02:58:24.870
So Akram Senior migrates here as a student in 98.
2193
02:58:24.890 --> 02:58:25.150
Yeah.
2194
02:58:27.400 --> 02:58:32.765
talking to people who know him, his wife and others, what was his attitude?
2195
02:58:33.546 --> 02:58:35.808
And we could reconstruct this on 9-11.
2196
02:58:36.368 --> 02:58:36.929
Did he cheer?
2197
02:58:37.189 --> 02:58:39.871
Did he say, good on you, Bin Laden?
2198
02:58:39.891 --> 02:58:41.733
You've stuck it up those Americans, right?
2199
02:58:41.793 --> 02:58:48.759
Because the Americans, partly through support for Israel, the Palestinian cause or whatever, whatever.
2200
02:58:49.580 --> 02:59:07.488
whatever strand or particular sub-narrative they're buying into deserved, you know, a punch in the face with, you know, bringing down of the Twin Towers and so on and so forth, you know, or was he repelled by that?
2201
02:59:08.648 --> 02:59:10.209
There's an interesting thought.
2202
02:59:11.070 --> 02:59:19.235
As then the post-911 campaigns in both Afghanistan and Iraq unfolded, how did he react to those?
2203
02:59:20.455 --> 02:59:22.637
Was it, hang on, the Muslims are being put down.
2204
02:59:22.977 --> 02:59:25.598
You know, Bush has gone into Afghanistan.
2205
02:59:26.339 --> 02:59:31.022
Okay, maybe you can accept that because that's where al-Qaeda was based, but they've gone into Iraq.
2206
02:59:31.162 --> 02:59:31.742
Where next?
2207
02:59:32.443 --> 02:59:32.663
Yeah.
2208
02:59:33.263 --> 02:59:33.543
Yeah.
2209
02:59:35.024 --> 02:59:41.310
We're losing our Muslim identity around the world, crass consumerism, promiscuity.
2210
02:59:41.330 --> 02:59:45.654
You know, I don't agree with women having the rights that they're given.
2211
02:59:46.735 --> 02:59:47.716
How did he's thinking?
2212
02:59:47.736 --> 02:59:51.359
The man's dead, but to the extent you can reconstruct this –
2213
02:59:52.600 --> 02:59:54.161
How did he react?
2214
02:59:54.261 --> 03:00:04.468
And it might have been that there were no indicators of this because he wasn't chatting, he wasn't sending people messages, but privately to his relatives or to his friends, he was going, yeah, it's good that they stuck it to the Americans.
2215
03:00:05.208 --> 03:00:11.472
Or it's good that the Palestinians, you know, Hamas or Hezbollah are sticking it to Israel.
2216
03:00:13.133 --> 03:00:16.516
How did that – what did he think about the caliphate?
2217
03:00:16.757 --> 03:00:22.802
There seems to have been – we know at the end they were displaying the IS flag, the caliphate flag.
2218
03:00:23.903 --> 03:00:26.365
What sort of discussions were being held in the household?
2219
03:00:26.525 --> 03:00:32.230
Now, it appears – and again, we can just go off what's been said publicly – they weren't talking to others, it would seem.
2220
03:00:32.630 --> 03:00:32.830
Right.
2221
03:00:32.850 --> 03:00:33.471
Right.
2222
03:00:33.631 --> 03:00:36.872
There was this trip to the Philippines in more recent times.
2223
03:00:36.932 --> 03:00:41.273
But around 2014, what were father and son talking about?
2224
03:00:42.214 --> 03:00:44.674
The younger one was still quite young.
2225
03:00:45.695 --> 03:00:48.875
He would have been, what, 13 at the time.
2226
03:00:49.896 --> 03:00:52.136
How did dad view the caliphate?
2227
03:00:53.517 --> 03:00:56.478
Did he think those beheading videos were good?
2228
03:00:56.498 --> 03:01:00.739
You know, people in the orange jumpsuits, Westerners being beheaded?
2229
03:01:03.183 --> 03:01:05.544
To answer your question, you need to reconstruct that.
2230
03:01:06.425 --> 03:01:15.630
I think that actually should be a case study for the Royal Commission because the failure points, so-called, why is that behaviour not detected?
2231
03:01:15.750 --> 03:01:17.651
Well, in a sense, it's the strength of our society.
2232
03:01:17.671 --> 03:01:26.356
If you're kicking those sorts to yourself or to your most intimate friends, you know, you go outside and say, oh, you know, I hope this caliphate gets up and running.
2233
03:01:26.396 --> 03:01:27.176
You're not online.
2234
03:01:27.196 --> 03:01:28.597
You're not in a chat group.
2235
03:01:28.617 --> 03:01:28.937
You're not...
2236
03:01:29.557 --> 03:01:47.023
searching the internet, you're not sending messages to, you know, ISIS.com, you know, recruitment office, I want to come and be a fighter, almost impossible to pick you up, because we don't have that intrusive surveillance that would otherwise pick you up.
2237
03:01:47.983 --> 03:01:48.103
Now,
2238
03:01:49.860 --> 03:02:00.629
There is then the 2019 point where we know from what Mike Burgess has said that the younger Akram became the subject of an investigation.
2239
03:02:01.950 --> 03:02:07.795
I think he's been described as a preliminary investigation to see if a more detailed investigation was warranted.
2240
03:02:08.515 --> 03:02:11.377
I think that ran, I think Mike Burgess said, for six months.
2241
03:02:12.057 --> 03:02:26.306
And he said we threw everything at it, including our classified capabilities, and we came to the view that he was on the periphery of these street preacher groups, impressionable young man, but not requiring ongoing intrusive surveillance.
2242
03:02:27.546 --> 03:02:33.670
In a sense, as terrible as the outcome then was, because 15 innocent Jewish Australians were killed, um...
2243
03:02:35.275 --> 03:02:39.319
The fact that the security intelligence service of your country says, look, I've had a look at you.
2244
03:02:41.000 --> 03:02:43.902
If you come up again, we'll have another look at you, but we're not going
to tag you.
2245
03:02:43.922 --> 03:02:44.663
We're not going to follow you.
2246
03:02:44.683 --> 03:02:45.764
We're not going to be on your device.
2247
03:02:46.485 --> 03:02:48.226
That's actually the sign of a free society.
2248
03:02:48.466 --> 03:02:48.666
Right.
2249
03:02:49.367 --> 03:02:50.888
But it then creates that risk.
2250
03:02:51.008 --> 03:02:51.169
Yeah.
2251
03:02:51.409 --> 03:02:56.653
So it's just he and dad increasingly saying, look, son, we're not even going to tell mum to protect mum.
2252
03:02:56.673 --> 03:02:58.435
And I think there's a sister, I think.
2253
03:02:59.376 --> 03:03:01.037
Let's go out the back and have a discussion.
2254
03:03:01.257 --> 03:03:01.457
Yeah.
2255
03:03:02.498 --> 03:03:13.992
it's almost impossible to break into that thinking because there's no communication tale or tell associated with that increasing ideation, that increasing intent.
2256
03:03:15.098 --> 03:03:34.984
Now, the Royal Commission might find otherwise, and there might have been potentially a dramatic intelligence failure, but from everything we're hearing, including ASIO statements in relation to a Four Corners program, for instance, that was aired last month, those indicators were not available.
2257
03:03:35.004 --> 03:03:43.046
So to close some bigger questions on the intersection between immigration and security, take the
2258
03:03:44.768 --> 03:03:50.596
total space of immigration policies that Australians would plausibly accept.
2259
03:03:52.018 --> 03:03:57.065
If you were Xi Jinping, which set of policies in that space would you most like us to have?
2260
03:03:57.085 --> 03:04:02.392
Hmm.
2261
03:04:05.387 --> 03:04:16.479
I think he would like to have a change in an adjacent policy area, not quite immigration per se, but in some of the security checking and character checking.
2262
03:04:17.820 --> 03:04:20.302
So that it is easier to infiltrate Australia?
2263
03:04:21.864 --> 03:04:24.827
And there's probably not much more I can say on that.
2264
03:04:26.780 --> 03:04:42.124
So I think the settings that he would, to the extent he's given it any thought, I mean, he's got a lot of responsibilities, but to the extent that he's thought about this or he's caused to think about it, he would be more concerned and he'd want to see Australia relent to the extent that he can affect that.
2265
03:04:42.984 --> 03:04:52.706
He'd be concerned about our hardened counter-espionage and counter-interference posture that's emerged since 2016-17, so the last 10 years.
2266
03:04:52.746 --> 03:04:52.946
Yeah.
2267
03:04:57.487 --> 03:04:58.207
Anything else on that?
2268
03:04:59.648 --> 03:05:00.348
Nothing you can say.
2269
03:05:01.728 --> 03:05:01.968
Okay.
2270
03:05:01.988 --> 03:05:02.928
So hypothetical.
2271
03:05:03.249 --> 03:05:06.969
Imagine you're secretary of the department in 2027.
2272
03:05:07.670 --> 03:05:08.990
China blockades Taiwan.
2273
03:05:10.010 --> 03:05:12.351
And this triggers a regional economic crisis.
2274
03:05:12.391 --> 03:05:14.971
Shipping through the Strait of Taiwan is disrupted.
2275
03:05:15.811 --> 03:05:20.933
And simultaneously, three major migration flows converge on Australia.
2276
03:05:21.333 --> 03:05:22.553
Firstly, the Taiwanese.
2277
03:05:27.054 --> 03:05:27.594
There are.
2278
03:05:27.854 --> 03:05:30.495
It might not be that much, but I'd have to check the number.
2279
03:05:30.515 --> 03:05:31.435
Yeah, people shouldn't quote me.
2280
03:05:31.455 --> 03:05:32.215
It'll be in that range.
2281
03:05:32.235 --> 03:05:35.356
Yeah, people shouldn't quote me on that, but maybe roughly that order of magnitude.
2282
03:05:36.476 --> 03:05:48.399
Some of them will be on temporary visas, and they'll now claim protection, but they'll also pressure the government to accept some of Taiwan's 23 million citizens, many of whom will be evacuating the island as refugees.
2283
03:05:49.240 --> 03:05:49.480
Yep.
2284
03:05:50.580 --> 03:06:06.738
There might be Southeast Asian boat arrivals, so people from countries like Indonesia, Vietnam, and the Philippines, who are pushed to travel to Australia to escape this sort of instability and economic crisis that the blockade has triggered.
2285
03:06:07.179 --> 03:06:11.123
And then thirdly, there'll be a lot of onshore people coming.
2286
03:06:12.143 --> 03:06:25.306
out of necessity overstaying, so that like those 2 million temporary migrants we discussed, who may even lose their jobs if there's an economic downturn in Australia as well, but they won't want to leave because of the crisis.
2287
03:06:25.546 --> 03:06:25.786
Okay.
2288
03:06:26.207 --> 03:06:35.649
So having set up that hypothetical scenario, can you just walk me through how, as Secretary of the Department, you would think about that and maybe...
2289
03:06:36.829 --> 03:06:42.294
Just to sharpen the question for you, maybe operationally, what happens in the department in the first 72 hours?
2290
03:06:42.334 --> 03:06:44.236
What happens in the department in the first six months?
2291
03:06:44.756 --> 03:06:53.204
Well, you're at a prior stage because the Department of Home Affairs is now more deeply embedded in the national security architecture.
2292
03:06:53.865 --> 03:07:01.552
And I can assure you the most sensitive intelligence, including the prospects of an invasion or the prospects of a blockade or...
2293
03:07:02.212 --> 03:07:16.543
The prospects of a military strike, those assessments are given to the secretary and a few other officers, not because they're responsible for military defence, but there's other issues around cyber warfare, critical infrastructure protection, protection against sabotage, for instance.
2294
03:07:16.723 --> 03:07:20.565
So there's a whole other part of the home affairs brain that gets engaged.
2295
03:07:21.506 --> 03:07:28.769
not in relation to this immigration set of challenges, but Home Affairs has also got that domestic security and civil defence role.
2296
03:07:29.230 --> 03:07:42.096
So the Secretary's already, along with the Foreign Secretary, the Defence Secretary and others, already starting to think weeks out, if not months out, and they're probably, they should be thinking about this now, whole series of
2297
03:07:43.076 --> 03:08:03.848
preventative and mitigation measures, everything to do with keeping the internet on, critical infrastructure protection, defence against drone attacks, sabotage and the like, then an element of that planning, so it's not first 72 hours, it actually should be weeks if not months before, would be in those three areas.
2298
03:08:04.548 --> 03:08:08.150
What does a Taiwan maybe temporary humanitarian program look like?
2299
03:08:08.411 --> 03:08:08.611
Mm-hmm.
2300
03:08:09.971 --> 03:08:14.394
one which you'd want to coordinate with the Americans and a few others, maybe Canada and a couple of others.
2301
03:08:15.515 --> 03:08:26.062
It'd be good to get our early share of people in advanced IT and chip making.
2302
03:08:26.182 --> 03:08:27.162
Chip manufacturing, yeah.
2303
03:08:27.383 --> 03:08:29.944
Because temporary could become permanent.
2304
03:08:30.164 --> 03:08:33.306
So you'd have a humanitarian Taiwan program.
2305
03:08:33.326 --> 03:08:33.426
Yeah.
2306
03:08:35.427 --> 03:08:42.250
with boat arrivals, you don't want any in a war or pre-war situation.
2307
03:08:42.270 --> 03:08:46.051
Blockades, almost certainly, the early phases potentially of a war.
2308
03:08:46.071 --> 03:08:52.654
It's not quite clear from your question as to whether military operations have commenced between the US and China, but you'd have to think.
2309
03:08:52.714 --> 03:08:55.875
Yeah, I kind of left that out deliberately because it brings in some other...
2310
03:08:56.035 --> 03:08:56.395
Correct.
2311
03:08:56.415 --> 03:09:18.087
So let's assume that you're in a pre-conflict phase, but you're alert enough that conflict could start soon, potentially, particularly if the Chinese want to take some US assets off the table and Australia is implicated in a war, you'd want to harden up your maritime border protection anyway.
2312
03:09:18.407 --> 03:09:18.567
Right.
2313
03:09:18.587 --> 03:09:24.230
You don't want any vessels coming towards Australia, whether they're carrying people or saboteurs or...
2314
03:09:25.190 --> 03:09:27.772
internet cable cutting equipment or whatever.
2315
03:09:28.453 --> 03:09:34.256
So you would surge Operation Sovereign Borders, and yes, you would be doing turnbacks.
2316
03:09:34.296 --> 03:09:37.879
You would be ensuring that that flow is stopped.
2317
03:09:38.379 --> 03:09:44.663
Because in my scenario, the boat arrivals here are certainly dwarfing the numbers of arrivals in 2013.
2318
03:09:44.943 --> 03:09:52.989
And it might be that in that circumstance, you've got to look, and this would be part of the planning, at serious onshore detention
2319
03:09:53.789 --> 03:09:56.491
as you sort through, so you can't just rely on Nauru.
2320
03:09:56.511 --> 03:09:59.613
Because there are too many boats to turn back.
2321
03:10:00.313 --> 03:10:00.674
Too many.
2322
03:10:01.074 --> 03:10:03.035
So you apprehend them on the land.
2323
03:10:03.395 --> 03:10:16.724
If they get through that far, or you apprehend inside the migration zone and you simply accept that your defences have been overwhelmed and you have a massive... You open up your onshore northern detention.
2324
03:10:16.744 --> 03:10:22.368
Because it's not like you're in peace time saying, we're deterring you because we're going to send you to Nauru and from Nauru.
2325
03:10:22.908 --> 03:10:29.656
You're going to be put through regional processing and then you'll, in a peacetime context, end up in another country but not Australia.
2326
03:10:30.597 --> 03:10:37.425
If you're getting to a point where the arrivals are overwhelming the catches, that peacetime arrangement falls apart.
2327
03:10:39.005 --> 03:10:51.960
So you do turn backs where you can, and you should be checking as many targets as possible, contacts of interest, because they might be laying mines, they might be doing all sorts of other things, rather than just carrying people.
2328
03:10:52.360 --> 03:10:58.867
So you'd have to run an integrated border force and naval operation just for that screening.
2329
03:11:00.029 --> 03:11:04.552
And that would chew up virtually all of Australia's maritime surveillance capability.
2330
03:11:04.632 --> 03:11:19.384
So different podcast, different discussion, but our ability to contribute naval and other forces forward in a Taiwan scenario, even pre-war, is very much limited just by the vastness of our maritime domain.
2331
03:11:19.404 --> 03:11:27.551
We'll have to keep, to use a football analogy, we've got to defend our own line rather than push forward.
2332
03:11:28.151 --> 03:11:35.375
And when you say defend, that predominantly includes just turning back refugees.
2333
03:11:35.635 --> 03:11:39.637
It's not even- If you can, because it might be you're getting overwhelmed.
2334
03:11:39.657 --> 03:11:47.301
It might be that the number of arrivals that are streaming through, say, Java, you'd work with Indonesians to try to block off the flow as much as you could.
2335
03:11:47.661 --> 03:11:50.402
People might be slipping through PNG into East Timor.
2336
03:11:50.703 --> 03:11:52.924
They might be coming the long way around from Malaysia.
2337
03:11:54.244 --> 03:12:01.528
you'd certainly, as your first port of call, try to blockade or barricade at Java.
2338
03:12:01.688 --> 03:12:02.168
Yeah.
2339
03:12:02.368 --> 03:12:05.370
That's the main thoroughfare to block off.
2340
03:12:05.390 --> 03:12:08.551
But let's say you've done everything and boats are still overwhelming to you.
2341
03:12:09.232 --> 03:12:11.353
You have to accept a degree of onshore arrival.
2342
03:12:12.013 --> 03:12:15.315
So the Navy's not far from kind of...
2343
03:12:16.826 --> 03:12:21.988
undertaking military
operations, the Navy is actually getting sucked into helping turn back boats.
2344
03:12:22.008 --> 03:12:25.189
Some assets, your ANZACs and maybe your LHDs.
2345
03:12:25.249 --> 03:12:29.831
I mean, you'd keep your air warfare destroyers and submarines off for other missions.
2346
03:12:30.411 --> 03:12:35.493
But certainly your patrol boats, your frigates, and probably your LHDs, you might use your...
2347
03:12:36.313 --> 03:12:43.077
LHDs, the two large aircraft carrier type vessels, as helicopter carriers for surveillance.
2348
03:12:43.397 --> 03:12:53.922
And they might be doing a combination of looking for drones and mine laying, internet cable sabotage, as well as illegal maritime arrivals.
2349
03:12:53.942 --> 03:12:54.703
So you might have a...
2350
03:12:55.903 --> 03:12:57.004
It'd be one operation.
2351
03:12:57.124 --> 03:12:58.985
It'd be... Now, the good thing is...
2352
03:12:59.745 --> 03:13:01.425
IOSB is headed by a rear admiral.
2353
03:13:01.646 --> 03:13:08.547
So they could exercise military command and command over the Australian Border Force as one joined up operation.
2354
03:13:08.567 --> 03:13:12.508
And they actually wear two legal hats to do that at the same time.
2355
03:13:12.908 --> 03:13:25.232
And then the third element, which was just the people here, well, long-term permanent residents and citizens, you would treat no differently.
2356
03:13:25.372 --> 03:13:25.752
And you...
2357
03:13:26.532 --> 03:13:30.675
certainly would not go down the path of any kind of mass interment.
2358
03:13:32.056 --> 03:13:35.338
Any Chinese Australian you would assume is loyal until proven otherwise.
2359
03:13:35.598 --> 03:13:35.739
Yeah.
2360
03:13:36.019 --> 03:13:54.712
So if ASIO or AFP had particular concerns about a group or a cell, a network that they felt or they judged were being tasked by Beijing, sure, they get attention, not because they're Chinese Australians, but because they've been tasked by Beijing.
2361
03:13:55.112 --> 03:13:56.234
Mm-hmm.
2362
03:13:56.414 --> 03:14:11.192
And then people who can't travel back, there might be airline closures, there might be the early start of military operations, as you've seen in the Middle East, you would be looking to extend visas.
2363
03:14:11.212 --> 03:14:11.573
Right.
2364
03:14:11.593 --> 03:14:11.773
Right.
2365
03:14:13.513 --> 03:14:14.614
Okay, final question.
2366
03:14:14.634 --> 03:14:17.378
I'm cheating a little bit here because it's a double-barreled question.
2367
03:14:17.558 --> 03:14:24.366
But do you predict populate or perish will make a comeback and should it?
2368
03:14:26.408 --> 03:14:28.671
I think yes.
2369
03:14:30.133 --> 03:14:32.976
And that's simply a function of- Sorry, yes to which part?
2370
03:14:32.996 --> 03:14:33.076
Yes.
2371
03:14:34.277 --> 03:14:34.658
To both.
2372
03:14:35.018 --> 03:14:35.298
Okay.
2373
03:14:35.318 --> 03:14:36.559
It'll make a comeback and shoot it.
2374
03:14:37.019 --> 03:14:55.013
Yes, because as
much as we might generate leverage through AI agent capability, so relatively small population, but we've become super productive because everyone's got their AI agent, you know, in their workplace, right?
2375
03:14:55.433 --> 03:15:03.220
there still is going to be a requirement, whether it's in building, whether it's in military services, whether it's in healthcare, for humans.
2376
03:15:04.561 --> 03:15:18.293
And to secure Australia, just say as a military problem, a population of 28 million, and that's even if you allow for a degree of national service or a degree of conscription,
2377
03:15:19.173 --> 03:15:25.136
is only going to generate a defence force if you have to mobilise it to defend Australia in a war to a certain level.
2378
03:15:25.176 --> 03:15:39.983
Now, AI can help offset that to some extent, but as a military strategist and a military defence planner, I look at Australia, I'd want to be protecting Australia with 40 or 50 million people rather than 28.
2379
03:15:40.283 --> 03:15:41.424
Now, there's all sorts of issues.
2380
03:15:41.444 --> 03:15:43.345
I mean, where are those 20 million people going to live?
2381
03:15:43.365 --> 03:15:43.465
Yeah.
2382
03:15:44.025 --> 03:15:46.886
Do you simply double or triple the size of Sydney and Melbourne?
2383
03:15:46.906 --> 03:15:46.967
No.
2384
03:15:47.927 --> 03:15:53.830
Do you end up, are you in a better place where somewhere like Perth has 5 million people?
2385
03:15:54.190 --> 03:15:56.311
Yes, but can Perth take 5 million people?
2386
03:15:56.331 --> 03:15:56.891
Don't know.
2387
03:15:57.211 --> 03:15:59.312
Don't understand enough about sustainability there.
2388
03:16:00.033 --> 03:16:05.915
So you'd want to, and Kevin Rudd was probably the last Prime Minister who talked in these terms.
2389
03:16:05.935 --> 03:16:06.876
He talked in general terms.
2390
03:16:06.896 --> 03:16:13.259
I think he mentioned it in his memoir, for instance, of talking about an Australia of 40 million people.
2391
03:16:13.739 --> 03:16:21.522
Well, the irony of Rod's big Australia is that he kind of got a lot of pushback for talking about an Australia of, I think, 35 million people.
2392
03:16:21.562 --> 03:16:23.543
I think it was about 35, maybe 40.
2393
03:16:23.563 --> 03:16:24.343
By 2050.
2394
03:16:24.883 --> 03:16:34.146
But that's, you know, today, however, 17 years later, that's the ABS's midpoint projection for 2050.
2395
03:16:34.266 --> 03:16:34.786
We're on track.
2396
03:16:34.807 --> 03:16:38.608
So our population growth has been well out for...
2397
03:16:39.786 --> 03:16:49.389
relative to 20 years ago, more recent population projections are likely to be more accurate, particularly with the establishment of the Centre for Population in Treasury.
2398
03:16:49.629 --> 03:16:49.789
Yeah.
2399
03:16:50.089 --> 03:16:53.910
But you go back to- And was that just net migration catching them off guard?
2400
03:16:53.950 --> 03:16:55.590
Is that why we're always underestimating?
2401
03:16:55.850 --> 03:16:56.710
Yes.
2402
03:16:56.730 --> 03:16:59.031
Yeah.
2403
03:16:59.051 --> 03:17:05.913
And not a turnaround in fertility, but less of a decline in fertility than what was predicted.
2404
03:17:05.953 --> 03:17:06.093
Okay.
2405
03:17:06.113 --> 03:17:06.313
Okay.
2406
03:17:06.854 --> 03:17:15.951
So if the ABS's midpoint projection for 2050 is about 35 million people, from a defensive standpoint, what would you prefer to see by 2050?
2407
03:17:15.971 --> 03:17:17.013
No, about 40.
2408
03:17:17.033 --> 03:17:17.254
Okay.
2409
03:17:19.392 --> 03:17:19.892
About 40.
2410
03:17:19.912 --> 03:17:20.933
That's only an extra five.
2411
03:17:20.993 --> 03:17:21.473
That's not too much.
2412
03:17:21.493 --> 03:17:24.654
You've got to figure out whether... Yeah, but that's another Sydney or another Melbourne.
2413
03:17:24.774 --> 03:17:25.034
Yeah.
2414
03:17:25.074 --> 03:17:25.214
Yeah.
2415
03:17:26.195 --> 03:17:31.757
And just exactly, that extra five million, what does that get us defensively?
2416
03:17:31.997 --> 03:17:36.059
So 40 million, it's a function also of how much you spend on defense.
2417
03:17:36.099 --> 03:17:42.701
But from a defense point of view, you go from a full-time ADF of about 60,000.
2418
03:17:42.921 --> 03:17:43.181
Yeah.
2419
03:17:44.042 --> 03:17:44.962
Very, very light.
2420
03:17:45.202 --> 03:17:46.323
And you don't have any depth.
2421
03:17:46.343 --> 03:17:46.723
Yeah.
2422
03:17:47.223 --> 03:17:52.664
And even with AI and automation and digitalisation, you don't have the hitting power that you need.
2423
03:17:52.684 --> 03:17:53.005
Yeah.
2424
03:17:53.285 --> 03:17:56.825
And a Defence Australia podcast is entirely different.
2425
03:17:56.845 --> 03:17:57.606
We'll have to do that another time.
2426
03:17:57.626 --> 03:17:58.726
We'll have to do that another time.
2427
03:17:58.746 --> 03:17:58.846
Yeah.
2428
03:17:59.306 --> 03:18:06.048
But for an ADF of 60,000, you just don't have enough coverage.
2429
03:18:07.028 --> 03:18:13.850
But with a defense budget of, let's say, 3% of GDP, there's nothing magical about 3%, just more cash.
2430
03:18:13.930 --> 03:18:15.410
So it's about a percentage point on top.
2431
03:18:15.950 --> 03:18:17.351
Because we're about 2% currently.
2432
03:18:17.371 --> 03:18:17.891
2%.
2433
03:18:18.151 --> 03:18:23.312
Let's say 3%, ideally a bit more than that, because it's going to become a pretty tough world.
2434
03:18:23.412 --> 03:18:24.513
But there's lots of trade-offs.
2435
03:18:24.533 --> 03:18:25.853
Where do you get that percentage point?
2436
03:18:27.414 --> 03:18:44.464
And in population terms, if you carry through sort of current ideas about recruitment, retention, life in the military, do I want to sort of do 20 years or whatever, and exclude for a moment national service, you get an ADF of about 100,000.
2437
03:18:44.784 --> 03:18:47.466
And that is probably the minimum viable.
2438
03:18:47.826 -->
03:18:48.006
A 3%...
2439
03:18:49.751 --> 03:19:09.212
budget and an ADF of about 100,000 gives you the number of people you need to then, even if you've digitised, automated, gone heavily into drone warfare, it gives you the kind of size of a defence force that you'd need for the most credible contingency that we would face, which is basically...
2440
03:19:09.949 --> 03:19:23.097
a theatre-wide war where Australia's not been attacked directly because someone's attacking Australia, but we're part of a theatre war which extends from the middle of the Indian Ocean probably right up to Alaska.
2441
03:19:23.677 --> 03:19:27.680
And it's a bit more like the conflict that we faced in 1942.
2442
03:19:27.720 --> 03:19:28.280
In that war...
2443
03:19:31.282 --> 03:19:52.952
or in that kind of credible contingency, because for the next century at least, all things being equal, unless Indonesia turns into a very different sort of country, it's almost impossible to see a circumstance where Australia is engaged in an existential military conflict where it's fighting for its life, absent a broader war.
2444
03:19:53.113 --> 03:19:53.733
Yeah, I see.
2445
03:19:53.753 --> 03:19:59.796
So it's actually quite an important assumption here that you're not contemplating the defence of Australia, you're contemplating a theatre war.
2446
03:20:00.776 --> 03:20:02.917
Where the defence of Australia is a subset.
2447
03:20:03.538 --> 03:20:04.899
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
2448
03:20:05.079 --> 03:20:06.279
It's a subcomponent of that war.
2449
03:20:06.299 --> 03:20:07.000
Right, right, right.
2450
03:20:07.040 --> 03:20:09.581
But we're not trying to repel an invasion to the continent.
2451
03:20:10.562 --> 03:20:11.302
Okay.
2452
03:20:11.322 --> 03:20:14.844
So that makes more sense in terms of beefing up the ADF's numbers.
2453
03:20:15.885 --> 03:20:27.452
Because what you'd want is an army, in rough terms, about a 60,000 army around, and an air force of 20,000 roughly, and a navy of 20,000 roughly, and...
2454
03:20:28.352 --> 03:20:29.653
They're very much at the low end.
2455
03:20:29.953 --> 03:20:38.397
And then probably through reserve service and or national service, the ability to probably double those numbers in relatively short order.
2456
03:20:38.837 --> 03:20:45.060
So you get to an army of about 100,000 or so and Navy and Air Force of roughly 50,000 each.
2457
03:20:45.840 --> 03:20:47.201
Sorry, absolute last question.
2458
03:20:47.221 --> 03:20:53.604
Do you know what kind of increase we'd need in migration levels to achieve that extra 5 million by 2050?
2459
03:20:55.996 --> 03:20:58.038
Hmm.
2460
03:20:58.238 --> 03:21:02.102
It wouldn't be that much because of the compounding effect.
2461
03:21:02.122 --> 03:21:04.625
So I'd need to look at the numbers.
2462
03:21:04.745 --> 03:21:04.985
Okay.
2463
03:21:05.165 --> 03:21:10.230
But I would have thought you wouldn't be far off that with a permanent program of 190 to 200,000, I think.
2464
03:21:10.391 --> 03:21:10.671
Okay.
2465
03:21:10.691 --> 03:21:11.131
Yeah.
2466
03:21:12.272 --> 03:21:15.616
I think because you get generational benefits.
2467
03:21:15.636 --> 03:21:16.417
People have children.
2468
03:21:16.437 --> 03:21:16.537
Yeah.
2469
03:21:17.737 --> 03:21:22.119
depending on fertility, they have at least two, if not three children.
2470
03:21:22.239 --> 03:21:39.367
So you'd want to crunch the numbers, but I don't think you'd be that far off that extra 5 million over, what is it, a 25-year period with a program of around 200,000 maybe, but I'm really just taking a stab at that.
2471
03:21:40.678 --> 03:21:48.580
Which is above our long-run historical average since the Howard years, which has been about 180 thereabouts.
2472
03:21:48.600 --> 03:21:51.021
So you're looking to put 10,000 to 20,000 on top.
2473
03:21:51.121 --> 03:21:52.241
Yeah, got it.
2474
03:21:52.801 --> 03:21:53.821
Well, we'd better leave it there.
2475
03:21:53.862 --> 03:21:56.662
This has been a truly fantastic conversation, Mike.
2476
03:21:56.702 --> 03:21:57.442
Thank you so much.
2477
03:21:57.482 --> 03:21:57.903
Thanks, Joe.
2478
03:21:57.943 --> 03:21:58.723
I've really enjoyed it.
2479
03:21:58.763 --> 03:21:59.123
Thank you.
2480
03:21:59.843 --> 03:22:00.083
Done.
2481
03:22:00.343 --> 03:22:00.823
Thank you, sir.
2482
03:22:01.323 --> 03:22:01.704
Thank you.
2483
03:22:01.724 --> 03:22:02.304
Appreciate it.
2484
03:22:03.504 --> 03:22:04.786
I hope you enjoyed this episode.
2485
03:22:04.926 --> 03:22:11.936
If you did, you can support the show by leaving a five-star rating on Apple Podcasts or Spotify, or by subscribing on YouTube.
2486
03:22:12.356 --> 03:22:20.327
Thanks to this episode's sponsors, you can find them in the episode description, and thanks to Bill Manos and the Manos Foundation for their generous patronage of the show.
2487
03:22:20.948 --> 03:22:30.211
If you'd like to become a sponsor or patron, you can go to jnwpod.com slash sponsor or email me at joe at jnwpod.com.
2488
03:22:30.711 --> 03:22:34.452
That's J-O-E at J-N-W-P-O-D dot com.
2489
03:22:35.012 --> 03:22:35.792
Thanks for listening.
2490
03:22:35.953 --> 03:22:36.753
Until next time.
2491
03:22:36.973 --> 03:22:37.233
Ciao.