TRANSKRIPT 🔗
[0:01] Welcome to the e-commerce IP report.
[0:06] Hello everyone, and welcome to the e-commerce IP report
[0:09] with Adam or Ban Check.
[0:12] Adam is the principal attorney at AU LLC,
[0:15] a Chicago law firm focused on intellectual property litigation,
[0:19] e-commerce disputes, and helping businesses
[0:21] protect their brands in a rapidly evolving marketplace.
[0:24] I'm Sean O'Connor and today, Adam and I are discussing
[0:27] what Amazon sellers should do after receiving
[0:30] a Schedule A lawsuit.
[0:32] Adam, good to see you.
[0:34] Good morning, Sean.
[0:36] Hey, let's, since this is the inaugural episode,
[0:39] let's start by cluing listeners in on,
[0:44] how you got into this particular practice area,
[0:47] e-commerce, intellectual property,
[0:50] give them a little background, and we'll go from there.
[0:54] Sure, so our practice was founded back in 2012.
[0:58] I'm a registered patent attorney for the USPTO,
[1:01] so we were handling intellectual property matters
[1:05] come generally, probably more in the prosecution side.
[1:08] And then perhaps around 2017, 2018 or so,
[1:14] we started representing, probably by virtue
[1:17] of the fact that our office is located in Chicago,
[1:20] in which the US District Court
[1:21] for the Northern District of Illinois is located,
[1:24] that is a bit of a ground zero
[1:28] for Schedule A litigation throughout the country.
[1:32] Other courts, it occurs in other courts too,
[1:34] but that's most of the cases which have been filed
[1:38] in this vein had been filed there.
[1:41] So we just, perhaps happened to be in the location
[1:46] where it was happening.
[1:47] And then by virtue of regular SEO
[1:49] and then referral business,
[1:51] we picked up more and more clients
[1:53] and we've been doing it in earnest since then.
[1:57] Our practice has been representing many, many,
[2:01] of course, predominantly foreign Chinese resellers
[2:04] who are involved in these types of cases.
[2:07] And then we represented some plaintiffs,
[2:09] so on the other side of the aisle two,
[2:12] with the same types of claims
[2:13] and facing the same type of procedural questions
[2:15] and jurisdictional questions.
[2:17] Got it, that's helpful, helpful.
[2:20] So let's start, I would just once a Schedule A lawsuit,
[2:24] and why are Amazon sellers so frequently targeted by them?
[2:28] Well, Amazon sellers are targeted by them.
[2:31] I guess by virtue of the fact that Amazon
[2:33] is going to be the largest marketplace.
[2:38] And at least, we're talking about the United States.
[2:41] Those payment accounts on Amazon,
[2:42] US platform are going to be reachable
[2:44] by temporary restraining order
[2:47] or court judgment that issues from a US district court.
[2:50] There are other marketplaces
[2:51] that also operate here in the United States
[2:55] for just Shopify, there's eBay, there's Walmart.
[2:58] Yeah, you know, Teemo is, as a newer one.
[3:02] There have been others that have come and down on two.
[3:04] Like, I guess wish might still be around.
[3:07] I think there's machine is around two.
[3:10] So that has changed.
[3:12] What hasn't changed is Amazon being the 800 pound gorilla
[3:16] in the EAM or something like, of course.
[3:18] So that's the biggest market.
[3:20] That's where most of the activity authentic or otherwise
[3:27] is occurring.
[3:28] So most of the time, the defendant profile
[3:32] in these cases are going to be Amazon sellers.
[3:35] But there are still other, there's no shortage of Walmart sellers
[3:39] or Teemo sellers or Sheen sellers
[3:43] or businesses that have Shopify accounts
[3:45] are also located and are also find themselves
[3:48] in the receiving end of these texts of schedule a lawsuits.
[3:53] It's, what's a schedule a lawsuit?
[3:56] For me, am I,
[3:59] it's going to be an intellectual property lawsuit.
[4:03] So there'll be trademark infringement claims,
[4:05] copyright infringement claims, design patent
[4:08] infringement claims, utility patent infringement claims
[4:10] to a lesser extent, against a group of sellers
[4:13] who most of the time are anonymous at the outset
[4:17] in the case for a couple of reasons.
[4:20] But those are organized in a schedule or an exhibit.
[4:26] So the schedule is really a type of exhibit
[4:28] that is itemized in some fashion.
[4:30] So they call it a schedule A.
[4:31] And there was some convention started years ago
[4:35] where they just called it schedule A,
[4:37] I guess, for some practical purpose.
[4:39] And hence everybody just says this schedule A
[4:42] could be exhibit a lawsuits, it could, okay.
[4:46] So it's just some, you know, a term of art
[4:48] within the trade, so to speak, that came about.
[4:51] I wasn't sure if I was missing something there, I get it.
[4:54] Sure.
[4:56] So as far as the type of the litigation is,
[4:59] and it's been covered recently, quite a bit as a result of,
[5:05] at least from the academic, from the academic lens,
[5:08] some criticism over how the case is proceed.
[5:14] And there's, there are different views on that.
[5:19] But the basic of a schedule A lawsuit is a rights holder,
[5:24] whether a copyright holder or a trademark right holder
[5:27] or a patent holder or something.
[5:28] They're going after a group of defendants all at the same time.
[5:33] In one case, alleging that based on the profile
[5:39] of the defendants that they're going to be related,
[5:42] and thus the court is permitted to join them in one lawsuit.
[5:45] Okay.
[5:46] The cases filed simultaneously with the filing,
[5:50] the rights holder will file a motion
[5:52] for a temporary restraining order under seal,
[5:55] or though in addition to sealing certain aspects
[5:58] of the case filing.
[5:59] So like the schedule A itself, the list of defendants,
[6:02] that's usually going to be sealed,
[6:05] go be a motion for a temporary restraining order
[6:07] that will, that is intended to force or order
Load full transcript
the platforms
[6:11] to take the offending list things down,
[6:14] locate assets that are associated with the accused's sales.
[6:18] You know, restrain those, allow for some expedited discoveries
[6:23] so the plaintiff can figure out who the defendants are.
[6:26] Initially, from the platform itself,
[6:28] because the platform will have those defendants registration
[6:32] information, ostensibly the address and a point of contact,
[6:35] things like that.
[6:37] The defendable or the plaintiff will also ask for leave
[6:41] to serve the defendants electronically via email,
[6:44] and not have to go through the tremendous hassle
[6:47] or it might be practically impossible for a couple of reasons.
[6:50] To actually knock on doors and hand people,
[6:53] pay to deliver in Shenzhen, that can be an issue.
[6:56] So there's motion practice on that,
[6:59] there's motion practice on everything else.
[7:01] Those requests are going to be supported by some evidence.
[7:04] So, you know, you file a lawsuit,
[7:07] you're generally not going to have to plead your evidence
[7:10] for most contacts,
[7:13] but if you're asking the court for some extraordinary relief
[7:17] under rule 65, you're in federal court,
[7:20] you're going to need to bring some evidence
[7:21] and then show the court that, you know,
[7:23] you're likely to succeed on these claims.
[7:25] So you should do XYZ, that evidence is going to be
[7:29] most of the time screenshots of listings
[7:33] that show the infringing activity.
[7:36] Other candy pictures of test spies
[7:38] that investigate or the plaintiff's investigator
[7:41] or their attorney's order into the jurisdiction,
[7:46] they'll identify what's wrong with them.
[7:48] Like these are inauthentic for XYZ reasons
[7:51] or these products are infringing the plaintiff's patent
[7:54] for these reasons in a claim chart or something like that.
[7:58] That's submitted to the court along with the rule 65 motion,
[8:03] along with the declaration from somebody on the plaintiff's side
[8:05] saying that this is what it is and this is true.
[8:08] The court will review all that, make a determination,
[8:12] and then what the plaintiff is looking for
[8:15] is a temporary restraining order
[8:16] that will command the plaintiffs to shut things down temporarily,
[8:21] at least temporarily, and then allow for some expedited discovery.
[8:25] And then at that point, the defendants are made aware
[8:27] of what's going on because, hey, I can't access my Amazon.
[8:31] Yeah, I was going to ask you, how did they,
[8:33] how did they find, you mentioned, you know, serving via email,
[8:37] I was wondering how these sellers find out
[8:39] that they're named in one of these suits.
[8:41] Is it just like one day they wake up
[8:43] and their shop isn't working?
[8:47] Yeah, that's going to be most of it.
[8:49] That's going to be the first thing to hear about.
[8:50] So, you know, the platforms respond to those orders
[8:56] more or less properly.
[8:57] I see for the most part, like Amazon,
[9:00] if they're receiving a TRO,
[9:02] they're going to act in just a couple of days.
[9:04] That's going to be quick.
[9:05] But Amazon, again, is enormous.
[9:07] They have a large team that's dedicated
[9:11] to just processing TRO since the penis and all of that.
[9:14] So they can turn around that activity pretty quickly.
[9:18] Other platforms may not be as responsive.
[9:22] You know, in our experience, you know, Walmart takes
[9:24] a little bit more time.
[9:25] Team move is pretty prompt.
[9:27] She is pretty prompt too, but then other platforms
[9:31] that may or may not exist any longer didn't respond as well.
[9:35] Probably for some big logistical reasons.
[9:37] They did.
[9:37] They know the infrastructure, right?
[9:40] So, yeah, they're going to find out about,
[9:42] you know, the defendant is going to find out what's going on
[9:44] because the platform sends them a note saying,
[9:47] hey, we received this, we received some notification
[9:50] from X, Y, Z court.
[9:52] Here is the, the plaintiff's attorney's contact information.
[9:55] Reach out to them.
[9:56] Here's the case number and then that's it.
[9:58] And that'll happen,
[9:59] I mean, that'll happen before even electronic services
[10:03] made presuming the court allows the plaintiff to do that.
[10:06] Right.
[10:07] So that's going to be the first couple of days.
[10:08] So usually after the tarot is entered,
[10:10] you would send it on the plaintiff's side.
[10:12] You send it to the platform.
[10:14] You might, you might start hearing from defendants
[10:17] as asking what's going on or they're apologizing or whatever.
[10:22] That might happen in just a couple of days.
[10:24] Yeah.
[10:25] Are there, are there mistakes, you know,
[10:28] the sellers make mistakes in the first few days
[10:30] after learning that they've been sued that you've seen?
[10:34] Yes, I think probably typical of defendants in other cases.
[10:42] Maybe, you know, they,
[10:45] they, what they might do is understand it's a problem
[10:49] and in haste to get over the issue
[10:52] and have the matter resolved
[10:54] and just get on with their storefront
[10:58] because they have some,
[10:59] they have some storefront and they're selling
[11:01] a certain amount of money,
[11:03] a certain amount of every month or every day.
[11:05] Or so business, right.
[11:06] Their priority is getting that up and running
[11:09] and having access to those funds
[11:10] because they need that to order inventory and so on.
[11:13] So what they may do is reach out to the plaintiff's council
[11:18] and I guess one, admit, acknowledge and or admit
[11:24] that what they did is violating any of the plaintiff's rights.
[11:30] Maybe misunderstand this, you know,
[11:33] misunderstand exactly what they're being accused of
[11:36] because you know, once they receive the notification,
[11:40] you know, once the TRO's entered the platform
[11:43] will notify the seller
[11:45] that they're involved as a defendant in a suit.
[11:48] They'll usually provide say the case number
[11:50] and most, probably most courts, most cases,
[11:54] at least the complaint is going to be unsealed
[11:58] and then there will be portions of the file,
[12:02] the pleadings, like the schedule A,
[12:05] maybe the exhibit to the complaint
[12:07] that contains the intellectual property rights at issue.
[12:11] So yeah, the aunt itself, that might be in the sale.
[12:15] The trademark registration that's being enforced,
[12:18] that might be it under sale.
[12:20] The plaintiff does that because they don't want
[12:21] to have that stuff public and then tip off
[12:25] so seller communities.
[12:27] So they see that the day it's filed
[12:30] and then they take actions that might
[12:33] vitiate some of what the plaintiff is trying to do.
[12:35] Right.
[12:36] In other cases, in other courts,
[12:38] they will allow the entire case to be sealed.
[12:40] So you're not, you know, even if you have a piece or a con,
[12:43] for example, in your defendant,
[12:44] your relatively sophisticated,
[12:46] you're not gonna be able to dig up exactly what's going on.
[12:49] So you know, a mistake might be reaching out too quickly
[12:54] before you have a firm grasp of what you're being accused of.
[12:58] Right.
[12:58] And just apologizing,
[13:02] or you're acknowledging making admissions
[13:04] to the plaintiff's attorney that you did something.
[13:07] Yeah.
[13:09] You know, as the seller,
[13:10] you might have an idea of,
[13:11] I guess you should have an idea of what you're selling.
[13:14] At least, I'm aware that we have these a sins.
[13:17] Maybe you didn't know that there was a problem
[13:20] with some aspects of the listing
[13:23] or you pulled some photos off of 1688.com.
[13:26] And you didn't,
[13:27] if you didn't take a good look to see that the flood pants,
[13:30] the girls wearing have a swoosh on it.
[13:32] You're just kind of, like,
[13:34] maybe that's what you did.
[13:35] And that, I think that's what happens.
[13:37] That's what happens.
[13:39] Maybe, you know,
[13:41] I helped the majority of the time.
[13:42] So say 60% and all right.
[13:44] Just sloppy,
[13:45] just sloppy lazy,
[13:47] co-opting images.
[13:49] Then you could, I don't know,
[13:52] maybe it's sloppy.
[13:53] I think, if you're an e-commerce seller,
[13:57] you want to sell lots of products,
[13:58] you're chasing trends necessarily.
[14:01] Yeah.
[14:01] Most sellers are not conglomerates
[14:05] and not like huge organizations to sell right.
[14:08] I think a lot of it can be,
[14:10] can be not for a given in the context.
[14:13] It's not, you know,
[14:14] they're still responsible for it.
[14:16] But maybe it's understandable
[14:17] how it happens very often.
[14:18] Yeah.
[14:19] It's not a vast conspiracy per se.
[14:22] No, I wouldn't say it's a vast conspiracy.
[14:24] No.
[14:25] And a political
sense.
[14:26] No.
[14:27] No.
[14:28] That being said,
[14:30] I mean, there are organizations
[14:32] to use that term very loosely that do,
[14:36] you know,
[14:37] intellectual property infringement and counterfeiting
[14:39] and fake goods is a significant problem.
[14:43] And that's now undeniable.
[14:45] And the amount of money who is just in the United States,
[14:48] that's lost to sales of goods that are inauthentic
[14:53] is intense.
[14:54] Ends in tens of billions of dollars.
[14:55] Every year,
[14:56] CPP is publishing reports over what their seizures are.
[15:01] And that's what percentage of the things they see.
[15:04] Yeah, that's what they got.
[15:05] Yeah.
[15:06] That's what they got.
[15:07] Like the Georgia trade almost.
[15:09] Right.
[15:10] Well, these musts are great.
[15:11] But, you know,
[15:12] if that's how much you're getting,
[15:13] how much you're not getting is more alarming.
[15:15] So it's a serious problem.
[15:19] It's just, you know,
[15:20] in our experience on the defense side,
[15:22] it's, it's not tremendously willful.
[15:25] It might be, you know, reckless.
[15:27] I guess they just didn't know.
[15:29] But then there are other defendants
[15:30] who absolutely know what they're doing.
[15:32] And it is deliberate.
[15:34] And are some fingerprints
[15:35] and that kind of behavior too.
[15:36] So it goes both ways.
[15:39] Yeah.
[15:40] No, I get that.
[15:41] What could happen?
[15:43] Let's say a seller's business
[15:45] or marketplace, you know, they're suspended.
[15:48] What happens if they don't respond quickly?
[15:50] If they wait,
[15:52] so if I'm, if I'm a,
[15:54] a defendant on Amazon,
[15:55] I'm selling Amazon.
[15:56] And I get a notification from Amazon
[15:58] that one of my listings was shut down.
[16:00] My accounts frozen.
[16:01] I decide not to do anything.
[16:04] Either I decide that to do anything
[16:06] or,
[16:08] or perhaps I have a number of storefronts
[16:11] and I just miss the email.
[16:14] Yeah, because they have a lot
[16:15] of stuff going on.
[16:16] And I just missed it.
[16:17] Yeah.
[16:18] And I can't manage all of these storefronts
[16:20] and all of these asins every single day.
[16:23] Yeah.
[16:24] And I have all of these accounts.
[16:25] And maybe one of them had $500 in it.
[16:28] And that's not really putting a dent in my cash flow.
[16:31] So like,
[16:32] oh, yeah.
[16:33] I had no idea because we're doing this.
[16:35] We're doing XYZ volume.
[16:37] And it didn't,
[16:39] you know, it didn't.
[16:42] It wasn't that impactful.
[16:43] Yeah.
[16:44] If they don't act quickly, I suppose, you know,
[16:47] once they find out about the case,
[16:49] you know, most of the time,
[16:50] it's because the terror was entered.
[16:52] So that's going to be a restraint
[16:54] that the account is imposing.
[16:58] That the platform is imposing on the account.
[17:01] And they can object to, you know,
[17:04] they can move to, you know,
[17:06] vacate it for one or more reasons.
[17:09] The temporary restraining order is temporary.
[17:13] And if the rights holder wants to continue that restraint,
[17:16] they'll have to convert that into a temporary,
[17:19] a preliminary junction.
[17:21] Effectively, at some point,
[17:22] usually it's going to be 14 or 28 days later.
[17:25] The court, you know,
[17:26] the rights holder might move to extend the TRO
[17:30] for another 14 days if they're waiting on discovery.
[17:34] That's like lagging from a particular platform,
[17:36] or is there some order behind to serve everybody?
[17:39] But if they don't respond again,
[17:42] then I guess the, you know,
[17:44] the preliminary junction will be entered.
[17:46] And then that is going to be restraining everything
[17:49] for the duration of the litigation.
[17:52] God, if they still don't do anything after they're served,
[17:55] at some point, the plaintiff will move for entry
[17:57] of the default judgment.
[17:58] It's maybe like a move for entry of default
[18:00] and a different course handle it a bit differently.
[18:03] But the plaintiff will be asking the court
[18:05] to have the court entered default
[18:08] for the defendants who haven't responded
[18:10] in the 21-day period.
[18:13] And then at some point, sometimes coincidentally
[18:15] with that request or sometime after that request,
[18:18] the plaintiff will ask the court to enter a default judgment
[18:20] in which the court is going to be, you know,
[18:23] granting the plaintiff the relief it's seeking,
[18:27] at least from a junked of standpoint.
[18:29] You know, the plaintiff can be asking for,
[18:32] you know, maximum statutory damages or whatever.
[18:35] But, you know,
[18:36] it does mean the court is going to just grant that automatically.
[18:40] But once that's entered, then you have this judgment.
[18:44] Then the plaintiff will take the judgment
[18:46] and send that back to the platform and ask the platform,
[18:48] you know, liquidate, you know,
[18:50] you know, permanently shut the ASINs,
[18:52] if you're on Amazon, for example,
[18:54] shut the ASINs down,
[18:56] and then liquidate the account, whatever's in there,
[18:59] up to the judgment award.
[19:01] And then if there are other, you know,
[19:03] email addresses or other contact information
[19:05] that was disclosed by the platform,
[19:07] the plaintiff can then sort of march around,
[19:09] platform to platform,
[19:11] they might ask PayPal, hey,
[19:13] did you, have you seen the email address?
[19:16] Can you identify any accounts associated with the email address?
[19:18] Okay, great.
[19:19] How much is in that account?
[19:20] And they'll just, you know,
[19:21] seek to enforce the judgment there.
[19:24] Now, at what point have you not acted, you know,
[19:27] at what point it's not that you're acting,
[19:28] it's not that you're not acting quickly.
[19:30] It's just disregarding the matter entirely.
[19:32] Right.
[19:33] There's
a line to draw out there.
[19:35] Right.
[19:38] But, you know, surely you,
[19:40] all defendants will want to avoid a default judgment.
[19:43] Yeah, yeah.
[19:44] Well, that's, that's,
[19:45] that's definitely a goal.
[19:47] I get it.
[19:48] I get it.
[19:49] Well, Adam, with the, you know,
[19:50] we've got just a couple of minutes left.
[19:51] I want to, I want to just sort of
[19:53] shift in a little bit and ask you,
[19:55] you know, for,
[19:56] for folks listening out there,
[19:58] is there anything Amazon sellers can do proactively,
[20:02] you know, to reduce the risk of ending up
[20:04] in one of these lawsuits in the first,
[20:06] in the first place?
[20:07] Can you, can you give a couple of best practices real quick?
[20:11] The thing you avoid, you notice what we find on the trend
[20:14] inside,
[20:15] what gets clients in trouble the most is
[20:20] taking content from supplier websites,
[20:23] like 1688.com,
[20:25] and then just copying,
[20:26] basing it.
[20:27] I mean, that's,
[20:28] that that's something I know it's,
[20:30] it's 2026.
[20:31] Nobody should be doing that.
[20:34] Going online and copying things,
[20:36] whether it's Google Images,
[20:38] or it's something on a website,
[20:40] don't be copying and pasting anything.
[20:42] Don't be taking photographs from listings
[20:45] and then repurposing them.
[20:46] Right.
[20:47] They may look professional
[20:48] and great.
[20:49] You may,
[20:50] you may just be interested in reselling those products.
[20:53] So there's a,
[20:54] so there's a supplier.
[20:55] You want to just pull that stuff
[20:57] from overseas and then sell it through your Amazon storefront.
[21:00] Don't take the listing photographs.
[21:03] If it's all possible,
[21:05] they might be subject,
[21:06] they're going to be,
[21:07] if you didn't take the photographs,
[21:08] they're going to be subject to somebody else's copy.
[21:10] Very interesting.
[21:11] Yeah.
[21:12] If it's copy,
[21:13] if it's a website copy,
[21:14] or like listing copy,
[21:15] the copyright protection
[21:16] and that might be vanishing,
[21:18] it might exist.
[21:19] That might be vanishingly thin.
[21:21] But you,
[21:22] you're going to want to make sure you read it.
[21:24] And there could be trademarks buried in there.
[21:27] Sure.
[21:28] You may not appreciate.
[21:29] Not everything is Nike
[21:31] or Lou Lemon
[21:33] or Louis Vuitton.
[21:34] There are,
[21:35] you know,
[21:36] millions of copper or trademark registrations.
[21:38] Sure.
[21:39] Many which are for things that aren't that remarkable
[21:42] and you,
[21:43] you could miss.
[21:44] You may not appreciate.
[21:46] Well,
[21:47] best practice is just to have everything original to you
[21:49] and to write your own stuff.
[21:51] That's,
[21:53] that's the number one thing to do.
[21:55] Okay.
[21:56] And second, you know,
[21:57] if you are on the,
[21:58] if you do find yourself on the receiving end,
[22:00] definitely do some research before you,
[22:03] you know,
[22:04] you would ever reach out to the plaintiffs council
[22:06] if that's even advisable.
[22:07] Right.
[22:08] Or, you know,
[22:09] we have chat GPT.
[22:10] We have,
[22:11] you know,
[22:12] if you have,
[22:13] if you have any kind of a platform,
[22:14] you have access to the internet.
[22:15] There's a lot of information available about these types of cases.
[22:17] They've been going on for
[22:18] 10 or 15.
[22:19] Yeah.
[22:20] We have.
[22:21] We've been doing it for coming on 10 years or so.
[22:23] We've been involved.
[22:24] And it was going on.
[22:26] Probably going back to like 2006,
[22:28] maybe any odds.
[22:29] Not to the same volume,
[22:31] but there's a lot of information.
[22:33] Don't race to do something
[22:36] because you're interested in getting the store back up and running.
[22:38] At least it almost anything.
[22:40] Educate yourself a little bit.
[22:42] And then reach out to Cal, you know,
[22:44] reach out to,
[22:45] to Calisol and ask for some options.
[22:46] Got it.
[22:47] Got it.
[22:48] Well, thanks Adam.
[22:49] Sorry to cut you off.
[22:51] We're out of time.
[22:52] But good stuff for sure.
[22:54] Great.
[22:55] Great talking to you.
[22:56] Thanks for sharing your expertise.
[22:58] And I look forward to future conversations.
[23:01] Sure.
[23:02] Thanks for your time.
[23:03] That's it for this episode of the e-commerce IP report
[23:06] with Adam or Ban Check.
[23:08] To learn more about Adam's practice,
[23:10] visit AU-LLC.com.
[23:13] Thanks for listening and do us a favor.
[23:16] Leave us a review.
[23:17] Subscribe to the podcast.
[23:19] Maybe share a link with someone in your world
[23:21] who would find this content helpful.
[23:23] I'm Sean O'Connor.
[23:24] Have a great day.
[23:28] Thanks for watching.
[23:29] Be sure to hit that like
[23:30] and subscribe button.
[23:31] And leave us a review in the comments.