TRANSKRIPT 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: So I want to give you a quick update on the key coalition talks. Seeing that from sometime this week, some councils will be seating. Remember, councils have until Friday next week to hold their first meetings where mayors would be selected. The DA and the ANC have finally met. Action SA and the DA have met. Action SA and the ANC have also met, which really are the parties that I think here in Gauteng are likely to be key in deciding what will unfold in our metro. So let's start with Jordan Hill-Lewis, who is the leader of the Democratic Alliance. Thank you so much, Jordan, for making time for us. Good morning.
00:00:37
Speaker 2: No problem, Clement. Nice to be with you. Good morning to you and all the listeners.
00:00:40
Speaker 1: You finally met with the ANC. Was it yesterday? How did the talks go? Did they yield any decisions?
00:00:48
Speaker 2: No, they went very well. It was a very long engagement, I think over three hours. And, you know, I think very constructive in the main. Obviously, some points of... shall we say, constructive disagreement and some points of agreement. But, you know, the overall message, Clement, is that even though we've been hard at work at this for a week already, it is still relatively early days. I know that the clock is ticking, but this, I think, is going to be the crucial week where we start to move beyond the initial icebreaker discussions and into some detailed discussions. And I think that is what we can expect to start to ramp up significantly in pace in the coming days.
00:01:36
Speaker 1: So live it up to the last week, eh? Did the ANC negotiators relay the message from the NEC, though, that the DA must be a coalition of, quote-unquote, last resort?
00:01:49
Speaker 2: Well, yes, I mean … The sentiments from the NEC are clear and were made clear, but I also don't want to get into the confidential nature of what's discussed in the boardroom. Our pledge to all of these parties is that the detail of those discussions will remain confidential. We don't negotiate through the media until we publish our coalition agreements, which we have committed to publishing at the appropriate time. But suffice to say that there is still a lot to discuss. We've got a lot of detailed work to do this week, and we will do that.
00:02:25
Speaker 1: Action SA seems to still be sticking to its condition that Helen Ziller can be Johannesbeck mayor. They're willing to give you Johannesbeck and Ekuruleni as long as you drop Helen in Johannesbeck and choose someone else. Is that something you're considering?
00:02:41
Speaker 2: Well, you know, we have to consider the demands of and all the requirements or stipulations, I'm not sure what the correct word is, of all of our potential partners. I don't want to rule out any of our potential partners. We also had a very productive meeting with MKP, which a lot of people were surprised about, let's say. But I think in the past, we have we have mistakenly sent a clear signal that we don't have any options because we're refusing to talk to the so-and-so. And I disagree with that. Our prospective partners must know that we do have other options and we do have other cards to play. So we've had productive conversations with all of them. And yes, we are still very far apart on a number of things, that being one of them. But that does not mean that we are shutting off those engagements. I think that there is a lot of potential for us to work with ASA. And we just have to keep talking to each other until we can find one another. And we are committed to doing that constructively.
00:03:47
Speaker 1: Okay, just to make sure that I understand you well, you're not necessarily closing the door to the condition or demand, whatever you want to call it, that Action SA has put before you, that drop Helen. And that's something you are considering as the DA.
00:04:02
Speaker 2: I think it goes without saying that that's extraordinarily difficult for us to swallow. And I'm not sure that it would be right to the people of Johannesburg who voted, certainly a plurality of people of Johannesburg voted for Helen. What I am saying clearly is that I don't like this concept of red lines and throwing around the phrase no deal. I just don't think that that's a good basis for negotiations. You can start out very, very far from one another. And you can slowly but surely, inch by inch, make your way to find one another somewhere in the middle. And my sincere hope is that we can carry on that conversation. And I think that we will to get to that point.
00:04:47
Speaker 1: If the ANC goes with Action SA and the EFF, does this affect the GNU? Will you then review that at national level?
00:04:56
Speaker 2: I think that is a question that the party will have to confront. I want to be honest about that. I think there will be a lot of people in the DA that will say, we have tried to put together a stable national government in the national interest to try and begin the turnaround of the South African economy. Not that it is going nearly as well as it should go, but it is going better than it was. And If that show of good faith is spurned or is just thrown to the ground, then what does that mean for a national partnership? I certainly believe that there will be people asking that question. I can't speculate as to what the decision of the party will be in the coming months, but I can guarantee that that question will be raised, and I think it will be a tense time. But nevertheless, that is not going to color my focus now. My focus now is what gives us the best chance of putting together governments that are stable, that can get these cities working. That is the overwhelming message that residents in those cities sent. They are sick and tired of everything being broken and not working, and they want to begin a turnaround. There's lots and lots of analysis out there about the deeper political trends and the bigger, wider political messages. Actually,
Load full transcript
it's quite simple. All those cities are broken. Voters want them fixed. That is the overwhelming bright light message that was sent in this election. And we want to try and put together governments that can start to do that.
00:06:36
Speaker 1: Yeah. You did indicate it earlier that a lot of people are surprised that you spoke to the MK party. Well, they are surprised because as the DA, you know, you had said that you don't want to work with the EFF or the MK party. You know, you described them as, you know, the ANC EFF MK party as a doomsday coalition. So is it fair to say that view has now changed from the DA side?
00:06:59
Speaker 2: Well, I believe firmly that what it does is it kneecaps your negotiating strategy. When you say to your other potential partners, we do not have any options. You are our only option because we refuse to talk to these other people. And I don't think it helps in this new world that we live in of coalitions, which is here to stay. It doesn't help to anathematize, if that's a word. Maybe I just made that up. Anathematize other potential political partners in a coalition. The voters have said, you must work together in coalitions. And so it might be the case that after discussion on the basis of our principles and what we want to achieve in government, we decide actually there's no good faith partnership to be had here. But I don't think that as a point of departure, we should close ourselves off to any options and send the signal to everyone else that actually we're limiting ourselves. We should not do that. That's a very bad way to do these negotiations.
00:08:02
Speaker 1: All right. Jordan Hill-Lewis, thank you so much for chatting to us and all the best with the rest of the talks this week.
00:08:08
Speaker 2: Thank you very much. Sure.
00:08:09
Speaker 1: Jordan Hill-Lewis is the leader of the Democratic Alliance. Interesting that now it seems he says he disagreed with the position the DA had taken to close the door to conversations with the EFF and the MK Party. I mean, even if you remember what happened when Hemin Mashabu was mayor in Johannesburg, Helen Ziller, who was one of the leaders at the time, kept calling him a what, an EFF mayor of sorts and criticized the relationship he had with the EFF. So it's always been the position of the DA, but under Jordan Hill Lewis, that seems to be changing. Let's bring in now Michael Beaumont, who is actually an SA's chairperson, who's joining us here in studio. Michael, thanks for also chatting to us. Good morning. Clement, good morning.
00:08:50
Speaker 3: It's good to be speaking with you and your listeners.
00:08:52
Speaker 1: So you've met with the ANC twice. I'll get to the DA in a moment, but you've met with the ANC twice now. Are you getting somewhere with the talks now?
00:09:00
Speaker 3: Not as quickly as we'd like. I think coalition talks, you've got to move as fast as your slowest members. And certainly we are, I don't want to say impatient, but, you know, we're getting there. I think the South African people hate uncertainty. They've expressed themselves in elections and they want to see a future for their municipalities, given the state of hopelessness that they've been living under for so long. And I think there's an extent to which these things could be moving along quicker. But, you know, part of coalitions is appreciating not everyone sees the world you see it and you need to operate as a collective. And we'll continue engaging with patients in the hopes that that clarity will come. But certainly I can tell you if we had it our way, governance solutions would have already been announced. In fact, we are breaths away from announcing solutions in municipalities where we're in a position to do so.
00:09:51
Speaker 1: Yeah. But where are you leaning towards though? Is your best option the ANC on the da what's best for action sa.
00:09:58
Speaker 3: I think what's best for action sa is that we take these decisions on the merits of the municipality in question my preferred outcome would actually be that we're working with one configuration of parties in some areas and a different configuration in another you know there are a lot of hung councils clement 139 is a lot and that does create a tendency where people want to trade at a centralized level but You know, I think you can't be that irresponsible. Municipalities have their own distinct issues, communities, financial problems, service delivery backlogs and leadership credentials that need to be dealt with on their merit. So I think we want to see ourselves working with different configurations in different places. And that will demonstrate to me that as a party, we've applied our mind to this challenge consistently. And we've availed ourselves to the best solutions in the best places.
00:10:43
Speaker 1: What about here, though, in Gauteng? What do you think is best for Action SA, for stability and for services, for service delivery?
00:10:51
Speaker 3: Well, I mean, I don't want to sound too trite when I say this, but as many municipalities as possible led by Action SA. That's the point around the city of Twane and the story that's emerged from that particular election. I think from that point of view, we are engaging both the ANC and the DA.
00:11:06
Speaker 1: Mm-hmm.
00:11:07
Speaker 3: We are amenable to coalition solutions on both sides of the aisle, so to speak. But really, we want to examine with whom those political parties will be. Can we agree on a service delivery agenda and financial stabilization plans, both of which are essential to the long term turnaround of these municipalities that will not happen overnight? And clearly, it's going to have to be a number of days more. of talks with both parties before we can make a determination in that regard.
00:11:34
Speaker 1: Um, do, do you, are you still sticking to your, I don't know what to call it. Is it a demand? Is it a condition? Is it a request for Helen Zillett to be dropped as,
um, as, as, as a mayoral candidate for Johannesburg for the democratic alliance? As you heard, Jordan Hill Lewis seems to think that, well, we must consider all the demands of all the potential partners, but is that still your request slash demand slash condition?
00:12:00
Speaker 3: Yeah, I, like Jordan, want to avoid using the terms red lines and conditions because you can't negotiate if you walk in there and just hold a situation hostage and say this or nothing else. But certainly we feel very strongly about it. And there's a reason why it's often mischaracterized in the media to say that this is a personality thing.
00:12:17
Speaker 2: It's not.
00:12:18
Speaker 3: It's got nothing to do with personalities. It's got to do with the track record of leadership. We've adopted a policy framework for our negotiations. that has indicated we do not put in failed mayors back to lead municipalities. And I'm afraid that is a problem for Mr. Saleer's brink. His governance track record is up there with the likes of Cabelo Guamanda and Olisi Caunda and people like that, who in fact did less to damage their metros than he did. And, you know, in terms of Johannesburg, I regret to say that Helen Ziller has been at the heart of many collapses of stable and functioning coalition governments in Johannesburg. Even during this campaign campaign, She's been at pain to say, well, we're not going to do it under these circumstances or those. And we want to see coalition partners who are going to roll up their sleeves and do whatever is possible to provide five years of stable and effective government. And that's why these challenges exist. Having said that, the DA is welcome to come back to us and communicate what their ideas would be to solve the impasse, which includes, by the way, years of bad blood between these parties. It was just four weeks ago, Clement, that the DA had action to say in the Electoral Court deregistering us as a political party on the PR ballot. And I asked the question at the time, does anyone realize that Action USA's constituents are the ones who guard our coalition decisions? Because that court case was about disenfranchising our constituents. Very short-sighted thinking that has caused these problems, but it's not that it can't be solved. Okay.
00:13:43
Speaker 1: Okay. But just to make sure that I understand you then, is that still a red line? We don't use the word red line. Is it a demand? It's a request we put forward. So it's a request, but it doesn't sound like a request because a request, I mean, if you go, it's either this or that. It's not a request. It's a condition.
00:14:03
Speaker 3: I use the word very strong request for what it's worth. The point is this. We see a problem that manifests in these two municipalities regarding the track record of these two leaders. We see that problem. We are putting this forward as a solution to that problem. If the DA doesn't like our solution, they should come up with one of their own. That's
the way a negotiation works. But I do agree that it would be very hard for us to move off this position because I don't think Saleer's Brink has gotten any better at leading municipalities in the last couple of years.
00:14:32
Speaker 1: Okay. But is this the will you're willing to die on? So are you, if, I mean, if the DA comes up with any other solution that still has Helen Ziller in, maybe they say, we give you deputy mayor or we give you 60% or 50% of MMC positions. What would make, their proposal more attractive enough for you to drop this strong request?
00:14:57
Speaker 3: We need to hear whatever they have to propose. I think the problem in these discussions, Clement, is to have this hypothetical discussion regarding a proposal that hasn't been developed. It makes it very difficult for us. From our point of view, it would be very hard to see us moving beyond that request because the concerns we have are real. And it appears the version of the DA is simply, well, we'll just get over it. Well, you can't get over it because these are very serious problems, and I don't think these people have changed their ways in respect to their approach to coalition government. But let's hear what they have to say. Maybe they've got creative ideas. Maybe they've thought about ideas that we haven't even thought about yet. But it's impossible to plan out every scenario and hypothetic that hasn't yet even been delivered to us.
00:15:39
Speaker 1: Yeah, but do you think it's fair, though, to say that, you know, as Action SA, you have had these strong requests slash demands before, like with the ANC? You were very clear that that's not the party you want to work with. You came back and you worked with them. So this is not something that can be fixed.
00:15:55
Speaker 3: Look, positions on coalition are a flexible thing. You've got to appreciate that two years ago we found ourselves in a multi-party charter for South Africa with a group of parties that said we will never, ever go into coalition with the ANC. And within days of the election, the ink's still wet on the ballot papers. They were all in the GNU picking out corner offices in the union buildings. So we are in a situation right now in South Africa where the only political party that is not in coalition with the ANC in the entire country is MK. And it's not for a lack of effort either. The era of saying we don't work with this political party is gone. We need to be able to work with everyone. And the only yardstick that matters is does that government deliver stability and does it deliver services? I don't think people... are concerned about the color of the T-shirt that delivers services. They just want the services.
00:16:43
Speaker 1: But yet you still use Helen Zillow and say she's a racist. So how do you reconcile that? If you're saying people really right now just want proper service delivery, they don't care about the color of the T-shirt or who's running.
00:16:58
Speaker 3: You don't think a person's attitude towards race and inequality is important from the idea that services should be delivered to everyone?
00:17:04
Speaker 1: No, I think it is.
00:17:05
Speaker 3: Well, then you get my point because the question around whether a leader can be trusted to deliver services to everyone and not just the lucky few, becomes an important consideration. I know that because I used to be part of that political party once upon a time, Clement, when Herman Mashaba was the mayor of Joburg. And one of the greatest pressure points we had in our relationship with our own party was a pushback campaign within that party that said, stop wasting time delivering services to people who don't pay rates. Now, that kind of thinking is incongruent with Action SA's idea of how we would like to govern. So we can't say that questions of race and attitude towards inequality is irrelevant from a point of view of service delivery for all.
00:17:45
Speaker 1: How would you address that as Action SA, the issue of non-payment of rates and taxes?
00:17:50
Speaker 3: Well, I think every South African has constitutionally enshrined rights to services. In fact, I don't think it.
00:17:55
Speaker 1: I know it.
00:17:57
Speaker 3: And a government has the responsibility to deliver services to everyone. When you're looking at municipalities that have budgets exceeding 80 billion rand, Do we really have to treat this as an either-or, you know, a zero-sum game, one gets and one doesn't? I foresee a situation where the municipality can govern well for everyone. And certainly in some areas, the challenges are much larger and are going to take longer time.
00:18:19
Speaker 1: To be resolved.
00:18:20
Speaker 3: But every South African should be seeing progress in services and stability in their community or at a street corner near them. That's the goal we should be working towards because the turnaround of these cities is not going to happen overnight. We know this because we've been in government. We are more familiar with the inner workings of the city of Johannesburg than any other candidate who's standing in that election. And we know exactly how bad it's gotten and how much bigger that mountain has become to climb. And what's really important is that the person who steps in there hits the ground running and knows what they're going to be doing on day one to address it.
00:18:51
Speaker 1: Yeah. When do you think you're going to be done with the talks? Jordan says this is crunch time this week. Do you see like a Thursday? Is it next week? Is it next week, Friday? Because with the GNU, the statement of intent was actually finalized on the morning the president was actually elected.
00:19:09
Speaker 3: Yeah, it's very difficult for me to say. What I can say to you with certainty is if we had control over this, it would have been done already. But we don't have control over it. We're a component and a cog in the wheel. And therefore, we need to work with all the other cogs to
answer that question.
00:19:26
Speaker 1: But based on how advanced the talks are, though, I mean, what's the temperature like?
00:19:31
Speaker 3: I think it's still lukewarm in terms of progress. Unfortunately, Clement, a lot of political parties emerged from the election having not applied their minds to these questions and just started talking about these things seemingly for the first time, which is really odd. As a party, we went through that process before the elections. We set up negotiating teams. They were ready to be in province. the next day, but we found ourselves alone with no one to talk to yet. So everyone's operating at a different pace. We have to move as fast as the slowest member. Certainly, I think there's going to be council meetings in the majority of the metros in the middle of next week or so. So end of this week, preferably. Early next week, you know, at the latest, certainly.
00:20:12
Speaker 1: Certainly. Okay, let me read some of the messages that have come through on the WhatsApp line. Kyle says, Clement, Action SA seems to have changed their stance on their four conditions for coalitions, no corruption, financial discipline, service delivery, priorities. So why the ANC? Listen to the voters they want Zilla and Brink. Action SA are not the voters. That's a message there from Kyle. And then Lee says, Clement, I'm listening to Jordan Hill Lewis. I'm disappointed as it seems he's thinking of dropping the two mayoral candidates falling in line with a vengeful Haman Mashaba. Then I will be disgusted. Helen worked harder than anyone else in increasing the DA vote. Another one says, Clement, never mind who's working with who. How do we know they both won't allow corruption to further abuse the public purse? That's a message there from Chad. Michael, thank you so much for coming through and joining us and all the best with the talks.
00:21:09
Speaker 3: Thank you very much.
00:21:10
Speaker 1: Yeah, sure. It's 10.30. 10.32, we're wrapping up our conversation with Michael Beaumont, who is the chairperson of Action SA. I read a message from Kyle who was talking about the four conditions for coalitions for Action SA and how it seems like you've changed your stance, Michael. And then somebody else, was responding to the interview with Jordan Hill-Lewis, and they're disappointed that Jordan seems to be considering your strong request, to use your words. And then Chad was the last message I read, and Chad said, it doesn't matter who's working with who. How do we know they won't allow corruption to further abuse the public purse?
00:21:52
Speaker 3: So, I mean, just a couple of things. I mean, you know, we've got to get off this notion that some political parties are holy and some are not. And I say that because if you think working with the DA is the answer to financial stabilisation, than you had living under a rock, certainly as it relates to the city of Tswane. The city of Tswane finances that Dr. Nasipi Moya inherited from Silias Brink was literally bankrupt. Its liquidity was 0.4, ESCOM debt grew from 2020 to 2024 by 6.8 billion rand, and audit outcomes had regressed to adverse levels in the company of Buffalo City in Mangahung. This new government, which involves the ANC and the EFF, led by Action SA, has turned around every one of those indicators. moving it in the right direction. So sometimes we must look at performance and not just make an assumption about which political parties are good or bad because performance has clearly not been in favor of the DA financially in that regard.
00:22:45
Speaker 1: Do you think that arrangement in Tswane has worked best, Action SA, ANC, EFF?
00:22:51
Speaker 3: Well, without any question, but let's use a people-centric answer to that question. Action SA had zero wards in Tswane in 2021 to 2026. Action SA now won 27 wards in Tswane. despite pollsters telling everyone that that party was only worth 8% for two years before it emerged with nearly 23% of the vote. And, you know, that brings me to the second point. There's this failed notion about this idea that people want Helen Zilla or Salih Zbrink or Nassipi Moya or Herman Mashaba based on a plurality of votes. We don't have such a system in South Africa. We have a system that requires 50% plus one to govern. And what is now emerging is is that some of these candidates who might have got more votes than others, but not a majority, no other political party is willing to work with them, because they've chosen candidates that are incongruent with stable and effective coalition governments. And now you've got political parties gathering around the likes of Dr. Nisipi Moya and Herman Mashaba that can deliver 51% of the vote, representing, I remind you, 51% of the constituency.
00:23:55
Speaker 1: And that is democracy at Why don't you replicate that then, the ANC and EFF? If it's worked so well and you guys have found sort of a structure, why don't you do that in Joburg and Akurulene? Is that much easier?
00:24:06
Speaker 3: We open to the discussion, as I've indicated. But let's also say that there have been places perhaps where it hasn't worked so well. I mean, please refer to Nelson Mandela Bay for further details. So from that point of view, we will approach this from the point of view of every municipality on its merits and deliberately so. And just to respond to Chad's question, because it's actually the best question in my opinion. It's about institutions. Whether you're governing with these guys or those guys, what actually matters is, is there a reliable institution in this municipality that is not dependent upon politicians for its existence and money, that can investigate without fear or favor and with complete independence from being controlled by political interests, that reports back to the public and really arrests people for wrongdoing? That's what we want to see in these municipalities. And I have drafted those coalition agreements and provided them to both the ANC and the DA. And we make that a prerequisite. We will not enter coalition where we do not have such an institution because it is vital that we have it regardless of who we govern with.
00:25:05
Speaker 1: All right, Michael, thank you so much and all the best with the talks this week. Thank you. It's 24 minutes now before 11 o'clock. let's walk the talk it's 20 minutes before 11 o'clock interesting um the conversations that are taking place around coalitions i must say i must say i'm really really not necessarily taken aback but i'm quite surprised by the da's approach to coalition negotiations this time around first of all you'll pick up the difference in John Steenhazen and, you know, the Helen Ziller kind of leadership of the DA, there's a difference in how Jordan Hill Lewis is conducting the negotiations. First of all, he actually says, I'm not going to take the same approach of just closing the door to the EFF and the MK party. We need to be more open to having conversations with everyone. I mean, from a party that during the Helen Ziller and John Steenhazen days declared ANC, MKP and EFF doomsday coalition in fact the EFF was enemy number one remember John Steenhuysen declared EFF enemy number one and you have the new leader of the DA come up and said I actually want to hear them I want to hear what the other people have to say what a different approach so interesting but also I thought the DA would probably say no from the word go when there's a condition that's been placed that drop Helen But if you heard what Jordan Hill Lewis said, I don't know about you, but it sounds to me like this is something that they are considering. I mean, he does say that, of course, it's difficult to swallow this condition that Action SA has put forward, that we can give you Johannesburg and Ekuruleni, you give us Suwanee, but Helen Ziller can't be mayor of Joburg. But Jordan Hill Lewis says we have to consider the demands of all our potential partners, even if that demand says that Helen Zille must go in Johannesburg. That's interesting to me, especially because when you've got other parties like the ANC and the MK party, where the MK party was trying to say back then, Cyril Ramaphosa has to step down as leader of the ANC for us to go into coalition with you. The ANC was like, that's it. We're not going to talk to a party that comes up with a demand like that. So out. We close the door. We'll talk to other people who are more quote-unquote rational, as one of the people said to me at the time. But here's the DA, willing to be open-minded, and I wonder what your thoughts are about that.