TRANSKRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.140 --> 00:00:12.820
Whether it's AI or any piece of technology, it's still really only as good as the people operating it, and we frequently encounter organizations that wanna spend their money on the shiny tools.
2
00:00:18.100 --> 00:00:30.560
[rock music] Welcome to Circuit Magazine, the number one source for information on protection matters. The industry-leading magazine for all security professionals who want to stay ahead of the game.
3
00:00:37.080 --> 00:00:39.420
Rethinking security convergence.
4
00:00:39.540 --> 00:00:53.100
Today, Elijah Shaw and myself are delighted to be speaking with Katie Barnett and Gavin Wilson, both security experts, but Katie, a cybersecurity expert, and Gavin, a physical/corporate security expert.
5
00:00:53.460 --> 00:01:03.760
Elijah, how are you doing? I am doing well. It's, uh, good to be back. Glad to be with my UK buddy on the other side of the globe here, and, uh, and we've got some great people on the...
6
00:01:04.160 --> 00:01:12.020
joining us for the conversation today. Well, it's great to have you back, and it's great to mull over this topic in a very practical way for the operator.
7
00:01:12.320 --> 00:01:19.860
'Cause I think initially every time people hear convergence, they say, "Nice, but what about me?" [laughs] Right. Right.
8
00:01:20.320 --> 00:01:45.160
Uh, you know, for me, I'm, I'm always a big believer in plain speak, and with that said, I know there are some technical terms and some subjects that ki- that you kind of had to have some technical expertise in order to, uh, to, uh, to kind of dive into, but I love it when people that we have on the show can kind of communicate those things and, and, a- and, and show the real world applicability to it.
9
00:01:45.360 --> 00:01:59.940
And, uh, and I thought Katie and Gavin did a great job in, uh, discussing the topic of convergence, but also showing how it's, uh, how we can use it in our, uh, uh, our lives as, you know, as, as operators in the field right now.
10
00:02:01.040 --> 00:02:10.590
Absolutely. And I think as operators, you know, out in the field, people will think, "Okay, do I have to go back and learn how to code?" And then we can reveal to them- [laughs]...
11
00:02:10.590 --> 00:02:20.740
you know, cybersecurity is, uh, much more, uh, uh, than coding and probably not, in fact, any coding in many respects. Um, but, but, but that it could be you and your buddy.
12
00:02:21.000 --> 00:02:30.260
I know that's an oversimplification, but I like to see it that way 'cause Gavin and Katie play off each other very well and work together very well as a team. I agree.
13
00:02:30.320 --> 00:02:35.970
In fact, one of the terms they kept using, uh, that I kind of made a note of was the word holistic.
14
00:02:36.600 --> 00:02:44.400
And, you know, holistic, you know, to me, uh, uh, is very synonymous with organic, and so it, it, you could see kind of the relationship piece.
15
00:02:44.780 --> 00:03:09.480
And so you
Load full transcript
have the physical security on one end, and on the other side have, on the other side you have cyber, but being able to blend those two together in order to, uh, to, uh, create a, a, a total coverage for your client, you know, that only works if, if everybody's firing on the same, same cylinder, if everybody is, is speaking, uh, uh, from, from the same, you know, hymn book.
16
00:03:09.860 --> 00:03:16.840
And so, uh, you guys use the word hymn book? I don't know if that's- Yeah, we say singing from the same hymn book. Yeah. [laughs] All right. Okay, got it. I, I might have butchered the phrase anyway.
17
00:03:17.100 --> 00:03:28.320
But it only works if everybody's on the same page, and so with that said, I... You know, listening to those two, I could tell they were on the same page and so- Mm-hmm... and so I, I really found the value in that.
18
00:03:29.160 --> 00:03:40.380
And do you think principals are looking towards the protector and thinking, "Well, you look after part of my security, so I suppose you should look after all of it." [laughs] Do they, do they really do that?
19
00:03:40.420 --> 00:03:45.700
[laughs] Of course, because I think in everything, uh, budgets play a part, you know?
20
00:03:46.180 --> 00:03:58.840
And so and I think that's why it's important to be able to kind of quantify and be able to talk about what, what the roles are and what the value is to the organization or the value is to the protectee.
21
00:03:59.400 --> 00:04:11.380
Once you're able to do that, then you can say, "This is why we need this," or, "This is why this is important." Yeah, and, and, and perhaps one could bring in the other. Um, it could be, you know- Yeah. Exactly. Sure...
22
00:04:11.420 --> 00:04:23.099
a, a, a partnership. And, and, and above all, it doesn't have to be you as the everything person. Absolutely. One of the, the takeaways when I was listening to them is that Gavin mentioned that he had...
23
00:04:23.360 --> 00:04:30.780
He, he started off in IT. So, so he had a knowledge of this, you know, going into physical security.
24
00:04:31.240 --> 00:04:51.560
And so that means it's a little bit easier to, to make people understand who might not get what IT does, what cyber does, you know, and, and think maybe it's just totally coding or, you know, or, or some aspect of the business that is so arcane or esoteric that we need to stay away w- away from because we just handle the nuts and bolts.
25
00:04:51.620 --> 00:04:56.800
I love it. Well, let's get into it with Gavin and, uh, Katie from Toro Solutions.
26
00:04:56.980 --> 00:05:08.520
I think this will be practical, this will be applicable to the protector, and, uh, and good to update the topic 'cause I think we've, we've kind of looked at this, uh, on a, on a couple other podcast sessions.
27
00:05:08.600 --> 00:05:16.300
Um, so, uh, so, so let's get into it, reimagining, uh, security convergence with Gavin and Katie from Toro Solutions.
28
00:05:18.400 --> 00:05:28.800
[rock music] And now let's meet one of the contributors to the Circuit Magazine.
29
00:05:40.480 --> 00:05:54.440
Rethinking security convergence. I'm delighted to welcome Katie Barnett, Toro's cyber lead, and Gavin Wilson, Toro's physical security lead. How are you both doing? Very well, thank you, Pelham. Nice to be here.
30
00:05:54.500 --> 00:06:02.740
Thank you. Well as well. Yeah. Well, it's great to have you both on, and this is a good format because we are looking at both sides of the house, so to speak.
31
00:06:02.800 --> 00:06:12.640
Of course, there are more sides, but what are we trying to solve? Because we've been talking convergence, quote-unquote, for years. What could a podcast like this hope to try and achieve?
32
00:06:13.200 --> 00:06:30.092
Why do we need convergence?Well, the problem is that the attack is converged, right? So the threat actors we're facing, the context, they are not adopting a linear approach.
33
00:06:31.352 --> 00:06:48.871
They are following the path of least resistance, and that is going to touch on all of our domains in security. So we need to have a converged approach to be able to defend against that converged attack. Okay.
34
00:06:49.052 --> 00:06:57.412
Makes sense. Makes sense. What about for you, Gavin? Um, you know, I'm gonna give you the physical hat. Yeah. I think it's the same whether you're wearing the physical or the cyber hat.
35
00:06:57.772 --> 00:07:12.452
Um, really we're seeing, and you only have to watch the news, uh, any version of the media anyway, that, you know, these threat activities, you know, risk events are happening, uh, faster and harder nowadays.
36
00:07:13.272 --> 00:07:24.332
Um, you know, we- we- we can't really sit still. Uh, technology, uh, is an enablement for both the threat actor and the security defender. Um, really
37
00:07:25.352 --> 00:07:41.652
we have to take a more aligned and interconnected approach to doing security in order to be able to keep pace with the- the, you know, the, with the change that we're seeing. Um, as Katie alluded to, you know- Mm...
38
00:07:41.662 --> 00:07:44.792
the, the attacker will normally follow the pathway of least resistance.
39
00:07:44.892 --> 00:07:56.232
Uh, if they can't get to you physically within a building, they'll try to do that through other means, which is normally online or through an IT network or, or some kind of breach.
40
00:07:56.912 --> 00:08:14.112
Um, nowadays it's normally using a combination of both, uh, you know, social engineering people, uh, getting access to passwords, breaching data sets, uh, getting physical access into a building or, or to an asset, whatever that may be, in order to achieve their goal.
41
00:08:14.852 --> 00:08:27.812
Um, we have to think about security as a more holistic risk managed approach and- Mm... less so as a siloed risk managed approach. All right. Okay.
42
00:08:27.892 --> 00:08:36.452
Well, this, you know, laudable goal and of course many people will be aware of, you know,
hybrid threats that, uh, that are faced in the industry. But let's take a step back.
43
00:08:36.532 --> 00:08:48.052
Obviously I'm very pleased to have you both on the podcast, but where does your passion for this come from? Tell us a bit about yourself, your journey, your passion. Katie? Bit of an odd journey for me, actually.
44
00:08:48.372 --> 00:08:59.792
Um, IT was always my hobby job. It wasn't something I thought I was going to go into as a career. Um, I actually did politics at uni, and then I converted to law.
45
00:09:00.972 --> 00:09:16.592
I trained and qualified as a commercial solicitor, and then immediately left because I decided that I didn't feel passionate about it, and instead did pursue my hobby job in IT.
46
00:09:17.412 --> 00:09:31.652
And so for me, the passion is born out of practice, that experience on the job where I was fortunate enough to grow with an organization that faced a
47
00:09:32.592 --> 00:10:01.552
converged risk, really, and by virtue of no one else stepping into the void and addressing the different elements of security, the, the humble IT manager that I was as I started out in that organization ended up taking on the mantle of security across the physical and the personnel domain as well.
48
00:10:02.132 --> 00:10:16.612
Mm. And that was working with a bunch of creative people that were operating on government contracts, so had to be very compliant.
49
00:10:17.572 --> 00:10:34.292
It was a high risk environment, some of the campaigns and the projects, so highly securitized, and I felt a personal sense of responsibility to cover off all bases and
50
00:10:35.332 --> 00:10:48.322
learn on the job, actually, how to address it, because it was obvious that I couldn't just tick the IT box or the, the cybersecurity box, because if I did, then
51
00:10:49.272 --> 00:10:54.652
the doors would be open, the access control wouldn't work, my comms room wouldn't be secure.
52
00:10:55.172 --> 00:11:12.452
We wouldn't know if anyone was coming into the building or not, and when we sent people traveling to conflict zones, I wouldn't know if they were safe. So very much the practical elements of security in practice- Mm...
53
00:11:12.512 --> 00:11:14.192
is where this is born for me.
54
00:11:15.472 --> 00:11:25.752
I love that, that, that hobby job transformation, and also the question of nature, nurture, the question of coaching, uh, or hands-on training versus, uh, book, uh, training and, and, and so on.
55
00:11:25.892 --> 00:11:31.512
We can, we can get onto all of that, but I, but I think that's really, uh, really useful to know. Um, what about for you, Gavin?
56
00:11:31.592 --> 00:11:43.492
Obviously, many people in the, uh, AP world know you, but, but, you know, where does your passion for this come from? It kind of grew over time. Uh, you know, I, I didn't set out to work in security.
57
00:11:43.592 --> 00:11:56.152
I, I worked in IT at a young age, and then I moved into security and worked my way up from
the b- the bottom. Um, I've worked... I, I'd say I'm very lucky in my career.
58
00:11:56.252 --> 00:12:05.232
I've had the opportunity to work and be mentored by some very amazing people, and I'd say that's what security does well.
59
00:12:05.872 --> 00:12:19.512
And for me, when I came into the industry and started working my, my way up from my first line manager through to their manager, and I've always been looked after and nurtured in a way that I think they've got the best out of me.
60
00:12:20.192 --> 00:12:34.696
Uh, and so my passion started to grow as I started to become more natural at doing-Security and, not just security, but risk. You know, it always, the foundation of security is risk, and incident management, resilience.
61
00:12:34.736 --> 00:12:39.676
And it was really around applying yourself, working hard, proving yourself constantly.
62
00:12:40.236 --> 00:12:52.436
But if you do that, and I think in my case, I say I've been very lucky in my career, lots of opportunities, because I've been well positioned to do that as people have nurtured me and, and got the best out of me.
63
00:12:53.096 --> 00:13:03.796
Ah, whereas I've, I'm, I'm now where I am in my career, you know, working opposite the amazing Katie, ah, and showing her what proper security is in physical of course.
64
00:13:03.805 --> 00:13:19.096
[laughs] But, um, you know- I always have to laugh when Gavin talks about starting off in IT, because now I swear computers just blow up around him. Yeah, because of- That's why we need Converged Security. [laughs] Yeah.
65
00:13:19.305 --> 00:13:30.895
I, I am one of these people that has probably got such a electromagnetic field that nothing works for me. But you've got to remember, Katie, when I worked in IT, it wasn't... [laughs] IT wasn't what it is now.
66
00:13:31.376 --> 00:13:42.456
It was an old- That's where you practiced your two-finger typing, isn't it? It is. And that's when the keyboards actually clicked. But these, I was working on 386, the SXs, and then DXs, and 486s.
67
00:13:42.536 --> 00:13:55.516
I remember the first Pentium. And so the way we use computers nowadays is very different to back then. Mm-hmm. And so damage control with me around computers was more limited [laughs] than what it is now.
68
00:13:55.966 --> 00:14:07.996
But it's a good point, right? Because every company will claim not to be an IT company, but no company can, or, or even individual can exist without their devices. Yeah. Mm-hmm.
69
00:14:08.036 --> 00:14:17.556
And, and, and that, that, that, that also kind of might resonate with the listenership because maybe, uh, quote unquote, "back in the day", uh, people were very hardware, uh, focused.
70
00:14:17.776 --> 00:14:26.176
Uh, okay, there were other people who were very software focused, but a lot of people started off with hardware. Then it became a little bit more involved, and it lost a few people along the way.
71
00:14:26.776 --> 00:14:35.936
Um, uh, which is funny because, y- you know, bef- before, before, you know, all, all of my friends were doing QBASIC, V- VBASIC, and, you know, things like that.
72
00:14:36.036 --> 00:14:47.936
Um, so what about the uninitiated that says that these terms that we've been using, I don't really get them, and, and convergence I've heard about it, but I just feel it's beyond me.
73
00:14:48.916 --> 00:14:58.716
What, what, what should, what should the uninitiated, in that sense, better try to understand? I think [laughs] I think you just got to understand we do it naturally anyway, you know.
74
00:14:58.816 --> 00:15:04.716
I, I think the world is, in whatever you do, is interconnected. You know, that's what technology has done for us.
75
00:15:04.756 --> 00:15:13.496
It's connected us in such a way that everything we do seems to be scripted within some kind of application.
76
00:15:13.576 --> 00:15:26.376
Or, you know, there, there are not many people out there that don't have a digital footprint somewhere doing something. I think, um, convergence or interconnectivities, uh, I get a bit bored of the word convergence.
77
00:15:26.516 --> 00:15:39.996
I was... I remember going back to the early 2000s when it, it was such a big buzzword. Nobody really under- Everybody understood it to be the working togetherness of cyber and physical. It's much more than that.
78
00:15:40.176 --> 00:15:50.656
I think it is, uh, interconnectivity, and it's about driving performance in what we do. I think we do it naturally in our lives now. It's just, it's there.
79
00:15:50.796 --> 00:16:02.316
I don't think we kind of fully understand where it fits into security. Or, or we have an impression of it, uh, but we keep on going back and falling back onto, well, it's who...
80
00:16:02.356 --> 00:16:26.096
If you work in security, it's your responsibility to, to convergence, where when we put it into context, there are so many different functions within organizations that have a role to play in security, whether it's in HR or finance and payroll, and all of these things that actually, that true convergence is that interconnectivity and that alignment of working
81
00:16:27.116 --> 00:16:34.795
within your job, within that organization. So that's, that's kind of what it means to me and the way I, I look at it.
82
00:16:35.436 --> 00:16:49.276
Um, I don't know- But that then and now comparison is relevant because I think convergence used to happen more naturally without perhaps us needing to talk about it so much. Because we used to just...
83
00:16:50.516 --> 00:17:00.356
If you think like the attacker, we need to understand what our crown jewels are, right? What are the, the critical things that we're trying to protect at all costs?
84
00:17:01.056 --> 00:17:14.976
And if I'm the, the threat actor or the attacker, how am I going to approach them? Now, historically, from an IT perspective, we used to use an analogy, the castle and moat,
85
00:17:15.896 --> 00:17:26.056
but that works from a
physical perspective as well, right? We used to have just a premises, a property, an office, and our crown jewels would reside within that.
86
00:17:27.596 --> 00:17:33.196
But all of our protections were largely just placed around the outside. But now,
87
00:17:35.436 --> 00:17:48.036
our crown jewels could be accessible from anywhere because we've got cloud computing, we've got mobile devices, we've got computers that we carry around in our pockets twenty four/seven.
88
00:17:48.936 --> 00:17:53.576
And so actually that attack surface area is so varied.
89
00:17:54.256 --> 00:18:20.836
Your phone could be stolen whilst you're using it out and about, and if it's unlocked, that criminal attacker has access to your whole life then, whether it's data, whether it's opening your apps to your bank accounts, whether it's your contacts, your photos, whether it's the intruder alarm or the CCTV at your house, because that's also connected via an app.
90
00:18:20.896 --> 00:18:36.084
And so the interconnectivity that Gavin's talking about is just harder to map because it's so disparate.Whereas historically it may have all been contained, and therefore it was easy to just wrap our security around it.
91
00:18:37.004 --> 00:18:51.404
Yeah. So we no longer live in castles, do we? We don't. Well, speak for yourself. [laughs] Um, no but, but with this, with this, am I safe in saying that the idea of the singular career path
92
00:18:52.304 --> 00:19:04.204
is not appropriate, never was appropriate, because a lot of people are coming to security as their second career anyway. Uh, they, they come to the party with a skill.
93
00:19:04.324 --> 00:19:15.564
It, it, it's about interoperability, as you said, Gavin. It's not about suddenly saying, "Oh dear, Gavin, you are not a DevSecOps engineer, ergo, you, you can't do security."
94
00:19:15.574 --> 00:19:25.284
It's about saying you, you, you should appreciate it, but, but, but we- we're not gonna say that, uh, that you should be it. Uh, what, what do you think about the singular career path idea?
95
00:19:25.784 --> 00:19:41.084
Well, for fear, for fear of putting us all out of a job, ideally security would be cross-disciplinary. It would be a function that everyone has to adopt in doing whatever it is they do. But the reality is that
96
00:19:42.644 --> 00:19:53.994
it's not that easy. But people have a day job, don't they? Yeah. Exactly. Yeah. I, I think the reality is you'll see security become what safety did, you know, a couple of decades ago, where every...
97
00:19:54.144 --> 00:20:05.384
it was driven as part of an organizational culture that everybody is responsible for safety to themselves and others. It will be the same as security, you know, and it, it will take on that mindset.
98
00:20:05.444 --> 00:20:15.954
It reminds me, uh, on a panel recently, somebody said, "You should hire for attitude, not aptitude." Was that you, Katie? I can't remember- Yeah... if, who it was. [laughs] Yeah. Yeah.
99
00:20:16.144 --> 00:20:25.174
Some, some- Call you out on that one... some of the, some of the, some of the salespeople that I used to work with had that on their s- uh, sort of sign-off slogan, and it kind of made me cringe because it...
100
00:20:25.174 --> 00:20:33.234
I thought I said, "Are you telling me that you don't have, uh, aptitude?" Um- Yeah... you, you know what I mean? Like it, it- No, I would maybe revise that.
101
00:20:33.344 --> 00:20:41.844
Yeah, but I think a lot of the time the skills can be learnt, but the aptitude can't, and that does hark back to your point about this being a singular career path.
102
00:20:42.044 --> 00:20:52.244
I think it does really help if you've got experience in other areas, because you need to be able to apply security in context. Whether it's a business, you need to understand the business objectives.
103
00:20:52.644 --> 00:21:11.984
Whether it's a high net worth individual or a smaller organization, a family office, you need to understand what their priorities are because often security is at one end of the scale, and flexibility is at the other end of the scale, and if you don't pitch your controls in the right place, then they're either going to be bypassed or they simply won't work.
104
00:21:12.344 --> 00:21:29.664
You see, uh, but I, I think that is a right saying because I think security is a attitude the same as safety and it's a mindset, and you can teach people to do something, and you can teach them to do it very well, and the more they do it, the better they're going to become at it.
105
00:21:30.384 --> 00:21:44.024
I also think, you know, you also asked about convergence. Can one person have all these plethora of skillsets and capabilities? Well, no. I think people naturally do what they're good at, uh, and, and you will grow them.
106
00:21:44.084 --> 00:21:54.904
As you know, as a, as a manager, um, one of your responsibilities is to grow people and nurture them. The same as what hap- has happened for, to me throughout my career.
107
00:21:55.724 --> 00:22:06.244
Um, we should be doing the same with the new talent that's coming in. S- if they've got the right attitude, that's so much easier. They will start to adopt those working practices that you're teaching.
108
00:22:06.284 --> 00:22:16.884
If they haven't got the right attitude, um, that's, that's very difficult. So I think aptitude comes easier with attitude, and so I think that is the right thing.
109
00:22:16.944 --> 00:22:20.904
And with security, you, you can't be an expert of everything.
110
00:22:21.244 --> 00:22:36.244
Um, it was on one of your forums recently, Peter, and that one of your panelists said, talked about security being a mile wide and inch deep and, you know, then we discussed do we need to be a mile wide or inches deep or a mile wide and a mile deep.
111
00:22:36.264 --> 00:22:47.464
And the reality is I don't think... Well, I've never met one person who's great at everything. I've met some people who
are brilliant at convergence and doing the cyber and physical stuff, but there is a limit.
112
00:22:47.984 --> 00:23:06.404
Uh, and I think it's what convergence really is, is the ability to interoperate between those different skillsets and all the different things that we do, and you can better achieve that with a team with the right attitude, where you can take them to the a- uh, aptitude they need to be instead of the other way, the other way around.
113
00:23:06.444 --> 00:23:14.984
And you two, you seem to have the right attitude. Um, may- maybe I'm trying to, you know, flatter you or something, but, but, but you do seem to have the right attitude. You, you, you're together.
114
00:23:15.044 --> 00:23:27.574
How do, do, do you, do you do that? How do you work c- in a converged way, both of you together? It's knowing what you don't know, right? I think that's Katie having a lot of tolerance. [laughs] I think that's...
115
00:23:27.844 --> 00:23:41.084
Katie's tolerant of me. But no, um- [laughs] I am very- Yeah. Very... understanding. [laughs] But you need to know what you don't know, and you need to know when to ask questions.
116
00:23:42.004 --> 00:23:58.564
So you can work off frameworks, you can have checklists, but ultimately if you've got relationships with people who specialize in different areas and you can pick their brains, when you know it's relevant, then you're going to get the best result.
117
00:23:58.624 --> 00:24:09.724
Yeah. I, I think there's a, a high level of respect, so you know, it doesn't matter how good you are at what you do, you have to be very respectful of how good other people are at what they do.
118
00:24:09.834 --> 00:24:22.124
And if you can see that in others and you've got a high level of respect and appreciation of what the other person does, you can better work together, you know. A- and when I s...
119
00:24:22.164 --> 00:24:37.944
My work relationship with Katie happened very quickly in that we, we didn't know each other before we started working together, but we just seemed to click, and I think that mutual respect and ability to want to learn from each other grew very quickly with practicing a converged approach to security.
120
00:24:38.104 --> 00:24:51.964
But we did know Peter-Uh, obviously who's the CEO of Toro, and I think he was very, uh, apt at picking us 'cause he probably identified that actually we would be able to work,
121
00:24:53.204 --> 00:24:58.564
um, in, cohesively in order to be able to approach what we wanted to do as a business.
122
00:24:59.304 --> 00:25:11.144
Uh, and we were only able to do that, I'd say working in a converged space where you're able to practice cyber and physical security together actually brings out that, that ability very quickly.
123
00:25:11.744 --> 00:25:18.084
Uh, you have to because you're, you're having to think more holistically. You can't just think in your own silos.
124
00:25:18.724 --> 00:25:30.764
Um, you're watching what the other person is doing, and you're picking up so much around how to more effectively and appropriately manage risk, um, because you're taking a more holistic view of it,
125
00:25:31.684 --> 00:25:42.384
uh, than you were before. So, uh, in the, in the few years I've been working closely with Katie, uh, Peter, and the others at Toro, uh, it's been nothing but an education.
126
00:25:42.844 --> 00:25:54.704
You know, and I thought I had that education before I came into Toro. I've had to rethink the way I approach things drastically in order to not just keep pace, um, but to add value.
127
00:25:55.584 --> 00:26:12.304
So I think if you do practice convergence, you will, uh, if you do it well and you're working with the right people, and you're open to change, um, your, your abilities will significantly improve very, very rapidly.
128
00:26:13.084 --> 00:26:29.274
I think we have very high expectations of ourselves as well. So challenge is really important. We have healthy challenge. We have honest conversations, and- Mm-hmm... we challenge each other if we think
129
00:26:30.244 --> 00:26:36.804
that there is something to question, and it's really important to be able to have those conversations.
130
00:26:37.844 --> 00:26:51.504
I think you can often encounter big egos in some disciplines, and people that aren't prepared to admit when they don't know something or when they've made a mistake,
131
00:26:52.444 --> 00:27:05.704
and that culture is really important to, to challenge because that's not the culture from which we learn and grow, and that applies in security as a whole.
132
00:27:05.784 --> 00:27:17.164
You want to create a security culture where people feel comfortable to speak up and admit if they've made a mistake or done something wrong so that you can address it and fix it.
133
00:27:18.404 --> 00:27:32.644
Which is great on your side, and it's great on your working relationship. But if I'm a listener, and I'm in the world of corporate security, how can I make all of this gel with my corporate structure?
134
00:27:32.714 --> 00:27:43.264
'Cause, you know, I'm, I'm, I'm, I'm thinking of perhaps an organization that is, quote unquote, "traditional." They have a budget for, uh, guarding. They have a budget for cameras.
135
00:27:43.724 --> 00:27:58.944
They have a separate IT budget, and then there's this other kind of info sec budget. How, how could your collaborative work gel with their budgetary silos? One quick way is testing.
136
00:28:00.204 --> 00:28:15.384
So engage a red team to attack your organization because with the flexibility to, like, be the attacker, you can demonstrate
137
00:28:16.544 --> 00:28:26.964
that the vulnerabilities are in those gaps between your different budget holders, your functions, your physical security, your cybersecurity, and your personnel security.
138
00:28:28.104 --> 00:28:42.284
And then once you present the results of that, you can show that actually maybe these functions need to be a bit more joined up
because when we simulated an attack, that's where the gaps were. Yeah.
139
00:28:42.384 --> 00:28:56.424
That's called simulate to integrate, and that is so powerful, and I think we're doing that far more in organizations where we are moving our mindsets, particularly in the security industry, w- where we're not thinking about could this happen?
140
00:28:57.024 --> 00:29:00.724
We're looking at more appropriately as in when this happens.
141
00:29:01.464 --> 00:29:15.204
Um, so we- we're, we're moving away from likelihood assessment to more consequence assessment 'cause we know bad things are happening more so, and we have to have that mindset of resilience. Um, but I think...
142
00:29:15.424 --> 00:29:24.184
Here's another one Katie said the other day, "At your convergence forum, go down the pub and have a chat." And, and I think there's a powerful thing around that because we're not talking enough.
143
00:29:24.264 --> 00:29:36.864
It's just breaking down those silos and those barriers to do that, and it's, again, it's that mutual respect for each other. Yep. And, you know, if you can speak the same language, you're able to overcome far more.
144
00:29:37.124 --> 00:29:44.784
And if you really want to tackle the budgets, if you can simulate those attacks, you can figure out exactly where your vulnerabilities are.
145
00:29:45.344 --> 00:29:52.494
You would identify them, and you can more appropriately budget for your defenses. So you, you could- It can be really challenging though, can't it? Yeah, of course it can be.
146
00:29:52.504 --> 00:29:58.804
If you're in an organization where you are very much told to stay in your swim lane, and you might not be in a position.
147
00:29:58.844 --> 00:30:07.224
You can build great relationships with your counterparts in other teams, but you might not be in a position to change where those budgets sit and who holds the purse strings. Yeah.
148
00:30:07.264 --> 00:30:17.474
But if you do have good relationships, then you can work together to try and align your strategic objectives and manage upwards as well as managing downwards, but it is challenging. Yeah.
149
00:30:17.474 --> 00:30:27.624
And for all the goodwill and pub talk in the world, which we do encourage of course, how have you managed to work with, uh, companies to make this succeed?
150
00:30:27.674 --> 00:30:41.304
'Cause, um, you know, have you man- managed to change their budgeting, uh, methodology? Uh, have you managed to maybe draw, uh, relationships from info sec and health and safety and, uh, EP?
151
00:30:41.424 --> 00:30:53.196
Um, how, how, how, how, how has your, uh, service worked in, in that regard?Yes, communication. We do a lot of workshops, and it's really about bringing everybody around the table for a common goal.
152
00:30:53.246 --> 00:31:00.716
And what you quite often find before you go into the workshop or you start having these conversations, they're all thinking in different directions.
153
00:31:00.756 --> 00:31:08.156
What you want to do is pull them together to start thinking in the same direction. Uh, and the moment you can do that- So, so you take, you take a piece of each person's budget.
154
00:31:09.156 --> 00:31:13.576
Well, you take a piece of each person's focus. You know, what are your priorities?
155
00:31:14.276 --> 00:31:28.836
Quite often, we all focus on our own priorities, our own objectives, our own goals, and that's what we're sticking to, and that will only work to so far when you're all trying to get the same budget from the same pot, and somebody has to decide who's having what, you know?
156
00:31:28.876 --> 00:31:34.145
And they're always going to, I guess, go with what they know, so that...
157
00:31:34.196 --> 00:31:42.136
if that risk assessment says the cyber team need more money because you've got to do this, and this is all the incidents that are happening, that's what the risk assessment says.
158
00:31:42.376 --> 00:31:47.156
Quite often they're going to go, "Well, yeah, you're right. This is what we have to do. We don't have a choice in that."
159
00:31:47.696 --> 00:32:10.166
But if you think more holistically, if you're bringing all of those priorities, all those singular objectives and that siloed thinking together, and you're learning an appreciation for actually the bigger picture, what needs to be achieved, then quite often in a business sec- you know, it, it needs to survive, it needs to, it needs to earn money, it needs to be profitable, security isn't their, their first focus.
160
00:32:10.496 --> 00:32:14.416
Quite often, the problem that we have as security professionals,
161
00:32:15.336 --> 00:32:31.036
as with any other discipline, I guess, we think that what we do has to be the priority, it has to be the focus of everybody else, and we're not figuring out how we should tailor our approach or our solutions to make it sit within the business or the organizational context.
162
00:32:31.056 --> 00:32:40.716
And if we can do that a little bit better, and the way to do that is to understand where the priorities are, where the objectives are, and what needs to be done, um, we can then have a better conversation.
163
00:32:41.316 --> 00:32:49.276
Uh, and that again goes back down to a common complaint we hear from security professionals, is that we don't have a voice at the top table.
164
00:32:49.796 --> 00:33:18.636
And I think that's a structural thing as well, because where you see there's a strong, uh, chief security officer, a, a strong chief risk officer who's looking more holistically and not just the CISO or the head of cyber or the head of physical, you're starting to see somebody who's actually being able to look at the bigger strategic requirement and fit what security needs to do within the organizational objectives and not what the organizational objectives need to do to fit within the security requirements.
165
00:33:20.676 --> 00:33:24.996
You keep coming back to risk, and I think that's a key
point.
166
00:33:25.506 --> 00:33:35.716
The most mature clients we have that are addressing this in a converged way are doing so because they recognize at the top table that risk, the risk is converged. Yeah.
167
00:33:35.796 --> 00:33:50.736
But you're quite right, Pelham, that in most instances it doesn't work like that, and where we have worked with clients who have managed to get buy-in across the different security disciplines, it often happens piecemeal.
168
00:33:51.476 --> 00:33:58.376
We'll often do one thing because they've got a line in their budget for their annual cyber pen test.
169
00:33:59.016 --> 00:34:27.436
But as part of that engagement, because we're always considering the holistic approach, if we flag actually that there was something more related to social engineering on top of that, which is actually a, a human risk, or that there's a physical element that they need to address, then that will start conversations with the other teams, and vice versa.
170
00:34:28.156 --> 00:34:41.266
If we've done a physical security review but it's pointed out that there are network security vulnerabilities, they're gonna have to liaise with the, the IT team or the, the IT security team- Mm-hmm...
171
00:34:41.266 --> 00:34:54.276
to address those network vulnerabilities that have an impact on the intruder alarm system or the access control, and it might force the conversation between the teams that will hopefully get them to align their agendas.
172
00:34:54.776 --> 00:35:15.596
And I've seen this in practice in a recent and ongoing client engagement where, you know, Gavin did a security review for a physical premises, but the report and the results of this has been raised with the information security team because actually these things are not disparate anymore.
173
00:35:15.616 --> 00:35:30.036
And off the back of that, a bunch of actions have been identified and security improvement program is being implemented. So you can approach it in different ways, and it happens in different orders,
174
00:35:30.936 --> 00:35:37.616
but hopefully the, the end game, the long-term goal is that we'll get there with converged security.
175
00:35:38.776 --> 00:35:52.076
And so to help our, our listener, to help say, you know, the protector, the corporate security leader, um, get there, as you said, right? Mm. You mentioned at the beginning that maybe IT was your, your hobby.
176
00:35:52.176 --> 00:35:59.976
Um, you, you were able to tinker around, and this, I think is quite, uh, quite useful, uh, as a, as a tool.
177
00:36:00.316 --> 00:36:07.696
Uh, many people seem to also like, um, on, on, on the cybersecurity side, they, they, they do try hack me, uh- Yeah...
178
00:36:07.726 --> 00:36:20.376
and, and tinker around with ciphers and try and decipher them, and, and it's a, it's a, it's a very, very hands-on way. But I guess this brings us to the kind of nature-nurture, um, question because
179
00:36:21.976 --> 00:36:26.696
lots of people have second careers that are security, and they've come from somewhere.
180
00:36:27.456 --> 00:36:40.906
Um, what are your thoughts against the backdrop of the question of the singular career path when you do see some people who come straight out of college and they, they begin in security?
181
00:36:41.396 --> 00:36:56.960
Like, h-how do we reconcile the need to bring something to the party with the emergence of people who are coming fresh?Yeah. I mean, obviously I'm biased because I started off, you know, on an IT helpdesk and then
182
00:36:58.000 --> 00:37:14.380
grew with that into cybersecurity, and I do find it strange when we see applicants who have done a cybersecurity degree, but they don't know the foundational IT infrastructure that most organizations run on.
183
00:37:15.200 --> 00:37:27.260
And I think, how can you protect it if you don't know how it works in the first place? I do think it helps if you've got some of that foundational knowledge, some of those building blocks, and
184
00:37:28.520 --> 00:37:44.440
even just understanding how a business operates is really important because ultimately you're going to be most successful in your security objectives if they enable and align with business objectives.
185
00:37:45.160 --> 00:38:10.240
And when we've run workshops and roundtables in the recent past, that ended up being the conclusion of all the experts and all the professionals around the table, was that unless they had the ear of the business, unless what they were trying to achieve furthered the business' objectives, then they weren't gonna get anywhere with security.
186
00:38:11.900 --> 00:38:22.420
I think, you know, you've got to hire for the individual. I think, you know, um, I, I've known some really great people to constantly hammer at the door, but it's never been opened for them.
187
00:38:23.360 --> 00:38:35.680
Uh, a-and, and that's upsetting. Um, I think it's really around looking for the right people for the right roles. Uh, and quite often you have to go on your gut feeling for that, um, a-and those positions.
188
00:38:35.780 --> 00:38:50.700
Experience counts for a lot of things. Attitude also counts for a lot as well. Um, and it's the making sure that you hire the right person into the role. And again, I think you can... I, I have
189
00:38:51.720 --> 00:39:02.640
no problem with hiring somebody in a second career if I know they're gonna be the right person for the job and they're gonna add value. But how do they, how do they, how do they get past the CV stage?
190
00:39:03.050 --> 00:39:09.740
'Cause you don't, you know, like, they've got the CV and- Well, it's starting out in security if they've been doing something else. Y-yeah.
191
00:39:09.800 --> 00:39:19.669
I mean, or, or something not too amazingly this similar in, you know, the world of security. Lots of people come from the military or the police. Yeah.
192
00:39:19.720 --> 00:39:28.120
And yes, there's always that challenge of having to demonstrate
commerciality and, uh, and the ability to transition. I get that. Mm.
193
00:39:28.130 --> 00:39:36.830
But, but, but what we're talking about here is knowing the person and knowing that they, they've got the right attitude. You're not gonna know that until... You're not gonna know that at CV stage. Yeah.
194
00:39:36.840 --> 00:39:46.520
And you've got the age-old adage of you need experience to get experience, which is really... I-it's really tough when you're trying to break into a new career. I, I've read some great CVs.
195
00:39:46.740 --> 00:39:57.920
I employed somebody who wasn't strong in what I was employing them for, but they gave me a great CV and told me what they were really good at and how they were gonna apply themselves to be better at what I wanted them to do.
196
00:39:58.800 --> 00:40:06.100
And so, you know, you get a lot of generic CVs, and you get a lot of people who don't try, they're just throwing the CV across.
197
00:40:06.360 --> 00:40:15.080
I wanna see effort, and I wanna see the right attitude, uh, and the, the wanting to become the best that they can be.
198
00:40:15.880 --> 00:40:26.920
Uh, and it's normally with those people that you're, you're, you are more willing to give your time to, to, to bring them up to the level that they need to be so that they can start doing it more naturally.
199
00:40:26.960 --> 00:40:41.560
So I, I do think I, I am very much an individual who hires around the person as opposed to just qualification alone. But do you think maybe seeing that tinkering, uh, if, if it... Let's say it's a, it's a, it's a- Yeah.
200
00:40:41.600 --> 00:40:48.150
If you've got personal projects- Yeah... if you've demonstrated, like, you've put yourself through a little bit of training, it doesn't need to be expensive- Yeah...
201
00:40:48.160 --> 00:40:59.590
but you've found some courses online, you've demonstrated that you're willing to apply yourself- Yeah... you're showing an interest in something beyond just, "I want a job," yes, I think all that counts, for sure. Yeah.
202
00:40:59.600 --> 00:41:10.579
Absolutely. And it's not just the CV, it's actually the letter that sits behind that, why you're going for the job. You know, don't make it generic, make it personable and make it relevant to what you're applying for.
203
00:41:11.220 --> 00:41:16.510
Um- Oh, don't worry, AI will make it very relevant. Yes. Well, that's the difficulty too. Yeah. I was just about to say that.
204
00:41:16.510 --> 00:41:26.840
That's the difficulty with AI and, and the problem is, is, uh, I was speaking to somebody recently who was complaining about having to read through a few hundred CVs, you know.
205
00:41:27.220 --> 00:41:30.840
And sometimes you just got that, the right stack and the wrong stack, haven't you?
206
00:41:31.860 --> 00:41:41.960
The, the reality is you've gotta give your time to find the right person, because you can go through to final rounds and you're never gonna find the right person, but they've been there all the time. Um,
207
00:41:43.200 --> 00:41:52.320
I don't think there's a trick in it. What I do know about security, it's, there is a network there. Somebody always knows somebody else and there's always recommendations.
208
00:41:53.020 --> 00:41:59.820
So I think it's a bit of both, following fair process and giving everybody the opportunity, uh, but reading into the individual.
209
00:41:59.920 --> 00:42:11.500
And whilst AI can make things stand up and sound great, it will fail you if you can't hold up to that in your interview, then all you're doing is wasting people's time, and that would, you would eventually get called out from that.
210
00:42:11.560 --> 00:42:17.640
I think be yourself, be honest, um, and be applicable to the role that you're applying for.
211
00:42:18.000 --> 00:42:27.700
Um, if you're applying for a job just for the sake of getting a job and you're not going to enjoy it, uh, you won't enjoy the job, you know, and that will stand out fairly quickly.
212
00:42:28.080 --> 00:42:31.920
So, so can we ask an actually useful question about, about AI?
213
00:42:31.980 --> 00:42:52.620
There is tons of AI content online that, um, might or might not be useful, but I think a useful question could be, around the topic of convergence, do you think it will be the standing on the shoulders of giants technology that enables, let's say, a manned guard to work, uh, on a CICD pipeline on software development, right?
214
00:42:52.940 --> 00:43:00.112
Because the prevalence of codeless compute-Will, will, will be fantastically useful for the people who cannot code.
215
00:43:00.772 --> 00:43:09.192
And the prevalence of lots of tools that, that require conversational interaction rather than, uh, something more complex.
216
00:43:09.632 --> 00:43:25.092
Do, do, do, do we feel that this could be key to enabling not the singular career path, but that, that, that, that appreciation? I don't know. Um, there's so many unknowns about AI right now.
217
00:43:25.192 --> 00:43:38.692
I, I think what we're, what we're seeing, uh, every day is, is just the, the tip of what is to come and what it can do for you. Um, it still needs a lot of input.
218
00:43:38.752 --> 00:43:45.032
You know, AI will make you sound more clever than what you are if you feed the right things into it, and it...
219
00:43:45.202 --> 00:43:55.212
But you've still got to know your subject and how it's going to be presented, and you will very quickly get called out if you're using it to put yourself in a position that you really know nothing about.
220
00:43:55.872 --> 00:44:13.912
I think AI will enable convergence to the extent that, in your example, someone employed in a man guarding position might be leveraging more technology tooling from, say, a monitoring and detection perspective, and the
221
00:44:14.832 --> 00:44:30.632
interoperability of that function from a physical security perspective in combination with a software tool that supports your
monitoring and detection capability. AI could plug the gap. Um,
222
00:44:31.772 --> 00:44:45.672
I read an article just yesterday that was a research study on AI tooling in several organizations that had been implemented to improve productivity,
223
00:44:46.572 --> 00:45:02.152
and everyone using it swore blind that they were working quicker and getting the jobs done faster. But the results of the research actually proved the opposite. Mm.
224
00:45:02.252 --> 00:45:06.132
That they weren't completing their tasks any quicker.
225
00:45:06.811 --> 00:45:21.692
They were just going down rabbit holes of all the possible ways of completing their tasks using the AI tooling, and actually just going into far more depth and detail than they needed to, which I found quite interesting.
226
00:45:22.092 --> 00:45:37.532
Because to Gavin's point, whether it's AI or any piece of technology, it's still really only as good as the people operating it, and we frequently encounter organizations that wanna spend their money on the shiny tools.
227
00:45:38.101 --> 00:45:47.452
But unless you configure those tools, unless you tune them to your environment, then you won't get the value out of them. And I think
228
00:45:48.452 --> 00:46:13.812
especially for those authorizing perhaps that spend, who aren't in the detail, who are being told by the people leading on that technology strategy that this tool will be the silver bullet, and it ticks a box that we've got twenty-four-seven monitoring, and look at all these thousands of alerts that are coming in and all of these attacks that we're preventing.
229
00:46:14.252 --> 00:46:30.012
But a lot of it is still noise, and the AI can help filter through some of that noise and support analysts who might otherwise be having to do that manually. But you still need the context.
230
00:46:30.652 --> 00:46:43.992
You still need to align it with the business so that it-- you get what you need out of it, and I think there's still a gap there. But that's still useful for the protector and that...
231
00:46:44.032 --> 00:46:55.532
I'm, I'm putting my mind, my, my, myself in the mind of the audience going, "Well, I am, uh, this. I am a corporate security leader, and I'm, I've, I, I'm frequently told to get back in my box."
232
00:46:56.502 --> 00:47:11.452
[chuckles] To, you know... So, so there is a side of convergence where maybe I am not, uh, the CISO, C-I-S-O, but I can be a super corporate security leader using this technology and appreciating the other side.
233
00:47:11.512 --> 00:47:24.012
Uh, may-maybe I, I wanna do an advance and my AI thing says, um, "This type of hotel room has a weird HVAC system. Have you checked it?" I don't know. I'm, I'm, I'm spitballing.
234
00:47:24.172 --> 00:47:35.292
Look, I, I, I'm a big fan of technology and security, uh, but I think we need to be mindful that technology needs to support the human capability, not the human capability support the technology.
235
00:47:35.312 --> 00:47:48.932
And quite often, uh, I do a lot of security design, and I do like the use of AI-enabled, uh, CCTV systems, both to detect threat, you know, event-driven capability.
236
00:47:49.052 --> 00:47:59.232
I think that really is the way forward, um, because it gives you greater eyes and ears. Um, you know, um, you, you know, detection without visualization isn't really detection.
237
00:48:00.012 --> 00:48:04.882
If, if you can get a really good understanding of what's going on, you can make a better judgment and response capability.
238
00:48:05.882 --> 00:48:14.792
Um, but all too often with the systems where you have spent out for event-driven technology, it's just not set up property- properly.
239
00:48:14.952 --> 00:48:24.992
So if you want the system to only detect unusual activity, human movement or vehicle movement, it's still detecting when there's a tree moving, a shadow or a fox in the...
240
00:48:25.152 --> 00:48:30.012
Because it just hasn't been set up properly, and I think a lot of this falls down with operational objectives.
241
00:48:30.832 --> 00:48:42.512
Uh, a lot of security designs are putting in this technology as a baseline, but it's not actually-- they're not, they're not actually designing it to achieve an end result. This is, "Well, this is what it does.
242
00:48:42.572 --> 00:48:52.892
Let's put it in there." But actually operationally it's not working for them. So a lot of these systems are falling down when you audit them because it's not achieving what the security team need. But the, the...
243
00:48:52.982 --> 00:49:04.772
It is available, it is having a significantly positive impact on what we do, uh, uh, as individuals and as an industry, but we have to keep it in perspective.
244
00:49:05.592 --> 00:49:15.238
Um, and it's around using technology for how you want to be able to operate more effectively and efficiently.And I think that's quite often lost in when we implement time.
245
00:49:15.248 --> 00:49:24.308
And recognizing that you're likely to have to spend a lot of time up front, as you say, to set it up to achieve your objectives, to configure it- Yeah... to tune it.
246
00:49:24.988 --> 00:49:32.188
You're not just buying a piece of technology and going, "There we go. It's done now." Yeah.
247
00:49:32.748 --> 00:49:42.468
You know, and in my experience, a really good set up event-driven CCTV system, for example, would take a good two to three months to bed in, so as you start...
248
00:49:42.808 --> 00:49:49.128
So the AI, it's learnt enough to understand the environment, and you've got to appreciate that these things will take time.
249
00:49:49.568 --> 00:49:56.238
You know, and if you're just gonna go onto Google to try and find a smarter way to write a CV or, or a policy- Mm...
250
00:49:56.258 --> 00:50:05.868
it's, unless you know what you're talking about and have a good understanding of it, it's probably not going to do exactly what you need it to do. It won't be as,
251
00:50:06.828 --> 00:50:23.268
um, as good as it needs to be, quite honestly, and whilst that may work in some organizations where you're the expert or, or supposedly the expert and, um, nobody knows any better, um, somebody will come along and have a look and go, "Well, that doesn't make much sense to me."
252
00:50:24.008 --> 00:50:36.268
And having a policy, having a procedural process that doesn't make much sense won't really work well. It's making things work for you, and it's having that end game. What do you want it to do?
253
00:50:36.408 --> 00:50:40.828
What needs to be achieved at the end of this? Um, what does that outcome need to be?
254
00:50:40.858 --> 00:50:56.568
And I think if you look at it with that mindset and that attitude and approach, you can do a lot of amazing things with technology and, and AI, and, you know, and most importantly, and it goes back to what we discussed at the beginning, it's being open to others.
255
00:50:56.628 --> 00:51:07.768
It's speaking to the right people. You know, it's... When, when we do a physical security review, it only takes me a minute to call Katie or one of her team and go, "This is a question I have.
256
00:51:07.828 --> 00:51:12.368
Am I correct, and can you give me something, because I think I need to have raised this to the client?"
257
00:51:13.028 --> 00:51:28.647
You know, you can't be an expert in everything, but if you do have access to a wider range of experts, it makes you a lot better. That's for sure. So we're not advocating for the super Katie Gavin person.
258
00:51:29.068 --> 00:51:37.478
[laughs] We're, we're, we're still advocating for- Yeah... a cyber expert and a physical s- expert. I think that's- I mean, a combination of both of us would be a- Yeah...
259
00:51:37.508 --> 00:51:46.628
pretty fantastic human being, but we've got to be realistic about it, right? Yeah. I, I think that you're only, uh, you're only as good as the people around you, right?
260
00:51:46.728 --> 00:51:52.868
You know, and having that strength of team and, and getting the right people to do the right work is key.
261
00:51:52.988 --> 00:52:04.228
I think that you do become better by working with each other because you're learning new skills constantly and, uh, at Toro, we, at least once a week, we're training each other.
262
00:52:04.268 --> 00:52:14.808
We deliver cross-training and, and that's why we're constantly learning. So you can be better at security following a holistic approach.
263
00:52:15.128 --> 00:52:28.768
But I think there is too much skills, too many qualifications, too many things that you have to do to be a super converse security person. Mm. I, I think that's... You know, we are only human after all.
264
00:52:28.808 --> 00:52:41.588
Um- So, so where's, where's the limit? Like, do, do we, do we want to, in our super team, have reputational risk? Do we want to have the insurance guru, maybe the financial risk guru?
265
00:52:41.948 --> 00:52:52.928
Like, where, where's the limits to this
convergence? Well, we would simpl- We would certainly consider those risks, and it comes down to risks- Yeah...
266
00:52:52.968 --> 00:53:06.048
depending on the context of the, the individual, the organization, the company, and if financial risk was one of their higher concerns, then we would definitely be tapping into
267
00:53:07.168 --> 00:53:24.288
the SME who deals in financial risk, knowing that we have a baseline of questions that we should be asking and risks associated with financial processes and controls that do overlap with our respective disciplines.
268
00:53:25.388 --> 00:53:36.228
And if those questions, the answers to those questions raises a flag, then we can start to unpick it and bring in the necessary SME if we need to.
269
00:53:37.288 --> 00:53:42.968
I think know the requirements, understand the requirements, and work to those. Um, you know, we...
270
00:53:44.188 --> 00:53:59.328
I, I, I do like these convergence or more holistic training courses that are coming along and, uh, a good leader, somebody that I worked with and respect a lot, um, just talked about the brilliant basics. You know, so
271
00:54:00.648 --> 00:54:15.828
you can't know everything, but you need to know what you need to know, and if you can understand the basics of each of these security disciplines that we, we have, it will give you a good footing in order to be able to have the conversation, engage with the expert.
272
00:54:16.308 --> 00:54:27.808
So we are only human. We know we are limited in capability, but we're not unlimited in our ability- Mm... to speak or bring the right person at the right time.
273
00:54:28.308 --> 00:54:41.848
So I do f- I do like the idea of the converse security training that we're starting to see now because it gives people an understanding of what those brilliant basics need to be, and I think that's the way forward.
274
00:54:42.708 --> 00:54:49.548
Um, so it gives you that start point to identify when you have a requirement and to be able to act on it.
275
00:54:49.768 --> 00:54:59.148
Do, do you think that, just thinking about our listenership, if, if they know of a new entrant to the world of work or maybe they want to jump career paths, do you think that's then useful?
276
00:54:59.188 --> 00:55:12.058
Because rather than maybe 10 years ago people were imagining the singular career path and, and so on, I don't know, maybe they still are, but it's, it's useful to say which slice of security do you wanna go into- Yeah...
277
00:55:12.088 --> 00:55:18.048
rather than off you go. It, the, the... You could do everything. Um- Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Uh, absolutely.
278
00:55:18.108 --> 00:55:28.072
You know, and it wasn't until I did my master's degree-Uh, that I fully appreciated what I was naturally good at and what I wasn't. You know?
279
00:55:28.412 --> 00:55:34.552
And, and as Katie says, what, you know, uh, what I should stay away from 'cause I just have [laughs] the ability to blow things up like that.
280
00:55:34.632 --> 00:55:49.912
So, uh, absolutely it, it does, and I think people will naturally sit in what they're good at, and it goes back to that nurturing, you know, with, with, with, with what I see, uh, appreciating my career, and people saw what I was really good at and, and nurtured me to become better.
281
00:55:50.572 --> 00:56:01.092
Um, there's no, you know, sometimes... And it's not to say you shouldn't try different things, but sometimes if you're great at one thing, why do you have to try and be great at something else and you never get there?
282
00:56:01.752 --> 00:56:17.732
So it, and it, it's then being able to build up the team around you so you've got everything covered, as we do at Toro, in that you c- you, you're rounded because you've got the right people to build up the team, and working cohesively together, you're constantly cross-teaching.
283
00:56:17.852 --> 00:56:25.632
Um, but everybody's doing what they're great at, and they're not trying to be great at everything because it's just not part of their natural ability t-to do so.
284
00:56:26.252 --> 00:56:33.772
So I think the training, the education, the way the industry is going, particularly towards the higher learning, is in the right direction.
285
00:56:34.052 --> 00:56:46.372
You know, it's not perfect, but it gives people an understanding of the skills, uh, and the, the types of jobs out there for them to decide actually what you want to learn and where you want to be focused on.
286
00:56:48.512 --> 00:56:59.792
And I think to do that, you can become a super security person- Mm-hmm... because you become great at what you're good at. Or we can take people from the world of, uh, law. [laughs] Exactly. Yeah.
287
00:56:59.992 --> 00:57:09.132
Well, I know what happens when things go wrong, and I'd rather be there to prevent it rather than... Which is ironic given that we do cyber incident response, so. [laughs] Yeah.
288
00:57:09.212 --> 00:57:15.192
And, and that's- But I would rather prevent the incident, uh, than deal with the litigation post-event. Yeah.
289
00:57:15.252 --> 00:57:25.472
Ka-Katie's probably one of the best security people I've ever worked with, although she started out on the dark path. [laughs] But again, I think it's the practitioner piece, right? It's doing- Yeah...
290
00:57:25.572 --> 00:57:32.772
it's knowing what it feels like to be the client and then applying that in a consultancy situation helps. Um- Yeah.
291
00:57:33.112 --> 00:57:43.632
Sometimes you've gotta stop thinking about what we want and actually start focusing on what our clients want, you know? And, and that's really key, and it... That's how you start delivering,
292
00:57:44.592 --> 00:57:57.992
you know, a, a security service. It, it's adapting what we know we need to do, and sometimes you just have to do it in bite-sized chunks to get to the bigger goal that you know has to be achieved. Okay.
293
00:57:59.172 --> 00:58:12.232
So where then does this leave us in
our convergence topic, and what's next for both of you? [laughs] I think it leaves us continuing to learn, doesn't it? And- Yeah...
294
00:58:12.282 --> 00:58:27.292
for us, it's about trying to instill that approach on all of our projects and with all of our clients and long-term partnerships. Yeah. Don't just say it. Do it. Do what works for you.
295
00:58:27.702 --> 00:58:36.482
Uh, a, a converged approach in one organization or one team may be, may look different to another organization, another team. It's, it's, it's...
296
00:58:36.622 --> 00:58:48.992
I, I do feel that convergence is driven by risk management, and I do think risk management is, is changing more to resilience, uh, as the world's changing, things become more fast-paced.
297
00:58:49.652 --> 00:58:58.072
Uh, and I do think technology, uh, will have a significant influence on how we do security and, and what convergence looks like.
298
00:58:58.192 --> 00:59:12.392
But convergence to me is working with subject matter experts in lots of different fields and s- constantly learning from them so that I can do my job better. And it is, resilience is key.
299
00:59:12.492 --> 00:59:25.512
The, the shift, the mindset, the expectation, whether it's from the regulators or otherwise, is what happens when, not if. And to know that, you have to test it.
300
00:59:26.292 --> 00:59:34.812
You can't just have a checkbox of controls and say, "I've done my annual pen test, therefore security, check."
301
00:59:35.752 --> 01:00:02.512
Because you don't know how resilient you are unless you've put yourself through the paces, and the best way to do that is to put your attacker hat on, think about how you would target the crown jewels, and really test yourself, whether that is through a cybersecurity vulnerability, a security vulnerability in the physical premises, or socially engineering the people involved.
302
01:00:03.352 --> 01:00:11.312
And if you're honest with yourself about that, then you'll be able to spot the vulnerabilities too, and hopefully defend against them. Yeah.
303
01:00:11.352 --> 01:00:24.482
A-as one of our colleagues says, "Training without testing isn't really training." Mm. So you constantly test because the, the, everything changes. But, uh, absolutely. Fantastic.
304
01:00:24.832 --> 01:00:36.982
Plus, it's fun trying to break into buildings. [laughs] It is, it is. Right. I'm gonna, I'm gonna use that as a quote, so I'll put it at the very beginning. Um- [laughs] No, but this is, this is fantastic.
305
01:00:37.072 --> 01:00:48.772
Thank you for, for, for spending the time, uh, with the podcast on this topic. It's a topic that people have, uh, hashed over quite a bit, um, but I think that we've made it a little more practical.
306
01:00:49.432 --> 01:01:02.292
Um, we, we, we, we've made it a bit more reachable, and we haven't, uh, you know, done down the individual specialisms, which I think is, is really, you know, key, um, at, uh, at this juncture.
307
01:01:03.032 --> 01:01:20.392
So Gavin and Katie, thanks very much for coming on. This has been another fantastic edition of the Circuit Magazine podcast. [rock music] Well, thank you very much, Gavin and Katie from Toro Solutions.
308
01:01:20.572 --> 01:01:33.076
I think reimagining, uh, you know, convergence and seeing how it's not becoming the one individual makes it all the more...Applicable to the singular protector. What do you think, Elijah? I, I agree.
309
01:01:33.236 --> 01:01:39.176
I, I think they did a great job of kind of illustrating that and playing off of each other's skills and talents.
310
01:01:39.556 --> 01:01:53.706
And then, and then as they talked, you could see, um, as a protector how that could be a benefit in order to have someone that you can, you know, this is my skill set, here is your skill set, and how do those two, pun intended, converge?
311
01:01:54.796 --> 01:02:04.196
Yeah. In- indeed. And, and whilst we are using the, you know, the parlance of convergence, I don't know if I like the word, uh, so much anymore.
312
01:02:04.376 --> 01:02:14.176
I feel interoperability is a good indicator or, or just appreciating other, uh, skill sets, other, uh, you know, uh, uh, specialists.
313
01:02:14.196 --> 01:02:26.286
Because I do remember when I, uh, was doing the Convergence event series when I started 10 years ago myself, people said, "Well, we've been talking convergence for 20 years." So if you add that up- [laughs]...
314
01:02:26.336 --> 01:02:36.466
uh, today, they've apparently been talking 30 years about convergence. However, I would say to them that many people imagined a singular career path. Sure, sure. Yeah.
315
01:02:36.496 --> 01:02:49.915
And I think that especially in protection, protection is often a second career that is dependent on a first career. Obviously, there are loads of roles. There, there, there's roles for people fresh out of college. Right.
316
01:02:49.956 --> 01:02:57.816
There's roles for people out of the SF. The, the... but, but, but that's, it's not a singular career path. What do you think? Right. No, I agree.
317
01:02:58.116 --> 01:03:09.476
I, and I think, you know, sometimes if you took the term or the word literally, convergence, you might think it, it, it's, it, it, it means one person doing all of these things.
318
01:03:09.516 --> 01:03:20.736
But, uh, I think Gavin mentioned in a discussion here his definition of convergence or the thing that he would, you know, the, he would use in, in place of that was interconnectivity.
319
01:03:20.776 --> 01:03:29.116
And I think he said, used the term, he said inter- interconnectivity driving performance. And, and I thought, "Wow, that's, that's a great description of it," right?
320
01:03:29.536 --> 01:03:42.196
You take the cyber aspect and you take the physical security aspect, which might be performed by different operators, but you figure how to blend those things together in service of the client.
321
01:03:42.596 --> 01:03:55.446
And the
other thing that, um, I believe it was Katie said was she said that the reason why this is important, and again, you know, bringing it back to the real world, is that the bad guys practice convergence.
322
01:03:55.916 --> 01:04:09.036
You know, the bad guys are working together in different lanes, right, in order to meet their objectives. So why would we treat them so siloed, right?
323
01:04:09.516 --> 01:04:22.716
Uh, and, you know, and we not communicate or, or we, or, or we not share information, share best practices, use one to build off of the other to complete the, the, the, the security, um, uh, assessment.
324
01:04:23.176 --> 01:04:30.436
Uh, if we're not doing that, then we're doing our clients a disservice. And, and perhaps then from the client's perspective
325
01:04:31.496 --> 01:04:39.186
they might find it challenging 'cause they, they, they, they've, they've known to procure EP services from EP operators. Sure, sure.
326
01:04:39.216 --> 01:04:55.896
They have not maybe known to procure a whole host of other services from the one operator, but there is this, you know, one throat to choke, you know, single, uh, you know, single, single person that, that, that, that is attractive, um, as, as a buyer, and I think that that will maybe spill over into corporations.
327
01:04:56.345 --> 01:05:05.096
Um, I know there are several, uh, people who sell cyber to physical security leaders in corporations, uh, one of them speaking at my Phoenix event, uh, as, as it happens, right?
328
01:05:05.416 --> 01:05:17.056
[laughs] But the thing is, I, I think that this just reiterates that the protector is less afraid to appreciate because there's not this,
329
01:05:17.996 --> 01:05:28.396
I don't know, standardization, uh, out there that maybe when I, when I, when I had 10 years ago, people, people said, "Oh, you gotta, you gotta do everything." And, and please, let me, let me give you one anecdote.
330
01:05:28.456 --> 01:05:35.496
I, I, I, I, I, I know this anecdote will totally bomb unless, uh, unless you, un- un- unless you, you, you get it.
331
01:05:35.576 --> 01:05:48.726
But people were very, very pleased, and they said to me, uh, "You don't start out, when you practice medicine, you don't start out as an oncologist and you work your way back to a general practitioner." Oh.
332
01:05:48.755 --> 01:05:54.596
So you don't start out as a specialist and you work way- Right... back to a generalist. And they thought that that was- Great analogy, sure. Well, no, no, no.
333
01:05:54.796 --> 01:06:02.056
You see, at first you think it's a great analogy, and I did too. I do think it's a great analogy, but go ahead. Please, go ahead. Give me the twist here. But the twist is
334
01:06:03.016 --> 01:06:22.936
that security is not medicine in that I feel we need to appreciate that, uh, maybe bouncers and SF and cybersecurity and actuarial risk and sec DevOps and loss prevention, it's, it, they're all unique specialisms that should be cherished.
335
01:06:23.286 --> 01:06:32.376
Whereas medicine is a bit more homogenous. I don't know. I, I thought I'd throw it out there. Oh, okay. I see where you're coming from with that.
336
01:06:32.936 --> 01:06:44.776
The thing that I would say to this though is that I'm of the belief that from a foundational level, protection work has the same foundation.
337
01:06:44.896 --> 01:06:51.896
So whether you're doing security or you're in special operations or you, you, you know, you're doing corporate EP.
338
01:06:52.236 --> 01:07:04.876
And so as I listen to that, I think about the fact that we do start off as generalists, but I, I, I, I, I do see the play that we're talking about here and, and, and how you were making that distinction in, in, in specialization.
339
01:07:05.256 --> 01:07:10.556
You know, but, um, as it relates to this piece here,
340
01:07:11.936 --> 01:07:51.732
I understand in the, in the areas of cyber that you can take the lane from, from, uh, uh, uh, IT and, and develop skills in IT and then meld those into other aspects of the security world where other people are specializing in those things, and then that security department, right, um, uh, you know, whether it's for a high net worth individual, whether it's for a, a, a corporate office, whatever that is, a corporate programThat security department benefits from all of those specialized areas converging.
341
01:07:52.312 --> 01:08:00.482
Hmm. I hadn't quite looked at it that way, so maybe I, maybe I should revisit that anecdote. I was, I was quick to, uh- Bro, I... Yeah [laughs] Yeah, yeah.
342
01:08:00.532 --> 01:08:08.052
I, I, I see where you're coming from with that and, you know, maybe this is a great time for, like, the listeners to kind of chime in on, you know, on what their take is. We can even do a poll, right?
343
01:08:08.532 --> 01:08:19.792
[laughs] Well, yeah, ex- exactly, exactly. An- answers on a postcard. Um, w- w- we definitely won't get as many, uh, answers on a postcard, uh, since the episode when we talked about robotics in EP.
344
01:08:20.212 --> 01:08:29.712
That, that, that one we got a lot of, uh, answers on a postcard. Um, but, but, but I do, I do like this topic, and I do think it was time to update it.
345
01:08:29.832 --> 01:08:41.152
Um, and I'm, I'm, you know, really grateful to Gavin and Katie, uh, for, for coming on. They are a great team. Maybe it is a great model, uh, for, for us to emulate.
346
01:08:41.412 --> 01:08:49.971
Uh, what a- what about, uh, other things in, in the world of, uh, protection? What's next for you, Elijah? Oh, wow. It's, it's been a busy one for me.
347
01:08:50.092 --> 01:08:58.012
Uh, you know, uh, when I say about problems, I always call them good problems, and being busy is a good problem. But, uh, but I've definitely been on the go.
348
01:08:58.592 --> 01:09:09.522
Uh, I've kind of had my foot on the gas, been doing a lot both operationally, and then involved with the, uh, the training programs that we do. So we just wrapped one up, uh, last month.
349
01:09:09.672 --> 01:09:18.612
That went extremely well, and, uh, and now I'm just trying to... I'm just getting back to my home office after about, uh, about 40 days on the road.
350
01:09:19.012 --> 01:09:28.072
And, uh, you know, I'm going through a pile of paperwork, and I'm happy that I was able to get on this conversation with you, uh, listening to these guys, Katie and Gavin, and I look forward to more episodes.
351
01:09:29.092 --> 01:09:37.832
Well, I'm, I'm thrilled that we, we, we caught you as well to- Yeah. [laughs]... uh, to, to, to listen and review on this. Um, uh, I, I, I hope to do many more intro/outros with you.
352
01:09:37.952 --> 01:09:50.282
Uh, of course, uh, John and Sean are always, uh, you know, uh, there, but it, but it's good, it's good to square the circle as well. Um- Sure... uh, for me, I have the Phoenix event coming up. Uh- Nice...
353
01:09:50.352 --> 01:10:00.451
Convergence, right? So, you know, segue, convergence. Um- Wait, wait, wait, real quick, what number is this? Well, it's the ninth annual Phoenix, uh, Cyber Physical Convergence, uh, Forum.
354
01:10:01.092 --> 01:10:05.172
Um, and yes, it's a dry heat this time of year, we have to say. It's a dry heat.
355
01:10:05.452 --> 01:10:16.852
[laughs] Um, but, but it's actually, um, uh, our 15th in-person Phoenix event, 'cause back in the day I used to do two and sometimes three, uh, per year. I feel that Phoenix- Very cool, very cool... is a great, great...
356
01:10:16.892 --> 01:10:34.442
a great hub, a great hub. Um, well, thank you very much. Um, I feel, uh, this was overdue, this update on Convergence. And, uh, you know, Gavin and Katie were great, uh, to, to, to, to come on. So, uh- Great.
357
01:10:34.472 --> 01:10:35.412
Yes.
358
01:10:35.472 --> 01:10:48.072
And I just wanna, you know, again, encourage the listeners if, you know, if you found value in this episode, if you have your thoughts on convergence, uh, you know, whether it works for you or, uh, your operations, please share with us.
359
01:10:49.312 --> 01:10:58.032
Absolutely. Yes, we want to hear. Um, you know, it's amazing. People say, "Oh, yeah, I've been listening all this time." I'm like, "Well, good, but tell us. Tell, tell us what you think."
360
01:10:58.612 --> 01:11:09.451
Uh, so, uh, you know, it's, it's much appreciated. Fantastic. So from Elijah and myself, this has been another fantastic edition of the Circuit Magazine podcast.
361
01:11:09.572 --> 01:11:22.552
[rock music] You have been listening to the Circuit Magazine podcast. Be sure to subscribe and be sure to not miss an episode.
362
01:11:29.712 --> 01:11:32.292
[rock music]