TRANSKRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.080 --> 00:00:03.040
Welcome back to another episode of the State of Sustainability.
00:00:03.200 --> 00:00:06.799
In today's episode, we are going to do something a little different.
00:00:07.040 --> 00:00:14.720
I have for a little while been wanting to dive into commodities that are at risk from a sustainability perspective.
00:00:14.960 --> 00:00:18.480
I have a sort of niche interest in commodities from a few angles.
00:00:18.640 --> 00:00:28.960
Longtime listeners will know that I used to be in the farming sector, but also actually, soon after I graduated, I had this brief fantasy of being a commodity trader.
00:00:29.359 --> 00:00:30.960
This manifested in two ways.
00:00:31.120 --> 00:00:34.960
One is that I looked into jobs in the cocoa trading industry.
00:00:35.039 --> 00:00:40.799
There was this guy who was making news at the time who was nicknamed Chalkfinger after Goldfinger.
00:00:41.119 --> 00:00:45.280
And this was his nickname because he had tried to corner the global cocoa market.
00:00:45.359 --> 00:00:52.079
He had a very sophisticated operation where he had agronomists going out and visiting cocoa growing areas.
00:00:52.240 --> 00:00:59.920
He had actually seemed to have co-opted the UK Foreign Service as well to acting as satellite offices for his operation.
00:01:00.399 --> 00:01:06.480
And he he gathered a huge amount of data on the global cocoa industry and tried to kind of corner the market by buying up stock.
00:01:06.640 --> 00:01:10.400
This made news, at least in my little news bubble, when I was graduating.
00:01:10.719 --> 00:01:15.200
And so I thought, wow, that looks like a really interesting, exciting, fast-paced industry to get into.
00:01:15.439 --> 00:01:17.760
I didn't actually become a cocoa trader.
00:01:17.840 --> 00:01:22.159
I went into the less glamorous area of potato trading for a little while.
00:01:22.560 --> 00:01:23.599
Story for another day.
00:01:23.760 --> 00:01:25.359
This is not an episode about potatoes.
00:01:25.519 --> 00:01:27.760
This is an episode, however, about cocoa.
00:01:28.000 --> 00:01:40.879
The reason this came to mind for me for this episode was also just yesterday I was warning my niece and nephew that my uh my dog Sassy must never be given chocolate because, of course, chocolate is potentially fatal for dogs.
00:01:41.200 --> 00:01:48.000
And so I thought, well, why not actually springboard off this inspiration and run our first commodity deep dive?
00:01:48.239 --> 00:01:50.239
And indeed, this one is on Coco.
00:01:56.719 --> 00:02:00.079
So, why is this actually a really good time to be doing a Cocoa episode?
00:02:00.159 --> 00:02:06.319
Well, Cocoa has just run one of the most violent price cycles of any major soft commodity this decade.
00:02:06.480 --> 00:02:28.879
It's gone from a sort of uh running average of about$2,000 to$2,800 per ton as a normal range to an all-time high of about uh$12,000 plus dollars per ton uh in late 2024, and then sort of
Load full transcript
collapsed again by about 70% to around$3,000 uh per ton as of spring 2026.
00:02:29.039 --> 00:02:35.120
It's now up again to close to$6,000, I believe, per ton as of mid-year.
00:02:35.360 --> 00:02:40.879
What you can see from this is this massive sort of swinging back and forth of cocoa prices.
00:02:41.039 --> 00:02:48.960
Uh, what is going to be an interesting theme for a few of these episodes that we might do is how volatility in general is on the rise.
00:02:49.120 --> 00:02:56.560
And anyone who's heard our episode a few episodes back on commodity price volatility will immediately be connecting the dots.
00:02:56.719 --> 00:03:05.360
Uh, we are seeing more volatility in commodity pricing, and we will see more volatility in commodity pricing, and the volatility will become even less predictable.
00:03:05.520 --> 00:03:10.479
What I mean by that is swings will get bigger, but swings will also be harder to see.
00:03:10.719 --> 00:03:30.240
We are gonna spend this episode talking a bit about the supply side, which is how cocoa is produced and grown, and the impact of sustainability and other forces really on the production of cocoa, but we're also gonna have some time talking about the demand side and just how the industry is responding and how that's shaping the global landscape for cocoa as well.
00:03:30.400 --> 00:03:33.599
Cocoa is very close, of course, to the hearts of most of us.
00:03:33.759 --> 00:03:38.560
And so I know that none of us would want to see a world where cocoa disappears.
00:03:38.639 --> 00:03:41.360
Uh, and we will talk a little bit about whether that's likely.
00:03:41.520 --> 00:03:43.840
Let's start by talking about where cocoa comes from.
00:03:44.000 --> 00:03:46.879
So, cocoa is extraordinarily concentrated.
00:03:47.039 --> 00:03:52.639
By the way, I know that uh some of you may be deep experts in cocoa trading and commodities.
00:03:52.800 --> 00:03:58.719
I expect that most uh most of you aren't, and so I'm gonna try and give a bit of a primer here as well on global cocoa.
00:03:58.879 --> 00:04:01.360
But production is extraordinarily concentrated.
00:04:01.439 --> 00:04:11.599
Uh, about 40 to 45% of global supply comes from one country, which is the Cote d'Ivoire, the Ivory Coast, uh, and about 12 to 15% comes from Ghana.
00:04:11.680 --> 00:04:22.560
So a majority of global cocoa production comes from just two countries, which makes cocoa extraordinarily exposed to adverse events, both climatic and frankly political as well.
00:04:22.720 --> 00:04:29.839
Uh, West and Central Africa combined, if you throw in uh Nigeria and Cameroon, it takes the total up to about 70%.
00:04:30.399 --> 00:04:38.480
Uh, the rest of it comes from Ecuador, which is uh the fastest growing new kid on the block, uh, and has been developing higher yield varieties as well.
00:04:38.560 --> 00:04:40.800
And so exports from Ecuador are on the rise.
00:04:41.040 --> 00:04:47.680
There's also some uh additional capacity coming from Indonesia, so there's a sort of a long tail, let's say, of smaller players.
00:04:47.839 --> 00:04:58.800
But really, what you need to think of for this episode is uh highly concentrated in West and Central Africa, and particularly Cote d'Ivoire and Ghana, accounting for about 60% of global cocoa production.
00:04:59.040 --> 00:05:11.759
Global output has been around about, let's say, 4.7, 4.8 million tons uh in 2024, 2025, uh, and we usually ping pong a little between a small surplus uh and maybe a small deficit.
00:05:11.920 --> 00:05:14.079
We're going to talk a little bit more about that as well.
00:05:14.319 --> 00:05:19.759
The production base of global cocoa is about 5 to 6 million smallholder farmers.
00:05:20.000 --> 00:05:23.680
There is a lot that can be said about smallholder farmers.
00:05:23.920 --> 00:05:34.000
Growing up in Pakistan, I found that the uh global development community always had an agenda to promote and encourage smallholder farmers.
00:05:34.160 --> 00:05:45.120
And the idea was that because smallholder farmers contribute to employment, because there are so many of them, there's an important poverty alleviation agenda to be contributed to by supporting smallholder farmers.
00:05:45.360 --> 00:06:13.279
My own view, which is kind of fringe in the development circles, I think, is that actually relying on a large base of smallholder farmers tends to decrease the resilience of agriculture and commodity production, which means that usually countries in the global south, countries like where I'm from, Pakistan, tend to be more exposed to volatility and in fact end up relying significantly on imports for any commodities where they don't have a massive home court agroclimatic advantage.
00:06:13.600 --> 00:06:15.759
And I think some elements of the same are true for cocoa.
00:06:15.839 --> 00:06:24.879
You have five to six million smallholder farmers, as I said, mostly farming on a base of two to four hectares, a very small base of production.
00:06:25.040 --> 00:06:31.600
Just to give you an example, my flower farm, which was by no means a large uh farm in any sense of the word.
00:06:31.759 --> 00:06:39.920
You have a large farm typically can be 10,000 hectares, uh, for instance, or more in Canada, in China, in Australia.
00:06:40.160 --> 00:06:46.959
Even a sort of mid-sized commercial farm in the US will probably be north of a thousand uh hectares, I would say.
00:06:47.199 --> 00:06:50.720
My farm was about 50, uh 40 or 50 hectares.
00:06:51.040 --> 00:07:03.040
And so imagine that, like uh, you know, the average cocoa producer is growing on two to four hectares of land, that's really not very much, which means this is uh basically a form of subsistence.
00:07:03.120 --> 00:07:16.399
Uh, this is the the Uber driver of the farming world who is typically uh having to underprice their labor, underprice their capital, underprice their entrepreneurship, underprice their land just to find a way to feed their family.
00:07:16.639 --> 00:07:30.160
This is, aside from you know, any any sort of social issues that we might raise, this is not a really resilient base from which to produce one of the most valuable agricultural commodities in the world.
00:07:30.480 --> 00:07:33.040
Let's now talk a little bit about complications.
00:07:33.199 --> 00:07:36.959
We're gonna talk about a few different supply-side complications, particularly.
00:07:37.040 --> 00:07:40.240
Uh, the first one I want to touch on is agronomic decline.
00:07:40.319 --> 00:07:48.959
I then want to talk a little bit about land loss, uh, and I want to go into climate and agroclimatic zone shift, and then we're gonna touch a little bit on economics.
00:07:49.120 --> 00:07:52.000
Some of these will overlap and kind of exacerbate each other.
00:07:52.240 --> 00:07:57.040
On the agronomic decline, the biggest problem is that the trees themselves are failing.
00:07:57.120 --> 00:08:03.839
So the aging tree stock within West Africa is one of the challenges here when you can when it comes to global cocoa supply.
00:08:04.079 --> 00:08:07.519
Most of West Africa's cocoa trees are past their productive prime.
00:08:07.759 --> 00:08:12.720
So a cocoa tree will take a few years really to start hitting its productive prime.
00:08:12.959 --> 00:08:17.439
And then around 25 years plus, it'll start to deteriorate.
00:08:17.600 --> 00:08:29.839
It was actually quite similar for the flower bushes that I was growing, where it might take you about three years to reach maturity on a bush growing jasmine, the kind of jasmine that would go uh into your Chanel number five.
00:08:30.160 --> 00:08:36.399
The bush might then be productive for up to 20 years, but after that point, the bush starts to decline in its productivity.
00:08:36.559 --> 00:08:48.720
It's pretty much the same with cocoa trees, where uh the yield starts to drop, it starts to be worse at resisting disease, and so actually the income per plot that the farmer receives goes down.
00:08:48.879 --> 00:08:56.159
As it is, the farmers only capture about 6% of the value of the end product that they're selling, in many cases, even less.
00:08:56.320 --> 00:09:04.159
We'll talk a little bit about the impact of volatility, which means that as yields start to decline, the farmer is really pretty stuck.
00:09:04.399 --> 00:09:06.960
It is worth talking a bit about diseases.
00:09:07.200 --> 00:09:10.399
There are two distinct disease threats.
00:09:10.480 --> 00:09:17.600
Uh, one is cocoa swollen shoot virus, CSSV, which is an existential threat to cocoa.
00:09:17.679 --> 00:09:22.399
It's incurable, it spreads via mealy bugs, and it ultimately kills the tree.
00:09:22.639 --> 00:09:25.759
This sort of thing is actually quite common in the climate world.
00:09:25.840 --> 00:09:32.000
I think that one of these was responsible for killing off an entire variety of banana.
00:09:32.159 --> 00:09:45.759
This is a complete digression, but uh some of you may know that bananas are actually a grass uh rather than a tree, uh, which means that every banana tree is basically genetically identical to every other banana tree.
00:09:45.840 --> 00:09:50.720
I'm calling it a tree, even though I've just said it's a grass, which means that they're very susceptible to disease.
00:09:50.799 --> 00:10:04.559
Uh, anyone who's seen those cartoons where you have a sailor slipping on a banana peel uh on the dock of the bay, uh, and if you think about it, you realize you no longer slip on banana peels today because banana peels aren't slippery.
00:10:04.720 --> 00:10:14.000
It actually refers to a variety of banana that doesn't exist anymore, which was a greasy, oily, slippery banana peel, and it doesn't exist because it was completely killed off by disease.
00:10:14.159 --> 00:10:24.799
So something like the cocoa swollen shoot virus can actually just kill off a large chunk of the production of cocoa, given that it's also so concentrated geographically.
00:10:25.039 --> 00:10:31.120
It is estimated that about 17% of annual production losses might be put down to CSSV.
00:10:31.519 --> 00:10:36.559
There's another disease, which is the black pod disease, a fungus, and it's a seasonal threat.
00:10:36.720 --> 00:10:42.080
It comes in wet conditions and is responsible for rotting the pods on the tree.
00:10:42.240 --> 00:10:58.559
And so whenever there's heavy rainfall in Ghana, the price of cocoa futures, which means that the amount that traders are paying for future stock, I'm simplifying, spikes when there's a heavy rainfall because people expect that black pod disease is going to kill off a bunch of cocoa.
00:10:58.799 --> 00:11:10.080
And then uh finally, if you kind of also just look at the agronomic impact, there's all kinds of randomized use of fertilizer, fungicide, improving uh and attempts at improving planting material.
00:11:10.240 --> 00:11:15.679
Uh sometimes farmers tend to underuse these things because they don't have the money to spend on them.
00:11:15.840 --> 00:11:30.960
And usually they buy these inputs from uh middlemen who function as loan sharks as well, selling them the inputs at a massive financing rate, which can be 25, 35, 40%, and then recovering it from the proceeds of sale.
00:11:31.039 --> 00:11:43.600
Uh and sometimes actually farmers are convinced to overuse these sorts of inputs because they're told this will actually result in a higher yield, which it actually may do in the short term, but often isn't very good for the long-term resilience of production.
00:11:43.759 --> 00:11:51.200
Uh, and so on the agronomic side, uh, there's a massive supply-side risk as well, just in the nature of the plant itself.
00:11:51.440 --> 00:12:00.240
Uh, we are going to touch, by the way, on the fact that while trees are aging, it is actually pretty hard to put up new trees.
00:12:00.480 --> 00:12:24.720
One reason that I'll touch on here, and then we'll come back to others related to actually sustainability
regulations, is that if you're going to use the same field for planting a new tree and you have this declining yield tree on that field, you're actually going to have to say, well, even though the yield is declining, I'm going to just take the hit, cut it down, plant a new one, wait two, three years for it to reach maturity.
00:12:24.960 --> 00:12:34.480
And actually, most farmers would rather take the declining yield than take the massive hit of cutting off that source of income and waiting two to three years for a new source of income to develop.
00:12:34.720 --> 00:12:36.559
Let's talk a bit about land loss.
00:12:36.879 --> 00:12:41.279
So this is kind of almost like in some ways a new phenomenon.
00:12:41.519 --> 00:12:51.519
And I've heard that in Ghana, this is called galampsy, which I might be mispronouncing, but it's basically about trying to gather gold and sell it.
00:12:52.080 --> 00:12:58.159
And so within Ghana is blessed with different types of mineral and agricultural wealth.
00:12:58.240 --> 00:13:02.159
And so, in addition to cocoa, uh, there are also gold reserves in Ghana.
00:13:02.320 --> 00:13:11.679
And recently there's been this phenomenon of unlicensed artisanal gold mining that has exploded across Ghana's uh cocoa regions, often with foreign financing.
00:13:11.919 --> 00:13:25.679
I have heard from other Ghanaians that there are sort of these Chinese uh prospecting companies that will finance cocoa farmers to sort of cut down the trees and start prospecting for gold uh on the chance that they might may find something.
00:13:25.840 --> 00:13:48.399
And if you have these sort of already low returns from cocoa because farmers don't capture much of the value, plus you have aging trees declining yield, plus you have disease sporadically popping up when it is heavy rainfall and so on, then actually either selling or leasing your plots of land to miners uh for immediate cash or trying to prospect yourself might actually start to look uh appealing.
00:13:48.480 --> 00:13:58.480
And so what they do is they strip the land, uh it mercury and cyanide is used that ends up sort of poisoning uh the land as well, rendering it useless for cocoa production for a generation.
00:13:58.639 --> 00:14:00.960
And you know, maybe you do, maybe you don't find gold.
00:14:01.120 --> 00:14:02.720
Either way, the cocoa is gone.
00:14:02.799 --> 00:14:09.360
And so more broadly, within the theme of land loss, you have an acreage freeze because of EUDR.
00:14:09.519 --> 00:14:20.639
This is sort of, I don't know if it's paradoxical, it actually seems quite logical, but if you think about EUDR and traceability legislation, the purpose is to stop deforestation.
00:14:20.799 --> 00:14:41.840
And so the idea is we want to avoid people cutting down forest land to plant plantations for agricultural production, including for cocoa, which means that actually, uh, if you would normally have expanded cocoa production by cutting down trees and planting cocoa trees, you can't do that anymore because that cocoa will become unsaleable into Europe.
00:14:42.080 --> 00:14:55.919
And so as a result, the whole sort of virgin forest recapture area just gets cut off for planting new trees, uh, which means there's not really much you could do to expand cocoa production other than cutting down those old trees.
00:14:56.000 --> 00:15:01.759
Where we mention, as we mentioned, there's just a real adverse incentive for farmers to do that.
00:15:01.919 --> 00:15:09.919
So you're sort of locked into this weird bind where the best places that you could grow cocoa are where are likely where there's already forest land.
00:15:10.000 --> 00:15:14.799
It's sort of uh it is land that could be available and could be uh useful for cocoa production.
00:15:14.879 --> 00:15:16.879
By the way, I'm not advocating deforestation.
00:15:17.039 --> 00:15:27.519
I'm just saying that from an agroclimatic zone perspective, if this is where the space is and you can't use that space for cocoa production, all you're left with is the space that you're already using.
00:15:27.679 --> 00:15:35.120
And so there's this uh another problem area around land loss and the lack of availability of new land for cocoa production.
00:15:35.360 --> 00:15:47.279
Let's now talk a little bit about climate and agroclimatic zone shift, which is actually the problem that I was thinking of more when I conceived uh this episode and before I dived into some of these other challenges.
00:15:47.519 --> 00:16:09.600
But you have sort of this near-term weather volatility with erratic rainfall, drought, uh, rain disruption, and you have this sort of supplemented by a structural shift in agroclimatic zones, which means that as a result of climate change, the area that is most optimized for growing a particular crop is now moving from one part of the world to another.
00:16:09.759 --> 00:16:11.840
We're seeing this all around the world.
00:16:12.000 --> 00:16:22.159
Just to give a quick like one minute on what the value of agroclimatic zones is, by virtue of digression into my own life story, as I frequently do.
00:16:22.320 --> 00:16:35.279
When I grew up in Pakistan, I used to study in our geography books how Pakistan was blessed with four perfect seasons, in that we had a few months of the year devoted to each of the four seasons, you know, winter, spring, autumn, summer, etc.
00:16:35.679 --> 00:16:47.759
And I learned later, actually, because my co-founder in my farming business pointed this out to me, he said, actually, these four seasons are an economic curse because it means that you're not really very good at growing any one thing.
00:16:48.000 --> 00:17:01.120
From an agricultural production perspective, the best outcome tends to be, in my opinion, where you actually have several months of a certain type of season where you can grow a certain type of thing for as long as possible.
00:17:01.279 --> 00:17:09.279
In the flower business, this meant that if you want
to grow roses, the ideal situation is where you can have rose yield seven, eight, nine months of the year.
00:17:09.440 --> 00:17:31.759
And so most roses are grown in a few different geographies around the world, around Lake Navasha in Kenya, for instance, or in Ethiopia or a few other countries in Latin America and Southeast Asia that tend to have this sort of agroclimatic zone that is perfectly optimized for growing this one thing under certain conditions of humidity, temperature, sunlight, etc., for as long of the year as possible.
00:17:31.839 --> 00:17:37.200
And that is the value of getting the right agroclimatic zone for the crop that you want to grow.
00:17:37.359 --> 00:17:54.559
Now, the agroclimatic zone optimization works in sort of these two ways, where because Cote d'Ivoire and Ghana are really well suited to growing cocoa, most cocoa is grown in these countries, in the same way that a very large share of the European roast supply is grown in Kenya and Ethiopia.
00:17:54.799 --> 00:17:58.720
And you therefore get this whole industry set up around that.
00:18:04.880 --> 00:18:12.000
Everyone sort of develops these corridors where it is perfectly optimized to growing in a certain way.
00:18:12.160 --> 00:18:25.519
In the example of roses, for instance, you manage to get these large acreages of rose production, but you also have the whole logistics setup optimized to getting that at lowest cost over into Europe where it's sold from having been grown in Kenya and Ethiopia.
00:18:25.599 --> 00:18:28.079
And the same thing exists for cocoa.
00:18:28.319 --> 00:18:36.000
Now, with climate change, the optimal agroclimatic zone for growing everything pretty much is shifting from one place to another.
00:18:36.240 --> 00:18:42.640
Some of you uh in the UK may have heard uh about how actually like English wine is reputed to be getting better.
00:18:42.720 --> 00:18:56.240
I don't know this because I don't drink English wine, but it is reputed to be getting better because the actual agroclimatic zones is shifting from uh, let's say France, which was much more conducive for growing wine, over towards uh to favoring England.
00:18:56.400 --> 00:19:03.039
We are likely to get more and more of these sorts of shifts everywhere in the world for every commodity, really.
00:19:03.279 --> 00:19:07.039
And the same is now true or expected to be true for cocoa as well.
00:19:07.279 --> 00:19:20.720
The expectation is that West and Central Africa could lose something on the order of 50% of the current uh climatically suitable cocoa area by 2050 under current projections of the impact of climate change.
00:19:21.039 --> 00:19:39.440
This is going to be a massive impact on the global cocoa industry, not just because it means that you need to start growing cocoa in completely different places, but also just because the whole logistics and supply chain is going to shift, employment is gonna shift radically.
00:19:39.599 --> 00:19:43.359
What do farmers do when they can actually no longer grow cocoa in these places at all?
00:19:43.599 --> 00:19:50.960
The areas that are most likely going to favor cocoa production in the future will be Nigeria, Cameroon, kind of if it moves further east.
00:19:51.119 --> 00:19:57.759
But then when you think about how you would uh bring new acreage under cocoa production, you'd have to go for deforestation.
00:19:57.920 --> 00:19:59.359
Again, you're limited by that.
00:19:59.519 --> 00:20:09.200
So actually, we're sort of stuck where in any event damage is coming to the industry, but there's not really a very clear way out.
00:20:09.599 --> 00:21:13.949
And so I think this is going to be this is going to be a real pickle, for want of a better word.
00:21:14.029 --> 00:21:17.309
Uh, and I am not yet sure how the world is gonna handle it.
00:21:17.629 --> 00:21:27.709
Moving swiftly on to another depressing topic, let's talk about the economic engine that uh really entrenches the current set of problems that we've been talking through.
00:21:28.029 --> 00:21:30.990
One is the value split.
00:21:31.149 --> 00:21:37.389
And what I mean by that is that we're clearly talking about a massive set of risks to global cocoa production.
00:21:37.629 --> 00:21:45.869
In an ideal world, the producers who are exposed to those risks would have the economic resilience to manage those risks.
00:21:46.029 --> 00:21:51.469
Uh, let me give actually another interesting example uh of where that is the case.
00:21:51.629 --> 00:21:53.149
Let's talk about textiles.
00:21:53.469 --> 00:21:58.589
Cotton production in Pakistan has been wildly variant.
00:21:58.990 --> 00:22:05.309
The yield seesaws up and down, water shortages, heat waves, all this impacts the cotton yield.
00:22:05.549 --> 00:22:08.909
Now, the cotton grower, unfortunately, is very exposed to this.
00:22:09.149 --> 00:22:19.789
However, the textile manufacturers, uh, as a sort of the industrial part of the value chain that sits just after the growers, has had historically the economic resilience to manage.
00:22:19.869 --> 00:22:37.230
And so the way that they have managed is that they have set up manufacturing capacity in other countries, in Bangladesh and Sri Lanka, uh, and so on, and then they source from other geographies as well, which means that they have had the economic capacity to diversify and protect themselves from climate the impact of climate change.
00:22:37.469 --> 00:22:44.669
Unfortunately, growers in general, and particularly the cocoa growers, do not have any of that economic resilience.
00:22:44.909 --> 00:22:49.549
Economic resilience doesn't necessarily mean you have a large store of cash sitting around.
00:22:49.709 --> 00:22:57.469
It can also just mean that you have the ability to, let's say, get insurance, you have the ability to raise a debt, for instance, to set up new capacity.
00:22:57.549 --> 00:23:06.829
Uh, you Of the ability or resilience to go a year or two years with lower income because
you're making a trade-off to shift to new production, for instance.
00:23:07.149 --> 00:23:17.629
But actually, there's none of this because the value share that farmers capture is typically under 7% of the sort of value chain of cocoa, and in fact, often much less.
00:23:17.869 --> 00:23:31.149
The living income gap figures that I've seen are typically around 40% or 50%, which means that farmers tend to make actually less than they would need to make for even just a living income in the geographies where they operate.
00:23:31.389 --> 00:23:40.269
To make this even worse, the two major geographies, Cote d'Ivoire and Ghana, have administered pricing, which means that actually prices are not set by farmers.
00:23:40.429 --> 00:23:44.669
Prices are set by a central market-making organization backed by the government.
00:23:44.909 --> 00:23:54.829
This central market-making uh organization, which is called Coco Bod or CCC, Coco Bod is in Ghana and Triple C is in Cote d'Ivoire.
00:23:55.230 --> 00:24:02.109
Uh, both these organizations restrict uh or control what the price is for cocoa at the farm gate.
00:24:02.349 --> 00:24:23.549
And because they're government organizations, perhaps, there tends to be a bit of a lag where when the price for cocoa spikes uh globally, because there's like a shortage, let's say, or some for you know, maybe a demand reason why it's spiked, these agencies tend to be late to coming up and raising prices at the farm gate, which means farmers don't benefit from the massive price spike.
00:24:23.789 --> 00:24:40.589
On the other hand, if the that price spike is followed later on by a price fall, often these agencies are late again and they've just realized, hey, there was a price spike, we're gonna raise prices at the farm gate, which means cocoa production is no longer competitive, and there ends up being an excess because buyers won't buy at those prices.
00:24:40.829 --> 00:24:53.629
So actually, this sort of controlled pricing tends to have a lag that ends up hurting farmers because they can't capture excess profit at a peak pricing and they can't actually protect themselves against lower prices.
00:24:53.709 --> 00:24:58.589
In fact, they're exposed at lower prices because they're price mispatched versus the market.
00:24:58.990 --> 00:25:02.750
Um, we've talked a fair bit about the supply side of cocoa.
00:25:02.909 --> 00:25:07.309
If you are not suitably depressed yet, let's now switch over to the demand side.
00:25:07.549 --> 00:25:14.669
It seems that manufacturers in general have responded to supply side volatility by reducing usage.
00:25:14.990 --> 00:25:18.109
What we can see from the data is that grindings have fallen.
00:25:18.189 --> 00:25:23.149
And so the drop in grindings across Q1 2026, for example, is about 7.8%.
00:25:23.949 --> 00:25:53.149
There has been a push towards reformulation and shrinkflation, which means smaller bars, cocoa butter being substituted with palm, uh, I'm never sure how to pronounce that, uh, and other fats and alternatives being used, uh, smaller bars as well, um, pricing impact where uh producers are passing through high price increases for where they're continuing to use uh use real cocoa or use proper cocoa.
00:25:53.389 --> 00:26:08.509
And analysts are increasingly expecting that a lot of these shifts are structural rather than temporary, which means that if they're uh if producers are substitute, manufacturers are substituting other materials for uh cocoa butter, they're likely not going to reverse that trend.
00:26:08.829 --> 00:26:13.069
If they've shifted towards smaller bars, they're likely not going to reverse that trend in the future.
00:26:13.230 --> 00:26:41.069
So the demand side is adjusting, uh, but it's almost almost worse because if what you're afraid of is that cocoa is gradually going to decline and you know, maybe at some point even disappear from the world, the last thing you want is for supply side volatility and risk to be met by demand side shift away from cocoa rather than a demand response that can actually support supply in risk resilience.
00:26:41.230 --> 00:26:45.309
Because actually, as you shift away from cocoa, it becomes then a self-fulfilling prophecy.
00:26:45.549 --> 00:26:50.029
A bunch of things that are happening, I think, will influence our predictions for the future.
00:26:50.109 --> 00:26:56.909
So EUDR is out and it increases the cost of the cocoa value chain.
00:26:56.990 --> 00:27:06.189
There's a massive traceability impact, uh, but actually also it does just make it harder to find new places to grow cocoa.
00:27:06.349 --> 00:27:19.469
Uh, we are already seeing some impact on EUDR repricing the market, where you have this two-tier market of compliant versus non-compliant cocoa, and that's gonna end up having a ripple effect on production as well.
00:27:19.629 --> 00:27:34.589
And you know, it remains to be seen how geographies that are producing non-compliant cocoa manage to continue doing that because they will be unable structurally to ever charge a premium for any of the other aspects uh of differentiation that their cocoa might have.
00:27:34.829 --> 00:27:37.709
There's obviously a massive issue around forced and child labor.
00:27:37.789 --> 00:27:39.789
We haven't really touched on that in this episode.
00:27:39.949 --> 00:27:45.389
Uh, you could have a whole entire other episode in its own right on this, and maybe we should.
00:27:45.869 --> 00:27:54.269
But you know, there's a bunch of stuff I would say that regulation has driven, uh, which is going to impact whatever predictions we might make for the future.
00:27:54.429 --> 00:27:57.789
Uh the industry is moving towards hedging and coverage.
00:27:57.949 --> 00:28:02.029
Uh there's the uh to sort of mitigate risk, at least on the buyer side.
00:28:02.189 --> 00:28:13.789
Uh, sustainability programs are leaning in to try and uh mitigate the environmental impact of cocoa, but also provide potentially
things like insurance solutions and support for farmers.
00:28:14.109 --> 00:28:20.189
My own read is that this is going to be a very small impact in the scheme of things.
00:28:20.349 --> 00:28:34.750
And actually, cocoa production is so intertwined across like a socioeconomic challenge in the geographies where it's being grown, plus an economic challenge plus an agroclimatic challenge that it leaves us in a real bind.
00:28:34.990 --> 00:29:02.269
And so I think that if we kind of were to now move over to making some predictions, I think that the only real way to fix the challenges that we're seeing around aging trees, agroclimatic zone shift, economic adverse incentives, and so on, is to find a good way to reconcile ourselves with replanting uh cocoa, either replanting cocoa or finding new places for cocoa to be uh to be grown.
00:29:02.509 --> 00:29:09.309
We need to find some way to have a larger share of the pie go to farms to make them more resilient.
00:29:09.629 --> 00:29:14.589
The state board infrastructure is clearly not gonna help this.
00:29:14.829 --> 00:29:18.589
Uh, I don't have high confidence in it getting a lot better.
00:29:18.829 --> 00:29:21.949
And so some sort of disruption needs to take place there.
00:29:22.029 --> 00:29:25.469
But given that it's state-backed, I'm not sure how likely that is.
00:29:26.189 --> 00:29:33.469
Regulation clearly needs to find some way to allow for adaptation of the growing ecosystem.
00:29:33.789 --> 00:29:36.429
But European regulation takes a long time to adapt.
00:29:36.589 --> 00:29:39.949
I think that might actually be the one that is able to give fastest.
00:29:40.109 --> 00:29:42.509
The others I don't see easy solutions for.
00:29:42.990 --> 00:29:53.549
Demand destruction will probably alleviate some of the supply risk in the near term, as there's just less less pressure and therefore less risk as well on production.
00:29:53.709 --> 00:30:08.189
But maybe that means that actually real cocoa just becomes a premium commodity that could end us in an equilibrium of some sort, but it's not it's not the ideal equilibrium, I would say, if a large share of the market just doesn't experience real cocoa.
00:30:08.509 --> 00:30:17.549
And so, on the whole, I would say my predictions for this market is I would say I don't see any alternative but for supply to decline long term.
00:30:17.949 --> 00:30:33.389
I don't see any alternative but for farmers to exit production, and I don't see any alternative then for cocoa to become an increasingly premiumized commodity on the demand side as the only way to get equilibrium in this space.
00:30:33.629 --> 00:30:36.029
I think price volatility will stay high.
00:30:36.189 --> 00:30:52.189
And I think that the area that we will probably see more innovation is around hedging products, insurance products, and others, other financial instruments uh that allow us as a value chain to cope with the inevitable volatility that this story is going to create.
00:30:52.349 --> 00:30:58.429
Uh so not the most uplifting note to end on, but hopefully still an informative episode for for you.
00:30:58.669 --> 00:31:09.629
Uh, if you liked listening to this episode and want to hear more from the state of sustainability and never want to miss an episode, please hit follow so that you get the episodes as soon as they're released.
00:31:09.709 --> 00:31:17.149
Uh, we will always appreciate a review, a five star rating, or a share to those in your network that you think might be interested.
00:31:17.629 --> 00:31:20.990
So, until next time, thank you so much and stay tuned.