TRANSKRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:04.919 --> 00:00:05.700
Welcome, yes.
2
00:00:08.640 --> 00:00:12.839
This is StarTalk at New York Comic Con, and I'm
3
00:00:12.859 --> 00:00:16.730
gonna bring out my guests. First, you're gonna meet my co-host,
4
00:00:17.230 --> 00:00:20.070
the one, the only, Chuck Nice. Chuck, comedian.
5
00:00:20.089 --> 00:00:21.710
Come on out.
6
00:00:24.629 --> 00:00:25.609
Come on out, Chuck.
7
00:00:27.170 --> 00:00:27.329
Yeah.
8
00:00:29.420 --> 00:00:30.660
Chuck, who'd you bring with you today?
9
00:00:30.960 --> 00:00:33.479
Hey, so you may know this.
10
00:00:34.079 --> 00:00:36.799
Who is another comedian? And he is also extremely funny.
11
00:00:36.840 --> 00:00:44.130
You probably know him from Impractical Jokers. On True TV,
12
00:00:44.229 --> 00:00:47.450
it's James Murr Murray!
13
00:00:53.549 --> 00:00:54.770
Yeah, I don't belong here.
14
00:00:54.789 --> 00:00:57.429
No, you're over here.
15
00:00:57.450 --> 00:00:57.630
Come on.
16
00:00:59.289 --> 00:00:59.649
All right.
17
00:00:59.789 --> 00:01:02.520
And so, did he tell you what we're doing tonight?
18
00:01:02.619 --> 00:01:03.140
What topic?
19
00:01:03.880 --> 00:01:06.180
You came at 8. You didn't know what the topic is?
20
00:01:07.840 --> 00:01:08.900
That's love. Oh, man.
21
00:01:08.939 --> 00:01:11.379
You really screwed up.
22
00:01:11.900 --> 00:01:14.609
Let me bring out our fourth and final guest, a
23
00:01:14.670 --> 00:01:19.129
colleague and friend of mine, theoretical physicist Brian Green.
24
00:01:19.189 --> 00:01:19.549
Brian! Brian!
25
00:01:27.750 --> 00:01:31.849
Brian, okay. Let me tell you why we brought out
26
00:01:31.950 --> 00:01:38.250
this firepower. Because tonight, we are going to handle three
27
00:01:38.349 --> 00:01:44.219
different topics. Very specific to this audience and our concerns.
28
00:01:44.739 --> 00:01:47.439
In part one, we are going to talk about time
29
00:01:47.500 --> 00:01:54.000
travel in Doctor Who. And in part two, we're gonna
30
00:01:54.060 --> 00:02:01.700
talk about the quantum physics of Ant-Man. And part three,
31
00:02:02.079 --> 00:02:08.639
we're talking about parallel universes in Stranger Things. So let's
32
00:02:08.699 --> 00:02:12.939
do this. All right. So, and thanks for coming. This
33
00:02:12.960 --> 00:02:13.960
is my first time I've met you.
34
00:02:14.020 --> 00:02:17.569
Likewise. I've been a fan of yours literally forever.
35
00:02:19.330 --> 00:02:21.310
No, that would not be literally true.
36
00:02:21.729 --> 00:02:25.289
Right, okay. Expect a lot more of that tonight.
37
00:02:26.240 --> 00:02:30.080
I'm just saying. So, we know Doctor Who's the longest
38
00:02:30.120 --> 00:02:37.900
running science fiction franchise ever on television. And the current Doctor,
39
00:02:38.840 --> 00:02:40.000
Jodie Whittaker, is that right?
40
00:02:40.539 --> 00:02:41.400
Yes, give it up!
41
00:02:43.780 --> 00:02:48.599
Is anyone here dressed as Jodie Whittaker? We got, nobody? Okay, fine. Okay,
42
00:02:48.639 --> 00:02:49.180
just checking.
43
00:02:49.599 --> 00:02:53.150
Wow, that is almost a statistical impossibility.
44
00:02:55.069 --> 00:02:58.490
Yeah, so as you know, Doctor Who follows the adventures
45
00:02:58.770 --> 00:03:03.909
of a humanoid alien, basically, and that person travels through
46
00:03:03.949 --> 00:03:07.629
space and time in a wibbly-wobbly, timey-wimey way.
47
00:03:08.469 --> 00:03:08.729
Yes.
48
00:03:09.409 --> 00:03:13.219
And so, given these facts, what we really want to know, Brian,
49
00:03:14.009 --> 00:03:20.139
is travel through time theoretically possible? At least as imagined
50
00:03:20.259 --> 00:03:20.710
in Doctor Who.
51
00:03:21.710 --> 00:03:23.050
You have to think about it.
52
00:03:23.050 --> 00:03:25.789
Oh, by the way, Brian, you know, had three best-selling
53
00:03:25.830 --> 00:03:31.430
books about this stuff, okay? Among them, The Fabric of
54
00:03:31.469 --> 00:03:34.770
the Universe, The Fabric of the Cosmos, The Elegant Universe,
55
00:03:35.270 --> 00:03:36.879
and the third of those was what?
56
00:03:36.900 --> 00:03:41.639
The Hidden Reality.
57
00:03:41.659 --> 00:03:44.860
The Hidden Reality. Thank you. Thank you. So go on, Brian,
58
00:03:44.879 --> 00:03:45.090
tell me.
59
00:03:45.629 --> 00:03:47.870
So you have to think about time travel in really
60
00:03:47.990 --> 00:03:51.340
two stages, because time travel to the future is very
61
00:03:51.379 --> 00:03:53.400
different from time travel to the past.
62
00:03:53.900 --> 00:03:54.800
So time travel to the future.
63
00:03:54.819 --> 00:03:55.879
They have different consequences.
64
00:03:56.099 --> 00:03:58.479
They have different consequences and they have a different standing
65
00:03:58.500 --> 00:04:01.139
with an understanding of the laws of physics. So as
66
00:04:01.240 --> 00:04:03.560
we know physics today, time travel to the future is
67
00:04:03.620 --> 00:04:07.860
not hypothetical. It's not some idea that people argue about.
68
00:04:08.180 --> 00:04:10.680
Time travel to the future is absolutely part of the
69
00:04:10.719 --> 00:04:13.750
way physics is constructed. There is nobody who knows anything
70
00:04:13.810 --> 00:04:15.889
about what they're talking about who would disagree with that.
71
00:04:16.949 --> 00:04:21.470
I like the way you worded that. Okay, so, but
72
00:04:21.529 --> 00:04:23.509
of course in Doctor Who, they go into the past.
73
00:04:23.990 --> 00:04:24.769
So what's going on there?
74
00:04:24.949 --> 00:04:26.949
That's a trickier one. That's a trickier one.
75
00:04:27.029 --> 00:04:28.649
Well, he's a time lord, so he figured it out.
76
00:04:28.730 --> 00:04:32.879
So my question to you is, In this universe, how
77
00:04:32.980 --> 00:04:35.560
would you make it happen such as the way we
78
00:04:35.600 --> 00:04:36.779
see it in Doctor Who?
79
00:04:37.100 --> 00:04:38.939
So if you want to travel to the past, there
80
00:04:39.000 --> 00:04:41.189
are a
Load full transcript
few proposals that are on the market, but
81
00:04:41.250 --> 00:04:43.750
I'd say the one that has attracted the greatest attention
82
00:04:43.810 --> 00:04:44.930
is to make use of wormholes.
83
00:04:45.470 --> 00:04:45.730
Okay.
84
00:04:45.870 --> 00:04:48.649
So a wormhole is a tunnel through space.
85
00:04:48.709 --> 00:04:49.449
It's a shortcut.
86
00:04:49.490 --> 00:04:51.529
Like any ordinary tunnel in the real world, it takes
87
00:04:51.569 --> 00:04:54.120
it from one point in space to another point in
88
00:04:54.230 --> 00:04:55.430
a more direct manner.
89
00:04:55.550 --> 00:04:57.250
So rather than going over the mountain, you go through
90
00:04:57.269 --> 00:04:57.569
the mountain.
91
00:04:57.589 --> 00:04:58.610
You go right through the mountain.
92
00:04:58.870 --> 00:05:00.889
Now that is a tunnel from a point in space
93
00:05:00.910 --> 00:05:02.829
to another point in space, but here's the thing. If
94
00:05:02.870 --> 00:05:05.029
you take one of the openings of the wormhole and
95
00:05:05.069 --> 00:05:07.290
you put it near a black hole and you let
96
00:05:07.329 --> 00:05:10.600
it hang out there, according to Einstein, time will elapse
97
00:05:10.660 --> 00:05:12.819
more slowly near the edge of a black hole because
98
00:05:12.839 --> 00:05:13.899
of the powerful gravity.
99
00:05:13.959 --> 00:05:14.220
Yes.
100
00:05:14.439 --> 00:05:16.480
And that means that time at this opening of the
101
00:05:16.519 --> 00:05:19.939
wormhole will be different from time at the other opening.
102
00:05:19.699 --> 00:05:21.610
Of the wormhole. Which is farther away from the black hole.
103
00:05:21.759 --> 00:05:24.769
Farther away from the black hole, feeling a different gravitational force.
104
00:05:24.790 --> 00:05:25.029
Yes.
105
00:05:25.329 --> 00:05:27.209
Which means now when you go through the wormhole, you're
106
00:05:27.230 --> 00:05:29.449
not just going from one point in space to another
107
00:05:29.490 --> 00:05:31.949
point in space, you're going from one moment in time
108
00:05:32.370 --> 00:05:33.689
to a different moment in time.
109
00:05:34.089 --> 00:05:35.209
Why does that mean you're going backwards?
110
00:05:35.290 --> 00:05:38.300
Well, one direction is forward, one direction is backwards. So
111
00:05:38.600 --> 00:05:40.740
it's depending on the direction you go through the tunnel,
112
00:05:40.920 --> 00:05:42.740
it tells you the direction in time that you're traveling.
113
00:05:43.300 --> 00:05:43.740
Ooh. Hmm.
114
00:05:45.269 --> 00:05:47.889
There is another way to travel back in time. Scrapbooking
115
00:05:47.970 --> 00:05:53.089
is a fantastic way. Facebook memories. You see those video
116
00:05:53.110 --> 00:05:55.290
collections they do? You go right back in time. You're
117
00:05:55.310 --> 00:05:56.589
transported there instantly.
118
00:05:58.069 --> 00:05:58.329
So.
119
00:05:58.350 --> 00:06:00.879
That's all I got.
120
00:06:00.889 --> 00:06:03.660
Oh, also Einstein Rosen bridges.
121
00:06:03.680 --> 00:06:07.519
Of course. That's stupid. Everybody knows that.
122
00:06:07.560 --> 00:06:08.399
But everyone knows that.
123
00:06:09.019 --> 00:06:11.800
So, what about the... the.
124
00:06:12.860 --> 00:06:12.959
the.
125
00:06:14.209 --> 00:06:15.829
Something conjecture, the.
126
00:06:16.250 --> 00:06:17.629
Chronology protection conjecture.
127
00:06:17.649 --> 00:06:21.959
Chronology protection conjecture. I believe I have a condom named that.
128
00:06:33.779 --> 00:06:35.439
That's for when you're looking for a good time.
129
00:06:36.600 --> 00:06:42.660
Chronology protection conjecture. So that sounds like time travel backwards
130
00:06:42.720 --> 00:06:43.480
should not be allowed.
131
00:06:44.310 --> 00:06:46.370
Yeah, this is an idea that came from Stephen Hawking,
132
00:06:47.170 --> 00:06:47.449
and he.
133
00:06:47.649 --> 00:06:49.069
Stephen Hawking, moment of silence.
134
00:06:49.089 --> 00:06:50.649
I love how he looks at me like I know
135
00:06:50.670 --> 00:06:51.449
Stephen Hawking.
136
00:06:53.480 --> 00:06:54.019
Stephen Hawking.
137
00:06:54.319 --> 00:06:57.800
And he asked the question I think all of us ask,
138
00:06:57.860 --> 00:07:00.579
which is if time travel to the past is possible,
139
00:07:01.120 --> 00:07:03.519
where are the time travelers?
140
00:07:03.740 --> 00:07:06.959
I've heard it hypothesized that the reason why the Titanic
141
00:07:07.000 --> 00:07:10.500
sank is everyone want to go back to the Titanic
142
00:07:10.779 --> 00:07:13.620
the first day a time travel device was invented. and
143
00:07:13.660 --> 00:07:15.879
then there were millions of people crammed on the Titanic
144
00:07:15.899 --> 00:07:16.459
and then it sank.
145
00:07:17.160 --> 00:07:21.699
Why would you go teleport to a sinking ship?
146
00:07:22.000 --> 00:07:24.500
That's a terrible idea. They wanted to experience a bit
147
00:07:24.519 --> 00:07:25.000
of history.
148
00:07:25.519 --> 00:07:28.019
And some of you may remember, I'm an old timer,
149
00:07:28.410 --> 00:07:31.269
the very first episode of Time Tunnel, they went back
150
00:07:31.310 --> 00:07:32.129
to the Titanic.
151
00:07:33.329 --> 00:07:33.399
Mmm.
152
00:07:35.019 --> 00:07:36.790
Okay, five of you are over 50 in the room.
153
00:07:36.870 --> 00:07:37.500
I was going to say.
154
00:07:37.639 --> 00:07:38.050
Remember.
155
00:07:38.060 --> 00:07:41.589
It's like either they're old or your geek level is
156
00:07:41.769 --> 00:07:42.870
off the charts.
157
00:07:43.069 --> 00:07:48.509
Like, that's super cool. Did he say, why not both?
158
00:07:50.310 --> 00:07:52.430
I stand corrected, you old geek.
159
00:07:58.250 --> 00:07:59.310
Old geek.
160
00:07:59.389 --> 00:08:03.430
So, Brian, so give me an example of the problem. Well.
161
00:08:03.449 --> 00:08:06.050
A demonstration of. why that conjecture might be true.
162
00:08:06.490 --> 00:08:09.470
Well, the puzzle is if you go to the past
163
00:08:09.490
--> 00:08:12.230
and you change things that prevent, for instance, your own birth,
164
00:08:12.269 --> 00:08:13.889
how were you there in the first place to make
165
00:08:13.930 --> 00:08:16.500
that change? So the usual example we talk about, you
166
00:08:16.540 --> 00:08:19.420
see it in Back to the Future, many other incarnations
167
00:08:19.459 --> 00:08:21.829
of these ideas. You go back to the past and
168
00:08:21.850 --> 00:08:24.670
you prevent your parents from meeting, right? So how were
169
00:08:24.689 --> 00:08:27.829
you there to execute that action if your parents never
170
00:08:27.930 --> 00:08:30.139
met so you were never born? So you run into
171
00:08:30.180 --> 00:08:33.820
this logical paradox if you allow certain kinds of changes
172
00:08:33.879 --> 00:08:36.340
to the past to take place. Now, there are ways
173
00:08:36.539 --> 00:08:39.240
out of this that you don't need the chronology projection conjecture,
174
00:08:39.259 --> 00:08:41.899
which would say you can't travel to the past. You
175
00:08:41.919 --> 00:08:44.620
could simply have it that the laws of physics prevent
176
00:08:44.700 --> 00:08:48.570
you from ever changing anything that was in the past. Namely,
177
00:08:48.950 --> 00:08:50.950
if you go to the past, you were always at
178
00:08:50.990 --> 00:08:53.289
that moment. There was never a version of that moment
179
00:08:53.350 --> 00:08:56.970
when you were not there. So it's always self-consistent because
180
00:08:57.110 --> 00:08:58.370
moments of time just are.
181
00:08:58.389 --> 00:08:59.529
They can't change.
182
00:08:59.789 --> 00:09:02.529
Could it be, for example, let's say I figure out
183
00:09:02.570 --> 00:09:06.559
how to send tachyons. in a text message, these are
184
00:09:06.580 --> 00:09:09.769
the hypothetical particles that would travel backwards in time. I
185
00:09:09.830 --> 00:09:11.370
see you walking, you're a good friend of mine, you're
186
00:09:11.389 --> 00:09:13.590
walking down the street, and you slip on a banana peel.
187
00:09:13.990 --> 00:09:16.289
And I said, oh, let me warn my friend that
188
00:09:16.330 --> 00:09:18.009
he's about to slip on a banana peel. So I
189
00:09:18.049 --> 00:09:20.769
quickly pull out my tachyon texting device.
190
00:09:20.970 --> 00:09:24.659
You're a better friend than I am, that's all I'm saying.
191
00:09:24.799 --> 00:09:28.639
Because that's hilarious, and I'm not warning you of anything.
192
00:09:29.080 --> 00:09:31.240
Oh my god, can you sext through time?
193
00:09:31.259 --> 00:09:35.519
That'd be amazing! So once I send a text, I say, Brian,
194
00:09:36.039 --> 00:09:37.820
watch out for the banana peel. So then it goes
195
00:09:37.879 --> 00:09:40.399
backwards in time. So then are you suggesting what might
196
00:09:40.440 --> 00:09:44.639
happen is you're walking down the lane and then I
197
00:09:45.220 --> 00:09:46.039
send you a text.
198
00:09:46.500 --> 00:09:49.639
And then you.
199
00:09:49.490 --> 00:09:50.429
Pick it up to read it.
200
00:09:50.429 --> 00:09:52.659
It says, watch out for the banana peel.
201
00:09:52.659 --> 00:09:55.850
And you slip on the banana peel because you were.
202
00:09:55.549 --> 00:09:57.629
Reading my text. Yes, exactly right.
203
00:09:57.629 --> 00:10:00.279
So that is the, so what you're saying is- no matter,
204
00:10:00.320 --> 00:10:03.820
you can't change because no matter what, you were there, period.
205
00:10:04.139 --> 00:10:06.179
Whatever that moment in time was, you were already there.
206
00:10:06.220 --> 00:10:07.720
He fell on his ass no matter what.
207
00:10:07.860 --> 00:10:08.840
Or the influence was there.
208
00:10:08.960 --> 00:10:10.320
Or the influence was there.
209
00:10:10.360 --> 00:10:12.240
Is there another possibility that when you go back in
210
00:10:12.320 --> 00:10:14.740
time and if you change something, it splinters off to
211
00:10:14.779 --> 00:10:15.840
its own different universe?
212
00:10:15.879 --> 00:10:17.639
That's the other possibility, yes.
213
00:10:17.779 --> 00:10:19.230
That's mind-blowing stuff. Yeah, yeah.
214
00:10:19.470 --> 00:10:23.450
So the other idea is that you can change the pattern.
215
00:10:23.470 --> 00:10:25.029
I just fist pounded you with a deal to cross Tyson.
216
00:10:27.500 --> 00:10:27.980
Sorry.
217
00:10:28.360 --> 00:10:29.299
NDT, baby.
218
00:10:30.740 --> 00:10:33.039
So you can change the past, but you can't change
219
00:10:33.080 --> 00:10:35.620
the past of your own universe. So if you go
220
00:10:35.679 --> 00:10:37.779
back into the past and say you prevent your parents
221
00:10:37.799 --> 00:10:40.460
from meeting, you're preventing them from meeting in a parallel
222
00:10:40.539 --> 00:10:43.779
copy of the universe within which you were born. So
223
00:10:44.000 --> 00:10:46.159
if they don't meet, that means you won't be born
224
00:10:46.279 --> 00:10:48.899
in that universe, but there's no mystery of where you
225
00:10:48.940 --> 00:10:51.419
came from. You were born in this universe. University of
226
00:10:51.480 --> 00:10:52.259
Parents did meet.
227
00:10:52.570 --> 00:10:54.690
See, but I have a whole different theory. You go
228
00:10:54.730 --> 00:10:58.110
back in time to keep your parents from meeting, but unfortunately,
229
00:10:58.230 --> 00:11:00.990
you get there just too late, and instead, you actually
230
00:11:01.029 --> 00:11:06.120
see the moment of your own conception. And then, because
231
00:11:06.159 --> 00:11:07.879
you witnessed that, you take out a.
232
00:11:07.899 --> 00:11:20.059
Gun and kill yourself. Thereby changing the timeline. Everyone here
233
00:11:20.100 --> 00:11:21.860
is now thinking about their parents doing it.
234
00:11:21.960 --> 00:11:26.860
Everyone. So, are you a fan of the Doctor Who series?
235
00:11:27.139 --> 00:11:29.529
I've actually only seen one episode.
236
00:11:29.889 --> 00:11:31.610
What?
237
00:11:31.690 --> 00:11:33.389
Security, could you? I'll
leave you.
238
00:11:35.429 --> 00:11:38.210
That is ridiculous because I've never seen a single episode.
239
00:11:38.549 --> 00:11:39.470
I'm sorry.
240
00:11:39.830 --> 00:11:43.529
Security. All right, so let me ask.
241
00:11:44.620 --> 00:11:47.899
Of course, everybody now wants to know what episode.
242
00:11:48.259 --> 00:11:54.909
I know, there was like this blue police thingamajiggy, and
243
00:11:55.210 --> 00:11:56.009
that's all I remember.
244
00:11:56.210 --> 00:11:57.450
Sorry, that's it.
245
00:11:57.450 --> 00:11:58.629
Does that clear it up for you?
246
00:11:58.649 --> 00:11:59.210
Take him out here.
247
00:11:59.250 --> 00:12:01.309
Right, because guess what? And she went just like this.
248
00:12:01.409 --> 00:12:07.019
That was episode 961. Oh, the one with the blue thingy. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
249
00:12:07.639 --> 00:12:12.039
So one of the interesting features of Doctor Who is
250
00:12:12.100 --> 00:12:18.889
that this blue thingy It's called a TARDIS. Which is
251
00:12:18.929 --> 00:12:22.970
an acronym for time and relative dimension in space.
252
00:12:24.509 --> 00:12:28.909
Okay, by the way, by the way, I gotta say
253
00:12:28.950 --> 00:12:31.090
that was pretty damn awesome what I just saw here.
254
00:12:31.450 --> 00:12:35.070
You just went, by the way, it's an acronym, stands for,
255
00:12:35.509 --> 00:12:37.830
and everybody else just said it right along with you.
256
00:12:37.889 --> 00:12:40.740
That's how we, because that's how we roll at Comic-Con.
257
00:12:40.789 --> 00:12:42.169
Wait, without missing a beat.
258
00:12:44.610 --> 00:12:47.090
So one of the fascinating elements of it, and they
259
00:12:47.110 --> 00:12:50.009
just treated this quite casually throughout the whole series, is
260
00:12:50.029 --> 00:12:52.429
that you walk into this police call box, it's a
261
00:12:52.470 --> 00:12:55.470
British police call box, and then inside is the entire ship.
262
00:12:56.570 --> 00:13:01.289
So that you're accessing another dimension of space by entering
263
00:13:01.610 --> 00:13:03.289
in it. So this would be like a fourth dimension.
264
00:13:03.549 --> 00:13:06.549
Yeah, so you're saying the inside is bigger than the outside.
265
00:13:06.570 --> 00:13:07.210
You didn't say it right.
266
00:13:07.250 --> 00:13:08.360
That's what I keep telling her.
267
00:13:09.240 --> 00:13:10.159
You just have to say.
268
00:13:11.759 --> 00:13:12.399
I don't know if it works.
269
00:13:12.480 --> 00:13:14.299
I don't know if the joke works.
270
00:13:14.320 --> 00:13:17.720
You just have to say, the phrase is, it's bigger
271
00:13:17.779 --> 00:13:19.879
on the inside. That's all you gotta say. Repeat that.
272
00:13:20.850 --> 00:13:21.309
Just repeat it.
273
00:13:21.870 --> 00:13:25.269
I'm afraid to.
274
00:13:25.570 --> 00:13:28.429
So, Doctor Who has just been very smartly written in
275
00:13:28.470 --> 00:13:32.190
this regard. It's got good physics in it. Yes, it's fiction,
276
00:13:32.289 --> 00:13:37.139
but it's got you thinking about how events can influence
277
00:13:37.750 --> 00:13:40.860
for past and future, and this is why they say
278
00:13:41.620 --> 00:13:45.539
time is this wibbly wobbly timey wimey. It's not so
279
00:13:45.659 --> 00:13:47.539
rigid that it's gonna follow what you think is a
280
00:13:48.700 --> 00:13:51.419
strict law of physics. It's got some more sort of
281
00:13:51.460 --> 00:13:52.559
chaotic elements to it.
282
00:13:52.740 --> 00:13:55.120
But it has a single timeline or it has multiple timelines?
283
00:13:55.220 --> 00:13:59.590
I interpret it as multiple timelines. And the Time Lord
284
00:13:59.620 --> 00:14:02.490
can access any timeline that is necessary for the task
285
00:14:02.529 --> 00:14:04.230
at hand, so that he can save the universe in
286
00:14:04.269 --> 00:14:04.809
every episode.
287
00:14:05.240 --> 00:14:08.039
Can I ask a general question? Is time just a
288
00:14:08.139 --> 00:14:09.000
human construct?
289
00:14:09.039 --> 00:14:12.059
Do other species understand the concept of time, the passing
290
00:14:12.100 --> 00:14:14.080
of it, and the future versus the past?
291
00:14:15.399 --> 00:14:17.200
Yes, okay, yes, they do.
292
00:14:17.259 --> 00:14:19.460
I mean, it's easy, it's all too easy for we
293
00:14:19.519 --> 00:14:22.860
humans to say what we do and think that other
294
00:14:22.940 --> 00:14:27.000
animals do not. And there's the human hubris deeply embedded
295
00:14:27.360 --> 00:14:29.980
in that assumption. Who are you to say that other
296
00:14:30.039 --> 00:14:33.340
animals don't think or contemplate or wonder about their fate?
297
00:14:34.240 --> 00:14:39.009
And Maybe we are pitied by eagles because our vision
298
00:14:39.330 --> 00:14:42.509
sucks compared to that of eagles. And they look, those
299
00:14:42.529 --> 00:14:45.549
poor humans, they can't even fly. Oh, I wonder if
300
00:14:45.590 --> 00:14:48.659
they dream about, oh, those poor things. Do you know
301
00:14:48.700 --> 00:14:51.659
how much pity we might be garnering in the minds
302
00:14:51.720 --> 00:14:52.779
and bodies of other animals?
303
00:14:53.519 --> 00:14:55.120
Most animals look down on me, yes.
304
00:14:55.320 --> 00:14:57.840
And I got another one. And here's another one, right?
305
00:14:58.139 --> 00:15:01.629
We can talk about and praise certain primates, other primates
306
00:15:01.669 --> 00:15:06.210
who maybe mimic sign language, okay? So these are animals
307
00:15:06.250 --> 00:15:10.210
that can speak to us using typically American sign language.
308
00:15:10.450 --> 00:15:16.269
But no one is asking, here are chimps speaking to
309
00:15:16.470 --> 00:15:18.850
us in our language, but at no time are we
310
00:15:18.970 --> 00:15:25.269
asked can we speak to them in their language. So
311
00:15:25.289 --> 00:15:27.529
they're smart enough to speak our language, we're not smart
312
00:15:27.570 --> 00:15:30.250
enough to speak theirs. So I don't know. I'm
not,
313
00:15:30.269 --> 00:15:32.529
I'm just, I want to, wait.
314
00:15:34.629 --> 00:15:37.899
All I know is what you said is beautiful and eloquent,
315
00:15:37.940 --> 00:15:40.460
but I doubt if there's a horse somewhere going, I
316
00:15:40.500 --> 00:15:42.399
wonder about the fabric of time.
317
00:15:46.159 --> 00:15:49.539
Yeah, goldfish are not thinking about time. They're just doing
318
00:15:49.620 --> 00:15:52.059
circles in the bowl. They can't remember their ass from
319
00:15:52.080 --> 00:15:52.519
their elbow.
320
00:15:53.240 --> 00:15:58.039
Yeah, keep telling yourself that. So one of Hawking's quotes,
321
00:15:58.149 --> 00:16:02.149
which is related to my Titanic comment, is if time
322
00:16:02.210 --> 00:16:05.379
travel were possible... Where are the tourists from the future?
323
00:16:05.480 --> 00:16:10.039
Yeah, I think that is the question. And one answer
324
00:16:10.139 --> 00:16:12.720
is every time they come here, we just put them
325
00:16:12.759 --> 00:16:14.179
in white coats and lock them up.
326
00:16:14.279 --> 00:16:16.039
I mean, that's one possibility.
327
00:16:16.490 --> 00:16:19.990
Or we put them in white coats and call them astrophysicists.
328
00:16:23.389 --> 00:16:29.110
But wait a minute. Isn't this quote from Hawking exactly
329
00:16:29.149 --> 00:16:30.620
what a time traveler would say?
330
00:16:34.080 --> 00:16:34.179
Ah.
331
00:16:34.620 --> 00:16:36.000
On that one, we just got to meditate.
332
00:16:36.080 --> 00:16:37.220
I see where you're going with this.
333
00:16:37.240 --> 00:16:39.399
I see where I'm going with that. So the people
334
00:16:39.440 --> 00:16:41.759
who are way ahead of the rest of us at
335
00:16:41.820 --> 00:16:45.629
any given time and space, like Da Vinci, like Einstein,
336
00:16:45.990 --> 00:16:48.809
like Marie Curie, like Stephen Hawking.
337
00:16:49.389 --> 00:16:50.110
Or Snooki.
338
00:16:50.629 --> 00:16:51.009
Snooki.
339
00:16:52.649 --> 00:16:54.909
Isn't it temporal law that if you ask a time
340
00:16:54.929 --> 00:16:57.149
traveler if they're a time traveler, they have to say
341
00:16:57.190 --> 00:16:57.950
they're a time traveler?
342
00:16:58.110 --> 00:16:59.570
Like a cop or a vampire, right?
343
00:17:01.210 --> 00:17:02.320
I have not heard that law, but.
344
00:17:03.460 --> 00:17:04.819
Temporal prime directive, no?
345
00:17:05.900 --> 00:17:11.880
So, what is the casual loop paradox? Is that something
346
00:17:12.440 --> 00:17:13.339
I just learned about?
347
00:17:13.380 --> 00:17:14.500
The causal loop paradox?
348
00:17:14.579 --> 00:17:15.980
I'm sorry, causal loop paradox, what is that?
349
00:17:16.140 --> 00:17:19.890
Yeah, so you don't want to have loops in space
350
00:17:19.950 --> 00:17:23.809
and time in which you can't have cause and effect
351
00:17:24.049 --> 00:17:27.390
be logically consistent, right? So we're all used to things
352
00:17:27.430 --> 00:17:29.619
in the past affecting things in the future, but if
353
00:17:29.740 --> 00:17:34.049
time loops around, then the future actually can affect the past.
354
00:17:34.529 --> 00:17:36.950
So the danger in a theory, and one of the
355
00:17:37.009 --> 00:17:39.589
diagnostics we use to see if a theory is healthy,
356
00:17:39.930 --> 00:17:41.490
is to make sure it doesn't have any of these
357
00:17:41.549 --> 00:17:45.269
closed time-like curves, in which cause and effect would be
358
00:17:45.569 --> 00:17:47.519
muddled up by the structure of space-time.
359
00:17:47.559 --> 00:17:50.180
This is a philosophical bias you are implementing on the
360
00:17:50.240 --> 00:17:50.900
universe itself.
361
00:17:51.119 --> 00:17:53.880
It's a little bit more than philosophical because you want
362
00:17:54.000 --> 00:17:57.339
the unfolding of events to be internally consistent.
363
00:17:57.380 --> 00:17:59.829
You're saying you want something to be true in the universe.
364
00:18:00.009 --> 00:18:01.089
That sounds like you're begging for something.
365
00:18:01.109 --> 00:18:03.849
Let me just say God needs it to be that way, right?
366
00:18:03.910 --> 00:18:08.710
Because if the laws of physics yield inconsistent results, then
367
00:18:08.910 --> 00:18:10.109
everything falls apart.
368
00:18:10.150 --> 00:18:10.710
Everything disappears.
369
00:18:10.730 --> 00:18:12.549
No, we just live in an inconsistent universe. You have
370
00:18:12.609 --> 00:18:13.190
a problem with that.
371
00:18:13.210 --> 00:18:13.430
No, no, no.
372
00:18:13.450 --> 00:18:16.539
What it means is our understanding is messed up. Clearly
373
00:18:16.599 --> 00:18:17.579
the world makes sense.
374
00:18:17.960 --> 00:18:18.259
No. No.
375
00:18:21.299 --> 00:18:22.220
I take that back.
376
00:18:22.400 --> 00:18:26.599
I take that back. I used to believe that.
377
00:18:26.759 --> 00:18:27.819
I take it back now.
378
00:18:28.380 --> 00:18:29.000
World mix.
379
00:18:29.119 --> 00:18:31.380
I just love that your voice cracked like you were
380
00:18:31.400 --> 00:18:33.220
a teenager when you said no.
381
00:18:34.269 --> 00:18:38.970
Clearly the word no. All right, so do you think
382
00:18:39.029 --> 00:18:40.190
one day we'll have a machine that will just send
383
00:18:40.230 --> 00:18:41.970
us forward in time? We know it's possible, but why
384
00:18:42.049 --> 00:18:42.910
aren't we doing it actively?
385
00:18:42.930 --> 00:18:45.450
Well, I think we do have a machine in principle, right?
386
00:18:45.630 --> 00:18:48.619
We just can't go very far forward in time. because
387
00:18:48.779 --> 00:18:51.359
every time you go into a vehicle and you undertake
388
00:18:51.420 --> 00:18:55.039
a round trip journey, you are traveling into the future.
389
00:18:55.140 --> 00:18:56.539
By some calculatable amount.
390
00:18:56.559 --> 00:18:59.309
Yeah, now at ordinary speeds, you're only going, you know,
391
00:18:59.329 --> 00:19:01.660
a billionth of a billionth of a second or something
392
00:19:01.700 -->
00:19:02.109
like that.
393
00:19:02.119 --> 00:19:02.640
Into the future.
394
00:19:02.690 --> 00:19:04.690
Into the future, but if you found yourself in a
395
00:19:04.750 --> 00:19:06.289
ship that was going near the speed of light, you
396
00:19:06.329 --> 00:19:07.970
go out for six months, you turn around, you come
397
00:19:08.009 --> 00:19:10.049
back for six months, You get off that ship, you
398
00:19:10.089 --> 00:19:12.410
will have aged one year, but depending on how close
399
00:19:12.430 --> 00:19:14.410
to the speed of light you got, when you step
400
00:19:14.490 --> 00:19:17.390
off the ship, Earth will be 10,000 years or a
401
00:19:17.430 --> 00:19:20.450
million years into the future. You will have jumped into
402
00:19:20.569 --> 00:19:23.150
Earth's future, and that is what we mean by time travel.
403
00:19:23.849 --> 00:19:27.630
How important in the future are the survival of humpback whales?
404
00:19:30.079 --> 00:19:34.109
Star Trek IV. Right, because it seems like we've got
405
00:19:34.130 --> 00:19:35.619
to solve the humpback whale problem.
406
00:19:35.630 --> 00:19:38.299
What's that? You just need transparent aluminum, and then you
407
00:19:38.319 --> 00:19:39.400
can solve it.
408
00:19:39.839 --> 00:19:41.160
That's it.
409
00:19:41.279 --> 00:19:41.799
Yeah.
410
00:19:42.759 --> 00:19:45.490
But the faster you go to the speed of light,
411
00:19:45.890 --> 00:19:49.170
the slower time moves, correct? So somebody on a spaceship
412
00:19:49.529 --> 00:19:51.839
would age... slower than somebody on Earth. They'd come back
413
00:19:52.240 --> 00:19:53.960
one year later, and the people on Earth have aged
414
00:19:53.960 --> 00:19:55.680
10 years, 100 years, something like that.
415
00:19:55.700 --> 00:19:56.859
That's the basic idea?
416
00:19:57.000 --> 00:19:57.599
That's the idea.
417
00:19:57.940 --> 00:19:59.940
And let me add, just to close out this segment,
418
00:20:00.339 --> 00:20:03.859
our GPS satellites orbit high enough so that there's a
419
00:20:04.000 --> 00:20:07.059
measurable and important difference in its rate of time that
420
00:20:07.119 --> 00:20:09.670
it keeps. compared to us here on the surface of
421
00:20:09.710 --> 00:20:12.769
the Earth. They're farther away from the source of gravity, Earth,
422
00:20:13.109 --> 00:20:16.660
so their time ticks faster than our clock time on
423
00:20:16.700 --> 00:20:18.819
the surface. And we know this, and it's Einstein's general
424
00:20:18.859 --> 00:20:22.049
theory of relativity. So they calculated how much faster their
425
00:20:22.230 --> 00:20:26.250
clocks would tick. And they back correct for that before
426
00:20:26.269 --> 00:20:29.130
it sends us the time that ends up on our smartphones.
427
00:20:29.190 --> 00:20:31.240
So if you accelerate towards the speed of light, time
428
00:20:31.359 --> 00:20:32.240
actually slows down.
429
00:20:32.319 --> 00:20:33.720
Yes. Okay, hold on.
430
00:20:39.579 --> 00:20:41.359
Chuck! Sell Apple!
431
00:20:41.720 --> 00:20:42.799
Sell your Apple!
432
00:20:44.910 --> 00:20:49.029
Thanks, everybody, for coming to the 2019 Comic-Con. You've been
433
00:20:49.049 --> 00:20:49.890
gone a year or something.
434
00:20:50.339 --> 00:20:53.059
All right, we've got to bring time travel to a close.
435
00:20:53.259 --> 00:20:56.500
Thanks for that topic. Comic-Con, our next topic is the
436
00:20:56.559 --> 00:21:00.759
quantum realm of Ant-Man. Give it up for my panel
437
00:21:00.779 --> 00:21:08.150
for that. I've got with me theoretical physicist Brian Green. Brian,
438
00:21:09.390 --> 00:21:09.809
you can, yes.
439
00:21:09.829 --> 00:21:17.519
Okay. I got Chuck Nice, my co-host, Chuck. Chuck, who
440
00:21:17.559 --> 00:21:18.019
did you bring?
441
00:21:18.799 --> 00:21:24.279
And of course, from Impractical Jokers, it's the mole!
442
00:21:24.299 --> 00:21:27.000
Hello, everybody. The mole.
443
00:21:28.039 --> 00:21:30.809
All right, so in a recent movie, The Ant-Man and
444
00:21:30.829 --> 00:21:35.130
the Wasp, okay, that's starring Paul Rudd, who we've had
445
00:21:35.309 --> 00:21:41.380
on StarTalk Live before. He is delightful. So, Brian, what
446
00:21:41.400 --> 00:21:43.349
does physics say about shrinking things?
447
00:21:44.410 --> 00:21:47.569
Well, it's tough to do, right?
448
00:21:47.769 --> 00:21:50.509
Because ultimately things are made of molecules and atoms and
449
00:21:50.529 --> 00:21:54.609
the quantum laws restrict the size of the individual atoms.
450
00:21:54.690 --> 00:21:57.920
So it's pretty tough to imagine changing them without changing
451
00:21:57.940 --> 00:21:59.480
the basic constants of nature.
452
00:21:59.539 --> 00:21:59.799
Wait, wait.
453
00:21:59.980 --> 00:22:04.140
But Rutherford, 100 years ago, noticed that atoms are mostly
454
00:22:04.220 --> 00:22:04.759
empty space.
455
00:22:04.779 --> 00:22:04.970
They are.
456
00:22:04.980 --> 00:22:06.380
Why can't you just squeeze that puppy down?
457
00:22:06.579 --> 00:22:06.759
Yep.
458
00:22:07.619 --> 00:22:08.779
Yeah, in fact, if you were to.
459
00:22:09.650 --> 00:22:13.359
squeeze down, if you could do it, the space in
460
00:22:13.380 --> 00:22:15.960
the atoms in every single human being that has ever
461
00:22:16.099 --> 00:22:19.269
lived on planet Earth, the resulting stuff would fit inside
462
00:22:19.289 --> 00:22:19.970
of a baseball.
463
00:22:20.089 --> 00:22:21.289
Wow. Ooh.
464
00:22:21.789 --> 00:22:25.079
And that's even with, you know, obesity problem in America? Yeah, yeah.
465
00:22:25.099 --> 00:22:25.859
Yeah.
466
00:22:26.980 --> 00:22:35.890
No, that's softball. So why is there some challenge then
467
00:22:36.210 --> 00:22:37.589
to shrinking out that empty space?
468
00:22:37.910 --> 00:22:40.210
It's very hard to get that empty space out because
469
00:22:40.490 --> 00:22:44.420
atoms have a certain amount of energy. And whereas we're
470
00:22:44.549 --> 00:22:47.269
used to being able to continuously
change the energy in.
471
00:22:47.190 --> 00:22:47.589
Something, right?
472
00:22:47.609 --> 00:22:49.250
If I take this from down on the floor, this
473
00:22:49.289 --> 00:22:51.430
water bottle, and as I raise it up higher and higher,
474
00:22:51.730 --> 00:22:55.390
it looks like I'm continuously adding in energy. Quantum mechanics
475
00:22:55.430 --> 00:22:59.220
says that is misleading. Energy comes in steps. You can't
476
00:22:59.299 --> 00:23:01.960
actually continuously change it. So for an atom, when you
477
00:23:01.980 --> 00:23:04.460
get down to the lowest step, the lowest energy, there
478
00:23:04.579 --> 00:23:06.160
is no lower step that.
479
00:23:06.579 --> 00:23:07.359
is in existence.
480
00:23:07.769 --> 00:23:09.930
So if you have a minimum amount of energy, you
481
00:23:09.970 --> 00:23:12.470
can't actually squeeze things down to zero size.
482
00:23:12.490 --> 00:23:14.430
You tell me that we can't have Ant-Man then?
483
00:23:14.769 --> 00:23:15.650
Well, you can have Ant-Man.
484
00:23:15.690 --> 00:23:20.500
All right, so let me ask you this. What constant
485
00:23:20.539 --> 00:23:23.289
of nature would need to be adjusted so that you
486
00:23:23.369 --> 00:23:25.309
could shrink down the atom. Is it Planck's constant?
487
00:23:25.329 --> 00:23:26.450
Yeah, Planck constant is one of them.
488
00:23:26.529 --> 00:23:28.589
So, you know, that's a, it could be a little
489
00:23:28.609 --> 00:23:31.349
bit technical, that's a dimension full number, but the radius
490
00:23:31.369 --> 00:23:33.930
of an atom depends on Planck's constant, it depends on
491
00:23:33.950 --> 00:23:36.630
the mass of the electron, it depends on the electric
492
00:23:36.710 --> 00:23:37.799
charge of the electron.
493
00:23:37.880 --> 00:23:41.519
So if you can imagine a zone where you influence
494
00:23:41.619 --> 00:23:45.519
quantum constants. you could, in principle, make a much smaller
495
00:23:45.599 --> 00:23:47.240
version of what existed in a larger state.
496
00:23:47.339 --> 00:23:50.119
You could. Now, you'd probably destroy the universe, but yes.
497
00:23:50.220 --> 00:23:51.140
That's all right, we'll take that risk.
498
00:23:51.160 --> 00:23:52.559
But it'd be worth it, though.
499
00:23:52.579 --> 00:23:53.880
Totally worth it.
500
00:23:54.539 --> 00:23:57.039
How would it destroy the universe? What's that? How would
501
00:23:57.079 --> 00:23:57.859
it destroy the universe?
502
00:23:58.000 --> 00:24:02.099
Well, the universe depends on the values of the constants
503
00:24:02.140 --> 00:24:04.160
in a very specific and delicate way.
504
00:24:04.460 --> 00:24:05.839
You started playing this game.
505
00:24:05.859 --> 00:24:07.680
The speed of light, the gravitational constant.
506
00:24:07.809 --> 00:24:09.970
Yeah, you change the ratio of the masses, you change
507
00:24:10.009 --> 00:24:12.789
the strengths of the forces, you change the fundamental speeds,
508
00:24:13.130 --> 00:24:15.950
and for instance,
stars no longer have nuclear processes, and
509
00:24:15.990 --> 00:24:16.910
stars don't light up.
510
00:24:16.970 --> 00:24:19.170
Without stars, the universe is a very different place.
511
00:24:19.589 --> 00:24:22.109
So in that sense, you don't just change the constants
512
00:24:22.170 --> 00:24:24.839
and look at how a bottle of water changes, you
513
00:24:24.859 --> 00:24:26.900
see how the entire universe changes.
514
00:24:27.000 --> 00:24:29.039
No, that's if you change the constants for the entire universe.
515
00:24:29.200 --> 00:24:31.099
I'm talking about changing the constants for just where Paul
516
00:24:31.140 --> 00:24:31.819
Rudd is standing.
517
00:24:32.000 --> 00:24:33.470
Okay, well, yeah, yeah, you.
518
00:24:33.769 --> 00:24:36.809
In principle, you could imagine that in your wildest dreams.
519
00:24:36.950 --> 00:24:37.230
But yeah.
520
00:24:37.250 --> 00:24:39.720
Yeah, that's what we do here. We imagine our wildest dreams.
521
00:24:39.740 --> 00:24:41.779
That's not even my wildest dreams. I live in a
522
00:24:41.819 --> 00:24:49.609
world where a reality TV star is the president, okay?
523
00:24:49.650 --> 00:24:52.279
Well, he's overinflated, isn't he?
524
00:24:56.900 --> 00:24:57.519
Where am I here?
525
00:24:57.700 --> 00:25:00.079
But yeah, in terms of shrinking, yes, if you could... Okay,
526
00:25:00.099 --> 00:25:00.839
so now watch what happens.
527
00:25:01.200 --> 00:25:03.859
So if you shrink, now I made you smaller, but
528
00:25:03.880 --> 00:25:07.339
you still have the same mass. And in the movie,
529
00:25:08.220 --> 00:25:11.900
Ant-Man is like riding the back of an ant. Now
530
00:25:11.940 --> 00:25:14.240
he would still weigh his 160 pounds or 170 pounds
531
00:25:14.279 --> 00:25:16.609
on the back of an ant, but he'd be this big.
532
00:25:16.829 --> 00:25:19.569
He squashed the ant. So is there any way in
533
00:25:19.869 --> 00:25:22.390
this universe to get rid of that mass? Because in
534
00:25:22.410 --> 00:25:25.039
the Ant-Man universe... I think there's something called a PIM
535
00:25:25.099 --> 00:25:29.660
particle that transfers your mass out into another dimension.
536
00:25:29.779 --> 00:25:32.599
Yeah, well, I mean, the quick answer is Einstein taught
537
00:25:32.619 --> 00:25:35.099
us that energy and mass are actually two sides of
538
00:25:35.140 --> 00:25:37.109
the same coin. So if you want to change the
539
00:25:37.160 --> 00:25:40.740
mass of something, you just extract energy from it. So
540
00:25:40.859 --> 00:25:43.299
you could have, you know, you have Paul Rudd there
541
00:25:43.359 --> 00:25:46.140
and you just watch heat and light and radiation all
542
00:25:46.200 --> 00:25:48.140
flying off of him as you shrink him down to
543
00:25:48.200 --> 00:25:48.660
a smaller size.
544
00:25:48.680 --> 00:25:51.640
And then he's on the amp, but he's just really tired.
545
00:25:53.470 --> 00:25:57.089
Okay, so if they were to put a nuance in
546
00:25:57.109 -->
00:26:01.349
the Ant-Man storytelling, he would be highly radiant as he
547
00:26:01.410 --> 00:26:01.970
got smaller.
548
00:26:02.029 --> 00:26:03.430
That would be one way of doing it, yeah.
549
00:26:03.529 --> 00:26:06.460
Sounds like you're describing a Swanson chicken dinner, like in
550
00:26:06.480 --> 00:26:07.079
a microwave.
551
00:26:07.099 --> 00:26:07.339
No.
552
00:26:09.730 --> 00:26:10.009
So.
553
00:26:10.390 --> 00:26:15.980
I'm just happy to be here, Neil. So then.
554
00:26:16.000 --> 00:26:16.059
So.
555
00:26:17.039 --> 00:26:23.549
Does anyone still eat Swanson chicken, dude?
556
00:26:23.589 --> 00:26:24.049
Is that what you.
557
00:26:25.650 --> 00:26:27.630
I'm an old geek, I'm sorry.
558
00:26:27.970 --> 00:26:29.190
Do you have a girlfriend or something?
559
00:26:29.210 --> 00:26:29.269
No.
560
00:26:29.329 --> 00:26:30.650
No, yeah, that's what I'm saying, right, right.
561
00:26:30.789 --> 00:26:31.730
Somebody to eat with.
562
00:26:31.769 --> 00:26:36.990
It's a TV dinner, you're still eating, that's the thing. So,
563
00:26:37.069 --> 00:26:40.849
but they describe the quantum realm. And just give me
564
00:26:40.970 --> 00:26:44.059
a couple of minutes reflection on the George Gamow series,
565
00:26:44.410 --> 00:26:46.339
where he changed the values of the constants.
566
00:26:46.420 --> 00:26:46.980
Oh, you mean Mr.
567
00:26:47.019 --> 00:26:47.599
Tompkins in Wonderland?
568
00:26:47.619 --> 00:26:47.799
Yeah, Mr.
569
00:26:47.819 --> 00:26:48.339
Tompkins in Wonderland.
570
00:26:48.359 --> 00:26:50.660
Yeah, that was from, I think, the 1940s or something
571
00:26:50.700 --> 00:26:53.400
like that. And yeah, it was a wonderful series of books.
572
00:26:53.990 --> 00:26:58.049
in which he imagined a universe in which somehow human
573
00:26:58.109 --> 00:27:00.430
beings are the same, but the constants of nature have
574
00:27:00.470 --> 00:27:01.190
a different value.
575
00:27:01.529 --> 00:27:02.029
So Mr.
576
00:27:02.089 --> 00:27:04.200
Tompkins is doing the kinds of things that Paul Rudd
577
00:27:04.220 --> 00:27:06.220
is doing, but with not quite the same special effects.
578
00:27:06.559 --> 00:27:08.759
You know, he's there playing pool and he hits the
579
00:27:08.799 --> 00:27:11.299
pool ball and the cue ball passes through one of
580
00:27:11.319 --> 00:27:14.059
the other balls on the table and it bounces around
581
00:27:14.160 --> 00:27:17.089
in a chaotic manner that illustrates like the many worlds
582
00:27:17.150 --> 00:27:19.740
of quantum physics. And I think it had a version
583
00:27:19.789 --> 00:27:22.089
where the speed of light was like five miles an hour.
584
00:27:22.470 --> 00:27:25.069
So then as people are walking by, they're shrunk and
585
00:27:25.089 --> 00:27:27.630
the rent's contracted to the size of a pancake as
586
00:27:27.650 --> 00:27:28.569
they're walking by you.
587
00:27:28.789 --> 00:27:30.289
So yeah, that was the kind of early version.
588
00:27:30.309 --> 00:27:32.589
So this would be an early version of just imaginary
589
00:27:32.630 --> 00:27:36.710
worlds that you would easily fold into a superhero universe.
590
00:27:36.730 --> 00:27:37.109
That's right.
591
00:27:37.329 --> 00:27:38.109
Yeah, yeah.
592
00:27:38.210 --> 00:27:40.500
So ironically, if you were shrunk down, you would have
593
00:27:40.559 --> 00:27:43.480
less energy, so you wouldn't be more powerful than you
594
00:27:43.519 --> 00:27:44.420
would be at full.
595
00:27:44.299 --> 00:27:44.859
Size, right? Oh, good point.
596
00:27:45.950 --> 00:27:50.059
You'd be like, that's two. That's two. For those who
597
00:27:50.130 --> 00:27:52.039
are counting, that's two. No, no, think about it.
598
00:27:52.039 --> 00:27:53.140
Jealous? Right, right.
599
00:27:53.200 --> 00:27:55.960
Because if you have power as a superhero, it's in
600
00:27:55.980 --> 00:27:57.960
your body somewhere. And if you've got to release all
601
00:27:57.980 --> 00:28:01.799
that energy to reduce your mass to become smaller, you're
602
00:28:01.819 --> 00:28:04.339
a weakling at that point. You don't have like the
603
00:28:04.500 --> 00:28:07.140
ant strength that people always want to talk about.
604
00:28:07.160 --> 00:28:08.180
Yeah, I think it has to do with like the
605
00:28:08.240 --> 00:28:10.740
ratio of the size to the, I mean, you have
606
00:28:10.759 --> 00:28:12.160
to really sort of work it out in detail.
607
00:28:12.180 --> 00:28:14.089
But yes, in principle, you could be right.
608
00:28:14.660 --> 00:28:17.680
Yes, unless you're Ruth Bader Ginsburg, in which case you
609
00:28:17.720 --> 00:28:27.950
have the power of ten men, no matter what.
610
00:28:28.089 --> 00:28:31.690
So, are you familiar with something called molecular disequilibrium?
611
00:28:32.950 --> 00:28:34.319
No, I don't think I am. You want to tell
612
00:28:34.339 --> 00:28:34.480
me that?
613
00:28:34.500 --> 00:28:35.779
That's because he just made it up.
614
00:28:36.200 --> 00:28:37.460
Ha ha ha ha ha!
615
00:28:38.130 --> 00:28:40.549
Well, can you give us a moment, tell us about
616
00:28:40.750 --> 00:28:41.569
quantum entanglement?
617
00:28:41.809 --> 00:28:45.019
Oh, quantum entanglement, yeah. So this is an idea that, again,
618
00:28:45.079 --> 00:28:45.900
came from Einstein.
619
00:28:45.940 --> 00:28:47.480
Is it only an idea? I thought we're doing it.
620
00:28:47.559 --> 00:28:50.839
Well, that's where it began, and Einstein brought it up
621
00:28:50.900 --> 00:28:53.039
because he didn't like quantum mechanics and thought this would
622
00:28:53.059 --> 00:28:55.599
be the death knell of quantum physics. he pointed out
623
00:28:55.640 --> 00:28:59.809
to all of the world's quantum mechanicians that their theory
624
00:29:00.119 --> 00:29:02.690
predicted that you could have a particle over here, another
625
00:29:02.730 --> 00:29:05.849
particle over here, distant from each other, but somehow, even
626
00:29:05.890 -->
00:29:08.950
though they're separated, and you do something to this particle,
627
00:29:09.069 --> 00:29:12.289
the math said that it will influence that particle, regardless
628
00:29:12.329 --> 00:29:13.990
of how far apart they are in space.
629
00:29:14.170 --> 00:29:15.589
I have a twin brother just like that.
630
00:29:15.630 --> 00:29:16.089
There you go.
631
00:29:17.130 --> 00:29:19.619
And Einstein called it spooky. That fact that you could
632
00:29:19.640 --> 00:29:22.160
do something here and effect something there. Spooky action at
633
00:29:22.200 --> 00:29:24.240
a distance. And he thought it was nuts.
634
00:29:24.400 --> 00:29:27.380
But in the movie, there are two characters that fuse
635
00:29:27.420 --> 00:29:31.009
together from a distance. So there's a quantum thing going on,
636
00:29:31.049 --> 00:29:34.329
but they're macroscopic objects. You're describing just subatomic particles.
637
00:29:34.349 --> 00:29:36.470
Yeah, I'm talking about particles like electrons and photons.
638
00:29:36.529 --> 00:29:39.630
But in principle, there's nothing about the world that would
639
00:29:39.670 --> 00:29:43.990
prevent these kinds of entangled qualities to exist on arbitrarily scales, right?
640
00:29:44.019 --> 00:29:44.210
Really?
641
00:29:44.390 --> 00:29:44.599
Yeah.
642
00:29:44.839 --> 00:29:45.880
It's just hard to.
643
00:29:46.680 --> 00:29:49.900
cause the particles to maintain those quantum properties.
644
00:29:50.180 --> 00:29:50.740
But it's just easier.
645
00:29:50.759 --> 00:29:51.839
When you have ensembles of particles.
646
00:29:51.859 --> 00:29:54.990
Yeah, because they're all banging into each other, knocking each
647
00:29:55.049 --> 00:29:59.150
other around, and diluting the cohesion of the system. But
648
00:29:59.190 --> 00:30:01.640
you can have it in principle on arbitrarily large scales.
649
00:30:02.210 --> 00:30:04.980
You know what's the crazy thing is that in our lifetimes,
650
00:30:05.519 --> 00:30:08.779
encryption will completely change. We are going to see it
651
00:30:08.940 --> 00:30:12.079
in the next 20, 30 years because of quantum entanglement.
652
00:30:12.099 --> 00:30:15.539
Of course, it will revolutionize passwords and how to decrypt
653
00:30:15.579 --> 00:30:17.869
things like that, but the Russians will still find ways
654
00:30:17.880 --> 00:30:18.529
to hack it, I'm sure.
655
00:30:24.089 --> 00:30:24.910
Can you imagine?
656
00:30:25.089 --> 00:30:26.690
I'm not fist bumping him on that one.
657
00:30:26.930 --> 00:30:30.539
You have a quantum entangled password, but the password is
658
00:30:30.599 --> 00:30:32.700
like one, two, three, four, five.
659
00:30:33.759 --> 00:30:34.660
Still stupid passwords.
660
00:30:34.680 --> 00:30:38.200
So, so, so.
661
00:30:38.339 --> 00:30:43.539
So, Brian.
662
00:30:55.809 --> 00:31:00.440
So we got, so give me just the plausibility of
663
00:31:00.460 --> 00:31:02.920
Ant-Man as a story mechanism.
664
00:31:03.420 --> 00:31:06.299
You
know, I'm not, just repeating my answer to Doctor Who,
665
00:31:06.329 --> 00:31:07.490
I've not actually seen Ant-Man.
666
00:31:08.660 --> 00:31:10.859
So I don't really know, but I know.
667
00:31:10.880 --> 00:31:13.960
Give the man a break. I've been working.
668
00:31:13.980 --> 00:31:15.500
I got things I got to do.
669
00:31:15.539 --> 00:31:18.759
He's a theoretical physicist, for God's sake.
670
00:31:18.819 --> 00:31:19.240
Thank you.
671
00:31:19.259 --> 00:31:24.829
He doesn't have time to go see Ant-Man. Solving the
672
00:31:24.890 --> 00:31:28.190
problems of the universe, and you mad because he's not
673
00:31:28.210 --> 00:31:30.529
sitting in the theater going, you know, Ant-Man, this ain't
674
00:31:30.549 --> 00:31:31.130
half bad.
675
00:31:35.130 --> 00:31:40.210
Brian, a couple more minutes in the segment. Brian, so
676
00:31:40.779 --> 00:31:43.079
have we ever found a realm in which our understanding
677
00:31:43.119 --> 00:31:45.460
of quantum, where quantum physics actually breaks down?
678
00:31:46.019 --> 00:31:48.980
We've never had a single piece of data, a single
679
00:31:49.019 --> 00:31:51.920
experiment that has contradicted the predictions of quantum mechanics.
680
00:31:51.960 --> 00:31:52.859
It has never happened.
681
00:31:53.920 --> 00:31:59.589
That's a profound comment. Second, we know that as you
682
00:31:59.609 --> 00:32:03.250
get smaller, the laws of physics manifest differently to you
683
00:32:03.640 --> 00:32:06.849
because different other forces dominate relative to when you're big,
684
00:32:07.400 --> 00:32:09.650
all right? So one of my favorite scenes in the
685
00:32:09.690 --> 00:32:14.710
movie A Bug's Life is when the geek ant goes to,
686
00:32:15.390 --> 00:32:16.549
and by the way, the theme of A Bug's Life
687
00:32:16.569 --> 00:32:19.809
was really just The Magnificent Seven, wasn't it? Think about it,
688
00:32:20.430 --> 00:32:24.089
think about it. So the colony's being terrorized by grasshoppers.
689
00:32:24.109 --> 00:32:27.009
The geek ant goes to find a set of roughneck
690
00:32:27.329 --> 00:32:30.569
other bugs to help protect them from these evil grasshoppers.
691
00:32:30.750 --> 00:32:32.730
And he goes to a bug bar. And at the bar,
692
00:32:32.950 --> 00:32:35.609
there's a mosquito who orders a drink. And what does
693
00:32:35.630 --> 00:32:38.970
the mosquito order? A Bloody Mary, of course. And so,
694
00:32:39.869 --> 00:32:42.009
not blood, it's a bar, of course. So it was
695
00:32:42.029 --> 00:32:43.890
a Bloody Mary. So what does the bartender do? Puts
696
00:32:43.930 --> 00:32:46.930
a blob of Bloody Mary right in front of it. Nice.
697
00:32:47.329 --> 00:32:48.430
That's surface tension.
698
00:32:48.450 --> 00:32:50.529
Surface tension! Right!
699
00:32:50.710 --> 00:32:52.309
It's here for surface tension.
700
00:32:52.349 --> 00:32:55.150
So they knew, the writers of this script, even though
701
00:32:55.190 --> 00:33:00.390
they gave the ant only four legs, They knew way
702
00:33:00.410 --> 00:33:07.059
more physics in this movie than biology. So there's the drink,
703
00:33:07.259 --> 00:33:11.480
and then the mosquito sticks its thing and sucks it out,
704
00:33:11.819 --> 00:33:14.380
and it was a beautiful moment. So my question to
705
00:33:14.420 --> 00:33:17.880
you is, if you get really, really quantum small, is
706
00:33:17.920 --> 00:33:22.130
there a point where our tiniest organisms actually need to
707
00:33:22.210 --> 00:33:25.650
interact in a quantum way? Or is quantum so small,
708
00:33:25.890 --> 00:33:26.670
they're not even there yet?
709
00:33:26.849 --> 00:33:27.630
No, absolutely.
710
00:33:28.609 --> 00:33:31.210
Think of a tardigrade. Think of a tardigrade. We'd love
711
00:33:31.230 --> 00:33:31.890
these little buggers.
712
00:33:31.930 --> 00:33:33.150
You're talking about those little.
713
00:33:33.470 --> 00:33:34.049
The water bears.
714
00:33:34.069 --> 00:33:35.410
You know who taught me about tardigrades?
715
00:33:35.450 --> 00:33:35.690
Who?
716
00:33:35.829 --> 00:33:38.130
The only other person in my life that's ever mentioned
717
00:33:38.150 --> 00:33:39.930
the word tardigrade, Paul Rudd.
718
00:33:40.519 --> 00:33:41.549
It all comes together, man.
719
00:33:41.559 --> 00:33:42.279
It comes together.
720
00:33:42.319 --> 00:33:43.339
It all comes together.
721
00:33:43.480 --> 00:33:43.759
Okay.
722
00:33:44.259 --> 00:33:46.359
But it's the case right now. So if you look
723
00:33:46.380 --> 00:33:50.099
at the molecular mechanisms... that are in your body producing
724
00:33:50.180 --> 00:33:53.200
energy right now, right? Anybody in organic chemistry, they learn
725
00:33:53.240 --> 00:33:56.619
about ADP, ATP, the details don't matter, but those are
726
00:33:56.640 --> 00:34:00.640
all quantum processes where these particles are coming together and
727
00:34:00.769 --> 00:34:04.089
allowing your body to persist only because of the laws
728
00:34:04.109 --> 00:34:07.670
of quantum physics acting themselves out trillions of times a
729
00:34:07.710 --> 00:34:08.750
second inside your body.
730
00:34:09.570 --> 00:34:10.429
So it's happening now.
731
00:34:12.949 --> 00:34:14.690
Wait, say that again. What about the big what?
732
00:34:14.829 --> 00:34:15.630
The big crush.
733
00:34:15.650 --> 00:34:18.400
The big crush. What about it?
734
00:34:19.199 --> 00:34:22.639
The opposite of.
735
00:34:22.659 --> 00:34:27.380
The Big Bang. Thank you. The opposite of the Big Bang.
736
00:34:28.039 --> 00:34:29.920
She said it's the opposite of the Big Bang for
737
00:34:29.960 --> 00:34:31.960
those of you in the back who cannot hear her.
738
00:34:37.070 --> 00:34:39.409
Well, so we'll get a minute from Brian on this,
739
00:34:39.449 --> 00:34:41.650
but then we gotta get to our next segment. So Brian,
740
00:34:42.210 --> 00:34:45.690
at the Big Bang, I'm quoting you almost verbatim, the
741
00:34:45.730 --> 00:34:51.340
large was small. And
quantum physics commands the small. General
742
00:34:51.380 --> 00:34:54.059
relativity commands the large. When the large is small, you
743
00:34:54.380 --> 00:34:58.559
have two very different theoretical descriptions of the universe in
744
00:34:58.579 --> 00:35:02.320
a shotgun marriage with one another. Thus is born the
745
00:35:02.360 --> 00:35:03.119
string theorist.
746
00:35:04.519 --> 00:35:06.380
There you go. All true.
747
00:35:06.400 --> 00:35:09.599
Ha ha ha!
748
00:35:09.639 --> 00:35:12.949
String theory. You're going to marry my daughter and make
749
00:35:13.030 --> 00:35:13.969
her an honest woman.
750
00:35:15.190 --> 00:35:16.579
Ha ha ha! Ha ha ha!
751
00:35:18.539 --> 00:35:23.480
All right, so just to affirm what our conclusions have been,
752
00:35:23.880 --> 00:35:27.000
that Ant-Man, there are ways you can imagine it happening.
753
00:35:27.300 --> 00:35:29.119
You just don't want to change the laws of physics
754
00:35:29.159 --> 00:35:31.980
for everyone, the quantum constants. You would do it just
755
00:35:32.019 --> 00:35:35.260
in the zone, in the quantum realm that Ant-Man occupies.
756
00:35:35.880 --> 00:35:38.000
Then Ant-Man can drop. Ant-Man, if we were to do
757
00:35:38.019 --> 00:35:41.059
it honoring known laws of physics, he'd have to release
758
00:35:41.119 --> 00:35:43.570
the energy of the mass that he loses, because mass
759
00:35:43.590 --> 00:35:46.469
and energy are equivalent. That would be an awesome, bright light,
760
00:35:46.860 --> 00:35:49.449
That could have made an interesting visual effect in the film.
761
00:35:49.829 --> 00:35:52.409
So then he gets small, he's gotta get energy from somewhere,
762
00:35:52.650 --> 00:35:56.250
but he has sort of normal bug strength at that level.
763
00:35:57.150 --> 00:35:58.690
So that's fine, and that's still consistent.
764
00:35:58.710 --> 00:35:59.110
That works.
765
00:35:59.769 --> 00:36:02.409
Now he's gotta get back, he's gotta absorb the energy
766
00:36:02.469 --> 00:36:03.280
back into himself.
767
00:36:03.530 --> 00:36:06.380
But first he has to go save a colony of ants.
768
00:36:08.960 --> 00:36:10.960
So that's some complicated, he has to go back in
769
00:36:11.000 --> 00:36:13.539
some machine or something to come back to life, back
770
00:36:13.579 --> 00:36:16.510
to his size. For sure. So you can make that work.
771
00:36:16.570 --> 00:36:17.510
I think we can make that work.
772
00:36:18.070 --> 00:36:21.349
Good to know. Wanted that affirmation. Brian Greene on.
773
00:36:24.849 --> 00:36:27.090
And we will not tell Paul Rudd that you have
774
00:36:27.130 --> 00:36:30.110
not seen either of his movies of Ant-Man. We will
775
00:36:30.130 --> 00:36:31.989
not tell him this, okay?
776
00:36:32.010 --> 00:36:32.710
Oh, I'ma tell him.
777
00:36:33.469 --> 00:36:34.070
Chuck.
778
00:36:37.929 --> 00:36:40.210
Welcome back to StarTalk at Comic-Con.
779
00:36:40.269 --> 00:36:41.320
Yeah. Yeah.
780
00:36:45.179 --> 00:36:47.869
I got Brian Greene, I got Chuck Nice, and we
781
00:36:47.889 --> 00:36:49.789
got The Mull. What's up, everybody?
782
00:36:50.070 --> 00:36:50.469
All right.
783
00:36:52.110 --> 00:36:55.769
We're gonna spend some time in the hit TV series
784
00:36:55.849 --> 00:37:02.730
on Netflix, Stranger Things. Yeah, they talk about sort of
785
00:37:02.869 --> 00:37:06.329
an upside down world, an upside down, it's some parallel
786
00:37:06.409 --> 00:37:09.170
universe where people can disappear into it, and they're still
787
00:37:09.190 --> 00:37:13.050
looking for people who went there. And can we?
788
00:37:13.969 --> 00:37:14.510
Poor Barb.
789
00:37:15.250 --> 00:37:16.070
What, what, what?
790
00:37:16.989 --> 00:37:17.530
Barb deserves better.
791
00:37:17.550 --> 00:37:19.769
Let me tell you something, you cannot say anything in
792
00:37:19.829 --> 00:37:23.349
front of this audience, okay? I'm just saying, you're like,
793
00:37:23.429 --> 00:37:25.489
and they disappear into it, and then all of a sudden,
794
00:37:25.510 --> 00:37:31.980
just dots of like, you know, forever! And I'll disappear!
795
00:37:32.039 --> 00:37:34.300
What happens to the people? Okay, now I'm like, see,
796
00:37:34.320 --> 00:37:36.420
I'm going to be like Brian right now, never seeing
797
00:37:36.460 --> 00:37:37.780
Stranger Things, so.
798
00:37:37.940 --> 00:37:38.460
You, what?
799
00:37:38.719 --> 00:37:40.980
Wait a minute, so, let me just ask. So Brian,
800
00:37:41.440 --> 00:37:44.400
when we want to think about multiple universes, I've heard
801
00:37:44.420 --> 00:37:48.199
the term brain used, B-R-A-N-E. Could you explain what that
802
00:37:48.260 --> 00:37:48.880
is in your world?
803
00:37:49.179 --> 00:37:51.599
Well, that's an idea that does come out of string theory.
804
00:37:51.980 --> 00:37:55.530
And the notion is that everything that we know about
805
00:37:55.869 --> 00:37:58.869
should be thought of as if it's one slice of
806
00:37:58.969 --> 00:38:00.769
space in a larger universe.
807
00:38:01.500 --> 00:38:02.000
Cosmos.
808
00:38:02.260 --> 00:38:03.139
Much higher dimension.
809
00:38:03.179 --> 00:38:04.300
Higher dimensional cosmos.
810
00:38:04.340 --> 00:38:06.719
The analogy that I like to use is imagine everything
811
00:38:06.739 --> 00:38:08.710
we know about is one slice of bread in a
812
00:38:08.730 --> 00:38:12.269
big cosmic loaf. And the other slices of bread would
813
00:38:12.289 --> 00:38:16.349
be other realms, other universes, potentially like ours, but separated
814
00:38:16.389 --> 00:38:19.989
from us by a distance along the axis of the loaf.
815
00:38:20.409 --> 00:38:24.469
So our entire universe would be one slice of bread.
816
00:38:24.510 --> 00:38:25.230
One slice of this bread.
817
00:38:25.250 --> 00:38:25.929
That's right.
818
00:38:26.150 --> 00:38:30.360
Okay. Okay, so if you left this universe... But you
819
00:38:30.400 --> 00:38:33.340
still existed. You, in principle, found some way to get
820
00:38:33.360 --> 00:38:34.360
to the next slice of bread.
821
00:38:34.800 --> 00:38:35.019
Yes.
822
00:38:35.440 --> 00:38:38.000
And in fact, we know, according to the physics that
823
00:38:38.039 --> 00:38:41.449
we study, how one would do that or how, in principle,
824
00:38:41.530 --> 00:38:43.570
energy can leave one slice of bread to the other.
825
00:38:43.989 --> 00:38:47.530
If the energy is carried by gravity, gravitational waves, then
826
00:38:47.550 --> 00:38:48.030
that can travel.
827
00:38:48.090 --> 00:38:48.489
Or jelly.
828
00:38:49.260 --> 00:38:51.860
So gravitational waves can leave our membrane and go to
829
00:38:51.909 --> 00:38:52.340
another membrane.
830
00:38:52.360 --> 00:38:54.309
That's right, so if you wanted to communicate from one
831
00:38:54.710 --> 00:38:57.530
membrane to another, you could have like a gravity phone
832
00:38:57.550 --> 00:39:00.500
that would send out vibrations in space time as opposed
833
00:39:00.519 --> 00:39:01.440
to vibrations in air.
834
00:39:01.760 --> 00:39:02.920
Would it be T-Mobile or.
835
00:39:04.840 --> 00:39:10.500
Ryan, this is a... Clearly we have some sponsors in
836
00:39:10.539 --> 00:39:11.260
the audience.
837
00:39:12.659 --> 00:39:13.079
Right.
838
00:39:13.480 --> 00:39:19.300
Verizon. Mer just said T-Mobile. They were like, Verizon!
839
00:39:19.429 --> 00:39:23.130
It's Verizon!
840
00:39:23.449 --> 00:39:27.170
You know what? When Verizon has a gravity phone, call me, okay?
841
00:39:27.909 --> 00:39:29.590
Can I ask you an honest question I've been hearing
842
00:39:29.650 --> 00:39:32.019
and seeing lots of videos and reading things about saying
843
00:39:32.059 --> 00:39:34.659
that in our lifetimes as well, we will be able
844
00:39:34.679 --> 00:39:38.099
to communicate with another universe. For example, the cold spot
845
00:39:38.119 --> 00:39:41.210
in space they think might be a spot where the
846
00:39:41.250 --> 00:39:44.630
universes are touching us in a parallel universe. Do you
847
00:39:44.710 --> 00:39:46.610
think that that is going to happen, that we'll be
848
00:39:46.650 --> 00:39:48.789
able to develop a way to communicate with another universe
849
00:39:48.849 --> 00:39:49.389
in our lifetimes?
850
00:39:50.079 --> 00:39:51.579
No. No.
851
00:39:52.280 --> 00:39:55.079
Screw you, Verizon. Whoa! I'm kidding.
852
00:39:55.099 --> 00:39:56.320
I love Verizon.
853
00:39:56.380 --> 00:40:00.440
I love it. I'm kidding. Top scientists at Verizon are
854
00:40:00.460 --> 00:40:00.739
working on it.
855
00:40:00.739 --> 00:40:02.280
Can I follow that up with just, here's a question
856
00:40:02.300 --> 00:40:06.030
that I hear all the time on Twitter, okay, which is,
857
00:40:06.639 --> 00:40:10.710
is dark energy or dark matter, whichever you want to
858
00:40:10.750 --> 00:40:14.429
go with, we know that there's a distinction, but is
859
00:40:14.590 --> 00:40:21.079
that perhaps the... other universe bleeding over into our universe,
860
00:40:21.239 --> 00:40:23.639
and that is why we're not able to really understand
861
00:40:23.659 --> 00:40:24.090
what it is.
862
00:40:24.530 --> 00:40:28.809
And it's a mysterious presence, and it's real matter in
863
00:40:28.849 --> 00:40:31.590
another universe, but now it's mysterious in our universe.
864
00:40:31.610 --> 00:40:34.389
Yeah, kind of like it's the, what we're seeing are
865
00:40:34.449 --> 00:40:37.199
the effects of the real thing someplace else.
866
00:40:37.239 --> 00:40:37.820
From another universe.
867
00:40:37.840 --> 00:40:39.900
From another universe. Could that possibly be the case?
868
00:40:39.960 --> 00:40:42.340
Yeah, actually this is an idea that people have studied.
869
00:40:42.969 --> 00:40:45.699
And it's a beautiful idea. I would love it if
870
00:40:45.739 --> 00:40:46.460
that were the answer.
871
00:40:46.500 --> 00:40:47.699
I'm one of those people, Brian.
872
00:40:47.719 --> 00:40:48.420
Yeah, there you go.
873
00:40:49.519 --> 00:40:51.679
I have studied this extensively on Twitter.
874
00:40:51.699 --> 00:40:56.869
You know, if the reason it's dark is because the
875
00:40:56.929 --> 00:40:59.849
light that it might emit simply can't traverse from that
876
00:41:00.309 --> 00:41:02.550
slice of bread to our slice of bread, that would
877
00:41:02.570 --> 00:41:05.150
be a beautiful solution. It's very hard to make that
878
00:41:05.230 --> 00:41:09.349
idea work mathematically. So it's out there, it's worth thinking about,
879
00:41:09.389 --> 00:41:11.760
but I have not seen a version that actually is
880
00:41:11.820 --> 00:41:14.260
able to dot all the I's and cross all the
881
00:41:14.280 --> 00:41:14.980
T's and make it work.
882
00:41:15.340 --> 00:41:17.519
Okay, so Brian, there's the gravity waves that can get,
883
00:41:17.900 --> 00:41:21.719
gravitational waves that can get across the membrane, but is
884
00:41:21.760 --> 00:41:26.659
there some way a wormhole could do it? Or is
885
00:41:26.699 --> 00:41:30.250
there some access to these higher dimensions that we just
886
00:41:30.269 --> 00:41:34.630
haven't figured out how to invoke yet? So, and in fact,
887
00:41:34.769 --> 00:41:39.369
in Stranger Things, this other Dimension it's got like monsters
888
00:41:39.409 --> 00:41:41.789
in it. I mean, it's not just another universe with
889
00:41:41.829 --> 00:41:45.750
me in it. It's a different place and so Is
890
00:41:45.769 --> 00:41:47.610
there can you imagine a way to do that and
891
00:41:47.630 --> 00:41:49.550
reason why I ask is there's this great example I
892
00:41:49.590 --> 00:41:52.030
think you've given which is it the flea on the
893
00:41:52.070 --> 00:41:54.269
tightrope get to tell us that example.
894
00:41:54.210 --> 00:41:56.329
Yeah, this is the idea that dimensions can be big
895
00:41:56.510 --> 00:41:59.739
and small and And if a dimension's curled up like
896
00:41:59.820 --> 00:42:03.019
this circular dimension that's on a tightrope wire, from a
897
00:42:03.079 --> 00:42:05.050
disadvantage point, you and I won't see it.
898
00:42:05.099 --> 00:42:06.940
The tightrope just looks like a straight line. You only
899
00:42:06.960 --> 00:42:07.940
see that one dimension.
900
00:42:08.239 --> 00:42:09.940
But if you zoom in and take the perspective of
901
00:42:09.960 --> 00:42:12.179
a little flea that's walking along it, that little flea
902
00:42:12.199 --> 00:42:14.769
can go along the tightrope but I can also walk
903
00:42:14.809 --> 00:42:17.849
around it, revealing that curled up portion of space that
904
00:42:17.889 --> 00:42:19.269
we would miss, because we're just too big.
905
00:42:19.449 --> 00:42:20.050
We're too big.
906
00:42:20.510 --> 00:42:23.650
So if you're the tightrope walker, it's a one-dimensional line.
907
00:42:24.110 --> 00:42:26.550
Your flea, it's a whole world to you. It's like
908
00:42:26.570 --> 00:42:29.409
the book Flatland, right? It's a version of that, yes,
909
00:42:29.469 --> 00:42:30.090
exactly right.
910
00:42:30.489 --> 00:42:34.139
So the real question is, if that flea had a phone,
911
00:42:34.199 --> 00:42:36.440
could it use Verizon to call us?
912
00:42:38.980 --> 00:42:40.980
Chuck is trying to save your ass in this thing.
913
00:42:43.030 --> 00:42:43.269
I'm sorry.
914
00:42:43.309 --> 00:42:45.199
I'm just worried about the people who paid my check.
915
00:42:46.900 --> 00:42:49.000
Oh my god, it's literally behind me. I didn't realize.
916
00:42:49.340 --> 00:42:52.619
I'm sorry. I didn't know. Nobody told me. I'm sorry,
917
00:42:52.639 --> 00:42:54.960
I didn't sign a sponsorship with you right before the game.
918
00:42:54.980 --> 00:42:55.349
Anyways, let's go.
919
00:42:55.360 --> 00:42:56.929
It's only on the sign 400,000 times.
920
00:42:57.139 --> 00:42:57.429
Okay.
921
00:42:57.610 --> 00:43:01.570
I'm just.
922
00:43:01.869 --> 00:43:03.630
Zooming on just him right now. Just give me a
923
00:43:03.650 --> 00:43:04.909
camera shot on him right now.
924
00:43:05.289 --> 00:43:05.809
See?
925
00:43:05.849 --> 00:43:07.349
Ryan's sitting right over your head right now.
926
00:43:07.530 --> 00:43:07.610
Okay?
927
00:43:11.050 --> 00:43:13.050
I'm just happy to be here, man. I'm just happy
928
00:43:13.070 --> 00:43:13.489
to be here.
929
00:43:15.039 --> 00:43:17.900
So, Brian, what I'm asking is, can we find some
930
00:43:18.079 --> 00:43:21.719
portal in our own universe, we just step through it
931
00:43:21.760 --> 00:43:24.519
and you disappear? What's preventing that?
932
00:43:24.679 --> 00:43:25.639
I want that.
933
00:43:25.699 --> 00:43:28.610
Yeah, well, in principle, these other slices of bread, these
934
00:43:28.690 --> 00:43:32.090
other brain universes... are governed by the very same laws
935
00:43:32.130 --> 00:43:34.570
of physics that we know about. We know in our universe,
936
00:43:34.590 --> 00:43:36.869
you can bend the fabric of space by having a
937
00:43:36.869 --> 00:43:38.550
lot of energy. You can bend the
bread by having
938
00:43:38.590 --> 00:43:40.420
a lot of mass, a lot of energy. That's what
939
00:43:40.460 --> 00:43:43.679
a black hole does. It creates a tunnel, an indentation,
940
00:43:43.719 --> 00:43:45.579
if you will, in the fabric of space. So imagine
941
00:43:45.599 --> 00:43:47.380
you got a black hole in that realm, a black
942
00:43:47.400 --> 00:43:49.579
hole in this realm, and you indent the space in
943
00:43:49.619 --> 00:43:52.679
such a way that they join together into this wormhole structure.
944
00:43:54.159 --> 00:43:56.980
Whether this could really work in this context, I don't know.
945
00:43:57.000 --> 00:43:58.280
That's not what I'm asking you. Is there a law
946
00:43:58.300 --> 00:43:59.119
of physics that prevents it?
947
00:43:59.119 --> 00:43:59.800
No, I don't think so.
948
00:43:59.909 --> 00:44:00.840
There it is.
949
00:44:00.909 --> 00:44:03.630
Is there a world in which you could have two
950
00:44:03.710 --> 00:44:08.389
quantum entangled pieces of information across universes?
951
00:44:08.750 --> 00:44:09.210
Absolutely.
952
00:44:09.250 --> 00:44:12.570
So if you had two gravitons that were entangled and
953
00:44:12.789 --> 00:44:16.369
one shot off our brain because gravity can freely move
954
00:44:16.449 --> 00:44:19.699
through the entirety of this larger cosmos, then yeah, you
955
00:44:19.719 --> 00:44:22.900
could have two entangled gravitons in principle entangled existing in
956
00:44:22.940 --> 00:44:23.699
different universes.
957
00:44:23.820 --> 00:44:28.329
That is pretty awesome. That's mind-blowing. But I still can't
958
00:44:28.369 --> 00:44:29.849
send a text from the Staten Island Ferry. I don't
959
00:44:29.869 --> 00:44:33.820
get it. No reception.
960
00:44:34.409 --> 00:44:39.340
So what is this multi-worlds interpretation of quantum physics? Do
961
00:44:39.360 --> 00:44:40.820
those count as parallel universes?
962
00:44:40.860 --> 00:44:41.260
They do.
963
00:44:41.280 --> 00:44:46.139
I mean, the key idea is that multi-universe theories don't
964
00:44:46.159 --> 00:44:47.110
come in a single flavor.
965
00:44:47.489 --> 00:44:49.489
There are various versions, and the one that you're referring
966
00:44:49.510 --> 00:44:49.829
to now.
967
00:44:49.849 --> 00:44:51.429
These are competing theoretical ideas.
968
00:44:51.710 --> 00:44:54.630
Oh, actually, some people think they're the same theory in disguise.
969
00:44:55.309 --> 00:44:57.909
You know, so in quantum mechanics, you have this idea
970
00:44:57.949 --> 00:45:00.769
that the equations only predict the probability for one outcome
971
00:45:00.809 --> 00:45:03.389
or another, like an electron has a... 40% chance of
972
00:45:03.429 --> 00:45:05.730
being here and 60% chance of being here. And the
973
00:45:05.750 --> 00:45:08.150
question is, when you measure the electron, you find it
974
00:45:08.250 --> 00:45:12.320
over here, what happened to the other possibility? And one
975
00:45:12.340 --> 00:45:14.980
of the notions that came out of the 1950s is
976
00:45:15.019 --> 00:45:18.059
that that other possibility is just as real as the
977
00:45:18.119 --> 00:45:21.480
one that you witnessed. It's simply taking place in another world,
978
00:45:21.559 --> 00:45:24.280
another universe parallel to yours, and there's a version of
979
00:45:24.320 --> 00:45:27.559
you in that world measuring that electron and seeing it
980
00:45:27.619 --> 00:45:31.050
at that position, thinking there's a unique outcome from your experiment,
981
00:45:31.340 --> 00:45:33.219
But you're completely wrong, because there are two of you
982
00:45:33.300 --> 00:45:34.239
each having that thought.
983
00:45:34.380 --> 00:45:35.420
There are multiple worlds.
984
00:45:35.440 --> 00:45:36.280
Calm down, calm down.
985
00:45:36.300 --> 00:45:36.500
Okay.
986
00:45:39.320 --> 00:45:42.559
He's about to blow a gasket there. That was awesome.
987
00:45:43.000 --> 00:45:43.559
That was awesome.
988
00:45:44.000 --> 00:45:46.039
The only way that could have been better is at
989
00:45:46.079 --> 00:45:48.400
the end of that little diatribe, you just.
990
00:45:48.300 --> 00:45:49.460
Went, I'm Pickle Rick!
991
00:45:50.019 --> 00:45:50.980
No, if he just.
992
00:45:52.619 --> 00:45:53.079
All right, all right.
993
00:45:53.719 --> 00:45:53.920
So.
994
00:46:01.840 --> 00:46:03.860
So now, where do we leave off on that?
995
00:46:04.460 --> 00:46:06.079
It seemed like he was about to slap Chuck. I
996
00:46:06.119 --> 00:46:08.079
don't know. He's getting very worked up.
997
00:46:08.360 --> 00:46:12.469
No, so we're just trying to understand that the idea
998
00:46:12.510 --> 00:46:14.369
that you can leave this universe and enter another one
999
00:46:14.389 --> 00:46:18.690
without any special arrangements, it's just, there's a place, and
1000
00:46:18.710 --> 00:46:22.750
you disappear there. Do I need special black holes and
1001
00:46:22.769 --> 00:46:26.409
wormholes and warps in the fabric of space-time. Well, can
1002
00:46:26.429 --> 00:46:28.010
I just pry open a hole?
1003
00:46:28.230 --> 00:46:30.409
No, I think you do need all those gadgets you're
1004
00:46:30.449 --> 00:46:33.230
referring to because, for instance, in the many worlds approach,
1005
00:46:33.530 --> 00:46:35.650
you would still be in this universe. There would just
1006
00:46:35.690 --> 00:46:38.219
be another version of you in that other universe. If
1007
00:46:38.239 --> 00:46:39.199
you really want to disappear.
1008
00:46:39.219 --> 00:46:42.440
So you're saying Schrodinger's cat is still alive somewhere?
1009
00:46:42.460 --> 00:46:45.099
In one universe, in this approach, Schrodinger's cat is alive,
1010
00:46:45.119 --> 00:46:48.000
and in another universe, Schrodinger's cat is dead. So each
1011
00:46:48.039 --> 00:46:50.639
of the outcomes happen. They just happen in different places.
1012
00:46:50.719 --> 00:46:54.119
Talk to me about Elvis. Alive, dead, and what?
1013
00:46:54.139 --> 00:46:57.239
That did not work, that joke.
1014
00:46:57.280 --> 00:47:00.719
I'm going to move on. Can you undo a fist bump?
1015
00:47:00.840 --> 00:47:02.159
Is that possible?
1016
00:47:02.460 --> 00:47:05.130
I'm down to one. Back down to one.
1017
00:47:05.139 --> 00:47:06.789
Yeah, you got docked one fist bump on that one.
1018
00:47:06.809 --> 00:47:09.110
There's another universe where I now have three fist bumps.
1019
00:47:09.269 --> 00:47:10.809
Yeah.
1020
00:47:16.670 --> 00:47:17.460
Sadly, not this one.
1021
00:47:17.469 --> 00:47:21.840
So, Brian, holding aside your loaf of bread, the multiverse,
1022
00:47:22.320 --> 00:47:24.260
whether or not they're lined up as loaves of bread,
1023
00:47:24.599 --> 00:47:27.739
we can still think of an infinite number of universes,
1024
00:47:27.840 --> 00:47:30.400
and a lot of talk about there's another universe where
1025
00:47:30.440 --> 00:47:32.949
we're all in stage, but we're seating in a different order,
1026
00:47:33.320 --> 00:47:36.449
or I have a goatee, which makes me evil, you know.
1027
00:47:36.849 --> 00:47:41.510
So, so... I've seen that episode. .
1028
00:47:41.449 --> 00:47:44.030
.
1029
00:47:45.869 --> 00:47:52.550
All right, so is it plausible to imagine that in
1030
00:47:52.590 --> 00:47:56.110
an infinite number of universes, everything is possible? Or, and
1031
00:47:56.130 --> 00:47:58.769
I kind of want to end on this thought, I
1032
00:47:58.809 --> 00:48:00.869
happen to know, I learned this early in life, that
1033
00:48:00.889 --> 00:48:03.969
there are orders of infinity. Some infinities are bigger than
1034
00:48:04.070 --> 00:48:07.670
other infinities. And is the infinity of multiverses a large
1035
00:48:07.710 --> 00:48:12.369
enough infinity to accommodate all possible variations in all outcomes
1036
00:48:12.670 --> 00:48:15.090
of all molecules assembled as all life?
1037
00:48:16.269 --> 00:48:19.710
The answer is yes, according to the traditional interpretation.
1038
00:48:19.730 --> 00:48:23.920
That is mind-blowing. It's inconceivable, almost, for the human brain.
1039
00:48:23.940 --> 00:48:26.539
The universe is under no obligation to make sense to you.
1040
00:48:26.599 --> 00:48:27.079
Yeah, I know.
1041
00:48:27.099 --> 00:48:27.179
Okay.
1042
00:48:29.340 --> 00:48:30.510
Or any of us, yes.
1043
00:48:31.969 --> 00:48:34.889
However, there's another universe where it is under that obligation.
1044
00:48:39.380 --> 00:48:40.840
So what are you saying here?
1045
00:48:40.940 --> 00:48:43.369
Yeah, so when you actually look at the quantum equations,
1046
00:48:43.429 --> 00:48:46.929
the idea is that any possible configuration of the particles
1047
00:48:47.309 --> 00:48:49.309
that's allowed by the laws of physics, which means it
1048
00:48:49.329 --> 00:48:54.579
has a non-zero probability of happening, is represented in one.
1049
00:48:54.719 --> 00:48:55.619
Of these worlds.
1050
00:48:55.940 --> 00:48:57.179
If there's an
infinite number of worlds.
1051
00:48:57.659 --> 00:48:59.699
There has to be an infinite number, and indeed there
1052
00:48:59.719 --> 00:49:00.559
are a number of them.
1053
00:49:00.579 --> 00:49:01.519
What do you mean there has to be?
1054
00:49:01.980 --> 00:49:06.199
Because there are so many configurations of the particles that
1055
00:49:06.219 --> 00:49:08.360
we wouldn't be able to accommodate it otherwise.
1056
00:49:08.380 --> 00:49:11.409
Because otherwise you would limit the configurations.
1057
00:49:11.449 --> 00:49:12.190
Yeah, you would.
1058
00:49:12.250 --> 00:49:14.349
I mean, imagine the universe goes on infinitely far. That's
1059
00:49:14.389 --> 00:49:17.039
a real possibility in terms of space going on infinitely far.
1060
00:49:17.050 --> 00:49:18.489
The extension of the universe goes infinite.
1061
00:49:18.530 --> 00:49:19.170
Yeah, so we could.
1062
00:49:19.199 --> 00:49:22.360
have an infinite number of particles in this infinite expanse
1063
00:49:22.400 --> 00:49:25.480
of space, and each of them has some configuration that's
1064
00:49:25.519 --> 00:49:27.909
evolving through time. So you have to be able to
1065
00:49:27.949 --> 00:49:30.150
accommodate that if this math is the right way of
1066
00:49:30.190 --> 00:49:30.650
doing things.
1067
00:49:32.730 --> 00:49:32.889
Woo!
1068
00:49:35.440 --> 00:49:37.539
I'm going to tell you one thing. I don't smoke weed,
1069
00:49:37.579 --> 00:49:38.619
but I'm going to start.
1070
00:49:38.739 --> 00:49:41.139
I'm just happy to be here.
1071
00:49:41.380 --> 00:49:43.480
And now I am too.
1072
00:50:03.190 --> 00:50:06.929
So Brian, could you offer us some parting thoughts on
1073
00:50:07.590 --> 00:50:11.699
what you would like to see treated more seriously or
1074
00:50:11.739 --> 00:50:15.719
more authentically in the imagination of science fiction writers based
1075
00:50:15.739 --> 00:50:17.920
on the physics that you know? For example, we had
1076
00:50:17.940 --> 00:50:21.820
the film Interstellar, which made great attempts to represent black
1077
00:50:21.860 --> 00:50:25.420
holes and wormholes and time dilation and the like. So
1078
00:50:26.179 --> 00:50:28.019
do you see more of that or should we leave
1079
00:50:28.079 --> 00:50:29.719
a little extra room there for people to make up
1080
00:50:29.760 --> 00:50:30.480
what the hell they want?
1081
00:50:30.789 --> 00:50:34.510
Yeah, I'm a big fan of make up part of
1082
00:50:34.719 --> 00:50:37.300
what you want because ultimately, at least when I, on
1083
00:50:37.340 --> 00:50:39.630
the one time that I've seen a film, you know...
1084
00:50:40.630 --> 00:50:42.670
You know, I just like it to wash over me.
1085
00:50:42.730 --> 00:50:45.210
I don't sit there like I think perhaps you do.
1086
00:50:45.210 --> 00:50:45.949
Or maybe you don't.
1087
00:50:46.389 --> 00:50:52.510
Where you're actually constantly judging the accuracy of what you're seeing.
1088
00:50:53.210 --> 00:50:55.670
Just take me
away. That's all I want to happen
1089
00:50:55.710 --> 00:50:59.059
in these things. So I'm a little bit different perspective.
1090
00:50:59.119 --> 00:51:01.219
I think. Did you not know there's no sound in space?
1091
00:51:03.500 --> 00:51:05.519
So, okay, so you can just, they can tell whatever.
1092
00:51:05.880 --> 00:51:07.039
Well, within reason.
1093
00:51:07.059 --> 00:51:07.699
And by the way.
1094
00:51:07.719 --> 00:51:10.159
No, no, let me qualify. Wait, wait, no.
1095
00:51:12.360 --> 00:51:13.739
You, I just want to say.
1096
00:51:13.760 --> 00:51:14.780
You're going to let me qualify.
1097
00:51:14.800 --> 00:51:15.079
I will.
1098
00:51:15.739 --> 00:51:17.409
You were in a science fiction movie yourself.
1099
00:51:18.090 --> 00:51:18.170
Yes.
1100
00:51:18.190 --> 00:51:18.849
Playing a professor.
1101
00:51:19.090 --> 00:51:19.489
That's true.
1102
00:51:19.590 --> 00:51:21.130
And you were in The Last Mimsy.
1103
00:51:21.150 --> 00:51:22.190
I was in The Last Mimsy.
1104
00:51:22.849 --> 00:51:23.150
Yes.
1105
00:51:24.030 --> 00:51:24.369
Yes.
1106
00:51:25.159 --> 00:51:27.760
You didn't remember him in the last Mimsy? The little
1107
00:51:27.800 --> 00:51:30.679
teddy bear had a chip in it that was very advanced,
1108
00:51:30.900 --> 00:51:33.360
more advanced than anybody, and you went in and analyzed
1109
00:51:33.380 --> 00:51:34.920
the chip. That was good.
1110
00:51:34.980 --> 00:51:41.829
There's nobody who understands that. Thank you. But the actual
1111
00:51:41.869 --> 00:51:42.989
way I would describe it is this.
1112
00:51:43.550 --> 00:51:47.889
I'm willing to buy into a fictional setting where whoever
1113
00:51:47.929 --> 00:51:50.440
it is, the writer, makes up the rules. And if
1114
00:51:50.500 --> 00:51:54.159
the rules are applied consistently and coherently, I'm willing to
1115
00:51:54.179 --> 00:51:56.389
go along for the ride. What I can't stand is
1116
00:51:56.670 --> 00:52:01.170
when partway through the rules change because it suits whatever narrative.
1117
00:52:01.429 --> 00:52:03.110
Yeah, I think we all agree on that.
1118
00:52:04.210 --> 00:52:04.409
Right.
1119
00:52:05.849 --> 00:52:09.739
We'll buy your rules, but stay consistent with them. Yeah,
1120
00:52:10.579 --> 00:52:13.090
that works, that works. Let me see if I can
1121
00:52:13.170 --> 00:52:15.070
offer some parting thoughts. I'll do so after you have
1122
00:52:15.090 --> 00:52:16.070
a final thought here.
1123
00:52:16.250 --> 00:52:19.010
My final thought is I'm not going to say I'm
1124
00:52:19.030 --> 00:52:22.539
just happy to be here. But thank you seriously for
1125
00:52:22.840 --> 00:52:23.300
inviting me.
1126
00:52:23.360 --> 00:52:24.440
It's not a final thought.
1127
00:52:24.519 --> 00:52:26.320
No, it's not. My final thought is this.
1128
00:52:26.420 --> 00:52:28.960
Listening to a lot of the conversation and thinking about
1129
00:52:28.980 --> 00:52:33.519
the multiverse and how inconceivable that is. It actually makes
1130
00:52:33.579 --> 00:52:38.699
you appreciate how incredible and special it is. this exact
1131
00:52:38.780 --> 00:52:41.829
moment is and the exact life you're living is because
1132
00:52:42.289 --> 00:52:45.309
it is only here and is a milli-trillion, trillion, trillion
1133
00:52:45.349 --> 00:52:48.550
times other varieties of that in existence according to quantum physics.
1134
00:52:48.889 --> 00:52:51.349
It just makes you really treasure and value how amazing
1135
00:52:51.369 --> 00:52:52.170
your life is right now.
1136
00:52:52.809 --> 00:53:01.320
Ooh. Chuck. Murr, that was really cool, man. It was beautiful.
1137
00:53:01.619 --> 00:53:04.900
Except I'm not... It's the weed talking, yes. Yes.
1138
00:53:06.320 --> 00:53:09.989
You know, my final thought on just the entire evening
1139
00:53:10.050 --> 00:53:13.130
is the fact that isn't it wonderful to see that
1140
00:53:13.929 --> 00:53:19.190
science and curiosity has reached a place where 3,000 people
1141
00:53:19.230 --> 00:53:22.320
can convene in New York City in an arena to
1142
00:53:22.579 --> 00:53:27.840
listen to two scientists talk about the possibilities and wonder
1143
00:53:27.860 --> 00:53:31.760
of science. that is indeed science, and because of people
1144
00:53:31.780 --> 00:53:33.860
like you, I have faith that.
1145
00:53:33.800 --> 00:53:37.159
We may indeed be all right after all.
1146
00:53:37.199 --> 00:53:48.070
Brian?
1147
00:53:48.510 --> 00:53:49.989
After that, I got nothing to add.
1148
00:53:50.030 --> 00:53:55.769
You got nothing? So let me offer some brief reflections
1149
00:53:56.579 --> 00:54:02.670
It was the 1890s when Percival Lowell, a wealthy amateur
1150
00:54:02.690 --> 00:54:06.030
astronomer who had enough money to build one of the
1151
00:54:06.070 --> 00:54:08.969
finest telescopes ever in the world and put it on
1152
00:54:08.989 --> 00:54:14.449
a mountaintop in Arizona. And his observatory is called Lowell Observatory. He,
1153
00:54:14.809 --> 00:54:19.199
among other things, launched the search that discovered Pluto, just
1154
00:54:19.360 --> 00:54:24.980
so you know. There's some Pluto lovers out there. Just
1155
00:54:25.019 --> 00:54:31.199
get over it. Well, get me started. So, too soon?
1156
00:54:31.280 --> 00:54:32.739
Too soon, okay.
1157
00:54:33.530 --> 00:54:38.590
So, he believed.
1158
00:54:37.889 --> 00:54:42.309
He saw canals on Mars. And it's because he didn't
1159
00:54:42.389 --> 00:54:48.909
understand Italian. There was an Italian astronomer who wrote that
1160
00:54:49.650 --> 00:54:53.769
he may have seen channels on Mars with his telescope.
1161
00:54:54.150 --> 00:54:58.010
And the word channel in Italian is canale. So he
1162
00:54:58.130 --> 00:55:01.150
reads this and says, oh, somebody sees canals on Mars,
1163
00:55:01.170 --> 00:55:03.130
but I have the best telescope at the best location.
1164
00:55:03.389 --> 00:55:05.090
Let me look. I bet I can see them better.
1165
00:55:05.550 --> 00:55:08.210
And so he looks and he thinks he sees canals
1166
00:55:08.289 --> 00:55:12.889
on Mars. And if a channel is different from a canal, why?
1167
00:55:13.309 --> 00:55:15.869
Because a channel is just something that running water makes.
1168
00:55:16.130 --> 00:55:21.280
A canal is something intelligently constructed. And he publishes books
1169
00:55:21.760 --> 00:55:25.559
on this. First book was titled Mars. Next one, Mars
1170
00:55:25.860 --> 00:55:29.019
and its canals. And he has maps of the surface
1171
00:55:29.079 --> 00:55:33.679
of Mars with canals connecting nodes to the poles. We
1172
00:55:33.719 --> 00:55:37.769
all know Mars has polar ice caps. Even when we
1173
00:55:37.949 --> 00:55:42.730
will lose ours, Mars will still have its. These were
1174
00:55:42.789 --> 00:55:45.889
canals and he was imagining that these were cities that
1175
00:55:45.929 --> 00:55:48.750
were losing their water supply and they were melting the
1176
00:55:48.849 --> 00:55:52.139
ice caps and bringing water in this huge irrigation system,
1177
00:55:52.440 --> 00:55:55.980
redistributing water across its surface. This was published in the 1890s.
1178
00:55:57.900 --> 00:56:03.559
Within a few years of this, H.G. Wells wrote War
1179
00:56:03.579 --> 00:56:11.170
of the Worlds. Inspired by those observations. If there is
1180
00:56:11.230 --> 00:56:14.320
life on Mars, I'm going to write a story about it.
1181
00:56:15.340 --> 00:56:18.250
I'm going to take our imagination to a new place.
1182
00:56:19.170 --> 00:56:19.369
H.G.
1183
00:56:19.389 --> 00:56:23.070
Wells was scientifically literate, and he had the imagination of
1184
00:56:23.230 --> 00:56:27.900
any brilliant writer, that any brilliant writer should. So, when
1185
00:56:28.019 --> 00:56:31.599
I see all of the storytelling that goes on, the
1186
00:56:31.639 --> 00:56:36.059
stories that we celebrate here at Comic-Con, all dimensions of
1187
00:56:36.099 --> 00:56:39.260
those stories, all the creativity from the writers, the producers.
1188
00:56:39.639 --> 00:56:42.920
One of the most beautiful things for me about Comic-Con is, yes,
1189
00:56:42.960 --> 00:56:45.619
you can bring in the actors, but the longest lines
1190
00:56:45.659 --> 00:56:48.110
are gonna be the ones for the writers and the
1191
00:56:48.199 --> 00:56:52.550
creative storytellers, because you know, this audience knows that this
1192
00:56:53.110 --> 00:56:57.349
is the source of that creativity. And so here we
1193
00:56:57.389 --> 00:57:00.239
had just within a couple of years, a creative person,
1194
00:57:02.159 --> 00:57:06.090
a creative person with the science literacy create this terrifying
1195
00:57:06.159 --> 00:57:10.440
story about Martians coming to Earth. I do not ever
1196
00:57:10.480 --> 00:57:14.900
want to see an end to the creativity following the
1197
00:57:14.940 --> 00:57:19.400
progress of science, giving us no end of stories to
1198
00:57:19.440 --> 00:57:21.360
take us into the future so that we can have
1199
00:57:21.420 --> 00:57:32.320
Comic-Cons until all the universes re-collapse. And that, I like
1200
00:57:32.340 --> 00:57:36.829
to think of that as a Cosmic perspective. I want
1201
00:57:36.869 --> 00:57:39.440
to thank you all, New York Comic Con, for coming
1202
00:57:39.539 --> 00:57:41.719
out for StarTalk at New York Comic Con.
1203
00:57:41.739 --> 00:57:42.460
Wait, wait. What's that?
1204
00:57:42.599 --> 00:57:44.639
Before you say goodbye, because I don't want there to
1205
00:57:44.679 --> 00:57:49.199
be an official end of the show until people recognize
1206
00:57:49.570 --> 00:57:53.389
that in just about three.
1207
00:57:53.230 --> 00:57:59.090
Hours from now, it'll be Dr. Neil deGrasse Tyson's birthday!
1208
00:58:04.889 --> 00:58:05.550
I'm an old man.
1209
00:58:09.670 --> 00:58:14.199
So the cool thing is, the very cool thing is,
1210
00:58:14.659 --> 00:58:15.150
we got to.
1211
00:58:15.110 --> 00:58:16.920
Do this a few years ago. We were on stage
1212
00:58:16.980 --> 00:58:17.780
on your birthday.
1213
00:58:17.800 --> 00:58:21.820
And it's not officially, but it is the coolest thing
1214
00:58:21.840 --> 00:58:27.539
in the world to have 3,000 people actually sing happy.
1215
00:58:27.199 --> 00:58:34.269
Birthday to Dr. Tyson. So can we? Happy birthday to you.
1216
00:58:35.030 --> 00:58:41.630
Happy birthday to you. Happy birthday, Dr.
1217
00:58:41.650 --> 00:58:41.750
Tyson.
1218
00:58:42.469 --> 00:58:46.030
Happy birthday to you.
1219
00:58:46.170 --> 00:58:48.230
Thank you.
1220
00:58:58.619 --> 00:58:59.679
Thank you.
1221
00:58:59.679 --> 00:59:03.449
How old are you? And a universe. How old are you?
1222
00:59:03.449 --> 00:59:04.710
And a universe.
1223
00:59:04.710 --> 00:59:08.469
Let me just say, I was born the same week
1224
00:59:09.030 --> 00:59:14.769
that NASA was founded. The same week. And so NASA
1225
00:59:14.789 --> 00:59:20.059
and I are the same age. We feel each other's pains.
1226
00:59:22.019 --> 00:59:26.800
When NASA looks at Neil, it says, Neil, I'm your father.
1227
00:59:31.440 --> 00:59:34.260
Here's what I want to do, with your permission. I
1228
00:59:34.280 --> 00:59:36.789
want to end, I'm going to take a little more
1229
00:59:36.849 --> 00:59:44.380
time here of your time, with your permission. A few
1230
00:59:44.389 --> 00:59:50.500
days ago I posted a birthday letter to NASA, an
1231
00:59:50.579 --> 00:59:53.059
open letter to NASA. I want to read that letter
1232
00:59:53.099 --> 00:59:55.719
to you as we end this evening, with your permission.
1233
00:59:56.449 --> 00:59:56.650
Okay.
1234
01:00:01.710 --> 01:00:08.619
Dear NASA, happy birthday. Perhaps you don't know, but we're
1235
01:00:08.639 --> 01:00:13.539
the same age. In the first week of October, 1958,
1236
01:00:13.539 --> 01:00:16.500
you were born of the National Aeronautics and Space Act
1237
01:00:17.079 --> 01:00:20.800
as a civilian space agency, while I was
born of
1238
01:00:20.860 --> 01:00:30.670
my mother in the East Bronx. Don't lie to me,
1239
01:00:30.670 --> 01:00:32.260
there ain't that many people from the Bronx here in
1240
01:00:32.280 --> 01:00:38.199
this room right now. So the year-long celebration of our
1241
01:00:38.340 --> 01:00:44.449
shared 60th anniversary provides me a unique occasion to reflect
1242
01:00:45.170 --> 01:00:49.230
on our past, present, and future. I was three years
1243
01:00:49.449 --> 01:00:53.389
old when John Glenn first orbited Earth. I was seven
1244
01:00:53.909 --> 01:00:57.519
when you lost astronauts Grissom, Chaffee, and White in that
1245
01:00:57.579 --> 01:01:01.210
tragic fire of their Apollo 1 capsule. on the launch pad.
1246
01:01:01.750 --> 01:01:06.769
I was 10 when you launched Armstrong and Aldrin, when
1247
01:01:06.789 --> 01:01:09.710
you landed Armstrong and Aldrin on the moon. And I
1248
01:01:09.730 --> 01:01:13.409
was 14 when you stopped going to the moon altogether.
1249
01:01:14.769 --> 01:01:18.469
Over that time, I was excited for you and for America.
1250
01:01:19.409 --> 01:01:23.449
But the vicarious thrill of the journey, so prevalent in
1251
01:01:23.469 --> 01:01:27.360
the hearts and minds of others, was absent from my emotions.
1252
01:01:28.320 --> 01:01:31.519
I was obviously too young to be an astronaut, but
1253
01:01:31.539 --> 01:01:35.340
I also knew that my skin color was much too
1254
01:01:35.400 --> 01:01:38.519
dark for you to picture me as part of this
1255
01:01:38.960 --> 01:01:43.280
epic adventure. Not only that, even though you are a
1256
01:01:43.340 --> 01:01:48.750
civilian agency, your most celebrated astronauts were military pilots at
1257
01:01:48.789 --> 01:01:53.530
a time when war was becoming less and less popular.
1258
01:01:55.070 --> 01:01:58.400
During the 1960s, the Civil Rights Movement was more real
1259
01:01:58.460 --> 01:02:02.039
to me than it surely was to you. In fact,
1260
01:02:02.119 --> 01:02:06.460
it took a directive from Vice President Johnson in 1963
1261
01:02:06.460 --> 01:02:10.199
to force you to hire black engineers at your prestigious
1262
01:02:10.300 --> 01:02:15.000
Marshall Space Flight Center in Huntsville, Alabama. I found the
1263
01:02:15.059 --> 01:02:20.449
correspondence in your archive. Do you remember? James Webb, then
1264
01:02:20.550 --> 01:02:24.590
head of NASA, wrote to German rocket pioneer Wernher von Braun,
1265
01:02:25.309 --> 01:02:28.539
who headed the center, and who is the chief engineer
1266
01:02:28.579 --> 01:02:32.400
of the entire manned space program, the letter boldly and
1267
01:02:32.460 --> 01:02:36.760
bluntly directs von Braun to address the quote, lack of
1268
01:02:36.940 --> 01:02:41.719
equal employment opportunity for Negroes in the region, and to
1269
01:02:41.800 --> 01:02:46.380
collaborate with area colleges, Alabama A & M and Tuskegee Institute,
1270
01:02:46.900 --> 01:02:52.469
to identify, train, and recruit qualified Negro engineers into the
1271
01:02:52.550 --> 01:02:58.280
NASA Huntsville family. In 1964, you and I had not
1272
01:02:58.380 --> 01:03:03.360
yet turned six when I saw picketers outside the newly
1273
01:03:03.400 --> 01:03:08.619
built apartment complex of our choice in the Riverdale section
1274
01:03:08.800 --> 01:03:13.929
of the Bronx. They were protesting to prevent Negro families,
1275
01:03:14.590 --> 01:03:18.769
mine included, from moving there. I was glad their effort failed.
1276
01:03:19.469 --> 01:03:25.760
These buildings were called, perhaps prophetically, the Skyview Apartments. on
1277
01:03:25.800 --> 01:03:29.219
whose roof, 22 stories over the Bronx, I would later
1278
01:03:29.300 --> 01:03:34.110
train my telescope on the universe. My father was active
1279
01:03:34.119 --> 01:03:37.489
in the civil rights movement, working under New York City's
1280
01:03:37.590 --> 01:03:41.610
Mayor Lindsay to create job opportunities for youth in the ghetto,
1281
01:03:42.309 --> 01:03:46.650
as the inner city was called back then. Year after year,
1282
01:03:46.989 --> 01:03:52.420
the forces operating against this effort were huge. Poor schools,
1283
01:03:52.619 --> 01:03:58.750
bad teachers, meager resources, abject racism and assassinated leaders. So
1284
01:03:58.769 --> 01:04:02.150
while you were celebrating your monthly advances in space exploration
1285
01:04:02.449 --> 01:04:06.469
from Mercury to Gemini to Apollo, I was watching America
1286
01:04:07.130 --> 01:04:11.110
do all it could to marginalize who I was and
1287
01:04:11.150 --> 01:04:14.489
what I wanted to become in life. I looked to
1288
01:04:14.510 --> 01:04:19.139
you for guidance, for a vision statement that I could
1289
01:04:19.179 --> 01:04:23.059
adapt that would fuel my ambitions, but you weren't there
1290
01:04:23.139 --> 01:04:27.480
for me. Of course, I shouldn't blame you for society's woes.
1291
01:04:29.070 --> 01:04:32.789
Your conduct was a symptom of America's habits, not a cause.
1292
01:04:33.469 --> 01:04:37.449
I knew this. But you should nonetheless know that among
1293
01:04:37.530 --> 01:04:41.170
my colleagues, I'm the only one in my generation who
1294
01:04:41.210 --> 01:04:45.130
became an astrophysicist in spite of your achievements in space,
1295
01:04:45.670 --> 01:04:49.989
rather than because of them. For my inspirations, I instead
1296
01:04:50.150 --> 01:04:55.989
turned to libraries. remaindered books on the cosmos from bookstores,
1297
01:04:56.409 --> 01:05:03.389
my rooftop telescope, and the Hayden Planetarium. After some fits
1298
01:05:03.469 --> 01:05:06.659
and starts through my years in school, where becoming an
1299
01:05:06.780 --> 01:05:10.539
astrophysicist seemed at times to be the path of most
1300
01:05:10.599 --> 01:05:16.000
resistance through an unwelcoming society, I became a professional astrophysicist.
1301
01:05:17.300 --> 01:05:22.150
I became a scientist. Over the decades that followed,
You've
1302
01:05:22.190 --> 01:05:25.820
come a long way. Whoever does not yet recognize the
1303
01:05:25.860 --> 01:05:29.380
value of this adventure to our nation's future soon will,
1304
01:05:29.780 --> 01:05:33.239
as the rest of the development and developing world passes
1305
01:05:33.300 --> 01:05:38.239
us by in every measure of technological leadership and strength.
1306
01:05:39.440 --> 01:05:42.610
Not only that, these days you look much more like America.
1307
01:05:44.130 --> 01:05:48.929
From your senior level managers to your most decorated astronauts, congratulations.
1308
01:05:49.710 --> 01:05:53.530
You now belong to the entire citizenry. Examples of this abound,
1309
01:05:53.570 --> 01:05:56.869
but I especially remember when the public took ownership of
1310
01:05:56.909 --> 01:06:01.409
the Hubble telescope, your most beloved unmanned mission. They all
1311
01:06:01.489 --> 01:06:06.010
spoke loudly back in the 2004, ultimately reversing the threat
1312
01:06:06.349 --> 01:06:08.829
that the telescope might not be serviced a fourth time,
1313
01:06:09.750 --> 01:06:13.989
extending its life for another decade. Hubble's transcended images of
1314
01:06:14.010 --> 01:06:17.590
the cosmos had spoken to us all, as did the
1315
01:06:17.659 --> 01:06:22.079
personal profiles of the space shuttle astronauts who deployed and
1316
01:06:22.159 --> 01:06:26.480
service the telescope and the scientists who benefited from its
1317
01:06:26.519 --> 01:06:31.889
data stream. Not only that, I'd even joined the ranks
1318
01:06:31.969 --> 01:06:35.449
of your most trusted as I served dutifully on your
1319
01:06:35.489 --> 01:06:39.369
prestigious advisory council. I came to recognize that when you're
1320
01:06:39.469 --> 01:06:42.489
at your best, nothing in this world can inspire the
1321
01:06:42.550 --> 01:06:51.000
dreams of a nation the way you can. Dreams fueled
1322
01:06:53.670 --> 01:07:07.340
by a pipeline of ambitious students eager to become scientists, engineers,
1323
01:07:07.360 --> 01:07:14.329
and technologists in the service of the greatest quest there
1324
01:07:14.389 --> 01:07:14.809
ever was.
1325
01:07:14.829 --> 01:07:19.449
Sorry, sorry.
1326
01:07:32.679 --> 01:07:38.039
You have come to represent a fundamental part of America's identity.
1327
01:07:40.639 --> 01:07:46.500
Not only to itself, but to the world. So as
1328
01:07:46.539 --> 01:07:51.500
we both turn 60 and begin our 61st trip around
1329
01:07:51.539 --> 01:07:56.179
the sun, I want you to know that I feel
1330
01:07:56.199 --> 01:08:02.630
your pains and share your joys. And I look forward
1331
01:08:04.989 --> 01:08:08.530
to seeing you back on the moon. But don't stop there.
1332
01:08:09.989 --> 01:08:22.220
Mars beckons, as do destinations beyond. Birthday buddy, even if
1333
01:08:22.279 --> 01:08:27.189
I have not always been, I am now your humble servant,
1334
01:08:28.130 --> 01:08:30.560
Neil deGrasse Tyson. Thank you all.
1335
01:08:43.800 --> 01:08:44.119
Dr.
1336
01:08:44.159 --> 01:08:46.239
Neil deGrasse Tyson, ladies and gentlemen.
1337
01:08:46.260 --> 01:08:47.300
Dr.
1338
01:08:47.380 --> 01:08:51.560
Neil deGrasse Tyson. And our panel.
1339
01:08:53.310 --> 01:08:57.409
And give it up for the Mer, James Mer Murray,
1340
01:08:58.750 --> 01:08:59.949
theoretical physicist.
1341
01:09:00.390 --> 01:09:02.029
Brian Green.
1342
01:09:02.050 --> 01:09:08.729
My name is Chuck Nice. Thank you. And as always,
1343
01:09:08.770 --> 01:09:09.770
we leave you with Dr.
1344
01:09:09.810 --> 01:09:12.170
Tyson saying, keep looking up.