TRANSKRIPT 🔗
speaker-0: Alright, welcome back to episode two of season two of reviews. Today my guest is John Strasner. John Strasner is an industry legend when it comes to bringing climate awareness to architects, designers, and manufacturers. He's also the host of Once Upon a Planet podcast. And I've gotten a chance to know John over the last little bit and really enjoyed. having him on today for our conversation. Hope you do too. Give give my audience just a sense of I know you talk a lot about yourself as a storyteller, an environmental storyteller, right? That's really kind of where you've excelled at. ⁓
speaker-1: ⁓ yeah. I it has evolved. I would say it has evolved. I really that was something, you know, when Verta and I were podcasting, that was something that we always talked about because we started podcasting because of COVID. We had planned all these in-person events. We were going to do these showroom events. And Verta being a designer and me being an activist, we thought, hey, let's get a subject matter expert and we'll go to a showroom. We'll have a big party. You know, and we'll talk about something different. And you'll provide this designer perspective. I'll provide, you know, this activist kind of perspective. And and between the three of us, we could make for some really interesting dialogue. And COVID hit and all of that got canceled. So then Verda and I pivoted and we decided to podcast. And we had no idea how to podcast. I literally was Googling, How do you podcast? You know, and ⁓ we figured it out and we're doing it all. you know, by ourselves for the first couple of seasons. And we were just talking to people that I knew, ⁓ that I'd gotten to know in my work as somebody interested in climate. And initially, you know, my position was let's talk about ocean plastic. Let's talk about, you know, the issues that we talked about were ⁓ a a lot of the early somewhat superficial issues around climate. It was, you know, how do we address carbon? What is this thing, carbon? You know, we kind of I had friends who were I had friends who had a company where they were recycling fishing nets and turning it into nylon pellets. And then we were able to make product out of these nylon pellets. And we were talking about things like that. And then we found that the conversation around climate became a lot more Sophisticated. And we found ourselves going from talking about ocean plastic to talking about the gender gap, right? Why are women so poorly represented in the way that we design product? Why, when we look at our own industry? Why are there so few women architects? Why are there so few women in leadership roles? And so, you know. When we were in the middle of our last season, that was when I I stopped and tapped the brake and said, holy cow, like this conversation is a lot different than it was before we started, you know? And I think that that's also the the the conversation around sustainability. It is so much more than what are the technical data points in a lead certified space. ⁓ you know, what are the things a company needs to do to address material transparency? Like these are all part of this umbrella that has just gotten bigger and bigger and bigger over the years. And I think that's made the communication side of it all a lot more challenging and a lot more complicated because now companies that want to address, you know, this wrangly topic of sustainability, now they have to look at social equity and they have to look at inclusivity and wellness programs and they have to look at what are they doing to affect their own ecosystem around them. What are the how you know how are they helping, you know, their own particular environment? It's more than just can we recycle this product? Can we ⁓ can we make it from recycled materials? It's there ⁓ there's more to it. And so I think my that's my personal journey is I went from a very superficial address of climate to A much more complex look at a healthy planet. Right. So now I and I hate the word sustainability. I've always hated the word sustainability. I I think to endeavor to sustain anything is a bit of a cop out. So I always kind of lean into planet health. Like that's what I want to see. I want to see planet health. But that was a long answer, my friend.
speaker-0: I love it. I love long answers. And it you know the nice thing about this is that I can't really plan for much because when I talk to good people who know what they're talking about, it's just gonna skyrocket into all these different avenues we can go down. So there's two avenues I want to go down that you kind of brought up there. Because I agree that I hate the word sustainability. I can agree that The concept or the umbrella, as you called it, started getting wider and wider and wider to include many different elements that were not necessarily climate-related, but I like how you framed it as planet-related. My concern when that started happening was that when you cast a very wide net. Right. You can sometimes miss the target of what you were trying to do. You do a lot of things, you try to do a lot of things all at once, and you think you're making an impact, but you're actually missing because you're trying to do too many things under one umbrella. That was my main concern, even when we started with ⁓ the shift towards wellness in in the built environment. That shift I was kind of at the forefront of. And I said, ⁓ this is fantastic, right? Like this is how. You know, people can optimize their health ⁓ in inside the built environment. I looked at it, sure, there's some similarities to climate and and planet health, but they are somewhat different things. In fact, sometimes they can actually oppose one another. Right?
speaker-1: And so
speaker-0: ⁓ I agree that that conversation has has started to shift. And where I'd love to focus on today is getting your thoughts on Where we are with 'cause you brought up the ocean plastics and recycling. Okay. And so we've
Load full transcript
been I've been doing a lot of research into the psychology of circularity. The psychology behind me. Okay.
speaker-1: Boy. Okay. Yeah, man, you're good. You're you're you're going down a rabbit hole, I can tell. Right?
speaker-0: This whole podcast is rabbit holes. Trust me. You're yeah, we're just getting started. But but it's interesting because you have such a background on this and an insight on this that I'm so curious to get your thoughts. So you were part of the rewritten exhibit. Yeah. You're familiar with remanufacturing. Right. The idea of remanufacturing and refurbishment has been around for quite some time. Just as long as recycling, I would say. Okay. But what I think has happened is they went in two different paths where we have somehow normalized recycled content in products to where no one flinches when you say, Yep, we're gonna take this discarded fishing net and turn it into pellets and turn it into a new product. Everyone jumps for joy and their dopamine is still
speaker-1: Yeah. Yeah.
speaker-0: Mention the word used, pre owned, refurbished. Yep. Okay. And it does something very different. So the interesting part, and you probably know, is that recycled content used to be visible. Right? Two decades ago, if you're getting something recycled, there would be visible imperfections in it.
speaker-1: You needed to be as a f as an early adapter, you needed to be accommodating.
speaker-0: Yep. That's right. That's right. And by doing that, we got to where we are today. So my question to you is that we've normalized recycled content in products. Why can't we normalize recycled products in projects?
speaker-1: That's ⁓ you know, th Andy, that's the million dollar question, right? ⁓ I'm I'm gonna I'm gonna give you my take on on that question, which probably parallels with, you know, my attitude around sustainability in general. I think I mean you're right. Like if if if I say to you, Andy, ⁓ I'm working with a tremendous design firm on your interiors, and we're really super excited about it, it's gonna be It's going to address wellness and it's going to address address inclusivity and it's going to address your brand and people are going to want to go to work there and it's going to be an amazing experience for your employees. And we can't wait to to fill it with this used furniture that we found. You know, then it's like, you know, you can hear the skid market, you know, the glass breaking. What? And I think that the the the challenge that we're having with this climate conversation is. We haven't framed it properly for a very, very long time. And you know, you're clearly a communicator. You're clearly somebody who understands the value of of storytelling and and bringing people along. And I think that the sustainability movement for too long has said, you know what? ⁓ scientists and environmental engineers go out there.
speaker-0: Your
speaker-1: And spread the good word for us. And unfortunately, scientists and engineers aren't the
best communicators. And they also, you know, they're subject matter experts. And so subject matter experts don't always make good leaders, just like good leaders aren't always subject matter experts. But what we have needed for a long time is a movement. And we've not been able to reach that level of awareness. And so we, you know, we go out with this depressing, this dystopian picture of what the future looks like. And, you know, as a result, ⁓ there are trigger words in the vocabulary that are people are just gonna turn you, they're gonna turn you off. They're gonna they're gonna tune you out. And I think used furniture is one of those. And I think the way to the we have to understand that. It's a conversation that we have to frame. And if you think one word is going to do that for you, ⁓ you're gonna be disappointed. And so, I mean, look at the clothing industry. The clothing industry mirrors the furniture industry very, very closely. There's a fast fashion industry that's destroying the planet. There's a fast furniture industry that's destroying the planet, right? We throw away a shit ton of clothing all the time. We throw away a shit ton of furniture all the time, right? And so Maybe the way to frame it when you're speaking with somebody who could be a client of yours is not that, hey, ⁓ we're putting new furna we're putting used furniture into your space. Maybe, maybe you figure out what is this individual's hot button? What what are the levers that you can use in this conversation? What we have to do is read the room and understand who we're talking to. And if if the lever is money. And let's face it, most of the time it is. Then you're talking about methods and ideas and solutions that are going to save your client money, right? Maybe the client has initiatives that they are trying to reach as a part of their own program, right? Those are levers that you use. Hey, you we have an opportunity, Mr. Client. Aren't you interested in lowering your carbon impact? Mrs. Client. Miss client, you know, aren't you interested in in repurposing a lot of your furniture? Aren't you interested in not sending the stuff that you paid good money on money for? Aren't you interested in not sending that to a landfill and not throwing that away? Aren't you interested in a really great story that you can put out there for your clients and your customers and your employees? Aren't you, you know, interested in these things? So rather than lead into We're putting used furniture in there. Why don't we lean into those those those levers that exist? And we have to know who we're talking to so that we know what those levers or what those hot buttons are. You know what I mean?
speaker-0: So what about if you think about it like this? Because you're right that framing and how we frame it is the most important part. We've seen this happen with other industries where the model didn't change, the psychology around it changed. And you would go from fringe to premium, right? So first you kind of pull it back and you start to think about okay, well, what is the definition of new? Right? Because you think that the definition of new is what? Newly Extracted raw materials, is that what makes something new? Not necessarily, because a lot of people will get something that has recycled components and recycled content in it and call it new. And the question becomes to your point about how you frame it with the story, is that what happens if circularity becomes invisible? Okay? Because for too long, and this is a tricky one for both of us, because I mean, this is something that when you're kind of environmental storyteller, right? And and someone that works for a company like Envirotech, it's like we have been working so hard to convince our clients that sustainable is better, or get excited about the conscious choice that you're making to do this. There's other industries. like the aviation industry that basically have circularity as a core function of how their business operates. Remanufacturing and and and refurbishing and repurposing products is normal, but they don't use those words. They make it invisible. Just as we've done with recycling, we've gone to this point where the market said, We're all about recycling. Sure. The the cooler the story of of, you know How many fishing nets or how many pounds of this product were had recycled components? That's great. We love it. But we don't want to see it. We want to call it new. We want to make sure it goes through a process that is what we consider new. And we don't really want to get any reminders that this was a fishing net.
speaker-1: Perfect.
speaker-0: And so we've figured that out with manufacturing. What about if the next thing we have to figure out is the dealer model? Because you could build a new workplace. Where people don't know the difference and we're not even talking about used product anymore. Where they walk in that space and everything is new to them. But we're afraid to do it just as I think early manufacturers were afraid to use too much of a recycled component where all of a sudden their product didn't refract reflect the the brand that they were.
speaker-1: I get it. I I know what you're saying, but but let let me advocate for the devil for a moment. Here's the thing, Andy. Here's thing. We are in an industry that follows trends, color trends, finished trends. Okay. And so we're also in an industry that's driven by design. Design by its nature is very superficial and very materialistic. Okay. And
speaker-0: Please do.
speaker-1: I listen, I design is going to help this industry have a greater impact on planet health. Without a doubt. We have designers and design firms who are pushing, aggressively pushing ⁓ sustainable initiatives, whether it's material transparency or it's supply chain management. And so they are the engine driving this industry for sure. ⁓ but it's also you could also argue that the end users at the end of the day have the final say.
And so the onus is really on designers to work harder to educate their clients. And if it's not in their scope and they don't have the time, then you know, we need dealers to come in and and educate and engage and get people excited. But but You know, the reason why I'm not sure if your vision of making circularity invisible, the reason why I'm not sure if that's possible is because you're probably always gonna have somebody who's gonna be like, Hey, you know, don't you want the latest color, don't you want the latest finish? This is the trend today in office design, this is the look, right? It's i is it benching, is it open space, is it collaborative, is it ⁓ resomercial? You know what I mean? And so if it was if it was jet airplanes and and engines and things like that, you know, that aviation industry is worried about performance and technological advancements and keeping up with that. They're really not worried about what's the latest ⁓ Benjamin Moore, what's the color of the year? What's the Benjamin Moore color of the year? Because we need to have that on the inside of this ⁓ you know, DC ten. I right. So that that's a challenge.
speaker-0: Okay, great point. Great point. Let's dive into Let's think about it like this.
speaker-1: I feel like you were ready for you. ⁓
speaker-0: No. Damn it. I just I like having these conversations and thinking through these things. Cause you're absolutely right. I don't want this process of sustainability or circularity or whatever RE word you want to use to hinder design. There is something that is beautiful and creative when you get to execute a vision, right? And create a space that is that people want to be in, that they feel their best in, that they work their best in. We don't want to make this a compromise. Okay. So let's again just pull it from product to project example. Is there a reason that human scale only uses roughly two pounds of recycled fishing net in a 40 plus pound chair? Yeah. Yeah. Yes, there is. It doesn't mean it doesn't mean that that's not commendable and and innovative, but there's a reason that they started with a percentage. Because they said this is how far we can go right now. With making this work based on current manufacturing constraints or whatever the reasons are that they that they're at that. So we've got a percentage. So when you look at a workplace, let's say a 50,000 square foot space, there's going to be certain things that you are going to need to have in the right colors, right? With the right, right upholstery that are going to be those pieces that in that space need to do that. That's why I'm saying the dealer model. But then there's a lot of things when you look at and you go, ⁓ right, all these workstations, for example, could the frame of all of these been repurposed? Possibly. Now you've got a little bit of percentage there. And could the Herman Miller Aeron chairs that they're using, could those have been sourced in another way? Maybe. Now all of a sudden,
just from that change alone, everything else is completely on trend, right? Everything else is spec'd is new. The warranties for those two components are the same as new. Now you start looking at a project as, ⁓ we were able to do five, ten, fifteen percent recycled, whatever you want to call it. Okay. And that's how you keep the design vision moving along, where you go, look, this is where we know we can build a chair with two pounds of fishing nets. We might be able to get to ten pounds one day. I don't know. But we have to start here.
speaker-1: Yeah, I you're right. I mean, everything you're saying is right. I think that, you know, the circularity movement is butting up against a fair amount of resistance. And, you know, the circularity movement would I mean, it's growing, Andy. It's growing. It's it's more today than it was five years ago, I feel, right? I mean, you're more deeply in it every single day. So you probably have a better understanding of growth than I do. But let's just look at that word growth for a second, right? as long as we define growth as making more, building more, selling more, I do think circularity will butt up against a fair amount of resistance, right? So, you know, can a company define growth i using a different vocabulary than let's sell more used ⁓ let's sell more new furniture this year than we did last year. And and I do think that that's, you know, that's a big every you know, I think in our industry, I think every manufacturer really for the most part, and I I know I'm generalizing, but the manufacturers are really trying to do the right thing. They're trying to do good things. ⁓ and I give them all a lot of credit 'cause it's ⁓ always a lot easier to to talk about it than it is to bear down and do it. ⁓ but when it comes to circularity, I haven't met a manufacturer yet that's figured out figured it out, right? You know, there's no take back program that works perfectly, right? there's once the product leaves your factory and it gets into the hands of a consumer, you just have no idea what that consumer is going to do with it. But but I do think it goes back to I just think the circ I just think that. the rees out there are just butting up against the competitive pressure of new. Right. ⁓ it's tough. It's t I don't and I we're not I don't think we're gonna uncover the answer right here, but it's what everybody's noodling on right now.
speaker-0: Maybe we will uncover.
speaker-1: If we do, I want fifty percent. Yeah.
speaker-0: Yeah. Well, I think you answered it in the sense that the Rees I like how you called it the Rees. The Rees are butting up with the new. What happens when the Rees become the new? Yeah.
speaker-1: Well, oof, I mean, that'll be you know, you're asking, will you know, will our industry reach, you know, like will these arcs intersect at some point? You know what I mean? And when they do, is that a moment of is that it like a define a redefining moment for the industry?
speaker-0: I think that, you know, I did this test with a couple designers to just really solidify the definition of what we consider new, right? And I go, okay, so a product that is made from a hundred percent recycled material. Is that new? And most always they go, yes, that is new. Even if it's a hundred percent recycled material. If you say a workstation that is remanufactured with fifteen percent. Recycle material. Is that new? They always say new, even though we've been calling it remanufactured. Right. And so again, I think that there will be a moment, it might be five years, 10 years, maybe 15 years from now, when where we are with recycled materials, there will be a norm of how we think about building our spaces to where we are building frequently. There is an economy behind it. We are making peop people are so afraid about, ⁓ are they are the rees going to replace new? No. They're going to work in the same just just as there's still virgin materials that we use, but some manufacturers are trying to incorporate existing raw materials, right? That same idea can continue to play out. We just have to stop calling it something different.
speaker-1: I I Yeah, I mean I I you're you're right. I'm not sure that you're entirely right. I I think that at the end of the day, Andy, it's it's like follow the money. At the end of the day, it it's always going to come down to money and convenience. Is what you're talking about gonna cost me more and is it gonna inconvenience me? Unfortunately, unfortunately, not everybody is willing to be convenienced to do the right thing. And I've said this before, as companies, we expect companies to behave like people, right? We expect to say, this is the right thing to do. We expect a company to do it. And it doesn't work that way, right? Companies are beholden to shareholders and profits. That's the reality. I think, you know, and you know, this is my pipe dream. I don't know if it'll ever happen, but you know, if we ever reach a point where government regulation makes new, you know, penalizes new, right? Addresses a carbon tax for new, right? I mean, this is my pipe dream. But, you know, what if what if there was a regulation that said, hey, if you're going to fill this building with new furniture, you know, not only are you probably going to pay more for the new furniture, but there's going to be a carbon tax here. Because the carbon footprint of that new stuff is going to be pretty significant. So you're going to want to You're gonna wanna think about that a little longer and a little harder. So, you know, I think that regulation would help this conversation a lot. I just don't know if we're anywhere near, you know, getting help in that way. But yeah.
speaker-0: I thought that that would help as well at a point. And then I realized more like people don't want to be told what they can or cannot buy. Yeah. Right. You want to you want to make it where it is not a compromise, but a conscious choice. And there's other industries that
have gone through this change. Right. That I feel like the RE words are in. Where, I mean a obvious one is is thinking about like Airbnb, for example, which was mentally categorized as couch surfing at the beginning. Right? Yeah. And it it was kind of this if you couldn't afford a hotel, you stayed at a hostel. If you couldn't afford a hostel, you stayed at a random person's house. Right. Now, if you can't afford to stay at an Airbnb.
speaker-1: Right.
speaker-0: You stay at a hotel.
speaker-1: Well, listen, I mean the fashion industry has figured it out, right? Vintage is cool. Vintage is cool.
speaker-0: Yes. They vintage is cool. You're right. Fashion has a different take on it. But you know, thinking from another manufacturer example, this was an interesting one. You know LOL? ⁓ do you know that manufacturer? They make LO
speaker-1: L L L ⁓ yes, yeah. Aren't they based in Minnesota? Are they based in Minnesota? Okay. Yeah, I know who you're talking about. Is it outdoor outdoor stuff? Yeah.
speaker-0: They do outdoor stuff. Yes. And there was one of they were one of the early ones I remember that ⁓ a rep group came to us and and talked about and like, ⁓ everything is out of recycled hundred percent recycled milk jugs or something, right? 100% recycled plastic. And very cool, very innovative. ⁓ and and we sold a number of their products and and it was great. And then I remember either during COVID or sometime around that. Obviously their mission was a hundred percent recycled post consumer recycled product. Yeah. That was their mission. But there got a point where they couldn't access enough recycled plastic. Hmm. Okay. And they kind of had to come out and say, Look, did they stop making their products? No. They just had to start incorporating some virgin plastic to make it.
speaker-1: Supplement. Yeah. Yeah.
speaker-0: Supplement, right? And so when you start thinking about it like that, that's where it doesn't have to be a one or another type of approach, right? And that's why I think when people think of Enviotech, they think of us either as a remanufacturer or pre-owned furniture. We're a new furniture dealer. We sell new furniture like everyone else. Just instead of being tied to maybe one manufacturer, we're an open line that specializes in incorporating recycled materials or recycled products. If a client comes to us and for some reason at that particular time, kind of going back to your point about the ⁓ you know, the ease of of of of purchasing through this method, if there's something that we cannot source or or build or remanufacture or remake that meets the design intent and the client standards, we don't just say, sorry, best of luck, find it somewhere else, just as Lull didn't, right? We go, okay, we're gonna have to use a virgin material for this to make this. And it's not a competition. It's not how much did you repurpose on your project versus this? Every little step forward it starts to become normal
speaker-1: This is this is
part of our problem, right? I think that listen, I you've heard it a million times, perfect is the enemy of good, right? ⁓ good and done is better than perfect impending, right? We all ⁓ you know, perfectionists are, you know, procrastinators, right? So let's stop trying to be perfect. Let's let's get comfortable with a little hypocrisy. ⁓ let's stop the gatekeeping, right? I do think that there's a lot of that where where ⁓ Company is really trying to be better, right? They're trying to be better and they get called out. There's a environmentalist out there or an activist out there who comes who just rings like the angry activist and they call them out. Well, you're not, you know, you're not, you could get that, that could be 100% recycled content and you're not doing it because you don't want to spend the money or the time, whatever, right? None of us are perfect. Like we're all human. You know, I think that we need to be okay being a little bit hypocritical. I think it's okay to say this should be all recycled. ⁓ shit. You know, we tried it. We couldn't, we couldn't get there. We wanted to get there, and we're working. The thing is, is it's a journey for everybody. And there's no finish line. There's no finish line. Everybody is on this journey. And as long as everybody is trying to get better and better and better, then that's the That's the best that's the best we can get to right now, you know?
speaker-0: It's a great line, John. Get comfortable with hypocrisy. I mean, it sounds weird when you say it like that, but it also means so much because if if you have an idea and a mission of where you want to take a company, a product, an idea, a movement, and you're so concerned about someone coming and pointing out this or that or that, it's we can't be like that. I think the world has lived through too much of that. Yeah. Canceling, right? Like we we need to move past that. We need to, to your point, I think the the even the doom and gloom narrative that used to be around sustainability, right? There was a really interesting example. ⁓ I was at a design firm ⁓ earlier this week and talking about just the narrative around it. And they were talking about ⁓ one of the children's hospitals in Toronto is called Sick Kids Hospital. And They they've worked with the marketing company who did a rebrand for this children's hospital. And before the the marketing and the advertising around it was all, you know, heart-wrenching images of sick children, right? Which people would actually just turn away from because it affected them so much. They pivoted this campaign ⁓ to where I believe I mean it's it's called stronger or or something like that. But it's all these same kids. showing how they can be stronger and and and and just kind of lifting them up. A shift that yeah they reframed it. They reframed it. And I think that that when I think about where we need to move our industry and and ⁓ you know what we're all passionate about in terms of a a a better planet. Right. And the better planet, you're absolutely right, is the umbrella. We can't just think of it in terms of the climate because if we've if we just thought about it on that, that's not really a better planet. There's also things that we can in, you know, aspire to be and and and move towards as an industry that aren't just GHG emissions. Yeah. Right. And I think we're starting, you know, we we we might have gone too wide at the beginning. Now we're kind of narrowing a bit, but you're absolutely right that we need to be open. ⁓
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-0: To saying something wrong, to making a mistake, to to to figuring something out where we just don't get canceled for
speaker-1: I think you know I think it's okay to say, man, you know, we're ninety percent of the way there. We we, you know, we set a goal, we're we we made it ninety percent, and we're gonna celebrate the fact that we got ninety percent of the way there. ⁓ you know, it's like I said, it's a it's a journey. And I think it's okay to it's even okay to say we did a little worse this year than we did last year. We're gonna figure out why and we're gonna fix it. The important thing is that we're looking at it and we're measuring it. We're being transparent and we're sharing we're sharing, you know, our journey with everybody. We want everybody to see what we're trying to do. I think that that, you know, that rings to me ⁓ very authentic and very true as opposed to, I mean, I f I would like to think that the industry is starting to outgrow greenwashing. ⁓ but I still think we see a lot of it, you know. I I won I wonder about all the talk about, you know, carbon neutral, you know, ⁓ because to me, if you are a manufacturer, you're taking things to make things. And so I don't think you can ever be carbon neutral unless you're doing some green accounting in there and you are applying some offsets, right? So I even think our industry is still using some language that is a little bit confusing, right? ⁓ I say that, but I also know that there are some manufacturers that are Utilizing offsets in a really responsible and productive way. And so again, I I feel like I'm open-minded to hear from everybody. So one day I could say, offsets are a tragedy, and none of us should put up with offsets. And then somebody can sit down with me and explain to me how they utilize offsets. And I can say, wow, okay. ⁓ I I'm feeling the offsets. Now that actually makes sense the way that you're utilizing those offsets. ⁓ and I understand what you're doing. I think at the end of the day, you're probably f in a traditional method of measuring our impact, you're not carbon neutral. But I appreciate what you're doing with those offsets. So
speaker-0: That's it. That's the nuance, is that there is a lot of things that if carbon offsets could, you know, it's not to say that certain investments that are framed as carbon offsets are bad. Right. A lot of them are are good and and some are better than others,
right? The problem of why carbon offsets I think have such a bad rap is exactly what you said. When you call something carbon neutral, yeah, right? Or carbon negative or whatever it is. What happens is people then go, ⁓ we've made it. we've made it. Okay. So we c we can manufacture now without any impact to the environment?
speaker-1: Yeah, it doesn't it just doesn't work that way. It doesn't work.
speaker-0: And we know No, and so that's why if they called it something else
speaker-1: You gotta be careful because we're almost doing we're all Andy, you and I are almost doing what we're saying we shouldn't do. And we're like, God damn it, you're using an offset. Shame on you. That's that's what we should
speaker-0: No, no, I'm not say no, I'm not saying that. I know the nuances is is the nuance is that look at the carbon offset and say, okay, you picked a bad carbon offset. That's fine. There's because there's some bad ones and there's some that are reasonable. Okay. I'm saying the language around carbon neutrality that everyone jumped to, that I can call out and say, that's not good. That was a that was a that was, you know, and it's not to say you can't call out things.
speaker-1: I'm saying we're almost
speaker-0: Right. You should call out things like you said where you call it greenwashing. And I wouldn't even call it greenwashing. It's just the carbon neutrality thing got out of hand too fast. And and it became a race for everyone saying that they're carbon neutral. And then no one knew what was happening because BP oil was carbon neutral and you know, like no it none of it made any sense. And then
speaker-1: Doyle started the whole concept of measuring your footprint. Did you know that?
speaker-0: Right, but that I did not know that they started that
speaker-1: That was a a BP ⁓ initiative. They're the ones that said, hey, measure, measure your footprint. That work we could go into a whole nother episode here, but that was BP's attempt to put the onus on the consumer. Right. Look at hey, consumer, measure your footprint just for giggles. Measure your footprint. Hold yourself accountable. Okay. Hold yourself accountable.
speaker-0: I learned something today.
speaker-1: Yeah learn your level of responsibility to to c ⁓ climate health and planet health. Yeah. Look Google it. Look it look it up. It's fascinating. Also, Google and and look up there was a ⁓ a commercial back in the the 70s where a Native American was ⁓ standing alongside of like a stream and a car went by and threw a handful of litter out and it kind of hit the ground and went all over his feet. And then you The camera looked up at the at the Native American and he had like a tear running down his cheek. So Google that commercial. That commercial was sponsored by at the time some of the some of the largest, most notorious polluters on the planet. It was like, ⁓ I can't remember exactly who they were, so I don't want to say, but you have to look into it. That was corporate America's first attempt. To say to the American consumer, we're having climate issues because you're littering. Not because we're making stuff out of the wrong material and we're using toxic ingredients, blah, blah, blah. It's because you're throwing your litter out the window. Right. And in fact, the actor who played that role of the of the Native American was an Italian American actor. And he went by the name. Chief Iron Eyes. Yeah, and he got into a lot of trouble for it for appropriating. ⁓ yeah. Go I'm telling you right now, Google it, look into it. Yeah, it's a fascinating story. Really interesting story. Anyway.
speaker-0: So they sponsored the ad. Okay. That's
speaker-1: That's interesting. There's a lot of there's a lot of parallels between ⁓ the cigarette industry and the fossil fuel industry in terms of how they are trying to frame what they're doing. Yeah.
speaker-0: the social media industry.
speaker-1: Yeah, for sure. But you know, that's th those are bigger problems than what you and I are trying to solve today, you know?
speaker-0: That's it. That's it. Well, I would say let's let's let's let's end it with this end. Tell me something that you're very excited about for this year.
speaker-1: ⁓ what am I really excited about for this year in in our industry and things that I'm doing? Okay. In our industry, what am I excited about? I'm well, I'll tell you one thing that I'm really excited about. I think that we are going to see some movement. ⁓ I'm excited about you know these guys. I'm excited about ⁓ Common Object Studio and what Fernando and Justin are doing right now. because what Justin and Fernando are doing from Common Object Studio is they are trying to redefine our supply chains and they're trying to redefine the design process, right? So they are really Going at they they are trying to achieve what I would call regenerative design, right? So they are taking a bill of materials that they know to be not harmful, repurposed, all these things that we look for in our materials. And they're saying, What can we make from this bill of materials? Where you know our standard design process is, hey, Andy, my company is really looking for a a side chair. Can you do some drawings for me? Show me some ideas that you have for a really good looking ⁓ side chair. And then, you know, we'll make some look like prototypes, then we'll make some work like prototypes, and then we'll start working on the bill of materials and see, you know, what we can make this chair out of to reach the price point that marketing says we have to be at. Right. That's probably the standard I'm generalizing. That's probably the standard design process. But ⁓ Common Object Studio is taking a bill of materials. They're saying, what if we used wool that typically gets thrown away? A huge amount of wool in the United States gets thrown away, never gets utilized, right? What if instead of using virgin wood, what if we use fallen timber from you know urban areas that
typically gets collected and mulched and wood chipped? What if we use that timber, right, for our wood source and You know, what if we create this bill of materials that we feel is actually good for the planet? And what if we find out what do we what if we work on what we can make from that? So I think this could be the year where we really look at our supply chains and clean them up. And I think we need these innovators like common object to we need to look, we need to give them space to create. You know? ⁓ really? Did I just tee it up for you?
speaker-0: You pretty much did. So we've been working with Common Object for the last six months. We've developed a prototype that is using one of the largest waste sources in our industry. It's not panels. It's not chairs. We're building a completely different product out of it. We are launching this at design days.
speaker-1: ⁓ wow. Okay. I did tee it up. ⁓
speaker-0: And it it's awesome. I mean, that was just a fluke.
speaker-1: Doesn't always doesn't always work that way.
speaker-0: No, so ⁓ so yeah, so they've been absolutely incredible to work with. I couldn't agree more that ⁓ I met them at ⁓ the human nature event in Toronto with Azure ⁓ few maybe two years ago. And I knew in right away, I'm like, this is this is what I believe is the future of the RE industry that we find ourselves in with because we're about to manufacture a product that it's not remanufactured.
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-0: Like I can't use that word anymore. It's not it's not that's not what it is. But it's something where When when you're looking at closing the loop, all of a sudden you can look at your thousand workstations, your old cubicles that you're getting rid of. And instead of thinking that, ⁓ yeah, those old cubicles are gonna turn into a slightly more modern cubicle, that's kind of the the world we live in, right? With right. It's ⁓ no, no, that's that's going to turn into a modular lounge system.
speaker-1: ⁓
speaker-0: And there's going to be a whole shift in I think what's possible because you're right. You start going down all these materials, you start using their way of thinking, you frame it differently. And all of a sudden the circular economy starts to feel much more tangible, even though I know the ocean bound plastics is important. It's still a bit of a a reach for someone to, you know, when they're getting rid of a floor of furniture, to say, ⁓ yeah, but I'm getting furniture that is made with a percentage of ocean bound plastic. The more you can make it tangible in that process, the more you can start to really rethink those core materials in a different way.
speaker-1: Well and I also I also I'll build on what you're saying too is that you know I I think there there could be a movement to adapt these regional supply chains where you know you are using a local economy, right, to make your product for you. And if I'm you know I'm not shipping now I'm not shipping product from Baltimore to San Francisco, right? Now I'm using local supply chains on the West Coast. to to supply my demand on the West Coast. Right. So, and that just there's the ripple effect of of that kind of an objective in your supply chain is huge.
speaker-0: Yes. And what I'm hoping as well is the ripple effect becomes let's make the RE products sexy. Let's make them desirable. Let's make it scalable. Let's make it work. Let's figure out how to frame it correctly. And then let's have a race. Let's have everyone else look at it where they go, ⁓ yeah, we can we can figure out a product like this. ⁓ we could figure out a product like this, right? That's what I'm hoping happens because of Guys like like Justin and Fernando and Common Object. It's it's that again, it's it's it's fringe right now. But I think the more the industry sees, okay, there is a different way of looking at supply chains and there is a way to execute this at scale. That's once you have those two things together, then we will see what happens. But ⁓ yeah. So are you coming to are you are you going to con design?
speaker-1: Exciting. Perfect. ⁓ Be there. Yeah, for sure. Yeah, I'm not I'm not sure yet if I'm gonna do rewritten again, only because that ⁓ you know, it's kinda last it's kinda it kinda has to be a last minute thing because you know, the Mart I have to find some space to do it. And the Mart wants to sell obviously they wanna they wanna lease out all the the space that they can. So I don't know. I loved last year. I loved doing rewritten. It was a it was it was amazing. It was a great amazing experience. And I love the concept. I love to I mean, I would love to find a way to do it. Maybe, you know, maybe over over at Fulton Market, do a pop up or something like that. That could be a lot of fun. So yeah I'd like to keep like the spirit of rewritten. I'd like to keep it going if I can. we'll see. Yeah. But I'll be there. I'll be there. Now I've got something new to look forward to.
speaker-0: Amazing. Well, I am excited to to show you. Maybe if you're doing your podcast there, we could do one with with Justin and Fernando and us at the Yeah, that would be a lot of fun. Yeah.
speaker-1: Yeah. Definite possibility. Well this was great Thanks Andy.
speaker-0: taking the time and you've got such great insights so thanks for thanks for going going down the rabbit hole.
speaker-1: Now we gotta climb back out and get on with our day.