TRANSKRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:03.838 --> 00:00:14.445
I was a former lecturer in AI, but I'll be the first to put my hands up and say, there's some things machines just cannot and will not ever do and shouldn't do but there are some things that are highly quantitative that machines are great at.
00:00:14.885 --> 00:00:23.756
So when you see a breakthrough technology that, can really reduce your workload, it makes sense to use it lean on it and those who do reap the rewards
00:00:24.396 --> 00:00:28.265
Good morning, good afternoon, or good evening, wherever you are in the world.
00:00:28.565 --> 00:00:30.635
This is the digital supply chain podcast.
00:00:30.786 --> 00:00:34.356
The number one podcast, focusing on the digitization of supply chain.
00:00:34.896 --> 00:00:38.765
And I'm your host global vice-president at SAP Tom Raftery.
00:00:38.923 --> 00:00:41.283
Hi everyone, welcome to the digital supply chain podcast.
00:00:41.372 --> 00:00:47.362
My name is Tom Raftery with SAP and with me on the show today, I have my special guest Allen.
00:00:47.703 --> 00:00:49.143
Allen, welcome to the podcast.
00:00:49.143 --> 00:00:50.732
Would you like to introduce yourself?
00:00:51.893 --> 00:00:52.823
Pleased to meet you Tom.
00:00:52.942 --> 00:00:56.292
My name is Alan Holland I'm the founder and CEO of Keelvar.
00:00:57.162 --> 00:00:58.442
And what is Keelvar?
00:00:59.633 --> 00:01:03.368
Keelvar is a software vendor headquartered in Cork in Ireland.
00:01:03.368 --> 00:01:06.337
And we specialize in advanced sourcing software.
00:01:06.427 --> 00:01:10.748
So we help big enterprises when they go to market and they're buying goods and services.
00:01:11.257 --> 00:01:15.427
We specialize in helping the largest enterprises doing that at scale.
00:01:16.393 --> 00:01:17.022
Fantastic.
00:01:17.022 --> 00:01:20.772
And congratulations on being based in Cork in Ireland, it's my hometown.
00:01:20.772 --> 00:01:21.725
It's where I grew up.
00:01:21.725 --> 00:01:25.415
So, uh, no better place I have to say apart from where I am now in Seville.
00:01:26.766 --> 00:01:27.225
Yes.
00:01:27.286 --> 00:01:35.135
People in Cork have a habit of congratulating themselves on their Corkness and celebrating is very frequently.
00:01:35.225 --> 00:01:36.596
It's what we're famous for.
00:01:38.460 --> 00:01:39.301
And rightly so.
00:01:39.546 --> 00:01:39.906
Yes.
00:01:41.040 --> 00:01:43.745
So, let's get back to Keelvar Allen.
00:01:44.305 --> 00:01:46.004
Why did you set Keelvar up?
00:01:47.730 --> 00:01:53.069
I set up Keelvar, because of a problem I encountered when I was a PhD student in fact.
00:01:53.459 --> 00:02:01.908
When I was studying for a PhD in computer science part-time in the evenings, I was working for my parents, a chemical company just to pay the way.
00:02:02.468 --> 00:02:09.384
I had to help my dad responding to tenders and RFQs from buyers of chemicals.
00:02:09.384 --> 00:02:12.495
So there's a big dairy companies, municipal water treatment plants,
Load full transcript
and so on.
00:02:13.034 --> 00:02:26.881
And I could see how frustrating it was for suppliers and these pricing mattresses that my dad would always be unsure of year to year whether he'd be winning contracts in the west, so to the east or the north.
00:02:26.881 --> 00:02:33.780
So he never knew where to place the storage facilities, how much to invest in transportation and manufacturing.
00:02:34.169 --> 00:02:36.069
I could see that this is an information problem.
00:02:36.280 --> 00:02:43.960
So that's why I started studying the topic of in academic circles is known as combinatorial auctions.
00:02:43.990 --> 00:02:50.680
So how suppliers could start communicating packaged beds with dependencies and capacity constraints, much richer information.
00:02:51.453 --> 00:02:58.953
The great thing for me was that I could see the opportunity for computer scientists and that there was a PhD in this because you needed an algorithms to compute winning outcomes.
00:02:59.432 --> 00:03:25.600
And so it was all neatly, came together, came across the problem and it was working in a new brand new AI research lab is very well funded at some of the world's top researchers in computer science coming from all over the world Cork and problem fell on my lap and when I finished my PhD, I was publishing case studies, real life examples, and companies started knocking my door saying: actually, this is a big problem for us.
00:03:26.170 --> 00:03:29.375
Could you help us with what was now been called sourcing optimization?
00:03:30.427 --> 00:03:34.747
So you went from there, you set up a company.
00:03:34.837 --> 00:03:36.038
Walk me through that whole process.
00:03:37.233 --> 00:03:42.955
Before I set up the company I was fortunate to have there's some funding agencies in our enterprise Ireland.
00:03:42.955 --> 00:03:50.854
It's a funding agency that helps researchers explore the commercialization potential of different research projects.
00:03:50.943 --> 00:03:56.223
So I was working as a lecturer, but also a part-time researcher.
00:03:56.250 --> 00:03:59.729
That allowed us to build prototypes and run projects.
00:03:59.789 --> 00:04:04.405
And one of our first projects was with the local Cork city council.
00:04:04.405 --> 00:04:13.168
We helped them buy a fleet of 250 vehicles and 16 categories and it was extremely successful.
00:04:13.168 --> 00:04:27.447
So we were able to prove that not only were buying organizations happy with the outcome that they make savings, but suppliers we're equally happy that they're increasing their profit margins, winning the right combinations of contracts.
00:04:28.322 --> 00:04:32.223
And that gave me the confidence to say, okay, well there's a business in this.
00:04:32.702 --> 00:04:48.571
So, I think I was fortunate that coming from a business family, I knew who to go to which solicitors you needed to help you incorporate the business and accountants, what they could do for you and what you're obliged to do when forming a
company.
00:04:49.365 --> 00:04:53.202
So I think coming from a business family helped in those early steps.
00:04:53.555 --> 00:04:54.156
Yeah, no doubt.
00:04:54.185 --> 00:04:54.485
No doubt.
00:04:54.516 --> 00:04:57.795
And so how long has Keelvar been in operation?
00:04:58.565 --> 00:05:07.355
So I set up the company in very late 2012, I left the university and we took some seed funding from seed investors.
00:05:07.752 --> 00:05:12.163
We've seen this work for public sector organizations really, really well.
00:05:12.904 --> 00:05:16.235
Let's do sourcing optimization for government bodies.
00:05:16.521 --> 00:05:28.151
I think we learned a lesson that just because you have a product that solves a problem doesn't necessarily a meaning a product market fit, and that market needs a certain patiance.
00:05:28.322 --> 00:05:44.235
And sales process to educate public bodies that they have additionally beyond that or what something they're buying presently that you actually need to be crafting the tenders for them to go to market to buy what you have.
00:05:44.961 --> 00:05:46.822
That, that was two slower process.
00:05:46.882 --> 00:06:02.144
So in 2013 and 14, we were building a solution and we kind of led 2014 and we realized that we should be trying to target enterprise companies because they understood what they needed to buy better than government bodies.
00:06:02.624 --> 00:06:09.134
And they are coming, knocking on our door and saying, I like what you're doing for those public sector organizations.
00:06:09.134 --> 00:06:10.504
Could you do something similar for us?
00:06:10.764 --> 00:06:11.064
Hmm.
00:06:12.384 --> 00:06:32.127
Procurement processes for enterprises are so much different to those for government bodies and governments are highly regulated procurement processes where frequent feedback loops and iterations and bidding not entertained very often whereas enterprises they're much more keen to impose more competitive tension in the process.
00:06:32.509 --> 00:06:36.511
In late 2014 we took a difficult decision to start from scratch.
00:06:36.576 --> 00:06:41.045
When funds were low, it's difficult to pivot when you're going to use that most of your seed funding.
00:06:41.682 --> 00:06:44.622
So that was a big risk but that's, that was the making of the company to.
00:06:44.851 --> 00:06:48.531
Because we had clarity on what we knew by that stage, what we should have built.
00:06:49.391 --> 00:06:52.432
But now we just had to go build us as fast as we could.
00:06:52.432 --> 00:06:58.089
And we were fortunate that we did some projects with very large enterprises who knew what best practice looked like.
00:06:58.089 --> 00:07:07.225
And builds trust in us because we ran some very successful projects for them that we could build a self-service project and product for their needs.
00:07:07.584 --> 00:07:10.774
And so some of our early customers, they backed us.
00:07:11.605 --> 00:07:14.194
And we still work very closely with
them.
00:07:14.314 --> 00:07:19.632
And we have that neutral trust built up over many years that's integral to who we are.
00:07:20.117 --> 00:07:22.266
Okay, where does the name Keelvar come from?
00:07:23.194 --> 00:07:25.624
Keelvar is it stems from an Irish word.
00:07:25.624 --> 00:07:28.994
So the Irish for sensible or intelligent is Ciallmhar.
00:07:29.144 --> 00:07:32.329
C I A L L M H A R an old Gaelic word.
00:07:32.399 --> 00:07:35.935
So it's an Anglicised spelling of what is it intelligent system.
00:07:36.004 --> 00:07:44.766
I used to teach intelligence systems in University College Cork, which is the application of AI and other techniques and intelligence software system.
00:07:45.576 --> 00:07:48.490
So yes, a nod to my university days.
00:07:48.689 --> 00:07:49.000
Nice.
00:07:49.189 --> 00:07:49.875
Lovely, lovely.
00:07:50.235 --> 00:08:07.901
So for people, because this podcast caters to a wide range of people in all aspects of supply chain, everywhere from engineering, planning, through to manufacturing, making, delivering, operations for people who might not be very familiar with procurement what problem is it that you're solving for . Companies?
00:08:08.730 --> 00:08:16.380
We saw the problem of how to find win-win outcomes between suppliers and your buying organizations.
00:08:16.380 --> 00:08:19.545
So, when you're going to market and you're buying at scale.
00:08:19.564 --> 00:08:21.718
So let's say you're buying transportation at scale.
00:08:22.098 --> 00:08:30.327
You're going to need to deal with small, medium and various suppliers because you probably have a large network of lanes that you move goods over.
00:08:30.728 --> 00:08:36.725
You'll have regional vendors, nationwide vendors, and you'll have local suppliers.
00:08:36.784 --> 00:08:38.014
They all have their strengths.
00:08:38.134 --> 00:08:46.941
Now, if you're very good at buying, you will allow them play to their strengths and you will also allow them see where they're not as strong nearly.
00:08:47.341 --> 00:08:51.850
Contracts they would not like to win unless than when something else besides that makes us viable.
00:08:52.091 --> 00:08:56.215
So what we provide is sourcing our first product was a sourcing optimization.
00:08:56.390 --> 00:08:58.640
You don't aggregate on behalf of the market.
00:08:58.760 --> 00:09:02.270
You break down what you need and to small, granular dots.
00:09:02.768 --> 00:09:17.472
And you say to your suppliers, you guys bundle, design the packages, tell us what we would like to combine things and where your economies of scale are, where your diseconomies of scale are and what kind of capacity constraints you have.
00:09:17.952 --> 00:09:22.384
So you're gathering much richer information from the marketplace.
00:09:23.644 --> 00:09:28.986
And so in the case of transportation, that might be, let's say it's a company that's got it's serving.
00:09:29.932 --> 00:09:33.111
They've already serving customers who are manufacturers in Atlanta.
00:09:33.142 --> 00:09:38.365
So they have trucks leaving Atlanta at a full, but they have trucks going back into Atlanta that are empty.
00:09:38.634 --> 00:09:42.085
So they might want to say to you of all the 20 lanes going into Atlanta.
00:09:42.294 --> 00:09:45.784
If we went in 15 of those 20, we'll give you a 20% discount.
00:09:46.634 --> 00:09:47.480
Something of that nature.
00:09:47.480 --> 00:09:59.120
So by facilitating that type of expressiveness and bedding, you're increasing efficiencies, operational efficiencies for your suppliers, and they can bid more competitively.
00:09:59.179 --> 00:10:01.820
So they share part of that savings.
00:10:01.863 --> 00:10:05.513
They're giving you a discount, but their profit margins increasing.
00:10:05.903 --> 00:10:08.812
So that's an example of win-win.
00:10:09.942 --> 00:10:10.423
No, sorry.
00:10:10.452 --> 00:10:12.582
There's two sides to the sourcing optimization coin.
00:10:12.623 --> 00:10:14.682
There's expressiveness for the marketplace.
00:10:15.163 --> 00:10:18.342
There's also the expressiveness for your internal stakeholders.
00:10:18.942 --> 00:10:33.048
So when that organization, let's say, that it's transportation, you're buying your given the flexibility to suppliers to be descriptive, but you also should give flexibility to your logistics managers to be descriptive about their preferences.
00:10:33.077 --> 00:10:43.758
So maybe you're a logistics manager in California uh, doesn't want to award more than 20% of the volume to any one carrier.
00:10:43.937 --> 00:10:53.403
And wants at least eight carriers, and, it doesn't want more than 50% of the lanes to be switched from incumbents.
00:10:53.702 --> 00:10:59.265
They may might have all sorts of, creative, um, constraints and preferences around what they would like.
00:10:59.265 --> 00:11:07.125
And sourcing optimizer allows the buying organization to very quickly model like in seconds, add constraints and see, Okay.
00:11:07.245 --> 00:11:11.625
I have that constraint and price has just gone up by $500,000.
00:11:12.826 --> 00:11:14.145
Is that really worth it?
00:11:14.326 --> 00:11:17.311
So you can assess those tradeoffs easily.
00:11:18.385 --> 00:11:18.806
Okay.
00:11:19.326 --> 00:11:28.352
Interesting, So do you have outcomes that you can speak to, for, customers that you've managed to make savings for or something like that?
00:11:28.842 --> 00:11:29.072
Yeah.
00:11:29.212 --> 00:11:35.548
So there's a few, a few dimensions to optimization and, and a there's, there's obviously the, the cost savings dimension.
00:11:35.548 --> 00:11:35.697
Right.
00:11:35.697 --> 00:11:38.788
And I think that was the primary driver of sourcing optimization in the early days.
00:11:38.817 --> 00:11:40.857
Most companies realize that, okay.
00:11:40.857 --> 00:11:42.687
By facilitating that expressiveness.
00:11:43.758 --> 00:11:44.687
You get savings.
00:11:44.827 --> 00:11:50.327
And they're typically in the
order of five to 15% and can be higher.
00:11:50.327 --> 00:11:56.989
We've seen 20, 25%, when compared to a process that's just simply just cherry picking.
00:11:57.528 --> 00:12:14.874
And now the other dimension still, I think that the more mature users of sourcing optimization realized that this is a grade two for improving value outside of cost too.
00:12:14.903 --> 00:12:22.494
So for example, if you want to start biasing in favour of faster suppliers.
00:12:22.813 --> 00:12:29.833
Let's say that there are all sorts of non-cost dimensions, but in supply chains, the speed is important.
00:12:30.283 --> 00:12:34.303
So what you could do is change the objective function to optimize for speed.
00:12:34.333 --> 00:12:40.724
So you could have a scenario where, okay, I've just completely ignored costs, but this is the fastest outcome we could achieve.
00:12:41.264 --> 00:12:43.813
And usually, that might be expensive though.
00:12:43.903 --> 00:12:47.984
Um, so now you're looking at the trade off, so you start to work.
00:12:48.764 --> 00:12:56.236
When organizations start to quantify, how much more would we pay for faster deliveries?
00:12:56.626 --> 00:13:04.636
And it's not something you need to come up with a number, because it's difficult to come up with a number for that before you go to market.
00:13:04.876 --> 00:13:10.667
It's when you, when you go to market and then you see that, okay, you have options, a, B, C, and D.
00:13:11.437 --> 00:13:16.302
A being the cheapest, but the slowest and D being the fastest, but the most expensive.
00:13:16.331 --> 00:13:27.432
Now you have a continuum you can select from, and that makes it quick and easy for organizations to move along what we call peripheral frontier and choose, choose an outcome that's the best balance for them.
00:13:28.065 --> 00:13:43.215
So, so organizations kind of moved, I would say second wave of, usage of source and optimization started to better explore the speed versus cost dimension, but another dimension is appearing and that's around sustainability.
00:13:43.485 --> 00:13:55.245
So now I would say our top users are including scope three emissions information gathering in their sourcing events so they can start.
00:13:55.725 --> 00:14:17.490
So instead of the kind of crude approach to trying to gauge rates, individual suppliers, you could actually be looking at a much more granular approach where you're looking at what trucks are being used in what regions, what cities, so that you can start bias in favor of, more environmentally friendly alternatives.
00:14:17.850 --> 00:14:28.379
So if you have an internal cost of carbon, you can start to be quantitative in and systematic and biasing in favor of more sustainable alternatives.
00:14:29.039 --> 00:14:39.529
And for enterprises who are trying to operate at scale and need to operate as quickly as much smaller competitors, that's very, very important benefit.
00:14:40.320 --> 00:14:56.697
It's interesting that you bring that up because, we are in the twenty twenties which is supposed of action, and it's, nice to hear that organizations are actually taking this seriously and are looking for ways to reduce their scope three emissions using a tool like this.
00:14:57.856 --> 00:15:43.163
Yeah, I think what has been heartening is that that recent procurement events we've attended And every, every, presentation I saw from a chief procurement officer, there was sin singling out sustainability, operationalizing sustainability as their number one objective.
00:15:44.063 --> 00:15:56.255
So, uh, I think that businesses have realized that in between generally speaking, between 60 and 90% of their emissions are scope three emissions, from their suppliers.
00:15:56.285 --> 00:16:12.434
So if they're going to make a dent in emissions overall, they have to be gathering much richer information from their suppliers and they have to start becoming systematic in building incentives into how they source.
00:16:12.644 --> 00:16:14.927
So that suppliers who are investing in this.
00:16:14.927 --> 00:16:16.677
area are winning
00:16:17.967 --> 00:16:19.018
Tremendous tremendous.
00:16:19.377 --> 00:16:26.677
Are there any particular industries Alan, that you guys are particularly suited to, or is it across the board?
00:16:27.477 --> 00:16:30.894
We serve industries with supply chains.
00:16:30.985 --> 00:16:40.074
So, say foods, automotive, industrial goods, mining, electronic goods, CPG.
00:16:40.096 --> 00:16:48.735
In all of those industries, if you look at the top five companies in the world, we will be serving one or two of those top five companies in all across all those major industries.
00:16:49.456 --> 00:16:49.665
Wow.
00:16:49.665 --> 00:16:59.800
That's impressive and already about the fact that you're based in cork, but your customer base are, they they're obviously not just Cork, where where are they based?
00:17:00.550 --> 00:17:02.150
Uh, yeah, we have a global customer base.
00:17:02.150 --> 00:17:13.151
So from Nestle and Switzerland to Siemens in Germany and Mercedes-Benz, and in the US, we serve the backs of Coca-Cola and Microsoft.
00:17:13.171 --> 00:17:21.040
So we have a blue chip customer base, predominantly in Europe and us but that's growing in Asia too now.
00:17:21.696 --> 00:17:22.506
That's fantastic.
00:17:22.536 --> 00:17:23.316
Congratulations.
00:17:23.885 --> 00:17:25.206
How do you do that?
00:17:25.206 --> 00:17:30.507
I mean, you are a startup, 10 years on since you started.
00:17:30.626 --> 00:17:32.037
How do you make that market?
00:17:32.037 --> 00:17:35.187
Because it is a relatively new market that you're making, right?
00:17:36.576 --> 00:17:37.407
Yeah, that's correct.
00:17:37.407 --> 00:17:41.157
We focused all our efforts on our product first and foremost.
00:17:41.187 --> 00:17:45.777
We only hired our first sales person just over two and a half years ago.
00:17:45.811 --> 00:17:55.554
We were quite, quite late in terms of
getting to the sales and marketing game, which allowed us to be quite ma I would say we were match fit in terms of our product.
00:17:55.584 --> 00:17:58.314
We were for all the customers we were serving.
00:17:59.516 --> 00:18:10.686
We possibly underestimated ourselves and strengths of our product because when, when we did start selling it and we did start marketing it more intensively, we were very high success rates when we involved in competitive processes.
00:18:11.105 --> 00:18:14.536
So we should have maybe should have been building a commercial team.
00:18:15.189 --> 00:18:16.819
And we lacked capital too, right.
00:18:16.819 --> 00:18:23.538
So we kind of come from, an origin where we had spent our seed money on, targeting the wrong market.
00:18:24.048 --> 00:18:35.686
And we were bootstrapped for several years and we didn't really look at alternative sources of capital until I suppose we started developing automation.
00:18:35.746 --> 00:18:47.026
That's our second product where we took a view that sourcing optimization is clearly delivering stellar results when it's applied by companies.
00:18:47.026 --> 00:18:57.136
But the big companies we serve have a limited number of experts in sourcing that would understand why and how to use sourcing optimization.
00:18:58.516 --> 00:19:04.996
So we said we won't boil the ocean and try to teach the whole world why and how to use sourcing optimization.
00:19:04.996 --> 00:19:23.267
Instead we'll develop sourcing bots to automate the eh, sourcing process so that you could have a sourcing bot for let's say packaging, ocean freight and that it would follow best practice, process and execute it to that standard every time.
00:19:24.076 --> 00:19:27.524
And when we took this to our customers, as our, second product.
00:19:28.964 --> 00:19:29.604
They loved it.
00:19:29.714 --> 00:19:34.761
They almost loved too much because they were saying, could we have sourcing bots for this and that?
00:19:34.761 --> 00:19:35.240
And the other.
00:19:36.041 --> 00:19:38.621
We said we're still relatively small.
00:19:38.621 --> 00:19:41.471
We were maybe a headcount of 20 back two and a half years ago.
00:19:41.891 --> 00:19:43.051
Um, we can't do everything.
00:19:43.771 --> 00:19:49.284
And so we said it's time to take on additional finance and grow, grow the team much faster.
00:19:49.314 --> 00:20:06.019
And so we, in the last two years have grown from 20 to over 80 and, we have kind of exciting new product roadmap ahead where we're, we'll be launching a much wider range of sourcing bots so our customers will be getting more of what they're looking for.
00:20:06.322 --> 00:20:09.412
when We'll be sating their appetite and it's probably more, hopefully.
00:20:10.457 --> 00:20:13.877
So that leads me nicely to my next question, which is what is next?
00:20:13.908 --> 00:20:15.307
Where to from here?
00:20:16.323 --> 00:20:16.623
Yeah.
00:20:16.663 --> 00:20:18.882
So, we're all about intelligent systems.
00:20:19.203 --> 00:20:25.233
Whenever we have these product meeting our, company meetings where I'm re restating our vision and focus.
00:20:26.753 --> 00:20:43.323
What we have a vision for procurement in which software agents to all of the tactical work and all of the grunt work and people in procurement do all of the strategic work We'll be adding more intelligence to our sourcing bots.
00:20:43.343 --> 00:21:00.663
So there'll be able to know when to go to markets, know who to go to market, to, invite, to compete then know, and be training themselves, on, sourcing strategy that's optimal for, for them, so that if you're in a competitive market, you can use a different strategy.
00:21:01.003 --> 00:21:14.513
And another market where there's a lack of supply so this, that type of tactical buying where they're sourcing bots can be reactive and can absorb much larger volumes of data that actioned intelligence.
00:21:14.543 --> 00:21:18.323
Now you were saying 2020 has been a decade of action.
00:21:18.363 --> 00:21:27.958
That really speaks to the imperative for intelligent automation, but it's not sufficient to have actionable intelligence, you want actioned intelligence.
00:21:28.408 --> 00:21:33.732
So, where we're going next is, is making sure there's more actioned intelligence.
00:21:34.727 --> 00:21:35.117
Nice.
00:21:35.387 --> 00:21:35.717
Nice.
00:21:36.137 --> 00:21:36.557
Okay.
00:21:36.607 --> 00:21:49.137
Superb Allen, we're coming towards the end of the podcast now, is there any question I have not asked that you wish I had, or aspect of this, we haven't touched on that you think it's important for people to be aware of?
00:21:50.937 --> 00:22:02.096
Yeah, I think that, you know, when we're talking about automation and intelligent automation, procurement, you know, sometimes we get asked about its impact on the future of work in procurement.
00:22:02.217 --> 00:22:10.295
And I think it can have a very healthy and positive impact on the role procurement plays in an organization.
00:22:10.384 --> 00:22:15.045
It would be a mistake to think that this is replacing jobs or moving jobs.
00:22:15.365 --> 00:22:30.035
Instead, what I would say is that it's making the jobs in procurement much more interesting because the focus of people's time will be on strategic activities, negotiations with suppliers, risk management, innovation discovery, and so on.
00:22:30.035 --> 00:22:44.948
Where you know there's, there's so much work machines can't, you know, I I was a former lecturer in AI, but I'll be the first to put my hands up and say, there's some things machines just cannot and will not ever do and shouldn't do but there are some things that are highly quantitative that machines are great at.
00:22:45.388 --> 00:22:51.942
So you apply machines when you see a breakthrough technology that that can really reduce your workload.
00:22:52.242 --> 00:22:56.312
It makes sense to use it lean on it and those who do reap the rewards.
00:22:56.882 --> 00:22:57.302
Very good.
00:22:57.502 --> 00:22:57.892
Superb.
00:22:58.502 --> 00:22:58.892
Okay.
00:22:58.892 --> 00:23:09.302
Alan, if people want to know more yourself Allan Holland, about Keelvar or any of the topics we discussed on the podcast today, where would you have me direct them?
00:23:10.332 --> 00:23:10.682
Yes.
00:23:10.682 --> 00:23:15.167
And there's our website Keelvar.Com there's also our LinkedIn page is a good source.
00:23:15.167 --> 00:23:25.777
If you want to follow us on LinkedIn, where we're regularly, producing new content with a great content team, um, who almost on a weekly basis producing new and excellent insightful content.
00:23:26.357 --> 00:23:26.957
Fantastic.
00:23:27.346 --> 00:23:28.187
Alan that's when great.
00:23:28.217 --> 00:23:29.836
Thanks a million for coming on the podcast today.
00:23:31.247 --> 00:23:31.637
Thank you.
00:23:33.350 --> 00:23:35.180
Okay, we've come to the end of the show.
00:23:35.780 --> 00:23:36.830
Thanks everyone for listening.
00:23:37.670 --> 00:23:48.470
If you'd like to know more about digital supply chains, head on over to sap.com/digital supply chain, or, or simply drop me an email to Tom dot Raftery @sap.com.
00:23:50.060 --> 00:23:56.860
If you like the show, please, don't forget to subscribe to it in your podcast application at choice to get new episodes, as soon as they are published.
00:23:58.009 --> 00:24:01.144
Also, please don't forget to rate and review the podcast.
00:24:01.355 --> 00:24:04.055
It really does help new people to find the show.
00:24:04.894 --> 00:24:06.605
Thanks, catch you all next time.