TRANSKRIPT 🔗
Speaker:
00:00:49
what is a
Speaker:
00:00:50
ventilated cavity?
Speaker:
00:00:51
Righto, ventilated
Speaker:
00:00:52
cavities.
Speaker:
00:00:55
Okay, um, so,
Speaker:
00:00:58
I can't believe we've got
Speaker:
00:01:00
Dr.
Speaker:
00:01:01
Cameron Munro stumped.
Speaker:
00:01:03
No, I'm
Speaker:
00:01:03
just trying to stick it
Speaker:
00:01:04
about where to start here
Speaker:
00:01:05
because I'd forgotten what
Speaker:
00:01:06
we're even talking about.
Speaker:
00:01:07
ventilated cavities.
Speaker:
00:01:08
Ventilator cavities.
Speaker:
00:01:10
I don't know what we're
Speaker:
00:01:11
talking about now.
Speaker:
00:01:12
I'm just getting
Speaker:
00:01:13
my head around it.
Speaker:
00:01:13
Alright.
Speaker:
00:01:14
Okay.
Speaker:
00:01:15
You didn't realize
Speaker:
00:01:16
Cameron that none of this
Speaker:
00:01:17
is getting edited out.
Speaker:
00:01:18
This is the beginning
Speaker:
00:01:19
of this episode.
Speaker:
00:01:21
terrific.
Speaker:
00:01:21
Great.
Speaker:
00:01:22
, okay.
Speaker:
00:01:23
So if we start with a
Speaker:
00:01:24
heating dominated climate
Speaker:
00:01:26
like a Melbourne or a
Speaker:
00:01:27
Hobart or a Canberra, the
Speaker:
00:01:29
water vapour for most of
Speaker:
00:01:31
the year, particularly
Speaker:
00:01:32
when it's cold, wants
Speaker:
00:01:33
to dry from or move
Speaker:
00:01:35
from the interior of the
Speaker:
00:01:37
building to the exterior.
Speaker:
00:01:39
And so in order to
Speaker:
00:01:41
allow that drying to
Speaker:
00:01:42
occur, we've got to
Speaker:
00:01:43
consider the buildups of
Speaker:
00:01:46
each layer within that
Speaker:
00:01:47
wall or roof system to
Speaker:
00:01:49
have increasing vapour
Speaker:
00:01:50
permeance as we move out.
Speaker:
00:01:52
So we have that ability
Speaker:
00:01:54
for that vapour to drive
Speaker:
00:01:55
towards the exterior.
Speaker:
00:01:57
And then when it hits the
Speaker:
00:01:58
exterior in a traditional
Speaker:
00:02:00
construction, we would
Speaker:
00:02:02
often have, say, a sarking
Speaker:
00:02:03
layer, which now would be,
Speaker:
00:02:05
need to be vapour permeable
Speaker:
00:02:07
in most of these climates.
Speaker:
00:02:09
But then we'd often just
Speaker:
00:02:11
fix our cladding directly
Speaker:
00:02:12
onto that sarking.
Speaker:
00:02:14
And that's where
Speaker:
00:02:14
the problems arise,
Speaker:
00:02:16
because we've just run
Speaker:
00:02:17
completely contrary to
Speaker:
00:02:18
our intention here of
Speaker:
00:02:19
having increasing vapour
Speaker:
00:02:21
permeance as we move out.
Speaker:
00:02:23
So we're allowing the water
Speaker:
00:02:24
vapour to dry towards the
Speaker:
00:02:25
exterior, but then we're
Speaker:
00:02:26
trapping it on the back
Speaker:
00:02:27
side of the cladding.
Speaker:
00:02:28
Whether that might be
Speaker:
00:02:29
like a fibre cement sheet
Speaker:
00:02:31
of some description, or
Speaker:
00:02:32
even weatherboards, or
Speaker:
00:02:35
potentially worst of all,
Speaker:
00:02:37
some sort of metal based
Speaker:
00:02:38
cladding like a standing
Speaker:
00:02:39
seam or something, where
Speaker:
00:02:41
completely trapped it.
Speaker:
00:02:42
And so a ventilated
Speaker:
00:02:43
cavity is where we try
Speaker:
00:02:46
and offset the cladding,
Speaker:
00:02:48
from that membrane,
Speaker:
00:02:50
that sarking layer.
Speaker:
00:02:52
So we can allow the wall
Speaker:
00:02:54
system to dry towards the
Speaker:
00:02:55
exterior so that vapour
Speaker:
00:02:57
that moves out towards the
Speaker:
00:02:59
outside of the building
Speaker:
00:03:00
gets into an air cavity
Speaker:
00:03:02
and then we've got air
Speaker:
00:03:03
movement through that air
Speaker:
00:03:04
cavity that allows the
Speaker:
00:03:06
vapour to be carried away.
Speaker:
00:03:08
So that's the fundamental
Speaker:
00:03:10
of a ventilated cavity.
Speaker:
00:03:12
, so for a number of years
Speaker:
00:03:13
recently, everyone was
Speaker:
00:03:14
sort of complaining
Speaker:
00:03:15
about, oh, weatherboards,
Speaker:
00:03:16
they just don't last as
Speaker:
00:03:17
long as they used to.
Speaker:
00:03:18
Is that because we
Speaker:
00:03:20
essentially changed the
Speaker:
00:03:21
way we build our walls?
Speaker:
00:03:22
Like we've changed
Speaker:
00:03:23
that drying potential
Speaker:
00:03:24
by to the wall.
Speaker:
00:03:25
We've got the
Speaker:
00:03:26
metal sarking, it's
Speaker:
00:03:27
wedged on hard.
Speaker:
00:03:28
Where if you look at my
Speaker:
00:03:29
house at the moment, it's
Speaker:
00:03:30
old hardwood studs, no
Speaker:
00:03:32
insulation, weatherboards
Speaker:
00:03:33
waxed stride on.
Speaker:
00:03:34
Is that why they're
Speaker:
00:03:35
not lasting?
Speaker:
00:03:35
Cause they're the ones
Speaker:
00:03:36
soaking in the water.
Speaker:
00:03:37
There's got no room for
Speaker:
00:03:38
it to dry out they're
Speaker:
00:03:39
just being eaten alive.
Speaker:
00:03:41
There's probably two
Speaker:
00:03:42
factors there isn't there?
Speaker:
00:03:43
I mean it's true in a way.
Speaker:
00:03:45
The timber that we've
Speaker:
00:03:46
used has changed.
Speaker:
00:03:47
It's no longer
Speaker:
00:03:49
very old hardwoods.
Speaker:
00:03:50
It's often softwoods or
Speaker:
00:03:52
plantation grown timbers
Speaker:
00:03:54
now that grow much more
Speaker:
00:03:55
quickly and therefore
Speaker:
00:03:56
can absorb more moisture
Speaker:
00:03:58
and are less tolerant
Speaker:
00:03:59
to high moisture levels.
Speaker:
00:04:01
But also
Load full transcript
as you point out
Speaker:
00:04:03
Matt, because we've moved
Speaker:
00:04:04
to a building technique
Speaker:
00:04:07
now where we're emphasising
Speaker:
00:04:08
thermal performance
Speaker:
00:04:09
and so we're putting
Speaker:
00:04:10
insulation in the walls.
Speaker:
00:04:12
Therefore, we're reducing
Speaker:
00:04:13
that heat movement through
Speaker:
00:04:14
the wall and reducing
Speaker:
00:04:16
the drying potential of
Speaker:
00:04:17
every element within that
Speaker:
00:04:19
wall, and particularly
Speaker:
00:04:21
those on the cold
Speaker:
00:04:22
side of construction,
Speaker:
00:04:23
which is the cladding.
Speaker:
00:04:25
So yes, we are, making
Speaker:
00:04:27
it more important that we
Speaker:
00:04:28
consider, what materials
Speaker:
00:04:30
we use on our cladding and
Speaker:
00:04:32
make sure they're durable
Speaker:
00:04:33
enough to high moisture.
Speaker:
00:04:35
So what we're probably
Speaker:
00:04:36
talking about here, if
Speaker:
00:04:37
you picture a building and
Speaker:
00:04:38
you've got your membrane
Speaker:
00:04:39
externally, that first
Speaker:
00:04:41
thing, if you've got a
Speaker:
00:04:41
vertical cladding, you'd
Speaker:
00:04:42
have your vertical, Counter
Speaker:
00:04:44
batten, we call it your
Speaker:
00:04:45
vertical batten, which
Speaker:
00:04:46
is typically we're using
Speaker:
00:04:47
a 19 mil batten Hamish.
Speaker:
00:04:48
I don't know if you're
Speaker:
00:04:49
using something similar.
Speaker:
00:04:50
We've, actually, switched
Speaker:
00:04:51
to using a 35 mil,
Speaker:
00:04:52
so 35 and 35, and the
Speaker:
00:04:54
reasons for that are
Speaker:
00:04:55
just more to standardize
Speaker:
00:04:56
our window reveals,
Speaker:
00:04:57
a good idea.
Speaker:
00:04:58
yeah,
Speaker:
00:04:59
we're going overall 70
Speaker:
00:05:00
mil because then we're
Speaker:
00:05:01
trying to fix our window
Speaker:
00:05:03
reveal prices with a
Speaker:
00:05:05
company at the moment.
Speaker:
00:05:06
So design in that
Speaker:
00:05:07
kind of reveal detail.
Speaker:
00:05:08
So it's standardized
Speaker:
00:05:09
across all our projects,
Speaker:
00:05:10
but minimum 20 mil.
Speaker:
00:05:12
So if you had a vertical
Speaker:
00:05:13
cladding, you didn't have
Speaker:
00:05:13
your cross batten, which
Speaker:
00:05:14
is a way typically using
Speaker:
00:05:16
a 90, in some cases.
Speaker:
00:05:19
, so that's creating that
Speaker:
00:05:20
sort of cross layer.
Speaker:
00:05:21
If you had a horizontal
Speaker:
00:05:22
cladding, you'd only need
Speaker:
00:05:23
your vertical cladding,
Speaker:
00:05:25
your vertical batten.
Speaker:
00:05:25
All right, so water
Speaker:
00:05:26
can drain down.
Speaker:
00:05:27
Now, the important part
Speaker:
00:05:29
though is that the cavity's
Speaker:
00:05:30
there for two reasons,
Speaker:
00:05:31
Cam, and one of them is
Speaker:
00:05:32
to allow air to circulate
Speaker:
00:05:34
through and dry up, but
Speaker:
00:05:35
the second is for moisture.
Speaker:
00:05:37
now.
Speaker:
00:05:37
Okay.
Speaker:
00:05:37
They both require
Speaker:
00:05:38
different thicknesses
Speaker:
00:05:39
for what they require.
Speaker:
00:05:41
, from my understanding
Speaker:
00:05:42
with drainage of water,
Speaker:
00:05:43
you only need a few mil,
Speaker:
00:05:45
technically, but the
Speaker:
00:05:46
air you need a lot more.
Speaker:
00:05:47
Do you want to maybe
Speaker:
00:05:47
explain that and why
Speaker:
00:05:48
that's important?
Speaker:
00:05:49
Yeah.
Speaker:
00:05:50
Okay.
Speaker:
00:05:50
So, uh, probably the two
Speaker:
00:05:51
words here I'd use would be
Speaker:
00:05:52
ventilation and drainage.
Speaker:
00:05:55
So, ventilation is
Speaker:
00:05:56
about the water vapor.
Speaker:
00:05:58
So, the gaseous water
Speaker:
00:06:00
that's in the air that
Speaker:
00:06:01
we can't see and this
Speaker:
00:06:03
the drainage is about
Speaker:
00:06:04
the liquid water.
Speaker:
00:06:06
So, this is the water
Speaker:
00:06:07
primarily that comes
Speaker:
00:06:08
in beyond the cladding.
Speaker:
00:06:10
So, Joe Starbrick has
Speaker:
00:06:11
famously always says,
Speaker:
00:06:12
there's the claddings
Speaker:
00:06:13
that have leaked and
Speaker:
00:06:14
the claddings that
Speaker:
00:06:15
haven't leaked yet.
Speaker:
00:06:16
You know, you've always
Speaker:
00:06:17
got to assume that your
Speaker:
00:06:18
cladding is going to have
Speaker:
00:06:19
a failure in it at some
Speaker:
00:06:20
point, and indeed when
Speaker:
00:06:22
we do Wolfie hygrothermal
Speaker:
00:06:24
analyses, we're required
Speaker:
00:06:26
by the standards that
Speaker:
00:06:27
we test those to, to
Speaker:
00:06:29
assume that 1 percent of
Speaker:
00:06:31
the rain water that hits
Speaker:
00:06:32
that wall, makes its way
Speaker:
00:06:35
in beyond the cladding.
Speaker:
00:06:36
And, in a real building,
Speaker:
00:06:37
that's probably going to
Speaker:
00:06:38
happen at your windowsills
Speaker:
00:06:39
probably is your first,
Speaker:
00:06:41
most worrying point.
Speaker:
00:06:43
So you're going to get
Speaker:
00:06:44
water, liquid water coming
Speaker:
00:06:46
in beyond the cladding.
Speaker:
00:06:48
And so you don't want
Speaker:
00:06:50
that hard up against your
Speaker:
00:06:52
sarking or your vapour
Speaker:
00:06:53
permeable membrane on the
Speaker:
00:06:55
exterior of your building.
Speaker:
00:06:57
because that liquid water
Speaker:
00:06:59
can potentially will
Speaker:
00:07:00
find any weak point.
Speaker:
00:07:01
, this is where
capillary
Speaker:
00:07:02
action of liquid
Speaker:
00:07:04
water comes in.
Speaker:
00:07:05
As we know, it can readily
Speaker:
00:07:07
find at the smallest
Speaker:
00:07:09
hole any, layer and
Speaker:
00:07:11
leak in beyond that.
Speaker:
00:07:13
And then if it accumulates
Speaker:
00:07:14
on our moisture sensitive
Speaker:
00:07:15
materials like our timber,
Speaker:
00:07:17
then we start having rot
Speaker:
00:07:18
and moisture problems.
Speaker:
00:07:19
So if you think about
Speaker:
00:07:20
this cavity, it's kind
Speaker:
00:07:21
of like the traditional
Speaker:
00:07:22
brick veneer, where they
Speaker:
00:07:23
drilled their timber frame,
Speaker:
00:07:24
they'd have the gap and
Speaker:
00:07:25
then they have the brick.
Speaker:
00:07:27
But for me, what I get
Speaker:
00:07:28
confused about, and I've
Speaker:
00:07:29
always not understood,
Speaker:
00:07:30
is why We thought about
Speaker:
00:07:32
this with brick, but no
Speaker:
00:07:34
other cladding, because
Speaker:
00:07:36
the weep holes were kind
Speaker:
00:07:37
of the ability to drain
Speaker:
00:07:38
out and you had those
Speaker:
00:07:39
vents that were allowed
Speaker:
00:07:40
to suck air through to
Speaker:
00:07:41
drain it to dry everything
Speaker:
00:07:42
out behind there, but
Speaker:
00:07:43
every other cladding
Speaker:
00:07:44
it just got ignored.
Speaker:
00:07:46
Yeah, so one of the reasons
Speaker:
00:07:48
why I think we've always
Speaker:
00:07:49
done the cavity with brick
Speaker:
00:07:50
veneer is because brick
Speaker:
00:07:52
is kind of like a sponge.
Speaker:
00:07:54
If you don't render or coat
Speaker:
00:07:56
that brick with something,
Speaker:
00:07:57
every time the rain hits
Speaker:
00:07:59
that brick it just gets
Speaker:
00:08:00
absorbed into the brick and
Speaker:
00:08:02
that can be fine if the sun
Speaker:
00:08:04
can then comes out and it
Speaker:
00:08:05
dries towards the exterior.
Speaker:
00:08:07
But often what will
Speaker:
00:08:08
happen when the sun comes
Speaker:
00:08:09
out, it actually dries
Speaker:
00:08:10
towards the interior.
Speaker:
00:08:12
And so you've got this
Speaker:
00:08:13
high grit buffering
Speaker:
00:08:14
capacity, this ability for
Speaker:
00:08:16
this brick to absorb vast
Speaker:
00:08:18
quantities of water and
Speaker:
00:08:20
then you're not quite sure
Speaker:
00:08:21
where it's going to go.
Speaker:
00:08:22
Depending on the
Speaker:
00:08:23
atmospheric conditions and
Speaker:
00:08:24
the conditions within the
Speaker:
00:08:25
house, it could go towards
Speaker:
00:08:27
the exterior or interior
Speaker:
00:08:29
or a combination of both.
Speaker:
00:08:30
And so you just need
Speaker:
00:08:31
to provide that cavity
Speaker:
00:08:33
to allow a bit of
Speaker:
00:08:35
weak ventilation.
Speaker:
00:08:36
But bear in mind that
Speaker:
00:08:38
in that, our traditional
Speaker:
00:08:39
brick veneer, you've got
Speaker:
00:08:40
very weak ventilation
Speaker:
00:08:42
within that cavity.
Speaker:
00:08:43
You've got 40 or 50 ml
Speaker:
00:08:44
of, of space, so any
Speaker:
00:08:47
liquid water that should
Speaker:
00:08:48
happen to get in there,
Speaker:
00:08:49
say through the mortar
Speaker:
00:08:51
joint somewhere or at a
Speaker:
00:08:52
window sill, can drain down
Speaker:
00:08:54
and out the weep holes.
Speaker:
00:08:56
That's fine, but you've
Speaker:
00:08:58
only got comparatively
Speaker:
00:08:59
weak ventilation because
Speaker:
00:09:01
you've only got those
Speaker:
00:09:01
weeps at the bottom to
Speaker:
00:09:03
allow air movement through.
Speaker:
00:09:05
Didn't you prove on
Speaker:
00:09:06
our passive house in
Speaker:
00:09:07
Williamstown though that
Speaker:
00:09:07
there's a high amount of
Speaker:
00:09:08
air exchange through there?
Speaker:
00:09:10
Because weren't they
Speaker:
00:09:11
arguing there was only
Speaker:
00:09:12
about eight, eight air
Speaker:
00:09:13
exchanges through those
Speaker:
00:09:14
weep holes but you
Speaker:
00:09:15
were able to prove that
Speaker:
00:09:15
was maybe around 40?
Speaker:
00:09:16
It
Speaker:
00:09:18
anything, Matt.
Speaker:
00:09:19
was enough to potentially
Speaker:
00:09:21
get certified.
Speaker:
00:09:22
let's just jump for a
Speaker:
00:09:23
second to talk about the
Speaker:
00:09:24
depths of the cavity.
Speaker:
00:09:26
You know, how deep
Speaker:
00:09:26
should that cavity be?
Speaker:
00:09:28
And let's differentiate
Speaker:
00:09:29
here between the two
Speaker:
00:09:30
functions, drainage
Speaker:
00:09:31
and ventilation.
Speaker:
00:09:32
Let's deal with the
Speaker:
00:09:33
drainage one first.
Speaker:
00:09:34
So this is about
Speaker:
00:09:35
liquid water, yeah?
Speaker:
00:09:36
So the liquid water that
Speaker:
00:09:38
whacks into our cladding
Speaker:
00:09:39
when it rains gets
Speaker:
00:09:40
beyond that cladding.
Speaker:
00:09:42
We need that to
Speaker:
00:09:42
drip down and away.
Speaker:
00:09:44
And all you really need
Speaker:
00:09:46
is in the order of two
Speaker:
00:09:47
to five millimetres for
Speaker:
00:09:49
that drainage occur.
Speaker:
00:09:51
If you've got one
Speaker:
00:09:52
millimetre, then you
Speaker:
00:09:53
imagine a drop of water.
Speaker:
00:09:56
and you put like a sheet
Speaker:
00:09:57
of glass, like maybe
Speaker:
00:09:58
put a drop of water on
Speaker:
00:09:59
your kitchen aisle and
Speaker:
00:10:00
benchtop or something like
Speaker:
00:10:01
that, and then put a bit
Speaker:
00:10:03
of glass on top of that
Speaker:
00:10:04
and just hold it
like a
Speaker:
00:10:05
millimeter above, there's
Speaker:
00:10:06
this, tension within that
Speaker:
00:10:08
water droplet that can
Speaker:
00:10:10
allow it to pull itself
Speaker:
00:10:11
up and can move vertically
Speaker:
00:10:13
within that, cavity.
Speaker:
00:10:14
And that's how you can
Speaker:
00:10:15
get things like rising
Speaker:
00:10:16
damp, because the water,
Speaker:
00:10:18
droplets within that.
Speaker:
00:10:19
, masonry or brick or
Speaker:
00:10:21
whatever it is can
Speaker:
00:10:22
move against gravity,
Speaker:
00:10:23
it can move up.
Speaker:
00:10:25
And so we need to break
Speaker:
00:10:26
the ability for that
Speaker:
00:10:27
capillary tension , to
Speaker:
00:10:29
move that water up.
Speaker:
00:10:30
And all you really need
Speaker:
00:10:31
is a couple of mil.
Speaker:
00:10:33
in order to do that.
Speaker:
00:10:34
And so if you look at many
Speaker:
00:10:36
of the external cladding
Speaker:
00:10:38
systems, like some of the
Speaker:
00:10:39
foam based cladding boards
Speaker:
00:10:41
or something like rock
Speaker:
00:10:42
wool or mineral wool type
Speaker:
00:10:43
product, they've often
Speaker:
00:10:44
got these grooves in the
Speaker:
00:10:46
back face of those boards.
Speaker:
00:10:48
And when you put those
Speaker:
00:10:49
onto your wall, those
Speaker:
00:10:51
grooves, you hopefully you
Speaker:
00:10:52
put the right orientation.
Speaker:
00:10:54
So the grooves are
Speaker:
00:10:54
running up and down.
Speaker:
00:10:56
So any water that gets into
Speaker:
00:10:58
that space, can then drain
Speaker:
00:11:00
through those very minimal
Speaker:
00:11:02
grooves, you know, they're
Speaker:
00:11:03
only two or three mil deep.
Speaker:
00:11:05
, so if the drainage is
Speaker:
00:11:07
relatively easily solved,
Speaker:
00:11:09
provide two or three
Speaker:
00:11:10
mil of cavity, and sure
Speaker:
00:11:12
obviously you've got a
Speaker:
00:11:12
drainage at the bottom
Speaker:
00:11:13
for that water to get
Speaker:
00:11:14
away, problem solved.
Speaker:
00:11:16
The trickier bit is
Speaker:
00:11:17
ventilation, and for
Speaker:
00:11:19
ventilation you tend to
Speaker:
00:11:20
need a lot more than two
Speaker:
00:11:22
or three mil, but how
Speaker:
00:11:24
much do you really need?
Speaker:
00:11:25
And much will depend
Speaker:
00:11:27
obviously firstly how much
Speaker:
00:11:28
water vapour is driving
Speaker:
00:11:30
through your assembly.
Speaker:
00:11:31
So if you've got a
Speaker:
00:11:31
conventional building and
Speaker:
00:11:33
you don't have an internal
Speaker:
00:11:34
air and vapour control
Speaker:
00:11:36
membrane and you don't have
Speaker:
00:11:37
HRV then potentially you've
Speaker:
00:11:39
got quite a large moisture
Speaker:
00:11:41
load building
up in the
Speaker:
00:11:42
interior of that building.
Speaker:
00:11:44
And if you live in a very
Speaker:
00:11:45
cold climate, say in Falls
Speaker:
00:11:47
Creek or Mount Buller or
Speaker:
00:11:49
Mansfield or somewhere
Speaker:
00:11:50
like that, as opposed to
Speaker:
00:11:52
a more benign climate, You
Speaker:
00:11:54
know, , New South Wales
Speaker:
00:11:55
coast or even the Victorian
Speaker:
00:11:57
coast, then the vapour
Speaker:
00:11:59
drive is much larger in
Speaker:
00:12:00
those very cold climates.
Speaker:
00:12:02
And so all else being
Speaker:
00:12:03
equal, you're going to
Speaker:
00:12:04
need a bigger cavity
Speaker:
00:12:05
to allow sufficient air
Speaker:
00:12:07
movement through to carry
Speaker:
00:12:08
away that water vapour.
Speaker:
00:12:10
What we're trying to ensure
Speaker:
00:12:11
here is that we carry
Speaker:
00:12:12
a lot more vapour away
Speaker:
00:12:14
than we can accumulate.
Speaker:
00:12:15
It's always about rates.
Speaker:
00:12:17
And so the rate at which
Speaker:
00:12:19
air moves through that
Speaker:
00:12:20
cavity is a function of
Speaker:
00:12:22
a whole heap of things.
Speaker:
00:12:23
The climate, the
Speaker:
00:12:24
exposed wind, , the
Speaker:
00:12:25
color of the cladding.
Speaker:
00:12:27
So darker color claddings
Speaker:
00:12:29
will get warmer and
Speaker:
00:12:30
therefore drive more
Speaker:
00:12:31
stack effect, more
Speaker:
00:12:32
buoyancy through that
Speaker:
00:12:33
cavity and move more air.
Speaker:
00:12:35
The orientation
Speaker:
00:12:37
of the wall.
Speaker:
00:12:37
If it's south facing,
Speaker:
00:12:38
it gets less sun and
Speaker:
00:12:40
therefore is cooler and
Speaker:
00:12:41
drives less air movement
Speaker:
00:12:42
than a north facing wall.
Speaker:
00:12:44
And of course then
Speaker:
00:12:45
things like, have you got
Speaker:
00:12:47
shadowing on that wall?
Speaker:
00:12:48
You know, if you've got
Speaker:
00:12:49
big trees and vegetation
Speaker:
00:12:51
and a garden right next
Speaker:
00:12:52
to the north facing wall,
Speaker:
00:12:54
then the effect of the
Speaker:
00:12:55
sun on heating that space
Speaker:
00:12:57
and driving that chimney
Speaker:
00:12:58
effectively reduces.
Speaker:
00:13:01
And then the other
Speaker:
00:13:02
part to this is what
Speaker:
00:13:03
are you doing at the
Speaker:
00:13:04
bottom and at the top?
Speaker:
00:13:06
Because even if you say,
Speaker:
00:13:08
for argument's sake, look
Speaker:
00:13:09
I've got a house where
Speaker:
00:13:10
I can put a 45mm batten
Speaker:
00:13:12
or even maybe put like a
Speaker:
00:13:13
70mm batten on edge and
Speaker:
00:13:15
create a very, very deep
Speaker:
00:13:16
cavity, if you then go
Speaker:
00:13:18
and constrain air movement
Speaker:
00:13:20
getting in and out of that
Speaker:
00:13:22
cavity with a bug screen
Speaker:
00:13:24
at bottom and top, then it
Speaker:
00:13:26
probably doesn't matter.
Speaker:
00:13:27
that you've gone through
Speaker:
00:13:28
a very deep cavity.
Speaker:
00:13:29
You might have be able
Speaker:
00:13:30
to get away with a 35 or
Speaker:
00:13:32
45 given how throttle,
Speaker:
00:13:34
your constraint is at
Speaker:
00:13:35
the inlet and outlet.
Speaker:
00:13:36
Three questions.
Speaker:
00:13:37
First question.
Speaker:
00:13:38
And it's going back
Speaker:
00:13:39
to something you said
Speaker:
00:13:40
before and may or may
Speaker:
00:13:41
not be quite relevant.
Speaker:
00:13:43
But I'm interested
Speaker:
00:13:44
to know the answer.
Speaker:
00:13:45
You said on a brick wall
Speaker:
00:13:47
when it's absorbing that
Speaker:
00:13:48
water or that rain, how
Speaker:
00:13:50
and why does the sun drive
Speaker:
00:13:52
it into the building?
Speaker:
00:13:53
What's happening there?
Speaker:
00:13:54
Yeah, so it's about the
Speaker:
00:13:56
vapor pressure and the
Speaker:
00:13:57
radiation from the sun.
Speaker:
00:13:59
you're heating outside
Speaker:
00:14:00
surface, So it's, taking
Speaker:
00:14:02
it to the least vapor
Speaker:
00:14:03
pressure, which in
Speaker:
00:14:04
that situation will be
Speaker:
00:14:06
towards the interior.
Speaker:
00:14:08
And it might only happen
Speaker:
00:14:09
for a short period of
Speaker:
00:14:09
time, but often we'll be
Speaker:
00:14:11
confronted with situations
Speaker:
00:14:12
where we get that storm
Speaker:
00:14:13
comes through, the wall
Speaker:
00:14:15
gets whacked, and then the
Speaker:
00:14:17
storm clears and the sun
Speaker:
00:14:18
comes out, particularly
Speaker:
00:14:19
this time of year around
Speaker:
00:14:20
December, and the sun is
Speaker:
00:14:22
very strong, you know,
Speaker:
00:14:24
it's coming into summer
Speaker:
00:14:25
and so you can potentially
Speaker:
00:14:27
get quite a lot of, that
Speaker:
00:14:28
vapour driving into the
Speaker:
00:14:30
cavity behind the cladding.
Speaker:
00:14:32
That was a big conversation
Speaker:
00:14:34
in our Williamstown
Speaker:
00:14:34
project, Cameron.
Speaker:
00:14:36
That exact issue.
Speaker:
00:14:37
a really difficult problem.
Speaker:
00:14:39
It's like a lot of
Speaker:
00:14:40
these things, you've
Speaker:
00:14:40
always got multiple
Speaker:
00:14:42
factors at play and
Speaker:
00:14:44
you're never quite sure.
Speaker:
00:14:46
On balance, which of these
Speaker:
00:14:47
is going to dominate, or
Speaker:
00:14:49
where things are going
Speaker:
00:14:50
to land, and this is
Speaker:
00:14:51
why we sort of need to
Speaker:
00:14:52
be conservative in our
Speaker:
00:14:53
thinking, I
think, about
Speaker:
00:14:54
a lot of this, and say,
Speaker:
00:14:55
well, let's assume all
Speaker:
00:14:57
else being equal, the
Speaker:
00:14:58
worst case, to give us
Speaker:
00:15:00
best chance of, not having
Speaker:
00:15:01
issues down the track.
Speaker:
00:15:03
I've got another question
Speaker:
00:15:04
and it's relevant for a
Speaker:
00:15:06
project where I've got
Speaker:
00:15:07
coming up where we've
Speaker:
00:15:08
got rockwall externally
Speaker:
00:15:11
and then we have,
Speaker:
00:15:12
cladding battens over
Speaker:
00:15:13
the top of that rockwall.
Speaker:
00:15:15
Now, immediately my mind
Speaker:
00:15:17
goes to wind washing.
Speaker:
00:15:19
Is there something in the
Speaker:
00:15:20
makeup of that rockwall,
Speaker:
00:15:22
mineral wall, whatever,
Speaker:
00:15:23
that is not as impacted
Speaker:
00:15:25
as much by wind washing?
Speaker:
00:15:27
Wind washing may or
Speaker:
00:15:28
may not be the right
Speaker:
00:15:29
term, but obviously you
Speaker:
00:15:29
want to encourage, air
Speaker:
00:15:31
movement in that cavity.
Speaker:
00:15:33
Is that, , detracting
Speaker:
00:15:35
from the insulation
Speaker:
00:15:36
value of that rockwool?
Speaker:
00:15:37
washing is about the
Speaker:
00:15:39
movement of air past our
Speaker:
00:15:40
insulation and essentially
Speaker:
00:15:41
scouring the insulation
Speaker:
00:15:43
and taking some of those
Speaker:
00:15:44
the air that's otherwise
Speaker:
00:15:46
caught in the cavities
Speaker:
00:15:47
of our insulation and
Speaker:
00:15:48
degrading the performance
Speaker:
00:15:49
of the insulation and the
Speaker:
00:15:51
analogy I use is Standing
Speaker:
00:15:53
on the top of a mountain,
Speaker:
00:15:54
got a woolen jumper on.
Speaker:
00:15:56
If it's a still day in the
Speaker:
00:15:57
middle of winter, you're
Speaker:
00:15:58
perfectly warm and fine.
Speaker:
00:16:00
But if the wind picks up,
Speaker:
00:16:02
then the air is penetrating
Speaker:
00:16:03
right through that woolen
Speaker:
00:16:04
jumper, scouring away
Speaker:
00:16:06
the thermal resistance
Speaker:
00:16:07
that's providing and
Speaker:
00:16:09
therefore you feel cold.
Speaker:
00:16:10
So how do you respond?
Speaker:
00:16:11
You put a Gore Tex jacket
Speaker:
00:16:13
on top, but the Gore Tex
Speaker:
00:16:14
jacket has no thermal
Speaker:
00:16:15
resistance whatsoever.
Speaker:
00:16:17
but it's preventing air
Speaker:
00:16:18
movement and it's helping
Speaker:
00:16:20
the insulation, the
Speaker:
00:16:21
woolen jumper work best.
Speaker:
00:16:23
Now if we take that analogy
Speaker:
00:16:25
a bit further, if I use
Speaker:
00:16:27
a very loosely knitted
Speaker:
00:16:29
woolen jumper, I'm going
Speaker:
00:16:30
to be more susceptible
Speaker:
00:16:32
than if I use a very
Speaker:
00:16:33
tightly knitted jumper
Speaker:
00:16:34
or one of these more sort
Speaker:
00:16:35
of synthetic fibers that
Speaker:
00:16:37
create a very dense weave
Speaker:
00:16:39
within that insulation.
Speaker:
00:16:40
and insulation in our
Speaker:
00:16:42
buildings is the same.
Speaker:
00:16:43
So your high density
Speaker:
00:16:45
wall, glass wall
Speaker:
00:16:46
insulation is maybe 20
Speaker:
00:16:48
to 30 kilogram per cubic
Speaker:
00:16:50
meter density and that
Speaker:
00:16:52
can be quite susceptible
Speaker:
00:16:53
to wind washing.
Speaker:
00:16:54
And which is why we
Speaker:
00:16:55
would have that external
Speaker:
00:16:57
membrane on that.
Speaker:
00:16:58
When you move to something
Speaker:
00:16:59
like a semi rigid or a
Speaker:
00:17:00
rigid type insulation,
Speaker:
00:17:02
like a rock wool, a mineral
Speaker:
00:17:03
wool, they're usually
Speaker:
00:17:04
north of 60 kilograms
Speaker:
00:17:06
per cubic meter density.
Speaker:
00:17:08
So two to three times the
Speaker:
00:17:10
density of your typical
Speaker:
00:17:11
wall, glass wool bat.
Speaker:
00:17:13
And when you get to that
Speaker:
00:17:14
level of density, you're
Speaker:
00:17:16
far less susceptible
Speaker:
00:17:17
to wind washing.
Speaker:
00:17:19
So there's some good,
Speaker:
00:17:20
, experimental studies that
Speaker:
00:17:21
were done, uh, in Canada
Speaker:
00:17:23
by a consulting company
Speaker:
00:17:24
called RDH, so people
Speaker:
00:17:26
can Google that if they
Speaker:
00:17:27
want, looking for that.
Speaker:
00:17:28
, looked at the wind washing
Speaker:
00:17:30
impact, in Canada they use
Speaker:
00:17:32
a lot of this mineral wall
Speaker:
00:17:33
insulation or exterior,
Speaker:
00:17:34
externally clad like
Speaker:
00:17:35
high rise buildings, like
Speaker:
00:17:37
commercial buildings,
Speaker:
00:17:38
which are obviously far
Speaker:
00:17:38
more exposed to wind, and
Speaker:
00:17:41
in a place like Vancouver,
Speaker:
00:17:42
they you know, it's going
Speaker:
00:17:43
to be pretty heavily
Speaker:
00:17:44
exposed to wind and rain.
Speaker:
00:17:47
And they found that when
Speaker:
00:17:48
you get to that sort of 60,
Speaker:
00:17:50
80 kilogram density, the
Speaker:
00:17:53
impact of wind washing is
Speaker:
00:17:54
very small to negligible.
Speaker:
00:17:57
And so you save yourself
Speaker:
00:17:59
having to go for that,
Speaker:
00:18:00
another membrane on
Speaker:
00:18:02
the top of that, on the
Speaker:
00:18:03
exterior face of that.
Speaker:
00:18:05
Awesome.
Speaker:
00:18:05
And one last question.
Speaker:
00:18:07
We were talking before
Speaker:
00:18:09
about the impacts of
Speaker:
00:18:10
different claddings on
Speaker:
00:18:12
walls and
then different
Speaker:
00:18:14
cladding types on different
Speaker:
00:18:14
elevations, you're
Speaker:
00:18:15
talking about some impact,
Speaker:
00:18:17
moisture movement or
Speaker:
00:18:18
air movement than others.
Speaker:
00:18:21
Should we have
Speaker:
00:18:22
different cavity batten
Speaker:
00:18:25
thicknesses or depths
Speaker:
00:18:27
on different elevations?
Speaker:
00:18:29
do you mean like the pitch
Speaker:
00:18:30
of the roof sort of thing?
Speaker:
00:18:31
Like it would a five degree
Speaker:
00:18:32
roof mean like
Speaker:
00:18:33
a bigger cavity?
Speaker:
00:18:35
yeah, or like you got
Speaker:
00:18:36
monument, tin cladding on
Speaker:
00:18:38
a Western elevation and you
Speaker:
00:18:39
got monuments in planning
Speaker:
00:18:40
on the Southern elevation.
Speaker:
00:18:42
Should that cavity
Speaker:
00:18:44
be different on the
Speaker:
00:18:45
West or the South?
Speaker:
00:18:46
Oh, I like this question.
Speaker:
00:18:48
I hope the answer is not
Speaker:
00:18:49
yes, we should, because
Speaker:
00:18:50
that's just a head's fuck
Speaker:
00:18:51
when we go to construction.
Speaker:
00:18:53
We want to standardize
Speaker:
00:18:54
to make it easier, but
Speaker:
00:18:55
I'm, curious to know the
Speaker:
00:18:56
reasons why it might make a
Speaker:
00:18:58
But you potentially might
Speaker:
00:18:59
be able to, you might be
Speaker:
00:19:00
able to just make it the
Speaker:
00:19:00
largest and then you're
Speaker:
00:19:02
safe in all situations.
Speaker:
00:19:03
And that's probably
Speaker:
00:19:04
where we get to in the
Speaker:
00:19:05
real world, isn't it?
Speaker:
00:19:06
Because in theory, if we
Speaker:
00:19:08
had perfect knowledge about
Speaker:
00:19:10
the boundary conditions
Speaker:
00:19:11
here, we knew everything
Speaker:
00:19:12
about the climate, we knew
Speaker:
00:19:13
everything about what the
Speaker:
00:19:14
occupants do, like how
Speaker:
00:19:16
long are their showers,
Speaker:
00:19:18
how much moisture is
Speaker:
00:19:19
being generated in that
Speaker:
00:19:20
building, exactly how
Speaker:
00:19:22
airtight it is, then you
Speaker:
00:19:23
could probably calculate
Speaker:
00:19:25
down to the millimetre
Speaker:
00:19:26
how thick that batten is.
Speaker:
00:19:28
In that, your ventilated
Speaker:
00:19:29
cavity needs to be on each
Speaker:
00:19:30
of those walls and roof.
Speaker:
00:19:33
In practice we don't,
Speaker:
00:19:34
and so we need a level of
Speaker:
00:19:36
conservative assumption,
Speaker:
00:19:37
and of course we can
Speaker:
00:19:38
only buy battens in given
Speaker:
00:19:40
increments of thickness.
Speaker:
00:19:42
so we probably come to
Speaker:
00:19:43
the question of, you know,
Speaker:
00:19:44
how deep a ventilation
Speaker:
00:19:45
batten do I need for
Speaker:
00:19:47
a particular scenario.
Speaker:
00:19:49
And as I alluded to before,
Speaker:
00:19:50
there's so many variables
Speaker:
00:19:52
at play here that there
Speaker:
00:19:53
is no generic answer.
Speaker:
00:19:55
And so I would say, as
Speaker:
00:19:57
a guide, I think we can
Speaker:
00:19:58
only work off general
Speaker:
00:19:59
first principles here.
Speaker:
00:20:00
If you're building a
Speaker:
00:20:01
building in Mildura, say,
Speaker:
00:20:03
which is a relatively
Speaker:
00:20:04
warm Victorian climate,
Speaker:
00:20:06
except in the winter it
Speaker:
00:20:07
can get quite cool there
Speaker:
00:20:08
too, and you're building
Speaker:
00:20:10
this building in Monument,
Speaker:
00:20:11
which is probably not
Speaker:
00:20:12
the best idea for a, you
Speaker:
00:20:14
know, otherwise mostly
Speaker:
00:20:15
hot climate like Mildura,
Speaker:
00:20:17
and you're building it in
Speaker:
00:20:18
a field where there's no
Speaker:
00:20:19
trees or shading around,
Speaker:
00:20:21
and you've got a HRV in
Speaker:
00:20:22
the building, and you've
Speaker:
00:20:23
got an internal air and
Speaker:
00:20:25
vapor control membrane.
Speaker:
00:20:27
Then, you know, 20
Speaker:
00:20:28
mil batten, you'd
Speaker:
00:20:29
probably go intuitively,
Speaker:
00:20:30
yeah, I feel pretty
Speaker:
00:20:31
comfortable with that.
Speaker:
00:20:32
And if you're building
Speaker:
00:20:33
in Melbourne, you'd say,
Speaker:
00:20:34
well, that's a bit cooler.
Speaker:
00:20:35
It's got a bit more rain.
Speaker:
00:20:37
Then maybe I'm looking
Speaker:
00:20:38
more like a 35 batten.
Speaker:
00:20:41
And now I'm building
Speaker:
00:20:42
on top of Melbourne.
Speaker:
00:20:43
a very cold climate or
Speaker:
00:20:45
maybe in Canberra, then
Speaker:
00:20:46
perhaps I'm pushing towards
Speaker:
00:20:48
a 45 batten, particularly
Speaker:
00:20:50
if the client also wants
Speaker:
00:20:51
his house to be surf mist
Speaker:
00:20:52
or some very light colour.
Speaker:
00:20:54
look, we can model this,
Speaker:
00:20:56
you can model this in
Speaker:
00:20:57
hygrothermal modelling,
Speaker:
00:20:59
it's something like ORPHE,
Speaker:
00:21:01
and I think that's often a
Speaker:
00:21:02
good idea if it's something
Speaker:
00:21:04
unusual or you're trying to
Speaker:
00:21:06
push a boundary somewhere.
Speaker:
00:21:08
But not as a means of
Speaker:
00:21:10
giving you an answer,
Speaker:
00:21:11
it's okay or it's not.
Speaker:
00:21:12
So coming back to
Speaker:
00:21:13
Matt's point before,
Speaker:
00:21:14
we proved in modelling
Speaker:
00:21:16
that this was okay.
Speaker:
00:21:18
We never prove
Speaker:
00:21:18
anything in modelling.
Speaker:
00:21:20
Ever.
Speaker:
00:21:21
Because we can't.
Speaker:
00:21:22
There's just too many
Speaker:
00:21:23
input assumptions to
Speaker:
00:21:25
allow us to have 100
Speaker:
00:21:26
percent confidence that
Speaker:
00:21:27
this is going to be okay.
Speaker:
00:21:30
All we can do is use the
Speaker:
00:21:31
modelling as a guide.
Speaker:
00:21:33
To say, well, with, these
Speaker:
00:21:34
good aspects of this build,
Speaker:
00:21:36
you know, it's being a
Speaker:
00:21:37
dark color and not ex
Speaker:
00:21:39
fully exposed in a mild
Speaker:
00:21:40
climate, as opposed to
Speaker:
00:21:42
these negative aspects.
Speaker:
00:21:43
There's no HRV or
Speaker:
00:21:45
air and vapor control
Speaker:
00:21:46
layer on balance.
Speaker:
00:21:47
The modeling would seem to
Speaker:
00:21:48
suggest it's more likely
Speaker:
00:21:51
to be okay than not.
Speaker:
00:21:53
We are playing a
Speaker:
00:21:54
probabilities game and
Speaker:
00:21:56
we're trying to minimize
Speaker:
00:21:57
the probability of failure.
Speaker:
00:21:59
Maximize the probability
Speaker:
00:22:00
of success, but We
Speaker:
00:22:02
never have a hundred
Speaker:
00:22:03
percent confidence this
Speaker:
00:22:04
is never going to fail,
Speaker:
00:22:05
and we never have zero
Speaker:
00:22:07
percent confidence that
Speaker:
00:22:08
this is going to fail.
Speaker:
00:22:09
What percentage
Speaker:
00:22:10
do we have though?
Speaker:
00:22:11
What would you roughly say?
Speaker:
00:22:13
impossible to say, right?
Speaker:
00:22:15
You know, you look at
Speaker:
00:22:16
any risk stuff like,
Speaker:
00:22:18
so back in my aerospace
Speaker:
00:22:19
days, you know, you're
Speaker:
00:22:20
looking at, it was
Speaker:
00:22:21
always ten to the nines,
Speaker:
00:22:22
Is this when you're at
Speaker:
00:22:23
NASA, building rockets?
Speaker:
00:22:25
I was not doing it.
Speaker:
00:22:26
Never.
Speaker:
00:22:27
But you know, you're
Speaker:
00:22:28
looking at a failure
Speaker:
00:22:29
rate of how many million
Speaker:
00:22:30
hours can this aircraft
Speaker:
00:22:32
fly before it hits a
Speaker:
00:22:34
level of turbulence
Speaker:
00:22:35
that is so great.
Speaker:
00:22:37
So beyond anything that
Speaker:
00:22:39
we've designed this
Speaker:
00:22:40
aircraft for that it's
Speaker:
00:22:41
going to structurally fail.
Speaker:
00:22:43
You know, you're looking
Speaker:
00:22:44
for the likelihood of
Speaker:
00:22:45
that happening being so
Speaker:
00:22:47
minusculely small because
Speaker:
00:22:49
of course, the consequences
Speaker:
00:22:50
of failure are Uh, in
Speaker:
00:22:53
building is not quite that
Speaker:
00:22:54
extreme, but it's still
Speaker:
00:22:56
fairly extreme because of
Speaker:
00:22:58
course the last thing we
Speaker:
00:22:58
want is to have demolish
a
Speaker:
00:23:00
building or, have mold and
Speaker:
00:23:02
rot forming in a building.
Speaker:
00:23:03
So we're trying to
Speaker:
00:23:04
minimize the risks, but
Speaker:
00:23:05
also minimize the cost.
Speaker:
00:23:07
So how do we get
Speaker:
00:23:08
that balance right?
Speaker:
00:23:09
And this is where I just
Speaker:
00:23:11
would bang on about saying
Speaker:
00:23:12
modeling is a tool to
Speaker:
00:23:13
help inform a decision.
Speaker:
00:23:16
But you can't just
Speaker:
00:23:17
blindly go into the
Speaker:
00:23:18
modeling and say, look,
Speaker:
00:23:20
give me an answer here.
Speaker:
00:23:21
I don't even want
Speaker:
00:23:21
to think about this.
Speaker:
00:23:22
Just tell me the answer.
Speaker:
00:23:23
Is it yes or no?
Speaker:
00:23:24
You know, that's
Speaker:
00:23:25
not how it works.
Speaker:
00:23:27
just coming back to that
Speaker:
00:23:28
sort of depth of the
Speaker:
00:23:29
cavity, this is so many
Speaker:
00:23:30
parameters at play here.
Speaker:
00:23:32
And this is where I
Speaker:
00:23:34
think testing it within
Speaker:
00:23:35
something like Wolfi and
Speaker:
00:23:37
saying, well, with this
Speaker:
00:23:38
combination of things,
Speaker:
00:23:39
Here's a hierarchy.
Speaker:
00:23:41
Here's the things
Speaker:
00:23:41
that are more likely
Speaker:
00:23:42
to be problematic.
Speaker:
00:23:44
And so we can talk with
Speaker:
00:23:46
the builder, with the
Speaker:
00:23:47
architect, with the
Speaker:
00:23:48
client and say, well, we
Speaker:
00:23:50
realize there's a client,
Speaker:
00:23:51
you're cost constrained
Speaker:
00:23:53
and you're trying to do
Speaker:
00:23:54
the minimum required.
Speaker:
00:23:56
We think you should
Speaker:
00:23:57
spend your money doing
Speaker:
00:23:58
X, Y and Z over these
Speaker:
00:24:00
other, other things
Speaker:
00:24:01
to minimize the risks.
Speaker:
00:24:02
we're trying to identify
Speaker:
00:24:03
the main levers that are
Speaker:
00:24:05
going to reduce our risk.
Speaker:
00:24:07
So, I think one thing
Speaker:
00:24:08
that we need to get in
Speaker:
00:24:09
our heads a lot of the
Speaker:
00:24:10
time, and most people are
Speaker:
00:24:11
starting to do a really
Speaker:
00:24:11
good job of wrapping the
Speaker:
00:24:13
external wall of a house.
Speaker:
00:24:15
And then putting in some
Speaker:
00:24:16
form of a baton on whether
Speaker:
00:24:17
they're doing it right or
Speaker:
00:24:18
not and restricting that
Speaker:
00:24:20
access of air to flow
Speaker:
00:24:22
through from the bottom
Speaker:
00:24:22
is a whole and maybe
Speaker:
00:24:23
different conversation.
Speaker:
00:24:25
But a wall is also
Speaker:
00:24:26
a roof just tilted.
Speaker:
00:24:28
what I see a lot of the
Speaker:
00:24:29
time
is people go spend all
Speaker:
00:24:30
this money on all these.
Speaker:
00:24:31
Awesome Rats is what,
Speaker:
00:24:32
which is where we need
Speaker:
00:24:33
to spend our money on a
Speaker:
00:24:34
build, but then they go
Speaker:
00:24:35
whack Anticon on the roof.
Speaker:
00:24:36
And I feel like it's
Speaker:
00:24:37
kind of defeating the
Speaker:
00:24:38
purpose because all
Speaker:
00:24:40
that a roof should be
Speaker:
00:24:41
is that wall tilted on
Speaker:
00:24:42
whatever angle you want.
Speaker:
00:24:44
Now, it does change once
Speaker:
00:24:45
you get under 10 degrees
Speaker:
00:24:46
quite significantly
Speaker:
00:24:47
and definitely when
Speaker:
00:24:48
you get under 5.
Speaker:
00:24:49
you maybe explain why
Speaker:
00:24:50
that is the case that
Speaker:
00:24:51
a wall is a roof?
Speaker:
00:24:54
Yeah, so the vapor drive
Speaker:
00:24:56
in a heating dominated
Speaker:
00:24:57
client from in to out
Speaker:
00:24:58
obviously applies both
Speaker:
00:24:59
on a wall and on a roof.
Speaker:
00:25:01
It's more problematic on
Speaker:
00:25:03
a roof because in a house
Speaker:
00:25:04
you've got stack effect,
Speaker:
00:25:05
the hot air rises, heat
Speaker:
00:25:07
doesn't rise but hot air
Speaker:
00:25:09
rises and as that hot air
Speaker:
00:25:10
rises there's a pressure,
Speaker:
00:25:12
an air pressure that's
Speaker:
00:25:13
trying to drive that air
Speaker:
00:25:15
carrying moisture into
Speaker:
00:25:16
your roof and if you've
Speaker:
00:25:17
got 50 down lights in
Speaker:
00:25:18
that ceiling and the
Speaker:
00:25:19
plasterboard is acting
Speaker:
00:25:20
as your air tightness
Speaker:
00:25:22
then you've got all this
Speaker:
00:25:23
moisture laden air moving
Speaker:
00:25:24
into that roof cavity.
Speaker:
00:25:26
So you've got the
Speaker:
00:25:26
potential, you've got
Speaker:
00:25:27
all this moisture there
Speaker:
00:25:29
plus in the middle of
Speaker:
00:25:31
winter, that roof sheet is
Speaker:
00:25:33
exposed to the night sky.
Speaker:
00:25:35
So when it's a clear,
Speaker:
00:25:37
still overnight in the
Speaker:
00:25:39
middle of June or July
Speaker:
00:25:40
in Canberra, Melbourne,
Speaker:
00:25:41
Hobart, wherever, then
Speaker:
00:25:43
that roof sheet will get
Speaker:
00:25:45
very much colder than the
Speaker:
00:25:46
ambient air temperature.
Speaker:
00:25:48
So even if the ambient
Speaker:
00:25:49
air temperature only
Speaker:
00:25:50
gets down to one, five
Speaker:
00:25:52
degrees, something like
Speaker:
00:25:53
that, the roof sheet
Speaker:
00:25:54
can be minus five.
Speaker:
00:25:55
It can be below freezing,
Speaker:
00:25:57
which is why you'll get
Speaker:
00:25:57
frost on that roof sheet.
Speaker:
00:26:00
Or you get
Speaker:
00:26:00
condensation on it.
Speaker:
00:26:01
And so you've got a
Speaker:
00:26:02
combination of moisture
Speaker:
00:26:04
from inside the building
Speaker:
00:26:05
getting into the
Speaker:
00:26:06
roof, plus you've got
Speaker:
00:26:07
a much colder roof.
Speaker:
00:26:09
And it's that combination
Speaker:
00:26:10
of moisture and cold that
Speaker:
00:26:12
creates the problems.
Speaker:
00:26:13
So roofs are even
Speaker:
00:26:14
more problematic.
Speaker:
00:26:15
Plus we're not getting
Speaker:
00:26:16
the stack effects to the
Speaker:
00:26:18
same level on a roof as
Speaker:
00:26:20
we do on the walls simply
Speaker:
00:26:21
because of orientation,
Speaker:
00:26:23
the wall being vertical,
Speaker:
00:26:24
the roof being pitched.
Speaker:
00:26:25
So then, we have
Speaker:
00:26:27
our counter battens
Speaker:
00:26:27
on our roof.
Speaker:
00:26:28
And then we've got
Speaker:
00:26:29
the same system.
Speaker:
00:26:30
So typically you're 19
Speaker:
00:26:32
and you're 35 Hamish was
Speaker:
00:26:34
talking about before.
Speaker:
00:26:35
And we usually have
Speaker:
00:26:35
our membrane on the
Speaker:
00:26:36
underside of that.
Speaker:
00:26:37
So any condensation can
Speaker:
00:26:38
hit it, drain down and
Speaker:
00:26:39
away from the building.
Speaker:
00:26:41
On top of that crock
Speaker:
00:26:43
counter batten, if
Speaker:
00:26:44
condensation is such an
Speaker:
00:26:45
issue on that roof sheet
Speaker:
00:26:46
in those colder months,
Speaker:
00:26:48
why then don't we put
Speaker:
00:26:49
Anticon on top of that
Speaker:
00:26:50
roof batten as well to
Speaker:
00:26:52
mean that the condensation
Speaker:
00:26:53
is happening on the other
Speaker:
00:26:54
side and we're keeping that
Speaker:
00:26:55
section of the roof warm?
Speaker:
00:26:57
And that's what, how we've
Speaker:
00:26:58
traditionally dealt with is
Speaker:
00:26:59
something like a foil face
Speaker:
00:27:01
blanket, like an anticon.
Speaker:
00:27:03
And it sort of works
Speaker:
00:27:04
like it, it captures
Speaker:
00:27:06
any moisture that
Speaker:
00:27:07
forms immediately
Speaker:
00:27:08
under the roof sheet.
Speaker:
00:27:09
It prevents air moving
Speaker:
00:27:11
on the underside of
Speaker:
00:27:12
that roof sheet, which
Speaker:
00:27:13
allows condensation.
Speaker:
00:27:14
And so in a lot of
Speaker:
00:27:15
sort of our high
Speaker:
00:27:16
performance passive house
Speaker:
00:27:18
buildups, we're getting
Speaker:
00:27:19
rid of the anticon.
Speaker:
00:27:21
And we're just having a
Speaker:
00:27:22
free, freely ventilated
Speaker:
00:27:25
cavity, counter batten,
Speaker:
00:27:26
batten, roof sheet.
Speaker:
00:27:27
And we've got air coming
Speaker:
00:27:28
in from underneath.
Speaker:
00:27:29
So we've
got a much
Speaker:
00:27:30
higher volume of air
Speaker:
00:27:32
that is passing by that
Speaker:
00:27:34
cold roof sheet and
Speaker:
00:27:35
therefore a higher level
Speaker:
00:27:37
of condensation risk.
Speaker:
00:27:39
And so intuitively we
Speaker:
00:27:40
go, well that's actually
Speaker:
00:27:41
counterproductive,
Speaker:
00:27:42
isn't it?
Speaker:
00:27:43
Well, not necessarily,
Speaker:
00:27:45
because one of the concerns
Speaker:
00:27:47
we have with some of
Speaker:
00:27:48
these fall face blankets
Speaker:
00:27:49
is their durability.
Speaker:
00:27:50
what happens over, six
Speaker:
00:27:52
years, ten years, twenty
Speaker:
00:27:53
or thirty years plus.
Speaker:
00:27:55
A lot of us have probably
Speaker:
00:27:56
pulled off roof sheets
Speaker:
00:27:57
and seen that anticon, or
Speaker:
00:27:59
that foil faced blanket,
Speaker:
00:28:01
essentially, fall into bits
Speaker:
00:28:03
because roofs are insanely
Speaker:
00:28:05
difficult environments.
Speaker:
00:28:07
they're like the
Speaker:
00:28:07
climate multiplied
Speaker:
00:28:09
by a factor of 10.
Speaker:
00:28:10
They get much colder
Speaker:
00:28:11
overnight in winter and
Speaker:
00:28:13
they get much, much hotter.
Speaker:
00:28:14
So it's, you know, even on
Speaker:
00:28:16
a spring day in Melbourne,
Speaker:
00:28:18
a light colored roof,
Speaker:
00:28:20
like a surf mist type
Speaker:
00:28:21
roof will get well above
Speaker:
00:28:23
60 degrees immediately
Speaker:
00:28:24
under the roof sheet.
Speaker:
00:28:25
I think they've got
Speaker:
00:28:26
recordings of 90 to
Speaker:
00:28:27
100 degrees between
Speaker:
00:28:28
that cavity, like
Speaker:
00:28:29
it's quite high.
Speaker:
00:28:30
And it will depend again
Speaker:
00:28:32
on what the color of the
Speaker:
00:28:33
roof sheet is and what the
Speaker:
00:28:34
climate is and how well
Speaker:
00:28:36
ventilated that space is.
Speaker:
00:28:38
you know, a material,
Speaker:
00:28:39
materials don't like going
Speaker:
00:28:40
through hot, cold cycles.
Speaker:
00:28:42
You take any material,
Speaker:
00:28:43
particularly a metallic
Speaker:
00:28:44
material like aluminium,
Speaker:
00:28:46
which expands and
Speaker:
00:28:47
contracts and you make it
Speaker:
00:28:48
hot, make it cold, make
Speaker:
00:28:49
it hot, make it cold.
Speaker:
00:28:50
Eventually it
Speaker:
00:28:51
starts to fail.
Speaker:
00:28:53
so,
Speaker:
00:28:53
so, key taking out of
Speaker:
00:28:54
that though is Anticon
Speaker:
00:28:55
should not be on a roof.
Speaker:
00:28:56
Yeah.
Speaker:
00:28:57
If you wrap consistently
Speaker:
00:28:58
externally with a
Speaker:
00:28:59
ventilated cavity on your
Speaker:
00:29:00
roof system, is there any
Speaker:
00:29:02
situation where you might
Speaker:
00:29:03
still run the anticon
Speaker:
00:29:05
or an air cell product?
Speaker:
00:29:07
Or are we just best
Speaker:
00:29:08
allowing it to dry out and
Speaker:
00:29:09
creating a thicker cavity?
Speaker:
00:29:11
Or potentially looking at
Speaker:
00:29:12
an adhered product on our
Speaker:
00:29:14
roof, so it's a peel and
Speaker:
00:29:15
stick membrane instead.
Speaker:
00:29:16
Yeah, so there's a
Speaker:
00:29:17
lot of things in that.
Speaker:
00:29:18
So my primary concern
Speaker:
00:29:20
with any of these
Speaker:
00:29:21
foil faced products is
Speaker:
00:29:23
about that durability.
Speaker:
00:29:25
And so, once that starts
Speaker:
00:29:27
to fail, if my, you expect,
Speaker:
00:29:30
accept my hypothesis
Speaker:
00:29:31
that it'll fail, then
Speaker:
00:29:33
it's bits of it start
Speaker:
00:29:34
dropping down into the
Speaker:
00:29:36
ventilated cavity below.
Speaker:
00:29:37
So I'm starting to impede
Speaker:
00:29:39
the ability air to move
Speaker:
00:29:41
through that cavity and
Speaker:
00:29:42
therefore allow drying.
Speaker:
00:29:44
And if I'm impeding
Speaker:
00:29:45
drying, then I risk
Speaker:
00:29:46
getting an accumulation
Speaker:
00:29:47
of moisture in my roof
Speaker:
00:29:48
and building failure.
Speaker:
00:29:50
And so I want, because I'm
Speaker:
00:29:51
not expecting the occupant
Speaker:
00:29:53
to lift the roof sheet
Speaker:
00:29:54
every five years and check
Speaker:
00:29:55
their Anticon or their
Speaker:
00:29:57
foil based membranes we
Speaker:
00:29:58
need something that's gonna
Speaker:
00:29:59
last for a very long time
Speaker:
00:30:01
, and we want to keep that
Speaker:
00:30:02
ventilator cavity clear.
Speaker:
00:30:04
But they've got insulation
Speaker:
00:30:05
values too, so how
Speaker:
00:30:06
do we now compensate?
Speaker:
00:30:07
Because I think there's
Speaker:
00:30:08
also a misconception
Speaker:
00:30:09
that these wraps
Speaker:
00:30:10
also hold an R value.
Speaker:
00:30:11
and then I've also seen
Speaker:
00:30:12
a lot of people talk
Speaker:
00:30:13
about saying,
Speaker:
00:30:14
Hey, well, now,
Speaker:
00:30:15
the wraps or the
Speaker:
00:30:16
antique on that.
Speaker:
00:30:17
well, no, well, I know
Speaker:
00:30:18
you don't like NatHerzCam,
Speaker:
00:30:19
they'll put in the anti con
Speaker:
00:30:20
as, oh, we need the extra
Speaker:
00:30:21
R value in the ceiling
Speaker:
00:30:23
through the anti con.
Speaker:
00:30:24
So there's, that's
Speaker:
00:30:24
probably part one.
Speaker:
00:30:26
Part two is people still
Speaker:
00:30:27
have a misconception
Speaker:
00:30:28
that these membranes
Speaker:
00:30:29
is weather resistant
Speaker:
00:30:29
membranes have an R value.
Speaker:
00:30:31
It's nothing meaningful.
Speaker:
00:30:33
And then two, I think
Speaker:
00:30:34
there's also this
Speaker:
00:30:35
misconception is now that
Speaker:
00:30:36
we've got this huge cavity,
Speaker:
00:30:37
we've got say in Hamish's
Speaker:
00:30:39
case is 70, 35 and 35.
Speaker:
00:30:41
We've now got a 75
Speaker:
00:30:42
mil cavity in there.
Speaker:
00:30:43
Well, isn't air an
Speaker:
00:30:44
insulation value?
Speaker:
00:30:45
So we're getting,
Speaker:
00:30:46
we're getting
Speaker:
00:30:47
insulation to that too.
Speaker:
00:30:49
I think there's a few
Speaker:
00:30:49
misconceptions that occur
Speaker:
00:30:50
in our industry around
Speaker:
00:30:52
that, breakdown and that
Speaker:
00:30:53
buildup of that, that
Speaker:
00:30:54
roof or wall section.
Speaker:
00:30:55
so a foil phased bat.
Speaker:
00:30:58
has an R value, it has a
Speaker:
00:30:59
thermal resistance, because
Speaker:
00:31:00
it has a bulk insulation
Speaker:
00:31:02
there, there is glass
Speaker:
00:31:03
wool, you know, 50 mil
Speaker:
00:31:04
potentially of glass wool.
Speaker:
00:31:05
Now if you go and highly
Speaker:
00:31:06
compress it under your
Speaker:
00:31:07
purlins, then that's
Speaker:
00:31:08
reduced, but let's just
Speaker:
00:31:09
accept for a moment
Speaker:
00:31:10
that it's at full
Speaker:
00:31:11
loft, then there's no
Speaker:
00:31:12
question that there
Speaker:
00:31:13
is a material R value,
Speaker:
00:31:16
but does it contribute
Speaker:
00:31:17
at the assembly level?
Speaker:
00:31:19
Now if you put your
Speaker:
00:31:20
Anticon underneath the
Speaker:
00:31:22
roof sheet and you don't
Speaker:
00:31:23
have a ventilated cavity,
Speaker:
00:31:26
So your traditional system
Speaker:
00:31:27
may be with a warm roof
Speaker:
00:31:28
where you've got insulation
Speaker:
00:31:29
batts and essentially hard
Speaker:
00:31:30
up against the anticon.
Speaker:
00:31:32
Then yes, the anticon
Speaker:
00:31:34
or the foil faced
Speaker:
00:31:35
bat will contribute
Speaker:
00:31:36
thermal resistance.
Speaker:
00:31:38
Absolutely.
Speaker:
00:31:38
No question about it.
Speaker:
00:31:40
Now, I have concerns about
Speaker:
00:31:41
that assembly because it's
Speaker:
00:31:42
not allowing outward drive.
Speaker:
00:31:44
You know, we're trapping
Speaker:
00:31:45
the, vapour that's
Speaker:
00:31:45
diffusing towards the
Speaker:
00:31:47
exterior or the air
Speaker:
00:31:48
that's moving through
Speaker:
00:31:49
that assembly will touch
Speaker:
00:31:51
the interior face of
Speaker:
00:31:52
our foil faced bat and
Speaker:
00:31:53
it can't get through.
Speaker:
00:31:55
And then we risk getting
Speaker:
00:31:56
condensation on that
Speaker:
00:31:57
when it gets very, very
Speaker:
00:31:58
But it's got
Speaker:
00:31:59
holes poked in it
Speaker:
00:32:00
The holes are something
Speaker:
00:32:01
of a misnomer, I think.
Speaker:
00:32:03
You know, I keep trying
Speaker:
00:32:04
to bang on about this.
Speaker:
00:32:05
If you want to avoid
Speaker:
00:32:06
condensation, you've
Speaker:
00:32:07
got to stop water vapor
Speaker:
00:32:09
touching cold surfaces.
Speaker:
00:32:12
And something like
Speaker:
00:32:13
your foil faced bat is
Speaker:
00:32:14
presenting a cold surface
Speaker:
00:32:16
to just on the resistance
Speaker:
00:32:19
of air cavities, a still
Speaker:
00:32:20
air cavity does indeed
Speaker:
00:32:22
have thermal resistance.
Speaker:
00:32:24
But the creed bit here
Speaker:
00:32:25
is still, so you've got
Speaker:
00:32:26
to trap an air void.
Speaker:
00:32:28
Now, insulation is
Speaker:
00:32:30
fundamentally about
Speaker:
00:32:31
still air gaps.
Speaker:
00:32:33
That's exactly what we're
Speaker:
00:32:34
trying to do with every
Speaker:
00:32:35
insulation product, be
Speaker:
00:32:36
it a foam, or being it
Speaker:
00:32:37
something like glass wool,
Speaker:
00:32:39
or rock wool, or whatever.
Speaker:
00:32:40
We're just trying to
Speaker:
00:32:41
create all of these,
Speaker:
00:32:42
still air gaps.
Speaker:
00:32:43
When you have a film,
Speaker:
00:32:45
like a 25, or a 35, or
Speaker:
00:32:48
whatever cavity, If you
Speaker:
00:32:50
trap the air within that
Speaker:
00:32:52
cavity, then yes, that
Speaker:
00:32:54
can contribute, although
Speaker:
00:32:55
as it gets thicker, you
Speaker:
00:32:57
get convection, you get
Speaker:
00:32:58
little eddy currents of
Speaker:
00:32:59
air moving within that
Speaker:
00:33:00
space, which reduces
Speaker:
00:33:02
its thermal resistance.
Speaker:
00:33:04
But when we're trying to
Speaker:
00:33:05
do ventilated and drained
Speaker:
00:33:06
cavities, of course,
Speaker:
00:33:08
fundamentally, we're trying
Speaker:
00:33:09
to actually encourage air
Speaker:
00:33:11
to move through that space.
Speaker:
00:33:14
And so, if we come back to
Speaker:
00:33:15
our roof build up, where
Speaker:
00:33:17
we've put our rafters or
Speaker:
00:33:18
our truss down, we've then
Speaker:
00:33:20
put a vapour permeable
Speaker:
00:33:21
membrane on top, and
Speaker:
00:33:23
then we've put a batten,
Speaker:
00:33:25
put our roof sheet on,
Speaker:
00:33:27
and maybe we put a foil
Speaker:
00:33:29
faced bat underneath
Speaker:
00:33:30
there, the foil faced
Speaker:
00:33:32
bat is not contributing
Speaker:
00:33:33
any material R value
Speaker:
00:33:35
to the total assembly,
Speaker:
00:33:37
because we've got this
Speaker:
00:33:38
ventilated space between,
Speaker:
00:33:40
which is exactly what
Speaker:
00:33:41
we've designed it to do.
Speaker:
00:33:42
But we can't then double
Speaker:
00:33:43
count and say that,
Speaker:
00:33:44
oh, hang on, I've got
Speaker:
00:33:45
a foil faced bat here
Speaker:
00:33:46
that's contributing R1.
Speaker:
00:33:48
3 or whatever.
Speaker:
00:33:49
this is the other thing
Speaker:
00:33:49
that we do is, we've got
Speaker:
00:33:51
this foil facing an air
Speaker:
00:33:53
gap and we say that has
Speaker:
00:33:55
thermal resistance because
Speaker:
00:33:56
of the radiation foil.
Speaker:
00:33:59
And again, that in
Speaker:
00:34:00
theory works if it's
Speaker:
00:34:01
a still air gap.
Speaker:
00:34:03
But if it's a highly
Speaker:
00:34:03
ventilated cavity, which
Speaker:
00:34:05
is what we're trying to do
Speaker:
00:34:06
for moisture management,
Speaker:
00:34:07
it's then you can't
Speaker:
00:34:08
make that claim anymore.
Speaker:
00:34:09
But that still air gap
Speaker:
00:34:10
can only be certain
Speaker:
00:34:11
thickness, can't it?
Speaker:
00:34:11
Is it over 20mm
Speaker:
00:34:12
that it starts to
Speaker:
00:34:13
become practically
Speaker:
00:34:16
It still has some
Speaker:
00:34:17
resistance, but it
Speaker:
00:34:18
diminishes because
Speaker:
00:34:19
of that convection,
Speaker:
00:34:20
that eddy current sort
Speaker:
00:34:21
of idea that forms.
Speaker:
00:34:22
It's the same with, you
Speaker:
00:34:23
know, a double glazed
Speaker:
00:34:24
unit depending on whether
Speaker:
00:34:25
it's air or argon or
Speaker:
00:34:27
whatever fill need sort of
Speaker:
00:34:29
a minimum level, sort of
Speaker:
00:34:30
say 10, 12 mil, but beyond
Speaker:
00:34:32
sort of 20 or so mil.
Speaker:
00:34:34
it diminishes because
Speaker:
00:34:36
of that, that impact
Speaker:
00:34:37
of convection and air
Speaker:
00:34:39
movement within the,
Speaker:
00:34:40
within the cavity.
Speaker:
00:34:41
So I guess in summary,
Speaker:
00:34:42
like 20 mil good.
Speaker:
00:34:44
Less than 20 mil bad in
Speaker:
00:34:46
terms of cavity batten.
Speaker:
00:34:47
70 mil okay, not too bad.
Speaker:
00:34:49
Bigger in some
Speaker:
00:34:50
cases are better.
Speaker:
00:34:51
I know I touched on this
Speaker:
00:34:53
before, but what we're
Speaker:
00:34:54
trying to do on our
Speaker:
00:34:55
sites is to standardize
Speaker:
00:34:56
and simplify things.
Speaker:
00:34:57
So 70 mil overall cavity
Speaker:
00:35:00
from the, face of our
Speaker:
00:35:01
WRB to the back of the
Speaker:
00:35:02
cladding is something that
Speaker:
00:35:04
we're working towards.
Speaker:
00:35:04
Because that means you
Speaker:
00:35:05
could then turn a 70 mil.
Speaker:
00:35:07
Yeah, yeah,
Speaker:
00:35:07
Cam made a really
Speaker:
00:35:08
good point about it's
Speaker:
00:35:08
restricting that air flow
Speaker:
00:35:09
at the bottom or the top.
Speaker:
00:35:10
So if we just go whack on
Speaker:
00:35:11
these cavity closers at the
Speaker:
00:35:12
bottom, say for example,
Speaker:
00:35:14
you know those James Hardy
Speaker:
00:35:15
strips that have those drip
Speaker:
00:35:16
edges with little slots?
Speaker:
00:35:17
Like that's kind
Speaker:
00:35:18
of starting to
Speaker:
00:35:18
defeat the purpose.
Speaker:
00:35:19
Like it needs to be
Speaker:
00:35:20
something like an aluminium
Speaker:
00:35:22
mesh that still allows
Speaker:
00:35:23
air to come through.
Speaker:
00:35:24
That stops the bugs.
Speaker:
00:35:25
Like it's, we can't
Speaker:
00:35:27
just start closing
Speaker:
00:35:27
these up either with
Speaker:
00:35:28
these plastic PVC
Speaker:
00:35:30
materials or an aluminum
Speaker:
00:35:31
trim.
Speaker:
00:35:32
top, top and bottom too
Speaker:
00:35:33
though, correct Cam?
Speaker:
00:35:34
and even at transitions
Speaker:
00:35:36
of where your, wall might
Speaker:
00:35:37
hit an eave overhang
Speaker:
00:35:38
or something like that.
Speaker:
00:35:39
Like, there's all these
Speaker:
00:35:40
things that you want
Speaker:
00:35:41
to consider, like just.
Speaker:
00:35:42
this is what was running
Speaker:
00:35:43
into my head before, like
Speaker:
00:35:44
there's so many things to
Speaker:
00:35:46
think about when you're
Speaker:
00:35:47
building a home and trying
Speaker:
00:35:49
to put these, I would call
Speaker:
00:35:50
performance construction
Speaker:
00:35:51
elements in your home.
Speaker:
00:35:53
And I know on our
Speaker:
00:35:54
sites, we're not always
Speaker:
00:35:55
getting it right.
Speaker:
00:35:56
And we're always having
Speaker:
00:35:56
to pick up the phone
Speaker:
00:35:57
and ask the brains
Speaker:
00:35:58
trust or ask cam.
Speaker:
00:36:00
I guess this is what I love
Speaker:
00:36:01
about getting you on cam.
Speaker:
00:36:02
Cause I think every time
Speaker:
00:36:03
I've had, we've had you
Speaker:
00:36:04
on, I've come away with
Speaker:
00:36:04
a bit of an aha moment.
Speaker:
00:36:07
I'll just jump back
Speaker:
00:36:07
to this whole thing
Speaker:
00:36:08
about how you deal with
Speaker:
00:36:09
those cavity closures.
Speaker:
00:36:11
, because I think this is,
Speaker:
00:36:12
is the key bit to this,
Speaker:
00:36:13
where we sort of get
Speaker:
00:36:14
a bit, infatuated with
Speaker:
00:36:16
the idea of how deep
Speaker:
00:36:17
should my batten be.
Speaker:
00:36:19
and then dealing with
Speaker:
00:36:20
the question of the,
Speaker:
00:36:21
the entry point and the
Speaker:
00:36:22
exit point later on.
Speaker:
00:36:24
And a lot of those
Speaker:
00:36:24
proprietary cavity closes,
Speaker:
00:36:26
as Matt alluded to, are
Speaker:
00:36:27
sort of slots, and I
Speaker:
00:36:29
would hypothesize, I don't
Speaker:
00:36:31
know, but it
strikes me
Speaker:
00:36:33
when I look at those,
Speaker:
00:36:34
this looks like it's
Speaker:
00:36:34
intended for drainage,
Speaker:
00:36:36
not for ventilation.
Speaker:
00:36:38
Like when my water drips,
Speaker:
00:36:39
drops, drip down, they can
Speaker:
00:36:40
escape through that slot.
Speaker:
00:36:41
Great, no problem.
Speaker:
00:36:43
But it's severely
Speaker:
00:36:45
restricting the air flow.
Speaker:
00:36:47
through that space.
Speaker:
00:36:48
So even if I've got a 20mm,
Speaker:
00:36:50
35mm, whatever it is, if
Speaker:
00:36:52
I've only got like a 3mm
Speaker:
00:36:53
wide slot running in 100mm
Speaker:
00:36:56
lengths or something,
Speaker:
00:36:57
I've only got an opening
Speaker:
00:36:58
area of maybe 5 percent of
Speaker:
00:37:00
the theoretical maximum.
Speaker:
00:37:02
You know, it's tiny.
Speaker:
00:37:03
And so I do prefer going
Speaker:
00:37:05
for a mesh solution, but
Speaker:
00:37:08
coming back to our fire
Speaker:
00:37:09
thing, if we're building
Speaker:
00:37:10
in a bell area where
Speaker:
00:37:12
we've got to go with 2mm
Speaker:
00:37:14
mesh, Then that's having
Speaker:
00:37:15
a significant impact too.
Speaker:
00:37:17
I mean, the rule of thumb,
Speaker:
00:37:19
you know, and an analogy
Speaker:
00:37:21
is when you put a fly
Speaker:
00:37:22
screen on a door and you're
Speaker:
00:37:24
trying to create a stack
Speaker:
00:37:26
of it, you're trying to
Speaker:
00:37:26
flush out your building
Speaker:
00:37:28
in the summer by opening
Speaker:
00:37:29
the door once cool change
Speaker:
00:37:30
comes through, you're
Speaker:
00:37:32
reducing air movement
Speaker:
00:37:33
across that opening by
Speaker:
00:37:35
about 40 percent by putting
Speaker:
00:37:36
the fly screen there.
Speaker:
00:37:37
Which is, you know,
Speaker:
00:37:38
quite impactful,
Speaker:
00:37:39
quite significant.
Speaker:
00:37:40
So even though, you know,
Speaker:
00:37:41
you're going to have
Speaker:
00:37:41
to put a mesh, no more
Speaker:
00:37:43
Well, maybe we need
Speaker:
00:37:43
to change the way we
Speaker:
00:37:44
build though, and not
Speaker:
00:37:45
use claddings that need
Speaker:
00:37:46
ventilated cavity and
Speaker:
00:37:47
look at things like say
Speaker:
00:37:48
a brick or a wood fiber
Speaker:
00:37:50
externally and render it
Speaker:
00:37:51
or something like that.
Speaker:
00:37:52
So maybe we need to
Speaker:
00:37:53
actually start to change
Speaker:
00:37:54
the way we construct
Speaker:
00:37:55
in these areas.
Speaker:
00:37:56
Well, I don't mind, I
Speaker:
00:37:58
think we didn't say this
Speaker:
00:38:00
earlier, but if anything,
Speaker:
00:38:01
probably the drainage
Speaker:
00:38:02
function of that cavity
Speaker:
00:38:03
is more important than
Speaker:
00:38:03
the ventilation function.
Speaker:
00:38:05
The building's going to
Speaker:
00:38:06
fail an awful lot faster
Speaker:
00:38:07
if it's got a leak.
Speaker:
00:38:09
than if it's got a,
Speaker:
00:38:10
a vapour problem.
Speaker:
00:38:12
, so you would fibre
Speaker:
00:38:13
with your render.
Speaker:
00:38:14
Yeah, that's okay.
Speaker:
00:38:15
I can see how that
Speaker:
00:38:16
can, in theory, get
Speaker:
00:38:17
away without the
Speaker:
00:38:18
ventilator cavity there.
Speaker:
00:38:20
But it does severely
Speaker:
00:38:21
restrict your ability to do
Speaker:
00:38:22
any other form of cladding.
Speaker:
00:38:24
and brick still needs,
Speaker:
00:38:26
you know, there's no
Speaker:
00:38:26
question you need a
Speaker:
00:38:27
cavity with brick.
Speaker:
00:38:28
I don't see a problem
Speaker:
00:38:30
with putting in a
Speaker:
00:38:31
ventilated cavity.
Speaker:
00:38:32
We do that fairly
Speaker:
00:38:34
regularly now.
Speaker:
00:38:35
It does surprise me when
Speaker:
00:38:37
you see details where the
Speaker:
00:38:38
cavity batten is actually
Speaker:
00:38:40
running horizontal.
Speaker:
00:38:42
It kind of suggests to
Speaker:
00:38:43
me that you've maybe
Speaker:
00:38:44
misunderstood what the
Speaker:
00:38:45
purpose of this cavity is.
Speaker:
00:38:47
when you're doing that
Speaker:
00:38:48
or maybe you're putting
Speaker:
00:38:49
on like two mil packers
Speaker:
00:38:51
or five mil packers or
Speaker:
00:38:52
something yeah okay that
Speaker:
00:38:54
theoretically will solve
Speaker:
00:38:56
the drainage part of the
Speaker:
00:38:56
problem as we've talked
Speaker:
00:38:57
about but it does very
Speaker:
00:38:59
little for your ventilation
Speaker:
00:39:00
I think it's just
Speaker:
00:39:01
to make the cladding
Speaker:
00:39:01
easier to install.
Speaker:
00:39:02
I don't think anyone that's
Speaker:
00:39:03
doing just a horizontal
Speaker:
00:39:06
batten to put, they're not
Speaker:
00:39:07
thinking about air movement
Speaker:
00:39:09
or the drainage at all.
Speaker:
00:39:10
They're simply just
Speaker:
00:39:11
thinking about how do
Speaker:
00:39:12
I fix my cladding on?
Speaker:
00:39:13
that's why we always come
Speaker:
00:39:14
back to first principles
Speaker:
00:39:15
isn't it like on one
Speaker:
00:39:17
hand as an engineer I say
Speaker:
00:39:18
you've got to model it
Speaker:
00:39:19
but on the other hand as
Speaker:
00:39:20
I will Think about where
Speaker:
00:39:21
the vapor and the water,
Speaker:
00:39:23
liquid water is moving
Speaker:
00:39:24
through this assembly.
Speaker:
00:39:25
Have I encouraged and
Speaker:
00:39:26
supported drying through
Speaker:
00:39:27
this construction?
Speaker:
00:39:29
And as soon as you do that
Speaker:
00:39:30
and think that
through, you
Speaker:
00:39:31
go, well, hang on a minute.
Speaker:
00:39:32
Horizontal button?
Speaker:
00:39:34
Yeah, maybe not.
Speaker:
00:39:35
Yeah, so I think from
Speaker:
00:39:36
now on, the terminology
Speaker:
00:39:37
should be ventilated and
Speaker:
00:39:39
drainage cavity, I know
Speaker:
00:39:41
we've been sort of calling
Speaker:
00:39:42
it a ventilated cavity.
Speaker:
00:39:44
With the assumption that
Speaker:
00:39:45
it drains, but I think
Speaker:
00:39:46
we just need to be more
Speaker:
00:39:46
explicit, because then
Speaker:
00:39:47
it paints a different
Speaker:
00:39:48
picture in your brain,
Speaker:
00:39:49
because you're, dealing
Speaker:
00:39:49
with the ventilation, but
Speaker:
00:39:50
also the drainage, which
Speaker:
00:39:52
is probably, as you said,
Speaker:
00:39:53
the most important part.
Speaker:
00:39:54
That's actually good.
Speaker:
00:39:55
I like that, Haym.
Speaker:
00:39:57
sitting here thinking
Speaker:
00:39:58
before that I'm, I'm
Speaker:
00:39:58
really glad that I.
Speaker:
00:39:59
At the very minimum get
Speaker:
00:40:01
to listen to this twice
Speaker:
00:40:02
because I always listen
Speaker:
00:40:03
to it when it comes
Speaker:
00:40:03
out because there's
Speaker:
00:40:05
been so much that I've
Speaker:
00:40:06
like taken in today
Speaker:
00:40:07
and let's make that
Speaker:
00:40:08
another episode because
Speaker:
00:40:10
I think there's enough to
Speaker:
00:40:10
digest in this episode.
Speaker:
00:40:12
I've got two more
Speaker:
00:40:13
questions quickly
Speaker:
00:40:14
for you though, Cam.
Speaker:
00:40:15
Probably by the time this
Speaker:
00:40:16
podcast gets released,
Speaker:
00:40:17
we're in a whole new year.
Speaker:
00:40:18
What are you most
Speaker:
00:40:19
excited for in 2025?
Speaker:
00:40:20
uh, I don't know.
Speaker:
00:40:22
You should have asked
Speaker:
00:40:22
me, uh, given me
Speaker:
00:40:23
a lead up on that.
Speaker:
00:40:24
well, there's a
Speaker:
00:40:25
sort of a follow up
Speaker:
00:40:26
question in a sense.
Speaker:
00:40:26
Is, have you got like
Speaker:
00:40:27
a 2025 project that
Speaker:
00:40:29
you're most excited
Speaker:
00:40:30
to see get to site?
Speaker:
00:40:31
And it can't be the one
Speaker:
00:40:33
Hamish just said, or
Speaker:
00:40:34
is it one you really
Speaker:
00:40:35
want to see finished?
Speaker:
00:40:36
Or there's something
Speaker:
00:40:36
you're working on and
Speaker:
00:40:37
you're like, no, no,
Speaker:
00:40:37
this is really good.
Speaker:
00:40:38
And it's challenging me.
Speaker:
00:40:39
There's a very large
Speaker:
00:40:41
project, I'm doing
Speaker:
00:40:43
residential project with
Speaker:
00:40:44
an awful lot of steel
Speaker:
00:40:45
in it, which has caused
Speaker:
00:40:47
me any, any number of,
Speaker:
00:40:48
any amount of grief.
Speaker:
00:40:50
It'll be nice to see the
Speaker:
00:40:51
back end of that for the
Speaker:
00:40:52
grief side of it, but also
Speaker:
00:40:54
to actually see it come
Speaker:
00:40:55
to fruition given the.
Speaker:
00:40:56
level of detailing that
Speaker:
00:40:58
has been required on that.
Speaker:
00:41:00
Certification level,
Speaker:
00:41:02
a certification is a,
Speaker:
00:41:03
client requirement.
Speaker:
00:41:05
So it's, it's a
Speaker:
00:41:06
non negotiable.
Speaker:
00:41:08
and you couldn't just
Speaker:
00:41:08
put glulam beams in,
Speaker:
00:41:10
uh, nope.
Speaker:
00:41:11
this probably does go back
Speaker:
00:41:12
to, you know, for those
Speaker:
00:41:14
listening, you may be
Speaker:
00:41:15
keen on pursuing passive
Speaker:
00:41:16
houses, get your team lined
Speaker:
00:41:18
up from the outset, get
Speaker:
00:41:19
everyone on board with what
Speaker:
00:41:21
you're trying to do here.
Speaker:
00:41:23
be challenging.
Speaker:
00:41:24
I mean, there's
Speaker:
00:41:25
multiple constraints.
Speaker:
00:41:26
It's always building.
Speaker:
00:41:27
It's always that
Speaker:
00:41:28
competitive tension
Speaker:
00:41:29
between different
Speaker:
00:41:30
disciplines from my thermal
Speaker:
00:41:32
engineering point of view.
Speaker:
00:41:33
2025 model.
Speaker:
00:41:35
Get your team
Speaker:
00:41:35
together early.
Speaker:
00:41:37
It's so important.
Speaker:
00:41:38
It really is, yeah.
Speaker:
00:41:39
it comes even at the
Speaker:
00:41:41
fundamental geometric
Speaker:
00:41:42
design of the building.
Speaker:
00:41:43
You know, you're
Speaker:
00:41:43
architect, you're building
Speaker:
00:41:44
designer, you're draftee.
Speaker:
00:41:46
You know, we could talk
Speaker:
00:41:47
about this some other time,
Speaker:
00:41:48
but your flat roofs, your
Speaker:
00:41:49
parapets, your box gutters.
Speaker:
00:41:52
How many times do
Speaker:
00:41:52
we have to have
Speaker:
00:41:53
these conversations?
Speaker:
00:41:54
I know they're
Speaker:
00:41:55
architecturally great, and
Speaker:
00:41:56
they, you know, might be
Speaker:
00:41:57
required for your res code
Speaker:
00:41:59
in a certain place, but
Speaker:
00:42:01
man, they create headaches.
Speaker:
00:42:03
Thanks.
Speaker:
00:42:03
it does come back
Speaker:
00:42:04
to this debate about
Speaker:
00:42:05
probability and risk.
Speaker:
00:42:06
You know, you can't have
Speaker:
00:42:07
zero risk but as soon
Speaker:
00:42:10
as you if you're doing
Speaker:
00:42:12
things like a flat roof,
Speaker:
00:42:13
you are locking in a
Speaker:
00:42:14
much higher level of risk
Speaker:
00:42:16
than you otherwise would
Speaker:
00:42:18
and we cannot entirely
Speaker:
00:42:19
mitigate that risk no
Speaker:
00:42:21
matter how hard we try.
Speaker:
00:42:23
I think we leave it
Speaker:
00:42:24
there because Dr.
Speaker:
00:42:24
Evil is probably about to
Speaker:
00:42:25
piss off more architects
Speaker:
00:42:27
saying that you can't
Speaker:
00:42:27
have flat roofs and
Speaker:
00:42:28
they should be banned.
Speaker:
00:42:29
So no flat roofs with
Speaker:
00:42:31
a fireplace on them.
Speaker:
00:42:33
I didn't
Speaker:
00:42:35
say bad.
Speaker:
00:42:36
Thank you,
Speaker:
00:42:37
Thanks, Cam.
Speaker:
00:42:38
Thanks,
Speaker:
00:42:38
See you, Maddy.