TRANSKRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:03.111 --> 00:00:04.921
and even me, I mean, I'm guilty of it.
00:00:04.950 --> 00:00:08.521
Before I knew, I would be like,"Oh, my district said I have to do this to fidelity.
00:00:08.521 --> 00:00:11.340
That's what I need to do." But, like, I didn't even know what I was saying.
00:00:11.410 --> 00:00:18.609
there's never anything that can be done with fidelity, if we're talking about a human connection and a human experience as teaching.
00:00:23.123 --> 00:00:23.632
Okay, guys.
00:00:23.655 --> 00:00:33.679
Welcome back to Math Therapy, and today, against my better judgment, we are wading into the very murky waters of one of the hottest debates in math education right now.
00:00:33.722 --> 00:00:44.701
So I'm just gonna rip the Band-Aid off and give you one question to ponder: If we don't want our students to be robots, why would we ask our teachers to teach like robots?
00:00:44.825 --> 00:00:51.305
Now, look, I'm not an expert in curriculum, and I'm still trying to figure out how I even feel about this debate, but here's what I do know.
00:00:51.607 --> 00:00:57.381
So many teachers, students, and parents that I talk to every day feel pulled in two opposing directions.
00:00:57.654 --> 00:01:05.765
We want kids to think creatively, take risks, and develop their own strategies, and we want teachers to feel empowered to support each student however they can.
00:01:06.001 --> 00:01:17.939
But on the other hand, many teachers are being asked to, like, follow highly prescribed curricula designed to ensure that every student gets access to high-quality instruction, no matter who's teaching them.
00:01:18.254 --> 00:01:25.591
But what happens when following the script means ignoring what you know your own unique students actually need?
00:01:25.998 --> 00:01:29.311
And at what point does consistency come at the cost of good teaching?
00:01:29.777 --> 00:01:36.126
Well, today's guest is living this debate firsthand, and this episode was both unplanned and unhinged.
00:01:36.546 --> 00:01:45.171
I met Trista Matthews at the Cotsen Foundations annual conference in California, where she introduced me before my session, and within hours, we were recording this podcast.
00:01:45.629 --> 00:01:53.441
Trista has spent twenty-three years teaching elementary school, and she's now a mentor coach, helping other educators navigate some of the toughest challenges in teaching.
00:01:53.703 --> 00:02:00.385
Today, we're getting into the messy reality of what happens when curriculum expectations clash with the art of teaching.
00:02:00.819 --> 00:02:08.734
We're talking teacher autonomy, the pressure to follow the rules, and whether it's even possible to teach with fidelity when you're working with actual human beings.
00:02:08.838 --> 00:02:17.906
So if you're a teacher who's ever felt torn between doing what you're told and doing what you know is right for your students, trust me, you are going to feel seen in this episode.
00:02:21.014 --> 00:02:21.137
Okay.
00:02:21.137 --> 00:02:21.417
Okay.
00:02:21.437 --> 00:02:21.697
Hi.
00:02:22.676 --> 00:02:23.086
Hi.
00:02:23.176 --> 00:02:23.847
Thank you for having me.
00:02:23.847 --> 00:02:23.887
Welcome to the pod.
00:02:23.887 --> 00:02:23.907
Thank you.
00:02:23.907 --> 00:02:24.097
Okay.
00:02:24.097 --> 00:02:25.776
So what, who are you?
00:02:26.086 --> 00:02:26.776
Okay, so
00:02:27.576 --> 00:02:30.046
I love how you reacted so normally to that.
00:02:30.046 --> 00:02:30.417
Okay.
00:02:30.426 --> 00:02:31.887
Yeah, so I see that this is your...
00:02:31.887 --> 00:02:34.106
So just so you guys know, we have just met today.
00:02:34.116 --> 00:02:34.146
Yes.
00:02:34.247 --> 00:02:35.556
A matter of hours ago.
00:02:35.597 --> 00:02:35.887
Yes.
00:02:35.926 --> 00:02:38.796
Because Trista introduced me today.
00:02:38.977 --> 00:02:43.736
Which was so nice, but when she introduced me, I realized we had to have you on the podcast.
00:02:43.986 --> 00:02:44.257
Yes.
00:02:44.257 --> 00:02:48.896
'Cause I feel like there's more to the story, but I also don't know anything about you.
00:02:48.896 --> 00:02:49.182
So- Yes.
00:02:49.182 --> 00:02:50.507
Because it was divine intervention.
00:02:50.507 --> 00:02:51.806
Okay, so let's hear about this please.
00:02:51.847 --> 00:02:52.146
Okay.
00:02:52.206 --> 00:02:54.157
So my name is Trista.
00:02:54.546 --> 00:02:58.787
I am an teacher here in Southern California.
00:02:58.796 --> 00:02:58.947
Okay.
00:02:58.986 --> 00:03:00.612
Actually in Orange County.
00:03:00.663 --> 00:03:04.462
this is my 23rd year in elementary school, general education, public school.
00:03:04.932 --> 00:03:11.173
and Three years ago, I was introduced to the Cotsen Foundation, which is the conference that we're at today.
00:03:11.203 --> 00:03:11.383
Yeah.
00:03:11.453 --> 00:03:12.652
it's their annual conference.
00:03:13.263 --> 00:03:22.787
the Cotsen Foundation, very, just very quickly, is an amazing nonprofit organization who, gives back to teachers and supports teachers, in any way possibly they can.
00:03:23.016 --> 00:03:31.956
Mainly through offering, professional development, through amazing educators and consultants like yourself, and also through the coaching process.
00:03:32.426 --> 00:03:32.977
And so-
00:03:32.977 --> 00:03:33.597
You guys have like an intensive coaching process.
00:03:33.727 --> 00:03:34.477
Yes, we do.
00:03:34.806 --> 00:03:40.616
And so I, at my school site where I teach, was, asked to be the coach at my site.
00:03:40.657 --> 00:03:41.176
Okay.
00:03:41.227 --> 00:03:46.276
So I am currently the Cotsen mentor or Cotsen coach at my school site.
00:03:46.586 --> 00:03:51.197
and I have a group of six teachers that I work with at my school site.
00:03:51.257 --> 00:03:59.552
And so my job is to support them in the goals that they create, for their year.
00:03:59.582 --> 00:04:01.432
It can be a short-term goal, long-term goal.
00:04:01.432 --> 00:04:03.703
So we work
Load full transcript
together for two years.
00:04:03.763 --> 00:04:07.622
so I get to do this job for two years with the same six teachers.
00:04:07.622 --> 00:04:09.026
That is incredible.
00:04:09.165 --> 00:04:24.833
And so if you know anything about working in public education and being a general education teacher, the one thing that us as teachers always want is time to, perfect our craft and support in order to do it.
00:04:24.862 --> 00:04:30.233
And so Cotsen offers those two things through professional development and coaching through a coach.
00:04:30.233 --> 00:04:30.706
And so-
00:04:30.877 --> 00:04:31.706
Which is unbelievable.
00:04:31.716 --> 00:04:35.713
Like, just even being here today, the vibe is, like, you know what?
00:04:35.713 --> 00:04:37.523
It's like the vibe is, like, hopeful.
00:04:37.682 --> 00:04:37.903
And I feel...
00:04:37.913 --> 00:04:47.233
Like, not that other teachers aren't hopeful, I just feel like it's so hard because we often go to professional development, and it's like you know you're having this inspiring day, but you know there's nothing after that.
00:04:47.322 --> 00:04:47.903
Exactly.
00:04:47.913 --> 00:04:48.202
Right?
00:04:48.202 --> 00:04:54.802
And so my job as a Cotsen mentor coach is to now sit down with my, we call them fellows.
00:04:54.843 --> 00:04:56.213
They're fellows in the program.
00:04:56.233 --> 00:05:04.973
So my teachers that I work with are my fellows, and we will sit and talk about our day today and talk about what are some things that really spoke to you?
00:05:04.992 --> 00:05:06.952
Is there anything that you wanna try out in the classroom?
00:05:06.952 --> 00:05:17.512
Like, for example, being in one of your sessions today, something that I know one of my teachers already spoke to me about was your exit ticket and keeping a receipt, and she's like,"I wanna try that." Yay.
00:05:17.512 --> 00:05:21.233
So on Monday, we are going to pull up that resource.
00:05:21.593 --> 00:05:24.242
We're gonna print some out, and we're gonna try in a classroom.
00:05:24.242 --> 00:05:26.362
And so my job is to support her in that.
00:05:26.642 --> 00:05:29.862
How can I keep her accountable in what she wants to do?
00:05:30.072 --> 00:05:37.362
And maybe even help her collect some data on it to see if it actually is changing a student's belief about who they are as a math- mathematician.
00:05:37.372 --> 00:05:39.023
What, how would you do that, by the way?
00:05:39.052 --> 00:05:45.562
Like, if you, for this particular thing, like, I'm just curious'cause I'm like, oh, like, how would you pu- like, what kind of data would you collect?
00:05:45.603 --> 00:05:51.502
Yeah, so it's, the great thing about the Cotsen program is it's all about what the teacher needs from me.
00:05:51.512 --> 00:06:01.819
So the teacher is really driving their journey, Say, for example, one of their goals is,"I want my students to really, have a positive math identity.
00:06:01.889 --> 00:06:19.100
I want my students to see themselves as mathematicians, to see themselves as, successful and this is something I can do." What I would do then is what I feel like she's probably going to do, is have me collect data on these, and I'm just kind of throwing it, an idea out there.
00:06:19.350 --> 00:06:24.019
If they're doing these receipts, right, of, you call them positive-
00:06:24.019 --> 00:06:24.990
Wait, let's explain that.
00:06:24.990 --> 00:06:26.209
So it's like the idea of the receipt.
00:06:26.220 --> 00:06:26.240
Yeah.
00:06:26.250 --> 00:06:28.439
Tell me what you understood, then I can see if I explained it properly.
00:06:28.740 --> 00:06:29.019
Okay.
00:06:29.019 --> 00:06:29.519
Okay.
00:06:29.519 --> 00:06:45.279
So what I understood is that we all have, like this self-fulfilling prophecy of like, if I think I'm a bad mathematician, if I think I'm not a good math person, then I'm going to find things that kind of fulfill that belief in me.
00:06:45.279 --> 00:06:47.480
Oh my God, you're going so deep, but that is so correct.
00:06:47.660 --> 00:06:49.100
yes, that's our brain's confirmation bias.
00:06:49.100 --> 00:06:49.689
Exactly.
00:06:49.689 --> 00:06:53.180
We wanna like confirm- So that confirmation bias like subconsciously we're like trying to confirm things we believe to be true.
00:06:53.189 --> 00:06:53.720
Exactly.
00:06:53.720 --> 00:06:57.459
So my negative self-talk is going to tell me things like,"I can't do that.
00:06:57.470 --> 00:07:08.699
That problem's too hard for me." and so what, what I took away is this is just like a concrete example of something you did well as a mathematician today.
00:07:09.120 --> 00:07:09.730
I took risks.
00:07:10.307 --> 00:07:16.216
I tried a problem and I, you know, didn't, like- Have an anxiety freak out about it, have a, have a meltdown.
00:07:16.216 --> 00:07:16.516
Yeah.
00:07:16.536 --> 00:07:17.427
I asked a question.
00:07:17.447 --> 00:07:17.797
Yeah.
00:07:17.846 --> 00:07:21.226
Maybe some kids just don't feel comfortable asking questions.
00:07:21.237 --> 00:07:22.747
Or like, I showed up to class today.
00:07:22.747 --> 00:07:23.326
Exactly.
00:07:23.346 --> 00:07:24.706
And so like, what are...
00:07:24.726 --> 00:07:34.266
And I love that you had some already like pre-written ideas on there, like taking, I took a risk, I asked a question, like I solved a problem.
00:07:34.297 --> 00:07:35.776
Different things that you had on there.
00:07:36.057 --> 00:07:54.747
What I would do as, as a mentor, as a coach for my teacher, is we would sit down and say like,"What kind of data are you looking for?" And she'd probably say something like,"Well, I wanna see that my children's identity of themselves, identity as mathematicians, is really coming out in what they're doing in the classroom."
00:07:54.807 --> 00:07:55.093
Mm.
00:07:55.093 --> 00:07:57.552
So let's just to back up for everyone listening.
00:07:57.742 --> 00:08:00.223
So this is something I called keeping the receipt.
00:08:00.223 -->
00:08:00.442
Yes.
00:08:00.442 --> 00:08:00.702
So the i-
00:08:00.752 --> 00:08:01.223
Keeping the receipt.
00:08:01.223 --> 00:08:01.326
Yeah.
00:08:01.533 --> 00:08:08.512
So the idea of the exit ticket is like at the end of every day, the exit ticket is a student has to write down something, like a win.
00:08:08.512 --> 00:08:08.603
Right?
00:08:09.132 --> 00:08:10.192
Like just something that was good.
00:08:10.192 --> 00:08:10.923
Literally anything.
00:08:10.923 --> 00:08:12.043
It could be like,"I showed up to class.
00:08:12.093 --> 00:08:14.853
I didn't have a- math meltdown." Like,"I helped somebody else.
00:08:14.853 --> 00:08:16.713
I understood something more than yesterday." Whatever it is.
00:08:16.733 --> 00:08:17.072
Yeah.
00:08:17.093 --> 00:08:24.182
Then the idea is to turn in those receipts, and the teacher is collecting this data so that they have a pile from every student to be like, like-
00:08:24.192 --> 00:08:24.812
No, you did.
00:08:24.812 --> 00:08:24.932
Like-
00:08:24.932 --> 00:08:28.403
You look at all the stuff you've done, and we can decide what to do with that pile.
00:08:28.502 --> 00:08:28.673
Exactly.
00:08:28.673 --> 00:08:38.092
But now you're saying,"Oh, we could use that pile as data." And maybe the teacher's like,"I'm looking to see if them keeping those receipts actually affects the way they interact and perform in math class."
00:08:38.153 --> 00:08:38.523
Yes.
00:08:38.562 --> 00:08:38.822
Okay.
00:08:39.582 --> 00:08:41.643
So we can, I mean, it can be anything-
00:08:41.643 --> 00:08:42.143
Then how do you do that?
00:08:42.143 --> 00:08:42.403
Yeah.
00:08:42.403 --> 00:08:49.942
So it can be anything from, just looking at how maybe class discussions are going.
00:08:50.363 --> 00:08:54.403
Maybe like it was, like a students weren't talking in math class.
00:08:54.462 --> 00:08:54.763
Right.
00:08:54.812 --> 00:08:57.722
Like she would ask a question, and it would be like silenc- silence.
00:08:57.722 --> 00:08:58.712
Like crickets, right?
00:08:58.993 --> 00:09:23.159
Well, maybe as we're collecting these, these exit tickets, keeping the receipt, and we start to notice that children or the students are saying like these positive things about themselves, or we as the teacher are reminding them,"Hey, like remember when you ask a question or you took a risk?" By us affirming them in that, is that changing the, how discussions happening in the classroom?
00:09:23.173 --> 00:09:24.503
We can take anecdotal data.
00:09:24.503 --> 00:09:33.777
We can even interview some students and, and say, how do you feel about yourself as a mathematician now?" Then maybe compare it to before we started, you know, um, taking this-
00:09:33.777 --> 00:09:35.667
Well, and this is when you can combine strategies.
00:09:35.677 --> 00:09:38.976
So I don't know if you ever used, have you ever used like a math mindset survey?
00:09:39.456 --> 00:09:39.797
Yes.
00:09:39.817 --> 00:09:46.027
Where at the beginning of the year
you kind of ask them how they feel about themselves as like a mathematician as a reader, as a writer.
00:09:47.072 --> 00:09:52.412
in the show notes to a resource I made with a math, mindset survey that you can do that with for anyone who wants to do that.
00:09:52.412 --> 00:09:54.951
But that, that's a great way to combine resources, right?
00:09:54.951 --> 00:10:03.172
Because you could do that- then you could do something like the keep the receipts, and then you could measure the, you could do the math mindset survey, like a month or two after to see if things have changed.
00:10:03.182 --> 00:10:03.581
Yeah.
00:10:03.581 --> 00:10:16.741
And so, you know, and then once, if we start to see change in the classroom, I'm like,"Awesome." I, you know, I meet with my fellow, meet with my teacher, and usually what comes from that is, well, what can, how can we build on this?
00:10:16.812 --> 00:10:20.652
And then another goal might, you know, come from that first goal that we created.
00:10:20.692 --> 00:10:27.011
So that's really my job as a coach and mentor, at my school site to support my teachers.
00:10:27.011 --> 00:10:27.126
You said...
00:10:27.126 --> 00:10:29.261
Wait, first of all, we haven't talked about the divine intervention thing.
00:10:29.272 --> 00:10:30.081
Yes, I know.
00:10:30.081 --> 00:10:30.581
I need to talk.
00:10:30.662 --> 00:10:31.022
I know.
00:10:31.022 --> 00:10:31.601
I could tell.
00:10:31.601 --> 00:10:31.831
Right?
00:10:31.831 --> 00:10:33.861
You were probably like,"What is happening?" Yes.
00:10:33.912 --> 00:10:34.932
Don't worry, I'm tracking.
00:10:34.932 --> 00:10:36.162
I was like, hold on a second.
00:10:36.162 --> 00:10:38.251
Why is it di- divine intervention that we met?
00:10:38.251 --> 00:10:38.692
Yeah.
00:10:38.902 --> 00:10:39.111
Well,
00:10:39.111 --> 00:10:42.302
I- Because I'm about to ask you a whole different question, I was like, no, we have to bring this back.
00:10:42.312 --> 00:10:42.662
Okay.
00:10:42.662 --> 00:10:46.412
Well, be- so before you ask that question, I'll tell you about the divine intervention.
00:10:46.422 --> 00:10:46.662
Okay.
00:10:46.672 --> 00:10:52.402
So as another part of my job is to, find resources for my teachers.
00:10:52.412 --> 00:11:02.851
So say for example, they were thinking,"Oh, I really want to get students talking more in my class." Well, my job then as a mentor is to see if I can go and find resources for them.
00:11:02.875 --> 00:11:04.695
And you were a resource that I found.
00:11:04.695 --> 00:11:04.715
How?
00:11:04.715 --> 00:11:05.335
Why?
00:11:05.345 --> 00:11:15.235
So, I had a math fellow last year who was really struggling with, implementing what we call like these, the CGI strategies in her classroom.
00:11:15.384 --> 00:11:16.644
Can you say more about what that means?
00:11:16.674 --> 00:11:17.004
Yes.
00:11:17.154 --> 00:11:21.157
So CGI strategies, CGI stands for cognitively guided instruction.
00:11:21.157 --> 00:11:21.366
Okay.
00:11:21.657 --> 00:11:28.986
and so it's really centering students and their thinking and what they bring into the math classroom, and building upon what they know.
00:11:29.167 --> 00:11:40.606
So what strategy did you use to solve that problem, and not saying like,"Hey, that's a wrong way." That's the way you solved it, honoring their thinking, and then building upon that knowledge in the classroom.
00:11:40.982 --> 00:11:47.539
Knowing that we were gonna be getting, like, a new math curriculum this year, our district was, uh, piloting a math curriculum last year.
00:11:47.539 --> 00:11:48.124
Which one was it?
00:11:48.124 --> 00:11:48.779
Um, Eureka.
00:11:49.129 --> 00:11:49.220
Okay.
00:11:49.360 --> 00:11:49.559
Yeah.
00:11:49.929 --> 00:11:55.210
So they were piloting, a few, they were piloting a few, but Eureka was one of them, and that's the one our district ended up choosing.
00:11:55.799 --> 00:12:10.990
She was, struggling with,"How can I implement what I know is good teaching with, what this curriculum is asking me to do?" So I just was doing my research, and I came across your podcast.
00:12:11.120 --> 00:12:11.559
Oh my God.
00:12:12.059 --> 00:12:12.340
And-
00:12:12.710 --> 00:12:13.639
The podcast that we're on right now.
00:12:14.139 --> 00:12:14.159
Yeah.
00:12:14.159 --> 00:12:14.630
I love a full circle.
00:12:14.630 --> 00:12:14.820
Okay, yeah.
00:12:14.820 --> 00:12:18.279
And, and I sent it to her, and I said,"You have to listen to this.
00:12:18.590 --> 00:12:19.779
This is amazing.
00:12:20.149 --> 00:12:22.730
what she's talking about is so relevant to what not just you
00:12:22.730 --> 00:12:23.360
What was it?
00:12:23.360 --> 00:12:23.970
Are going through.
00:12:23.970 --> 00:12:25.049
Like, what were you even listening to?
00:12:25.059 --> 00:12:30.399
So it was, it was a podcast just on, I think it was, like, beginning of the year.
00:12:30.450 --> 00:12:30.779
Okay.
00:12:30.799 --> 00:12:46.179
It wasn't the beginning of the year when I found it, but the very first podcast that I happened to listen to, it was about beginning of the year implementing, like, beginning of the year routines or i- But it wasn't specifically about the routines you were talking about.
00:12:46.210 --> 00:13:05.169
It was the bigger picture that you were talking about, like looking at kids in their full humanity and what they're bringing into the classroom, and really talking about math anxiety and traumas that us as teachers maybe have inflicted upon kids without knowing it, and how we can How can we fix, how can we fix it?
00:13:05.629 --> 00:13:07.059
And so it was just good teaching.
00:13:07.070 --> 00:13:10.259
And so I loved it so much, I loved your podcast so much-
00:13:10.259 --> 00:13:10.740
Oh, my God
00:13:10.740 --> 00:13:20.639
that I sent it to not just her but I sent it to all of my teachers because I felt like it wasn't just relevant to teachers of math, but it was relevant to all teachers.
00:13:21.059 -->
00:13:23.450
And so we just started listening to it.
00:13:23.500 --> 00:13:30.419
So we've been listening to you for, you know, the last year and, and here's where the divine intervention part comes in.
00:13:30.429 --> 00:13:30.879
So-
00:13:31.250 --> 00:13:37.169
I love, I just want everyone to know- that we have Trista's friend- sitting in the wings, okay?
00:13:37.500 --> 00:13:40.480
And just, like, making the funniest comments.
00:13:40.860 --> 00:13:44.220
She just, like, it's like, it's like we really have our own audience here.
00:13:44.230 --> 00:13:44.590
Yes.
00:13:44.940 --> 00:13:50.240
But she seems to be very excited about the part that's about to come up- Yeah in the story.
00:13:50.250 --> 00:13:51.460
So hopefully it meets your expectations.
00:13:51.460 --> 00:13:54.019
So I just want you guys to know what the situation is over here.
00:13:54.039 --> 00:13:54.299
Yes.
00:13:54.309 --> 00:13:55.860
We're gonna see if we can get her on.
00:13:55.940 --> 00:13:56.059
Yes.
00:13:56.059 --> 00:13:57.830
She says she doesn't like to speak publicly, but-
00:13:57.840 --> 00:13:59.149
She needs a couple more glasses of wine
00:13:59.149 --> 00:14:00.889
She, she does like to heckle the crowd.
00:14:00.919 --> 00:14:02.909
The, she likes to heckle the speaker, as it seems.
00:14:03.850 --> 00:14:03.879
Okay.
00:14:03.940 --> 00:14:04.240
Okay.
00:14:05.220 --> 00:14:26.153
So, um, right now our teachers are just in a really hard spot where they're really struggling with now we have this new curriculum and all of the demands that are getting put on teachers as to, how it should be taught to fidelity, and even having teachers be told, like, to throw out CGI, and we only have to teach the curriculum.
00:14:26.462 --> 00:14:30.043
And so they're just struggling, and so I felt like-
00:14:30.043 --> 00:14:38.432
And can I- sorry, just to like, the struggle is here, this is something we've talked about on the podcast before- but just to be so clear for like a new listener who's like,"What is the problem?
00:14:38.432 --> 00:14:39.345
Just follow the curriculum.
00:14:39.349 --> 00:14:49.783
All good." Often the curriculum- the idea of teaching to fidelity means basically follow exactly, do not insert any of your own literal anything.
00:14:49.793 --> 00:14:49.932
Yes, yes.
00:14:49.932 --> 00:14:53.043
So like read the question, read the lesson as written.
00:14:53.043 --> 00:14:53.293
Yes.
00:14:53.293 --> 00:15:05.062
And if you're doing that and you in your mind know of some practices that you love, that are effective, you wanna bring in some CGI, you wanna bring in- some math therapy, you wanna throw in- Yes some building thinking, like whatever- Yes you're not supposed to do that.
00:15:05.192 --> 00:15:05.383
Yes.
00:15:05.383 --> 00:15:12.393
So all of the stuff you've learned as a teacher, an expert at your craft you're basically being asked to toss that out the window and just follow a script.
00:15:12.592 --> 00:15:12.923
Yes.
00:15:12.982 --> 00:15:16.863
And that is a struggle often when the script is not aligned with what you know to be good teaching.
00:15:16.893 --> 00:15:17.202
Yes.
00:15:17.293 --> 00:15:17.572
Okay.
00:15:17.793 --> 00:15:23.452
And so the teacher who is struggling actually heard about Building Thinking Classrooms from you, from your podcast.
00:15:23.773 --> 00:15:24.033
Peter?
00:15:24.062 --> 00:15:24.773
Loves Peter.
00:15:24.773 --> 00:15:25.456
Are you listening?
00:15:25.456 --> 00:15:27.302
And is actually Tamra's, co-teacher.
00:15:27.302 --> 00:15:28.442
She teach- teaches sixth grade.
00:15:28.442 --> 00:15:29.543
Shout out to Kelly Calvert.
00:15:29.913 --> 00:15:30.092
Oh, my God.
00:15:30.123 --> 00:15:34.952
Um, so Tamra teaches with Kelly and was like,"I love Building Thinking Classrooms.
00:15:35.202 --> 00:15:38.222
And they want me to do this curriculum, like to fidelity.
00:15:38.653 --> 00:15:45.395
And she because she listens to you now too, was like,"Trista, Vanessa just did this amazing podcast with, Chase?
00:15:45.446 --> 00:15:46.166
I forget his name.
00:15:46.336 --> 00:15:46.956
With Chase.
00:15:46.995 --> 00:15:47.505
Chase.
00:15:47.505 --> 00:15:47.755
Yeah.
00:15:48.395 --> 00:15:48.566
Okay.
00:15:48.566 --> 00:15:48.671
Yes.
00:15:48.671 --> 00:15:49.094
Okay, that makes sense
00:15:49.094 --> 00:15:49.306
With Chase.
00:15:49.306 --> 00:15:51.775
And she's like,"You have to listen to this." This was two weeks ago.
00:15:51.816 --> 00:15:52.105
Okay.
00:15:52.115 --> 00:15:55.225
And I know that podcast was, like, back in June, I think, June 18th.
00:15:55.225 --> 00:15:55.885
It was, yeah, it was, like, in, yeah, June.
00:15:55.885 --> 00:15:58.525
But then you just did in the beginning of September-
00:15:58.535 --> 00:15:59.235
Yes
00:15:59.275 --> 00:15:59.765
the one-
00:15:59.916 --> 00:16:00.466
The Middle Path.
00:16:00.525 --> 00:16:01.566
Yes, the Middle Path.
00:16:01.566 --> 00:16:04.096
So we did another episode unpacking that episode with Chase-
00:16:04.105 --> 00:16:04.466
Yes
00:16:04.466 --> 00:16:07.326
where I did a live, kind of like this but in front of an audience.
00:16:07.346 --> 00:16:07.706
Yes.
00:16:07.706 --> 00:16:09.096
Me and Chase talked about curriculum stuff.
00:16:09.115 --> 00:16:09.796
Yes, you did.
00:16:09.796 --> 00:16:09.966
And then I did, yeah.
00:16:09.995 --> 00:16:11.485
We'll put all the links to all of these in the show notes.
00:16:11.556 --> 00:16:11.865
Yes.
00:16:11.865 --> 00:16:11.966
Okay.
00:16:12.166 --> 00:16:16.475
So Kelly was like,"You have to listen to this because, this is what we're living right now.
00:16:16.485 --> 00:16:18.566
Like, where do I find that middle ground?
00:16:18.905 --> 00:16:22.115
Where can I not get fired?" Yeah.
00:16:22.365 --> 00:16:29.115
Like, like he was talking about, like Chase was talking about, but still keep my job and stick to what I know is good- is good teaching.
00:16:29.436 --> 00:16:32.015
And so she sent
it to me, and that was like two weeks ago.
00:16:32.355 --> 00:16:47.476
and it just touched me so greatly that I sent it again, like I do Vanessa's podcast link to all of the teachers that I know with me in my cohort at another school that we work with they listened to it.
00:16:47.756 --> 00:17:00.486
And so on Tuesday, just this last Tuesday, I had my monthly meeting with my group of teachers at my cohort, and of course that's what they wanted to talk about, like they're struggling with the new math curriculum.
00:17:00.756 --> 00:17:12.287
Just feeling the weight of not being able to, you know, teaching is an art, and not being able to show that in their classroom and be responsive to what their kids need.
00:17:12.596 --> 00:17:27.267
So I told them about your podcast, and I shared it with them, talked to them at how amazing you are and so much that I have learned about, math anxiety in the classroom and not wanting to cause further trauma to our students.
00:17:27.626 --> 00:17:41.646
And after that meeting was over, I go to my computer, and I have an email from Julie Graham, who's the director of Cotsen, and she is letting me know that I'm gonna be introducing someone at the conference on Saturday.
00:17:41.656 --> 00:17:42.166
Okay.
00:17:42.227 --> 00:17:43.933
And It's your name.
00:17:44.054 --> 00:17:45.273
Oh my God.
00:17:45.273 --> 00:17:57.144
And I'm gonna start crying because I Literally, you have been in the topic of conversation for the last maybe the last year of my life as a fellow.
00:17:57.335 --> 00:17:57.394
Oh my gosh.
00:17:57.394 --> 00:18:00.335
But the last two weeks you've come up often.
00:18:00.734 --> 00:18:13.914
And so for me to go and sit in front of my computer after I just talked about this podcast and what it has done for me, and to know that first of all that you were gonna be at the conference, I started freaking out just knowing you were gonna be here.
00:18:14.224 --> 00:18:21.688
And then I get the email like,"Oh, you're gonna introduce her." And Julie has no idea about this connection that I've had with you over the last year.
00:18:21.688 --> 00:18:22.279
There are no coincidences.
00:18:22.279 --> 00:18:23.019
That's what I always say.
00:18:23.019 --> 00:18:23.664
There is not.
00:18:24.285 --> 00:18:24.865
Uh-huh.
00:18:24.901 --> 00:18:30.691
And I think we all have points in our career to where we question, like,"Am I doing what I'm supposed to be doing?
00:18:30.701 --> 00:18:33.881
Was I the right person chosen for this coaching position?" Yeah.
00:18:33.941 --> 00:18:46.161
and to see your name pop up, I think was just confirmation for me, like,"Trista, you're exactly where you're supposed to be, doing exactly what you're supposed to be doing," and advocating for these teachers and in turn advocating for students.
00:18:46.651 --> 00:18:50.280
And I was just so honored to be able to introduce you today-
00:18:50.310 --> 00:18:50.921
Oh my God
00:18:51.631 --> 00:18:52.009
and to meet you.
00:18:52.009 --> 00:18:52.065
Yes.
00:18:52.741 --> 00:18:53.981
And you did an amazing job.
00:18:53.981 --> 00:18:54.571
It was like the nicest-
00:18:54.571 --> 00:18:54.791
Oh, thank you
00:18:54.791 --> 00:18:55.602
introduction ever.
00:18:55.932 --> 00:18:56.892
So much hype.
00:18:57.442 --> 00:18:59.469
that obviously means so much to me.
00:18:59.491 --> 00:19:05.392
And I feel like we're all, in this world and in this space- like, doing different parts of the work.
00:19:05.422 --> 00:19:06.051
Do you know what I mean?
00:19:06.051 --> 00:19:28.612
Like, it's like- you know, and, like, sure, I have a podcast and I'm, like, always, like, ranting and blabbing, but it really is an honor for, for me to even know that it's in, beyond it being entertaining- that it's in any way, like, helpful in terms of actually, like you said, like, honing your craft and feeling like you have, not permission because you don't need me to give you that, but, the...
00:19:28.632 --> 00:19:29.521
what's the word?
00:19:29.531 --> 00:19:31.811
Like, not motivation'cause it's not that.
00:19:31.811 --> 00:19:33.182
Well, it's like, it's an encouragement.
00:19:33.182 --> 00:19:35.061
Yeah, the encouragement to keep going.
00:19:35.061 --> 00:19:41.092
And what you said about these bracelets, too, in your session is that a lot of times we stand in that room by ourselves.
00:19:41.102 --> 00:19:41.402
Yeah.
00:19:41.642 --> 00:19:42.112
You know?
00:19:42.122 --> 00:19:51.432
We're in that room with stud- we're in with students, but we in a sense are alone in that we are the only teacher in that room.
00:19:51.852 --> 00:20:02.882
And so to know that I can look at this and say I have a community of math, not just math teachers, but of educators that are telling me, do what's right for kids.
00:20:03.741 --> 00:20:07.221
Like, be responsive to what's happening in front of you.
00:20:07.672 --> 00:20:21.162
And if that just means, like, I push off that curriculum lesson for the day because I have a student in front of me that, needs more support or that needs to be pushed, and that's not in my lesson for today, then, then that's what this reminds me of.
00:20:21.832 --> 00:20:22.392
Oh my God.
00:20:22.461 --> 00:20:23.242
Can you just come with me?
00:20:23.242 --> 00:20:25.125
That's what you're doing for
00:20:25.321 --> 00:20:26.571
That means so much
00:20:26.571 --> 00:20:26.699
for teachers.
00:20:26.699 --> 00:20:26.891
So thank you.
00:20:26.891 --> 00:20:27.882
'Cause, I mean, I also feel...
00:20:27.882 --> 00:20:28.251
Thank you.
00:20:28.261 --> 00:20:29.132
That means so much.
00:20:29.192 --> 00:20:30.582
I mean, I often think that too.
00:20:30.592 --> 00:20:31.832
Like, I'm like- what am I doing?
00:20:31.832 --> 00:20:32.991
Or, like, yeah, is this...
00:20:32.991 --> 00:20:35.801
I think we all question that at different points in our lives.
00:20:36.061 --> 00:20:46.902
And I actually think that's really good in a way, because one thing, I'm, not
in the session you went to, but the session before, I talk about our definitions of success and failure and how they should grow and change as we grow and change.
00:20:47.172 --> 00:20:52.392
And something we may have wanted and have achieved might no longer align with who we are.
00:20:52.402 --> 00:20:52.932
Exactly.
00:20:52.942 --> 00:21:00.402
So I actually think it's really, like, important to be reflective, and I think if you're questioning whether or not you're meant to be where you are, it doesn't mean you're not meant to be where you are.
00:21:00.711 --> 00:21:09.152
It means that you have the wherewithal to be reflective and to take a look around and to see the forest for the trees, and to just make sure...
00:21:09.172 --> 00:21:10.092
It's like a check-in, right?
00:21:10.092 --> 00:21:13.281
You wanna check in to be like,"Am I still doing what's aligned with me?" Yes.
00:21:13.301 --> 00:21:13.571
Great.
00:21:13.622 --> 00:21:17.009
But if you don't do that check-in, you just end up following the motions.
00:21:17.009 --> 00:21:20.509
Like, before you know it, you're like,"Oh my God, it's been 10 years and I'm doing this thing that doesn't align."
00:21:20.538 --> 00:21:20.969
Exactly.
00:21:21.019 --> 00:21:24.469
And I mean, that, this kind of almost ties in in a way to, like, everything you're saying.
00:21:24.479 --> 00:21:31.628
I actually wanna ask you, since you're actually dealing with this, and you're dealing with educators who feel so frustrated by the, this curriculum conflict.
00:21:32.189 --> 00:21:33.388
It's kind of the same thing, right?
00:21:33.388 --> 00:21:38.868
If we just start following, if we just start being like, fine, we're following with fidelity, we're not, when we're not thinking, right?
00:21:38.909 --> 00:21:44.318
Like, when we're not using the free will that we have access to, we, we risk being out of alignment.
00:21:44.368 --> 00:21:44.709
That's right.
00:21:44.729 --> 00:21:49.108
And then we risk being frustrated and feeling like we're not fulfilling our purpose as educators.
00:21:49.409 --> 00:21:55.259
How, what's some advice do you have for educators who are feeling like,"I've gotta follow this curriculum with fidelity.
00:21:55.499 --> 00:22:04.358
I'm not allowed to bring any of myself to teaching." And I love how you said it, the art of teaching, the practice I've honed- is something I can no longer be creative with.
00:22:04.378 --> 00:22:05.128
What do you say?
00:22:05.469 --> 00:22:06.048
What do you do?
00:22:06.548 --> 00:22:10.078
I think recently I've learned just the word fidelity.
00:22:10.199 --> 00:22:12.161
Can you really have fidelity in anything if it's-
00:22:12.161 --> 00:22:12.246
Like,
00:22:12.246 --> 00:22:13.818
what does that even mean?
00:22:13.818 --> 00:22:14.858
Yeah, if it's being done by a human.
00:22:15.288 --> 00:22:15.959
Oh, wow.
00:22:15.959 --> 00:22:18.709
Like, if it's being done by a human, can you really have fidelity in it?
00:22:18.749 --> 00:22:19.778
Because as a human-
00:22:19.778 --> 00:22:20.961
What's the definition of fidelity?
00:22:20.961 --> 00:22:21.434
Ooh, wait.
00:22:21.434 --> 00:22:21.672
Yeah.
00:22:21.672 --> 00:22:23.092
I might be able to help.
00:22:23.092 --> 00:22:24.454
We got our fact checker over here.
00:22:24.454 --> 00:22:25.040
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
00:22:25.040 --> 00:22:25.237
But,
00:22:25.237 --> 00:22:26.939
I mean- Oh, glass of wine is almost empty.
00:22:26.969 --> 00:22:27.638
Yeah, yeah.
00:22:29.878 --> 00:22:30.348
We're all adults.
00:22:30.388 --> 00:22:35.249
You're asking a human being to present a curriculum to fidelity.
00:22:35.548 --> 00:22:38.608
But as a human, I'm bringing all of my lived experiences.
00:22:39.398 --> 00:22:43.209
I'm bringing everything that I am as a person.
00:22:43.608 --> 00:22:49.338
There's no way that that curriculum is gonna be presented with fidelity.
00:22:49.338 --> 00:22:49.551
What does it mean?
00:22:49.551 --> 00:22:49.923
Tamra?
00:22:50.502 --> 00:22:51.249
Got the fact-checking.
00:22:51.261 --> 00:22:51.594
Okay.
00:22:51.785 --> 00:22:57.939
Fidelity means the quality of being faithful, loyal, or exact in reproducing an original.
00:22:58.038 --> 00:22:58.439
Yes.
00:22:58.479 --> 00:23:00.449
Okay, this is making it even more fucked.
00:23:00.449 --> 00:23:00.798
Yeah.
00:23:01.038 --> 00:23:03.128
So to me it's like, do you want a robot?
00:23:03.628 --> 00:23:04.159
Because to me-
00:23:04.159 --> 00:23:07.318
Do you Well, this is so funny, all the conversations that are anti-AI.
00:23:07.409 --> 00:23:08.108
Yes, exactly.
00:23:08.108 --> 00:23:15.118
And now we're, oh my, okay, wait, so the exactness with which a copy, sound, picture, or translation matches the original.
00:23:15.489 --> 00:23:24.159
So you, oh, that makes sense, high fidelity- Yes in audio is, like, reproduces audio or images very closely to the live source.
00:23:24.568 --> 00:23:25.838
Okay, so hold on.
00:23:25.838 --> 00:23:26.929
This is a great point.
00:23:26.939 --> 00:23:28.199
So that completely takes art out of the picture.
00:23:28.489 --> 00:23:28.769
Well, you can't.
00:23:28.769 --> 00:23:30.259
Like, and humanity.
00:23:31.298 --> 00:23:31.382
You're a photocopier.
00:23:31.382 --> 00:23:31.409
Exactly.
00:23:31.409 --> 00:23:32.878
So I'm a human.
00:23:32.878 --> 00:23:39.278
Like, I can't do anything with fidelity- if I am bringing my whole self.
00:23:39.778 --> 00:23:39.939
And-
00:23:39.939 --> 00:23:41.618
Even if you were bringing a little of yourself.
00:23:42.028 --> 00:23:42.199
Exactly.
00:23:42.199 --> 00:23:43.048
That's what I mean.
00:23:43.048 --> 00:23:49.388
So, so when I hear administrators or anybody, and even me, I mean, I'm guilty of it.
00:23:49.419 --> 00:23:53.499
Before I knew, like, I would be like,"Oh, my district said I have to do this to fidelity.
00:23:53.499 --> 00:23:56.318
That's what I need to do." But, like, I didn't even know what I was saying.
00:23:56.388 -->
00:24:04.192
Like, there's never anything that can be done with fidelity, if we're talking about a human connection and a human experience as teaching.
00:24:04.491 --> 00:24:05.521
Drop the mic.
00:24:05.541 --> 00:24:06.961
Except do not touch your microphone.
00:24:06.961 --> 00:24:07.291
Okay.
00:24:07.291 --> 00:24:11.761
Okay, this is such Like, I don't know how I've not thought of this, but I have not thought of this before.
00:24:11.761 --> 00:24:13.961
Like- that is such a good point.
00:24:13.971 --> 00:24:22.221
So, so then I'm, like, kind of like,"Okay, hold on, so what the fuck are they wanting here?" Like, you, why hire, why even go to teacher's college?
00:24:22.231 --> 00:24:22.991
Exactly.
00:24:23.031 --> 00:24:26.192
You could just hire, like, somebody to work an assembly line, essentially.
00:24:26.201 --> 00:24:26.231
Yes.
00:24:26.541 --> 00:24:28.011
'Cause you just want them to read a script.
00:24:28.041 --> 00:24:28.461
Yes.
00:24:28.501 --> 00:24:30.882
But so, so what is, what is the balance here?
00:24:31.250 --> 00:24:35.632
What's, like, a version of fidelity Well, first of all, I think we should stop saying that word.
00:24:35.642 --> 00:24:36.241
Yeah.
00:24:36.741 --> 00:24:38.582
Which it, you're right.
00:24:38.781 --> 00:24:39.112
Right?
00:24:39.142 --> 00:24:39.372
Like-
00:24:39.382 --> 00:24:39.811
You're right
00:24:39.811 --> 00:24:40.721
What are we meaning?
00:24:40.771 --> 00:24:42.152
Like, what should we mean?
00:24:42.172 --> 00:24:44.511
What's, what- what do you coach teachers to do?
00:24:44.521 --> 00:24:48.332
'Cause it's like, okay, so they need to fo- Okay, I don't, I wanna stop using the word need.
00:24:48.332 --> 00:24:50.862
The, the call to action is to follow the curriculum.
00:24:50.922 --> 00:24:51.251
Yes.
00:24:51.959 --> 00:25:04.209
So if the call to action is to follow the curriculum, the way that I'm following th- the curriculum in my class might look very different from the way Tamra is following the curriculum in her class, depending on the students that are sitting in front of her.
00:25:04.719 --> 00:25:22.009
And so I still feel because it's, teaching is a human art form, I have to put some of myself in it, and I can follow a curriculum, but still be able to add my art to it.
00:25:22.459 --> 00:25:26.308
My friend Allison Mello always says,"The curriculum is the chicken-"
00:25:26.499 --> 00:25:26.778
Yes
00:25:26.828 --> 00:25:30.449
but we, like, bring the spice." So it's like you're still making chicken.
00:25:30.769 --> 00:25:30.838
Like, you're gonna- I heard that episode.
00:25:30.838 --> 00:25:30.878
I heard that podcast.
00:25:30.878 --> 00:25:30.888
Right?
00:25:30.888 --> 00:25:30.929
It's a good one.
00:25:30.929 --> 00:25:35.558
Whenever she And I was like,"Oh, my God, I really like that." I'm sorry.
00:25:38.449 --> 00:25:38.628
Yes.
00:25:38.659 --> 00:25:38.959
Right?
00:25:38.999 --> 00:25:42.108
Or, like, someone might need, you were saying, you're still
gonna have a salad.
00:25:42.249 --> 00:25:42.699
Yeah.
00:25:42.878 --> 00:25:43.528
Did I say that?
00:25:43.588 --> 00:25:47.179
You in, in the podcast that I heard- you, you were talking about salad.
00:25:47.179 --> 00:25:47.324
Okay.
00:25:47.324 --> 00:25:48.196
Yeah, I do love a salad.
00:25:48.196 --> 00:25:49.719
Some people might need Chinese chicken salad.
00:25:49.749 --> 00:25:52.509
Some people might need a Santa Fe chicken salad.
00:25:52.528 --> 00:25:57.878
Some pe- people might not be able to have chicken at all in their salad, but they're still gonna have the salad.
00:25:57.888 --> 00:25:59.398
I don't think I said any of this.
00:25:59.669 --> 00:25:59.919
Did I?
00:26:00.388 --> 00:26:00.898
Yes.
00:26:00.979 --> 00:26:01.479
Oh, my God.
00:26:01.479 --> 00:26:02.578
I'm gonna go listen to this.
00:26:02.598 --> 00:26:05.419
This might have been,'cause I like to listen to archived episodes.
00:26:05.419 --> 00:26:05.981
Yeah, this could've been.
00:26:05.981 --> 00:26:06.404
Like, old episodes.
00:26:06.404 --> 00:26:06.969
This could have happened.
00:26:06.969 --> 00:26:07.509
I love this.
00:26:07.509 --> 00:26:09.288
I love that you know me better than I know myself.
00:26:09.628 --> 00:26:13.769
Okay, so, so this is interesting though because I'm also, like, just, like, thinking about this on a deeper level.
00:26:13.769 --> 00:26:17.568
I'm like, okay, so did this Is this new?
00:26:18.068 --> 00:26:20.138
Like, all of this, like, all of a sudden people really cracking...
00:26:20.138 --> 00:26:20.828
Did, has this always...
00:26:21.048 --> 00:26:24.388
'Cause just so you know, by the way, I've mentioned this on previous episodes, but I'll say again.
00:26:24.648 --> 00:26:26.489
In Canada, we do not have curriculum.
00:26:26.669 --> 00:26:27.112
Yes, I've-
00:26:27.112 --> 00:26:27.598
In this way.
00:26:27.598 --> 00:26:27.919
Right?
00:26:27.919 --> 00:26:28.618
Like, we, we don't-
00:26:28.618 --> 00:26:29.249
I have heard you say that.
00:26:29.288 --> 00:26:29.538
Yeah.
00:26:29.538 --> 00:26:29.578
Yeah.
00:26:29.578 --> 00:26:31.568
So we just, like, the, we're not standardized testing.
00:26:31.568 --> 00:26:32.098
Or standardized testing.
00:26:32.189 --> 00:26:32.368
Yeah.
00:26:32.479 --> 00:26:35.788
When we use the word curriculum in Canada, we mean content.
00:26:35.878 --> 00:26:36.528
Oh, you mean content.
00:26:36.528 --> 00:26:36.808
That's right.
00:26:36.808 --> 00:26:38.679
So it's like what's in the curriculum?
00:26:38.788 --> 00:26:41.167
Adding fractions is in the curriculum.
00:26:41.180 --> 00:26:43.318
The Ontario curriculum has fractions in it, right?
00:26:43.558 --> 00:26:50.308
So you don't, and you, you go to teachers college, and then you go into the classroom, and there's worksheets and there's some ti- you can teach however you want.
00:26:50.388 --> 00:26:51.872
You just teach however you want.
00:26:51.872 --> 00:26:53.509
So you actually have an art of teaching.
00:26:53.558 --> 00:26:53.878
You have an...
00:26:53.959 --> 00:27:02.509
But what's funny is when I started learning about curriculum in America, I was like,"Oh, my God, that sounds so convenient." Like, in, in Ontario- Yes like, we, you gotta make all your own lesson plans, whatever.
00:27:02.509 --> 00:27:02.778
Yes.
00:27:02.778 --> 00:27:05.118
But then I slowly realized it's a slippery slope.
00:27:05.128 --> 00:27:05.348
Yes,
00:27:05.358 --> 00:27:05.638
it is.
00:27:05.638 --> 00:27:10.179
Because actually you're not allowed to do anything at all.
00:27:10.189 --> 00:27:12.479
You have to just follow this thing and become this robot.
00:27:12.739 --> 00:27:13.128
Yes.
00:27:13.378 --> 00:27:20.689
And then it is an art, and most educators go into educating because they are creatives, they are healers.
00:27:20.699 --> 00:27:20.729
Yes.
00:27:20.729 --> 00:27:21.769
That's what we do.
00:27:21.778 --> 00:27:27.098
We are these social beings with empathy- Yes who care and care about the student.
00:27:27.108 --> 00:27:27.479
Yes.
00:27:27.499 --> 00:27:31.239
And that is the complete opposite from being an actor who wants to read a script.
00:27:31.288 --> 00:27:32.098
Exactly.
00:27:32.278 --> 00:27:37.679
And so now I think you understand why so many educators feel unseen.
00:27:37.699 --> 00:27:38.019
Yeah.
00:27:38.519 --> 00:27:48.548
Unheard, unsupported, because truly their identity and wanting to care for the reason why they went into teaching on the first pla- in the first place is being taken from them.
00:27:48.558 --> 00:27:49.749
This is so crazy.
00:27:49.888 --> 00:27:51.328
So, can, is this new?
00:27:51.578 --> 00:27:52.929
Like, has it always been like this?
00:27:52.929 --> 00:27:53.989
I th-
00:27:54.449 --> 00:27:54.855
It goes in waves.
00:27:54.855 --> 00:27:54.871
Yeah.
00:27:54.871 --> 00:27:54.934
It goes in waves.
00:27:54.934 --> 00:27:54.951
Okay.
00:27:54.951 --> 00:28:18.548
It goes in waves, and I feel like With the pressure of standardized testing and scores, which goes back to funding and money, the pressure becomes more enduring those times of like"oh my gosh, we're not meeting our, you know, our growth target." and so this curriculum, everybody has to do it.
00:28:18.648 --> 00:28:23.939
That way, the district or the administration can say,"Well, we've done our part.
00:28:24.169 --> 00:28:29.449
Everybody has the same exact, like everybody's delivering the same lesson.""We're doing...
00:28:29.459 --> 00:28:31.009
So it can't be us."
00:28:31.068 --> 00:28:31.648
I get it.
00:28:31.659 --> 00:28:33.519
I just had such an epiphany.
00:28:33.519 --> 00:28:36.759
That probably everyone else already knows, but I realize what's happening.
00:28:36.868 --> 00:28:37.308
Yes.
00:28:37.308 --> 00:28:43.368
I'm like, so basically it's like test scores are low, so the solution is let's standardize everything.
00:28:43.449 --> 00:28:43.778
Yes.
00:28:43.858 --> 00:28:44.739
So it's like, okay, fine.
00:28:44.828 -->
00:28:45.588
Test scores are low.
00:28:45.778 --> 00:28:47.378
Everyone just read this script.
00:28:47.378 --> 00:28:47.709
Yes.
00:28:47.769 --> 00:28:52.038
Get kids to do the exact same thing, and then everyone's on a, quote, unquote,"equal playing field." Yes.
00:28:52.058 --> 00:28:53.179
We know it doesn't work that way.
00:28:53.229 --> 00:28:53.608
Yes.
00:28:53.608 --> 00:28:55.848
But it's like, right, it's like, it's like we, we...
00:28:56.219 --> 00:29:02.528
Then exactly, we've done our part because- Yeah everyone's reading from the exact same book- Exactly and doing the exact same thing.
00:29:02.788 --> 00:29:05.489
But it's like such a misunderstanding of the problem.
00:29:06.169 --> 00:29:08.138
Cause like test scores are not low.
00:29:08.409 --> 00:29:14.288
I mean, because by that theory then, the theory is that test scores are low because there's variety in teaching.
00:29:14.348 --> 00:29:15.169
Exactly.
00:29:15.368 --> 00:29:19.058
And because some teachers are not teaching properly, let's say.
00:29:19.068 --> 00:29:19.749
Yes, that's correct.
00:29:20.098 --> 00:29:23.739
But the truth is test scores are low for so many other reasons.
00:29:23.878 --> 00:29:30.949
Some of those reasons, one of the major reasons being that we are teaching too homogeneously- That's right in the first place, and not every kid can learn the same way.
00:29:30.959 --> 00:29:31.628
Exactly.
00:29:31.638 --> 00:29:32.098
Am I right?
00:29:32.098 --> 00:29:32.939
I'm just yelling at this.
00:29:32.939 --> 00:29:32.965
That,
00:29:32.965 --> 00:29:32.991
no.
00:29:32.991 --> 00:29:33.019
Okay.
00:29:33.019 --> 00:29:33.709
That is correct.
00:29:33.778 --> 00:29:35.409
And you're exactly correct.
00:29:35.419 --> 00:29:35.439
Yeah.
00:29:36.118 --> 00:29:39.638
So the solution to that is what you guys are doing, in a way.
00:29:40.138 --> 00:29:42.078
Like, p- part of the solution.
00:29:42.088 --> 00:29:42.209
Yes.
00:29:42.209 --> 00:29:42.759
Yeah, yeah.
00:29:42.808 --> 00:29:42.999
Yes.
00:29:42.999 --> 00:29:48.659
Which is being able to teach the curriculum while pulling on these individual threads of what might work with your students.
00:29:48.669 --> 00:29:49.588
Exactly.
00:29:49.898 --> 00:29:59.239
Or having the freedom, which even some districts are not even allowed to have the freedom to say like,"Let me look at this curriculum and use it as a resource."
00:29:59.328 --> 00:29:59.709
Oh.
00:29:59.709 --> 00:30:06.739
Or like, maybe I m- might wanna pull this lesson because this is something my, you know, this fraction lesson, my kids are really struggling.
00:30:07.108 --> 00:30:11.598
but you know, they're doing really well in, you know, associative property.
00:30:11.608 --> 00:30:14.479
And so I won't need, I don't need that lesson.
00:30:14.909 --> 00:30:23.618
But when it, when districts are asking you to do things in fidelity, it's like you're not being responsive to the kids that are in front of you and what they need.
00:30:23.638 --> 00:30:42.598
And so I think if teachers knew that they had the permission to be creative and pick and choose things that they know will work for the kids that are in front of them, That that is where I think we need to start.
00:30:42.659 --> 00:30:46.338
But unfortunately, that takes a district releasing control.
00:30:47.509 --> 00:30:47.808
Right?
00:30:47.848 --> 00:30:50.878
That means they have to be able to trust the teacher.
00:30:50.888 --> 00:31:03.598
They have to be able to trust the educator, that the educator's gonna make wise choices and do what's right for kids, and I think that's really hard for a district to do when- With the pressure with the pressure- Yeah of scores.
00:31:04.078 --> 00:31:09.469
So can you say something to the teacher right now who's listening, who's, like, yelling at this podcast being like-"that's me.
00:31:09.759 --> 00:31:11.969
I'm being told to follow the curriculum with fidelity.
00:31:11.979 --> 00:31:12.818
What the fuck do I do?" Yeah.
00:31:12.828 --> 00:31:15.558
"Like, tell me what to do." What's one thing you would say?
00:31:16.058 --> 00:32:02.516
I would say, number one, make sure that you have a community of other teachers that are with you, that it's not something that you are doing by yourself but that you have a group of teachers that are going to be on the front lines with you and saying,"This is what we're gonna do together." And be an advocate for your students because, to me, how can you say no to what a teacher is doing when, like, if I had my principal come into my room and say, for example, I was supposed to be on lesson 15, you know, module two on that day, which is what a lot of districts are asking for, right, that we're all on the same lesson the same day.
00:32:02.965 --> 00:32:09.195
but she walks into my room, or he walks into my room, and sees students, not on that lesson.
00:32:09.266 --> 00:32:12.385
However, they are engaged in mathematical discourse.
00:32:12.836 --> 00:32:14.715
There's joy in the learning.
00:32:15.086 --> 00:32:21.125
They are asking questions about the mathematical practices that are happening in front of them.
00:32:21.395 --> 00:32:23.056
They're encouraging one another.
00:32:23.056 --> 00:32:32.135
Like, I don't see any principal or administrator walking into my classroom, seeing that, and saying,"Why aren't you on lesson 15, day th-" Like-
00:32:32.165 --> 00:32:32.566
Right
00:32:32.596 --> 00:32:36.885
so to me, it's the, the teaching that needs to speak for itself.
00:32:37.786 --> 00:32:43.576
If they're gonna trust us to do what we know is right for kids, then when they walk into our room, they have to see that happening.
00:32:43.576 --> 00:32:43.875
Yeah.
00:32:44.236 --> 00:32:46.226
Well, this has been so amazing.
00:32:46.226 --> 00:32:55.715
Can I ask you if there's anything, just because this is kind of how we started, for, for teachers listening, are there any episodes of ours that you were like,"You need to listen
to this one." Like, if you were gonna recommend one.
00:32:55.726 --> 00:32:57.715
Are there any Math Therapy things you think they should try?
00:32:57.715 --> 00:33:00.496
Like, tell me any of that before we end today.
00:33:00.675 --> 00:33:01.026
So-
00:33:01.036 --> 00:33:02.746
Like, what has kind of moved the dial for you?
00:33:02.776 --> 00:33:02.925
I
00:33:02.925 --> 00:33:03.061
think-
00:33:03.061 --> 00:33:04.605
Just'cause I also wanna know I'm making a difference.
00:33:04.685 --> 00:33:05.046
Okay.
00:33:05.046 --> 00:33:05.066
Of course.
00:33:05.066 --> 00:33:06.615
This is kind of for my own validation, to be honest.
00:33:06.615 --> 00:33:09.855
Well, of course, and I would love to affirm and validate you.
00:33:10.105 --> 00:33:13.556
I, because it's truly gonna come from a place from my heart.
00:33:13.586 --> 00:33:19.395
So when I started listening to your podcast, it was really for my teachers.
00:33:19.405 --> 00:33:19.695
Yeah.
00:33:19.705 --> 00:33:22.445
Like, what can I take from you that I can share with them?
00:33:22.826 --> 00:33:32.346
What I've learned is that anxiety is anxiety, and it can transfer- Not just to math, but to real world just life.
00:33:32.786 --> 00:33:40.145
And so a lot of things that you talk about in your podcast are not just specific to math, but living life.
00:33:40.526 --> 00:33:48.786
And I've even helped, like, when you talk about confirmation bias, like, that is so true in all identities of our lives- right?
00:33:48.816 --> 00:33:50.066
Not just in our math identity.
00:33:50.066 --> 00:33:50.306
Yeah.
00:33:50.655 --> 00:33:57.776
but even with my daughter, I have a 10-year-old who struggles, a lot with her, she doesn't like school.
00:33:57.905 --> 00:33:59.205
"I hate going to school, Mommy.
00:33:59.205 --> 00:34:00.036
I don't like it.
00:34:00.046 --> 00:34:01.046
I don't have friends.
00:34:01.056 --> 00:34:18.976
I'm not good at it." And so something that I learned fr- and I can't think of the title right now, but that I learned from your podcast really is, like, we need to, and even I think you mentioned it today, is take whatever those negative, that negative thoughts that are happening and replace them with something positive.
00:34:18.976 --> 00:34:29.775
So instead of when you come home, instead of telling me all of the bad things that happened in your day, let's start with two good things first- and then we can go to what, you know, you wanna tell me about.
00:34:29.775 --> 00:34:36.846
But that came from listening to you, listening to you talk about math and the trauma and anxiety that happens around math.
00:34:36.916 --> 00:34:40.275
So it's so transferable into our daily lives.
00:34:40.606 --> 00:34:41.646
I think that's number one.
00:34:41.646 --> 00:35:00.856
Number two, the podcast with Chase, and I think that's just because it's fresh in my mind, and then the follow-up that you did just recently in September because I think a lot of us struggle with that balance of- What we in, you know, the United States call curriculum and then doing what we know is right for kids and what really is good math teaching.
00:35:01.126 --> 00:35:10.755
So that is the one that I shared with all of my teachers, and, I had a group, another Cotsen mentor who does what I do but at a different school.
00:35:11.135 --> 00:35:14.346
She sat down all of their tea- and they all listened to it together.
00:35:14.476 --> 00:35:17.166
They listened to your podcast together as part of their meeting.
00:35:17.295 --> 00:35:17.655
Okay, stop.
00:35:17.655 --> 00:35:25.666
So, like, they were like,"Oh my gosh, Trista, you sent us that, you sent us that link, and we listened to Vanessa, and we loved her," so they all came and saw you today, too.
00:35:25.996 --> 00:35:26.619
Because, um-
00:35:26.619 --> 00:35:28.005
Thank you for being my greatest hype woman ever.
00:35:28.005 --> 00:35:28.545
I know.
00:35:29.338 --> 00:35:29.699
Okay.
00:35:29.708 --> 00:35:31.596
But yeah that's what I can think of right now.
00:35:31.615 --> 00:35:31.945
Well, thank you.
00:35:31.945 --> 00:35:32.536
But you're amazing.
00:35:32.545 --> 00:35:33.635
You're so amazing.
00:35:33.655 --> 00:35:38.005
I mean, just, I feel so lucky for the teachers that get to work with you.
00:35:38.206 --> 00:35:38.885
Oh, you're so kind.
00:35:38.885 --> 00:35:38.905
Thank you.
00:35:38.905 --> 00:35:38.925
You know?
00:35:38.925 --> 00:35:40.496
And, I mean- Right?
00:35:40.545 --> 00:35:46.545
Like, it just, it just, I mean, first of all, it's such a beautiful, I know this isn't, like, we're not here to, like, prop up, like, Cotsen Foundation.
00:35:46.567 --> 00:35:56.666
But it's, it's really cool to see a program that, um, c- like, values and understands that professional growth and any type of growth needs consistency and long-term.
00:35:56.666 --> 00:36:01.255
I mean, we we can always go to a one-and-done PD and be inspired, and change can come from that.
00:36:01.255 --> 00:36:10.525
So I'm not out here, I actually think, I think there's power in all, whatever we can access there's power, but what great power to be able to work with you- consistently over two years.
00:36:10.525 --> 00:36:12.795
And I'm so glad you found me.
00:36:13.115 --> 00:36:13.869
I'm so glad I did, too.
00:36:13.869 --> 00:36:14.601
And I'm glad to find Intervention.
00:36:14.907 --> 00:36:16.936
Okay, the two final questions I ask everybody.
00:36:16.938 --> 00:36:19.864
You have 30 seconds to answer each one, but this isn't a timed test, so, like, whatever.
00:36:19.905 --> 00:36:21.994
But you ask everybody on your podcast.
00:36:21.994 --> 00:36:22.268
Yeah.
00:36:22.291 --> 00:36:23.248
So I think I know the questions.
00:36:23.277 --> 00:36:23.322
Okay.
00:36:23.615 --> 00:36:24.396
But no, go ahead.
00:36:24.896 --> 00:36:28.585
Oh my gosh, every- Okay, so question number one, if someone was like,"Wow, you're so cool.
00:36:28.585 --> 00:36:33.585
Love it all," whatever,
but, like, yeah, just,"I'm not a math person, so I'm never gonna be good at math," what would you say?
00:36:34.085 --> 00:36:35.976
I would say,"What makes you think that?"
00:36:36.476 --> 00:36:38.025
Someone was at my session today.
00:36:38.175 --> 00:36:38.186
Ah.
00:36:38.686 --> 00:36:39.782
I love that.
00:36:39.782 --> 00:36:41.065
I love that.
00:36:41.065 --> 00:36:41.606
Thank you.
00:36:41.615 --> 00:36:47.496
What experience in, in your life that have happened that make you think that you're not a math person?
00:36:47.925 --> 00:36:48.126
Love it.
00:36:48.126 --> 00:36:48.706
What makes you think that?
00:36:48.755 --> 00:36:49.346
Love it.
00:36:49.385 --> 00:36:49.865
Love it.
00:36:49.896 --> 00:36:50.585
Fucking love it.
00:36:50.815 --> 00:36:54.496
And finally, if there's one thing you could change about the way math is taught in schools, what would it be?
00:36:54.786 --> 00:36:55.755
You can pick one thing.
00:36:55.815 --> 00:36:57.255
A genie will grant you one wish.
00:36:57.315 --> 00:36:59.916
Oh my gosh, about the way math is taught in schools?
00:37:00.416 --> 00:37:06.885
I would probably say I feel like sometimes math is taught in isolation.
00:37:06.885 --> 00:37:08.496
It can be very, like, um-
00:37:08.525 --> 00:37:09.135
Siloed?
00:37:09.215 --> 00:37:10.356
Yeah, siloed.
00:37:10.876 --> 00:37:17.385
And I would love to see us almost approach it as we do, like, a science.
00:37:17.425 --> 00:37:17.806
You know?
00:37:17.806 --> 00:37:30.456
Like, well, math is a science, but, like, how we would approach, like, a science lesson or a biology lesson or a chemistry lesson, where we really start with, like, more, like, that inquiry-based, and we're working collaboratively as a group to solve this problem.
00:37:30.795 --> 00:37:30.891
I love that.
00:37:30.891 --> 00:37:35.706
So really less siloed and more working together as a team.
00:37:35.766 --> 00:37:36.045
Yeah, it's more-
00:37:36.045 --> 00:37:37.545
And maybe even across...
00:37:37.876 --> 00:37:48.119
Like, I'm thinking of, like,'cause I, I used to teach kindergarten and first grade, so I'm thinking of, like, how powerful would it be if my first graders got to go and, and work with Tamra's sixth graders.
00:37:48.554 --> 00:37:49.405
So really, like, look at that.
00:37:49.405 --> 00:37:50.195
Yes.
00:37:50.505 --> 00:37:52.476
Teaching math that way.
00:37:52.485 --> 00:37:52.806
Yeah.
00:37:52.815 --> 00:37:54.806
Like, what, how powerful would that be?
00:37:54.865 --> 00:37:55.925
Like a team sport.
00:37:56.115 --> 00:37:56.516
Yes.
00:37:56.896 --> 00:37:57.715
I love that.
00:37:58.005 --> 00:38:00.876
Um, I, thank you so-
00:38:00.916 --> 00:38:01.646
You are so welcome
00:38:01.655 --> 00:38:03.556
mu- what a, like, what a random, sweet thing.
00:38:03.556 --> 00:38:03.936
I know.
00:38:03.945 --> 00:38:06.585
You're also such a great pod- Like, she's so articulate.
00:38:06.835 --> 00:38:08.795
Like, you were just like- Well, thank you like, you really broke things down.
00:38:08.795 --> 00:38:13.255
I feel like I was really, like, grasping for words, and you just said everything so concisely and perfectly.
00:38:13.255 --> 00:38:14.155
Oh, well, thank you so much, Vanessa.
00:38:17.269 --> 00:38:19.293
Okay, guys, how amazing is Trista?
00:38:19.501 --> 00:38:24.190
Like, first of all, can we just appreciate the fact that we met hours before recording this episode?
00:38:24.389 --> 00:38:25.460
Like, what are the chances?
00:38:25.476 --> 00:38:31.827
And I honestly cannot thank her enough for being so open and honest about what teachers are going through right now.
00:38:32.750 --> 00:38:43.231
One thing I keep coming back to from this conversation is something Trista said,"Teaching is a human art form." And I love that because isn't that what this whole debate really comes down to?
00:38:43.655 --> 00:38:54.695
We're trying to figure out how to give every student the education they deserve, while also recognizing that every student is different, every teacher is different, and learning is a human experience.
00:38:55.338 --> 00:39:03.688
And look, I know there are people listening who disagree with some of what we said today, and I genuinely wanna hear from you because I don't think this is a debate with one simple answer.
00:39:03.940 --> 00:39:11.257
But one thing I hope we can all agree on is that teachers deserve to feel trusted, supported, and empowered to do what's best for their students.
00:39:11.568 --> 00:39:21.539
So whether you're a teacher who's feeling completely shackled by your curriculum, or maybe you're someone who believes strongly in the importance of consistent instruction, I want to know what you think.
00:39:21.543 --> 00:39:22.960
So text us right now.
00:39:23.112 --> 00:39:28.047
You can do that using the link in the show notes, or come join the conversation in our Math Therapy Facebook Group.
00:39:28.677 --> 00:39:35.079
A huge, huge, huge thank you to Trista for this beautiful, completely unexpected conversation, and thank you for listening.
00:39:35.469 --> 00:39:41.255
And I just know there's someone in your life that came to mind while you listened to this episode, so share it with them right now.
00:39:42.286 --> 00:39:48.534
Math Therapy is hosted by me, Vanessa Vakharia, produced by David Kochberg, and the theme music is by our band, Goodnight Sunrise.
00:39:48.960 --> 00:39:49.940
All right, love you guys.
00:39:50.010 --> 00:39:50.938
See you next week.