TRANSKRIPT 🔗
Speaker 1: Welcome to season three of impacted. I'm Rodney Foxworth and I'm here with my cohost Eric Horvath. Today's conversation sits right at the intersection of something that sounds quite technical, but actually touches just about everyone listening, your retirement. Because right now there's a significant shift underway. Firms like Blackstone, Apollo and KKR are making a push into retirement accounts, into the vehicles that millions of people rely on for long-term financial security. And depending on who you ask, this is either a long overdue opening up of investment access or a move that introduces more complexity, higher fees and new risks into a system that was designed to be simple and transparent. So that's what we're unpacking today. Supporters call this democratization. More people getting access to private markets, but critics on the other hand would say access to what exactly and at what cost? To help us sit in that tension, We've got two great guests with us today. Ben Schifrin is director of securities policy at Better Markets. Ben brings a policy and consumer protection lens with a focus on how financial regulation impacts everyday investors in the broader system. We're also joined by Ian Fuller, CEO and co-founder of West Fuller, a values-driven investment advisory firm. Ian thinks a lot about how capital actually gets deployed, how capital impacts people and communities, and how investment structures evolve in practice. Our goal today is straightforward, to understand what's actually changing, who benefits, and whether this shift is ultimately serving the best interests of everyday investors. Let's dig right in.
Speaker 2: All right, Ben, so I'm glad you're here. We want to start with you. what has changed policy wise and why are we seeing this push now?
Speaker 3: I think the biggest change is the Department of Labor's proposed rule or guidance to fiduciaries that's intended to provide them with a so-called safe harbor for investing 401k plan assets in the private markets. Private markets are notoriously more risky than public markets because they don't have the same disclosure requirements that public market assets do. They don't have the same that public market assets do, and they have higher fees than public market assets do. This has made the managers of 401k plans wary of investing in the private markets. There's a push from the administration to open up these private markets to 401k plans. We're seeing that at both the Department of Labor and the SEC, and recently the Department of Labor just came out with a proposed rule to kind of put its thumb on the scale of private market investments and say to fiduciaries, hey, if you follow this process, we're going to give you a safe harbor so you can't be sued, which is what fiduciaries are fearful of. They're fearful of putting their participants in these riskier assets and getting sued if something goes wrong. And so that's the biggest change. There are other changes at the SEC that we can talk about, but that's the one that's getting the most attention.
Speaker 1: Thanks for that, Ben. And I'm curious because you run a values aligned investment shop, an investment firm that works with lot of institutions and obviously have a long career in investment management. I'm just curious about how you're thinking about what these opportunities open up for fund managers and investment advisors and concerns that you might even have.
Speaker 4: Yeah, I think, ⁓ Ronnie, it's a fabulous question. ⁓ anytime I start to hear the democratization of, ⁓ financial solutions to the public, I sort of hair raises on my back, right? Alarm bells start to go off. ⁓ I started my career in sort of traditional finance in wall street 20 plus years ago. And we know this is an industry often that is creating complex products to sell for fees. Right. And so, ⁓ at the time in which this was first sort of clearly introduced, I think it divided administration, I think is when this more ⁓ conservative stance around access to private market solutions within 401k's was first raised ⁓ with a more conservative bent right of sort of recognition that these may not be suitable investments and instruments for working everyday people. ⁓ And sort of see has been rightly noted sort of this ⁓ turnaround, this pendulum swinging over this last year with the new administration. the recent clear rulings from the Department of Labor, putting the finger on the scale has been notes again, ⁓ it creates sort of alarm bells, right? I think we work with institutions that are, of course, using the full gamut of asset classes and fund manager solutions, but have very different investor profiles. These are long-term, often permanent capital. Investors have a very different sense of risk and return objectives. The notion of bringing these complex products down to regular working people sounds putatively right on its surface. Again, this democratization ⁓ principle that we are seeing. And yet at the same time, deeply complex, illiquid, high cost ⁓ investment products don't necessarily lead to better outcomes ⁓ as sort of academic research has long proven. And so for me, I love the notion of it. I don't think we have the right tools, the right vehicles, and certainly not the right policy to support. practical prudent implementation of this and it feels very much like the barbarians are being sort let through the gates ⁓ without sort of the right kind of policy framework to really ensure that 401k holders are ensuring that their long-term retirement security is being met.
Speaker 2: Yeah, I actually want to just tag in Ian to the democratization piece too. I'm sure people on the listeners are familiar with Robinhood or CalStri and the prediction markets. If you look at the rise of Robinhood also really baked into democratizing finance and democratizing trading. And I feel like we're seeing that right now with the prediction markets as well. And similarly, very leery of what
Load full transcript
protections there are for consumers, retail investors. especially thinking about the level of sophistication and opacity, which I think
Speaker 4: that's also touching on.
Speaker 1: Yeah, one of the things I'm just also thinking about too is that, and we'll get to more of this question around quote unquote democratization. But know, this distinction between, as you put it, and as you know, this distinction between institutional investors that have a lot of long-term ⁓ capacity and thinking versus broader retail markets and, you know, Ben, This shifts in terms of like some of the protections that are just being sort of like disregarded at this moment. Can you just, what are we losing? Cause a lot of folks might not realize that are listening to the podcast, might not even know some of the protections that are currently in place and how like the shift changes things.
Speaker 3: Well, I think what you're really losing is the fundamental investor protections of the federal securities laws. This gets a little wonky, but I'll try to explain it as easily as I can. You have to remember that when you're selling securities to the public, that's supposed to be through a registered offering with the SEC that provides investors with a whole slew of information, pretty much all material information that they could possibly need so they can make an informed investment decision. That's the foundation of securities regulation in our country. There were initially envisioned to be so-called private offering exemptions. If you wanted to just go to a narrow slice of people, so-called sophisticated, what we now call accredited investors that could fend for themselves that didn't need those protections, you could do that. But that was supposed to be very now and very limited. Over time, those exemptions have expanded. And so now you can raise as as much. money privately as you can publicly. And that's what's led to this idea. Well, if all these companies are staying private longer, shouldn't retail investors get into that space? But I think that gets it exactly backwards when you're talking about this whole democratization of the private markets, because what you're talking about then is making an offering of a supposedly private investment to the general public. There's really no such thing as a private market investment. that's made to the general public. That is by definition a public offering that should be registered with the SEC and to which investors are entitled to all the disclosures that come with an offering of securities to the
Speaker 1: Yeah, I think that's really great, Ben, in terms of just framing that out for folks because a lot of people probably aren't aware that a lot of accreditation laws, to your point, and the status to be an accredited investor haven't shifted much, which does grow the pie of people who can actually be private market investors. That has led to the massive proliferation in the private markets, whether you're talking about private equity, private credit, venture capital, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. And there is this, you know, been to your point, you know, there are, there are perspectives that, wow, like so many everyday investors are being left out. I mean, you said this are being left out at sort of like the increasing valuation of these opportunities. And we're seeing these sort of massive companies where there's an open AI or anthropic accruing so much value in the private markets and everyday investors by the time they go public, I'm probably going to sort of get the least. amount of the value that are accrued in the public markets. That's the tension that think a lot of people have. I'm curious about how any of you think about that, whether Ian, Ben, or Eric, how you guys sit with that question of that clear distinction that so much is being accrued in a private market that people just don't have access to.
Speaker 2: I mean, I'll just kind of my reaction is, and it makes me think of Ian's comment of like on its face or spiritually, you know, agree with democratization is a good value to have even in the kind of finance and investing space. So this idea of retail investors or a middle-class like one class folks having exposure to ⁓ successful high growth investments in theory, like we would like people to participate. in the rapid growth of our economy. And some of that is, you know, over the last few decades have shifted more away from the public market. So I get it in theory. But like when Ben talks about protections and like regulation, like, like I think that we need to find the combination of both of them understand that they want to participate in growth. But that doesn't mean especially with people that have most at risk and are most vulnerable to if something goes to zero. or something doesn't go well, like what are those protections? And it seems like we're kind of walking back a lot of that in our kind of current 2026 regulatory environment.
Speaker 4: Yeah, I think that's fabulously put Eric. I I will say, feel like I'm particularly attuned to this issue of equity, justice, access and inclusion because these investor protection laws, arguably inadvertently have kept communities, particularly communities of color, communities that have long not had access to wealth and opportunity away from private market solutions. And yet at the very same time, as we think about these tensions swinging to the other way in which we have a fully liberated sort of capital market and private markets specifically that provide sort of vulnerability, if you will, to some of the most complex, most illiquid, most high cost investments doesn't feel like the right solution for their retirement security long term. And so while I embrace it, just as Eric rightly said, embrace the notion conceptually, and certainly a principle that I very much hold on to, it doesn't feel like the right thinking has been put forth and what is the appropriate framework that could support
this if it's appropriate at all. And I think there's also reason for us to question the appropriateness at its core, right? Most private market investments, unfortunately, are not in fact outperforming the S &P 500. We know most active managers are not in fact outperforming the S &P 500. So are we truly providing a product solution through private capital that is in the best interest thinking as a fiduciary for working people across America. I'm not sure that private market solutions on their face are in fact the right solution in this regard, right? If you thought about sort of private equity or venture capital fund managers, it's essentially the top 10 % or so produced 90 % of the overall returns for that asset class. Most investors, and particularly I would say retail investors investing on behalf of their retirement plans, likely won't have access to those top tier managers. And so looking at sort of opportunity costs and risk return profile, quite frankly, a passive indexing strategy more than likely is going to produce better long-term risk adjusted returns for those individuals. And so I think we really have to like grapple with the empirics behind this democratization notion, which frankly just sometimes feels like cover for the private markets industry, the Black Rock, the Blackstones, KKRs, the Apollos of the world. ⁓ to have sort of a field day, if you will, for commercial opportunity. Much like to some degree we're seeing in the private credit market that is really going through its doldrums right now in a very public way.
Speaker 1: Ian, I really appreciate you bringing that up because there's a perspective, I'm not going to say that I hold this perspective, but maybe I do, that is in alignment with you terms of effectively, you could argue that the large scale, in particular, private market asset managers have effectively exhausted like, the endowments, the pensions, like they've exhausted as many institutional investors as possible and they need another source of capital. need more pipeline. need more investment to come in. And I think that is, that's a fundamentally important story. And I think it connects Ian to your point too earlier in terms of we've got this historical context in which Everyday investors, particularly folks of color coming from communities of color have been sort of excluded from opportunities from investing into these things. And, you know, to put it more bluntly, it's almost, from my vantage point, it's almost like, wow, once the big asset managers and private markets has exhausted everything else, they're now coming for like by parents, valuable retirement. And so there's this interesting kind of, you know, contrast, right, like, both on the one hand, excluded from optimizing for wealth on one hand. And then on other hand, now that there's been enough ⁓ exhaustion of capital and investment from ⁓ institutions, let's see what we can get from from, you know, grandparents and parents, right. And so I just I think that's a fascinating thing to hold in this moment that I am racking my brain.
Speaker 2: And before I want to take it to Ben and we want to hear some of your thoughts on this democratization frame before we take it over to that. I piggyback over Ian and Rodney are saying to Ian's point around the, you know, outperforming venture firms, top decile and who has access to those and whatnot. I'm really thinking about, you know, the aunties out there, like who gets stuck holding the bag basically, like if it all goes to zero. Like what is going to happen? like, ⁓ we'd have to have a whole three hour other podcast and we actually think there's another season, another episode around capital, but like, you know, just understanding like how many of those funds do not work out and then like how it's, very different for someone that is an accredited investor that's high net worth and they can absorb those losses. It's very different to be like, what, how is that, you know, Auntie down the street going to be made whole? ⁓ when they're, when they're retirement money is put at that kind of risk in those kind of assets. But Ben, I think we want to also bring it to, back to this democratization kind of theme. And if you have any thoughts around what's maybe misleading or incomplete about this kind of pitch of, know, we're going to democratize all these amazing investments to, to regular folks. Like, how do you feel about that kind of framing of the issue?
Speaker 3: I the most important thing is you have to realize who it is that's making the pitch, right? It's not that retail investors are clamoring for greater access to these liquid, opaque, riskier private market assets. It's that the private funds industry is pushing to get access to retail investors. As was alluded to a moment ago, I think that's partially, if not mostly, because they're traditional sources of funding from institutional investors and high-net-worth individuals. is drying up. I think it was drying up even before the turmoil that we're seeing in especially private credit into a lesser extent private equity. And so they need to have a new source of funding. And so they are turning to retail investors. I ⁓ once saw someone from the private funds industry say or there was reporting that said they view the 12 trillion dollars that Americans have in their retirement accounts as the holy grail. They want to get their hands and I understand why it's a holy girl from their perspective. I just don't understand why that means they should get access to that money that could put retail investors at risk. And so I think when you're talking about this narrative of democratization, well, that's great for the people pushing the narrative. It may not necessarily be as good for the retail investors. And one of the key reasons why, and Ian alluded to this, is retail investors are not necessarily going to be in the same position as the institutional investors and high net worth individuals that have long
had access to the private markets. Think about it from the perspective of a retail investor who, let's say, someone says to them, OK, now you have access to private market investments, go. What are they supposed to do? We at Better Market say, yes, you want more people to be able to save for retirement. by investing in the stock market. Like that's good. I think one of the things we think when you're talking about, well, there aren't the same opportunities for people in the public markets as they used to be. Well, there should be more opportunities in the public markets. Let's just expand the public markets and retail having all these great companies be in the private markets. Cause then people can just invest in the stock market, invest through index funds as Ian said earlier and grow their world that way. But if all of a sudden now you have money, you greats, you've been able to save, you'll be able to invest, you know, and you're being told, go invest in the private markets. Where do you start? How are you going to know to distinguish? Everybody says in terms of democratization, well, why shouldn't retail investors be able to get in on the ground floor of the next Google or Apple or now, know, whatever the hot AI company is, how are they going to know to invest in the one that takes off as opposed to the 99 that fail? If you're an institutional investor, a venture capital fund, you can invest in 100 and if 99 don't pan out, that's okay. You're hoping that the one does, you make all your money that way. But number one, retail investors aren't gonna have enough resources to invest in all 100. They're gonna have to choose one or two. And what are the chances they're gonna be able to identify with the limited disclosure that is involved in the private markets, the one right choice? It sounds great in theory, but I really think about it What would they do? Where would they even start? You know, figuring out which is the right private market asset to invest.
Speaker 1: You know, I want to say something to Ben because you made this comment about, you know, people advocating. want people to be able to invest into the next, you know, Google or, or, or Amazon or Apple. Well, guess what? People used to be able to do that at the ground for it because to your point, Ben, those companies went public far earlier. So you actually could invest in Apple far earlier. can invest in Microsoft far earlier. You can invest in those companies that have become sort of in the US the standard, right, in terms of what does it look like to be growth and also be able to provide ⁓ liquidity to folks. And so I think that's it, that you tying in those pieces is really important. So I appreciate you naming.
Speaker 2: ⁓ yeah, I mean, Ben, there's this one thing that really stood out your opening comment to this one round, who is asking for it. And, you know, Rodney and I like to think, ⁓ we think very like multi interdisciplinary and I'm thinking about like social movements and
people that are clamoring for, ⁓ democracy, politically speaking. And where does that drive, does it come from like me and my neighbor or does it come from the person? who's in power or sitting on top of the hill saying like, yeah, you guys should get, ⁓ some democracy and have some social movements and everything. It certainly comes from, in this example, the retail investors or the individuals. So I really appreciate that frame of like, where is that coming from? Is it democracy by us for us, or is it being kind of onto us? And then this other piece that, I thought was so important is, I really think about how, you know, and to pull out the metaphor more about like democracy and nation building and, you know, civic society is, ⁓ you know, it's, very different to run or win an election versus to govern. And when you talk about like, we, we, it's good, there should be more options. ⁓ but it's like, how do you actually execute that or how does that get operationalized? Because, ⁓ you know, like having those ideals versus it actually being implemented with those values in place. much harder than it sounds.
Speaker 1: Yeah. know, thing I want to, you know, because Ian, I mean, Ben, Ian, you both brought this this topic of risk and who bears the risk in particular. I listen, there's a lot of economic precarity among even accredited investors. I think that's an important part of this to be really clear. It's not, you know, among accredited investors as much as, you know, the the working class. Right. And so, you know, people are pulling. from their 401Ks to make their daily lives function, right? For childcare, for all sorts of things. And so it's a fascinating time to open the floodgates to retail markets or private assets. so, just thinking about the risk that people are gonna be bearing, Ian, would this, do you?
Speaker 4: for watching.
Speaker 1: I would love to hear how you think about that question. mean, because you're, you you're so you sit at this intersection is so amazing, you know, because Eric put up brought up the fact of like social justice and movements. You're so involved in a number. I couldn't even list the amount of things that you're involved in in terms of bringing racial and economic justice and environmental justice, health equity to to communities. And you're also this very thoughtful and values driven. investment advisor and manager. And so when we think about like the question of risk, how do you think about that for people?
Speaker 4: Yeah, I think it's a fabulous question. I want to draw maybe as a starting point back to Ben's point earlier in terms of just where would people start with private markets, right? I've seen this stat before on this, and frankly, I think this is still even overblown in which perhaps 12 % of 401k holders in fact know what private market investments are. I actually think that that is highly overinflated just based on the 20 plus years. that I've been both advising asset owners really across the spectrum of wealth, both in pro bono capacities, but all the way upwards to the work that we do in our investment advisory firm. And so when I think about risk, I think in this context, where my mind goes first is to the loss of secured capital, the loss of earned wage income that has been intentionally put away for future wellbeing. And if I think about it in that context, I start to say, what is the rigor? What's the framework again that we have in place to really ensure the safe protection of these really extraordinarily essential resources and assets, particularly in the absence of a broad safety net operating within America. And so this is truly the safety net that our workers have at play. I put the kind of sort of risk metric applied to the kinds of investments up to a very high standard that should be in place. So I've heard everything from democratization and I think the current administration has said the sort of ⁓ impulse that the Biden administration had around policy and protectionism on ⁓ such ⁓ private market complex solutions as paternalistic. ⁓ I think this notion needs to really be ⁓ interrogated and analyzed far greater. because I think the kinds of protections that Ben is rightly saying are there to protect working Americans. And because I've been in the industry so long and lived through 2008 and 2009 and saw what complex assets often do, it's frankly in my mind, this is a skeptic in my world, even though I love the work that I do, of separating sort of everyday working people from their hard-earned investments and income. And that's fundamentally If I'm to sort of animate what risk means to me outside of the typical kind of technical aspects of volatility and other such things, risk is the loss of count.
Speaker 2: And Ian, can we just double click on what was that percentage, that number of you said, uh, can you just repeat that for us? Yeah.
Speaker 4: 12 % ⁓ of 401k asset owners ⁓ purport to have knowledge on private equity and private market investments. Again, believe anecdotally it's far lower than that. That's my sense.
Speaker 2: 12 % and I mean, or knowledge is not the same as being a successful private markets investor. Do you think 12 is, it's lower than that? What percentage of that would people actually be benefiting from that? even, even probably smaller, but Ben, how are we thinking about, how are we thinking about risk? ⁓ gone off of Ian's comments.
Speaker 4: There you are.
Speaker 3: Yeah, well, the first I'll say is I can give you numbers too. was saying before that retail investors aren't clamoring to get into the private markets. The Wall Street Journal had an article about six months ago that said, you know, there's this push to get retail investors into the private markets. We decided to ask retail investors whether this is something they want or not. And it turned out only 10 percent of retail investors said they want to expand their options in their 401 case that things like alternative assets like
the private markets only 10 percent, you know, so why we
Speaker 4: Austria-
Speaker 2: Wall Street Journal too.
Speaker 3: That's exactly right. Not even a batch of, know, whatever. So I think that's pretty noteworthy. I think one of the reasons that is, like, is the stock market not doing great? I mean, I think we can talk about the fact that not enough people are able to invest in the stock market. And therefore the gains of the stock market only go to some people. But, you know, if you're a retail investor looking at your 401k, you're probably not like, now is exactly the time that I need to have different types of assets in my 401k and then the flip side is the risk. think now is exactly the time to be asking why do I want to get into the private markets? Look at the turmoil that's going on, especially in private credit. have institutional investors, high net worth individuals, even some retail investors. Literally, they can get out fast enough, right? A lot of private funds cap their redemptions at 5 % and you don't have to take my word for it. Just Google redemption requests in private. credit right now and there no end of articles about funds not having redemption requests that far exceed the 5 % limit. Some are being forced to raise that limit. Some are sticking with that limit, which means people can't get out when they want to. Rodney talked a second ago about people now using their 401ks because of affordability issues. They now need to use that to pay their rent or whatever it is. Well, you know, we can debate whether that's like good or bad, is it good that people are getting out of their 401ks earlier? But think about it, if you're a person who needs to access their 401k either for retirement or you need to access it earlier for whatever reason, and you're now in an illiquid private market investment that you can't get out of, what are you going to do? Retail investors are used to being able to get their money when they want it. You can sell index funds, ETFs, mutual funds, and get your money pretty, pretty, pretty... you know, on demand. Imagine if you're told, no, you have to wait to the next quarter or the next year or until we can sell out of this private company and get your money back. I mean, think that's what that's going to do to people who are really depending on access to those funds.
Speaker 1: Yeah, one of the things I think about within that too, Ben, and it's already been touched upon, is that, you know, we had a, Impact had a conversation ⁓ with Jed Emerson about the business of asset management. And one of things that you bring up, you know, Ben, is the business of managing private market assets is more profitable for managers. And so we're seeing this across a landscape where And your point about 2008, 2009, there are firms that 2008, 2009 were doing quite well without engaging in the business model that is private assets. And they're now clamoring, acquiring, trying to get access to private market asset managers
because it's much more profitable because as you kind of opened up with Ben, you can charge more for those assets for that service. can do a lot. You can. do a lot more in terms of as a manager getting a piece of current interest, these sorts of things that you just can't do or can't do a certain price rather. And the other thing that comes to mind for me around this and, know, Ian and Ben, you both talked about this, but the example of private credit is really important here because what you understand, whether it's the data set that You know, Ian's referring to the 12 % 401k holders understanding what private markets are or been to your point about the Wall Street Journal piece that references 10 % either way, very low and prior lower. But the reality is when you reference things like the the Blue Owl private credit fund and as an example. Advise financial advisors. It seems did not prepare their clients well enough to understand the realities of even been your point about the 5 % redemption. That's a lot. seems like a lot of folks were not educated and informed enough about what that actually means when they were going to try to call back capital. I say that just to reinforce this thing, this notion that
Speaker 3: Bye.
Speaker 1: you know, the existing kind of infrastructure isn't doing well by everyday investors, not informing them enough, educating them enough to understand that, hey, if you're going to put your capital with this private credit fund, you're not going to be able. We're calling it semi-liquid. And you hear that that means I can draw it down when I want to. That's not what that means. And so we're seeing that as just one example, I think, of just a level of difficulty it is. to really engage retail markets in this way.
Speaker 4: No, no, I think that's exactly right. Rodney, I think if you're looking back once at the just the fee differential within private market solutions versus your standard sort of passive index funds. So right. Two and 20 is, as they say in the private markets is a standard thing. Two percent annual management fee. Twenty percent of profits referred to as carry. And yet a standard kind of Vanguard S &P 500 index fund, probably about three basis points of point zero three percent. That is a huge quantum of difference in fees and it doesn't yet necessarily yield the best outcome. rightly hit on it. We've had extraordinary market returns from the S &P 500 over the last three years, quite frankly outperforming private equity at large for this period. If you evaluate that even further to Ben's point, this has been not only the challenges and with private credit, which had been all the sort of Discussion in the public domain in the last year or so, but if you looked at private equity as well Distributions have gone down Dramatically exits have gone down dramatically over these last few years and so the cynic in me while again I would very much espouse the notions of democratization of capital and access to wonderful vehicles The same time we have to be thinking through are these asset managers? in the industry looking for other sort of green fields of opportunity during a period which many sophisticated asset owners that I happen to serve in and help manage assets for are really interrogating are the right solutions. So the level of rigor now from sophisticated asset owners has really been turned on significantly to ensure private equity managers at large can in fact deliver what they they purport to deliver and further that clients can get their money back. at the sort of 10, 12 year period, rather than what we have been seeing over this last few years, relative to the extraordinary returns we're seeing in the public markets. And so there's an interesting kind of backdrop behind the liberalization of this industry and access into 401ks that speaks to this like tension that exists right now ⁓ within both tension and I'd say very much a shifting landscape for access to capital for private market providers.
Speaker 3: I Ian made a really important point that I want to jump in on, if I may, which is that sophisticated market participants are trying to ask more questions in this private market space. Because one of the things you'll hear people at the SEC and the Department of Labor in the private funds industry say is, well, of course we want to do this so-called responsible retailization with sufficient guardrails. And one of the guardrails that they talk about is, we want it to be done in conjunction with fiduciaries that are supposed to be looking out for the best interest of the retail investors. But are all retail investors going to be investing with such a fiduciary? Like, I think, you know, there would still be tremendous risks in the private markets if retail investors have somebody advising them. But if all retail investors can go to an Ian and Ian is then going to ask the right questions, that probably mitigates the risk somewhat. Are all retail investors going to have an Ian? I'm not sure that's the case. I'm not sure if you're just a teacher or a construction worker or a firefighter or what have you. And now you're like, great, I have amassed this wealth that I can invest. You're going to be able to call up some sophisticated investment advisor that's going to know the right questions to ask. And so I think this idea that the guardrails are these produce share is just kind of falls by the wayside if you really think about this. Does everybody have access to the right person to ask the right questions?
Speaker 2: So Ben, is, you know, on the podcast, like a big ethos of the podcast is trying to relate and talk to and like ground our perspective in regular, right, everyday people. And I don't think that everyone is going to have Ian or Ian's colleagues to call on and have necessarily this level of thoughtfulness, but to both of you, you know, keeping, I don't know, your neighbor, your second cousin, pretend you're like, you know, at a family
reunion, you're talking about this stuff and they tell you, okay, you know, my retirement, these people are telling me all this stuff, make, I can make a lot of money. Like, you know, what would you kind of tell them? Like, you know, what would you kind of talk to them about? ⁓ just so they can be more informed or how would you approach that conversation around the dinner table?
Speaker 1: And we know that this is not investment advice.
Speaker 2: I, of course, it never would be. ⁓
Speaker 4: that it is not advice. The candid thing is I have people ask me these questions all the time, right? Like, what do you think about crypto? What do you think about private equity, venture, angel investing? I am almost unequivocally a hard no for most people, even though I'm an active investor in those markets after 20 plus years, I think, unfortunately, you need to lose money in some of these complex products to understand and ask the right questions and kind of take your hard knocks. And I think as a result, most people, for better or for worse, probably don't have the capacity to do that deep interrogation that Ben is speaking to, may not have the right kind of professional advice. Because I would even say, to the point Rodney was raising before, that many individual sort of investors, retail investors, were not being sort of fully explained. I would maybe be willing to argue that the financial advisors maybe didn't know either and weren't getting the proper training from their investment research departments to ensure it's I don't believe necessarily that all retail investment advisors are operating with malice or mal intent in any regard. They often are not getting the right training as well. I will tell you this is like a 20 year old at mid 20 year old who started in the industry. That was often the case for me 20 plus years ago. ⁓ And so in that respect, I think for most it's it's it is this assessment of what are your goals going back to the investment tenant basics, right? What are your goals? What's your risk tolerance? Are you conservative? Are you moderate? What's going to keep you up at night and really getting an assessment of is this the right kind of solution that I should even be contemplating? If you can get to a yes on many of those things, I'm still of the view that it is probably a very small allocation for these kinds of high risk, high growth. illiquid investments, if it's in fact, suitable at all. Generally speaking, I'm very much a kind of a traditionalist around you should just be passive index investing quite frankly in your 401k's, because we know the data shows that that leads to long term better results through and through.
Speaker 3: Yeah, no, I think what I would always say is do your own research, right? Even if you if you can find somebody that is in the industry that you can trust greed, but the very least do your own research and just start by Googling. You know, you'll get some results that are like. You got to diversify, you gotta get into the private markets and we want to democratize, but you'll also get some results that are like, put your money in an index fund and don't look at and touch it for 30 years in. what's right and what's wrong, I don't know, but then that person can at least decide for themselves. I will say, you do see people over and over and saying, you know, as Ian was saying before, you know, what's wrong with just plain boring, you know, investments like index funds. And I'm always reminded there was a, there is a professor at Duke Law School, Elizabeth de Fontenay who testified, who writes about private markets. And she testified before Congress about 10 years ago, I think it was 2017, back when there was another push to so-called democratize the private markets. And she said, finally, I'm paraphrasing, but she said something like, we finally got people to understand that low cost index funds is a great way to save for retirement. And now we're going to turn around and try to push them into these risky, illiquid and expensive private market assets. How could that be? And here we are 10 years later where I think the risk of the private market assets have come to the floor and yet we're still making that push. Again, people can decide for themselves if they have a higher risk tolerance, it should totally be up to them to make their own decision. But I just worry about the narrative. Like if the narrative is being pushed by the administration, the SEC, the Department of Labor. Other government officials and agencies and the private funds industry, only one story is going to be told. And at least people should go into this with their eyes open after having done their own research.
Speaker 1: I think that's a perfect way to end this podcast guys. I appreciate the rigor of the conversation, the perspective, the experience, the expertise that each of you bring. ⁓ It was exactly what we're looking forward to and having this kind of conversation. So I just want to thank you both, Ian and Ben. CEO and co-founder of West Fuller and Ben, Director of Securities Policy at Better Markets. Thank you both. The opinions expressed in this program are those of the individuals interviewed today, are for general informational purposes only, and are not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual or on any specific security. This program is only intended to provide education about the financial industry. To determine which investments may be appropriate for you, consult your financial advisor prior to investing. Any past performance discussed during this program is no guarantee of future results. As always, please remember, investing involves risk and possible loss of principal capital. Please seek advice from a licensed professional. West Fuller Advisors is an SEC registered investment advisor. Advisory services are only offered to clients or prospective clients where West Fuller Advisors and its representatives are properly licensed or exempt from licensure. All views expressed by our guests are their own.
Speaker 3: you
Speaker 1: and do not necessarily express the views of West Fuller advisors.