TRANSKRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:09.599 --> 00:00:12.800
Hello and welcome to this Herbert Smith Free Hills Kramer podcast.
00:00:12.800 --> 00:00:22.239
I'm Mora Mackintosh, a knowledge counsel and litigation team in London, and I'm also one of the general editors of our textbook, Class Actions in England and Wales, published by Sweet and Maxwell.
00:00:22.239 --> 00:00:28.320
This is the second in our series of podcasts to mark the launch of the third edition of the book earlier this autumn.
00:00:28.320 --> 00:00:34.320
In this episode, we'll focus on product liability cases, which have long been a fertile source of group litigation.
00:00:34.320 --> 00:00:42.880
And I have with me two of the co-authors of the textbook, David Bennett, a partner in our disputes team in London, specializing in product liability and health and safety.
00:00:43.359 --> 00:00:44.159
Hello, everyone.
00:00:44.560 --> 00:00:52.719
And also Natasha Johnson, a commercial litigation partner whose practice is increasingly focused on class actions defence work, including product liability claims.
00:00:52.719 --> 00:00:53.840
Thanks, Maura.
00:00:54.000 --> 00:00:54.320
Good to
00:00:54.320 --> 00:00:54.880
be here.
00:00:54.880 --> 00:01:03.039
Starting with you, David, just to set the scene, can you outline how product liability group actions are brought in this jurisdiction?
00:01:03.759 --> 00:01:04.079
Sure.
00:01:04.079 --> 00:01:12.480
Well, the first point to understand is that there is no general US-style opt-out class action mechanism in England and Wales.
00:01:12.480 --> 00:01:27.519
Apart from claims for infringement of competition law, which have a separate statutory regime that does allow for opt-out claims, claims generally need to be brought on behalf of individual identified claimants who take active steps to join the proceedings.
00:01:27.519 --> 00:01:30.319
In other words, the claimants must opt in.
00:01:30.319 --> 00:02:04.400
Where large numbers of claimants bring similar claims, the court may decide to manage them together by way of a group litigation order or GLO, or using bespoke case management procedures without a formal GLO, but they are essentially a collection of individual claims rather than a single claim brought on behalf of the entire class that's been affected by the particular issue, which in product liability claims will typically be an allegation that a product sold on the market is defective and has caused injury or some other loss to large numbers of consumers.
00:02:05.439 --> 00:02:08.319
So you mentioned injury or some other loss.
00:02:08.319 --> 00:02:21.199
I understand that the earliest group actions brought in the English courts back in the 1970s and 80s were product liability cases alleging personal injuries caused by pharmaceutical products or medical devices.
00:02:21.199 --> 00:02:23.759
But I think things have moved on from that?
00:02:24.479 --> 00:02:25.919
Yes, to some extent.
00:02:25.919 --> 00:02:34.719
Personal injury claims do still account for a significant proportion of product liability claims, and so do pharmaceutical and medical products.
00:02:34.719 --> 00:02:44.240
But yes, we are increasingly seeing claims alleging that products have failed to perform as advertised or expected, even if they haven't caused any physical harm.
00:02:44.240 --> 00:02:54.800
The diesel emissions litigation, which Natasha and I are both heavily involved with, um, along with many others, is an obvious and very high-profile example of this trend.
00:02:55.199 --> 00:02:56.560
Yes, yeah, indeed.
00:02:56.560 --> 00:03:01.280
Natasha, do you want to tell us a bit about the diesel emissions litigation?
00:03:01.919 --> 00:03:02.400
Sure.
00:03:02.400 --> 00:03:12.879
So, I mean, it's one of the largest, in fact, I expect probably the largest uh product liability group action we've seen in England and Wales so far.
00:03:12.879 --> 00:03:25.759
The first claims were brought against um Volkswagen um uh in sort of uh VW1, as we call it, and that litigation settled uh a while ago.
00:03:25.759 --> 00:03:36.719
But similar cases were then brought against not only VW in a second round, but also against other manufacturers.
00:03:36.719 --> 00:03:50.719
And those claims have been managed together by the courts under what is essentially a super GLO comprising 13 separate GLOs for the different manufacturer groups.
00:03:50.719 --> 00:04:04.800
Um the the claims are rather different from the original VW allegations which were around um a sort of binary switching device and are much more complex.
00:04:04.800 --> 00:04:18.560
There are essentially four lead GLOs um uh which are acting as lead cases, and that includes Mercedes-Benz GLO, which is the one on which we're acting.
00:04:18.560 --> 00:04:54.079
The underlying allegation in all of the cases was that the defendant manufacturers fitted their vehicles with a so-called defeat device, um, but these were quite complex modulations of the emission control system, and the uh allegation is that they were those um were intended to reduce emissions during the statutory tests um in order to uh obtain regulatory approval, but not in the same way in real driving conditions.
00:04:54.079 --> 00:05:24.160
As David said, there's no allegation that the claimants in those cases suffered any kind of personal injury or physical damage to any property, and in fact it's not even alleged that the defeat devices necessarily adversely affected the performance of the vehicles or indeed emissions overall, for example carbon dioxide, as opposed to narrowly just NOx emissions in certain driving conditions.
00:05:24.160 --> 00:05:44.079
The claimants' main argument um as to loss though was that they had suffered economic losses on the premise that their vehicles were worth less than uh they would have been had they been as warranted, so not fitted with defeat devices.
00:05:44.560 --> 00:05:45.439
Thanks, Natasha.
00:05:45.439 --> 00:05:48.000
That's that's a really
Load full transcript
helpful explanation.
00:05:48.000 --> 00:05:50.959
Uh where has the litigation got you now then?
00:05:51.439 --> 00:06:09.120
Well, so far there's been two preliminary issues trials, one in 2024 on legal issues regarding uh European law, and a very substantial trial in 2025 um on key technical and liability issues.
00:06:09.120 --> 00:06:26.079
Um and we had judgment in that over the summer, and we're currently um uh have begun in the middle of another trial um concerning quantum and causation arising out of that judgment.
00:06:26.079 --> 00:06:29.680
Uh so what did the judgment say?
00:06:29.680 --> 00:06:36.959
Well, following the liability trial, the court held that the manufacturers were essentially overwhelmingly successful.
00:06:36.959 --> 00:06:51.759
So the vast majority of the sample vehicles that the court was looking at were found not to have contained um prohibited defeat devices under the court's interpretation of the emissions regulation.
00:06:51.759 --> 00:07:11.199
And uh whilst the claimants have applied for permission to appeal, in the meantime, the third quantum trial is proceeding in respect only of one Mercedes sample vehicles where the claimants partially succeeded.
00:07:11.199 --> 00:07:41.680
Uh the court is considering um in that case key issues around quantum, such as how any losses should be assessed, which are said to have flowed from the existence of that one defeat device in that particular vehicle, but also looking at what the correct date of assessment is and whether claimants can recover damages for distress, disappointment, or loss of um immunity.
00:07:41.680 --> 00:07:55.600
Uh the other claims that remain against um one of the other manufacturers' PCD have been at stayed pending the outcome of the claimant's appeal.
00:07:56.959 --> 00:07:57.680
Thank you.
00:07:57.680 --> 00:08:11.199
Uh so I presume the result of this quantum trial then is going to be important for product liability cases of this sort generally, where claimants allege economic losses rather than personal injury or or property damage?
00:08:11.680 --> 00:08:13.279
Yes, I think it might.
00:08:13.279 --> 00:08:27.519
As we move further away from traditional cases, as David said, where consumers have suffered personal injuries or property damage, and and there the question would be whether this was caused by the product or by something else.
00:08:27.519 --> 00:08:46.399
We're moving into a world where claims are being made in the absence of what we might neutrally call um less obvious or less concrete losses, and it will be interesting to see what boundaries the courts choose to set in those scenarios.
00:08:47.679 --> 00:08:49.519
Yes, yeah, no, interesting.
00:08:49.519 --> 00:08:53.759
So uh obviously the diesel emissions litigation has been huge.
00:08:53.759 --> 00:08:57.279
Uh but are we seeing other product liability cases being brought?
00:08:57.279 --> 00:09:00.720
And and do you think product liability claims are increasing more
generally?
00:09:01.840 --> 00:09:13.039
Yes, I think four years ago when the second edition of the textbook was launched, the view was that there had been a steady growth rather than any sort of explosion in product liability claims.
00:09:13.039 --> 00:09:26.240
And I think that's still true, and it's likely to remain the case certainly for so long as the mechanism for bringing this sort of claim, as David explained, is opt-in rather than opt-out.
00:09:26.240 --> 00:09:31.120
But there have been a number of factors driving growth.
00:09:31.120 --> 00:09:39.360
Um, that includes the expansion of specialist claimant firms who are looking for claims to build a book on.
00:09:39.360 --> 00:09:43.200
There's an increased availability of litigation funding.
00:09:43.200 --> 00:09:48.720
It's you know, we've seen a lot of liquidity in that market, um, at least for a while.
00:09:48.720 --> 00:09:54.879
And there's greater consumer awareness and regulatory scrutiny.
00:09:54.879 --> 00:10:03.679
Social media as a tool for identifying and connecting with potential claimants at scale is obviously also very important.
00:10:03.679 --> 00:10:14.080
I'm sure though we've all received messages and seen adverts encouraging us to sign up to some sort of mass consumer claim.
00:10:14.080 --> 00:10:24.399
Um, so they're not always brilliantly targeted, but they um do have far reach, um, and you know, that includes the diesel emissions litigation.
00:10:24.399 --> 00:10:28.159
So I suspect that trend is likely to continue.
00:10:28.720 --> 00:10:29.679
Thank you.
00:10:29.679 --> 00:10:32.000
Um turning back to you, David.
00:10:32.000 --> 00:10:35.200
So what's the legal basis for product liability claims?
00:10:35.200 --> 00:10:37.600
Are they mainly statutory claims?
00:10:38.720 --> 00:10:45.679
Traditionally they have been mainly statutory claims, um, but not exclusively that, um, and there's quite a bit of a variation.
00:10:45.679 --> 00:10:55.679
I mean, there are there are a number of different courses of action that consumers typically rely on in product liability claims, whether brought as group actions or individually.
00:10:55.679 --> 00:11:15.919
Um, and the three most common that you see are first claims in contract, um, such as for breach of the statutory implied term of satisfactory quality, um, second, tort claims, alleging negligence on the part of the manufacturer of the product or somebody else in the supply chain.
00:11:15.919 --> 00:11:20.480
And thirdly, of course, statutory claims under the Consumer Protection Act.
00:11:20.480 --> 00:11:34.879
Um, as I say, the last of these has been the most important traditionally, but claims can very often be brought on any one of these bases or often a combination of all three of them or others.
00:11:34.879 --> 00:11:47.759
But just looking at the um the specific kinds, a contract claim can only be brought by the direct purchaser against the direct seller of a product, um, since, of course, there needs to be privity of contract.
00:11:47.759 --> 00:12:10.639
Um, but claims in negligence and under the Consumer Protection Act can be brought against a much wider range of potential defendants, um, which can and does include manufacturers, designers, installers, distributors, importers, uh, certification bodies, um, and even many others in the supply chain, not just retailers at all.
00:12:10.639 --> 00:12:16.799
Um, and also those claims aren't limited to claims by the direct purchaser.
00:12:16.799 --> 00:12:28.159
Um, claims in negligence and under the Consumer Protection Act can be brought by effectively anyone who's suffered personal injury or other damage as a result of using the product.
00:12:28.159 --> 00:12:39.519
Think, of course, the classic example of the person who drank the bottle of ginger beer with the decomposed snail in it in the um in the 1930s case of Donna Hew and Stevenson.
00:12:39.519 --> 00:12:51.600
Um she couldn't sue the manufacturer in contract because she hadn't purchased the bottle herself, but the manufacturer was found to owe a duty of care and negligence to her, which allowed the claimant to proceed on that basis.
00:12:51.600 --> 00:12:58.000
Um and there are various advantages and disadvantages between the different causes of action.
00:12:58.000 --> 00:13:06.320
Um as I say, claimants can often and do often rely on more than one, so they don't necessarily need to pick, but there are um differences.
00:13:06.320 --> 00:13:19.039
For example, to succeed in contract, the claimants only need to show that the contract was breached, most obviously because the products weren't of satisfactory quality and that damage was suffered as a result.
00:13:19.039 --> 00:13:27.039
Crucially, they don't need to show any fault on the part of the manufacturer or anyone else, just um the breach of that term.
00:13:27.039 --> 00:13:34.080
For claimant negligence, by contrast, the claimants obviously do need to establish that the defendant was negligent one way or another.
00:13:34.080 --> 00:13:48.799
And for statutory claims, under the Consumer Protection Act, there is a need to show that the product was defective as defined within the Act, which means that the safety of the product was not such as persons generally are entitled to expect.
00:13:48.799 --> 00:13:57.519
And safety in this context includes not only risks of death or personal injury, but also risks of damage to property.
00:13:57.519 --> 00:14:08.799
So where a defect in that sense is established, there's a strict liability regime under the Consumer Protection Act rather than any need to show negligence per se on the part of the manufacturer.
00:14:09.279 --> 00:14:20.000
Yes, uh uh in terms of establishing a defect, I I imagine there's probably significant room for argument as to what persons generally are entitled to expect in terms of safety.
00:14:21.039 --> 00:14:32.159
Yes, absolutely, and that that has tended to be the focus of the main cases in this area
that have been seen in the period since the late 1980s when it when it came into force.
00:14:32.159 --> 00:14:53.679
Um the act provides that in considering that very question, all circumstances should be taken into account, and that will include things like the marketing of the product and any instructions or warnings that are given in relation to it, um, what might reasonably be expected to be done with the product and the time when the product was supplied.
00:14:53.679 --> 00:15:04.720
So you can't use hindsight, for example, to infer that a product is defective just because safety was improved in later versions of that product or of other products in a similar class.
00:15:04.720 --> 00:15:06.480
Um that's not enough.
00:15:06.480 --> 00:15:15.679
And risks that are considered to be inherent in a product will not make that product defective, so long as they're obvious to consumers or appropriately flagged.
00:15:15.679 --> 00:15:19.759
Think about uh sharp knives or hot drinks, for example.
00:15:19.759 --> 00:15:34.799
So, although it is a strict liability regime, it's not a question of absolute safety, but rather a question of the level of safety that consumers are entitled to expect, which obviously ties into questions of reasonableness at every stage.
00:15:34.799 --> 00:15:40.240
There are also certain statutory defenses established in the Act.
00:15:40.240 --> 00:16:04.080
For example, if the defendant can show that the defect in question didn't exist at the time that the product was produced, or that the defect was attributable to compliance with a legal requirement, or that the state of scientific and technical knowledge at the time was such that the producer wouldn't be expected to have discovered the defect.
00:16:04.080 --> 00:16:11.840
All of those can be used as the statutory of defences against what would otherwise be a pure strict liability regime.
00:16:12.720 --> 00:16:13.200
Thank you.
00:16:13.200 --> 00:16:14.960
Um that's a helpful explanation.
00:16:14.960 --> 00:16:17.600
And that's obviously the the current law.
00:16:17.600 --> 00:16:22.639
Um I understand there's a potential shake-up of product liability legislation under consideration.
00:16:23.200 --> 00:16:24.080
Yes, absolutely.
00:16:24.080 --> 00:16:26.480
Um and this is this is timely in that sense.
00:16:26.480 --> 00:16:45.200
The the Law Commission um has been looking for a long time now at this area, um, and it has launched a public consultation which is going to run until mid-January next year, um, having published a very detailed um report with some of its initial um views and considerations just recently.
00:16:45.200 --> 00:16:55.840
One of the key questions being looked at, perhaps unsurprisingly, is whether the product liability regime needs any amendment to adapt to the digital age.
00:16:55.840 --> 00:17:01.279
And the law is the Law Commission's initial view certainly seems to be that it does.
00:17:01.279 --> 00:17:14.079
So, for example, the consultation that's been published proposes that products covered by the regime should be expanded to include software and AI systems and online platforms, to name just a few.
00:17:14.079 --> 00:17:28.480
Um, and there are also proposals around modification of the definition of defect, including the introduction of a non-exhaustive list of principles for assessing the level of safety consumers are entitled to expect.
00:17:28.480 --> 00:17:35.359
So that may go towards uh curing some of the uncertainty in uh prior case law that we've talked about.
00:17:35.359 --> 00:17:45.599
And also the Law Commission is looking at whether it should be made easier for claimants to establish defect and causation in some cases through the use of rebuttable presumptions.
00:17:46.160 --> 00:17:52.720
So, what do you think the impact of the proposals would be on product liability class actions if they're implemented?
00:17:53.519 --> 00:18:03.519
Yeah, it's it's difficult to predict because obviously we don't know and we won't know for some time what actual changes emerge from the process.
00:18:03.519 --> 00:18:12.480
That said, I think some of the changes the Law Commission have in mind are likely to encourage further growth in product liability class actions.
00:18:12.480 --> 00:18:25.680
And I say that because some of the proposed changes look like they could lower the threshold for claims, which will provide further encouragement to claimant law firms and funders, who are already, of course, very active in this area.
00:18:25.680 --> 00:18:40.319
Um and also some of the changes, the potential changes, look like they will create new questions that will have to be considered by the courts in test cases, and those could well emerge as class actions rather than anything else.
00:18:40.319 --> 00:18:46.400
Um and finally, also, some of the changes are intended to expand the scope of product liability.
00:18:46.400 --> 00:18:56.559
For example, as I've said, to remove any doubt at all that it's um that the regime applies to software and AI systems and all kinds of digital or digitally enabled products.
00:18:56.559 --> 00:19:04.799
Um as those products become even more and more ubiquitous than they already are, we will inevitably see more claims being brought in that area.
00:19:05.359 --> 00:19:06.079
Thank you, David.
00:19:06.079 --> 00:19:09.839
Sounds like it could have a pretty significant impact then.
00:19:09.839 --> 00:19:14.960
Um and I know that's not the only Law Commission project that could affect this area as well.
00:19:14.960 --> 00:19:19.279
It's it's also considering consumer class actions more generally.
00:19:19.279 --> 00:19:22.000
Uh, Natasha, do you want to tell us a bit about that?
00:19:22.720 --> 00:19:23.440
Yeah, sure.
00:19:23.440 --> 00:20:00.079
So this is a separate but related project where the government has asked the Law Commission um to assess whether consumer law enforcement could be strengthened by introducing a standalone
opt-out consumer class actions regime, and that would be done essentially by extending something like the opt-out mechanism we already have for competition claims in the Competition Appeal Tribunal to the broader consumer protection space.
00:20:00.079 --> 00:20:33.920
The Law Commission's been gathering early input through an initial scoping questionnaire which asks stakeholders to um tell them about the benefits and risks of such a regime and if it's introduced what features it should have, including, for example, how to promote the efficient conduct of litigation at proportionate cost and how to avoid promoting speculative claims where they are without merit.
00:20:34.559 --> 00:20:48.559
Yeah, but presumably product liability would be an area that's very likely to be affected if a consumer opt-out regime were ever introduced, given how often product defects affect very large numbers of consumers?
00:20:49.039 --> 00:20:50.640
Well, yes, absolutely.
00:20:50.640 --> 00:21:05.759
Um the current opt-in regime um is really one of the main reasons why product liability group actions in this jurisdiction look quite different from in the US.
00:21:05.759 --> 00:21:18.480
And um, you know, claimant firms and funders here they they need to work to re recruit enough claimants to make a case economically viable.
00:21:18.480 --> 00:21:28.720
Uh, it's therefore just much harder where individual losses are modest, even where you have very large numbers of people who are affected.
00:21:28.720 --> 00:21:44.880
And it can take a long time, for example, for um the book of claims to reach critical mass, it can involve significant outlay in terms of the reach out they need to do to consumers, advertising.
00:21:44.880 --> 00:21:59.680
And you might have several law firms competing for claimants, meaning that some will ultimately lose out on the prized role of lead solicitor in any subsequent GLO, which is really where the greatest chunk of fees.
00:21:59.680 --> 00:22:01.119
Can be earned.
00:22:01.119 --> 00:22:07.359
An opt-out regime would remove that constraint for consumer product liability claims.
00:22:07.359 --> 00:22:23.119
So it you know it clearly could result in a significant ramping up of low-value, high-volume claims arising from defective consumer products, where today it simply may not be feasible to build a claim.
00:22:23.119 --> 00:22:31.279
Effectively, this would mirror what we've already seen in the competition sphere after an opt-out mechanism was created.
00:22:32.000 --> 00:22:36.640
Yes, I expect businesses are going to have some concerns at that prospect?
00:22:37.039 --> 00:22:39.519
Yes, and I look I think rightly so.
00:22:39.519 --> 00:22:53.599
There's a risk that an opt-out regime would significantly increase the burden on businesses, um, without necessarily resulting in a in a real benefit to those affected by the alleged wrongdoing.
00:22:53.599 --> 00:23:16.960
Experience of opt-out collective proceedings in the Competition
Appeal Tribunal and in other jurisdictions with opt-out regimes suggests that even where the claim succeeds, compensation may not in practice reach those who've suffered harm as a result of difficulties in identifying who should benefit and distributing the proceeds.
00:23:16.960 --> 00:23:22.559
And there may also be a lack of take up by potential beneficiaries.
00:23:22.559 --> 00:23:29.759
So it's really the lawyers and the funders, I'm afraid, who generally stand to benefit from most of those cases.
00:23:29.759 --> 00:23:45.839
And then, of course, there's the risk that an opt-out consumer class action regime would damage the UK's reputation as a competitive and cost-effective place to do business with the associated impacts on economic growth.
00:23:45.839 --> 00:24:08.160
So if a regime is going to be introduced, then I think it's going to be essential to ensure that it includes safeguards to protect businesses from claims without merit and which are frankly drummed up by claimant firms and litigation funders with funding that they want to employ.
00:24:08.160 --> 00:24:27.839
The safeguards could include genuinely robust certification stage with a proper merits test, and on that point it's worth noting that there is a separate ongoing review of the opt-out regime in the Competition Appeal Tribunal.
00:24:27.839 --> 00:24:39.440
And there the government has proposed amendments to the threshold for certification, recognising that it may be seen as too low currently.
00:24:39.440 --> 00:24:51.599
There should also be provisions to ensure that only those claims which will genuinely benefit consumers rather than the lawyers and the funders can proceed.
00:24:51.599 --> 00:25:07.200
So, by way of example, requiring evidence of likely take up on the part of consumers and a credible distribution plan so that any damages can actually be distributed properly.
00:25:07.200 --> 00:25:14.880
We've responded to the Law Commission's um initial scoping questionnaire raising these issues.
00:25:15.200 --> 00:25:21.680
Yes, yeah, well it'll certainly be interesting to see how the Law Commission weighs up all of these um considerations.
00:25:23.039 --> 00:25:31.759
It certainly will, and of course, whether any recommendations they come up with are actually implemented is another question.
00:25:31.759 --> 00:25:42.000
Any new regime could fundamentally change the shape of product liability litigation in this jurisdiction, though, in the coming years, and we wait and see.
00:25:42.640 --> 00:25:43.599
Yes, absolutely.
00:25:43.599 --> 00:25:49.680
Um perhaps by the time of our fourth edition of the textbook there'll be um a clearer direction of travel.
00:25:49.680 --> 00:25:52.960
Um so that brings us to the end of this episode.
00:25:52.960 --> 00:25:59.519
If listeners want to know more about product liability group actions, please do take a look at the new third edition, which is available on Westlaw.
00:25:59.519 --> 00:26:04.480
And for more on class actions, generally keep an eye out for further episodes in this series.
00:26:04.480 --> 00:26:10.400
But in the meantime, thank you, Natasha and David, and thanks to all of you for listening.