TRANSKRIPT 🔗
[0:01] Welcome to Fresh Start with Jason Cline.
[0:04] Welcome back to Fresh Start with Jason Cline,
[0:07] founder of the law office of Jason Cline and Albert Kirkking in Mexico.
[0:11] Jason helps individuals and families across New Mexico find clarity
[0:14] and confidence through chapter 7 and chapter 13 bankruptcy solutions.
[0:18] I'm Evan Mac and today we're talking about tax refunds
[0:21] and how they're treated in bankruptcy
[0:23] and what people in New Mexico should understand before filing Jason.
[0:26] Welcome back.
[0:27] Thank you, Evan. It's great to see you again.
[0:29] Stuff today. So why do tax refunds become such a major concern for people considering bankruptcy?
[0:35] One thing you have to understand is the tax refunds are often the largest amount of cash
[0:39] a person receives during the year.
[0:41] So many families rely on that money to catch up on their bills, repair vehicles,
[0:47] pay for school events.
[0:49] Then simply build a little breathing room in their budget, start savings.
[0:53] So when some of us are considering filing for bankruptcy,
[0:56] the first question is often, am I going to lose my tax refund?
[1:00] Because a refund can be considered an asset.
[1:02] It's something that needs to be carefully evaluated before filing.
[1:06] So Jason, what factors determine whether someone can keep their tax refund after filing?
[1:11] Well, there are several factors that come into play,
[1:13] including which chapter you're going to file.
[1:16] The timing of the filing, the amount of the refund,
[1:18] and the exemptions available under the bankruptcy law.
[1:21] So every case is going to be different.
[1:23] Some refunds can be fully protected, some partially protected,
[1:27] and some situations a trustee may have a claim to the entire refund.
[1:31] How can the timing of bankruptcy filing affect what happens to a refund?
[1:35] So timing can make a tremendous difference.
[1:38] A tax refund doesn't simply appear when the return is filed.
[1:42] It accumulates throughout the year as taxes are withheld from a person's paycheck.
[1:47] Depending on someone's files for bankruptcy,
[1:49] a portion of the refund may be considered part of the bankruptcy estate.
[1:53] So strategic timing can sometimes help maximize the protection available.
[1:58] Also, if we're in the tax time of the year,
[2:02] and that refund is coming,
[2:04] we may just want to wait until that refund is received,
[2:08] spend it on approved items,
[2:10] so we'll make sure that it's protected that way because it's not owed anymore.
[2:15] How are the tax refunds treated differently in chapter seven versus chapter 13 cases?
[2:20] So in a chapter seven case,
[2:22] the trustee can evaluate whether a refund is available for creditors.
[2:25] If it's not fully protected by exemptions.
[2:28] Now in New Mexico,
[2:30] we've got a pretty healthy exemption that we can usually protect most or all of it.
[2:34] But that is something that we need
Load full transcript
to evaluate and look at before we file the case.
[2:41] In a chapter 13 case refunds are handled very differently.
[2:46] We have to put people through what's called a means test where we determine if there's disposable income in a month or if you're above the median income level.
[2:57] And people that are above the median income level generally have to pay their tax refunds each year of the chapter 13 plan to the trustee,
[3:05] where if they're below the median income level,
[3:08] they get to keep their refunds throughout the life of it.
[3:12] Now that's a New Mexico specific role,
[3:14] so that does change state to state.
[3:16] If someone already spent their refund before filing bankruptcy,
[3:19] does that create issue with they should be aware of?
[3:22] You know, it can,
[3:23] but the key question is,
[3:24] what have a spent on?
[3:25] So using a refund for reasonable and necessary expenses such as rent mortgage payment, utilities, groceries,
[3:33] medical expenses, vehicle repairs, home repairs,
[3:38] those are generally going to be less conserving,
[3:41] concerning than giving the money away.
[3:43] One of the worst things that you can do is repay a family member with your tax refund.
[3:49] Dezzo to family members should not be repaid prior to filing a bankruptcy case.
[3:54] The way the bankruptcy court will view it is that the family member should understand your struggling where capital one doesn't need to.
[4:02] So paying back a family member with your tax refund could turn into the trustee going after that family member and getting that money back again to pay creditors with.
[4:14] Also got a watch for buying luxury items.
[4:19] But important to talk to an attorney before spending that refund because there are a lot of approved ways to do it.
[4:29] I will always recommend spending it or yeah, spending it before we file the case rather than keeping it around unless we claim the full exemption on it.
[4:39] Can you share an example of a case where the timing of a tax refund significantly affected the strategy or outcome?
[4:44] One example involved a client who was expecting a substantial refund within a few weeks.
[4:50] So rather than filing immediately, we evaluated whether waiting for the refund was to be received and properly spent on necessary living expenses would produce a better result.
[5:01] I mean, by carefully planning the timing the client was able to address important household needs, make some vehicle repairs.
[5:10] Actually, they need to put down a deductible for a roof on their house and then we move forward and filed with a stronger bankruptcy case and in essence they kept the tax refund.
[5:21] So Jason, other situations where only part of a tax refund is protected in bankruptcy?
[5:26] Absolutely. So it really is dependent on the exemptions available in the size of the refund.
[5:33] So it's possible for a portion to be protected while another portion remains exposed.
[5:38] So here in New Mexico, we have to protect your tax refund with what we call a wild card exemption.
[5:44] So wild card can be used on basically anything that's not exempt other than real estate.
[5:51] So it's $15,000 per person.
[5:55] So we have to also combine that with money and bank accounts and anything else the wild card exemption needs to be used on.
[6:01] But this for example, purposes, if you had a $15,000 or less refund that wild card exemption will cover it.
[6:08] If your refund is over $15,000, then the portion above that $15,000 could be owed to the bankruptcy estate and you'd lose that but keep the 15.
[6:17] What kinds of refund related mistakes can create problems during bankruptcy cases?
[6:22] I mean, common mistakes could include failing to disclose the refund, spending in ways that raise concerns as I was stating before transferring that money to friends or family members.
[6:33] Don't pay back friends and family members.
[6:37] And then just filing for the bankruptcy without understanding how the expected refund will be treated.
[6:44] So when we're filing for bankruptcy, transparency and the planning are critical.
[6:49] Don't leave things out. Tell your attorney everything because most problems can be avoided by discussing the refund with your attorney before filing.
[6:58] So for someone counting on a tax refund to help stabilize their finances, what should they understand before deciding when to file?
[7:05] Well, they should understand that the timing of the filing can be just as important as the decision to file itself.
[7:10] A tax refund may represent an important financial resource and understanding how it fits into the bankruptcy process can make a significant difference.
[7:20] So before filing, it's worth taking the time to review the refund, the household budget, the available legal options, so the filing.
[7:30] So that the filing strategy supports the client's long term financial goals.
[7:35] Oh, this stuff, Jason. Thank you so much.
[7:38] Oh, thank you, Evan.
[7:39] That's it for today's episode of Fresh Start with Jason Cline to learn more about Jason and how he helps New Mexico residents navigate bankruptcy with clarity and confidence.
[7:47] Visit attorneyjasoncline.com. Thanks for listening.
[7:50] Don't forget to like, subscribe and leave a review so more people can find the fresh start they deserve.
[7:55] Thank you so much and we'll see y'all later.