UDSKRIFT 🔗
[0:05] Welcome to Trial Talk: Insights from Legal Expert Michael Joseph New York Trial Attorney, Michael Joseph.
[0:10] Hi, everyone, and welcome to Trial Talk: Insights from Legal Expert Michael Joseph.
[0:19] Today, we're joined by John Tait, an associate attorney with the firm who handles a wide range
[0:24] of personal injury cases, including claims involving retail stores, supermarkets, and other
[0:29] commercial properties.
[0:30] John has significant experience, litigating premises liability cases involving unsafe conditions
[0:36] in public spaces.
[0:37] I'm Sean O'Connor, and today, John and I are talking about injuries in stores and supermarkets
[0:43] and how the law determines who may be responsible.
[0:47] Very common, common situation, John, good to see you, good to see you, Sean.
[0:53] So when someone is injured, you know, at the grocery store, they're at the IGA, they're
[0:59] I mean, we probably shouldn't name names here, they're injured in a store, supermarket.
[1:05] What, you know, what determines whether the business itself can be held responsible?
[1:10] You know, it's really a straight and negligent standard, and that's basically did the business
[1:16] owner act reasonably, right?
[1:18] Did the business owner do something that a reasonable business owner would not have done,
[1:24] or conversely did the business owner fail to do something that a reasonable business owner
[1:30] should have done, or would have done.
[1:32] And that's usually a factual question for the finer effect.
[1:36] It's a reasonableness standard, a reasonable business owner standard.
[1:39] I get it.
[1:41] And in your work, you know, what types of hazards do you see most commonly?
[1:47] You know, we get the falling products, you get the slip and falls, the wet floors, particularly
[1:52] wintertime.
[1:53] You have products on the floor, supermarkets are well known, people will grab stuff off
[1:58] the shelf, maybe eat a few grapes and walk around the store.
[2:01] You get display malfunctions, we've had that, we have big displays coming crashing down
[2:06] on people.
[2:07] There can be many hazards in stores and supermarkets.
[2:10] And so, you know, we were talking about the standard of reasonableness, you know, what does
[2:15] a store, a store manager, the person, what they actually have to do on a day-to-day basis
[2:21] to keep customers safe and to, you know, sort of show, hey, we're not in a dangerous place.
[2:27] Sure.
[2:28] You know, the law kind of, well, it requires store owners and supermarkets act reasonably
[2:35] and make sure there are no hazards, right?
[2:37] It's not a guarantee that there'll be no hazards, but they have to do their best in a reasonable
[2:41] manner to make sure they're not.
[2:43] Typically, they should walk through the store on a routine basis with a specific intent
[2:50] really to look for hazards.
[2:52] You can't just walk through the store and wander, listen to your phone talk, you got to look
Load full transcript
[2:55] for hazards on a routine basis throughout the day.
[2:59] Policies are always important.
[3:00] You have to implement policies and training of your employees to report hazards and quickly
[3:07] repair, remediate, or, you know, remove any of the hazards from the store.
[3:13] You know, some of the better stores have the policy.
[3:15] You see it.
[3:16] You own it, right?
[3:17] You see a spill, your responsibility to get it done.
[3:21] Don't call somebody.
[3:22] Don't do this.
[3:23] Go get them off.
[3:24] You clean it.
[3:25] That's really what a reasonable business owner would do.
[3:28] That's what juries have found.
[3:29] A reasonable business owner would do, inspect their properties, ensure that it's safe to the
[3:33] best of their abilities, and have these policies and training in place, because it's going
[3:38] to be inevitable that there will be hazards in stores and supermarkets, that's busy ones
[3:43] in particular.
[3:44] You got to have the policies in place to deal with that.
[3:46] Yeah, I see.
[3:47] So, you know, especially at a trial, you know, I mean, again, accidents are going to happen,
[3:51] but I'm thinking, you know, a store in this case wants to be able to say, hey, we have
[3:57] it in the manual, you know, we follow procedures to deal with this sort of thing, and, you know,
[4:03] this did or did not happen, but I'm guessing that you don't want to be caught without the procedures
[4:10] in place that just makes you look negligent, probably, you know.
[4:13] It does.
[4:14] It reflects poorly on you when you don't have, and nowadays, you know, juries are so attuned.
[4:20] They want evidence.
[4:21] They want video evidence.
[4:22] They want DNA evidence.
[4:23] They want evidence.
[4:24] I didn't.
[4:25] Yeah.
[4:26] The day of taking someone's word for it is over.
[4:27] If you say I train them like that, then you better have it in your training materials.
[4:31] Yeah.
[4:32] Well, I know we'll get into, I know the surveillance of the ubiquity of the digital, the
[4:37] digital realm.
[4:38] We'll get to that.
[4:39] But let's talk about timing.
[4:40] You know, how does timing factor into these cases when it comes to how long a hazard was
[4:45] present, I guess?
[4:46] Oh, so again, this speaking to your last answer on, you know, regularly patrolling the
[4:51] property, the store, how does that come into play?
[4:56] That's, you know, that water's been sitting there for a long time, whatever a long time.
[5:00] No, timing is absolutely huge when it comes to a negligence claim against a store or supermarket
[5:06] because the plaintiff has a burden to show that the store or supermarket had noticed of
[5:12] the condition and an opportunity to correct it.
[5:16] Now there are, there are two ways in New York that's called actual notice and then you have
[5:20] constructive notice.
[5:23] Actual notice is when the store actually had notice of the condition.
[5:27] If you know, the store employees saw, you
know, the water comes splashing down on the floor.
[5:33] They didn't do anything about it.
[5:34] They had notice.
[5:36] Another subset of actual notice is when the store or its employees created the condition.
[5:42] When you get that, you know, people mopping, people store employees dropping things.
[5:47] If you create the condition, then you're considered to have actual notice.
[5:52] Now in those situations where you can't show that the store or its employees had actual
[5:58] notice of this dangerous hazardous condition, then plaintiff must show constructive notice.
[6:03] It's a burden on plaintiff to show that that condition existed for a sufficient amount
[6:08] of time that a reasonable store owner would have found the condition and taken steps to correct
[6:15] it.
[6:16] And that burden's on plaintiff.
[6:17] You have to, plaintiff has to show that to a jury.
[6:21] So talking about evidence, we mentioned video, I'm guessing this might come up, you know,
[6:25] what types of evidence are most useful when it comes to proven a store that they knew about
[6:31] or should have known about a dangerous condition.
[6:33] Yeah, well, you're correct.
[6:35] Our valence video is certainly helpful to that effect.
[6:39] It'll show not only the defect, hopefully, but how long it was there.
[6:43] Wow, it's particularly helpful when you see employees in the video walking by the hazardous
[6:50] condition before the accident and doing nothing about it.
[6:53] Other types of evidence are photographs.
[6:57] The photographs of a defect may show it was a hazardous condition for some time.
[7:03] It could have been rovers by shopping carts, could have been stepped on by other customers,
[7:06] other customers can be stepping around it.
[7:09] So photographs, believe it or not, could be very important evidence outside of a video.
[7:16] And of course, witnesses, any witnesses who saw the condition before the accident are
[7:23] obviously important.
[7:24] They can testify to what they saw and, you know, to help establish notice to the supermarket.
[7:32] Yeah, that's a, that'd be a gold, that'd be gold, right?
[7:35] Like I told them, I told them about it and they didn't do anything.
[7:39] I'm sure you've seen, right?
[7:40] I mean, you've seen cases where the surveillance footage from the store itself made a major difference.
[7:46] Absolutely.
[7:47] Absolutely.
[7:49] A surveillance video is great because it also not just shows the condition.
[7:53] It really helps a jury understand what occurred.
[7:57] You know, when it's captured on video, it alleviates any doubt about how the incident occurred,
[8:02] what caused the incident and that the plaintiff suffered injuries.
[8:07] You know, incident reports are helpful as well because they document that an accident occurred
[8:12] in the store and usually they list witnesses and sometimes even the cause of the accident and
[8:17] remedial measures taken after the accident.
[8:20] And this information
is certainly helpful when you're trying to develop your case.
[8:25] And the incident report is that a something that's happening at the store level.
[8:31] This isn't like I'm thinking police report in my head, you know, but no, typically it's
[8:38] their insurance requirements for supermarkets and stores.
[8:41] And so the incident reports are usually taken by the store employees.
[8:46] It could be a manager or a system manager and then they're, they're actually sent off
[8:49] to insurance companies so they can open up a claim.
[8:53] But they have a lot of information which insurance companies require the stores to keep,
[8:58] which turns out to be very helpful for plaintiff and plaintiff's counsel when they're proceeding
[9:03] with the case.
[9:04] They'll always make sure, you know, you fill out an incident report if you can.
[9:08] Yeah, that makes sense.
[9:10] You know, earlier, I think in this conversation, you know, if I'm at different, you know,
[9:15] different causes of the accident, I'm wondering how a case might change, you know, when the
[9:20] injury is caused by like a tower display falling versus melted ice, you know, water on the
[9:29] floor.
[9:30] How does that change the nature of the case or well, the negligence standard still applies.
[9:34] It's the same reasonable negligence standards.
[9:37] And often with falling merchandise or a falling display, the store will usually try and point
[9:42] the finger at another customer, you know, and claim that another customer must have removed
[9:46] the object, manipulate, display, create that hazardous condition before the item fell videos.
[9:54] Of course, we discussed our helpfulness regard.
[9:58] But the store also has a responsibility to display its products in a way that a customer cannot
[10:03] easily make the display dangerous by simply removing a product.
[10:08] And you do go into some of these supermarkets.
[10:10] I know certainly New York City, they have those very impressive cans that go up to the ceiling
[10:16] and there are cases where they said they come down.
[10:19] They're held up by cardboard boxes that are not designed to actually support the weight of
[10:25] these products.
[10:26] It's designed to contain them and the cardboard gives way.
[10:29] I've seen cases, you know, where they come quite, quite high, high and crashing down because
[10:35] the cardboard box gave way that's unreasonable.
[10:40] That's negligence.
[10:41] A reasonable supermarket would not do that.
[10:44] That's same standard, but different considerations.
[10:47] Yeah, I want you to know right here, I'm going to go on record, you can keep this defense.
[10:56] But I'm thinking we're going to call it the Jenga Defense.
[11:00] Absolutely.
[11:01] Or not defense, but, you know, rule, the Jenga rule, right?
[11:07] It's like, you pull something, of course, it's going to fall down.
[11:10] What about damages, right?
[11:12] What types of damages can be pursued after being injured in a store?
[11:17] So New York, you get your economic damages, the medical expenses, your out-of-pocket expenses,
[11:23] your loss wages, and you get your non-economic damages.
[11:27] The pain and suffering caused by, you know, the injuries caused by the incident, and those
[11:32] are two categories of damages, those are jury, we'll have to come up with, you know, you
[11:36] present your evidence for economic damages pretty straightforward.
[11:40] Here are my lost wages, here are my paychecks, here are my expons, here's my bills, here's,
[11:44] you know, non-economic damages, you know, it's a little harder for juries to really stick
[11:50] a number on.
[11:51] It's your pain, your suffering, how to affect your life, things you can do, but not do as
[11:56] well because of your injuries, things you can't do because of your injuries, and how that affects
[12:01] you and your family.
[12:03] So those are the two categories of damages you're entitled to under New York law.
[12:07] Okay.
[12:08] The way we often like to roll up these conversations is, you know, come out of from the practical
[12:18] side a little bit for, you know, for anyone listening out there, maybe they've been hurt, or,
[12:23] you know, it could happen, right?
[12:24] It's just good to hear, like, oh, you know, you get hurt in the store or supermarket, right?
[12:28] What steps should they take to protect their rights?
[12:32] Sure.
[12:33] A couple things you want to do, and again, this is, if you're injured and you're going
[12:37] away by an ambulance, don't worry about these things.
[12:41] If you're, you know, if you can, or if you have a friend or something you're with who can,
[12:45] you know, make sure you can make a report with the store.
[12:48] If that's an option, if they're going to willing to accept a report, you make a report.
[12:51] You take out your phone, you take photographs of the hazardous condition.
[12:57] When you're deposed or you're testifying two years later, you know, sometimes it's difficult
[13:01] to explain to a jury what the hazardous condition looked like, how large it was.
[13:05] You take a photograph of it, you have it.
[13:08] You want to get the names and addresses of any witnesses, you know, and of course, you
[13:13] know, call a personal injury attorney, one with experience, and they'll walk you the rest
[13:18] of the way through.
[13:19] Oh, that's good.
[13:21] That's great.
[13:22] You know, I was thinking about the, as a consumer, you know, I'm going through a store,
[13:29] I slipped by fall, like, you know, I twist my ankle, and I'm, you know, we talked earlier
[13:33] about the ubiquity of, you know, cameras these days.
[13:36] How do I access the footage, or is that, that's something that you would do right away
[13:43] if I called you?
[13:45] So now, I mean, there's no real trick to it.
[13:47] It's what we do is we draft what's called a preservation letter, and I send that out, you
[13:53] know, as soon as we're paying our sign, the first thing out the door is a preservation
[13:57] letter.
[13:58] And that letter advises the landowner, store, supermarket, whatever it might be, that there
[14:03] is a claim that they have an obligation under New York law to preserve evidence.
[14:09] And of course, you know, you know, if they do not preserve that evidence, and it's later
[14:14] destroyed or gotten rid of, then you can get a spoilation of evidence instruction to the
[14:19] jury.
[14:20] The jury can be told, you know, they have the right not the obligation, but they may, if
[14:24] they want to assume that that destroyed video would have been favorable to the plaintiff.
[14:30] Yeah.
[14:31] And so we set out the preservation letter.
[14:33] We also, you know, tell them, hey, listen, you know, put your insurance carrier on notice,
[14:38] you know, because we don't want them to lose insurance coverage because they decided not
[14:41] to tell their insurance company.
[14:43] So we, we tell them the claim, we give them the preservation letter, preserve videos, documents,
[14:49] and then, you know, insurance notice.
[14:52] So anyone can do that.
[14:53] You don't need to be a lawyer to do that.
[14:55] It's just smart to let them know about the claim.
[14:57] And also, one of the benefits of the incident report is they then have notice that they must
[15:04] preserve the videos.
[15:08] And of course, usually they get sent straight to the insurance companies for the insurance company
[15:11] now has notices.
[15:12] Well, so fill out an intern report, have a friend fill it out.
[15:16] If you're going to the hospital, if you have to go back the next day or three days later,
[15:20] go back the next day or two days later and call on the attorney.
[15:24] Yeah.
[15:25] No, that's good.
[15:26] Yeah.
[15:27] Triggers some legal things, so that's, that's good to know, good to know.
[15:34] Well, Joe, we're out of time, but as usual, great to talk to you.
[15:38] That's great talking to you.
[15:40] I look forward to a future conversation.
[15:42] All right.
[15:44] That's it for today's episode of Trial Talk: Insights from Legal Expert Michael Joseph
[15:50] and today's guest, John Tait.
[15:52] If you or someone you know has been injured in a store commercial property, you can visit
[15:56] their website, New York trial lawyers.org to learn more about your legal options and connect
[16:02] with their team.
[16:03] My name is Sean O'Connor.
[16:04] Thank you for listening and do us a favor.
[16:07] Leave a thumbs up, share a link, subscribe to the podcast.
[16:12] That's always really helpful for everyone.
[16:14] Have a great day.
[16:22] Thanks for watching.
[16:24] Be sure to hit that like and subscribe button and leave us a review in the comments.