UDSKRIFT 🔗
00:00:01
Elizabeth Smart: Today's episode includes discussion of sensitive topics. Listener discretion is advised.
00:00:08
Amanda Knox: They put a hat over my head until it covers my face and then push my head between my knees the entire car ride. I'm literally being kidnapped. Is what is happening. I'm being literally kidnapped by the police.
00:00:22
Elizabeth Smart: That seems, besides highly unethical, that just seems shady.
00:00:27
Amanda Knox: It was shady AF, my friend. It was shady AF.
00:00:31
Elizabeth Smart: Amanda Knox never asked to become famous. She was a 20-year-old college student on a semester abroad in Italy when she found herself accused of murdering her roommate, Meredith Kircher. Almost overnight, everyone was talking about Amanda Knox. Her looks, her behavior, even the way she grieved were picked apart by people who had never met her. For the next eight years, Amanda's case played out in courtrooms and in headlines around the world.
00:01:01
Amanda Knox: I went back to prison, which was now my home for the next 26 years, and I had to completely rethink my life and how to survive this. And my first thought was, trigger warning, I don't know if I want to survive this. I don't know if it's fucking worth it to live.
00:01:25
Elizabeth Smart: I'm Elizabeth Smart, and today on The Survivor Files... It's my conversation with Amanda about the nightmare she lived through and the challenge of starting over after the whole world knows your name. We get into dating, marriage, and raising children in the public eye. We also talk about the Cornell case, Lindsay Clancy, and why it's so easy to judge people when you don't know the whole story.
00:01:51
Elizabeth Smart: Amanda, first of all, it's so nice to finally meet you. I feel like over the years there's been At least for me, there's been like so many times where I've gone and spoken somewhere and they're like, oh, last year Amanda Knox spoke or next year we've already booked her to speak. Anyway, it's so nice to finally meet you.
00:02:11
Amanda Knox: Yeah, I have to say I've had a very similar experience that like I think the first time I was talking with anyone very early on after I got out of prison about what the prospect of trying to set the record straight and get my story out there would look like, people referred me to your book. And like just your experiences. And I was like, OK, you know, young, in your case, very young female kidnapped, turned into a public figure based upon traumatic events. It's hard to find people who quite exactly know what that feels like. And I'm really excited to get into all of this with you and finally actually have a chance to speak with you.
00:02:59
Elizabeth Smart: Yes, me too. So I guess just diving right in, what made you want to do a study abroad in Italy?
00:03:07
Amanda Knox: Well, a big reason why I wanted to go study abroad was because from a very young age, I knew that the world was bigger than my own backyard. My mom and dad were divorced from a very young age. They lived in houses that were actually like neighboring each other. They were very close to each other. So I didn't get this sense of like they were separate worlds, but they certainly felt like separate cultures because my dad was like all American, you know, hamburgers, baseball, like all-American kind of guy, whereas my mom was born in Germany, and I was very ethnically German. We sang German Christmas songs at Christmas, and we made Reladen and Zwetschgenknödel, and I had this deep, deep understanding that there are different cultures and different languages in the world, and I was very deeply curious about that. So I knew going into. College that I absolutely was going to study abroad, and the question was, where? And the obvious answer was Germany, but the more romantic answer was Italy.
00:04:10
Elizabeth Smart: I mean, was Italy everything you prior, prior to everything?
00:04:18
Amanda Knox: Prior to it being the nightmare. That it was.
00:04:21
Elizabeth Smart: Yeah, but prior, was Italy like the romantic dream? Was it everything that you had imagined it to be?
00:04:28
Amanda Knox: At the very beginning, largely, yes. I was making friends really easily. I was. totally immersing myself in the food and the art. I was living with three other young women, two of whom were Italian. So they were really like teaching us how to cook Italian food. And in that way, it was really good. That isn't to say that there weren't like, you know, awkward things. Like I did find that men were very aggressive in Italy. Which isn't to say they aren't aggressive elsewhere also, but this was a new form of.
00:05:03
Elizabeth Smart: No, I can appreciate it. I lived in Paris for 18 months and yeah, there's a different level of aggressiveness there.
00:05:11
Amanda Knox: Yeah, just like direct, hey, and also like there's a different perception of you as an American girl that I wasn't fully aware of going into it. Like in Italy, there's this idea that all American girls... are kind of slutty party girls. And so to be sort of automatically treated like I was a slutty party girl when I wasn't, I was actually more of a nerdy academic type, like awkward type girl. Like that was something that I had to grapple with in the very few weeks. That I had before everything bad happened. But the good news is that pretty quickly, I met a really sweet, nerdy Italian guy who had all the good qualities of an Italian guy. Like he was deeply romantic, right? Like he wants you to feel special. He wants you to feel beautiful. He wants to take you out and show you the countryside. Like that was the vibe that I got from my Italian boyfriend that I had for five days. And then.
00:06:17
Elizabeth Smart: And then...
00:06:18
Amanda Knox: And then.
00:06:19
Elizabeth Smart: The things happened. So November 2nd came and I feel like, you know, I have heard tellings, retellings of your story many times, but obviously this is the first time I've ever spoken to
Load full transcript
you. So can you just talk me through November 2nd and what it was like coming into your apartment and everything you saw and found?
00:06:43
Amanda Knox: Yeah. Yeah. So I had been in Italy for, you know, five or six weeks at this point. And I was, again, living with three other young women in the upstairs apartment of this cottage. There were four young men who lived in the downstairs apartment, but they were separate. Two of my roommates were older. They were late 20s Italian women. And then there were two younger foreign exchange students, me, And my roommate, Meredith Kircher, who was English and a year older than me. So I was the youngest in the house. I spoke the least good Italian. I was, you know, the most immature in the sense of having just less life experience and sophistication. But like, you know, I'm a fun kid. I'm easy to be around. I'm easygoing. That night, I had spent the night at Raffaele's house. So Raffaele is my sweet, romantic Italian boyfriend. And like every night prior to that, I was staying over at his house because we were in the midst of having our fling of a lifetime.
00:07:52
Amanda Knox: And it was a long weekend and he wanted to take me on this romantic getaway to a nearby town called Gubbio that's famous for truffles. So my plans were simply to go home, take a shower and get dressed in something pretty. And that's what I did. But when I came home, the house wasn't as I had left it. The main thing that I noticed that gave me some alarm was that my front door was wide open, but nobody was home. And that had never happened before. That said, we did have a sketchy lock on our front door. The door wouldn't stay closed unless it was like fully locked with the deadbolt. And so I thought, oh, maybe when somebody left, they didn't fully close the door. And so it didn't lock. And then maybe the wind blew it open. Like I tried to sort of rationalize a reasonable reason why that could be. I didn't immediately jump up in alarm and think, oh my God, the worst has happened. So I go inside, I get undressed, I go into my bathroom to brush my teeth, take a shower, and then I notice the next alarming thing. There's spots of blood in my bathroom. They're in the sink. They're on the bath mat. But again, I try to rationalize it.
00:09:09
Amanda Knox: I'm a young woman. I'm in a house full of young women.
00:09:12
Amanda Knox: It's not crazy for there to be blood in the bathroom, given that we all have our periods. So I think, you know, maybe that's what's going on. I thought maybe someone might have cut themselves when they were cooking. Like I had no idea. And again, I wasn't jumping to worst case scenarios. So I take my shower. I get dressed in something pretty. I go to blow dry my hair in the other bathroom. There were two bathrooms in our apartment. And I noticed that there was feces left in the toilet. And that combined with everything else that I saw actually gave me chills. And like I couldn't rationalize that in my mind because
all of my other roommates were cleanly and they wouldn't have left an unflushed toilet. So suddenly I was like, oh, no, somebody. who shouldn't have been here has been here. And so I immediately left to go back to Raffaele and I'm having a little panic. I start calling my roommates. They're not answering the phone. None of them.
00:10:11
Amanda Knox: So I get to back to my boyfriend's apartment and I'm like, here's what I found. My roommates aren't answering their phones. Should I be worried? Am I overreacting? And he goes, no, no. Like, let's let's call your roommates. Like, let's get a hold of your roommates. I'll go back with you and we'll check it out for sure. So he goes back with me. And that's when we do some genuine poking around and we find that there has been a broken window, that somebody broke into our house. So he called the police for me, one, because I didn't know how to call the police at the time. And two, because my Italian wasn't good enough to explain the situation to the police. So he took care of that for me. Meanwhile, I'm finally getting in touch with one of my roommates. And she tells me the other Italian roommate is out of town. So that's why she wasn't answering and why she wasn't there. But we should be able to get in hold of Meredith. And Meredith isn't answering her phone. And I'm telling her there's this break in. So she freaks out and she decides to come back to the house with her boyfriend. to figure out what's going on. In the meantime, we're calling the police. The police arrive. My roommate arrives. We find that Meredith's bedroom door is locked. We try to break it down. Philomena's boyfriend ends up breaking it down while I'm in the kitchen talking with the police officers, and they find Meredith's body. Everybody just started screaming in Italian. So I actually didn't even know exactly what they had found. Like everyone's just screaming in Italian. I'm trying to piece together what they're talking about. I misunderstand them initially. Like I heard blood. I heard foot. In my mind, I'm thinking, did they find like a severed foot in her room? Like I had no idea. And I also didn't know if it was Meredith or not. Like maybe the person who broke into our house, maybe their body is in there. But like there was a lot of things. that weren't making sense and Meredith wasn't answering. So we were all really scared. And this sort of just hits me like a ton of bricks. Over the course of the next few hours, I pieced together that there's a body in the room and then the body is Meredith's and there's blood everywhere. I don't know how she died. I know there's blood. When they take me to the police station, the police officers tell me that she had been stabbed in the neck.
00:12:26
Elizabeth Smart: And was this all in Italian?
00:12:28
Amanda Knox: All in Italian. All of this in Italian. This is a language that I speak like a four year old. I can't like I'm trying to piece together what everyone's saying and I'm doing the
best I can. Raffaele is doing the best he can. He can speak a little bit of English. So he's doing a little bit of translating for me. But ultimately, I find myself in a foreign experience in so many different ways, not only in a foreign context and everyone speaking a foreign language, but I'm just like utterly unprepared psychologically and emotionally for what is happening to me because nothing traumatic has ever happened to me like this in my life. The only thing I can think to do is call my mom. And all she can think to tell me to do is to do what the police tell me to do and stay safe, which how do you do that when the very place that you lived and thought you would be safe was where your friend just got murdered? And so like, it's just like everything was happening really quickly all at once. I was reacting emotionally in a lot of different ways. There were times where I was just like crying and weeping. There were times where I was just dead faced and like frozen, like the lights had gone out and I was just like numb to everything around me. Other times I was like weirdly manic because I was like, oh my God, I'm alive. Oh my God, I'm alive. Like I could be dead right now. And so like I was a little manic and I was just emotionally pressing this experience without realizing that I was being judged.
00:14:02
Elizabeth Smart: I mean, did they start suspecting you like really quickly?
00:14:06
Amanda Knox: From the very first day.
00:14:07
Elizabeth Smart: From the very first day.
00:14:09
Amanda Knox: Yeah. And the reason I know that today, and that's a question that I had for many years, the reason I know that today is because they tapped my cell phone from the very first day. So they targeted me specifically because I was the one who discovered the crime scene. I was the odd one out.
00:14:30
Elizabeth Smart: I mean, yes, but no, you didn't break down the door. You saw some blood and- You saw some poop in the toilet.
00:14:37
Amanda Knox: Yeah. I think that given how things shook out and the way that the police were communicating with me from the very beginning conveys that I was already a suspect from day one. Like, I was questioned way more than anybody else. Over the next five days, I was questioned for somewhere around 53 hours.
00:14:57
Elizabeth Smart: Oh, my. Wow.
00:14:58
Amanda Knox: I was just called back in day after day after day, whereas other people... only had to like go to the police office and give testimony or like, you know, respond to questions on the first day. So I spent days just answering questions and what I thought was helping the police when really they were just zeroing in on me and ultimately trying to weaponize my words against me, which is what they ultimately did.
00:15:29
Elizabeth Smart: When this was still all in Italian? I mean, trying to learn another language. Okay. I can only speak for myself, but I remember when I was trying to learn French, my head would just pound like halfway through the day. It was almost like my brain just turned off and I just was like, yeah, I have no idea what you're saying. So 10 plus hours a day of being questioned in Italian. And you're probably more adept at languages than I am, but that would be brutal even for a native Italian speaker.
00:15:59
Amanda Knox: Well, and it was hard because also like the police kept acting like they were mad at me. Like their demeanor towards me was often like frustrated. And I assumed that was because my Italian was so bad. Like they kept having to repeat themselves and I just didn't know the words that they were using. So I kept having to ask them to explain to me in different ways. So like it was just this exhausting process. of answering the same questions over and over again. And then eventually, you know, at the end, like at the final part of these five days of being questioned, being brought in overnight, like at 10 p.m. to undergo questioning where they start accusing me of lying to them. And I'm terrified that this is all just a big misunderstanding. but they don't believe me. And so suddenly I'm in this position of like trying again to explain to them in a language that is not mine, that I'm telling the truth. And I really don't know what happened to Meredith. They're convinced that I know something that I'm not telling them.
00:17:08
Elizabeth Smart: And through this whole time, like you don't have a lawyer, you don't have an attorney. Nope. It's just you, a foreign language and aggressive, intimidating police.
00:17:19
Amanda Knox: Yeah. And what ultimately transpires is, is the worst thing that's ever happened to me, frankly. They convince me that I'm crazy, that I don't actually know what's real, that I witnessed something so traumatic that my mind erased it and made up memories to cover it up. And so everything I think I remember and think is true is not. But also if I don't remember my true memories, I'll never see my family again. And so like I'm in this situation where they're telling me lies that I don't know are lies, that they know that I was present when the crime occurred. They know that I know who the murderer is and they just need me to tell them so that they know not to arrest me as like an accomplice. And I'm just like, oh, my fucking God, like, I don't know what you're even talking about. Like, I don't know who the murderer is. Like, I wasn't there. They don't believe me. And finally, they tell me, well, maybe you witnessed this terrible thing and don't remember it. And you have trauma induced amnesia. But we need you to try to remember to prove that you're on the side of the good guys. So I try to remember something that I can't remember. The Police cobble together a statement. I, in a complete state of just defeated, confused exhaustion, sign it and off to prison I go.
00:18:56
Elizabeth Smart: So they just arrested you right there and took you to prison?
00:18:59
Amanda Knox: Mm-hmm.
00:19:01
Elizabeth Smart: Oh my gosh.
00:19:01
Amanda Knox: Yeah.
Well, first they stripped me naked and photographed my entire body and then they took me to prison.
00:19:08
Elizabeth Smart: Oh my gosh.
00:19:09
Amanda Knox: So.
00:19:09
Elizabeth Smart: That's disgusting.
00:19:11
Amanda Knox: Evidence.
00:19:12
Elizabeth Smart: Evidence.
00:19:12
Amanda Knox: They were looking for evidence.
00:19:14
Elizabeth Smart: Evidence.
00:19:17
Elizabeth Smart: Okay, you get to prison. Your first night must have just been hell. Yeah.
00:19:24
Amanda Knox: They didn't even tell me that I was being taken to prison. They told me that they were taking me to the place for my protection. They said that it would only be for a few days. And so I assumed that they were taking me to, like, some kind of hotel for protected witnesses, you know, whatever. Like, I had no idea. And they take me instead to a prison, which I've never stepped foot in a prison before. And I don't even see it from the outside because they like put me in a police car, put a hat over my head until it covers my face and then push my head between my knees the entire car ride. So, like, I don't even, like, I'm literally being kidnapped. Is what is happening. I'm being literally kidnapped by the police.
00:20:11
Elizabeth Smart: I'm no expert in, like, ethics as far as, like, law enforcement goes. And definitely not foreign law enforcement. But that seems, besides highly unethical, that just seems, what is even the right word? I don't know. Like, shady?
00:20:25
Amanda Knox: It was shady AF, my friend. It was shady AF. Yeah. Well, and they bring me there.
00:20:33
Amanda Knox: And I think it's supposed to be a place where I'm supposed to be protected and I'm supposed to be only for a few days. And I keep asking for my mom and they say, you'll see your mom soon. And so they just keep sort of like brushing me off and I'm brought in there. I'm photographed again and they walk me into this isolation cell and they put me in this cell and basically just bark at me that I'm not allowed to speak to anyone and I'm not allowed to touch anything. So I just curl up on a foam mattress on a steel bed frame. I wrap myself in this coarse wool blanket and I sob myself to sleep. I just want my mom. I feel like a wreck. I don't know if it's true that I've witnessed something or not. I keep telling them I don't know what's real or not. And they just are like, don't worry, you'll see your mom soon. Okay.
00:21:31
Elizabeth Smart: The first night passes, but then you're not, you weren't released.
00:21:36
Amanda Knox: I was in there for 1,428 days.
00:21:40
Elizabeth Smart: Like, how did you do it?
00:21:43
Amanda Knox: Well, the first two years, I felt like I was living in a state of limbo. Like, I felt like I was living somebody else's life by mistake. And I was just waiting for. the adults in the room to like realize that this was all just a big misunderstanding and to give me my life back. And the way that my family and I got through it, the imprisonment and the trial was my family said that it was like being in a dark tunnel, but there was a light at the end of the tunnel. So however dark and scary the situation was, there was an exit.
00:22:23
Elizabeth Smart: But, I mean, there must have been times for you where you felt like, I'm innocent, I've been in here for so long, like, if they thought I was innocent, they would have let me go.
00:22:32
Amanda Knox: Certainly there were moments when I was like, oh, as soon as the detectives get the evidence and realize that I had nothing to do with it, they'll let me go.
00:22:41
Elizabeth Smart: And they didn't.
00:22:43
Amanda Knox: And then they actually found... evidence of who really murdered Meredith and they captured him and they caught him and they brought him in and I was like, oh, now they'll figure it out and let me go.
00:22:54
Elizabeth Smart: I mean, when did you find that out? When did you realize someone else had been arrested?
00:23:00
Amanda Knox: So the really frustrating thing about this story is that They found who really did it very early on. Within two weeks, they found who actually did it. Definitive proof that he actually did it. His DNA was all over the crime scene. His fingerprints and footprints were left in Meredith's blood. He fled the country and adopted a false identity. He was on the run. And they captured him. They captured him and brought him back. They extradited him back to Italy all within weeks. But they had already committed themselves in the international media to a story of me being responsible for Meredith's death. They got signed statements from me saying like implicating myself in the crime. So they just found a way to make it work. And they said, oh, well. Amanda must have orchestrated this crime. And the guy whose DNA is all over the crime scene was just her pawn. He was just the one who sexually assaulted Meredith and then held her down while Amanda stabbed her to death. And that was the story that they went with.
00:24:14
Elizabeth Smart: Has the man that was convicted, has he ever apologized to you? Because yes, absolutely. Like Italian authorities are at fault, but I mean, he left you to take the fall.
00:24:28
Speaker 3: Yeah. So this guy was not a guy that I knew. He was somebody who played basketball with the boys who lived downstairs from us. And what's weird is that the one time. He seemed to ever express any concern over what was happening to me was prior to his arrest. So like I mentioned, he had fled the country, but he still had friends in town and he would be like on Skype with them. And on one of these like Skype calls, he tells one of his friends after the news broke that I had been arrested and, you know. Case closed, they said, oh, the case is closed. We found the murderer. He tells his friend Amanda didn't do it. That's the one time that he expressed any kind of concern. After he was arrested and extradited back to Italy, his tune changes. And he doesn't. Explicitly accuse me, but he does say that he's
innocent, that he had nothing to do with it, and somebody else committed the murder. He then proceeds to go through his own separate trial from us. They separated us in the trial process. And they don't really need to try to convict him because the evidence is, you know, overwhelming and, you know, there's nothing that, like, his claims of innocence are patently absurd. Like, it just doesn't make any sense. So they don't worry really about convicting him. And what they end up doing is they don't actually charge him with all the crimes that he committed. They don't even put a weapon in his hand. In the way that they describe his culpability, the prosecution... charges him with sexually assaulting Meredith, not with actually murdering her, just in participating in the murder orgy. And so he ends up getting convicted and is sentenced to a lesser sentence. He's sentenced to 16 years. And at the end of it all, he gets out after 13, all the while maintaining that he's innocent and letting me take the fall.
00:26:44
Elizabeth Smart: I mean, like his trial really was fast-tracked, but yours went on for years. Can you just kind of quickly take me through the different trials and verdicts that you experienced?
00:27:00
Amanda Knox: The legal rollercoaster?
00:27:01
Elizabeth Smart: Yes, the legal rollercoaster.
00:27:03
Amanda Knox: Yeah, so the actual murderer took advantage of something that they do in the Italian legal system, which is Sort of kind of the equivalent of a plea bargain here in the U.S. It's called a fast track trial. The idea is the prosecutor delivers their theory to a judge and then the judge determines whether or not that theory makes sense and whether or not they can convict or not convict the person. And the benefit of this is you get a lesser sentence if you are convicted. And that's why his trial was separate from mine. It's why it went way quicker and why he was given a lesser sentence, other than the fact that he wasn't ever found guilty of stabbing Meredith to death. I and my defense team opted to do everything we possibly could to defend me, which included having defense witnesses and defense experts and a trial by jury. I was on trial, going into court every week for an entire year. And at the end of it, I was convicted. And I was sentenced to 26 years. And to answer your earlier question of how I got through all of that, that was a moment where it totally changed everything for me. Because up until that moment, I kept thinking that everything was just a big misunderstanding and I was living somebody else's life by mistake and I was waiting for the adults in the room to a judge and a jury to figure that. Out and let me go home. And that didn't happen. And so I went back to prison, which was now my home for the next 26 years. And I had to completely rethink my life and how to survive this. And my first thought was, trigger warning, I don't know if I want to survive this. I don't know if it's fucking worth it to live that life.
So I imagined not doing it. And I imagined how I would end it. And I went through all of that process. And I ultimately decided to keep living. But that was an important part of it for me. Because I had made the choice to keep living. Which meant that it was my responsibility. to make my life worth living. Nobody could hand me a life worth living. That was up to fucking me. And it shifted the way that I handled psychologically the situation. And I'll tell you the truth. I had to do, and I'm sure you as well. had to do so many mental gymnastics to make your life tolerable. But you figure it out. You take it one day at a time. I was able to find a sense of purpose by recognizing all of the advantages that I had compared to other prisoners. That was now my community. They didn't have any kind of support. And so I became a sort of unofficial scribe and translator for people. And that gave me a sense of purpose, even as, you know, everything that I wanted and what that was important to me, including my family and including the idea that I would one day be a mother were taken from me. Now, to go back to the legal roller coaster of it all.
00:30:52
Elizabeth Smart: I mean, you were. It was eventually overturned. But then you got convicted again. I mean, take me into your mind. How did you go from like, okay, finally, to right back into it?
00:31:05
Amanda Knox: So one of the things that I learned from being convicted the first time was that the truth didn't matter. That only stories matter. And that it would be foolish to expect that I would one day be vindicated and freed. Because the truth didn't matter. And in the next trial during my appeal, the truth very much seemed to matter. They appointed independent DNA experts who came in and said, no, like everything that they presented in the first trial was wrong. Like that mattered. And people were asking all the right questions. And I was eventually acquitted. And so that seemed to be like, oh, well, maybe the truth does matter. Except I then entered into a world where I was no longer an anonymous college student. I was the girl who was accused of murder. And I was technically still on trial. Because in Italy, you're not like done once you're acquitted. You're only done once the Supreme Court definitively makes a judgment. And what ended up happening is the next level of court, the highest level, overturned my acquittal. and sent me back down to the second level for retrial, where I was convicted again. And so it wasn't until another four years later, so eight years total on trial, that the highest level court then overturned my second conviction and definitively acquitted me. This legal roller coaster of convicted, acquitted, convicted, acquitted, that took over my entire adult life up until that point and put me in the spotlight of public scrutiny that was viewing me in the worst possible of circumstances, in the worst possible light, accused of a heinous crime against another young woman. And I grew up in that. And I've never fully escaped it because, as you well know, once you're known for something.
00:33:16
Elizabeth Smart: The girl that was kidnapped.
00:33:17
Amanda Knox: Once you're known for that, that's what you're known for. And you have to find a way to integrate that experience into your life, not just because you went through it, but also because you are known for it. Yes.
00:33:31
Elizabeth Smart: Yeah. I understand that. So I want to kind of explore this a little bit farther. I remember clearly like just seeing headline after headline about your case. Did you realize like how much the whole world was watching?
00:33:49
Amanda Knox: I didn't really fully grasp it until I got out of prison because in prison I was a little bit protected by it, which isn't to say that I was fully protected by it.
00:34:00
Elizabeth Smart: Right.
00:34:00
Amanda Knox: Like when I got into the courtroom, there were like dozens and dozens of cameras pointing at me. I didn't know if that's what all courtrooms were like or not. I didn't have any comparison. I did know that in prison I was considered the famous one. And my case was constantly on TV and being written about in the newspaper and written about in all of like the magazines. And we did have access to those things. And so everyone in the prison was constantly gossiping about me. local politicians would come to the prison and they would always go immediately to my cell to view me like a freaking zoo animal. That was just my existence, was like being the famous one, the one that was constantly being observed, the one that everyone was constantly talking about. And even then, that didn't prepare me For like my flight home where everyone else in my family has fallen asleep. I'm too like high on adrenaline from being out of prison after four years to fall asleep. So I turn on the TV and every single channel has my face on it. And I'm like, oh, no. And I go home. And I can't even like go through the airport. I have to get like private security to get through the airport. I have to do a press conference the second I walk off of the plane. There are helicopters that chase me home from the airport. That level of being an object of public fascination, I was not prepared for it.
00:35:52
Elizabeth Smart: Well, and it should have been, I don't know, victorious or like triumphant. Like you finally got out of Italy. Like you got your freedom. Like it should have been a positive experience coming home. But I'm sure having that level of intensity probably didn't make it feel like it was very positive.
00:36:12
Amanda Knox: Yeah. I mean, there were a lot of conflicting emotions, right? There was an immense feeling of relief. But I also had to like transition psychologically from prison to the free world, which itself was already challenging because I was used to spending most of my time in my own head, not talking to anyone, staring at a wall. And now I was surrounded by people who all wanted my attention. And
I found myself immediately overstimulated. by like how much interaction cost me. Like I just wasn't used to it anymore. Like I went from not swimming to swimming a marathon. And on top of that, I couldn't even go home to my house because there were press vans surrounding my house. And so we went to my aunt's house instead. And that sort of went on for years in the sense like it was It wasn't always helicopters that were following me around, but you never knew when they would come out. And like I would go on a walk with my friends in the woods and we would pass somebody walking in the woods and we'd think, oh, that's just a normal person walking through the woods until they pulled out a camera out of their backpack and started taking photos of me. It was just like there was nowhere that I was safe. There was nowhere where I wasn't under a microscope. And anyone that I potentially talked to who I didn't know from before was somebody who was attempting to potentially exploit me. Like somehow they would get interviews with people who lived in the same apartment building that I eventually moved into. Like I remember this one article where Somebody who had never met me before, but who lived in my apartment building, like, was speculating about what kind of movies I was watching and if I was a fan of Mad Men. And, like, it was just like. And they're publishing this, which is what is insane to me. They were so hungry for anything that they were asking random people off the street. And it was just deeply isolating and dehumanizing and overwhelming. And I tried for years to sort of hide from it. And it wasn't like a victorious thing. It wasn't like, oh, Amanda Knox vindicated and freed innocent person. Like, no, there was this like lingering feeling of, well, did she or didn't she?
00:38:52
Elizabeth Smart: Well, that's kind of like my next question because yes, our stories are very different, but we both had a lot of media coverage and people make up their opinions, make up, you know, presumptions about you so in my life I have definitely felt like there's Elizabeth Smart that everyone has an idea of who she is and and knows stuff about her but then there's actually me and it's almost like we're two different people.
00:39:27
Amanda Knox: Or like you're a million different people
00:39:29
Elizabeth Smart: Or you're like a million different people.
00:39:30
Amanda Knox: Like the idea of you isn't consistent yeah right like that's the thing that I found so weird and difficult to navigate was it wasn't just one idea of me. Every single different person had their own take and was projecting their own ideas and feelings and fantasies onto me. And like, I noticed some, and I'm curious if you have found this as well, like I've noticed some themes, like You know, there are a lot of people who think that I got away with murder. And that's, you know, one side of it. There are a lot of people who think that I'm a criminal justice icon and saint. And like there are some people who think that there's like the pornographic version of me in people's minds because, you know, a sexually active young woman accused of a sex crime. There's like a pornographic fantasy to that. Like the innocent sexually active woman accused of a sex crime becomes this like pornographic fantasy. The guilty sexually active woman accused of a sex crime becomes a pornographic fantasy. And walking through the world trying to figure out what version of me is like in the room before I even get there is....
00:40:48
Elizabeth Smart: Exhausting?
00:40:49
Amanda Knox: Exhausting!
00:40:50
Elizabeth Smart: I mean, I don't know that I have necessarily had as many... personas to contend with that you have, but I feel like there definitely is Elizabeth Smart, who knows everything about survivorship and knows exactly all the resources and has like cracked the code perfectly to healing. And you can just talk to her and she knows it all. I don't. I definitely don't.
00:41:16
Amanda Knox: You know a lot. I'll give you that.
00:41:18
Elizabeth Smart: I can speak for myself. I couldn't tell anybody else what to do. I mean, I can talk about my own experience, but, you know, everyone's different. What works for me might not work for anyone else.
00:41:28
Amanda Knox: But here's something that I have found. There are some universal things that extreme experiences can shed light on that I have actually found to be really useful. Like even just, you know, a friend going through a divorce and feeling like their life is over because they're going through a divorce. And then, like, I can come in and say, well. Even when you feel like something bad is happening that's not in your control, it doesn't mean your life is over. Like, let me tell you, it doesn't mean your life is over. I promise you, your life isn't over. Stay curious about what your life may be. But you're right. Like, there is a version of you and also of me where people think we have all the answers. And it's like, I wish.
00:42:17
Elizabeth Smart: Yeah. Well, sure. I wish that. But also, like, I'm not perfect. I think if you talk to me for a little bit, you're like, oh, she's just her.
00:42:25
Amanda Knox: Yeah. The pressure of being perfect.
00:42:28
Elizabeth Smart: Yeah. The most innocent victim.
00:42:30
Amanda Knox: Mmm.
00:42:31
Elizabeth Smart: Yeah.
00:42:33
Amanda Knox: Yeah. The perfect victim.
00:42:34
Elizabeth Smart: Yeah. I certainly am familiar with that.
00:42:40
Speaker 1: Moving on a little bit. When I got home, you know, I was 15 and you know, what did happened to me. I mean, yes, there was a woman involved as well, but it was the man who sexually abused me. And for a while I was scared of men. I did eventually overcome it. I did eventually start dating. I mean, I'm married and have kids now, but there was always a question mark kind of in the back of my head. Like, do you really like me? Like just me who I truly am or Do you just like the thought of going out with Elizabeth
Smart? Was that hard for you? When you started dating again or getting into relationships again, were you hesitant to do that?
00:43:28
Amanda Knox: God, there's so much to unpack from what you just said. And I don't want to skim over the... justified fear of men like that's let's just pause on that for a moment um because in a way lesser way i have felt exploited and sexualized and objectified by men you've gone through that way worse than me but there is the complicated feeling of being like how is it that I am attracted to monsters. Like, yeah, it's so frustrating. Like the number of times I've been like, I would be so much happier if I were a lesbian. I think, you know, I have to say, which isn't to say that women can't be monsters. But like, good God, the way that I had felt turned into a pornographic object, like over and over and over again by men. Whether they were. Sending literal like photoshopped pornographic images of me to me burning in hell or they're going on air as a TV anchor. And the headline is "Amanda Knox: Would ya" like like stuff like that? Like just feeling like being an object of anyone's sexual interest was actually a punishment, not a good thing. And having to like unpack that and actually feel safe to be an object of someone's sexual interest. Like there was that to work through. But then beyond that, there's the issue of being a public woman. Being the partner of a public woman is not an easy thing. You know, like my first partner after all of this was somebody that I had known from before Italy. I was absolutely not dating anybody that I didn't already know. I didn't trust anybody. And he also happened to be a kind of reclusive person. So we would just like hole up together and barely go outside. And the thing that ultimately made that really difficult was that I was very lonely. I was lonely because I felt like the people who loved me and cared about me didn't understand me. And I didn't know what to do about it. We all have a deep desire to want to be known and recognized and loved for who we really are. And I was feeling deeply unrecognized and misunderstood and hated for being something that I wasn't. And hiding away wasn't helping that. So eventually, I start going out there and I start telling my story. And my next partner was somebody who was very supportive of that, but really struggled with the fact that suddenly like the spotlight that was on me was impacting him and his family. Journalists showing up outside his mom's house, random people calling his parents wanting to quote him. He was a musician. And there was this one time where a journalist wrote to him and said, oh, I would love to profile you for this musician magazine. And he shows up for the interview and the guy only asks him questions about me. He felt really diminished by the spotlight that was cast on me and really struggled with that. The man who is my husband and partner today is has been remarkably psychologically healthy about the fact that
like in a lot of people's eyes he's just amanda knox's boy toy right like literally that was a headline like amanda knox's new boy toy meet this guy and here's a bunch of non-real facts about him like that happened to him and people started sending him you know images on facebook of like pictures of himself with knives in them He got that treatment and he's been very good about being like, okay, these are a bunch of crazy people who are not in touch with reality.
00:47:44
Elizabeth Smart: Yeah, they need to get a life.
00:47:45
Amanda Knox: Yeah, they need to get a life. But in another way, he hates that that's my reality and he's a problem solver. And so for a long time, he would do troll whispering is what he called it. He would like get online and and just like find the people saying mean things about me. And he would just try to argue with them.
00:48:04
Speaker 2: Like he would try to like have a constructive conversation, a reasonable conversation with somebody and see if he could change their mind. And of course he can't because they're committed to their own ideas. And so he went like months of doing that and just like driving himself crazy, being like, how is it that I can't like just speak reasonable facts at people? And they're just like completely out of their minds. And so like we both had to do some soul searching and also research into human psychology. And how is it that people convince themselves of things that aren't true so that we could grapple emotionally with what was actually happening in our lives? And in a way, I think my husband still wants people to be nice to me.
00:48:45
Elizabeth Smart: As a husband, like, he should want people to be nice to you. I think there's many remarkable things about you. But I think something that is incredible about you is that you haven't been shy. I mean, like, you.
00:49:02
Amanda Knox: I'm stubborn.
00:49:03
Elizabeth Smart: You haven't just disappeared. I mean, you have taken your life and control of it in so many ways. I mean, I have a list of things. You've got your podcast, Hard Knocks. You've got your one-woman show, Cartwheel. You've written two books about your experience, including your latest one, Free, My Search for Meaning. And I wonder, does exploring your story through so many different projects change the way you look at it yourself?
00:49:31
Amanda Knox: It's funny. Right before I left to go to Edinburgh to put on my one-woman show... A friend of mine who is a museum curator, she was like, Amanda, there needs to be like a museum exhibit just about the ways that you've made art about what happened to you. Because like it's true. I just keep processing my experience in real time and I keep finding new objects of inquiry around it. Like to give an example with Cartwheel, like Cartwheel is about motherhood. because I'm raising a daughter. And the way I was raised by my own mother, in some ways, very ill-equipped me for what happened to me. And in other ways, absolutely gave me
the strength and the love that I needed to survive. And now I'm thinking about being a mother to a daughter in a world that is still very unfair and unsafe for women? And what do I do about that? Like, how do I do that? And like, that's the central question that I'm unpacking in Cartwheel. And it necessitates that the audience understand that I've been through a very traumatic experience as a young woman. Like, this is my reality. What do I take from that as a mother? That's that question. It's interesting. I'm actually going to be teaching a memoir class later in November. I've written two memoirs, right? And I would say that they're very different. Like, my first memoir was directed towards people who were interested in the case from a true crime perspective, who wanted to know the facts as I experienced them, and then my feelings around those facts. My second memoir is not about the facts of the case. It's about how I've found a way to rebuild my life in the shadow of the case and still sort of carrying the trauma of it and all the mistakes that I made along the way. Because of course, like I want to deconstruct this idea that only perfect victims deserve justice. And so that's what that's about. My podcast, one of the things I'm most proud of that I did on my podcast was this series that we did called False Confessions, which was about how this whole process of interrogation grew. Where did it come from? And what could we be doing differently? I'm trying to understand what I went through. And I'm not the first one it ever happened to.
00:52:13
Elizabeth Smart: I mean, I think your podcast sounds so amazing. And actually, I'm really excited to come on. So there's that.
00:52:21
Amanda Knox: So there's that.
00:52:22
Elizabeth Smart: There's that. But You know, recently I did an episode on my podcast where I had some survivors that I have interviewed come in and kind of weigh in on the Cornell 7 case. And one thing that we noticed was how quick people were to judge Jane Doe's character and why did she do what she did and why this and why that. And so I wonder when you see situations like that, does that take you back to your own case? Does that stir up really strong feelings and emotions for you?
00:52:56
Amanda Knox: It stirs up strong feelings and emotions for all of the reasons why you mentioned and also more because I've undergone trial by media. I have strong feelings about how facts of a case get disputed outside of the legal context and in the public arena and how there are no rules around it and how harmful and not just destructive to people, but also to the truth-seeking process that can be. At the same time, there is a reason that people talk about it because a lot of people can relate to it. They're putting themselves into the scenario. And what's interesting for me is that I've been on the victim side of things. I've been on the defendant side of things. And so I always end up seeming to have a perspective that's a little bit different than everybody else's. What I found really obnoxious is there's this impulse for people to be like, well, but didn't you actually want that violence to happen to you? Like, didn't you actually consent to that violence that was done to you? just by your behavior or just the fact that she worked out in a gym, suddenly that is used as evidence that she couldn't have had violence done against her. Like, it drives me crazy. The ultimate thing that I find really frustrating is a lot of people cherry pick. Like, the deeper they get into it, it's not because they are like, deeply seeking a truth, it's because they're seeking confirmation of what they already believe.
00:54:30
Elizabeth Smart: Absolutely.
00:54:31
Amanda Knox: And so to like give you just an example of that in my own case. So Meredith also worked out in the sense that like back in England, she had taken some karate classes once. And In order to argue that she must have been the victim of a group killing and not a single armed man who was also athletic. They argued that she would have been strong enough to fight off a athletic male wielding a weapon because she had taken a few karate classes. I was like, are you fucking kidding me? People will cherry pick reality in order to fit whatever conclusion that they want.
00:55:17
Elizabeth Smart: I am with you. Like, and the reality is like I have trained and I have run marathons and I lift, and my husband, he's great. He does not consistently work out. But me, at my best running, he could still outrun me. He was still faster than me.
00:55:36
Amanda Knox: This is a fact of life.
00:55:37
Elizabeth Smart: Me right now, lifting five, six days a week, guess what? He's still stronger than me. And also... Like one of my good friends is a world champion in Brazilian jujitsu. She's done cage fighting. She's done it all. She's done MMA. You could say she's a lethal weapon, but she is a survivor herself. And she'll be the first one to tell you that even she, with her extensive training, her decorated athleticism, it could still happen to her tomorrow. We have trauma responses that we have no control over. Yeah.
00:56:12
Amanda Knox: And one of those trauma responses being, when you're outnumbered and overwhelmed to sort of freeze. And like, I'm glad that Jane Doe is still Jane Doe. And this is not like a person's image and face that's being thrown out there. But like, I do find myself frustrated with how obtuse people are being about this. Like, Just because somebody agrees to do a threesome doesn't mean that they agreed to do a gangbang. I just I find the whole conversation around that very obtuse. I think what's more interesting as a conversation is how like drugs complicate questions like this, how group dynamics complicate questions like this, how culture complicates questions like this. I think all of those are worth asking. And I do not think it is worth scrutinizing the victim. I do not think that that is worth asking. Yeah.
00:57:11
Elizabeth Smart: Okay. So you did recently write about the Lindsay Clancy case and the speculation and conspiracy theories surrounding her husband, Patrick. What are your thoughts and feelings of the way that people have judged Lindsay and Patrick without letting the legal process play out?
00:57:31
Amanda Knox: Great question. So I think that the Lindsay Clancy trial is bringing to light some really important facts, like realities to people. That something as horrific as the murders of three innocent, defenseless children, babies, could be not an act of evil. Even though it feels like the most evil thing possible, it could be a failed system that failed a woman who was in dire need of help and all of that. Like I was not mad that people were considering the complications of being a postpartum traumatized woman and how that might impact her reality and all of the ways that like she sought help and didn't get the help that she needed. Like I thought that that was really valuable information. in terms of like talking about what happened. And I think it was really great that in a case where like, you know, she doesn't deny that she did it. She just denies that she did it maliciously and willingly and not because she had crazy voices in her head that made her feel crazy. That was an interesting conversation. The turn that then happened, though, Where suddenly she's not the bad guy that everyone is looking for. They suddenly like want a bad guy. And so they start looking at her husband's behavior and totally reframing. behaviors of his that were celebrated like a year earlier, like him running a marathon in honor of his children in order to raise money for the hospital where he brought them and they died in his arms. Like he was celebrated as somebody who was, you know, performing his grief. in a way that was constructive and healthy. And suddenly now people are reframing that as, well, if Lindsay's not the evil person we're looking for, we're looking for an evil person. Maybe he actually did it and then threw her out the window and then convinced her that she did it. Like just the amount of like reaching that I saw to sort of blame this man who had lost his children just like bothered me. I just felt like, people were reaching for the evil answer just in a roundabout way instead of focusing on what do we do about the fact that there are people who struggle with mental illness when they're in the most vulnerable position and with the most vulnerable people in our society. And what are we doing about that?
01:00:20
Elizabeth Smart: I think your insight on that is so important and for people to hear. And you really don't know I mean, it's like that saying, you'd never know what a person's going through until you walk a mile in their shoes. I really do appreciate the time that you've taken to chat with me. I feel like I could sit here and ask you questions all day.
01:00:35
Amanda Knox: Well, I feel like we could talk at length. So I look forward to the next time.
01:00:41
Elizabeth Smart: Me too. Me too. Next time on The Survivor Files.
01:00:46
Anna Nasset: I was on my cell phone with my dad. And out of nowhere, he just appears in front of my car. I scream, he's here, hung up on my dad, threw my car into reverse and drove away.
01:00:59
Elizabeth Smart: Ana Nasset spends almost a decade being stalked by a stranger.
01:01:04
Anna Nasset: He knew the line. If I just linger, she's probably not going to call the cops. This is terrifying to my core, but what do I do with it? How do I report any of this?
01:01:16
Elizabeth Smart: Wherever she goes, it feels like he's there too.
01:01:20
Anna Nasset: How did a five-minute conversation with this guy change my entire life forever?
01:01:28
Elizabeth Smart: Amanda Knox's memoir, Free! My Search for Meaning, is available now, and her documentary, Mouth of the Wolf, Amanda Knox Returns to Italy, is currently streaming on Hulu. Thank you for listening to The Survivor Files. New episodes every Monday. Listen, subscribe, share, and don't forget to set up automatic downloads. You can also follow us at the Survivor Files pod on Instagram. The Survivor Files is produced by Marwar Junction Productions for iHeart Podcasts. Our producers are Steve Kniff and Natalie Freed. Our executive producers are Joseph Freed and Allison Berkley. The executive producer for iHeart Podcasts is Katrina Norvell.