UDSKRIFT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:07.145 --> 00:08.707
[SPEAKER_00]: and welcome to our show.
00:08.987 --> 00:11.310
[SPEAKER_00]: The shit no one tells you about writing.
00:12.050 --> 00:15.975
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm best selling author Bianca Marie, and I'm joined by C.C.
00:16.035 --> 00:20.840
[SPEAKER_00]: Lira of Wendy Sherman Associates and Carly Waters of PS Literary.
00:21.972 --> 00:34.267
[SPEAKER_00]: Hi everyone, today's guest is the number one international bestselling author of 15 novels, more than 100 short stories, the lyrics of a country based in album and a non-fiction lore book.
00:34.708 --> 00:38.012
[SPEAKER_00]: His books are sold in 150 countries and translated into 25 languages.
00:40.895 --> 00:49.921
[SPEAKER_00]: His first novel featuring Lincoln Rhyme, the bone collector, was made into a major motion picture starring Denzel Washington and Angelina Jolie.
00:50.281 --> 01:05.470
[SPEAKER_00]: CBS's head television show Tracca is based on his culture short series of thrillers, is received or been shortlisted for a number of awards around the world, including novel of the year by the international thriller writers and the end flaming steel dagger from the
01:08.912 --> 01:17.414
[SPEAKER_00]: He was recently named the Grand Master of Mystery Rites as of America, who's ranks included Agatha Christie, Illyre Queen, and Alfred Hitchcock.
01:17.815 --> 01:25.297
[SPEAKER_00]: In 2014, he was the recipient of three Lifetime Achievement Awards, a former journalist, folks, singer, and attorney.
01:25.657 --> 01:34.839
[SPEAKER_00]: He was born outside of Chicago and has a Bachelor of Journalism degree from the University of Missouri and a Lord degree from Fordham University.
01:35.000 --> 01:36.460
[SPEAKER_00]: It's my pleasure to welcome back
01:36.860 --> 01:39.561
[SPEAKER_00]: Jeffrey, Deva, Jeffrey, welcome back to the show.
01:39.801 --> 01:41.642
[SPEAKER_01]: Thank you, good to talk to you again, Bech.
01:41.982 --> 01:44.023
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, my goodness, that is one hell of a bio.
01:44.063 --> 01:46.524
[SPEAKER_00]: I lost my breath there a few times, you know?
01:46.544 --> 01:49.225
[SPEAKER_01]: I had a laugh of Bech as I can see you.
01:49.285 --> 01:50.966
[SPEAKER_01]: I love these podcast videos.
01:51.306 --> 01:52.546
[SPEAKER_01]: And you're holding a tone.
01:52.986 --> 01:55.607
[SPEAKER_01]: A book that looks like it has about 500 pages in it.
01:55.647 --> 01:58.348
[SPEAKER_01]: And I thought, that must be my entire biography.
01:58.368 --> 01:59.949
[SPEAKER_01]: And you gave a little pre-see of it.
02:02.082 --> 02:05.744
[SPEAKER_00]: It is absolutely incredible when you have to cut down your buyer.
02:06.145 --> 02:15.470
[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, so for those of our listeners who are not watching on YouTube, I am holding up the book, cover the book we're discussing today is the collateral heart.
02:15.930 --> 02:18.772
[SPEAKER_00]: As mentioned earlier, it's part of the Lincoln Rhyme series.
02:18.892 --> 02:23.075
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm going to just read you the flap copies so they will all on the same page and they will be diving in.
02:23.635 --> 02:29.398
[SPEAKER_00]: When a harrowing arson in Manhattan boons are building to the ground, raiman sacks are called to investigate.
02:29.858 --> 02:35.040
[SPEAKER_00]: Only to discover in the rubble a package of clues that teases where the purple strike next.
02:35.580 --> 02:44.184
[SPEAKER_00]: raiman sacks were feverishly to unravel the mystery, turning to an unlikely source for help, one of the nation's most popular history podcasters.
02:44.724 --> 02:54.169
[SPEAKER_00]: along the way they're cross paths with dead demonavail, a determined detector from Long Island who is in search of the killer of a young woman from her neighborhood.
02:54.589 --> 03:00.932
[SPEAKER_00]: As rhymes team digs into both cases, it becomes increasingly clear that their suspect's plot
03:01.452 --> 03:04.213
[SPEAKER_00]: might be more complicated than they initially thought.
03:04.553 --> 03:09.976
[SPEAKER_00]: But can rhyme and sex unpack his vile scheme and stop the carnage in time.
03:10.296 --> 03:18.700
[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, so the last time we spoke Jeffrey, these are the things we covered so I don't want to cover them again for our listeners.
03:19.310 --> 03:22.571
[SPEAKER_00]: go back into our archives, you will find this interview.
03:22.591 --> 03:42.519
[SPEAKER_00]: So what we really broke down in that interview was one Jeffrey Shade, he's really business minded philosophy on publishing in which he emphasised that authors need to view their books as commercial products and they need to treat the audience as valued customers who demand a high quality
03:45.652 --> 03:49.493
[SPEAKER_00]: And that really helped to reframe a lot of writing for me.
03:49.553 --> 03:52.514
[SPEAKER_00]: You stability that, Jeffrey, I don't believe anything's changed there.
03:52.934 --> 03:53.654
[SPEAKER_01]: Absolutely.
03:53.935 --> 04:05.078
[SPEAKER_01]: I feel that we authors, I mean, what a one of blessed role we have and life to be able to make up stories that will be emotionally engaging for people.
04:05.898 --> 04:16.307
[SPEAKER_01]: and sit on our rear ends and chairs and stare at the ceiling and talk to our dogs when we're on walks and think of ideas, what a wonderful life that is.
04:16.887 --> 04:24.914
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think that means we have such a responsibility to give readers something that will be worthy of their money.
04:25.394 --> 04:27.316
[SPEAKER_01]: It's a product, of course, as I said.
04:27.576 --> 04:30.799
[SPEAKER_01]: But also, if they're time, we are so inundated.
04:31.406 --> 04:32.387
[SPEAKER_01]: with life.
04:32.707 --> 04:38.932
[SPEAKER_01]: I can't even, we'd spend the whole half hour talking about everything that steals our attention and steals our time.
04:39.352 --> 04:55.785
[SPEAKER_01]: But if you're going to turn to a book, which I feel is the most engaging emotionally creative
Load full transcript
experience we can have, we better give them something that will allow our product to stand out above the den of the streaming and life in general.
04:56.419 --> 04:57.959
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, totally, totally agree.
04:57.979 --> 05:01.500
[SPEAKER_00]: They people's attention spans are shorter than ever used to be.
05:02.000 --> 05:04.201
[SPEAKER_00]: And so we've got to grab them even earlier.
05:04.281 --> 05:06.141
[SPEAKER_00]: And we discussed this last time as well.
05:06.501 --> 05:20.844
[SPEAKER_00]: We kind of did a deep dive into the specific techniques required to grab a redesign from page one, maintain like a very, very tight narrative tension so that they'll keep turning pages late into the night.
05:21.224 --> 05:30.983
[SPEAKER_00]: So for our listeners who are coming into this interview, hoping for that, go back and listen to the last one, because I'm crawling even further into Jeffrey's brain in this interview.
05:31.539 --> 05:54.992
[SPEAKER_00]: But Jeffrey, you know, as a hyperplotter who can spend up to 8 months crafting detailed outlines that you've said, or sometimes 150 to 200 pages before you write a single word of the actual novel and this is a core piece of this page turning methodology can you take us through that process.
05:55.833 --> 05:56.533
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, of course.
05:56.893 --> 05:57.733
[SPEAKER_01]: I am obsessive.
05:58.314 --> 06:04.095
[SPEAKER_01]: I know hundreds, if not thousands of authors, I've been writing now for full time for about 40 years.
06:04.955 --> 06:09.036
[SPEAKER_01]: I am the most outlining outliner of anyone I know.
06:09.916 --> 06:17.458
[SPEAKER_01]: You as beginning authors or as establish authors do not need to do that, but you need to know where you're going.
06:18.018 --> 06:21.281
[SPEAKER_01]: I think of Joyce Carol Oce's wonderful statement.
06:21.321 --> 06:25.405
[SPEAKER_01]: You can't write the first sentence until you know what the last sentence is.
06:25.425 --> 06:28.568
[SPEAKER_01]: And there are many variations on that.
06:28.688 --> 06:32.692
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, Gustav Flobert said that books are pyramids.
06:32.792 --> 06:35.315
[SPEAKER_01]: That's how they're constructed according to a plan and it's
06:35.855 --> 06:36.756
[SPEAKER_01]: laborious work.
06:36.796 --> 06:40.378
[SPEAKER_01]: Hemingway said that writing is architecture.
06:40.578 --> 06:42.180
[SPEAKER_01]: It's not interior design.
06:42.540 --> 06:59.932
[SPEAKER_01]: So you have to get that structure down, and I could go on and on about the reasons for that, but essentially there are two of the one that a book, and I say any book, whether it's a book or a word, nominee, a short list, or the kind of commercial fiction that I write for the fun of it, it's about structure.
07:00.392 --> 07:02.434
[SPEAKER_01]: I would rather read a well-structured book,
07:03.034 --> 07:07.477
[SPEAKER_01]: than one that is filled with the glossy, simple-ladening process and what do I mean by structure?
07:07.797 --> 07:10.519
[SPEAKER_01]: Look at Beethoven, my favorite romantic ira composer.
07:11.019 --> 07:19.064
[SPEAKER_01]: He did not give you five on Dante movements together because by the second half of the second one you're starting to lose attention.
07:19.124 --> 07:20.225
[SPEAKER_01]: It's not exciting anymore.
07:20.665 --> 07:25.428
[SPEAKER_01]: in order to give you four adagios one right after another because you'd fall asleep.
07:25.648 --> 07:28.969
[SPEAKER_01]: No, he did what I use as a model for my books.
07:29.430 --> 07:30.570
[SPEAKER_01]: We opened with a theme.
07:30.910 --> 07:31.991
[SPEAKER_01]: Believe me, I'm not going to sing.
07:32.011 --> 07:43.257
[SPEAKER_01]: I was a folk singer, but I respect you viewers and listeners far too much for me to even home a tune, but we opened with a theme and then we'll have an on Dante and then we'll have a Vachie and the book.
07:43.877 --> 08:11.092
[SPEAKER_01]: leads up the more exciting variety come later the slower lentil movements come come in between those then there's the crescendo the big end and I will do da da da da da da da da you get it then at the end there's a soft reconciliation of that theme that's called a coda well that's how I structure my books and I think that's how authors should structure their books why emotional engagement so that's one reason to outline the other reason is and I won't believe
08:12.813 --> 08:15.374
[SPEAKER_01]: figuring out where you're going to go having a roadmap is vital.
08:15.934 --> 08:18.635
[SPEAKER_01]: And the reason is this, there are some books that should not have been written.
08:19.355 --> 08:20.436
[SPEAKER_01]: And how does that happen?
08:20.596 --> 08:28.839
[SPEAKER_01]: Because we come up with a brilliant idea, we sit down, we start to write, the first chapter comes out, oh, it's so exciting and it's oscillating and wonderful.
08:29.159 --> 08:30.379
[SPEAKER_01]: We do the second chapter.
08:30.679 --> 08:34.861
[SPEAKER_01]: Still good, third chapter slows down a little bit, five, six, we come up with a sixth chapter.
08:35.541 --> 08:37.322
[SPEAKER_01]: And it is a brick wall,
08:39.136 --> 08:41.117
[SPEAKER_01]: why because you didn't know where you were going.
08:41.477 --> 08:45.959
[SPEAKER_01]: You've then got about 200 pages of well-written prose, but you don't know where it's going to go.
08:46.479 --> 08:50.201
[SPEAKER_01]: You then have two options, and you're going to get my take on it right now.
08:50.641 --> 09:03.486
[SPEAKER_01]: One is the it'll actually dishonest, cowardly, reprehensible approach, and that is to throw in a cliche written middle and have a DSX Mac and a ending where you kind of come up with the killer at the last minute and put that out in the stream of public.
09:03.526 --> 09:05.007
[SPEAKER_01]: And you have given your readers,
09:08.788 --> 09:10.468
[SPEAKER_01]: Number two, you throw the whole thing out.
09:10.909 --> 09:14.289
[SPEAKER_01]: The morally courageous
upright and leisurely honest thing to do.
09:14.969 --> 09:17.770
[SPEAKER_01]: And it's a terrible waste of time and it's hard to do.
09:18.490 --> 09:22.271
[SPEAKER_01]: But if you were outlining, you have the little post that notes on your board.
09:22.471 --> 09:24.392
[SPEAKER_01]: You throw them up, you spend a week looking at it.
09:24.452 --> 09:27.052
[SPEAKER_01]: And you think, you know what, this is a book that should not be written.
09:27.532 --> 09:31.073
[SPEAKER_01]: You go back to page one and start on something that should be written.
09:31.493 --> 09:33.114
[SPEAKER_01]: Outlining helps you do that.
09:34.134 --> 09:34.414
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
09:34.674 --> 09:34.954
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
09:35.518 --> 09:47.583
[SPEAKER_00]: Listen, as a chronic cancer who cannot outline for neither love nor money, I wish I could because it is such a more efficient process and I agree 100% with everything you have said.
09:47.943 --> 09:52.184
[SPEAKER_00]: But the minute I know what's going to happen in my novel, I have zero desire to write it.
09:52.605 --> 09:53.865
[SPEAKER_00]: But I agree with you as well.
09:54.045 --> 09:56.206
[SPEAKER_00]: I feel like writers are made in the second act.
09:56.780 --> 10:10.351
[SPEAKER_00]: You can have a brilliant first act, you can have a brilliant third act, but really good writers are made in that act too where you say it a lot of the times are just kind of the whole thing falls apart and people are like, I'm not quite sure what they're how to do here.
10:10.812 --> 10:14.515
[SPEAKER_00]: I very recently interviewed Linwood Barclay for the part cost.
10:14.755 --> 10:18.716
[SPEAKER_00]: And I mentioned to him that I noticed he barely describes characters.
10:19.096 --> 10:22.678
[SPEAKER_00]: He gives sort of a word or two a stroke here or there.
10:23.098 --> 10:38.042
[SPEAKER_00]: So while reading the collateral heart, it really stood out to me how much time you spend on describing clothing and sitting and how much heavy lifting does, in fact, beyond description.
10:38.062 --> 10:41.624
[SPEAKER_00]: So I'm going to read a few here for our listeners just so that they can
10:43.004 --> 10:48.708
[SPEAKER_00]: Bale retired to her room for a fast-cold shower, body, not hair, and then dried herself.
10:49.168 --> 10:51.550
[SPEAKER_00]: She pulled on a beige dress with a high-colonic.
10:51.930 --> 10:59.835
[SPEAKER_00]: The belt seemed a bit tighter than what she remembered from when she'd lost one or the outfit, and me a five days ago, probably imagination.
11:00.216 --> 11:06.700
[SPEAKER_00]: She would, however, go to the peanut buttercrust, mattey disdained, a look at herself in the mirror, form fitting.
11:07.000 --> 11:15.426
[SPEAKER_00]: It was the sort of garment whose upper quadrant men used to glance at, but did no longer, unless it was to note a self-sure or coffee stain.
11:15.886 --> 11:22.951
[SPEAKER_00]: Then sensible flats and adjective her mother used frequently to describe clothing, kitchenware and men.
11:23.472 --> 11:26.934
[SPEAKER_00]: Minimal makeup enough to erase, say, four years.
11:27.474 --> 11:31.477
[SPEAKER_00]: In the kitchen she had to cross anyway and curried a cardboard
11:36.154 --> 11:42.664
[SPEAKER_00]: Now firstly when I read that I thought of a Lincoln rhyme would freak out if he knew she used the word curing as a verb.
11:43.535 --> 11:49.399
[SPEAKER_00]: We're just the first thing I cracked up at and there's another one that we're going to get to not.
11:49.419 --> 11:56.263
[SPEAKER_00]: But can you just like talk about the heavy lifting this description does because it gives us backstory.
11:56.323 --> 12:02.667
[SPEAKER_00]: It gives us curiosity seeds and does so much more than just paying to picture that we can imagine here.
12:02.947 --> 12:04.588
[SPEAKER_01]: Forgive me if I said this earlier.
12:04.668 --> 12:07.090
[SPEAKER_01]: This is a sounds like a tangent, but there's some point to it.
12:07.690 --> 12:12.393
[SPEAKER_01]: I would like to now give you and the readers what I consider our mission statement.
12:13.069 --> 12:14.670
[SPEAKER_01]: as authors, as novelists.
12:15.371 --> 12:16.452
[SPEAKER_01]: And that is this.
12:16.532 --> 12:17.733
[SPEAKER_01]: I alluded to it a moment ago.
12:18.233 --> 12:26.420
[SPEAKER_01]: And that is to create the most emotionally engaging experience we can for the readers, intense and developing, consuming.
12:27.284 --> 12:29.345
[SPEAKER_01]: and, well, that's kind of grand language.
12:29.785 --> 12:30.666
[SPEAKER_01]: What do I mean by that?
12:31.166 --> 12:36.349
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, I define the most emotionally engaging experience in a story as this.
12:36.709 --> 12:47.795
[SPEAKER_01]: It's a work of fiction could be a short story or novel in which living breathing characters, fully fleshed out characters, good and bad, confront increasingly difficult questions,
12:48.475 --> 12:57.258
[SPEAKER_01]: and conflicts, ideally in a short period of time, which conflicts and questions are ultimately resolved to the reader's satisfaction.
12:57.518 --> 13:00.739
[SPEAKER_01]: Not necessarily a happy ending, but a satisfying ending.
13:01.040 --> 13:06.362
[SPEAKER_01]: That is the model for all of my 50 books in a 120-some odd short stories.
13:06.742 --> 13:08.902
[SPEAKER_01]: I always keep that in mind.
13:09.303 --> 13:10.383
[SPEAKER_01]: And part of that,
13:10.904 --> 13:16.671
[SPEAKER_01]: the definition which you heard a moment ago is living breathing fully fleshed out characters.
13:17.011 --> 13:29.145
[SPEAKER_01]: I heard something quite interesting on national public radio here in America, and it was that it was a neuroscientist who said the same portion of our brain.
13:30.027 --> 13:33.730
[SPEAKER_01]: that forms a connection with real individuals.
13:34.031 --> 13:45.741
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, people we have a true deep connection with our husbands, wives, partners, spouses, not to be redundant, but you know, Mary
couples, not Mary couples, children, parents, a close friends.
13:46.281 --> 13:51.566
[SPEAKER_01]: That part of the brain, which I cannot pronounce and I won't try to, but it's an actual little thing in the in the brain.
13:52.230 --> 13:56.634
[SPEAKER_01]: is the same that creates within us in emotional connection with fictional characters.
13:57.094 --> 14:01.478
[SPEAKER_01]: And that's one of the reasons we love, say, I loved, I grew up in the James Bond books.
14:02.039 --> 14:03.800
[SPEAKER_01]: I love the concept of James Bond.
14:03.820 --> 14:04.921
[SPEAKER_01]: I wanted to spend time with him.
14:05.362 --> 14:12.108
[SPEAKER_01]: And the kids with Harry Potter nowadays, and the younger games characters, we just absolutely love
14:12.708 --> 14:13.288
[SPEAKER_01]: the characters.
14:13.668 --> 14:19.709
[SPEAKER_01]: And the story can be, you know, some are better, some are worse than others, but they want to spend time with the characters.
14:20.089 --> 14:32.492
[SPEAKER_01]: So that's why I add those little things, and kudos to you for recognizing which I do sometimes to torment, like in rhyme, what I call it, you're going to love this, verbing nouns, which we drive him crazy as well.
14:32.552 --> 14:36.373
[SPEAKER_01]: But little, little Phillips like that, I think, can really make a book.
14:38.455 --> 14:42.296
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, well, it's specificity that makes a story come alive, right?
14:42.616 --> 14:44.456
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm going to read another part here as well.
14:44.856 --> 14:48.257
[SPEAKER_00]: The detective was a large man for ever battling his weight.
14:48.637 --> 14:51.717
[SPEAKER_00]: Ryan wasn't sure why he bothered and this it was a health matter.
14:52.097 --> 14:53.718
[SPEAKER_00]: Then there was the issue of garments.
14:53.998 --> 14:57.758
[SPEAKER_00]: It seemed he brought clothing that was resistant to an iron stud.
14:58.219 --> 14:59.779
[SPEAKER_00]: He was constantly disheveled.
15:00.179 --> 15:02.459
[SPEAKER_00]: The two men used to be partners in the days before
15:06.380 --> 15:22.330
[SPEAKER_00]: and he sometimes wondered if Salitha's look was intentional, calculated to put suspects at ease, give them a sense of confidence and superiority, lowering their defenses so that he could land like a fainther, destroy their phony stories, and skewer them into confessing.
15:22.770 --> 15:29.074
[SPEAKER_00]: Today the rumpled attire was grey, a slightly too large suit, maybe indication of him dropping a few pants.
15:29.214 --> 15:34.578
[SPEAKER_00]: The shade was light, wouldn't darker be aesthetically safer with wrinkles, a white shirt.
15:34.978 --> 15:38.020
[SPEAKER_00]: He wore tie to and rhyme new it would be a clip on.
15:38.380 --> 15:45.385
[SPEAKER_00]: He street fighting days were largely over, but he still followed the practice of some gold shield to wore fake ties so a
15:48.975 --> 15:53.798
[SPEAKER_00]: So again, they would get like this description of him, but we get so much more.
15:53.839 --> 15:56.120
[SPEAKER_00]: We get things from their day-to-day life.
15:56.160 --> 15:57.881
[SPEAKER_00]: Like they would never have a coat to me.
15:57.901 --> 16:00.403
[SPEAKER_00]: You have to wear clip-on ties or someone doesn't choke you.
16:00.523 --> 16:05.987
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, and what this tells us so much is because this is from Lincoln Ryan's perspective.
16:06.127 --> 16:12.792
[SPEAKER_00]: It tells us so much about him as he's describing the detective at the same time.
16:13.607 --> 16:16.028
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, you have sent a very important point there.
16:16.268 --> 16:22.751
[SPEAKER_01]: One of, I guess, the foundational rules in writing fiction is show, don't tell.
16:23.791 --> 16:31.114
[SPEAKER_01]: And I could very easily have said, when we can rhyme, noted his former partner, Salito, show up in a wrinkled suit.
16:31.835 --> 16:36.857
[SPEAKER_01]: And that would have registered and people would have thought, OK, but there's no emotional connection there.
16:37.542 --> 16:41.604
[SPEAKER_01]: but you made the very good observation that seen from Lake Inder Island's point of view.
16:42.245 --> 16:50.149
[SPEAKER_01]: Suddenly, we now know something about Saleto and something about rhyme so that maybe it took me a little more effort.
16:50.209 --> 16:51.930
[SPEAKER_01]: And I remember writing that passage.
16:52.150 --> 16:53.591
[SPEAKER_01]: Took me a little more effort to do.
16:53.671 --> 16:55.792
[SPEAKER_01]: And again, I sit back and close my eyes.
16:55.872 --> 16:59.914
[SPEAKER_01]: And imagine Saleto walking into the room, but that
17:00.433 --> 17:17.293
[SPEAKER_01]: little extra added element can, I think, solidify these characters in the minds of readers, so that when the bad guy, say, walks into Lincoln Rhymes, room is central park west townhouse with a weapon, we suddenly care all the more, because Lincoln's the hero, of course,
17:17.753 --> 17:21.696
[SPEAKER_01]: But now we don't want him to die, we don't want him to be more injured.
17:22.096 --> 17:25.038
[SPEAKER_01]: And imagine doing that as I do the same level of description.
17:25.459 --> 17:32.724
[SPEAKER_01]: With secondary and tertiary characters that are like the fifth man on the Starship Enterprise, you know, we know they're expendable.
17:33.275 --> 17:34.896
[SPEAKER_01]: And so, oh no, we love this guy.
17:34.916 --> 17:36.277
[SPEAKER_01]: He's going home to, he's a witness.
17:36.297 --> 17:41.279
[SPEAKER_01]: He's going home to see his wife, and yet what happens, but then the bad guy jumps out of the alley.
17:41.719 --> 17:42.800
[SPEAKER_01]: And what's going to happen?
17:43.240 --> 17:47.322
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, of course, then being the manipulative person that I am, we cut immediately to a different scene.
17:47.702 --> 17:55.686
[SPEAKER_01]: So we, I keep readers going to see if our, our character, whom we learned a lot about, and his love of his family and children, but he is expendable.
17:55.886 --> 17:56.746
[SPEAKER_01]: He's going to live or not.
17:56.826 --> 17:58.167
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, keep turning those pages.
17:59.247 --> 18:26.418
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I love it and also the way that Lincoln thinks because Lincoln would be the kind of person who would put those associations together like does he do it on purpose to throw somebody off and make them under estimate him for example and someone else looking at him would just be like Jesus guys will slob you know they wouldn't they wouldn't put those reasons together so for our listeners who are writing descriptions of other characters and we're in a specific
18:27.078 --> 18:37.765
[SPEAKER_00]: character's POV, whether it's first person or third person, remember you've really got explained the kind of things that they would notice in the world and Lincoln Rime is a character who notices everything.
18:38.065 --> 18:52.333
[SPEAKER_00]: You could have a very materialistic woman in a scene who's going to notice someone else's purse and how big her ring is and what she's wearing, but if you have somebody who's not at all like that, they're not even going to notice what the person's wearing.
18:52.353 --> 18:56.096
[SPEAKER_00]: So it always needs to come through very clearly in that person's point
18:57.115 --> 19:01.616
[SPEAKER_01]: And let me give one caveat here, the way I write is on a keyboard.
19:01.896 --> 19:04.357
[SPEAKER_01]: I find dictating too fast.
19:04.957 --> 19:06.837
[SPEAKER_01]: I find long hand, too slow.
19:07.538 --> 19:13.399
[SPEAKER_01]: And the way the thoughts go down to the hands on the keyboard, and I can touch type, so I can close my eyes and type.
19:13.879 --> 19:14.939
[SPEAKER_01]: That's just perfect.
19:15.319 --> 19:26.062
[SPEAKER_01]: But because of the ease of computer keyboards is supposed to what I began on old typewriters, mechanical typewriters, I can write a lot very quickly.
19:26.777 --> 19:31.938
[SPEAKER_01]: And so the passages you just read were originally probably twice as long.
19:32.418 --> 19:40.220
[SPEAKER_01]: And indeed, the entire book, the first draft of the entire book is not twice as long, but I mean, they now average about 100,000 words.
19:40.580 --> 19:43.501
[SPEAKER_01]: They start out being 110, 120,000 words.
19:44.141 --> 19:46.541
[SPEAKER_01]: And I go back and it doesn't make me panic.
19:46.621 --> 19:49.762
[SPEAKER_01]: I read passages and I say, oh, the slows down is too much here.
19:50.142 --> 19:50.762
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't panic.
19:50.802 --> 19:51.722
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't you have to trim.
19:54.423 --> 20:02.030
[SPEAKER_01]: There are only great rewriters, and so I rewrite, rewrite, rewrite, and this might be helpful for beginning authors out there.
20:02.050 --> 20:03.951
[SPEAKER_01]: I rewrite in three different ways.
20:04.572 --> 20:10.437
[SPEAKER_01]: One, I rewrite on the computer, because it's very easy to change names if I want to.
20:10.597 --> 20:11.458
[SPEAKER_01]: Search
and replace.
20:12.038 --> 20:14.620
[SPEAKER_01]: I also may get an idea in my head.
20:14.900 --> 20:16.142
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, but you know what?
20:16.282 --> 20:19.945
[SPEAKER_01]: In that scene on the peer, he should have found
20:20.746 --> 20:25.168
[SPEAKER_01]: a second clue that would read Harry that might mislead the readers.
20:25.528 --> 20:26.749
[SPEAKER_01]: But where was that scene?
20:26.769 --> 20:27.629
[SPEAKER_01]: I just don't remember.
20:28.149 --> 20:31.511
[SPEAKER_01]: I took in the pair and it shows up immediately.
20:31.851 --> 20:38.774
[SPEAKER_01]: I also have a trick that I use that I would recommend when it comes to like character names or location names.
20:39.434 --> 20:40.755
[SPEAKER_01]: Like let's give an example.
20:40.955 --> 20:44.676
[SPEAKER_01]: I've got a character named I'm making this up at Frankovitch.
20:44.837 --> 20:45.177
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay?
20:45.597 --> 20:46.897
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, that's kind of tricky to type.
20:50.892 --> 20:54.015
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, I don't, I don't, I don't have to do that.
20:54.135 --> 20:55.916
[SPEAKER_01]: I type three F's in a row.
20:56.176 --> 21:01.881
[SPEAKER_01]: So, you know, detective FFF picked up the gun and then he got in his car and drove to MMM.
21:02.542 --> 21:02.822
[SPEAKER_01]: What's that?
21:02.962 --> 21:03.422
[SPEAKER_01]: Manhattan.
21:03.703 --> 21:06.345
[SPEAKER_01]: So when that's all done, I've been able to write quickly.
21:06.785 --> 21:10.168
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't have to worry about stumbling for spell check or anything like that.
21:10.548 --> 21:15.112
[SPEAKER_01]: I simply, when the book's done, I do assertion replace FFF becomes Frank of it.
21:15.132 --> 21:16.353
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, MMM becomes Manhattan.
21:16.800 --> 21:17.681
[SPEAKER_01]: It's all there is to it.
21:17.981 --> 21:19.843
[SPEAKER_01]: It's quite an easy thing to do.
21:20.243 --> 21:25.588
[SPEAKER_01]: But anyway, I headed on the computer and, you know, I do rearranged chapters occasionally.
21:26.048 --> 21:30.412
[SPEAKER_01]: I write for Amazon original stories and I'm writing one right at the moment.
21:30.672 --> 21:31.633
[SPEAKER_01]: And those are very fun.
21:31.693 --> 21:32.634
[SPEAKER_01]: I like short fiction.
21:32.734 --> 21:34.616
[SPEAKER_01]: I have to say I'm pretty good at getting the twists in.
21:34.636 --> 21:35.757
[SPEAKER_01]: The people seem to like them.
21:36.397 --> 21:37.738
[SPEAKER_01]: And I did the outline.
21:37.898 --> 21:38.839
[SPEAKER_01]: Very short outline.
21:38.879 --> 21:39.580
[SPEAKER_01]: It's only about
21:40.178 --> 21:46.460
[SPEAKER_01]: the stories about 40,000 words, kind of almost a novella, but I got to the end and I thought, why did I outline it this way?
21:46.480 --> 21:48.081
[SPEAKER_01]: It gives away one of the big twists.
21:48.521 --> 21:50.822
[SPEAKER_01]: So on the computer I simply cut and pasted.
21:50.962 --> 21:55.924
[SPEAKER_01]: I just moved the one chapter to after that, re-numbered and we're good to go.
21:56.424 --> 22:00.865
[SPEAKER_01]: So on the computer, that's probably 10, 20 re-rides on the computer.
22:01.406 --> 22:02.486
[SPEAKER_01]: Then I print the book out.
22:03.513 --> 22:12.178
[SPEAKER_01]: you have to read it in paper because we process words differently when they are on a printed page in front of us than when it's on a computer.
22:12.798 --> 22:15.019
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know why, but it's beyond anecdotal.
22:15.459 --> 22:18.861
[SPEAKER_01]: I haven't done a double-blind study, but I know that that's a fact.
22:19.543 --> 22:23.185
[SPEAKER_01]: So then I do that two or three times, then the book's ready to go, right?
22:23.586 --> 22:24.286
[SPEAKER_01]: No, it's not.
22:24.706 --> 22:24.987
[SPEAKER_01]: Why?
22:25.287 --> 22:26.588
[SPEAKER_01]: Because we have to listen to it.
22:27.088 --> 22:27.969
[SPEAKER_01]: Word for Word.
22:28.449 --> 22:32.712
[SPEAKER_01]: And sometimes it's the last thing you want to do because you've just written the damn thing.
22:33.112 --> 22:36.814
[SPEAKER_01]: You have just rewritten the damn thing, but now you got to listen to it.
22:37.135 --> 22:40.116
[SPEAKER_01]: And I use Word, Microsoft Word, which I would recommend.
22:40.157 --> 22:44.740
[SPEAKER_01]: There are other word processing programs out there, but Word is very uniform.
22:47.589 --> 22:49.490
[SPEAKER_01]: know it, it's easy to convert to PDFs.
22:49.530 --> 22:51.152
[SPEAKER_01]: If you need to, it's just very handy.
22:51.352 --> 22:53.213
[SPEAKER_01]: Good spell check and good grammar check.
22:53.653 --> 22:58.236
[SPEAKER_01]: So you do that, but you listen to it and it has a read aloud function.
22:59.177 --> 23:06.582
[SPEAKER_01]: And I can't tell you how many times sitting there listening, following along, word by word and highlights each word is it goes along.
23:07.163 --> 23:08.263
[SPEAKER_01]: I've said, you know what?
23:08.664 --> 23:11.986
[SPEAKER_01]: No, no, no, I missed a plot twist here or I gave something away.
23:12.206 --> 23:12.426
[SPEAKER_01]: So it
23:15.666 --> 23:28.602
[SPEAKER_01]: It doesn't more than that, and it allows me to craft a book that is a little better logically, but also better sonically, because books are relatively new creations in the whole function of the world.
23:29.122 --> 23:33.508
[SPEAKER_01]: Most of our entertainment was in the form of place and epic
23:33.948 --> 23:36.130
[SPEAKER_01]: poetry read out loud by poets.
23:36.790 --> 23:42.715
[SPEAKER_01]: Books are only, I mean, Pamela was that Thomas Fielding, I forget who it was, somebody could correct me on that.
23:43.135 --> 23:53.502
[SPEAKER_01]: But 200 years, say 300 years, where we would pick up a book and read it, or at least the majority of the population could pick it up and read it as literacy spread.
23:53.522 --> 23:54.623
[SPEAKER_01]: So that's relatively new.
23:54.643 --> 23:54.683
[SPEAKER_01]: So
23:56.109 --> 24:04.412
[SPEAKER_01]: I think we
have an obligation to make the word sound good, you know, you've got the civilist, you've got S words right next to each other, that sounds a little plunky.
24:04.673 --> 24:16.878
[SPEAKER_01]: So you've got a character, like I'm just going to rename my character, James, because the proper manual is if you're going to apostrophize the S for the possession, it sounds a little weird.
24:16.938 --> 24:17.498
[SPEAKER_01]: James is.
24:17.518 --> 24:18.678
[SPEAKER_00]: James is.
24:18.718 --> 24:21.800
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, but, but we don't need to, and that is proper.
24:21.860 --> 24:22.300
[SPEAKER_01]: You can't put
24:25.561 --> 24:26.882
[SPEAKER_01]: So it changes the name to Fred.
24:27.082 --> 24:27.502
[SPEAKER_01]: That's fine.
24:27.522 --> 24:28.462
[SPEAKER_01]: He doesn't care what he's called.
24:28.482 --> 24:36.346
[SPEAKER_01]: He's going to be dead anyway in another chapter So that's fine, but you do have to listen to it and while we're on this topic of electric stuff
24:37.100 --> 24:42.665
[SPEAKER_01]: Let me just say this and of course this comes to the topic of artificial intelligence, which we have to talk about nowadays.
24:43.186 --> 24:49.772
[SPEAKER_01]: It's okay for, I mean, I use it for spell check, punctuation, and basically spacing.
24:49.912 --> 24:52.534
[SPEAKER_01]: For instance, sometimes, we're just kind of strange.
24:52.714 --> 24:56.398
[SPEAKER_01]: Sometimes it will not indent properly, or sometimes it indents twice.
24:57.078 --> 25:15.011
[SPEAKER_01]: So I use jet GPT, I pay for the version, and I tell jet GPT, I upload my paragraph, and I say, correct for punctuation, felling, and spacing only, period, full stop, and it does, and it gets a little irritated.
25:15.212 --> 25:21.256
[SPEAKER_01]: Because then it says, here it is, and it does a very good job, but then it says, do you want me to check for content?
25:21.356 --> 25:23.097
[SPEAKER_01]: Do you want me to check for word choice?
25:25.839 --> 25:27.925
[SPEAKER_01]: And so you can bleep this out if you want.
25:27.965 --> 25:30.915
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think chatGPT gets a little pissed off at my attitude.
25:31.402 --> 25:39.548
[SPEAKER_01]: because I think it wants to keep writing, but no, I never have, never will, and I'm telling you, never do it under any circumstances.
25:39.948 --> 25:47.073
[SPEAKER_01]: First of all, for the fun of it, I've looked at some additional things that have been written by large science models, and they're bad.
25:47.253 --> 25:48.173
[SPEAKER_01]: They just don't work.
25:48.253 --> 25:49.374
[SPEAKER_01]: They lack emotional depth.
25:49.754 --> 25:51.736
[SPEAKER_01]: The word choice is just awkward, so don't do it.
25:51.976 --> 25:53.757
[SPEAKER_01]: And also, you're stealing other people's work.
25:54.037 --> 25:57.600
[SPEAKER_01]: Where do you think CHEPT and Claude got that information?
25:58.120 --> 26:05.368
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm part of the lawsuit against anthropic now they're going to pay me multiple thousands of dollars because they stole my work so just don't ever do it
26:06.145 --> 26:11.090
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I'm also part of that, and we keep waiting for that to happen.
26:11.110 --> 26:24.742
[SPEAKER_00]: I something that you said, Emma Thompson, the actress, she also writes a lot, and she was pitching about AI being like, can I change your sentence for you, and she was like, fuck off, oh, you can't.
26:24.802 --> 26:28.746
[SPEAKER_00]: I think that over and over, it's hilarious.
26:29.253 --> 26:33.699
[SPEAKER_01]: I figured I could say pissed off, given the title of your podcast, so I'm glad we got it.
26:33.720 --> 26:34.140
[SPEAKER_01]: Thank you.
26:34.260 --> 26:35.342
[SPEAKER_01]: I think that we are quite old.
26:35.382 --> 26:43.013
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, let me just say one of the things about AI and this is what I tell my students that large language models are capable of writing fiction.
26:43.033 --> 26:45.096
[SPEAKER_01]: There's no question about it, but they're very suited to work.
26:45.616 --> 27:06.776
[SPEAKER_01]: not fiction because fiction requires emotional experience and emotional depth, which large language models are not really capable of bringing and also a problem and perhaps more troublesome is that they are based on misrepresentation and the world of authorship and minority writers, women and writers of
27:07.056 --> 27:15.643
[SPEAKER_01]: of color often are not well represented in the field of the information that is scraped up by the large language models.
27:16.384 --> 27:17.505
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, you heard what I just said.
27:18.405 --> 27:20.207
[SPEAKER_01]: And I'm pretty much memorized at this point.
27:20.907 --> 27:27.493
[SPEAKER_01]: Every one of those words was generated by chat GPT in response to my question, can you write fiction?
27:28.394 --> 27:30.495
[SPEAKER_01]: Which in itself is pretty fucking scary?
27:34.627 --> 27:38.308
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh my god, we we talked about it so much on the podcast.
27:38.408 --> 27:39.468
[SPEAKER_00]: It's kind of insane.
27:39.988 --> 27:43.849
[SPEAKER_00]: The thing that drives me nuts is I have always used M-dashes.
27:44.209 --> 27:45.689
[SPEAKER_00]: I write long sentences.
27:46.149 --> 27:48.470
[SPEAKER_00]: I use a lot of M-dashes now apparently.
27:48.810 --> 27:56.291
[SPEAKER_00]: The sign that you have used chat to PT is M-dashes and I am not giving up my damn M-dashes for anybody.
27:56.391 --> 27:58.791
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm not very issue quite interesting.
27:59.212 --> 28:00.192
[SPEAKER_01]: I am a writer who
28:02.305 --> 28:02.967
[SPEAKER_01]: in my writing.
28:03.668 --> 28:06.274
[SPEAKER_01]: He walked into the room and let's let's do it this way.
28:06.875 --> 28:12.788
[SPEAKER_01]: M-dash, a place he said he'd never, oh again, the right-hand M-dash.
28:13.873 --> 28:20.860
[SPEAKER_01]: here he was, well, to introduce parenthetical information with parentheses, that's a speedball.
28:21.241 --> 28:22.262
[SPEAKER_01]: That slows things down.
28:22.702 --> 28:34.816
[SPEAKER_01]: To introduce it as a separate sentence, or a compound sentence, compound sentence, or this a comma involved, also can slow things down, and M-dash, I consider the grease of the punctuation mark,
28:35.276 --> 28:37.819
[SPEAKER_01]: And it moves the story a lot more quickly.
28:38.220 --> 28:42.245
[SPEAKER_01]: But if it's any reassurance to you, I have looked into this quite a bit.
28:42.525 --> 28:51.496
[SPEAKER_01]: I listen to a podcast, I think it was the, what was it called, Hard Fork, in which a wonderful podcast, no longer, it's so with us, but it's the presenters have changed.
28:51.976 --> 28:56.820
[SPEAKER_01]: But the individual they had on, he ran a AI testing company.
28:56.960 --> 29:05.446
[SPEAKER_01]: You put your book through it, and someone's book through it, and it would give an indication of whether it was 70% AI generated or not.
29:05.806 --> 29:08.908
[SPEAKER_01]: And he said, the new models do not rely on dashes.
29:08.948 --> 29:10.869
[SPEAKER_01]: That's no longer a tip off.
29:10.929 --> 29:14.492
[SPEAKER_01]: It's other syntactical, syntaxes is word order.
29:15.273 --> 29:24.524
[SPEAKER_01]: Star Wars Yoda, a butcher of syntax is, they rely on syntax and they rely on other sentence structure in word choice more than M-dashes.
29:24.564 --> 29:31.312
[SPEAKER_01]: So, dammit, you know, we are sticking with our M-dashes and we will protest that to the grave as far as I'm concerned.
29:31.876 --> 29:34.780
[SPEAKER_00]: I am tinging on to my quilt of m dashes.
29:34.820 --> 29:39.565
[SPEAKER_00]: I don't know what the collective non-fritz would be, but it's like that is what I'm saying.
29:39.705 --> 29:44.731
[SPEAKER_01]: It's like a murder of Crowes that would be murder of a maybe a slaughter of m dashes.
29:44.811 --> 29:45.873
[SPEAKER_00]: Sort of m dashes.
29:46.173 --> 29:46.453
[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
29:46.734 --> 29:50.258
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, we actually don't have time with pastime, but I do want to ask you one more question.
29:50.964 --> 30:05.387
[SPEAKER_00]: So even with all of your art planning, even knowing these characters as well as you do have they ever surprised you have they ever taken you after you've done your outline and something happens and you're like, oh, I did not see that coming.
30:06.195 --> 30:24.702
[SPEAKER_01]: very rarely because I live with the outline for as you said six or eight months and believe me the outline is a full-time job it's eight hours a day and that's part of the book too people say well it's not writing oh yes it is writing I write the outline and occasionally I write a pass and study extract from the outline
30:25.282 --> 30:26.023
[SPEAKER_01]: and put in the book.
30:26.364 --> 30:29.588
[SPEAKER_01]: So I will get surprises there at that stage.
30:30.168 --> 30:33.793
[SPEAKER_01]: I will get a surprise about a plot twist after I've done the outline.
30:33.813 --> 30:34.975
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm sitting there staring at it.
30:35.515 --> 30:38.018
[SPEAKER_01]: My dogs at my feet, she's looking at the outline too.
30:38.078 --> 30:39.841
[SPEAKER_01]: She doesn't really help, but she's staring at it.
30:40.441 --> 30:55.013
[SPEAKER_01]: And I follow her eyes and maybe she's looking at something I'm joking now of course But I will get an idea that was not in the original premise for the short story or the novel and Yes, that changes, but when the outline's pretty much done.
30:55.433 --> 30:55.813
[SPEAKER_01]: It's done.
30:56.053 --> 31:00.497
[SPEAKER_01]: I have some changes You know, I in the outline I I tend to murder too many people
31:01.057 --> 31:01.917
[SPEAKER_01]: murders a big deal.
31:01.998 --> 31:02.978
[SPEAKER_01]: You can quote me on that.
31:02.998 --> 31:06.039
[SPEAKER_01]: It has a, it has a, it has a lot of consequences.
31:06.239 --> 31:07.040
[SPEAKER_01]: The police are involved.
31:07.080 --> 31:07.880
[SPEAKER_01]: Relatives are involved.
31:07.920 --> 31:08.981
[SPEAKER_01]: Relatives get very sad.
31:09.321 --> 31:12.122
[SPEAKER_01]: When even a hitman dies, hitman of relatives.
31:12.162 --> 31:13.103
[SPEAKER_01]: And they have family too.
31:13.663 --> 31:15.864
[SPEAKER_01]: So, you know, I tend to cut on the body count.
31:15.924 --> 31:17.485
[SPEAKER_01]: And that's after the outline is done.
31:17.825 --> 31:21.246
[SPEAKER_01]: When I'm writing the book, I say none of this person doesn't need to need to die.
31:21.266 --> 31:24.228
[SPEAKER_01]: So there is some change, but generally it's the outline is 95% there.
31:25.845 --> 31:27.045
[SPEAKER_00]: okay, amazing.
31:27.505 --> 31:29.126
[SPEAKER_00]: Jeffy, thank you so much for your time.
31:29.146 --> 31:31.286
[SPEAKER_00]: This has been wonderful for our listeners.
31:31.386 --> 31:34.247
[SPEAKER_00]: Again, I'm holding up the Collateral Heart.
31:34.307 --> 31:37.147
[SPEAKER_00]: We linked it on our bookshop.org affiliate page.
31:37.188 --> 31:43.769
[SPEAKER_00]: If you get the book, they you support an independent bookstore and the podcast at the same time.
31:43.949 --> 31:45.109
[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you so much, Jeffrey.
31:45.709 --> 31:46.890
[SPEAKER_01]: Delightful conversation.
31:46.930 --> 31:48.410
[SPEAKER_01]: Hope we can do it again in the near future.
31:48.836 --> 31:50.719
[SPEAKER_00]: And that's it for today's episode.
31:51.099 --> 31:52.862
[SPEAKER_00]: I hope you'll join us for next week's show.
31:53.122 --> 31:54.624
[SPEAKER_00]: In the meantime, keep at it.
31:54.924 --> 31:57.228
[SPEAKER_00]: Remember, it just takes one yes.