UDSKRIFT 🔗
Stephanie: I can't govern on anxiety. so I cannot write for this. I cannot plan for this. And so I cannot moderate or enforce this. And that phrase alone has gotten me through such difficult conversations, both community members and leaders. they agree. It's like, I might be anxious, but this might not translate into something that we can action on.
Tim: There's a kind of labor that never shows up in a dashboard. The emotional weight community leaders carry when they're the human buffer between a company and the people who trust it. Stephanie Nakano most recently oversaw Internal Community for Salesforce, a 70,000 person organization, where she handled employee conduct, trust, safety, and confidentiality issues. While community work has a reputation of being fluffy, her work directly impacted both people's well being at work and and the value and risk few price into the title. We'll cover the mindset and the business case for high-stakes community leadership, frameworks to scale impact, and the human elements that grow in the age of AI. You're listening to the Roundabout Show and I'm your host, Tim Courtney. For more than two decades, from the founding team of Lego Ideas to venture-backed startups, I've helped leadership teams turn their most engaged users into co-creators, designing the ecosystems that connect community to product, research, and revenue. Durable growth isn't accidental. It's architected through trust, participation, and the people who already believe in why you're building. Like navigating a roundabout, this work requires clarity, patience, and trust. To learn more about my work, visit roundabout.community. Now let's turn to today's conversation. Stephanie, welcome to the show.
Stephanie: Thank you so much Tim for having me on the roundabout. Excited to be here.
Tim: I would just love to hear in your own words, a bit more of your background and what the focus of your work is and a little bit of how you got there.
Stephanie: Well, for our audience listeners, I am a professional builder and grower of a field called online community management. that sounds like a lot of words, but I promise you it's something that all of us have either been a part of, done, with or without our knowledge. So what does that mean? for me, it meant that I got to help. The most amount of people doing the most critical and foundational work possible. And that's what the value that led me to become a community manager. I've done it for over a decade. I specialize mostly in the operational, strategic, and even the foundational aspects of what it means to build communities from the ground up. And one of the thing my favorite things about what I do isn't just helping people. It's about seeing what happens when you let people come together and share in the topic that they enjoy or love the most.
Tim: Hmm. Well it's often that when you bring people together, you know you don't know what that outcome is gonna be. You know that it's gonna be something that's a multiple or will compound from what the original vision was. But you can never tell what direction it's gonna go in.
Stephanie: Agreed that is that's the nature of community management: is that you can make best guess, but you can never really control in that way. you kind of have to let the community kind of manifest itself and grow in its own way. but in my line of work, what I found is that yes and letting people grow. In a space also means that you have to make it comfortable for all, Whether it's
Tim: Mm-hmm.
Stephanie: myself as a manager of the space, others who are joining, others who have been in the space for some time, and those who are perceiving what that space is about. so there's a lot of factors that go into not necessarily control, but the observation and the interpretation of of these spaces.
Tim: before we dive into that meat, especially for people who aren't as familiar with what community means in this context, community management, community leadership, or that intersection of business and community, which I I find that there's a lot of of tension in. Maybe we can take a step back and say, like, what do we mean when we say community? And how I've been reflecting on this is I feel like in the conversations that I have with people I'm meeting for the first time, and I say community, I feel some people take it in a direction where they're assuming I'm talking about tools. They assume that I'm talking about platforms, they assume that I'm talking about, yeah, a marketing channel, things like that. And I'm coming from a place where the community is the people and the relationships between each other and the entity you're supporting, the the company, the organization. And and also maybe say this of the subgroups and the different groups of stakeholders. So that's a little bit of how I perceive it. How would you explain this to someone?
Stephanie: I would explain this to someone as I like using metaphors just because it helps me connect, it helps others connect to something more general, That that I would say a community is like a city. I consider myself a city manager. I consider myself somebody who helps designate areas like public spaces, parks,
Tim: Mm.
Stephanie: I help make sure that there's infrastructure to support this city, and I help address emergency situations that arise. that is also something that helps balance and grow the city. in a in the most effective and most open way. and so again, you want people to come to your city, right? You want people to have a good impression of your city. So that's my metaphor of explaining what community is about and reframing it a little bit as a it's a place, it's a space where people gather. And to your point,
Tim: Okay.
Stephanie: Tim, you're right. It is about the people, Because a city is not anything without people. So yeah, that would be my very, very simplistic explanation of what community is about.
Tim: And that would be a fun metaphor to kind of keep exploring and
Load full transcript
diagramming out. but I think that that's a really nice way of framing it that's tangible for people to to understand. so Stephanie, you are a part of a group called the Integrity Institute. what is that group? And tell me a little bit about the work that they do.
Stephanie: Absolutely. the Integrity Institute is a global nonprofit think tank. there is approximately six hundred or so members who are trust and safety professionals. we represent over 80 different platforms, and I believe we come from more than a dozen countries. so it is a very global space. and one of the things that Integrity Institute does is we help organizations understand and anticipate risks that come with operating in digital environments. What that means is hey, can we help address if there's a root cause? If we can evaluate those existing safeguards or no safeguards. put out and we offer evidence-based mitigation. So one aspect of the Integrity Institute that is inherently unique is that we actually provide and produce a lot of research. and so our work has become a lot more important as AI kind of really accelerates and the pace and complexity of risk have pretty much been It's like warp speed, And
Tim: Yeah.
Stephanie: so our group in itself, we all believe that we need to be in the front line because the frontier of technology is is moving at that pace. And so the Integrity Institute is a space that I am very, very engaged and fond of just because we share a very deep value. but more importantly, we feel like bringing our expertise is what is necessary in this time of accelerated change.
Tim: Yeah, and you talk about that speed and it's it's I see that the web and digital communication is yes, things are speeding up because AI brings the cost of content creation to zero. And now we have agents running around and so much web traffic is now agent traffic. established fields like SEO are are changing rapidly because people are are talking with large language models to find answers and placement within those answers is what's increasingly mattering. And at the same time we're finding a a need to have more human only spaces or like as automation increases, the the need to address our shared humanity is also increasing at the same pace. So it's a to me I look at this technological shift as a yes and. yes we're seeing more automation, yes we're seeing y more AI, we're in this age of transformation, and there's human value and then there's also human risk that's amplified.
Stephanie: Wholeheartedly agree, and that's pretty much the crux of this the issue that we're all facing, just as professionals and as practitioners, looking at the same problem, but we're seeing it at very different angles. And that's something that is not unheard of, As AI changes and it evolves. much more from an application standpoint, as you had mentioned with how agents are now becoming much more integrative and a part of the web in itself. But I think it's very important to make that distinction. You had you're you're touching on this Tim and I feel like you're you're right there, which is protecting the human experience also means setting very clear guardrails and boundaries of what AI Is.
Tim: Mm. And there was an article that you co authored, with the Integrity Institute that I read You talked about Claude's constitution.
Stephanie: Yes, yes, we do. so the articles about examining the constitutional AI, specifically Claude's constitutional AI. it was released earlier this year. and the crux of all of that that constitution, and I highly doubt anybody wants to read all eighty-eight, eighty-nine pages of it, is that they set values. That Claude follows.
Tim: Mm.
Stephanie: And it's very interesting because that concept is basically anthropomorphizing AI, meaning that it has decision and process making ability and behaviors. And if you follow that line of thought, you'll find that that sounds oddly human-like. And our article
Tim: Mm.
Stephanie: is very much surfacing warnings about what it means to humanize AI. and we've seen some detrimental effects of it already, but I think that for everybody who's not really, aware of this issue. There's an inherent danger in doing that because you now can almost substitute human connection if AI is presenting itself as as just as human.
Tim: I notice that people I'm around people who are building agents for their work. And it always strikes me as funny to me when people name their agents human names. And as someone who's just setting up my own for the first time, I am really thinking that I'm going to go away from human names. I haven't decided a naming convention for them yet. But finding some third where they're not abstract names, but they are not, Bob or, some somebody like that, Because then i if you have a human name, you're gonna start thinking of this thing that you're talking to a as a human and that it's gonna change how you relate to it.
Stephanie: And and Tim, like what you had just said, you would be not surprised to know that many people don't put that boundary up. People don't think about those things. They just think of whatever's easiest for them. And I think naming an agent is very standard practice, and I'm not telling anybody not to, especially when you're just trying to put something to name, And it's just use for you.
Tim: Yeah.
Stephanie: But at the same time, there there is a group of people who don't understand the risk and don't understand there are any boundaries. And that's who we're trying to safeguard this from is that the constitutional AI of of Claude, it is a values document. If you read it closely, you'll notice that it doesn't really tell anybody How it's enforced. What pathways can somebody take to engage in flagging a certain aspect that is a signal or a warning? So, what happens when you have something that is of value, but no mechanism to enforce it? It's just kind of there, right? It doesn't really serve anything. and so In in our first posts we we do note that
the constitution is performative And I understand that that word brings a lot of feelings to people when they hear it.
Tim: Yeah.
Stephanie: But I also feel that it is the right word to convey the seriousness of having something this open. unregulated and really give it its own thinking.
Tim: Well, and there's no clear separation of power being established here. I believe your article spoke about Meta having a separate body that will rule kind of like a Supreme Court on dispute issues that happen on their platforms. And that doesn't exist here, does it?
Stephanie: you're right, Tim, that it that does not exist here. I've read the constitution twice I can safely say that I did not identify any governing body, source, or who makes the determination between what is good, bad, right, or wrong.
Tim: Mm. And this is just one company and it's the company that, at at least in the culture that we're a part of, is seen as the more safety alignment oriented organization. And if they don't have it, then what is happening with all of the other models?
Stephanie: That is the right question, Tim. Because if this
Tim: Yeah.
Stephanie: is the most forthcoming What else are we not hearing or seeing or being told?
Tim: So let's talk about happier things for a minute and get into this later.
Stephanie: It's so grim. Like you have to like change this. You have to change this for the like the the like two-thirds of the way through, change it to that.
Tim: Maybe I'm gonna edit and like take this segment and put it at the end. but no, okay, so this we really dove in the deep end. This is kinda how I do my life. I usually cannonball on the deep end or whatever I'm going into and then figure out how to swim afterward. I don't know how that served me, but it I I I'm I'm still here. and But let's walk back just a little bit because as we reconnected over the spring, I always find your stories fascinating about about your previous role. and I know that you can't speak to everything in in detail, but describe to folks what your role was at Salesforce and what that entailed, and how that drives value and manages risk for the organization.
Stephanie: So at scale internal community isn't a nice to have least not at work. It is an operating infrastructure, the value comes up when speed, alignment, and resilience all interconnect. People get answers faster. There's expertise and work being distributed with less friction. new employees on board quicker, and for people feel connected to the company and the mission. it also becomes like kind of like a like a sensing function, if you will. Like you can spot where there's friction or confusion or emergent emerging issues like earlier on. before it becomes problematic or a surprise PR headline.
Tim: in some sense internal community exists whether you design for it or manage it or not. And even when you do manage for it through your official channels, unofficial channels exist. And this goes back to how we started and that is the community is the people. If a bunch of people who gather in your city go meet up in another city, are they still a community? The the the formal structure Around the the venues that you create don't have a exclusive contract on these people's relationships and their ability to gather. So by framing that internal community, and then there might be a platform that you run it on, and in your case it's Slack, and then you have the way that people engage your company culture, your standards, your code of conduct, what your values and and how that plays out.
Stephanie: it's one thing to have your community on Slack. It's a whole different level when the company you work for owns the platform that the community is on. So there are levels here that I
Tim: Mm.
Stephanie: kind of want to denote as we're speaking is that What might be true for most communities on Slack is likely or could not be true in the sense that this internal community. But that's the kind of the golden rule, What works for one might not work for another. And to
Tim: Mm-hmm.
Stephanie: your point, it's like, people of these communities, these cities, they might love living at the beach, but others might just enjoy visiting versus it being black and white in that way. And some of the value drivers that I want to just quickly just list off the transfer of information, that's a big thing for me. If why are people in a specific community if they can't access information? They need answers, they want to connect, they want to find out what is or isn't for them. and then also how do they become a part of this community? How do they Be good citizens in this community, And that sense of engagement and belonging, next value, builds retention and encourages and elevates productivity. And of course, it is an indication of the entirety of the community's health. I know that I'm a big and firm believer in data, especially sentiment. 'Cause I feel like that's a very, very powerful indication of how healthy. Is there a thrive in the community? Is there a decline in the community? Those are just points in which I look at when I'm overseeing a community and how my values come into play.
Tim: Hm. I think one of the headlines that we're burying here, and it's something that you could borrow and you speak to somebody, when I think about you, I think here is probably the biggest slack power user in the world.
Stephanie: First off, thank you. I would love that that type of mantle and and in my perspective, if I did earn that, I promise that it did not come overnight. I have been a user of Slack since V one, which I believe came out in 2014 I've used it through all the iterations up until the point that I oversaw the community that I was tasked with. That being said, Being holding that title to me means that you are completely and utterly always learning. platform
Tim: Mm-hmm.
Stephanie: changes so quickly, the experiences evolve as the platform changes. And the level of touch points over the years, because
again, Slack in itself was supposed to be quick chatting between teams and channels, That was that was the initial intent. But over time it became this massive, productivity tool that includes community communication, all of these aspects that go into operating and running.
Tim: That was workflows and their
Stephanie: I don't know one person who's not worked in. A company that has a technology facing aspect that doesn't use Slack or a similar tool. And in my perspective,
Tim: Mm-hmm.
Stephanie: even if you did use a similar tool, you are very well aware of Slack in itself.
Tim: Yeah, yeah. Well and what are some of the ways that you in your role you you saw a lot of things, and you set the guidelines and you set the parameters and you were the administrator that not only sets and communicates rules of engagement, but when those rules of engagement are violated then it's part of your role to investigate and build a case and see a situation through no matter what that might be. So what are maybe some of the types of risks and what are some of the types of ways that you measure those risks and the financial impact to the company as as well as work to mitigate them?
Stephanie: That is such a full question because I don't think that I could ever encapsulate everything that I did, but I think that if if I could, simply explain it, it would be What are all the best parts that can be captured about the company's culture that I can speak to? The opposite of that is what are all the biggest risks to the company culture that I can speak to?
Tim: Mm-hmm.
Stephanie: And those are the two aspects, buckets I wanna say, that these issues that I've dealt with range in. So it's not all bad, but it's definitely not all good, One of the things that I wanna like, bring into picture here is When you drive and and and manage a community that size, there is a level of governance that goes into what you do. That means that there's formality, there's structure, there's procedures, there's things that help you make those decisions. Again, those two buckets, and how to clearly enforce those, And what we know that as right now is in the positive bucket side, what enhances and supports the company culture, what engagement programming? What levels of program can we put out there that help employees tap into, what they feel is part of the company culture? How do they present themselves? How do they come out to be themselves? so that's the engagement side of the equation. The other side is the enforcement work, That's the stuff that you always hear about when it comes to moderation and content and policy, all of that. Change management, risk management. You you hear all of that in there. But I want to say that part, the latter part, although not what I would recommend for people if they really wanted to. walk away energized most days. I want to say it is the most rewarding because again, that fills my value of I want to help the most amount of people doing the most productive things. And so in my aspect, I'm a firefighter. I'll run in there and I will look at a situation and I will look to see how I could better bring it back to neutrality. Or at least bring it back to a space where it's not contentious or negatively impacting the community. Because I think a lot of people are like, well, you go and you solve issues. That's not the case. That's not how humans work, We have emotions, we have range. So you can't just turn off emotions. You can't turn that off. Not even if it everything went your way, you can't turn off those emotions. And so I like to think of it as. Can I bring these people back into the community fold in a neutral and supportive way? And then we can work collaboratively together to find what's next. And I know that that's a very fluffy way of saying, look, I'm looking for ways to make things better, but I can't do it without their help.
Tim: Mm, mm. And so that improving upon that work with every case, with every situation, you also learn from that process and collect feedback from that process from the stakeholders and the people impacted. to to then hopefully the next time something of that nature happens, then it's it's a more positive experience for the employees, and it's more productive for the company. Maybe it takes less time to resolve or the downside risk is mitigated.
Stephanie: Is correct, Tim. Like every issue that we can de-escalate and neutralize and bring to a supportive and understanding point ensures that future concerns are resolved instantly as much as possible, right? But more importantly,
Tim: Hmm.
Stephanie: we as community managers and builders don't have to spend the met mental capacity. to have to make decisions in time of pressure and if
Tim: Yeah. Well and and emotional capacity. Because you're a human
Stephanie: Correct, correct. Yes. So if any
Tim: too.
Stephanie: Yes, yes, that is exactly it. 'Cause
Tim: And an issue that's coming up is gonna push on a button of yours, no matter what that issue might be. we're talking about HR issues that could include, people's personal beliefs or it could include people's gender or identity or or power relative to each other. So these are really serious hard things.
Stephanie: It is. And have to say Tim, one of the hardest aspects of what I do isn't the job itself. It is actually recentering and refocusing on the most unbiased perspective that I can put myself in. And
Tim: Mm.
Stephanie: that it took a lot out of me to really pause and think through and put aside my own beliefs and can the things that I know, the things that I believe. Put all of that to the side and just look at the situation objectively. And you would be surprised how difficult that is, especially when you have to make judgment calls on that very thing you
Tim: I wouldn't be surprised, Stephanie. I know how difficult it is.
Stephanie: Okay.
Tim: Well, I've done something very similar in at a similar scale, but but in the public. So in in your situation, it is I mean,
I'm not gonna make a comparison game around the stakes, because you've got a multi billion dollar company and you've got 70,000 employees, And in my situation, we had the reputation of one of the world's top brands. And we had their most passionate fans who were competing in and participating in one of the top opportunities for those people to be positioned next to the brand. so there's a lot of emotion there, and there's also people who are I think really hungry for that reward and for that validation. And that drives people to do some pretty creative things when they engage with us, when they engage with each other. And so the situations that I've been a part of firefighting or problem solving and also setting the governance and setting the guidelines for and then carrying out the enforcement decisions, those have also been really emotional. And those have also kind of put me to my edge. And this was many years ago now, it also led to a couple periods of burnout.
Stephanie: you on that and as somebody who's done also the external user-to-user facing level of work that you've done, I would say the the personal risk in my perspective is a little bit higher because as employees you know where that person works
Tim: Mm-hmm.
Stephanie: And you know that person's name. It is not a vanity
Tim: Right.
Stephanie: name. And you know their location. Those are things that don't always get set by you as a person. Those those are actual points of data that your company has and sets for you.
Tim: Well, and you have support around you because this is bounded by the organization. So you've got your employment contracts, you've got your HR rules, you have your security team. Everything is is contained. And yeah, you're right. In the situation where it was more public, there were certainly a few cases where and it was also asymmetric because I chose, and this was my choice, and I made this choice in an era when we all thought much better things, more noble things about social media. I chose to use my real name. I chose to use my real name with the public because that was one of the tools that I used to build trust in a brand new program that even though it was associated with this brand, the users, the creators that we were targeting, they didn't really know that they could trust the process. But I knew that they could trust me based upon my reputation. And so I was locked in to that. I was public with my name, and then controversies would come up. And it became a thing where at a couple of moments in time I was a personal target. And I can think of a couple cases of some, you know, rather extreme behavior by some of the users that we had to make some difficult decisions that we didn't take lightly. And then I have an undefined, number of people unhappy with me on the internet.
Stephanie: That is also my experience when I worked externally with a very big user base. And to your point, Tim, earning trust is paramount. A little bit of a different aspect that I want
to bring to the table is that earning trust with users to me is something that you had to do and build at scale. Right. You had to really get in there, you had to really facilitate things. You had to come in there, be on the front line, make fair and clear policies,
Tim: Mm-hmm.
Stephanie: make fair and clear decisions, all that aspect.
Tim: And that trust was built over time. It was, yeah, we set the vision, we set the standards, we set the values, and then when the situations would come up when people see us consistently in the way that we guide an interaction or if need be enforce an interaction, then that trust comes from the consistent behavior over time. And then people start to understand and a culture goes around that. So I remember when it went from a year and a half of that firefighting and a lot of very heavy, very public moderation. I'm, removing this comment because X, I'm suspending this user because Y. And being public about that. to the to the extent we could say, of course. And then the culture emerging where it became self reinforcing. It's users would say to each other, We don't use that kind of language here, or you won't be allowed to stay. or you don't work on a project in this way or the moderators aren't gonna like that. And then it became the job became a little bit easier over time because as people built that trust in in they knew what to expect from the company, from the platform, from the program and our behavior, then that the cul the culture emerged.
Stephanie: Yes, plus one 100% on my side. it's just those are the indicators of trust solidifying and the community maturing. Those are the
Tim: Mm-hmm.
Stephanie: same indications that I also look for, but I had to kind of split a little bit. I had to earn the trust of the user base, which is the entirety of the group. And then I also had to earn the trust of leadership. and the biggest stakeholders there are who can help me enforce and and and kind of be supported. So that was a new thing for me is finding what portion of trust that I can funnel between the two groups. But more importantly, how does it overlap? It's very, very delicate. it's like paper thin at certain points,
Tim: Mm, is. It is. And you've got them the management and then you've got the workforce. So you're kind of between two different stakeholder interests are a bit a bit at odds with each other sometime. And you're and you're in b and you're
Stephanie: Yeah, and I and keep in mind that I'm in the middle.
Tim: in between. And you're in between it. You've got to represent the interests of either one, to the other. And and obviously one side writes your paycheck.
Stephanie: Yes. But also I think that there is an aspect of advocacy that comes into play when dealing with trust. An aspect of advocacy that I I saw, I observed, was the right time and place. Saying what matters in the right time and place for it to be impactful versus just bringing it all to the table and hoping for the best.
Tim: Mm-hmm.
Stephanie: And in my own experience, smaller organizations tend w tend to want you to front load everything. Bring it all to the table. Let's see what we can do. Let's, you know, pivot as we need to. But my experience in bigger organizations, there's a lot of buy-in. There's a lot of iteration. There's a lot of procedural and and bureaucracy around it in order to just facilitate. the idea and socialize it before even moving forward. So the pace and scale are, they they take different strides, but I would say that that was the biggest difference between the two that I found was yes, you might have the same exact plan and it might move at lightning speed in a smaller, more nimble organization, but at a bigger organization, boy, like you're just like turning a boat. You know what I mean? You just gotta
Tim: Yeah.
Stephanie: go wide and make sure you don't get too close to anything and avoid that's just how I would explain it.
Tim: the other thing that we talked about was this and I think that we've really set the stage for it well with the last few minutes, and that is the the context with in within which we know each other is this community industry. And that's a bit of a buzzword. Everybody's talking about it and whenever people use that word. It it it always means something different. It's kind of annoying. But what are the blind spots do you think that exist within that industry? What do you feel like I know that you have a really strong opinion about this, and what do you feel that you see that few other leaders see?
Stephanie: Wow, like I don't think I've ever been asked that question. But I feel like I've encountered this without realizing it. using and saying the word community is like saying religion. It means different things to everybody, right?
Tim: Yeah.
Stephanie: It just that's just what it is. and then people have different interpretations of it, how much you should do it, how much you shouldn't do it, and what
Tim: Like or what it is, even.
Stephanie: it is and what it should mean for everybody who's not the believer.
Tim: Yeah, and w right, and what yeah, what it should mean for everybody.
Stephanie: Right.
Tim: Very prescriptive. Yes.
Stephanie: I I would say that's how my perspective is inherently different. I'm a big sociology nerd. Like if nothing else in the world existed, I would study and and remain an advocate of sociology. you just study societies, you study people, That's what I bring to this. I always think of what you had said, the human element and how it functions in a society. And what if that society
Tim: Hmm.
Stephanie: was just digital? Same rules, different space. And so for me, that's why I I I I always tell people when they hear community and they they have strong feelings about it, they think it should be done a certain way. I just like to interpret it as religion.
Tim: That helps actually. I've been I've been dancing around this this tension, you know, in my own mind with even the label of of the kind of work
that I do. because it is I feel like we don't do ourselves any favors by just using a a a blanket term to cover a very diverse range of Whether it's platforms, groups, gatherings, events, tools, processes, and a lot of things could be bucketed under this word, but when the word itself is so the word isn't it's not polarizing, but it's it's loaded, it's controversial
Stephanie: Controversial. It's loaded.
Tim: we don't we don't we don't think it's controversial in the classic way, but it is. And it's because people have such strong kind of emotion and sort of prior thoughts and feelings about it.
Stephanie: That is exactly the same words that I've used in the past to really dive into what community means when I tell others what I do. And community, just in its small c community, it feels
Tim: Right.
Stephanie: like saying the word religion. It feels like you're saying a non-denominational religion. Well, what is it then? When you
Tim: Mm-hmm.
Stephanie: dive in and tell the person what type of religion it is, or you talk about them not having a religion or not believing in a religion, that's when you get a fuller picture of understanding what community is about, is that you have to distinguish whether or not they believe in community. Do they find value in community? Do they even know what community is? Right. And when you have those
Tim: Mm-hmm. And then what types of community do they find value in, right?
Stephanie: Exactly, exactly, replied.
Tim: Yeah. Yeah, so even the language that we use and I know that the industry itself is sometimes and for the very longest time, struggles to define not only what it is, but the business value that it creates. And and I think a lot of that can be attributed to to even the way that we describe ourselves.
Stephanie: I absolutely and wholeheartedly agree on that because I have also shared this struggle and I think that that's what distinguishes me from other builders in our space is that technology changes, the spaces changes, the ideology changes, but we as humans don't change and that I always reroute and reorient myself. into the aspect of how do humans behave in a shared space.
Tim: And I think that the host of the gathering, the host of the community is you said it in the beginning, is that you don't control the output. You don't control the outcome of the conversation. and hopefully you set the stage and hopefully you curate the guests to the point where the outcome is, infinitely better than you could possibly could imagine. But the risk is that, things could go could go sideways. I I I love the religion metaphor because what I've been the idea I've been playing with in some of my own writing, I might have even told you this, I can't remember, is that back to religion, growing up in a church myself, the the pastor of the church would say he would he would draw some comparison to the church isn't the building that we're in, the church is the people. And I translate that directly to the community work.
And that is the community isn't Slack, it's not Microsoft, Teams or SharePoint or Twitter or Discord or what or an events platform or the event itself. It's the people who come and it's the relationships that they have with each other and it's that shared sense of purpose that they gather with. So everyone's gonna come with their own agenda. what they want, their own interests, their own stakeholder group, their own identity, whatever it is. But the interest that brings them together, that gives them that common sense of purpose and and and and the reason to have these shared bonds, that is like what forms it into a community versus an audience or just another group of people.
Stephanie: Right. And early on in my career I had always thought that social media was a one way street. It was just the brand using social channels to talk to the void, to the ether. If people reacted, great. If people didn't, well. I chose community because of that connection, that two-way ness that comes with the work and realizing that you're not going to be able to control the outcome and what people feel, but you can definitely help shape the experience and give them some emotion to ponder about. And I think that that's what drew me to this field so quickly was the fact that I could be human too. And that's the biggest, biggest perk of working in our field is that not only do we help other humans be and stay connected, but that we can be connected too.
Tim: another aspect of this community work is the field of trust and safety and We most recently connected at a platform or marketplace risk conference where all of the vendors and all the speakers were really dealing with these hard questions of business value and what risks there are in terms of say e-commerce fraud or in terms of moderation, things of that nature. as professionals who work in this community field. and as people who are really handling other humans and and and their full selves as they express, we're gonna come into we're gonna come into situations that require a lot from us to to handle and these are roles and these are fields that I think it's safe to say have been traditionally under leveled, under invested in. And would you say that that's developed a mindset in the industry? And how does that play out in your experience and what are some shifts that community industry professionals can can make to to be more empowered, to have more tools, to have more resources at their disposal?
Stephanie: A good question. just backing up a little bit for context. Scarcity mindset is actually a socio economical phrase. It's actually a description that says, Hey, because you were in a situation where Food or money or resourcing was scarce, you behaved or acted or lived in a certain way that actually perpetuates the scarcity mindset, you've seen this elsewhere where example immigrants going to a new country. And their former country did not have as many resources as their new country. And even though they live now
in the new country, they start living and and and feeling that there's a scarcity. So they're saving things. They don't, they don't want to, leverage certain things. And but by doing that, they perpetuate that mindset, that negativity, onto their surroundings and environment. So with that kind of context in mind, how that applies specifically to community, as you had touched on Tim, we're t we're typically under resourced and so we work with very little. We're typically undervalued. So we don't really get as much headcount. There's no business proof in why you need these people. And then there is an emotional Aspect of being under kind of valued, which is you don't people outside of our field don't realize how heavy the work is because it's soft work, It's the emotional work, it's carrying that work. So when you put all of that together, how that manifests in community is, we and I'm just bringing up an example off top of my head. We don't we we limit how many people can come to an event because of the resourcing. But by doing that, all the future events become maybe more exclusive because of how small it's become. And again, the intent wasn't just to say, no, like I didn't want more people to attend, But the impact was was that now you're making these events more exclusive and you're being exclusionary, which is the very counter. to being in a community. And again, this is just like a very broad and general example, but that's just a
Tim: Sure.
Stephanie: kind of like a thought that I want to put out there on what scarcity of mindset means.
Tim: So we our actions, we limit what we do, because we don't have the resources to to do more. And if you were to flip that around, if we could imagine or or secure those resources, then we might be able to have a bigger impact.
Stephanie: Yes. But also the scarcity mindset is interesting because it's pervasive. So let's just say we got this community team and we put them in a space where they're super valued and they're super resourced and they're super supported and their work is transparent and it matters directly to what they're doing and and the company's mission. You will notice that. Community teams are so used to being undervalued that we don't know how to better make our work transparent. We don't know how to make our work more I guess, scale or or be bigger in the scope of things, So the harder part is is that how do you expand and how do you come back from that scarcity mindset? And some of the ways that as community professionals that we could do that is holding our ground on certain things. If you set a particular standard on the I don't know, let's go back to the events saying, Tim, you only want thirty people to come to this event. If you don't get near that event or at least 20 or over, you might have to call it and say, Hey, we shouldn't have an event because it's not really a lot as many people as we thought. We don't want to keep downsizing and shrinking and then make these events less valuable to those who do make the effort.
Tim: Mm.
Stephanie: That's that's a really hard call. I don't I don't deny that that's a super hard call. But also it can look like, hey Tim, like we can't work on these type of issues until we get resourcing because we can't work at the current capacity, provide the level of w quality that you expect, and then produce what everybody else expects. So it's a very big shift and balance of mindset. And I've tried some of these exercises myself in in my my day-to-day work and and as a professional. boy. It's just like working on your core or your flexibility. It takes time for you to really develop that muscle and to like bend that way.
Tim: Yeah. Well and there's something to be said about the the skills and the language and the tools to build that business case to get the funding, to get the headcount. And in your experience, what are the kinds of arguments that have worked to fund this human side of the community work that isn't so measurable? And what are some of the arguments that fell flat or how do we begin to translate this into numbers that the CFO is gonna take seriously?
Stephanie: such a good but weighted and and such a
Tim: Yeah.
Stephanie: full question because I have tried everything in the past saying we as a team don't feel that has not worked We will say the community feels dot dot dot. boy, that has not worked. And here's what XYZ other community did. Nope, that did not work either. What did work, what did translate and what hit home was productivity, retention, and making sure that we are addressing issues in a timely fashion. Things that are measurable and tangible work a lot better and become stickier. Because again, you're measuring how that works. So retention, not just users. I'm talking about your actual team itself,
Tim: Yeah.
Stephanie: Cause you like going up to a business executive and saying, hey, in the last like 12 months, I've had three team members depart. Here's what it cost us to have to replace, retrain, and revamp for somebody to come in. And every time that this happens, here's all the goals that we missed. boy, that gets a lot of attention, And then the other aspect that has worked is, and Tim, you and I spoke about this, offline at one point, the risk. Here's all the risks that we did not mitigate because we just did not have the resources or time to deal with it. And here's all the issues that have spiked since then. Here's all the unresolved issues. here's all of the requests that have come in from the product team that haven't been. Addressed and and we haven't delivered feedback on because again, we don't have the bandwidth to do so. And what are they gonna say at that point? So they're gonna say, this doesn't impact just this team, it impacts other areas of the business, and it is functionally, well, it's dysfunctionally, It's dysfunction.
Tim: Well and and and yes, and this is all this is exactly what I was hoping to hear back and these are excellent examples.
And also there's a case to be made that and how I see this kind of work playing out in organizations is that it's the connective tissue. It's the connective tissue between the different v siloed functions, between the different stages of say a customer journey from their very first awareness all the way through the end of life of the of the relationship, through the the marketing and and interest, through their journey into the sales funnel, converting and kicking off as a client, their success, their customer service issues, their renewals, their upsells, hopefully, if you do your job right, their advocacy. Right. And they're reducing acquisition cost. And then, through their through their life cycle. It's the the work of these relationships. It's it's like horizontal relationship management, across these vertical silos. And so if I were to place a community organization within a company, it's it's almost like a a matrix, but it's something that probably should roll into I don't know, something like operations, something that's responsible for everything, versus say, marketing or or service or product.
Stephanie: Absolutely. And at the heart of everything that I do, I've always seen myself as a very operations oriented person, working in systems, working in frameworks. And the idea behind the operations, you said, is that connective tissue. making sure that those signals go from place to place that they're supposed to go, because that work matters. it matters in very high stakes situations. And it matters for, like you said, the longevity of the company in itself, right? If you lose all of these customer relationships and these accounts, will there be a company? I don't
Tim: Hm.
Stephanie: think so.
Tim: Right. So we spent a little bit on the on the business value, And how we can start to quantify this. How you succeed how you failed and how you succeeded. And how we can quantify this. And the scope of the impact is broad. it's not one siloed function within an organization. The scope of managing these relationships, whether it's external customer communities or it's internal employee communities and that culture is is broad scope. The the the other side to this coin is that human center. you in a prior conversation we talked about how leaders they keep wanting to unsee what they know deep down inside is true about the people in their communities. what what does that mean to you? when when we come back to that thread.
Stephanie: Yeah, Call this the culture gap. I call this the culture gap because there is a disconnect between leaders and the people in their community. And it when I say that, I see broadly, Obviously, it includes those who report to this leader. There's a huge disconnect. And I call that a culture gap simply because they don't want to hear the noise of the community in itself. So when it comes down to it, we are the signal builders. And the human aspect
Tim: Mm.
Stephanie: and the human center of it, we operate from a standpoint
of what signals are we telling this leader that mad that makes the most impact and sense for them to hear? But more importantly, how can it be beneficial for everybody? And when you said the human center, I mean that makes perfect sense to me because. That leader is also a human, There's probably a lot
Tim: Mm-hmm.
Stephanie: going on that front, but if we make it easier to have things that should warrant for them it should be warranted for them to see. That brings back that trust. So the culture gap can only be bridged with trust.
Tim: Mm-hmm. Well, and those leaders, yes, they are human and the the noise in the community, the the the the conversations and even what might really be impassioned conversations for some people at a certain level or in a certain area is not always relevant or worth bubbling up to a certain level. what is it that you and your team can can handle and then simply report on after the fact versus what needs to be assembled in a way that gives an executive a pitch picture that they need to make a call on or that they need to have as a background so that when they're engaging with the employees, they are briefed on a situation, what needs to rise to that level and You you are we are that filter.
Stephanie: add to this really quick. I'm also we are also the group that helps Kind of collate and then quantify what trade-offs look like. Because I think that you the this is really important in the aspect of unseeing what is true is simply because they don't know what to do to address it. And when you put into perspective what the trade-offs are, what are the options in front of them, they're not technically seeing it, but they are addressing it. And in that capacity, when you think about it, That actually helps us more than them seeing
Tim: Mm.
Stephanie: something. Because in the end, what can we tangibly do about it just because somebody sees something?
Tim: Hmm. and the executive is is either choosing a direction and communicating that to the team, or they are resourcing it in some way, or they're giving air cover to it. They're signing off on it. We've already made a decision as the team. Unless you tell us to stop or do something else, this is what we're gonna do. Okay. That requires thirty seconds a minute of my bandwidth to read the briefing, absorb that and say, Okay, I see the trade offs, I see the arguments, I'm behind you.
Stephanie: Exactly. And that's kind of the secret here is that aspect of just because leaders feel or or that perception of that they want to unsee what they know is true. You also have to digest it from our standpoint is what signals are we sending? What trade-offs are we
Tim: Mm-hmm.
Stephanie: giving them? What option? What strategies are we recommending? And do those make sense?
Tim: Yeah. And and maybe when they wanna see, when there's that reflex to to not wanna look at the mess and deal with the mess, that's it's it's community leaders' jobs to present that in a way that is digestible, that it is relevant, and then that allows a leader to engage with it at the amount of bandwidth that's appropriate for them in the situation.
Stephanie: Always ask us professionals in this space, Tim, are we trust champions? Or are we just community builders? I would say the prior, because to be trusted advisors, we have to champion trust from the community all the way up. And
Tim: Mm-hmm.
Stephanie: yeah, that's that's the secret.
Tim: And that goes both directions. part of the work and I think part of the reason why this kind of work requires so much capacity of the the people who engage in it is that we also have to go toe-to-toe with these leaders sometime to challenge their thinking and challenge their decision making because that trust goes both ways. And if we are stewards of the trust, then we need to flag when a leadership action might not or might negatively impact the trust of that community, whether that is your your the public, whether that is a user base, whether that is a an an organization, a team of employees.
Stephanie: I agree with you, Tim, but I want to pin this one aspect that I want to reframe. I have gone toe-to-toe with a lot of leaders. Some not so big, some very big. And the thread that I see that is common across all of those leaders that I've ever engaged with. They want to trust you, but you need to give them the reason to trust you. And what I found was you just have to let them decide on the best way that the decision that they make, how not just how it would impact the community, but how would it be a reflection of their leadership? And I found that when I re when I framed it just in that way, very subtly, it's like a light bulb goes off. And they Almost, I want to say almost, not all the time, make the decision what I think was most appropriate with the information that we had. So, yes, that does sound like some ways like softening a story or maybe hardening it up just to make you know a certain outcome come. I'm not denying that. But what I am saying is that leaders want to be perceived as leaders and they will not risk
Tim: Mm.
Stephanie: that perception. over a wrong decision.
Tim: Love this. This this is brilliant. you can you can obviously this also means that you are hired into the right position because your values align with, say, the org the leaders in the organization's stated values. And in the moment, they might be feeling a certain way about. whatever else is going on, looking at a situation in isolation, or with other pressures top of mind, and they might be tempted to go down a direction that wouldn't reflect well on their leadership. And by cue Yeah, and by cueing that, just
Stephanie: Because they don't think yeah. They don't think it Yeah. Mm-hmm.
Tim: by cueing that, just by thinking about that, you are saying, you're causing them to pause. How are the history books gonna remember this? How is the media going to play this?
Stephanie: Got it, Tim. And that's I know a lot of times our leaders are not
always connected with the work that we do, but the that connection I feel we always talk about it in a time that we need something or we think it's pertinent. in my line of work and what I've done in the past, that's not always the case. It's always, always. What is the reflection of this decision going to look like on your leadership? And are you willing to stand by this decision moving forward? And the answer is almost like what it they'll they'll pause and they'll be Steph, what is easiest for you and your team? Be like, I'll tell you. Because they don't want the hard, the hard part, right? The hard part would sit on their shoulders, in which I don't I've never worked with a leader who was like, give me the harder of the two options that I should
Tim: Ha.
Stephanie: take on, right? They're like, what's the
Tim: Right.
Stephanie: easiest? What's the least amount of friction? How do we achieve what we're trying to do with the least amount of like time spent on?
Tim: Yeah. Well and maybe to qualify, it might be like what's the what's the easiest what's gonna be the long term win, Because sometimes the easy thing in the short term is the hard thing in the long term. It's that we incur some tech debt or some cultural debt or we take a shortcut that we have to pay a lot more for later. So I think, yeah, what is the easiest, What's the most consistent with our values or with our shareholder interest or whatnot?
Stephanie: I I want to offer an example here, and this is generic. in Slack communities, the topic broaches around channel management. Who's the channel manager of XYZ channel? Those are just whatever.
Tim: Mm-hmm.
Stephanie: But it comes into which channels get arc archived and which channels stay up. Then you start to dig a little bit more. All right. Well, what happens, Tim, if you archive a channel that has been the most engaging, controversial, or even just the most impactful? That's what people recognize when they come into this community. What happens when you have to potentially archive that channel? When facing an issue like this, we think, just archive the channel. It is what it is. No. Sometimes those decisions are, like you said, linked to these tangible leadership outcomes and how they're framed. It's like Tim, CEO of XYZ company, loses control of his community by archiving an entire channel to silence them. Is that a headline? Is that a headline that anybody wants on their plate or record?
Tim: Yeah. No.
Stephanie: That's permanent, right? The internet is permanent. And so
Tim: Yeah.
Stephanie: that being framed in that way makes leaders, rethink what a simple action, what the easiest action now to do, might inadvertently cause a long-term hardship.
Tim: Do you have any maybe you can't share specific stories, but I'm so curious about moments that either in your work you you either earned a lot of trust in a high stakes situation or or if there were situations that that lost trust and trust had to be repaired, and and how you navigated situations like that.
Stephanie: I mean, like I have an example from just, you know, past years of work and and just past experiences here. we talked a lot about trust in this conversation. We also briefly mentioned the word privacy. There was a case of privacy leak slash concern that occurred while it was inadvertent. The team that was working with did s some things and the Slack Connect feature inadvertently added people that weren't supposed to be in a customer facing channel. That did reduce and erode trust with our customer because then they didn't feel like that was something that they were kept in the loop in. And then the developers who were engaged in the conversations were like, this is a lot of noise. It's distracting us from our work. Like we don't have the time to deal with, you know, people being outraged about this. So if you guys don't want to come together and work on this, we're just gonna move on this project.
Tim: Mm.
Stephanie: And that erosion of trust was was not a highlight of my work. But more importantly, it helped me reinforce what privacy means a standpoint of like the thorough communication, setting of the expectations, whether it's in a closed space or open space. And more importantly, just like what the consequences are, If we don't abide by these like trust and safety and even these. privacy aspects, result might not be what we think, Yes, the loss of trust, but also maybe the loss of resources and and time consumption that you can never get back. So that's an example of like maybe a challenge that I had to really, really overcome. And it took a really long time to rebuild those relationships from all ends. A time that I think that the trust held up under pressure, that resilience. was probably when there were bunch of controversial things occurring in the world and everyone around me, whether they were leadership or in the community, had very oppositional opinions about what to do and what aspects of behavior should be expected. And leveraging in on kind of like the governance and the framework and the strategy the and the consulting that work that we've always done as community builders, was able to point to here's our code of conduct, here's our community guidelines, here's what we do in channels. As long as what behaviors that we expect are abide by this, there's no issue. But what does become an issue is that if you try to circumvent these these established points of governance. So that in itself, that resilience held up under a lot of pressure. And when I say a lot of pressure, I'm talking like dozens of people with
Tim: Mm-hmm.
Stephanie: much, much, much, much levels of influence over me, felt compelled to abide to say. Hey, we trust that this will be for the best and while we don't agree, trust. That was very stressful the the whole time, but more importantly, the the aftermath of it. I always had to tell people, I'm like, hey, don't always be on guard, right? Like we got what we asked for. You
you are you you have the space that you still have. There were no changes, and things are gonna be okay. And so that aspect of that resilience doesn't come without a price. So I just want to put it
Tim: Mm mm.
Stephanie: out there is that it wasn't a clean breakaway, if that makes any sense.
Tim: you grounded it in principles and the way that we've operated. And as long as the way that you've operated was built withstand these kinds of pressures that are gonna come up from time to time. And if it's worked for us in the past, it won't always work in the future. I don't want to caveat that. But if it's worked in the past and it's been pressure tested in other ways, then That should absolutely be our starting point. You know, we shouldn't make any sort of radical changes because we have these more extreme views on how to handle the situation during a time of say a lot of discontent, hopefully the foundation is there, if it's built in the right way, it's also gonna survive during those times. So it wasn't, hey, just trust me, this is my plan. It's these are our principles, these are our frameworks.
Stephanie: Exactly. And also address empathy fatigue. As you know, working on these like high pressure and and these crises, it drains you and it drains you fast, If you try to take on new change and address these concerns at the same time manage those change, it's not gonna work out in your favor. By saying, hey, this is what we've done. stick to this. And anything that falls outside of this, we will address as it comes. We will not make changes just because there is unfounded fear or there's nervousness or anxiety. I'm like, I can't plan anxiety. Okay?
Tim: No.
Stephanie: I can't enforce anxiety. And I and I'm a big proponent of mental health and and I always encourage people to Do what's best for their mental health, but I can't govern on anxiety. so I cannot write for this. I cannot plan for this. And so I cannot moderate or enforce this. And that phrase alone has gotten me through such difficult conversations, both community members and leaders. they agree. I might be anxious, but this might not translate into something that we can action on.
Tim: before we before we wind down, wondering, we we we covered a lot of ground. covered some really high stakes stuff. And we started off with the human toll and the the the the the human emotional labor that goes into this that's kind of the the thing that you don't really see on the dashboard. And So what I think translates here is the frameworks and the principles that allow us to scale. We talked around a lot of that. What could you give some examples of principles, values, frameworks that you use as a way to make these decisions that withstand the the test of these pressures?
Stephanie: Yes. so caveat right here, Tim, like I've read your work and I just want to say that these principles are very much likely something that you've either pioneered or wrote yourself. So it might really sound familiar, but I have pressure
Tim: Ha ha ha.
Stephanie: tested some of these aspects in my own line of work, not realizing, the source, and then when I saw and reread your work I was like, no wonder that's where I read it from. So
Tim: What was the remind me remind me of the work?
Stephanie: believe it might have been some of your early community work for that big brand that you were part of. Yeah, yeah. It's just yeah, so it's it was
Tim: Right. Yeah, we we can name the brand, yeah. but I think it was the was it the I thought we were talking about the moderation guidelines or our terms of service for Lego ideas,
Stephanie: Correct.
Tim: our house rules, our project guidelines, which incidentally became the the source material for some broader company wide code of conduct, which when I read my own words in that, you know, ten years later was was kind of a that was a moment for me.
Stephanie: Yes, and that's what I wanted to preface this with, because that work that you had done so long ago was still impactful even for, I would call as peers, but for workers who are like myself who are like, hey, where have I read this before? I know I read this somewhere, but I I couldn't recall at that moment in time. the principles that I would say translate them best or most cleanly. participation, engagement. Right? like what works, what doesn't, where, when. What does recognition look like? What do we want people to do in our communities? And but how do we reward them? How do we make them visible?
Tim: Yeah.
Stephanie: transparency, that's a big one for me, obviously. Transparency, like the rules. What are the rules?
Tim: Yeah,
Stephanie: Put them up.
Tim: yeah.
Stephanie: Tell me what they are. So you like tell me how you enforce them. What do you moderate on? What do you not moderate on? then I think the last thing is, and of course, titling of this entire talk in itself, closing the loop. Let people know
Tim: Mm-hmm.
Stephanie: what happened with the outcomes of certain things. Let people know that their
Tim: Mm-hmm.
Stephanie: feedback reached the product team. the product team announce when these feedback aspects have been applied into a feature. and really like is and I hate I always hate this because I'm so bad at it sometimes. aspect of closing a loop also involves telling people what they don't want to hear. Meaning like saying
Tim: Does.
Stephanie: no, And telling them
Tim: Mm-hmm.
Stephanie: why. And it's just leaving them kind of stranded has always been something that weighed heavily on me. as a builder, but more
Tim: Yeah.
Stephanie: importantly it's like that non answer. That non answer.
Tim: Yeah, no no response is always worse than a no response.
Stephanie: Correct. Correct.
Tim: And I'm the I'm the kind of person that it's still a growth area for me. Is that courage to say no Is that courage to face communicating what people don't want to hear It that's a muscle too. It's hard.
Stephanie: yes. Super hard.
Tim: Well thanks for that. That's I didn't expect
it to so cleanly map to to some of what I've done before. But yeah, I certainly recognize all those words. So thank you so much for that. okay, so really what I what I love to do when I speak with people is go into, you know, AI hype cycle. We're in that now. everywhere. There's all kinds of new buzzwords, there's all kinds of new tools. but like our work is around people, and from where you sit and from your perspective, what are the things that maintain or grow in value the further we get down this AI adoption cycle?
Stephanie: again, this is such a loaded question, not because like I don't have an answer, but it's more of like there's just so much to consider, right? It changes every day. But AI has and will continue to accelerate information, ac the accessibility of information. But it's not gonna replace trust. Some of the things that I see that will grow in value are governance, guardrails, legitimacy, and how does human judgment come into play? Into say, hey, you can't replace this trust. These are the things that are needed to be trustful. more importantly, like in communities, how does that look? In inside of certain communities, I want to say. Sure, AI can like help summarize and help you kind of like procedurally do things from a workflow standpoint and it kind of helps you with reducing repetitive work. Great. the hardest parts to me are, in my opinion, what matters the most are What happens with conflict, fairness, the distribution of power and authority and care. I feel like those require like humans to be accountable and have like clear principles behind that. that to me is just something that came to my mind when I was thinking
Tim: Mm.
Stephanie: about what it looks like. Both in the near future and moving forward.
Tim: Wow. Yeah, I'm right there with you on that. I mean, I know that from our our recent chats we seem to be pretty aligned on a lot of these things. So so thanks for outlining that. is there anything that that maybe we haven't covered that you want to dive into or I know that maybe you're up to some new things that you wanna tell people about?
Stephanie: Yes. I just again following our our thread of thought here is much more around like community governance and what that looks like and what are the trade-offs and the strategic decision making that goes into it. Those are some of the areas that I'm exploring because I believe that that is the bridge between community builders and trust and safety. I feel that that bridge is gonna become A lot more broad as time goes on, as AI becomes much more integrated in day-to-day life. and I feel like those conversations we've not really like had collectively, right? Because we always assume trust and safety sits like kind of, you know, they're like our cousins, right? They're part of the family, but they don't
Tim: Yeah, and and that's a function. That's that's over there, right? It's it's kinda how we treat compliance stuff. It's a necessary evil.
Stephanie: Correct, but I don't f it is, it is, but I don't think that those lines, division between the two will hold up. It will become very blurry and it will become very intentional because of the scale in which we have to deal with AI. 'Cause right now, like you had said, there it AI is already out in the internet, right? What happens when AI is joined?
Tim: And we're not and it's n we're not gonna put the the the genie back in the bottle. Let's face it. It's not going away.
Stephanie: Right, but what happens when AI joins communities?
Tim: Hm. Yeah. What what are you up to now? What's what's what's new? Anything you want to share?
Stephanie: yeah, so as mentioned, my work is just gonna make sure that people know where that bridge between community and trust and safety are and that where where does it cross? And work is gonna be more fuzzy between the two. as that becomes more prevalent, I feel that it's very important for community builders like ourselves and professionals to be very, very aware. of what happens and how to address it and how to cleanly and effectively at the forefront without risking themselves.
Tim: Well, and actually this jogged my memory back to what I was gonna say, and that was I made a flippant comment that said necessary evil, and then as soon as I said it, I I realized the connotation of that. And you know, we think about things like, well, we've got the compliance, like, we gotta go follow the law or these ethical standards or whatnot. But it's not evil. it's good. It's actually what These are ground rules that underpin our society that ensure, hopefully, obviously, you know, in a in a rose colored, you know, textbook of our history, right? Not always in practice, but but ensure fairness and equity. And it ensures that we're holding ourselves to some standard. And so I wanted to walk that back and even though that was a flippant comment to say necessary evil, I don't want that coded in people's minds that in fact these these this work is essential. For our humanity. following the rules, following some standards and and ensuring trust and keeping everybody safe. This is table stakes, this is the foundation. If we don't have that, then we don't have anything else because whatever it's built on, if we don't have it on that, it's a foundation of sand.
Stephanie: that very much. And you had said that term, the necessary evil, and it made me think about of reflecting on the work that I'm I'm hoping to forward is I want everybody to know that it's an intentional trade-off. The value
Tim: Mm.
Stephanie: of our work is an intentional trade-off because when you think about the trade-offs and you live in that space, in my perspective, that's where resilience comes in. Because the neutrality of it, when things go up or down, it always recenters. And recentering is neutrality. in my perspective, that's where trade-offs and intentional trade-offs would live in, is that that's how you build for the future, but don't sacrifice everything, like you said, that aspect, right? Because the more you sacrifice, the more you feel like there's nothing that's giving you value back. if you feel like there's a balance that you can strike between the two. that's the space that I I want it want my work to live in and that's what I hope to bring to organizations.
Tim: Wonderful. Well, thank you so much. This has been great conversation. certainly deep as always.
Stephanie: Thank you so much, Tim, for having me.