UDSKRIFT 🔗
[0:01] Welcome to the Luca Ledger.
[0:05] Welcome back to the Luca Ledger with Brett C. Arnold's CPA and president of Luca Financial.
[0:10] Brett works with entrepreneurs and small business owners to help them understand their
[0:14] numbers, reduce unnecessary tax burdens, improve cash flow, and build more profitable businesses
[0:19] through strategic financial planning and fractional CFO guidance.
[0:23] I'm Evan Mack.
[0:24] Today we're talking about one of the most misunderstood parts of running a business.
[0:28] How owners actually pay themselves.
[0:30] Difference between salary and owner's draws and why getting it wrong can create financial
[0:36] and tax problems later.
[0:38] Brett, welcome back brother.
[0:39] Hey, thanks Evan.
[0:40] I appreciate it.
[0:41] I think this one will be a really crucial episode for business owners.
[0:43] Yeah, this is going to be a good one.
[0:46] Brett, like paying yourself sounds simple on the surface, but a lot of these business owners
[0:50] are unclear on how it's actually supposed to work.
[0:53] Why does this become such a common issue?
[0:56] Yeah, it does sound really simple.
[0:59] But like you mentioned, it's probably one of the most common questions we get from clients,
[1:03] especially new clients.
[1:04] I've set up this business.
[1:06] How do I get money out?
[1:07] If I take it out, am I taxed on it?
[1:09] If I don't take it out, am I taxed on it?
[1:12] So we get a lot of questions there.
[1:14] I think it's because there's a lot of different types of business structures you can set up.
[1:18] And those types dictate how you're going to go pay yourselves.
[1:23] And there can be compliance issues.
[1:25] If you pay yourself the wrong way, you can get penalized and you'll pay underpayment
[1:29] fines, you'll pay extra tax, there's errors.
[1:32] Or maybe you're not paying yourself at all, again, depending on the entity structure, there's
[1:37] penalties and fines and additional tax.
[1:41] So I think that's where a little bit of the hesitation comes from business owners is I've
[1:45] heard all these types of ways I should pay myself what's the best way and it really depends
[1:51] on the way your business is set up from the beginning.
[1:54] That's the difference between taking a salary and taking an owner's draw.
[1:59] Yeah, so really important question and really important distinction.
[2:03] Whenever we use the term salary, we're specifically talking about a W2, a payroll paycheck with
[2:10] taxes with hell, but it's coming your way.
[2:12] So just like if you were to go be hired and employed by another organization receiving a paycheck,
[2:17] that is your salary.
[2:19] Same thing if you own a business, again, depending on the type of entity and we'll get into that
[2:23] in a little later in the episode, depending on the type of entity, you need to take a salary.
[2:27] Again, that's when taxes are being what held, you're getting paid every two weeks, once
[2:31] a month,
Load full transcript
whatever it might be.
[2:33] Versus owner's distribution or an owner's draw, it's kind of the same concept there.
[2:38] That's when you're simply just taking money out of the business bank account and depositing
[2:44] it into your personal bank account.
[2:47] Two very different things, they've got different tax implications depending on the entity set up
[2:51] that you've got, but the distinction there is salary is a W2 that is reported to the Social
[2:57] Security Administration that's having taxes without draw or distribution is simply a transfer
[3:03] withdrawal.
[3:04] You're writing a check from a business account to a personal account.
[3:09] How does the structure of a business affect the way in order pays themselves?
[3:13] Yeah, so very important here.
[3:15] So a lot of times new businesses set up an LLC.
[3:20] Most of the time, sometimes you do business as a sole proprietor under your Social Security
[3:24] number or you get an EIN associated with your name, but most of the time we've got an LLC
[3:28] set up.
[3:29] An LLC is formed or a limited liability company is formed at the state level.
[3:33] So every state has their different way to set up an LLC, but that's a state designation.
[3:40] Whenever you set up an LLC, all that does is it provides a little bit of liability coverage
[3:47] between you, the business owner and you, the individual.
[3:51] It separates those assets when you start to put things into an LLC versus you owning them
[3:55] with your, let's say, Social Security number.
[3:58] So in the eyes of the IRS, when you have an LLC, it's almost treated as the same thing as
[4:04] you not having an LLC in terms of taxability.
[4:08] So it's called a disregarded entity.
[4:10] You don't file a separate tax return.
[4:12] It's just another form on your individual tax return when you have an LLC.
[4:16] Let's assume you've got one number.
[4:18] When you have an LLC, you should not pay yourself a salary.
[4:24] If you pay yourself a W2 payroll from an LLC that has not incorporated, then you're out
[4:30] of compliance.
[4:32] Reason being is any earnings that come into an LLC that are not taxed differently are subject
[4:37] to self-employment taxes and all of those earnings are subject to self-employment taxes.
[4:41] So you're out of compliance, if you go pay yourself a salary, you just take owner's
[4:45] withdrawals.
[4:46] However, everyone here is of S-corps, the magic S-corporation.
[4:51] If you were to go tell the IRS, I have this LLC that I set up in the state of Texas or whatever
[4:56] state it might be.
[4:57] But hey, Mr. IRS, I want you to treat me as a small business corporation or an S-corporation.
[5:03] And that's a designation that the IRS allows business owners to make to say, hey, we're going
[5:07] to treat you this way.
[5:09] If we treat you that way, though, because there's some tax benefits there, if we treat you
[5:13] that way, we need hours as you get yours.
[5:17] So we need you to put
yourself on a payroll.
[5:20] That is one of the compliance requirements from an S-corporation standpoint.
[5:25] So whenever you do establish your LLC as an S-corporation, you have to pay yourself a salary.
[5:32] So you'll pay yourself a wage, you'll withhold Social Security Medicare, a W-2 goes to the Social
[5:38] Security Administration, payroll reports, go to the IRS.
[5:42] And then you can also take draws.
[5:44] But that's an important distinction between the two.
[5:46] And there's also a lot of tax benefits depending on how you set it up as well.
[5:50] So what are some of the biggest misconceptions business owners have about paying themselves
[5:55] properly?
[5:56] So a lot of times I see owners, especially in single member LLCs or partnership LLCs who
[6:03] have not incorporated paying themselves a salary because they think, hey, I've done some
[6:11] research and I think that if I were to go higher myself, I would pay somebody about $75,000
[6:15] a year.
[6:16] So I'm going to set myself up on payroll.
[6:19] Again, that's non-compliant and that is caused for penalties and fines from the IRS if you
[6:25] do that.
[6:26] So a pretty big misconception there.
[6:28] And then another really big misconception I get is if I take money out of my business bank
[6:34] account, I'm going to pay taxes on it.
[6:37] That is categorically false.
[6:40] When you earn the money is when you have to pay taxes.
[6:43] The IRS doesn't care what bank account it sits in.
[6:46] So when it was earned is when you have the liability to pay the tax.
[6:52] So an example I always like to share.
[6:55] If I've got a business who, let's say they had $200,000 of income, we're going to go with
[7:00] the year 2025, they had $200,000 of income in 2025.
[7:04] They had $100,000 of expenses.
[7:07] Let's say rent expense, marketing, software, maybe they had a contractor.
[7:11] So they made $100,000 at the end of that year.
[7:15] Income 200 expense, $100,000, I made $100,000 in that year.
[7:18] They left it all in their business bank account.
[7:21] They didn't take any of it out.
[7:22] They didn't have an owner's draw.
[7:23] Let's say they were an LLC, they didn't have payroll.
[7:27] They left it all in their business bank account because they're under this misguided conception
[7:31] that if I don't take it out of my business account, I don't have to pay taxes.
[7:36] So then we go to file the tax return and I say, hey, it looks like on company ABC, you
[7:41] made $100,000, you need to send a check to the IRS for $27,000 or whatever the tax might
[7:46] be.
[7:47] And then they'll say, but I didn't take it out of my business.
[7:50] And that's when I say, but the concept is one, it was earned is when the taxes do.
[7:55] So fine, great, I'll send my check to the IRS so they pay their taxes.
[8:00] So now we're in the year 2026, 2026, hard year, I made no money.
[8:06] I had no income, I had no expenses, but I still had that $100,000 in my business bank
account.
[8:11] I needed it.
[8:12] So I took it out of my business bank account in 2026.
[8:16] Well, at the end of the year, you don't pay any tax on that money even though you took it
[8:20] out of your business bank account and put it into your personal account because you pay
[8:24] taxes on it when it was earned last year.
[8:27] So that's a really important misconception that a lot of clients make is that if I leave
[8:31] it in my bank account, I don't have to pay taxes on it.
[8:34] I take it out of my bank account, I do have to pay taxes on it, just on how it works.
[8:40] How important is it to separate that personal spending from the business finances, especially
[8:46] as you continue to grow as a business?
[8:48] Yeah, this is huge.
[8:51] So it's just, it's of the utmost important as a business owner that you are not using
[8:56] your business accounts for personal expenses.
[8:59] You set up that LLC for a reason.
[9:02] It's a limited liability corporation because it gives you liability and separation between
[9:06] your business and your personal.
[9:09] But the minute you start to commingle those expenses, they call it piercing the corporate
[9:15] veil.
[9:16] You've pierced that veil.
[9:17] There's no longer a separation between business and personal one anymore.
[9:21] So that liability, that limited liability coverage kind of goes away because now I'm coming
[9:27] link things.
[9:28] So I had on our Q1, 2026 webinar, we had Colleen McKnight on our call.
[9:34] She was a business attorney out of Houston and we talked about this topic in particular.
[9:39] And she reiterated the importance of keeping those things separate.
[9:45] So anytime we start talking to new entrepreneurs, I say, you go get yourself a business credit
[9:50] card and you only use that for business expenses.
[9:53] I keep two cards in my wallet.
[9:55] I've got a business credit card and a personal credit card.
[9:57] I use my personal credit card for anything personal and my business for anything business.
[10:03] And that way I'm not I'm not mixing those expenses and that's really important.
[10:08] Colleen mentioned if you were to ever get into some sort of litigation or a lawsuit or any
[10:12] IRS trouble and they look through your records and they're seeing commingling of those expenses.
[10:18] That's when you could really find yourself in a lot of trouble because again, that coverage
[10:21] that you get by setting up the LLC kind of dissolves.
[10:26] So with that being said, what should business owners think about when deciding how much money
[10:31] to leave inside that business versus paying themselves more personally?
[10:36] Yeah, so big question here.
[10:39] And a lot of times we tell business owners.
[10:41] So there's kind of a common idea among the entrepreneur world that you want to keep 3 to 6 months
[10:49] of expenses in cash reserves in your business bank account.
[10:53] It's a pretty good a smart idea and like we talked about on our last episode talking about
[10:58] cash crunches, this is an important tool to help you kind of weather some of those tough times
[11:02] keeping that money in there.
[11:04] But then we've also told our clients, but you don't want to keep everything in your LLC because
[11:09] again, when you set up an LLC that gives you that limited liability coverage.
[11:15] So if someone were if you had a disgruntled client and they were to go file a lawsuit against
[11:19] that LLC, the assets in the LLC are what are at risk.
[11:24] So if I'm just keeping all of my life savings in my business and not taking it out, that's
[11:29] that risk.
[11:30] So cash flow planning is a really important tool here, but as a business owner, you can decide,
[11:36] what's this kind of like comfort level of cash that I want to keep in my business?
[11:40] And then I've earned all this other cash, I'm going to take it out and go put it into my
[11:44] personal portfolio and buy assets with it or put it into a savings account or leave my
[11:49] life with it, that sort of thing.
[11:50] So big decisions there, the two biggest are kind of a cash flow and then a liability standpoint
[11:57] as well.
[11:59] So how can the way an owner pays himself impact the taxes in the cash flow or that long-term
[12:06] business stability?
[12:07] Yeah, so taxes can be a really huge impact on an owner, on an owner pay.
[12:13] That's why a lot of times you hear a lot of stories about us corporations and why they're
[12:16] important and they say people a lot of money.
[12:19] So just by, let's say I've got a business owner making $100,000 a year, by telling the
[12:24] IRS they would like to be treated as an S corporation, their tax bill goes from, let's say, close
[12:31] to $30,000 down to about $15,000.
[12:34] Again, there's a lot of variables that play there.
[12:37] But just making a simple S corporation can save you about $15,000 in a year at minimum.
[12:44] So it's a really important election to make and whenever you make that election, again,
[12:50] you've got to be compliant and start paying yourself the salary.
[12:52] So there's some tax impact on how you've got your business structured.
[12:57] It's not for everybody.
[12:58] We'd want to review your situation to say here's what makes sense for you when we're looking
[13:02] at tax numbers.
[13:03] But that's an important distinction to make, I say whenever we're talking about taxability.
[13:09] Cash flow wise, I think cash flow is very important in any way your business is structured
[13:13] because when I was giving the examples earlier of looking at our cash line, I think
[13:17] on the last episode we talked about this as well, managing the expectation of where your
[13:22] cash is going is important.
[13:24] So I like my business owners to set up a consistent owner's distribution or owner's draw to themselves
[13:30] rather than trying to take up big chunks of money.
[13:33] But hey, I'm going to auto deposit
$1,000 for my business account to my personal account
[13:39] every week.
[13:40] So that way it happens, I'm getting money out of my business, it's not getting stuck
[13:43] in my business.
[13:44] Again, as long as your cash flow plan supports that, I think that's a really important tool
[13:49] to make.
[13:50] And then finally, long term stability, I think whenever you've got your entity structure set
[13:54] up the correct way and you're monitoring your cash flow, that's when things become stable.
[13:59] So you want to make sure that I'm planning for dips in cash flow over the next quarter.
[14:06] That way, if I do recognize that I'm going to dip below this kind of minimum cash threshold
[14:12] that I've set for myself, myself, I can plan for that.
[14:15] I'm going to delay a payable, I'm going to try to push up a receivable, I might not take
[14:19] an owner's draw this week, whatever it might be, but that's a really helpful tool as well.
[14:25] So Brett, can you have an example of a situation where changing the way in order paid themselves
[14:29] significantly improved the financial side of their business?
[14:32] Yeah, absolutely.
[14:34] So the IRS, let's look at an S corporation again.
[14:39] So we kind of gave the example on the last question about if you were to elect into an S corporation,
[14:44] you could save to probably 15 grand or more in taxes.
[14:47] That's cold hard cash that you're not sending into the IRS.
[14:51] But another example is when you are in S corporation, and the IRS says, hey, you need to pay yourself
[14:57] a payroll.
[14:58] But that doesn't mean you can go pay yourself a $20,000 payroll.
[15:01] They say it needs to be a reasonable compensation.
[15:05] That's basically the only direction the IRS gives you.
[15:07] It needs to be reasonable.
[15:08] What's reasonable?
[15:09] Nobody knows.
[15:10] They'll tell you whenever they're auditing you.
[15:12] So we have a process whereby we calculate a reasonable compensation for our clients.
[15:19] So a perfect example is I had a client, it was a marketing firm owner, and they made about
[15:25] $250,000 a year net.
[15:28] So let's say $1 million in expenses, income, $750,000 in expenses, they made about $250,000
[15:37] after that.
[15:38] They were paying themselves $240,000 on a W2, that is a very high number, especially when
[15:45] you consider their earnings were only $250.
[15:48] So they're paying themselves $240,000 on a W2, and I said, why are you paying yourself
[15:53] that much?
[15:54] And they said, well, I was under the impression that I basically had to pay everything out to
[15:57] myself as a salary, and I said, well, by you paying yourself a salary that high, you're
[16:04] paying Social Security tax up to the limit.
[16:07] So you're paying your total Social Security tax up to, I think the cap is this, you're $170,000
[16:15] somewhere around there.
[16:16] You're paying Social Security tax on that.
[16:18] And then you're paying Medicare tax, the 2.9%, you're paying that on all those dollars
[16:22] that you're earning.
[16:24] So we did a reasonable compensation interview with them, and I said, hey, based on what
[16:29] you do, I would adjust your salary and pay you something where like $85,000 a year.
[16:36] So I will, from 240 to 85.
[16:40] So then you take the savings of almost 15.3%, it's a little more complex than this, but about
[16:45] 15% of that difference, so 240 minus 80, what is that, 160,000, 160,000, 15% of that number
[16:55] is how much you say, because you're no longer paying payroll taxes on that amount.
[16:59] So again, just huge numbers, $12,000, $13,000 in tax savings by making one small little tweak.
[17:06] We're being compliant, we're following the tax code, doing nothing illegal, it's just being
[17:11] smart.
[17:12] Yeah.
[17:13] Well, to kind of put a nice bow on this conversation here, Brad, what usually changes in the way
[17:19] business owners approach compensation, once they start treating the business more strategically
[17:23] like you've mentioned?
[17:24] So I think business owners, one of the most important ways business owners start paying themselves
[17:32] once we do these studies and they understand is it's just a lot more consistent.
[17:37] So there's a book called Profit First by Mike McHallowicz, and I really like the book
[17:42] for entrepreneurs, and one of the lines he has in his book is he says, we want to talk
[17:47] about eradicating entrepreneurial poverty.
[17:50] So entrepreneurs are really great at their trade or their skill, not so great on the financial
[17:56] side.
[17:57] So they can be good at growing their business and making more money, but they're not good
[18:01] at paying themselves.
[18:02] And so this book talks about kind of feeding this cash monster that's just eating your cash.
[18:08] So once we can put a plan in place for our business owners and say, hey, this is going
[18:11] to be your salary.
[18:12] We're going to pay you $80,000 a year.
[18:15] But then we want to also take an owner's distribution.
[18:17] So you're also going to take an owner's distribution of $1,000 every week.
[18:21] So by forcing that and building it into the cash flow model, that allows owners to finally
[18:27] feel like I'm earning something from what I'm building.
[18:32] And when you make it smaller increments consistently, it allows you to take money out of your business
[18:37] and live your life the way you planned on when you wanted to be an entrepreneur and build
[18:41] the business, rather than trying to take a big chunk of money out every quarter or every
[18:47] six months.
[18:48] Because maybe you had a big windfall and I haven't paid myself since January and I'm going
[18:52] to take a payment, but putting it into your plan, making small incremental payments really
[18:57] allows you to feel the success of your business.
[19:01] Let's go stuff, Brett.
[19:03] I appreciate your job, brother.
[19:04] I appreciate it.
[19:05] Thanks, Evan.
[19:07] That's it for today's episode of the Luca Ledger with Brett Arnold.
[19:10] If you'd like to learn more about strategic tax planning, fractional CFO services or building
[19:14] a stronger financial foundation for your business, visit Luca-FS.com.
[19:20] Thank you for listening.
[19:21] Don't forget to subscribe.
[19:22] Leave a review and share this episode with another business owner who could benefit from
[19:26] the conversation.
[19:27] And we'll see you next time.