UDSKRIFT 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.180 --> 00:00:09.500
[gentle music] What does dystopian fiction have to tell us about our current political moment? What doesn't it have to tell us [laughs] about our current political moment?
2
00:00:09.980 --> 00:00:24.200
I think there's an appeal to the clarity of good and evil in, in some of these works. Does it risk short-circuiting the nuance we need to navigate a morally complex world?
3
00:00:24.800 --> 00:00:39.680
Where dystopian fiction gets really interesting is when we're given the opportunity to see the slow slide of a culture from freedom into tyranny. Welcome to The Liberalism.org Show.
4
00:00:40.220 --> 00:00:52.860
I'm Eron Ross Powell, senior director of liberal projects at the Institute for Humane Studies, and I'm joined today by returning guest Sarah Squire, senior program officer at Liberty Fund and a Liberalism.org fellow.
5
00:00:53.820 --> 00:01:06.360
This time, Sarah and I are talking about literature and dystopias. When the news starts to feel like one long run of bad headlines, people reach for stories about worlds gone wrong, and I wanted to know why.
6
00:01:07.440 --> 00:01:25.520
We talk about what separates the hope of The Hunger Games from the airless dread of 1984, where the 2010s wave of young adult dystopias came from, and why the books that show a free society sliding into tyranny one small rule at a time might be the ones most worth reading now.
7
00:01:25.520 --> 00:01:42.000
[upbeat music] Welcome back to The Liberalism.org Show, Sarah. Thank you. It's very good to be back. What does dystopian fiction have to tell us about our current political moment?
8
00:01:43.100 --> 00:01:47.060
Uh, what doesn't it have to tell us [laughs] about our current political moment? Um,
9
00:01:49.260 --> 00:02:11.240
I th- I saw, I saw something really interesting online the other day, which was a, a complaint from some satirical comedians who said, you know, that reality needed to slow down, um, and let them catch up because they couldn't produce satire quickly enough because it was just being produced so rapidly by the moment n- that we're living in.
10
00:02:12.000 --> 00:02:29.560
Um, and I think that there's a way in which sort of fans of dystopian fiction might feel like that a little bit sometimes these days, where, you know, you, you, uh, y- you open up the, the
11
00:02:30.640 --> 00:02:47.460
news on, on your laptop, and there's more about the war, and you open up the news on your laptop, and there's more about, um, gas prices, and you open up the news on your laptop, and I saw a story this morning that condom prices are going out of control because of supply line difficulties.
12
00:02:48.020 --> 00:03:04.600
And, and it just seems like it's just every news is, every piece of news is bad news, and I think that, um, dystopian fiction sort of lives in that space, um, and tries to think about
13
00:03:05.740 --> 00:03:22.680
what it does to a culture and what it does to the people in the culture
Load full transcript
when all of the news feels like bad news, right? And all of the news is bad news. Is it cathartic then? I think it can be.
14
00:03:23.780 --> 00:03:37.900
Um, I think a lot of the reasons that, that people write it and read it is because it is cathartic. Um, there was a, a huge, uh, vogue maybe 10, 15 years ago.
15
00:03:37.960 --> 00:03:42.260
It seemed like every young adult novel was dystopian, right?
16
00:03:42.360 --> 00:04:05.820
It was all, um, sort of, you know, young, [laughs] young teenagers in love trapped in a, trapped in a political society that was completely oppressive and shutting down freedom, and whether that's Scott Westerfeld's, uh, the Uglies, or whether it's, um, Hunger Games, or, uh, you know, you could just keep listing and keep listing and, and, and keep listing titles.
17
00:04:06.560 --> 00:04:15.760
And what's, I think, appealing about those books in particular is that you always have this protagonist who
18
00:04:17.160 --> 00:04:30.280
looks at that world and sees how bad that world is and understands the horror of living in it and tries to do something about it, and I think that's a, that's a, a, a cathartic, um,
19
00:04:31.380 --> 00:04:42.740
role for fiction, um, especially for young people, right? Gr- I think growing up right now, right? I have a, I have an 18-year-old and a 20-year-old, right?
20
00:04:42.960 --> 00:04:49.820
And so they were, uh, in, uh, junior high school and, and high school during COVID.
21
00:04:50.440 --> 00:05:10.200
Um, they're, uh, in college and high school now with, with wars and, uh, rising antisemitism and political violence and, uh, uh, rising prices on everything that th- that they, you know, to the point that they, they notice it.
22
00:05:10.900 --> 00:05:22.040
Um, and I think that there is something cathartic about that kind of fiction for, for them to be reading right now, and I think that's, that's part of the appeal of that genre for young people certainly.
23
00:05:23.920 --> 00:05:37.660
It also seems, as you're saying that, it occurred to me that there's an empowerment angle to these stories, and particularly the YA version of the young lovers up against the system.
24
00:05:37.780 --> 00:05:45.660
Typically, there's named tribes of some kind or another- Yeah... that people are in, um, various factions. But
25
00:05:47.280 --> 00:05:59.460
there's a, when you're young, um, and particularly if the world is kind of scary or confusing, it's confusing and scary in many, many ways, in diverse ways, um-
26
00:06:01.076 --> 00:06:08.716
But the dystopian fiction, like clarifies it down to there's these bad guys. It's, it's that guy at the head of the state, or it's this evil corporation- Yes...
27
00:06:08.756 --> 00:06:26.476
or whatever it happens to be, and we can set our sights on taking that thing down. Yes. There's an identifiable bad guy, or bad entity, or bad government, or bad corporation that can be attacked and can be resisted.
28
00:06:27.316 --> 00:06:36.796
Excuse me. And whether you can win or not, um, depends on which novel you happen to be reading, right? But, um, the, the bad guys are identifiable, right?
29
00:06:36.876 --> 00:06:48.116
There's a great, there's a great moment in one of the episodes of Buffy the Vampire Slayer where Buffy's had a really bad day, and she says to her watcher, Giles, you know, uh, "Just lie to me, Giles."
30
00:06:48.176 --> 00:06:50.376
And he says, "Well, you know, the, the...
31
00:06:51.416 --> 00:07:00.056
Everything always works out all right in the end, and the, the good guys always wear white hats, and you can easily identify the bad guys by their black hats and evil smiles," or something like that.
32
00:07:00.576 --> 00:07:18.376
And, and dystopian fiction for young adults is, is often like that. Um, I don't think, I don't think that's necessarily true of the best dystopian fiction. Um, stuff like Orwell's 1984,
33
00:07:19.456 --> 00:07:36.816
um, the whole point of 1984 is that the dystopia is so, um, is so totalizing that there's no room for resistance. There's no way to tell who's against you because they're all against you.
34
00:07:36.856 --> 00:07:46.176
There's no, right, there's no, there's no room to move in 1984, um, which is very different from something like Hunger Games, where y-
35
00:07:47.236 --> 00:08:03.156
the traps are enormous, the danger is enormous, but there is, there's space for resistance still. Is that just an adult fiction versus a YA fiction thing? Like, is, is adult dystopian fiction usually that more
36
00:08:04.456 --> 00:08:17.836
it's totalizing, there's no way... 1984 does not have a happy ending. I, I don't... Yeah. No. [laughs] No. No, it doesn't. [laughs] Um, yeah, spoiler alert for, for listeners. It, it doesn't go well at the end. Um,
37
00:08:19.016 --> 00:08:33.456
I don't think it's necessarily, um, an adult fiction versus young adult fiction distinction, and I'm always nervous about, um, an interpretation that's like young, young adult fiction is somehow
38
00:08:34.496 --> 00:08:48.776
intrinsically, like lighter or it's gonna, you know, it's, it's less, less full of problems than adult fiction. 'Cause I think that, that, um, that underrates the comple- complexity of the best writing for young adults.
39
00:08:49.076 --> 00:09:00.856
Um, but like if you look at, um, say, some of Kafka's, uh, stories about, uh, being caught in a, in a totalizing state, right?
40
00:09:01.376 --> 00:09:13.896
The, the horror of a Kafkaesque bureaucracy is, um, that it's sort of endless and you're always in process, but also it's always incompetent, right?
41
00:09:14.396 --> 00:09:26.836
Nothing's getting done because they can't get anything done, and that's very frustrating, and that's very, creates its own kind of prison. But that's a very different kind of prison from the, uh, totalizing, uh,
42
00:09:27.776 --> 00:09:41.956
view that, that Big Brother and the party have on someone like Winston Smith, right? So there's space
in Kafka in almost the same way that there's space in something like Hunger Games. When we're looking, then, at
43
00:09:42.976 --> 00:09:59.636
dystopian fiction as, so you're living through a time of authoritarianism, or totalitarianism, or rising versions of eithers, or attempted rising versions of either, um, and you're engaging with this fiction.
44
00:10:02.516 --> 00:10:10.136
On the one hand, we can say like the, I know you don't wanna divide it into YA versus adult- Mm-hmm... but just as, as like a shorthand. Yeah, yeah.
45
00:10:10.596 --> 00:10:22.215
Um, the, the adult is kind of more realistic about the prospects in some ways, or is, in terms of the powerlessness in the face of things.
46
00:10:22.296 --> 00:10:39.476
But whereas the, the young is like the, these kids can somehow overthrow the system, um, which I guess we've have seen happen in places. But I, what I'm thinking of is, like which is sending the more helpful message?
47
00:10:40.616 --> 00:10:54.456
Uh- I mean, I think the more helpful message is, is always gonna be the message that encourages hope, and resistance, and, and, you know, fighting, uh, fighting the forces of [laughs] evil and the, the black hats.
48
00:10:54.676 --> 00:11:10.756
Um, and, uh, you know, that's certainly, that's certainly a, a message that I always wanna carry forward and I always want, um, the people I love to carry forward when, when times are dark. Um, I don't,
49
00:11:12.516 --> 00:11:30.296
I don't know that you get through dark times by reading something like 1984. You might get through dark times by reading something like Hunger Games. Um, 1984 might keep you from returning to dark times,
50
00:11:31.256 --> 00:11:45.996
right? 1984 might be the vaccine, right, that prevents you from, from going back. Um, although one would think we've been, well, [laughs] we've been reading it for a long time. Yes. We maybe should pay better attention.
51
00:11:46.056 --> 00:11:49.636
But, um, um, but yeah.
52
00:11:49.676 --> 00:12:01.876
I mean, I think, I think i- if, if we're looking for helpful, right, like if we're looking for a book that we wanna, or a, a literary message that we wanna share with people in dark times, it's always gonna be a message of hope.
53
00:12:01.916 --> 00:12:05.336
It's always gonna be a message of resistance. Because you never know.
54
00:12:06.076 --> 00:12:21.144
But if you're looking for a message that is gonna warn people about the dangers of going too far down dark roads, then you want a different kind of book for that. So "1984" came out in the '40s? Yes.
55
00:12:21.563 --> 00:12:33.404
Um, the Hunger Games was, what? The 2010s? Was that the, the peak of- I think that that is right, yes... of Hunger Games and the various Hunger Games analogues that flooded the market. And I'm just...
56
00:12:33.524 --> 00:12:48.864
I'm curious about the timing. And there may be a very boring answer to my question- Mm-hmm... I'm about to ask, um, about why we had that wave of dystopian YA fiction when we did. And it could just be
57
00:12:49.784 --> 00:12:52.904
The Hunger Games was very popular. Yeah.
58
00:12:52.944 --> 00:13:02.824
Publishing is fad-driven in a lot of ways, so then lots of other people started writing things that were like The Hunger Games in order to try to capitalize on the popularity of Hunger Games. Um, but
59
00:13:05.284 --> 00:13:08.844
is there a more interesting answer? Because what I'm thinking of is, like,
60
00:13:09.884 --> 00:13:18.024
you know, you, you can imagine you live through really dark times, and then once you're out of it, you try to process it through dystopic fiction- Mm-hmm...
61
00:13:18.144 --> 00:13:28.044
to, to work out the, the feelings and the perspectives and so on. But the 2010s, I guess we were coming out of 9/11.
62
00:13:29.204 --> 00:13:36.464
But a lot of the people who were reading it were young enough that they weren't really engaged- Right... with that. So, like, what gives?
63
00:13:36.504 --> 00:13:47.944
'Cause it seems like we had this wave of it at a time that now younger people are, like, looking back on with nostalgia as the good old days. Yeah. Okay, so I'm theorizing with no basis.
64
00:13:49.184 --> 00:14:01.824
But, um, since you're asking me to, to guess, um, I think Harry Potter probably has a lot to do with it. Okay. So when the Harry Potter novels started coming out, first of all, it
65
00:14:03.184 --> 00:14:15.404
revivified, uh, young adult fiction, particularly young adult fantasy fiction, right? Just took... I mean, it took off like crazy. I was actually working in a bookstore when those books came out, and it was
66
00:14:16.524 --> 00:14:29.764
unbelievable how many copies of the new Harry Potter book we would sell on a given day. It was crazy. Um, so there was this market for children's fiction.
67
00:14:30.684 --> 00:14:47.624
Harry Potter also revealed that kids would read really long books. Mm. And kids would read really long books with scary stuff in them, and violent stuff in them, and big fights between good and evil, right? Um,
68
00:14:49.464 --> 00:15:03.424
but I think, in f- in fact, I know because some of them have said so, some of the people who then went on to write more dystopian young adult fiction felt that Harry Potter was a little,
69
00:15:04.904 --> 00:15:19.504
uh, sort of sweet, unrealistic, kinda candy-coated, um, in its approach. I mean, it's, it's children fiction, so that's not really a problem. But that was, that was what they saw in it that they wanted to correct.
70
00:15:19.584 --> 00:15:39.944
And so Naomi Novik's, uh, Scholomance series, which is about a school for magical education, um, but a very dark one, and a very twisted one, and a very dystopian one, is a direct response, and she has said so, to the Harry Potter novels, um, and to particularly the way that magic works in Harry Potter.
71
00:15:40.544 --> 00:15:55.444
Right? So I think that some of that dystopian fiction sort of popularity,
um, in the young adult world was spurred as a reaction and a response to Harry Potter.
72
00:15:55.644 --> 00:16:06.004
Uh, jumping on the bandwagon, of course, 'cause young adults are buying books by the thousands, by the millions, right? Let's get in on it. Um, but also because people felt that there was maybe,
73
00:16:07.044 --> 00:16:20.624
um, there were themes that, that Harry Potter was not addressing that they wanted to address. Um... I'm curious then, too, about the... these things were widely read by adults. Mm-hmm. Like, we...
74
00:16:20.664 --> 00:16:23.944
it was happening the same time that YA fiction came to...
75
00:16:24.264 --> 00:16:35.344
I, I don't know the numbers, but it, it felt like it was the most popular thing going and that an extraordinary percent of the people who were reading it were not- Not kids, yeah... not kids. Um,
76
00:16:37.844 --> 00:16:53.204
so again, if there's, like, a, a desire to engage with darker themes, um, darker characters, more bleak plots, there's lots and lots of adult fiction- Yeah... that does that. And so why the...
77
00:16:55.044 --> 00:17:11.884
why that moment of adults reading YA fiction, and particularly YA dystopic fiction? Good question. I thi- I think there's an appeal to the clarity of good and evil in, in some of these works.
78
00:17:12.564 --> 00:17:26.664
Um, I think, um, I think stories about resistance and about hope are empowering and inspiring. Um, I think that, um, a lot of
79
00:17:27.644 --> 00:17:41.164
the, uh, a lot of dystopian fiction aimed at younger readers, um, y- uh, comes, uh, from female writers, has a female protagonist.
80
00:17:41.944 --> 00:17:58.884
Um, and I think that's a voice, um, that is often lacking in science fiction/fantasy written for adults. Um, it's gotten better, but still largely, particularly science fiction is, is very male-driven.
81
00:17:59.684 --> 00:18:14.124
Um, uh, so I think, I think that's some of the appeal there. Um, but I, uh, you know, and I think, I think probably, again, adults started reading Harry Potter as sort of a- Yeah... kinda nostalgic comfort read, right?
82
00:18:14.164 --> 00:18:30.464
This, it was new stuff, but it felt Narnia. It felt Wizard of Oz. It fe- you know, it felt- Kind of a familiar kind of storytelling with a new plot. And so, y- you know, natural to get drawn into that and to love it.
83
00:18:30.884 --> 00:18:40.904
And then while you're browsing the YA section, right, what else do you find? What else can you find, right? And people finding out that there's great writing going on there, too.
84
00:18:42.744 --> 00:18:51.084
Is, if we look at it then from the perspective of engagement in politics- Mm-hmm... or political ideas, um,
85
00:18:52.184 --> 00:19:03.924
the last time you and I talked, we talked about the ways that we can get lessons about the world and help us think through- Yeah... things in the world through fiction. So if we apply that to dystopian fiction,
86
00:19:05.604 --> 00:19:11.344
on the one hand, engaging with dystopian fiction can show you
87
00:19:12.284 --> 00:19:25.044
the threats, can clarify the threats, um, can make real to you what it means for there to be authoritarianism, totalitarianism, autocracy, whatever it is. Um,
88
00:19:26.084 --> 00:19:37.164
but on the other hand, it seems like if, if we're reading the YA version, or in the YA version, part of the appeal of it is this clarity of good guys, bad guys. Mm-hmm. The bad guys are really bad.
89
00:19:37.204 --> 00:19:46.904
The good guys are really good. Occasionally, you have the character who rides the line, but for the most- Yeah... part, it's, it's this bifurcated thematic structure.
90
00:19:49.464 --> 00:20:00.664
Does that run a risk of, like, that's not how the world... There are really bad guys in the world, but they're not like this tribe over here is the bad guys and this tribe over here is the good guys. And so does it risk
91
00:20:01.664 --> 00:20:18.644
kind of short-circuiting the, like, the nuance we need to navigate a, like, a more morally complex or culturally complex world that we actually find ourselves in? Yeah, I mean, it does.
92
00:20:18.744 --> 00:20:27.044
I think we do a pretty good job as humans of short-circuiting that kind of thinking anyway. We're, we're very, we're very tribal, um, in our approach to things.
93
00:20:27.084 --> 00:20:40.144
We're very black hat, white hat in our, in our approach to things already. So I don't know how much blame I wanna put on, you know, [laughs] dystopian young adult fiction for that tendency in our character. Um,
94
00:20:41.184 --> 00:20:55.604
and I do think, um, I, I actually think probably that, you know, uh, y- you want kids to get that mes- message of hope. You want people to get that message of ho- hope. But,
95
00:20:56.544 --> 00:21:15.724
um, perhaps more important than that, and perhaps more important than the sort of identifying who the bad guys are, um, for me, at least when I'm reading, where dystopian fiction gets really interesting, right, where it gets really sort of rich and complicated and I start really paying attention, is when
96
00:21:16.684 --> 00:21:24.784
we're given the opportunity to see the slow slide of a culture from freedom into tyranny.
97
00:21:25.784 --> 00:21:40.084
And I find that absolutely fascinating, and I find that a really interesting thing, um, that several novels have done. I'm thinking, uh, Mark Dunn's wonderful book, Ella Minnow Pea- Yeah...
98
00:21:40.224 --> 00:21:54.184
uh, which is not a young adult novel specifically, but I've r- taught it to high school students, um, and college students for, for years. So it works perfectly well. Um, which, uh,
99
00:21:56.724 --> 00:22:07.864
I'm trying not to give you too long of a summary here. Um, but, uh, y- the, you watch, uh, a, a town council take linguistic control
100
00:22:08.784 --> 00:22:19.084
over a town, um, piece by piece by piece until by the end of the novel, um, there's,
language has completely dissolved.
101
00:22:19.124 --> 00:22:34.304
And when language dissolves, law dissolves, and, um, history dissolves, and religion dissolves, and culture dissolves. Um, and y- you can watch it all happen because the novel is told as a series of letters.
102
00:22:34.344 --> 00:22:48.804
And so you can watch language fall apart over the course of that. And it starts with one tiny, tiny regulation from the town council, and you just watch it dissolve over about 150 pages. Um, and then, um,
103
00:22:50.004 --> 00:23:16.484
The Mandibles, which is by Lionel Shriver, which is a favorite book of mine, um, basically takes, um, creates, imagines a perfect storm of economic crises in a near future United States where all of the various economic crises we have already gone through in fact are sort of repeated all in one short course of time and just destroy everything.
104
00:23:17.184 --> 00:23:31.804
So, you know, by the end of the novel, um, you know, the, the elderly are being left to die in the streets because no one can support them. And, and, you know, it's terrible. Um, and, uh,
105
00:23:33.124 --> 00:23:40.784
and you go from, you know, a very standard United States at the beginning of the novel to, to this horror show at the end.
106
00:23:41.364 --> 00:23:53.604
Um, and that slow slide I think is really interesting, um, and really important for thinking about, um, how political change actually happens, which is not usually overnight,
107
00:23:54.924 --> 00:24:05.304
um, and not usually out of nowhere, and not usually with no warning, right? In 1984, you're just dropped in the middle of it. Hmm. Right?
108
00:24:05.604 --> 00:24:19.284
So you don't have a sense really of how things changed gradually to get you to 1984. It's just, you know, you've always been at war with Eastasia. [laughs] Um, right? So, um-
109
00:24:20.664 --> 00:24:37.534
So I take this as you defending the Star Wars prequel trilogy. [laughs] No. Much of what we talked about has been... Well, so, like, we talked about Hunger Games and analogous sort of stuff. Mm-hmm. But that was
110
00:24:38.654 --> 00:24:56.014
15 years ago or whenever. It was, um, it was before the present troubles- Yeah... I suppose. Yes. Um, is dystopian fiction still riding a high right now? Or I guess another, like, a version of this question is
111
00:24:56.974 --> 00:25:10.014
what does it look like now compared to what it looked like with The Hunger Games and- Oh... all of its versions? That's an interesting question. I think the, um...
112
00:25:15.454 --> 00:25:30.294
I think people sort of overdosed on dystopian fiction. Um, and uh, it became, uh, very tropey and became, uh... There's really just so much of it. Um, and uh,
113
00:25:31.934 --> 00:25:42.074
young readers in particular are very sensitive to that. And, like, to a certain point, they love it if they can read 30 of the same book over and over again, right? Give me a good long series, and I'll just go at it.
114
00:25:42.414 --> 00:25:50.534
But then at some point they sort of wake up, and they have the ick all of a sudden. And they're just over it, and it's too predictable, and they're tired of it, and you already know what's gonna happen.
115
00:25:50.834 --> 00:26:03.234
And so you just kind of stop. And I think that they hit that point with dystopian fiction. There's still dystopian fiction out there, but I feel like the, that, uh,
116
00:26:04.374 --> 00:26:17.494
we've moved into more of a, a straight, straight f- well, a queer fantasy kind of a area with a lot of romantasy fiction, um, which I wrote about for Reason Magazine not too long ago. Um,
117
00:26:18.954 --> 00:26:32.754
but I feel like that's, that's more where things are going. Um, I'm seeing at least somewhat less, um, dystopian stuff coming up.
118
00:26:32.814 --> 00:26:40.773
Now, I know that anybody who's listening to this is about to email me with their top 50 favorite current dystopian novels, and I would like to get those, so.
119
00:26:40.773 --> 00:26:48.714
[laughs] Y- yeah, I was just thinking of, uh, I think you're right. Like, we've seen the kind of rise of, like, solar punk- Yeah...
120
00:26:48.774 --> 00:27:00.774
science fiction, which is, like, we can make a better future, and here's what it looks like. But at the same time you've also seen... And its aversion to dystopia is cyberpunk fiction has made a real...
121
00:27:00.814 --> 00:27:08.594
I mean, a lot of it's concentrated around a very popular video game that- Yeah... you know. But, um, that seems to have come back, too.
122
00:27:08.634 --> 00:27:19.274
And I see a lot of, like, we're living in that kind of like we ended up in a cyberpunk world without even noticing it kind of discourse. Right. And I think, I mean, I think that, um,
123
00:27:21.174 --> 00:27:25.534
I, I'm, I guess part of what it is is that I think the thing that we're scared of right now is AI.
124
00:27:26.674 --> 00:27:44.434
Um, and I think the most dystopian thing that people are, are facing aside from whatever one might think about the current political context, um, I think AI is the current sort of fear for sort of a totalizing kind of a terrifying thing that would produce a dystopia.
125
00:27:44.794 --> 00:27:52.274
And I guess in my head that's more straight science fiction than it is- Okay... dystopian. I might just need to revise that in my mind.
126
00:27:53.274 --> 00:28:07.094
Um, because I do think, you know, books like The Circle, which is about sort of, like, social media run amok and, and, and some others that are about, you know, the fear of AI sort of lean that way.
127
00:28:12.994 --> 00:28:23.274
So what do you think will make a... Asking you to make predictions. Um- [laughs] We'll have, I mean, all publishing things move in sine waves. Yeah. Um,
128
00:28:24.714 --> 00:28:34.874
we'll get, even if it's tapered off from the Hunger Games high, we'll get dystopian fiction will come back as it has over and over and over again. I mean, it depends what Grok wants to write, right? Yeah. Yes.
129
00:28:34.894 --> 00:28:52.534
[laughs] Uh, so again, we're living through the moment we're living through. Yeah. Um, and when it's behind us, whatever that looks like, people will, as they always do, process that in art. Mm-hmm.
130
00:28:52.794 --> 00:29:09.814
Um, what do you think it'll look like going forward? What do you think the next wave will look like? Oh, that's a really good question. I wish I knew because I could make so much money writing it. Sure. Wow.
131
00:29:10.474 --> 00:29:20.834
Um, I don't know. Um, if, like, if George R.R. Martin hadn't already sort of done it
132
00:29:21.774 --> 00:29:31.654
with Game of Thrones, I would think it, it might be time for a big sort of, like, faux medieval kind of world building sci-fi thing, right?
133
00:29:31.714 --> 00:29:41.814
Where you can have tyrannical kings and, and wicked advisors and, and power run amok and that kind of thing. And maybe we'll get that. Or maybe we'll get
134
00:29:42.774 --> 00:29:57.474
sort of a, a, um, you know, Sinclair Lewis and, uh, and Mark Twain style sort of satirical political novels. That would be interesting. Um, even sort of some, some Tom Wolfe style,
135
00:29:58.674 --> 00:30:15.094
you know, Bonfire of the Vanities but, but updated for our particular bonfire and our, our own very special vanities. Um, I don't know. And I wouldn't, I, I would love to predict the next, uh, young adult novel fad, but
136
00:30:16.194 --> 00:30:32.034
I couldn't tell you. Judging by what my kids are reading, it's gonna be horror. Okay. Um, but, uh, we all know I'm too scared to read that, so. [laughs] With that, I wanna thank you for coming back on the show, Sarah.
137
00:30:32.314 --> 00:30:46.014
Anytime. [outro music] If you enjoyed my conversation with Sarah, you can find more like it along with original essays from contemporary liberal scholars at www.liberalism.org.
138
00:30:59.614 --> 00:30:59.914
[outro music]