UDSKRIFT 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.071 --> 00:00:03.616
Karl Marx is writing to one of his friends in New York.
2
00:00:04.277 --> 00:00:09.344
He's saying, those people who've gone out to Australia, they don't realize how much they've made our world shrink.
3
00:00:10.025 --> 00:00:14.951
It's kind of like it's a really early statement about globalization after gold.
4
00:00:15.872 --> 00:00:17.953
was discovered in 1851.
5
00:00:18.573 --> 00:00:21.535
Without a policy, the default was it was open borders, right?
6
00:00:22.115 --> 00:00:25.236
We're the only country that's done assisted passage on scale.
7
00:00:25.596 --> 00:00:27.817
I don't think many people know that it goes back to the 1830s.
8
00:00:28.038 --> 00:00:37.622
About three and a half million people came to Australia whose fare was either fully subsidised or generously subsidised, who otherwise probably wouldn't have come.
9
00:00:38.362 --> 00:00:48.811
In terms of its vision, stakes and execution, the post-war migration program is the most epic policy experiment in Australian history.
10
00:00:50.334 --> 00:00:50.855
broad degree.
11
00:00:51.535 --> 00:01:00.725
If the US had, after World War II said, we're open again, many of the migrants from the countries that Australia signed agreements with would have gone to the United States instead.
12
00:01:00.845 --> 00:01:06.431
But the US didn't begin reopening to migration until the mid-1960s.
13
00:01:06.891 --> 00:01:10.836
So we had this window of opportunity.
14
00:01:11.759 --> 00:01:21.489
If you had to boil down why the post-war migration program was so successful to the most basic set of preconditions, what would they be?
15
00:01:22.123 --> 00:01:22.763
Full employment.
16
00:01:23.263 --> 00:01:23.483
Yes.
17
00:01:23.904 --> 00:01:24.784
Yeah, full employment.
18
00:01:25.704 --> 00:01:29.345
Migration has made Australia larger and has made it different.
19
00:01:30.286 --> 00:01:31.486
It hasn't made it more prosperous.
20
00:01:31.546 --> 00:01:42.609
We probably would still be, in terms of incomes per head, roughly the same now as we are, had we not had a big pickup in, big boost in migration after World War II.
21
00:01:43.410 --> 00:01:44.070
By and large,
22
00:01:45.239 --> 00:01:55.158
the Australian experience with migration is probably the best the world can offer.
23
00:01:57.555 --> 00:02:00.756
Today, it's my great pleasure to be speaking with Mark Cully.
24
00:02:01.077 --> 00:02:11.481
Mark was Chief Economist of the Department of Immigration from 2009 to 2012, and he is the author of a forthcoming book, A History of Immigration in Australia.
25
00:02:11.862 --> 00:02:14.803
I've read the manuscript, and it'll be one of the books of the year.
26
00:02:15.343 --> 00:02:16.724
So Mark, welcome to the podcast.
27
00:02:17.064 --> 00:02:18.725
Thanks, Joe, and thanks for the plug.
28
00:02:19.965 --> 00:02:24.988
So the title, I think, will be Waves of Plenty, and it's going to be published in September.
29
00:02:25.968 --> 00:02:29.771
It's striking that there's a huge gap in the literature.
30
00:02:29.791 --> 00:02:38.417
Australia doesn't really have a general history of immigration, something that covers the full sweep from British, the arrival of the British through to the present day.
31
00:02:39.017 --> 00:02:42.180
So it's a huge service that you're doing for the country.
32
00:02:43.174 --> 00:02:56.404
In the book, you give a kind of macro overview of that whole history, but you also focus in particular on six decades and you provide like a narrative history of each of those decades.
33
00:02:56.444 --> 00:03:00.267
So those decades are the 1830s, the 1850s, the 1890s, the 1950s, 1970s and 2000s.
34
00:03:00.327 --> 00:03:00.467
Yeah.
35
00:03:00.487 --> 00:03:01.027
So...
36
00:03:07.049 --> 00:03:12.938
As I told you before we started recording, the book left me with a number of mysteries or questions, which we'll get to.
37
00:03:14.200 --> 00:03:20.850
I've got some big picture questions, and I also want to go through each of the different decades and ask a few different questions on each of them.
38
00:03:22.261 --> 00:03:27.928
But we'll start with my first mystery and the 1830s.
39
00:03:28.849 --> 00:03:36.918
So one of the defining features of Australia generally, but in particular immigration to Australia in the 19th century is,
40
00:03:37.639 --> 00:03:43.863
is that there are these chronic labor supply shortages, which are a function of the tyranny of distance.
41
00:03:44.263 --> 00:03:55.050
I think in the book you write until the mid-19th century, it was about five pounds to travel from the UK to America, whereas about 20 pounds to travel from the UK to Australia.
42
00:03:55.830 --> 00:03:57.391
And the amount of time it took.
43
00:03:57.411 --> 00:03:58.892
It was like about three times as long.
44
00:03:59.532 --> 00:03:59.672
Yep.
45
00:03:59.852 --> 00:04:00.032
Yeah.
46
00:04:00.152 --> 00:04:00.933
About three months.
47
00:04:01.193 --> 00:04:01.713
Three months.
48
00:04:01.973 --> 00:04:05.315
And you have to think about the opportunity cost of your time.
49
00:04:05.335 --> 00:04:06.116
You can't earn a wage.
50
00:04:06.136 --> 00:04:06.636
You bought a ship.
51
00:04:07.076 --> 00:04:07.556
Exactly.
52
00:04:08.137 --> 00:04:09.898
And at a much higher death rate as well.
53
00:04:10.218 --> 00:04:11.058
It was about 2%.
54
00:04:11.459 --> 00:04:12.979
People died on the voyage on the way over.
55
00:04:13.039 --> 00:04:15.000
Higher for kids.
56
00:04:15.481 --> 00:04:15.741
Yeah.
57
00:04:16.481 --> 00:04:21.324
I mean, in some ways it was almost like the then equivalent of traveling to the moon or something.
58
00:04:22.064 --> 00:04:22.304
And...
59
00:04:23.505 --> 00:04:33.967
So as a function of that, Australia had these chronic labour supply shortages and colonial governments primarily tried to address those through assisted migration.
60
00:04:35.067 --> 00:04:50.270
But it's striking that Australia never turned
Load full transcript
to slavery like other countries like America and South Africa did to solve their labour supply issues.
61
00:04:51.435 --> 00:05:05.480
And that's particularly striking because there was a local indigenous population and yet we still exported a lot of labor from either the Pacific Islands or from the United Kingdom and Ireland.
62
00:05:06.180 --> 00:05:14.003
So, yeah, do you have like an account or an explanation for why Australia didn't turn to slavery like some other countries did?
63
00:05:14.943 --> 00:05:20.245
People and scholars make a distinction between free and unfree labor.
64
00:05:20.485 --> 00:05:20.705
Yeah.
65
00:05:22.168 --> 00:05:34.752
And you could have slavery at one continuum and then you could kind of have, I don't know, people just being hired as employees in a labour market and covered by kind of rights and conditions at the other end.
66
00:05:37.053 --> 00:05:44.515
When you're asking about slavery, you kind of, I think, need to think of frame it within that kind of unfree labour.
67
00:05:44.535 --> 00:05:46.196
I see.
68
00:05:52.218 --> 00:06:01.082
the kind of conditions under which Aboriginal Australians did work in the labor market as being on the borderline of unfree.
69
00:06:02.262 --> 00:06:06.364
They had few rights.
70
00:06:07.064 --> 00:06:09.826
Their wages were grossly underpaid or often not paid at all.
71
00:06:11.386 --> 00:06:19.590
And they weren't necessarily that much different from, and we might go on and talk about the,
72
00:06:20.805 --> 00:06:25.969
the South Sea Islanders, in the way in which they were brought into Australia as indentured workers.
73
00:06:27.490 --> 00:06:36.938
The chronic labour shortage only became, started to become an issue in Australia during the 1820s.
74
00:06:37.578 --> 00:06:43.343
And I guess the way I'm thinking about it is that in the 1820s
75
00:06:52.547 --> 00:06:56.510
forgotten his first name, Big, the Big B-I-E-G-E, Big Report.
76
00:06:56.970 --> 00:07:03.396
He basically ran a kind of a royal commission into the operation of the convict system.
77
00:07:04.316 --> 00:07:13.704
And there were some concerns in Britain that being transported to Australia did not have sufficient terror attached to it.
78
00:07:15.285 --> 00:07:17.527
And Big was sent out to investigate this.
79
00:07:18.107 --> 00:07:19.068
And so there was this
80
00:07:21.369 --> 00:07:32.538
tension between the colonial authorities and British reformers and the British authorities as to what were these penal colonies there to do?
81
00:07:33.038 --> 00:07:44.388
Were they there to send the criminal underclass from the UK away and to Australia and so they're out of sight, out of mind?
82
00:07:45.476 --> 00:07:46.657
and just keep sending them there?
83
00:07:47.118 --> 00:07:57.769
Or were these colonies to be, because there were two, New South Wales and Van Diemen's land by that point, were they there to be something different to a penal colony?
84
00:07:57.809 --> 00:08:03.314
Were
they to become, in effect, a dominion?
85
00:08:04.756 --> 00:08:08.600
And at the same time, there was a push against...
86
00:08:09.878 --> 00:08:31.845
push starting against against transportation for kind of moral grounds because slavery was being contested i think it was 18 18 early 1830s that the the slavery act was was passed to abolish slavery within the empire so the the opportunity i guess for slavery to take off in australia whatever form it might have taken
87
00:08:34.205 --> 00:08:53.934
didn't happen before 1830, which is when assisted passage started, and didn't happen after 1830, slavery had been expunged in the British Empire, that there are a series of papers which look at the use of Aboriginal Australians as workers in different parts of Australia.
88
00:08:54.334 --> 00:09:00.317
It's kind of well known that they worked as kind of jackaroos and so on on cattle stations.
89
00:09:02.915 --> 00:09:10.319
It's a fairly thin literature, I would say, so it's very hard to be definitive about it.
90
00:09:11.039 --> 00:09:23.585
I guess the one thing that people know is kind of the backdrop to this is the population numbers were collapsed calamitously.
91
00:09:25.005 --> 00:09:30.928
There were perhaps, so Boyd Hunter's done some work on this,
92
00:09:33.912 --> 00:09:41.416
a million Indigenous inhabitants of Australia in the late 18th century.
93
00:09:43.497 --> 00:09:59.045
And by about the 1840s, halfway through the 1840s or thereabouts, the number of colonists had gone past the number of Indigenous Australians who had died principally from disease rather than from...
94
00:10:00.608 --> 00:10:01.128
warfare.
95
00:10:01.729 --> 00:10:13.634
I guess I'd observe that even in the United States, they didn't, not in any significant scale that I know of, enslave their own indigenous people.
96
00:10:13.654 --> 00:10:16.396
They brought people out from Africa to do that.
97
00:10:16.616 --> 00:10:16.836
Yeah.
98
00:10:17.916 --> 00:10:20.177
So a question about the 1850s.
99
00:10:21.478 --> 00:10:27.121
I've come to view the 1850s as perhaps the most important decade in Australian history.
100
00:10:28.201 --> 00:10:29.162
And I've been trying to puzzle
101
00:10:31.380 --> 00:10:51.382
what it means to have so many people in a country who are there for the first time, maybe the most striking statistic from that period is I think by the end of the gold rush decade, so we're talking early 1860s now, seven in 10 people in Victoria were born overseas.
102
00:10:51.862 --> 00:10:52.123
Mm-hmm.
103
00:10:53.072 --> 00:11:00.698
It must have been such a strange experience to live in a society where most of your fellows were not originally from the place.
104
00:11:00.998 --> 00:11:01.578
Right.
105
00:11:01.818 --> 00:11:06.141
It almost feels like a weird Lord of the Flies kind of situation or something.
106
00:11:06.222 --> 00:11:09.504
In some very real sense, it's like you're creating a society from scratch.
107
00:11:09.964 --> 00:11:10.284
I just...
108
00:11:11.185 --> 00:11:20.290
I've just been recently trying to puzzle through exactly how that affected Australian culture, that influx of newcomers.
109
00:11:20.310 --> 00:11:21.530
Right.
110
00:11:21.550 --> 00:11:29.174
And not even the particular qualities of the newcomers, but just the fact of having so many new people in such a short space of time.
111
00:11:30.135 --> 00:11:30.795
Victoria.
112
00:11:32.692 --> 00:11:47.497
didn't have any colonists except for some, you know, renegades and kind of outlaws who were doing stealing along the Southern Ocean until the mid-1830s when the Port Phillip District was established.
113
00:11:48.898 --> 00:11:51.719
So it went from kind of, you know, basically no white people
114
00:11:53.110 --> 00:12:01.012
to I think it must have been 400,000 odd by the end of the 1850s.
115
00:12:01.873 --> 00:12:03.493
So it went from having no white people at all.
116
00:12:03.553 --> 00:12:15.937
Between 1835 and 1850, most of what is now Western Victoria and Central Victoria, Northeastern Victoria, became occupied by squatters.
117
00:12:16.297 --> 00:12:17.098
Yeah.
118
00:12:17.418 --> 00:12:19.938
And there were huge numbers of sheep there.
119
00:12:21.039 --> 00:12:21.799
Melbourne was a...
120
00:12:23.852 --> 00:12:26.233
a big town of 20 odd thousand ish.
121
00:12:26.913 --> 00:12:42.497
And then after gold was discovered in 1851 and effectively you had, you essentially had an, without a policy, the default was it was open borders, right?
122
00:12:43.477 --> 00:12:46.498
There were, there was no restrictions on anybody turning up.
123
00:12:47.383 --> 00:12:56.646
if so long as you could find a ship to bring you to Melbourne, you could come and you could start searching for gold.
124
00:12:56.846 --> 00:13:08.309
And people did come from all over North America, from all over Europe, from Britain and Ireland.
125
00:13:10.202 --> 00:13:18.745
from New Zealand and I guess most famously, because it's the way it played out over the course of that decade, from China.
126
00:13:19.966 --> 00:13:26.368
William Howart was already a fairly distinguished writer in London at that time and elderly.
127
00:13:27.517 --> 00:13:32.838
And he decided he'd come out to see what all the fuss was about and wrote a memoir of his time there.
128
00:13:32.858 --> 00:13:47.461
And it's so colourful and so evocative of, like you said, this land taken over by these white people searching for gold.
129
00:13:47.741 --> 00:13:51.162
And it was, I don't know, it was an incredible...
130
00:13:52.673 --> 00:14:20.188
It was both a kind of an upheaval of everything that had gone before, but it was also this tremendous kind of, I guess, a melting pot in that sense that people sometimes use it in the context of the United States in the late 19th century of throwing all of these people together and everyone having to find ways of accommodating the way in which they saw the world and the way in which they
interacted with one another
131
00:14:21.358 --> 00:14:25.102
And it was the birth of Australian culture.
132
00:14:26.623 --> 00:14:30.007
There was certainly a lot of swagger and a lot of larrikins.
133
00:14:34.627 --> 00:14:45.031
There were a lot of former convicts who'd come from, particularly from Van Diemen's Land, to try to make their riches.
134
00:14:46.092 --> 00:14:52.234
And there were lots of colourful stories about the escapades that they got up to.
135
00:14:53.495 --> 00:15:03.459
And in fact, the Victorian Legislative Council tried to ban former convicts from Van Diemen's Land coming over to Melbourne because of all the uproar that was being created.
136
00:15:05.476 --> 00:15:34.140
There's also an argument which people have been making for a long time, people like Geoffrey Searle, that if we think about the attributes of convicts and of assisted migrants and then compare those two groups with the people who came in the 1850s, we're comparing the British and Irish
137
00:15:36.083 --> 00:15:44.346
with, in those three groups, the convicts, the assisted passage migrants, and the people paying their own way.
138
00:15:46.327 --> 00:16:01.653
That last group were more middle class, more literate, and more skilled in their kind of background trades than the other two groups.
139
00:16:01.993 --> 00:16:03.914
The assisted passage migrants were,
140
00:16:05.016 --> 00:16:10.101
were very much labouring poor, and particularly from Ireland.
141
00:16:10.121 --> 00:16:22.813
The Irish were very overrepresented amongst the assisted passage migrants, and the convicts were also very much working class.
142
00:16:23.954 --> 00:16:25.535
And a number of those people who had...
143
00:16:27.315 --> 00:16:52.332
come as paid their own way in the 1850s to search for gold had spent a lot of time at chartist rallies in in britain arguing for electoral reform so you see a number of things kind of flowering particularly in victoria but also in in new south wales in in that decade around
144
00:16:54.079 --> 00:16:57.123
seeking kind of broad, a broad franchise.
145
00:16:58.318 --> 00:17:02.660
And part of the resolution of the Eureka Stockade was to settle on a broad franchise.
146
00:17:04.120 --> 00:17:13.624
You see the first industrial agreement in the world on an eight-hour working day for putting up the law building at Melbourne University.
147
00:17:15.124 --> 00:17:16.605
It is a very fascinating decade.
148
00:17:16.625 --> 00:17:20.887
I don't know whether it's the most consequential one in Australia's history or not because there's a few contenders for that.
149
00:17:21.187 --> 00:17:22.227
Yeah, no doubt.
150
00:17:22.347 --> 00:17:24.208
But it was a fascinating one.
151
00:17:24.528 --> 00:17:25.649
Yeah.
152
00:17:26.130 --> 00:17:33.077
So all of those things in terms of the sort of experiences and the composition of the migrants who arrived in that decade, I think...
153
00:17:34.059 --> 00:17:34.719
Very important.
154
00:17:34.739 --> 00:17:41.302
You can draw pretty clear lines from those to the egalitarian culture that Australia is known for.
155
00:17:41.842 --> 00:17:44.343
For example, the Chartists and whatnot.
156
00:17:45.243 --> 00:17:47.384
But, yeah, I'm still trying to – it's still a mystery to me.
157
00:17:47.744 --> 00:17:55.666
Like the fact of – imagine living in a country or a city where 70% of the people around you are there for the first time.
158
00:17:56.307 --> 00:18:00.148
I'm trying to work out the importance of that fact in and of itself.
159
00:18:02.372 --> 00:18:03.632
And yeah, it's still a mystery to me.
160
00:18:04.653 --> 00:18:11.694
You can see in the letters that people write home and the guidebooks that are being produced.
161
00:18:12.295 --> 00:18:17.736
There's kind of official guidebooks that are being produced by the Colonial Land and Emigration Commission.
162
00:18:19.196 --> 00:18:25.038
There are kind of, I guess, proselytizers and boosters who are talking about
163
00:18:25.778 --> 00:18:29.702
what it's like to move to this place.
164
00:18:30.382 --> 00:18:40.851
So I guess it has elements of a wild, wild west frontier in the way in which we sometimes think about the way in which the expansion westwards of the United States happened.
165
00:18:42.153 --> 00:18:45.436
You know, a little bit lawless, a little bit wild.
166
00:18:46.476 --> 00:18:50.300
There were so many people coming that ships had to wait for two days off the coast.
167
00:18:51.833 --> 00:18:54.434
Queenscliff before they could get a berth to land.
168
00:18:55.054 --> 00:19:03.557
And then when people landing, they're being quoted these outrageous sums of money to be able to take their bags from the port of Melbourne into the centre of Melbourne.
169
00:19:03.697 --> 00:19:10.219
So they just throw them away or they have an impromptu sale down on the wharf.
170
00:19:10.399 --> 00:19:10.639
Yeah.
171
00:19:11.440 --> 00:19:12.440
There are so many people...
172
00:19:14.060 --> 00:19:21.847
arriving that the average number of people living inside rooms in Melbourne doubles.
173
00:19:21.967 --> 00:19:25.411
And I think each dwelling has like eight or nine people in it.
174
00:19:26.832 --> 00:19:33.298
And there's so few housing that they build a tent community on the edges of the Yarra where there's 7,000 people at one stage just living in tents.
175
00:19:34.699 --> 00:19:37.282
So you really are throwing all these people together into really...
176
00:19:38.658 --> 00:20:02.028
unsettling environment but the the probability that somebody could become extremely wealthy overnight was was much higher than it had ever been previously and sufficiently high that brought so many so many people out and it made there's a there's a quote i have where where karl marx is writing to one of his friends in in new york
177
00:20:03.282 --> 00:20:12.847
he wasn't old at that stage, but he's saying, he's saying those people who've, who've, who've gone out
to Australia, they don't realize how much they've made our world shrink.
178
00:20:13.548 --> 00:20:18.050
It's kind of like, it's a really early statement about, um, about globalization.
179
00:20:18.831 --> 00:20:26.155
Um, and that we, we could never have imagined this, you know, before in the 1840s and here he is, you know, in the 1850s writing about this, uh,
180
00:20:27.098 --> 00:20:37.366
This colony, which, and, you know, Melbourne kind of emerging overnight as, and growing faster than Chicago did, for instance.
181
00:20:37.746 --> 00:20:49.315
I think Melbourne probably has the record in the 19th century for the, it grew faster than San Francisco, grew faster than Chicago as the fastest growing new city.
182
00:20:49.655 --> 00:20:50.276
Mm-hmm.
183
00:20:51.415 --> 00:20:51.655
Okay.
184
00:20:51.936 --> 00:20:53.877
One quick question on the 1890s.
185
00:20:54.718 --> 00:21:13.576
So if the depression of the 1890s hadn't happened and instead around the time of Federation, we had economic conditions like those of the post-war era, so close to full employment, good growth, directionally, how different do you think the White Australia policy would have been?
186
00:21:15.151 --> 00:21:17.393
I'm not sure that it would have been any different.
187
00:21:18.013 --> 00:21:38.290
The level of antipathy that had developed towards Chinese migrants from the mid-1850s through to the late 1880s, it was extremely high.
188
00:21:38.470 --> 00:21:42.694
It wasn't unparalleled because it also happened, especially in the United States,
189
00:21:44.923 --> 00:22:03.797
And in both the United States and Australia, you see this tension between the governing authorities, which are trying to broker these effectively trade arrangements to give them access to the Chinese market and to Chinese goods,
190
00:22:05.085 --> 00:22:11.697
So opening up these relationships under, you've got to say, on the Chinese side, a fair degree of duress.
191
00:22:12.058 --> 00:22:14.603
What we call the Nanking Treaty, they call the Unjust Treaty.
192
00:22:17.522 --> 00:22:31.597
But on the ground, the white Americans and the white Australians, the colonists, were repulsed by the Chinese migrants.
193
00:22:33.118 --> 00:22:38.244
And I don't know whether there's a precedent for it in the US, but the
194
00:22:39.345 --> 00:22:50.995
You know, there is the report that was done, the Goldfields Commission report on the Eureka Stockade uprising, which I think dates from 1855, talks about yellow hordes.
195
00:22:51.476 --> 00:22:53.557
And this is an official government document.
196
00:22:54.158 --> 00:23:00.944
And that language and that antipathy, it's in countless newspaper columns.
197
00:23:01.624 --> 00:23:02.145
It's in...
198
00:23:04.326 --> 00:23:07.469
nativist nationalist leagues that were formed.
199
00:23:08.649 --> 00:23:18.897
It's in riots against, to remove Chinese miners in different gold fields, notably in Lamming Flat.
200
00:23:20.278 --> 00:23:27.404
But I think the one that really stood out for me, which predates the recession, the depression, sorry, of the 1890s, was in 1888.
201
00:23:32.679 --> 00:23:47.542
where a ship sailed from Hong Kong, the SS Afghan, carrying about 270 Chinese men who were coming to Melbourne, Sydney, and then on to New Zealand.
202
00:23:47.602 --> 00:23:49.223
They were getting off at different points.
203
00:23:51.263 --> 00:24:00.025
And so under duress, the Victorian governor invoked quarantine laws to say, I won't let this ship go.
204
00:24:01.823 --> 00:24:10.895
dock in Melbourne and it then went around to Sydney and Henry Parks, the New South Wales Premier said, I won't let this ship dock in Sydney.
205
00:24:14.440 --> 00:24:17.824
Somebody on behalf of the shipping owners
206
00:24:19.492 --> 00:24:28.841
And some of the people on board took it to the New South Wales Supreme Court, who said, you have to let this ship dock.
207
00:24:28.881 --> 00:24:30.663
There are people in it who have landing permits.
208
00:24:31.344 --> 00:24:35.888
They are already residents of New South Wales, and they're allowed to come back in.
209
00:24:36.709 --> 00:24:37.730
And the Premier...
210
00:24:39.002 --> 00:24:47.207
went out and said, I cast to the wind your landing permits, your cobwebs of technical law.
211
00:24:48.168 --> 00:25:02.837
And he then wrote retrospective legislation which endorsed the actions that he and his government had taken to prevent these Chinese men from disembarking.
212
00:25:04.267 --> 00:25:09.629
And it went all the way up to the British Prime Minister who said the people of New South Wales have gone stark raving mad.
213
00:25:11.170 --> 00:25:30.237
But you have all of the ingredients that kind of prefigured the tamper about we are not letting this boat disembark, come what may, the writing of retrospective legislation to protect what they were doing.
214
00:25:30.797 --> 00:25:33.178
And it was wildly popular.
215
00:25:34.625 --> 00:25:50.620
And, I mean, Parks took that action in part because a mob of, I think it was about 10,000 people thereabouts had descended and were basically going to enter the New South Wales Parliament and kind of destroy it if action wasn't taken to prevent this boat from...
216
00:25:52.375 --> 00:25:53.275
from disembarking.
217
00:25:53.576 --> 00:25:54.896
So I... That was 1888.
218
00:25:55.076 --> 00:25:55.757
That was 1888.
219
00:25:56.137 --> 00:25:58.778
So that's three years before... Before the economic troubles.
220
00:25:58.938 --> 00:25:59.138
Right.
221
00:25:59.338 --> 00:26:01.159
Yeah, yeah.
222
00:26:01.619 --> 00:26:07.122
So it's a story about cultural and economic protection.
223
00:26:08.363 --> 00:26:11.764
There's kind of two perspectives on how to do that, but maybe we can get into that in a minute.
224
00:26:12.004 --> 00:26:12.425
But the...
225
00:26:13.665 --> 00:26:31.894
There's kind of cultural protection around we don't want miscegenation, mixing of races,
and economic protection in that we don't want cheap workers undercutting high wage rates here.
226
00:26:32.555 --> 00:26:37.017
And so I don't think the 1890s depression...
227
00:26:38.075 --> 00:26:41.038
had it not occurred, would have altered that trajectory.
228
00:26:41.139 --> 00:26:41.379
Right.
229
00:26:42.600 --> 00:26:57.257
A historian friend reminded me recently another sort of cultural considerations that at least the founding fathers had in mind was they were looking very closely at the American experience and they were looking
230
00:26:57.857 --> 00:27:03.121
and the civil war and they were keen to avoid the same, what they perceived to be the same race issues.
231
00:27:03.981 --> 00:27:09.865
So they saw a sort of stability through having a very racially and ethnically homogenous society.
232
00:27:10.706 --> 00:27:14.809
That's the resolution that's arrived at in Queensland.
233
00:27:15.609 --> 00:27:16.470
So Queensland...
234
00:27:17.385 --> 00:27:25.589
was the only one of the colonies that made use of South Sea Islanders as indentured workers.
235
00:27:26.990 --> 00:27:27.750
On the cane fields?
236
00:27:28.351 --> 00:27:29.291
Sugar cane, yeah.
237
00:27:29.591 --> 00:27:32.453
They almost exclusively worked on sugar cane fields.
238
00:27:33.854 --> 00:27:42.538
So it's probably more in the low 50,000s, but there were 60,000 contracts signed, as it were, if you believe these contracts are signed.
239
00:27:45.212 --> 00:27:50.739
But the population was maybe of the order of about 10,000 in any given year.
240
00:27:52.181 --> 00:27:53.883
And the other colonies...
241
00:27:55.650 --> 00:28:05.518
had decided, partly by reference to the United States, they didn't want their colonies to become plantation societies.
242
00:28:06.739 --> 00:28:21.089
And in Queensland, there was a real split between the North and the South, because the North is where the sugar cane is grown and milled and turned into sugar, and the South...
243
00:28:23.562 --> 00:28:24.622
The South doesn't have that.
244
00:28:25.102 --> 00:28:28.043
And so there was this cleavage between the North and the South.
245
00:28:28.504 --> 00:28:36.686
And this was a real contest in Queensland politics from the mid-1860s through to 1900.
246
00:28:39.542 --> 00:28:59.112
In the end, it was the North that ended up voting yes for Federation because they wanted to be able to sell their sugar tax-free within the new Federation rather than having to pay tariffs or duties on that sugar being sold into the other colonies.
247
00:29:01.152 --> 00:29:11.442
And the deal that was eventually done in 1901 was the first kind of active of industry policy in Australia.
248
00:29:11.482 --> 00:29:13.885
So there was a sweetener for the sugar industry.
249
00:29:15.386 --> 00:29:17.108
Nice.
250
00:29:17.528 --> 00:29:21.952
Yeah, in 1901 to kind of support the industry as it made this transition away from...
251
00:29:23.170 --> 00:29:30.413
from kind of quite large-scale sugar plantations to smaller-scale operations.
252
00:29:31.174 --> 00:29:44.620
But they had to give up their use of South Sea Islanders, and most but not all of those South Sea Islanders were forcibly repatriated back to their homes.
253
00:29:46.270 --> 00:29:52.975
But sorry, so how is that relevant to the Australian founders wanting to avoid the American race experience?
254
00:29:54.196 --> 00:29:56.117
That was the closest that you got to it.
255
00:29:56.177 --> 00:29:56.697
Oh, I see.
256
00:29:57.098 --> 00:30:04.483
The Queensland model, for want of a better term, could have been replicated in other industries in other parts of Australia.
257
00:30:05.084 --> 00:30:09.707
And those governments in other parts of Australia said, we don't want a bar of it.
258
00:30:10.607 --> 00:30:11.988
They didn't want it in Queensland.
259
00:30:13.329 --> 00:30:15.291
And once a federal...
260
00:30:16.117 --> 00:30:20.801
Parliament had the authority over the country.
261
00:30:21.141 --> 00:30:22.942
It said, no, we are not having this in Queensland.
262
00:30:23.823 --> 00:30:25.665
Okay.
263
00:30:26.085 --> 00:30:28.807
The 1950s post-war migration program.
264
00:30:29.548 --> 00:30:29.828
So...
265
00:30:31.490 --> 00:30:39.575
Let me share two statements of my opinion and just give me a gut reaction to each statement.
266
00:30:40.255 --> 00:30:40.996
So first statement.
267
00:30:42.376 --> 00:30:52.863
In terms of its vision, stakes, and execution, the post-war migration program is the most epic policy experiment in Australian history.
268
00:30:57.826 --> 00:30:58.346
Broad agree.
269
00:30:58.366 --> 00:30:59.206
Wow.
270
00:30:59.226 --> 00:30:59.366
Yeah.
271
00:31:00.923 --> 00:31:11.392
Next statement, Arthur Corwell was more consequential in his role as immigration minister than many Australian prime ministers have been.
272
00:31:12.753 --> 00:31:13.434
Qualified degree.
273
00:31:13.874 --> 00:31:14.075
Yeah.
274
00:31:14.835 --> 00:31:22.982
So he kind of fascinates me because he strikes me as like a Lyndon Johnson-esque figure in terms of
275
00:31:23.823 --> 00:31:30.448
a great sense of personal agency, but also a willingness to use like Machiavellian means to achieve noble ends.
276
00:31:30.929 --> 00:31:32.190
Because it's quite striking that
277
00:31:34.012 --> 00:31:39.595
He often tells noble lies to the public to bring them on side.
278
00:31:39.795 --> 00:31:45.778
So, for example, one of those is that for every one non-Britain, we're going to bring out 10 Britains.
279
00:31:46.198 --> 00:31:48.159
And he knows that that is not achievable.
280
00:31:48.299 --> 00:31:48.479
Yeah.
281
00:31:48.819 --> 00:31:54.002
But he's just an enigmatic and charismatic figure.
282
00:31:54.562 --> 00:31:54.762
Yeah.
283
00:31:54.822 --> 00:31:56.123
I'd say qualified agree.
284
00:31:56.143 --> 00:31:56.303
Yeah.
285
00:31:58.056 --> 00:32:01.577
He was only immigration minister for three years, right?
286
00:32:01.777
--> 00:32:02.217
Yeah.
287
00:32:02.357 --> 00:32:03.637
1947 to 1949.
288
00:32:04.697 --> 00:32:10.118
And Harold Holt replaced him as the immigration minister after the 1949 election.
289
00:32:10.138 --> 00:32:14.959
And I think Holt was minister for about double the amount of time Caldwell was.
290
00:32:16.139 --> 00:32:23.821
And most of the agreements that Australia signed with European countries around...
291
00:32:25.332 --> 00:32:37.440
opening up to migrants from those countries, a number of them with assisted passage as part of the deal, many more of them were signed by Holt than by Caldwell.
292
00:32:37.620 --> 00:32:37.840
Yeah.
293
00:32:39.702 --> 00:32:44.285
But Caldwell was the person who...
294
00:32:46.406 --> 00:32:54.852
So he's fascinating because he's got this kind of diametric view on...
295
00:32:57.555 --> 00:33:05.301
on what kind of migrants he would prefer to have and how he would prefer to see Australia evolve.
296
00:33:05.721 --> 00:33:19.671
So he was terribly, terribly vindictive to people from Asian countries who were given temporary refuge in Australia during World War II because their countries were being invaded and they were able to flee and make their way to Australia.
297
00:33:20.272 --> 00:33:25.436
And there were maybe 10,000 of these people who were left in Australia at the end of World War II and he said, no, you've all got to go.
298
00:33:26.564 --> 00:33:36.028
And he took this woman who had, who's, her and her family, a larger number of kids, about eight or nine kids, the O'Keeves.
299
00:33:37.008 --> 00:33:38.789
So her first husband had died in the war.
300
00:33:39.449 --> 00:33:41.190
And then she married a British soldier.
301
00:33:42.925 --> 00:33:46.287
And that, by law, should have made her recognised as a British subject.
302
00:33:46.307 --> 00:33:47.307
But he said, no, you've got to go.
303
00:33:47.467 --> 00:33:51.729
And he went all the way to the High Court to expel her.
304
00:33:52.129 --> 00:33:53.850
And the High Court said, no, you can't.
305
00:33:54.470 --> 00:33:57.091
And then he changed, he wrote an Act to say, I can.
306
00:33:57.551 --> 00:33:58.472
And it went through the Parliament.
307
00:33:59.535 --> 00:34:01.156
And the Liberals then reversed it.
308
00:34:01.196 --> 00:34:01.896
So he had that.
309
00:34:02.176 --> 00:34:25.683
But then he also was extremely fleet-footed and creative in setting up arrangements to bring 170,000 people who were in refugee camps after World War II into Australia from a whole mix of countries of people who'd never previously come to Australia before.
310
00:34:26.003 --> 00:34:29.164
So this is not the Italians and the Greeks.
311
00:34:29.324 --> 00:34:35.465
This is people from the Baltic states, Ukraine, Poland mainly.
312
00:34:36.945 --> 00:34:38.686
And they're hanging out, and from Germany.
313
00:34:39.686 --> 00:34:40.526
Many of them are Jews.
314
00:34:42.326 --> 00:34:46.767
And they're hanging out in these refugee
camps.
315
00:34:46.787 --> 00:34:50.468
There are more than a million of them in refugee camps all across Europe.
316
00:34:52.835 --> 00:35:02.541
And the International Refugee Organization was trying to work out ways of resettling these people in other countries across the world.
317
00:35:03.601 --> 00:35:09.184
And that had not been Caldwell's preferred path.
318
00:35:09.565 --> 00:35:20.091
He maybe was not even aware of it early on or just didn't want to pay attention because Australia was not really engaged in the discussions with the International Refugee Organization about this.
319
00:35:21.888 --> 00:35:24.995
But when he found that he just couldn't get enough migrants from Britain,
320
00:35:26.165 --> 00:35:27.945
and from Scandinavian countries.
321
00:35:28.786 --> 00:35:34.687
And he was hearing that from his people on the ground in Europe, that the caliber of these people was high.
322
00:35:35.367 --> 00:35:36.347
He said, no, let's go for it.
323
00:35:37.168 --> 00:35:54.152
And so he very quickly, like within a couple of months, he got it put before, put for cabinet, got agreement, flew over to the UK and then to Europe personally to make all of this fall into place.
324
00:35:56.873 --> 00:36:04.682
And even as it kind of kicked off, what they were trying to do was to phrase economists sometimes use about skimming the cream.
325
00:36:05.243 --> 00:36:09.368
If you're selecting from a pool, you want to get the cream.
326
00:36:10.029 --> 00:36:12.552
And he was told, if you don't move fast, you're not going to get the cream.
327
00:36:13.453 --> 00:36:14.654
So he decided to move fast.
328
00:36:15.315 --> 00:36:15.736
And then...
329
00:36:18.183 --> 00:36:30.130
Even after that first agreement, what he found was the International Refugee Organization wasn't giving Australia a high enough priority because the US had agreed to take 200,000.
330
00:36:30.551 --> 00:36:32.072
So he said, okay, we'll match the US.
331
00:36:32.692 --> 00:36:33.793
Let's just make it 200,000.
332
00:36:33.853 --> 00:36:34.873
Added a zero.
333
00:36:36.194 --> 00:36:37.315
Effectively added a zero.
334
00:36:37.675 --> 00:36:40.817
Let's go and do this so we can get these ships coming.
335
00:36:41.277 --> 00:36:44.920
And if it was the right course...
336
00:36:45.785 --> 00:36:51.627
Maybe we can get to that, but if it was the right course to bring more people to Australia, it was a fantastic deal because Australia only paid £10 per person.
337
00:36:52.387 --> 00:36:54.427
The International Refugee Organization paid the rest.
338
00:36:55.368 --> 00:36:57.228
The US could have taken more, right?
339
00:36:57.808 --> 00:37:00.169
And they didn't?
340
00:37:00.189 --> 00:37:07.091
I can't recall how many the US took, but I think they honoured their agreement.
341
00:37:07.751 --> 00:37:13.893
I remember a line in the book where you say that if they'd been more open to migration in the 50s and 60s, we would have been left with the breadcrumbs.
342
00:37:15.016 --> 00:37:17.399
That's about free migration, people paying their own way.
343
00:37:18.181 --> 00:37:30.137
And so in the 1920s, the US basically closed its doors to migrants from Europe.
344
00:37:31.077 --> 00:37:36.820
And it did this by putting in, well, particularly from Southern Europe, it did it by putting in place quotas.
345
00:37:38.300 --> 00:37:42.282
And so in the 1900s, there were roughly 200,000 Italians per year.
346
00:37:46.552 --> 00:37:55.097
going to Ellis Island, you know, that archetypal migration journey, 200,000 of them a year going through Ellis Island into the US.
347
00:37:55.997 --> 00:38:08.084
And the United States, what it did was it said, we're going to put a quota on the number of migrants every year based on the share of the population in 1890 when they did their census.
348
00:38:09.005 --> 00:38:10.926
And that meant that the number of Italians was...
349
00:38:12.435 --> 00:38:13.917
capped at 4,000 a year.
350
00:38:14.117 --> 00:38:16.661
So 200,000 a year to 4,000 a year.
351
00:38:17.482 --> 00:38:23.371
So the United States, and Australia actually introduced quotas as well, the United States had shut itself off
352
00:38:24.400 --> 00:38:28.824
between the early 1900s and World War II.
353
00:38:29.264 --> 00:38:42.256
So the peak of when we talk about the era of mass migration from Europe to the New World, that went from 1840 until 1914, and then it stopped.
354
00:38:42.856 --> 00:38:45.198
And after World War I, it didn't start again.
355
00:38:45.598 --> 00:38:50.102
And after World War I, a lot of restrictions were put in place in both the US and Australia.
356
00:38:50.483 --> 00:38:51.343
So my point was...
357
00:38:52.124 --> 00:39:09.997
If the US had, after World War II said, we're open again, many of the migrants from the countries that Australia signed agreements with, so your Netherlands, Italy, Greece, Yugoslavia,
358
00:39:11.268 --> 00:39:21.593
Many of them would have gone to the United States instead had they been able to, but the US didn't alter, didn't begin reopening to migration until the mid-1960s.
359
00:39:21.673 --> 00:39:22.233
I see.
360
00:39:22.553 --> 00:39:23.113
Okay.
361
00:39:23.353 --> 00:39:35.659
So we had this window of opportunity where economic conditions were good in Australia, where...
362
00:39:37.407 --> 00:39:40.470
The country had not been physically ravaged by war.
363
00:39:40.591 --> 00:39:42.793
The people had been a bit, but the country had not.
364
00:39:43.574 --> 00:39:48.079
And it looked like, you know, it looked like what it had in the 1880s.
365
00:39:48.139 --> 00:39:51.102
It looked like paradise to get out of Europe and come to Australia in the 1950s.
366
00:39:51.122 --> 00:39:51.242
Yeah.
367
00:39:53.658 --> 00:40:07.981
So we might have an interesting difference of opinion on this next question, but if I recall correctly, in the book you write that the perish arm of the populate or perish policy was weak.
368
00:40:09.701 --> 00:40:15.823
And even if we doubled or tripled the population size, it still wouldn't have helped much with defense.
369
00:40:16.523 --> 00:40:17.183
Why do you believe that?
370
00:40:18.037 --> 00:40:26.820
So the first idea of the perish one was a population of 20 million is sufficiently high to defend ourselves.
371
00:40:27.300 --> 00:40:33.782
So I think that's contestable straight away is a population of 20 million compared to 7 million, 7.5 million.
372
00:40:35.263 --> 00:40:38.684
Obviously, you're better equipped to defend yourselves with 20 million than you are with 7.5 million.
373
00:40:41.454 --> 00:40:43.075
When were you going to reach 20 million by?
374
00:40:43.496 --> 00:40:53.803
So Menzies, when he was leader of the opposition in 1944, said, we'll have a population of 20 million in 20 years.
375
00:40:55.285 --> 00:40:56.626
And Giblin.
376
00:40:59.127 --> 00:41:03.110
I can't remember what the L and F stand for in his name off the top of my head.
377
00:41:03.511 --> 00:41:04.872
But Giblin was...
378
00:41:06.495 --> 00:41:11.959
That's kind of senior economic advisor in the bureaucracy during the war period.
379
00:41:12.439 --> 00:41:15.801
And he got out a bit of pen and paper and did some jottings.
380
00:41:15.841 --> 00:41:16.422
And he said, well...
381
00:41:17.800 --> 00:41:24.345
if you're going to hit 20 million in 20 years, your population is going to have to grow at an annual rate of pretty close to 6%.
382
00:41:25.145 --> 00:41:26.886
And that's not going to happen, right?
383
00:41:27.187 --> 00:41:28.047
That's not going to happen.
384
00:41:28.067 --> 00:41:33.371
It's just not sustainable to grow your population at that fast.
385
00:41:34.112 --> 00:41:37.974
So it's not going to happen by 1964.
386
00:41:38.014 --> 00:41:40.396
It's going to happen a good deal after that.
387
00:41:40.456 --> 00:41:43.058
And he said, look, probably your kind of optimal population
388
00:41:44.668 --> 00:41:55.515
optimal rate of fast population growth without straining capacity and allowing infrastructure and housing to kind of keep up is about 2% a year.
389
00:41:56.016 --> 00:41:58.658
Half of that to come from migration, half of that from natural increase.
390
00:41:59.098 --> 00:41:59.979
So you're not going to get there.
391
00:42:00.259 --> 00:42:10.406
And now the other point I make is almost the entire 7.5 million people huddled in the southeast corner of the country.
392
00:42:11.006 --> 00:42:12.127
And part of the idea about
393
00:42:13.723 --> 00:42:18.135
avoiding perishing was about protecting the North from invasion.
394
00:42:18.155 --> 00:42:21.885
Now, you're not gonna, it's gonna be difficult to defend the North
395
00:42:23.270 --> 00:42:27.155
even with the population that's increasing if they're all huddled in the southeast corner.
396
00:42:27.735 --> 00:42:27.976
Okay.
397
00:42:28.456 --> 00:42:31.139
Let me pick up on two things, two threads.
398
00:42:31.159 -->
00:42:43.373
So if by that time the way to defend Australia is just to defend the air-sea gap to the north, to make that extremely costly for any would-be attacker to cross...
399
00:42:44.174 --> 00:42:46.555
That's a very capital intensive exercise.
400
00:42:46.595 --> 00:42:50.217
So it relies primarily on a Navy and an air force, not an army.
401
00:42:50.237 --> 00:42:50.698
Right.
402
00:42:51.018 --> 00:42:53.379
And presumably that's a function of GDP.
403
00:42:53.679 --> 00:42:56.361
So having a larger population helps with that indirectly.
404
00:42:56.481 --> 00:42:57.101
Yeah, I'd agree with that.
405
00:42:57.261 --> 00:43:04.165
That would probably be the crux of my disagreement on your critique of the parish arm of the argument.
406
00:43:05.402 --> 00:43:09.604
The second thing I wanted to follow up on was the Giblin formulation.
407
00:43:09.804 --> 00:43:14.646
So the 2% per year, 1% from net migration, 1% from natural increase.
408
00:43:15.466 --> 00:43:20.648
And obviously, Corwell picks that up and then it becomes the official policy for a whole generation.
409
00:43:21.937 --> 00:43:26.500
It has a very politically appealing symmetry to it.
410
00:43:27.281 --> 00:43:35.166
It seems like a much easier sell than saying we'll take 1.3% from net migration and 0.7% from natural increase, something like that.
411
00:43:35.806 --> 00:43:38.928
Do you know how he actually arrived at that formula?
412
00:43:39.129 --> 00:43:39.429
I don't.
413
00:43:39.449 --> 00:43:39.789
Formulation?
414
00:43:39.969 --> 00:43:40.209
Okay.
415
00:43:41.630 --> 00:43:45.313
There is a memo in the archives where he explains it.
416
00:43:46.831 --> 00:43:49.792
I can't recall what it says.
417
00:43:50.432 --> 00:43:53.213
Because it almost feels like a political decision, right?
418
00:43:53.813 --> 00:43:57.014
Rather than just something that falls out of the demographic modelling.
419
00:43:57.894 --> 00:43:58.654
Well, so...
420
00:43:58.974 --> 00:43:59.594
The one-on-one.
421
00:44:01.075 --> 00:44:12.898
I guess you have to... Part of the context before then was that the birth rate had slowed in the 1930s and the demographers were worried...
422
00:44:14.475 --> 00:44:15.376
that it was permanent.
423
00:44:15.636 --> 00:44:30.068
So they were saying this is a structural change in family formation preferences by husbands and wives deciding what they're going to do.
424
00:44:31.449 --> 00:44:35.533
And it turned out that they were wrong.
425
00:44:35.553 --> 00:44:36.434
Well...
426
00:44:38.470 --> 00:44:43.073
The structural shift they were talking about, they anticipated too early, in a sense.
427
00:44:43.213 --> 00:44:51.138
And the slowdown in the 1930s was due to economic conditions where there was so much unemployment that people were going...
428
00:44:52.848 --> 00:44:59.372
let's not have another child because it's costly and we're not sure whether we'll be able to raise this child well.
429
00:45:00.133 --> 00:45:05.397
And once the economy turned around, the birth rate took off.
430
00:45:05.757 --> 00:45:10.420
So the 1% around the birth side was kind of an optimistic rate.
431
00:45:11.491 --> 00:45:19.457
at that time, an optimistic reading of what population growth from natural increase might be.
432
00:45:20.318 --> 00:45:32.648
And I think the idea was you probably want to keep the numbers coming from migration and natural increase in a kind of balance so that
433
00:45:35.286 --> 00:45:41.435
you have some sense around the direction of the country in terms of the share of migrants that are in the population.
434
00:45:43.635 --> 00:45:55.705
And, you know, Giblin, like Nugget Coombs, was an artful economic advisor, and it probably was really nicely pitched to ministers.
435
00:45:56.165 --> 00:46:04.852
So you've had a number of senior public servants on your show, so you know that part of their job is to talk to ministers in a way...
436
00:46:05.913 --> 00:46:29.912
where ministers can latch on to an idea and appreciate its appeal so i'm sure giblin was being political quote unquote in the way in which you put it but i think he was probably being artful in going one plus one that's a neat way of describing this thing you can talk about that in public in ways that people will understand and it doesn't sound scary yeah yeah so what
437
00:46:33.014 --> 00:46:37.120
There's a Canadian immigration scholar, Freda Hawkins.
438
00:46:37.601 --> 00:46:37.781
Yes.
439
00:46:38.623 --> 00:46:47.777
And she says that the main difference between Canadian immigration policy and Australian immigration policy, and obviously this is a...
440
00:46:49.271 --> 00:46:54.954
a pertinent comparison because Canada is the country we're most often compared to immigration wise.
441
00:46:55.515 --> 00:47:07.921
She says that the main difference is that Canada never had the strategic imperative, the security imperative that we did because they were protected by the big oceans and the southern border with the United States.
442
00:47:09.022 --> 00:47:21.248
Do you know whether that lack of the security imperative, that context gave them poorer or different policy outcomes?
443
00:47:23.185 --> 00:47:30.091
So I read her book on the 1970s to 1980s immigration policy compared with Australia and Canada.
444
00:47:30.311 --> 00:47:31.012
Yeah.
445
00:47:31.532 --> 00:47:33.614
If it's in there, I hadn't picked that up.
446
00:47:34.795 --> 00:47:50.529
The main point of difference that you observe between Australia and Canada from 1947 to the late 1950s is that we got the jump on British migrants.
447
00:47:52.923 --> 00:48:00.367
So we had a scheme of a 10-pound cap.
448
00:48:01.048 --> 00:48:03.669
Well, it was free if you were a British soldier.
449
00:48:04.870 --> 00:48:09.793
And if you weren't, the cap was 10 pounds.
450
00:48:09.973 --> 00:48:16.436
And the fare at that time to get to, like in 1950, was probably about 100 pounds.
451
00:48:17.477 --> 00:48:19.718
So that was a
huge subsidy for people.
452
00:48:20.219 --> 00:48:21.619
Canada didn't do that.
453
00:48:21.699 --> 00:48:22.500
Canada thought...
454
00:48:24.073 --> 00:48:27.857
when they looked at what Australia was doing, it would attract the idle and the work shy.
455
00:48:29.478 --> 00:48:34.323
And it wasn't until they set up their own, they copied Australia.
456
00:48:34.423 --> 00:48:35.684
We copied a lot of things from them.
457
00:48:35.844 --> 00:48:41.269
They copied us in setting up their own immigration department about seven years after us.
458
00:48:41.790 --> 00:48:43.111
And then they were pretty adroit
459
00:48:44.070 --> 00:48:51.633
partly because much the same as it had been a century earlier, it's just easier to get to Canada than it is to Australia.
460
00:48:51.873 --> 00:48:52.113
Yeah.
461
00:48:52.993 --> 00:48:57.515
And easier to get back if you want to go back.
462
00:48:57.955 --> 00:49:06.238
And so by the late 1950s, they were attracting more British migrants than Australia was.
463
00:49:07.580 --> 00:49:12.282
Scaling a business is hard enough already, so you don't wanna be bottlenecked on things like compliance.
464
00:49:12.602 --> 00:49:20.446
And while achieving compliance can help you win bigger deals and to new markets and deepen trust with customers, it can also cost a lot of time and money.
465
00:49:21.066 --> 00:49:28.610
By automating up to 90% of work involved in SOC 2, ISO 27001 and more, Vanta gets you compliant quickly.
466
00:49:29.250 --> 00:49:30.131
It also saves you money.
467
00:49:30.491 --> 00:49:41.601
A recent white paper by the International Data Corporation found that Vanta customers achieve $535,000 per year in benefits, and the platform pays for itself in just three months.
468
00:49:42.201 --> 00:49:45.504
A startup I worked at used Vanta, and I found it really reliable.
469
00:49:46.124 --> 00:49:54.432
Over 12,000 global companies like Atlassian, Replit, and Cursor also use Vanta to manage risk and prove security in real time.
470
00:49:55.092 --> 00:50:01.181
My audience can get a special offer of $1,000 off Vanta at vanta.com slash joe.
471
00:50:01.681 --> 00:50:06.588
That's V-A-N-T-A dot com slash J-O-E for $1,000 off.
472
00:50:09.310 --> 00:50:22.000
One of the other remarkable features of the post-war migration program is just how much effort went into very careful propaganda to encourage the Australian population to accept these migrants.
473
00:50:22.620 --> 00:50:34.749
There are so many anecdotes we could tell here, but the one I liked the most from the book was the millionth migrant, Barbara Porritt, who was very carefully selected and kind of almost paraded around.
474
00:50:34.769 --> 00:50:35.930
Oh, she was paraded around.
475
00:50:35.950 --> 00:50:36.050
Yeah.
476
00:50:36.270 --> 00:50:36.730
Literally.
477
00:50:36.750 --> 00:50:37.171
Yeah.
478
00:50:37.411 --> 00:50:37.611
Yeah.
479
00:50:37.871 --> 00:50:52.580
And even when she went back to the United Kingdom for
a holiday, the department officials were stressing that she might not come back and they would go to the pirate's place every three months to check up on them and how are you enjoying Australia.
480
00:50:53.981 --> 00:51:01.465
So incredibly, the propaganda was so carefully calculated.
481
00:51:02.306 --> 00:51:05.248
Counterfactually, how much of a difference do you think it made?
482
00:51:06.123 --> 00:51:10.084
To Australians' acceptance of migrants?
483
00:51:11.865 --> 00:51:12.805
That's a hard question.
484
00:51:14.786 --> 00:51:15.546
Slight digression.
485
00:51:16.107 --> 00:51:16.267
Yep.
486
00:51:17.667 --> 00:51:26.370
One of the most popular books in Australia in the late 1950s was They're a Weird Mob by Nino Colotta.
487
00:51:26.590 --> 00:51:27.131
You know this book?
488
00:51:27.671 --> 00:51:28.191
I've heard of it.
489
00:51:28.431 --> 00:51:28.691
Okay.
490
00:51:28.831 --> 00:51:29.792
Oh, this is a good story.
491
00:51:29.972 --> 00:51:30.192
Okay.
492
00:51:30.632 --> 00:51:33.593
Nino Colotta was an Italian migrant
493
00:51:35.284 --> 00:51:38.325
who ends up working on a building site in Punchbowl in Sydney.
494
00:51:39.385 --> 00:52:01.089
And it's, you know, it's in some ways, it's very much a kind of a celebration of Australian ocherism about migrants assimilating to Australian ways by themselves, you know, becoming effectively an ocher and learning the lingo and how to behave dreadfully to women and so on.
495
00:52:02.843 --> 00:52:05.406
And the thing about it is it's actually a literary hoax.
496
00:52:06.347 --> 00:52:11.993
It was written by a person of an Australian of Irish descent called John O'Grady.
497
00:52:13.835 --> 00:52:15.838
And so Nina Clotto didn't exist.
498
00:52:15.918 --> 00:52:19.522
He was a dentist or something for the New South Wales government.
499
00:52:20.503 --> 00:52:20.743
And...
500
00:52:21.730 --> 00:52:27.074
When the book started to sell like hotcakes, the ABC contacted the publisher and said, we want to interview him.
501
00:52:27.274 --> 00:52:30.616
And he had to come out and break the facade.
502
00:52:30.636 --> 00:52:31.897
Actually, sorry, it's not me.
503
00:52:31.937 --> 00:52:32.517
No, it's John.
504
00:52:34.358 --> 00:52:39.602
But the book sold in – it sold millions of copies and got turned into a movie.
505
00:52:40.162 --> 00:52:41.003
And it kind of –
506
00:52:43.480 --> 00:52:59.849
In a sense, John O'Grady was reflecting the way in which Australians themselves thought about these people who'd come from Europe and how they were fitting into Australian society and how they ought to fit in.
507
00:53:01.170 --> 00:53:04.191
How they ought to assimilate.
508
00:53:05.432 --> 00:53:07.313
But there's tenderness there.
509
00:53:08.963 --> 00:53:20.990
So the book gets a mixed press because it's got various racist tropes in it and it's terrible with women, but there's definitely a tenderness towards the Italian migrants
510
00:53:23.673 --> 00:53:29.736
And the propaganda bit, I mean, obviously, Corwell was the information minister in the war before he became immigration minister.
511
00:53:30.256 --> 00:53:30.836
True.
512
00:53:31.037 --> 00:53:34.578
And he was a person who popularised the term New Australians.
513
00:53:34.638 --> 00:53:34.898
Yeah.
514
00:53:35.659 --> 00:53:42.642
And I still remember, you still remember, you know, conversations you had with people in the 70s and 80s and they would talk about New Australians.
515
00:53:42.962 --> 00:53:43.662
Oh, really?
516
00:53:44.063 --> 00:53:45.523
Because it's not really a term anymore, is it?
517
00:53:45.563 --> 00:53:46.484
It's not a term anymore.
518
00:53:46.504 --> 00:53:46.564
No.
519
00:53:46.624 --> 00:53:47.344
It's not a term anymore.
520
00:53:47.364 --> 00:53:48.825
In fact, I've never heard anyone use it.
521
00:53:48.945 --> 00:53:49.165
Right.
522
00:53:49.285 --> 00:53:49.545
Yeah.
523
00:53:49.705 --> 00:53:51.526
But I heard it in my childhood.
524
00:53:51.826 --> 00:53:52.106
Yeah.
525
00:53:52.266 --> 00:53:52.687
Interesting.
526
00:53:52.847 --> 00:53:53.027
Mm-hmm.
527
00:53:54.007 --> 00:54:09.778
So in other words, there was a kind of pervasive semi-openness to migrants and maybe that would have enabled acceptance without propaganda.
528
00:54:10.458 --> 00:54:22.687
It was a grudging acceptance, somewhat indifferent and discriminatory
529
00:54:24.442 --> 00:54:39.350
but not rejection, not rejection, and where you could cross cultural barriers because circumstance threw you into that.
530
00:54:41.832 --> 00:54:51.197
There was genuine kind of engagement and openness and friendliness.
531
00:54:53.841 --> 00:55:13.565
I mentioned in the start of the book about my own migration story, and we settled in the northern suburbs of Adelaide in 1965, and it was a real polyglot community of what seemed to us polyglot, exotic.
532
00:55:15.626 --> 00:55:21.447
There were people from Malta, Greece, the Netherlands, Germany, Italy,
533
00:55:23.965 --> 00:55:31.169
and lots of Poms, Scots, Welsh, and lots of working-class Australians.
534
00:55:31.189 --> 00:55:40.293
And we all kind of, we went to school together, we played football together, you know, we had scraps together.
535
00:55:41.294 --> 00:55:43.575
It wasn't kind of engineered, it just kind of happened.
536
00:55:46.016 --> 00:55:49.798
What's a good number to quantify the scale of the post-war migration program?
537
00:55:50.662 --> 00:55:54.584
We added 2.5 million migrants in about 20 years.
538
00:55:55.024 --> 00:55:57.205
47 to 71, 2.5 million.
539
00:55:57.325 --> 00:55:57.485
Yeah.
540
00:55:58.265 --> 00:55:59.866
More than half of them were not British.
541
00:55:59.886 --> 00:56:00.386
Not British.
542
00:56:00.486 --> 00:56:00.666
Yeah.
543
00:56:00.806 --> 00:56:00.966
Yeah.
544
00:56:01.406 --> 00:56:02.707
Yeah.
545
00:56:02.727 --> 00:56:14.871
So if you had to boil down why the post-war migration program was so successful to the most
basic set of preconditions, what would they be?
546
00:56:15.452 --> 00:56:16.092
Full employment.
547
00:56:16.559 --> 00:56:19.021
Yeah, that was my first one.
548
00:56:19.121 --> 00:56:20.042
Yeah, for employment.
549
00:56:20.062 --> 00:56:20.282
Yeah.
550
00:56:20.862 --> 00:56:35.153
I think the thing about that period is, and it goes back to that kind of argument about population or populate or perish.
551
00:56:36.914 --> 00:56:39.596
The 1950s wasn't really about populate or perish.
552
00:56:39.656 --> 00:56:41.917
It was really about migration as economic development.
553
00:56:41.937 --> 00:56:42.638
Yeah.
554
00:56:43.021 --> 00:57:07.976
And the people who came out, large numbers of the men and significant numbers of the women worked in factories and they produced cars, televisions, refrigerators, washing machines in Australian factories that were then sold to the migrants and to Australians.
555
00:57:08.757 --> 00:57:11.539
And so they were both producers and consumers
556
00:57:13.106 --> 00:57:16.872
And it was the heyday of Australian manufacturing.
557
00:57:16.952 --> 00:57:27.527
It's when Australia became genuinely kind of industrialised, was in the 1950s, and it couldn't have done it on the scale in which it did.
558
00:57:29.243 --> 00:57:30.164
without migration.
559
00:57:31.404 --> 00:57:52.897
And then you had this, you know, the fascinating circumstance of a very conservative liberal premier of South Australia adopting a kind of quasi-socialist economic and industry policy, which is all based around...
560
00:57:53.992 --> 00:58:20.009
bringing in large volumes of workers who could also be consumers, whose wages were below the wages of similar workers in Victoria and New South Wales, and designing whole towns like Elizabeth, which is where I grew up, around that area, designing these whole towns to house these workers
561
00:58:21.893 --> 00:58:28.117
who would then work in the neighboring factories, and then their children would go to school and then work in those factories, which is what I was expected to do.
562
00:58:28.998 --> 00:58:34.981
And it worked until full employment stopped, and then it stopped working.
563
00:58:35.902 --> 00:58:40.525
I tried to write my own list, and full employment was the first item on the list.
564
00:58:40.765 --> 00:58:40.985
Right.
565
00:58:41.426 --> 00:58:41.666
Yeah.
566
00:58:42.366 --> 00:58:44.668
Possibly it just dominates all the other ones.
567
00:58:45.088 --> 00:58:46.749
I mean, the three others I had were...
568
00:58:48.367 --> 00:58:58.851
Culturally a gradual process of focusing first and mainly on British migrants, but then gradually moving farther afield to then Eastern and Southern Europeans.
569
00:59:01.151 --> 00:59:09.074
Thirdly, a compliant receiving population with the national security imperative, the assurances from the government, the propaganda.
570
00:59:09.774 --> 00:59:14.636
And then fourthly, I'm not sure about this one, but an egalitarian culture.
571
00:59:17.694 --> 00:59:19.476
maybe that makes people more receptive.
572
00:59:21.998 --> 00:59:29.325
And if you think of like a much more kind of hierarchical culture, like I can imagine France trying to do what we did.
573
00:59:29.545 --> 00:59:29.885
Yeah.
574
00:59:29.985 --> 00:59:34.789
I'd probably almost give more weight to that one than your, your other two in a sense.
575
00:59:35.150 --> 00:59:35.410
Yeah.
576
00:59:35.550 --> 00:59:40.535
And the, the, the, the first lot of, of, of,
577
00:59:41.972 --> 00:59:46.234
There were very few people who were coming out from Britain in 1947, 1948.
578
00:59:46.854 --> 00:59:58.919
And so the displaced persons, 170,000 of those, you know, the ones who came and went to Bonnegilla, that camp near Wodonga in Victoria, that was happening in 1949.
579
00:59:58.939 --> 00:59:59.079
And...
580
01:00:01.940 --> 01:00:08.948
There wasn't really any stage at which there was this shift away from British towards European migrants.
581
01:00:09.008 --> 01:00:10.530
It all happened at the same time.
582
01:00:11.131 --> 01:00:13.774
So almost all the British migrants were assisted, about 90%.
583
01:00:16.045 --> 01:00:20.390
And the numbers vary by country.
584
01:00:21.291 --> 01:00:23.914
According to the rest, I think for the Italians, it was about a quarter.
585
01:00:23.934 --> 01:00:25.456
And that was one of the lowest ones.
586
01:00:25.516 --> 01:00:26.877
But there were assists.
587
01:00:27.157 --> 01:00:32.183
So the government signed... And am I right in distinguishing assisted migrants from the displaced persons?
588
01:00:32.664 --> 01:00:32.964
Yes.
589
01:00:33.244 --> 01:00:33.805
In the counting?
590
01:00:34.165 --> 01:00:34.566
Yes.
591
01:00:34.766 --> 01:00:36.568
Sorry, the displaced persons are...
592
01:00:38.718 --> 01:00:40.058
Nowadays we would call them refugees.
593
01:00:40.819 --> 01:00:43.939
We didn't have a refugee program then or humanitarian program.
594
01:00:44.239 --> 01:00:45.760
So they were called displaced persons.
595
01:00:46.320 --> 01:00:47.060
They didn't have homes.
596
01:00:48.160 --> 01:00:49.600
Their lives had been destroyed.
597
01:00:51.581 --> 01:00:57.422
And so they came to Australia to resettle under the auspices of the International Refugee Organization.
598
01:00:57.982 --> 01:01:03.243
The other countries that signed agreements, the countries that signed agreements with Australia, sometimes that was done with a...
599
01:01:06.253 --> 01:01:10.595
a third party body, I think it was called the European Committee for Migration or something like that.
600
01:01:10.955 --> 01:01:15.097
And they did do some of the co-funding of assisted migrants.
601
01:01:15.117 --> 01:01:24.743
So Australia would, it got the British to partly pay for assisted passage of British migrants up until 1952-ish.
602
01:01:25.243 --> 01:01:27.564
And then the Brits said, hang on, this is crazy.
603
01:01:27.624 --> 01:01:32.547
Why are we spending all
this money sending our people over to Australia when we've got our own labour shortages?
604
01:01:36.402 --> 01:01:38.110
but the Australians were very good at hitting up
605
01:01:39.435 --> 01:01:48.740
not only the International Organization for Refugees, but the European Committee for Migration as co-contributors to the assisted passage.
606
01:01:48.800 --> 01:01:53.903
So wherever they could, Australians would always hit up other governments to send their people to Australia.
607
01:01:55.563 --> 01:01:56.664
Smart, smart deal.
608
01:01:57.845 --> 01:02:06.009
So moving briefly to the 1970s, you told me by email that in many ways you think the 1970s is a more compelling decade than the 1950s.
609
01:02:06.029 --> 01:02:06.249
Yeah.
610
01:02:08.490 --> 01:02:13.955
Reading the book, it wasn't obvious to me why, but do you remember what you had in mind when you said that?
611
01:02:14.815 --> 01:02:25.424
When I did the first kind of what does the structure look like on this book, I had four decades and I added the 1830s and I added the 1970s.
612
01:02:39.264 --> 01:02:46.689
was consequential in a bunch of ways.
613
01:02:46.709 --> 01:02:48.531
It was very significant for immigration.
614
01:02:48.571 --> 01:02:53.935
So firstly, I think probably people are very familiar with the idea that we ended the White Australia Policy.
615
01:02:54.355 --> 01:02:56.216
Yeah.
616
01:02:56.336 --> 01:02:59.759
The 1970s was the first time in which we...
617
01:03:03.006 --> 01:03:05.669
introduced a formal refugee program.
618
01:03:05.909 --> 01:03:26.708
So we had been a signatory that said, we recognise that there are these things called refugees, these people called refugees, but we did nothing really to encourage or resettle refugees, except when we were bullied by or cajoled by other countries to do so.
619
01:03:26.808 --> 01:03:28.850
And particularly we were terrible refugees
620
01:03:30.739 --> 01:03:48.704
at ignoring the plight of Chileans who were escaping the repression of the Pinochet regime in the 1970s and of Indian Ugandans who were being expelled by the Idi Amin regime in the early 1970s.
621
01:03:48.744 --> 01:03:52.245
We kind of washed our hands of those in ways that the Canadians didn't.
622
01:03:52.265 --> 01:03:54.386
The Canadians were very generous in both of those cases.
623
01:03:54.406 --> 01:03:54.886
We go, no.
624
01:03:56.096 --> 01:04:13.002
But it was when we started getting boat people, boat people in inverted commas, arriving in Darwin in 1976 and provoking this kind of big discussion around what does it mean for Australia to be a country of first refuge?
625
01:04:13.062 --> 01:04:15.282
It had never really been a country of first refuge before.
626
01:04:16.043 --> 01:04:19.024
In a country of first refuge, the refugee protocol comes into effect.
627
01:04:19.044 --> 01:04:23.225
You have to take these people in.
628
01:04:24.655 --> 01:04:32.960
determined that, yes, they are refugees and they need our support and you're not allowed to refoul them, you know, they're not allowed to send them back.
629
01:04:34.021 --> 01:04:50.351
There were small incidents of where this had happened, like in 1956 in the Melbourne Olympic Games, a bunch of Hungarians said, we don't want to go back to Hungary with the suppression of the uprising in Budapest and other places.
630
01:04:51.512 --> 01:04:53.033
There was people who, Portuguese, Portuguese,
631
01:04:54.886 --> 01:05:02.953
and local functionaries who'd been supporting the Portuguese in East Timor came to Australia and were kind of ignored for quite a while by the Whitlam government.
632
01:05:03.494 --> 01:05:19.628
So Australia was in this untenable situation where it had to do something to work out a more systematic way, a more considered way of dealing with this rising issue of people coming to Australia seeking asylum.
633
01:05:19.788 --> 01:05:20.168
And it did.
634
01:05:20.588 --> 01:05:20.909
And it did.
635
01:05:21.129 --> 01:05:22.290
And it ended up,
636
01:05:24.133 --> 01:05:32.416
being part of an international deal with a number of countries in the Southeast Asian region and the US and Canada and what have you.
637
01:05:32.937 --> 01:05:46.982
And we brought in 60,000 Indochinese refugees from the late 1970s to the early 1980s, which was proportionally more per population than any other country in the world did.
638
01:05:47.823 --> 01:05:48.023
And...
639
01:05:49.786 --> 01:05:52.908
That marks the genuine end, it seems to me, of the White Australia policy.
640
01:05:53.368 --> 01:05:58.110
And then we also had multiculturalism.
641
01:05:58.130 --> 01:06:10.697
It was introduced in 1977 formally, and it's the start of what becomes a kind of objective movement
642
01:06:12.274 --> 01:06:31.346
system for selection of migrants and the kind of compartmentalization of streams of migrants into humanitarian, skilled and family reunion and the introduction of the first points test for choosing amongst would-be skilled migrants in 1979.
643
01:06:31.406 --> 01:06:34.108
So those four things are all highly
644
01:06:36.378 --> 01:06:37.419
Highly consequential.
645
01:06:38.380 --> 01:06:47.007
Are they less consequential than the scale of migration that happened from Europe and Britain in the 1950s?
646
01:06:49.008 --> 01:06:49.389
Probably.
647
01:06:50.830 --> 01:06:57.195
But when I started delving into this, I realised that I had to write about the 1970s because of those four things.
648
01:06:57.515 --> 01:06:59.377
Yeah, you'd underrated it originally.
649
01:06:59.517 --> 01:07:01.358
I had underrated it originally, yeah.
650
01:07:02.279 --> 01:07:02.539
So...
651
01:07:03.587 --> 01:07:05.388
The final decade, the 2000s.
652
01:07:06.509 --> 01:07:19.017
So the big theme of the 2000s is this growing disconnect between permanent migration or the permanent migration program and the population due to the rise of temporary migrants.
653
01:07:19.238 --> 01:07:19.398
Mm-hmm.
654
01:07:20.995 --> 01:07:38.265
Are you aware of any other analogues in world history of such large populations of people present in a country who aren't fully bought into the national project or even certain of their future prospects in that country?
655
01:07:38.285 --> 01:07:44.308
So the poster child example...
656
01:07:46.338 --> 01:07:47.960
Well, there's actually quite a number.
657
01:07:47.980 --> 01:07:48.901
Yeah.
658
01:07:50.362 --> 01:08:08.440
So you have to think about with the end of slavery and the use of indentured labour schemes to replace that in many countries across the world saw huge numbers of people from China, China.
659
01:08:09.869 --> 01:08:14.930
and India in particular, also Japan, go and work in other countries across the world.
660
01:08:15.730 --> 01:08:19.771
And they didn't have the same rights as the people living there.
661
01:08:21.332 --> 01:08:24.492
You still see that play out in Fiji to this day.
662
01:08:25.273 --> 01:08:33.814
The tensions between the people of indigenous heritage in Fiji and people of Indian heritage in Fiji.
663
01:08:34.415 --> 01:08:35.855
They've had coups about it.
664
01:08:36.702 --> 01:08:46.211
After World War II, the archetypal example are Turkish migrants, temporary migrants going to work in German factories.
665
01:08:46.572 --> 01:08:47.332
The guest workers.
666
01:08:47.372 --> 01:08:47.973
Guest workers.
667
01:08:48.053 --> 01:08:48.614
Gestarbeter.
668
01:08:48.654 --> 01:08:49.715
That's the word came from.
669
01:08:49.735 --> 01:08:50.676
It's a German word.
670
01:08:50.736 --> 01:08:50.956
Yeah.
671
01:08:51.196 --> 01:08:51.877
Gestarbeter.
672
01:08:53.623 --> 01:09:07.870
And that took decades before the, you know, sometimes the three generations on, the descendants of those Turkish migrants, before they were recognised as being citizens of Germany.
673
01:09:08.050 --> 01:09:08.330
Yeah.
674
01:09:09.951 --> 01:09:11.652
They're the two that stand out.
675
01:09:11.672 --> 01:09:18.035
I mean, nowadays you also have similar circumstances in several of the Gulf countries.
676
01:09:20.436 --> 01:09:21.977
So the...
677
01:09:25.361 --> 01:09:31.565
The country which has the most Indian migrants resident in it is the United Arab Emirates.
678
01:09:31.805 --> 01:09:32.465
Yeah.
679
01:09:32.525 --> 01:09:36.387
I think there's three million Indians living in the United Arab Emirates.
680
01:09:36.548 --> 01:09:36.768
Yeah.
681
01:09:37.682 --> 01:09:40.484
either in the United States or about equal with the United States.
682
01:09:41.045 --> 01:09:43.106
And they have no rights there.
683
01:09:44.827 --> 01:09:54.575
Another interesting example was the temporary agricultural workers from Mexico in the US in the 40s, 50s, and then to 64.
684
01:09:54.655 --> 01:09:56.496
Yeah, that's another good example.
685
01:09:56.756 --> 01:09:56.977
Sure.
686
01:09:59.378 --> 01:10:04.943
One interesting characteristic that maybe distinguishes the Australian experience
is that,
687
01:10:06.016 --> 01:10:16.721
The temporary workers in Australia, many of them at least nominally are here under the aspiration of permanent residency and citizenship.
688
01:10:17.402 --> 01:10:31.209
So if you go right back to 1901, the Immigration Restriction Act effectively put a ban on the use of temporary contract workers, except in circumstances permitted by the minister.
689
01:10:31.309 --> 01:10:33.430
And then that was tightened up in an act in 1905.
690
01:10:37.072 --> 01:10:45.759
hardly any temporary contract workers between 1901 and World War II.
691
01:10:45.779 --> 01:10:46.359
We didn't need...
692
01:10:53.435 --> 01:10:58.999
temporary workers in the 1950s and 60s because we had so many permanent migrants coming.
693
01:11:00.220 --> 01:11:07.646
And some of them could be temporary in the sense that they decided after a number of years they didn't like it and returned home.
694
01:11:08.306 --> 01:11:20.996
And there are stories, particularly of British people who got assisted passage and then spent a couple of years in Australia and then went back to Britain, using it as a kind of an early prototype of a working holidaymaker scheme.
695
01:11:21.256 --> 01:11:21.456
Yeah.
696
01:11:22.895 --> 01:11:41.142
But the temporary migration programs were all designed in good faith about meeting a particular objective that except for the temporary skilled workers one was not related to work.
697
01:11:42.243 --> 01:11:46.344
And now the three big ones, the biggest one is international students.
698
01:11:47.945 --> 01:11:51.306
And then there are working holiday makers and then there are temporary skilled workers.
699
01:11:54.640 --> 01:12:08.190
three large ones, and they have all become de facto labour schemes as well as serving other needs.
700
01:12:08.451 --> 01:12:08.691
Yeah.
701
01:12:10.072 --> 01:12:11.053
There's been this drift.
702
01:12:12.494 --> 01:12:12.754
So...
703
01:12:15.618 --> 01:12:22.181
The international education industry has obviously boomed in Australia.
704
01:12:22.201 --> 01:12:27.224
I think it reached about $18 billion per year by 2010.
705
01:12:28.504 --> 01:12:32.246
It's usually around our third biggest export.
706
01:12:33.567 --> 01:12:40.970
The point you make in the book is that that is inflated because the ABS uses conventional products.
707
01:12:42.588 --> 01:12:55.466
method of trading international students where it assumes that all of their expenses are funded from overseas money, but obviously many of them work part-time in Australia to fund their living expenses.
708
01:12:56.608 --> 01:12:58.050
The specific question I had was,
709
01:12:59.755 --> 01:13:06.961
Say you did count properly, do you know the kind of magnitude of the inflation?
710
01:13:07.001 --> 01:13:12.506
And would that be enough to knock it down the rankings of our top exports?
711
01:13:14.708 --> 01:13:15.389
So, yes, I do.
712
01:13:15.409 --> 01:13:18.992
But I'd probably make a few points there.
713
01:13:19.052 --> 01:13:20.193
So, firstly...
714
01:13:22.008 --> 01:13:31.935
As you said, the ABS follows international statistical conventions in how you classify the export income from international education.
715
01:13:34.557 --> 01:13:36.719
There's an offsetting item in the balance of payments that's the balance of payments.
716
01:13:38.415 --> 01:13:48.479
which captures the income that is earned in Australia of people who are not Australian citizens.
717
01:13:48.659 --> 01:13:51.780
I'm not entirely sure how it's the methodology, but how it's created.
718
01:13:52.120 --> 01:13:58.103
The Reserve Bank has published a paper not so long ago where they report the number...
719
01:13:58.883 --> 01:14:11.293
And they say currently it's about 60% of the export income is income generated from outside Australia and 40% is generated from within Australia.
720
01:14:12.213 --> 01:14:16.557
You can find means of artificially growing of...
721
01:14:19.224 --> 01:14:35.829
using economic policy levers to create incentives for people to alter their decisions that ends up reallocating resources to growing, making certain industries be larger than they otherwise would be.
722
01:14:38.330 --> 01:14:40.891
The question that you then have to ask is that is...
723
01:14:42.542 --> 01:14:43.442
Is that optimal?
724
01:14:43.542 --> 01:14:44.783
Is that in the national interest?
725
01:14:45.103 --> 01:14:48.844
It's certainly in the interest of many people in those industries.
726
01:14:49.424 --> 01:15:06.868
It's certainly in the interests of vice chancellors earning more than a million dollars, earning, according to Paul Freitas, and Gigi Foster probably four times more than they'd earn for running a comparable institution in the United States.
727
01:15:07.603 --> 01:15:08.243
Wow, really?
728
01:15:09.764 --> 01:15:37.062
You would have made similar points about the use of incentives in using migration rules as incentives to encourage people to work in horticulture, in abattoirs, in hospitality, where for various reasons those industries have trouble working
729
01:15:38.257 --> 01:15:45.823
hiring enough people who are already living in Australia to take on jobs at the prevailing paying conditions.
730
01:15:46.784 --> 01:15:55.010
So these are all choices that governments have made that have distortionary effects on the allocation of resources across the economy.
731
01:15:56.512 --> 01:16:01.756
And they're done in ways which are quite hidden because they don't involve the payment of
732
01:16:06.219 --> 01:16:09.500
any fancy tax and transfer things.
733
01:16:10.020 --> 01:16:13.500
They're just straight out migration incentives.
734
01:16:15.501 --> 01:16:25.483
And they're enabled by the fact that most of those temporary visas are uncapped.
735
01:16:26.723 --> 01:16:33.985
And so if you are a young person with moderately good English
736
01:16:39.551 --> 01:16:56.839
All the Philippines, you can probably earn vastly more than you would be able to earn if you stayed in your home country by coming to Australia, even if it's for a fixed number of years, but if you can land permanent residency, all the better.
737
01:16:58.180 --> 01:17:06.744
And we have allowed that to develop over time
738
01:17:08.356 --> 01:17:18.623
Because many people still have this mercantilist attitude towards exports, that export income is a good thing because it's good for the economy.
739
01:17:20.065 --> 01:17:28.631
Whereas, I know you're speaking with Martin Parkinson, he will say to you, exports pay for imports.
740
01:17:29.651 --> 01:17:30.312
That's what they're for.
741
01:17:32.153 --> 01:17:34.475
So what do you think of the costs when not counting?
742
01:17:34.495 --> 01:17:34.595
Okay.
743
01:17:36.413 --> 01:17:42.297
I think the costs that we're not counting, that we have a group of...
744
01:17:44.339 --> 01:18:01.331
So setting aside New Zealand citizens, which I think is definitely a special case, there are near enough to 2 million people in Australia who are temporarily...
745
01:18:01.711 --> 01:18:04.213
Here on a visa which has a specified end date.
746
01:18:05.860 --> 01:18:32.199
Many of them are being exploited through underpayment of wages or working excessive hours, and employers are able to get away with this because of the lure of permanent residents, often their sponsors, and it's their signature that's going to matter that's going to help get the permanent residents.
747
01:18:33.080 --> 01:18:33.640
Yeah.
748
01:18:33.820 --> 01:18:56.136
we've moved away from being a so-called settlement society where the people we brought in who came to the country were being welcomed as new members of this society and expected to be kind of participants, active participants in it and in shaping the country.
749
01:18:56.256 --> 01:19:01.240
And now we've got these people here on a kind of transactional basis and we've
750
01:19:04.149 --> 01:19:14.682
even after they've done their time, they still have to wait another, at least another year before, after many years already being here, before they can become an Australian citizen.
751
01:19:15.864 --> 01:19:18.748
So we have, I think, maybe...
752
01:19:23.549 --> 01:19:38.649
given too much weight to what the economic benefits of migration are without having regard to the, what some of the social costs are.
753
01:19:40.912 --> 01:19:41.653
And as well as
754
01:19:43.380 --> 01:19:53.349
the earlier point around what would the shape of Australian industry look like if our international education industry wasn't so large, for instance.
755
01:19:53.870 --> 01:19:55.731
Yeah.
756
01:19:55.752 --> 01:19:58.334
So as one kind of mild pushback...
757
01:20:01.737 --> 01:20:08.622
You could say that a benefit of the rise of temporaries is that it helps people kind of try before they buy, so to speak.
758
01:20:09.502 --> 01:20:21.130
And so we might end up with more kind of committed permanent migrants that way because it gives people
from overseas the opportunity to see whether they will be able to fit into Australian society or find jobs here.
759
01:20:22.331 --> 01:20:23.592
Yeah, I don't deny that.
760
01:20:23.812 --> 01:20:27.355
And then there's the other benefit, which is...
761
01:20:31.035 --> 01:20:32.577
mostly on the fiscal side.
762
01:20:33.898 --> 01:20:45.509
So Bob Gregory has this phrase where he says these international students are million-dollar babies because you're getting a fully functioning, educated adult.
763
01:20:46.730 --> 01:20:52.335
You didn't have to spend that first 20 years raising and schooling them.
764
01:20:52.616 --> 01:20:52.756
Mm-hmm.
765
01:20:54.453 --> 01:20:57.836
And there's definitely truth in that.
766
01:20:58.877 --> 01:21:17.152
I'm pointing to the strains that are evident from allowing this to kind of develop in a fairly untrammeled fashion and suggesting that there needs to be some rethinking about
767
01:21:20.676 --> 01:21:42.563
the, how much temporary migration you want and, and what, and some point at which there becomes a resolution in people's status where they cease being temporary and become a permanent resident, or they cease being temporary and leave Australia.
768
01:21:43.504 --> 01:21:47.425
And at the moment we don't do either of those things.
769
01:21:49.997 --> 01:21:57.639
So a very brief kind of personal interlude, but you were the inaugural chief economist at the Department of Immigration.
770
01:21:57.979 --> 01:21:58.159
Yeah.
771
01:21:59.159 --> 01:22:03.360
I'm very curious whether you could share some of like the more interesting questions that you worked on.
772
01:22:05.280 --> 01:22:13.742
And you don't have to go into detail on each one, but just, yeah, I don't even know what your role looked like or the kind of things that you were investigating.
773
01:22:13.902 --> 01:22:14.862
I'd be interested to hear.
774
01:22:16.063 --> 01:22:17.763
So I started in that job
775
01:22:19.235 --> 01:22:22.616
right at the end of 2008 and the beginning of 2009.
776
01:22:23.716 --> 01:22:28.617
And it was not long into the life of the first Rudd government.
777
01:22:30.918 --> 01:22:39.840
And yes, they wanted, the minister, Chris Evans, wanted somebody who could help him think through
778
01:22:41.898 --> 01:22:47.281
the interactions between immigration and the labour market and the economy.
779
01:22:48.201 --> 01:22:50.943
The immigration department was full of lawyers.
780
01:22:52.083 --> 01:23:01.688
And there's not a solution to a problem that a minister faced at that time that somebody in the department would write a regulation about.
781
01:23:03.715 --> 01:23:08.597
And he just wanted a kind of fresh set of eyes to help him think through some of these things.
782
01:23:09.458 --> 01:23:19.082
The thing that I got involved with that had the most consequence, and I worked with several other people on this, was...
783
01:23:20.778 --> 01:23:41.873
This was when the very first spike in international student numbers had taken off and there were a range of overnight colleges that sprung up offering diplomas in cooking, for example, hairdressing.
784
01:23:41.893 --> 01:23:43.074
And...
785
01:23:45.329 --> 01:23:46.430
A number of them were pretty dodgy.
786
01:23:46.710 --> 01:23:47.491
Yeah.
787
01:23:47.511 --> 01:24:00.005
And at the time, under the existing rules in the Migration Act, and particularly the rules for applying to become an independent skilled migrant,
788
01:24:02.077 --> 01:24:18.829
was you could have basically 100% probability that if you were under 30 and your English was pretty good and you enrolled in one of these courses and completed it, you would meet the points test pass mark.
789
01:24:20.070 --> 01:24:23.373
And there was a backlog of...
790
01:24:24.397 --> 01:24:28.580
emerging of applicants who were waiting their turn in the queue to be processed.
791
01:24:28.680 --> 01:24:35.845
So the current blowout that we have in bridging visas was starting to take place then as well.
792
01:24:37.246 --> 01:24:39.948
And the minister wanted a review to be done.
793
01:24:40.088 --> 01:24:50.295
In particular, he wanted a review done of this regulatory instrument that Phil Ruddock had introduced called the Migration Occupations in Demand List Program.
794
01:24:51.639 --> 01:25:04.233
So this list was updated two or three times a year by officials in the department in consultation with employers and with the employment department around evidence on jobs that were in skill shortage.
795
01:25:04.774 --> 01:25:10.821
And if you could demonstrate that you had a skill shortage.
796
01:25:12.504 --> 01:25:21.170
that you're in this occupation that was on the list as a cook or as a hairdresser, for example, you got 15 extra points in the points test.
797
01:25:21.710 --> 01:25:24.192
And that was one of the main things that tipped you over the pass mark.
798
01:25:25.933 --> 01:25:31.337
And so I got asked to lead the review of that on the immigration department side.
799
01:25:32.638 --> 01:25:38.042
And then we worked jointly with colleagues in the then Department of Education and Employment.
800
01:25:39.578 --> 01:25:40.379
I was coming in as a...
801
01:25:41.100 --> 01:25:46.147
I hadn't worked in the public service for like 20 years and I had no idea about...
802
01:25:46.267 --> 01:25:51.414
I had no idea about my seniority and clout and I had no idea about public service processes...
803
01:25:52.622 --> 01:25:58.004
And I went to three meetings between us and the officials in education and employment.
804
01:25:58.804 --> 01:26:01.225
And we were just arguing about the terms of reference for the review.
805
01:26:01.245 --> 01:26:02.665
And I got fed up.
806
01:26:03.386 --> 01:26:06.787
So I wrote a discussion paper and circulated it.
807
01:26:07.447 --> 01:26:09.148
And then the next meeting, everything blew up.
808
01:26:09.208 --> 01:26:12.209
And it was like, you had no authority to write a
discussion paper.
809
01:26:12.569 --> 01:26:14.649
I said, it's a discussion paper and nobody else has seen it.
810
01:26:14.870 --> 01:26:15.550
We're discussing it.
811
01:26:16.570 --> 01:26:18.351
And...
812
01:26:20.632 --> 01:26:30.257
You can see the outcome of that review in the discussion paper, because it just articulates a very kind of clear set of principles about how to think about skilled migration policy.
813
01:26:31.177 --> 01:26:42.043
And it ended up being, we ended up, the government ended up agreeing to a bunch of proposals to end the migration occupations in demand list.
814
01:26:43.323 --> 01:26:48.226
And then a really important initiative, which wasn't in my discussion paper, but was worked up by
815
01:26:49.038 --> 01:26:54.699
other people in the department was to make the application for skill migration.
816
01:26:54.719 --> 01:26:55.839
It's a two step process.
817
01:26:56.480 --> 01:26:58.680
So the first step was an expression of interest.
818
01:27:00.120 --> 01:27:03.561
And after the expression of interest, you would be invited to apply.
819
01:27:04.041 --> 01:27:07.902
Whereas the prevailing law, if you applied, you had to be given a decision.
820
01:27:08.122 --> 01:27:12.163
And if you were over the pass mark, you had to be given a visa.
821
01:27:12.743 --> 01:27:17.464
So it basically tried to prevent the backlog emerging by only the,
822
01:27:18.194 --> 01:27:24.903
inviting the number of people to apply, consistent with the number of skilled migration visas you wanted to issue in any given year.
823
01:27:27.446 --> 01:27:34.230
It caused a huge outcry when this came out, particularly amongst Indian authorities.
824
01:27:34.250 --> 01:27:45.257
I can remember we had to go and see the Indian ambassador who said, you've left my people high and dry to me and the minister.
825
01:27:45.817 --> 01:27:47.958
There was various grandfathering arrangements put in place.
826
01:27:50.060 --> 01:27:51.741
But it would all been pretty sensible.
827
01:27:52.021 --> 01:27:53.522
And then it all progressively got undone.
828
01:27:56.570 --> 01:28:07.513
particularly by lobbyists from the international education, to the universities in the main, because the numbers went down quite a lot the following year and they lobbied really hard.
829
01:28:07.613 --> 01:28:12.674
They got Michael Knight, the former New South Wales Minister for the Olympics, to do a review.
830
01:28:13.155 --> 01:28:22.837
And he's the one whose review came up with the recommendation for a very generous post-study work visa for overseas students.
831
01:28:25.527 --> 01:28:31.829
And the numbers of international students have grown to levels that I thought were unimaginable back in 2010.
832
01:28:31.869 --> 01:28:32.729
But here we are.
833
01:28:33.069 --> 01:28:33.349
Yeah.
834
01:28:34.209 --> 01:28:40.651
It's funny when people talk about the influence of private, of special interests over Australian policy outcomes.
835
01:28:40.731 --> 01:28:44.612
The kind of classic examples are like the mining companies around the mining tax.
836
01:28:44.752 --> 01:28:55.094
But I think the international education sector, the universities, is like a very underrated example of people are digging in to very ferociously defend their rents.
837
01:28:56.938 --> 01:29:03.932
I have some big picture questions and I wanted to start with a few questions on culture and social cohesion.
838
01:29:05.014 --> 01:29:25.980
This is more of a comment, but in the book, you say that the two best analogues for Australia, if we didn't embark on the post-war migration program are Sweden and Belgium, and that counterfactually, Australia might look more like those countries, very homogenous, still rich, but much smaller, older populations.
839
01:29:27.001 --> 01:29:31.342
The Sweden analogy is a really interesting one more broadly because
840
01:29:33.252 --> 01:29:37.956
Sweden has a similar political culture to Australia in a couple of ways.
841
01:29:38.416 --> 01:29:40.678
There's the egalitarianism and the statism.
842
01:29:41.999 --> 01:29:44.461
There are all these strange parallels between Australia and Sweden.
843
01:29:45.121 --> 01:29:59.092
I put Sweden in there as a provocation because there's a bunch of people, you know, on the kind of left-leaning people who hold Scandinavian countries up, especially Sweden as an exemplar.
844
01:30:00.763 --> 01:30:02.288
that Australia might emulate.
845
01:30:03.011 --> 01:30:06.021
And so Sweden nowadays has
846
01:30:07.480 --> 01:30:15.904
It has had for quite a number of years brought in significant numbers of refugees, but it's never had a migration programs like we've had.
847
01:30:16.705 --> 01:30:28.571
And the point I was trying to make was the conflation of the mistake that people make over what we think about prosperity and that migration has made Australia prosperous.
848
01:30:28.671 --> 01:30:32.313
Migration has made Australia larger and it's made it different.
849
01:30:33.253 --> 01:30:34.454
It hasn't made it more prosperous.
850
01:30:34.514 --> 01:30:35.795
We probably would still be...
851
01:30:36.435 --> 01:30:51.568
in terms of incomes per head, roughly the same now as we are had we not had a big boost in migration after World War II.
852
01:30:52.389 --> 01:31:03.059
So the reason why I picked Sweden and Belgium is we had the same population as them, roughly speaking, around the time of World War II, and we're now two and a half times larger than Sweden and about three times larger than Belgium.
853
01:31:04.500 --> 01:31:06.402
But we still have broadly similar.
854
01:31:07.082 --> 01:31:13.747
We've matched the living standards of Swedens and Belgians basically all the way through from the 1950s to the present.
855
01:31:15.689 --> 01:31:17.510
So that's not due to migration.
856
01:31:17.530 --> 01:31:18.371
It's due to other factors.
857
01:31:18.731 --> 01:31:18.952
Yeah.
858
01:31:18.972 --> 01:31:22.995
I want to come
back to the living standards thing because I think that's really interesting and important.
859
01:31:23.875 --> 01:31:29.500
What do you think is the single best measure for the speed of acculturation of a migrant group?
860
01:31:31.013 --> 01:31:38.658
So you could think of like, you could think of intermarriage, you could think of language shifts, you could think of second generation wage premium.
861
01:31:39.118 --> 01:31:39.998
You had to pick one.
862
01:31:41.399 --> 01:31:42.600
I think it would probably be how...
863
01:31:44.897 --> 01:31:49.702
second generation and third generation see themselves, how they identify themselves.
864
01:31:50.222 --> 01:31:51.784
You would collect that through survey evidence?
865
01:31:51.864 --> 01:31:52.464
Oh, possibly.
866
01:31:52.484 --> 01:31:53.505
Yeah.
867
01:31:54.746 --> 01:32:01.973
But, you know, what are the bits of their parents, grandparents' culture that they hang on to?
868
01:32:02.694 --> 01:32:04.155
Do they identify as...
869
01:32:08.135 --> 01:32:10.797
heritage dash Australians or do they identify as Australians?
870
01:32:11.217 --> 01:32:11.417
Yeah.
871
01:32:12.218 --> 01:32:21.764
The intermarriage stuff is obviously a phenomenon and it's a bit tricky to kind of get underneath and interpret.
872
01:32:22.865 --> 01:32:26.967
And I'm not an expert in that field at all.
873
01:32:28.048 --> 01:32:35.713
I know in the sociological literature, it's often used as the most important both cause and measure of...
874
01:32:37.085 --> 01:32:37.805
acculturation.
875
01:32:38.506 --> 01:32:40.006
Yeah, whatever acculturation is.
876
01:32:42.267 --> 01:32:44.348
And acculturation is a two-way street as well, right?
877
01:32:44.628 --> 01:32:45.909
And there are different dimensions.
878
01:32:47.509 --> 01:33:02.516
The pushback against assimilation in the 1950s and then the embrace of multiculturalism in the 1970s was because the acculturation was only a one-way street, not a two-way street.
879
01:33:03.396 --> 01:33:05.577
And so migrants were expected to
880
01:33:08.065 --> 01:33:21.691
not speak their own language out of doors, not draw attention to themselves, not live in enclaves together to kind of suppress their identities.
881
01:33:23.992 --> 01:33:26.853
And multiculturalism, the embrace of that was partly a
882
01:33:29.651 --> 01:33:43.178
a well-organised political reaction against the attempts by the dominant group, the Anglo-Saxons, to impose their cultural hegemony over the rest of the population.
883
01:33:44.699 --> 01:33:58.307
So for me, I'll give a trivial example, would be if you turn on the television and watch one of those contestant shows like MasterChef,
884
01:34:00.768 --> 01:34:13.198
or the voice, you see evidently people of migrant heritage, second generation, third generation.
885
01:34:15.279 --> 01:34:16.520
They seem Australian to me.
886
01:34:17.461 --> 01:34:19.963
Those, you know, you do not see...
887
01:34:20.728 --> 01:34:25.169
You do
not see Australia on Home and Away or on Neighbours.
888
01:34:25.449 --> 01:34:28.830
You see it on MasterChef and The Voice.
889
01:34:29.991 --> 01:34:44.635
These people from Western Sydney, Broadmeadows, wherever they are, they're people who get on with life and maybe they marry within their community.
890
01:34:45.860 --> 01:34:49.943
as defined by their parents or their grandparents, but maybe they don't.
891
01:34:51.164 --> 01:35:01.951
The country seems to me to be richer, culturally richer, and less homogenous for that.
892
01:35:02.772 --> 01:35:11.958
And it's definitely the kind of critiques about Anglo-Saxon hegemony and whiteness,
893
01:35:16.593 --> 01:35:21.496
Less salient, I think, now than they were 20 or 30 years ago.
894
01:35:21.516 --> 01:35:37.525
You can't go through the streets of our main capital cities without recognising that these are very diverse and mostly tolerant communities.
895
01:35:37.985 --> 01:35:40.867
I don't deny there's issues around...
896
01:35:43.490 --> 01:35:50.615
so-called social cohesion and that there's evidence of discord and some fracturing.
897
01:35:52.456 --> 01:36:06.005
By and large, the Australian experience with migration is probably the best the world can offer.
898
01:36:08.402 --> 01:36:18.369
I've been kind of like slowly trying to write this thing, maybe it's an essay or something, on why Australia has historically been so effective at acculturating migrants.
899
01:36:19.610 --> 01:36:21.031
And in conversations I've had with...
900
01:36:22.212 --> 01:36:24.553
various experts over the last year or two.
901
01:36:25.734 --> 01:36:41.001
One of the big explanations that comes up a lot is that Australia's always taken a mix of national and cultural groups such that no one group is large enough to form a breakaway culture like the Quebisua in Canada or the Catalonians in Spain.
902
01:36:42.615 --> 01:37:02.606
And we haven't done this in any given period, like in any one year, but we've done it over the course of decades by moving from kind of hopscotching from the British to Northern Europeans, Eastern and Southern Europeans, the Turkish, the Lebanese, the Vietnamese, the Indo-Chinese, now today Chinese and Indians.
903
01:37:03.206 --> 01:37:10.130
And so we've ended up with this incredibly diverse overseas-born population, but the
904
01:37:11.388 --> 01:37:15.311
At least since 1973, we've had a principle of non-discrimination.
905
01:37:15.331 --> 01:37:17.793
It seems like this hasn't been planned.
906
01:37:17.853 --> 01:37:19.294
It's just kind of unfolded.
907
01:37:20.574 --> 01:37:39.928
And if that's true, that's a really striking fact about Australia and Australian history because one of the most important characteristics of Australia as the OECD country with the highest proportion of overseas-born citizens or residents is,
908
01:37:41.624 --> 01:37:46.207
we have kind of like stumbled into that situation very successfully.
909
01:37:47.368 --> 01:37:55.893
Are you aware of, have officials or governments ever thought deliberately about the mix?
910
01:37:56.513 --> 01:38:03.497
And when I say mix, I mean making sure that we have not too many from different groups.
911
01:38:03.998 --> 01:38:07.480
Do you know whether that has ever been thought of in a deliberate way?
912
01:38:08.781 --> 01:38:10.942
And if so, what would the policy levers be?
913
01:38:12.480 --> 01:38:16.983
Because my assumption is that we haven't thought of it in a deliberate way, but I'm wondering if I'm wrong.
914
01:38:18.104 --> 01:38:28.431
Well, it's obviously, I think it has been thought about in a deliberate and quite applied way for much of Australia's history, some of it kind of hidden and behind the scenes.
915
01:38:29.251 --> 01:38:31.773
But if we restrict it to the post-war era?
916
01:38:32.934 --> 01:38:33.234
All right.
917
01:38:33.554 --> 01:38:35.115
Restrict it to the post-war era.
918
01:38:35.616 --> 01:38:41.260
So firstly, the door was effectively closed to...
919
01:38:42.320 --> 01:38:53.408
anyone outside of Europe, the British Isles and North America up until 1973.
920
01:38:54.649 --> 01:38:59.192
So that's, so if you're thinking about mixed, that was, that was very deliberate.
921
01:39:00.413 --> 01:39:04.075
So that was a continuation of the, of the white Australia policy.
922
01:39:06.237 --> 01:39:09.519
The relaxation of that policy in 1973 was,
923
01:39:11.498 --> 01:39:20.824
had no material impact on the mix of migrants until we welcomed in the Indochinese refugees.
924
01:39:22.605 --> 01:39:35.374
But even within Europe, the immigration officials would select individual migrants, so they would reject people.
925
01:39:36.514 --> 01:39:37.215
But it wasn't just...
926
01:39:38.580 --> 01:39:42.363
the door's open for anybody from Italy or Greece.
927
01:39:44.205 --> 01:39:50.211
Okay, the door is open to this many migrants from Italy and we want them to come from the north.
928
01:39:50.371 --> 01:39:51.632
We don't want them to come from the south.
929
01:39:54.134 --> 01:40:00.240
We want them to be people with a background in skilled trades.
930
01:40:00.280 --> 01:40:01.481
We don't want illiterate peasants.
931
01:40:03.031 --> 01:40:21.081
And then when the door was opened to Turkey, which was defined as being European in about 1969, we want Assyrians, we want Christians, we don't want dark-coloured Muslims from Turkey.
932
01:40:21.541 --> 01:40:30.306
So those decisions were all made by immigration officials personally in the 1950s, 1960s, and early 1970s.
933
01:40:33.322 --> 01:40:44.354
And it's not until 1973 when those people all lose their jobs effectively as decision makers, they now have to follow rules that are written down and codified and transparent.
934
01:40:45.495 --> 01:40:49.319
So prior to 1973, there was heaps of discrimination exercised.
935
01:40:50.579 --> 01:40:53.460
This was the kind of, that was the era of the angels and arrogant gods.
936
01:40:53.560 -->
01:40:54.000
That's right.
937
01:40:54.060 --> 01:40:54.240
Yeah.
938
01:40:54.340 --> 01:40:54.681
Yeah.
939
01:40:54.701 --> 01:41:00.583
That's the title of the book by Harry, forgotten his surname, who was a migration officer.
940
01:41:00.623 --> 01:41:04.384
And it's a kind of memoir of his time and of other migration officers in the immigration department.
941
01:41:05.004 --> 01:41:12.747
So there's no doubt they were exercising those decisions against individuals or for individuals a lot.
942
01:41:13.048 --> 01:41:14.108
And that altered the...
943
01:41:15.482 --> 01:41:23.425
Composition relative to what it might otherwise have been if people had just been allowed to fill their quotas according to how they self-selected.
944
01:41:24.766 --> 01:41:41.513
After 1973, there was quite a reaction against, firstly, the thing called the Structured Selection Assessment System introduced in 1973, and then the Perf First Points Test, which was called the Numerical Multi-Factor Assessment System.
945
01:41:42.651 --> 01:41:49.076
in 1979 about criteria that might be biased against people from certain countries.
946
01:41:49.376 --> 01:41:57.123
And so particularly it's a big argument about English language and how proficient people had to be in English before they would be allowed to migrate.
947
01:42:00.705 --> 01:42:08.872
And that was eventually resolved by saying, yes, as a country, we do want people to be
948
01:42:10.829 --> 01:42:16.611
where we can exercise some choice over the kind of migrants that we want to have.
949
01:42:17.192 --> 01:42:30.557
So leaving aside partner visas, it's very hard to impose requirements on if I want to marry somebody from China who doesn't speak a word of English, what right does the government have to tell me who I can marry and who I can live with?
950
01:42:30.817 --> 01:42:37.040
So they've kept away from, by and large, from interfering in partner visas, but in most other visas they've...
951
01:42:37.700 --> 01:42:49.278
There has been agreement, eventually bipartisan agreement, that proficiency in English helps people, in your terms, acculturate.
952
01:42:50.881 --> 01:42:52.884
So that's been quite deliberate.
953
01:42:54.475 --> 01:42:56.277
But I think this proves my claim.
954
01:42:56.677 --> 01:43:09.831
So if you imagine like 100 little silos representing different countries, over time it's like we've filled each little silo up no further than its brim.
955
01:43:10.151 --> 01:43:17.458
So we'll take this many Greek people, this many Italian people, this many Vietnamese until we've kind of...
956
01:43:18.159 --> 01:43:20.561
ended up with a really diverse...
957
01:43:20.761 --> 01:43:22.402
Except we haven't chosen those mixes.
958
01:43:22.702 --> 01:43:24.323
It's been self-selected.
959
01:43:24.503 --> 01:43:25.104
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
960
01:43:25.144 --> 01:43:26.705
And it happens through chain migration.
961
01:43:26.785 --> 01:43:27.425
That's how it happens.
962
01:43:27.445 -->
01:43:27.925
Yes, yes.
963
01:43:28.346 --> 01:43:31.107
And then another chain starts, right?
964
01:43:31.127 --> 01:43:33.029
So you talked about India.
965
01:43:33.889 --> 01:43:47.358
India, if you go back to pre-2000, there were fewer than 100,000 Indian-born people living in Australia.
966
01:43:47.378 --> 01:43:47.478
Yeah.
967
01:43:49.017 --> 01:43:50.518
and there are now close to a million.
968
01:43:50.698 --> 01:43:50.919
Yeah.
969
01:43:51.779 --> 01:43:54.381
And that's happened through chain migration.
970
01:43:55.382 --> 01:44:05.510
You know, everyone is... You would hop into a cab, and there'd be some young Sikh driving the cab.
971
01:44:05.630 --> 01:44:10.474
You'd go into petrol stations, and you just started to see that.
972
01:44:11.014 --> 01:44:11.915
And so it's been very...
973
01:44:12.675 --> 01:44:16.198
It's actually been quite... And chain migration happens like this a lot.
974
01:44:16.318 --> 01:44:16.999
It happens in...
975
01:44:19.492 --> 01:44:22.014
Small areas of a given country.
976
01:44:22.054 --> 01:44:23.055
It's not a national thing.
977
01:44:23.075 --> 01:44:25.777
I mean, you can't speak about India as being a homogenous country at all.
978
01:44:25.897 --> 01:44:28.339
It's way more multicultural than Australia is.
979
01:44:29.740 --> 01:44:34.743
But we have a lot of the Indian-born migrants living in Australia come from the Punjab.
980
01:44:35.344 --> 01:44:36.364
There's Sikhs from Punjab.
981
01:44:36.404 --> 01:44:38.106
They are way overrepresented in Australia.
982
01:44:38.126 --> 01:44:38.226
Yeah.
983
01:44:39.268 --> 01:44:41.569
amongst the Indian born than they are in their own country.
984
01:44:42.209 --> 01:44:43.170
So that, and.
985
01:44:43.510 --> 01:44:46.672
Like one in five Indian migrants to Australia are six.
986
01:44:47.392 --> 01:44:48.012
I think that's right.
987
01:44:48.032 --> 01:44:50.513
It might be a bit, it might even be one in four, something like that.
988
01:44:50.653 --> 01:44:51.074
Yeah.
989
01:44:51.114 --> 01:44:53.335
Whereas in India is like 2% of the population.
990
01:44:53.495 --> 01:44:53.795
Yeah.
991
01:44:53.995 --> 01:44:54.195
Yeah.
992
01:44:54.295 --> 01:45:00.218
So, so these, these things do evolve and iterate over time.
993
01:45:00.258 --> 01:45:01.819
It's really fascinating to look at.
994
01:45:02.927 --> 01:45:22.193
when people, when the peak population was for particular groups, communities of migrants, sorry, that language is a bit funny, people born in different countries coming to migrate to Australia.
995
01:45:22.314 --> 01:45:26.575
So, and you can check this at the different census dates.
996
01:45:26.915 --> 01:45:29.056
So the number of Italians
997
01:45:30.163 --> 01:45:34.364
born and Greek born in Australia peaked, what year do you think?
998
01:45:35.604 --> 01:45:35.844
1971.
999
01:45:35.924 --> 01:45:36.304
Okay.
1000
01:45:37.844 --> 01:45:43.925
So the Baltics, people from the Baltic States peaked in 1954.
1001
01:45:45.846 --> 01:45:49.166
People from the Netherlands and Germany in the 1960s.
1002
01:45:49.186 --> 01:45:58.068
I mean, I thought it would be, I would think most people's prize would be, it would be much later than 1971 because it's not until the,
1003
01:45:59.195 --> 01:46:13.444
the 1970s that there's a celebration of cappuccinos and pizzas and all that stuff washing through Australian culture, but the number of, you know, that population had already by then become quite elderly.
1004
01:46:13.865 --> 01:46:16.586
That's when you see the nonnas in black in the 1970s.
1005
01:46:17.367 --> 01:46:23.611
But, okay, so I take your point that we shouldn't have this illusion of control, like this is driven by
1006
01:46:25.145 --> 01:46:29.607
migrants making the decision to move here and then things like chain migration.
1007
01:46:30.087 --> 01:46:32.288
Just let me push on this further.
1008
01:46:32.348 --> 01:46:36.010
So take, I don't know, the United States.
1009
01:46:36.210 --> 01:46:41.353
Maybe the modal group are people from Mexico because of America's geography.
1010
01:46:41.813 --> 01:46:47.796
So there's just – and then you see how this manifests in American society.
1011
01:46:47.816 --> 01:46:52.618
Like you go to California and the road signs are all in English and Spanish.
1012
01:46:52.838 --> 01:46:52.978
Mm-hmm.
1013
01:46:54.575 --> 01:47:07.845
We don't, and maybe for us, the modal group are like the British, but we don't seem to have anything like that because there's a big spread of different groups.
1014
01:47:08.385 --> 01:47:13.209
And that is the thing that just seems to have happened accidentally.
1015
01:47:13.249 --> 01:47:13.349
Yeah.
1016
01:47:14.185 --> 01:47:17.007
So I do mostly agree with that.
1017
01:47:17.307 --> 01:47:24.031
But in the appendix, I've got a table on the birthplaces of migrants and how that's evolved over time.
1018
01:47:24.171 --> 01:47:25.332
Yeah.
1019
01:47:26.233 --> 01:47:29.835
And in the 1860s, 20% of the population had been born in England.
1020
01:47:30.395 --> 01:47:35.539
That's your point earlier, about 70% of people born overseas in Victoria in the 1850s.
1021
01:47:35.659 --> 01:47:40.722
So at a national level, if you can think of Australia being a nation in 1861...
1022
01:47:43.130 --> 01:47:47.091
Over 20% of the people resident in the population had been born in England.
1023
01:47:47.831 --> 01:47:50.011
And then in 1901, it dropped to 10%.
1024
01:47:50.031 --> 01:47:51.192
In 1947, it had dropped to 5%.
1025
01:47:51.252 --> 01:47:52.932
In 1961, it had dropped to 2%.
1026
01:47:52.972 --> 01:47:53.872
Yeah, it's just dropping down.
1027
01:47:53.892 --> 01:47:55.113
And no other country's...
1028
01:48:07.317 --> 01:48:28.258
since the late 19th century, there hasn't been any particular country that has dominated the population as an immigrant group, other than you would talk, you would, you know, the British to its bootstraps thing.
1029
01:48:28.278 --> 01:48:28.979
Mm-hmm.
1030
01:48:30.743 --> 01:48:47.741
So in 1947, the overseas-born share of the population was 10%, so lowest it's been, if we look just at the colonist population, since the early 1800s at 10%.
1031
01:48:52.808 --> 01:48:58.711
but it was culturally homogenous and British Australian.
1032
01:49:00.012 --> 01:49:04.694
You know, that's all over the history about the way in which people saw themselves as British.
1033
01:49:04.714 --> 01:49:06.035
So that has...
1034
01:49:11.385 --> 01:49:22.851
that crimson thread of kinship, as Henry Park called it in the kind of discussions around Federation, that thread has faded and frayed.
1035
01:49:24.772 --> 01:49:27.474
And it's no longer so hegemonic.
1036
01:49:29.675 --> 01:49:29.935
So...
1037
01:49:33.865 --> 01:49:39.529
In the last couple of months, there's been some unprecedented polling of political opinions.
1038
01:49:40.669 --> 01:49:51.456
So for the first time in its history, One Nation is now, its primary vote is on par with the Liberal Party or with the coalition, tied with the coalition at 23%.
1039
01:49:54.666 --> 01:49:55.846
There was a December poll.
1040
01:49:55.926 --> 01:49:57.527
So that was a demos AU poll.
1041
01:49:57.787 --> 01:50:10.991
Then there was an earlier poll in December by Roy Morgan, had One Nation at 17% nationally, more than doubling since July 2025, beating the previous record they'd set in 1998 of 14.5%.
1042
01:50:13.938 --> 01:50:20.362
So you've got an anti-immigration party now enjoying unprecedented support.
1043
01:50:20.782 --> 01:50:22.183
How do you explain that?
1044
01:50:23.164 --> 01:50:40.695
There's never been an anti-immigration party in Australia that's had any real presence or support up until...
1045
01:50:42.671 --> 01:50:52.976
But when I mean anti-immigration, I mean anti-immigration in the sense of anti a certain mix of migrants.
1046
01:50:55.038 --> 01:51:03.963
The only comparable period, it's not even comparable, but there was a lot of trade union opposition to migration migration.
1047
01:51:06.741 --> 01:51:12.767
in the 1860s, 1870s, 1880s.
1048
01:51:14.128 --> 01:51:20.535
They were successful, the trade unions were successful in getting assisted passage to basically stop
1049
01:51:22.110 --> 01:51:25.133
in everywhere other than Queensland and Western Australia.
1050
01:51:26.514 --> 01:51:41.066
And of course, there was opposition to migrants from outside Britain because of the issues we've discussed before around maintaining the purity of the white race and around competition for jobs.
1051
01:51:42.207 --> 01:51:43.528
So the trade unions were the leading leaders
1052
01:51:45.949 --> 01:51:58.676
opposers of immigration, which is what makes the post-war migration boom under a Labour government so remarkable, and a government with very deep ties to the trade union movement.
1053
01:51:58.876 --> 01:52:02.518
So that was what was remarkable about that particular period.
1054
01:52:05.679 --> 01:52:13.003
The arguments about immigration have always been more concerned about the mix rather than about the level, and I'm not sure...
1055
01:52:14.617 --> 01:52:15.557
in the past I'm talking about.
1056
01:52:15.577 --> 01:52:43.124
I'm not sure whether the rallies that we've seen, the March for Australia rallies and the rise in support to One Nation is an argument about level or a reaction against level and against this idea that migration has been too high since the pandemic and it's pushed up house prices and it's put pressure on congestion and what have you.
1057
01:52:43.164 --> 01:52:43.884
Is it about that?
1058
01:52:45.048 --> 01:53:01.458
Is it about that there are too many people of Muslim faith coming in and they are not integrating into society and there's a number of radical jihadists?
1059
01:53:03.323 --> 01:53:08.125
amongst them and they're causing fractures in Australian society.
1060
01:53:08.445 --> 01:53:16.768
So I don't know which... And they might be connected to, like concerns about the level might have spillover effects for concerns about the mix or something.
1061
01:53:17.349 --> 01:53:18.049
Does that make sense?
1062
01:53:18.889 --> 01:53:19.869
Yeah, maybe.
1063
01:53:20.010 --> 01:53:23.931
So I'm not sure what it's about, but the levels are clearly coming off.
1064
01:53:24.311 --> 01:53:24.551
Yeah.
1065
01:53:25.832 --> 01:53:26.132
And...
1066
01:53:27.530 --> 01:53:56.467
you know, at least at a superficial level, the kind of high-level indicators in the Scanlon Foundation's annual social cohesion survey still suggests that a very clear majority of Australians, who are talking kind of like four and five, are saying we support multiculturalism and we support a diverse intake of migrants and...
1067
01:53:57.683 --> 01:54:00.684
Which would suggest that the concern is more about the mix.
1068
01:54:01.384 --> 01:54:03.505
Except they're saying we support the diverse intake.
1069
01:54:04.205 --> 01:54:06.666
Four and five are saying we support a diverse intake of migrants.
1070
01:54:07.226 --> 01:54:08.086
Yeah, I see.
1071
01:54:08.346 --> 01:54:19.690
So I guess they say that and then there's also net negative sentiment about migrants from Muslim backgrounds and migrants from Sudan and Iraq.
1072
01:54:19.970 --> 01:54:20.170
Yes.
1073
01:54:21.811 --> 01:54:25.652
So I wonder if you take all that together, then maybe that suggests that the concern is the mix.
1074
01:54:27.314 --> 01:54:32.743
So I think there is some concern about the mix, but I don't...
1075
01:54:33.525 --> 01:54:41.157
So the only period that I can think of in recent history that looks like now...
1076
01:54:42.312 --> 01:54:46.393
is the late 1980s and early 1990s.
1077
01:54:46.693 --> 01:54:52.274
So there's been a question asked in opinion polls since the mid-50s.
1078
01:54:52.814 --> 01:54:57.095
Do you think the level of immigration in Australia is too high, about right, or too low?
1079
01:54:58.135 -->
01:55:07.077
And in almost all years, in almost all polls in all years since that's been conducted from the mid-1950s through to the present,
1080
01:55:08.966 --> 01:55:11.248
The largest group are people who say it's about right.
1081
01:55:12.008 --> 01:55:16.331
The second largest group are people who say it's too high and the lowest group is people who say it's too low.
1082
01:55:18.073 --> 01:55:29.261
There's been only a handful of times where the proportion saying it's too high is greater than the proportion saying it's about right.
1083
01:55:30.042 --> 01:55:37.567
And there was a prolonged period where that was the case from around the mid-80s to the late 1990s.
1084
01:55:39.665 --> 01:55:53.173
And that coincided with, it kind of kicked off with Geoffrey Blaney making his remarks about wanting the rate of immigration from Asian nations to slow down.
1085
01:55:54.814 --> 01:55:59.557
Then John Howard hinting at that in the late 1980s.
1086
01:55:59.857 --> 01:56:00.958
And then Pauline Hanson was.
1087
01:56:02.918 --> 01:56:05.719
being elected to the federal parliament in 1996.
1088
01:56:06.499 --> 01:56:22.144
So there was definitely, it seems to me, a reaction in the Australian community, some disquiet about the volume of immigration from Asian nations over that period, even though the question was about the level.
1089
01:56:23.025 --> 01:56:27.046
Because the migration intake, the migration levels in that period were not high.
1090
01:56:28.226 --> 01:56:30.147
Unemployment was high and...
1091
01:56:32.598 --> 01:56:46.342
the immigration intake had become possibly majority Asian or very close to it majority Asian from the kind of mid-'80s through that period, and I think there was a reaction against that.
1092
01:56:47.262 --> 01:56:56.944
And I think that that was also partly fundamentally underpinned by a slowdown in the rise in living standards.
1093
01:56:57.624 --> 01:56:59.645
And when they started to pick up again...
1094
01:57:01.742 --> 01:57:29.238
when our little kind of productivity boom happened in the 1990s and we started to see real income gains year on year, I think that and a little bit of similar reaction to what people had had in the 1960s to the wave of migrants from Italy and Greece and just going, well, actually these people are, they're hardworking, they're aspirational, their kids are doing well at school,
1095
01:57:31.415 --> 01:57:32.376
They seem to be having a go.
1096
01:57:33.176 --> 01:57:40.742
And I think people probably became a little bit more relaxed about that over time.
1097
01:57:40.922 --> 01:57:42.643
And that fell away.
1098
01:57:44.164 --> 01:57:51.870
But it looks to me maybe that there is some fracturing around...
1099
01:57:53.071 --> 01:58:13.041
the migrant intake at present, and whether it will abate as the level of net overseas migration continues to fall as it looks like it will do, is I think still up in the air.
1100
01:58:14.882 --> 01:58:17.863
At least until Bondi, my explanation for the...
1101
01:58:19.663 --> 01:58:31.111
increasing negative sentiment towards immigration had been three causes, a touch, a roughly equal weighting to each, so a third, a third, a third, for want of better evidence.
1102
01:58:31.752 --> 01:58:36.715
The first one was the stagnation in living standards, contributing to the kind of zero-sum mindset.
1103
01:58:37.096 --> 01:58:44.501
And as you know from studying history, the first scapegoat in that situation is usually immigrants.
1104
01:58:44.521 --> 01:58:45.442
Yeah.
1105
01:58:45.882 --> 01:58:53.031
Second cause was the perceptions of a loss of control after the post-COVID surge in net migration.
1106
01:58:53.051 --> 01:59:01.963
And then the third, which I think is the most underrated, is negative mood contagion from the United States and the United Kingdom.
1107
01:59:02.183 --> 01:59:02.323
Mm-hmm.
1108
01:59:03.084 --> 01:59:06.406
And we forget that we don't have an autonomous media ecosystem anymore.
1109
01:59:07.007 --> 01:59:08.067
Everyone's on the same Twitter.
1110
01:59:08.107 --> 01:59:09.288
Everyone's on the same YouTube.
1111
01:59:09.888 --> 01:59:15.712
All the Australian influencers are following Elon Musk and Donald Trump.
1112
01:59:16.012 --> 01:59:19.494
And people kind of just copy and paste the same talking points.
1113
01:59:20.355 --> 01:59:26.899
The immigration debate is very different over there because of the issues with illegal immigration that they have, which we don't really.
1114
01:59:28.520 --> 01:59:31.341
And, yeah, I think that kind of seeps into the Australian debate.
1115
01:59:32.992 --> 01:59:34.333
I'm not going to dim you off from any of that.
1116
01:59:34.353 --> 01:59:36.494
I think that sounds plausible to me.
1117
01:59:36.514 --> 01:59:59.445
I know lots of people are going to try and push me on questions like this about my book, but it is a work of history, and I'm not a commentator, or I don't want to be a commentator, about current issues, and less to the extent that there are lessons from history that might be useful.
1118
02:00:04.486 --> 02:00:25.584
what a, how a government might reconcile having a racial discrimination act, a non-discriminatory visa policy, and how you might square that with
1119
02:00:26.563 --> 02:00:29.364
some preferences around adjusting the mix.
1120
02:00:30.225 --> 02:00:34.147
I don't know how you can do that without giving up one of those things.
1121
02:00:34.427 --> 02:00:36.848
Yeah.
1122
02:00:37.148 --> 02:00:51.075
And that means that you are returning to something that is discriminatory by ethnicity or race or cultural background, faith or something.
1123
02:00:53.793 --> 02:00:56.314
And, you know, we've said since 1933 we're not doing that.
1124
02:00:57.554 --> 02:01:10.038
But if that's being entertained, then that means opening up those debates and I can't imagine that's going to be pretty.
1125
02:01:10.438 --> 02:01:10.678
Yeah.
1126
02:01:11.999 --> 02:01:16.400
So to
finish on some more big picture questions, but these ones aren't related to culture,
1127
02:01:18.073 --> 02:01:25.956
Are there particular periods in Australian history where immigration has made a large difference to living standards, either positively or negatively?
1128
02:01:27.396 --> 02:01:45.983
So I think the way I think about this is that there are times when if we had not had large intakes of immigration, we would have had headwinds.
1129
02:01:47.505 --> 02:01:49.306
We would have just hit capacity.
1130
02:01:49.346 --> 02:02:03.450
We would have been operating at full capacity and not been able to meet demand without inducing more supply.
1131
02:02:06.551 --> 02:02:07.851
So that's one thing.
1132
02:02:07.971 --> 02:02:10.532
And I think that that's...
1133
02:02:13.902 --> 02:02:17.985
We'd probably talk about the 1950s as an example of that.
1134
02:02:18.966 --> 02:02:29.114
The other thing, so I do not buy the argument that some people buy that migration increases productivity.
1135
02:02:29.914 --> 02:02:34.498
I just do not find the evidence on that at all persuasive.
1136
02:02:36.800 --> 02:02:42.144
And I think there's two mistakes that are made by...
1137
02:02:43.382 --> 02:02:48.307
people who talk about how migration lifts living standards.
1138
02:02:49.347 --> 02:03:05.342
Well, so one is that a lot of the gain that appears in the modelling is an artefact of the age composition of the migrants being heavily skewed young.
1139
02:03:05.602 --> 02:03:06.543
Yeah.
1140
02:03:06.923 --> 02:03:08.225
And that gives you...
1141
02:03:09.646 --> 02:03:20.551
a lift in your participation rate that you otherwise would not have had, which manifests itself in a higher GDP per capita than you otherwise would not have had.
1142
02:03:20.972 --> 02:03:24.894
But it's simply a function of the age of the migrants, not of their school.
1143
02:03:26.194 --> 02:03:31.537
And then the second one is I don't think the kind of people who advocate these things
1144
02:03:33.130 --> 02:03:53.089
try to work through the general equilibrium resolution of bringing in larger numbers of skilled migrants in terms of how that plays out over time into the occupational composition of employment.
1145
02:03:53.109 --> 02:03:53.249
Yeah.
1146
02:03:55.270 --> 02:04:12.056
So at the margin, if all of your intake was skilled and it was all clustered in one occupation, engineers or something like that, it's obviously those people coming in are not all going to be employed as engineers.
1147
02:04:13.096 --> 02:04:24.920
So how does the intake alter the, over time, the occupational composition of employment relative to what it otherwise would
1148
02:04:25.146 --> 02:04:35.549
would have been, I'm not convinced that it makes the overall composition more highly skilled.
1149
02:04:36.709 --> 02:04:42.131
I just think there's a lot of shuffling in the queue for different jobs.
1150
02:04:44.231 --> 02:04:48.192
And in a sense, this has always been the case with first-generation migrants.
1151
02:04:48.852 --> 02:04:50.593
They pay a penalty.
1152
02:04:53.512 --> 02:04:58.342
Even international students pay a penalty for not having been born in Australia.
1153
02:04:59.557 --> 02:05:17.342
and they accept job offers that are inferior to what they would prefer and are inferior to what an otherwise identical Australian-born person receives.
1154
02:05:18.343 --> 02:05:23.544
And those effects tend to wash out by the time you get to the next generation.
1155
02:05:24.664 --> 02:05:26.565
So the thing I dislike about the...
1156
02:05:27.897 --> 02:05:37.119
discussions about migration in Australia is they, even the analysts tend to be advocates.
1157
02:05:38.199 --> 02:05:39.299
Well, they're either anti or pro.
1158
02:05:39.319 --> 02:05:41.200
We don't really have anybody like George Borhas.
1159
02:05:41.280 --> 02:05:48.001
I guess we had Bob Birrell for a while, who was an analyst who was, who thought that the immigration intakes generally were too high.
1160
02:05:49.102 --> 02:05:51.002
He was probably our equivalent to George Borhas.
1161
02:05:53.022 --> 02:05:55.623
But most of the people who work on,
1162
02:05:57.836 --> 02:06:04.690
migration in Australia are a little too selective in the way in which they talk about evidence.
1163
02:06:05.251 --> 02:06:05.953
Yeah, no doubt.
1164
02:06:06.514 --> 02:06:09.240
So do you agree with Ian McLean that,
1165
02:06:11.368 --> 02:06:16.251
on net migration probably hasn't mattered for Australian living standards.
1166
02:06:16.872 --> 02:06:23.116
It certainly mattered for Australian GDP, but it hasn't really changed living standards.
1167
02:06:23.396 --> 02:06:34.403
So we don't get to run, you can't run kind of fat tools, but that's partly the argument I was making earlier on about Sweden and Belgium.
1168
02:06:34.723 --> 02:06:34.923
Yeah.
1169
02:06:35.604 --> 02:06:40.407
So it's possible that our living standards might not be as high as they presently are.
1170
02:06:41.355 --> 02:06:48.238
Um, but, uh, materially, I'm not sure that it's going to be that great.
1171
02:06:48.618 --> 02:06:48.818
Yeah.
1172
02:06:49.038 --> 02:06:49.598
A difference.
1173
02:06:50.739 --> 02:06:51.179
So I agree.
1174
02:06:51.199 --> 02:06:52.100
I agree with Ian McLean.
1175
02:06:52.760 --> 02:06:53.040
Okay.
1176
02:06:53.060 --> 02:06:53.220
Yeah.
1177
02:06:53.400 --> 02:06:53.600
Yeah.
1178
02:06:54.020 --> 02:06:54.220
Yeah.
1179
02:06:55.341 --> 02:07:02.624
So I have this framework in my head for thinking about our ability to accept the
1180
02:07:05.438 --> 02:07:07.420
our ability to accept immigrants.
1181
02:07:07.480 --> 02:07:12.944
And I think you could think of like three constraints on immigration.
1182
02:07:12.984 --> 02:07:16.027
The first is like the carrying capacity of the continent.
1183
02:07:16.187 --> 02:07:18.149
And maybe that's like a stock concept.
1184
02:07:18.729 --> 02:07:23.153
The second is the economy's
ability to absorb migrants.
1185
02:07:23.253 --> 02:07:24.934
And maybe that's like a flow concept.
1186
02:07:25.014 --> 02:07:31.800
And then the third is like the rate of acculturation of migrants to the mainstream and vice versa.
1187
02:07:33.362 --> 02:07:42.927
if you think that that's a good framework, if you look back over Australian history, which of those three constraints do you think has tended to be the binding constraint?
1188
02:07:44.248 --> 02:07:45.268
So that's a hard question.
1189
02:07:45.288 --> 02:07:58.776
So I think it's probably important to say that up until 1950, migration wasn't managed in the way in which we think about it now.
1190
02:08:00.156 --> 02:08:00.957
The only way...
1191
02:08:02.789 --> 02:08:26.185
The only real two ways the government managed migration was through the volume of assisted passage, which tended to move in line with the economic cycle and by constraining the mix through the Immigration Restriction Act.
1192
02:08:27.157 --> 02:08:41.930
So it's not until the 1950s that you start to see technocratic discussions about the level of immigration and what's optimal.
1193
02:08:44.673 --> 02:08:52.620
And there, at least on the economist side, it was about
1194
02:08:54.997 --> 02:08:59.519
capital investment keeping pace with population growth.
1195
02:09:00.780 --> 02:09:04.281
So it's a pace argument rather than a carrying capacity argument.
1196
02:09:06.382 --> 02:09:16.767
The first kind of period where you see a carrying capacity argument come to the fore is in the early 1970s.
1197
02:09:19.270 --> 02:09:22.671
when it became fattish to advocate for zero population growth.
1198
02:09:23.431 --> 02:09:25.072
Mm-hmm.
1199
02:09:25.092 --> 02:09:35.715
And so it was an early manifestation of the Greens and the Democrats, I think, were advocating zero population in the early 1970s.
1200
02:09:36.455 --> 02:09:39.456
And you started to get the first environmentalists involved.
1201
02:09:41.585 --> 02:09:49.809
arguing on carrying capacity grounds that Australia's population couldn't go past a certain level.
1202
02:09:50.389 --> 02:10:08.596
And then you have, I use this story that I heard Ken Henry tell when I was in the immigration department about a discussion he had on carrying capacity between him and Kevin Rudd after Kevin Rudd became prime minister.
1203
02:10:12.085 --> 02:10:20.148
It's such a good story and I couldn't use it in my book until I found out that Ken Henry had told that story on your podcast.
1204
02:10:21.229 --> 02:10:22.109
And so I've used it.
1205
02:10:22.609 --> 02:10:31.812
And it's a great story because there's this confusion between Rudd and Henry about the number.
1206
02:10:32.833 --> 02:10:38.615
And Ken Henry says he thinks the optimal size of Australia's population
1207
02:10:39.477 --> 02:10:43.918
given the way it manages its resources and so on at the time, was 15 million people.
1208
02:10:44.558 --> 02:10:46.558
Which is kind of a crazy thing to say, right?
1209
02:10:47.899 --> 02:10:57.020
Because Australia's population at the time was, I think, was 21 million and Rudd misheard him and thought he'd said 50 million and Rudd said, great, that's exactly what I thought, 50 million.
1210
02:10:57.040 --> 02:11:06.182
So it's, I mean, I guess Ken Henry was trying to pull him up to make him think seriously about what, what,
1211
02:11:07.185 --> 02:11:11.227
kind of country, Australia, would look like if it had a population of 50 million versus 15 million.
1212
02:11:12.468 --> 02:11:15.449
But I don't think we've had a proper discussion, really.
1213
02:11:15.469 --> 02:11:26.235
There's been various attempts over time to kind of integrate a discussion around population policy and immigration policy, and they've always fallen over.
1214
02:11:27.036 --> 02:11:30.958
They've probably always fallen over because of the vested interests
1215
02:11:33.049 --> 02:11:36.816
in maintaining relatively high immigration intake.
1216
02:11:37.056 --> 02:11:37.296
Yeah.
1217
02:11:37.777 --> 02:11:46.672
So on that, Peter McDonald told me that as far as he's aware, the post-mort migration program is the only...
1218
02:11:48.526 --> 02:12:04.394
The only time a country in history has had an explicit population plan, that is to say a target of we want to get to 20 million and we're going to do it by growing migration through this much migration and this much natural increase.
1219
02:12:05.175 --> 02:12:06.395
It's hard to verify that.
1220
02:12:06.415 --> 02:12:08.537
But does that check out with...
1221
02:12:10.818 --> 02:12:24.052
So I think the idea of the 20 million population target fell away very quickly after World War II and what drove high immigration levels was labour demand.
1222
02:12:25.857 --> 02:12:28.418
fundamentally, and every year.
1223
02:12:29.658 --> 02:12:44.301
So I don't think there was a population plan as opposed to an annual process under the auspices of the Immigration Planning Council advising the minister on what the right level of immigration ought to be in any given year.
1224
02:12:46.121 --> 02:12:50.202
There was a couple of times where they came up with a five-year plan.
1225
02:12:50.802 --> 02:12:52.563
I think there was one published in the late 1950s
1226
02:12:55.196 --> 02:12:59.032
And there's been various attempts by different people
1227
02:13:01.796 --> 02:13:18.241
expert advisors to government on immigration to try to get them to agree to a longer-term migration planning framework, which is de facto, becomes a population policy if you accept that, at least on the natural increase side, demography is destiny.
1228
02:13:18.541 --> 02:13:23.482
And things change, but there's a fair bit of constancy.
1229
02:13:24.143 --> 02:13:28.304
So your migration policy becomes a de facto immigration policy.
1230
02:13:29.242 --> 02:13:40.388
So beyond the 1%, 70,000 people a year target, I mean, Peter might be true that that's not being done in any other country.
1231
02:13:41.809 --> 02:13:52.755
The 1% target was only met for a handful of years in the 1950s because there was a pretty high outflow, which wasn't being factored into thinking properly.
1232
02:13:53.615 --> 02:13:56.797
And that got called out by the Vernon government
1233
02:13:57.562 --> 02:14:06.126
committee report in 1965, which said, if this is your target, you haven't met it for the last decade, and we think it's too high a target anyhow.
1234
02:14:06.826 --> 02:14:08.387
They wanted 0.9%.
1235
02:14:09.467 --> 02:14:26.254
Yet there's been, as I said, various attempts to try to get governments to think about whether a long-term planning framework on immigration, migration, is a good thing to do, but I can't think of any governments that have really kind of gone...
1236
02:14:28.265 --> 02:14:37.889
Yes, we'll do that, partly because they don't really like having decisions that bind them.
1237
02:14:38.970 --> 02:14:44.072
They don't really like having technocrats tell them what the decisions are.
1238
02:14:46.053 --> 02:14:54.357
You see the way the treasurer bristles every month when the Reserve Bank, or every eight times a year about the Reserve Bank setting interest rates,
1239
02:14:57.520 --> 02:15:02.645
And they would much rather have the flexibility of adapting according to circumstance.
1240
02:15:03.005 --> 02:15:04.766
So would it be a good thing?
1241
02:15:04.786 --> 02:15:13.994
On balance, it probably would be better for there to be a bit more certainty.
1242
02:15:14.955 --> 02:15:19.839
It might help state governments do better planning around infrastructure and so on.
1243
02:15:21.941 --> 02:15:23.523
It might help with...
1244
02:15:24.687 --> 02:15:49.905
making the public feel more confident that immigration was being managed well, but it's not going to happen until there's some kind of re-imagination of what a migration program looks like that factors in the level of temporary migration into its thinking and that,
1245
02:15:52.538 --> 02:16:08.876
considers use of capping the number of temporary migration visas in any given period and factors in a period of time under which people can remain as a temporary migrant in Australia.
1246
02:16:09.918 --> 02:16:10.018
Yeah.
1247
02:16:10.038 --> 02:16:10.218
Yeah.
1248
02:16:11.511 --> 02:16:12.332
Final question.
1249
02:16:12.792 --> 02:16:23.558
Could we just pull together a list of some of the things that makes Australian immigration history exceptional relative to other settler countries?
1250
02:16:24.199 --> 02:16:30.523
So, we've just spoken about the fact that maybe Australia is the only country to have had a population plan.
1251
02:16:31.983 --> 02:16:36.086
It was also, I think, the first country in the world to have a dedicated Department of Immigration, which,
1252
02:16:37.760 --> 02:16:43.262
What are some other things that stand out to you as unique about Australian immigration history?
1253
02:16:43.982 --> 02:16:46.763
Again, relative to other
settler societies.
1254
02:16:47.963 --> 02:16:51.365
So we're the only country that's done a sister passage on scale.
1255
02:16:51.605 --> 02:16:51.845
Yeah.
1256
02:16:52.125 --> 02:16:52.325
Right?
1257
02:16:52.345 --> 02:16:55.806
That's – I don't think many people know that it goes back to the 1830s.
1258
02:16:55.826 --> 02:16:56.086
Yeah.
1259
02:16:56.106 --> 02:16:57.007
Right?
1260
02:16:57.087 --> 02:16:57.247
It's –
1261
02:16:59.667 --> 02:17:16.959
And I think the rough magnitude is about three and a half million people came to Australia whose fare was either fully subsidized or generously subsidized, who otherwise probably wouldn't have come.
1262
02:17:17.200 --> 02:17:17.400
Yeah.
1263
02:17:18.200 --> 02:17:21.983
Some of them would have come anyhow and had their fare paid for them, but a fair number of them didn't.
1264
02:17:23.397 --> 02:17:27.680
So no other country did that on the scale in which Australia did over such a long period of time.
1265
02:17:28.541 --> 02:17:33.945
That's probably in many ways more fundamental than having a dedicated immigration department.
1266
02:17:35.806 --> 02:17:36.807
English language training.
1267
02:17:37.716 --> 02:17:42.080
Australia was the first country in the world to offer that.
1268
02:17:42.981 --> 02:17:45.843
She said it started in kind of baby steps in the late...
1269
02:17:45.863 --> 02:17:47.584
It started on board ships, actually.
1270
02:17:47.785 --> 02:17:48.845
And in the camps in Europe.
1271
02:17:48.966 --> 02:17:50.026
And in... No.
1272
02:17:50.487 --> 02:17:51.328
Was it in the camps in Europe?
1273
02:17:51.348 --> 02:17:54.911
It was definitely on board ships, and it was in the camps in Australia, like Bonagilla.
1274
02:17:57.833 --> 02:17:59.915
I don't know whether any other countries have...
1275
02:18:02.651 --> 02:18:08.121
an equivalent to SBS TV and ethnic radio.
1276
02:18:08.141 --> 02:18:11.968
I mean, possibly they do in Canada, I'm not sure.
1277
02:18:13.712 --> 02:18:17.433
But that's been something that Australia's done.
1278
02:18:18.833 --> 02:18:35.057
Australia got a kind of first jump on exploiting the opportunity for people from developing countries to obtain an educational qualification from a developed country.
1279
02:18:36.858 --> 02:18:37.238
We were...
1280
02:18:38.888 --> 02:18:45.973
So in absolute terms, I think Australia ranks third behind the United States and the United Kingdom, but we have a much smaller population.
1281
02:18:46.013 --> 02:18:49.295
So on a per head basis, we've been first in the world for a long, long time.
1282
02:18:50.376 --> 02:18:51.296
Not sure if I'm missing anything.
1283
02:18:51.777 --> 02:18:56.080
We were the first to do mandatory detention for unlawful non-citizens.
1284
02:18:57.540 --> 02:18:59.302
So we haven't discussed this at all.
1285
02:19:00.735 --> 02:19:06.000
We could go for another hour on the question of Australia's treatment of refugees.
1286
02:19:06.180 --> 02:19:26.517
I'm
not sure whether we were the first or not, but it is a fascinating history with lots of suffering involved on the parts of many people about mandatory detention and particularly I think what was notable, I tell this story about the cycle of history moving quickly
1287
02:19:29.927 --> 02:19:56.731
that a mining camp that was set up, I think it was a BHP camp, but it could have been a Rio Tinto camp, but I think it was a BHP camp in Port Hedland being requisitioned to house 21 Cambodian asylum seekers who'd come on a boat and had been held in Villawood for a couple of years and...
1288
02:19:57.556 --> 02:20:02.237
And they were sent to Port Hedland because they would be out of the way of lawyers.
1289
02:20:03.938 --> 02:20:04.898
That's why they were sent there.
1290
02:20:06.678 --> 02:20:18.841
And it's no coincidence that almost all of those camps were set up in areas where it was very difficult for lawyers to go and for the public to protest.
1291
02:20:18.861 --> 02:20:20.221
And...
1292
02:20:24.760 --> 02:20:29.809
You know, people were treated in really inhumane ways.
1293
02:20:30.750 --> 02:20:36.180
They were treated as prisoners and they hadn't committed any offence.
1294
02:20:36.621 --> 02:20:37.342
Mm-hmm.
1295
02:20:38.587 --> 02:20:49.376
I guess one other thing that makes us exceptional is the highest share of overseas born in our population among OECD countries.
1296
02:20:49.436 --> 02:20:50.457
It's not quite that.
1297
02:20:50.477 --> 02:20:52.218
There's some funny wrinkles.
1298
02:20:52.598 --> 02:20:54.540
Oh, is it Luxembourg that beats us or something?
1299
02:20:54.560 --> 02:20:57.062
Luxembourg, Switzerland's about up there.
1300
02:20:57.082 --> 02:20:57.943
Yeah, true.
1301
02:20:57.963 --> 02:20:58.163
True.
1302
02:21:00.935 --> 02:21:01.396
Israel.
1303
02:21:01.676 --> 02:21:03.337
Yeah, yeah.
1304
02:21:03.377 --> 02:21:07.980
Yeah, you could say like for a country with a population larger than 10 million or something, we've got the highest.
1305
02:21:09.060 --> 02:21:26.792
Well, so I think, I mean, everyone thinks, so the US, if we do it the comparison with the US, the US has 50 odd million people in it who are born outside of there and it's more than any other country in the world in terms of the volume of migrants they have.
1306
02:21:27.823 --> 02:21:30.465
And there they make up about 15% of the population.
1307
02:21:30.865 --> 02:21:34.108
Whereas in Australia, I think it's now nudging 32%.
1308
02:21:36.255 --> 02:21:48.987
And it will, given what's happening, you know, even with much reduced immigration intake, it's still going to be rising because it's going to outweigh natural increase.
1309
02:21:49.467 --> 02:21:52.750
So it will continue to drift upwards.
1310
02:21:54.071 --> 02:21:55.012
Somebody's done some modelling.
1311
02:21:55.032 --> 02:21:56.834
It might even be in Alan Manning's new book.
1312
02:21:56.894 --> 02:21:59.376
And he says Australia's going to come out somewhere in the 40s.
1313
02:22:01.128 --> 02:22:06.375
40%, which, you know, it hasn't been since probably about the 1870s, 1880s.
1314
02:22:06.395 --> 02:22:06.615
Wow.
1315
02:22:06.635 --> 02:22:06.935
Yeah.
1316
02:22:06.955 --> 02:22:10.760
Do you know when we'll hit that?
1317
02:22:10.860 --> 02:22:11.040
No.
1318
02:22:11.841 --> 02:22:16.066
I mean, you could do some back of the envelope calculations, but I haven't bothered to try and do that.
1319
02:22:16.086 --> 02:22:16.267
Yeah.
1320
02:22:19.166 --> 02:22:22.208
it's high, right?
1321
02:22:22.228 --> 02:22:22.608
It's high.
1322
02:22:23.529 --> 02:22:34.175
And there's no slowing down in the appetite of people who wish to come to Australia.
1323
02:22:34.475 --> 02:22:45.782
I think one of the things that intrigues me, because it goes partly to this question about living standards and partly about who benefits from migration,
1324
02:22:47.282 --> 02:23:02.129
is if you weight the migration intake by the incomes of the countries from which they come, that weighted average figure has not altered since the 1970s.
1325
02:23:02.189 --> 02:23:02.630
Yeah.
1326
02:23:04.030 --> 02:23:07.312
And world incomes, average world incomes have more than doubled in that time.
1327
02:23:07.832 --> 02:23:15.336
So that means that our intake is increasingly coming from poorer countries.
1328
02:23:16.733 --> 02:23:19.214
This feels important, but I don't know what to make of it.
1329
02:23:19.874 --> 02:23:21.915
It feels important, but I don't know what to make of it too.
1330
02:23:22.635 --> 02:23:35.080
Because, you know, by and large, those people who are coming are coming through skilled channels or they're coming through as spouse of skilled migrants.
1331
02:23:35.800 --> 02:23:43.163
So they've been vetted on their occupations and vetted on their educational qualifications and vetted on their English proficiency.
1332
02:23:44.023 --> 02:23:44.283
And...
1333
02:23:48.040 --> 02:24:01.206
Many of them are doing, as other migrants have done, they're either succeeding in their preferred jobs or they're doing well in their less preferred jobs, but they're making sure their kids are doing really well.
1334
02:24:02.287 --> 02:24:10.350
So, yeah, I mean, what do you think we should make of it, that fact, that we're increasingly taking people from poorer countries?
1335
02:24:11.010 --> 02:24:14.832
I think that's probably true for other countries besides Australia.
1336
02:24:17.178 --> 02:24:30.487
that in the aggregate the overall picture is 4% of people in the world are living in countries in which they were not born.
1337
02:24:31.708 --> 02:24:33.730
So 96% of people are.
1338
02:24:36.331 --> 02:24:39.594
But in Australia it's about 32%, so it's kind of 8%.
1339
02:24:43.097 --> 02:24:45.358
800 times, well, you know, eight times that 4%.
1340
02:24:45.539 --> 02:24:49.281
So it's a huge magnitude difference.
1341
02:24:50.061 --> 02:24:55.524
But in the OECD countries, that 4% becomes about 15.
1342
02:24:56.565 --> 02:24:58.206
It's been rising.
1343
02:24:58.626 --> 02:24:59.666
Yeah.
1344
02:24:59.807 --> 02:25:02.208
And rising in all OECD countries.
1345
02:25:02.808 --> 02:25:09.252
And I think, you know, people like Heinderhass, who...
1346
02:25:11.185 --> 02:25:34.563
analyzes these kind of movements would say you have this kind of development hump where people in very poor countries don't have the resources or wherewithal to migrate and people in rich countries don't need to migrate.
1347
02:25:35.455 --> 02:25:38.176
but it's the countries in the middle of those.
1348
02:25:38.556 --> 02:25:44.918
So you get this inverted U shape about the propensity to migrate from given countries.
1349
02:25:45.198 --> 02:25:55.701
And that's more of the world now is in that hump and have the wherewithal to get to OECD countries.
1350
02:25:55.841 --> 02:26:00.442
And OECD countries have been since the 1990s, as in Australia,
1351
02:26:01.482 --> 02:26:09.910
liberalizing the opportunities for people to migrate to their countries as workers and as students.
1352
02:26:11.391 --> 02:26:19.538
And the pressures for them to continue to do so because of population aging are going to remain high.
1353
02:26:21.340 --> 02:26:23.322
So it's hard to see...
1354
02:26:25.685 --> 02:26:52.825
that tension that exists in almost all OCD countries over migration, dissipating because there's this economic need to find workers to do jobs that locals don't want to do and just to help them manage their shrinking, otherwise their participation rates would come off
1355
02:26:54.120 --> 02:27:00.446
And we haven't not seen that in Australia, which has been interesting and surprising in many ways.
1356
02:27:02.508 --> 02:27:09.995
But we will eventually without continuing to have moderate to high levels of immigration.
1357
02:27:10.275 --> 02:27:10.495
Yeah.
1358
02:27:12.677 --> 02:27:12.937
All right.
1359
02:27:13.538 --> 02:27:14.179
Let's leave it there.
1360
02:27:14.479 --> 02:27:15.059
This has been great.
1361
02:27:15.600 --> 02:27:16.040
Thanks, Mark.
1362
02:27:16.140 --> 02:27:16.421
Okay.
1363
02:27:16.481 --> 02:27:16.741
Thank you.
1364
02:27:17.866 --> 02:27:19.167
I hope you enjoyed this episode.
1365
02:27:19.287 --> 02:27:26.314
If you did, you can support the show by leaving a five-star rating on Apple Podcasts or Spotify or by subscribing on YouTube.
1366
02:27:26.735 --> 02:27:28.196
Thanks to this episode's sponsors.
1367
02:27:28.236 --> 02:27:30.378
You can find them in the episode description.
1368
02:27:30.739 --> 02:27:34.683
And thanks to Bill Manos and the Manos Foundation for their generous patronage of the show.
1369
02:27:35.303 --> 02:27:44.588
If you'd like to become a sponsor or patron, you can go to jnwpod.com slash sponsor or email me at joe at jnwpod.com.
1370
02:27:45.068 --> 02:27:48.810
That's J-O-E at J-N-W-P-O-D dot com.
1371
02:27:49.390 --> 02:27:50.170
Thanks for listening.
1372
02:27:50.330 --> 02:27:51.131
Until next time.
1373
02:27:51.331 --> 02:27:51.571
Ciao.