UDSKRIFT 🔗
speaker-0: Rather than just being a price taker, retail now plays a role in liquidity, in volatility, in narrative.
speaker-1: the more people are invested the more they're forced to be rational critical thinkers. for any democracy, having more rational critical thinkers is a very, very, very good thing.
speaker-2: Gentlemen, introduce yourselves.
speaker-1: Just that.
speaker-0: Yanning Melling, co founder and co CEO of Public.
speaker-1: Life, same thing.
speaker-2: We do have to start with the big macro question, which is what you are seeing in the economy right now from your from your seats, because I know investors have a different view, I think, on the economy sometimes than economists.
speaker-0: So I think we're coming off of a year where, retail investors are getting smarter. They're using more AI tools research is becoming less of an edge for institutionals, which generally tends to happen when you have the democratization of these kind of tools happening. and then at the same time, they have proven again to just be very, very
speaker-1: Resilient.
speaker-0: I think you saw back after the tariff announcements in April that individual investors were some of the first to very confidently buy the dip, which many, I mean most of our users did as well. That turned out so far at least to be a very, very good decision.
speaker-2: if you were to sum it up in three words the economy that was in twenty twenty five, what would those three words be?
speaker-1: Okay, why was one word? No, but like no, but like the the the the dip buying piece and especially the dip buying around the Liberation Day, I think is also one of the core reasons of why it was such a great way up for retail from a gain's perspective. And just that culture that has been that kind of has developed throughout the years now, of the dip buying, kind of habit, I would argue, has so far been playing out well for them. And I think one of the big reasons for it is always that like as a retail investor, most people have a way longer outlook because their outlook is for the rest of their life. And versus like, institutionals who might have to, just get a good year in. And therefore the behavior is very different. And so for them it's like, hey, when I see an opportunity and what with a stock that I like, I'm gonna buy it. Also think that's why retail you know, is so engaged in the AI space in terms of investing theses because they have a little bit this tendency to look at companies and stocks that have some sort of good future story.
speaker-2: I think what was fascinating about the activity behavior around the dip was that they, the retail investor, had enough conviction that it was gonna come back. I mean, given all of the uncertainty, I think the taco trade was a big part of it, right? Trump always chickens out. I mean that to me was really fascinating that they had so much more optimism and bullishness around the cycle versus some of the maybe sentiment that was being thrown out
Load full transcript
there around like all the uncertainty.
speaker-0: I think it's kind of two things, right? if you're a a Democrat, then you might subscribe to the taco theory. If you're a Republican, you most people, the Republicans, just like very much believe in the tariff policy. And so it became this thing where like not a lot of people, I I mean, in the very beginning, obviously market tank, but very quickly a lot of folks were like, actually, there's not really a big kind of negative here. And again, To Leif's point, I think many individuals have realized like they're investing with multi decade Kana Horizon. And so, yeah, there might be a new administration in three years, right? And so people also had that in the back of their minds.
speaker-2: So that's the big picture. Let's get to what you saw on the platform. Were there any big trends or themes that really stuck out to you amongst just your base of users compared to the broader market or any trends that surprised you that you thought, well, maybe our public investors were savvier in these areas or more opportunistic or earlier?
speaker-1: I mean high level first off to Yannick's comment of like it's definitely more of a risk on environment again. We s for your users.
speaker-2: User.
speaker-1: For for our users, like we're seeing a lot of users basically taking money that they had in fixed income and had in like high savings accounts specifically and rotating it into stocks. And also Bitcoin a lot, to be honest. But like that is happening a lot. Where I think in the in the last few years, with rates also just being at this, crazy highs, like we had rates of, five percent plus on, higher cash accounts and so on. And with that dropping and with the trends you're seeing in the public markets, there's a lot of kind of cycling that money into into other asset classes again. Yeah, absolutely. Like volume group.
speaker-0: Grew multifold. and I think and also faster than just sort of account balances or deposits kind of grew. And so I think people, yeah, this is a year where most folks were making a lot of moves. And I think that goes back to the risk-on, the opportunistic sort of mindset. But also, I kind of compare it sometimes a little bit to the pent up travel demand you had after COVID. Like you had a lot of people just sitting in fixed income for a while. Tech stocks were, taking a beating. Now you have this new AI wave. You obviously had Trump coming into office, promising deregulation, tax cuts, et cetera. And so I think generally speaking, for especially the the first sort of three fourths of the year, it was very much game on for individual investors.
speaker-2: Well, what about in terms of the asset classes? Any specific themes, trends that surprised you that really dominated?
speaker-1: We're seeing the very much like still very much the the the the obvious names, from all the big AI names, all the Mag 7s obviously Palantir is always up there with the retail investors and so on. with rates more
coming down, we would expect to see a longer tail of small cap to get more attention again. Right? As borrowing becomes cheaper, investment into growth. becomes cheaper therefore and therefore more small cap should find more attention again. That would be my assumption now, not financial advice. And so that I think that is something that we will likely see play out more now throughout the and I think the other thing is also that I think people are looking a little bit more deeper as like, hey, getting out of the names that everyone else is investing into and like a little bit more on their personal strategies again and stuff like that. That's also by the way what we're seeing with generated assets, right? Of that's AI product we've launched where you can essentially create your own index using using AI. and we see these like really custom point of views that people have on the markets and like trying to find these names that are not just a typical seven or ten names that
speaker-0: And I think just to double click on that, I think the reason for that is this could have been another free words, but like the return of alpha. Like you had a long period from call it eighteen, espe at least especially for twenty twenty and twenty twenty one, where it's just like all beta, all market kind of beta swings, and then all beta down as well, frankly. in twenty two and twenty three. And now, it's been much more of a barbell, obviously. And so with that the return of stock picking, the return of actually having a thesis, having a viewpoint. and I think that has also that's also why you're seeing a lot of growth, especially in the equity sector.
speaker-2: I mean crypto had a bit of a a mixed year, I would say. I mean you had the very rise. Well, I mean, I'm just talking about that one per
speaker-0: Yeah, Bitcoin was actually that.
speaker-2: But but yes, by by the end of the year, yes. I'm curious your perspective on that. Is this the stabilization point that we should be expecting? Or are you expecting to see more volatility and where would that volatility be driven by or or how?
speaker-0: I think it was an interesting year for for crypto because the hero asset Bitcoin was actually down in twenty twenty-five. but at the same time you had so much evolution in the industry of crypto in terms of regulatory frameworks and such. And I think a lot of people were pricing a lot of that in really quickly. And then maybe became a little kind of questionable kind of throughout the year. And then I think maybe year to date in in twenty twenty six at least, people are again realizing, okay, when you underwrite how the industry is evolving, as well as sort of I think a lot of people use Bitcoin to sort of still underwrite how much fiat are being printed by governments around the world. And so I think when Elon sort of left with Doge, the government, et cetera, it that became kind of a moment that a lot of people really kind of thought about. And so I think I think that will continue to be the trend in twenty twenty six as well, in terms of like, will the US government continue to print more money, continue to debase the US dollar, and then you have this macroeconomic argument of like, okay, Europe's doing the same. Actually everyone's doing the same. And then people kinda come back to Bitcoin. And then you are at the same time continuously chopping away at sort of the some of the uncertainties that existed in the past couple of years around The regulatory framework specifically.
speaker-2: People are using it as a hedge, right, against all the currency fluctuations or they're using it as a little bit of marginal diversification.
speaker-1: And
speaker-0: A of people have it as such that's now their biggest percentage range.
speaker-1: I think there's still like there is I think with crypto bitcoin specifically, I think there is always still a lot of concepts floating around like using it as a hedge. I would not argue that it's proven that it actually works as such. you still see how it is very much correlated to the movements in the public markets as well, and therefore correlated to the general macro, conditions, things like, you know, rate cuts, et cetera, et cetera. So like how much it really works as a hedge yet, conceptually, it kinda should likely, I would agree with that. But I think it hasn't necessarily been proven out yet. Which also then means that we just haven't seen enough adoption of it yet for it to be actually playing out like that.
speaker-0: And I think like like people like the equity markets and crypto are still moving kind of closer than anyone realised. I think, you know, then you can talk about are the equity markets in itself a hedge to a a weakening dollar? And there's a case for that. And so from a currency perspective it might be a hedge, but as a sort of as a class relative to equities, I would say it's l it's less the case.
speaker-2: What's been the activity on the platform specifically with ETF adoption of all I mean, there's there was like like a hundred or so, you know, new ETFs that were rolled out tied to different crypto assets and bitcoin
speaker-0: The point I say that's maybe like the next thing that you'll you'll see more of these ETFs. But I I would say you had the Bitcoin had the IPO moment when the ETFs kind of finally launched. And then it went quiet pretty quickly, I would say. we just acquired a business called Alto, crypto IRA, who were among the first to enable individual investors to hold crypto assets in their retirement accounts. That's still something people want to do, much more than just owning the ETF and owning the wrapper. and obviously at the same time, you're coming to the end of some of these campaigns that a lot of the Bitcoin ETFs had were like no management fees for the first year or two or whatever. And so I think this is not to say that we've seen terminal scale adoption in any way, shape, or form. I just think the ETFs initially maybe they're
better suited for institutional investors. because There you had a situation where maybe it was actually a ten X better product for individual investors. They're questioning is it a better way to get exposure to Bitcoin in the first place? But obviously some institutional investors can't go and buy Bitcoin on chain or haven't been able to historically at least. And so that's I think an area where there was like very clear appetite. But then yeah, I I would say people really individually still like the real thing for like a bit
speaker-1: ETF has
speaker-0: I would say been Market expansion.
speaker-1: People that before did not engage with crypto are now engaging with crypto through the ETFs. And I think the folks that fall into that segment, I would say the the, population that has done it so far is likely crazy, crazy, crazy, crazy tiny. You know. And that's, you know, why the argument likely is that there's still a lot of room to grow because comparatively speaking, the the the the ETFs, I've I would say are still very early in terms of adoption because it like hits a whole different set of people, right? The the the one big thing that people always talk talk about is financial advisors specifically, until it trickles to the system of, internal compliance team to be okay with, you know, potentially advising people and recommending people and having a part of their portfolio in, cryptocurrencies and then through the wrapper of the ETF, then them having conversations with their clients, those clients wrapping their head around it, then putting some money into it, potentially betting for the next tax year, yada, yada, yada yada. And and then the amount of assets that in retail investors still sit with advisors as well. You know, again also skews is older, therefore the reaction time likely is much slower, you know, to adapt these new assets and understanding them, et cetera, et cetera. And so there's still, I think, so much that is still trickling through the system to really get to the adoption on the ETF side. that it will take some time. But I think that's these these are just different segments and I think the instruments are just are being adopted by different segments of the market.
speaker-2: two two really different sets of investor DNAs, ones that will dip directly into that pool versus being invested through the wrapper. let's talk about generated assets, which is this new product that you launched about a month ago. For those who are not as familiar, sum it up for for everybody. Because to me, and I know there are some reasons, like if I were to write the headline that generated assets are D I E T Fs. When I get a phone call from your PR department saying that headline isn't accurate.
speaker-1: You would you would get a phone call from our compliance team that that is any accurate?
speaker-2: Yeah, so let's talk
speaker-0: so here's the thing.
speaker-2: about why ETF sounds great, branding for me.
speaker-0: I'll I'll kind of recap how it works. So we've basically built this generated assets tool, which is a prompting tool where you can prompt your own index. So you could go like, Hey, give me companies that do well if global inflation stays structurally higher than three percent. Or more qualitative ones like, let me invest in CEOs who tend to underpromise and over deliver on earnings called. Or even sort of like people are calling now remixing indices, where like give me the top quarter of the S B five hundred. And the top corner of the NASDAQ, within that, take out companies with too much debt, or that might be affected by tariffs, double exposure to companies in the AI sector instead. And then you basically hit go. Like it could be whatever prompt you want. You hit go, you get a full back test, benchmark against the SP 500 on returns, volatility, drawdown. And then you can invest in it directly on public. The way you invest in it is more of a direct indexing mechanism. So The reason you couldn't call it a DIY ETF is because ETF stands for exchange traded fund. This is not it traded on the exchange. This is unique to you as unique to the public platform. And there's a lot of power that comes with basically building this in the technology layer versus it living on the exchange. And some of those things are you are the direct shareholder of the underlying assets, which enables things like tax loss harvesting at the end of the year. Other way you can also vote the shares, which is another thing I think we saw people care in an increasingly amount about in 2025, specifically with the Tesla vote. and then you also just have the ability to turn these around much faster, right? So if you write the prompt with the 3% sort of inflation companies that do well in that environment, it will rebalance sort of back to that prompt as well. And it will suggest to you, hey, if you now you might have companies that do better or worse relative to when you wrote the prompt in the first place. So it's a much more dynamic product. there's a ton of benefits to it and that's why we've seen a a lot of traction on that.
speaker-2: Right, so how much traction are we talking about? And just give us a sense we're we're speaking today, mid mid January. So officially I think you opened or you you started to roll it out at the beginning of twenty twenty six or was it at the end?
speaker-0: No, no, no. we rolled it it was like yeah, the holidays kind of thing, which actually anybody will tell you is a terrible time to launch a product.
speaker-1: A week before Thanksgiving.
speaker-2: Great, great timing, yeah, okay.
speaker-0: But nevertheless, I think we're inching actually close now to a hundred thousand generated assets created.
speaker-2: Since pre Thanksgiving time. Yeah.
speaker-0: over the holidays kind of thing. and so it's it's definitely, I mean, I think it's it's been one of the most kind of viral launches we've ever done as well.
speaker-2: On average, how many generated assets are users
experimenting with and
speaker-0: I don't actually know that number, to be totally honest.
speaker-2: Do you have like you have like hyper
speaker-0: I mean, they're definitely they're definitely so I I'll tell you some of the feedback that we've gotten and this is also something that we're working on that's kind of coming soon. You definitely have people that love to tinker with this stuff that have multiple worldviews and thesis around the market. And again, it's it's stuff that a typical thematic ETF would not cover, So instead of just like ETF healthcare sector, it's like give me an index what companies that will benefit from the rise in medical costs. And so it's it's a little bit more specific, it's more targeted. And so you have a lot of users doing that. And then you have a lot of users that are very, very eager to see what other users are doing. And that's that's an area where we are going to launch a fast follow soon.
speaker-1: More discovery for people to to see what other people doing, inspiration you can say and so on.
speaker-2: Right, the social component I think might be coming back where I think you talked about this with with Josh Brown around like sharing my playlist, sort of features that is something like the That is how you I mean who who should be sweating under their collar a little bit here? Like if you are a fund manager or you are a financial advisor, like should you
speaker-1: It kind of it kind of attacks two things, right? One, obviously ETFs, because ETFs are currently cookie cutter are not personalized, right? That's the that's like the obvious one.
speaker-2: Like State Street should like nervous.
speaker-1: You said it, not me. and then and then obviously there is an aspect of financial advisors where generated assets is a good example where it also already kind of attacks a little bit of it, right? There's like when we look at financial advisors, we're often talk there's like these three aspects that they do, right? One is like groundwork. Yeah. For you to like help to set up strategies. Tax loss harvesting is a good example, right? the second is like, advice, which is like essentially opinions. on top of research. Yeah. and then the last is essentially emotional support.
speaker-0: Yeah.
speaker-1: Like huge something is happening in the markets, who can I call to just like feel better? You know, and like talks it off the ledge or whatever might be. and you can really see how like AI is kind of taking one by one these different aspects of it. You know, I mean we'll see when you have enough of the emotional relationship with your AI that they will be the ones you call an emotional in an emotional
speaker-2: Well you're embarrassed to ask a question of somebody else, right? Yeah.
speaker-1: that's exactly and I think I I I actually think that is a massive point, to be honest, where also why people have financial advisors and so on. it's just this notion of, being a little bit afraid of asking the wrong questions
and looking stupid. And and therefore it's like, I'm not gonna even gonna gonna discuss what you're setting with me because if I ask questions I feel a little bit embarrassed and bad about it. So just do what you say and it's gonna be okay, which can be bad as well, right? And so
speaker-0: The other side is like in our world, very few things are a zero sum game. Like generated assets can continue to grow exponentially and ETFs can continue to grow at the same time. Because unlike Apple who might run out of people to sell iPhones to, there's always more assets being generated, both in terms of equity value, the money supply continues to be increasing. So in that world, both things can be true at the same time. But I agree with life. I think it's it's a it's a larger topic around AI that, especially with sort of the digital generation, you're dealing with a generation that is way more financially literate. Recent investors just had a fantastic year, the best year ever. Sort of the the spread between the average hedge fund institutional gains and the average individual are becoming smaller and smaller. And so I think you then look at the three hundred and seventy five thousand something financial advisors in this country that I believe have an average age around sixty years old. maybe that is not a great space to be. I always think like in any industry with AI, there's always gonna be, if you're the best of the best, you're never gonna have a problem. But to be very straightforward, if you're mediocre, I think you're gonna have a tough time as a financial advisor serving the sort of millennial or and especially the Gen Z generation who will grow up in a world where they have access to tools like this.
speaker-2: Yeah, I mean this is a big theme that I cover on Macro Talk is, the future of work. And, you know, I said it kind of as a joke, but really it is kind of a warning or a signal to some people who are in this space that they should be worried about their jobs if they're mediocre, if they're not able to connect. if you are a financial advisor looking at something like a generated assets come online or you're, you know, a fund manager, what should you be doing to increase your own alpha and your own edge, the competitive edge in this environment where it is more DIY
speaker-0: I'll I'll tell you one s thing that you maybe can interpret as a signal. A lot of financial advisers are very interested in generating assets, like using it for their clients, right? So I think that alone will tell you that and again I think you know AI will play a role there. and you know, speaking of the compound, like this is something Josh talks about too. And so I think folks who are earlier on that will probably do better than folks who don't embrace it. That's generally the arc of technology. and so I think Yeah, I I just think it's gonna be hard. I mean, the the wealth transfer at the same time is so big that like you can have ten new hundred billion dollar companies if only forty percent of it goes to the goes to the new generation and actually the majority still stays with financial advice. It's like this is like how big the wealth transfer is. You're talking a hundred trillion plus dollars. And so and and by the way, and and it that number keeps growing also with market appreciation and it's gonna play out over the next fifteen years. And so you might look back at it and say cumulatively it was like two hundred trillion dollars. So it's just such a massive opportunity that multiple things can be true at at the same time. But we have seen signals that some financial advisors and RA businesses are thinking, okay, this is This is really, really cool and therefore also it's something where I think people realize, hey, if you can do this in twenty, thirty seconds yourself, can you still charge one to two percent as a financial advisor? And that might become tougher. Again, for a generation that has grown up more financially literate, we always call this generation self directed first because everybody's sort of had some exposure to the market since they were very young.
speaker-2: explain exactly how you're ensuring the risks are are tampered down.
speaker-0: So when you type in a prompt, the AI will interpret your prompt. What it actually does under the hood is it farms that out to a swarm of agents. You could think about it as like there is an AI agent that is a stock analyst for every stock in the market. And so they very specifically evaluate a stock that they know very well against a certain criteria. And so that's sort of one step. in obviously reducing what you would typically would call sort of hallucinations or or kind of quality issues. Then that gets rolled back up to the master agent, which presents everything, but everything is presented with a relevancy score from zero to a hundred that you can click and actually see a description of why that company was chosen. And this has become hugely educational for folks because you have a lot of companies today, especially some of the conglomerates, that have exposure to many different things, right? And so, if you have a company that owns a little bit of like a like people forget of things like Amazon owns Twitch and some of these things, right? That doesn't mean that if you're building a live streaming portfolio, Amazon should be a hundred a hundred, but maybe it should be ten or twenty and it should still be included to some extent. And and I think that has been one, a very educational thing that that we've sort of seen about the future. But again, it also helps people catch if there's something that they don't necessarily agree with. Because I think what's important to understand is This is not like a black box, sit it and forget it. I think when we build AI products, we actually have the opposite kind of principle. We wanna make everything as transparent as humanly possible. I think finance have had enough black boxes historically. We don't
need more of those. And and I also think that's how you get user adoption on these things. Like people need to be able to to kind of see why the AI arrived at the results that it did. And then it's very much still a copilot experience. So if there's something you don't agree with, you can hover and X out and and that company is no longer and it kind of reruns the back test immediately.
speaker-2: But the risk is ultimately one that the user chooses and so then you have hands off on the ultimate
speaker-1: You you make the last decision of what the thing is you're investing into and you have full control over what's in it and what the allocations are and all that kind of stuff, and you see the underlying data points, underlying reasons of why something was picked, etcetera, etcetera.
speaker-2: So the choice that someone makes if the prompt was written in a way that maybe wasn't the most accurate or precise and it came up with an allocation that yielded a result that the customer or the user is unhappy with. it's sort of like, Well, you you bought it, so you kinda have to live with it.
speaker-0: Exactly. At the end of the day, you're you're kind of still buying it, but I mean, in that moment you're reviewing everything and explains in the experience actually why it made those picks. It's also not you're not trying to one-shot things, like you will continue to iterate. So this is the behavior that most people are doing. They'll be like, Okay, I actually didn't want this company. Can you remove companies that have less than 10 billion market cap? Because I didn't really specify that in the first prompt and I don't want to invest in penny stocks. So it's like I said, it's very much a co-pilot experience. think about it more like a cursor than one of these other companies that just like tries to write all the code for you automatically in a black box and deploy it It's more like you're using it as a kind of sparring tool, but ultimately still with the benefit of you being able to build your own index fund in or your own index in minutes, get the full backtest, get the full sort of ratings of diversification, volatility, historic drawdowns and everything else. And that's a big, I mean, a lot of quants have reached out and be like, Can I best this tool for myself?
speaker-1: In your example, yeah. It would be more buyer's remorse in terms of I've already agreed now that I wanted to buy this and now I've invested and now I feel like maybe I should have done something different. That obviously happens to anyone who then makes a decision and then changes their mind.
speaker-2: Got it. So it's the same as if they were just buying Apple at the wrong time and lost money. And so that they they understand that. really curious on just the evolution of the products that you are building How are you making these decisions and prioritizing the rollout?
speaker-0: Technology piece is obviously critical. I mean, obviously, hence all the stuff that we've done and continue to do in AI. But I think we kind of think about it more as we believe there's a huge gap in the market for someone that wants to build a sophisticated portfolio, but in a simple way. Like historically, there was always a big trade-off there. Sophisticated tend to mean complicated, simple tend to mean gamified. And there's a lot of folks that are looking at their life savings are like, I don't want any of those two things. And so really the way we think about it is like we're building a very deep set of products, hence why we've rolled out treasury bonds and fractional corporate bonds and things like multi-asset, multiple different account types we've rolled out as well. Very sort of heavy in terms of research, access to financials, et cetera. So definitely for the sort of more the user that that wants to build something sophisticated that can stand the test of time, but don't want to sit there with six screens and trying to be that person either. And that's why a AI is actually a really, really interesting technology because I think it's a platform shift and in many ways a user interface shift that can help people achieve that even more.
speaker-2: So your your TAM is quite narrow and like kinda defined kind of person. I'm wondering when you look at competitors out there and the inclusion of things like prediction markets as part of, I don't know, for funsies or people who actually think, you know, I was talking to some other reporters in this space and the institutional investors who are actually interested in prediction markets, they are sort of like Jones in for some action. So with like all the passive stuff that's out there, like the funds, they're like, Okay, we need to like you know, add a little bit more risk into our life. So we'll we'll kind of play with this. And so I'm curious your perspective on where prediction markets come into play with financial markets. Is it all gambling at the end of the day? Do you find yourselves wondering how it could fit into the portfolio of someone who is sophisticated but just wants to have a little play money on the side, or if you think it could be a more sophisticated tool?
speaker-1: So events contracts, first off, obviously is an instrument. And then the question is what is this instrument being used for? Right. And, like the first events contracts of when was it like nineteen nineties or something when they came out, right? But it really is a question of like how it's used, right? And obviously you could argue that right now, you know, a lot of platforms are kind of stretching maybe a little bit the, you know, use case, let's call it. and you know there are some potential regulatory arbitrages around things like sports, betting and so on. And so what we kind of look at it is like it's an instrument, there is a place generally for events contracts for sophisticated investors and certain use cases, but it depends on the underlying use case of it.
speaker-2: Give me some examples.
speaker-1:
So we, for
speaker-0: Yeah.
speaker-1: example, like will not necessarily go into sports, but for example. having events contracts on specific macro events, can make sense. to dissect, for example, events around companies can make sense, right? So like being able to trade a specific EPS versus just how the market responds to the overall earnings call and things like that. Because you might have your forecast of like and run your models on where the EPS might come out of, but you might not know how the overall market, r reacts to everything else around it. And so like there are certain things like that that that that I think can can can really make sense.
speaker-0: Anything that correlates with your portfolio, I think is something that we think is interesting. Whether the stealers win on a on a on a Sunday night or whatever, it tends to have very little to do with the price of the S P five hundred the next day. That's called zero correlation in finance speak. And then you have some of these other things like where rates going to be. Where do CPI where CPI numbers gonna flush out? the the political stuff obviously have massive implications for the average person's kind of stock portfolio. and that's something that, yeah, generally we think is is quite interesting for people to use either as a hedge or as something where they just wanna add some exposure for whatever reason. And and so that's I think a very interesting use case.
speaker-2: Last couple of questions here, just on the K ship economy. I mean, that has been sort of the dominant talking point and theme that everyone's like worried about, watching very closely. Is that being reflected at all in the investing behavior if you're looking at your users or are your users generally more of a certain household income level?
speaker-1: Yeah, I think it sh so our users are more on that top end of that K, you know. And I think that is that is obviously like what we're seeing. I think the the general sense here is that the wealth disparity in the US is just showing more and more and more. And that then also leads in our space, for example, to companies to, behave a certain way depending on who's the person we're actually serving. Right. So the example right now of like, call it, sports betting and stuff like that, to be more broader, that kind of falls in a little bit often also to, basically being sold to more lower income people because in that world it's like, hey, it's really hard for me to really build wealth, you know. I don't want to say I've given up, but maybe like my my hope around that, upon it, you know, is you know, it might be, you know, not that it's highest peak right now. And so therefore I'm looking for outlier returns. So if I have some money around, I don't care about making five percent or s ten percent a year. I care about how can I have, a two hundred percent return on this, And then the risk of me to being like, okay, I might have a ninety percent chance of losing this, but I
have a ten percent chance of 10xing it, therefore I will take that bet, Versus in the upper end, it is about the compounding of the wealth and the people who are truly benefiting of, the performance of the stock market because they have money they can put into the markets
speaker-0: first place. And it's also exactly it's like the lower end of the K is speculation, the upper end of the K is compounding.
speaker-2: in the minds of of you know people who are worried about this. They see this as introducing products that may entrench certain people into bad behaviors. And then for others they might say, Well if you're savvier you can manage this. How worried are you about how widespread this could get? I mean there were jokes about the golden globes and in poly market and I mean being shown on screen.
speaker-1: Yeah, I mean so I can also say the thing of like selfishly speaking for our business, I'd love for more Americans to do better and be more financially successful because those are the people that for example we're serving and so if that cohort becomes bigger, selfishly speaking, fantastic. Okay. All right. And so and so generally speaking, like yeah, like, you want we want people to do well.
speaker-0: And it goes back to like why do we have a K-shipped economy in the first place? And a big reason for that is some people, when sort of the the rally started and obviously you've had a number of dips, but like now it's the AI rally. Before that it was maybe like the cloud rally, et cetera. Some people bought into that before it rallied, other folks didn't. Largely I think I I think that's there's a few reasons why this is, but this is number the This is one of the greatest reasons that there's such a K-shaped economy, because you don't actually see that all places in the world, but also the participation in the equity markets is actually much lower elsewhere in the world on a sort of average basis. and then you have other things like these I think they're called Trump accounts now, the thousand dollar they they had a couple of different names. The thing that Grad Bersner has been very vocal about, we've put out some stuff around that as well. that I think is fantastic, right? Like that I think is something that every other continent should look at and be like, that just makes a ton of sense. Like that argument is is there are very few argument in the world the policies is like a hundred percent pure. But I think the way Brad has positioned that or if it like that is just like a massive net positive and I don't think anyone can say anything different.
speaker-1: Generally speaking, a big believer in that the more people are invested in the US economy, aka the US markets, and have skin in the game there and learn therefore by that forcing function of being invested, the more they're forced to be rational critical thinkers. And for any democracy, having more rational critical thinkers versus everyone just being emotional is a very, very, very good
thing. Right. And so again from a bunch of new generations now having an account to start and there are more people being forced to, adapt this rational thinking which you do when you're in invested in the markets and that critical thinking. early in their lives and so on, and having a chance to compound that over time and to bring them on a certain path mentally, so to say, I think is a very, very healthy thing for society at large and the and the health of democracy overall, so to say.
speaker-2: Any last words, thoughts on twenty twenty six, the markets? Anything that you wanna make a prediction about
speaker-0: you know, when we started the company back in twenty nineteen when we launched, I think retail participation was like five, six, seven percent maybe of volumes. Now it's thirty I believe. And so that has grown tremendously in a short amount of time. and that's just the share and I think the markets overall.
speaker-2: How much of that share do you think comes from you guys?
speaker-0: No idea. But but I think the important dynamic that you're starting to see is that rather than just being a price ticker, which has always been the case for retail, retail now plays a role in liquidity, in volatility, in narrative. And I think you're starting you you saw that with multiple companies in in 2025. And I think you'll see a lot more of that going into 2026.
speaker-2: How do you think companies have changed with more retail participation? Like on the sort of social good side, I feel maybe you have more accountability, maybe
speaker-1: I think most haven't yet to be honest. I think well I think most peop most public companies have not truly embraced retail in that regard yet. And I think there's certain companies also
speaker-0: Early there. It's so early there. How many Alex Karps are out there? Like some companies really get it. Like I think you you sort of have a list of, you know, a bunch of them, but you are still, I mean, Elon Musk was arguably the the sort of case zero for somebody that could really speak directly. He was the first person to bring like just Tesla fans onto earnings calls and such. and I think Alex Cobb is doing a version of that. And I think you'll see a lot more of that. Just like dynamic COs that talk directly to the end retail investor rather than kind of going through layers of of of bankers and whatnot. Twenty twenty five was a a great year for that trend, but I think the slope will be even higher in twenty six.
speaker-1: I I actually think that like a lot of CEOs are gonna flip with this from an earnings call being something that they're kinda dreading and being like, ugh, earnings call next week, ugh, to something that they're excited about. Because speaking to retail and speaking therefore also to shareholders that have a long term belief in your company and buy in also into your future story, not just into the next quarter is something that I think most CEOs and founders are getting very excited about. And then the format likely also being different, you're gonna see more video, you know, earnings calls as well, et cetera, et cetera, will make a lot of CEOs suddenly being excited about going, on earnings calls versus dreading them.
speaker-0: Once you see more video, you're s gonna see more cuts for social media, short form things. Again, when is the last time you scrolled through your social media feed and you saw like an excerpt from an earnings call? Like it happens very rarely, right?
speaker-2: Jack Dorsey did this a little bit when he was at Twitter. I wanna pick this up in a separate conversation because I think there's a lot more to talk about. I think that companies probably need to change to answer to a lot more people. So let's leave it here for now. Thank you guys so much
speaker-1: Thanks for coming by,