UDSKRIFT 🔗
00:00:02
Speaker 1: Hey there, folks. It is Friday, November 20th, and we are just getting word that it has happened again. Another case of the head of a family killing his entire family. Welcome to this episode, another episode of Amy and TJ, in which we are, babe, shockingly... talking about another familicide, or as they say, family annihilation case. What is happening?
00:00:38
Speaker 2: And here's the crazy part. The end of this familicide was actually captured on a 911 call. How about that? So the final moments of this horrific, unthinkable tragedy were actually heard by someone on the other end of the phone. Can you even begin to process that?
00:01:01
Speaker 1: Okay. That is a twisted detail. It adds to some headline making.
00:01:11
Speaker 2: Yes.
00:01:12
Speaker 1: It adds to a lot there, babe. And it adds to the impact this has on some first responders. Babe, why is this happening? Again, this is three kids under the age of five.
00:01:28
Speaker 2: Correct.
00:01:29
Speaker 1: Who were just taken out by their own daddy.
00:01:33
Speaker 2: Yes, and then daddy took out mommy and then killed himself.
00:01:38
Speaker 1: What is going on?
00:01:41
Speaker 2: I don't know, and this all happened in the afternoon. Yesterday afternoon, as of this recording, this happened on Thursday around 3.30 p.m., That was November 19th. So yes, literally from this recording about 24 hours ago. And what could possibly have been going on that would have led to this? We don't know. And like in so many of these cases, we may never actually know because everybody is gone. And in most of these cases, there isn't. A suicide note. There isn't some sort of final goodbye. There isn't some explanation. We're all left, and the people who loved this family and knew this family are almost always left guessing and wondering what could possibly have led to this, and what signs did we miss?
00:02:32
Speaker 1: And we should say what we know and we don't know right now. This is new.
00:02:36
Speaker 2: Yes.
00:02:37
Speaker 1: And so they haven't released the names of the victims. Obviously, people there in the community know who they're talking about, but They haven't officially released the name of the victims, the name of the husband, the shooter, if you will. But there is not an ongoing threat to the community. They do believe this was a murder-suicide. So we're waiting to get all those details. But, baby, what is possibly happening at 3.30 in the afternoon in a home on an afternoon in Florida? This is Plant City, Florida, which is at Tampa. It's about 30 miles away from Tampa to the east. What could be going on at 3.30 in the afternoon?
00:03:17
Speaker 2: It's hard to imagine, but on Thursday, Hillsborough County dispatchers received that 911 call. And at first, no one was responding on the other end of the phone.
00:03:30
Speaker 1: Do I have right? They never actually talked to anybody, did they? It was an open line.
00:03:34
Speaker 2: So they don't hear anybody actually say, hey, I need help, nothing like that. Dispatchers are listening in. And that's when they heard a man say... sorry buddy, and then after that, a loud bang, which we can only assume was a gun firing a bullet, and then a small child, this is how they're describing it, begging for his life in the background. That is what we're told, and they actually do go into some details.
00:04:08
Speaker 1: The set is a... Yes. The voice was a male voice?
00:04:11
Speaker 2: Yep. They say in the distance you can hear a small child begging for his life, and this is the quote that I see pretty much everywhere. Dada, Daddy, please don't shoot me. Daddy, please don't kill me.
00:04:25
Speaker 1: I hope they never release that 911 tape.
00:04:27
Speaker 2: God, no. Then they say they hear another three... Or four times of begging. So this child went on and on and on. And then another bang was heard. And the begging stopped.
00:04:41
Speaker 1: I don't know. These are part of public record and whatnot. I hope they never release that. I know some news organizations, but I hope they never. I hope that never gets out.
00:04:50
Speaker 2: Well, this never needs to go to trial.
00:04:52
Speaker 1: I hope that never gets out.
00:04:54
Speaker 2: So there's no reason why that 911 call ever needs to be heard. Look, I know these first responders. I know these dispatchers are trained to handle just the most horrific of times. thinkable. And yet when you actually imagine having to process receiving a phone call like that, hearing that on the other end, and then also being a first responder who has to then 10 minutes later, by the way, it only took 10 minutes for first responders to get to the scene of that home, but they.
00:05:29
Speaker 1: Actually, where was it? I saw that note.
00:05:31
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:05:31
Speaker 1: 10 minutes is a, it's a long time. Like, is this, they're out in a particular, right? This is not, that's a long time, baby.
00:05:38
Speaker 2: From a 911 call to that, that must have been the closest deputies that were nearby. But they got there 10 minutes later and they saw a child they described as appearing lifeless inside the home when they walked around the residence. Because look, they don't know if they have an active shooter. They don't know if this... person, daddy, who was identified at least by the 911 call, if they're still alive, if they still have a gun. Um, so they ultimately decided to kick in the front door to stop the threat. You got to give that to them, man. Think about how brave those first responders had to be. And I know they're trained to do this, but still, I, I still have to imagine like knowing that was the 911 call you're walking into knowing that a domestic dispute is by far the most dangerous situation a police officer can walk into.
00:06:29
Speaker 1: Yeah.
00:06:30
Speaker 2: You know, to have to go in and you see a child is dead. You can see from the outside looking in. And you kick in the front door
Load full transcript
in the hopes that you're hopefully saving a life. Unfortunately, it was too late.
00:06:54
Speaker 1: They find five people dead. The man dead. what they believe is a self-inflicted wound. Three kids dead, woman dead, kids ages one, three, and five. Robes, I haven't seen anywhere yet any response or reaction from neighbors, people who know the family, to suggest anything about what might have been going on. If there were issues, if he had issues, and what we have often seen in these cases, and we have seen a lot in the past six months, something has recently shaken the family and the man in particular.
00:07:43
Speaker 2: Yes.
00:07:44
Speaker 1: Lost job, lost status, relationship found out, something.
00:07:51
Speaker 2: Yes, exactly. And look, at this point, it's early days. It's early times. Yes. So we don't have those details, but we know that that has typically been the case. We do know this, that police have never been called to this house for any sort of disturbance. Neither the dad or the mom had any sort of criminal history. But that all fits in line with... With the familicides we've been talking about, unfortunately, throughout this year, there are hallmarks of what kind of man ends up committing this kind of unthinkable crime. And almost all of them are educated. They're family-centered. They don't have a history of violence. There aren't criminal records. There aren't even documented cases of domestic violence. And so, unfortunately, these are... Men who tend to snap, literally, and there's some sort of shame, like some impending shame or doom that's falling upon them or their family, and they feel like they decide that as the patriarch of the family, it's better to have everybody not be here instead of just taking his own life.
00:09:01
Speaker 1: The elderly Ohio State professor.
00:09:04
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:09:04
Speaker 1: Right? The thread of pictures... coming out from some nudie pics that he exchanged with some woman online he was afraid of those as soon as she threatened to put those out that woman that same day he kills it that idea of shame and this was a 40-year professor at ohio state university i mean respected guy so to that point it is how do you identify who is capable of this.
00:09:30
Speaker 2: It's really tough and already started to look at some of the pictures that are just starting to populate online of this family. And it just, you never, when you look at the pictures, you would never be able to predict this type of violence. And look, from the latest reports that are coming out, this is somebody who had a 14-year marriage, had just taken his wife out on a date night the day before. His sister-in-law has been talking to the press and is talking about just how nobody saw this coming. They're claiming they've all been blindsided, that there was no indication he was suffering from any kind of mental health issues. There was nothing, according to these early reports, That led anyone to believe that anything could
be wrong, where he would take such a dramatic... I mean, this is just an unthinkable crime. Obviously, there had to be something. It's just that no one around him was aware.
00:10:37
Speaker 1: And who knew? I mean, we'll learn plenty more, as we often do in these cases and what we often... I don't know. Sometimes we don't learn about signs and signals and things that were missed. Yes, there's mental illness in some cases. In other cases, these are guys, as we speak of, are upstanding members of the community, upstanding guys who have great jobs and are great family men in many cases. Who knows? It's just... As we wait for details, the thing that's unmistakable here is a pattern, is something going on. There's almost 10 I can come up with off the top of my head. How is that possible that there have been that many of these? And is this a situation? We were just talking about it with a woman in Minnesota, right? Just killed her two kids.
00:11:33
Speaker 2: Yes.
00:11:35
Speaker 1: Are people seeing this on television and the Lindsay Clancy story on television and in some way being triggered or inspired, quote unquote, to do something like that? That's the fear. Are people getting the idea of this when things are going bad in their lives, things are falling apart in their lives, that this is triggering something?
00:11:57
Speaker 2: I do think we have to consider that being a possibility. And when we come back, we're going to talk about some of these other recent familicides. And yes, it's hard not to draw a connection between all of these cases. Welcome back, everyone, to Amy and TJ. This, unfortunately, is another horrific case of a, they call it familicide. Isn't this also considered a patricide, where you have the male head of the household taking out his entire family, his children, his wife, and then himself? And we've just seen this time and time again this year. There's a pattern that began. We started I think documenting it, so to speak, in April. And we have been shocked by how many other cases have just continued to pop up in the headlines week after week, month after month. We've lost count at this point of how many similar circumstances have ended in this type of tragedy.
00:13:15
Speaker 1: That is a true statement. We have lost count. It's remarkable to think that there have been, I think, what, March, certainly April or May.
00:13:26
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:13:27
Speaker 1: When several of these started. And there were times since May that we've had two or so in the same week.
00:13:36
Speaker 2: Yep.
00:13:37
Speaker 1: But certainly one a month. And on average, certainly one a month that you're seeing cases where there are eight dead, seven dead, six dead, five dead, four dead. And kids that are one year to five and six and seven, it is, these are devastating stories and they're difficult to understand. And it doesn't seem, and we talked about this as well, babe, that it doesn't, how can you prioritize a case that's closed when you're
already short on resources and there are cases that are open? There's no murderer on the loose with this family of eight. That guy killed his family. We know who did it. There's not a whole lot more investigation into what led up to it. Correct. So are we ever going to get that? And short of that, how can you ever find out what's really going on?
00:14:31
Speaker 2: Exactly. And there's never a court case, right? Because all parties are deceased. So you aren't even, you're not having a criminal case. You're not having a civil case. And so with having a court case you don't have headlines without headlines people aren't talking about it and then people forget and I do think that these are really unfortunate because yes you've got these big salacious headlines clickbait oh my god can you believe what happened in this town or with this family the seemingly perfect family living in a beautiful home with a wealthy father providing for this gorgeous family and they're all gone and then No one talks about it again. And I just think that that is unfortunately how these types of stories are swept under the rug because we don't keep talking about them. There's no reason to keep talking about them. There's no justice that anyone's seeking.
00:15:27
Speaker 1: Yeah, I don't know. Then how are we going to understand? Nobody's going back and doing... Like a trial would result in people going back and doing interviews with people who have known that person for the past year, two years, or whatever. And there's no examination of these cases. There's none. So how are we ever going to understand why this is happening? And we haven't yet, authorities haven't yet, taking this on as a problem.
00:15:57
Speaker 2: No, and I think also because we're talking about something we're noticing from state to state to state to state. It's not like it's hitting or sweeping one city or one state so that local officials would take notice. This is a nationwide, and there are no boundaries. There are no barriers. There's nothing that shields anyone from unfortunately becoming a part of the statistics, except for that we do know this is predominantly white men, correct? Yes. who are well off, who are educated, who you wouldn't have suspected something like this from in the first place. And so maybe they don't think about seeking out help because they're this, they're, I don't know, they're in this bubble, they're in this protected, seemingly protected bubble where you don't expect this to happen and then people don't talk about it after it does. But just to name a few, April, Shamar Elkins, look that up. In June, Ryan McFarland in Iowa. In June, Ryan Whiten in Florida. In July, Christopher Kurlakowicz. I used to say it, now I can't say it anymore, in Michigan. Nathan Brown in Minnesota in August. Benjamin Parker in Oregon in August as well. Then you have David Grotnick in New Jersey. Look, we could go on and on. It's just... disturbing and alarming. And we want to point it out because we need to remember and not forget that this kind of thing is happening to try and understand and prevent it.
00:17:31
Speaker 1: Uh, we'll keep an eye on what's happening with this latest incidents in a horrific 911 call attached to this one. But, um, but the bottom line is this has happened again, this time in Florida, uh, A man, according to authorities, has killed his wife and his three young children, age one, three, and five, in another case of family annihilation, another of several we have seen in the past several months. So sorry to be closing out on that note on a Friday, but it's still a story worth noting. I'm TJ for my dear Amy Robach. We'll talk to you all soon.