UDSKRIFT 🔗
00:00:21
Speaker 1: Film Spotting is presented by Regal Unlimited, the all-you-can-watch movie subscription pass that pays for itself in just two visits. See any standard 2D movie, anytime, with no blackout dates or restrictions. Sign up now on the Regal app or at the link in our description and use code FILMSPOT26 to receive 15% off.
00:00:45
Speaker 2: What kind of a show are you guys putting on here today?
00:00:48
Speaker 1: You're not interested in art?
00:00:49
Speaker 2: No.
00:00:50
Speaker 1: Well, look, we're going to do this thing.
00:00:51
Speaker 2: We're going to have a conversation. From Chicago, this is Film Spotting. I'm Adam Kempinar.
00:00:58
Speaker 1: And I'm Josh Larson.
00:00:59
Speaker 2: I still have this.
00:01:00
Speaker 3: Weird feeling that there's some things that I'm not seeing. It's because I don't have anything to hide.
00:01:07
Speaker 2: There have been bigger movies in 2026, but perhaps no bigger surprise than You Can See Everything. Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim's almost three-hour documentary about Elizabeth Holmes tearing up the box office.
00:01:19
Speaker 1: We've got some thoughts. We have a lot of thoughts. We probably have a few questions as well. Plus my reviews of Wildwood and Palme d'Or winner Fjord. That and more ahead on FilmSpotting.
00:01:42
Speaker 2: Welcome to Film Spotting. Just a couple of weeks into its release, Josh, you can see everything is the biggest documentary of the decade. Maybe in a couple of decades, we'll have to get our crack research team on that. Later in the show, after we talk about that film, listeners will share their picks for some of the decade's other notable docs. And we'll have a new poll asking about Martin McDonough's best film.
00:02:07
Speaker 3: Why?
00:02:07
Speaker 2: Well, the Irish playwright turned director comes to theaters this weekend with Wild Horse 9. That stars Sam Rockwell and John Malkovich. I haven't caught it yet. You have.
00:02:20
Speaker 1: And we will discuss it and decide if maybe that is Martin McDonagh's best film. We'll be tackling that one on next week's show.
00:02:28
Speaker 2: You know, we call Martin McDonagh an Irish playwright, but I looked this up today. He did grow up around London, for what it's worth.
00:02:35
Speaker 3: Hmm.
00:02:36
Speaker 1: Interesting.
00:02:36
Speaker 2: Didn't know that. Summered in Ireland, from what I can tell, but grew up around London. Later in the show, you've got thoughts on Wildwood and Christian Munjoo's fjord. Now, when you're pronouncing a word like fjord and knowing just what little I know about it, that one has to be close to your heart, Josh. It's the motherland. It is.
00:02:57
Speaker 1: It is the motherland, man. What Fjord the movie says about the motherland, that's one of the interesting aspects of Munju's Fjord. Yeah, those two together, Munju and Fjord. I hope I'm coming somewhat close.
00:03:12
Speaker 2: Munju's film won the Palme d'Or at this year's Cannes Film Festival. A reminder, Film Spotting is available as a video podcast. You can watch us talk over at youtube.com slash filmspotting. First up, you can see everything.
00:03:26
Speaker 3: So I know you guys invited me to stay here.
00:03:31
Speaker 2: Does any part of.
00:03:32
Speaker 3: You worry about me being here 24-7? I don't think so. But what if I see something that makes you look bad? I think this is the moment in time to capture this story before I'm gone.
00:03:55
Speaker 1: Adam, let's talk about the movie that everyone has been talking about. You Can See Everything, co-directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim. The filmmakers were invited by disgraced Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes and her partner Billy Evans to conduct a series of intimate interviews shortly before she began serving her prison sentence in 2023 for fraud. Fielder and Oppenheim embed themselves and their many, many cameras in the couple's lives. only to come away with far more questions than they had at the start of the endeavor. Similarly, I've had more conversations with people about this movie than any other 2026 release, and I don't think I've come away from any of those with all of my questions answered. What is this strange three-hour artifact? We know it's a hit. This past weekend, it was number one at the box office in its third week of release and Writing for Rotten Tomatoes, our Chicago colleague Eric Childress noted that You Can See Everything is the first non-concert-related documentary to top the box office since Michael Moore's Fahrenheit 9-11 in 2004. Aside from it being a box office success, what is You Can See Everything? An investigative documentary? A celebrity documentary? Is it possible? This is a mockumentary. While discussing the dropout, that 2022 Hulu series dramatizing the Theranos scandal, someone in You Can See Everything describes that series as fiction land. Adam, is that where we are here?
00:05:40
Speaker 2: We might be, Josh. This really is the question. It's not very often we go to the movies anymore, if we ever did, and certainly not a case where we go to documentaries and walk out having to ask ourselves, what did we just see? Not just what do we make of it? What do we think about it? What do we think it's really getting at? But what in fact is that? I certainly haven't gotten that question out of my head since seeing it. And I'll tell you, the only way I have begun to start to process that question is framing it in slightly different terms. Instead of what it is, I've been forcing myself to think about why it is. Why did the subjects who did initiate the project here, why did the subjects want it made? And why did the filmmakers agree to make it? I do think we know the answer to the first question. That is, if we can take anything in this movie at face value. Because the movie opens, if I recall correctly, the opening image, certainly one of the first images we see, is Billy Evans, Elizabeth Holmes' husband, on the bed or on a couch. He's
Load full transcript
lying down and the camera is on a close-up of his face and he's talking to someone on the phone. And he says why the cameras are here. He says what the agenda is. And obviously, I think there's a reason why Oppenheim and Fielder decide to open with that moment. They explain what I think you'd expect. The world thinks Elizabeth is some kind of monster, but they just don't know her. They don't know the real Elizabeth. And I think he remarked something like, what you don't know, you don't fear, or you're going to vilify. So hopefully this vehicle, this documentary, whatever it turns out to be, this will reveal her and reveal her humanity.
00:07:43
Speaker 1: So this would be a variation on the celebrity doc, right?
00:07:46
Speaker 2: Exactly.
00:07:46
Speaker 1: What he's describing, at least.
00:07:48
Speaker 2: Image rehabilitation.
00:07:49
Speaker 1: Yes.
00:07:50
Speaker 2: It's PR 101. And you maybe can wonder then, well, what the point is when she is about to go to jail, as you noted, I think 34 days away or something like that when the movie opens, and she's going away for 11 years and three months. That's been reduced to 10 years and three months, but it's not like she's going to have a chance to be back in the public eye. for some time. She's not going to be interacting with the public, so why does it really matter what anyone thinks of her? Well, maybe there's your answer, actually. She's not going to be in the public eye for a while. Nobody will be thinking about Elizabeth Holmes at all. So a movie, in particular, a movie like this one could be so desirable. A movie that someone like Nathan Fielder would make, one that will surely blur the lines between fiction and reality, one that probably won't devote much time to rehashing the facts of the legal case, the science behind Theranos and the product Edison, which was at the core of Theranos, the downfall of Theranos that has been chronicled in so many different places and in so many different forms, one that will likely confound audiences, right? Spark debate, tons of online discourse, And as a result, do what? Only serve to further mythologize Elizabeth Holmes. And as long as that is happening, that's good for the brand, right? So here's how savvy I think she and Billy ultimately are. Whether the objective was actually to humanize her, to demogul her, and allow for the possibility of audiences to sympathize with her. Or it was to increase the legend of Elizabeth Holmes. They succeeded. I think both of those things happened in my mind by the time you get to the end of this movie. What's more interesting to me, though, is considering what Fielder and Oppenheim's objectives were. And that is where I'm going to kind of dodge your question, but only because I don't want to monopolize too much more time. That's where I can start to wrap my head around what I think the achievement of this film is, but that is going to involve me talking a whole lot more. So I want to throw it back to you, and
I'm going to, as you speak, Josh, I'm going to to stare at you with wide open eyes unblinkingly while you address how important it was to you to consider the motivations, if at all, of the parties involved. And why do you think Fielder and Oppenheim made this movie?
00:10:36
Speaker 1: I mean, it's a psychological whodunit. So this question you're asking about the motivations, I think, is the key thing. And this is part of why I think this has been a hit. This is sort of like gossiping in real time about people who are giving you new material to gossip about in the moment, right? It's where... That's why people are turning to each other in the theater, or you can hear in theaters gasps and... Because this is what we're doing. We're trying to figure out who is after what. And the party split, we think it's right. That's part of the intrigue is that the party split fairly early on. You laid it out, what seems to be going on in the surface. And then we'll get to a point where we will start talking in spoilers, but I think we should do avoid some, even though just about everyone seems to have seen this for a little bit. But you start to see how these questions we're asking about motivation are perhaps might be different for Elizabeth Holmes than Billy Evans. And then the one you're posing now, Oppenheim and Fielder. I do wonder, when it comes to Fielder and Oppenheim, why they chose this project. For one thing, it might have just been because they were both obsessed. I forget if Fielder addresses his knowledge of Holmes before this. It might come up, and I'm not recalling. But maybe they were both, like so many people, obsessed with the figure of Elizabeth Holmes. Now, I went into, you can see everything, knowing very little bit about her. If you had asked me, I would have said, yeah, she was busted for fraud, some sort of medical startup.
00:12:16
Speaker 2: The basics.
00:12:17
Speaker 1: Yeah, the very basics. I just didn't go down the rabbit hole. Those basics didn't intrigue me enough at the time to follow more. But I get it now. I mean, this is such an inscrutable figure, person. And in a way, she's this cipher you can't look away from. I totally understand the obsessions. And so perhaps Oppenheim and Fielder already had that and were like, what? They're asking us of all people?
00:12:48
Speaker 3: Yes.
00:12:49
Speaker 1: Perhaps they were like me and vaguely knew about her and had one interview with her and were like, this is a mystery box we need to spend time with.
00:12:59
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:13:01
Speaker 1: I like to think maybe that was the primary motivation. And then what you have, Adam, is this perfect match. And it is a match of cipher slash ciphers. We can talk about how much Billy Evans is a cipher. I think he begins to reveal more and more of himself as the documentary goes on.
00:13:21
Speaker 2: Absolutely. How much of that is calculated, though?
00:13:24
Speaker 1: A lot of him is revealed early on too, we must say.
00:13:27
Speaker 2: Perhaps.
00:13:27
Speaker 1: But yes, he definitely reveals different sides to himself. It's a perfect match of Cyphers and Inquisitor. Because part of the joy for me is equally, having known equally little about Nathan Fielder, not having watched any of his previous stuff, this is someone who's almost as much of an enigma, it strikes me, on screen as Elizabeth Holmes. Yes. But in different ways.
00:13:52
Speaker 3: Yes.
00:13:53
Speaker 1: And so to have this cipher matched against this Inquisitor is just endlessly fascinating. And I do think I have to take them at their word that their primary motivation in this was to be Inquisitors in that way. And that the story opened up in ways that I think they prompted. I think they came in strategically differently than you might, obviously, if you're going to do a puff piece, and that that opened things up that did genuinely surprise them. And then their interest was probably just magnifies, as it is for us as viewers over the course of these three hours. You just get continually re-hooked in to this, like, drug thing. That I mean, it's it's like it's reality TV. I mean, in its basic form, I think it's way more artful than that. And we can talk about I think it's less exploitative than that at the end of the day. But the same feed we're getting off of it comes back to the gossiping thing is reality TV drug that we're getting.
00:15:10
Speaker 2: So we were largely in the same boat going into this film in terms of only knowing the basics about Elizabeth Holmes, knowing enough to go into this film probably, and also not knowing a whole lot about Nathan Fielder. I know of him. I know of him and his infamy, I suppose, as I know about Elizabeth Holmes probably. I haven't actually watched any of his work, but you talk about going down the rabbit hole. this made me so interested that I did watch the Alex Gibney documentary, Out for Blood, in Silicon Valley, about Elizabeth Holmes, just because I was so curious to learn more about Elizabeth Holmes. And whether what I'm about to say has anything to do with their motivations, consciously, unconsciously, or I'm completely off base, nevertheless, this is how the film works for me. This is what fascinates me about the movie, and how I interpret what I imagine to be what drew them to these subjects, even if it was left unstated by Billy at the beginning of the film, they have to know the PR work that the subjects are trying to engage them in, right? And they probably have considered that Elizabeth and Billy hope to exploit them even beyond that, to that mythologizing point that I was making. Plenty of documentarians have entered into similar contracts. with subjects and had to figure out how they're going to navigate that kind of relationship to fulfill whatever purpose they want to fulfill and to not be taken advantage of. And Nathan, at at least one point, says something along those lines. I don't think he uses the word taken advantage of or that
phrase, but he says that more or less. Like, I don't want to be manipulated by her. It's tempting to say that Fielder... is if you ask someone, if you had to sum it up, well, then what is his goal? I think it would be very easy to say that you watch the movie, he's seeking the definitive truth about who Elizabeth Holmes is, that he wants clarity. He's going to use this unprecedented access and his unconventional inquisitive style to extract this, that maybe he will be the one to get it. And that he does just want to make sense of her. Is she really the fraud that she's been painted to be, that she's been portrayed as, that she's been convicted as? Was the enigmatic, black-clad tech genius the character? Is this vulnerable, innocent, incessantly naive, and an almost helpless wife and mother the character? Which one is it? Well, by golly, Nathan Fielder is going to get to the bottom of all this, but I don't think that's it. I don't think that can be it, because Fielder has to know what we all know, which is she is a fraud. She simply is. There's too much evidence to suggest that she is, and he is familiar with that evidence.
00:18:22
Speaker 1: And to that point, he begins the questioning early on. The line of questioning is, already assuming she is, because what he starts with is, you really don't think you did anything wrong. So he's already starting from a point of assuming guilt based on her actual convictions. And I think that does, at least to your point, suggest an interest beyond the, you know, who is this person really? He's kind of accepted she's a fraud, which just makes more interesting the level of, you said documentarians go into this in other situations. Yes, commonly. How often do they go into it knowing that the person has been convicted of deception? So it's a deceptive trap they're walking into with a deceiver.
00:19:07
Speaker 2: Right. Whether or not she has changed at all, well, like anybody else, she has changed. Life has changed for her as she's become a wife and a mother. And she may be different. And maybe there are aspects of the way she is portraying herself now that are authentic. But she was fundamentally a liar. She still is a liar because, as we see, she simply will not accept any accountability whatsoever. So we know who she is. Nathan Fielder knows who she is. I think there is actually clarity there. And if the definitive Elizabeth Holmes record is what mattered, then he would have given credence to a lot of other external material. He would have brought in some of the depositions and the legal transcripts and we would have gotten more into her relationship with her former business partner, Sonny. We would have gotten more into the sexual assault and the abuse in her past that she raised at her trial and that her father here experienced. mentions on camera. Her father mentions it and gives him an avenue to explore it, and he doesn't choose to go down that route, right? So I don't think that Fielder is really trying
to figure out who the real Elizabeth Holmes is. I think he knows who she is, and I think he knows exactly that. What he doesn't know And what's worthy of investigation on camera is whether someone who commits fraud on the scale that she did and who is a liar of the magnitude that she is can actually be capable of maintaining that facade of innocence 24-7 under the scrutiny of a camera and eventually multiple cameras. They started it. And you can see it early in the film where They're just panning one camera like a traditional doc, and then later we actually see the crew members too. They've got multiple cameras to get every response from every angle, right?
00:21:09
Speaker 3: Yes.
00:21:10
Speaker 2: And eventually they've got all that in place, right? So under that scrutiny and under Fielder's own incredibly close, dubious, spying eyes, will she ever break? Can Fielder make her break? Will there even be a crack in... Or might I, as the investigator here, Nathan Fielder, will I potentially even get cast under her spell? But I think more importantly, Josh, and you suggested this earlier too, more importantly, how will my interpretation, here again, I'm speaking as Nathan Fielder, how will my interpretation of my experience in the moment with my eyes differ from the interpretations of what occurred or what's actually happening from what Lance Oppenheim saw when he's in the room too, the other crew members who are in the room, the other crew members who are watching through lenses instead of their eyes, and those who will ultimately watch at home as well. Because the title of this movie, You Can See Everything, is of course, I think we're all supposed to understand it as ironic. There's a moment in the film where she texts him, she agrees to let him stay, and she says, you can see everything. And if the goal here is clarity of any kind, and the idea that by seeing everything, she somehow will come into focus, that's what the title is connoting, well, that's obviously ironic because we don't get that kind of clarity. But it's not ironic at all if you take everything to mean essentially the same as anything. In any single reaction or word choice or line rendering or gesture or body movement, Every possible interpretation of its meaning is on the table here. You can see everything and anything you want in it and in Elizabeth Holmes. And that is what certainly kept me compelled as a viewer.
00:23:18
Speaker 1: Well, and the interesting, compelling aspect too, is that every creative choice Fielder makes as co-director and interviewer and Oppenheim makes as co-director. And of course, in the editing, when they get all that footage together, Every creative choice tips the scales in one direction or another. Not necessarily, perhaps, how they may or may not intend it. Because as you're describing, there are levels of intent going on here. There is Holmes' intent. There's Billy Evans' intent. There's Fielder's intent. There's Oppenheim's intent. And we'll get to it. These layers of interpretation are only made more complicated by the involvement of another figure about halfway through the film and how Fielder's experiences of Holmes are processed through yet one more layer. I want to say a few things quickly. One thing, um, as you were describing how Fielder came in, knowing she's a fraud and not wanting to investigate that. Did you love the formal touch for how they convict her in like the first 10 minutes? There is a shot where she is in the playroom of this cottage, holding a baby and, um, just looking so maternal, like nuzzling the baby. Do you remember where the camera is? I'm assuming it's a crib.
00:24:30
Speaker 2: Through the bars.
00:24:31
Speaker 1: It's like inside a crib through the bars.
00:24:33
Speaker 2: I think it might be the first time we see her.
00:24:36
Speaker 1: So like they've already put her behind bars. Yes. Like in the first 10 minutes of the film. So I think that's just some formal evidence to what you're talking about in regards to their assumptions. I want to say just a few things about Holmes as a screen presence and Fielder as a screen presence to put some context on this, maybe for those particularly who haven't seen it yet. She is so fascinating to me because her default expression, and I think this plays into the notion of innocence that you were describing. The only way I can describe it is it's the smile of someone who's getting ready to smile.
00:25:12
Speaker 2: Anticipatory, you're right.
00:25:15
Speaker 1: I see this in myself when we're doing these video recordings. It's like, don't forget to smile as we're starting.
00:25:23
Speaker 2: You're hanging on my every word, Josh. I know.
00:25:25
Speaker 3: Yeah.
00:25:26
Speaker 1: I mean, it's, you know, it's just, it's something you do whenever any camera comes out.
00:25:30
Speaker 2: Right.
00:25:31
Speaker 1: But she seems to never progress to full smile. It's always in that. And it's different though, than saying she wears a fake smile. I don't mean that there's something psychologically revealing about how her default expression is someone who's getting ready to smile. And another thing about the innocence is, you know, That whole sequence where Fielder plays or who's on first, the Abbott and Costello routine, and is trying to see how do you process how things like irony and misdirection. And that was so fascinating to me, whether it's straightforward, that this is really how her mind thinks, that she's almost too literal, which is how she explains it, right? She thinks very literally. So she never got the joke. Or is she somehow processing that it's better for me to present myself this way?
00:26:29
Speaker 2: Billy's certainly smart enough to know that it's better for them.
00:26:33
Speaker 1: And he starts steering it that way. Yeah. Now, in regard to Fielder, again, my first exposure to him, such a strange presence. He's so unexpressive in so many ways, stares a lot, so intensely, very good at
piercing questions that will catch your subject off guard. Here's the key that, you know, it's a skill for an interviewer of any kind in this sort of scenario. He is not worried about being uncomfortable with long silences. I love that exchange between, this is a point where Billy is trying to nudge them toward a legal investigation, the kind of which you were describing that they're not interested in. And he's going on and on about these details and about how this would be a good aspect. You guys should look into this. I think it'd be really good for the documentary industry. And Fielder is just standing there expressionless, doesn't say anything. He's got those headphones on.
00:27:24
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:27:24
Speaker 1: So he can kind of have some protection. Like I'm doing some filmmaking here.
00:27:27
Speaker 3: Right.
00:27:28
Speaker 1: Finally, Billy just goes, any thoughts?
00:27:30
Speaker 3: Yeah.
00:27:30
Speaker 2: And he thought, and doesn't he kind of storm out and close the door, like slams it?
00:27:34
Speaker 1: After Fielder goes, I was just listening.
00:27:36
Speaker 3: Right.
00:27:37
Speaker 2: After Fielder, that's all he has to say. He clearly just chooses to not engage.
00:27:41
Speaker 1: Exactly. And so I think he does have his own sort of demeanor and approach to people and in and sort of distanced inquisitiveness that is perfect for this assignment.
00:27:54
Speaker 2: I have more to say about the screen presences of both figures in this movie, but I think we would like to pause for a moment and recognize the tremendous support that we get, Josh, via the members of the FilmSpotting family. Who are we going to recognize this week?
00:28:13
Speaker 1: A couple of longtime listeners this week, Family Plus member Maddie Roberts, who's in Lenexa, Kansas, and then family member James Martin in Phoenix, Arizona. Maddie wrote this, my best friend's brother, Jack Zarnicki, told me how great the show was about 15 years ago. It took me a couple of years to start listening to podcasts, but film spotting was my first. I'll remember your tribute to Roger Ebert after his passing as one of the first episodes I heard. I love the Madness tournaments, especially as you've gone further back in time. I watch TCM every night before bed, so the 40s tournament was a real treat. The only major oversight on the bracket was the omission of 1949's A Letter to Three Wives, but it was a heck of a bracket. A movie that made me a cinephile? Anytime my Uncle John and Aunt Teresa visited from New York, they took me to movies. When I was five, they took me to A Christmas Story. Then we snuck in and watched the back half of Return of the Jedi. I was hooked.
00:29:09
Speaker 3: Wow.
00:29:10
Speaker 1: I don't know, Adam. I love that tradition to have an aunt and uncle who come and take you to the movies. I don't know how I feel about.
00:29:15
Speaker 2: Yeah, do you condone such behavior?
00:29:18
Speaker 1: I mean, is this the first time Maddie saw
Return of the Jedi and he just dropped in for the second half? I mean, that would kind of, especially as a kid, blow my mind.
00:29:27
Speaker 2: See, that's the part that bothers you. It's not the sneaking in part. It's how did you take in Return of the Jedi?
00:29:33
Speaker 1: Oh, man. We did... Come on. We did double features.
00:29:36
Speaker 2: You know what? This is how much of a square I am. I've never once snuck into any part of a movie.
00:29:44
Speaker 1: Really?
00:29:44
Speaker 2: You never?
00:29:45
Speaker 3: No.
00:29:45
Speaker 1: Wow.
00:29:46
Speaker 3: No.
00:29:46
Speaker 1: Well, that's just so you could get hired as an usher. And when they ask you that question, you could have honestly said no.
00:29:54
Speaker 2: There you go. And it worked.
00:29:56
Speaker 1: You got the job.
00:29:56
Speaker 2: Just like Elizabeth Holmes, I'm completely innocent.
00:29:59
Speaker 3: Yeah.
00:29:59
Speaker 2: Josh, never lied. Here's what I love about our listeners is Maddie. Didn't say it was a minor oversight. He didn't say it was an oversight. He said it was a film spotting madness, major oversight. And the movie he's referencing is a movie I've never heard of.
00:30:18
Speaker 1: So the, So the committee, the selection committee, of which you are a part, didn't spend a lot of time debating a letter to three wives. Nope, we certainly did not. But now it's on our radar if we ever go back to the 40s. Here's James Martin.
00:30:32
Speaker 2: I found you doing a Google search for podcasts back in the Sam Van Halgren co-hosting days. Favorite segment, I think it was a best of the year episode or maybe the original review. Don't remember, but it turned me on to Rian Johnson and Brick. Current Letterboxd four favorites. These are good. Do the right thing. Hail Caesar. Punch drunk love. and the 2017 Japanese metazombie movie One Cut of the Dead.
00:30:55
Speaker 3: Nice.
00:30:55
Speaker 2: Favorite book about movies or moviemaking, this is one I think I have on my shelf somewhere, Stephen D. Katz's film directing, colon, cinematic motion.
00:31:05
Speaker 1: Well, thank you, James and Maddie, for joining the family and for all those years of listening. Both of them are on Letterboxd. If other listeners would like to follow, James is at Mr. L. Riley, R-E-I-L-L-Y, And Maddie is at DreadPirate82.
00:31:23
Speaker 2: If you would like to learn more about joining the FilmSpotting family and possibly join the FilmSpotting family, you can do that at FilmSpottingFamily.com. You get a weekly newsletter, access to the complete FilmSpotting archive, access to the family-exclusive Discord. Among the other benefits is a monthly donation. bonus show in your feed, and we did just drop into the feed your October bonus show. This was a very fun draft of the best films of the 2020s, so five years, with Maria Marquezini. She is in Kent, UK, a very lovely, brilliant Italian woman living in Kent, UK, who has listened to, I think, all of our episodes, she said. She went back- Into the archive after discovering us. And she was great. Some of us were very mean to each other. One of us, not necessarily here recording this show, was very mean to Maria with their pics, but she still likes us anyway.
00:32:30
Speaker 1: I think we should prepare the family for Sam's behavior. He has such a reputation as a nice guy.
00:32:37
Speaker 2: Of course.
00:32:38
Speaker 1: Man, he was having a bad day or something.
00:32:41
Speaker 2: Speaking of having a bad day, I was all set to give you the results, the current results, because voting is ongoing. If you're a FilmSpotting family member, right there in the show description and whatever podcast catcher you use, you can click, see all the draft picks, and you can see the link to vote for who do you think won the 2020s Metacritic draft. And I was feeling so good, Josh, that even though I stole Sam's number one pick, And then he proceeded to pay me back by taking the two films that I was maybe hoping most after my first pick to get. I was winning. I've been winning this poll, believe it or not. Probably on the strength of my top pick. And I just clicked on it. And you know who's in the lead now? Uh-oh. It's not you. Oh. You're last, Josh.
00:33:33
Speaker 3: Last?
00:33:34
Speaker 2: Yeah, you're where you usually are with these things.
00:33:36
Speaker 3: Come on now.
00:33:36
Speaker 2: You're last.
00:33:37
Speaker 1: Maria.
00:33:38
Speaker 3: Maria.
00:33:39
Speaker 2: Maria is in first. If there was anybody I would root for other than myself, it would be Maria. So you can listen to that fun draft. You can vote now. FilmSpottingFamily.com is where you can learn more. Also, we love ratings. Yes, we've been around a long time. Yes, we have a lot of ratings. Unfortunately, they are predominantly positive, but it does still help us reach new listeners and make us feel good too. So go to Spotify or especially Apple Podcasts and Throw us five stars there.
00:34:12
Speaker 1: I fell in love in that first conversation.
00:34:15
Speaker 3: Before or after that she revealed she was the founder of Theranos?
00:34:19
Speaker 1: Probably before.
00:34:20
Speaker 3: I mean, weren't you worried she was sort of scamming you?
00:34:24
Speaker 1: 100%, but what did she have to gain from me?
00:34:27
Speaker 2: Well, isn't your family rich?
00:34:29
Speaker 3: Yeah, I think that there's like a lot of different levels of wealth.
00:34:34
Speaker 2: Going back to Fielder, especially here, At some point, Josh, you have to acknowledge that this movie is deeply funny. Now, I saw it with a mostly full theater. Not a huge theater, but mostly full. And it was on a Sunday afternoon. And there weren't a lot of laughs. But it is still hilarious to watch almost all of those cuts to Fielder watching from a distance what's going on. Like he's Nosferatu.
00:35:07
Speaker 1: In a corner.
00:35:09
Speaker 2: They are vampiric-like, voyeuristic looks. And they cracked me up every time that we would
just get this cut, something, a scene would play out of this family or something Elizabeth Holmes was doing and then cut to a corner and there he is in the shadows looking on, right? Trying to make sense of what he was looking at. It cracked me up every time. So that's part of his presence.
00:35:37
Speaker 1: It's so good. And it speaks to the filmmaking strategy, okay? Because this is framed as a thriller that becomes a comic thriller. And so you have to ask yourself, those shots you're describing, when did they decide that's how they were going to frame Fielder in particular?
00:35:57
Speaker 2: I mean.
00:35:58
Speaker 1: It's conceivable they went back after realizing this is how we're going to form this material because there are shots of him completely in silhouette against a window or against the, you know, they're near the ocean against the seascape. They could have gone back and gotten those just as, you know, B roll that they're like, we need to, we need to double down on this spectral presence that he has. I think also it goes back to the cameras. Very early on, I started asking myself how many cameras did they get in here? This is why I even threw mockumentary into the possibilities because it's, you know, it's, it's not, it's not a mockumentary, but it, they got such great stuff with so many cameras that it almost feels, let's talk about the egg scene, the egg beating scene again, early on. So I don't think Fielder has moved in to the cottage yet or to the, to the house right next door, the, you know, the guest house.
00:36:56
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:36:57
Speaker 1: Um, But this is a moment where Elizabeth is beating eggs to make an omelet and Fielder is in the kitchen talking to her and Billy's kind of off camera, but walks in, grabs the bowl of eggs from her and starts whipping them faster. And everyone, you know, in the theater, both times I saw it, we're like, oh, like immediately, like this guy is so funny. I went with Debbie because she hadn't seen it the second time. Five minutes in, as soon as Billy shows up, She just lets out a loud, this guy. It's like, just like the antenna, the antenna was up. Anyway, he grabs the eggs. Everyone's like, what? And Nathan Fielder asks, why did you just do that?
00:37:38
Speaker 2: We're all thinking he actually asked.
00:37:40
Speaker 1: Exactly.
00:37:40
Speaker 3: Yes.
00:37:40
Speaker 1: Which is again, why he's a great inquisitor.
00:37:42
Speaker 3: Right.
00:37:42
Speaker 1: But what I'm thinking, Adam, is the formal quality of this, because you have, if you think about it, you have Elizabeth Holmes in medium shot beating the eggs. You have Billy. when he comes in, in his own medium shot, you have Fielder watching in closeup after the exchange of the eggs, they have a closeup shot of him. Then you have a closeup of their hands on the eggs. And I'm thinking to myself, like there may be a zoom from a medium into that closeup, but like how many cameras do they have in this space to get everything they need for this scene to play as dramatically and psychologically layered and deft and allowing Fielder to to involve himself at precisely the right moment. It's elements like that where it's just, you know, happenstance plays a lot into projects like this, but strategy does as well. That they went in, to your point, about wanting to perhaps nail her and then finding along the way, oh, you know what? We have to be equally cognizant of nailing Billy. Of course. Because this is an entirely deserving subject of its own. And again, just to have in the editing, this works too, but to have the cameras in place to capture a scene like that speaks to the formal sophistication going on here. Yeah.
00:39:10
Speaker 2: Just back to Fielder for one second and what we were saying about his presence, that one shot too, where he's looking out at them frolicking, or they're not even really frolicking, but Billy and, Elizabeth are out in the water sort of having a good time and he's looking on. If it hasn't been done already, someone could very easily take footage from this movie and turn it into a trailer about a stalker. That's how this could be portrayed. It wouldn't be difficult at all. But to your point about the cameras, it goes back to what I was trying to get at too in terms of what I think is being explored here or certainly what it conjured for me in terms of thinking about is every reaction that matters. Every response to every moment matters because it's fundamentally about the subjective truth in everything that's happening. And the only way then that you can capture that is to capture everything. You can't be sort of hoping you get the most important moments when you've got maybe a single camera or even two cameras and they're trained on Nathan. Meanwhile, Billy's over in the corner and the look on his face is the thing that when I'm watching Josh, I'm going to take away the biggest response to. I'm going to focus on that and it's going to make me completely reinterpret the scene. Meanwhile, you're looking at something that Elizabeth Holmes did or said in that scene. we have to be able to take all of that in. And I think they fundamentally understood that.
00:40:43
Speaker 1: Yes. And coverage, just general coverage is not going to capture that.
00:40:48
Speaker 3: No.
00:40:48
Speaker 1: So this speaks to what everyone's been joking about, these extreme close-ups, particularly of Holmes' eyes. But you get close-ups of, you've already referenced one of Billy as well, you get close-ups of Fielder. And this is why after my first viewing, I just came away with, literal nightmares of Elizabeth Holmes' face hovering over me. That's how effective it was. Notice they're also using, it's like, it's not a square aspect ratio, but it's definitely condensed more towards that. What does that do? It increases, it's better for portraiture, like they're doing, and increases the claustrophobia. So that's another key choice. And even things, I mean,
the editing throughout is, this has to be nominated, Whatever happens with the categories has to be nominated for best editing, right? But even things like the music as well, I really... it's a creepy and suspenseful. This is where they're, they're leaning into the comic thriller in a way.
00:41:48
Speaker 2: That's it. It's another non-traditional documentary element makes it feel like a narrative and it, it amplifies the thriller element for sure.
00:41:57
Speaker 3: Yeah.
00:41:57
Speaker 1: Ari Balusian did the music and I thought, you know, there are some moments where it's like an Angelo Badalamenti score for Lynch actually is where we're going here. And one other formal touch that I absolutely loved You were discussing the title and what it means and the variations of it. When that title appears on the screen, I mentioned how they're at the beach, and so there are shots of the water. It's against the horizon where the sky meets the water, but the bottom- Slightly obscure. The bottom third of each letter is below the horizon, so you can't fully see the letter. I noticed that too. It's just the level of craft that is at work here that I think is one thing that makes this special. and distinct, honestly, among other documentaries tackling similar subjects.
00:42:46
Speaker 2: So I think the editing nomination seems almost certain. The documentary nomination seems almost certain. Potentially the best picture, as many have discussed. The one that would be really hilarious that will never happen is if Elizabeth Holmes got an acting nomination. Probably should happen.
00:43:06
Speaker 1: Well- Should we go to the person now that we're well into this and can talk spoilers? Maybe, maybe. Who I've also heard may get a nomination.
00:43:12
Speaker 2: I have a few other things, but we'll get there first. Okay, okay. A couple other things first. The other one I'll just briefly throw out because you gave me an entree to this. I doubt it will happen, but you could make a strong case that it deserves a Best Cinematography nomination as well. And it's not just because of the number of cameras that are being juggled And the shots that they capture and the way they capture them. Think about, as a documentary, in these natural spaces and how they are confined and they're running and gunning in its natural light. There's no way they could have fit in. a bunch of lights and on the move.
00:43:55
Speaker 1: Right, right, right, right.
00:43:56
Speaker 2: They're not setting up a lot of shots. Yeah, it looks great. But it looks great. It actually does look great. So I would at least throw that out there that it's a dark horse and very unlikely, but I think people should actually give it some consideration.
00:44:09
Speaker 1: Well, and I think they should for that. Yes, it does look, it looks really good under those conditions, but I think people don't think of those other things like camera placement and that sort of strategic change choices that have to be made
when it comes to cinematography. We often think more about how it looks on the screen and less about what they had to do to get the cameras there. And I think both are strong qualities of this movie.
00:44:35
Speaker 2: But you mentioned what makes it distinct. And all these things we're talking about in terms of exploring the line between objectivity and subjectivity and truth. On this front, I don't think what it's doing is necessarily groundbreaking because of Filmmakers like Errol Morris, certainly Werner Herzog, they've been challenging objective notions of truth in documentary for years. Also, for what it's worth, Errol Morris made Theranos commercials. Worked with Elizabeth Holmes. No, you're kidding me.
00:45:03
Speaker 3: Yeah.
00:45:03
Speaker 1: You're kidding me.
00:45:04
Speaker 2: Actually made commercials for Elizabeth Holmes. The difference here, as you touched on, I think the difference here is the distance. And I mean that figuratively and literally. Literally. Morris has the interitron between him and his subject. Even Joshua Oppenheimer in The Act of Killing, he takes us inside the mind of Anwar in ways that traditional documentaries certainly wouldn't and wouldn't even consider. But I'd argue that he still maintains a separation that feels more like one between a journalist and a subject, like we expect from some documentaries. Sure. That wall, that wall is completely obliterated here. There's no space for that wall between them with how closely he is leaning in. And the figurative part of that is he cuts to them twice at one point later in this film, not a spoiler. He cuts to them twice, frolicking together in the sea, undercutting his own, to the camera, unsaid, but I... I think, still direct contention that he hasn't fallen under her spell.
00:46:23
Speaker 1: Oh, that's precisely.
00:46:24
Speaker 2: That's what he's doing. He's giving to his audience that he has, in fact, fallen under her spell. There is no space between documentarian and subject here.
00:46:35
Speaker 1: No, I have to just jump in on that. The swimming footage fascinated me because there's two instances in the movie.
00:46:41
Speaker 2: And it's a surprise. They surprise us with it. We don't know that it happened.
00:46:45
Speaker 1: Well, there's a reference where Holmes.
00:46:47
Speaker 2: Invites- They allude to it, but we don't know that it's followed through on until we see it.
00:46:51
Speaker 1: Exactly.
00:46:52
Speaker 3: Yes.
00:46:52
Speaker 1: Exactly. And it's even more nuanced than that because Holmes invites him to swim and he says something like he doesn't like cold water. Yeah. And then we do, this is, okay, the first time we see it, it's after Fielder, this is, let's just say this is after Holmes has gone to prison. Two years later, Fielder has returned to the cottage. He's with someone else we'll get to. And the first time we see that footage, he looks out the window and we cut to, it's further away. So to me, it looked like it could
have been them. It could have been Fielder and Holmes, but I was too far to know for sure. And so I thought maybe this is just another couple. It's again, like B-roll footage and they're putting it there to remind us of the earlier conversation. So planting that seed, right? The second time, is after Fielder tells someone else on camera, this is way later in the film, I'm just trying to be accurate, you know, and it cuts back to that same footage, but we're closer now and it's longer on the screen and you can see that it is Holmes and Fielder. At least I'm 99% sure it's that. No, it is. Because his hair is wet and he looks different, you know, um, So it's just, I'm just reiterating basically what you were saying, how it's placed there by Fielder to undermine his supposed objectivity.
00:48:13
Speaker 2: That's right.
00:48:13
Speaker 1: Now, the layer we've alluded to, but haven't really dug into is Fielder and Oppenheim are still manipulating us. And I don't mean that necessarily in a devious way, but do we trust that Fielder, like, What is the motivations of Fielder to include that in such a self-condemning way? Is it because he thinks it'll make for a more risque aspect to think about? Like, ooh, did he fall for, you know, is it because he really just wants to self-interrogate on film? Perhaps he seems like he might be that sort of guy. Is it because it was a business decision? And this will give us, goes back to my gossip idea. This is one more thing to gossip about. Now we can gossip about whether Fielder and Holmes had something going on after this movie. And it was almost like, you know, 60% creative decision, 40% business decision.
00:49:15
Speaker 2: I hate to be equivocal here or equivocate here, Josh, but it seems to me like you can say it's both. That Nathan Fielder is probably someone who, as an artist, is both more than willing to self-interrogate, and that's what's happening. but he also deeply understands that by self-interrogating.
00:49:34
Speaker 1: This is juicy.
00:49:36
Speaker 2: It, it opens the movie up for these types of discussions. It makes the movie far more interesting. And so like Holmes herself as well, there's a certain amount of manipulation going on. But here's the thing. Here's the thing. We expect that from Nathan Fielder. People who know his work expect that going in. And so they shouldn't be duped by that. And so then I think it's perhaps more okay. Even people like you and me who don't know a ton about his work but know enough to maybe expect that, it should be fine. And then people who don't know anything at all, I think by the time we get to that moment, you probably know enough about how he works within the context of this film to expect it, right? So it doesn't feel like it's completely out of left field. But on that note, And here again, we're going to get to the part I know you want to get to because I want to get to it as well. But this really is a perfect transition into something I wanted to bring
up. And this is where the one aspect, maybe there's two, part of watching the Gibney documentary afterwards that ended up being beneficial for me is that I knew she was a liar. I was convinced on that. All of that was already established. But what I found, fully realize, Josh, is that she was a liar who created her entire reputation off of authenticity. It wasn't just her brilliance. It was brilliance combined with warmth and emotion and idealism. And she understood how to construct moving narratives. That's how she convinced everybody. I actually think that froggy voice of hers that makes her more endearing. And the pattern that she developed over the course of her time at Theranos was she would befriend and utilize and put on her board these aging white men, like people like George Shultz, the former Secretary of State, and Henry Kissinger, right? These extremely intelligent, no matter what you think of them, extremely intelligent and savvy men who've been around the block. And yet when faced with those big blue eyes and her conviction and her narrative that she's spinning, it's like they all, these are my words, it's like they all turn into proud grandpas who are convinced that their sweet little girl, who's at the time 1920, their sweet little girl is just impeccable and can do no wrong. So her whole bit was that she wanted to make people's lives better. Her product was there to make the world a better place. And it didn't feel false to anybody. And I think that's why we both hate her and are fascinated by her still. Why we look at her and still are compelled to look at her because she's a mirror in a way reflecting back at ourselves. If you get duped by someone who's a pretty slick kind of salesperson or even, let's say, an actual magician or illusionist, right, who's doing the sleight of hand right in front of you and you know they're performing the trick, that's one thing. You got got. Okay. You can even maybe have some respect for them. But it's another thing entirely to have no idea at all that you were being conned and to have your heartstrings tugged at. like Elizabeth Holmes was doing with people. And I think that's, that's maybe why, even as we see in the film that she, if we believe Nathan Fielder, why she was so fascinated by the comparison that he makes of her to David Blaine, because what if in her mind, Josh, what if in her mind, she's actually been doing that the entire time. She's always been doing an illusion. She's always knowingly been carrying out a con right in front of us and always been getting away with it. She never believed any of that stuff. And so she's been getting us this whole time. She's been like David Blaine. That could be one case.
00:54:15
Speaker 1: So the David Blaine calling out that scene, keep in mind that scene is one of the reenactments. I, I firmly understand. Yes. Right.
00:54:26
Speaker 2: Yes. And so he's claiming that that happened.
00:54:29
Speaker 1: I know. I know. I, I, I'm just saying like,
we're getting like layers apart, like as we're getting more definitive of what we think she is up to and how she operates. Yeah. The movie, you can see everything at least can't speak to the Gibney doc, but is, is like delivering that, through layer increasing layers of artifice.
00:54:54
Speaker 2: It is.
00:54:55
Speaker 1: And so here's something that struck me when I, when I wanted to like, think about the structure, do we see, would you think she goes into prison about halfway through? Would you say two thirds of the way through this film?
00:55:09
Speaker 2: Maybe are we officially getting into spoilers at this point? Do we need to put out a warning or I think we should, we can. Yeah. So much to see on the big screen this weekend, Josh, including the, or I would say especially the two movies that we're most excited to talk about. Martin McDonagh's new one, Wild Horse Nine, tons of buzz ever since it played the festival circuit. And you got to see Godzilla on the big screen. A small screen cannot contain Godzilla, right?
00:55:38
Speaker 1: You know that. And may I also advise bringing earplugs for Godzilla. I have them handy just in case it gets to be a little much and Yeah, that roar is overpowering in the theater as it should be for Godzilla.
00:55:55
Speaker 2: Legitimate question, old man. Did you wear earplugs while you watched it?
00:56:00
Speaker 1: No, I'm not lying. I'm not making this up. I started doing this a few years ago, mostly for trailers. I gotta say, mostly for trailers.
00:56:09
Speaker 2: And every once in a while, a movie.
00:56:12
Speaker 1: Is as thunderous as Godzilla. And I just, you know, a little A little self-care, self-protection.
00:56:17
Speaker 2: Self-care, very, very smart. Also out, though, I'm going to keep bringing it up just to make you smile every time. I'm going to start shadowboxing. I'm going to start throwing the tennis ball against the ground. I play Rocky is out. I can't wait to see it. And I can pair it. I can make it a double feature at Regal Cinemas, Josh, with a 50th anniversary screening. They're doing a limited engagement, November 7th through the 11th, limited engagement for its 50th anniversary. with the original Rocky. See how it got made, and then go back and see what got made.
00:56:52
Speaker 1: Lord, Lord Almighty. You know, I haven't had to pull this phrase out from my daily critic days. I think for I Play Rocky, I need to remind myself, anything can be great. Sometimes I'd be faced with a day of screenings, and I would say, you can do this. Anything can be great. And that's what I believe about I Play Rocky. But I'm going to let you see it first and tell me if that's the case.
00:57:15
Speaker 2: Maybe we've done this before or a version of it, but a top five someday, if we could remember them, would be top five. It ended up being great movies. Movies we were sure would be terrible.
00:57:25
Speaker 1: Yes.
00:57:25
Speaker 2: And then it actually shocked us.
00:57:27
Speaker 1: I
like that.
00:57:28
Speaker 2: All four of the movies I mentioned are available now at Regal Cinemas, and you can see them for free if you are a Regal Unlimited member. Regal Unlimited is the all-you-can-watch movie subscription pass that pays for itself in just two.
00:57:41
Speaker 2: Yes, Regal is offering our listeners endless movies for less to get Regal Unlimited and to get 15% off. All you have to do is sign up for Regal Unlimited using the code FILMSPOT26. You can see any standard 2D movie anytime, no blackout dates, no restrictions, and you don't just save on tickets. You get 10% off all non-alcoholic concessions. Please do sign up now in the Regal app or at the link in our podcast description. And don't forget to use the code filmspot26 to get your discount.
00:58:18
Speaker 3: I mean, it took me a really long time to be okay with letting someone see me cry.
00:58:33
Speaker 1: So yes, at this point we will talk about the, this figure who we've been referencing and yeah, everything else is fair game. So if you don't want to know, and I would advise, yes, if you're intrigued enough to see, you can see everything, um, based on what we said and have not seen it yet. Go watch it, come back and finish this review. You really don't want to watch the movie. I did not know that this person was involved.
00:58:57
Speaker 2: Um, I didn't either.
00:58:58
Speaker 1: It's, and it's a surprise.
00:59:00
Speaker 2: It's a revelation and a welcome one.
00:59:03
Speaker 1: One of the master strokes of the documentary.
00:59:05
Speaker 2: It is undoubtedly.
00:59:06
Speaker 1: So going back to the David Blaine magician conversation at this point, this whole thing is being reenacted because Amanda Seyfried, who played Holmes in the Hulu series, The Dropout that I referenced, Fielder tracks her down and starts talking to her about her experience with playing Holmes, not with Holmes. I don't think she ever met her. And so we get a number of instances and we can talk about different ones and how they work differently, where Fielder has Cyfred play homes again to reenact some of his interactions with her or after she goes to prison, phone calls he's had. So the magic one is so fascinating to me because it comes post prison. And, I don't think we see Elizabeth Holmes, the actual person on camera, after the camera follows her walking into prison, which is about halfway through the film.
01:00:00
Speaker 2: No, I'm pretty sure we don't.
01:00:01
Speaker 1: So think about this, Adam.
01:00:02
Speaker 2: Not until the end. Not until the very end. I think that's... Not until the very, very end. The very end.
01:00:07
Speaker 1: And there's another... We do see there's a point where they're talking about whether she and Billy accepted money for the doc, and we cut back to footage of her telling Fielder, I'm not making any money on this, but it was... shot before she went to prison. So we do see her actual face for a brief moment in that clip, but otherwise all we're seeing, and I'm not saying this is like, I'm just saying like, we always have to keep this in mind post prison. When we think we're learning anything about Elizabeth Holmes, anything it's via what Billy Evans says she has told him. It's via Fielder's memory of their interactions. It's via the scripts he writes based on those interactions. Then it's about Cy Fred's, it's through Cy Fred's performance of Holmes. And so this is not to defend Holmes at all, but it's a bizarre experience where I feel like I'm learning more about her as this movie goes on. And then I have to tell myself, I have not seen this woman. in the documentary for the past 60 minutes. And all of the quote unquote evidence I'm being given is being filtered through all of these people who I don't have any, well, Billy, I have reason to believe is being nefarious. I don't have reason to believe that Cy Fred or Fielder are being nefarious. I don't know that I can entirely trust their interpretations, especially once Cy Fred gets called out for Was it ethical to play her this way?
01:01:39
Speaker 2: So that's fascinating too.
01:01:41
Speaker 1: She gets defensive, right?
01:01:42
Speaker 2: I mean, Josh, that's the key thing is that not only is Seifert being used as a vehicle to interrogate Fielder's interrogation of Elizabeth Holmes, but then as we've already suggested, Fielder himself starts to get indicted slash investigated for his complicity in falling under her spell and potentially by cypher it with her looks at him. Some of these suggestive looks at him, great closeups again, great closeups that he either does answer or doesn't answer. Or you could argue he does answer with the looks he gives back, right? There's these silences, but then the reverse is also true. Imagine I was for a good part of this film, I was imagining what the conversations were like between Fielder and Seyfried to get her involved in this film and how fascinating it must have been and how interested she actually must have been. If you take everything here again at face value, you see how giddy she is to play this character again.
01:02:56
Speaker 1: She's gossiping with us.
01:02:58
Speaker 2: To just get back into this mindset and do some of this detective work that she's doing, which actually feels like real detective work, right? But then something happens in particular in one scene where she's now under the microscope. She's now having to answer for some of her choices and whether or not they were the right choice and whether or not she's part of this entire machine that has turned Elizabeth Holmes into something that she really isn't. And she doesn't really have good answers for it. And I was almost waiting for Seyfried on camera to go, hey, time out. I didn't sign up for this.
01:03:36
Speaker 1: Yeah, you're right.
01:03:38
Speaker 2: This wasn't supposed to be about me under scrutiny. It gets that awkward. I'm here to help with Elizabeth Holmes.
01:03:45
Speaker 1: Yep. And the editing of
that sequence, Adam, because it's Seyfried as Holmes who's complaining about the dropout. And presumably we're getting this dialogue from Fielder's recollections of talking to Holmes about the dropout, right? saying how that series ruined her life. This might be the point where she says, here's another meta layer. Holmes through Fielder, through Seyfried, says that her fellow prisoners thought the dropout was a documentary. How about that? But back to the editing, when Seyfried is confronted with this, who's confronting the real Seyfried? Seyfried is Holmes. They cut No, but it's Seyfried playing Holmes who's accusing the real Seyfried. So they added it back and forth so that she's literally accusing herself.
01:04:42
Speaker 2: And that is jarring in the moment. When you go back to Holmes, but it's not Holmes, you know it's Seyfried playing Holmes. But to look like her. Exactly. You're thinking about both moments and her as an actress. In one moment, her as herself processing... this complaint from the person she was portraying and then having to portray the person complaining. Yes, it's loaded and it's endlessly interesting.
01:05:12
Speaker 1: But Josh, here's the- And it's why people are talking about her as a supporting.
01:05:16
Speaker 2: Actress role, right? So this is what I wanted to say. I caught myself during the sequence where Nathan goes to visit her in prison. and finally gets the sit down with her.
01:05:31
Speaker 3: Yes.
01:05:32
Speaker 2: And especially when the camera is really focused on her and, and her response and her reactions and, and isn't cutting back to, to field her as much. I caught myself thinking I was looking at Elizabeth Holmes. Me too. I, I had to tell myself, I had to catch myself that this was Amanda Seyfried Seyfried. And so the, the, The fact that it's not my point here isn't ultimately to praise her as an actress, even though that is what I'm doing. It's just to point out that within all of these, under all of these layers that work in this film, there I was watching her thinking I was watching for a serious span of time. I was under the illusion that I was watching the person I was watching from earlier in the film.
01:06:25
Speaker 1: Yes.
01:06:25
Speaker 2: And that's crazy.
01:06:27
Speaker 1: It is. And it's, yeah, you do have to check yourself. I think that's good advice for going into this documentary is constantly check yourself. And whenever you think, maybe this is the takeaway of the movie, is not who Holmes actually is, not who Billy Evans actually is, not what Nathan Fielder or Oppenheim wanted to get out of this. It's that whenever you think you've reached a conclusive thought about this entire scenario, check yourself. And ask, how did I arrive here? Yeah. What information brought me here? Who presented it? What choices did they make that? I mean, it really is. I agree with you. I don't think this is, you know, some of the hyperbole about this documentary is like it's breaking new ground.
Documentaries have never done this before. I don't think it's doing that. You've listed a few that have done similar things, but I do think it does offer a master class and a very entertaining one for students learning about the possibilities of the documentary form, right?
01:07:28
Speaker 2: And all of the big questions about documentaries, all of the ethical, they're all kind of jammed into this film.
01:07:33
Speaker 1: All jammed in here. And that one good advice of going into any documentary, even a more straightforward one, is to check yourself and to say, why do I feel like I know what I know now? It doesn't mean it's wrong. It doesn't mean you've come to an incorrect conclusion, but this movie shows you that things are always shifting under your feet. In any documentary, this one is just kind of laying bare the many ways it can shift.
01:08:01
Speaker 2: That last third, I think, is so important that the movie... This is a fairly inane thing to say, but let me try to get at what I really mean here. The movie would not be what it is without that last third. I found myself, Josh, at the point she goes to prison... not being aware of what time it was sort of feeling like I'd been in the theater for a little while, but not three hours. I didn't have a watch. I didn't know where I was in the film. I thought, is this, is this ending here? Is this the end of the movie with her? It it's been building to this. Maybe this is the end of the film. And while I'm thinking about, as I'm watching a lot of the things that we're talking about here and I I'm enjoying then the film and it's a provocative film, I was maybe a little disappointed thinking this, this, this is it. There has to be more to this.
01:08:54
Speaker 1: Yeah, yeah.
01:08:55
Speaker 2: And then it takes this turn that you never, I never could have imagined that it would take. And even there, though, I want to note that when he first starts incorporating Seyfried, my reaction wasn't, oh, goody, I can't wait. This is going to get so amazing. Yeah, Errol Morris, other filmmakers have used reenactments, right?
01:09:18
Speaker 3: Yeah.
01:09:19
Speaker 2: And done them in really.
01:09:21
Speaker 1: We talked about a great documentary from earlier this year, Everybody to Kenmure Street, which very effectively uses reenactments.
01:09:27
Speaker 3: Yeah.
01:09:28
Speaker 2: And at first my reaction was, how much insight am I really going to get? And this is no offense to her, but it's just the actress who portrayed her in a Hulu series. how much stock am I supposed to put into whatever insight she's going to bring to Elizabeth Holmes? But of course I didn't know how this was going to play out and how she was going to be utilized. And as you see it play out, you, you then go, okay, Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim knew what they were doing. And this is where the movie does go to another level. It just does.
01:10:05
Speaker 3: I agree.
01:10:06
Speaker 2: I agree.
01:10:07
Speaker 1: Um, I,
you know, as maybe we're wrapping up here, maybe not. You might have many more things to say.
01:10:12
Speaker 2: I have one more thing.
01:10:13
Speaker 3: Okay.
01:10:13
Speaker 1: Go for that. And then I do want to mention just a few other docs. Again, in case this is making so much money that there are people coming to this who don't see a lot of documentaries or are starting to understand them in a new way because of this. Just wanted to list a few. I know you've named a few, but titles we can point people to who are like, whoa, documentaries can be this?
01:10:35
Speaker 2: I didn't know we were doing an impromptu top five here, Josh.
01:10:37
Speaker 1: No, no, no, not a top five. You've already listed like two or three.
01:10:40
Speaker 2: I have a few.
01:10:40
Speaker 1: But anyway, go ahead.
01:10:41
Speaker 2: What was your other thing? I just wanted to mention one line in particular that was crucial for me watching this film. And to whatever extent you can get clarity, I'm not even going to say get clarity about Elizabeth Holmes, but can give you yet another thing to feel like you're latching on to at least until the next time you see something else or hear something else that then, that then causes you to slip off the edge of the building, right? Is, is a line where he asks her, it's in that conversation where he asks her about her experience with lying and asks her to define a lie. And so what I was saying earlier about maybe she's, always known. Maybe she truly has always been manipulative. She's been a magician before our eyes conning us. And she's keenly aware of that. That presupposes a certain nefariousness then, right? But there is a potential other explanation. And what's interesting is it's an explanation that I think you could say is supported not only by this moment I'm going to bring up, but then validated by an exchange that occurs and actually the overarching narrative of the Gibney documentary. And I was really shocked that Nathan Fielder in the moment, because he does choose to scrutinize so many interesting moments and call out certain word choices, and he didn't call this one out, Josh. So I wonder if this had any impact for you. But In this moment, they're talking about if she's ever lied, he gets her to define what it is. And her answer is one that I just don't think most of us, if we were asked by someone to define what lying is or what a lie is, I don't think that's how we would phrase it. I just don't think we would. And maybe I'm not getting her wording exactly right. But the key part of what she says is, she says, well, it's when someone says something they believe to be false. Believe.
01:13:02
Speaker 1: Yeah, that sounds right.
01:13:03
Speaker 2: Believe. That's the part she absolutely says, because that really caught my ear. Believe there, I think, is doing a lot of work. If someone asked me what a lie is, I would just say, I'm telling a lie when I say something that's false. Untrue. When I say something that's untrue. When I say something that I know to be false, not when I say something I believe to be false. See, you can never tell a lie. You can never tell a lie if the intentions behind your lie are good, if you actually believe it. If you believe that what you're saying is fundamentally honest, then whether or not all of the details are true can be irrelevant. Effectively, the end can justify the means, right? And I think that more likely explains why she doesn't think she's being dishonest when she says, oh, the Edison device works. That's a better explanation than, oh, she's just too literal or she can't actually parse the difference between the meaning of the words capable and can. In her mind, the Edison's a workable product because she so adamantly believes that it's a necessary product and it's serving humanity and it's capable of working. She's seen it works, so it works. And so here's the part then. I have all this in my mind. And then in the Gibney doc, he uses on camera a behavioral economist who what they do is fundamentally talk about how our brains work and the decisions we make and the why behind it. And he more or less suggests that perhaps she started with good intentions and it spirals as she tries to hang on. maybe it's more of a universal thing. Like if we were in that situation, we might have done similar. This isn't something where it's just, she's a bad person and she's, she's inherently fraudulent. So this is what she did. And he uses an experiment. I'm not going to get into the details because it's confusing and I don't even know all the details, but what's, what's important is he to make his point mentions an experiment he did where people roll a dice and they, If you roll a high number or a low number, you can get paid more money or less money, but it's dependent on whether or not you decided ahead of time in your mind, whether it's the low number or the high number that matters. Okay. And so people roll the dice and then they say to the researcher, well, you owe me this money. What do you know? Everybody gets extremely lucky. everybody seems to, more often than not, get the high number and get paid. So then they change the experiment and they do it where the same thing plays out, but now they're hooked up to a lie detector. And the lie detector detects what you would expect it to, which is that a lot of the people are lying. The lie detector is detecting the friction between their what they're expressing and what they actually did, right? What their mind said to themselves originally, what they processed in their head before. So then they do one more version of this where they roll the dice, they make them decide ahead of time, they hook them up to a lie detector, but they tell them at the outset that they're rolling the dice and collecting money for charity. It's for a good cause. Guess what happens? It plays out exactly the same way. Almost the same number of people collect the same amount of money.
Say, yep, I got the number. I got the higher number. I got the lower number. I got what I decided. Pay me. But the lie detector doesn't detect the lies. It doesn't detect the lies because there's no friction. The people fundamentally believe what they're saying. When we do things for the right reasons... we believe we're being honest. We're not lying. And for me, that moment, again, I saw that afterwards, but it validated that moment for me where I was watching her say what I believe. A lie is something when I don't believe it is effectively what she's saying. And that's not really what a lie is.
01:17:35
Speaker 1: Well, that parsing of believe does connect to the sequence where she brings out all the parts for the Edison prototype puts them on a table and tries to explain it to Fielder. And they, this is what leads to the who's on first. Yes. Sequence.
01:17:51
Speaker 2: And that's what I mean by capable versus can.
01:17:53
Speaker 3: Yeah.
01:17:54
Speaker 1: Yeah. He can't understand why she can't understand that. What she's saying is not.
01:18:02
Speaker 3: Yeah.
01:18:02
Speaker 1: That could. Yeah.
01:18:04
Speaker 2: I think she's so internalized. The righteousness of her cause. I think that's possible. Or she's been a fraud since the very beginning and she knows she's pulling a trick on us. But that is the wonder of this film and the wonder of Holmes as a figure is even after all that's been written about her, all the documentaries and other things that have been made and this film with him staring at her for who knows how many hundreds of hours of footage.
01:18:33
Speaker 1: Yeah, you're not going to get to the bottom of it.
01:18:35
Speaker 2: No.
01:18:35
Speaker 1: And, you know, that's probably because there is a level of self-deception at play to some degree, for sure, on her part. Absolutely. So let me, you mentioned a few good documentaries like Joshua Oppenheimer's The Act of Killing also involves reenactments, a very different setting, though. That's one I would point people to. Kirsten Johnson's Dick Johnson is Dead, which is one of the candidates in the poll we're going to get to later here in the show. a more personal documentary, but one that uses reenactments in creative ways. Abbas Kiarostami's Close Up, I mean, that's like the... like the granddaddy of, and even more blurs the line of- Yeah, where.
01:19:16
Speaker 2: You can't call it a documentary, probably.
01:19:17
Speaker 1: I know, it's so its own thing. But when people, the terms people are using to describe You Can See Everything, make me think of how that really applies to Close Up. And then you mentioned Herzog. I thought, Adam, at one point, this was almost like if Herzog could have interviewed Timothy Treadwell, his posthumous subject of Grizzly Man. What if Herzog had actually gotten in his face and asked some of those piercing questions that he wonders about in Grizzly Man, how that man thought this way? what were his motivations?
01:19:55
Speaker 2: He
could have been in the tent with him 24-7. But if he could have been.
01:19:58
Speaker 1: In the tent with him, would he have gotten any clear of a picture? I don't know. This is almost like, this shows us like, even if you get in the tent and you're right there with them, certain people are just so complicated that a three-hour documentary isn't going to get to the bottom of them.
01:20:15
Speaker 2: And of course, and I say this with all seriousness, if He actually got in the tent with him. There may not be a Werner Herzog or any film.
01:20:23
Speaker 1: That's true. Yeah. That would have been a bad idea, actually.
01:20:26
Speaker 2: I would also say, going back to Errol Morris, the starting point, if you haven't seen it, the starting point for You Can See Everything is the thin blue line.
01:20:38
Speaker 1: Yes.
01:20:38
Speaker 2: You have to start with Errol Morris' The Thin Blue Line. It's a Criterion collection. I'm sure it's on the Criterion channel. And that will set you on your... subjectivity in documentary path. And it will be a, there you go. It will be a fun journey. You can see everything is also a fun. If enigmatic journey, it's currently out in wide release. We would love to hear your thoughts about the film, especially if you disagree with our thoughts, you can email us feedback at film spotting.net. They told me what happened to you, to your son, Is it true? The Portland, Oregon-based Leica Animation Studio got its start in features with the 2005 Tim Burton collaboration Corpse Bride. They went on to make 2009's Coraline, 2012's Paranorman, 2016's Kubo, and The Two Strings. Those are all really good films, among others. I'm not familiar with among others. Maybe you can fill me in on that or those, Josh. Their latest, directed by Travis Knight, is Wildwood, an adaptation of a chapter book pretty big one by Decembrist frontman and fellow Portlander Colin Malloy. Fill me in maybe on those others and your relationship with the three that I mentioned. And what did you think of Wildwood?
01:22:05
Speaker 1: Yeah, despite my love for stop motion, I'm not a like a completist, I've got to say, and that's on me. I should finish that up at some point. My favorite is probably still Coraline. Kubo, very good as well. I have always I always know I'm going to get the craft. I think sometimes, and you know, the glory days of Pixar have raised expectations for us in the field of animation. I think sometimes the storytelling is like maybe a slight bit behind the craft for some of the Laika films I've seen, but I've enjoyed everything I've seen. And that is maybe a nitpick I have with Wildwood, but I don't want to start there because this is I want to start with that craft because the staggering scale of this movie, when you consider that they are working at such a miniature level, this is a fantasy film that's as expansive as like a Narnia movie or a Lord of the Rings movie, Princess Mononoke came to mind. And they're doing all of this with stop motion puppetry and sets and the number of characters, the number of locations that they've devised for this. It's absolutely incredible. And even at a moment where there's a battle scene and you're starting to see some of the familiar beats of a battle scene, like even the Lord of the Rings camera going to swoop in as the two groups are about to crash, right? Part of my brain is like, oh, this again? And then the other part of my brain is saying, but you realize they're doing this with puppets. And so it's like, okay, I got to give it to you then.
01:23:44
Speaker 3: Yeah.
01:23:45
Speaker 1: The basic story for those who don't know, you can get a sense of what I'm talking about here. It's basically about a headstrong teen who's supposed to be watching her baby brother lives in Portland. And then the boy is kidnapped by crows. So she goes after him into this forbidden forest. And that's where all of this fantastical stuff starts taking place. It's funny, it's not only those grand sets though, but one of the developments, and I looked into this after seeing it because I couldn't believe how they were doing it, were the facial expressions on Prue, this main character in particular, and turns out they use 3D printers to just give us an array of inflections visually for the face and attach those to the puppets so that you, what happens here is you have a puppet that's basically threading the needle between, you know, teenage snark in a moment and then teenage exasperation. And those are very, we know Adam, those are very, two very different things, but in a rudimentary stop motion puppet, they probably, you know, they look the same, right? Not here, not with Wildwood. It has that degree of visual sophistication to it. So my nitpick is just with that story. It is very sprawling, um, It feels a little bit like a pastiche of some of those influences more than its own unique thing. But you, I can't get over the detail. The last example I'll give in terms of that, this is where stop motion is just so wondrous. There is a giant golden eagle character. And at one point it lands on the roof of a mail truck. And they have animated and designed things so that the talons from inside the mail truck, the talons like form an indent. And you can just see that shape making its way, which again, live action, you use some sort of special effects, traditional animation, you draw it in. But to be able to do that with this handcrafted art form is incredible. I also noticed with Wildwood, that's a unique thing about stop motion is it really makes, there's some psychological thing going on where sound design is way more tactile in its own way when you know that all of this is actual existing material. I'm thinking of like the clink of keys that a character carries or those talons punching down into the metal, um, the pitter patter of a rat's paws. There's something, your mind does something where, you know, these are real puppets and you hear it and it just feels
it's audibly tactile, if that makes any sense. And so there's a lot of that going on in Wildwood. It has, um, It didn't open well. I know it's done okay because of good word of mouth. So I do encourage people to go see this in a theater and support this sort of movie making. Just be warned, it's PG-13. It is quite dark. There is a lot of violence here. It's not for little kids. So keep that in mind. But yeah, go see this if you're at all intrigued.
01:26:57
Speaker 2: You also caught up with Christian Mungiu's Fjord, Palme d'Or winner at last year's Cannes. stars Sebastian Stan and Renata Reinsva. They are a couple who emigrate with their children from Romania to Norway. Being a Munju film, I'm guessing that things don't go perfectly.
01:27:22
Speaker 1: Yeah, they get complicated, let's just say. And some of the things this movie is tackling, this Adam is creeping onto my top 10 list. So I'm going to preface by saying that, um, because his films often tackle difficult subjects and don't turn away from them. Um, but I think this is worth seeing, even if it's a bit of a heavy lift, it's handling Scandinavian progressivism, um, religious devotion, immigrant discrimination, parental rights, all of these things are at play and mixed up. I've been fascinated to see, this has been out in limited release for a week or two now, maybe three even, people reacting to this movie and he's pushing some real buttons here and some arguments as to, is this movie on the side of the Norwegian state when this family comes under question? I think I'll say for possible abuse. Is this movie on the side of the family? Is it not critical enough of their religious life? How is that related to their parenting style? It personally was fascinating having grown up in a fairly religiously devout family, raised my own kids this way. And this is a movie that is asking questions about what is the difference between unhealthy indoctrination and raising your kids to share your values. And it's doing that in a specific context, but we could ask that question in a secular context as well. Like just the values you want your kids, the perspectives you want your kids to have at one point, at what point are those the right things they should think, or should you be backing off and let them developing those things on their own? This movie is really provocative on that front. Um, I will also say it, um, this one in particular, I don't know that all of Mungu's films do this beyond the hills does this. And I think it's because they share a religious background. It messes with you think in terms of, is there any sort of spiritual metaphysical realm at play in what's going on? It does it very lightly. And in a way that, um, I almost missed in the middle and away at the end that I've also enjoyed seeing people argue about. We've been doing some talking about this on the film spotting discord, actually for film spotting family members.
01:30:01
Speaker 2: I've had some other people.
01:30:02
Speaker 3: Yes.
01:30:03
Speaker 1: Yeah. They've they're using the spoiler, the spoiler. So it's blocked out, which is helpful, but I've enjoyed hearing others interpretations about, let's just say the final shot of this movie. It's one of those films where that can reorient a lot of what you've been thinking about. I think obviously in a, healthy, provocative way, but I'm starting to see reactions dribble out where it's, um, people are responding strongly negative in a negative way to this film. That is also, I think to its credit, I think he's doing some really, um, interesting, helpful, provocative work here with Fjord. Not sure if it'll end up on my top 10 list, but, um, the more I sit and think about it, the more people I see write about it, or I have conversations with about it. Um, It's heading that way.
01:30:50
Speaker 2: What happened to you? I just fell down the stairs.
01:30:54
Speaker 3: You have to pray every day?
01:30:56
Speaker 1: What happens if you don't do your prayers?
01:30:58
Speaker 3: Is there a physical punishment? Define physical.
01:31:05
Speaker 2: 92%, not that it's the end-all be-all on Rotten Tomatoes, though. So critics, for the most part, are responding to it, as I think they usually do with Munju films. We've been very positive on his work here. I cannot wait to see it. It is out now.
01:31:19
Speaker 1: You've got to check it out.
01:31:19
Speaker 2: Yeah, in limited release. And we really debated whether or not to wait and discuss this one or just have you give your solo take because you caught up with it several weeks ago now at this point, I feel like.
01:31:31
Speaker 1: Yeah, I think it was part of the festivals are blurring together. I think it was part of the Chicago Fest. So yeah.
01:31:38
Speaker 2: And I can now see it. It just opened this past weekend, that film scene.
01:31:43
Speaker 3: Nice.
01:31:43
Speaker 2: Near me, but I knew I would not get to it before this recording. We thought it made sense to put it on everyone's radar and get your thoughts out there. Now, we may not get to talk about it again, maybe, until end of year time. We will see, but I will certainly catch up with Fjord. Wildwood is out in wide release.
01:32:02
Speaker 1: Nobody ever heard of the Harlem Culture Festival. Nobody would believe that happened.
01:32:10
Speaker 2: Let's look at some poll results. A couple weeks ago, prompted by You Can See Everything, we asked you about some other notable documentaries released this decade. The options we gave you were All the Beauty in the Bloodshed, Boys State, Dick Johnson is Dead, Fire of Love, Flee, No Other Land, Summer of Soul, or you could write in other. And Josh, I will go ahead and say right now, we got some really good write-ins. options via other, including one that would absolutely, at least one that would absolutely fit the category you were referencing when we were talking about You Can See Everything. I would put it up there with those other films.
01:32:55
Speaker
1: Okay, nice. Yeah, that'll be revealed in where other placed in this poll, because it wasn't in last place. We have three titles packed together here at the bottom, three to four percent of the vote for these, Boys State, Fire of Love, and Flea. Then All the Beauty in the Bloodshed received 7% of the vote. Tight pack here. No Other Land, 18%. Dick Johnson is dead, 19%. And then Other, also 19% of the vote. Winning the poll, though. A feel-good one, I think, for the most part. Summer of Soul, 26% of the vote. Eric B.
01:33:30
Speaker 2: Says, Summer of Soul may have cemented my son as a movie fan. He was eight, and I had taken him earlier in the afternoon to watch The Boss Baby 2. which he said at the time afterward he didn't enjoy. But he asked to stick around after to watch Summer of Soul with me, and watching that kid tap along with the music and ask questions when it was over, that's something I'll never forget.
01:33:50
Speaker 3: Wow.
01:33:50
Speaker 1: Yeah, just imagine having a bad time with Boss Baby 2 and then realizing, Dad, I could have been watching Summer of Soul. What are you taking me to? Here's Trent Robb. Great choices. So many different feels to all these movies. I was trying to decide between All the Beauty in the Bloodshed and Summer of Soul, two very different movies. I went with the one that is way ahead, so now I wish I would have given love to the other one.
01:34:17
Speaker 2: Andy Bucati in Kansas City says, Watching Paul McCartney literally create the song Get Back in real time is one of the highlights of any movie this decade in the Beatles' Get Back, while Grand Theft Hamlet, that is one we kicked around, was the most inventive use of the medium.
01:34:32
Speaker 1: Yeah, I think a golden brick Nominee Grand Prize.
01:34:35
Speaker 2: Absolutely. A finalist. That's right.
01:34:36
Speaker 1: Yep. Mark Friedman here. I'm voting Other. Afternoons of Solitude by Albert Serra. Serra provokes the audience to enter challenging spaces and confronts us with complex questions, but he does not proselytize or dictate truths, as many contemporary documentaries do. Serra has an artist's sensibility for depicting the beauty, ideology, and passion of his subjects while simultaneously invoking an outside observer's critical opinion. discomfort. Is this, is this the bullfighter one?
01:35:06
Speaker 2: The bullfighter doc that I had as my number three movie of last year. And not only that, I don't know if I mentioned this on air or not. If I did, it was a long time ago, but I did submit a review of Afternoons of Solitude, a written review. First time I've written a review of something in who knows how long to an academic journal, a sport journal that is going to be published. I just don't know when it's going to be published. So it will be my first academic publishing. I can't wait to share it with the world, but I don't have a publishing date yet. I will, of course, share that information when it does become available. Great pick, Mark. Aaron Bergstrom says, smashed other to represent for Adam Curtis, the definitive documentarian of our insane post 2016 times. Of his three exceptional works from this decade, including Russia, 1985 to 1999, Trauma Zone, 2022, and Shifty, 2025, I'm going with Can't Get You Out of My Head from 2021, which not only captures the vibe of the COVID era better than any other movie, but also compellingly and emotionally shows why so many radical progressive movements of the past 50 years have petered out and given birth to the authoritarian capitalist world of Trump at all. We live in the age of the information deluge, so it's fitting that a mosaic filmmaker like Curtis, working exclusively from archival footage, would be able to separate the signal from the noise.
01:36:38
Speaker 1: And Sam left a note here that Curtis's films can be found on the BBC iPlayer, and they're also on YouTube, if folks want to check those out. Here's Jeffrey Overstreet. Kauther Ben-Hania's film, Four Daughters, isn't just my favorite documentary of the decade so far, it's my favorite feature film of 2023. Its creative use of reenactments that involve people who were part of the original off-camera events makes it an interesting film to revisit while reflecting on You Can See Everything.
01:37:06
Speaker 2: Yeah.
01:37:06
Speaker 1: I think that one, Sam, considered for the poll as well, right?
01:37:10
Speaker 2: I think he did, and it deserved to be considered. We talked about it here on the show. Very good movie. And one that does indeed have performers, actors, actresses playing characters. But as I recall, performing actual lines, I think, from previous written down forms of expression. I can't remember exactly what the conceit is, but they are doing something that mirrors reality. but obviously using a narrative form in order to do it. Here's Bruce from Portland to close us out. Of the listed titles in this poll, I've only seen Boy State and Summer of Soul. I enjoyed both, but not as much as Secret Mall Apartment. In 2003, eight Rhode Islanders created a secret apartment inside a busy mall and lived there for four years, filming everything along the way. Another was Listers, a glimpse into extreme birdwatching. Two brothers dive into competitive birdwatching, living in a van for a year while traveling across the country to participate in a big year contest. Like You Can See Everything, both of these films begin as a stunt and wind up being so much more. I haven't heard of the latter. The former is one I meant to see and regret not catching up with it.
01:38:27
Speaker 1: Yeah, Secret Mall Apartment sounded fascinating. I never got to that either. And Listers, this kills me. I remember I think Dana Stevens might have actually put Lister's on her top 10 list.
01:38:37
Speaker 2: You might be right.
01:38:38
Speaker 1: Because she loved it so, so much. And I remember hearing her talk about it and meaning to watch it too. So there's another nudge from Bruce.
Thank you.
01:38:50
Speaker 2: We thank everyone. who voted in that poll and left a comment our new deeply flawed film spotting poll relates to Martin McDonough's latest Wild Horse 9 that comes to theaters this weekend it's the writer director's fifth feature for this poll we're only giving listeners two options Josh it is effectively sort of a death match.
01:39:12
Speaker 1: It's a death match between in Bruges and the Banshees have been a Sharon, but we're also giving the option of other. So I don't know, maybe, maybe with other there, it's not exactly a death match, but yeah, we thought those are the two most well-received and, um, have the most fans on letterboxd. I think Sam did some of that research. So we thought it'd be good to pit those against each other and see where people fall now. Uh, you know, I'm going to say this about the Genesis of this poll. Mm-hmm. I think if someone's dragging their feet about joining the film spotting family, uh, they should do so. And we should figure out a way if they do so in the next week to send them retroactively Sam's weekly email newsletter, right. Which was about this poll, but largely about his feelings on the films of Martin McDonough, um, which I'm not going to spoil here, but it was a fascinating read and all of Sam's emails, uh, Email newsletters are great that family members get, but this one I think is worth joining for.
01:40:15
Speaker 2: Okay. Great is a word for it. Josh, I like the way you phrased that. Certainly something that.
01:40:21
Speaker 1: Bold.
01:40:22
Speaker 2: Bold. I think bold is a very good word. Maybe better. We at least know this. We know that in 10 years, Sam will watch these movies again and change his mind. And that's the part I always look forward to.
01:40:33
Speaker 1: I think I might have actually told him we have a... We were wrong once episode, put it on the schedule. So, um, yeah, but you and I, you are the huge McDonough fan. I actually, without getting into it.
01:40:45
Speaker 3: Yeah.
01:40:46
Speaker 1: Go ahead. Without getting into it. I, I understand some of Sam's points he made there, but Banshees and Sharon is where I, I was just like, okay, everything this guy does well is clicking here. And so for me, it's a pretty, even though I liked in Bruges when it came out, I don't think I've seen it since Banshees is, is for me the pick.
01:41:06
Speaker 2: I don't think he's made a bad film. So yes, I'm a Martin McDonough fan. I don't go hard for In Bruges the way some people do, but I'm a fan of that. I think it's better than Seven Psychopaths, but I like that film too. It is Banshees. And yes, the one everyone gets all in an uproar about three billboards that I think are his two best works. And on that ground or on those grounds, then I do consider myself a Martin McDonough fan. I have also read some of his plays, and I like those works too. Let's just say Sam wishes there might have been a Behanding in whatever part of London Martin McDonagh grew up in, and he wouldn't be able to write his plays or his screenplays.
01:41:49
Speaker 1: Oh, wow.
01:41:50
Speaker 3: Wow.
01:41:51
Speaker 2: I don't know if he was that harsh, but- Yeah, pretty close.
01:41:54
Speaker 1: Speaking of We Were Wrong Once episodes, can we just please never do one on three billboards? Let's just You're just going.
01:42:01
Speaker 2: To go ahead and say, like, never going to happen. I mean, if there was ever.
01:42:04
Speaker 1: If you notice, I didn't even bring it up. We don't have to name that that movie exists.
01:42:07
Speaker 2: I know. If there was ever a movie to do it, though, it probably should be that one.
01:42:13
Speaker 1: Oh, my.
01:42:13
Speaker 2: What if I truly end up saying, yeah, hand up. Got it wrong. Terrible film.
01:42:19
Speaker 1: It's still not... As much as I would enjoy that, it's not worth having to watch Three Billboards again. But you didn't say anything to me. And you didn't do anything to me. Well, that's what I was thinking, like, I just don't like you no more.
01:42:35
Speaker 2: Well, we would love to know what you think about the career of Martin McDonagh, especially in the form of this poll. Do you have a clear preference between In Bruges or The Banshees of Inishere, or is it one of his other films? Please do vote and leave a comment at filmspotting.net. We might just read it on air. We'll share those results in a couple of weeks. Josh, that's our show.
01:42:59
Speaker 1: If you want to connect with us on social media, you can find Adam and the show on Instagram, Facebook, Letterboxd, YouTube, and Blue Sky at Film Spotting. You can find me at Larson on Film. We are independently produced and listener supported. So yes, you can support the show by joining the Film Spotting family at filmspottingfamily.com. You will listen early and ad free, but you'll also get that weekly newsletter from producer Sam, monthly bonus episodes too, and of course, access to the entire Outstreaming.
01:43:36
Speaker 2: This is one I'm sure we're both very curious about. Possible Love, the new one from director Lee Chong Dong. It's his first film since 2018's Very Good Burning. You can see that on Netflix. In limited release, Queen at Sea, a family struggles to care for a woman with advanced dementia. Juliette Binoche stars as the woman. Tom Courtney is her husband.
01:43:59
Speaker 1: This is the new one from Lance Hammer, the director who hasn't made a film since Ballast, which I loved. And so, yeah, I was excited to see that this was heading our way. I will have to catch it.
01:44:12
Speaker 2: Good cast, interesting director. I'm sold. Outwide, The Cat in the Hat, the animated film from the writer of Borat's subsequent movie film and girls' trip. Voices include Bill Hader, Quinta Brunson, and Bowen Yang. Godzilla minus zero. It's the sequel to 2023's Godzilla minus one. Also out wide, Josh, Jimmy, a Jimmy Stewart biopic. Now, Sam has put a question mark here in our notes. This suggests to me that maybe he hasn't seen the trailer. I've seen the trailer.
01:44:47
Speaker 1: Oh, you have?
01:44:48
Speaker 2: I've seen the trailer. It played before something I went to the other day. And it's a Jimmy Stewart biopic.
01:44:56
Speaker 1: Who's Jimmy Stewart?
01:44:58
Speaker 2: As far as I can recall, a nobody. Somebody I have never seen before. Someone I don't recall. But he is leaning into it. And I am not going to see this film.
01:45:12
Speaker 1: Until it's nominated for 10 Oscars.
01:45:14
Speaker 2: There you go. Martin McDonagh's Wild Horse 9. Sam Rockwell, John Malkovich. That is also out. And that might actually get 10 Oscar nominations later. the way people are talking about it next week in the film spotting feed, the movie racket with Michael Phillips is back after our great movie death match episode this week, where they're discussing two noir films debating between Ann Thompson and Matt Gorley debating, which noir classic starring Orson Welles is a bad guy is better touch of evil or the third man. That episode came out. We're back to the movie racket and you're going to get Matt Singer, who's also on Tuesday's Film Spotting streaming video unit with Jordan Hoffman. This was recorded at the Refocus Film Festival. They're going to be talking about comedy.
01:46:01
Speaker 1: What else?
01:46:02
Speaker 2: Matt Singer. He wrote a book.
01:46:03
Speaker 1: There you go. Perfect.
01:46:04
Speaker 3: Okay.
01:46:05
Speaker 2: On Tuesday's Film Spotting SVU, Matt and Jordan will be talking about the new Netflix film, Possible Love. On Thursday, The Next Picture Show has part two of their Albert Brooks and his film, Real Life, pairing with You Can See Everything. And on Friday, we'll see what else we get up to, but we will definitely talk about Wild Horse 9.
01:46:28
Speaker 1: Film Spotting is produced by Golden Joe DeSoto and Sam Van Halgren. Without Sam and Golden Joe, this show wouldn't go. Our production assistant is Sophie Kempinar. Ariana Martinez is our marketing and social media assistant. Special thanks to everyone at WBEZ Chicago. More information is available at wbez.org. For Film Spotting, I'm Josh Larson.
01:46:48
Speaker 2: And I'm Adam Kempinar. Thanks for listening.
01:46:50
Speaker 3: This conversation can serve no purpose anymore. Goodbye.