UDSKRIFT 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:12.000 --> 00:00:19.000
Hi, everyone. Welcome to another Bella Asks episode of the Ethicast. I'm your host, Bill Coffin.
2
00:00:19.000 --> 00:00:22.000
And I'm your co host, Julia Boyce.
3
00:00:22.000 --> 00:01:18.000
Here at Ethisphere, we believe there is no competition in compliance. That's why we're using this show as a platform to answer high level questions about business integrity that have been posed to us by the members of the Business Ethics Leadership alliance, or Bela. Bella is a global ethics and compliance community that provides exclusive access to helpful data, benchmarking events and other resources to advance your E and C program. It also provides a concierge service by which members can submit questions around best practices, and our internal experts will provide an answer, plus helpful resources with more information. Many of these questions are particular to a specific company's needs, but many more of them speak to challenges or opportunities facing ENC professionals everywhere. So in this episode, we're going to answer a few such questions as part of our ongoing mission to make the world a better place by advancing business integrity. Joining us once again to answer your questions is Bella chair Erica Salmon Byrne. Erica, it's so good to see you again. Thank you very much for joining us.
4
00:01:18.000 --> 00:01:26.000
Absolutely, Bill, I'm delighted to be here with you and Julia and have a chance to answer yet another great batch of questions from our brilliant community of Bella members.
5
00:01:26.000 --> 00:01:31.000
They are great questions. And Julia, I'm going to hand the mic over to you for the first one.
6
00:01:31.000 --> 00:01:54.000
Thanks, Bill. All right, Erica, we have been getting a lot of interesting and very specific questions around implementing AI within the ENC program. And the one we want to pitch to you today reads, for companies that use AI to manage their gifts and entertainment or conflicts of interest processes, do they usually build these solutions in house or do they outsource to vendors?
7
00:01:54.000 --> 00:05:51.000
It's a great question because both options are totally, totally viable depending upon your internal resources. So first thing I want to do is I want to reference two particular pieces of research that we have done, one of which is out already and one of which will be out very soon. So for those of you listening to the three of us who have not already spent a little bit of time with our AI report that we produced this summer, I definitely recommend taking a look because it's going to give you a great sense of, you know, what are the kinds of things that the ethics and compliance community is regularly doing to address AI, to use AI in their programs? What are some of the challenges they're running into, things like that. The second is we ran a research project this fall with the Bella community where we asked BELLA members about different workflow tools and whether or not they were satisfied with what they had in place or contemplating a change, would they recommend what they are currently using to other Bella members? So if you are a member of the community and you're listening to the three of us, definitely keep an eye out because that report will be coming out very soon. So now to get to the question. Julia, I hate to give the it depends answer, but honestly, it depends. And the reason it depends is this. It's all about your internal resources. If you are in a position where you have the internal resources to build on your own, you can do something that is very custom to your workflows, to your issues, to your concerns. If, on the other hand, your internal AI resources are busier building tools for sales, you're going to probably want to look at what is available in the third party, off the shelf vendor community. And a couple of things that if you go that route, you should really press your third parties on. Where does the data live? If I need to get my hands on a routing decision on an initial screen, on a triage on whatever the case may be, am I going to be able to get my hands on that? Importantly, can I defend how the decision was made? Do I understand enough of what is in the decision making process where the AI is sitting on top of my conflicts of interest process, for example? So let's say hypothetically, you are, you're, you know, you decide to utilize AI to speed up your AI, your conflicts of interest policy, and you give it, you know, several years worth of precedent and your policy, and you have it, you know, you start training it on how to make the initial decision as to whether or not something get needs to get escalated or not, or whether or not something needs to get triaged or have a mitigation plan or not. You definitely want to be able to defend down the road how you trained it, what information did you give it, things like that. You also want to make sure that you understand if, if and when the vendor updates the model. Who's responsible for making sure my process is still working? Right, because we've all seen situations, we've lived it here at Ethisphere, right? We have this wonderful regulatory update agent that runs regulatory research for us every morning while all of us are asleep. So we come in first thing and there's the little slack channel with a little regulatory update. And every time a model update gets pushed, the agent goes a little haywire, right? Does some misses some things, decides justice.gov is no longer in my instructions. So I'm not going to see what the DOJ is doing. Right. You have to build that into whatever AI processes you're doing internally. And so if you're building it yourself, your IT team should give you a heads up when model updates are getting pushed. If you're doing a third party, how are you going to know, right. How are you going to know if an update gets pushed and something decides to stop working? So couple pieces, a couple thoughts
Load full transcript
there on that one. Both are totally viable routes, really just depends on your individual company circumstances.
8
00:05:51.000 --> 00:05:57.000
Great. Thank you so, so much, Erica and Bill, I'm going to toss it to you for our next question.
9
00:05:57.000 --> 00:06:20.000
Thank you so much. And by the way, it's been a while since we got a really good it depends answer from Erica and Bill asks. So I feel like we've returned to form. It's such a, such a great thing, Erica. Our next question is about whistleblowing and it reads, is it considered a good practice for global companies to maintain a separate standalone whistleblowing policy versus addressing within the code of conduct and or broader ethics policies?
10
00:06:20.000 --> 00:08:40.000
Yep. So this is a place where we've been seeing a lot of evolution, Bill, and we've been particularly seeing it since the European Union Whistleblower Directive came into effect a couple of years ago, where more and more organizations are deciding that there is enough that needs to live in this document that it should have its own space. So we see references for sure in things like codes of conduct and other related policies. But increasingly we are seeing a speak up policy that is kind of a standalone document, not 100% of the time for sure. But companies are increasingly saying, you know what, there is now enough I need to cover here that goes into how does my process work? That goes into, you know, where to go if you have questions. That goes into specific Q and A on things like retaliation prevention, expectations of investment investigators, how should I be treated during the course of an investigation? All of those things are increasingly things that we are seeing show up in these standalone policies that then get cross referenced in a number of different places. So as I said, not, you know, not everywhere at this point, but certainly something we are seeing as on the rise and that that on the riseness is definitely being driven by companies wanting to get information in front of employees in a way where they are able to let it breathe because it's got, you know, it's not, it's not buried in a code of conduct. It's not in a part of the page. You're going to skim over things along those lines. So if you're out there listening to the three of us and you're thinking, you know, do I want to take a second look at my speak up language? Do I want to take a second look at my non retaliation language? Definitely. I would sort of take those pieces together and then ask yourself, you know, is this topic worthy of a standalone document? It do I want to give it the gravitas of a standalone document? Do I want to allow it to have that kind of space where I can then have shorter references in other places? But I have this kind of central repository of my company's approach to these key issues. So that's not quite an it depends answer, Bill, but it's awfully close.
11
00:08:40.000 --> 00:08:49.000
Well, look, I have a
follow up question for you, but it's not a true follow up. It's really, it's a sneaky double header question. But it really kind of takes a. It's on a related subject because
12
00:08:49.000 --> 00:08:50.000
when
13
00:08:49.000 --> 00:09:03.000
we talk about whistleblowing that very naturally segues into internal investigations. So this is really an investigations question and it reads, should there be a dividing line between investigators who engage in fact finding and those who are involved in the disciplinary process?
14
00:09:03.000 --> 00:13:46.000
Yeah. So I'm going to break disciplinary process into two component pieces here, Bill. You have a recommendation of discipline. And we do often see an investigator who's engaging in fact finding, who at the end of that report will say something along the lines of, you know, these allegations are substantiated and based upon our disciplinary matrix, you know, this particular fact pattern, you know, should be eligible for this kind of discipline. Right. Assuming of course, that you have a disciplinary matrix and you have precedent that you have been tracking. So some of the component pieces of answering this question really go into the infrastructure of your investigations process. Is discipline, disciplinary decision making, purely the remit of human resources, employee relations and the business line manager, which in many organizations it still is or is disciplinary decision making and disciplinary calibration. Something where you are trying to look broadly across the business and you have some recommendations based upon precedent of different types of discipline that are available for different types of misconduct. So one of the things we're seeing a lot of organizations do and have done over the course of the last couple of years is really look at what kind of discipline is appropriate for a specific level of misconduct and to try to standardize that across the business so that people understand how you came to the discipline you came to and you're not running into situations where discipline decisions are dependent upon how important a particular employee might be to a particular part of the business. Right. This is an effort to get out in front of the typical highest performing salesperson can get away with everything. Or based on the news the last couple of days, legendary CEO can get away with stuff that really like, I mean, you're threatening to pull off your employees arms and beat them to death with them. Like, come on, man. And for anybody who hasn't read the latest New York Times story on the culture at Nvidia, that is what I am referencing. So back to the question. The disciplinary decision making matrix is the process document that allows you, when you have that high performing salesperson who engages in substantiated misconduct, it allows you to have something to fall back on so that you can say to that manager who's mad that they are going to have to discipline their high performing salesperson. This is how we handle tier three concerns. And so if you have that document, then what we see investigators doing is saying, you know, these are the, these are the facts. And we recommend to the disciplinary committee that this be considered a Tier 3 eligible for this discipline. They're not involved in decision making, but we do see them involved in recommendations in the event that there is that kind of disciplinary matrix that they can use to guide those recommendations. In the absence of that, generally speaking, what we see is a divide. Investigators engage in fact finding. They recommend whether or not something is substantiated. And then there is a different group that determines discipline. The challenge, if you have that different group determining discipline is what guides that group? How do you think about consistency within that group? How do you navigate challenges about key personnel in that group? What does your escalation process look like? Who's responsible for making sure the discipline actually happens? Right. These are all questions that are critically important from an employee perspective in terms of trusting the process. And yet they are very challenging to navigate in the moment when you attach people's names to those decisions. So like many things that you and I touch on, Bill, on this program, I recommend taking a Lockean utopia style position and get these things in place before you have to use them. Right. Imagine what you want the process to look like if you don't know who's going to have to engage in that process. And that's the conversation to have so that you have some tools to guide you in these, these moments that can get, I mean, look, some of these decisions are the hardest things that ethics and compliance teams have to deal with on a regular basis. And the more structure you have that you can fall back on because everybody agreed on the structure and the hypothetical, the better.
15
00:13:46.000 --> 00:13:52.000
Outstanding. Well, thank you so very much for that answer, Erica. And for our next question. Julia, I'm going to hand things back over to you.
16
00:13:52.000 --> 00:14:12.000
Yeah, thank you, Bill. We're going to pivot a little bit. Erika, our next question is, it's really interesting and it's about how shareholders are viewing ethics and compliance. The question reads, are there any surveys targeting shareholders or investors specifically to gauge their perspectives on enc?
17
00:14:12.000 --> 00:17:39.000
Yep. Great question. And it's one of those questions that I love to see come in from the Bella community because it really goes to this analysis of who are our key stakeholders. And without question, shareholders slash investors are critically important stakeholders. Whether you are publicly traded company where you probably have somebody that's engaging pretty regularly with your key, your key large investors at a minimum, or if you're a privately held company and you've
got an ownership structure and you, you know, kind of know a little bit more about who those people might be. So from a broad survey perspective, you know, we have not seen a ton of survey work of that community done over the course of the last couple of years. The last broad survey of investors I was able to find was from 2023. And at that point, for sure, business integrity was a critically important question that, that investors were responding to. Now, obviously, the world's a little different now than it was in 23. We have seen a little bit of a decrease in terms of interest in things like ESG and long term investing. But I did find, you know, an interesting piece of research that we've been citing a lot this year about the risk factors that organizations are navigating. So this is not a, an investor side survey. It's a, it's a leader side survey. So it was a survey that was sent out to CEOs and other kind of key chief executives at companies. And they all cited governance concerns, which is basically where ENC fits as the most important reputational risk factor for them in 2026. And so, you know, we've had a lot of examples of what can happen when governance goes south. We've had a lot of examples of what can happen when potentially your ethics and compliance program is not as well staffed or resourced as it should be. We have seen, I mean, again, not to pick on Nvidia, but it's Nvidia is, this is the dominant story right now for so many people that are kind of tracking this whole, this whole issue. And you know, if you look at the Export control side, which of course for an organization like Nvidia is a key piece of the compliance functionality. If I'm an investor, right. I mean, I think there are six derivative lawsuits that have been filed so far. Like, if I'm an investor, I'm pretty upset about what is coming out from an ethics and compliance perspective. So, you know, I think there are lots of proof points, Julia, of all of the reasons why investors should be caring about these issues. And then the last thing I would offer to anybody listening to us who is curious about kind of how to get their arms around this a little bit more is I would go talk to, particularly if you're publicly traded, when was the last time you talked to your corporate secretary or your investor relations team about what they're hearing from investors about your organization specifically? So the question was, was phrased as kind of a broad question about what are we seeing about shareholders and investors perspectives on these issues broadly. But, you know, your individual shareholders are likely in communication with someone at your organization. They are probably talking about you on investor message boards. Someone is watching Discord, someone is watching Reddit, someone is watching, you know, the market movement that is happening around your organization. So go get that information because odds are there's something in there that you as an ENC professional can use.
18
00:17:39.000 --> 00:17:52.000
Thanks, Erica. That's great advice and things I'd never thought of before. So thank you, Bill. I want to pass it to you because I think we have time for an extra question today.
19
00:17:52.000 --> 00:18:12.000
I think we do. Thank you so very much. Dalia. This next question is around consumer privacy laws. And it reads, which area within the organization should be responsible for creating the processes around consumer privacy laws, such as gdpr, ccpa, the India DPDP act, et cetera, and which area should be responsible for handling the requests directly?
20
00:18:12.000 --> 00:20:47.000
Yep. So this is an area of tremendous evolution, Bill, and we see that in our data. So if you go back to 2019, 2020, 2021, and you look at some of the data that's available from a benchmarking perspective in, in our platform, you'll see kind of this like, little bit of jagged movement on who, who owns privacy. Is it in the ethics and compliance teams remit? Is it a team that sits next to the ethics and compliance team? And what we have seen, particularly over the course of the last couple of years is a real sort of, you know, like the lines kind of hockey sticking. Right. In terms of ethics and compliance teams being responsible for data privacy. Now, does that mean data privacy process or does that mean data Privacy policies. And more often than not, what we see when we dig into this is the E and C team is responsible for setting down the company's position in terms of how they will handle GDPR or these other related privacy laws. What does the policy look like? What do teams that actually interact with this information need to do? They will be a key stakeholder in things like process mapping, in things like employee training around these concerns. But the actual implementation of the process of handling requests for, you know, access to information, request update information, you know, some of the different consumer side pieces of things very rarely live with that particular team. Instead, they live with the team that is responsible for collecting and managing that information. So it's a cross functional exercise. Inside most organizations, what we see is, you know, whether it's marketing or sales or some other group that that is actually holding, collecting, holding, navigating and utilizing this information, those are the groups that are responsible for the actual activities associated with these data privacy rules. But the ENC team is a critical stakeholder in setting expectations, setting policy, educating employees on what's expected, and sort of navigating the control, putting in place the controls. So if we think about a lot of this work as people processing controls, right. The ENC team is involved in the people side of things. What do people need to understand? They are a stakeholder in process, but they are rarely the ones that are actually doing that piece of the work.
21
00:20:47.000 --> 00:21:08.000
Thanks, Erica. As we wrap up this episode, we want to thank all of those in the Bela community who shared these great questions. Erika, for those who are unfamiliar with the Business Ethics Leadership alliance, what's something that you love about Bela that might not be on everyone's radar yet. Yet. And where can people go to learn more?
22
00:21:08.000 --> 00:22:57.000
So I think this month, Julia, what I am loving about Bella is, is two things. The first, and you guys got just a little bit of a taste of this during the course of the four questions we answered in this episode. This is a very sophisticated group of ethics and compliance professionals that are asking hard questions of us and of each other. Right. So like, we are not doing surface stuff over here. I almost said something instead of stuff, so I'm glad I didn't. We're not doing surface stuff over here. Right. We are really digging into how do you demonstrate the roi? How do I more efficiently target my communications? Right. Bill and Julia and I chose four questions out of about 40 that we could have done on this particular episode of Bella Asks. And they were all, all interesting, tough, sophisticated questions with people about people who are really trying to push the. The work that we do here. And so I love being part of that. It challenges us every day to find, you know, the community, the resources and the answers that they need. So that is one of my. My favorite things. And my second favorite thing is related to that, which is, you know, everybody inside of Bella lives by the mantra that there's no competition and compliance. And so we are fortunate to shepherd and curate a community of people who are not just asking tough, sophisticated questions, but are sharing what they've tried and hasn't worked. Right. How hard is it to tell somebody that you failed at something? Like, we've got a lot of people here who'll be like, yeah, I tried that. Sorry, not working. Next. Right. Um, and we can all learn from that. And so. So those are. Those are this month's two favorite things about Bella.
23
00:22:57.000 --> 00:23:34.000
Well, if you have a question that you would like answered on this program, please contact the Bella concierge service and we'll get to work on it for you right away. This has been another Bella Asks episode of the Ethicast. Thank you so much for joining us. We hope you've enjoyed the show. For new episodes of the Ethicast each week, be sure to subscribe to us on YouTube, Apple Podcasts, and Spotify. Also, if you haven't already, please follow at the sphere on LinkedIn to learn more about how we help organizations measure and improve their ethics and compliance programs. Together, we can make the world a better place by advancing business integrity. That's all for now, but until next time, remember, strong ethics is good business. See you soon.
24
00:23:34.000 --> 00:23:51.000
Bye. All. Right, there.