UDSKRIFT 🔗
Intro
Broadcasting around the world. This is engineering. Tomorrow, the podcast committed to bringing you the best in commercial construction, design and engineering from the brightest minds in the industry. This is the stuff they don't teach you in school. So sit back, relax and open your mind. You're about to get the insider knowledge to improve your next construction project or advance your career.
Intro
This is engineering. Tomorrow.
Brian Gomski - Midwest Machinery
Hey, everybody. We are here today with Joe Parsons, who is the senior marketing sustainability manager for ClimateMaster. And today we are talking about the huge tax incentives that have been released by and passed by Congress. And I found no one better as it relates to geothermal. To talk to about some HVAC credits moving forward for specifically commercial and commercial businesses.
Brian Gomski - Midwest Machinery
So, Joe, thanks for meeting with us today.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
Sure. Glad to be here. Glad always glad to talk about tax credits. Sure.
Brian Gomski - Midwest Machinery
So I guess, what exactly are these tax credits that have passed for geothermal? Let's kind of just start there.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
Okay. You're talking about primarily about commercial converters. So we'll focus there. Yeah, we've had a 10% tax credit for commercial geothermal applications for many years now. What the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 has done for us, it's increased that. So now we have the opportunity to go from 10% to 30% or even beyond. We'll talk about some of the bonus bonus areas as we go through the conversation today.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
But the way the tax rate is structured now, we start out at 6%. We have the option to do five times 6% or get to 30%. And in order to do that, your project needs to be if your project is less than one megawatt. Basically, a thermal transfers of your system is your cooling load for your cooling capacity of your system is less than one megawatt.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
We're about 284 tons on a project. Then you would immediately qualify for 30%. You get the five times bonus. Your project is larger than that and we're seeing a lot of commercial projects that that need more than 284 times. Then that project you had to use prevailing wage rates and also have an apprenticeship program and that was included in the bill just really for jobs creation.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
That was one of the justifications for, you know, for the inflation reduction and job creation around geothermal systems. So that is the other qualifier projects. Also that started before January 29th, 2023 also would qualify. So there was a ruling that was made basically back in November that said anything that happened within 60 days or started within 60 days would also be grandfathered in.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
So those are really the qualifiers now. But in 2023, no less than one megawatt or use prevailing wage rate and having an apprenticeship program that gets to 30%.
Brian Gomski - Midwest Machinery
That sounds like pretty good. But tax credit does the we haven't seen anything like this in the commercial space prior to this.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
No, absolutely not. Absolutely. It's been capped at 10%. We did have, you know, before we also had accelerated depreciation. We still have that. That makes this you know, the credits are even more lucrative, really, for commercial applications.
Brian Gomski - Midwest Machinery
So, okay, we've got this tax credit, I'm sure the commercial building or even. But what about what about, like a a school? Would they qualify for the tax credit?
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
Absolutely. And that's something that's new we really should talk about before, in order to get a tax credit, you have to have tax liabilities. They have to get tax load. And when you had tax load, you could get a credit against against your the taxes that you owed. What has happened with the passage of this bill? Now, nonprofits can also qualify.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
So this really expands the market. So local, state, local governments, for example, government buildings or even rural electric co-ops that can qualify for the credits. And so obviously schools K through 12 schools obviously would qualify. But since there is no tax liability, there's options now for transfer ability and actually direct pay of this tax credit. So it's basically like you're getting a rebate.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
It's basically like Treasury is going to write you a check once your project is completed. So you can use that. You know, those funds to offset the cost of geothermal. And you could, you know, use it for really any purpose. So it's really opened up the market substantially where before lots of lots of projects were done around schools, but they just couldn't take advantage of the tax credits.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
And so the payback period, you know, payback period with geothermal were good. They were typically in the 5 to 6 year range as far as, you know, paying back the incremental difference as compared to the system that would have gone in before. But this is just totally changed the landscape where you're looking at, you know, systems that actually were cash positive in the first year.
Brian Gomski - Midwest Machinery
When is, you know, if I'm and I think we should also mention that this tax credit is for renovations as well. It's not just for new buildings. So if you're looking to replace all your equipment, you could also qualify for that for that tax credit. Now, let's say I'm in that scenario. I'm either I'm either in charge of a nonprofit building or school and we're evaluating what heating and cooling system or we're a commercial building and we're evaluating healing and heating and cooling options.
Brian Gomski - Midwest Machinery
Who what's the process? What's the best way to take your typical system, whether it just be rooftop units or or
Load full transcript
whatever, and then compare it to geothermal and then do the math on if this makes sense or not. Like, how would you recommend going about that?
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
Yeah, that's it's a good question and it's it's we have a solution for that. So what we've done at ClimateMaster has created what we call geoeconomics tool. Okay. And this takes into consideration the geothermal product, the efficiency of it, and basically the cost per square foot for that project for geothermal. And also it takes into consideration whatever system would have been selected for that before it did go to commercial building.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
They've already specked in something that's more conventional than geothermal. So you have that that number already. You know, most designers, most system designers will understand the cost per square foot of that technology. And if they've done any sort of geothermal design, they also understand, you know, the opposing cost per square foot. So that really becomes the basis with the calculation.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
But the cool thing about this tool is we baked in all the tax information. So you going to tell you're going to basically what the dropdown menu, you know, what type of building it is, where it's located because that's going to tell you about the state taxes and the federal taxes, all that gets rolled into this calculation. Also, you're going to say if this building is, you know, for a nonprofit organization, if it's a scope, for example, you know, if it's an ad score, for example, you know, some sort of pass through entity, you load that in as well.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
So all this is done very easily and you can do this calculation probably easily within 15 or 20 minutes so that you can get from I know about geothermal, I've heard of super efficient. We've also heard it's super expensive, you know, So this gets you from no to go basically pretty, pretty quickly. And again, it bakes in all the information around the taxes.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
You tell it also when you know when that project goes, it actually begins when when usually when the project began. So you tell it a year and you even tell it the quarter where it was started because that's going to be used to calculate your accelerated depreciation, all that rolls in. So what you're going to end up with, ultimately you're going to have a cost for the geothermal system.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
So you have the overall operating savings and then you all and then you also have the depreciation effect. So good thing about geothermal, it qualifies as an energy property and it's can be depreciated over a five year period where conventional equipment gets 39 year straight line depreciation. So that it takes a long time for, you know, the you know, the units have already been replaced before they actually depreciate themselves.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
So you're looking at five years plus. There's also a bonus depreciation that's baked into into the tax bill now, which means in the first year, if you elect to have you tax situation where it's beneficial for you to take that depreciation in the first year, you can take in 2023, you can take up to 80% of that cost in the first year makes a huge difference.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
You do have to reduce your tax basis by 50% of the tax credit itself. But again, you're looking at commercial applications where this tool will show that you're cash positive in the first year while it's amazing, it's just it's truly amazing to see how quickly you can accomplish this just by plugging in those numbers. Also, we talked about 30%, but there are opportunities to get to 40% or even 50% tax credits.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
Now. And this calculator also factors that in so you're going to tell it, you know, if you didn't qualify, you could it would pull up the rate of 6% if you didn't qualify for the bonus. But there are ways of getting beyond 30% to 40 and 50. So you get to 40. Basically, you're looking at what is what's known as domestic domestic content.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
There's still a lot of clarification that's needed around what that project needs to look like to qualify for domestic content. But generally as a an equipment manufacturer, you know, first of all, product has to be manufactured in the U.S. basically not assembled, but manufactured. So you're taking components and building, putting things together. So it has to be manufactured in the US.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
And it stands right now, it looks like the qualifier is going to be, at least for the first couple of years of basically 40% of the cost of that manufactured product in the US needs to be with products that are US made basically. So you could have a a unit that might have a partner come from Germany, you know, but you have to to reduce the overall percentage by the cost of that particular item.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
So that's also a schedule increase over the years. So that I think by 2027 the content is going to be up to like 55%. But it looks like most of the geothermal systems are manufactured in the US already. So major manufacturers are here. So it looks like from a standpoint of the geothermal heat pumps, that part should be covered without any questions.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
So anyway, expecting more guidance from Treasury coming later in the year on exactly. In a calculated weight. Go ahead.
Brian Gomski - Midwest Machinery
What would you one more question about qualifying. What if someone says, man, there's a 30% tax credit, I'm going to I'm just going to drill one geothermal well and then I'm out of fluid coolers and Bunsen ciliary stuff. What is the actual like requirement for that?
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
Yeah, basically you're looking at, you know, 75% of the the thermal requirement needs to be provided by the ground. I think that that's a good way a good way to look at that. And again, I think that was
done to one. Obviously, we're trying to save energy here. We're trying to, you know, enhance decarbonization throughout the country. So having the efficiency is, you know, is there We have systems out there, though, that don't incorporate drag.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
It works, for example, but they're not there to mitigate the load, you know, the cooling. They're there basically, and they're typically only operate in the winter. So you're basically recharging at ground. So heat that you dissipate it in throughout the summer months. You can bring that back over. We come over when it's 46 degrees outside or lower. So we're basically recharging that loop and your loop field stays more constant, link temperature stays constant and maintains a higher efficiency.
Brian Gomski - Midwest Machinery
What's so we're going to we've decided we're going to move forward with geothermal. How much of this project can I include in my total submission for the tax credit? Like, is it just the equipment? Does it include the the wells? Does it include the labor to drill the wells like what's all what all covered under the tax credit that we can submit for.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
geothermal commercial site is pretty unique. And the fact that the project, the basis for the project includes most almost every everything related to that project. Okay. And this is, you know, we've had that 10% tax credit. So this is, you know, this ruling, these rulings have come down over many years. So, you know, 10% tax credit. You basically recount, obviously your your labor to install a loop, the interconnecting piping, the wiring, the electrical to support the heat pump operation in downstream items like piping and pumping and, you know, air handlers, things like that are included.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
Even the engineering and the design work that can be attributed to the AC system will be included in the in the basis of the system. So it's if you've covered most everything, everything we're on the residential side. It's the some uncertainty, but basically on the residential side, it's pretty much limited to the to the ground loop and the equipment and not really covering downstream items like, you know, radiant floor system, things like that.
Brian Gomski - Midwest Machinery
Okay. When it comes to the actual application, are we pre qualifying, are we pre qualifying ahead of time or are we doing this project? And then just submitting post project And then the would you recommend when it comes to the actual paperwork working with to get that submitted.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
Okay. That's a really good question and there are a couple of different answers for it. So if you're in a in a in a taxable situation, okay, first of all, you need to be using our calculator to determine, you know, what your exposure is going to be so that you can justify that expenditure. But there's really no requirement for pre qualification for taxable situations.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
There's some guidances just come out. You're supposed to be some clarification. Recall next week in Washington to clarify what is required for those nontaxable entities. So it looks right now that there will be a pre-qualification process for nonprofits. Okay, so you're going to have to file and the forms aren't available yet. Obviously. But what we've learned so far is you'll need to file for pre-approval.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
You'll be assigned a number basically, which will follow that, follow that project through. And then also nonprofits. You typically didn't even have to file a tax return will have to file a tax return. Now to you know, to receive that, you have to initiate that rebate check. Okay. So that's that's that's kind of the long and short of it.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
There are some requirements coming out looking for clarification toward the end of the year and some but like I say, some of the tax forms won't even be created until 2024.
Brian Gomski - Midwest Machinery
Okay. When is the best time to I guess if I am going back to my previous scenario, I'm in charge of construction for this project or or it's my building. When is the best time to start looking at geothermal and what what trades or entities should get involved, i.e. like is this at the engineering phase or do you want to get involved?
Brian Gomski - Midwest Machinery
You want to start this at the architecture phase, Like what's the best time to start this whole process with geothermal, not only using your tool but just getting the all parties involved and what parties need to be involved in that decision.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
Again, another really good question. You know, the answer is is certainly as soon as possible, because obviously with geothermal system you have to deal with ground level. So, you know, there are opportunities to during, you know, virtual site work for a and some of this could start really, you know, long before the construction process begins. So if you had made your decision to go geothermal and can do some of the installation of the ground loop before the construction starts, you know, that's always a good thing because, you know, it's much easier to get the drilling equipment in.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
You're not having to do to move around, you know, very carefully and set up drills. It's it's a lot easier to come in. It's a lot more economical to bring in a commercial driller so that they can do. You know, some of these projects have several hundred boreholes. So, you know, for them to be able to get in and do that and a production scale is a lot more economical than coming in after after the fact.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
Also, there's some projects where the leaks are actually going under the building. So for the slab is forward. So, you know, during that process, so it, you know, it makes make sense to do that. We have a project, it's a it's almost commercial in nature just because the size of
the building development and in Kentucky and all of those ground are put you know under these residential applications underneath underneath the slab.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
So doing that planning ahead, it just makes a lot more sense. It makes it a lot more economical to do that. But you're going to need to involve your geothermal system designer quickly, too, so that you know exactly how much ground to to install. You'll be really working through cross-platform through all of the, you know, all the trades and engineering segments of that project.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
So you're going to need accurate load calculation. Obviously that's going to roll into the loop calculation to determine how much loop is that's going to be based on where the system's located. You know, is it a cooling dominant system or a heating dominant system? All that's going to roll into making sure that you have enough ground room to support the work that you do on the systems.
Brian Gomski - Midwest Machinery
Okay. I think that is all the questions I had. I mean, I think you did a really good job answering and clarifying a lot of things that a lot of people were wondering about this new tax credit. Is there anything else that you would like to add that we haven't covered today regarding the incentives?
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
one more thing for sure, because I've mentioned before, there's an opportunity to get to 50% tax credit and I'm really didn't discuss how to do that. There are there's a segment of the bill that deals with energy communities, and these are locations that have been where there's been a great deal of emphasis and employment around fossil fuel.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
Getting this call it if you're a fossil fuel employment areas.
Brian Gomski - Midwest Machinery
Okay.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
And if you're in one of those areas, there are a couple of ways of qualifying. So if you're in an area where there has been a coal fired power plant that's closed basically after 1999, or if you are in an area where a coal mine is actually closed, I think that the day time after 1995, then you would qualify for could qualify for an additional credit there.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
So that's one area. So if your project is in one of those areas and this is based around a census tract, okay. But it's not just that census tract where that plant was located or it mine was located, but any census tract that was actually adjoining or abutting that census tract would also be covered. So there are maps out there.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
That deal is put on the Internet now where you can actually see this and you can see census tracts. Typically they're represented in like a dark orange and then a lighter orange surrounding the area surrounding that. And that was done really, too, because, again, this is around job creation and putting back into those areas where people are involved in fossil fuel industry and they could have potentially lost their jobs or whatever.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
So you got you got those plant closures, coal mine closures. And then there are also areas that are what are basically called statistical areas. So you've got metropolitan, metropolitan statistical areas and then you've got non-metro areas, so basically rural areas. So these areas, if you you have a in the area that would qualify if again, if there had been involvement in the fossil fuel industry and if the rate of unemployment is substantially higher than, again, another area basically.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
So it's really interesting. We put together some maps that illustrate this quite well and there's a substantial amount of the country that is are in these areas. A lot of the coastal areas in Texas, I'd say you have 50% of the state of Texas would qualify for this some areas in the in the southwest as well. So it's really interesting that, you know, that this could take your tax credit from 40 to 50%.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
Also. Excuse me also, if you're building on an area that's been determined to be a brownfield site, also that would qualify for the additional 10%.
Brian Gomski - Midwest Machinery
Okay, Joe, I want to thank you for taking the time to help us clarify and where can everyone check out the tool that we mentioned earlier to get your estimations? And then if they're interested in continuing that conversation with geothermal, who should they reach out to?
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
So to get the information, just come to our website. You can go to climate investor dot com or cc climate controller dot com. Very easy to find what you'll find there a link to be able to download the you know the calculator tool. There are also tax credit brochures both for residential and commercial. It can be downloaded. These are relatively large documents that go through the credits and really continually update.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
As I mentioned before, there's a lot of information that is coming out piecemeal from Treasury basically as to what qualifies when it qualifies, what are the processes to get that done. So we keep those as current as possible. So those are available for download and basically to get more information, I would suggest reaching out to your local, your regional representative from ClimateMaster.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
You know, they've gone through the training, they understand the credits and if they can't get those answers, most have access also to a presentation or several presentations that we put together. A completed webinar actually just yesterday or two days ago. Now, the Contracting Business magazine. So those presentations are out there and available. And if you if you need a copy of those presentations to better understand it, those reps can provide you with a copy of that.
Brian Gomski - Midwest Machinery
All right. All right, Joe, thanks again. And if anything changes with the tax credits, we will have you back on and hopefully explain that further. Otherwise, everyone I strongly consider it doesn't hurt anything to just check the comparison with geothermal. This is, in my opinion, the best time that we have ever seen to install geothermal with the incentives that are out right now.
Brian Gomski - Midwest Machinery
So. All right. Thanks again, Joe.
Joe Parsons - ClimateMaster
All right. Thanks.
Outro
Thanks for joining us on engineering Tomorrow. If you liked the show, please take a moment to subscribe on iTunes or Spotify for even more great engineering or construction knowledge, visit engineering tomorrow. Dot Blog.