UDSKRIFT 🔗
Creating the Conditions to Thrive
===
[00:00:00]
Liz Worthen: Hello and welcome back to the Creating Value in Schools podcast with me, Liz Worthen, where we talk about ways to work sustainably and flourish in your school life. Today we're starting with a question, what's enabled you to thrive in your education role?
And to help answer that, I'm delighted to have with me Yamina Bibi, who will be drawing on her own experience and the research project she's part of, to help us unpick ways to remove barriers, be more inclusive, and create belonging. Let's dive in. Oh, welcome, Yamina. It is great to be with you. I'm looking forward to delving into ways we can thrive and flourish in our education careers, inspire others to do the same and understand what can get in the way and what we can do about it. Now you've had an interesting career journey, which has taken you from the classroom to senior leadership out of school back in again.
So what or who would [00:01:00] you say has enabled you to thrive in your career?
Yamina Bibi: Oh, great question. Thank you so much for having me. It's great to be here. What or who has helped me thrive? I've been very lucky to have a number of mentors and coaches who've really supported me and empowered me. And I think as somebody who suffers, I'm gonna use the word suffering, but really deals with inner critic and imposter syndrome, I don't always necessarily see what I can do really well. And it's been really powerful to have mentors and coaches who really supported me to either elicit the brilliance within me, but also just to develop me in, in my own competence and understanding of myself. So, particularly, there's so many I could shout out 'cause I've just been very lucky to have so many, particularly female leaders, I should say, who supported my journey.
But my NQT mentor, my first mentor when I was studying, you know, doing my first year of teaching, Teresa Dunseith was absolutely like my inspiration to, with everything I do now. Like really [00:02:00] thinking about teacher education, supporting others in the profession. Teresa did it all and I always talk about how I want to be more Teresa.
So definitely, Teresa at the start of my career. And then as I've headed through into senior leadership, I've been really lucky to be led by some incredible leaders, female leaders again, but Thahmina Begum, who was my head teacher when I was at Forest Gate Community School, was one of the youngest head teachers in the country when she was appointed.
But also from my own experience, the only hijab wearing Muslim female head teacher that I saw and that I worked directly with. And she just really helped me see the brilliance in myself, but also believed in me. And I, I found that really hard 'cause I'm not very good at believing in myself, but she did and she taught, she did both the kind of radical candour approach where she supported me a lot, but she also challenged me to think differently and to, you know, think of myself differently.
And I, yeah. So that, those are my [00:03:00] two kind of icons in the education sector who've helped me to thrive.
Liz Worthen: Oh, amazing. Thank you. Actually, tell me a little bit more about the term radical candour. I think I, I feel like I've heard it, but I dunno a lot about it.
Yamina Bibi: Yeah, it's from the book titled Radical Candor by Kim Scott.
And I will, I'm somebody who's not very good at having those more challenging or courageous conversations, particularly at the start of my career or when I became a kind of middle leader, senior leader. And it was Thahmina actually who recommended it to me and said, look, have a read of this book. And essentially the term is about how we help our others grow, particularly people that we're, we are leading.
And it talks about this kind of quadrant of like providing high challenge and high support. And then if we do that really well, we will be helping colleagues grow. And it's about profound growth. But then she also talks about what happens when it's the opposite, when there's low challenge and low support, and really talks about how that comes across.
And how as leaders we need to be in that space where we help us, you know, help others grow, but also [00:04:00] have those courageous conversations that help us grow as well. So yeah, that's what I understand from that term.
Liz Worthen: Oh, really interesting. Yes. Which actually brings us onto, so it's brilliant, isn't it, that you've encountered great mentors and people who've encouraged you. But I know one of the things you are very involved with, isn't it, is the project which Mission 44 are funding to investigate diversity and how we can increase diversity in initial teacher training and, and the barriers that people face.
'cause I think we know that, uh, people from different backgrounds, they apply to teacher training, but don't necessarily get in or, or don't complete or the dropout rates are higher. So yeah, tell us a bit about through that work, what are some of the barriers that you see to people being able to thrive and flourish in their school careers?
Yamina Bibi: Yeah, thank you. The Mission 44 funded project is in consortium with Being Luminary, the Chartered College of Teaching and Chiltern Learning [00:05:00] Trust. And I'm the project manager, project specialist. Um, I have like many different titles for that role. I never get it right, it's two years in as well.
But the project is exactly that. It's really identifying, but also addressing the barriers that particularly global majority teachers and candidates face as they come into the profession, but also as they move through the profession into kind of more senior and executive leadership roles. And those barriers start at, even before they've applied around recruitment, like where they're seen, when they look on websites are, do they feel like they're represented in the senior leadership of that initial teacher training provider or those schools
Load full transcript
that they might be placed in.
It also starts with things like interview panels and selection panels and how diverse and representative it is of the widening school communities, but also the UK society as a whole. And then as you move into, you know, through recruitment, you go into retention and you think about, particularly for trainee teachers, but also teachers from the global majority across the board.
It's about the experiences in school, the experience of leadership, the, you know, [00:06:00] many report facing discrimination, quite explicit and implicit racism, in, in many parts. And the sense of not feeling belonging. And we're talking a lot about belonging for young people, but how are we talk, how far I would say, argue, are we talking about it for staff and staff with protected characteristics?
So though the project focuses on global majority, I actually think it is helpful for anybody with a protected characteristic to be really thinking about the barriers that those colleagues might face who need those additional reasonable adjustments. And then even in terms of things like assessment, like how global majority trainee teachers and teachers and leaders are assessed, there's implicit bias even in that.
And the conversation, we actually designed an online course that's free, that you can Google as diversity and ITT online course, where we really explored the bias in all of those kind of three areas around recruitment, retention, and assessment, and the barriers that trainee teachers are facing.
But within that course, we also talk about the solutions. So [00:07:00] we actually provide through sector experts, solutions and strategies that colleagues in initial teacher training or in schools can apply to really reduce those barriers.
Liz Worthen: For links to that free online course, information about the Mission 44 project and the Radical Candour Framework, check out the show notes or description. There's a link there to sign up to our newsletter as well for ongoing insights and updates. Now back to the show for more from Yamina on strategies to remove barriers, where responsibility sits for making school life more inclusive, and how making reasonable adjustments could improve life for everyone.
And of course, 'cause this is so important, isn't it?
Because we need a teaching workforce, we need a school workforce. And if we're overlooking candidates or people are not completing the course, or, you know, failing things when they maybe don't need to be, then we are losing out on the opportunity to get good people into the sector, aren't [00:08:00] we?
But yeah, give us some examples then perhaps of like, what are some of the things that leaders and managers can do to understand some of these things?
Yamina Bibi: Brilliant. I would, the first thing I would, uh, suggest is really thinking about building our own racial literacy and real understanding of that.
So before we even start to think about the strategies, I would say just raising consciousness within ourselves. And, our online course does do that, but there are such brilliant organisations like Belonging Effect, who are really focusing on those. The African Caribbean kind of network is doing some brilliant work around anti-racism as well.
So really building our own racial literacy. I think it should be compulsory for all, anybody who works with, global majority leaders and teachers should have a racial literacy course that they go on to raise their own awareness. And then in beyond that, I would say really thinking about your recruitment practices.
So again, like the questions around who is seen, who is valued, who are we signalling to that they belong in our organisations, through our [00:09:00] marketing, our communications. Like, do we make those reasonable adjustments? So instead of just waiting for, colleagues to come to us, which is what some, you know, initial teacher training provider says, well, look, we're in an area where actually it's not, it's not diverse.
What can we do? And the question I would say is, well, what are you doing to go out into those communities to show people that they belong, whatever their protected characteristic. So have we considered our websites, you know, what those marketing materials, again, who is represented on those? Is it diverse of a variety of protected characteristics?
And then really thinking about our selection and interview panels. Are we just judging based on these specific criteria or is there more that we can do? So for example, lots of SCITTs and teacher training providers say, but Yamina lots of the times we're rejecting them or we are saying no because they don't have the qualifications and so, or that their personal statement doesn't come across as effective.
And then our question is, what can you do as an organisation to support? Maybe you could, so [00:10:00] there are some brilliant, um, initial teacher training providers who are part of our project who have actually really started thinking about reasonable adjustments or additional courses or meetings that they can have with those candidates to almost like coach them.
Which is really exciting. And lots of people say, oh, but isn't that bias? And I'm like, actually what you are doing is removing barriers that might be impacting them. And, along with that, they're also thinking about school placements. So the majority of trainee teachers and obviously current teachers and leaders are in schools.
And it's that experience that they talk sadly, most negatively about. They say that there aren't enough that when they face racism or discrimination, there's not enough done about it. So one of the strategies that the experts suggest is actually having a really clear policy and process about when it happens, not if it happens.
So not, just like with safeguarding, right? And it's now in the new safeguarding policies isn't it, that racism is included as one of the things that we need to be thinking about. Is that something
[00:11:00] we've got a process for? What happens? And the other question I would say is what many SCITT leaders or ITT providers from global majority backgrounds themselves say is, it always comes to me. That because I'm the only person of colour here, I then have to be the person who has that conversation with the black trainee teacher or the South Asian or the Muslim, you know, the Jewish trainee teacher because I'm Jewish, 'cause I'm black, 'cause I'm Muslim.
And then you've added that additional burden and pressure on that leader themselves. So how, you know that, that's why I go back to the build your own racial literacy across the, the provider across your school rather than just hoping that somebody with lived experience might know best. Because I can be honest with you and say, yes, I'm visibly Muslim, but I'm not always the best representative of what it means to be a Muslim woman.
Right? Like, my experience might be different to somebody who might wear the face covering, for example. That doesn't necessarily make me an expert just because I've got lived experience in terms of racial literacy. So being aware of that as well. I'd go on, but I'll stop.
Liz Worthen: Yeah. [00:12:00] Oh, interesting, Yamina, and also, cause I've been reading the latest version of keeping children safe in education recently and yeah, one of the things, one of those threads that comes through is just because it's not being reported, that doesn't mean it isn't happening.
So yeah, really take that point that actually we might not know. We might not think, we might think it's not happening here, but actually you need to be prepared and or know or be proactive in those things.
Yamina Bibi: Exactly. And those processes and policies are important because when people are looking at your school organisation, then they might be looking for those things and saying, okay, what will happen if X, Y, and Z happens to me?
And I think, again, lots of colleagues who've been on this project said, what worried about, what that might be saying about organisation? Does that mean lots of racism happens or that antisemitism happens? We're saying no, what that signals is that you are ready for it, you know exactly what's going to happen and you've got zero tolerance and you've got processes and policies in place to support colleagues if slash or when it does happen.
That's really empowering [00:13:00] and, and, and really positive I think. And what we've found is actually, sorry, now I'm talking about the project, but what we found from the project is trainee teachers actually reporting more of those incidents. And we said that's actually an indicator that it's working because they, they say we feel safer to report it because we know something's going to get done.
So actually see as a positive, not a negative.
Liz Worthen: Absolutely. And that's the same as, I think a similar thing happens, isn't it? Maybe in schools who are concerned about bullying or introduce bullying policies.
Actually, what you often see initially is that rates of reporting go up. And that doesn't mean that you've, by talking about it, you've made more bullying happen.
It means that people, that children feel more empowered to go and talk about it.
Yamina Bibi: Yes, exactly.
Liz Worthen: I was thinking too as well when you were talking, because I was talking to Maisie Cass recently who works on neuro inclusion and we were talking about neurodiversity in the workplace, in school settings and how, yeah, I think we need to understand, don't we, we need to think [00:14:00] about these protected characteristics because actually so many people in our school workforce will have some kind of protected characteristics where, isn't it, whether it's it's race, being from the global majority or whether it's yeah, a neurodiversity or a disability, all of these things, isn't it?
So actually by thinking about, being prepared for or mindful of all of those things is going to help us have that more diverse, richer workforce, isn't it?
Yamina Bibi: Yes, absolutely. I'll just read, I mean, I can't, I dunno if you can see it on my bookshelf, but there's a book by Frances Akinde that's just been released called Intersectionality in Schools.
And I think that's the other thing I would say is there are specific things that we can do when it comes to a protective characteristic like race, for example, around anti-racism. But I think, you know, if we really think about it, I can't separate those different identities within myself. Like, um, I'm not just a British Muslim, a woman.
I'm not just neurodiverse, you know, I don't just wear this. All of those things are part of me. And actually, if we can [00:15:00] preempt that and think about how we create schools that are responsive to the intersection, intersectionality within some somebody's identity, then we'll be doing great work, I think. And it can feel overwhelming.
Like you just say, oh my God, there's, there's nine protected characteristics and how am I going to help everybody and I can't do it. And actually it's just thinking, well, what are some of the barriers that colleagues in general might be facing and how can we reduce that? And so, and I think that will really support the kind of greater work around inclusion and belonging in our schools for both staff and students.
And you're absolutely right. You know, if we look at the data, I'm not very good with numbers, but if you look at the data around how many people in the general population are neurodiverse there, they must be leading in our schools, they must be teaching our schools. And yet I think it's still a taboo, unfortunately, to say, I've got dyslexia, I'm dyspraxic, I need this.
And I say that as somebody with that lived experience. You know, when I first started teaching, I remember applying for a job in one of my schools and my friends who were already working there saying, don't say that you're [00:16:00] dyslexic. Don't say, and I didn't. So I didn't tick that. I just said, I'm absolutely fine.
And I struggled for most half of my career because I was afraid of what that would tell people about me. That they would think I wasn't good enough or competent enough or skilled enough to be a leader. And actually what I found is in the most empowering spaces and places, I could say that I had these, these needs like dyslexia and ADHD, and I was, it was welcomed and it was something that was adjusted to and seen as not a problem, which in some schools it might be.
Liz Worthen: I think as well, yeah, conversation with Maisie, something that came up, but I'm still thinking about also is like this idea of belonging to ourselves, or as you say, talking, feeling that sense of belonging, which means that I can then show up at school as myself and feel like myself.
Yamina Bibi: Yeah, that authenticity can't be denied. And I think schools, yes, we are professionals now and I believe in an authentic professional self. [00:17:00] So, you know, I don't, I don't, I don't need everyone to know everything about me. But I do think being able to bring that professional, authentic self is really important.
Liz Worthen: So what, do you have any suggestions for someone who perhaps is in a setting where they feel like, they're, yes, they're not able, they don't feel able to say what they need or what might help them? Any suggestions for navigating that?
Yamina Bibi: Yeah, it's really hard.
I mean, I would say find that, you know, we talk to young people about trusted adult? I would say, who's your trusted adult? You know, your trusted mentor, your trusted leader in that school. And tell them. It's the only way I, I think we can get that support that we need. But also, again, what we're doing there is placing it the onus on the person themselves with the lived experience, with the characteristic.
Whereas actually it's, the Equality Act 2010 makes it a duty upon workplaces, on leaders, employers to provide those reasonable adjustments. So that's what I, you know, it's, and it's, you are not a burden is what I'd say. I used to feel like for [00:18:00] so long that I was a burden on my school leadership teams or my head teacher, because, you know, I needed data 48 hours in advance just so I could process it.
But actually the best leaders and the most effective leaders will understand that by them doing that for me, it meant that when I got into that SLT meeting room, for example, I was the best at, at that, I'd be able to analyse it in the detail that I needed. 'cause I'd had the reasonable adjustment of that additional time that some of my colleagues who are neurotypical might not need.
But actually, if we do that same thing for everybody, where we give everybody the 48 hours in advance, not only is it, is it vital for me, it's might be also helpful for somebody who's neurotypical, right? So, yeah, definitely that isn't, it's like, you know, I, I think people talk about wheelchair ramps and things like that.
Wheelchair
ramps are absolutely vital for wheelchair users, but actually the majority of people who use it are people who are able bodied, for example.
But I would say, you know, find that trusted adult, trusted mentor, that you can speak to about the reasonable adjustments you need. If that person is HR, that is HR's job.
So go to HR. I, I, when I was diagnosed [00:19:00] with ADHD, I actually went direct to HR and said, look, this is what I've been told. What can you do to support? 'Cause I still don't understand my diagnosis myself, so what can you do? And my HR person was amazing. Um, but also I would urge organisations and leaders to do that work first and foremost.
Liz Worthen: Yeah, absolutely. And I guess too and if you're not finding those trusted adults or mentors within your organisation, maybe look more widely at some of the other, the great organisations out there, like WomenEd you're involved with, aren't you? Other things too. Other places too.
Yamina Bibi: Yeah, there's so many fantastic leaders out there who are doing this work.
So I mentioned Frances Akinde who's just an expert in all things SEND, but also race and really explores the kind of intersectionality of race and SEND, for example. So reach out to, you know, to them. But yeah, WomenEd, we are a charity organisation. We provide free events like social networking events as well as kinda professional events.
But within that we also have experts who are, current head teachers, [00:20:00] CEOs, teachers across the board really who who you can delve into. And I, and I found personally, um, I know not everybody agrees, but social media networks like LinkedIn and previously X have been so empowering for me because I've never felt lonely.
Once I tweet something or I put it on LinkedIn, there'll be lots of people who come and say, oh, I got this, or what about this? And just feel that sense of community beyond your, just your school and organisation. You are not alone is the key thing.
Liz Worthen: And we always like to hear about what you've been reading or listening to recently that's inspired you. And of course we should mention, people might wanna read your book, Yamina, which is the little book of thriving in your early career, early years of teaching.
Is that right? Yes. Thriving in your first
Yamina Bibi: years years of teaching. I'm not very good at plugging it, you see Liz. So I think that's why I've got it in the background 'cause it just the awkwardness of me having to do it for myself. But yes, please do, if you have got, you know, you know, new teachers, trainee teachers.
But what I've tried to do in that [00:21:00] book is also just make it general. So if you just need a little, pick me up. If you just need, somebody called, one of the trainee teachers, which tells you my age now, called like, it's like an auntie voice and I'm like, okay, yes, an auntie voice, I'll take that. I've never thought I'd be an auntie, but yeah, we called an auntie voice, like, okay.
But you know,
if you need a little, pick me up. If you need a little recap and reminder, it is helpful not just for ECTs and, and new teachers, but also for others. But yeah, as I mentioned, there's so many books I've been reading, it's been, I've started to read Mary Myatt's new book around the key stage three curriculum and being really ambitious around that.
Yeah, I've been reading and dipping in and out of Frances Akinde's intersectionality in schools because I'm fascinated with what we can do as leaders to really think about the intersectional lens of both staff, but also students as well.
Liz Worthen: And yes, so tell us, so what is this year gonna bring for you?
Alongside the Diversity and ITT project, are there other things [00:22:00] you're gonna be focusing on and doing?
Yamina Bibi: Yes, it's been really strange because I've got, I, I like to call it an eclectic kind of portfolio career really. So the diversity in ITT project is a kind of part-time role, which I absolutely love.
I might as well just do it full-time because I love it so much and I'll talk about it anywhere and everywhere. But I've also just taken on, I'm full-time now with Chiltern Learning Trust as their strategic lead and school transformations or something like that. I never remember the full new fancy title, but essentially it means that I go in and support schools who are part of the RISE programme as well, um, nationally.
So I go and support them in raising standards and outcomes, which has been so fun. And I was just talking, off screen wasn't I Liz, about and delivering CPD in schools, which I absolutely love doing. I find really energising. So I'm doing lots more of those sorts of things for colleagues. And then I've also just got a secondment role, which is, which is actually part of my job that I'm paid for, with Bedfordshire Futures.
And that's a specific charity called The Connolly Foundation that are based in Luton and Bedfordshire. And our [00:23:00] project is all about working with schools in those, in that region to increase aspirations, but also access to opportunities for young people, in secondary and secondary school and in sixth forms to really be able to access their kind of further and higher education and, and raise those aspirations.
And that's been really fun project to kind of get my teeth into, working with thirty schools across Luton Bedfordshire. So that's been really fun but scary.
Liz Worthen: That's great. Good to see new challenges and yeah, finding things to enable you to thrive and flourish further. That's brilliant. Thank you so much, Yamina.
It's been wonderful to talk to you. And, thank you for sharing those insights and yeah, we look forward to hearing more about what goes on for you, the in the future.
Yamina Bibi: Thank you
Liz Worthen: And thank you for listening. You can find all the books that Yamina has mentioned, including her guide to Thriving in Your First Years of Teaching, in the Creating Value in Schools bookshop. Link in the show notes or description, along with other resources. And if this [00:24:00] episode has resonated, you might enjoy listening to our conversation with Hannah Wilson, Who Gets to Belong in Schools, as well as the episode with Maisie Cass, What About the Adults? Neuroinclusion in Schools.
Be back with you soon.