UDSKRIFT 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.840 --> 00:00:04.710
For early access and ad-free episodes, check out our Patreon,
2
00:00:04.889 --> 00:00:07.960
Apple Premium and Spotify subscription memberships.
3
00:00:11.859 --> 00:00:13.019
Thank you very much.
4
00:00:41.979 --> 00:00:43.020
Acast recommends.
5
00:00:44.469 --> 00:00:47.729
This is John from the David McWilliams podcast. Now, if
6
00:00:47.750 --> 00:00:52.289
you're looking to make sense of what's happening in the world, economically, politically, culturally,
7
00:00:52.689 --> 00:00:53.649
you'll find it here.
8
00:00:53.990 --> 00:00:56.170
We take the big ideas shaping your life and we
9
00:00:56.229 --> 00:00:58.929
break them down in a way that's clear, curious and
10
00:00:59.130 --> 00:01:00.590
actually worth your time.
11
00:01:00.969 --> 00:01:03.049
New episodes every Tuesday and Thursday.
12
00:01:03.210 --> 00:01:06.689
Follow the David McWilliams podcast wherever you get your podcasts.
13
00:01:06.989 --> 00:01:08.049
Acast is home to.
14
00:01:07.950 --> 00:01:09.269
The world's best podcasts.
15
00:01:10.129 --> 00:01:13.430
Including Crime World, The Other Hand, and the one you're
16
00:01:13.450 --> 00:01:14.790
listening to right now.
17
00:01:33.359 --> 00:01:37.430
Our episodes deal with serious and often distressing incidents. If
18
00:01:37.469 --> 00:01:40.849
you feel at any time you need support, please contact
19
00:01:40.890 --> 00:01:45.280
your local crisis centre. For suggested phone numbers for confidential
20
00:01:45.319 --> 00:01:49.000
support and for a more detailed list of content warnings,
21
00:01:49.420 --> 00:01:51.879
please see the show notes for this episode on your
22
00:01:52.079 --> 00:02:00.329
app or on our website. Ed Chambers would do anything
23
00:02:00.409 --> 00:02:04.010
for his wife, Marguerite. The couple, who lived in the
24
00:02:04.049 --> 00:02:08.319
city of Grand Rapids, Michigan, were a team. Together, they
25
00:02:08.360 --> 00:02:11.319
had provided a safe and loving home for four children
26
00:02:11.500 --> 00:02:17.009
and built successful careers. But in 1972, Ed noticed a
27
00:02:17.069 --> 00:02:22.430
change in Marguerite's personality. His highly intelligent and quick-witted wife
28
00:02:22.490 --> 00:02:27.949
became forgetful and confused. After seeking medical advice, the couple
29
00:02:28.030 --> 00:02:35.460
received devastating news. At 42 years old, Marguerite had Alzheimer's disease.
30
00:02:36.000 --> 00:02:40.080
an incurable type of dementia that destroys memory and thinking skills.
31
00:02:41.840 --> 00:02:45.360
Over the following years, Marguerite became frail and was unable
32
00:02:45.400 --> 00:02:49.860
to carry out the simplest of everyday tasks. Ed took
33
00:02:49.900 --> 00:02:53.060
an early retirement to help his wife, but by the
34
00:02:53.150 --> 00:02:58.810
early 1980s, he accepted that Marguerite needed round-the-clock care by professionals.
35
00:03:00.509 --> 00:03:04.009
Live-in care facilities around Grand Rapids at that time were
36
00:03:04.069 --> 00:03:07.620
few and far between, so Marguerite's name was added to
37
00:03:07.659 --> 00:03:13.120
a long list of applicants. After a two-year wait, a
38
00:03:13.180 --> 00:03:17.930
bed became available at Alpine Manor. Situated on the outskirts
39
00:03:17.969 --> 00:03:21.310
of Grand Rapids and backing onto a densely wooded area,
40
00:03:21.830 --> 00:03:25.210
the 208-bed nursing home was only three blocks from the
41
00:03:25.229 --> 00:03:29.849
chamber's house. This meant Ed could visit Marguerite as often
42
00:03:29.909 --> 00:03:35.009
as he wanted. He couldn't believe his luck. When Ed
43
00:03:35.069 --> 00:03:38.840
Chambers approached the single-storey brick facility, he was greeted by
44
00:03:38.879 --> 00:03:43.080
the director of nursing who gave him a tour. Alpine
45
00:03:43.120 --> 00:03:46.860
Manor was divided into four wings. Each wing had its
46
00:03:46.960 --> 00:03:51.819
own nursing station. The facility was very clean and the
47
00:03:51.860 --> 00:03:56.969
staff were polite and well-presented. In a common area, residents
48
00:03:57.009 --> 00:04:02.030
sat together chatting and playing games. Ed had anticipated that
49
00:04:02.050 --> 00:04:04.949
the nursing home would be sterile and cold so he
50
00:04:04.990 --> 00:04:08.129
was delighted to see that the floors were carpeted, curtains
51
00:04:08.169 --> 00:04:13.009
hung from the windows, and artwork lined the walls. Residents
52
00:04:13.050 --> 00:04:16.000
could visit a beauty shop, and there was a designated
53
00:04:16.069 --> 00:04:20.879
dining room for meals. There were even craft activities and
54
00:04:20.980 --> 00:04:26.839
social studies classes on offer. Although Ed felt immense guilt
55
00:04:26.920 --> 00:04:30.259
at having to move Marguerite into Alpine Manor, its homely
56
00:04:30.339 --> 00:04:34.620
atmosphere helped ease some of the pain. The director of
57
00:04:34.689 --> 00:04:38.439
nursing reassured Ed, telling him that Alpine Manor had been
58
00:04:38.500 --> 00:04:42.040
assessed by the Michigan Health Department as a standout nursing
59
00:04:42.100 --> 00:04:48.879
home facility. By the mid-1980s, Marguerite Chambers could no longer
60
00:04:48.959 --> 00:04:52.939
walk or talk. She spent all day in bed, often
61
00:04:53.019 --> 00:04:57.220
curled in a ball and rocking back and forth. Ed
62
00:04:57.339 --> 00:05:03.050
still visited her every day. The minute Marguerite heard his voice,
63
00:05:03.329 --> 00:05:05.949
she stopped rocking and reached her hand up for him
64
00:05:06.009 --> 00:05:10.209
to take. He sat beside her, holding her hand and
65
00:05:10.290 --> 00:05:16.449
talking to her. Occasionally, she would make eye contact. Ed
66
00:05:16.560 --> 00:05:22.160
knew that she still recognised him. Each night, Ed tucked
67
00:05:22.240 --> 00:05:25.160
Marguerite into bed and left her to the care of
68
00:05:25.220 --> 00:05:56.610
the
Load full transcript
staff at Alpine Manor. 23-year-old Kathy Wood dreamed of
69
00:05:56.689 --> 00:06:00.319
working in healthcare. She had done voluntary work as a
70
00:06:00.379 --> 00:06:04.519
nursing assistant in high school and enjoyed helping people. At
71
00:06:04.620 --> 00:06:07.920
age 17, Kathy's career was put on hold when she
72
00:06:07.959 --> 00:06:12.529
became pregnant. Now that her daughter was at school, Kathy
73
00:06:12.569 --> 00:06:16.850
was eager to rekindle her passion for nursing. A nursing
74
00:06:16.930 --> 00:06:23.399
home a few blocks away was hiring. Alpine Manor, Kathy
75
00:06:23.439 --> 00:06:27.850
Wood impressed management with her enthusiasm. She was hired as
76
00:06:27.889 --> 00:06:33.069
a nursing aide and started immediately. Some residents only needed
77
00:06:33.149 --> 00:06:36.709
minor help, such as assistance with getting dressed or showering.
78
00:06:37.620 --> 00:06:41.480
Others were high-needs residents who required help with daily living,
79
00:06:41.819 --> 00:06:45.639
such as eating and drinking, bathing, and turning in bed
80
00:06:45.699 --> 00:06:51.160
to prevent pressure sores. Before long, Kathy came to know
81
00:06:51.300 --> 00:06:56.060
every resident and their specific needs. She was a hard worker,
82
00:06:56.360 --> 00:07:00.779
intelligent and easy to talk to. Before long, she became
83
00:07:00.839 --> 00:07:05.779
a valued member of Alpine Manor's staff. Being a night owl,
84
00:07:06.000 --> 00:07:09.850
Kathy gravitated towards the night shift. It was less busy
85
00:07:09.899 --> 00:07:12.790
than day shifts and gave her more time to socialise
86
00:07:12.829 --> 00:07:18.089
with her co-workers. Nursing aides joked that Kathy was like
87
00:07:18.250 --> 00:07:20.610
one of the cool kids at high school because her
88
00:07:20.649 --> 00:07:24.389
colleagues followed her around, hanging off every word she said.
89
00:07:26.670 --> 00:07:31.110
Kathy Wood wasn't used to the attention. She had struggled
90
00:07:31.149 --> 00:07:35.389
with her weight her entire life, reaching almost 450 pounds
91
00:07:35.509 --> 00:07:36.389
after the birth.
92
00:07:36.189 --> 00:07:36.910
Of her daughter.
93
00:07:38.089 --> 00:07:41.250
As a result, she spent most of her married life indoors,
94
00:07:41.569 --> 00:07:46.019
fearful of the judgment of strangers. But at Alpine Manor,
95
00:07:46.360 --> 00:07:50.730
Kathy was showered with compliments. She began taking double shifts
96
00:07:50.870 --> 00:07:55.449
just to spend more time with her colleagues. Over the
97
00:07:55.509 --> 00:07:59.610
following months, Kathy's husband Ken watched as she changed before
98
00:07:59.649 --> 00:08:04.360
his eyes. Most of Kathy's days off were spent socialising
99
00:08:04.420 --> 00:08:08.579
with Alpine Manor staff. She never used to drink alcohol,
100
00:08:08.779 --> 00:08:12.360
but returned home from these get-togethers drunk and high on cannabis.
101
00:08:13.930 --> 00:08:18.209
The once-dedicated stay-at-home wife and mother now had little interest
102
00:08:18.269 --> 00:08:21.610
in spending time with her daughter and fought with Ken often.
103
00:08:22.889 --> 00:08:26.649
When they weren't fighting, Kathy told Ken all the work gossip.
104
00:08:27.910 --> 00:08:31.449
Love triangles among the nursing aides were common, as were
105
00:08:31.490 --> 00:08:37.519
drunken threesomes and altercations between love rivals. Fighting among staff
106
00:08:37.559 --> 00:08:41.429
members often occurred at work, while residents listened on, unable
107
00:08:41.470 --> 00:08:46.669
to extricate themselves from the toxic environment. As Cathy pumped
108
00:08:46.769 --> 00:08:50.190
Ken full of staff secrets, he often thought to himself,
109
00:08:51.350 --> 00:08:59.620
what the hell is going on at Alpine Manor? In
110
00:08:59.679 --> 00:09:04.039
September 1986, less than six months after Cathy Wood started
111
00:09:04.100 --> 00:09:06.960
working at Alpine Manor, She told Ken that she had
112
00:09:07.059 --> 00:09:11.320
fallen in love with someone else, an 18-year-old fellow nursing
113
00:09:11.480 --> 00:09:17.000
aide named Dawn. After seven years of marriage, Kathy wanted
114
00:09:17.039 --> 00:09:21.809
a divorce. Ken believed she was going through a phase
115
00:09:21.990 --> 00:09:25.590
and would return to him. In the meantime, he took
116
00:09:25.669 --> 00:09:28.730
their daughter to live in a hotel while Kathy remained
117
00:09:28.769 --> 00:09:34.080
in their family home. Without Ken at home, Kathy needed
118
00:09:34.139 --> 00:09:38.490
help paying the bills. A staff member introduced her to
119
00:09:38.529 --> 00:09:43.039
a new nurse's aide at Alpine Manor, 22-year-old Gwendolyn Graham,
120
00:09:43.340 --> 00:09:47.879
who went by the name Gwen. Gwen had no previous
121
00:09:47.960 --> 00:09:50.840
experience in nursing, but had taken on the role as
122
00:09:50.879 --> 00:09:55.690
a stepping stone to become a paramedic. Alpine Manor was
123
00:09:55.789 --> 00:10:00.100
chronically understaffed, so, like Cathy, Gwen had been hired on
124
00:10:00.139 --> 00:10:06.250
the spot. Cathy and Gwen hit it off immediately. Having
125
00:10:06.330 --> 00:10:09.669
recently broken up with her girlfriend, Gwen was looking for
126
00:10:09.690 --> 00:10:12.110
a place to stay and had jumped at the chance
127
00:10:12.190 --> 00:10:17.039
to move in with Cathy. Within a week of Gwen
128
00:10:17.100 --> 00:10:20.559
moving in, Kathy had broken up with Dawn and she
129
00:10:20.600 --> 00:10:26.120
and Gwen began dating. Alpine Manor's nursing staff were amused
130
00:10:26.179 --> 00:10:31.690
at the couple's appearance. Gwen was athletically built, weighing 140
131
00:10:31.690 --> 00:10:34.809
pounds and was 5 foot 2 with freckles and a
132
00:10:34.850 --> 00:10:39.409
ginger mullet. Kathy was 6 foot tall with a large frame,
133
00:10:39.629 --> 00:10:44.549
blue eyes and bleached blonde hair. The staff joked
that
134
00:10:44.590 --> 00:10:48.580
the pair completed each other. Kathy provided the brains in
135
00:10:48.620 --> 00:10:54.799
the relationship, while Gwen provided the brawn. Kathy and Gwen
136
00:10:54.879 --> 00:10:59.299
bonded over their troubled upbringings. Kathy's father had been a
137
00:10:59.360 --> 00:11:05.330
strict disciplinarian, often resorting to physical violence. Her mother took
138
00:11:05.370 --> 00:11:07.929
a back seat and left the care of her other
139
00:11:07.970 --> 00:11:11.169
children to Kathy, who was responsible for making sure they
140
00:11:11.190 --> 00:11:15.509
were looked after. Gwen had been the victim of child
141
00:11:15.549 --> 00:11:19.529
sexual abuse at the hands of her own father. She
142
00:11:19.590 --> 00:11:22.570
self-harmed in her teens, describing it as a way of
143
00:11:22.669 --> 00:11:27.990
freeing herself from the pain of her childhood. Both Kathy
144
00:11:28.029 --> 00:11:31.309
and Gwen knew they were carrying a lot of emotional baggage.
145
00:11:32.649 --> 00:11:37.379
There was also something else they harboured. Hatred for their
146
00:11:37.500 --> 00:11:46.980
elderly parents. Deaths at Alpine Manor were common. On average,
147
00:11:47.299 --> 00:11:51.240
five to ten residents passed each month from conditions relating
148
00:11:51.279 --> 00:11:55.399
to old age. Flu season saw the death toll climb
149
00:11:55.440 --> 00:12:00.370
even higher. It wasn't long after Gwen Graham started that
150
00:12:00.419 --> 00:12:04.389
she witnessed her first death, an elderly woman named Helen
151
00:12:04.509 --> 00:12:09.850
who died from pneumonia. Gwen appeared devastated at the loss,
152
00:12:10.590 --> 00:12:13.840
but After Helen had been transported to the funeral home,
153
00:12:14.240 --> 00:12:20.759
the tears stopped. Gwen told her colleagues, I couldn't stand Helen.
154
00:12:21.289 --> 00:12:24.629
I couldn't stand that woman. All she did was whine
155
00:12:24.690 --> 00:12:30.769
all the time. About a month after Gwen started working
156
00:12:30.830 --> 00:12:33.769
at Alpine Manor, another new nursing aide was on the
157
00:12:33.840 --> 00:12:36.940
night shift when a resident pressed the call button next
158
00:12:36.980 --> 00:12:41.399
to their bed. The room was occupied by two residents,
159
00:12:41.659 --> 00:12:44.720
so the nursing aide entered quietly and in the dark.
160
00:12:46.830 --> 00:12:49.970
As she approached the bedside, the aide could see that
161
00:12:49.990 --> 00:12:54.070
the resident was sound asleep. As she searched for the
162
00:12:54.110 --> 00:12:56.409
call button to see how it had been pressed on
163
00:12:56.450 --> 00:12:59.980
its own, the aide felt a tight grip around her ankle.
164
00:13:01.379 --> 00:13:07.860
She fled the room screaming, waking Alpine Manor's residents. Moments later,
165
00:13:08.120 --> 00:13:13.080
Gwen Graham emerged from underneath the residence bed, laughing hysterically,
166
00:13:13.399 --> 00:13:20.279
while other aides comforted the frightened residents. Gwen played practical
167
00:13:20.360 --> 00:13:23.830
jokes on her fellow staff almost every night at the
168
00:13:23.879 --> 00:13:28.669
expense of the residents of Alpine Manor. When coming on shift,
169
00:13:28.950 --> 00:13:31.669
Gwen would turn their beds around so the bottom of
170
00:13:31.710 --> 00:13:35.360
the bed was where the headboard should have been. When
171
00:13:35.419 --> 00:13:38.879
this got old, she moved residents into different rooms to
172
00:13:38.919 --> 00:13:44.100
surprise and confuse nursing aides. Gwen pulled all the wire
173
00:13:44.139 --> 00:13:47.279
screens from the windows that backed onto the courtyard so
174
00:13:47.320 --> 00:13:49.960
she could make a hasty retreat if the charge nurse
175
00:13:50.019 --> 00:13:54.179
was coming. She also hid in the courtyard at night
176
00:13:54.259 --> 00:13:58.409
to bang on the windows and scare staff. It also
177
00:13:58.509 --> 00:14:05.450
terrified the residents. Nighthouse supervisor Tish Prescott was sick of
178
00:14:05.509 --> 00:14:09.500
the shenanigans. She knew a lot of the trouble stamped
179
00:14:09.580 --> 00:14:14.019
from Kathy Wood and Gwen Graham. They used the PA
180
00:14:14.059 --> 00:14:17.659
system to gossip about other staff and had residents with
181
00:14:17.799 --> 00:14:22.620
speech impediments read announcements just to laugh at them. Tish
182
00:14:22.659 --> 00:14:25.940
had tried to separate the women, but they swapped shifts
183
00:14:26.019 --> 00:14:30.639
with other aides so they could remain working together. Tish
184
00:14:30.679 --> 00:14:32.960
had resorted to sneaking up on the pair to keep
185
00:14:33.000 --> 00:14:36.669
her eye on them. She often found them alone in
186
00:14:36.769 --> 00:14:42.590
residence rooms. Tish had also heard reports of nursing aides
187
00:14:42.669 --> 00:14:47.850
sneaking off to spend time together in unoccupied beds. Rumours
188
00:14:47.929 --> 00:14:51.210
circulated that Gwen Graham had sex with an orderly in
189
00:14:51.330 --> 00:14:56.039
one of the residence rooms. Tish took her concerns about
190
00:14:56.080 --> 00:15:00.019
Cathy Wood and Gwen Graham to the Director of Nursing, saying...
191
00:15:00.899 --> 00:15:04.639
Those two are just no good for each other. She
192
00:15:04.700 --> 00:15:08.340
pleaded for something to be done, explaining that resident care
193
00:15:08.379 --> 00:15:13.379
was suffering as a result. Upper management declared that they
194
00:15:13.440 --> 00:15:16.899
weren't in a position to step in. Whatever the staff
195
00:15:16.960 --> 00:15:20.230
chose to do on their breaks was out of their control.
196
00:15:22.389 --> 00:15:25.470
One night, Gwen Graham came to work so drunk that
197
00:15:25.509 --> 00:15:29.629
she couldn't walk in a straight line. Tish Prescott sent
198
00:15:29.669 --> 00:15:33.570
her home and reported Gwen to management, expecting she would
199
00:15:33.610 --> 00:15:38.600
be fired. However, Gwen was back on shift the following night.
200
00:15:43.940 --> 00:15:48.860
At 4.30 one morning in December 1986, Nancy Hahn was
201
00:15:48.919 --> 00:15:53.860
woken by her telephone ringing. The caller identified herself as
202
00:15:53.940 --> 00:15:59.179
a nurse from Alpine Manor. She explained that Nancy's mother,
203
00:15:59.460 --> 00:16:03.440
Belle Burkhardt, a resident of the facility, had declined quickly
204
00:16:03.519 --> 00:16:08.120
in health. Belle wasn't expected to make it through the day.
205
00:16:10.440 --> 00:16:14.519
Nancy lived three hours' drive away from Alpine Manor. She
206
00:16:14.580 --> 00:16:17.799
couldn't afford to miss work that day, so after a long,
207
00:16:18.039 --> 00:16:22.909
anxious shift, she raced to her ailing mother. She hoped
208
00:16:22.970 --> 00:16:26.529
and prayed that she'd still be alive to say her goodbyes,
209
00:16:28.700 --> 00:16:31.960
Nancy arrived at Alpine Manor and rushed to Belle's room.
210
00:16:33.240 --> 00:16:39.139
Her bed was empty. Nancy inquired at the nursing station.
211
00:16:40.480 --> 00:16:44.610
None of the nurses knew where Belle Burkhardt was. They
212
00:16:44.669 --> 00:16:47.809
appeared bemused when Nancy told them she had received a
213
00:16:47.870 --> 00:16:50.889
phone call in the early hours from a nurse telling
214
00:16:50.950 --> 00:16:55.379
her that her mother was about to pass away. Belle
215
00:16:55.419 --> 00:16:59.409
Burkhardt was discovered sitting at a dining room table, alive
216
00:16:59.750 --> 00:17:04.349
and like her normal self. Nancy fed her dinner and
217
00:17:04.430 --> 00:17:07.150
then stopped to talk to the charge nurse who checked
218
00:17:07.230 --> 00:17:13.079
the record. Nobody had logged a call to Nancy. Furthermore,
219
00:17:13.400 --> 00:17:16.960
there were no staff notes indicating concerns for her mother's health.
220
00:17:18.819 --> 00:17:21.759
It became clear that Nancy had been the victim of
221
00:17:21.819 --> 00:17:25.890
a cruel hoax call from the night shift. The charge
222
00:17:25.930 --> 00:17:29.910
nurse checked who had been working that shift. One name
223
00:17:29.990 --> 00:17:37.859
stood out. Kathy Wood. At the end of 1986, an
224
00:17:38.799 --> 00:17:42.559
anonymous complaint was made to the Michigan Health Department regarding
225
00:17:42.619 --> 00:17:46.819
the level of care at Alpine Manor. There were reports
226
00:17:46.880 --> 00:17:50.839
of residents sitting in soiled incontinence aids for hours and
227
00:17:50.900 --> 00:17:55.960
only being bathed once a week. Staff turnover was cited
228
00:17:56.019 --> 00:17:59.539
as the main reason for the lack of care. 112
229
00:17:59.539 --> 00:18:04.509
nurses' aides had been hired during that year. By October,
230
00:18:04.509 --> 00:18:10.569
71 had left. To quell public concern, Alpine Manor was
231
00:18:10.609 --> 00:18:16.400
subject to an unannounced visit from a health
inspector. A
232
00:18:16.470 --> 00:18:20.700
lot had changed in recent years. One staff member described
233
00:18:20.900 --> 00:18:25.559
Alpine Manor as having an eerie atmosphere. Residents were treated
234
00:18:25.660 --> 00:18:30.400
like children. Staff spoke to them in childlike voices and
235
00:18:30.519 --> 00:18:35.950
styled the female residents' long hair into pigtails. The craft
236
00:18:36.009 --> 00:18:40.190
room now only contained children's colouring books and a few crayons.
237
00:18:41.509 --> 00:18:46.490
Cartoon pictures and drawings were taped to the walls. Residents
238
00:18:46.549 --> 00:18:50.200
reliant on wheelchairs were pushed together with nothing to keep
239
00:18:50.259 --> 00:18:55.309
them occupied. Meanwhile, a local radio station blasted over the
240
00:18:55.349 --> 00:18:59.650
PA system to drown out the screams from residents with dementia.
241
00:19:01.920 --> 00:19:05.660
Following the visit from the health inspector, a report was issued.
242
00:19:07.160 --> 00:19:12.029
It found that Alpine Manor was safely practising within state guidelines.
243
00:19:13.690 --> 00:19:23.130
No further follow-up was needed. Despite the ongoing issues caused
244
00:19:23.269 --> 00:19:27.359
during their employment, both Cathy Wood and Gwen Graham continued
245
00:19:27.490 --> 00:19:32.079
to receive praise from upper management. They regarded the women
246
00:19:32.160 --> 00:19:36.900
as extremely hard workers. Both often pulled double shifts to
247
00:19:36.940 --> 00:19:41.640
make up for understaffing. On a competency test issued by
248
00:19:41.660 --> 00:19:47.089
the State Health Department, Gwen scored a 97% mark. On
249
00:19:47.170 --> 00:19:50.539
her test sheet, the examiner wrote the word grander. on
250
00:19:50.599 --> 00:19:56.190
every page and drew a big smiley face. They were
251
00:19:56.230 --> 00:20:01.809
particularly impressed with Gwen's use of washcloths. On her exam paper,
252
00:20:02.069 --> 00:20:04.869
Gwen wrote that she rolled them up into log shapes
253
00:20:05.089 --> 00:20:07.950
and put them in the palms of residents' clenched hands
254
00:20:08.130 --> 00:20:12.319
to stop their fingernails from digging into their skin. She
255
00:20:12.400 --> 00:20:15.559
always carried washcloths with her and could be seen with
256
00:20:15.599 --> 00:20:18.079
at least one flapping from the back pocket of her
257
00:20:18.119 --> 00:20:23.740
pants at all times. Kathy and Gwen had a tight
258
00:20:23.789 --> 00:20:27.170
friendship circle of fellow nursing aides, but there were a
259
00:20:27.210 --> 00:20:31.410
few staff members who saw through their charade. They regarded
260
00:20:31.490 --> 00:20:35.930
Kathy and Gwen as bullies and liars who ruled through intimidation.
261
00:20:37.390 --> 00:20:40.410
Kathy once complained about a fellow aide she didn't like
262
00:20:40.450 --> 00:20:44.119
to a superior, saying that the aide wasn't changing incontinence
263
00:20:44.240 --> 00:20:49.099
aids overnight. The charge nurse accompanied Kathy and found a
264
00:20:49.160 --> 00:20:53.769
resident lying in a puddle of urine. Later, it transpired
265
00:20:53.849 --> 00:20:56.869
that Kathy had asked Gwen to pour cups of water
266
00:20:56.970 --> 00:21:02.430
over the resident's legs to make them soaking wet. As
267
00:21:02.519 --> 00:21:07.039
detailed in the book Forever and Five Days by Lowell Caulfield,
268
00:21:07.579 --> 00:21:13.500
Gwen later said, Everybody was scared of Kathy. Kathy would
269
00:21:13.599 --> 00:21:17.119
fuck with you. That was just her thing, and everybody
270
00:21:17.180 --> 00:21:20.859
knew it. It kinda made me feel good because she
271
00:21:20.940 --> 00:21:23.980
was my girl, and as long as she was my girl,
272
00:21:24.579 --> 00:21:30.009
nobody was going to fuck with me. One morning, a
273
00:21:30.069 --> 00:21:33.410
nursing aide was working with Kathy to dress a particularly
274
00:21:33.539 --> 00:21:38.980
difficult resident. All day he screamed and yelled, yet whenever
275
00:21:39.019 --> 00:21:44.019
he saw Kathy Wood, he quietened straight away. Nurses had
276
00:21:44.079 --> 00:21:49.059
previously joked about Kathy's ability to silence the man. On
277
00:21:49.119 --> 00:21:52.700
this occasion, the nursing aide asked Kathy how she managed
278
00:21:52.819 --> 00:22:00.089
to quiet him. Just watch, Kathy said. She proceeded to
279
00:22:00.170 --> 00:22:05.029
whisper something into the man's ear. Within seconds, he became
280
00:22:05.150 --> 00:22:10.849
fearful and silent. The aide asked Kathy what she had said.
281
00:22:11.930 --> 00:22:17.869
With a smile, she replied, I said, go ahead, scream
282
00:22:17.990 --> 00:22:21.819
one more time. But look at me, I'm bigger than you.
283
00:22:22.619 --> 00:22:26.660
I'm huge, in fact. You are helpless, I am not.
284
00:22:27.690 --> 00:22:30.410
You scream one more time and I will kill you,
285
00:22:31.009 --> 00:22:33.430
and there will be nothing you can do to stop me.
286
00:22:35.710 --> 00:22:39.950
The aide considered reporting Cathy Wood's remark to management, but
287
00:22:40.059 --> 00:22:42.720
she was too frightened of the fallout from Cathy and
288
00:22:42.779 --> 00:22:49.079
Gwen and chose to keep it to herself. Nights later,
289
00:22:49.099 --> 00:22:52.660
a nursing aide named LaDonna was working the night shift
290
00:22:52.819 --> 00:22:56.420
when she answered the call button of 87-year-old Clara Pearce.
291
00:22:57.849 --> 00:23:00.890
Clara had been at Alpine Manor for six years and
292
00:23:01.009 --> 00:23:05.309
suffered from dementia. She was still quite lucid and could
293
00:23:05.349 --> 00:23:10.190
hold conversations with the staff. As soon as LaDonna entered
294
00:23:10.230 --> 00:23:15.380
her room, Clara screamed, They're gonna kill me. They whisper
295
00:23:15.420 --> 00:23:19.799
to me that they are going to kill me. Clara
296
00:23:19.859 --> 00:23:23.200
had recently been
found wandering the halls at night, so
297
00:23:23.240 --> 00:23:25.589
the doctor had ordered that her wrists be tied to
298
00:23:25.630 --> 00:23:30.269
the bed while she was sleeping. LaDonna released Clara and
299
00:23:30.349 --> 00:23:34.880
escorted her to the bathroom and back to bed. As
300
00:23:34.960 --> 00:23:40.220
LaDonna reapplied Clara's restraints, she begged not to be tied up, yelling,
301
00:23:40.240 --> 00:23:49.619
LaDonna reassured Clara that no one was coming to kill her.
302
00:23:51.089 --> 00:23:55.410
LaDonna turned off the light and left Clara alone, strapped
303
00:23:55.549 --> 00:24:12.750
to her bed. Casefile will be back shortly. Thank you
304
00:24:12.809 --> 00:24:18.539
for supporting us by listening to this episode's sponsors. Having
305
00:24:18.599 --> 00:24:22.119
a great business idea is one thing. Getting it online
306
00:24:22.319 --> 00:24:26.240
is another. Shopify makes that part easy with everything you
307
00:24:26.319 --> 00:24:29.970
need to start selling from day one. That's exactly what
308
00:24:30.029 --> 00:24:33.369
Casefile team member Paulina found when she switched her online
309
00:24:33.390 --> 00:24:37.180
store to Shopify. She said the migration was simple, there
310
00:24:37.220 --> 00:24:40.039
were plenty of professional themes to choose from, and lots
311
00:24:40.099 --> 00:24:44.119
of built-in features she hadn't had access to before. What
312
00:24:44.200 --> 00:24:48.440
really stood out was the checkout experience. Shopify checkout makes
313
00:24:48.509 --> 00:24:51.109
it quick and easy for customers to complete their purchase,
314
00:24:51.410 --> 00:24:54.690
while returning customers can check out with their saved details
315
00:24:54.869 --> 00:24:58.589
in just a tap. Because Shopify handles the setup and
316
00:24:58.670 --> 00:25:02.349
day-to-day essentials, you can spend less time managing your website
317
00:25:02.589 --> 00:25:08.109
and more time growing your business. With inventory integrations, responsive support,
318
00:25:08.329 --> 00:25:13.190
secure infrastructure and easy collaboration with developers, it's built to
319
00:25:13.250 --> 00:25:18.190
grow with you. With Shopify, nothing stands between your idea
320
00:25:18.369 --> 00:25:23.750
and a real business. So, go make it one. Start
321
00:25:23.849 --> 00:25:28.410
your free trial at Shopify.com.
322
00:25:33.529 --> 00:25:36.650
We all love to communicate. But with more ways to
323
00:25:36.690 --> 00:25:39.769
do it than ever, it can be confusing. Sometimes it's
324
00:25:39.829 --> 00:25:44.970
like a different language. We're Comreg, Ireland's independent communications regulator
325
00:25:45.009 --> 00:25:48.529
for mobile and broadband services. We have online support and
326
00:25:48.569 --> 00:25:50.750
we can help you resolve issues with your provider if
327
00:25:50.789 --> 00:25:54.880
things go wrong. When communication needs navigation, we'll help you
328
00:25:54.960 --> 00:25:58.259
find the way. Hi, this is Comreg. How can I help?
329
00:25:58.880 --> 00:26:02.500
Visit comreg.ie ACAST recommends.
330
00:26:03.990 --> 00:26:07.230
This is John from the David McWilliams podcast. Now, if
331
00:26:07.269 --> 00:26:11.799
you're looking to make sense of what's happening in the world, economically, politically, culturally,
332
00:26:12.210 --> 00:26:13.150
you'll find it here.
333
00:26:13.519 --> 00:26:15.700
We take the big ideas shaping your life and we
334
00:26:15.759 --> 00:26:18.440
break them down in a way that's clear, curious, and
335
00:26:18.660 --> 00:26:20.119
actually worth your time.
336
00:26:20.500 --> 00:26:22.579
New episodes every Tuesday and Thursday.
337
00:26:22.720 --> 00:26:26.220
Follow the David McWilliams podcast wherever you get your podcasts.
338
00:26:26.480 --> 00:26:30.579
Acast is home to the world's best podcasts, including Crime World,
339
00:26:30.599 --> 00:26:33.430
The Other Hand, on the one you're listening.
340
00:26:33.210 --> 00:26:43.880
To right now. Thank you for listening to this episode's ads.
341
00:26:44.460 --> 00:26:48.359
By supporting our sponsors, you support Casefile to continue to
342
00:26:48.400 --> 00:27:02.000
deliver quality content. On Christmas Day 1986, Ed Chambers drove
343
00:27:02.039 --> 00:27:06.160
to Alpine Manor to visit his wife, Marguerite. He was
344
00:27:06.220 --> 00:27:09.509
joined by his daughter, Jan, who had some warm clothing
345
00:27:09.549 --> 00:27:13.789
to give her ailing mother. Marguerite's room in Alpine Manor
346
00:27:13.970 --> 00:27:17.150
always seemed to be cold and Marguerite often kicked off
347
00:27:17.190 --> 00:27:22.630
her bedsheets with her rocking movements. Upon arriving at Alpine Manor,
348
00:27:23.009 --> 00:27:27.509
Jan noticed dried food caked around her mother's mouth indicating
349
00:27:27.609 --> 00:27:32.349
that she hadn't been cleaned since her last meal. Jan
350
00:27:32.410 --> 00:27:35.809
found a washcloth and dampened it. When she went to
351
00:27:35.869 --> 00:27:40.069
wipe her mother's face with it, Marguerite jumped. She turned
352
00:27:40.109 --> 00:27:43.009
her head from side to side, refusing to have her
353
00:27:43.049 --> 00:27:48.970
mouth cleaned. Marguerite's Alzheimer's prevented her from speaking, so Jan
354
00:27:49.009 --> 00:27:52.670
couldn't ask her what was wrong. But when she looked
355
00:27:52.730 --> 00:27:56.289
into her mother's eyes, she saw something she would never forget.
356
00:28:01.079 --> 00:28:04.490
During the week prior, Marguerite Chambers had been looked after
357
00:28:04.549 --> 00:28:08.849
by two nurses more than any others, Kathy Wood and
358
00:28:08.950 --> 00:28:16.839
Gwen Graham. Post-Christmas, Marguerite was not herself. She was feverish
359
00:28:17.119 --> 00:28:22.259
and appeared to have gone downhill physically. Nobody could pinpoint why.
360
00:28:24.349 --> 00:28:28.710
A little under a month later, on Sunday January 18 1987,
361
00:28:28.710 --> 00:28:34.829
Ed Chambers returned to Alpine Manor. Marguerite made rocking movements
362
00:28:34.890 --> 00:28:37.710
in bed as Ed held her hand and talked to
363
00:28:37.769 --> 00:28:42.970
her for an hour. At 8pm, he said goodnight and left.
364
00:28:42.970 --> 00:28:50.079
30 minutes later, a nursing aide found Marguerite Chambers unresponsive
365
00:28:50.180 --> 00:28:55.180
in bed. Efforts to revive her failed and Marguerite was
366
00:28:55.240 --> 00:29:01.839
pronounced dead. She was 60 years old. One by one,
367
00:29:01.980 --> 00:29:05.579
nursing staff went into Marguerite's room to pay their respects.
368
00:29:06.579 --> 00:29:13.000
Among them were Cathy Wood and Gwen Graham. As per
369
00:29:13.059 --> 00:29:16.640
protocol following a death at Alpine Manor, the charge nurse
370
00:29:16.700 --> 00:29:21.250
phoned the facility's on-call doctor. It was a Sunday night
371
00:29:21.589 --> 00:29:23.750
and he didn't want to drive through the heavy snow
372
00:29:23.829 --> 00:29:28.339
to examine Margaret's body in person. Instead, he ordered her
373
00:29:28.420 --> 00:29:32.720
to be transferred to the mortuary over the phone. The
374
00:29:32.779 --> 00:29:37.250
following day, the doctor signed Marguerite's death certificate without having
375
00:29:37.309 --> 00:29:41.400
seen her body. Under the cause of death, he wrote,
376
00:29:42.200 --> 00:29:47.720
heart attack. Three weeks later, on the morning of Tuesday,
377
00:29:47.819 --> 00:29:52.079
February 3, a registered nurse began her shift at Alpine Manor.
378
00:29:53.039 --> 00:29:57.279
She soon noticed that a 95-year-old resident named Myrtle Luce
379
00:29:57.420 --> 00:30:01.380
had blood dripping from her nose. The nurse applied a
380
00:30:01.440 --> 00:30:04.400
compress and made a note of the incident, but didn't
381
00:30:04.440 --> 00:30:08.980
think any more about it. A series of strokes and
382
00:30:09.059 --> 00:30:12.700
organic brain syndrome had robbed Myrtle of her normal functions.
383
00:30:13.890 --> 00:30:16.430
Although she was somewhat aware of what was going on
384
00:30:16.470 --> 00:30:20.809
around her, she could no longer walk or talk. Myrtle
385
00:30:20.890 --> 00:30:23.650
spent the majority of her time curled up in bed
386
00:30:23.710 --> 00:30:28.019
in the fetal positions. The only time Myrtle seemed to
387
00:30:28.079 --> 00:30:30.380
know what was going on around her was when her
388
00:30:30.440 --> 00:30:35.640
son came to visit. When she saw him, Myrtle changed instantly.
389
00:30:36.559 --> 00:30:41.640
She smiled and patted his face. Because of her high
390
00:30:41.700 --> 00:30:45.849
care needs, Cathy Wood openly complained to her colleagues that
391
00:30:45.930 --> 00:30:50.329
she didn't like Myrtle Luce. She found her too difficult
392
00:30:50.410 --> 00:30:56.119
to take care of. A week after Myrtle was treated
393
00:30:56.210 --> 00:30:59.900
for her unexplained bloody nose, a nurse aide found her
394
00:30:59.960 --> 00:31:04.579
deceased in bed. This time, her nose was covered in
395
00:31:04.660 --> 00:31:09.849
mucus and looked bruised. On the mattress beside Myrtle's body
396
00:31:10.049 --> 00:31:15.230
was a rolled up washcloth. Myrtle's body was sent directly
397
00:31:15.289 --> 00:31:18.890
to the mortuary by the Alpine Manor doctor without examination,
398
00:31:19.430 --> 00:31:23.690
as in the case of Marguerite Chambers. And like that incident,
399
00:31:24.130 --> 00:31:27.690
the doctor listed Myrtle's cause of death as heart attack.
400
00:31:29.910 --> 00:31:32.809
Myrtle's loved ones were surprised by the news of her
401
00:31:32.869 --> 00:31:37.789
sudden death. She had undergone a physical exam just days earlier,
402
00:31:38.109 --> 00:31:41.670
during which the doctor had described her heart health as impeccable.
403
00:31:43.430 --> 00:31:46.920
Following Myrtle's funeral, her family panned a card to the
404
00:31:47.000 --> 00:31:49.759
Alpine Manor staff to thank them for the care and
405
00:31:49.839 --> 00:31:53.859
compassion they had shown Myrtle while she was alive. It
406
00:31:53.900 --> 00:32:00.319
was pinned to the staff bulletin board. Days later, Kathy
407
00:32:00.380 --> 00:32:04.789
Wood and Gwen Graham invited Kathy's ex-girlfriend Dawn over to
408
00:32:04.829 --> 00:32:09.089
their place. As they sat in the living room drinking,
409
00:32:09.529 --> 00:32:13.930
Gwen casually mentioned that she had been responsible for Myrtle's death.
410
00:32:15.390 --> 00:32:20.509
Gwen asked Dawn if she wanted to see proof. Dawn
411
00:32:20.589 --> 00:32:24.799
followed Gwen and Kathy into the bedroom, On a shelf
412
00:32:24.980 --> 00:32:30.240
lay a single sock. This belonged to her, Gwen said.
413
00:32:32.849 --> 00:32:35.829
Dawn was well aware of the twisted pranks and mind
414
00:32:35.890 --> 00:32:39.849
games the couple often played. She passed off the comment
415
00:32:39.910 --> 00:32:44.289
as a sick joke. Kathy was known to steal from
416
00:32:44.309 --> 00:32:48.089
the residents of Alpine Manor, once taking a resident's rosary
417
00:32:48.130 --> 00:32:50.829
beads to hang from the rearview mirror of her truck.
418
00:32:52.470 --> 00:32:55.430
The more Dawn thought about it, the more she believed
419
00:32:55.589 --> 00:32:58.430
that the pair had just stolen a sock, or that
420
00:32:58.470 --> 00:33:04.230
it belonged to Kathy. Dawn told herself, Gwen's just fucking
421
00:33:04.259 --> 00:33:13.119
with me. On the morning of Monday February 16 1987,
422
00:33:13.119 --> 00:33:17.440
an Alpine Manor nursing aide named Sean peered into the
423
00:33:17.480 --> 00:33:24.079
room of 79-year-old resident May Mason. May, who had Alzheimer's disease,
424
00:33:24.319 --> 00:33:28.240
was awake. She fidgeted with her hands in bed and
425
00:33:28.380 --> 00:33:33.220
seemed agitated. Sean took a damp washcloth to freshen May,
426
00:33:33.519 --> 00:33:37.000
wiping it over her
face and hands. But this only
427
00:33:37.079 --> 00:33:42.400
heightened May's distress. She kept clutching at the washcloth, not
428
00:33:42.460 --> 00:33:46.970
wanting it to touch her skin. Sean tried to calm May,
429
00:33:47.170 --> 00:33:50.849
but had to check on other residents. She rolled May
430
00:33:50.890 --> 00:33:53.789
from her side onto her back and tucked her in,
431
00:33:54.130 --> 00:33:58.630
pulling the covers to her neck. When she left, May
432
00:33:58.750 --> 00:34:05.740
was wide awake. Two hours later, Sean checked on May again.
433
00:34:06.920 --> 00:34:10.559
Her skin had turned grey and her fingernails were now blue.
434
00:34:12.119 --> 00:34:16.659
Her pulse was imperceptible and she was pronounced deceased at 4am.
435
00:34:19.530 --> 00:34:24.619
Sean was devastated and sought support from her colleagues. Fellow
436
00:34:24.699 --> 00:34:29.980
aide Gwen Graham did her best to comfort her. Mae
437
00:34:30.039 --> 00:34:33.630
Mason's cause of death was listed as cardiac arrest by
438
00:34:33.670 --> 00:34:39.349
her family physician. Her death came six days after Myrtle Luce.
439
00:34:42.789 --> 00:34:47.690
The next day, 74-year-old Alpine Manor resident Belle Burkhardt was
440
00:34:47.750 --> 00:34:51.400
found to have bruising to her face, particularly around her
441
00:34:51.480 --> 00:34:56.420
nose and right cheek. The injuries were reported to management.
442
00:34:58.360 --> 00:35:01.679
As Belle often suffered from seizures, they put the injuries
443
00:35:01.739 --> 00:35:06.349
down to an unwitnessed seizure during the night. It was
444
00:35:06.409 --> 00:35:08.730
assumed she must have hit her head on the bed's
445
00:35:08.789 --> 00:35:14.130
metal railings. The nurse assigned to Belle that night was
446
00:35:14.210 --> 00:35:18.340
Kathy Wood. She was never questioned about it and it
447
00:35:18.400 --> 00:35:25.320
wasn't investigated further. Kathy often complained to other staff about
448
00:35:25.400 --> 00:35:30.789
Belle Burkhardt's high care needs. She didn't like Belle. The
449
00:35:30.829 --> 00:35:35.510
feeling was mutual. Belle made it difficult for Kathy to
450
00:35:35.570 --> 00:35:40.639
turn her, often gripping onto bed bars. Whenever Kathy tried
451
00:35:40.679 --> 00:35:44.780
to verbally intimidate her, Belle would just laugh in her face.
452
00:35:47.119 --> 00:35:52.389
At 3am on Thursday February 26, Kathy volunteered to supervise
453
00:35:52.469 --> 00:35:55.550
the nurse's station while the other staff went on break.
454
00:35:56.989 --> 00:36:02.460
Belle Burkhardt was found deceased a few hours later. The
455
00:36:02.500 --> 00:36:05.679
nursing aide who found her noticed that Belle's arm was
456
00:36:05.739 --> 00:36:10.090
positioned at an odd angle underneath her body, When Belle's
457
00:36:10.150 --> 00:36:13.760
body was bathed for the funeral home, the aide noticed
458
00:36:13.909 --> 00:36:18.719
that the same arm was badly bruised. Nobody knew
why.
459
00:36:20.599 --> 00:36:24.219
One of Cathy Wood's nursing friends suggested that the bruising
460
00:36:24.300 --> 00:36:27.000
might have been caused from the nursing aide not turning
461
00:36:27.059 --> 00:36:33.639
Belle during the night. The matter was dismissed. Belle was
462
00:36:33.699 --> 00:36:36.889
released to the mortuary without a doctor viewing her body.
463
00:36:38.030 --> 00:36:40.780
The cause of death was listed as a heart attack.
464
00:36:42.559 --> 00:36:47.320
Like Myrtle Luce's family, Belle Burkhardt couldn't believe what had happened.
465
00:36:48.820 --> 00:36:52.360
During a check-up a week prior, the doctor had mentioned
466
00:36:52.599 --> 00:37:00.780
her heart was fine. As the number of sudden deaths
467
00:37:00.880 --> 00:37:04.739
in Alpine Manor grew, Cathy Wood, Gwen Graham and their
468
00:37:04.800 --> 00:37:09.949
Alpine Manor cohorts became increasingly out of control. The couple
469
00:37:10.010 --> 00:37:13.150
would host wild parties at their home on their days off,
470
00:37:13.570 --> 00:37:17.130
during which staff in attendance would run down the street topless.
471
00:37:18.670 --> 00:37:22.320
For no discernible reason, the disorderly group would get into
472
00:37:22.380 --> 00:37:25.860
physical fights with each other at pubs and clubs, resulting
473
00:37:25.920 --> 00:37:30.690
in serious injuries. Nursing aide LaDonna had two of her
474
00:37:30.750 --> 00:37:35.789
teeth knocked out during one inexplicable altercation. In the book,
475
00:37:36.050 --> 00:37:41.639
Forever and Five Days, LaDonna said, We had all gone crazy.
476
00:37:42.280 --> 00:37:45.960
We didn't care for each other's feelings. We didn't have
477
00:37:46.059 --> 00:37:53.079
any feelings. One day in April 1987, a nursing aide
478
00:37:53.199 --> 00:37:56.320
named Catherine snuck through the back door of Alpine Manor
479
00:37:56.480 --> 00:38:00.929
and into the Director of Nursing's office. With a black eye,
480
00:38:01.190 --> 00:38:04.489
her arm in a sling and a cracked rib, Catherine
481
00:38:04.550 --> 00:38:06.789
didn't want to be seen by her colleagues as she
482
00:38:06.949 --> 00:38:11.760
asked for time off. Initially brushing off her injuries as
483
00:38:11.820 --> 00:38:15.179
the result of an accident, the truth was soon uncovered.
484
00:38:16.760 --> 00:38:19.900
Kathy Wood had lured Catherine to a deserted area on
485
00:38:19.920 --> 00:38:23.539
the outskirts of Grand Rapids with the pretense of hooking up.
486
00:38:25.039 --> 00:38:28.639
Other nursing aides were also there, watching in amusement as
487
00:38:28.739 --> 00:38:33.800
Gwen Graham confronted Catherine. She knocked her to the ground,
488
00:38:34.019 --> 00:38:37.639
then punched and kicked her repeatedly in the chest and stomach.
489
00:38:39.960 --> 00:38:42.679
Gwen was called into the office and asked if the
490
00:38:42.719 --> 00:38:49.739
story was true. Smiling, Gwen explains, I wouldn't do something
491
00:38:49.860 --> 00:38:55.530
like that. She left the office and faced no repercussions.
492
00:38:57.489 --> 00:39:01.250
The incident had staff terrified of Kathy and Gwen, with
493
00:39:01.329 --> 00:39:06.429
many refusing to work with them. Reports continued to flood
494
00:39:06.489 --> 00:39:11.150
management about the pair's toxic behaviour. Yet, when given a
495
00:39:11.210 --> 00:39:15.250
report about Kathy's bullying, The Alpine Manor manager ripped it
496
00:39:15.449 --> 00:39:18.800
up and threw it in the bin. She was friends
497
00:39:18.840 --> 00:39:24.039
with Kathy and didn't want her to get into trouble. Instead,
498
00:39:24.280 --> 00:39:27.460
the manager decided to separate Cathy from the aides that
499
00:39:27.480 --> 00:39:31.980
were making the allegations against her. Cathy was called into
500
00:39:32.000 --> 00:39:36.269
the manager's office and was given the good news. She
501
00:39:36.309 --> 00:39:41.130
had been promoted. She was now in charge of nursing
502
00:39:41.269 --> 00:39:54.480
aides on her shift. Casefile will be back shortly. Thank
503
00:39:54.500 --> 00:39:58.050
you for supporting us by listening to this episode's sponsors.
504
00:40:01.889 --> 00:40:05.699
Thank you for listening to this episode's ads. By supporting
505
00:40:05.780 --> 00:40:10.460
our sponsors, you support Casefile to continue to deliver quality content.
506
00:40:19.579 --> 00:40:22.940
Many of Cathy Wood's work friends were thrilled with her promotion.
507
00:40:23.860 --> 00:40:29.630
But there was one who wasn't. Gwen Graham. She believed
508
00:40:29.789 --> 00:40:32.030
she worked harder than Cathy and she should have been
509
00:40:32.050 --> 00:40:37.090
the one promoted. It made things difficult at home. Cathy
510
00:40:37.130 --> 00:40:40.949
and Gwen argued often, with the fights often culminating in violence.
511
00:40:42.280 --> 00:40:44.860
The walls of their house were damaged with holes as
512
00:40:44.920 --> 00:40:48.869
a result of punches thrown in fits of anger. When
513
00:40:48.929 --> 00:40:52.429
Kathy learned Gwen had sex with another nursing aide, she
514
00:40:52.489 --> 00:40:56.289
became furious, yelling so loudly that her screams were heard
515
00:40:56.329 --> 00:41:00.630
from down the street. When Gwen tried to leave the house,
516
00:41:01.050 --> 00:41:03.710
Kathy dragged her back in by her hair and slapped
517
00:41:03.750 --> 00:41:07.730
her repeatedly. She was often seen at work covered in
518
00:41:07.789 --> 00:41:15.179
scratches and bruises. By mid-1987, Gwen had had enough. She
519
00:41:15.219 --> 00:41:19.239
moved out of Kathy's home and into a trailer, Joining
520
00:41:19.280 --> 00:41:23.010
Gwen was her new girlfriend, a 21-year-old nursing aide from
521
00:41:23.119 --> 00:41:28.190
Alpine Manor named Heather Barriger. Heather, who had never been
522
00:41:28.230 --> 00:41:31.489
in a relationship before, told Gwen she was madly in
523
00:41:31.530 --> 00:41:36.889
love
with her. Together, they hatched a plan. They would
524
00:41:36.969 --> 00:41:40.650
leave Grand Rapids and return to Gwen's hometown in Texas
525
00:41:40.809 --> 00:41:46.349
to start over. Kathy found out and visited Gwen, demanding
526
00:41:46.429 --> 00:41:52.960
she return home. After an argument, Gwen agreed. Kathy took
527
00:41:53.000 --> 00:41:57.280
her to the bedroom where they had sex. As detailed
528
00:41:57.340 --> 00:42:01.110
in Forever and Five Days, as Gwen lay on the bed,
529
00:42:01.630 --> 00:42:05.130
Kathy retrieved some restraints she had taken from Alpine Manor.
530
00:42:06.269 --> 00:42:10.250
She tied Gwen's wrists to the bed. Then, she walked
531
00:42:10.369 --> 00:42:13.769
to the foot of the bed. In her hands was
532
00:42:13.789 --> 00:42:18.630
a loaded gun that belonged to Gwen. Kathy inserted the
533
00:42:18.670 --> 00:42:25.400
gun barrel into Gwen's body, threatening, I'll kill you. Kathy
534
00:42:25.460 --> 00:42:29.699
left Gwen tied up for three hours. When she returned,
535
00:42:29.980 --> 00:42:35.070
Kathy removed the gun and untied her. After a discussion,
536
00:42:35.429 --> 00:42:40.329
Kathy agreed it was over between them. Gwen returned to
537
00:42:40.369 --> 00:42:44.989
her girlfriend Heather. She asked why Gwen dropped everything to
538
00:42:45.050 --> 00:42:53.460
please Kathy. Gwen responded, Kathy has something over me. Gwen
539
00:42:53.519 --> 00:42:57.500
and Heather decided now was the time to act. In
540
00:42:57.579 --> 00:43:02.119
August 1987, they packed their belongings into Gwen's car and
541
00:43:02.239 --> 00:43:10.789
fled for Texas. With nowhere else to turn, Kathy Wood
542
00:43:10.869 --> 00:43:15.199
returned to her ex-husband, Ken. She told him she and
543
00:43:15.280 --> 00:43:19.369
Gwen had done things she was afraid of. She wanted
544
00:43:19.389 --> 00:43:22.210
to tell Ken, but he had to promise her first
545
00:43:22.429 --> 00:43:26.530
that he would keep it secret. He gave her his word.
546
00:43:28.250 --> 00:43:32.730
After a moment's silence, Kathy said to him, What's the
547
00:43:32.789 --> 00:43:35.409
worst thing you could think of to do to someone?
548
00:43:36.719 --> 00:43:42.489
Ken replied, Murder would be the worst. Thinking there was
549
00:43:42.610 --> 00:43:46.510
no way Kathy would murder someone, he was completely taken
550
00:43:46.550 --> 00:43:54.550
aback when she replied, Well, try six times. Kathy told
551
00:43:54.630 --> 00:43:58.369
Ken about one of the residents they had killed, 97-year-old
552
00:43:58.610 --> 00:44:03.000
Edith Cook. Edith was one of the most popular residents
553
00:44:03.119 --> 00:44:07.860
among staff and other residents at Alpine Manor. She had
554
00:44:07.920 --> 00:44:11.400
been there for six years, once telling a social worker
555
00:44:11.639 --> 00:44:15.619
that Alpine Manor is grand, everything is all very lovely.
556
00:44:17.659 --> 00:44:20.880
She spent her days visiting and chatting to
other residents.
557
00:44:21.880 --> 00:44:26.619
But in the months before her death, Edith's health deteriorated rapidly.
558
00:44:27.960 --> 00:44:30.539
One night, she was found with her legs poking through
559
00:44:30.579 --> 00:44:34.590
the metal bars on her bed. Pressure sores developed which
560
00:44:34.659 --> 00:44:40.719
turned into painful gangrene. Edith's condition was deemed to be palliative,
561
00:44:41.010 --> 00:44:45.559
meaning that she would not survive. At 2.30 on the
562
00:44:45.599 --> 00:44:50.300
morning of Thursday April 7, 1987, Edith Cook was found
563
00:44:50.440 --> 00:44:55.239
deceased in her bed. The night nurse assigned to her
564
00:44:55.320 --> 00:44:59.820
care was Kathy Wood. Also working on the wing that
565
00:44:59.900 --> 00:45:06.199
night was Gwen Graham. In an effort to understand what
566
00:45:06.260 --> 00:45:10.000
his ex-wife had just confessed, Ken asked if Kathy and
567
00:45:10.099 --> 00:45:16.630
Gwen killed people to end their pain and suffering. Kathy replied, No,
568
00:45:17.389 --> 00:45:26.659
we did it for fun. Kathy went on to detail
569
00:45:26.719 --> 00:45:31.909
her experiences. The idea to murder residents at Alpine Manor
570
00:45:32.030 --> 00:45:34.550
arose one day as she and Gwen sat at their
571
00:45:34.610 --> 00:45:39.389
dining table doing the morning crossword puzzle. Work had been
572
00:45:39.429 --> 00:45:42.230
getting boring and the pair had always wondered what it
573
00:45:42.269 --> 00:45:47.730
would be like to kill. They chose 60-year-old Marguerite Chambers
574
00:45:47.809 --> 00:45:52.300
to be their first victim. On the night of Sunday
575
00:45:52.389 --> 00:45:54.030
January 18 1987, after Marguerite's husband left for the night,
576
00:45:57.960 --> 00:46:02.989
Kathy said she and Gwen approached her room. Keeping watch
577
00:46:03.050 --> 00:46:06.289
by the door, Kathy made sure the coast was clear
578
00:46:06.469 --> 00:46:11.590
as Gwen slipped inside. She held two washcloths rolled into
579
00:46:11.650 --> 00:46:17.010
log shapes. Kathy claimed that Gwen took one washcloth and
580
00:46:17.110 --> 00:46:21.320
positioned it under Marguerite's chin to support her jaw. She
581
00:46:21.360 --> 00:46:26.920
placed the other washcloth over Marguerite's nose. Then she squeezed hard.
582
00:46:28.440 --> 00:46:32.570
Marguerite thrashed in bed trying to free herself, but Gwen
583
00:46:32.750 --> 00:46:39.909
easily overpowered the ailing woman. Marguerite then went limp. Gwen
584
00:46:39.949 --> 00:46:43.349
slipped out without drawing attention from anyone else and walked
585
00:46:43.429 --> 00:46:47.440
back to her assigned wing. Both she and Kathy were
586
00:46:47.519 --> 00:46:51.300
tending to other residents when Marguerite was found deceased less
587
00:46:51.420 --> 00:46:57.070
than 30 minutes later. This was not the first time
588
00:46:57.159 --> 00:47:00.949
Kathy and Gwen had tried to kill Marguerite. They had
589
00:47:01.010 --> 00:47:06.050
attempted the same method a month prior. Kathy explained that
590
00:47:06.139 --> 00:47:09.219
it had all gone to plan. They waited for the
591
00:47:09.239 --> 00:47:12.820
nursing aide assigned to Marguerite's care to find her dead.
592
00:47:13.739 --> 00:47:20.360
But Gwen had only rendered Marguerite unconscious. From this failed experience,
593
00:47:20.659 --> 00:47:23.630
Gwen learned she needed to suffocate her victim for a
594
00:47:23.690 --> 00:47:28.829
few minutes after they stopped moving. This attempted murder explained
595
00:47:28.889 --> 00:47:32.269
why Marguerite Chambers had been so terrified of having her
596
00:47:32.369 --> 00:47:38.349
face cleaned with a washcloth. Kathy gave a strange explanation
597
00:47:38.449 --> 00:47:43.820
as to why they targeted Marguerite Chambers first. At Alpine Manor,
598
00:47:43.940 --> 00:47:48.139
there was a logbook. Every time a resident passed away,
599
00:47:48.440 --> 00:47:51.059
their name was entered into the book with one entry
600
00:47:51.099 --> 00:47:57.320
per line. Marguerite started with the letter M. If they
601
00:47:57.340 --> 00:48:00.650
could find another five residents to kill with the initials
602
00:48:00.750 --> 00:48:03.989
they were looking for, then running down the page, they
603
00:48:04.030 --> 00:48:08.829
could spell out the word murder. But their plan was
604
00:48:08.889 --> 00:48:12.989
too hard. The residents they needed to make the murder
605
00:48:13.070 --> 00:48:18.360
acronym were active and lucid. Instead, the couple chose victims
606
00:48:18.389 --> 00:48:23.440
who were non-verbal or suffering advanced dementia. That way, if
607
00:48:23.519 --> 00:48:26.519
they survived the suffocation, they would not be able to
608
00:48:26.579 --> 00:48:31.079
tell anyone. Even if they did, no one would believe them.
609
00:48:33.260 --> 00:48:36.320
Kathy and Gwen pinched residents' noses while they lay in
610
00:48:36.389 --> 00:48:38.769
bed to see how they would react to having their
611
00:48:38.849 --> 00:48:42.570
air supply cut off suddenly. If one put up too
612
00:48:42.610 --> 00:48:45.429
much of a fight, the pair moved on to someone else.
613
00:48:46.980 --> 00:48:50.519
This was why some residents were found with unexplained bruising
614
00:48:50.639 --> 00:48:54.440
or bloody noses. When it was time to carry out
615
00:48:54.500 --> 00:48:58.500
the killings, Gwen used washcloths to prevent any bruising that
616
00:48:58.539 --> 00:49:04.630
could raise suspicion. According to Kathy, Gwen said she felt
617
00:49:04.690 --> 00:49:08.329
more relaxed after killing someone, saying it helped to ease
618
00:49:08.349 --> 00:49:12.949
her tension. Kathy and Gwen believed that sharing the secret
619
00:49:12.989 --> 00:49:22.300
of the murders would bind them together forever. Ken struggled
620
00:49:22.360 --> 00:49:25.300
with what to do with the information Kathy had given him.
621
00:49:26.380 --> 00:49:29.440
He wanted to believe it was a fabricated story, but
622
00:49:29.539 --> 00:49:34.300
he didn't want to dismiss it entirely. Over a year
623
00:49:34.360 --> 00:49:38.909
passed as Ken agonised over what to do. During this time,
624
00:49:39.280 --> 00:49:42.780
he kept Cathy's confession to himself as she continued to
625
00:49:42.820 --> 00:49:49.630
work at Alpine Manor. On Thursday October 6 1988, Ken
626
00:49:49.670 --> 00:49:52.150
was driving past the police station when he made a
627
00:49:52.230 --> 00:49:59.170
last-minute decision. He went inside to report Cathy's allegations. When
628
00:49:59.269 --> 00:50:01.789
asked why he had waited so long to come forward,
629
00:50:02.090 --> 00:50:06.670
Ken explained, I didn't want to destroy my life and
630
00:50:06.730 --> 00:50:09.409
I didn't want to destroy her life by turning her in,
631
00:50:09.989 --> 00:50:12.730
but I felt I should find out if Kathy was dangerous.
632
00:50:13.769 --> 00:50:15.909
I know she can hate with the best of them.
633
00:50:18.760 --> 00:50:21.699
The following day, Kathy Wood was at work when a
634
00:50:21.739 --> 00:50:25.920
detective arrived at Alpine Manor. He found Kathy wandering the
635
00:50:25.980 --> 00:50:29.000
hall and told her he was taking her in for questioning.
636
00:50:30.159 --> 00:50:34.739
Kathy didn't act surprised or ask why. She grabbed her
637
00:50:34.800 --> 00:50:40.050
coat and accompanied the detective in silence. Kathy agreed to
638
00:50:40.090 --> 00:50:44.730
be interviewed. When told that her ex-husband had implicated her
639
00:50:44.809 --> 00:50:47.750
and Gwen Graham in the murder of an Alpine Manor resident,
640
00:50:48.269 --> 00:50:52.780
Kathy threw her head back and laughed. The detective told
641
00:50:52.820 --> 00:50:56.099
her he didn't think it was very funny, prompting Kathy
642
00:50:56.159 --> 00:51:01.280
to sober up. Kathy was an open book to detectives.
643
00:51:02.269 --> 00:51:05.639
Although she'd told Ken there were six victims, she told
644
00:51:05.699 --> 00:51:11.280
police of five. Marguerite Chambers, May Mason, Belle Burkhardt, Edith
645
00:51:11.380 --> 00:51:16.179
Cook and Myrtle Luce. There might have been another three
646
00:51:16.260 --> 00:51:19.829
that Gwen killed, but Kathy maintained that she couldn't remember
647
00:51:19.869 --> 00:51:23.110
the details or wasn't at work when they were killed.
648
00:51:24.449 --> 00:51:29.699
She described planning the crime spree as, quote, almost exciting
649
00:51:29.780 --> 00:51:36.380
in a way. Kathy recalled the night Gwen murdered 79-year-old
650
00:51:36.480 --> 00:51:40.579
May Mason. Gwen approached Kathy and told her she was
651
00:51:40.639 --> 00:51:44.420
going to do May. Kathy warned her it was not
652
00:51:44.460 --> 00:51:48.119
the right time. There were two nurses nearby and Kathy
653
00:51:48.159 --> 00:51:51.780
was assigned to a different wing. But they came up
654
00:51:51.880 --> 00:51:56.989
with a plan. Kathy
distracted the nurses with gossip while
655
00:51:57.050 --> 00:52:02.429
Gwen slipped into May's bedroom. They were very nearly discovered
656
00:52:02.530 --> 00:52:07.539
when Gwen killed Belle Burkhardt. That morning, Kathy had volunteered
657
00:52:07.579 --> 00:52:10.760
to supervise the nurse's station while the other staff went
658
00:52:10.820 --> 00:52:15.400
on a break. As she sat alone, Gwen approached from
659
00:52:15.420 --> 00:52:19.530
the wing she was assigned to. In her back pocket
660
00:52:19.650 --> 00:52:24.789
were two washcloths. Kathy described how Gwen went into Belle
661
00:52:24.849 --> 00:52:27.989
Burkhardt's room while Kathy kept an eye out front from
662
00:52:28.030 --> 00:52:32.579
the nurse's station. An intercom ran from Belle's room to
663
00:52:32.619 --> 00:52:36.960
the station. Kathy could hear a rustle of sheets and
664
00:52:37.039 --> 00:52:42.510
then groaning noises. For a few minutes, gurgling noises sounded
665
00:52:42.590 --> 00:52:48.570
over the intercom and then stopped. Moments later, Gwen appeared
666
00:52:48.650 --> 00:52:54.039
from the room. Belle was discovered deceased by a nursing
667
00:52:54.199 --> 00:52:57.039
aide a few hours later with her arm positioned at
668
00:52:57.079 --> 00:53:00.469
an odd angle underneath her body and severe bruising to
669
00:53:00.510 --> 00:53:05.650
the skin. According to Kathy, Gwen said that Belle had
670
00:53:05.710 --> 00:53:09.710
put up a tremendous fight. The bruising on her arm
671
00:53:09.769 --> 00:53:12.269
had been caused by Gwen kneeling on it to keep
672
00:53:12.309 --> 00:53:17.789
her still. During her police interview, Kathy was asked what
673
00:53:17.829 --> 00:53:24.150
would motivate Gwen to murder. She replied, Gwen liked pain
674
00:53:24.369 --> 00:53:27.389
and painful things. She had a lot of pain in
675
00:53:27.449 --> 00:53:31.019
her life, I don't know if she wanted other people
676
00:53:31.139 --> 00:53:36.079
to feel the same. Kathy said her role in the
677
00:53:36.119 --> 00:53:39.030
murders ended because she grew tired of it and didn't
678
00:53:39.050 --> 00:53:42.550
want to be a lookout anymore. She never told Gwen
679
00:53:42.610 --> 00:53:47.090
to stop because she wanted her to be happy. Still,
680
00:53:47.469 --> 00:53:52.989
no further killings took place. The women had originally planned
681
00:53:53.150 --> 00:53:55.869
to take it in turns to kill, but Kathy said
682
00:53:56.010 --> 00:54:00.420
she could never bring herself to be the murderer. She explained,
683
00:54:01.780 --> 00:54:04.619
Those people in there were like family to me, and
684
00:54:04.659 --> 00:54:10.260
I couldn't do that to them. Kathy asserted that Gwen
685
00:54:10.300 --> 00:54:14.340
had kept a memento of every victim. From Myrtle Luce,
686
00:54:14.480 --> 00:54:18.050
she took a sock, from Belle Burkhardt, she took a jewellery,
687
00:54:18.610 --> 00:54:21.809
from Edith Cook, an earring, and from May Mason, a
688
00:54:21.869 --> 00:54:27.059
keyring trinket. From Marguerite Chambers, she took a balloon given
689
00:54:27.099 --> 00:54:29.599
to her with a bunch of flowers from her children.
690
00:54:32.380 --> 00:54:35.940
Gwen kept them in a shoebox in the bathroom, but
691
00:54:36.039 --> 00:54:40.909
there was a problem. Kathy explained that when Gwen moved out,
692
00:54:41.230 --> 00:54:46.869
she had thrown the box away. Police raided the Alpine
693
00:54:46.889 --> 00:54:50.489
Manor files pertaining to resident deaths at the time Kathy
694
00:54:50.530 --> 00:54:55.820
Wood and Gwen Graham worked together. Upper management showed little
695
00:54:55.860 --> 00:55:01.480
concern about the murder investigation. Alpine Manor had just received
696
00:55:01.559 --> 00:55:04.860
a glowing review from the government body that certified the
697
00:55:04.900 --> 00:55:11.400
nursing home for Medicaid. During their search, detectives uncovered a
698
00:55:11.440 --> 00:55:16.780
letter Cathy had written. It read in part, I love
699
00:55:16.820 --> 00:55:20.699
you Gwen, I think you're great. For this afternoon, I
700
00:55:20.739 --> 00:55:24.590
cannot wait. That's when we'll wake up and that's when
701
00:55:24.619 --> 00:55:28.409
I'll kiss you. That's when I'll hold you. Oh Gwen,
702
00:55:28.789 --> 00:55:33.369
I miss you. Bunny hop over here and let me
703
00:55:33.489 --> 00:55:37.710
lick you on the ear. Oh please say you'll be mine.
704
00:55:38.590 --> 00:55:45.150
Forever and five days. Detectives asked Kathy what the last
705
00:55:45.250 --> 00:55:49.030
line of her poem meant. She explained that it was
706
00:55:49.090 --> 00:55:52.550
their take on the Shakespearean line, forever and a day.
707
00:55:53.980 --> 00:55:57.519
Every time they killed a resident, Kathy and Gwen added
708
00:55:57.579 --> 00:56:05.940
an extra day to the saying. Six days after Kathy's
709
00:56:06.000 --> 00:56:10.869
ex-husband first approached police, officers arrived at Gwen Graham's trailer
710
00:56:10.929 --> 00:56:14.630
in Texas where she'd started a new life with girlfriend Heather.
711
00:56:15.960 --> 00:56:19.179
With no concrete evidence of murder having been uncovered yet,
712
00:56:19.579 --> 00:56:23.389
police arrested Gwen for writing bad checks three years earlier.
713
00:56:24.570 --> 00:56:27.010
They hoped that she might open up while sitting in
714
00:56:27.050 --> 00:56:33.869
the county jail. Instead, Gwen protested her innocence. She was
715
00:56:33.929 --> 00:56:36.289
so certain that she had nothing to do with the
716
00:56:36.329 --> 00:56:38.940
deaths at Alpine Manor that she offered to take a
717
00:56:38.980 --> 00:56:43.920
polygraph test. The operator told the lead detective on the
718
00:56:43.960 --> 00:56:48.010
case that in his mind, Gwen was a cold-blooded killer,
719
00:56:48.929 --> 00:56:53.909
but the results of the test were inconclusive. Gwen Graham
720
00:56:53.969 --> 00:56:57.250
was free to go. She went back
to her new
721
00:56:57.309 --> 00:57:03.070
job as a nursing aide for a Texas hospital. Kathy
722
00:57:03.139 --> 00:57:07.000
Wood also took a polygraph test. As one of her
723
00:57:07.059 --> 00:57:10.699
first baseline questions, Kathy was asked what the best thing
724
00:57:10.719 --> 00:57:14.380
that ever happened to her was. She replied that it
725
00:57:14.420 --> 00:57:18.900
was her daughter, Then she changed her mind and said Gwen.
726
00:57:20.619 --> 00:57:23.920
As for the worst thing, Kathy immediately said that it
727
00:57:23.960 --> 00:57:35.769
was when Gwen left her. She was then asked, After
728
00:57:35.869 --> 00:57:39.510
two hours, the polygraph examiner was left with little doubt
729
00:57:39.610 --> 00:57:43.860
that Kathy was trying to manipulate the test. She was, quote,
730
00:57:45.039 --> 00:57:50.500
playing a subtle, intelligent game. He believed that Gwen Graham
731
00:57:50.579 --> 00:57:55.050
hadn't killed anyone. It was all a ploy mastered by Kathy,
732
00:57:55.550 --> 00:58:00.550
the ultimate revenge for Gwen leaving her. In a follow-up
733
00:58:00.670 --> 00:58:04.590
polygraph test, Kathy was asked why someone would make up
734
00:58:04.630 --> 00:58:09.469
a story like this. She replied, They'd have to be
735
00:58:09.630 --> 00:58:14.639
awfully unhappy, awfully lonely. Maybe they even want to go
736
00:58:14.699 --> 00:58:17.679
to prison like I do because then they won't have
737
00:58:17.719 --> 00:58:24.840
to worry about anything. As the Alpine Manor murders investigation
738
00:58:24.960 --> 00:58:28.300
reached its sixth week, an excavator was brought to the
739
00:58:28.340 --> 00:58:33.159
Rosedale Memorial Cemetery. The decision had been made to excavate
740
00:58:33.199 --> 00:58:37.630
the remains of Marguerite Chambers and Edith Cork. Every other
741
00:58:37.710 --> 00:58:43.820
victim listed by Cathy Wood had been cremated. Marguerite's husband, Ed,
742
00:58:43.969 --> 00:58:48.190
had given the go-ahead. He was haunted by the realisation
743
00:58:48.230 --> 00:58:51.570
that she might have been murdered, telling the Associated Press,
744
00:58:52.809 --> 00:58:56.150
I went through Marguerite's death once. I don't want to
745
00:58:56.170 --> 00:59:01.050
go through it twice. Since news of the alleged murder,
746
00:59:01.250 --> 00:59:04.630
he had suffered nightmares every night about being suffocated in
747
00:59:04.670 --> 00:59:10.880
his sleep. Water had leaked inside Marguerite's coffins, making an
748
00:59:10.960 --> 00:59:16.679
examination of her body difficult due to decomposition. Both Marguerite's
749
00:59:16.780 --> 00:59:20.590
and Edith's mouths were checked, with the medical examiner hoping
750
00:59:20.619 --> 00:59:24.570
to find fibres of washcloths to support Cathy's murder theory.
751
00:59:25.909 --> 00:59:29.070
He also checked the skin on their faces for abrasions
752
00:59:29.409 --> 00:59:33.809
and checked their eyelids, looking for pinprick-sized bruises that can
753
00:59:33.869 --> 00:59:40.079
indicate suffocation. No fibres or signs of suffocation were found.
754
00:59:42.300 --> 00:59:45.719
Cathy claimed that when Gwen killed Edith Cook, she said
755
00:59:45.860 --> 00:59:48.460
she had made a mistake by suffocating her with her
756
00:59:48.519 --> 00:59:53.289
false teeth still in. If true, the examination would show
757
00:59:53.349 --> 00:59:56.579
abrasions to Edith's mouth and indicating that she had bitten
758
00:59:56.619 --> 01:00:04.099
down while being suffocated. They weren't there. Marguerite and Edith's
759
01:00:04.119 --> 01:00:08.079
scores of death were listed as heart attacks. When the
760
01:00:08.119 --> 01:00:11.619
pathologist examined their hearts, he was certain of one thing.
761
01:00:12.659 --> 01:00:15.659
Their hearts were in good condition and they had not
762
01:00:15.719 --> 01:00:20.860
died from a heart attack. Based on these findings and
763
01:00:20.880 --> 01:00:25.480
the circumstantial evidence provided by Cathy Wood, the medical examiner
764
01:00:25.539 --> 01:00:29.679
changed their cause of death from heart attack to homicide.
765
01:00:35.889 --> 01:00:40.949
On Sunday December 4 1988, detectives surrounded Gwen Graham's home
766
01:00:40.989 --> 01:00:45.409
in Texas with an arrest warrant in hand. The lights
767
01:00:45.469 --> 01:00:48.960
were on inside, but knocks to the front door went unanswered.
768
01:00:50.449 --> 01:00:53.849
The trailer park manager revealed that Gwen and her girlfriend
769
01:00:53.889 --> 01:00:58.110
had fled weeks ago. He had no idea where they went.
770
01:00:59.760 --> 01:01:03.079
Detectives returned to their vehicles and as they pulled up
771
01:01:03.119 --> 01:01:07.920
to an intersection, a Mustang drove by. Behind the wheel
772
01:01:08.159 --> 01:01:13.739
was Gwen Graham. She was swiftly arrested without incident and
773
01:01:13.780 --> 01:01:18.139
held on a million dollar bond. Kathy Wood was arrested
774
01:01:18.159 --> 01:01:23.670
a few hours later. Al Van Dyke was sitting at
775
01:01:23.730 --> 01:01:26.489
home when he received a telephone call on behalf of
776
01:01:26.630 --> 01:01:32.219
Alpine Manor. Reading from a pre-written statement, the caller explained
777
01:01:32.380 --> 01:01:35.019
that the purpose of his call was to notify Al
778
01:01:35.059 --> 01:01:38.460
that his mother, Ruth Van Dyke, was a possible victim
779
01:01:38.539 --> 01:01:41.320
in a series of alleged homicides that happened at the
780
01:01:41.360 --> 01:01:47.190
nursing home. Al couldn't believe it. He was a former
781
01:01:47.230 --> 01:01:54.500
homicide detective himself. Another call went to Donald Urbanski, the
782
01:01:54.559 --> 01:02:00.090
nephew and legal guardian of 90-year-old Wanda. Having been told
783
01:02:00.110 --> 01:02:04.449
that Wanda had died from pneumonia, Donald said the realisation
784
01:02:04.530 --> 01:02:07.369
that his aunt could have been murdered hit him like
785
01:02:07.409 --> 01:02:11.739
a bolt of lightning. He thought back to her last
786
01:02:11.860 --> 01:02:15.400
months in Alpine Manor and something began to make sense.
787
01:02:16.989 --> 01:02:20.800
Staff were regularly contacting him to advise that Wanda had
788
01:02:20.840 --> 01:02:27.099
sustained bruising, abrasions and lacerations. He had always wondered why.
789
01:02:27.119 --> 01:02:34.639
Wanda couldn't move. The representative from Alpine Manor made another
790
01:02:34.780 --> 01:02:39.369
five calls that day. In total, Cathy had named eight
791
01:02:39.469 --> 01:02:42.929
residents in her interviews with detectives that she believed had
792
01:02:42.969 --> 01:02:48.519
been murdered. However, Belle Burkhardt's daughter, Nancy Hahn, found out
793
01:02:48.559 --> 01:02:52.780
from a journalist who called at her home. When she
794
01:02:52.840 --> 01:02:55.739
rang Alpine Manor the following morning to find out why
795
01:02:55.820 --> 01:03:01.289
she hadn't been notified, the manager replied, I'm sorry, it
796
01:03:01.329 --> 01:03:08.190
was an oversight. In January 1988, the Michigan Health Department
797
01:03:08.230 --> 01:03:13.460
conducted its own investigation. It found that Alpine Manor management
798
01:03:13.559 --> 01:03:17.039
had acted appropriately and had no reason to suspect that
799
01:03:17.079 --> 01:03:19.579
there was any elder abuse going on at the time
800
01:03:19.619 --> 01:03:24.480
of the murders. As news of the homicides broke, nursing
801
01:03:24.539 --> 01:03:28.559
staff were ordered not to speak to the press. One
802
01:03:28.639 --> 01:03:33.900
manager did tell reporters, Cathy Wood's reviews were great. You
803
01:03:33.940 --> 01:03:38.320
couldn't ask for anyone more professional. Cathy was very popular.
804
01:03:39.039 --> 01:03:51.000
She was a favourite. Prosecutors faced a problem. There was
805
01:03:51.079 --> 01:03:54.079
only enough evidence to charge Gwen Graham with the murders
806
01:03:54.119 --> 01:03:57.579
of Marguerite Chambers and Edith Cook, the two women whose
807
01:03:57.639 --> 01:04:02.320
bodies were exhumed. Even then, the case relied heavily on
808
01:04:02.380 --> 01:04:07.949
Cathy Wood's testimony. Without her cooperation, the case would fall apart.
809
01:04:09.849 --> 01:04:13.269
Because of this, the prosecution offered Cathy a plea deal
810
01:04:13.329 --> 01:04:17.949
in exchange for her testimony at trial. If Kathy pleaded
811
01:04:18.070 --> 01:04:22.150
guilty to second-degree murder and one count of conspiracy to
812
01:04:22.199 --> 01:04:25.280
commit murder, she would be given a more lenient jail
813
01:04:25.320 --> 01:04:31.900
sentence with the possibility of parole. Kathy agreed, and with that,
814
01:04:32.300 --> 01:04:36.849
further charges were brought against Gwen. She was now charged
815
01:04:36.929 --> 01:04:40.670
with conspiracy to commit murder and the first-degree murder of
816
01:04:40.769 --> 01:04:46.610
five residents from Alpine Manor. Gwen's defense team were almost
817
01:04:46.789 --> 01:04:51.130
certain she would be acquitted. There were no washcloth fibers
818
01:04:51.349 --> 01:04:55.329
or fingerprints linking their client to the victims. None of
819
01:04:55.389 --> 01:04:59.130
the mementos that Kathy claimed Gwen had taken as souvenirs
820
01:04:59.190 --> 01:05:04.090
had been found. The only link to Gwen was Kathy's word,
821
01:05:04.489 --> 01:05:08.769
who they said had a motive for lying. They alleged
822
01:05:08.909 --> 01:05:12.150
that the entire story was concocted by Kathy to get
823
01:05:12.190 --> 01:05:16.599
back at Gwen for leaving her. It was an allegation
824
01:05:16.659 --> 01:05:20.380
supported by many of Gwen's friends and co-workers, who couldn't
825
01:05:20.400 --> 01:05:25.119
believe for a second that Gwen was guilty of murder. Yet,
826
01:05:25.599 --> 01:05:29.239
Gwen and Kathy had confessed their involvement in murdering Alpine
827
01:05:29.280 --> 01:05:32.940
Manor residents to at least three other nursing aides and
828
01:05:33.079 --> 01:05:38.269
to Kathy's sister. None of them believed they were being serious.
829
01:05:41.449 --> 01:05:46.889
The trial began in September 1989. In his opening statements,
830
01:05:47.110 --> 01:05:51.559
the assistant prosecutor warned the jury that this is a
831
01:05:51.599 --> 01:05:57.460
bizarre case and it was committed by bizarre people. Cathy
832
01:05:57.519 --> 01:06:02.639
testified against Gwen for two full days. Appearing tearful and
833
01:06:02.800 --> 01:06:06.780
softly spoken, she detailed how she stood lookout while Gwen
834
01:06:06.840 --> 01:06:11.219
suffocated the victims of Alpine Manor. She appeared to the
835
01:06:11.280 --> 01:06:15.320
jury that she herself was a victim of Gwen's testifying
836
01:06:15.429 --> 01:06:17.449
that she was the one who had been tied to
837
01:06:17.489 --> 01:06:22.429
their bed with a gun inserted in her vagina. The
838
01:06:22.469 --> 01:06:26.710
prosecution had one final witness to call. It was Gwen's
839
01:06:26.730 --> 01:06:30.269
girlfriend Heather, who confirmed that she and Gwen were no
840
01:06:30.309 --> 01:06:34.780
longer a couple. Heather told the courtroom about the day
841
01:06:34.840 --> 01:06:39.119
police had first come to the trailer to search. After
842
01:06:39.159 --> 01:06:42.880
they visited, Heather asked if she had murdered residents of
843
01:06:43.000 --> 01:06:49.960
Alpine Manor. Gwen replied, yes. Not wanting to believe it,
844
01:06:50.510 --> 01:06:56.110
Heather replied, no you didn't. Heather showed the jury how
845
01:06:56.190 --> 01:07:00.159
Gwen had shaken her by the shoulders, saying, I know
846
01:07:00.219 --> 01:07:02.449
you don't want to believe it, but I did it.
847
01:07:02.460 --> 01:07:07.800
I did. As Heather stepped down from the witness box
848
01:07:07.900 --> 01:07:13.219
and was escorted away, Gwen shouted, I still love you, Heather.
849
01:07:16.150 -->
01:07:20.989
The jury deliberated for six hours. For the first-degree murder
850
01:07:21.030 --> 01:07:24.849
of five victims and the charge of conspiracy to commit murder,
851
01:07:25.289 --> 01:07:31.030
Gwen Graham was found guilty. Gwen showed no emotion as
852
01:07:31.090 --> 01:07:35.099
the verdicts were read. She was sentenced to life in
853
01:07:35.179 --> 01:07:40.760
prison with no possibility of parole. Families of the victims
854
01:07:40.840 --> 01:07:45.840
crowded the steps outside the courtroom. They were collectively happy
855
01:07:45.880 --> 01:07:50.179
with the verdict, although Marguerite Chambers' husband, Ed, told reporters
856
01:07:50.300 --> 01:07:53.090
he wished Michigan still had the death penalty in place.
857
01:07:54.409 --> 01:07:57.909
His daughter, Jan, said, One noticeable absence at the trial
858
01:07:58.030 --> 01:08:00.929
was Hazel Dredge, the daughter of murdered victim Myrtle Luce.
859
01:08:14.010 --> 01:08:16.970
Hazel had been a constant presence in Myrtle's life while
860
01:08:17.010 --> 01:08:21.310
she was alive. She visited Alpine Manor almost daily to
861
01:08:21.350 --> 01:08:25.260
make sure her mother was being cared for. But, like
862
01:08:25.310 --> 01:08:30.840
her mother, Hazel had succumbed to Alzheimer's disease. At the
863
01:08:30.880 --> 01:08:34.340
time of the trial, she was a resident at Alpine Manor.
864
01:08:37.399 --> 01:08:40.750
Following the trial, Alpine Manor released a statement to the
865
01:08:40.810 --> 01:08:45.399
media which read, Even though we find it difficult to
866
01:08:45.439 --> 01:08:49.409
believe that any of this actually happened, our primary goal
867
01:08:49.489 --> 01:08:52.369
is to help the wellbeing of residents and their families.
868
01:08:53.369 --> 01:08:56.840
We will continue to provide quality care in a supportive
869
01:08:56.899 --> 01:09:07.359
environment in our nursing home. In October 1989, Cathy Wood
870
01:09:07.439 --> 01:09:11.899
was sentenced. Her lawyer read from a statement which said,
871
01:09:13.149 --> 01:09:18.109
Saying I'm sorry is not enough. Mere words cannot express
872
01:09:18.149 --> 01:09:20.670
the remorse or guilt I'll have to live with for
873
01:09:20.689 --> 01:09:25.949
the rest of my life. Before handing down his sentence,
874
01:09:26.250 --> 01:09:29.189
the judge remarked, If I turned you loose today, I'm
875
01:09:29.229 --> 01:09:43.439
convinced you wouldn't do anything like this again. Kathy Wood
876
01:09:43.520 --> 01:09:47.640
was sentenced to 20 to 40 years in prison. With
877
01:09:47.760 --> 01:09:51.180
good behaviour, she would be eligible for parole after serving
878
01:09:51.319 --> 01:09:58.300
only 16. Many people believed that Kathy was more involved
879
01:09:58.340 --> 01:10:03.279
in the murders than simply standing lookout. Nursing staff remembered
880
01:10:03.319 --> 01:10:06.640
her as a manipulative liar and were convinced that she
881
01:10:06.680 --> 01:10:10.159
pulled the wool over everyone's eyes, from detectives on the
882
01:10:10.199 --> 01:10:15.500
case to the trial judge. As detailed in the book
883
01:10:15.619 --> 01:10:20.220
Forever and Five Days, a hairdresser named Maureen Haverhill was
884
01:10:20.300 --> 01:10:23.640
tending to Alpine Manor resident Lucille van der Veen in
885
01:10:23.720 --> 01:10:30.010
late 1987. Lucille was very distressed and told the hairdresser,
886
01:10:31.050 --> 01:10:34.010
They tried to kill me last night. They tried to
887
01:10:34.090 --> 01:10:37.609
smother me in my bed. But I fought back. I
888
01:10:37.670 --> 01:10:40.850
swung and I kicked and I scratched, and they couldn't
889
01:10:40.890 --> 01:10:45.920
do it. Maureen assured Lucille that nobody was trying to
890
01:10:45.960 --> 01:10:49.720
kill her. But after hearing of the Alpine Manor murders,
891
01:10:50.020 --> 01:10:54.899
she realised that Lucille might have been telling the truth. Yet,
892
01:10:55.500 --> 01:10:59.640
it couldn't have been Gwen Graham who attacked Lucille. She
893
01:10:59.680 --> 01:11:06.460
had left Alpine Manor five weeks earlier. A former inmate
894
01:11:06.500 --> 01:11:09.720
of Kathy Woods said she bragged about the murders in prison.
895
01:11:10.210 --> 01:11:15.069
showing other inmates clippings from newspapers about the case. The
896
01:11:15.109 --> 01:11:18.300
inmates said that they were discussing the murders when Cathy
897
01:11:18.340 --> 01:11:23.039
allegedly admitted, I did the murders. I really got that
898
01:11:23.140 --> 01:11:27.319
bitch back. That's what Gwen gets for breaking up with me.
899
01:11:29.600 --> 01:11:34.979
In September 2018, Cathy Wood came up for parole. Her
900
01:11:35.039 --> 01:11:38.239
application was challenged by family members of the victims of
901
01:11:38.359 --> 01:11:42.739
Alpine Manor who filed an appeal. They believed she had
902
01:11:42.800 --> 01:11:46.439
shown no remorse and, like the majority of people involved
903
01:11:46.479 --> 01:11:49.310
in the case, believed that she was more active in
904
01:11:49.329 --> 01:11:53.789
the murders than she admitted. They also lived in fear
905
01:11:53.869 --> 01:11:56.470
that Cathy would hunt them down when she was released
906
01:11:56.550 --> 01:12:02.380
from prison. May Mason's granddaughter, who was particularly vocal in
907
01:12:02.439 --> 01:12:06.109
her condemnation of Cathy's parole, armed herself with a gun
908
01:12:06.350 --> 01:12:12.310
and top-of-the-line home security. Despite the appeal from the victim's
909
01:12:12.369 --> 01:12:16.949
families and considerable public outrage, Kathy Wood was deemed as
910
01:12:17.069 --> 01:12:21.869
no longer a threat to society. At 57 years of age,
911
01:12:22.149 --> 01:12:25.850
after serving a 30-year sentence, she was released from prison
912
01:12:25.989 --> 01:12:29.090
and moved to South Carolina to live with her sister.
913
01:12:31.489 --> 01:12:34.470
A retired detective who worked on the
case believed she
914
01:12:34.550 --> 01:12:38.489
shouldn't have been paroled, telling local news station Wood TV.
915
01:12:40.149 --> 01:12:43.689
I believe that Kathy Wood was the mastermind. She was
916
01:12:43.710 --> 01:12:47.680
the one that was pulling strings on Gwen Graham. For
917
01:12:47.760 --> 01:12:51.819
safety reasons, I wouldn't want my grandchildren or elderly residents
918
01:12:51.880 --> 01:12:55.500
around her. She's a serial killer and she could do
919
01:12:55.539 --> 01:13:01.880
it again. And most of them do. With Kathy Wood's
920
01:13:01.920 --> 01:13:05.600
parole came the release of court documents previously withheld from
921
01:13:05.619 --> 01:13:09.699
the public. For the first time, it was revealed that
922
01:13:09.739 --> 01:13:13.279
at one stage, Kathy and Gwen were under investigation for
923
01:13:13.340 --> 01:13:17.560
a total of 12 deaths at Alpine Manor. However, a
924
01:13:17.859 --> 01:13:21.000
lack of evidence prevented the cases from moving to trial.
925
01:13:22.720 --> 01:13:26.680
Over the years, Kathy and Gwen earned the moniker, The
926
01:13:26.739 --> 01:13:37.380
Lethal Lovers. A year after the trials, Alpine Manor was
927
01:13:37.420 --> 01:13:41.220
sold to a hospital group who extensively renovated and rebranded
928
01:13:41.279 --> 01:13:45.979
the nursing home. Legislation in Michigan was reviewed and nursing
929
01:13:46.020 --> 01:13:52.189
homes subject to more stringent conditions. In Michigan today, suspected
930
01:13:52.270 --> 01:13:55.409
order abuse in nursing homes must be reported to Adult
931
01:13:55.449 --> 01:14:01.600
Protective Services investigators. Nursing homes still struggle with the same
932
01:14:01.659 --> 01:14:04.649
problems evident at the time of the Alpine Manor murders.
933
01:14:05.289 --> 01:14:10.470
An ageing population requiring full-time care, an understaffed workforce, and
934
01:14:10.609 --> 01:14:15.649
overworked and underpaid nurses are enormous challenges faced in providing care.
935
01:14:17.109 --> 01:14:21.380
Current legislation in Michigan dictates that only one certified nursing
936
01:14:21.439 --> 01:14:26.659
assistant be required for eight residents during the day. At night,
937
01:14:27.220 --> 01:14:31.479
one certified nursing assistant can legally be assigned 15 residents
938
01:14:31.520 --> 01:14:37.460
to care for. It will probably never be known exactly
939
01:14:37.539 --> 01:14:41.960
what motivated Kathy Wood and Gwen Graham. A lawyer who
940
01:14:42.020 --> 01:14:46.100
represented another nurse convicted of murdering dozens of elderly patients
941
01:14:46.220 --> 01:14:49.500
over the span of two decades in Kentucky and Ohio
942
01:14:49.779 --> 01:14:54.250
told the Detroit Free Press that, The people that are
943
01:14:54.270 --> 01:14:57.430
commonly committing these crimes are those that are rejected by
944
01:14:57.510 --> 01:15:02.250
society or feel rejected. The only people they can lash
945
01:15:02.350 --> 01:15:05.729
out at are those less powerful than they are. The
946
01:15:05.770 --> 01:15:12.399
people they care for. Before Kathy Wood was sentenced, her
947
01:15:12.479 --> 01:15:16.260
ex-husband Ken wrote a letter to the judge. In it,
948
01:15:16.479 --> 01:15:21.199
he said, Kathy is guilty of taking lives, or at
949
01:15:21.239 --> 01:15:25.000
least not preventing Gwen from taking them. But how much
950
01:15:25.100 --> 01:15:29.020
life did she really take? All of the victims weren't
951
01:15:29.100 --> 01:15:34.260
even living. They enjoyed nothing, experienced nothing, and were going
952
01:15:34.300 --> 01:15:39.859
to die. This was the opinion voiced by the majority
953
01:15:39.880 --> 01:15:43.050
of the public at the time of the murders. The
954
01:15:43.109 --> 01:15:46.510
general consensus was that Cathy and Gwen didn't deserve to
955
01:15:46.550 --> 01:15:50.140
be sentenced too harshly for their actions because they targeted
956
01:15:50.180 --> 01:15:54.920
the weak and sick. It was an opinion that devastated
957
01:15:54.979 --> 01:16:00.859
the victims' families. Maxine Luce, the daughter-in-law of victim Myrtle Luce,
958
01:16:01.180 --> 01:16:04.060
said that their targeting of the vulnerable was what made
959
01:16:04.079 --> 01:16:09.609
their crimes particularly abhorrent. Quote, When I think of Myrtle
960
01:16:09.680 --> 01:16:13.159
in that position and someone deliberately cutting off her breath,
961
01:16:14.159 --> 01:16:17.600
that's the horror of the thing. When they're so helpless,
962
01:16:18.300 --> 01:16:25.300
like children. Jan Enderman, Marguerite Chambers' daughter, said to Wood
963
01:16:25.340 --> 01:16:28.159
TV that she was devastated that she never got to
964
01:16:28.229 --> 01:16:32.329
say goodbye to her mother. Kathy and Gwen took that
965
01:16:32.369 --> 01:16:38.640
away from her. John Engman, son-in-law to victim Mae Mason, said,
966
01:16:40.180 --> 01:16:43.739
May did not deserve this sort of death. None of
967
01:16:43.779 --> 01:16:48.920
those people did. They lived good lives and expected people
968
01:16:49.020 --> 01:16:52.890
would take care of them until they passed from natural causes.
969
01:17:05.340 --> 01:17:05.670
Thank you.
970
01:17:24.859 --> 01:17:26.220
We'll see you next time.