UDSKRIFT 🔗
speaker-0: Hello, political candidates. Your campaign's website domain is an important factor in your website's SEO. It's crucial for your campaign website to include your first and last name. It gives AI models like ChatGPT an authoritative source of truth to pull from, helping to prevent the AI from hallucinating or picking up outdated information from third-party blogs or partisan attacks. So visit name.com today and buy your personalized.vote website address. Let AI be your friend. Your potential voters will thank you.
speaker-1: Sam and I are always talking about being prepared, whether it's hurricanes in Florida, earthquakes in California, flooding in Arizona, or supply chains disruptions. Exactly, Chuck. When pharmacies shut down, it does not matter how tough you are, you still need access to critical medicine. That's why we trust Jace Medical. The Jace case comes with five life-saving antibiotics and key over-the-counter meds so you're covered when things get disrupted. And Jace goes beyond just the Jace case. They also offer first aid kits, daily prescriptions, and long-term nutrition with Jace Pantry. Don't wait for the next hurricane warning or natural disaster. Take control of your health and peace of mind today. Visit Jace.com and use code FUTURE at checkout for $10 off your order. That's FUTURE at JASE.com. To run a successful business, you need one thing, customers. And how do you get customers? You get them through advertising. You get them through lead generation. But what happens if the leads don't exist or they don't have valid contact information? This is a familiar story all businesses deal with. And they call these leads who don't exist or they're bad numbers or they're not in their service area. Argus101 verifies every lead before your team picks up the phone. It's a real person in your area and a neighborhood that matches your ideal customer. Your team only calls people worth calling, thus saving you money. Free trial at argus101.com. That's arguus101.com. Help your business expand today. Go to Argus101.com. ARGUS101.com. Welcome to Breaking Battlegrounds. I'm your host Chuck Warren. Sam Stone is out today. Our first guest is Thomas Grove, one of our favorites. He is the Wall Street Journal's bureau chief of Russia, formerly based in Mosh Moscow, which is not a possibility now. Today he's calling us from Poland. How are you doing, Thomas?
speaker-2: Dum.
speaker-3: Well, I'm good thanks tonight. How are you?
speaker-1: Doing well, thank you. All right, let me start right away with something that just sort of disappeared from the news. the U you know, there was a lab leak in Russia, in Siberia to be specific, and the US escalated pressure on Russia to give us more information. Did we did the world ever get more information or did that just sort of disappear with everything else over the last two weeks?
speaker-2: you
speaker-3: Well, it's it's been quite a t it's it's been it's been a couple of weeks, so I mean you know, needless to say, it attention has definitely shifted elsewhere. funny enough, watch this space. We do have a story coming out in the next couple of days. Right. On that lab leak. and on the institute that the lab worker was working at whenever she fell ill. So you know, it's we really we are none the wiser, you know, in terms of what happened with this poor woman's death in in early October, the the government's basically been giving the same line since day one and which is basically that this woman died from a pneumonia of an unknown etiology or an unknown cause. So, you know, w we've done lots of research, we've asked a lot of people about it, what could have happened, and I mean the short answer is we just don't know.
speaker-1: Well, they're not very forthright on such incidences, are they? Ever.
speaker-3: Well, I mean we've seen, you know, everything from from Chernobyl to, you know, a you know, late Soviet Union outbreak of you know, of of of infectious d infectious diseases there too. And so, you know, it's the fact that she worked at an anti plague institute certainly does make people wonder. you know. On the other hand, you know, Russia's and and the United States for that matter, you know We do have naturally occurring plague cases from time to time, you know. It can be contracted in in the wilderness and so it's you know, it it if if that's what it was, it it could have been in the wild. but, you know, like I say, she was working at an anti plague institute, so that that, you know, could account for a lot.
speaker-1: You know, it was interesting. I was reading your story again this morning, and you know, in two thousand five there was this global health pack called the International Health Regulations, which require people to notify the World Health Organization with twenty four hours of events like this happen. You know, we have these international treaties, Thomas, and I'm sure you've you've you know all. What teeth do they have? Did you do you ever watch the show Modern Family? Have you ever seen that since you've been out in Europe for so long? Do you ever see the show Modern Family?
speaker-3: I think I I think I've missed that one while I've been abroad.
speaker-1: Well the the older patriarch of the show married a younger Colombian woman and they go to an escape room and they said, So if you lose, do you lose a finger? Because she's from Columbia and they go, No, it's just a game. They go they go, then then what's the motivation to win? And I feel like there's no teeth in these international groups. I mean, yeah, you're supposed to report in twenty four hours. What happens if they find out they just didn't comply with anything?
speaker-3: Yeah. I mean, you know, speaking from the Russian case, you know, there's been you know, there there have been outbreaks and you know, what they what the WHO gets is is pretty, you know, thin soup, I think, at the end of the day. You know, so it there there isn't any I mean, there isn't any,
Load full transcript
you know, teeth to this and there's there's no way of of really enforcing you know, anybody to really be truthful about what's happening. And that's you know, that's c you know, clearly a problem. I mean luckily that's when you have you know, you know, countries like the United States trying to step up and and and figure out what's going on. But as far as I understand, I don't think they've been any clearer with us either.
speaker-1: Yeah, no, it it's it was amazing. It just sort of disappeared from the news. We're with Thomas Grove, Wall Street Journal's bureau chief for Russia. So Russia released a captured American this week. Tell us about it. Who is this gentleman? Why was he captured? What happened?
speaker-3: Then that is correct. Yeah, we had Stephen Hubbard was released, a a seventy four year old gentleman who had been living in eastern Ukraine, you know, up until the two thousand and twenty two invasion. And you know, he he had a partner there, he had kind of found you know a life there, had made a life for himself in eastern Ukraine and and from what we understand his pension just went further and he decided to stay there. you know, fast forward to April two thousand and twenty two, you have Russian troops rolling in. He was basically detained and and charged with being a mercenary. Now, you know, I think we can all you know, decide for ourselves whether or not or not a a seventy year old man at the time was you know, acting as a mercenary or not. But you know, for for one reason or another, most likely being an American, he was he was brought in and he's been in, you know, very severe kind of conditions i in a Russian prison since then. He's his his health d has deteriorated greatly from what I understand. as far as I understand he's not even going back with Whitkov in the same plane. He's kind of in in in that bad a shape. So you know I I I don't know his whereabouts right now. I understand that he's you know he he left Russia with Whitkov yesterday. So I you know, we all we can do is wish him the best.
speaker-1: What can you explain to us how do these negotiations work with Russia in particular, because I'm sure you've covered more than one now. To release these American hostages. I mean this is sort of an odd l there's just sunny f first of all I'm I'm I'm always just baffled that someone knows this is going to happen, this invasion. We all knew, right? And it's like, you know what, I'm sticking out here in eastern Ukraine with my pension.
speaker-3: I mean, you know, it was a funny time. I was in Ukraine when you know, days and the weeks before the invasion started, you know, and there really was a real denial among the authorities there o of what was going on. You know, the US intelligence was there. I mean we were, you know, really trying to make it clear at the time what was gonna happen. And I think, you know, the Ukrainian authorities I I think they just wanted to wish it all away and so they they they really you know, have have been under a lot of criticism for kind of not being as prepared as they could have been for it. but if you look br but I mean if you if you regarding these hostage negotiations, I mean so we've seen successive iterations of these negotiations and the real and and and prisoners being released, right? And and it's it's you know, everybody wants a political prisoner released. I mean there's there's no doubt about that. You know, and and you know, whenever we had you know, our own colleague Evan Gershkovich, he was, you know, detained and released in a in a similar you know, prisoner release. And so he was he was released on one side, there were some Russians released on the other side. And you know, and and you know, in previous administrations we have you know, the State Department has basically a a special office for kind of you know, prisoners held abroad. It's called Spiha and and and you know, up until the Trump administration basically worked through that office. And and now with with Steve Whitcoff you know, playing such a heavy role in in the administration's dealings with Russia. He plays, I would say, probably the most central role right now. So kind of all of what was going through the administration and the State Department before is is pretty much going through him now.
speaker-2: you
speaker-1: Do you think that's a wise strategy? Do you think he's been successful taking that lead?
speaker-3: I mean I think we've seen you know, so I mean clearly we saw in twenty twenty four the biggest kind of prisoner swap since since the end of the Cold War, right? That was amazing. It was a it was a huge orchestrated effort. We had, you know, several countries involved. it was it was it was messy, it was complicated but it it it it happened. I mean w Witcoff has been able to bring home Mark Fogle, who is, you know, a personal friend of mine. I mean I I'm grateful that that that happened. And Stephen Hubbard is back. You know, it's it's a different way of doing things and I think you know, I I don't know it I don't know enough to say w if one way is better than the other. We've seen continued results and I think that's what's most important.
speaker-1: Correct, correct. Okay, so he struck a deal to buy diesel fuel from Russia and I'm sure Ukraine is just pulling the hair out of their head. Can you explain to I mean, it's obviously there's election issues revolved around this, right? But what exactly is the deal and how is Ukraine what are they saying to themselves about this?
speaker-3: I mean Ukraine Ukraine is clearly very unhappy about this deal. I mean they I think the last thing Ukraine wants is to see this kind of rapprochement between the United States and Russia, right? That's right. They want the United States squarely on their side. and and this is clearly a you know, a big sign that that's you know, can you say that the US is not on Ukraine's side? I think you the they're worried about friendly noises, you know, increasingly made
between the US and and and Russia. And if we if we look at the deal itself, you know, Zelensky made a calculation of as as to how much money this is going to win for for Russia. And it's it's it's not exactly true. I think we what we're gonna see over the next six months, if it all goes according to plan, analysts say about two hundred million dollars for Russia. And that's That sounds I mean that's a lot of money for us, but it's not really that much for the for the for the Russian budget. you know, what we're looking at here is selling diesel to the United States or selling and we're talking about small amounts of diesel here. selling diesel to the United States or selling it to say West Africa or Turkey, like the price differential between those markets, right? So it's it's not like you know, th they're gonna be s if they have excess diesel more diesel than their own domestic market can absorb, they're gonna export it, right? And it's just a matter of where. And and of course the U the US is a more attractive market than other countries.
speaker-1: Sure. Well, when I was getting ready for the show I looked up and they said Russia spends between five hundred and fifty million and a billion dollars a day on the war in Ukraine. So like you said, it that seems like a you and I would like two hundred million dollars today. I think we agree on that. Well you and I would probably even split it if one of us got it. But five hundred fifty five hundred fifty yeah, exactly. But five hundred fifty million to billion dollars a day war, you know, it if it's a billion it's it's twenty percent of the day.
speaker-2: you
speaker-1: So it's really not that big of a thing for Russia.
speaker-3: It it's not that big of a bank for Russia and it's not really that big for the United States either. You know, at the end of the day we're talking it about this would cover about half of the US daily consumption of diesel. You know, what what Russia's providing in a month would basically be used up in about thirteen or fourteen hours in the US.
speaker-1: Yeah, that's amazing. But you know, so it's election season. It's more cosmetic more than anything, it seems like.
speaker-3: Of course. No, for sure. I mean, you know, it's it's about farmers, it's about truckers and and you know, everybody's worried about what's happening at at at gas pumps, right? It's you know, it's all it's it's
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-3: It's yeah, pretty transparent.
speaker-1: we've got a minute left here. Thomas, how do folks find you before we go on to the next segment? How do they follow your work and find you?
speaker-3: I'm on X at T G Grove. you can always subscribe to the Wall Street Journal and follow me there. it's that that's about that's about it. I don't have a huge social media presence. Well that's that's that's actually it. There's no other way. Well
speaker-1: You don't have time, that's the problem, right? You're always, you know, going to a war zone or s you know, the Russia folks keep you busy, right?
speaker-3: They keep us busy, yeah. There's there's there's a lot to do. It's you know, it's it's a busy place.
speaker-1: Tom we're with Thomas Grove. He is the Wall Street Journal Bureau Chief for Russia. This is Breaking Battlegrounds. We'll be right back and continue our conversation of Thomas and Ukraine and Russia and all that fun stuff right now. Welcome back to Breaking Battlegrounds. We're going continue our conversation with Thomas Grove. He is the Wall Street Journal Bureau Chief for Russia. You can find him on X at T G Grove. G-R-O-V-E. Thomas, going back discussing Ukraine, so do you feel there's any light at the end of the tunnel of this war ending? Or do you just feel like you and I could be talking about this five years from now?
speaker-3: I mean five years is a long time, especially whenever you know, you consider the state that both Ukraine and and Russia's economies are in. but I d I don't see it ending any time soon. I mean there's we we've just seen, you know, the latest round of negotiations with Steve Whitkoff going to both Oslo where he spoke with Ukrainian and European leaders, and Moscow. I'm sorry, ra actually Saint Petersburg. He was in Saint Petersburg where he he met with with Vladimir Putin. And You know, so clearly there's been, you know, some back and forth, some shuttle diplomacy, you know, they're trying to work out potential, you know, new approaches. but I I just don't think Russia's there yet, quite honestly. I mean I think they going into the winter, they feel very confident right now in in their ability to really inflict a lot of pain on Ukrainian civilians. And I that's kind of what the difference is this year as opposed to previous years in the war. Whereas they've you know, really focused on the the battlefield, you know, making inroads into eastern Ukraine, pushing further and further westward. It's it's just not happening. This has been probably the most dismal year for their troop movement on the battlefield. And so in instead of, you know, with that sta stagnation, they've decided to focus on Ukrainian cities and Ukrainian civilians, unfortunately. And so I think they they f they feel, you know, you know, the ability to really inflict a lot of pain. They they have have a huge arsenal of missiles and drones as we know. And basically, that's what they're gonna do. They're gonna be focusing on power supplies, they're gonna focusing on sewage. it's gonna be a new thing this year. And and it's gonna be it's gonna be rough. It's gonna be probably the worst year a lot of people are excuse me if I get out of my car here. Go ahead. It's gonna be the worst year probably that Ukraine Civilian civil civil. That's what people expect.
speaker-1: Expla explain you you made you made a point about sewage. Explain to your you know, I I understand the energy infrastructure and I I get the sewage thing, but explain to your audience why hitting sewage is gonna matter. explain that to them.
speaker-3: There there's a few things here at play. Basically, you know, on one hand, you are trying to they make it as painful as possible for for for Ukrainians you know, to break their will, so to speak, right? That's that's the idea here. On the other hand, they're also trying to create a migration crisis for Europe. So if you have, you know, hundreds of thousands of Ukrainians crossing the border westward back into Poland, Slovakia, Hungary, you know, you will have you know another crisis on your hands. And, you know, they're they're already in a in a place these countries that you know have been very welcoming to Ukrainians at the start of the war, they're in a place where a lot of the population is wondering, you know, can we accept more? Can we continue to welcome Ukrainians? can we continue to have them here? So it's become a political issue in in all of these countries. So So Putin is really pushing on that button.
speaker-1: Yeah, okay. And so you you know, it's funny how sometimes things segue. So now you have these riots in France and Italy and so forth. does that alarm people in in leadership in Poland and elsewhere, that what they're seeing? And does that also give them more pause, not that the Ukrainians are from North Africa, but does that give them more pause to say, you know what, we just can't bring more people in. We're just gonna have to say no.
speaker-3: mean I think generally I mean I think most the I think p the Polish leadership sees that the immigration dynamic in Poland is different than it is in in Spain and in France and Italy. You know, it's been traditionally you know th they they have brought in migrants. They've they've brought in immigration from a lot of from Southeast Asia actually throughout the kind of you know eighties and nineties and and and into the two thousands. you know, with Ukraine it's been It's it's been a different sort of set of problems. I mean, we've seen inflation rise, of course, because of the demand for housing. but the Ukrainians have also added quite a bit to the GDP here and and they've you know I think there's there's a lot of you know, some argument about, you know, the extent to which they've they've kind of really added to the economy here. So it's it's a different thing. It's certainly people play politics with it because, you know, that's what politicians do. but I think it's it's a it's a very different dynamic than it is in Western Europe.
speaker-1: What can the United States do? A, to help Ukraine more do you think that they're willing to do? And B, what can the United States do if there is a true migrant crisis of a half a million Ukrainians leaving this winter because they have no power sewage?
speaker-2: you
speaker-3: Yeah. Yeah. Well I think that's something that's that's the the what the United States can do in terms of migration, I think is is limited. I mean it's like there's there's limited resources everywhere at this point, right? I mean the economy economies everywhere are in pain and and what's more, you know, all of these countries are going into election season. Yes. We have elections in France, it's gonna be you know, not long before there's another one in Germany, here in Poland as well. So it's You know, it's it's really in the forefront of everybody's mind. I mean, in terms of Ukraine and and the United States, you know, it's it's intelligence sharing. It's you know, finding the right balance between where what patriot interceptors go where between the Middle East and and and Ukraine. You know, it's right. You know, there's a lot of hard hard decisions that have to be made you know, regarding exactly where our priorities are foreign policy wise.
speaker-1: last question before we let you go here. So Putin has floated an idea of a summit with Trump and Chi to discuss a Ukraine deal. Why does Putin want to bring in China? And do you think this again is just simply cosmetics and nothing's gonna come of it?
speaker-2: you
speaker-3: I I you know, I think something that Putin has always wanted is a trilateral between himself and the two most other powerful countries in the world. You know, this really this really affirms, you know, Putin's sense of Russia being a great power. Yeah. You know, the way that it was throughout the Cold War and and being, you know, kind of the the the foil to the United States throughout the fifties, sixties, seventies, eighties. you know, of course things have changed, you know, and you you know, when we look at the other, you know, markers of a great power, economics, technology, things like that, Russia's really not stepping up to the plate here. But nonetheless, this is a status that Putin really wants to hold on to and really wants to affirm for his country. you know, I don't think any meeting between Putin she and Trump is going to bring an end to the Ukraine war. These are all leaders who want very, very different things, you know, in that conflict. And so I I you know, it's not gonna it's it's not really the pathway to peace, but it's really more about just dividing up the world, so to speak, into, let's say, areas of influence, you know, strategic backyards and things like that. That's something Putin's just not gonna get.
speaker-1: No, he's not at all. As we wrap up here, have you have you read the book The Lost Empire of Emmanuel Nobel, The Rom Romanovs, Revolutionaries and the Forgotten Titan Who Fueled the World World? Have you read that book?
speaker-3: wow, that sounds fascinating. I've never no, never have. It sounds wonderful.
speaker-1: I'm gonna I'm gonna have my producer reach out to you I'm gonna mail you a copy. It's fantastic. And you being a Russia expert, I think you will I think you will find this brilliant and it's a great read. I I find books written by reporters, which this was, are generally better reads than an actual historian. So I'll send that to you. So I'll send that to you.
speaker-3: Fantastic. So I appreciate that. I'll I'll look
forward to it. I'm I'm I'm finishing up a book right now, so I'll it'll be my next one.
speaker-1: Well folks, Thomas Grove, again, Wall Street Journal's bureau chief of for Russia. I su s suggest you do a Google alert, read his article, subscribe to the Wall Street Journal. Thomas, thank you for your time. We know it's hard, we know it's late out there, and stay safe, my friend.
speaker-3: So much. Thank you so much for having me. It's been a pleasure.
speaker-1: Breaking Battlegrounds, we'll be right back. To run a successful business, you need one thing, customers. And how do you get customers? You get them through advertising, you get them through lead generation. But what happens if the leads don't exist or they don't have valid contact information? This is a familiar story all businesses deal with. Then they call these leads who don't exist, or they're bad numbers, or they're not in their service area. Argus 101 verifies every lead before your team picks up the phone. It's a real person in your area and a neighborhood that matches your ideal customer. Your team only calls people worth calling, thus saving you money. Free trial at Argus101.com. That's arguing.com. Help your business expand today. Go to argus101.com. A-R-G-U-S-101.com. Hello Breaking Battlegrounds listeners. Did you know that private student loan debt in the United States totals about $300 billion? That's with a B. About $45 billion of that is labeled as distressed, which means people are behind on payments. Why ReFi, who is a proud sponsor of our show, refinances this distress or defaulted private student loans that others won't touch. They don't even care what your credit score is, they provide you with a custom loan. Payment based on your ability to pay. YREFI is not a debt settlement company. They work with each borrower individually to tailor a loan that meets your specific financial situation and helps you pay this loan off. So, folks, if you would like to learn more how to put your mind at ease and your budget back on track, call YReFi at 877-400-9989-00800. and tell them Sam and Chuck sent you, you can go and look into them at YRefi, Y-R-E-F-Y dot com to get more information. They will help you reduce your monthly payment and guarantee interest rates under 6%, ensuring financial relief to you as you pay off your private student loan. Jump on that website or call them today.
speaker-0: Dear political candidate, listen up. I'm talking to you. Your name.vote should be the starting point of every campaign. It's memorable, looks great on signs and mailers, helps voters find you online, and gives AI tools a direct path to your campaign website. Why send people to a complicated web address when your name can be the address? Visit name.com today and claim your.vote domain.
speaker-1: Sam and I are always talking about being prepared, whether it's hurricanes in Florida, earthquakes in California, flooding in Arizona or supply chains disruptions. Exactly, Chuck. When pharmacies
shut down, it does not matter how tough you are, you still need access to critical medicine. That's why we trust Jace Medical. The Jace case comes with five life-saving antibiotics and key over-the-counter meds so you're covered when things get disrupted. And Jace goes beyond just the Jace case. They also offer first aid kits, daily prescriptions, and long-term nutrition with Jace Pantry. Don't wait for the next hurricane warning or natural disaster. Take control of your health and peace of mind today. Visit Jace dot com and use code FUTURE at checkout for ten dollars off your order. That's FUTURE at J A S E.com.
speaker-0: In today's digital world, standing out is more important than ever. Whether you're running for office, leading a cause, or hosting a vote for the cutest pet in town, you need a web domain that's simple, memorable, and action-oriented. You need a.vote web domain. It's clear, impactful, and establishes a lasting presence for your campaign. Don't wait, head to godaddy.com or name.com, type in your name.vote, and get started today. Because after all, Every pet deserves a web address that's as special as they are. Crimes were killers from my free. I'm co-case file. Crime corners where the stories go deep.
speaker-1: So B, what chaos has happened in the world this week?
speaker-0: There's a lot of drama in this one, so it's pretty interesting today.
speaker-1: Is this like a reality show?
speaker-0: Like reality show. And it was a woman named Michelle Parker. She was getting sued by her ex fiance Dale. Dale Smith Jr. He she had lost her wedding ring, so he was suing her for five thousand dollars. Now on
speaker-1: C because she lost the wedding ring. Now were they still engaged? They were broken up.
speaker-0: They're broken up at this point and like she if you watch back on the video, the episode's actually still online. You can find it. I'll post it too. But if you look back, you can see her t starting to get in on his character and how he was a mean drunk, he was aggressive, he was violent, and you kinda see like his character change in this and freeze a little bit.
speaker-1: Every reason not to marry him.
speaker-0: a set of twins, three year old twins. And the day this episode aired
speaker-1: They did not marry but they had twins.
speaker-0: the day and she had another kid too. She had three children and this was in Florida too. The day this episode aired, not the day it was filmed, but the day it aired November seventeenth, two thousand eleven, she was missing. And the last place she was her address was pinged to but wasn't an exact location was his address where she was dropping off the twins. And that was also the last place she was seen. Now she also they found a text message from her to her brother shortly after she arrived at that location telling him she was in a completely different city. Her mother actually filed a wrongful death suit against him in twenty thirteen.
speaker-1: And what has he been saying for fifteen
years?
speaker-0: For twel twenty twenty when it was finally dismissed and he didn't have to pay a dime. Sure, there's no buy. Now, October twentieth, forensic technology, little increase, of course, it always happens, it grows. They found the exact location of her phone. They found lost messages that he tried to delete. They found all this technology and evidence that was deleted that put him at the location and he's now getting charged.
speaker-1: Where was the phone at?
speaker-0: They found her phone in the lake. But they scraped through more DNA and more of that evidence and still didn't find anything. But no body. Right?
speaker-1: did they find this phone in the lake? Yeah, but how did they find the phone? I mean it was some fisherman. I mean, how did they find this?
speaker-0: They sweeped the lake that was nearby from where her last like ping was.
speaker-1: So does some officer in cold case just said had a hunch? I mean how I mean that seems so random.
speaker-0: Back then, I guess in back in twenty eleven when they first did this investigation, they did not have the type of tracking stuff we have. Yeah.
speaker-1: Sure.
speaker-0: So the location was like a huge bubble. From what I remember, like back when tracking was around and like finding a lost phone, like it was a very wide range of where it could be. But it gave you this bubble and I think that they tracked it within that bubble and there was a lake. So they luckily found that in the lake. But I'm still shocked how they found nobody.
speaker-1: Well, you know, I mean y you've been to Florida, right? Lots
speaker-0: Yeah, that's true.
speaker-1: of lots of water, lots of empty land. I mean, I think folks always have the mistake of thinking Florida, they think Miami, Orlando, or or Tampa. But I remember because I've been there many times to work, sometimes I will just drive up to Orlando from Miami. The center of that state, there is a lot of empty nothing.
speaker-0: Yeah.
speaker-1: Lots of cows. I mean I don't think most people realize that. Florida is like the third or fourth largest cattle producer in the United States. There's a lot of nothing out there, just green. And then you got lots of trees, you got swamps. I mean, it's and then of course you got ocean all around. Yeah, too. You
speaker-0: Gators too.
speaker-1: got gators, you got sharks in the oceans. Yeah. Well it's amazing. So is he still claiming he's innocent? He's gonna go do it.
speaker-0: Yeah. He's yeah, he's still pushing for innocence. But
speaker-1: How older are the kids now?
speaker-0: the kids, this was they're three in twenty eleven. Math, math.
speaker-1: They're teenagers if not out of the house.
speaker-0: Teenagers, yeah, they're probably I think they're in their twenties now. That's crazy. Still not knowing where your mom is.
speaker-1: Well yeah, and who knows what the dad has told them. yeah.
speaker-0: yeah. Right. I wonder how the custody is on that.
speaker-1: Well, he got custody because they were you know, she disappeared. Her mom Yeah, but you know, I I remember talking to a child custody individual who works for the state and there's this couple was splitting time, he wasn't great. She goes, Look, as long as he doesn't get an F, he gets custody as well. That's how it goes. So you know, he could be a C or D father and again they haven't proved anything that he killed her because they don't have a body. Yeah. He obviously got custody. I I can't even imagine that didn't happen. So what did he teach her over the years? Anyway, this is Breaking Battlegrounds. We'll be right back with our next guest, Joel Pollack, with the California Post. We'll be right back. Welcome back to Breaking Battlegrounds. I'm your host Chuck Warren today. We are lucky to have with us from the great state of Ohio, Senator John Husted. He is running for reelection, but currently he's in the Senate offices and we're gonna talk about what he's doing on the US Senate and his hope for America. Senator, welcome to the show.
speaker-4: Great to be with you.
speaker-1: So I was reading this morning some of the most expensive hotels this weekend are LSU versus Mississippi, which brings me to college sports. And I know you used to be a college your your football guy. you you have gone and proposed a bill regarding college sports and it talk to our audience about what you hope the bill will accomplish.
speaker-4: Well, if you're talking about LSU, the the Lane Kiffin situation there has helped encourage Congress to act to s quote save college sports, right? We have NIL, we have transfer portals, we have you know, pro athletes trying to transfer back in and play college athletes. So Congress is being asked by college ath college institutions to save college sports by putting guardrails around this whole thing. But I want to make sure that we're looking out for American student athletes because there's been a growing number of roster spots and scholarships that have been taken by student athletes from other countries. you look at tennis teams and golf teams, you'll s you'll s soccer, hockey, roster rosters full of foreign athletes taking away opportunities from American citizens. You you take the Paris Olympics of twenty twenty four of NCA affiliated athletes per participating in in the the Paris Olympics. 63% of those NCA affiliated athletes represented other countries in the Olympics. Only 37% were actually Americans. So this is getting out of hand. And if you put more money in the system, as we're talking about doing with NIL and other things, and Congress pr providing those protections, you're gonna see an a a greater flow of Foreign athletes in American sports taking away roster spots from American citizens who go to these taxpayer-funded colleges and universities. So I want to put a cap on it at 20%. We're not banning foreign athletes. We're just saying you can limit it at 20%. 80% of the roster spots have to go to American student athletes. And that's what I'm
trying to get in the bill because. The American government should look out for American citizens, just like the French government should look out for French citizens. And right now, we're not doing a very good job of that when it comes to college sports.
speaker-1: That seems like a great common sense bill. You also have another common sense bill that passed the House with a huge margin yesterday, bipartisan, called the Rate Payer Protection Act. Will you please discuss to our audience what that does and how it protects consumers?
speaker-4: Would require data centers to pay for all of the electricity infrastructure that they use to f to power their data centers. So if you need more generation, you need more transmission lines, the data centers pay for it. Simply says that that the states will will put rules together to make sure that that happens in their respective states. It passed the House of Representatives 417 to 3, all right? Nothing passes the House of Representatives by that kind of margin these days unless you have strong bipartisan support. So I have legislation on this in the Senate. I'm going to take it to the floor this afternoon to try to get it done. And hopefully the Democrats will not block it.
speaker-1: Explain to our audience d that simple tactic. Why would decr Democrats, why would they block it? How can they block it? Because people will look at them and say, This is just such common sense. Why can't Congress just get this done? So why would they block this today?
speaker-4: Well we'll see if they do. I think a lot of them, frankly, just don't want to see Republicans get credit for solving the problem. I I mean, i that's the bottom line.
speaker-1: How frustrating is that? You have this great idea. You're going to protect the American citizens, which, you know, they've all gone back and swore that's what they want to do. How frustrating is that coming up with such a great common sense solution and having some pushback?
speaker-4: i it is the ways of Washington. That's why we've gotta we gotta change. It it is it's just common sense. Look, sometimes l like why can't we have a bipartisan win? Four seventeen to three in the House. Let's move it to the Senate. Let's get a bipartisan win. Let's go forward with it. Tell the American people we're actually doing things to solve problems that they care about.
speaker-1: Do you know just by chance how many of these data centers are actually providing their own utilities and energy and things of those nature right now? Is there a percentage you know of or is this something that you're gonna it's
speaker-4: More and more more and more of them are doing it all the time just because it's it's how you avoid the pushback at the local level. If you tell your local the local community, hey, we're gonna build our own generation and any excess we have, we're gonna put it back on the grid to lower your energy prices, then you're much more you're much more inclined to be welcomed by the local community than rejected by the local community. And so data centers are doing it out of their own vested interest in many cases. Now we just need to ensure. that families, small businesses, senior citizens aren't having to foot the bill for the data center's new energy and infrastructure demands, put that on the data centers. They will build their own power. They will do it in the most efficient, effective way possible.
speaker-1: you with Senator Bernie Marino have sponsored a bill that bans licenses for undocumented migrants. And there's a personal story to that regarding Ohio. Can you tell our audience what is the genesis of this bill? And I can't believe there's seventeen states that actually provide licenses.
speaker-4: Yeah, well we've had we had three Ohioans in nine days get killed by illegal aliens on our road
speaker-1: my goodness.
speaker-4: legally not allowed to be in this country that came in under the Biden, Sherid Brown in my case when he was a senator, border invasion. And even though under President Trump we've cut off the inflow, I think we're sixteen months without a illegal border incursion. but now you have you know, millions of people in this country illegally and you have sanctuary states like Connecticut who issued these and this is to get to the point of your question, the drive only licenses. There are 19 states in the District of Columbia that issue drive only licenses for illegal for people who are in this country illegally. Okay? I I didn't know that was happening at the scale that it is. Sure. It's happening and one of those states, Connecticut, issued a driver's license to Someone in the country illegally and then drove to Ohio and killed an Ohio resident. So what I'm saying is no more. You're in this country illegally, in these sanctuary states, no more issuing these driver's licenses. And if you do, you lose your highway funding. And if you remember back a couple decades ago, federal government has the ability to do this. They said, hey, states, raise your drinking, raise your drinking age to 21, or we're gonna cut off your highway funds. Supreme Court upheld that. So if you're gonna have states, sanctuary states, that are gonna issue driver's licenses to people who are in this country illegally, endangering the lives of Ohioans and Americans across the country, then you should get your highway funds cut off. And maybe with that step we can get them to stop basically sanctioning illegal activity and dang and endangering the lives of American citizens.
speaker-2: you
speaker-1: Have you got much do you have many co sponsors for this?
speaker-4: Senator Moreno and I just unveiled it. I I hope that others will join along. You know, we did it because th I mean, three Ohioans dead in nine days from ill from illegal driving on our roads. I mean, I mean, I'm saying we don't issue these driver's licenses in Ohio. It's illegal to do that in Ohio, but they come from other states that get sanctioned to do this and then
they end up killing people in our state. And I bet a lot of your listeners in their states would be pretty frustrated by this too. One hundred
speaker-1: Chian.
speaker-4: And and it's happening all around the country. I'm just giving you the Ohio example.
speaker-1: Senator, we have a poverty trap and I think a lot of people there's AEI put out data points today that even the working class people don't like socialism, but they feel like they're falling further behind. They feel like they're unable to achieve the American dream in a lot of ways. But we have a true poverty trap. Explain to our audience how you view what the poverty trap is and how do we get out of it?
speaker-4: Yeah. Well, this is really one of my personal passion projects. I want to end the poverty trap that's been created in this country over the last fifty years. Think about this. If you're s many of your listeners may not have some of them may know about the benefit cliff. You talk to any any entry level employer and they'll tell you, Hey, I have somebody working at my restaurant. I offered them a raise. They told me no. They told me they didn't want more hours because they would lose more in benefits than they gain in pay.
speaker-1: Yes. So
speaker-4: So they don't take the raise, they don't take the job, they don't take more hours. And that's by design. The federal government designed this system to trap people. And there's a simple way out of it. As you're maybe a single single parent with two children, and you get a certain number of benefits. And you know, for largely for your children, you might get food assistance, things like that. As you earn more. We can gradually reduce benefits until you get yourself stabilized. And and and then we can slowly move you towards full-time work, get you benefits, 401k, health insurance, things like that. And then after you get your life stabilized, then we can reduce your benefits and put you to work and give you a path towards self-sufficiency. This this this is I'm gonna give you a great example of of this. I had a I had a business owner tell me that he's having a hard time competing because China Is subsidizing their workforce. And and then it occurred to me in that conversation that I said, well, they're smarter than we are, because they're paying people to go to work. We're paying people to stay home. Yeah. Our
speaker-1: Yes. Think about that. Yes.
speaker-4: system works in America. And I want I and I believe if if one in ten people trapped in poverty to use this use this upward mobility act that I've sponsored, I sponsored something called the Upward Mobility Act to end this. process. If one in ten did it, it would be the equivalency of adding three million people to the American workforce. And I know at least one out of every ten people on these poverty programs wants a way out. I think it's a lot more than that, but at least one out of ten want want a way out and we gotta give them that way out through passing the Upward Mobility Act. And that's something I'm very passionate about because I want people to have access to the American dream, but if you're trapped in these poverty programs and you never get out and there's no way to get out, you can't set a good example for your children. You can you don't have the hope of getting ahead.
speaker-1: Well, life becomes very depressing when you're stuck in the mud. And that's what seems to happen with this benefit trap. you just sort of get stuck and just think this is what life is supposed to be and it's not. You're supposed to because you'll find greater satisfaction and upward mobility and providing for your family and being part of your community. And the current system right now does not help do that. Yeah.
speaker-4: You may be trapped in a twenty hour a week job because you you have you need child care for your s your children, you need to have SNAP benefits to help pay, and you need health care. But the only way you're ever gonna get that i earn enough is if you get to forty hours a week. But you can't do it just overnight because you're gonna lose all of these other services if you're that that individual. So if we let that person move to forty hours a week. work maybe the 90 day probationary period they need to get the 401k and their and their health insurance. And then let them do that and then gradually reduce those benefits as they get ahead. We will save the taxpayer dollars, we'll save taxpayer dollars, and we'll help people get ahead and we'll we'll we'll give them hope for the future. That's what I want to do.
speaker-1: Last question, we have about a minute left. I'm optimistic about America, but I'm always optimistic about America. Do you think America's best days are ahead of us?
speaker-4: They certainly can be, but it depends I'm sorry, it depends on who who we elect. If we
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-4: if we lean towards freedom and free markets or if we move towards socialism, that's a choice that the American people are gonna make about which direction they wanna go. N no socialist society's best days are ahead of it.
speaker-1: That's very true. That's very, very true.
speaker-4: but but societies that lean into freedom and competition, their best days can be ahead of us. So if that's the path America chooses, our best days will be ahead of us. But if we chose if we choose the Mandami El Sayyed Sherrod Brown way, then then we will we will struggle to get ahead.
speaker-1: last second, thirty seconds. Hassan Piker sort of become a spokesperson for the left in a lot of ways and he said that America basically is worse than Al Qaeda. What's your quick response to that?
speaker-4: He's nuts.
speaker-1: Yeah, very much so. I mean
speaker-4: America America protects the rights of people who we don't even like because that's what our constitution says. and and we believe in freedom and freedom of religion and freedom of speech and f freedom to spend your paycheck the way that you want to spend your
paycheck. That's what freedom's about. People fought and died to create this nation two hundred and fifty years ago on the idea of one single concept freedom. Freedom, not socialism, not collectivism, not government control, but freedom. And and so Piker couldn't be more wrong.
speaker-1: Well, Senator John Husted from the great state of Ohio, thank you for joining us today. How do people reach your office or learn more about you?
speaker-4: yeah, you just go to our Senate can Senate office, it's head.senate dot gov. Hestead dot senate dot gov.
speaker-1: And folks, we'll also post that on our social media. Senator, have a great day and thank you for taking time to meet with us. Meet with you. This is Breaking Battlegrounds. You can follow us on BreakingBattlegrounds.vote. We'll be back next week. Have a great weekend. Sam and I are always talking about being prepared, whether it's hurricanes in Florida, earthquakes in California, flooding in Arizona, or supply chains disruptions. Exactly, Chuck. When pharmacies shut down, it does not matter how tough you are, you still need access to critical medicine. That's why we trust Jace Medical. The Jace case comes with five life-saving antibiotics and key over-the-counter meds so you're covered when things get disrupted. And Jace goes beyond just the Jace case. They also offer first aid kits, daily prescriptions, and long-term nutrition with Jace Pantry. Don't wait for the next hurricane warning or natural disaster. Take control of your health and peace of mind today. Visit Jace.com and use code FUTURE at checkout for ten dollars off your order. That's FUTURE at JASE.com.
speaker-0: Dear political candidate, listen up, I'm talking to you. Having an exact matched domain, like your name.vote, isn't a luxury, it's campaign basics. It's easy to print on yard signs and mailers, easy for voters to remember, helps people find you directly, and gives AI tools like ChatGPT a clear source for campaign information. So why settle for a long patchwork website address when you can own your actual name with a.vote domain? Visit name.com today and claim your personalized.vote website address.
speaker-1: Hello Breaking Battlegrounds listeners. Did you know that private student loan debt in the United States totals about $300 billion? That's with a B. About $45 billion of that is labeled as distressed, which means people are behind on payments. Why ReFi, who is a proud sponsor of our show, refinances this distress or defaulted private student loans that others won't touch. They don't even care what your credit score is, they provide you with a custom loan payment. Based on your ability to pay, YReFi is not a debt settlement company. They work with each borrower individually to tailor a loan that meets your specific financial situation and helps you pay this loan off. So, folks, if you would like to learn more how to put your mind at ease and your budget back on track, call YReFi at 877-400-9989 and tell them Sam and Chuck
sent you. You can go and look into them at YReFi. refy dot com to get more information. They will help you reduce your monthly payment and guarantee interest rates under 6%, ensuring financial relief to you as you pay off your private student loan. Jump on that website or call them today. Welcome back to Breaking Battlegrounds. Our next guest is Darla Rumfo. She is the president and chief operating officer of the Children's Scholarship Fund. It's a nonprofit dedicated to providing partial scholarships for low income children in grades K through eight to go to private school. Darla, welcome to the show.
speaker-5: Thank you so much for having me.
speaker-1: Okay, so first of all, let's let's tell a little story here. What do these scholarships mean for these low income kids and how much better do they do when they go to these private schools on to high school versus a children in a low income setting who goes to a public school?
speaker-5: Well, I when I first came to this job, I could not even believe that the a scholarship valued at maybe a couple thousand dollars could be that life changing for a child. But it turns out that it's very life changing. My two co founders, Teddy Forstman and John Walton, they set out to in nineteen ninety nine to give away forty thousand scholarships for four years and they just wanted to even see if there was really demand for an alternative. They had a million two hundred and fifty thousand applications for forty thousand scholarships. Yeah. And so and these were parents who had to pay part of it themselves.
speaker-1: How do the parents how do the parents hear about this?
speaker-5: Well, at that time Ted got on Oprah Winfrey and she sang out our one eight hundred number. So that brought in a lot of application.
speaker-1: All Oprah. All Oprah. Okay, continue. Continue.
speaker-5: So yeah, so we had a million two hundred and fifty thousand applications, which kind of put us, you know, nail in the coffin of people are satisfied with the choices that they have. Became very clear. That was kind of a that was a real shot in the arm for school choice because it proved the point that people are not satisfied, that people want alternatives. And it it really it's I've learned over the years, like empowering parents is the key to everything. Putting parents in charge of their children's education, it's it just changes everything. It changes everything for that child. I know that it's a slow going and that our you know, if you look at overall education results in this country, I would say it's not that school choice has failed, it's that school choice has not really been tried at scale. That if we really did empower parents with the level of dollars that they needed to make a real choice and the parents actually felt like they could make a choice, I think we'd have a completely different marketplace than we do now in education.
speaker-1: Darla, so you've been sending these kids and they go to K through eight, they get partial scholarships for private schools, which means the parents still have to sacrifice and come up with more money. Right. Okay. Have you tested how they do once they get to high school? Are they better prepared versus their peers in a local school? I mean what do we have any empirical evidence of what this has done to better these kids?
speaker-5: Mm-hmm. Well, we follow our kids all the way through college and out of college. And we know that our kids yeah, we that we we do something called we put their n submit their names to this thing called a clearinghouse and we can track where they go and w if they graduate from college. And our kids, low income kids, they graduated from college at a higher rate than the average population, four times as high as the as a as a similar population. And we know that college isn't the be all and end all for everybody. It's not you know, the right thing, but it's a also it is an indicator that they get they have aspirations, they have goals, they complete high school. They complete high school at like ninety-eight percent completion rate. So these are all really important things to to these are signposts like if you do these things, we also know, you know, our kids there's a we we talk to them and try to put they're in places where they also the success sequence is in place that if you do certain things in a certain order. Your chances of being in poverty, even if you came out of poverty, are very, very low. If you finish school, get a job, get married, have kids in that order instead of out of order, your chances of being in poverty are very low. And our kids are on a much higher track of following that success sequence as well.
speaker-1: So Children's Scholarship Fund will be one of the major scholarship granting organizations for the Trump administration's Education Freedom Tax Credit Scholarship Program. Can you explain to our audience what the Education Freedom Tax Credit Scholarship Program is and why are some states, mostly blue, fighting this tooth and nail?
speaker-5: Good question. So, well, first of all, the program itself, beginning January first, twenty twenty seven, every taxpayer in America, regardless of what state you live in, every single taxpayer in America, if you have a tax liability of one dollar up to seventeen hundred dollars if you're a single person, up to thirty four hundred if you're married filing jointly, you can get a dollar for dollar credit against your tax pa taxes, meaning your taxes get reduced one dollar for every Every dollar that you give away, if you write a check to a scholarship granting organization, such as a children's scholarship fund, that appears on a qualified SGO list in a in a particular state. But every taxpayer in America can take that that credit if they make that donation.
speaker-1: How high can they go? How how h how high can they go on their tax liability for that?
speaker-5: Thirty four hundred dollars for married filing jointly. Okay. Seventeen
hundred dollars for single. Okay. However, if we get those donations, let's say that we get those donations from someone who lives in California. CSF will not be able to use those donations to help a child in California unless California opts in on behalf of their their children. And California has not done that yet. And you
speaker-1: And they won't and they won't.
speaker-5: Probably not. But you know, we do have hope in the blue states. you know, Governor Hokel from New York has indicated, she hasn't actually done it yet, but she's indicated very strongly that she intends to opt in. And the reason for that, which she stated herself, is that she does not want to watch all these tax dollars from New York taxpayers leave her state and be spent on children in another state when they could have been spent on New York kids. And let it be let's be clear, she she said it and it's the truth. It doesn't take one dollar away from public schools. Right. It's only additive. In fact, you can actually use these scholarships to help public school kids with tutoring, SAT prep, so any number of things.
speaker-1: how many states have opted in to this program? Folks, we're with Darla Rumfo. She is the president and chief operating officer of Children's Scholarship Fund. It's a nonprofit dedicated to providing partial scholarships to give parents a choice for their kids going to K through eight. when how many kids are now experiencing and using school choice, whether that be charter school, private school or something, today versus say twenty years ago.
speaker-5: I think that number's at least l at least tripled. I mean, it's there's only about eighty percent of kids that are now in public schools. So it there's about twenty percent of kids that are using something else. There's many more kids that are qualified to be to you know, they can be they're in a state that has choice. It's just learning to take it up. And I also think a lot of our our state choice programs are not large enough for families to actually be able to make that choice. I wanna go back to one other thing you asked though. You asked why do I think that the it the Democratic governors have not opted in? Well, the teachers' unions are not for this. No. And I don't think they will ever be for it. And the reason I don't think they will be for it is because it puts pa power in the hands of parents. And that's a very, you know, we're talking about a power struggle here. And when parents are empowered and the money follows the child, then it's not controlled by someone else. And that's a that's a power struggle between the parents and and you remember when Glenn Young ran for governor and his opponent at the time said the parents shouldn't have anything to say about
speaker-1: Yes.
speaker-5: Yeah, that was, you know, people that that people were like reacted very strongly to that. That just does not sound right because it's not right. Parents are the first educators of their children. I mean, God gave kids to parents. He didn't give them to school districts or, you know, communities. He actually gave them to parents. And when we give parents the the tools that they need to make the best decisions for their children, after doing this for nearly thirty years, I will say with every ounce of my being that I believe in parents. I know they're not all perfect and I know some don't care about their kids. I know that that's true for some number. But I would say, generally speaking, if we can tap into that thing about parents that's innately in them and that they want to do the best for their children, if we empower that in and get parents to really take make the choices for their kids, I think we're we're really onto something. Like we can actually transform education, the culture, everything.
speaker-1: You know, i I was thinking about there are some parents who don't care, but my assumption would be that parents that go and take a partial scholarship and have to come up the rest of the money for their child's private care
speaker-0: Take care.
speaker-1: a lot. They care a lot, right? I mean it's it's it's really sort of a metric that you could just tell if they care or not, right? Because they still have to come up with money. And that money has to come from somewhere, especially if you're low income.
speaker-5: Yes. And I'm always gonna come down on the side of parents and I'm really gonna come down on the side of poor parents because I'm not I have seen it over and over again. We have parents in our program in New Hampshire, they are part of our parent ambassador program. They can articulate what school choice means better than I will ever be able to. And they can do it with such fervor and and just so much knowledge because they know their kids and they know what it's meant to them and it's real.
speaker-1: What percentage of these school choice partial scholarships go to minorities, black, Hispanic, so forth? Do you have do you keep that number?
speaker-5: We don't we don't track that number but it's a high percentage because a lot of the kids and you know, it's it's a high percentage. Okay. but we don't track it p by race. Do you
speaker-1: Do have some success stories you can tell us about, about a parent sending their kids to get this partial scholarship and you know, became an academic st I mean, do you have some schol stories like that?
speaker-5: I have I have hundreds of stories, but there's there's one that I really love. His name was Hansel Lopez. And Hansel was one of our first scholarship recipients. He was kind of floundering and lost and not doing well in school. And his mom got a flyer stuck in her hand about the Children's Scholarship Fund. This was in New York back in the late 90s. And she took she knew that she needed to do something different for a child. She ended up putting him in a Catholic school, I starting in sixth grade. And he said it at one of our board meetings. He said it was like the ripple effect. That just
everything in my life changed. My attitude about school and then all the opportunities I I started to have. It just started to ripple into my life. He ended up graduating from Cornell. Wow. he's got his own business in Miami. He he's spoken at different functions of ours and he's so articulate and just such a lovely person, such a good human being. And that's one of the things I would say about everybody that has been a participant in our program that I've had the good fortune of coming across. And getting to know better, which is a lot at this point, they are so grateful. And gr you know, gratitude, if you look at what it takes to be happy in life, being grateful is foundational. If you wake up and say you're all the things you're grateful for every day, you push out everything else. And I I always notice that about our parents, about our children, they're all so grateful.
speaker-1: Well, what a rewarding job you have. You know, in in a in a world where there's so many jobs that are not rewarding or can be a bit depressing, you get to see the best of humanity. You get to see the best of parents sacrificing and you get to see these sons and daughters of God getting reaching their full potential or g or or heading towards it. And that's, you know, what a what a wonderful way to start your day and end your day every day.
speaker-5: it really is. I am so grateful for the work I've been able to do. It's been such a gift in my life.
speaker-1: Well, Darla Rumpfo, thank you so much for joining us again. Folks, you can find about this scholarship on scholarshipfund dot org. Scholarshipfund dot org. Darla has an X but she hasn't used it since twenty one, so we're not gonna give you that. But Darla, thanks a million for joining our show today.
speaker-5: Thank you so much.
speaker-1: You too. Thank you. Folks, this is Breaking Battlegrounds. We'll be right back. Welcome back to Breaking Battlegrounds. Our final guest we're lucky to have with us today Representative Pamela Carter. She's an L D four which covers Scottsdale, Valley, and parts of Arcadia. Is that correct?
speaker-0: Paradise? Arcadia Phoenix.
speaker-1: What would you think first of all I want to get into the great success you've had your first first term. What do you think is a unifying concern of your district?
speaker-0: Well I think I think people want safety for their children. They want good education. They want to keep school choice, but they also want their charter schools and public education. So my main my main goal is to keep all of it. We need the public schools for those that want to go, but we cannot eliminate parents' choice. I call it parents' choice. It's choice.
speaker-1: It parents.
speaker-0: Not really school choice. It's parents choice.
speaker-1: Yeah, two thousand twenty six. You've had great success your first term, passed five bills. Yes. let's talk about the first one, Cade's Law. What came up with it? What does it accomplish?
speaker-0: well actually I was born and raised in I'm a fourth generation native Arizona and raised in the Arcadia district by a single mom. And so my family experienced a lot of trauma y with divorce and all that. And I feel like kids nowadays are are experiencing so much input from social media, friends, and also broken families. Since I came from a broken family I I just had a burden for these teens that had no hope. I actually was one of those teens and felt like there was something I could do to help. I I had a burden to address teen suicide, it's the second leading cause of death in America for our children.
speaker-1: It's a tragedy that just hangs with the family forever too. Because
speaker-0: It does.
speaker-1: they're always gonna say, What could we have done? And and friends say it and it's just anybody who's dealt with the suicide of a loved one, it's I don't think the sting ever leaves
speaker-0: No, I don't think it does, especially when our children are being bullied. i there wa that was my burden and so I did not get to do that in my first my first go around the first year. First year. But I just I was b actually praying. Yeah, I'm a I'm a woman of faith. I was praying in my office at the house and a mom walked in my office, she wanted to meet with me. She says she was a fan, she's a fan of mine. Which always is nice to hear us as representative.
speaker-1: Hey, it's a great way to introduce yourself. I'm a fan.
speaker-0: But she just handed me a card. She set a card. She was with a suicide group. and she set a card on my desk in the house, and she said, This is personal. And I looked down and there was a name on the card, Cade. And
speaker-2: you
speaker-0: I I said, And what what is this that's personal to you? She said, That was my son Cade.
speaker-1: My goodness.
speaker-0: He took his life two years ago, 16 years old, was a welding student actually, at Maricopa County School System. was a welder, loved life, loved welding. And he was online and with 12, actually 11 peers and one that was over 18 at the time. And he had posted three videos online. of what he intended to do to end his life.
speaker-1: And how long had he been doing that, posting what he was going to do?
speaker-0: Well she only knows about the one incident that night.
speaker-1: Yeah, I can't imagine just one night like
speaker-0: Going on and on and on. Right. but she no one reported it, no one called nine one one and she told me that her son Cade had taken his life and she found him the next morning after he had posted the videos online.
speaker-2: you
speaker-0: Chuck, I tell you my heart broke. Yeah. I we both started crying in my office And I said, you are an answer to my prayer. I was just praying this morning and I said, I am gonna get this bill passed to address teen suicide online. And this is a huge issue nationally check nationally. you have chat rooms that are another bill that was attached to this bill. Two six six five address teen suicide if you address eighteen and you know
about it and you're over eighteen and you encourage them by direct communication, texts, or online, to go ahead, let's do it. This is these are some of the ways you can do it. and it actually is happening. And so we I talked with the county attorney and she said I think you should also address sexual extortion of a minor. Right. It's called sextor
speaker-1: Sextor.
speaker-0: And I had never heard of it. I actually I'd never heard that term. And so I
speaker-1: It's quite phenomenal right now, especially with younger people because they get a little you know, kids and they go and send pictures and things and then all of a sudden you have bad, vile, evil actors who take advantage of them and threaten them with life and limb and they're gonna embarrass them unless they pay XYZ.
speaker-0: Well, they pay with money. Yes. sexual favors. Some of these meet these kids. Uhhuh. And
speaker-1: I didn't even know that part of it. I just always heard about the Mauri stuff of it. Yeah, that makes sense though.
speaker-0: but the main thing is extortion of money, sexual favors, more photos, and then they're afraid if they don't comply, everything that's online that they and they think this is another peer, like you know, a guy with a s another fifteen, sixteen year old child. Right. Now this was addressed by the county attorney, anyone under sixteen years of age. Right. But we wanted to address it for s anybody sixteen, seventeen, or and under eighteen. Now, an adult to a minor is considered at eighteen you're considered an adult. That was one of the hurdles I had to overcome was I had some back backlash from the left.
speaker-1: And what was the backlash?
speaker-0: Backlas was well, we don't want to punish another kid. You know, if they happen to be online and they think it's their peer and they're sending photos or they're and so I had to click
speaker-1: That's not but that's not the point. It's Sextortion. It's you know, Sextortions from extortion. Right. So that they think it's okay for a teenager to extort someone?
speaker-0: Evidently. Evidently. Well
speaker-1: That's weird. Let's just let's just call that weird. Let me go back here for a minute. So what is K so Cade's Law, you dad this story. So what does it do? What does it do?
speaker-0: All right. Kate's Law addresses any anyone over eighteen that knowingly agrees, maybe a kid's online, I wanna kill myself, I wanna I wanna end my life. It's actually called now death by I I don't know if it's called death by suicide, but but if you if you knowingly then encourage them through text, email or social media to go ahead. Let's do it. And you're over you're over eighteen, then they can be charged with manslaughter. Manslaughter.
speaker-1: think this is an important point for people to understand how bill making is done. Mm-hmm. You have this great bill. Mm-hmm. It's a problem. It's truly a problem.
speaker-0: It is.
speaker-1: And I don't think people we looked it up once. What people don't understand
it it was regarding overdoses. How many people does it affect? And it was like it affects an average of twelve close people to them. So same thing with suicide, right? If not probably higher. You
speaker-2: you
speaker-1: have Democrat colleagues That were okay with over eighteen, but they were they didn't want to touch the minor element on
speaker-0: No, we didn't even discuss over eighteen.
speaker-1: New not to
speaker-0: No, they there was pushback on some of the committees. Well we don't wanna we wanna make sure that we're not punishing a minor to another minor.
speaker-1: And what I want people to understand is they just think, Pamela's gonna go up there, she has this great idea and she just gets away what she wants to get. And that's not reality, is it? No. Has that been a frustrating thing for you as a legislator?
speaker-0: Well, it it was a learning curve.
speaker-1: Yeah, because especially for something you think is so common sense.
speaker-0: Yes, yes.
speaker-1: It's like, yo, suicide bad. Yeah,
speaker-0: Right. Right.
speaker-1: it depends who does it, who helps, right?
speaker-0: Right. But but that was the pushback even from some of the Republicans. So so I talked with the county attorney and she said you you let's make it eighteen. So I had to clarify in the bill eighteen is considered an adult and then once we did that then actually both those bills, the sexual extortion of a minor and Kate's Law, we were there until It's so emotional 'cause I had worked with this mom and the family Megan Keller for a year. So this and we were up in committee, people were up in arms about it. And then she and and her husband I love Megan Keller. I want to give her a big shout out. Megan Keller and her husband Brian were up in the up in the galley until after midnight that night that we voted on this bill. my god.
speaker-1: Goodness.
speaker-0: And the whole place was weeping. The h everyone, Republicans, Democrats, we were all weeping because the mom and dad were up there and they waited. They waited all day from morning until after midnight that night to get this thing over the finish line. Chuck, it was crying and she came down.
speaker-1: I c I can't I can't I can't even imagine what the I can't even imagine what the parents were re le reliving that day. So
speaker-0: Yeah. Yeah.
speaker-1: okay. So that's what Cade's Law does. What is the the sex tortion bill?
speaker-0: Extortion is actually it it is a class two felony now. If you extorted a minor online for money, sexual favors and more photos and it is prosecuted of course by the county attorney and so we do have it's a class two felony. And then case law will be manslaughter.
speaker-1: I had a friend who thought their son was involved in this and called me last month and they asked my advice and said, just tell it doesn't matter.
speaker-2: you
speaker-1: Who cares? And I just if someone goes a h leaks a picture of him naked, I said, doesn't matter, who cares? And I guess that was the reply and they came back and said, Yeah it ended. Just like I don't care.
speaker-0: He didn't care.
speaker-1: Well he of course he cared, but the point is he was just saying so what?
speaker-0: That's how we got out of it.
speaker-1: He told his parents he was honest about it and they just said, So you know, so what? I mean that's a point. They can extort you all you want, but so what
speaker-0: But yeah, I get it.
speaker-1: Right but as kids we're embarrassed to the adults as well, right? We all have that shame on
speaker-0: I don't think I would like my picture. Although
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-0: I would never do
speaker-1: Okay. Lemon Law Expansion. Tell me about this.
speaker-0: now these were all constituent bills and this is what you have to understand as a legislator. Yes. Okay. a constituent
speaker-1: Had a lemon car.
speaker-0: had a Mercedes that was I should probably say the the name of the dealer, but anyway, it was Mercedes. and it was a lemon. She had tried to work with the
speaker-1: Was this a buyer lease? It was a lease. A lease, okay.
speaker-0: This is what the problem twenty years in the Supreme Court of Arizona it was a that you could only do a purchase. You could not pa you could not use a consumer warranty for a leased vehicle. In Arizona, only two states, New Mexico and Arizona, had that law. Twenty years the lemon law lawyers were trying to overturn it.
speaker-1: Was that the auto dealers pushing this?
speaker-0: It was the just the warranty manufacturers and someone had sued Chrysler and then nineteen ninety six and they overturned and the Supreme Court of Arizona voted in favor of the the gentleman and s twenty years and the Lemonlaw lawyers were They were so overjoyed when we got this thing passed. I bet. Yes, because they had been working twenty years for someone to address it. No legislator is willing to take it on, but me, but I'm very brave about that kind of thing. I just thought this is cool. I'm gonna take it on. So we now and so we passed that bill unanimous in both houses and and both Democrats
speaker-1: It's such common sense. So I think there's something here that you have brought up that would be of interest to people. These bills all came up because a constituent approached you. It wasn't like you laid a bed at night and said, Boy, those lemon laws really get on my nerves.
speaker-0: Right.
speaker-1: Right? And so you listen so people think, Well, I have no say in government. Well that's a lie. You
speaker-0: It is a lie.
speaker-1: have an open door?
speaker-0: Take it to your representative or
speaker-1: Yeah, take your representative, you brought it up and you found a solution and and all these constituents they were with you on it and they helped on it. And folks, that's how it works. I think
speaker-0: Exactly.
speaker-1: people think there's some nefarious council of people who push this and they don't realize how many Yeah, lobbyists. Yeah,
speaker-0: Lobbyists, lobbyists.
speaker-1: I
lobby, lobby, lobby. But what they don't realize is how many of these type of bills come up because an actual constituent comes up. And this is the form of government we have and it's a good form.
speaker-0: And that's what I really want to do, Chuck, is listen to my constituents. I have another one too.
speaker-1: Telling, telling, telling.
speaker-0: I had a deployed Arizona National Guardsman that came to me about a situation where his he's was deployed out of Arizona and he had to continue to pay his registration vehicle license no.
speaker-1: And registration's not cheap in Arizona.
speaker-0: And so he said, I'm trying to get a refund, nobody'll help me. So lo and behold he came though, this is my first my first term. He came to me, this is my first bill I passed. It was so fun. And so we worked on it and we were able to get that law to where now I've gotta tell you this story if we have a little time. I was I was in committee arguing my case for and I had this gentleman testify in committee because you had first draft the bill, then it goes to committee, then you're actually you have to have it heard in committee. So I'm arguing right now with one of the Democrat legislators and she says, Well, if they're not deployed out Of er i out of the out of the country then this this doesn't apply. And I said, May I ask you a question, ma'am? What was your oath when you took office? She said and I said, Wasn't it to defend against all enemies, both domestic foreign and domestic ma'am?
speaker-1: She says.
speaker-0: She said, I withdraw my I withdraw my amendment.
speaker-1: You know And by the way, I you know, you don't need a comment on this. I will. So don't need to comment on this. But I have found Democrats talk about veterans all the time and boy they put a real
speaker-2: you
speaker-1: uproar about doing anything to give them a little something extra. It's it's pretty incredible. Now
speaker-0: They already got that passion. And it's not only passed. It's now.
speaker-1: Actually signed into law. So now you come up and if you're reelected, you're gonna what are you gonna push on your second term?
speaker-0: Ugh, well, I have a lot of ideas. I probably won't talk about it right now, but definitely wanna keep our taxes low, I wanna help our businesses, I wanna make sure we continue to keep school choice, but I also want to address some some super important issues that are dear to my heart. Right. and I am going to be working on those with behind the scenes.
speaker-1: So Pamela Carter, why should people re elect you and put you back in office for another two terms? Two y two years.
speaker-0: successful. I I feel like I've had a successful first first term to be able to pass five law five bills not only pass but have them signed into law in a divided government. I
speaker-1: Democrat government
speaker-0: have learned how to work across the aisle. I learned how to na navigate and just hear my the other side You may not agree and they know where I stand. The other situation was border security. I was very strong. I'm endorsed by almost every law enforcement agency in Arizona. They trust me. I was the vice chairman of public safety and law enforcement. I was on transportation, infrastructure, and water. Water is a big issue right now in Arizona. So I think that would be another big issue. education or water. We need to well well. Which we did Yeah, refineries. We did prices
speaker-1: Refinery Definitely I cannot believe I don't think people realize we've talked about in the show how much we rely on California refineries for gas, which is one reason we're more expensive than Utah and and some other states that are neighbors.
speaker-0: Right, right. Yeah. Well we are required by Arizona law and the governor to buy the boutique gas blend, summer blend. That's what's driving up prices. Yeah. Right,
speaker-1: And that's what we have to get from the California refineries.
speaker-0: right. So we're trying to bring in another another pipeline, you know, from Texas, right?
speaker-1: Well Pamela Carter, thank you so much for joining us. How do people learn about ya?
speaker-0: Okay, you can go to my website, pamela carter.com for more information to donate, and hope to have your vote.
speaker-1: That's great. Pamela Carter, thank you. Folks, this is Breaking Battlegrounds. Thank you for joining us this week on behalf of Brennan, Jeremy, myself, and Pamela who's in studio. Have a great weekend. You can follow us at breaking battlegrounds dot vote or wherever you get your podcast and you can catch us on the Salem Media Network. Have a great weekend.