UDSKRIFT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:01:00.089 --> 00:01:15.609
When you're preparing for a food or beverage certification, especially as your knowledge becomes more advanced and the examinations more grueling, a particular type of bond of friendship and camaraderie can take place between candidates that is akin to trauma bonding.
00:01:16.250 --> 00:01:20.650
You've both devoted your time and effort to something most people are never going to pursue.
00:01:20.969 --> 00:01:24.329
You've both dealt with doubt and worry and insecurity.
00:01:24.890 --> 00:01:27.289
Both experienced elation and disappointment.
00:01:27.609 --> 00:01:31.289
Both likely wrestled with validation and imposter syndrome.
00:01:32.009 --> 00:01:38.729
Some of my friendships in the beer industry in particular have been forged because we share an understanding of what it took to get where we are.
00:01:40.250 --> 00:01:58.969
The purpose of earning certification as a sommelier, Cicerone, chocolate taster, BJCP judge, pommelier, whatever other industry-specific vetting programs are out there should obviously never be to lord one's knowledge over other people and gatekeep the enjoyment of a particular food and drink.
00:01:59.930 --> 00:02:04.409
You don't have to be an expert of any kind to enjoy artists and foods and beverages.
00:02:04.490 --> 00:02:13.449
And the democratic nature of the tasting experience is part of what makes it such a powerful tool of connection between people of different backgrounds and experiences.
00:02:13.930 --> 00:02:23.530
As I've grown in knowledge as a beer educator and earned my advanced Cicero certification in 2021, I've mostly found the Dunning Kruger effect to be verified over and over.
00:02:23.770 --> 00:02:28.969
The more I learn and the more my colleagues learn, the more we realize there still is to be learned.
00:02:29.930 --> 00:02:39.289
Two friends and colleagues I've been privileged to get to know over the last several years have been on a publicly documented quest to pass the brutal master scissorone exam.
00:02:39.689 --> 00:02:46.490
We all passed our advanced exams around the same time, and while I chose to stop my pursuit there, they have pressed on.
00:02:46.969 --> 00:02:49.530
The advanced exam on its own is a beast.
00:02:49.770 --> 00:02:54.009
The master exam is the final boss when it comes to beer knowledge examination.
00:02:54.810 --> 00:03:00.169
In late 2025, Scott Fielder became just the 29th Master Cicero in the world.
00:03:00.490 --> 00:03:09.530
His best friend and partner in this process, Chris Crow, came close to doing the same and is more determined than ever to pass the test on his next try in late 2026.
00:03:10.890 --> 00:03:15.930
I sat down with Scott and Chris recently to talk not so much about the exams themselves.
00:03:16.090 --> 00:03:26.490
There are plenty of resources and stories out there about these quests, and you can learn a lot about Scott and Chris's journey specifically on their Instagram accounts and YouTube channel, which I'll link to in the show notes.
00:03:27.290 --> 00:03:34.810
But about how their pursuit of knowledge and the certifications that confirm it have impacted their experience and enjoyment of beer.
00:03:35.610 --> 00:03:49.370
We also talk about the vulnerability of documenting preparation as publicly as they have and how we can balance providing consumers with useful information without gatekeeping and using exclusionary or opaque descriptive language.
00:03:50.730 --> 00:04:01.210
While the focus of this episode is obviously beer, I think anyone who is interested in learning about a particular food or beverage segment will find value in this conversation and things to relate to.
00:04:01.689 --> 00:04:12.330
For you craft chocolate listeners, just for fun, I had Scott and Chris taste a couple single origin bars in the middle of the episode and describe them as a tasting exercise, so you can tune in for that.
00:04:12.730 --> 00:04:21.290
By nature of this conversation, there is occasionally some inside baseball talk about beer, but hopefully context will explain most of it.
00:04:21.449 --> 00:04:29.050
If you have any specific questions after listening to this here or in any episode, always reach out and I'm happy to explain anything further.
00:04:29.209 --> 00:04:32.889
I hope you enjoy my conversation with Scott Fielder and Chris Crow.
00:04:34.009 --> 00:04:36.889
Chris and Scott, welcome to Bean to Barstool.
00:04:37.129 --> 00:04:39.209
Glad we finally got to connect on this.
00:04:39.370 --> 00:04:40.889
Where are you guys at in the country?
00:04:41.050 --> 00:04:43.370
Tell our listeners where you're talking to us from.
00:04:43.769 --> 00:04:46.969
We are in the Los Angeles basin area.
00:04:47.129 --> 00:04:54.649
Scott's out in Long Beach, and I'm in Irvine, California, and we spend our time engaging with beer mostly out here.
00:04:54.969 --> 00:05:00.969
I want to hear from you guys a little bit about how you got invested in beer to the degree you are now.
00:05:01.129 --> 00:05:06.409
Usually on beer podcasts, I feel like we always get asked the how did you get into craft beer question.
00:05:06.569 --> 00:05:13.370
And at this point, we all kind of know that we got into it some variation of the same way, and it's not that interesting anymore.
00:05:13.689 --> 00:05:29.290
But I want to know how beer went from being a thing you enjoyed, craft beer was cool, whatever, to being something that you got much more invested in, something you recognized that the tasting experience and the sensory experience was going to be a deeper part of your life.
00:05:29.610 --> 00:05:37.689
Yeah, for me, I um I was lucky for a long time in a different profession to just be able to taste beers from all over the country.
00:05:37.850 --> 00:05:40.650
Um, and that's how I got a really exploratory mindset.
00:05:40.730 --> 00:05:48.329
But I don't think the sensory component really clicked until I had a beer that I didn't know could
Load full transcript
taste like that.
00:05:48.569 --> 00:05:56.889
That beer for me was New Belgium's Les Terroirs, which is a moderately famous American sour beer that's dry hopped.
00:05:57.290 --> 00:06:08.009
And I just remember before that point I wasn't particularly into proper service methods or sensory of beers.
00:06:08.090 --> 00:06:12.170
You know, it was just an experiential, purely enjoyment-based kind of thing.
00:06:12.329 --> 00:06:30.970
And I poured that beer into a glass and kind of the lights went on, being able to smell it uh in a slightly different environment, drinking a beer, not just to drink for purely enjoyment, but kind of like to uh to immerse yourself in all the different aroma and flavor capabilities that the beer has.
00:06:31.209 --> 00:06:54.730
And you know, that was 13 years ago or so, and I was already pretty full on beer nerd at that point, but not not in not in terms of like compartmentalizing it and fragmenting out all of the different components, and so I just remember never thinking beer could taste like that, and I wanted to know why it tasted like that, more so than just find the next beer that tastes like that.
00:06:54.889 --> 00:06:57.050
And for me, that kicked off the why.
00:06:57.290 --> 00:07:04.490
And most beers since then I wanted to know how they were made and why they were made that way, and why they tasted the way that they do.
00:07:04.730 --> 00:07:05.850
Scott, how about you?
00:07:06.170 --> 00:07:10.730
I had a very, very similar experience in terms of it.
00:07:10.810 --> 00:07:17.769
There was a singular beer that just completely in the heavens parted, didn't know beer could taste like this.
00:07:17.850 --> 00:07:26.410
Uh, I'll try and keep the story short, but basically running a hospitality event that had drink tickets, we had a bunch of tickets left over.
00:07:26.569 --> 00:07:29.850
Uh, we decided we wanted to try some beer from their bottle list.
00:07:30.009 --> 00:07:33.689
We picked out, uh, I said, What about this Rodenbach vintage beer?
00:07:33.769 --> 00:07:35.610
Vintage is a cool word in wine.
00:07:35.689 --> 00:07:37.050
Why don't we we get that?
00:07:37.209 --> 00:07:41.610
This is 2018, they bring out a bottle of 2011 Rodenbach vintage.
00:07:41.769 --> 00:07:46.410
None uh everybody is thinking this is just gonna taste terrible, right?
00:07:46.490 --> 00:07:49.610
Like what what beer tastes good after seven years?
00:07:49.930 --> 00:07:58.329
And obviously, looking back on it, had been cellared perfectly, uh, totally uh piqued my curiosity, like I never could have imagined.
00:07:58.650 --> 00:08:16.810
And really, where it to me kind of became uh this thing that I knew was gonna be important in my life was realizing that at some point I was probably going to have to transition careers and then kind of finding the Cicerone program.
00:08:17.370 --> 00:08:32.490
And that also not only being sort of a beginning of developing sort of a backup plan, but also just an outlet for uh my competitiveness, uh, the fact that there's blind tasting involved and that you can be good at this particular thing.
00:08:32.889 --> 00:08:34.409
Played sports all of my life.
00:08:34.569 --> 00:08:43.769
When I got into grad school, I was diagnosed with a um with a condition that you know keeps me from playing contact sports, or at least I'm very hesitant to.
00:08:44.169 --> 00:08:54.409
And so always trying to find um outlets for those sorts of things, uh, and really choosing, you know, beer not only for that experience, but just also that beer was accessible.
00:08:54.569 --> 00:08:59.850
Like I would hear wine people say, you know, oh, a cheap blind flight is you know$100,$120.
00:09:00.649 --> 00:09:05.129
And I'm thinking, I I can, you know, I I don't even like wine that much, and I really like beer.
00:09:05.209 --> 00:09:10.409
And so, you know, I'm sure just like many people on Google, what is a is there such a thing as a beer sommelier?
00:09:10.649 --> 00:09:26.329
And that's how I found found Cicero and then it's like, well, I can I can do this and I can get a certification, and it's you know, I can just you know spend 20, maybe 30 bucks if it's a you know really expensive uh you know uh you know style flight or or something.
00:09:26.649 --> 00:09:44.329
But then then I just realized it much like Chris 2, like the science behind it began to you know intrigue me immensely, and figuring out how all of those things worked and where they came from and how they came to be uh uh just an infinite rabbit hole to go down, which I love.
00:09:44.729 --> 00:09:46.250
That's interesting for both of you.
00:09:46.409 --> 00:09:47.849
It was a sour beer.
00:09:48.009 --> 00:09:50.329
It was a sour that yeah, that's really cool.
00:09:50.489 --> 00:09:56.649
And I think that uh certainly that is going to be a something surprising for folks who have never experienced that before.
00:09:56.809 --> 00:10:06.409
Uh, when I'm introducing people to sour beers in classes, I do some uh like library classes, so a lot of the people in there are truly brand new.
00:10:06.569 --> 00:10:09.689
And I always have to explain that these are beers that are sour on purpose.
00:10:10.250 --> 00:10:15.129
There is an alternative, but we're we're gonna taste sours that are supposed to be sour.
00:10:15.609 --> 00:10:27.929
A lot of folks who follow you guys on Instagram have uh been paying a lot of attention over the last couple of years because you guys have been very open about your preparation process for those Cicerone exams.
00:10:28.250 --> 00:10:33.370
So both taking the advanced and then uh the master over the last couple years.
00:10:33.689 --> 00:10:47.289
And you guys have been really, really open and like vulnerable with this is this is the process, these are the good days, these are the bad days, this is the flight where I bombed everything and didn't get anything right, and like really been kind of an open book.
00:10:47.370 --> 00:10:59.370
And I
think that has been permission for a lot of people who are prepping for these exams to be able to see that because I know when I was taking the advanced exam, I am a very private person primarily.
00:10:59.529 --> 00:11:02.250
And when I was prepping, I did that entirely alone.
00:11:02.569 --> 00:11:07.289
I didn't have any study partners and I felt very protective about that process.
00:11:07.609 --> 00:11:13.370
It was a very, you know, vulnerable thing that I was guarding for myself because I had a lot wrapped up in it.
00:11:13.449 --> 00:11:19.769
And it's been cool to see you guys do the complete opposite of that and just kind of lay open here's here's what we're doing.
00:11:19.929 --> 00:11:32.329
I want to talk a little bit about the impact of studying for those exams on your own enjoyment of beer, not on your careers, but on you as two dudes who like beer.
00:11:32.649 --> 00:11:35.769
What has the preparation for that done for you?
00:11:36.089 --> 00:11:43.209
Before we talk about that specifically, most of the listeners on Bean to Barstool are actually coming primarily from the chocolate side.
00:11:43.370 --> 00:11:46.329
I'd say it's about two-thirds are coming from that side versus beer.
00:11:46.729 --> 00:11:54.489
So could you can you guys just sketch a little bit of the scope of what we're talking about in terms of the preparation you've done over the last couple years?
00:11:54.889 --> 00:11:55.929
Yeah, absolutely.
00:11:56.250 --> 00:12:00.329
So we kind of joined study forces in 2020.
00:12:00.489 --> 00:12:06.889
Um, our connection was born out of the pandemic and having some extra time to get ready for some of these things.
00:12:07.049 --> 00:12:16.409
Um, there's a lot longer, more detailed version of events, but in essence, we met at a time that we were both getting ready to take the advanced Cicerone exam.
00:12:16.729 --> 00:12:23.689
And we didn't at the time know when it was going to be available next because the world was in chaos.
00:12:24.569 --> 00:12:31.129
And we that exam is the third level out of four for the Cicerone program for those that don't know.
00:12:31.370 --> 00:12:45.769
And it's a basically an eight-hour day exam that includes um significant written uh oral exams and most importantly for our purposes, a uh very involved tasting exam.
00:12:46.169 --> 00:13:00.809
And the tasting exam, I think a lot of people see the Somalier program and kind of use that as their guiding light for knowing how beverage professionals operate in some of these exam conditions.
00:13:00.969 --> 00:13:11.689
And some of it on the beer side is certainly inspired by some of the things that you need to do in wine, but the tasting exam in practice is kind of completely different because there are different goals.
00:13:11.929 --> 00:13:19.209
And so some of the overlap is that you have multiple samples where you have to determine if there's something wrong with the beer.
00:13:19.529 --> 00:13:30.409
And um, that thing that could be wrong with the beer is either from a brewing problem, uh storage and handling problem, or maybe even a service issue.
00:13:30.649 --> 00:13:34.089
And so on the advanced exam, there are what is it?
00:13:34.250 --> 00:13:36.969
It's got 11 off-flavor compounds.
00:13:37.129 --> 00:13:39.449
Um that yeah, 11 or 12.
00:13:39.529 --> 00:13:40.729
Yeah, one of those two.
00:13:41.049 --> 00:13:50.009
Um, and then for the master exam, it bumps up to possible 29 different uh flavor compounds that you have to be able to recognize.
00:13:50.169 --> 00:13:59.849
And so that's both the uh expensive and involved part of getting ready for the tasting exam is um getting exposed to all of those flavor compounds.
00:14:00.169 --> 00:14:03.289
On advanced, there's a panel like that.
00:14:03.370 --> 00:14:06.009
On the master exam, there are multiple panels like that.
00:14:06.169 --> 00:14:11.929
And then there are tasting panels that force you to flex your descriptive capabilities of beer.
00:14:12.169 --> 00:14:15.929
And those are both consumer-friendly versions of descriptions.
00:14:16.089 --> 00:14:29.049
Um, think of it like something you would see on the side of a bottle of beer that would tell you a little bit about what's going to be in the beer, um, but also technical where you're writing for your peers, um, using technical terminology where necessary.
00:14:29.370 --> 00:14:34.889
And then kind of the last class of tasting panels that that exist are styles.
00:14:35.049 --> 00:14:54.089
And this to me is the one that's most akin to wine, besides some of the off-flavor stuff, um, where instead of trying to figure out the vintage and the varietal uh of the grape, you're figuring out what which one of 104 different possible beer styles that a sample in front of you could be.
00:14:54.250 --> 00:14:58.889
Um, and so this is what we had been getting ready for for a long time.
00:14:58.969 --> 00:16:01.720
And we, I think a lot of people we had we had learned they approach this exam, the tasting components of both the advanced and master exams, not not uh not too not, I don't want to say like lightly, but it's it's expensive and it's involved.
00:16:01.799 --> 00:16:08.119
And so some people might only get exposure to some of the off-flavor compounds, for example, a handful of times before the exam.
00:16:08.440 --> 00:16:15.799
We invested, we eventually invested in buying the compound spikes directly from Aroxa, the corporation that they use.
00:16:16.200 --> 00:16:29.240
And we did we practice that and every panel weekly uh over the course of what now we're on, we just finished year five basically of doing doing that.
00:16:29.319 --> 00:16:32.440
Um and we obviously had restrictions early in the pandemic.
00:16:32.519 --> 00:16:56.039
Um, and we've moved and things have changed, but we in essence have done focused uh sensory and tasting at least once a week um over the course of four to five years, and tasted thousands of samples at
this point, and that's all under the umbrella of preparing for these exams.
00:16:56.200 --> 00:17:00.679
So definitely with the the sensory and analytical hat on.
00:17:01.159 --> 00:17:02.200
Yeah, that's wild.
00:17:02.359 --> 00:17:09.879
And then on top of that, uh for for those listening, beyond just the tasting component, you're also going to be writing essays till your arm falls off.
00:17:10.039 --> 00:17:15.720
So you have to have the back end technical knowledge beyond experience, you just have to know everything backward and forward.
00:17:15.799 --> 00:17:26.599
So you guys have invested an incredible amount of time into something that most people are just deciding to enjoy or not enjoy on a random night and not not doing all that thinking.
00:17:26.919 --> 00:17:33.480
So you guys started digging deeper originally on beer because you wanted to know why a beer tasted that way.
00:17:33.799 --> 00:17:46.679
You wanted to learn more about why you were experiencing what you were experiencing, hopefully in the goal that that was going to make your experience even more enjoyable, that that was going to blossom in your appreciation of beer.
00:17:47.159 --> 00:17:48.759
Have you found that to be true?
00:17:48.919 --> 00:17:59.640
Uh, I want to talk a little bit about how you've noticed the at times grueling and exhausting work affecting the enjoyment of the beer in your hand.
00:17:59.960 --> 00:18:05.480
Yeah, I think there's uh I think like anything, it kind of goes in ebbs and flows.
00:18:05.560 --> 00:18:09.000
I I think there's a sort of seasonality to it.
00:18:09.240 --> 00:18:29.640
And I think it the big part of it is that there just tends to be certain parts of the preparation for the exam that you enjoy a little bit more and uh and others that you you know that you don't that have to do with kind of the sensory and tasting portion uh of of the exam.
00:18:30.039 --> 00:18:46.680
But uh I would say for for me, from and especially, you know, kind of in uh in response to what I hear from a lot of people, or what people often kind of say is like, are you just now happy to just to be able to enjoy uh a beer?
00:18:46.920 --> 00:18:49.160
I would say it's sort of the opposite.
00:18:49.400 --> 00:18:52.760
I think there's only one way I know how to enjoy beer now.
00:18:53.080 --> 00:19:09.000
Um I don't really have I don't really have a desire to kind of go back to uh, you know, I don't, you know, mindless sounds like it's sort of akin to, you know, someone being dumb, but just not really having to to focus on it or to concentrate.
00:19:09.240 --> 00:19:20.520
And I think it's because I found a lot of positives in the idea that being in a moment where you are going to focus on one thing uh has a lot of benefits to it.
00:19:20.680 --> 00:19:31.480
Uh I remember I was um throughout the the process of preparation and and moving and lots of other other life events, I was seeking out uh therapy for some depression.
00:19:31.800 --> 00:19:42.680
And the my therapist asked, you know, what's a time where you just feel like you're you're focused and you're enjoying something and you're not kind of and everything just kind of seems to melt away.
00:19:43.000 --> 00:19:46.360
And it the only thing that I could come up with was sensory.
00:19:46.760 --> 00:19:54.040
It it was just honing in on this one thing, and then everything else just kind of and it just kind of doesn't exist.
00:19:54.440 --> 00:20:01.880
And especially in a in a world like today, I feel like that's something we clamor for to a certain extent.
00:20:02.200 --> 00:20:04.280
Yeah, I know I really resonate with that.
00:20:04.440 --> 00:20:20.760
Early in the pandemic, especially, my anxiety was spiking really badly, both for obvious reasons, but uh specifically related to what we're talking about, with those early strains of COVID, you know, people were sometimes losing their sense of smell and not getting it back.
00:20:21.240 --> 00:20:28.200
And I when I learned that that was a possibility, I was like, well, shit, I mean, this is my favorite thing that I do.
00:20:28.280 --> 00:20:29.320
This is my career.
00:20:29.560 --> 00:20:49.000
And I found during that time that the sensory process, like sitting down, putting a beer in front of me or chocolate or whatever it was, locking everything out and just getting away from being cerebral primarily to being a sensory instrument was very centering and very settling.
00:20:49.160 --> 00:20:52.360
Uh something I was consciously using as a tool for that.
00:20:52.520 --> 00:20:55.000
So definitely uh resonate with what you're saying.
00:20:55.160 --> 00:20:56.200
Chris, how about you?
00:20:56.520 --> 00:20:58.280
Yeah, I it it's interesting.
00:20:58.360 --> 00:21:10.680
And when I was getting ready to go for level two, the certified cisfrone had a lot of industry friends at that time that they would ask, like, oh, you do you really want to be this analytical about beer?
00:21:10.920 --> 00:21:12.520
You know, it's just for enjoyment.
00:21:12.760 --> 00:21:15.400
Is it gonna take the the joy out of it?
00:21:15.640 --> 00:21:19.720
And I didn't really believe that that was possible at the time.
00:21:19.880 --> 00:21:23.560
And you hear from a lot of people, they'll they'll still ask that question to this day.
00:21:23.720 --> 00:21:29.400
Oh, can you just go out and enjoy a beer uh without uh or are you able to turn it off essentially?
00:21:29.560 --> 00:21:31.720
Can you just you know turn off that mindset?
00:21:31.880 --> 00:21:35.880
And I don't think you can, at least for me, turn it completely off.
00:21:36.440 --> 00:21:41.400
But I found that that brings more enjoyment to beer in almost every instance.
00:21:41.560 --> 00:21:48.600
There are some others um that I think if you're on too high alert, that maybe it impacts your enjoyment of the situation.
00:21:48.680 --> 00:21:59.640
But when we were getting into this and really getting serious about
studying, we were still in different versions of our own like exploratory beer phase.
00:21:59.720 --> 00:22:17.160
And what I think definitely happened is we gained a really massive appreciation for the classics, um, a lot of the old-world styles and just like classic archetypal examples of some of these beers that you don't normally just kick back and drink.
00:22:17.400 --> 00:22:19.400
Huge appreciation for those beers now.
00:22:19.560 --> 00:22:33.800
Um, and they're ones that you study a lot because they're made by really great breweries for a long time, and they have sensory programs that are trying to recreate the same beer every single time and make sure that you experience that beer roughly similarly every time.
00:22:34.040 --> 00:22:43.240
And I also thought like connecting the beers to different parts of the exam or different parts of beer knowledge really unlocked new pathways of enjoyment.
00:22:43.480 --> 00:23:10.920
So, one example is you could be hyper-technical about the sensory qualities of a beer and you don't like it's not a beer you would normally drink, you know, kick back with the homies and have some of, but when you learn what that beer tastes like and what it creates with food, for example, it's it's like okay, in my just I think people think of their everyday enjoyment of just drinking beers as drinking it by itself.
00:23:11.080 --> 00:23:24.920
And when you do that, I think you pick beers that are either unobtrusive, you know, that are just light and easy drinking, or maybe flavor-forward beers, but they're but are ones that you enjoy the beer by itself.
00:23:25.080 --> 00:23:43.400
And studying for this exam, um, all these exams, particularly the beer and food part, just unlocked a whole new enjoyment pathway where I'm not known to sit back and just enjoy Bellhaven Scotch Ale by itself.
00:23:43.560 --> 00:23:47.560
Like I'm not splitting a six pack of that with Scott on a Wednesday night or something.
00:23:48.440 --> 00:23:52.440
But having that with a meal is a different game entirely.
00:23:52.600 --> 00:24:00.120
And it can unlock in enjoyment in the pairing that far surpasses what having any beer by itself could do.
00:24:00.600 --> 00:24:06.120
So I think it really increases enjoyment in a lot of ways, even if you're being technical about it.
00:24:06.360 --> 00:24:15.560
I will say that maybe one area where it's hard to turn it off or you know not let it creep in is how do I best describe this?
00:24:15.800 --> 00:24:24.120
Either like hypermodern beer styles or you know, massively rotating beer styles, like the IPA of the week from your local brewery or something like that.
00:24:24.280 --> 00:24:29.640
I think that you that there's a thin needle to thread when you're making new products every week.
00:24:29.960 --> 00:24:38.280
And I think people are on the hunt for what is either wrong with those or what IPA it tasted like similarly before.
00:24:38.600 --> 00:24:48.440
But perhaps more importantly, Scott, Scott and I have been at different points really disappointed in the service aspect of some of some of the beers.
00:24:48.520 --> 00:24:50.440
And so that's the part that's hard to turn off.
00:24:50.520 --> 00:25:09.880
Um, it can be something as simple as going to a place that claims to serve your beer in proper glassware, so they set an expectation for that, and then you don't receive it in the proper glassware, and so there's nothing wrong with the beer necessarily, but there's something really wrong with the experience after the expectations were set.
00:25:10.040 --> 00:25:22.280
Or the worst of all would be, you know, going to a brewery or a bar that doesn't clean their lines, you know, and so that that impacts that impacts your enjoyment in a way that you can't really recover from.
00:25:22.440 --> 00:25:36.040
So I think it puts you it put me on high alert in a handful of other situations, but mostly it has made me appreciate historical old world classic stuff way more than I ever anticipated that I could.
00:25:36.440 --> 00:25:43.880
I think one thing I noticed for myself was that once I became aware early on of the idea of off-flavors.
00:25:44.040 --> 00:25:59.960
So when I was studying for the certified exam and you're first getting exposed to those handful of super common brewing faults, as soon as you become aware of them, it's like the rule of the instrument, the idea that like when you're holding a hammer, every problem looks like a nail.
00:26:00.200 --> 00:26:03.160
Suddenly you're looking for it and you want to find it.
00:26:03.480 --> 00:26:17.720
And I feel like there's a for a lot of people, there's this arc of knowledge acquisition where there's a difference between when you learn a thing and when you've known the thing long enough to know what to do with it.
00:26:18.200 --> 00:26:24.520
And with off flavors, a lot of times, uh, there's a difference between, okay, now I can recognize this.
00:26:24.680 --> 00:26:27.960
Now I want to find it, now I want to point it out when I find it.
00:26:28.280 --> 00:26:31.800
And just understanding what does this off flavor even mean?
00:26:31.960 --> 00:26:35.080
Is this something that most people are even going to be aware is there?
00:26:35.560 --> 00:26:38.520
Is it something that's objectively unpleasant?
00:26:38.920 --> 00:26:41.480
Or is it just maybe not style appropriate?
00:26:41.640 --> 00:26:44.040
And like there's a difference between those.
00:26:44.200 --> 00:27:04.120
And I think uh one of the steps of growth in knowledge with beer, and I'm sure this is true of any other artisan food or drink, is getting past the okay, now I know what this is and I want to use it, and having settled into having that knowledge and understanding how to use it.
00:27:04.520 --> 00:27:10.520
We had a we had a mentor early on helping us for the advanced exam, uh, Master Cicero and Brian Reed.
00:27:10.600 --> 00:27:18.760
And I think he he put that very uh succinctly and just
said, There is a point in your learning where you will know just enough to be dangerous.
00:27:19.080 --> 00:27:19.560
Yeah.
00:27:19.880 --> 00:27:21.560
To annoy everyone around.
00:27:22.120 --> 00:27:23.000
Yeah, yeah.
00:27:23.240 --> 00:27:43.480
And uh and also the I think with the the the sort of once you uh learn about off flavors and then you know your imagery of every you know problem you having a hammer and ever every problem becoming a nail, I think there's also the aspect of it that your your sensory uh you know sort of experience is almost like this stained glass window.
00:27:43.720 --> 00:28:04.040
And when you learn about certain off flavors, it it kind of puts a crack in that window because then it's not only that you maybe even go looking for them, but that you realize that the ones that you really like or the styles that you really like or the place that you really like to go drink beer actually probably has some, you know, some flaws in it.
00:28:04.200 --> 00:28:11.240
I I even know certain sensory people who, when they do that, they're just it's like a preemptive apology just in case I ruin your favorite beer for you.
00:28:11.400 --> 00:28:12.360
But you know.
00:28:12.760 --> 00:28:21.000
I remember uh years ago before I got serious about beer, I was uh was traveling and I had a I think it was an amber ale.
00:28:21.560 --> 00:28:27.720
And at the time I thought it was awesome because there was a flavor in there that I had, you know, had not experienced in beer before.
00:28:28.040 --> 00:28:33.000
I now know that it was one of the worst diacetal issues in a commercial beer I've ever experienced.
00:28:33.240 --> 00:28:36.920
But at the time I was like, butterscotch beer, this is awesome.
00:28:37.160 --> 00:28:39.640
And I loved it, you know, like I was whatever.
00:28:39.720 --> 00:28:41.880
Every new beer was a cool thing.
00:28:42.200 --> 00:28:50.600
And now I'm like, if I had that, I would like I would be telling people I knew of like, you would not believe how bad this diacetal problem was in this beer.
00:28:50.760 --> 00:28:59.240
Like uh it definitely changes our our perspective on things that in some cases we might have enjoyed, you know, before we we knew them.
00:28:59.640 --> 00:29:19.000
I'm curious, I want to hear you guys talk a little bit about how uh knowing what you know about beer and having put the work into particularly to be able to identify and describe flavors in beer, how that applies to the education component for other people.
00:29:19.160 --> 00:29:24.520
Like if you're now going to have the role of introducing other people to beer, helping them to appreciate it more.
00:29:24.840 --> 00:29:41.960
One thing that I've seen in recent years that I think is excellent from intent is stripping away gatekeeping, stripping away snobbery, not making there, you know, a a required amount of knowledge for people to be able to just enjoy beer, which I think is awesome.
00:29:42.440 --> 00:29:52.120
But I
think one consequence of that sometimes is that we then penalize knowledge and penalize doing anything more than that and describing in more detail.
00:29:52.680 --> 00:30:08.520
What do you guys think about like the balance between being able to give people the tools and and describing something and celebrating complexity, but not doing that in a way that makes them feel like this is not for them because there's a barrier to entry.
00:30:08.840 --> 00:30:17.480
Yeah, I I'd like to connect that briefly to our study preparation and it being so public and vulnerable.
00:30:17.720 --> 00:30:22.360
Um, and part of I mean, that was a conscientious decision on our part.
00:30:22.520 --> 00:30:25.880
We talked about how we wanted to document um our journey.
00:30:26.040 --> 00:30:28.840
Some of it was organic, you know, we just liked sharing.
00:30:29.000 --> 00:30:44.600
Um, uh, but there there were several moments where we were having difficulty cracking through and attaining knowledge and mentorship from other people, and it just felt like this big chimera that we couldn't really poke through in a meaningful way.
00:30:44.760 --> 00:30:53.480
And then the other kind of epiphany was that while both of us are competitive, I think to go for some of these credentials, you have to be somewhat competitive.
00:30:53.720 --> 00:30:58.040
We realized this this arena is not competition with other people.
00:30:58.200 --> 00:31:21.000
Um, and we wanted to leave the chess pounding behind, um, which I think craft beer especially had um problems with that uh for quite still does in many corners, I'm sure, but there was definitely a turn around, you know, the exposure of some impropriety at different breweries where we're getting ready to study at the same time, and we don't want to be associated with any of that.
00:31:21.080 --> 00:31:27.720
And so part of approaching our process with humility, being humble, open, vulnerable.
00:31:27.880 --> 00:31:42.680
We were just tired of running into situations where people acted like they knew everything about beer, and we much preferred being around people and learning from people that admit that they're still learning something new about beer every day.
00:31:42.840 --> 00:32:14.920
And so I think throwing ourselves into that end of the water made it made us more approachable, and so our entire demeanor is you know, Scott couldn't maybe speak to it differently, but I think that there is a uh we try to set the terms of comfortability in talking about beer, and that there are what you know, while there are strictly wrong answers in some senses, that the more that we can expand our experiential capabilities and understandings, the better.
00:32:15.080 --> 00:32:17.400
You know, people people have been writing about this more and more.
00:32:17.560 --> 00:32:26.840
Mark Dredge has done a a a couple of articles about something as simple as different cultural connections to different flavor compounds.
00:32:27.000 --> 00:32:37.320
And so I think craft beer had an era where, you know, a certain compound always had to taste like this, had to smell like this, and it was taught and drilled into people a certain way.
00:32:37.480 --> 00:32:43.800
And we've found that we're learning exponentially more when that pool of descriptors is widened.
00:32:44.200 --> 00:32:52.040
Um, and I think that that makes it easier to learn, but it also makes it so that you don't seem as intimidating.
00:32:52.200 --> 00:32:55.960
You know, you it's it's a more inviting form of beer education.
00:32:56.440 --> 00:33:13.160
And when when it is more inviting, even if it's not explicitly so, it's just based off of your demeanor, then that that veil is lifted and there's a there's a connection that's more direct and organic and non-confrontational.
00:33:13.320 --> 00:33:21.240
Um, and I think beer is doing a better job at being less know-it-all and more invitational.
00:33:21.480 --> 00:33:27.720
Um, but I think that that swinging to the invitational end of the spectrum has helped has helped a ton.
00:33:27.960 --> 00:34:02.440
Yeah, I think uh a really good example of what uh Chris was talking about that we both experienced when we took uh Cicerone did kind of their version, their first kind of version of Aroxa that was because uh for people who don't know Aroxa is a flavor standard company, uh they hold an annual uh five-day uh taster training course that kind of at some point, I don't know when, but basically kind of became part of the like, if you want to pass the master exam, like you need to take this course.
00:34:02.600 --> 00:34:14.920
And for however many years now is usually if it's held in the United States at some point, it is usually in a city very close to where the exam is gonna be, and often the week before the exam.
00:34:15.159 --> 00:34:21.559
And we Cicerone kind of did their own version that is actually geared completely towards the master exam.
00:34:21.719 --> 00:34:28.920
And just the the first panel out of the gate, you know, there's three master cicerones in the back, they're doing the off-flavors along with us.
00:34:29.079 --> 00:34:32.519
We get done with the first set of panels, and you know, Dan M.
00:34:32.599 --> 00:34:41.159
Dike, one of the two owners of Cicerone, just says, just so everybody knows, like nobody back there is batting a thousand, you know, and that's all it takes.
00:34:41.400 --> 00:34:44.280
It just takes one, you know, it just takes one thing.
00:34:44.360 --> 00:35:04.440
And I now, like Chris said, with how sort of open we've been with our process, a lot of the times when I do education now, especially around sensory, I just say, if there was anybody who really, really wanted to, they could, they could dig through my Instagram account and make a solid argument out of context that I am a terrible taster.
00:35:05.400 --> 00:35:19.000
They could take every you know, zero and one out of seven that I've ever, you know, gotten and uh,
you know, one or two out of five that I got studying for advanced, and they could make a case, you know, without all the context that I am just not a great, uh, a great taster.
00:35:19.159 --> 00:35:25.960
And I think just even just that one simple thing uh really does uh a lot for setting expectations.
00:35:26.280 --> 00:35:55.159
And I think the other part of it too is, uh and maybe this is different for everyone who goes through you know programs like these, but I think there is a certain point, uh, especially I think I would say argue that it happens in the the upper levels of most of these programs, is there there is a point where you start to realize that even though you may know a lot more than maybe the vast majority of people, you understand how much you still do not know.
00:35:55.400 --> 00:36:04.839
Uh and so that alone is a is a humbling uh experience and revelation to you know to kind of come to for you know whoever and whenever that happens.
00:36:05.079 --> 00:37:48.269
And uh so that's why I think uh honestly at the times where we've maybe seen that or even run into that, uh, it's people who uh again, it's not that they're a certain level in the in the program, but they're they're just it seems like maybe they've just crossed over into that knowing just enough to you know to be to be dangerous because we we listen to all the beer podcasts and uh you know there's every so often there's always a story about somebody and it's like oh this Cicerone came in, uh, you know, and uh it you know, and it's and unfortunately for some people it just takes one of us, you know, to kind of put a put a bad taste in then all of a sudden it's like oh they're all kind of snobby like that and they just want to tell you what to do and tell you how you're you know how you're wrong.
00:37:48.430 --> 00:37:58.910
And but we also that's honestly something we struggle with too, because sometimes we will see something and we're like, wow, that's really like not super great uh information.
00:37:58.990 --> 00:38:09.150
And then we uh usually are like, you know, like maybe it's not our place, you know, to say anything, so we just kind of you know talk internally and just say, okay, is this kind of what you were were seeing?
00:38:09.309 --> 00:38:14.750
But then I've kind of also posed the question to Chris, then then whose job is it?
00:38:14.910 --> 00:38:21.789
You know, are we all just kind of just allowed to kind of float in the you know the ether of social media and just say whatever?
00:38:22.190 --> 00:38:31.230
Uh, you know, and and that's why for us personally, that's why we hold uh MSODR at Pints and Panels as just the gold standard.
00:38:31.710 --> 00:38:47.150
Just the person who will put something out that has some internal, you know, connections and resources that that she you know consults and then will quickly uh and publicly, you know, change information saying I've learned X, Y, and Z because so and so.
00:38:47.390 --> 00:38:52.269
And
these people have reached out to her because they know that she is willing to hear that.
00:38:52.510 --> 00:38:59.710
And for us, that is, you know, that that's truly one, that's like something that we uh, you know, would aspire to be like.
00:39:00.269 --> 00:39:06.750
How do you think that posture translates to how we present products to consumers?
00:39:06.910 --> 00:39:13.710
I think one trend we're seeing is getting away from hyper focus on style names that people haven't heard of.
00:39:13.950 --> 00:39:23.470
I know in the cocktail world there's some movement away from rather than just a list of ingredients, here's five keyword flavor descriptors.
00:39:23.869 --> 00:39:35.630
What do you think is the balance there between that approachability while also giving people the tools to have that knowledge if they if they want it and not just not removing the idea of knowledge from this?
00:39:35.950 --> 00:39:43.070
Yeah, what what is that balance between not gatekeeping but still giving accurate and useful information?
00:39:43.630 --> 00:39:49.630
Yeah, for me it's all bound up in service and developing a service forward identity.
00:39:49.869 --> 00:40:06.269
It's the most difficult thing to teach, especially having tended bar and done beer tending for years, is the instinctual understanding of where a customer is at based on what they're asking about or how they're interacting in a beer environment.
00:40:06.430 --> 00:40:20.910
And so, you know, we exist in this world where uh dozens of beer myths have done the general populace the disservice of you know saying things like, I don't like loggers, but I like pilsners.
00:40:21.070 --> 00:40:25.230
You know, and that's like not a moment to, it's not a gotcha moment.
00:40:25.390 --> 00:40:36.430
You know, you have to figure out quickly, you have to understand the context of how a person could get to saying something like that and uh uh approach them where they are.
00:40:36.590 --> 00:40:43.869
Um, and that's not in terms of talking down or developing some more dictatorial strategy or something.
00:40:43.950 --> 00:40:48.269
It's just like, oh, okay, this is where this person is in their beer journey.
00:40:48.510 --> 00:40:55.789
Remember when I was at that part of the beer journey, and how would I appreciate being coaxed out of it or at least coaxed forward?
00:40:56.110 --> 00:41:02.110
So all the way from there up to flavor notes for the the next hottest IPA.
00:41:02.190 --> 00:41:05.070
You know, I think that the best thing that a lot of tap rooms do.
00:41:05.309 --> 00:41:19.710
I I love when I walk into a tap room and I'm asking about a beer, and the beer tender says, Oh, I think this smells like peaches and nectarines, but Scott really gets this citrus kick out of it.
00:41:19.950 --> 00:41:20.590
Try it.
00:41:20.829 --> 00:41:35.710
You know, it's just everything is like so inviting and communal where you're presenting the information as, oh, people perceive this in different ways, but you don't have to explain, you know, the history of genetic differences in in tasting and smelling.
00:41:35.869 --> 00:41:38.510
It's just it's apparent, it's part of the presentation.
00:41:38.829 --> 00:41:41.390
So-and-so gets X out of it, I get Y.
00:41:41.789 --> 00:41:42.590
What do you think?
00:41:42.750 --> 00:41:44.829
And that's the invitational component to it.
00:41:45.150 --> 00:42:01.230
And so, yeah, I think, you know, we've already talked about knowing just enough to be dangerous, and I think switching from that danger being like the intentional weaponization of your knowledge to it being more like, oh, I'm still learning about this too.
00:42:01.630 --> 00:42:02.990
Here's here's what we think.
00:42:03.150 --> 00:42:06.510
Let's make this decision together based on the information that we have.
00:42:06.829 --> 00:42:08.750
I think that fixes the problem quite a bit.
00:42:09.150 --> 00:42:20.510
One of the difficult things with this is figuring out how to give knowledge to the people who want it without talking down to the folks who just want to enjoy whatever's in front of them.
00:42:20.670 --> 00:42:27.950
My my wife uh is from Chicago and she was talking at one point about going to a coffee cupping at a coffee roastery in Chicago.
00:42:28.110 --> 00:42:29.470
She knew nothing about coffee.
00:42:29.710 --> 00:42:32.990
So she's going there to learn a little bit about coffee.
00:42:33.309 --> 00:42:51.630
And the the posture of the the baristas who were running it was so hands-off from a we don't want to influence you, we don't want to talk down to you, that they ended up not really giving her any tools to understand what is the difference between these uh coffees that you put in front of me.
00:42:51.710 --> 00:43:03.630
Like it's great that you don't want to tell me I'm wrong because I taste this or that, but at the same time, I'm wanting to come away from this with some some tools and some pieces and some language, and that's not there.
00:43:03.710 --> 00:43:08.990
And I feel like that that balance and that tipping point is the hardest thing.
00:43:09.230 --> 00:43:18.990
Uh how do you give that when people want it and not be, you know, mansplaining to whoever's on the other side of the bar when they're not asking for that.
00:43:19.230 --> 00:43:23.630
And it's very difficult to universally design that approach, right?
00:43:23.710 --> 00:43:28.910
Like you want it to be the space to be available for both versions of that person, right?
00:43:28.990 --> 00:43:32.910
The one that's receptive to to education and the one that's the one that's not.
00:43:33.070 --> 00:43:37.550
Because if you want to just show up and drink beers and not be lectured to, I got no problem with that.
00:43:37.710 --> 00:43:43.230
Like that is a that is a disposition that is important for a variety of reasons, you know.
00:43:43.309 --> 00:44:02.430
And Scott and I are kind of going through a bunch of theorizing about how to create
that type of space where you can put on an event where if somebody just wants to show up and enjoy the beer that's being featured, um, meet some new people and not feel like it's school, they can do that.
00:44:02.590 --> 00:44:08.670
But that there are avenues for existing in that space where you can ask a bunch of questions.
00:44:08.829 --> 00:44:18.269
There might be menu items that dive a little bit deeper, but they're not overwhelming and you know, put in front of your face as sort of the gatekeeping to the event.
00:44:18.670 --> 00:44:27.070
I really agree with uh with Chris's kind of read the room uh, you know, uh approach and really setting expectations.
00:44:27.309 --> 00:44:38.829
I'm I'm personally not gonna lose any sleep if I'm talking about a sensory event that I'm gonna do that's for people who are gonna be taking, you know, the local Cicerone or advanced Cicerone tasting exam.
00:44:38.910 --> 00:44:44.590
Uh, and then somebody shows up and says, you know, why why are we uh only drinking one kind of beer?
00:44:44.750 --> 00:45:10.750
And and it's like, you know, it's like, okay, like I was never really gonna probably reach that person anyway, or somehow they ended up here, and this is not what they um and so I think just setting clear expectations, and I think you were that something that you were saying, David, I think it's giving people as many tools as they can, and then just but then helping them along the way so that they can kind of come to their own conclusion.
00:45:10.990 --> 00:45:32.829
And that that conclusion, uh sometimes for, you know, and it just kind of staying on sensory, uh, even though there even though there are some uh you know, compounds where it's like this is kind of what it smells like, you know, this is what uh a lot of people get, some compounds that has been drilled in because there aren't really a lot of other ones.
00:45:33.150 --> 00:45:39.470
You know, maybe there's maybe there's one other one and it's this very specific, you know, cultural, uh, cultural aspect.
00:45:39.630 --> 00:45:41.789
This was a great story that uh Dr.
00:45:41.869 --> 00:45:43.630
Bill Simpson of Oroxa told us.
00:45:43.710 --> 00:45:53.309
He said he was uh teaching a class in Asia and he was having a lot of trouble uh with getting people to understand that diacetyl to a lot of people smelled like butter.
00:45:53.550 --> 00:46:02.110
And for anybody who doesn't know, diacetyl is a um uh kind of uh fermentation byproduct that happens in beer making uh all the time.
00:46:02.269 --> 00:46:10.590
In certain styles, having some of it is okay, but the vast majority of the time it's seen as a uh as an off-note uh and not supposed to be there.
00:46:10.750 --> 00:46:43.309
And he just really couldn't make this connection until finally somebody said, This is what it's like when somebody has left rice in the rice cooker for too long and the bacteria in it has started to create these sorts of compounds because in that particular region of the world, every household had a right, you know, has a rice maker, you know, but they rarely use, you know, these kinds of, you know, kind of fake movie theater butter, you know, kind of products in the cuisine, you know, of that region.
00:46:43.710 --> 00:46:49.789
Um, and so yes, there might be some that are, you know, where maybe in a A particular part of the world, it's different.
00:46:49.950 --> 00:46:57.950
But then there's others where I mean, uh, there was three of us in a study group at one point, and uh one compound, we all smell it completely differently.
00:46:58.110 --> 00:47:05.869
Sometimes we even smelled it at different concentrations, depending on how strong it was or how much was present uh in the beer.
00:47:06.110 --> 00:47:15.070
And so uh again, giving people the tools of this is this is a really good way to if you're really trying to parse out some of these things, if that's what you're shooting for.
00:47:15.230 --> 00:47:18.590
So figuring out what what the goals are uh for that person.
00:47:18.670 --> 00:47:46.670
And again, you can just you can hold an event and you can have people who are coming in who are studying for an exam and other people who are like, I just want to learn more about beer, uh, you know, and so it's kind of figuring out, okay, like when he when this person is asking this question, like Chris said, okay, they seem like they're coming from you know this sort of a of a knowledge base and and trying to base that uh off of evidence and not just, you know, sort of assumptions, um, just doing our best to, you know, engage with people.
00:47:46.829 --> 00:47:49.789
I think that's the other thing that Chris has said that I think is just so important.
00:47:49.869 --> 00:48:05.150
The more that we can kind of engage and get the person to kind of open up about maybe what they're looking for or what their relationship is to be or the goals that they have, uh, then we become better at helping them uh, you know, find whatever it is they're looking for.
00:48:05.470 --> 00:48:06.269
Yeah, for sure.
00:48:06.430 --> 00:48:16.190
But something that uh comes up in Kraft Chocolate, which we're about to talk about, most craft chocolate is enjoyed in areas of the world where cacao is not grown.
00:48:16.349 --> 00:48:25.550
And so standardizing descriptive language, going back to cacao growing regions and saying, well, you know, this the chocolate that's coming from this tastes like blueberry.
00:48:25.710 --> 00:48:27.950
Well, blueberries aren't grown there.
00:48:28.110 --> 00:48:30.110
Like blueberry is not a flavor reference.
00:48:30.190 --> 00:48:53.309
And so being able to not not take that descriptive language back to cacao growing regions in this very colonial way and say, no, these are the flavor descriptors, and figure out what is the common language we can use, what is the mutual education that can take place so that we can communicate about this is something really interesting
that's happening in that space.
00:48:53.550 --> 00:48:57.390
On that note, uh, you guys have a couple chocolate bars that we're going to taste.
00:48:57.550 --> 00:49:01.710
So you have two bars from Dandelion out there in California.
00:49:02.030 --> 00:49:09.630
Dandelion is sort of a, they're kind of like a Sierra Nevada type of company for craft chocolate, where they were one of the early ones.
00:49:09.869 --> 00:49:14.430
They're still one of the biggest ones, but making still making very good product.
00:49:14.670 --> 00:49:24.750
Uh, and for a lot of people, uh, especially early adopters in craft chocolate, they probably would have been one of the first, if not the first, that they tasted.
00:49:25.070 --> 00:49:27.710
Uh so I'm excited for you guys to taste these two.
00:49:28.030 --> 00:49:36.510
You've got two single origin bars, 70% bars, one from Tomaco, Colombia, one from Simaliki Forest, Uganda.
00:49:36.750 --> 00:49:40.430
So, what I want to do here, you've got both of these bars in front of you.
00:49:40.590 --> 00:49:43.950
Um, go ahead and open, let's start with the Columbia bar.
00:49:44.030 --> 00:49:45.150
Go ahead and open that one.
00:49:45.630 --> 00:49:48.910
First thing you're gonna do, same with beer, is take a look at it.
00:49:49.309 --> 00:49:55.390
And there's a couple different things that you can uh evaluate as you're looking at your bar of chocolate.
00:49:55.950 --> 00:50:07.630
One, obviously, color, gonna give you a general indication probably of uh cacao percentage, but that's not always going to be one-to-one between you know the same bars.
00:50:08.030 --> 00:50:16.910
Also looking at the shine of the bar, uh looking at how much gloss it has, give you a little sense of the texture of what you're looking at there.
00:50:17.150 --> 00:50:22.430
A good gloss is often an indication of a well-tempered bar.
00:50:22.990 --> 00:50:25.630
Chocolate is a fat suspension.
00:50:25.869 --> 00:50:29.150
So you're grinding up the bean, it's about 40% fat.
00:50:29.309 --> 00:50:30.430
The rest of it is solids.
00:50:30.670 --> 00:50:37.710
And as you're grinding all that up and then rehardening it from a liquid, it's a very specific process to get it to reharden correctly.
00:50:37.789 --> 00:50:42.030
And what happens is all those solids end up in suspension in the fat in there.
00:50:42.269 --> 00:50:48.269
And when that's done properly, you get a really nice even gloss on the surface of the bar there.
00:50:48.670 --> 00:50:59.550
And then one cool thing that chocolate makers do uh that we don't have any corollary to in beer is get to come up with any kind of mold design for the bar itself.
00:50:59.630 --> 00:51:05.150
So some of them are custom, some of them are kind of generic, and you just get squares, some of them are super elaborate.
00:51:05.230 --> 00:51:06.269
Uh, very, very cool.
00:51:06.590 --> 00:51:10.430
Scott, I just saw you hold up the piece and snap it by your ear there.
00:51:10.510 --> 00:51:12.110
So you've done this a little bit before.
00:51:12.269 --> 00:51:16.349
It's one of my favorite rituals in craft chocolate is the snap.
00:51:16.510 --> 00:51:24.670
So you hold the piece up to your ear, snap it, get that nice clean uh snapping sound is another indication of proper tempering.
00:51:24.910 --> 00:51:38.829
It's one of those things that really means nothing to the the actual tasting of the bar, but it's it's a ritual that I enjoy for its own sake because it really has no corollary in any sort of beverage application.
00:51:38.910 --> 00:51:45.150
Like it's something that like just that that audible sound is kind of just like a cue that you're about to start this process.
00:51:45.230 --> 00:51:45.950
So I love that.
00:51:46.349 --> 00:51:48.750
Uh, you certainly can smell your chocolate.
00:51:48.829 --> 00:51:59.230
Now, being a solid, it's not gonna give off as much from a volatile standpoint as a liquid like beer will, but you can still smell it to get a little bit of an indication there.
00:51:59.550 --> 00:52:03.789
In doing that, anything stand out to either of you with this Columbia bar?
00:52:04.349 --> 00:52:08.030
To me, it smells less roasty than I would have expected.
00:52:08.190 --> 00:52:24.510
Um you know, we're we're taught in in beer that you can't really smell textures or primary tastes, obviously, but it it smells like it's gonna be smoother and creamier um than I would have anticipated for a bar that's I think 70% cacao.
00:52:24.670 --> 00:52:25.070
Yeah.
00:52:25.470 --> 00:52:38.670
Yeah, one thing with that, uh, while the the percentage obviously tells you how much cacao is in there, the relative roast level of how how significantly they've roasted those beans could vary within that.
00:52:38.829 --> 00:52:47.390
Uh and then obviously, of course, origin to origin, you can get some difference, but depending on the roast profile, you might get more or less of that intensity.
00:52:47.869 --> 00:52:56.910
Yeah, and the road the roast roasty or toasty character there is reminds me more of mixed nuts than it does of say coffee.
00:52:57.470 --> 00:52:57.869
Sure.
00:52:58.510 --> 00:53:05.390
If I'm not mistaken, uh this is one of their more uh approachable origins that they're doing.
00:53:05.550 --> 00:53:14.430
It is more kind of classically chocolatey, you know, rather than being something that has a bunch of different exotic descriptors that we're gonna be coming up with.
00:53:14.510 --> 00:53:19.630
So I feel like that that nutty kind of creamy profile probably makes sense.
00:53:19.950 --> 00:53:20.190
All right.
00:53:20.269 --> 00:53:23.470
Next thing you're gonna do, put it on your tongue, let it melt.
00:53:23.630 --> 00:53:26.030
Uh, I would encourage you not to chew it.
00:53:26.190 --> 00:53:36.590
You can break it up with your teeth, but don't necessarily like chew it with your molars so much as just break it up into small pieces so you're exposing surface area and then just letting
that melt on your tongue.
00:53:36.990 --> 00:53:43.230
Well-tempered chocolate uh melts just a few degrees below body temperature.
00:53:43.630 --> 00:53:49.230
So it generally does need to sit on your tongue for a few seconds before it really starts melting and releasing those.
00:53:49.390 --> 00:54:01.470
So one of the reasons when pairing with beer, it's so important to allow the chocolate to melt first before you take a sip of the beer, because otherwise it just locks it in place and it won't melt and release those aromatics.
00:54:02.269 --> 00:54:06.349
I would say that to me, that unfolds a lot differently than I anticipated.
00:54:06.430 --> 00:55:28.849
It's as it's beginning to melt, it's definitely like a a lot of almond butter sensation.
00:55:29.490 --> 00:55:34.930
I don't I don't know a lot about um craft chocolate other than I enjoy it immensely.
00:55:35.090 --> 00:55:40.690
Um and I and I do seek out single origin bars in particular.
00:55:40.769 --> 00:55:44.530
I just kind of like want to know what cacao from a region might taste like.
00:55:44.849 --> 00:55:50.769
But from what you've said about the tempering quality, I mean it's a really uniform melt over the tongue.
00:55:51.170 --> 00:55:58.530
It kind of starts to wash with this almond butter type of character to me, and then like a classic cocoa.
00:55:58.769 --> 00:56:02.289
But then after a few seconds, there's something distinctly fruity.
00:56:02.530 --> 00:56:08.050
It's very like almost um plum, like a like a juicy plum.
00:56:08.450 --> 00:56:11.650
Yeah, I'm getting a little bit of uh of that.
00:56:11.809 --> 00:56:40.289
It's a little bit of like um like a toasted hazelnut, and also just I would say kind of like a very uh kind of like ripe, uh like peach uh kind of flavor, uh, and then just kind of like an indistinct kind of florality, like kind of kind of reminds me of like a freshly picked, you know, peach with the stem, you know, still on it with some of the you know, kind of the leafy herbaceousness still in the background.
00:56:40.610 --> 00:56:46.050
So Scott, uh do you have a little bit of familiarity and background with craft chocolate?
00:56:46.450 --> 00:56:47.250
Only a little bit.
00:56:47.409 --> 00:56:53.409
During the during the pandemic, I did beer, cheese, and chocolate pairings via Zoom.
00:56:53.889 --> 00:57:04.849
And uh so I've got some of the kind of like more popular, like, you know, chocolate books, and a lot of the stuff you're you're talking about, I'm um I'm very familiar with.
00:57:04.930 --> 00:57:08.289
And much like Chris, like I enjoy craft chocolate.
00:57:08.450 --> 00:57:11.329
Um, I'm a particularly a fan of of dandelion.
00:57:11.570 --> 00:57:21.409
I have family in San Francisco, and whenever I'm there, I always go there and try some of the interesting stuff they only have that, you know, maybe it's harder for them to ship uh and that sort of thing.
00:57:21.730 --> 00:57:31.730
But uh and then obviously I've bought uh any of the like chocolate pairing books that you've um produced, I've I've definitely have those in my library as well.
00:57:31.889 --> 00:57:45.730
So uh definitely had some uh you know some beer and chocolate pairing uh experience, but no, nothing like going to a chocolate tasting on you know on my own or anything like you were, uh like you were kind of mentioning with the you know coffee cupping.
00:57:46.130 --> 00:57:46.450
Sure.
00:57:46.610 --> 00:57:49.570
No, but that's cool uh that you've got a little bit of background with it.
00:57:49.889 --> 00:57:54.690
And then of course, the the last thing that you're paying attention to uh as you're you're tasting it is that texture.
00:57:54.849 --> 00:58:04.610
You know, you had Chris, you had used the word creamy in describing the the aroma, which you know you you you explained obviously isn't something you can smell, but you get that indication.
00:58:04.849 --> 00:58:06.610
What did you feel about the melt here?
00:58:06.769 --> 00:58:09.090
Did you get that kind of creamy texture?
00:58:09.250 --> 00:58:11.970
How would you describe that mouthfeel?
00:58:12.530 --> 00:58:22.450
Yeah, it was I would say that it's creamy, but it is more like a either a syrup or like a honey that has no grit to it.
00:58:22.610 --> 00:58:27.889
So it's tongue-coating, but not oppressively so.
00:58:27.970 --> 00:58:29.570
Um, it still has some lift.
00:58:29.730 --> 00:58:53.730
I think the the fruit notes really help with that perceptually, but yeah, I would I would train change it from like generically creamy, which evokes vanilla and dairy and those things, and more to like a like a sugar solution, like a like a honey or a chocolate syrup, like a really good chocolate syrup, not a not a fake one, but yeah, it's it's got that texture to it to me.
00:58:54.050 --> 00:58:54.450
Very cool.
00:58:54.690 --> 00:59:03.329
Yeah, it's got a it's got a very uh yeah, kind of approachable density to the uh to the melt.
00:59:03.409 --> 00:59:07.970
It's not sort of this kind of cloying kind of sensation.
00:59:08.450 --> 00:59:18.610
One thing that helped me uh a lot with understanding texture in chocolate was understanding a little bit of the chocolate making process.
00:59:18.690 --> 00:59:23.329
It you know, it this does get liquefied before it becomes a solid.
00:59:23.490 --> 00:59:29.570
And so that that fat is getting melted and you are you're getting what we call chocolate liquor.
00:59:29.650 --> 00:59:35.170
And so it is becoming basically a a syrup, a sauce, and then getting rehardened.
00:59:35.250 --> 00:59:51.970
And so when you're tasting it in that solid form, it's very easy to recognize that earlier gestational stage for it where it's like this this was a liquid and it kind of wants to be a liquid, and it's wanting to to melt and turn into that format.
00:59:52.289 --> 01:00:23.409
And is there is there a wide variation when when people are you know crafting this and and wondering how how they sort
of want it you know to melt, or is there just kind of like a gold, you know, standard of like this is kind of where you I'm kind of trying to think, is it kind of like cheese where there's some cheeses where it's like you're gonna have a more crumbly, you know, and there's kind of levels of hardness to the texture, all the way down to you know, some that are you know just themselves calling them, you know, calling them a solid seems like a lie.
01:00:23.570 --> 01:00:23.730
Right.
01:00:24.610 --> 01:00:27.170
Oh, they're they're runny if if if anything.
01:00:27.490 --> 01:00:33.809
So the higher the percentage of the cacao butter that's in a bar, the more likely it is to melt.
01:00:33.889 --> 01:00:50.769
So when you're looking at something like uh a uh lower percentage milk chocolate, where there's gonna be they're adding in some of that butter or white chocolate, which is chocolate, but there's no cacao solids, it's just the cacao butter, you're gonna expect those to melt at a lower temperature.
01:00:50.849 --> 01:00:58.849
Once you get into dark chocolate, higher percentage milk chocolates, there's gonna be a difference to the texture of that melt.
01:00:59.090 --> 01:01:07.650
And you can definitely, once you get familiar with them, uh start employing language to describe how how readily this wants to melt.
01:01:07.730 --> 01:01:31.170
But in terms of actual temperature, it's it's roughly within a pretty narrow range in there when it's properly tempered, because the specific physical format that the fat crystals have to be in is like one specific format, like that these you have to hit these temperature thresholds up and down uh to be able to get it to turn into this particular type of fat crystal.
01:01:31.329 --> 01:01:35.409
So once it's in that, there's a pretty, pretty uniform range.
01:01:35.490 --> 01:01:36.369
Um gotcha.
01:01:36.690 --> 01:01:42.610
But that is gonna change a little bit as you go down in percentage and you're getting away from those cacao solids uh as much.
01:01:43.490 --> 01:01:45.409
Let's go ahead and uh taste the second bar.
01:01:45.490 --> 01:01:50.530
So this other one is from Uganda, Semeliki Forest, same percentage.
01:01:51.170 --> 01:01:59.570
Uh, and I think this is a really fun opportunity tasting the same maker at the same percentage because now the only thing we're changing is cacao origin.
01:02:00.130 --> 01:02:15.010
Uh so it's it's kind of like tasting the same breweries, three IPAs where they're just doing three different hops, and you're eliminating any other variables, and all you're now seeing is uh you know the difference in these three smash beers or something like that.
01:02:15.329 --> 01:02:15.809
Right.
01:02:16.130 --> 01:02:23.090
It's distinctly darker than the than the first one, uh, is the first thing the first thing that I notice.
01:02:23.329 --> 01:02:25.329
There's definitely a color difference.
01:02:25.650 --> 01:02:27.250
Yeah, similar sheen.
01:02:27.409 --> 01:02:35.010
Um it's the same kind of emboss on the square, but yeah, definitely a shade or two darker.
01:02:35.809 --> 01:02:36.130
Nice.
01:02:36.369 --> 01:02:42.130
Can you tell we study together and I won't ask you SRM on the chocolate.
01:02:43.250 --> 01:02:44.130
24.
01:02:45.010 --> 01:02:51.170
Yeah, go ahead and go through uh that same process and feel free, either one of you to say anything that's standing out throughout there.
01:02:51.650 --> 01:02:57.730
Kind of skipped audibly describing aroma, but it was definitely less nutty on first pass.
01:02:58.369 --> 01:03:05.809
More almost smelled like um bushberries of some kind, like like red currants or something like that.
01:03:06.210 --> 01:03:10.849
Yeah, I was gonna say raspberry on the on the palate for sure.
01:03:11.490 --> 01:03:13.650
It switches directly to raspberry on the palate.
01:03:13.809 --> 01:03:15.809
It was like raspberry, mulberry.
01:03:16.690 --> 01:03:17.970
This is like a wave.
01:03:18.130 --> 01:03:28.050
I mean, this is like like amber, like amber, you know, honey that like leads into yeah, red raspberry.
01:03:28.289 --> 01:03:32.289
I forget what the what the original fruit you were saying on the on the aroma was.
01:03:32.369 --> 01:03:33.409
That's definitely kind of in there.
01:03:33.809 --> 01:03:34.289
Red currant.
01:03:35.010 --> 01:03:36.130
Yeah, red currant, yeah.
01:03:36.289 --> 01:03:44.530
Red currant for sure, kind of like uh yeah, this very like tropical, uh, you know, kind of almost tropical red, you know, red fruit.
01:03:45.490 --> 01:03:47.970
And there's some dried fruit characteristic too.
01:03:48.050 --> 01:03:50.690
Like we get in get in multi beers a lot.
01:03:50.769 --> 01:03:57.570
It's like a it's not like a bright vibrant cherry, it's like dried cherry in a trail mix, basically.
01:03:58.130 --> 01:04:01.650
But raspberry, I think, is the best immediate descriptor.
01:04:01.730 --> 01:04:12.930
It's almost it almost even has akin to the peach stem on the last chocolate, the seed, you know, it has like a tannic seed like quality to it as well.
01:04:13.090 --> 01:04:14.930
But that doesn't impact the texture.
01:04:15.090 --> 01:04:17.409
The texture is very similar to the first one.
01:04:17.730 --> 01:04:22.130
I was gonna ask, if do you feel like there is any kind of astringency along with that?
01:04:22.530 --> 01:04:27.010
There there's maybe a little more, it might just be more chocolate on the palate, more uh more.
01:04:27.490 --> 01:04:28.610
That's what I was wondering too.
01:04:28.690 --> 01:04:29.090
Yeah.
01:04:29.409 --> 01:04:37.570
But yeah, maybe a less dense, uh uh, it seems like a less dense creamy honey texture character than than the first chocolate.
01:04:37.889 --> 01:04:53.650
Yeah, and also the uh Chris saying that it kind of smells less distinctly, kind of like, you know, kind of like what maybe we would associate with kind of milk chocolatey, it doesn't really it definitely doesn't kind of
present that way on on the palette either.
01:04:53.730 --> 01:04:58.130
I'm trying to think of what that's I'm I'm I'm right with Chris.
01:04:58.210 --> 01:05:07.090
I'm like, okay, if you're talking about the base chocolate, like think about it like you're describing malt, like you're what is it like how do you how are you describing the soul of this of this chocolate bar?
01:05:07.329 --> 01:05:10.050
Well, I'm curious, uh, and this is not a leading question.
01:05:10.210 --> 01:05:27.170
I'm not tasting the bars with you to uh to to be able to to know, but uh when you're describing it as having a lighter texture, do you think that is actually organic to the mouthfeel, or is that those brighter flavors kind of pulling it up and making it making it seem less heavy?
01:05:27.490 --> 01:05:29.090
I think it's the latter.
01:05:29.170 --> 01:05:52.690
I'm I was thinking through that when I was describing the the little bit of fruit lift on the first chocolate, but the second one, the um semaliki, is so fruity and berry in character that I think that it's especially on the retro nasal, is so lively that it's almost tricking me into thinking that the that the that it's lighter, that the body of the chocolate is lighter.
01:05:52.930 --> 01:06:00.530
But if um I didn't uh maybe I will on the next little piece, but I didn't like plug my nose to try to really sit with the texture only.
01:06:01.010 --> 01:06:09.490
But I I wouldn't be surprised if it was more similar to the first one than I thought, and that it's the it's the fruit notes doing the heavy lifting or little light lifting in this case.
01:06:09.889 --> 01:06:13.090
Yeah, because it really is it, yeah, it really is the power.
01:06:13.250 --> 01:06:18.610
I mean, the for people listening, the power of perception and and sensory is is very, very real.
01:06:19.090 --> 01:06:32.289
Um and uh I I mean, just if told to describe the two textures, I would say the first one is I agree, kind of this more like thicker, kind of more syrupy uh kind of thing.
01:06:32.369 --> 01:06:41.730
And this is more maybe just like if you're talking like like a chocolate pudding, but on like the the most dense, you know, end of that possible.
01:06:41.889 --> 01:06:49.889
Um, but just a just a little bit airier to it, to the perception is what I would assume.
01:06:50.450 --> 01:06:51.329
Yeah, I love that.
01:06:51.490 --> 01:06:59.970
I love uh hearing you guys talk about these bars when they are basically identical bars, just different cacao origins, and how much of a role that that plays.
01:07:00.210 --> 01:07:02.610
Oh man, it's fascinating.
01:07:03.010 --> 01:07:04.289
Well, what are your takeaways?
01:07:04.450 --> 01:07:13.650
Uh obviously you've uh you both had chocolate before, but I mean just sitting here now and tasting these two side by side, any thoughts or takeaways you have from the experience?
01:07:14.050 --> 01:07:24.610
Mine to me, since we have chocolate from the same chocolate maker, um,
and it's just different origins, it's it, I mean, it's the power of of origin.
01:07:25.490 --> 01:07:33.570
It's you know, the the whatever philosophy of chocolate making is in the is in these bars is hard to compare when they're both from dandelion.
01:07:33.970 --> 01:07:49.250
So that that experience is maybe flattened in favor of this is what hopefully is what Semaliki Forest evokes for me now is a much like livelier, fruitier, top note type of coffee.
01:07:49.329 --> 01:07:52.289
Um, and the Colombian chocolate uh I said coffee.
01:07:52.450 --> 01:07:57.250
I uh I came into uh this from a coffee nerd angle even before beer.
01:07:57.329 --> 01:08:01.570
So a lot of a lot of stuff I borrowed from that, but I meant chocolate, not coffee.
01:08:01.730 --> 01:08:04.289
The Colombian one is more it's interesting.
01:08:04.450 --> 01:08:11.970
I didn't realize that this was maybe intentionally one of their more approachable craft chocolates, but it it tastes like that to me.
01:08:12.050 --> 01:08:20.210
It you know, it's it's nutty, it's like what you would think of a craft chocolate should taste like in terms of like its chocolate density.
01:08:20.369 --> 01:08:22.690
You know, we talk about beer that tastes like beer.
01:08:22.770 --> 01:08:30.289
Um, I think that the first square has a you know, it's got an essence of chocolate that tastes like chocolate in it.
01:08:30.369 --> 01:08:38.210
Um, and the the um the African chocolate is completely upends those expectations.
01:08:38.369 --> 01:08:41.170
Yeah, it's very cool experiment side by side.
01:08:41.409 --> 01:08:47.810
I love how much tasting outside of our target area can just make us better tasters.
01:08:48.050 --> 01:08:57.890
You know, even if your goal is just to be a better beer taster, taste wine, geek out on coffee, like just explore widely.
01:08:58.210 --> 01:09:11.970
Not only do you gain knowledge on uh how different types of people talk about the sensory experience in these different segments, but your your range of flavor references, uh, all of those things expand.
01:09:12.610 --> 01:09:13.970
Well, that's true.
01:09:14.450 --> 01:09:17.490
And we need help in beer in some respects on that.
01:09:17.650 --> 01:09:24.850
Um, I think we have a very limited set of ways to define the texture of a beer.
01:09:24.930 --> 01:09:31.809
You know, we sort of talk about carbonation and volumes and give it a little, you know, low to high range.
01:09:31.970 --> 01:09:42.050
Um, and it might be sweet finishing or dry and astringent, but like I always look up to the wine community and their ability to describe the texture of a wine.
01:09:42.210 --> 01:09:44.849
They just have so many more tools at their disposal.
01:09:45.010 --> 01:10:02.769
Um, so I crib a lot from wine, and I think chocolate has some overlap of the Venn diagram there, where you're forced to use and learn different descriptures for texture and the mouthfeel of it because it's so far outside of the realm of our
normal.
01:10:03.329 --> 01:10:04.769
beer sensory experience.
01:10:05.090 --> 01:10:05.329
Yeah.
01:10:05.409 --> 01:10:18.689
I would say anybody who I do education for, uh, any of my students that I teach through Beer Scholar, what usually when it's how do I get better at at beer sensory, it's usually twofold.
01:10:18.849 --> 01:10:22.769
Uh the first one is it's going to be really hard if you're doing it by yourself.
01:10:22.930 --> 01:10:39.250
Uh it's I mean I I didn't understand that until our advanced Cicero study group during the pandemic where it was just like even just with three or four other people just talking about it together, totally enriches your your vocabulary.
01:10:39.409 --> 01:10:41.010
It expands your vocabulary.
01:10:41.250 --> 01:10:44.849
It helps you to see things that maybe you you didn't notice.
01:10:45.329 --> 01:10:50.130
But then most of the time it's you gotta smell other stuff that's not beer.
01:10:50.289 --> 01:10:50.529
Yeah.
01:10:50.609 --> 01:10:53.729
Uh because there is just tons of overlap.
01:10:54.050 --> 01:10:56.050
I mean it's it's fermentation.
01:10:56.130 --> 01:10:58.689
You can you can ferment a lot of different things.
01:10:58.769 --> 01:11:02.289
And so there's just always going to be some kind of overlap.
01:11:02.689 --> 01:12:50.210
And thankfully there are some there's so much overlap in these different industries partnering together and just having chocolate in beer you know is uh I I love that there's a lot more breweries that are doing things where it's we're releasing this set of six or seven beers and it's uh you know one uh a brewery here locally Bottle Logic did it and they did it with seven different vanilla varietals from different places and it was just it was again rather than a single hop it was single you know vanilla variety and it was it was much like this it it was very much like the the chocolate was just or the sorry the vanilla was just singing and and they just all had a different note to them that even in some cases may the beers be perceived to be sweeter drier uh you know have different textures uh and so it's this is no different the chocolate is chocolate is no different I find that kind of exercise very very helpful i i've noticed as a taster I struggle sometimes when I don't have comparative references so my weakest panel even when I passed the advanced exam was style discrimination because if you give me all four of the beers that are options here yes of course I could I think I can go through and say which is which and and compare them but one in isolation you don't have that that bracket on either side is to to you know reference to and so being able to do this kind of exercise where you're changing one thing and so that's the only real variable that you have to uh that that most of your focus can go to is a wonderful training experience.
01:12:50.289 --> 01:13:04.930
And Chris to what you were uh talking about from a texture standpoint I think one of
the reasons chocolate offers such a cool opportunity to evaluate texture is because the physical food changes format in your mouth.
01:13:05.170 --> 01:13:23.409
You know beer you're drinking as a liquid you're swallowing as a liquid you it's maybe going to foam up but all you have to to be able to evaluate it is just like all right the liquid is there I've got to figure out how to describe this that chocolate is starting as one thing and it is slowly melting and changing.
01:13:23.489 --> 01:13:29.730
And so you are getting that evolution of texture and you are kind of forced to contend with that during the tasting process.
01:13:29.890 --> 01:13:30.529
It's very cool.
01:13:30.850 --> 01:14:25.970
I like that a lot well uh last thing I want to talk about uh just on a kind of fun note you guys loved Doppelbach and uh you are you are trying to popularize uh Doppelbach you've got the hashtag on Instagram drink more Doppelbach where did this start well so it it it kind of has two main origins they they stem from a similar spot but we in all the studying that we've done Doppelbach from time to time ends up on a you know a style identification panel and it started as a casual joke where you know after the tasting evening is done whatever the samples that you're going back to you know or that you hadn't had in a while and you really like and we'd just be sitting there and be like man have you guys ever had Doppelbach before it's pretty good um and just you know kind of joking about it in in that way.
01:14:26.609 --> 01:14:39.090
I also remember early on being like staking out my claim that I already said use the phrase beer that tastes like beer and we use that usually to mean like macro american lager.
01:14:39.970 --> 01:14:45.649
And I I would make the claim in our study sessions I'd be like no Doppelbach is beer that tastes like beer.
01:14:45.890 --> 01:14:55.329
Macro macro lager is intentionally tastes like lit little else you know it's it's um it's it's built to not taste like much.
01:14:55.569 --> 01:15:35.250
And Doppelbach is so densely Munich malty that I was like this is this is what I when I taste it I think this is what the soul of beer is like this is the most beery beer that I could that I could possibly pick off of a shelf um and then it kind of morphed into this hilarious bit where we were just like you know not not only is Doppelbach delicious but you can just like get Weinstefner Corbinian at the store right now for$399 a 500 milliliter bottle and have a world class beer for a very low price compared to the way prices for a lot of things are going right now.
01:15:35.489 --> 01:16:07.250
And nobody's even going to try to stop you you it this there's little to no resistance yeah we just we and so yeah and then it was just like in every in you know hyper specific scenario we were just like more evidence has been gathered and even in this even in this hyper specific scenario they still will not stop you from and then that even morphed even further into hashtag everything is doppelbach where it was well Munich Dunkel you mean Munich Dunkel you you mean session doppelbach is is what you're talking about, right?
01:16:07.329 --> 01:16:46.529
Or you know uh that sort of thing so a few years ago I had a uh friend who was playing a concert at a dead end dive bar uh and it was one of those so so we go in I've never been in the bar before and they've got a couple things on tap but they had a uh bottle and can list and it was one of those things where I'm looking at it and I'm like what sales rep came in and convinced them to buy some of these beers this is not their this is not their scene and they had bottles of Corbinian for a couple bucks so we sat in this just shitty dive bar listening to my friend play music just drinking bottles of Corbinion all night.
01:16:46.690 --> 01:16:51.489
Uh great great memory what kind of reach have you had with drink more doppelback?
01:16:51.569 --> 01:18:02.369
Like I feel like it shows up in my feed fairly often I see other some other now and then yeah we are starting to get like a good solid like you know one to two people a day like posting and tagging us and we're you know we we've got kind of our like set of our you know small circle here where it's like okay make sure to tag everybody you know in this so that we can you know kind of continue to you know kind of have this something that's hardly a viral moment by you know most people's standards but um I mean for us it was viral enough that like I got us t-shirts made with the very first Instagram post with the hashtag on it like as the you know as the front of the t-shirt and hashtag drinkmore doppelback um on the back and it you know I I think it's the the other thing the other thing to me is I've started listening to a lot more kind of like where's the industry going and people's predictions for the year and so many people are predicting that like multi-beers are gonna be the beers of 2026 yet nobody nobody mentions that Doppelbach is specifically going to be a part of that to of that movement and to to that I just say you have you have missed the point.
01:18:02.529 --> 01:18:22.690
Like you this is yeah I just think it's it's got range in all sorts of different ways and like Chris said we believe that it's beer flavored beer and anybody who this reaches who thinks this is cool and helps them to rediscover this style like whatever reach we end up do having with it like to me that's the the most fun part.
01:18:23.010 --> 01:18:37.970
Do each of you have a single favorite Doppelbach I I I always claim that Ondex Doppelbach is my favorite with maybe Corbinian being the one B, you know those those vi for my heart uh the most for sure.
01:18:38.289 --> 01:18:59.010
Yeah I and I would say it's Corbinian um especially since I've had that in Germany at the brewery um and then I would say the other one is uh is celebrator and uh uh honestly it's probably because it's the one that I could
call the exact beer blind the most of all the Doppelpox during during our study time.
01:18:59.090 --> 01:19:04.690
So I just felt like I was just like really honed in on that and that it you know would always speak to me.
01:19:05.010 --> 01:19:05.489
That's great.
01:19:05.649 --> 01:19:08.609
Well hey ondex is why we have Trog's Troganator.
01:19:08.850 --> 01:19:12.770
So it it inspired our most popular American doppelbox.
01:19:13.010 --> 01:19:21.329
Yeah yeah and you can still get 12 packs of Troganators so that's an excellent way to hashtag drinkmore doppelbock is to buy 12 at a time.
01:19:21.649 --> 01:19:22.130
There you go.
01:19:22.289 --> 01:19:36.690
Hey they're coming out with a new year round American stout they're just bringing back all the classes wow I love it I love it yeah wow all right well scott and Chris thank you so much for hanging out with me tonight tasting some chocolate talking beer I love geeking out with you guys.
01:19:37.010 --> 01:19:49.890
Oh too much too much fun thank you so much for the for the invite so this has been great appreciate you David thank you huge thanks to Scott and Chris for hanging out and discussing this stuff with me.
01:19:50.130 --> 01:20:01.569
Just as they have been so open and honest about their own preparation processes for these exams they are both also equally eager to help others doing the same no matter where you are in your own journey.
01:20:01.730 --> 01:20:03.409
I hope that can be said of me as well.
01:20:03.970 --> 01:20:27.569
The goal of eliminating gatekeeping in beer isn't to pretend there was never anything on the other side of that exclusionary gate, but to instead provide access to knowledge for anyone who wants it while accepting everyone wherever they are on that path, even if they plan to stay where they are beer is for everyone everyone gets to enjoy it how they want and if that means growing in knowledge for you ask us anything you'd like.
01:20:28.850 --> 01:20:35.890
Some of the topics Scott and Chris and I discussed around flavor language tie back to some noteworthy past episodes of Bean to Barstool.
01:20:36.289 --> 01:20:49.329
The very first seed of this podcast was planted out of a talk I gave back in 2019 about culturally informed flavor vocabulary and how the tasting experience can bring us together to learn more about each other.
01:20:49.569 --> 01:20:53.010
And the very first episode of Bean to Barstool focused on that.
01:20:53.250 --> 01:20:55.970
A little while later I spoke with the inimitable Dr.
01:20:56.050 --> 01:20:56.210
J.
01:20:56.369 --> 01:20:58.770
Jackson Beckham about this in further detail.
01:20:58.930 --> 01:21:03.730
I will link to both of those past episodes in the show notes as well as my conversation with M.
01:21:03.890 --> 01:21:06.850
Souter who was mentioned in today's conversation.
01:21:07.409 --> 01:21:19.569
One quick craft chocolate note before we sign off I just saw that Gansett Craft Chocolate has released a Battlecry whiskey bar using a whiskey from Sons of Liberty Spirits.
01:21:19.649 --> 01:21:29.329
So they used a 2017 batch of Battlecry beer barrel finished whiskey soaked Peruvian chuncho cacao nibs in it and made a 70% bar out of it.
01:21:29.489 --> 01:21:38.130
It looks like it is only available out of their craft chocolate shop, not online if anybody's had a chance to try it I would love to hear what you thought about it.
01:21:38.369 --> 01:21:41.489
Thanks so much to Scott and Chris for joining me on the show today.
01:21:41.649 --> 01:21:46.609
Thanks to everyone else for listening I hope you enjoyed this episode of Bean to Bar Store