প্রতিলিপি 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:03.308 --> 00:00:04.189
G'day, humans.
2
00:00:04.369 --> 00:00:07.270
Welcome to the safe space for dangerous ideas.
3
00:00:07.391 --> 00:00:14.355
And you are in for a treat because this is one of my favourite all-time episodes of Uncomfortable Conversations.
4
00:00:14.895 --> 00:00:30.265
It actually is dredged up from the archive, partly because the audience of this show is growing so quickly and has certainly grown so much in the past five years that if you are an average listener, you will not have been subscribed in November of 2021 when I had this conversation with you.
5
00:00:32.086 --> 00:00:37.850
Also, if you did hear it back then, then you, like me, will get a lot of joy out of re-listening to it.
6
00:00:37.890 --> 00:00:43.794
I was thinking about it the other day as I was listening to Tim Urban and just marveling at what an amazing mind he is.
7
00:00:44.415 --> 00:00:47.957
His TED Talk is where I first learned of him.
8
00:00:48.058 --> 00:00:51.320
It's called Inside the Mind of a Master Procrastinator.
9
00:00:51.560 --> 00:00:54.862
and it's one of the most masterful TED Talks you will ever see.
10
00:00:54.922 --> 00:01:06.631
Really, it's an amazing and punch-in-the-gut kind of analysis of the way we all fool ourselves about not getting around to the big projects that what our hearts want us to do.
11
00:01:07.151 --> 00:01:10.794
It's had combined views in excess of 100 million by now.
12
00:01:11.454 --> 00:01:13.656
Tim is a blogger by profession.
13
00:01:13.756 --> 00:01:14.597
His blog is awesome.
14
00:01:14.657 --> 00:01:16.238
It's called Wait But Why?,
15
00:01:16.478 --> 00:01:18.479
He has half a million Twitter followers.
16
00:01:18.819 --> 00:01:23.602
And this conversation is really one about the biggest questions of human existence.
17
00:01:24.123 --> 00:01:25.763
Will we all go extinct?
18
00:01:26.124 --> 00:01:29.566
What is the pace of technological change and what does it mean for us?
19
00:01:30.226 --> 00:01:35.069
How do we contextualize it in the overall duration of human history?
20
00:01:35.329 --> 00:01:37.090
Is there extraterrestrial life?
21
00:01:37.150 --> 00:01:42.594
What are the good arguments for it, the bad arguments for it, given the sheer size of the cosmos?
22
00:01:42.955 --> 00:01:45.937
How does procrastination work and the human mind work?
23
00:01:46.037 --> 00:01:53.763
It's always delightful to sit down with Tim, and the fact that this happened five years ago only makes it age like a fine red wine.
24
00:01:54.123 --> 00:01:59.367
Carve out a little window of time, and please enjoy, as much as I did, the one and only Tim Urban.
25
00:02:10.687 --> 00:02:15.110
I have been buried in trying to finish a book, and now I have finished the book.
26
00:02:15.130 --> 00:02:16.771
So that is a nice development.
27
00:02:17.051 --> 00:02:17.331
Yeah.
28
00:02:17.811 --> 00:02:21.093
That's better than the alternative of throwing your arms up in the air and going, fuck this thing.
29
00:02:21.113 --> 00:02:22.034
I'm never going to get this done.
30
00:02:22.174 --> 00:02:22.954
I don't care anyway.
31
00:02:23.635 --> 00:02:23.955
Yeah.
32
00:02:24.275 --> 00:02:25.016
You're not my mommy.
33
00:02:25.276 --> 00:02:26.036
You don't control me.
34
00:02:26.416 --> 00:02:27.077
You're not my daddy.
35
00:02:27.677 --> 00:02:28.157
Exactly.
36
00:02:29.438 --> 00:02:31.658
Well, it's great.
37
00:02:32.079 --> 00:02:35.620
I'm so happy that the book is also the same style as the blog.
38
00:02:35.680 --> 00:02:40.161
I wasn't sure if you were going to try to put on a wonky hat and pontificate a little bit more.
39
00:02:40.961 --> 00:02:42.722
But I like the fact that there are cartoons.
40
00:02:43.542 --> 00:02:45.063
But what I might... Yeah, yeah, yeah.
41
00:02:45.263 --> 00:02:51.305
I guess I'm most interested in what made you want to come out as a white supremacist after all these years.
42
00:02:51.325 --> 00:02:51.545
Yeah.
43
00:02:52.972 --> 00:03:00.995
Well, I was, you know, I just, it was always in me, and I just eventually couldn't hold it in anymore.
44
00:03:01.416 --> 00:03:02.776
You know what hasn't happened enough?
45
00:03:02.976 --> 00:03:09.379
White, straight males haven't been talking enough, and I'm going to write a book about why we have to think straight.
46
00:03:10.199 --> 00:03:10.660
That's right.
47
00:03:10.800 --> 00:03:11.240
I kid you.
48
00:03:11.260 --> 00:03:11.600
That's right.
49
00:03:11.700 --> 00:03:15.282
I kid you, but nonetheless, there will be some people who will take it that way.
50
00:03:16.242 --> 00:03:16.562
Correct.
51
00:03:16.903 --> 00:03:17.223
For sure.
52
00:03:17.624 --> 00:03:18.204
Does that bother you?
53
00:03:19.746 --> 00:03:25.592
And it's like, well, if you think about what that means, if you feel that pressure.
54
00:03:25.652 --> 00:03:27.154
So of course I felt the pressure, you know,
55
00:03:28.576 --> 00:03:29.657
write about any other topic.
56
00:03:30.178 --> 00:03:31.479
Why this topic?
57
00:03:32.500 --> 00:03:34.302
And with all the shit I'm going to get.
58
00:03:34.923 --> 00:03:38.606
But then I'm thinking about, well, who's giving me shit?
59
00:03:38.626 --> 00:03:43.992
It's not my readers, not my main readers who love when I go nuanced and talk about whatever.
60
00:03:45.934 --> 00:03:46.714
They have no problem.
61
00:03:46.834 --> 00:03:51.839
So it's other people, or it's a very small minority of my readers, and it's just a certain group of people who –
62
00:03:52.865 --> 00:03:55.787
it's not just that they disagree because a lot of people will disagree with points.
63
00:03:56.328 --> 00:04:03.793
It's a specifically, it's a specific, very small subset of the people who disagree, who want to pressure people to,
64
00:04:04.545 --> 00:04:14.237
who disagree with them to be silent and they're going to make it so unpleasant for people to, to, to disagree with them that they make the decision not to.
65
Load full transcript
00:04:14.257 --> 00:04:22.807
And so when I felt that pressure, I realized like that's what's happening is there's a small group of bullies that are, that, that, you know, that, that I'm feeling the pressure of the, of,
66
00:04:24.397 --> 00:04:28.721
And I was like, you know, that's not a reason to drive my writing decisions.
67
00:04:29.281 --> 00:04:30.783
And yet it does drive so much.
68
00:04:30.923 --> 00:04:41.572
I mean, it's amazing how many people I know who are in the same position as you and I find ourselves, who are behind closed doors when you get brunch with them, say, oh, I wish I could write something about this.
69
00:04:41.592 --> 00:04:42.953
I wish I could say something about this.
70
00:04:43.114 --> 00:04:45.175
But, you know, it's just too hard.
71
00:04:45.235 --> 00:04:46.717
I know the mob is going to come for me.
72
00:04:47.637 --> 00:04:59.281
And I think what you're saying is exactly right, which is a bit similar to what Peter Singer, the philosopher, said when I was at an event with him recently, which became an episode of this podcast, which if people haven't heard, they should go back and listen to that because he's fascinating.
73
00:04:59.621 --> 00:05:00.922
And he was like, it's pretty simple.
74
00:05:01.482 --> 00:05:08.164
Like, are you responding – when I was asking him about getting shit cancel culture-wise, he was like, are you responding to my arguments?
75
00:05:08.764 --> 00:05:15.397
Or are you just saying that the existence of my arguments means that I should be deplatformed without actually making a cogent case against my arguments?
76
00:05:15.418 --> 00:05:16.299
He was like, that's the difference.
77
00:05:16.319 --> 00:05:19.746
He was like, I welcome all pushback against everything, but make an argument.
78
00:05:20.679 --> 00:05:24.242
Don't just say that I shouldn't have the right to even talk about it.
79
00:05:24.562 --> 00:05:30.966
It's that, and it's also the difference between someone who says, those are terrible arguments, and here's why, right?
80
00:05:32.227 --> 00:05:37.231
Or even those are terrible arguments, so I won't read this, or I won't pay attention, or I'll unfollow you.
81
00:05:37.251 --> 00:05:38.371
There's nothing wrong with either of those.
82
00:05:38.391 --> 00:05:39.812
In fact, the first one is great.
83
00:05:39.852 --> 00:05:44.676
That's what makes society smart, is people saying that these are bad arguments, and here's why, right?
84
00:05:44.696 --> 00:05:45.697
That's how we get smarter.
85
00:05:45.717 --> 00:05:46.217
Okay.
86
00:05:46.777 --> 00:05:50.181
It's specifically someone who says those are bad arguments.
87
00:05:50.401 --> 00:05:53.284
So you're a bad person who needs to be punished.
88
00:05:53.444 --> 00:05:57.289
And so it's the attacking specifically of the person, not the arguments.
89
00:05:57.309 --> 00:05:57.909
Yeah, yeah.
90
00:05:57.929 --> 00:06:01.333
Those are the people that we should not be letting drive anything.
91
00:06:01.593 --> 00:06:01.793
Yeah.
92
00:06:02.193 --> 00:06:07.657
And then, of course, they all come back and say, well, what if the argument was we should burn all the Jews?
93
00:06:07.917 --> 00:06:09.638
You know, what should you do about Nazis?
94
00:06:09.678 --> 00:06:11.179
Shouldn't you be critical of Nazis?
95
00:06:12.040 --> 00:06:20.345
And then I would concede that, yes, once you've addressed the argument, once you've addressed using argument, why we shouldn't burn all the Jews, then you're allowed to be mean to Nazis.
96
00:06:20.785 --> 00:06:22.807
But until then, maybe just stick with the argument.
97
00:06:24.848 --> 00:06:25.928
So what is your argument?
98
00:06:25.988 --> 00:06:32.891
So for people who haven't seen the book and who may not even be familiar with you, except through your wonderful work on this very show, what is your argument?
99
00:06:35.892 --> 00:06:52.418
Well, it's my – the way I see a liberal society is it's kind of like a machine that is very complex and relies on a bunch – a very, very complicated system of –
100
00:06:53.390 --> 00:07:18.200
laws and rules, but also relies on a very nuanced system of norms and behavior and values that are kind of commonly shared, liberal values, liberal, lowercase l, liberal, like the core concepts of individual rights and free speech and free markets and equal opportunity
101
00:07:19.221 --> 00:07:27.989
And open discourse and the marketplace of ideas, all of that stuff that I think most Americans, if you polled them, would say, yeah, like regardless of my politics, I'm a lowercase liberal.
102
00:07:28.570 --> 00:07:32.714
So it's this kind of this machine that's a combo of rules and norms.
103
00:07:33.587 --> 00:07:37.410
The rules upheld by the government, the norms upheld by the citizens.
104
00:07:38.330 --> 00:07:43.093
And it's, in one hand, very robust.
105
00:07:43.173 --> 00:07:44.254
They last a long time.
106
00:07:44.915 --> 00:07:45.835
They respond.
107
00:07:46.095 --> 00:07:47.737
They're resilient in the face of challenge.
108
00:07:48.437 --> 00:07:49.798
On the other hand, you know, they're not...
109
00:07:50.825 --> 00:08:16.529
airtight they can be uh they you they can be broken you can and and and they can be uh a liberal society that machine can be if a group is you know uh if they set out to damage the system like they can and that's why the system has kind of an immune system like a like a like an organism and the immune system as i was just saying is made up of people who share these values these
110
00:08:19.550 --> 00:08:20.431
in the face of the threat.
111
00:08:20.952 --> 00:08:31.504
And so that's part of why they were a bust, because in another country, an illiberal group of people could have maybe a bunch of guns and machetes or whatever it is, and they can
112
00:08:32.058 --> 00:08:35.842
make it, you know, they can really take over the country with that because people are so scared.
113
00:08:36.462 --> 00:08:38.624
You
can't use the guns and the machetes here.
114
00:08:38.884 --> 00:08:41.727
And so you have to use kind of soft bullying, social bullying.
115
00:08:41.907 --> 00:08:45.911
And so usually, you know, the system can handle it.
116
00:08:45.991 --> 00:08:54.099
But the reason I wrote this book is that I feel like over the last few years, especially, you know, I started this in 2016 when I started to really feel it.
117
00:08:55.268 --> 00:08:56.809
The system is starting to break down.
118
00:08:56.849 --> 00:08:59.150
The immune system is not doing its job.
119
00:08:59.490 --> 00:09:05.552
And that's why I think it explains a bunch of current political stories that span the political spectrum.
120
00:09:05.592 --> 00:09:08.754
And I think what they all have in common is that the kind of the liberal...
121
00:09:09.763 --> 00:09:14.107
you know, mechanics are not standing strong right now.
122
00:09:14.247 --> 00:09:18.350
And, and illiberal groups are taking advantage.
123
00:09:18.490 --> 00:09:19.812
And so that was the initial point.
124
00:09:19.852 --> 00:09:20.953
As I said, what's our problem?
125
00:09:20.993 --> 00:09:22.134
Why is this happening now?
126
00:09:22.694 --> 00:09:23.895
What's exactly happening?
127
00:09:24.055 --> 00:09:25.476
Is it really as bad as I think it is?
128
00:09:26.157 --> 00:09:26.858
How do we get out of it?
129
00:09:26.918 --> 00:09:28.359
And that was, that's what got me writing.
130
00:09:28.913 --> 00:09:36.156
How did you make sure that the rabbit hole, that rabbit hole of thought doesn't open up and swallow you up and turn you into James Lindsay?
131
00:09:36.597 --> 00:09:48.562
And all of a sudden there are conspiracy theories everywhere with a global elite that is our puppet masters coordinating a plandemic and undermining Western values.
132
00:09:52.970 --> 00:09:53.331
I don't know.
133
00:09:53.431 --> 00:09:54.172
I don't know what it is.
134
00:09:55.513 --> 00:09:59.819
But in this case, that wasn't something that I don't think that's not exactly.
135
00:09:59.859 --> 00:10:02.222
I don't think anybody's point is not the nub of your concern.
136
00:10:03.889 --> 00:10:11.075
Well, the truth is everyone who is kind of fallen too far down conspiracy theory land, they don't believe they are.
137
00:10:11.095 --> 00:10:14.438
So maybe I am, and I am totally self-aware, but I don't think I am.
138
00:10:16.640 --> 00:10:22.446
I think if anything, this process has made me feel – because I think – so what is it when someone is so sure?
139
00:10:22.466 --> 00:10:25.508
Because it's not that – look, sometimes there are conspiracies.
140
00:10:25.629 --> 00:10:29.652
So some conspiracy theories are correct or based in some semblance of truth, right?
141
00:10:29.712 --> 00:10:30.173
So it's not that –
142
00:10:30.893 --> 00:10:32.714
conspiracy theories are necessarily bad.
143
00:10:32.774 --> 00:10:38.516
It's that people who believe them too readily and too often, and that's not good.
144
00:10:38.736 --> 00:10:49.840
And what that says to me is there's a lack of humility because if you have some semblance of humility, you're going to stay, I don't know a lot.
145
00:10:50.560 --> 00:10:55.905
And I think the kind of, you know, profile you're talking about is someone who says, doesn't say, I don't know very often.
146
00:10:55.925 --> 00:10:56.766
They say, oh, I know.
147
00:10:56.946 --> 00:10:57.927
Oh, I know what's happening.
148
00:10:57.947 --> 00:11:00.770
And you all don't know, but this is, and that's just not, I don't know.
149
00:11:00.790 --> 00:11:06.316
It's not my personality, but also writing this book has really, if anything made me feel more humble about what I know.
150
00:11:06.656 --> 00:11:08.318
And the only thing that I'm,
151
00:11:09.428 --> 00:11:16.633
feel really strongly about it, like in terms of actual policy, you know, I have some viewpoints and other ones I would say I'm not sure what I think.
152
00:11:17.073 --> 00:11:21.115
But this book isn't about specific policies or something.
153
00:11:21.155 --> 00:11:25.878
It's much more about things like broad things.
154
00:11:25.918 --> 00:11:30.681
Like I think free speech is not just important, but I think it is a critical function.
155
00:11:30.801 --> 00:11:31.002
Like,
156
00:11:31.842 --> 00:11:47.488
oxygen to a human to a healthy liberal democracy that i feel very strong and what i love about it is you as always you go back so far to first principles i mean the thing is like there are a lot of people wringing their hands about the fate of liberalism and the fate of
157
00:11:48.168 --> 00:11:51.873
Western democracy and can we end the fate of civility and are we all going to be nice?
158
00:11:51.953 --> 00:11:52.914
Are we going to get along?
159
00:11:52.954 --> 00:11:54.676
And free speech is important.
160
00:11:54.757 --> 00:11:58.101
It's a core belief and liberal values and the enlightenment and everything.
161
00:11:58.161 --> 00:12:02.826
And I can see when people talk about that, that people's eyes glaze over a little bit
162
00:12:03.607 --> 00:12:09.350
And there's a little cartoon version of themselves standing on their shoulder going, well, yeah, that's all very well.
163
00:12:09.950 --> 00:12:15.833
Those ideals also served to entrench a fairly unjust system for a long time.
164
00:12:16.013 --> 00:12:30.701
And they were also used by people who were total hypocrites, who might have been in favor of slavery or even Jim Crow, or who might have been quite sanguine about the genocide of First Nations people or about the fact that women were completely not represented in the hallways of power.
165
00:12:31.101 --> 00:12:38.004
So that's fine, but we also need some kind of an equity reckoning as well to make things better today.
166
00:12:38.464 --> 00:12:50.328
And instead of saying, well, yes, but don't go too far, which is what most people respond with, you actually go right back to first principles and go, okay, what makes a
good argument a good argument?
167
00:12:50.748 --> 00:12:53.869
How would we know if we were on the right track or the wrong track?
168
00:12:54.390 --> 00:13:02.133
What has worked like if human history were a 1,000-page book, which is like one of my favorite thought experiments of yours?
169
00:13:03.113 --> 00:13:04.634
So why don't we do that?
170
00:13:04.974 --> 00:13:10.977
Just remind people of the 1,000-page book analogy, and then I want to get to today.
171
00:13:12.888 --> 00:13:13.148
Sure.
172
00:13:14.130 --> 00:13:16.252
So, yeah, I mean, I like to zoom out.
173
00:13:16.312 --> 00:13:21.278
I think zooming out to start a book, to start a blog post, to start any thought process is good, right?
174
00:13:21.338 --> 00:13:26.744
It's like, to me, it's the, you know, the reason that we can see, you know, we have at least some idea of what happened in history.
175
00:13:27.695 --> 00:13:29.697
is because we have hindsight.
176
00:13:30.437 --> 00:13:35.962
And to me, it's a little like, imagine you're on a beach and you're trying to figure out the shape of the coastline.
177
00:13:36.002 --> 00:13:38.044
Are you on a big, someone just plops you on a beach.
178
00:13:38.064 --> 00:13:38.885
You have no idea where you are.
179
00:13:38.925 --> 00:13:39.766
Are you on an island?
180
00:13:39.846 --> 00:13:40.666
Is it a huge island?
181
00:13:40.706 --> 00:13:41.787
Are you on a continent?
182
00:13:42.628 --> 00:13:43.669
It's hard to know what's going on.
183
00:13:43.809 --> 00:13:44.950
And how could you figure it out?
184
00:13:44.970 --> 00:13:48.733
Well, if you somehow had a helicopter and you could go up, up, up, up, up.
185
00:13:49.194 --> 00:13:50.435
Oh, okay, now I can see more.
186
00:13:50.715 --> 00:13:51.696
And you go up even higher.
187
00:13:51.816 --> 00:13:53.798
Okay, now I can see the whole story, right?
188
00:13:54.458 --> 00:13:54.658
And...
189
00:13:57.120 --> 00:14:00.143
And so when we look at history, we have a little bit of that hindsight.
190
00:14:00.163 --> 00:14:02.825
It's like we're kind of up in a helicopter looking at the situation.
191
00:14:03.245 --> 00:14:05.507
But when you're in the present, you don't have that.
192
00:14:05.567 --> 00:14:09.010
You are just looking around trying to figure out what the hell is going on.
193
00:14:09.290 --> 00:14:15.655
And I think that it's hard for people to it's hard to know in your own time what the big story is in 100 years.
194
00:14:15.675 --> 00:14:17.196
And people look back on the 2020s and the 2010s.
195
00:14:18.745 --> 00:14:19.706
it's going to look like something.
196
00:14:19.726 --> 00:14:25.132
There'll be a clearer story about what was really going on, but that's fine for them.
197
00:14:25.232 --> 00:14:27.975
We need to figure it out now because we're actually driving the story.
198
00:14:28.275 --> 00:14:28.956
Those people are not.
199
00:14:28.976 --> 00:14:30.017
They're looking at what happened.
200
00:14:30.237 --> 00:14:33.421
We
can actually do something about it, but we also have the least good view of it.
201
00:14:33.461 --> 00:14:34.242
So I like to zoom out.
202
00:14:34.302 --> 00:14:36.684
And the way I did it with the beginning of this book is I said, all right,
203
00:14:37.525 --> 00:14:43.008
Let's just like zoom out on human history for a second, just to just just to orient ourselves to what the hell is going on.
204
00:14:43.048 --> 00:14:49.872
So, you know, we think it's maybe between 200 and 300,000 years old, depending on exactly what you're calling the borderline.
205
00:14:49.892 --> 00:14:57.097
So I said, OK, just say 250,000 years and let's make a thousand pages, each one with 250 years on it.
206
00:14:57.177 --> 00:14:59.398
If you wrote human history in a thousand page book.
207
00:15:00.225 --> 00:15:07.228
Um, and it was pretty amazing when you look at it like that, because first of all, it's almost all, you know, small tribes of hunter gatherers.
208
00:15:07.268 --> 00:15:09.429
That's who we were for almost all of human history.
209
00:15:10.129 --> 00:15:17.052
Um, and then you get to around 10,000 years ago, you start to have early agriculture and cities and, um, um, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh,
210
00:15:17.192 --> 00:15:22.016
And recorded history only starts on page 975 out of 1,000.
211
00:15:22.096 --> 00:15:30.683
And so almost everything we think of as modern civilization developed in the last 5% of this book, 3% to 5% of this book.
212
00:15:31.664 --> 00:15:35.987
And the crazier thing to me is comparing the very last page, so page 1,000.
213
00:15:36.007 --> 00:15:40.811
So according to this, we're at the very end of page 1,000 right now, about to embark onto the page 1,001.
214
00:15:42.012 --> 00:15:47.597
And if you think of it that way and you compare page 1000 to all the pages before, you understand that –
215
00:15:48.493 --> 00:15:51.014
You know, it seems like it's naive to think we live in such a special time.
216
00:15:51.074 --> 00:15:52.514
Oh, everyone thinks that about their time.
217
00:15:52.534 --> 00:15:57.276
But no, we actually do because page 1000 was the first page.
218
00:15:57.316 --> 00:16:00.077
This goes back to maybe 1770, right?
219
00:16:00.097 --> 00:16:01.918
1773 is 250 years ago.
220
00:16:01.938 --> 00:16:07.500
So all of U.S. history and all modern democracies, they all existed only on page 1000.
221
00:16:07.960 --> 00:16:11.281
Modern transportation, modern communication, anything like that.
222
00:16:11.661 --> 00:16:15.003
All electricity, the power was always out until page 1000.
223
00:16:16.724 --> 00:16:20.768
everything that we define as our modern world is extremely new.
224
00:16:20.808 --> 00:16:27.995
Like, and what the reason it all, it's all so, so much has happened on this page is that technology grows exponentially.
225
00:16:28.075 --> 00:16:32.559
And at some point you kind of hit a tipping point where things start going really, really fast.
226
00:16:32.919 --> 00:16:35.562
So even in our lifetimes, like, like,
227
00:16:35.882 --> 00:16:46.265
We witnessed the birth of the internet, the birth of mobile phones and social media and AI, like, and so many crazy world changing things, like just paradigm shifts, right?
228
00:16:46.525 --> 00:16:50.007
There's a paradigm shift starting every year in a whole different part of the tech world.
229
00:16:50.027 --> 00:16:54.028
So this was my one thought I had, right?
230
00:16:54.048 --> 00:16:55.948
So tech is growing exponentially.
231
00:16:56.309 --> 00:17:01.070
Then the next thought I had was that's not necessarily good or bad because, you know,
232
00:17:01.230 --> 00:17:04.391
More tech creates countless goods, right?
233
00:17:04.771 --> 00:17:11.492
Life, quality of life and medicine and prosperity and GDP per capita and life expectancy.
234
00:17:11.873 --> 00:17:15.313
And all of these things just go up exponentially in the last century.
235
00:17:15.533 --> 00:17:26.716
On the other hand, more technology brought us the biggest world wars of all time, brought us the biggest existential threat of all time in the 20th century with nuclear weapons and climate change and AI and all of this.
236
00:17:26.756 --> 00:17:30.277
And so the good is getting better, but the bad is getting scarier.
237
00:17:31.277 --> 00:17:34.440
if you could sum that up by saying the stakes either way are getting higher.
238
00:17:34.860 --> 00:17:37.482
So it's because of tech, the stakes are getting higher.
239
00:17:37.502 --> 00:17:43.587
Now couple that with what I was seeing around my society, which is that I was seeing wisdom seems to be going down.
240
00:17:44.227 --> 00:17:50.432
We are acting, we're, we're, we're, we're acting illiberal in a way that has not served other people in the past.
241
00:17:50.452 --> 00:17:53.474
We are, you know, public shamings are back in fashion.
242
00:17:53.514 --> 00:17:53.675
Like,
243
00:17:54.275 --> 00:17:56.497
But politicians are getting more clownish.
244
00:17:56.577 --> 00:17:57.517
Truth is on the decline.
245
00:17:57.578 --> 00:17:59.319
Media is not what it used to be.
246
00:17:59.379 --> 00:18:01.300
Media used to be much more trustworthy.
247
00:18:01.741 --> 00:18:07.845
Trust in general in our institutions is at an all-time low right now, or not all-time, but at least in the last 50 years.
248
00:18:08.225 --> 00:18:08.986
So this is awful.
249
00:18:09.006 --> 00:18:10.007
The stakes are getting higher.
250
00:18:10.047 --> 00:18:12.589
I'm not sure that media is more trustworthy.
251
00:18:13.970 --> 00:18:15.011
was more trustworthy.
252
00:18:15.351 --> 00:18:16.572
Media used to be more trusted.
253
00:18:16.993 --> 00:18:31.667
I think that the institutions, the reputable institutions of media are probably just as worthy of being trusted as they were or more as they were in the 1950s, say, when they had a more covert handshake with people in positions of power.
254
00:18:31.687
--> 00:18:32.508
I'm not sure I agree with that.
255
00:18:32.888 --> 00:18:34.549
Anyway, we can park that.
256
00:18:34.569 --> 00:18:47.975
I will agree with you on one front, which is that I think radio, the British Broadcasting Corporation, the Australian Broadcasting Corporation, and maybe the Times and even the reporting of the Wall Street Journal, if not the top-ed page and so on.
257
00:18:48.195 --> 00:18:56.419
But yes, so let's take the lack of trust as being at least as great a liability as a lack of trustworthiness, and then we agree.
258
00:18:58.178 --> 00:18:58.678
Sure, sure.
259
00:18:58.718 --> 00:18:59.318
Yeah, yeah.
260
00:18:59.438 --> 00:19:01.239
I think the lack of trust is a big deal.
261
00:19:01.659 --> 00:19:08.280
I think like the media, you could say, you know, I think people pine for the, you know, the Cronkite days, the Brokaw days.
262
00:19:09.141 --> 00:19:15.462
And I think that, you know, that's at least in the US, these are these giant national broadcasting stations, right?
263
00:19:16.022 --> 00:19:19.563
And I think, sure, they definitely had some, you know, who knows what, you know, what their broadcasts.
264
00:19:20.376 --> 00:19:22.657
deep down motives were and whether they were always telling the truth.
265
00:19:22.737 --> 00:19:27.699
But they had some semblance of neutrality and some semblance of professionalism.
266
00:19:27.739 --> 00:19:30.200
And they had six, 30 minutes a day to tell the news.
267
00:19:30.220 --> 00:19:31.400
So they focused on big news.
268
00:19:31.961 --> 00:19:35.382
And today you have these 24 hour news networks that no longer cater to the whole country.
269
00:19:35.402 --> 00:19:39.343
They cater to, they cater to very specifically to one political tribe.
270
00:19:39.704 --> 00:19:41.424
Yeah, I'm not including that.
271
00:19:42.205 --> 00:19:42.985
I'm not including.
272
00:19:43.065 --> 00:19:44.065
A lot of people today.
273
00:19:46.226 --> 00:19:52.488
are getting their media from MSNBC, from Fox News, from CNN, from Breitbart, from The Huffington Post, from Twitter.
274
00:19:53.068 --> 00:20:00.851
And I think you're more likely to see a non-fact-checked, not-professional journalism job in these headlines you're seeing than you used to.
275
00:20:00.871 --> 00:20:02.572
So I think it's a combo of both.
276
00:20:03.872 --> 00:20:12.198
Yeah, no, I guess I'm just saying that like The Economist still exists and the London Review of Books still exists and the New York Review of Books still exists and The New Yorker still exists.
277
00:20:12.218 --> 00:20:17.602
But what percentage of people are getting their news from one of those really kind of professional things?
278
00:20:17.942 --> 00:20:19.363
It's just the percentage has gone down.
279
00:20:19.403 --> 00:20:24.207
So many people are getting their news from very biased kind of tribal sources.
280
00:20:24.667 --> 00:20:28.549
So yeah, so yeah, I don't disagree with you on all fronts there.
281
00:20:28.569 --> 00:20:33.152
But I think it's so there's so many institutions that are a not what they used to be.
282
00:20:33.212 --> 00:20:38.095
But like you said, be even the institutions that are pretty good still are less trusted.
283
00:20:38.235 --> 00:20:39.856
And just probably the even bigger.
284
00:20:39.876 --> 00:20:49.162
The other thing that I'll throw into the point about how quickly things are changing and how critical it is that we have our wits about us at this particular point in time is I've mentioned this before.
285
00:20:49.182 --> 00:20:52.244
I don't remember if I mentioned it when we were chatting or on another podcast, but
286
00:20:52.644 --> 00:20:59.086
When my grandmother died, I went back from – it was the eve of her 100th birthday.
287
00:20:59.146 --> 00:21:00.106
She was in New Zealand.
288
00:21:00.746 --> 00:21:04.527
I'd been planning to come for her 100th birthday.
289
00:21:04.567 --> 00:21:06.968
She died on – no, actually, I wasn't going to come.
290
00:21:06.988 --> 00:21:07.508
That was the point.
291
00:21:07.528 --> 00:21:14.970
I sent a card instead, and then I accidentally – I beat the card because I was there for her funeral instead of her birthday card arriving before me.
292
00:21:15.030 --> 00:21:17.171
So I flew from New York to Auckland.
293
00:21:17.811 --> 00:21:25.353
attended her funeral, came back via Greece, where a friend of mine was living in Athens, and spent a weekend there.
294
00:21:25.373 --> 00:21:44.997
And I'm wandering around the Agora, the birthplace of democracy, and, like, standing on the northwest slopes of this hill where humans came for the first time ever with the radical idea of actually sorting things out by talking to each other about them and trying to figure out communally what to do
295
00:21:48.078 --> 00:21:51.622
you know, the cosmically divined emperor was telling them to do.
296
00:21:52.423 --> 00:21:58.629
And I'm like, wow, the age of this thing, the ancientness of Western democracy and Western civilization.
297
00:21:58.649 --> 00:22:01.211
And then I was like, well, hang on.
298
00:22:02.332 --> 00:22:05.696
It's 40 times 100 years.
299
00:22:07.692 --> 00:22:08.772
It's 4,000 years.
300
00:22:09.532 --> 00:22:10.653
It's 40 nana's.
301
00:22:11.513 --> 00:22:13.213
It's 40 nana's lifespans.
302
00:22:13.833 --> 00:22:28.816
So my nana, back to back, her lifespan, you only have to go back 40 to get to the very first example of Western democracy and Western, you know, I suppose, liberal thought.
303
00:22:29.076 --> 00:22:31.237
It's only 20 nana's to get back to Jesus.
304
00:22:31.937 --> 00:22:47.550
It's only a couple of nanas to get back to the Enlightenment, and it's only one nana to get back to the Gallipoli campaign, and then the invention of nuclear weapons, the evolution of flight, the entire space race.
305
00:22:48.150 --> 00:22:49.972
That's a one person's lifespan.
306
00:22:50.432 --> 00:22:55.817
And when you give the analogy at the
beginning of this book, Tim, where you're talking about the 1,000-page book where each page is 250 years –
307
00:22:57.378 --> 00:23:07.343
I mean, it's very funny because you have like a little cartoon of a dude who's reading the transition between page, say, 760 and 761.
308
00:23:07.744 --> 00:23:11.165
And the dude's saying, oh, wow, that tree is 14 feet taller.
309
00:23:11.906 --> 00:23:13.447
Or between pages 992 and 993, the person's going...
310
00:23:16.388 --> 00:23:18.289
Whoa, the Romans really went for it.
311
00:23:18.430 --> 00:23:19.450
What great buildings.
312
00:23:19.971 --> 00:23:21.992
AD is way cooler than BC.
313
00:23:22.532 --> 00:23:30.178
And then page 998 to 999, you get gravity, galaxies, human rights, the Western Hemisphere, like all of that.
314
00:23:30.818 --> 00:23:39.484
And then everything that my grandmother ever experienced is on the final third of the final page.
315
00:23:40.425 --> 00:23:46.828
And that's basically the dawn of people living lives that would be truly recognizable to us.
316
00:23:46.888 --> 00:23:48.989
In other words, the post-war period.
317
00:23:49.470 --> 00:23:50.450
So those are the stakes.
318
00:23:50.730 --> 00:23:51.531
That is the pace.
319
00:23:52.031 --> 00:24:02.777
That is the legacy that we need to take on from our forebears and move forward with is a terrifyingly rapidly changing legacy.
320
00:24:02.937 --> 00:24:09.080
And we have to be as well-equipped as we possibly can be to deal with the threats and opportunities that it throws up.
321
00:24:09.660 --> 00:24:13.423
So I'm glad that we've now, that's just my contribution to your laying the lay of the land.
322
00:24:15.004 --> 00:24:23.530
Now take us through maybe the easiest way to go through the sort of steps that you take in the book and talk about the ladder and liberal games and the downward spiral.
323
00:24:26.222 --> 00:24:40.572
Yeah, so I created a – because I was thinking that, you know, I think part of the problem is I think our conversations about this, both my personal ones and ones I see on TV and in podcasts and whatever, on Twitter, they're really constrained.
324
00:24:40.592 --> 00:24:49.938
I think, like, you know, when I look at politics or really any other line of argumentation, people are so focused on what you think.
325
00:24:50.338 --> 00:24:51.259
You know, here's what I think.
326
00:24:51.279 --> 00:24:51.879
Here's what you think.
327
00:24:51.899 --> 00:24:52.220
Who's right?
328
00:24:52.240 --> 00:24:52.500
Who's wrong?
329
00:24:52.520 --> 00:24:52.760
Who's wrong?
330
00:24:53.697 --> 00:24:57.302
That all to me is a horizontal axis situation.
331
00:24:57.342 --> 00:24:59.506
So we have left, right, center in politics, right?
332
00:24:59.526 --> 00:25:01.629
That's a horizontal one-dimensional axis.
333
00:25:02.170 --> 00:25:07.097
And in general, you could lay out the range of what you think on a spectrum of
334
00:25:08.118 --> 00:25:11.980
on most issues, even if it's oversimplifying a bit, it's a what you think axis, right?
335
00:25:12.240 --> 00:25:14.781
So I was like, how about we create a how you think axis?
336
00:25:14.881 --> 00:25:15.782
And we put it next to it.
337
00:25:15.842 --> 00:25:18.763
So we have a square now, a vertical axis.
338
00:25:19.464 --> 00:25:20.744
And I call that the ladder.
339
00:25:21.084 --> 00:25:25.927
And what I started to think is, you know, what makes...
340
00:25:27.138 --> 00:25:28.639
what are the different ways people think?
341
00:25:28.659 --> 00:25:31.962
And it came down to me, there's kind of two parts of our brain.
342
00:25:32.303 --> 00:25:39.649
And, you know, I'm not saying this as a neuroscientist, I'm saying this as a human who understands his own thinking, or, you know, what it's like to be in my own brain.
343
00:25:39.669 --> 00:25:50.438
And I know, and to me, so I procrastinate a lot, because there's two parts of my brain, there's one part, the kind of rational brain.
344
00:25:50.985 --> 00:25:52.766
part that says we should work now.
345
00:25:52.806 --> 00:25:54.027
It's 10 AM on a Tuesday.
346
00:25:54.107 --> 00:25:55.407
Obviously this is a great time to work.
347
00:25:55.427 --> 00:26:01.511
And then there's another part that self defeats that says, Nope, we're not going to work now because it's not because it's bad.
348
00:26:01.631 --> 00:26:02.631
It's not trying to hurt me.
349
00:26:03.011 --> 00:26:04.052
It's, it's confused.
350
00:26:04.152 --> 00:26:07.254
It is what I, you know, it's, it's what I would call the primitive mind.
351
00:26:07.294 --> 00:26:14.878
And this primitive mind, um, is, is an ancient part of our brain that, that doesn't, that has not been updated since, um,
352
00:26:15.518 --> 00:26:20.721
you know, civilization sprung upon us really quickly and our brains have not adjusted.
353
00:26:20.821 --> 00:26:30.867
So this primitive mind is this piece of software that thinks we live in 50,000 BC and it doesn't wanna work hard on a book because there were no books in 50,000 BC.
354
00:26:30.887 --> 00:26:33.468
You weren't working on a project that was gonna come out a year from now.
355
00:26:33.868 --> 00:26:36.510
You were, you were trying to fulfill your immediate needs.
356
00:26:36.950 --> 00:26:38.131
And so that's what it's really good at.
357
00:26:38.211 --> 00:26:51.181
And so procrastination, I think is a battle between this ancient software and, uh, that, that doesn't understand the concept of long-term work and wants to conserve energy and the rational part that sees what's going on and realizes you need to get to work.
358
00:26:51.381 --> 00:26:53.022
The same thing goes for when we eat unhealthy.
359
00:26:53.042 --> 00:26:55.404
I use the example of Skittles, like, um, um,
360
00:26:56.404 --> 00:26:57.605
Why do we ever eat Skittles?
361
00:26:57.625 --> 00:26:59.186
They're awful for you.
362
00:26:59.246 --> 00:27:01.307
There's nothing good about them nutrition-wise.
363
00:27:01.327 -->
00:27:05.290
It's funny that you used the example of Skittles because I just wolfed down a bag of Skittles last night.
364
00:27:05.950 --> 00:27:07.031
I mean, they're so good.
365
00:27:07.071 --> 00:27:10.413
But it's the primitive brain in your head.
366
00:27:10.613 --> 00:27:17.418
The primitive mind thinks that Skittles, because it hasn't been updated, if you found anything with the texture and the chewiness –
367
00:27:18.218 --> 00:27:26.645
And the flavor of Skittles back in 50,000 BC, you want to eat it because that is some delicious calorie dense food that you might not get calories for two weeks.
368
00:27:26.665 --> 00:27:27.726
It's an incredible bearing.
369
00:27:27.866 --> 00:27:29.487
Imagine coming across a Skittle tree.
370
00:27:29.807 --> 00:27:30.908
You'd be like, this is the best tree.
371
00:27:30.928 --> 00:27:32.950
I mean, this is obviously very popular.
372
00:27:33.490 --> 00:27:34.051
That's right.
373
00:27:34.091 --> 00:27:38.534
I would have been lots of wars, bloody wars, bloody battles fought over that tree.
374
00:27:38.694 --> 00:27:39.175
Exactly.
375
00:27:39.215 --> 00:27:45.059
I would have been there like Shylock or Fidler on the roof, just selling Skittles out of my bag next and hoarding the tree for all.
376
00:27:45.360 --> 00:27:45.820
But carry on.
377
00:27:46.837 --> 00:27:47.037
Right.
378
00:27:47.137 --> 00:27:49.258
And then you'd give all the ancient people diabetes.
379
00:27:50.339 --> 00:27:56.482
But so we end up with diabetes now because we have this brain that does not really understand what's going on.
380
00:27:56.522 --> 00:28:01.665
And it tries to do the right thing by, you know, eating the foods that you want, conserving energy, whatever.
381
00:28:01.785 --> 00:28:05.347
Now, I took this concept of these kind of the higher mind.
382
00:28:06.027 --> 00:28:08.708
that can see what's going on and wants to do what makes sense.
383
00:28:09.248 --> 00:28:16.770
And the primitive mind, which is a piece of software that doesn't understand the world you're in and is trying to survive in 50,000 BC, even though you live today.
384
00:28:17.310 --> 00:28:20.771
I took that paradigm and I said, how do we apply it to thinking, to our ideas?
385
00:28:21.371 --> 00:28:23.352
And I realized that I think the same thing is going on.
386
00:28:23.392 --> 00:28:23.872
I think that,
387
00:28:24.732 --> 00:28:31.996
The way the primitive mind wants to form beliefs is wants to form the same, you know, first of all, the same beliefs as the people around you.
388
00:28:32.276 --> 00:28:35.538
So they want to fit in and believe what the tribe believes.
389
00:28:36.138 --> 00:28:38.440
It wants to confirm those beliefs.
390
00:28:38.460 --> 00:28:41.821
It wants to feel conviction and express conviction about how right we are.
391
00:28:42.342 --> 00:28:45.083
And it wants to attach your identity to it.
392
00:28:45.143 --> 00:28:46.724
Those beliefs are part of who you are.
393
00:28:47.565 --> 00:28:47.685
And.
394
00:28:48.485 --> 00:28:51.326
the people who don't believe what you believe, they're not just wrong.
395
00:28:51.346 --> 00:28:52.246
They're bad people.
396
00:28:52.286 --> 00:28:53.787
They're those kinds of people.
397
00:28:53.947 --> 00:28:56.348
And we're these kinds of people who believe these things.
398
00:28:56.608 --> 00:29:05.291
And of course you would, if you think that way, that brain would never want to change its mind because then your whole identity shatters and your whole tribal connection.
399
00:29:05.331 --> 00:29:09.553
And now your self-esteem is tied to being the good person who believes the good things.
400
00:29:10.013 --> 00:29:13.154
So you identify with them, they become sacred beliefs to you.
401
00:29:13.174 --> 00:29:14.695
They become stitched to who you are.
402
00:29:14.895 --> 00:29:16.217
And I just want to make an analogy.
403
00:29:16.397 --> 00:29:19.301
Let me just make another analogy there to the to Skittles as well.
404
00:29:19.782 --> 00:29:31.578
There is there's something compelling and juicy and delicious and caloric about an idea that makes you feel like you're on the right side of history and like you're not only correct, but good.
405
00:29:32.718 --> 00:29:34.259
You know what I mean?
406
00:29:34.399 --> 00:29:42.463
It's all very well for me to hold an idea in my head like, oh, I don't know, Saturn is larger than Neptune.
407
00:29:43.163 --> 00:29:44.564
But that doesn't make me feel good.
408
00:29:45.164 --> 00:29:49.787
For me to feel good, I need an idea that has more moral cogency than that.
409
00:29:49.867 --> 00:29:56.030
And so an idea about something that's political, something that's cultural, something that's tribal, something that involves...
410
00:29:56.510 --> 00:30:15.600
discrimination against other people or a threat to my way of life, something that involves all that is good and pure versus things that are sinful and impure or something that involves appeals to egalitarianism and to decency and to fairness over hierarchy and evil.
411
00:30:15.640 --> 00:30:24.125
Like all of those things, like there's just a juiciness, there's a skittlesiness to many of the ideas that make us feel good.
412
00:30:24.165 --> 00:30:24.245
Why?
413
00:30:25.742 --> 00:30:32.067
The reason is because those things you mentioned, those were all related to life and death a long, long time ago.
414
00:30:32.817 --> 00:30:34.177
while Saturn was not.
415
00:30:35.058 --> 00:30:46.161
And there's actually an interesting study that they use an MRI on people, and when they have their non-political beliefs challenged, the kind of rational parts of their brain light up.
416
00:30:46.281 --> 00:30:55.883
And when they have their political beliefs challenged, whole different parts of their brain, the parts that deal with identity and internal focus light up because it's a different part of our brain that processes it.
417
00:30:56.143 --> 00:30:59.064
And those beliefs, of
course, are way less likely to change.
418
00:30:59.484 --> 00:31:02.525
People get angry and defensive and emotional when those beliefs are challenged.
419
00:31:02.645 --> 00:31:14.838
And of course, when we did believe that like the god of Neptune really did have agency in the cosmos, then we probably were really offended when people said nasty things about Neptune.
420
00:31:16.878 --> 00:31:24.242
Yeah, I mean, if we thought it had to do with the afterlife or it had to do with some powerful being that had power over us and our well-being, then yeah, I'm sure we did.
421
00:31:24.422 --> 00:31:24.903
Yeah.
422
00:31:24.923 --> 00:31:25.803
Okay, cool.
423
00:31:25.843 --> 00:31:27.284
It's whatever has to do with survival.
424
00:31:27.484 --> 00:31:28.645
So we've got all these ideas.
425
00:31:28.705 --> 00:31:35.989
So one part of your brain is trying to identify with the ideas and not change your mind, the same exact part of your brain that wants to eat those Skittles.
426
00:31:36.789 --> 00:31:42.053
Now, the other part of your brain, the one that says, let's not binge on Skittles because that's a bad decision.
427
00:31:43.013 --> 00:31:45.175
That same part of your brain thinks totally differently.
428
00:31:45.215 --> 00:31:47.116
That part of your brain does what makes sense.
429
00:31:47.496 --> 00:31:53.801
Just like it doesn't make sense, it makes sense to not eat too many Skittles, it also makes sense to form your beliefs based on evidence.
430
00:31:54.101 --> 00:32:02.967
And to be humble because you know from experience how often people are wrong and how complex things are and how hard it is to gain knowledge.
431
00:32:04.047 --> 00:32:14.940
And you're, of course, you're willing to change your mind when you're thinking rationally, because what is what is changing your mind, you have a mental model in your brain, like a little machine you've built, and you want that machine to be accurate, you want it to be true.
432
00:32:14.960 --> 00:32:17.823
That's, that's how it's going to serve you and others if you know have the truth.
433
00:32:18.384 --> 00:32:20.987
And if someone comes along and says, you're wrong about this.
434
00:32:22.060 --> 00:32:27.501
That higher mind in your head is not going to be offended or angry or defensive.
435
00:32:27.521 --> 00:32:29.762
It's gonna say, oh, you think my machine's broken?
436
00:32:30.022 --> 00:32:31.222
Well, I don't think so, show me why.
437
00:32:31.242 --> 00:32:32.923
Well, kick it, kick it, try to break it.
438
00:32:33.443 --> 00:32:40.545
And if that person can successfully break your machine and say, you know what, see, I pointed out a fatal flaw, you wouldn't say you're an asshole, you'd say, thank you.
439
00:32:41.085 --> 00:32:45.906
Wow, amazing, I like, I just got a little smarter because of you.
440
00:32:45.966 --> 00:32:50.527
I just updated, I just got a software update in my head and my brain's a little better off forever.
441
00:32:50.767 --> 00:32:54.288
Tim, do you know Dawkins' familiar anecdote about this?
442
00:32:54.668 --> 00:33:01.491
Yeah, where he says – in fact, if people are listening to this, then I am just about to do a Dawkins event in Brisbane.
443
00:33:01.511 --> 00:33:06.792
So if you're in Brisbane and there are still tickets left, then next week I'm doing Dawkins Live in Brisbane.
444
00:33:06.892 --> 00:33:08.833
But his anecdote about this is this –
445
00:33:09.834 --> 00:33:27.130
And you may tell me if I'm mangling it, but the scientist who had spent his entire life trying to defend this particular quirk of, I think, evolutionary theory, and a younger scientist was giving a big presentation to a packed out lecture hall that was going to demolish this old guy's ideas.
446
00:33:27.851 --> 00:33:32.856
And he gave the presentation and the old guy who was in the lecture hall got up and walked down to the front and...
447
00:33:33.536 --> 00:33:36.817
and everyone sort of held their breath as if there was going to be a big showdown.
448
00:33:36.837 --> 00:33:41.898
And the old guy shook his hand ferociously and said, thank you for proving me wrong.
449
00:33:41.918 --> 00:33:43.259
I've been wrong all of these years.
450
00:33:43.899 --> 00:33:52.361
And for Dawkins, that's the ultimate example of what science is versus superstition or faith or tribal beliefs.
451
00:33:52.401 --> 00:33:54.842
And that's the avatar towards which we should all aspire.
452
00:33:56.560 --> 00:33:59.804
Right, because a real scientist, think about this.
453
00:33:59.824 --> 00:34:02.968
If you're a perfect scientist, and that guy sounds pretty close,
454
00:34:04.292 --> 00:34:05.373
what are you doing with science?
455
00:34:05.673 --> 00:34:11.639
Science is a method of discovering the truth and it's collaborative over generations and over space and time.
456
00:34:12.240 --> 00:34:15.803
And so they're on the same team looking for the same truth, right?
457
00:34:16.104 --> 00:34:20.828
And so if someone disproves your thing, you'd say, oh, okay, I added my hypothesis.
458
00:34:21.069 --> 00:34:21.930
You've shown it was wrong.
459
00:34:21.970 --> 00:34:22.310
Okay.
460
00:34:22.330 --> 00:34:25.093
We all just went a little bit, we just took a step forward together.
461
00:34:26.334 --> 00:34:28.676
But of course, what so many scientists do
462
00:34:29.637 --> 00:34:36.739
is they get stuck in their, they become attached to their hypothesis, their theory, because their ego gets involved.
463
00:34:36.759 --> 00:34:38.339
Their primitive mind gets involved.
464
00:34:38.359 --> 00:34:40.640
And so their higher mind might be saying, great, let's find the truth.
465
00:34:40.660 --> 00:34:45.201
But their primitive mind is saying, that theory is part of me.
466
00:34:45.281 --> 00:34:49.602
And that theory being true is part of my self-esteem and part of my reputation.
467
00:34:50.302 --> 00:34:51.282
And so they will defend it.
468
00:34:51.302 --> 00:34:51.982
And what does that do?
469
00:34:52.002 --> 00:34:53.983
It makes them a much worse scientist.
470
00:34:54.043 --> 00:34:55.423
It makes them a much worse thinker.
471
00:34:55.883 --> 00:34:57.604
And of course, it's not just scientists.
472
00:34:58.384 --> 00:35:00.546
You can apply this thing to all of us, right?
473
00:35:00.566 --> 00:35:06.411
Like we all have times when we are thinking with our higher minds and we're, and we're, we're much more humble.
474
00:35:06.431 --> 00:35:07.552
We're willing to change our mind.
475
00:35:07.572 --> 00:35:09.634
We're not emotional or attached about our ideas.
476
00:35:10.254 --> 00:35:13.917
And that, that, that makes us a hyper, you know, hyper-efficient learning machine.
477
00:35:14.238 --> 00:35:14.358
Right.
478
00:35:14.398 --> 00:35:20.323
And if you just have, if you can get in that habit, you become one of those people that knows so much, but we also struggle.
479
00:35:20.403 --> 00:35:21.243
It's like a tug of war.
480
00:35:21.764 --> 00:35:26.288
So often we will find ourselves just not just,
481
00:35:27.131 --> 00:35:29.754
fully identifying with our ideas, but doing it with others.
482
00:35:29.814 --> 00:35:32.176
So our friends and us, we all agree.
483
00:35:32.476 --> 00:35:38.242
We all sit around talking about how right we are and how wrong those other dumb people, bad people are.
484
00:35:38.982 --> 00:35:44.808
And when we're doing that, we've gotten caught into kind of our primitive minds have banded together into kind of an ancient tribal ritual.
485
00:35:45.368 --> 00:35:49.873
And all of us have stopped learning and we're giving away the amazing human ability to learn.
486
00:35:50.173 --> 00:35:51.414
We're giving that away in favor of
487
00:35:52.455 --> 00:35:59.019
kind of pounding a bag of Skittles, intellectual Skittles, by talking about how smart and righteous and good we are.
488
00:35:59.039 --> 00:36:02.421
And so that's a tug of war in all of our heads.
489
00:36:02.681 --> 00:36:05.383
And some of us are better at being on the high rungs.
490
00:36:05.643 --> 00:36:10.446
So the ladder to me is, when you're on the top of the ladder, when your higher mind is just...
491
00:36:11.126 --> 00:36:13.607
running the show in your head, which happens to all of us sometimes.
492
00:36:13.947 --> 00:36:15.348
You're in a really good thinking zone.
493
00:36:15.928 --> 00:36:17.228
You're at the top rung of the ladder.
494
00:36:17.849 --> 00:36:26.152
Now, as the primitive mind starts to enter the equation, you start to go to drift down to those middle rungs when you're in the tug of war and you can feel the influence of both.
495
00:36:26.712 --> 00:36:32.394
And then a lot of times our primitive mind just totally takes over and we are completely consumed with, you know,
496
00:36:33.054 --> 00:36:37.515
Tribalism, intellectual tribalism, you know, we are totally identified with our ideas.
497
00:36:37.555 --> 00:36:39.136
There's nothing that could change our mind.
498
00:36:39.176 --> 00:36:44.398
Deep down, we know if you ask us that there's not actually anything that could make us say, I think I'm wrong about this.
499
00:36:44.618 --> 00:36:46.038
Okay, now we're at the bottom of the ladder.
500
00:36:46.058 --> 00:36:47.819
We're on the low rungs of the ladder.
501
00:36:47.859 --> 00:36:55.081
And so these two terms, that thinking, you know, high rung thinking and low rung thinking, that's this vertical axis that I think we need.
502
00:36:55.241 --> 00:36:59.822
And so when someone says, oh, I'm a center left person or I'm on the far right.
503
00:37:00.022 --> 00:37:01.363
Okay, that's a horizontal statement.
504
00:37:01.968 --> 00:37:02.168
Great.
505
00:37:02.488 --> 00:37:04.830
But that doesn't tell me how you got there.
506
00:37:05.751 --> 00:37:11.555
If that person is a high-rung thinker and they're on the far right, I'm thinking, okay, so this person has done a lot of thinking.
507
00:37:11.835 --> 00:37:12.956
They've been willing to change their mind.
508
00:37:12.976 --> 00:37:14.397
They probably changed their mind a lot of times.
509
00:37:14.597 --> 00:37:20.401
And after a lot of evidence, they've come to believe that staunch conservatism is the way to go.
510
00:37:20.881 --> 00:37:22.942
Regardless of whether I agree, I want to listen to that person.
511
00:37:22.962 --> 00:37:23.543
That's interesting.
512
00:37:23.643 --> 00:37:24.283
Okay, so let's talk.
513
00:37:24.303 --> 00:37:26.285
Same if they're on the far left or in the center or wherever.
514
00:37:26.865 --> 00:37:31.066
If that same person, I can tell that they're just there because this is who they are.
515
00:37:31.106 --> 00:37:33.827
They are a red Republican or they are a centrist.
516
00:37:33.927 --> 00:37:35.028
It's not just the right and left.
517
00:37:35.068 --> 00:37:35.728
It can be a centrist.
518
00:37:36.188 --> 00:37:38.669
And that's just part of their identity is being that thing.
519
00:37:39.109 --> 00:37:41.390
I don't care what they have to say because it's not real information.
520
00:37:41.430 --> 00:37:44.231
By the way, I can tell them every single position.
521
00:37:44.251 --> 00:37:45.591
They name an issue.
522
00:37:45.692 --> 00:37:46.812
I can tell you that person's position.
523
00:37:47.172 --> 00:37:53.217
It's like a computer spitting out some preordained conceits.
524
00:37:53.557 --> 00:38:04.946
And I think it's really worth remembering in the wake of how terrible conversations have been over the past few years, particularly around the pandemic and social justice.
525
00:38:04.986 --> 00:38:10.411
The key here is why we believe the things we believe.
526
00:38:10.591 --> 00:38:11.271
Like why?
527
00:38:11.372 --> 00:38:13.753
How did you arrive at the belief?
528
00:38:13.914 --> 00:38:14.334
I did a –
529
00:38:15.175 --> 00:38:20.660
a solo podcast, like a soapbox, I call it, about what I got wrong about COVID.
530
00:38:21.501 --> 00:38:41.099
And it was, you know, the amount of hate that I
got back from the, you know, the, I suppose, COVID, I don't want to call them conspiracy theorists, from people who think that the global reaction to COVID was completely manufactured or even invented or concocted or that the whole thing was a conspiracy.
531
00:38:43.427 --> 00:38:57.552
The point that I had been making was I've become renowned among certain circles in the wake of having been on Joe Rogan's show in January of 2022 and gotten into an argument with him about myocarditis as a result of vaccines.
532
00:38:58.112 --> 00:39:02.955
as being like the person who thinks there's no side effects from vaccines, which is not true at all.
533
00:39:03.015 --> 00:39:04.916
I just followed the data on that.
534
00:39:05.436 --> 00:39:15.722
My point has always been that in 2021, as Delta and Omicron were exploding and hospitals were still struggling to deal with it,
535
00:39:16.582 --> 00:39:26.248
It was not correct at the time to be more concerned about heart inflammation from our mRNA vaccines than you were about the spread of the disease.
536
00:39:26.388 --> 00:39:27.949
We didn't know enough back then.
537
00:39:28.589 --> 00:39:30.871
We knew enough to know that they were broadly safe.
538
00:39:31.731 --> 00:39:41.797
And the correct kind of epistemological position at the time was to cautiously be in favor of vaccinating as many people as quickly as possible in 2021.
539
00:39:41.837 --> 00:39:41.937
Yeah.
540
00:39:43.338 --> 00:39:47.319
Now, in 2023, my position can afford to be more nuanced.
541
00:39:47.339 --> 00:39:48.520
There's a lot more data.
542
00:39:48.620 --> 00:39:56.702
I would encourage males under the age of 50 not to get mRNA vaccines, but to opt for AstraZeneca or Novavax if they can, although they should still get.
543
00:39:56.902 --> 00:39:58.843
So anyway, I'm not going to go down that whole rabbit hole.
544
00:39:59.223 --> 00:40:02.584
But the point that I was trying to make in what I got wrong about COVID was...
545
00:40:03.364 --> 00:40:05.666
A stopped clock is right twice a day.
546
00:40:05.926 --> 00:40:19.316
If you've been banging on about mRNA vaccines and the damage that they can do to young male hearts now, that may be all well and good, and you may be absolutely correct about your data.
547
00:40:19.676 --> 00:40:26.241
But you weren't right to be banging on about that 18 months ago because it matters why you believe what you believe and how you got there.
548
00:40:26.281 --> 00:40:28.903
And the only reason why you were banging on about it in the middle of 2021...
549
00:40:29.924 --> 00:40:39.510
is because your tribe was banging on about it, and it gave you a sense of identity to be located in the pandemic in relation to the pandemic the way that you wanted to be related.
550
00:40:39.590 --> 00:40:40.931
It was not a rational position.
551
00:40:41.291 --> 00:40:45.834
You might, like, it's entirely possible to be right for the wrong reasons, is what I'm saying.
552
00:40:48.215 --> 00:40:57.541
Totally agree, because what you're saying is, if two people say today that what you just said about mRNA vaccines and the risks...
553
00:40:58.366 --> 00:41:03.910
One of them might be way up in the high rungs saying it, and another one would be in the low rungs.
554
00:41:03.950 --> 00:41:05.711
And that is all the difference in the world.
555
00:41:05.731 --> 00:41:08.313
In fact, that's what we should be focusing on.
556
00:41:09.654 --> 00:41:16.578
In general, each of our goal should be to just climb this ladder in our heads as much as possible.
557
00:41:16.638 --> 00:41:23.963
But secondly, when you see someone, when you talk to someone who disagrees with you, but they're doing it from kind of a high rung perspective.
558
00:41:24.597 --> 00:41:35.448
perspective, that person is way more an ally of yours in the long run and in the quest for knowledge and whatever, than someone who happens to agree with you who's doing it in a tribal way.
559
00:41:35.488 --> 00:41:42.155
Yeah, I mean, you could teach Coco the gorilla to say the right, the true things about mRNA vaccines.
560
00:41:42.896 --> 00:41:46.079
You know, it wouldn't mean that Coco has a great understanding or is good at reasons.
561
00:41:48.495 --> 00:41:48.815
Exactly.
562
00:41:48.835 --> 00:42:05.267
And again, a good litmus test is, you know, if this is the kind of person where when they tell you they're for Americans, if an American tells me their view on abortion and I know that I could immediately tell you their position without knowing anything else about them.
563
00:42:06.187 --> 00:42:12.689
on guns, on climate change, on immigration, on tax policy, who they voted for in the last election.
564
00:42:13.350 --> 00:42:14.770
That, to me, is not a thinker.
565
00:42:14.810 --> 00:42:16.231
There's no thinking happening.
566
00:42:16.311 --> 00:42:23.673
Maybe out of 100 high-rung thinkers, you will have one that happens to have come down the entire checklist in one way.
567
00:42:23.974 --> 00:42:24.674
Very unusual.
568
00:42:24.694 --> 00:42:25.774
It's unlikely.
569
00:42:25.794 --> 00:42:32.056
These issues are really – and by the way, they probably won't be so nuanced as just to have a clear, yes, higher taxes.
570
00:42:32.317 --> 00:42:33.657
No, yes, abortions.
571
00:42:33.857 --> 00:42:35.959
They'll also have a hundred things to say about it.
572
00:42:36.019 --> 00:42:40.183
If anyone needs proof of that, Tim, just look at how quickly the mob can turn.
573
00:42:40.323 --> 00:42:49.512
Look at what the Republican Party's attitude towards Medicare and Social Security or international relations has done in less than six years.
574
00:42:49.632 --> 00:42:55.057
They've gone from being interventionist hawks to being largely isolationist.
575
00:42:55.077 --> 00:42:58.640
They've gone from being Russia haters to Russia lovers.
576
00:42:58.660 --> 00:42:59.641
They've gone from being...
577
00:42:59.961 --> 00:43:05.003
We need to cut Social Security
and Medicare to get the budget in check to being we're never going to touch these things.
578
00:43:05.423 --> 00:43:08.124
And what all all at exactly the same time?
579
00:43:08.164 --> 00:43:11.025
And I could make similar arguments of, you know, of groupthink on the left.
580
00:43:11.045 --> 00:43:13.226
I don't mean to just say that it's a Republican phenomenon.
581
00:43:13.246 --> 00:43:15.366
But in the United States, that's it's more market there.
582
00:43:15.767 --> 00:43:23.409
But and all at the same time, everyone has independently concluded that all of these positions were wrong and that they should actually modify them.
583
00:43:23.469 --> 00:43:24.150
Of course not.
584
00:43:24.190 --> 00:43:25.310
It's a herd stampede.
585
00:43:27.202 --> 00:43:27.542
Correct.
586
00:43:27.722 --> 00:43:39.045
I mean, also, I mean, you could say, yeah, during the Obama years, all you heard was from the left was, I mean, from the right was that the deficit, the deficit, the debt.
587
00:43:39.105 --> 00:43:39.425
Right.
588
00:43:39.625 --> 00:43:46.006
And then Trump comes in office and silence, radio silence on that as this continues to balloon.
589
00:43:47.006 --> 00:43:48.987
You know, I don't know, five, seven years ago.
590
00:43:49.967 --> 00:43:59.773
Most people on the left in the U S mostly, you know, pretty, pretty fervent, you know, tribal leftists in the U S would have said, you know, colorblindness is great, right?
591
00:43:59.813 --> 00:44:03.815
Judge a person by their character, not their, not their skin color.
592
00:44:03.835 --> 00:44:03.996
Right.
593
00:44:04.036 --> 00:44:04.116
And,
594
00:44:05.316 --> 00:44:09.078
And today that entire group has shifted and said, the worst thing you can be is colorblind.
595
00:44:09.138 --> 00:44:11.920
And it's not that they all independently thought about it and came around.
596
00:44:12.020 --> 00:44:14.942
It was that they're down on the low rungs.
597
00:44:16.102 --> 00:44:23.347
The checklist has been, you know, has had switched and changed and all the people just kind of without thinking go along with it.
598
00:44:23.367 --> 00:44:29.970
And then suddenly, you know, we'll try to, you know, we'll hugely criticize scathingly anyone who has the view they had six years ago.
599
00:44:30.011 --> 00:44:30.551
Yeah.
600
00:44:30.591 --> 00:44:30.751
Yeah.
601
00:44:31.071 --> 00:44:40.985
And usually, by the way, these people, whether it's the left or right or center, these people that are getting their viewpoints from a checklist that are unwilling to change their mind, that are doing their thinking with their primitive mind.
602
00:44:41.506 --> 00:44:43.869
And again, I don't mean to be looking down upon them because I've been there.
603
00:44:44.810 --> 00:44:45.892
When people are down there.
604
00:44:47.963 --> 00:44:54.726
When when when people are down there, these are also people who are usually very bad at debating.
605
00:44:54.746 --> 00:44:56.908
You know, they have more conviction than anyone.
606
00:44:56.968 --> 00:45:02.711
These are the people who it's funny because on the high runs, they have a lot more actual knowledge and they can hold their own in a debate usually.
607
00:45:03.031 --> 00:45:04.112
But they'll often say, I don't know.
608
00:45:04.532 --> 00:45:05.952
But on the low rungs, they say, oh, I know.
609
00:45:06.032 --> 00:45:09.033
And not only do I know, but I know that anyone who disagrees with this is an awful person.
610
00:45:09.113 --> 00:45:19.795
Meanwhile, if you try to have an actual debate with them, a substantive one, they'll resort to, they'll either avoid it or they'll resort to ad hominem attacks and, you know, things like that because they don't actually have very much knowledge.
611
00:45:19.815 --> 00:45:23.815
So they have this unearned conviction, this tremendous amount of unearned conviction.
612
00:45:23.835 --> 00:45:27.056
And that's because the primitive mind is just wired that way.
613
00:45:27.076 --> 00:45:27.276
Yeah.
614
00:45:27.436 --> 00:45:30.656
Fervently believe stuff that it has no good reason to believe this.
615
00:45:30.976 --> 00:45:31.757
It's not very smart.
616
00:45:31.837 --> 00:45:33.297
And some, I mean, just on Skittles.
617
00:45:33.337 --> 00:45:33.757
That's right.
618
00:45:34.137 --> 00:45:34.557
That's right.
619
00:45:34.597 --> 00:45:54.866
And sometimes there are some issues that are so thorny and so resistant to simplification that the people on the lower rungs, as you said, I mean, avoidance, I'm glad you said that because it's not just – people will often say the modern environment, the modern cultural climate and social media make everybody more hostile and make us more extreme.
620
00:45:54.986 --> 00:45:56.507
And that's true to some degree.
621
00:45:56.547 --> 00:45:59.048
The algorithms are extremification machines.
622
00:45:59.688 --> 00:46:00.909
But they also –
623
00:46:02.004 --> 00:46:08.853
some of us up into such a pickle that we just have to avoid entire topics now.
624
00:46:08.953 --> 00:46:15.461
Like we really are not engaging on the challenge between equity and equality that you just pointed to.
625
00:46:15.561 --> 00:46:15.742
Are we
626
00:46:17.463 --> 00:46:22.888
you know, without regarding their skin colour and ethnicity as being salient, should that still be an aspiration.
627
00:46:23.148 --> 00:46:26.350
It's very hard to find people to talk sensibly about that.
628
00:46:26.671 --> 00:46:35.538
It's also hard to find people to talk sensibly about, you know, the fact that, again, six or seven years ago, it would have been a foundational principle of being on the left
629
00:46:36.198 --> 00:46:45.181
that there's something fundamental to the experience of being a woman in having grown up as a girl in a sexist world.
630
00:46:45.882 --> 00:46:54.765
And that the norm of allowing women to have women's only spaces and to define themselves however they collectively want to...
631
00:46:55.525
--> 00:46:59.048
is an utmost principle of the left.
632
00:46:59.688 --> 00:47:12.317
Now you throw in the question of, well, what is the category of woman and do people who were born biologically male but who are female inside get to dictate the trajectory of that cohort?
633
00:47:12.937 --> 00:47:16.558
well, we want to be really nice to trans people because we don't want to be bigots.
634
00:47:16.718 --> 00:47:27.080
And that is such a scramble and it's so difficult to unpick that rather than actually do the legwork of trying to nod it out and go, okay, well, what are the big values that we really care about?
635
00:47:27.120 --> 00:47:33.201
Like human agency and autonomy and compassion and how can we reconcile those values with the facts on the ground?
636
00:47:33.561 --> 00:47:37.241
It's much easier to just say, maybe we're not going to touch that.
637
00:47:38.222 --> 00:47:40.622
So that you either don't touch it or you're a firebrand.
638
00:47:41.767 --> 00:47:45.370
Well, but it's also, it's each of these issues, right?
639
00:47:45.390 --> 00:47:46.912
They're incredibly complicated.
640
00:47:46.952 --> 00:47:58.042
They need, you know, we get wise together if we can talk about stuff, if we can argue, if we can be unafraid to be wrong or even play devil's advocate and argue with something we know is wrong because it's interesting and seeing what happens.
641
00:47:58.702 --> 00:47:59.723
There's so much nuance here.
642
00:48:00.704 --> 00:48:02.146
And if you think about...
643
00:48:03.178 --> 00:48:13.670
What does it say when a person or a group is not just, you know, instead of disagreeing, they actually try to shut down conversation.
644
00:48:13.690 --> 00:48:16.514
They try to make it taboo to even talk about it.
645
00:48:17.214 --> 00:48:22.280
It tells me that it's like if someone feels confident that they have the truth.
646
00:48:22.861 --> 00:48:23.681
They love an argument.
647
00:48:23.701 --> 00:48:24.642
They love to talk about it.
648
00:48:24.662 --> 00:48:25.342
They bring it on.
649
00:48:26.563 --> 00:48:32.146
And so it tells me that it usually, again, it correlates with people who are very bad at arguing at something.
650
00:48:32.166 --> 00:48:35.028
And they don't actually they don't really know how to argue for their own beliefs.
651
00:48:35.508 --> 00:48:44.273
And so it's like if you put your you know, if the way you can test ideas is to throw them in the boxing ring with other ideas.
652
00:48:46.783 --> 00:48:50.105
there's people who will try to box your ideas, which is great.
653
00:48:50.205 --> 00:48:52.385
And then there's people who try to ban boxing, right?
654
00:48:52.425 --> 00:48:54.146
Ban boxing and try to make it uncomfortable.
655
00:48:54.446 --> 00:48:57.307
The fact that it's not, it doesn't just happen by itself.
656
00:48:57.327 --> 00:49:01.268
When you're saying these issues are really hard to talk about, that doesn't happen by itself.
657
00:49:01.308 --> 00:49:11.812
It happens because some people in the society are making it really scary to talk about by trying to punish people who talk about them without, unless they say the exact viewpoint that is approved.
658
00:49:12.852 --> 00:49:15.694
And so it doesn't serve trans people or women.
659
00:49:15.814 --> 00:49:17.655
It doesn't serve people of color.
660
00:49:17.975 --> 00:49:22.537
It doesn't serve any of the people that supposedly are being protected here.
661
00:49:22.577 --> 00:49:29.021
It's not helpful to make topics, discussion about these nuanced issues that affect them taboo.
662
00:49:29.141 --> 00:49:38.326
All it does is it just makes people dig their heels into these un-nuanced, one-dimensional narratives that actually, if you look at plenty of statistics, these narratives don't help.
663
00:49:38.626 --> 00:49:40.507
They don't help the people that they're trying to help.
664
00:49:40.547 --> 00:49:48.732
You've got a nice little cartoon in the book, Tim, with a person standing in front of a big boxer saying, this is the best boxer in the world.
665
00:49:48.992 --> 00:49:50.613
And another person says, wow, cool.
666
00:49:51.314 --> 00:49:52.754
Who has he beaten?
667
00:49:53.355 --> 00:49:55.216
And the other person says, no one.
668
00:49:55.236 --> 00:49:56.236
He's never fought anyone.
669
00:49:56.577 --> 00:49:59.579
And the other person says, then how do you know he's the best boxer in the world?
670
00:49:59.919 --> 00:50:01.480
And the other person says, I can just tell.
671
00:50:02.440 --> 00:50:05.181
And that's basically what we're doing to our beloved beliefs.
672
00:50:05.341 --> 00:50:16.484
We don't actually have to subject them to the rigorous scrutiny of getting in the ring because to do so would be to undignify them and to dignify our opponents with time.
673
00:50:17.264 --> 00:50:23.766
And our beliefs are too good and too noble to be put under that kind of withering criticism.
674
00:50:23.906 --> 00:50:26.487
And as a result, we quarantine them and they atrophy people.
675
00:50:27.047 --> 00:50:41.944
And as the old saying goes, if you don't really know why you believe what you believe, then you don't know – sorry, you know, if you're not allowing your belief to be critiqued by opponents and if you're not practicing criticizing your opponent's beliefs, then you don't really know why you believe what you believe either.
676
00:50:43.413 --> 00:51:03.582
And by the way, lots of young people in the US at least, and I think probably in Australia and England and other places, they're being taught at places like universities and in high schools and middle schools, they're being taught by teachers and by others that like this concept that argument is violence, that dissent is violence, that disagreement is rude and is harmful and dangerous and disagree.
677
00:51:03.902 --> 00:51:08.284
And what they're basically being taught by grownups is that boxing is bad.
678
00:51:09.005 --> 00:51:11.206
Metaphorical intellectual
boxing is bad.
679
00:51:11.806 --> 00:51:18.771
And so what they're doing is they're creating these people, they're training little kids to be bad thinkers.
680
00:51:18.851 --> 00:51:25.456
It's like you should be training them on the opposite, like teaching them how to argue and how to defend their ideas and how to evaluate evidence.
681
00:51:26.196 --> 00:51:29.299
And that's how you create robust truth-finding.
682
00:51:29.859 --> 00:51:30.279
Grownups.
683
00:51:30.579 --> 00:51:32.140
Tim, how do you respond?
684
00:51:32.460 --> 00:51:38.781
So I'm just trying to always keep on my shoulder the ear of the reasonable woke person here.
685
00:51:38.841 --> 00:51:53.825
So the response that I can feel welling up in the woke part of me is it's all very well for these privileged white dudes to get in the ring and to love wrestling with each other and to love the boxing match and the jousting and the verbal sparring.
686
00:51:54.406 --> 00:51:58.987
And you know who has to deal with the detritus that flies off them every time they punch each other?
687
00:51:59.627 --> 00:52:02.589
It's like the same groups of people who get shat on all the time.
688
00:52:02.669 --> 00:52:05.450
It's women of color, especially trans women of color.
689
00:52:05.490 --> 00:52:13.675
It's like even though we might roll our eyes every time we're like, oh, but what about the poor, disenfranchised, disadvantaged people?
690
00:52:14.155 --> 00:52:17.877
The reality is that there are communities that just have to constantly cop a whole lot of shit.
691
00:52:29.563 --> 00:52:32.030
Like, can we just stop having to hear...
692
00:52:35.587 --> 00:52:49.734
the institutions of power and bigotry constantly force themselves upon us and ask us to defend why they shouldn't be continued to allow, to be allowed to pillage and terrorise everybody.
693
00:52:49.774 --> 00:52:52.255
Like, it's exhausting, is something you hear.
694
00:52:52.275 --> 00:52:57.958
You know, it's exhausting to constantly have to explain why equity and justice are good ideas.
695
00:52:58.158 --> 00:53:04.281
So your boxing ring is fantastic, but can we also create spaces in which people can just...
696
00:53:04.961 --> 00:53:18.728
sit and be with each other okay well so here's what i would say because i i understand that and i mean i see where it's coming from and i've i've heard it before in person and here's here's what i would say to that
697
00:53:19.658 --> 00:53:24.783
The first thing is that it's not true that it's a bunch of white men being silenced.
698
00:53:25.003 --> 00:53:33.531
There's a lot of women and people of color who don't agree with the kind of woke orthodoxy who feel just as silenced.
699
00:53:33.691 --> 00:53:36.414
A friend of mine, Coleman Hughes, he's a great writer.
700
00:53:37.587 --> 00:53:45.497
you know, he's a black guy and he talked about being in class and having the white professor say something like every black person, you know, is, is a, you know, continual victim of racism.
701
00:53:45.538 --> 00:53:48.722
And he said, you know, in his head, he's thinking, I don't feel that way.
702
00:53:48.742 --> 00:53:50.985
That doesn't match up with my lived experience.
703
00:53:51.465 --> 00:53:52.046
But he said, yeah.
704
00:53:52.919 --> 00:53:59.084
And he, you know, this was in an article where he said, but saying that out loud would have been tantamount to social suicide.
705
00:53:59.365 --> 00:53:59.565
Yeah.
706
00:53:59.805 --> 00:54:03.428
And that's that's a black guy being silenced by a bunch of white people and a white professor.
707
00:54:03.728 --> 00:54:04.950
Indeed.
708
00:54:05.230 --> 00:54:16.840
In fact, as someone as someone who has quite a lot to do with the LGBTQIA plus community, I'll also just throw in that on this toxic issue of trans where I'm constantly caricatured by both sides as being.
709
00:54:18.020 --> 00:54:21.422
in opposition to them and in opposition to the trans community.
710
00:54:21.882 --> 00:54:27.164
Most of my trans friends want nothing to do with the fashionable orthodoxies on this.
711
00:54:27.284 --> 00:54:31.486
And most of my black friends don't want anything to – like are the least woke people.
712
00:54:31.506 --> 00:54:32.567
They roll their eyes at it.
713
00:54:32.627 --> 00:54:36.789
So it does strike me as being quite a straight white university educated thing.
714
00:54:36.869 --> 00:54:44.212
If you look at demographics, yeah, it is remarkable how –
715
00:54:45.626 --> 00:54:49.694
overwhelmingly white and well-off and college-educated
716
00:54:50.786 --> 00:54:53.649
a lot of the most vocal woke people are, right?
717
00:54:54.329 --> 00:54:59.234
So it's a myth that it's a bunch of, you know, white men being silenced, conservative white men.
718
00:54:59.254 --> 00:55:00.655
It really is, that's just not true.
719
00:55:01.135 --> 00:55:05.519
It's a lot of, it's people of all demographics being silenced.
720
00:55:06.700 --> 00:55:11.404
And the people doing the silencing are also of all demographics.
721
00:55:11.624 --> 00:55:14.587
And more often than not, they are white and quite privileged themselves.
722
00:55:15.107 --> 00:55:16.548
That's the very, so that's the first thing.
723
00:55:16.809 --> 00:55:18.430
The second thing that I think is more important
724
00:55:20.235 --> 00:55:28.660
is that there's this, and you mentioned this a little bit earlier when you talked about free speech has been the tool of a country that also did really bad things and whatever.
725
00:55:29.581 --> 00:55:32.923
To me, this is major misstep.
726
00:55:32.963 --> 00:55:34.724
It's throwing the baby out with the bathwater.
727
00:55:34.844 --> 00:55:39.327
And so first of all, people like to argue, your free speech isn't being taken away, right?
728
00:55:39.347 --> 00:55:41.988
The First Amendment still holds, the government's not arresting you, and that's true.
729
00:55:42.509 --> 00:55:46.351
But like I said, with a liberal democracy,
there's two things that hold it together.
730
00:55:46.391 --> 00:55:49.533
There's the rules and there's the laws and there's the norms, right?
731
00:55:49.813 --> 00:55:58.836
So to actually have free speech and have it work the way it should, which is a vibrant discourse, right, that makes us smarter over time, you need two things.
732
00:55:58.856 --> 00:56:01.496
You need the First Amendment, but you also need a culture of free speech.
733
00:56:01.897 --> 00:56:09.599
So when you have a group of people that are punishing people for saying the wrong thing, you might as well be taking away the First Amendment because you are going to chill free speech.
734
00:56:09.699 --> 00:56:12.940
So the reason I think this is bad is that if you look at...
735
00:56:13.700 --> 00:56:29.550
I think look at history, look at American history, every single successful social justice movement from women's suffrage to the 60s civil rights movement to the gay marriage movement, every single one of them, not only.
736
00:56:30.491 --> 00:56:33.572
used but completely relied on free speech.
737
00:56:33.612 --> 00:56:37.174
Free speech was the engine of those movements.
738
00:56:37.214 --> 00:56:37.614
Think about it.
739
00:56:37.914 --> 00:56:41.215
Free speech is the majority has their vote.
740
00:56:41.515 --> 00:56:42.676
The wealthy have their money.
741
00:56:42.736 --> 00:56:43.996
The elite have their connections.
742
00:56:44.096 --> 00:56:46.097
The powerless, they have none of those things.
743
00:56:46.137 --> 00:56:48.178
The one thing they have is they have free speech.
744
00:56:48.198 --> 00:56:50.058
They can create a mind-changing movement.
745
00:56:50.498 --> 00:56:56.981
If they're on the side of justice and they're on the side of truth, which the civil rights movement was and the gay rights movement was –
746
00:56:58.348 --> 00:57:08.870
if you're on the, if you, if you have, you know, actual kind of good, good on your side, free speech is your best friend and you will, you will over time change minds and change the world and change the way things are.
747
00:57:09.290 --> 00:57:17.231
So this idea that free speech somehow is the, I mean, I, this often comes up when we're talking about religious freedom questions, right?
748
00:57:17.251 --> 00:57:23.112
You know, in this, in Australia, like in the States, there are questions about when religious freedom bumps up against gay rights.
749
00:57:24.053 --> 00:57:25.613
You know, there's, there's, there, there's been a,
750
00:57:26.493 --> 00:57:35.120
An ongoing thing here, you know, people will be familiar with the kind of gay wedding cake example, the anti-gay baker scenario in the United States.
751
00:57:35.320 --> 00:57:45.548
In Australia, the similar thing is there are sports leagues that have pride rounds where every player is supposed to wear a rainbow jersey.
752
00:57:46.108 --> 00:58:00.997
Now, we have a lot of players in football, in Australian football here, not soccer, but,
you know, oval-shaped ball mostly, who are from Pacific Island nations, who are quite Christian, and who object to homosexuality.
753
00:58:01.697 --> 00:58:11.120
How much should we as a society accommodate the homophobic views of sports players in refusing to participate in pride rounds?
754
00:58:11.620 --> 00:58:19.703
My attitude is always as much as we humanly can in the sense of being as generous as possible to people's deeply held beliefs.
755
00:58:20.924 --> 00:58:32.715
most of my colleagues think that this is untenable and those people are guilty of hate speech and they should be effectively silenced or coerced into pretending to support gay rights.
756
00:58:33.255 --> 00:58:43.324
And my position is always similar to yours, Tim, here, which is what kind of a scenario do you think you're setting up if the rule moving forward is that what the majority thinks is
757
00:58:44.125 --> 00:58:48.288
is what needs to be enforced upon everybody who dissents.
758
00:58:49.008 --> 00:58:55.472
By definition, the majority is generally riding roughshod over the rights of the minority.
759
00:58:55.893 --> 00:58:59.795
How do you think that we managed to get gay rights in the first place?
760
00:59:00.175 --> 00:59:03.157
It was in the face of majority opposition.
761
00:59:03.237 --> 00:59:04.538
The majority didn't want it.
762
00:59:04.918 --> 00:59:11.523
Like, if you want to support minorities, then it seems a very peculiar way to go about doing that, to say...
763
00:59:12.163 --> 00:59:27.672
Because the majority currently agrees with my particular vision of which minorities need to be supported and which don't, I think the majority should have the right to enforce its ethics on everybody else and prevent minorities from speaking out.
764
00:59:27.732 --> 00:59:33.516
Because those minorities are now the ones that we regard as being bigoted slash deviant slash wrong slash evil.
765
00:59:33.556 --> 00:59:34.156
Well, guess what?
766
00:59:34.176 --> 00:59:36.798
A generation ago, they thought gay people were all those things.
767
00:59:38.122 --> 00:59:39.424
Well, there's an arrogance to it.
768
00:59:39.484 --> 00:59:45.511
It's this idea that, you know, people of totally perfectly good people of the past have been dramatically wrong.
769
00:59:46.332 --> 00:59:48.555
So for example, one perfect example is in 1958 in the U.S.,
770
00:59:50.723 --> 00:59:54.326
4% of the country approved of interracial marriage.
771
00:59:54.486 --> 00:59:55.427
Four.
772
00:59:55.467 --> 00:59:56.988
96% said it's immoral.
773
00:59:57.448 --> 00:59:57.928
It's wrong.
774
00:59:58.729 --> 01:00:02.512
Today, 94% of people approve interracial marriage.
775
01:00:02.932 --> 01:00:06.455
So it's not that 96% of the country were bad people back then.
776
01:00:06.495 --> 01:00:12.579
I guarantee if you go back and talk to many of those 96%, you're going to see lovely people who are no less good than you.
777
01:00:13.040 --> 01:00:14.441
They just didn't have as much knowledge.
778
01:00:14.941 --> 01:00:15.982
They were wrong about something.
779
01:00:16.749 --> 01:00:27.048
And what it entails, if you want to shut down free speech and you want to say that people who disagree with me should be silenced, what you're saying is that for the first time,
780
01:00:28.196 --> 01:00:32.098
We've reached a time when good people know the truth and that's it.
781
01:00:32.118 --> 01:00:33.699
They'll be, you know, we have it now.
782
01:00:33.739 --> 01:00:34.220
We got it.
783
01:00:34.360 --> 01:00:35.841
And that just makes no sense.
784
01:00:36.241 --> 01:00:38.602
So there's actually like a lack of humility, I think, there.
785
01:00:38.763 --> 01:00:42.165
And that doesn't mean that you can't have a moral stance and try to push for it.
786
01:00:42.605 --> 01:00:46.147
But you should try to push for it by convincing people, by being persuasive.
787
01:00:46.407 --> 01:00:53.252
You don't push for it by shutting down the discussion because look, any time in the past and you're going to find discussions...
788
01:00:54.132 --> 01:01:15.654
where um that we would see is completely primitive today and there's nothing there's no reason that we're not in the same situation right so that that's the ladder we've gotten through one chapter so far of your seven chapter tome uh what do you think is the most important thing to progress to we can probably maybe the downward spiral or red golem
789
01:01:17.805 --> 01:01:25.069
Yeah, I mean, when I talk about a downward spiral, I mean, this is to me what has been happening in Western countries.
790
01:01:25.329 --> 01:01:27.771
Again, I focus on the U.S. because I know the most about it.
791
01:01:27.851 --> 01:01:38.217
But I do think Australia and England and certain other places, Canada, have been mirroring a lot of the same trends.
792
01:01:39.157 --> 01:01:45.301
The downward spiral is a way of reminding myself and others that I don't think there's really bad people in this story.
793
01:01:45.361 --> 01:01:53.766
I think that there's been an environmental change, a shift over the last 30, 40, 50 years that is changing behavior.
794
01:01:53.826 --> 01:01:59.190
I think that humans, like any other animal, we react to our environment.
795
01:02:00.924 --> 01:02:04.088
I think that really we talked a little about the media landscape changing.
796
01:02:04.228 --> 01:02:09.294
So you go from kind of broadcast national media to tribal, you know, narrow cast media.
797
01:02:09.654 --> 01:02:11.156
That's a giant seismic shift.
798
01:02:11.196 --> 01:02:12.698
You have the birth of social media.
799
01:02:13.185 --> 01:02:25.748
you have a bunch of, you know, political changes in the US, you know, you start to have the Congress being up for grabs every two years, you know, that's a, that's a big change that makes it harder to compromise.
800
01:02:25.768 --> 01:02:28.749
So in the book, I get into a lot of reasons.
801
01:02:28.889 --> 01:02:38.271
But one of
the things in the US that's happened is that, that that we haven't had a very scary national enemy for a long time.
802
01:02:38.371 --> 01:02:40.832
And that is a source of unity in the US, even if it's not a,
803
01:02:41.112 --> 01:02:42.133
pretty thing, nationalism.
804
01:02:42.153 --> 01:02:43.014
It is a source of unity.
805
01:02:43.795 --> 01:02:50.023
And also the parties used to be much more mixed up ideologically, but they really kind of coalesced into very distinct ideological parties.
806
01:02:50.543 --> 01:02:55.449
And that also has an effect because it lights up that primitive mind in a lot of American sense.
807
01:02:55.489 --> 01:02:57.511
It turns things into a national kind of tribal war.
808
01:02:59.476 --> 01:03:06.338
And I think the political tribalism in the U.S. and political bigotry is the number one kind of tribalism and bigotry at the moment.
809
01:03:06.398 --> 01:03:10.578
And, you know, an example I could use is and of course, there'll be exceptions.
810
01:03:10.618 --> 01:03:16.620
But I think if you take 10 conservative white guys and they're maybe even a little racist.
811
01:03:17.120 --> 01:03:17.340
Right.
812
01:03:18.200 --> 01:03:22.901
And you have each of them, you know, you say you can you know, who do you prefer?
813
01:03:23.461 --> 01:03:26.802
This conservative black guy or this woke white guy?
814
01:03:28.124 --> 01:03:31.733
From my experience, at least, just talking to hundreds of people in the last few years,
815
01:03:32.801 --> 01:03:37.924
is that 10 out of 10 of those guys or nine out of 10 are going to, they say, Oh, I'll take that conservative black any day.
816
01:03:38.504 --> 01:03:40.565
Not, not the, not the right.
817
01:03:40.825 --> 01:03:44.707
Because, because political tribalism is the much more intense kind of travel.
818
01:03:44.767 --> 01:03:46.368
It's Trump's racial tribalism.
819
01:03:46.388 --> 01:03:47.989
It Trump's national tribalism.
820
01:03:48.469 --> 01:03:48.629
Right.
821
01:03:48.669 --> 01:03:53.392
So I think that, I think that people have to, you know, I think that we haven't really adjusted to that.
822
01:03:53.412 --> 01:03:57.254
We still think that, you know, the race and, and, you know, xenophobia are the main things.
823
01:03:57.274 --> 01:04:00.055
And of course they still exist, but, you know,
824
01:04:00.315 --> 01:04:06.497
There's this elephant in the room, which is that we've fallen into a complete craze of political bigotry and political tribalism.
825
01:04:06.837 --> 01:04:07.397
And that's real.
826
01:04:07.437 --> 01:04:08.737
And it's tearing the country apart.
827
01:04:08.777 --> 01:04:14.879
And so when I say it's a downward spiral, I picture a whirlpool, which is the media has changed, which affects how people think.
828
01:04:15.159 --> 01:04:18.060
But then the people demand certain things from the media.
829
01:04:18.080 --> 01:04:22.921
The people become more politically partisan, and they are going to reward the media
that does it.
830
01:04:22.961 --> 01:04:24.121
So they affect each other.
831
01:04:24.141 --> 01:04:28.243
And then the politicians are going to get elected by people who are who become more tribal.
832
01:04:28.263 --> 01:04:33.025
But then those politicians themselves are going to be spewing out more tribal things in their campaigns.
833
01:04:33.045 --> 01:04:37.967
And so these things are all in a downward spiral together, kind of swirling together down a vortex.
834
01:04:38.047 --> 01:04:58.233
And you know the data, Tim, about how the polling on when you ask progressive Americans their feelings about – well, like staunchly Democratic Americans, their feelings about if their child brought home or married a conservative Republican –
835
01:04:58.934 --> 01:05:08.888
Their distaste for that exceeds people's reported, white people's reported distaste for bringing home a black partner in like the 50s.
836
01:05:10.107 --> 01:05:10.848
When they compare it.
837
01:05:10.888 --> 01:05:22.759
So we are more racist now towards our, our political opponents than we ever were in the dark old days towards other racial tribes, which is kind of shocking when you think about it.
838
01:05:22.779 --> 01:05:23.860
It's genuine bigotry.
839
01:05:23.900 --> 01:05:25.482
It's genuine, you know, it's what is bigotry?
840
01:05:25.502 --> 01:05:28.284
It's giant, you know, it's making these broad negative stereotypes.
841
01:05:28.325 --> 01:05:30.086
It's dehumanizing people.
842
01:05:31.187 --> 01:05:32.689
It's not caring about, you know.
843
01:05:33.289 --> 01:05:36.171
their suffering and you're cheering for it.
844
01:05:36.951 --> 01:05:37.992
It's insulting them.
845
01:05:38.072 --> 01:05:39.693
It's, it's, it's, it's mocking them.
846
01:05:39.733 --> 01:05:47.877
You know, it's that it's just classic bigotry, but we don't see it as bigotry because it's, you know, because we just, it seems like it's fine.
847
01:05:47.897 --> 01:05:51.139
And of course, but of course no one wants to think of themselves as a bigot.
848
01:05:51.159 --> 01:05:53.961
So it never feels like bigotry when you're doing it.
849
01:05:53.981 --> 01:06:01.265
So I'm sure the immense amount of racial bigotry that was, you know, that you'd find in the Southern, you know, us in the fifties,
850
01:06:01.885 --> 01:06:04.808
for example, I bet those people didn't feel like bigots, right?
851
01:06:04.848 --> 01:06:05.769
They have a lot of reasoning.
852
01:06:05.789 --> 01:06:06.890
Oh, this is okay.
853
01:06:06.930 --> 01:06:07.951
No, we're not being bad people.
854
01:06:07.971 --> 01:06:09.693
Of course, no one thinks of themselves as bad people.
855
01:06:09.733 --> 01:06:12.956
So today we see racial bigots as bad people.
856
01:06:13.016 --> 01:06:15.819
Almost everyone sees that, and that goes for the right and the left.
857
01:06:16.079 --> 01:06:16.880
Mm-hmm.
858
01:06:17.480 --> 01:06:27.307
But we don't see when someone's saying that, you know, those moron right-wingers or those libtards, you know, we don't see it as bigotry, but it is.
859
01:06:27.327 --> 01:06:31.490
It's ugly, and it's causing a huge amount of problems.
860
01:06:31.510 --> 01:06:32.411
Tim, you know what?
861
01:06:32.491 --> 01:06:35.953
You're just making – I always feel so intellectually stimulated when I talk to you.
862
01:06:35.993 --> 01:06:45.420
I love you because I'm now just thinking about Jonathan Haidt's work on our different values, right, and the values that conservatives versus liberals hold.
863
01:06:45.440 --> 01:06:45.540
Yeah.
864
01:06:46.040 --> 01:06:55.269
And one of the things that is a foundational motivation of value, according to Haidt, the social psychologist, is our sense of purity.
865
01:06:55.889 --> 01:06:58.872
This is especially true amongst religious people and conservatives.
866
01:06:59.032 --> 01:07:02.695
And this fuels xenophobic arguments.
867
01:07:02.776 --> 01:07:04.978
It fuels nationalist arguments.
868
01:07:05.558 --> 01:07:08.000
It fuels honour arguments.
869
01:07:08.781 --> 01:07:11.702
Purity, maintaining the purity of the tribe.
870
01:07:12.342 --> 01:07:17.424
And much racism and xenophobia in the past has been justified on that basis, right?
871
01:07:18.264 --> 01:07:25.146
We don't want black people sullying our good, upstanding community with their ways.
872
01:07:25.166 --> 01:07:26.326
They're going to make us impure.
873
01:07:27.327 --> 01:07:27.847
Now...
874
01:07:29.149 --> 01:07:57.227
transpose that motivation onto the modern left, for example, there is a lot of tapping into that instinct in what Trump is doing to us and what hate is doing to us and what the crassness of the rising American right is doing to us is sullying and impurifying our noble American, smaller liberal tradition.
875
01:07:58.627 --> 01:08:00.428
Or go to a college.
876
01:08:00.588 --> 01:08:02.389
And what's been happening there?
877
01:08:03.130 --> 01:08:08.273
Conservative speaker comes to campus and many hundreds of examples of this.
878
01:08:09.614 --> 01:08:11.955
They either, there's a huge protest
879
01:08:12.997 --> 01:08:14.958
enough beforehand that the event is canceled.
880
01:08:15.219 --> 01:08:30.029
And by the way, it's actually, I'm wrong to say conservative because at least half of the people who have been disinvited had been progressives making the kind of points I'm making, kind of basic liberal, arguing for basic liberal things, which conflicts with woke orthodoxy.
881
01:08:32.511 --> 01:08:35.273
They either get the speaker disinvited or
882
01:08:36.129 --> 01:08:40.312
They will shout down the speaker so that no one can hear them until the event's canceled.
883
01:08:40.912 --> 01:08:43.114
Professors have been fired for misstepping.
884
01:08:44.014 --> 01:08:48.637
There's a lot of universities to hire even science professors.
885
01:08:48.697 --> 01:08:59.384
Now make them fill out a diversity statement, quote diversity statement, which is actually
basically a political litmus test to say, are you a proven social justice activist or else you can't be hired as a chemistry professor?
886
01:09:00.045 --> 01:09:00.505
What is that?
887
01:09:00.585 --> 01:09:01.486
That is the same thing.
888
01:09:01.526 --> 01:09:03.067
It is saying that this is a pure space.
889
01:09:03.667 --> 01:09:07.329
And that if these other ideas, they come in, they make it dangerous.
890
01:09:07.369 --> 01:09:08.770
They make it toxic.
891
01:09:08.830 --> 01:09:09.271
Toxic.
892
01:09:09.491 --> 01:09:11.692
That's like a disease.
893
01:09:11.772 --> 01:09:13.553
You want things to be pure, not toxic.
894
01:09:13.753 --> 01:09:14.274
It's amazing.
895
01:09:14.334 --> 01:09:16.235
This is exactly for professors.
896
01:09:16.295 --> 01:09:16.815
It's amazing.
897
01:09:16.935 --> 01:09:18.816
Once you see it, it's so hard to unsee.
898
01:09:18.837 --> 01:09:26.061
And I'm just seeing it like I look at Richard Spencer saying that Islam coming into America is going to make America toxic.
899
01:09:26.101 --> 01:09:29.003
It's going to sully the great American traditions.
900
01:09:29.043 --> 01:09:29.243
It is.
901
01:09:29.283 --> 01:09:30.103
It's a purity test.
902
01:09:30.143 --> 01:09:32.325
It's like we have to protect ourselves from...
903
01:09:32.705 --> 01:09:35.687
the dirty outside, you know, unwanted notions.
904
01:09:35.827 --> 01:09:37.568
It's an ugly tribal instinct.
905
01:09:37.608 --> 01:09:40.030
It's an ugly part of humans to do this.
906
01:09:40.150 --> 01:09:42.492
And it doesn't matter if it's on the left or the right, it's ugly.
907
01:09:42.592 --> 01:09:45.854
And when we see it happening, by the way, I've never voted for a Republican.
908
01:09:45.874 --> 01:09:57.622
So when I criticize, I mean, it's like, I'm not saying this out of a tribal kind of like, it took me a while to kind of accept the fact that the people I thought of as my people were doing a lot of the ugly things.
909
01:09:57.722 --> 01:09:58.623
So now I kind of,
910
01:09:58.823 --> 01:10:16.600
Tim, just to give voice again to my little inner woke critic, right, there's – I'm reminded of – there was like a critique of Karl Popper or maybe a – was it a Popperian idea that was going around a couple of years ago, which was this conceit that went viral on Twitter for a while, that –
911
01:10:17.281 --> 01:10:26.170
It's naive to try to believe in unlimited free speech because the people who are most going to manipulate that are people who want to put an end to free speech.
912
01:10:26.290 --> 01:10:38.882
So if your tolerance extends so far into tolerating intolerant people, you're just going to end up getting steamrolled by fascists because they're not going to give a shit about your tolerance and your free speech and they're going to shut it down.
913
01:10:39.342 --> 01:10:40.022
for everybody.
914
01:10:40.363 --> 01:10:55.509
So this idea of, oh, you know, the woke left is being tribal in a way just like Richard Spencer is, which I just was guilty of saying, can't the retort to that be, well, hang on a second, at some point, you have to draw a boundary around what is acceptable.
915
01:10:55.549 --> 01:11:00.331
Are we just going to be like, oh, you know, anti-Nazis are just so limited.
916
01:11:00.351 --> 01:11:05.113
They're just like Nazis, because they're really excluding Nazis from being part of the conversation.
917
01:11:05.173 --> 01:11:05.653
Like, how do you
918
01:11:08.774 --> 01:11:12.977
kosher without erecting some kind of a fence, a purity fence.
919
01:11:14.778 --> 01:11:21.442
So I'm really happy you brought this up because I actually talk about this in the book and I think it's one of the most important.
920
01:11:22.003 --> 01:11:26.326
This is the kind of thing that when we are not having conversations, we can get really confused about.
921
01:11:27.186 --> 01:11:34.271
So Popper's paradox, very famous, and it's often paraphrased as
922
01:11:36.716 --> 01:11:41.100
In order to maintain a tolerant society, we must be intolerant of intolerance.
923
01:11:42.542 --> 01:11:42.802
Right.
924
01:11:43.122 --> 01:11:50.489
Now, the problem with that is tolerance and intolerance are not good or bad on their own, right?
925
01:11:50.730 --> 01:11:52.852
If you're tolerant of intolerance.
926
01:11:53.496 --> 01:11:57.220
you know, a cult where men marry eight-year-old girls, that's bad.
927
01:11:57.280 --> 01:11:58.622
You'd rather be intolerant, right?
928
01:11:58.662 --> 01:12:00.304
It's good to be intolerant, right?
929
01:12:00.584 --> 01:12:06.731
If you're tolerant of people who look different than you or practice different rituals than you, that's good.
930
01:12:06.871 --> 01:12:08.133
We like that tolerance, right?
931
01:12:08.193 --> 01:12:09.414
So then being intolerant.
932
01:12:09.894 --> 01:12:12.077
So the question is always, you can't just say intolerance.
933
01:12:12.097 --> 01:12:13.378
You can say intolerance of what?
934
01:12:14.039 --> 01:12:24.404
Now, if you don't specify that, inevitably, everyone thinks that they're – everyone who's – whether they're being a bigot or not thinks I'm being intolerant of intolerance.
935
01:12:25.104 --> 01:12:32.027
If you go to dictators in other countries, when they jail dissidents, they jail people for saying the wrong thing or for the wrong religion.
936
01:12:32.047 --> 01:12:33.588
They never say we're jailing dissidents.
937
01:12:33.628 --> 01:12:36.229
They say we're being intolerant of intolerance.
938
01:12:36.269 --> 01:12:39.290
We're jailing – they basically use Popper's argument.
939
01:12:39.330 --> 01:12:42.432
And so it's twisted constantly to mean –
940
01:12:44.151 --> 01:12:47.013
We're being intolerant of intolerance.
941
01:12:47.453 --> 01:12:53.696
And what they mean by that often in this case is, you know, they'll see right wing arguments as intolerant.
942
01:12:53.816 --> 01:12:54.017
Right.
943
01:12:54.497 --> 01:12:56.258
And so those are
intolerant people.
944
01:12:56.858 --> 01:13:02.561
They'll say, you know, people who, you know, who disagree with me, that's intolerance.
945
01:13:02.601 --> 01:13:03.522
We have to be intolerant.
946
01:13:03.542 --> 01:13:05.743
But now Popper's paradox is longer than that.
947
01:13:06.123 --> 01:13:17.266
And what he actually says, and I have it here, he said, he says he doesn't imply that we should suppress the utterance of intolerant philosophies as long as we can counter them by rational argument and keep them in check by public opinion.
948
01:13:17.526 --> 01:13:24.668
Suppression would certainly be unwise, but we should claim the right to suppress them if necessary, even by force, for it may turn out that they're not prepared to meet us.
949
01:13:25.068 --> 01:13:28.952
on the level of rational argument, but begin by denouncing all argument.
950
01:13:29.333 --> 01:13:37.741
They may forbid their followers to listen to rational argument because it's deceptive and teach them to answer arguments by use of their fistals or pistols.
951
01:13:38.262 --> 01:13:39.443
Sorry, their fists or pistols.
952
01:13:39.803 --> 01:13:42.366
But fistals and pistols, I like it.
953
01:13:42.386 --> 01:13:43.387
That's going to be my next book.
954
01:13:43.807 --> 01:13:54.831
Yeah, it's so important because he specifically is saying that the that we shouldn't be intolerant of intolerant philosophies, we should be intolerant of people who are trying to shut down all argument, right?
955
01:13:54.911 --> 01:13:55.891
That is what his part.
956
01:13:56.271 --> 01:14:02.233
And that's so and so so in other words, we should be intolerant of the people who are tweeting about Popper's paradox.
957
01:14:02.693 --> 01:14:03.994
Yes, correct.
958
01:14:04.714 --> 01:14:10.057
So I have a comic and I show that someone says something, right?
959
01:14:10.097 --> 01:14:12.899
And then another person says, those are intolerant ideas.
960
01:14:13.019 --> 01:14:15.140
Popper said we have to be intolerant of intolerance.
961
01:14:15.300 --> 01:14:16.301
Stop him from talking.
962
01:14:16.401 --> 01:14:18.602
And I circle the stop him from talking.
963
01:14:18.942 --> 01:14:21.024
And I say, that's what Popper actually said.
964
01:14:21.084 --> 01:14:21.624
We had to be intolerant.
965
01:14:22.244 --> 01:14:23.325
to stop him from talking.
966
01:14:23.725 --> 01:14:32.271
So anyway, it's frustrating because in the Twitter sphere, you don't get, you can't, I just explained that for three minutes and read a quote, like you don't have the time for that.
967
01:14:32.291 --> 01:14:39.837
So people, that's why you end up with something like cancel culture, which is a direct violation of Popper's paradox being, you know,
968
01:14:40.617 --> 01:14:47.119
being argued as, again, people say that the people who defend a cancellation, they say, we're just being intolerant of intolerance.
969
01:14:47.280 --> 01:14:50.221
Actually, you're doing the exact thing that Popper said we should be intolerant.
970
01:14:50.301 --> 01:14:51.561
Or it's just consequences.
971
01:14:51.601 --> 01:14:53.462
It's just, it's just facing consequences.
972
01:14:53.782 --> 01:14:56.543
But again, I come back to Singer's point of like,
973
01:14:56.923 --> 01:15:04.287
The consequence of saying something stupid or wrong or malevolent should be that another person says something that corrects you.
974
01:15:04.687 --> 01:15:11.010
And yes, they can slap you down in so doing and people can feel free to choose not to associate with you.
975
01:15:11.350 --> 01:15:21.455
But once you start coordinating public mob campaigns to have you stripped of your livelihood or excluded from society because...
976
01:15:22.075 --> 01:15:28.601
You touched a subject or because you said or did something and your critics are not actually addressing the thing that you said.
977
01:15:28.621 --> 01:15:33.506
They're simply saying prima facie the fact that you said it is reasons for mob exclusion.
978
01:15:33.586 --> 01:15:34.607
That's the issue.
979
01:15:34.627 --> 01:15:39.491
To put terms to it, we could say criticism culture attacks ideas.
980
01:15:40.132 --> 01:15:41.333
That enriches discussion.
981
01:15:41.393 --> 01:15:41.753
It's good.
982
01:15:41.833 --> 01:15:43.334
It helps lift up the best ideas.
983
01:15:43.355 --> 01:15:43.895
Yeah.
984
01:15:43.975 --> 01:15:48.036
Cancel culture punishes people for saying the things.
985
01:15:48.236 --> 01:15:51.578
So cancel culture shuts down discussion.
986
01:15:51.758 --> 01:15:55.799
It protects the ideas of the culturally powerful.
987
01:15:56.259 --> 01:15:58.340
You know, criticism is a staple of liberalism.
988
01:15:58.640 --> 01:16:01.421
Cancel culture is the epitome of illiberalism.
989
01:16:01.461 --> 01:16:02.961
So they're actually opposite things.
990
01:16:03.241 --> 01:16:07.203
But if we can't define our terms, then it just seems like, oh, someone who is...
991
01:16:07.883 --> 01:16:09.084
Criticizing cancel culture.
992
01:16:09.104 --> 01:16:10.405
Well, now they're doing the canceling.
993
01:16:10.425 --> 01:16:13.647
And, you know, you can see how very quickly you just get confused here.
994
01:16:13.667 --> 01:16:15.929
But these are these are distinct and opposite things.
995
01:16:16.029 --> 01:16:17.150
Criticism and canceling.
996
01:16:17.170 --> 01:16:22.254
I saw someone denying that cancel culture existed on social media because Louis C.K.
997
01:16:22.274 --> 01:16:23.775
just played Madison Square Garden.
998
01:16:23.915 --> 01:16:25.816
Therefore, he hasn't been canceled.
999
01:16:27.437 --> 01:16:28.759
They also say that about Joe Rogan.
1000
01:16:28.779 --> 01:16:33.383
They say that Joe Rogan and Jordan Peterson are on these huge platforms saying their things.
1001
01:16:33.423 --> 01:16:34.284
It obviously doesn't exist.
1002
01:16:34.324 --> 01:16:38.628
But what I would say to that is, that sounds to me like someone saying, oh, Obama was
president.
1003
01:16:38.688 --> 01:16:40.109
Obviously, racism isn't a thing.
1004
01:16:40.270 --> 01:16:43.373
Oh, Caitlyn Jenner was on the cover of Vogue magazine.
1005
01:16:43.413 --> 01:16:45.995
Obviously, transgender people don't face any problems anymore.
1006
01:16:46.475 --> 01:16:54.798
Just because big-time people on big stages can survive does not mean there's not a giant problem.
1007
01:16:54.938 --> 01:17:00.020
Also, those giant people have to carve out their own shtick.
1008
01:17:00.180 --> 01:17:01.600
I mean, not in the case of Rogan.
1009
01:17:01.640 --> 01:17:05.441
He has a relationship with a big company, Spotify, but it's a big new tech company.
1010
01:17:05.462 --> 01:17:10.043
He's not being published in The New York Times and probably wouldn't be, even if he wanted to be.
1011
01:17:10.203 --> 01:17:12.424
And the fact that Louis C.K.,
1012
01:17:13.064 --> 01:17:36.918
like still has hands and legs and like a head and is capable of going onto the internet and selling tickets to and that madison square garden will rent out its space to him does not mean that there haven't been consequences for him in the fact that none of his shows are on any major streaming platforms anymore and you can't get his can't see his movie anywhere and you can't get any of his stuff through any mechanism other than
1013
01:17:37.278 --> 01:17:42.183
his own chutzpah and, and nows, like what would constitute cancel culture?
1014
01:17:42.203 --> 01:17:47.108
You'd have to behead him and cut his hands off and then he wouldn't be able to go and play, play the garden anymore.
1015
01:17:47.248 --> 01:17:47.528
Okay.
1016
01:17:50.008 --> 01:17:50.508
Exactly.
1017
01:17:50.548 --> 01:18:01.574
And it's, it's just, it seems like there's this willful denial, like that there's a problem and is, as opposed to just taking a look at it and being like, this isn't how like it's scary.
1018
01:18:01.814 --> 01:18:03.215
It shouldn't be a liberal democracy.
1019
01:18:03.235 --> 01:18:05.576
Shouldn't be such a scary place.
1020
01:18:05.956 --> 01:18:16.742
And the thing that that bothers me is that part of the reason I've always felt progressive is, and the thing that the reason it resonates with so many young people, a lot of young people come out of really strict, rigid households, right?
1021
01:18:17.022 --> 01:18:25.211
And they love to go to college and join and become progressive where it, because progressive is supposed to be a safe space to be yourself, to be different, to be weird, to mess up.
1022
01:18:26.092 --> 01:18:29.916
And, and it's supposed to, um, you know, to encourage difference and stuff.
1023
01:18:30.036 --> 01:18:37.164
And, and, and instead what, you know, what, what, what at least, uh, you know, what, what people would criticize, you know, what,
1024
01:18:37.845 --> 01:18:50.293
the woke movement of doing is being the opposite of that, of severe penalties for infraction and for enforcing conformity and for making being weird, being weird kind of intellectually to be bad, dangerous.
1025
01:18:50.393 --> 01:18:53.535
And so to me, it is, it's complete perversion of progressivism.
1026
01:18:53.575 --> 01:19:00.000
It's, it's, it's the same exact kind of thing that people try to escape from rigid conservative, you know, households to escape, right?
1027
01:19:00.020 --> 01:19:02.782
I mean, it's, it's, it's what people make fun of conservatives for.
1028
01:19:02.882 --> 01:19:04.603
And, and so I think that,
1029
01:19:05.203 --> 01:19:18.537
If you feel like if you if someone agrees with me about what I just said about, you know, a safe space to be wrong is good, and they still feel like tribally aligned with the left, I think it's worth examining that and saying the left doesn't deserve my loyalty.
1030
01:19:19.212 --> 01:19:20.553
just because they're the left.
1031
01:19:20.573 --> 01:19:25.177
They have to earn that, like anything else, by being upholding the values that I care about.
1032
01:19:25.397 --> 01:19:27.699
And if they're not upholding those values, I'm not going to go with them.
1033
01:19:27.739 --> 01:19:31.082
I'm staying here where my values are, and they can come back to me or not.
1034
01:19:31.222 --> 01:19:31.742
Well, that's right.
1035
01:19:31.822 --> 01:19:35.265
But also I would encourage you not to give up the mantle of the left to them.
1036
01:19:35.345 --> 01:19:40.069
Don't let people who are illiberal and unjust and have no interest in...
1037
01:19:40.669 --> 01:20:09.226
in equality fairness um free argumentation freedom of thought to to take up a word like the the left i mean they're not they can go and make and also don't go swing 180 sometimes people go 180 and they become tribal on the right you know exactly that's right that's sort of what i was joking don't do that either james lindsey yeah and and and the like um uh you just said something interesting which is it's it's scary the left is getting scary and
1038
01:20:10.593 --> 01:20:14.074
The thing is, it's only scary if you're not a conformist.
1039
01:20:14.994 --> 01:20:19.375
If you're a conformist, there's comfort in tribalism.
1040
01:20:20.135 --> 01:20:24.196
There's comfort in not having to think things through too closely.
1041
01:20:24.976 --> 01:20:40.360
There's comfort in not having to do the intellectual legwork of trying to figure out why you believe what you believe, but knowing that you're on the right side of history through your inherited beliefs through the osmosis of the correct tribe.
1042
01:20:42.462 --> 01:21:09.143
How do you I mean are you confident that the scariness of We're in this tug of war right That there are the people like you and me Who want nothing more than To tease out disagreement Figure out what is true Get our hands dirty in conversation Think as abstractly as possible Question everything And for people like that The modern moment is extremely scary
1043
01:21:10.405 --> 01:21:15.409
But for the people who are the
witch hunters, it's nice.
1044
01:21:16.310 --> 01:21:17.851
So who has the balance of power?
1045
01:21:17.891 --> 01:21:25.697
And at what point does the tyranny of the witch hunt become so widespread that there are enough people who are scared that they push back?
1046
01:21:25.877 --> 01:21:29.880
And how do they do so collectively without being picked off one by one?
1047
01:21:31.441 --> 01:21:36.946
Well, I think one of the things, I think most of the people who are, you know,
1048
01:21:38.133 --> 01:21:41.795
in the mob, we could say, or who are really enforcing the scariness.
1049
01:21:42.515 --> 01:21:43.496
I've talked to a lot of them.
1050
01:21:43.656 --> 01:21:50.039
I had multiple people like that read my book and give me feedback.
1051
01:21:50.640 --> 01:21:57.423
And shockingly, because remember, if you're thinking those people are all awful, you're being a bigot, right?
1052
01:21:57.463 --> 01:21:59.625
Shockingly, when you actually talk to them, people get to know them.
1053
01:21:59.945 --> 01:22:00.925
Most of these are good people.
1054
01:22:00.965 --> 01:22:01.846
Most of these people are
1055
01:22:03.133 --> 01:22:04.794
they got into this because they're empathetic.
1056
01:22:04.814 --> 01:22:05.915
They want to help.
1057
01:22:06.175 --> 01:22:07.536
They want to do social justice, right?
1058
01:22:07.556 --> 01:22:10.238
They, they, they, they want to do the right thing.
1059
01:22:10.258 --> 01:22:10.979
And, and,
1060
01:22:12.133 --> 01:22:17.635
I think that a lot of them have kind of been suckered into what is not what they think it is.
1061
01:22:17.835 --> 01:22:22.576
And you talked about, forget the fact that I would say that it's not good for the social justice causes.
1062
01:22:22.596 --> 01:22:23.837
I don't think it's good for black people.
1063
01:22:23.917 --> 01:22:26.958
I don't think it's good for women or trans people like we talked about a little bit.
1064
01:22:27.298 --> 01:22:27.958
But forget that.
1065
01:22:28.378 --> 01:22:31.119
I don't think it's good for the people, the witch hunters themselves.
1066
01:22:31.559 --> 01:22:32.599
You mentioned some of these things.
1067
01:22:32.759 --> 01:22:35.000
People have these deep needs for black people.
1068
01:22:35.961 --> 01:22:42.042
for meaning, for purpose, for identity, for community, for the feeling of righteousness, for self-esteem, right?
1069
01:22:42.463 --> 01:22:51.885
And what a movement like this and a million other movements and cults and religions, what they often do is it's like a get rich quick scheme, right?
1070
01:22:52.045 --> 01:22:53.305
It's a snake oil.
1071
01:22:54.005 --> 01:22:57.086
It promises you all those things in one stop shop.
1072
01:22:57.306 --> 01:22:59.266
You're gonna come here and suddenly you have your community.
1073
01:22:59.286 --> 01:23:00.047
You know who you are.
1074
01:23:00.087 --> 01:23:01.167
You know what your opinions are.
1075
01:23:01.187 --> 01:23:01.947
You have strong opinions.
1076
01:23:01.967 --> 01:23:02.707
You can sound smart.
1077
01:23:03.007 --> 01:23:03.728
You have your community.
1078
01:23:03.748 --> 01:23:04.248
You have meaning.
1079
01:23:04.268 --> 01:23:04.748
You have purpose.
1080
01:23:04.768 --> 01:23:05.808
You know why you get up in the morning.
1081
01:23:06.308 --> 01:23:07.129
You're good, right?
1082
01:23:07.409 --> 01:23:08.369
And it's not true.
1083
01:23:08.629 --> 01:23:09.630
It's not what it doesn't.
1084
01:23:09.690 --> 01:23:11.810
Of course, those things are much harder to find in life.
1085
01:23:11.830 --> 01:23:15.152
You don't just get those things with a weight loss pill, right?
1086
01:23:15.552 --> 01:23:23.195
And so I think it leaves a lot of these people, first of all, stuck in kind of social situations when they're scared to act up.
1087
01:23:23.755 --> 01:23:25.296
They probably feel the most pressure of all.
1088
01:23:25.616 --> 01:23:27.277
I know that from talking to a bunch of them.
1089
01:23:27.777 --> 01:23:33.739
But also, you just end up feeling empty in the end because it is not all those things.
1090
01:23:33.819 --> 01:23:34.339
It can't be.
1091
01:23:34.799 --> 01:23:42.182
And so I think that part of it is trying to, without attacking people who are doing this, to try to call them in.
1092
01:23:42.982 --> 01:23:50.285
You know, it's what the best movements in the world are the common humanity movements, the effective ones.
1093
01:23:50.325 --> 01:23:56.887
Pauli Murray and the civil rights activists said, when my opponents draw a circle to exclude me, I'll draw a bigger circle to include them.
1094
01:23:56.907 --> 01:23:57.287
Mm-hmm.
1095
01:23:57.547 --> 01:24:00.957
Um, and you know, so that's what I think.
1096
01:24:00.997 --> 01:24:04.066
I think don't, I think it's better to try to, um,
1097
01:24:05.750 --> 01:24:10.494
communicate some of these ideas that you're not a bad person.
1098
01:24:10.514 --> 01:24:11.454
You're trying to do the right thing.
1099
01:24:11.755 --> 01:24:13.876
Here's why I think it's misguided.
1100
01:24:13.936 --> 01:24:17.739
And here's why I also think that it isn't good for you.
1101
01:24:17.779 --> 01:24:19.120
It's not what you think it is.
1102
01:24:19.301 --> 01:24:21.342
And I think that can go a long way.
1103
01:24:21.362 --> 01:24:26.066
Of course, other people might say that's naive and you just have to get angry and have to show force and strength against strength.
1104
01:24:26.106 --> 01:24:26.206
And I
1105
01:24:27.787 --> 01:24:42.299
People in companies, CEOs that are being bullied by their employees or Twitter mob or whatever, I think they should very strongly say not apologize, not pander, not fire the person that they deep down don't think, doesn't think should be fired, but the mob does.
1106
01:24:42.639 --> 01:24:44.700
They should say, no, that's not how we do things here.
1107
01:24:44.760 --> 01:24:45.781
And that we need more of that.
1108
01:24:45.861 --> 01:24:48.043
And
some people have shown that, but not that many.
1109
01:24:49.084 --> 01:24:54.868
Tim, do you have enough time to go for a little bit longer or do you have a hard out?
1110
01:24:54.908 --> 01:24:55.469
No, I have time.
1111
01:24:55.747 --> 01:24:55.967
Great.
1112
01:24:56.388 --> 01:25:13.147
I want to talk about the cycle of good times and bad times, because towards the end, you sort of try to re-invoke the stakes of the book by saying that societies tend to have good times, and then they go stupid, and the stupidity causes them to enter periods of...
1113
01:25:13.708 --> 01:25:27.233
bad times and then those bad times through necessity require that they get their shit together and become wise and that wisdom then pulls them out of the hole and gets them back into a good time.
1114
01:25:27.654 --> 01:25:33.416
You're worried that we can't really afford the luxury of entering bad times in the 21st century.
1115
01:25:36.537 --> 01:25:37.878
Yeah, I think...
1116
01:25:39.084 --> 01:25:45.750
This is what I talked about earlier on with the liberal democracy is this pretty like magical artificial invention.
1117
01:25:46.311 --> 01:26:04.288
You know, we're living inside of these human constructs that protect us from other humans, protect us from violence and mob rule and warlords and all the bad things that can happen in human societies.
1118
01:26:04.917 --> 01:26:09.322
Um, and, and that, that, that didn't happen by accident.
1119
01:26:09.482 --> 01:26:10.824
That's not just the way things are.
1120
01:26:11.464 --> 01:26:14.548
That's something that we made through tons of trial and error.
1121
01:26:14.968 --> 01:26:21.495
And it can only, it, it, it's, it needs to be upheld, not just by the laws, but by the norms and by people defending it.
1122
01:26:22.096 --> 01:26:23.458
And I think that.
1123
01:26:24.993 --> 01:26:31.779
It was built in the first place, modern liberal democracies, by people who understood how bad it can be and how bad tyranny is.
1124
01:26:32.480 --> 01:26:33.661
And they didn't do a perfect job.
1125
01:26:33.841 --> 01:26:35.523
And these democracies have not been perfect.
1126
01:26:35.543 --> 01:26:38.105
There's been a lot of oppression and unfairness, of course.
1127
01:26:38.446 --> 01:26:42.650
But they've been better than the alternative, at least so far, you know.
1128
01:26:43.230 --> 01:26:55.041
And, and so I think that wise, they, these were built by wise people and a lot of ways there, you know, not just by wise people, but by accumulated wisdom going all the way back to the Agora, like you talked about.
1129
01:26:56.022 --> 01:27:01.827
And that, you know, after, you know, the fifties, I think after world war II, you know, in some ways you had, you had.
1130
01:27:02.498 --> 01:27:04.679
people who appreciated what they had.
1131
01:27:04.839 --> 01:27:08.120
And I think that that starts to fade when you don't have a threat.
1132
01:27:08.180 --> 01:27:09.660
And times are good for too long.
1133
01:27:09.680 --> 01:27:12.201
And you were born in a time when everything was stable.
1134
01:27:12.221 --> 01:27:16.162
And by the way, your parents also were only born in a time when everything was stable.
1135
01:27:16.202 --> 01:27:21.744
The boomers haven't experienced that much real fear of, they had some fear of the Soviet Union maybe or...
1136
01:27:22.204 --> 01:27:22.905
You know, things like that.
1137
01:27:22.945 --> 01:27:26.327
But but but really they they felt pretty secure and things have been good.
1138
01:27:26.367 --> 01:27:28.629
And when things are good for too long, you start to get cocky.
1139
01:27:28.849 --> 01:27:32.632
You start to take the thing you have for granted and it can't survive that.
1140
01:27:32.772 --> 01:27:33.793
It actually can't survive.
1141
01:27:34.013 --> 01:27:36.215
We need to be a little bit more scared of losing what we have.
1142
01:27:36.856 --> 01:27:44.462
And so it creates this merry-go-round where wise people create good times because they're so aware of how bad it can be.
1143
01:27:45.182 --> 01:27:47.085
And they're not cocky about it.
1144
01:27:47.225 --> 01:27:50.589
But then good times can create foolish, complacent, cocky people.
1145
01:27:50.749 --> 01:27:54.994
And those people can let things drift to very bad times.
1146
01:27:55.474 --> 01:27:56.616
And because we're in such a,
1147
01:27:57.477 --> 01:27:58.338
high tech time.
1148
01:27:58.718 --> 01:28:00.038
We talked about page 1000.
1149
01:28:00.078 --> 01:28:06.742
Well, page 1001, the good times can be even better and the bad times can be even scarier, like existentially really scary.
1150
01:28:07.042 --> 01:28:10.925
We don't want to mess with bad times in a world where we have so much power and so much tech.
1151
01:28:11.105 --> 01:28:14.367
So how do we, how do we, how do you do that?
1152
01:28:14.407 --> 01:28:25.793
Because, and we haven't really talked about social media, but the elephant in the room, my great fear is that as long as our conversations and our attention and our capacity to follow the thread, we're,
1153
01:28:26.393 --> 01:28:47.867
of important ideas is mediated by algorithms whose sole goal is to keep us addicted to notifications and to sharing and engaging as much as possible, that that metric makes it very hard to skip over and to migrate straight from being foolish clowns to being wise people.
1154
01:28:48.328 --> 01:28:48.828
How do we do it?
1155
01:28:49.669 --> 01:28:51.650
Okay, but, you know, like,
1156
01:28:53.338 --> 01:28:55.693
Even what you just said, if you said that eight years ago,
1157
01:28:56.533 --> 01:28:58.054
people would have raised an eyebrow.
1158
01:28:58.114 --> 01:28:58.314
What?
1159
01:28:58.714 --> 01:28:59.814
Like social media is bad.
1160
01:29:00.214 --> 01:29:06.197
You know, maybe, maybe not eight, maybe 12 years ago, people would say social media is where you go to post about your post your pictures from your vacation.
1161
01:29:06.277 -->
01:29:08.858
And, you know, and it brings people together.
1162
01:29:09.238 --> 01:29:10.659
Yeah, it's, it's, it's, it's great.
1163
01:29:10.679 --> 01:29:12.519
It's just this like silly fun thing we do, right?
1164
01:29:13.200 --> 01:29:20.583
So today, the fact that you would say that, and almost everyone listening would probably shake, you know, nod their head and say, yeah, these things are bad.
1165
01:29:20.683 --> 01:29:21.743
The algorithms are bad.
1166
01:29:22.043 --> 01:29:26.245
You know, we all saw, or a lot of us saw the social dilemma that, you know, that Tristan Harris movie and,
1167
01:29:29.907 --> 01:29:31.447
So right there, that's progress.
1168
01:29:31.847 --> 01:29:32.908
That's the first step.
1169
01:29:33.508 --> 01:29:36.889
You're really in trouble when you don't realize something bad can even happen in a certain thing.
1170
01:29:37.289 --> 01:29:39.630
We are much more wary and things are changing.
1171
01:29:39.750 --> 01:29:45.491
And so the way I would say it is like, I think that it's not just so obvious that we're just heading off the foolish cliff.
1172
01:29:46.171 --> 01:29:50.093
I think that there is wisdom here and it is in a battle with kind of foolishness.
1173
01:29:50.253 --> 01:29:54.614
And to me, the big metric that is going to help the kind of why the wisdom went out is
1174
01:29:55.354 --> 01:29:56.074
is discourse.
1175
01:29:56.234 --> 01:30:07.760
You know, we are no individual humans that smart, but when we're communicating and talking and disagreeing with each other and proving each other's theories right and wrong, that's when we can have some collective wisdom and we need it right now.
1176
01:30:07.800 --> 01:30:10.801
So, which is why, that's why my, I keep coming back to stuff like free speech.
1177
01:30:11.141 --> 01:30:12.382
It's not that I think, you know,
1178
01:30:13.182 --> 01:30:15.963
Something like wokeness in particular is like the worst thing ever.
1179
01:30:16.023 --> 01:30:16.964
I think it's a symptom.
1180
01:30:17.564 --> 01:30:22.026
I think it's a, it's a symptom of a time that a movement could do such damage to free discourse.
1181
01:30:22.406 --> 01:30:22.727
Right.
1182
01:30:22.947 --> 01:30:23.927
And it's the same thing.
1183
01:30:24.087 --> 01:30:25.248
It's not that Trump is the devil.
1184
01:30:25.308 --> 01:30:28.369
It's that we're in a time when we're vulnerable to demagogues.
1185
01:30:28.429 --> 01:30:30.390
That's what, that's what the Trump phenomenon tells me.
1186
01:30:30.830 --> 01:30:33.752
And so to me, because we want to be wise, we,
1187
01:30:34.432 --> 01:30:36.195
And discourse is the way to be wise.
1188
01:30:36.595 --> 01:30:47.008
We have to push back no matter what your beliefs, no matter where you are horizontally on the what you think axis, you've got to push back against people that are making it scary to be wrong, scary to put out ideas and to disagree.
1189
01:30:47.409 --> 01:30:48.630
That's like the number one thing.
1190
01:30:48.650 --> 01:30:50.092
It's like we have to be able to just...
1191
01:30:50.753 --> 01:30:51.955
freely talk.
1192
01:30:52.495 --> 01:30:56.020
And so when someone is, you know, something like cancel culture, it's not a joke.
1193
01:30:56.080 --> 01:30:56.741
It's real.
1194
01:30:56.781 --> 01:31:04.150
And it's, it has, it's scary because it makes our society dumber at a time when we really can't afford to become kind of dumb.
1195
01:31:04.310 --> 01:31:04.591
Hmm.
1196
01:31:05.684 --> 01:31:14.728
The antidote or one antidote that you leave people with at the end of the book is courage, basically, is becoming aware of this.
1197
01:31:14.808 --> 01:31:28.554
But I think we've done a good job of identifying this problem and you've done a great job of articulating the sense that people might have if it's just an ineffable kind of vague sense that something is broken about the way that we're conversing with each other at the moment.
1198
01:31:29.695 --> 01:31:32.037
You break courage into three sort of challenges.
1199
01:31:33.118 --> 01:31:44.589
The challenge to stop saying stuff that you don't believe, the challenge to start saying what you really think in private with people you know well, and the challenge to then go public.
1200
01:31:45.169 --> 01:31:48.893
It sounds a bit like a coming out.
1201
01:31:51.902 --> 01:31:52.122
Yeah.
1202
01:31:52.142 --> 01:31:57.303
I mean, I think in a lot of ways, in a lot of ways, it's, I mean, what, what, why is coming out so hard?
1203
01:31:57.703 --> 01:32:04.265
Because there is an orthodoxy that you're coming out will violate.
1204
01:32:04.365 --> 01:32:11.067
And the people who hold that orthodoxy are going to have a strong negative reaction and maybe cut ties with you and maybe worse.
1205
01:32:12.827 --> 01:32:14.407
This is not different in that regard.
1206
01:32:14.487 --> 01:32:16.068
It's not that it's as hard to,
1207
01:32:16.893 --> 01:32:26.423
Being, you know, having holding something it's as hard holding opposing political views to the orthodoxy as it is being gay.
1208
01:32:26.663 --> 01:32:26.843
Right.
1209
01:32:26.903 --> 01:32:31.448
It's not that it's the same, but it's the same concept, which is that it's not easy.
1210
01:32:31.508 --> 01:32:35.772
Humans can become pretty scary and we all care a lot about what other people think we're wired to.
1211
01:32:35.992 --> 01:32:55.449
I mean, as a gay person, I will allow you to make the analogy and I would actually go further and say that in large cities, in large generally progressive cities in the Western world in 2023, it's easier to come out as gay than it is to come out as the opposite political tribe or to question the orthodoxies of the political tribe that you're around.
1212
01:32:56.182 --> 01:33:00.845
Yeah, because political bigotry and political tribalism has become the number one kind.
1213
01:33:00.905 --> 01:33:03.766
So that's the scariest kind to defy at any given point in history.
1214
01:33:03.806 --> 01:33:13.271
Go back and whatever the main kind of tribalism is, you know, go back to the to the 50s and try to talk about how maybe the Soviet Union is OK. You're out of a job, right?
1215
01:33:13.291 --> 01:33:15.572
Because national tribalism was the big thing then.
1216
01:33:15.893 --> 01:33:21.235
So this is what this is our thing now is this kind of conservative versus progressive tribalism.
1217
01:33:21.255 --> 01:33:21.636
Yeah.
1218
01:33:22.676 --> 01:33:27.658
And and so I think that that's what requires a lot of courage.
1219
01:33:27.678 --> 01:33:36.482
But here's the cool thing about it is that, you know, the Iranian women throwing their hijabs in the fire, that is just a total different level of courage.
1220
01:33:36.502 --> 01:33:36.662
Right.
1221
01:33:36.983 --> 01:33:39.224
You know, defying the Maoists in the 60s.
1222
01:33:40.520 --> 01:33:47.723
You know, there's, you know, whatever it is, you can name any to try to defy the Nazis, defy the fascists in Italy when they're in power.
1223
01:33:48.203 --> 01:33:49.964
That's different because they will kill you.
1224
01:33:50.504 --> 01:33:50.764
Right.
1225
01:33:51.204 --> 01:33:52.445
They will put you in jail.
1226
01:33:53.045 --> 01:33:56.847
So the interesting thing today is we have a lot of the same fear of of.
1227
01:33:57.707 --> 01:34:09.317
of saying what we think because we're wired to care almost as much about being ostracized and people criticizing us as we are about physical danger, but it's not actually nearly as dangerous.
1228
01:34:09.437 --> 01:34:14.361
And so there's a soft power that is kind of the scary thing here, not a hard power.
1229
01:34:14.681 --> 01:34:15.521
That's a big difference.
1230
01:34:16.001 --> 01:34:21.223
And so I think a lot of people have to realize that if they started just saying what they believe, the sky is not going to fall on their head.
1231
01:34:21.303 --> 01:34:23.003
Like probably nothing will happen.
1232
01:34:23.043 --> 01:34:26.944
And actually, there's a good chance that a lot of other people have been secretly thinking those things too.
1233
01:34:27.284 --> 01:34:31.765
And the people will have a ton of respect for them for saying out loud what everyone's thinking.
1234
01:34:31.825 --> 01:34:41.868
And so it's good to remember that like the fear we feel is often the primitive, our primitive mind, which remember, doesn't know that we're not in a little tribe in 50,000 BC where being hated can mean death.
1235
01:34:42.848 --> 01:34:43.609
It doesn't know that.
1236
01:34:43.749 --> 01:34:45.892
And that actually, that's a lot of what's doing the thinking here.
1237
01:34:45.912 --> 01:34:48.716
And it's not very, it's not actually, it doesn't map onto reality.
1238
01:34:48.736 --> 01:34:53.703
And that courage, you don't need as much courage as you think you do to start representing people.
1239
01:34:54.208 --> 01:34:55.749
who you really are publicly.
1240
01:34:56.049 --> 01:34:57.309
You're probably not a terrible person.
1241
01:34:58.089 --> 01:35:03.651
If you start saying what you really think, you're probably going to find a lot of other also good people who say, you know what?
1242
01:35:03.711 --> 01:35:05.052
I kind of agree with that.
1243
01:35:05.692 --> 01:35:07.513
Now, some people are going to get fired from their jobs.
1244
01:35:07.553 --> 01:35:17.936
You know, I have a friend who is a teacher who said, if he even says anything about some of the kind of woke policies that he thinks are really bad at the school that are being enacted, which he thinks are bad for, you know, the kids and everything.
1245
01:35:18.357 --> 01:35:20.978
He says, if he mentions that he's out of a job, he'll lose his health insurance.
1246
01:35:20.998 --> 01:35:21.498
He has two kids.
1247
01:35:21.518 --> 01:35:22.058
He can't afford it.
1248
01:35:23.075 --> 01:35:23.995
I'm not talking about him.
1249
01:35:24.255 --> 01:35:25.596
I'm not asking him to be courageous.
1250
01:35:25.616 --> 01:35:26.856
I'm talking about everyone else.
1251
01:35:27.116 --> 01:35:30.557
And most of us will be fine, you know, if we start speaking up, even just with our friends.
1252
01:35:30.837 --> 01:35:33.638
So, but yeah, the very first thing is stop saying things you don't believe.
1253
01:35:33.698 --> 01:35:46.222
Because so much of the problem here is people parroting what's popular and saying what, you know, saying the things that are popular that are going to get a lot of likes or retweets or that are going to get people to think you're a good person and they don't really believe it.
1254
01:35:46.262 --> 01:35:47.682
And that's part of the problem.
1255
01:35:47.702 --> 01:35:52.884
That's what makes it seem like an actual minority view is the majority view.
1256
01:35:53.004 --> 01:35:58.808
Yeah, I mean, part of the problem is there are actual penalties to not saying what, like to refraining.
1257
01:35:58.868 --> 01:36:00.309
It's becoming a thought policing.
1258
01:36:00.329 --> 01:36:18.442
It's becoming quite Stalinist in the sense that, as you say, you might be going for an academic position and you'll be required to sign a document about your commitment to a specific set of diversity, equity and inclusion policies that go way beyond just saying that you believe that all people should be free from discrimination and violence.
1259
01:36:18.462 --> 01:36:19.163
That's McCarthyism.
1260
01:36:19.343 --> 01:36:20.705
That's a political loyalty.
1261
01:36:20.745 --> 01:36:21.807
We had those in the 50s.
1262
01:36:21.927 --> 01:36:34.666
In Australia now, it's necessary at every public event and every meeting and every Zoom meeting and every conference and everywhere to do an acknowledgement of country, which means like a land acknowledgement of First Nations.
1263
01:36:35.527 --> 01:36:36.108
uh, people.
1264
01:36:36.228 --> 01:36:42.031
And, you know, there's a general sense of, or, or like, you know, putting
pronouns in a person's, in your email signature.
1265
01:36:42.371 --> 01:36:50.815
These, these are little gestures that most people regard as being, uh, like, why would, why would you be so mean and ornery as to object?
1266
01:36:51.315 --> 01:36:56.558
But there's just something inside me that just feels like there's a, there's a,
1267
01:36:58.396 --> 01:37:04.621
There's something unhealthy about jumping on bandwagons, even if the bandwagon is a good one.
1268
01:37:04.741 --> 01:37:18.272
There's something unhealthy about unthinkingly joining what some of the people who are doing it might regard as being a fad at best and objectionable at worst.
1269
01:37:19.572 --> 01:37:20.113
or deranged.
1270
01:37:20.913 --> 01:37:22.314
I think it doesn't matter what it's like.
1271
01:37:22.714 --> 01:37:26.877
I think it's actually becomes, I think if you're a good liberal, lowercase liberal, right?
1272
01:37:27.157 --> 01:37:28.337
You stand up for liberal values.
1273
01:37:28.878 --> 01:37:30.879
I think it doesn't, it becomes irrelevant.
1274
01:37:31.039 --> 01:37:32.040
What is being forced?
1275
01:37:32.780 --> 01:37:39.084
I think if, you know, there's a story after, you know, the George Floyd riots, there was a woman who said that her boss said to her,
1276
01:37:39.944 --> 01:37:42.866
You're not posting about this on your social media, and that's a problem.
1277
01:37:43.246 --> 01:37:44.386
On your personal social media.
1278
01:37:44.587 --> 01:37:44.887
Right.
1279
01:37:44.947 --> 01:37:45.087
Right.
1280
01:37:45.787 --> 01:37:48.769
I think that it doesn't matter what the boss is saying to her.
1281
01:37:48.989 --> 01:37:54.692
It could be saying post about how great America is, post about how bad cop shootings are.
1282
01:37:55.172 --> 01:37:57.053
Post about how great Christianity is.
1283
01:37:57.093 --> 01:37:58.633
It doesn't matter what it is.
1284
01:37:58.893 --> 01:38:01.554
The answer should be no, because it's illiberal.
1285
01:38:02.255 --> 01:38:04.475
It doesn't matter what the political loyalty oath is.
1286
01:38:04.495 --> 01:38:07.396
It doesn't matter if it's exactly down the middle of my politics.
1287
01:38:07.496 --> 01:38:11.058
Again, I feel strongly about kind of classic liberalism.
1288
01:38:11.878 --> 01:38:14.321
If I'm at the university and they're saying, we don't want Marxists here.
1289
01:38:14.341 --> 01:38:15.683
We're going to make sure we don't get any.
1290
01:38:15.743 --> 01:38:18.807
We're going to do a test.
1291
01:38:18.847 --> 01:38:24.474
And if they're not a strong liberal like us, then they're not going to get – I would protest that just as much as anything else because it's not about what it is.
1292
01:38:24.494 --> 01:38:25.556
This is wrong.
1293
01:38:25.576 --> 01:38:26.156
It's illiberal.
1294
01:38:26.256 --> 01:38:26.537
It's a –
1295
01:38:27.218 --> 01:38:35.006
Yeah, I mean, it's also like the requiring football players to wear a rainbow jersey in order to play in
the game.
1296
01:38:35.046 --> 01:38:37.148
I mean, it smacks of the same kind of thing.
1297
01:38:37.228 --> 01:38:47.399
I understand the instinct that the smaller liberal thing to do is to demonstrate to LGBTQIA plus youth that we're on their side and that we're not bigoted.
1298
01:38:48.200 --> 01:38:54.627
But in order to do that, you're requiring another person to become an instrument in your social goal.
1299
01:38:55.108 --> 01:38:57.350
And they don't want to be an instrument in your social goal.
1300
01:38:57.430 --> 01:38:59.192
They disagree with that particular social goal.
1301
01:38:59.392 --> 01:39:01.294
They're not going out and beating young gay people.
1302
01:39:01.735 --> 01:39:07.762
They just want to be able to not have to proactively support the rainbow ideology.
1303
01:39:08.202 --> 01:39:08.882
They're Christians.
1304
01:39:09.042 --> 01:39:13.364
And by the way, they might agree with your social goal and choose to not express it in this context.
1305
01:39:13.424 --> 01:39:13.924
That's right.
1306
01:39:13.964 --> 01:39:15.765
It's not your business.
1307
01:39:16.405 --> 01:39:17.445
And it's this coercion.
1308
01:39:17.485 --> 01:39:19.746
It's this very – and that's just very illiberal.
1309
01:39:19.766 --> 01:39:25.548
It's this with us or against us kind of tone of really –
1310
01:39:26.648 --> 01:39:28.189
um, mobbish movements.
1311
01:39:28.369 --> 01:39:32.770
And sometimes, sometimes it's just, I mean, sometimes all it is, is fatuous and absurd.
1312
01:39:32.830 --> 01:39:44.113
Like I, I live in one of the most progressive neighborhoods in, uh, in Australia, in the inner West of Sydney, uh, which is sort of, you know, think Bushwick or, uh, like Williamsburg.
1313
01:39:44.153 --> 01:39:46.054
It's kind of, you know, hipster, hipster areas.
1314
01:39:46.714 --> 01:40:01.821
And when I got back here from the States a few years ago, I saw that on all of the street signs, the local council has put up a sign underneath the street name that says, say no to racism or racism not welcome here.
1315
01:40:02.481 --> 01:40:10.204
Now, these are highly multi-ethnic neighbourhoods with an extremely progressive and anti-racist population.
1316
01:40:10.484 --> 01:40:17.327
The only racism that exists here is the racism of white liberals dripping with sanctimony about how anti-racist they are.
1317
01:40:17.707 --> 01:40:30.293
The idea that it's necessary to put taxpayer money into congratulating ourselves for stamping out racism in the least redneck part of the entire country is like, that's almost like a kind of forced speech.
1318
01:40:30.313 --> 01:40:30.893
Like, I don't want to...
1319
01:40:31.413 --> 01:40:31.813
What are we doing?
1320
01:40:31.833 --> 01:40:34.114
It's kind of like putting a cross.
1321
01:40:34.374 --> 01:40:38.535
It's probably kind of like putting a cross up in a Christian theology.
1322
01:40:38.575 --> 01:40:39.515
Right, exactly.
1323
01:40:39.535 --> 01:40:40.155
Theocracy.
1324
01:40:40.255 --> 01:40:41.855
Yeah, that's right.
1325
01:40:42.275 --> 01:40:42.975
That's right.
1326
01:40:43.336 --> 01:40:50.557
And the bigger thing is that you know that if any city council member had said, I actually don't think that's what we should be doing, they would have been in big trouble.
1327
01:40:50.577 --> 01:40:52.077
And that's partially why it happens.
1328
01:40:52.497 --> 01:40:53.558
Everyone's scared to push back.
1329
01:40:53.598 --> 01:40:54.938
Tim, my own friend.
1330
01:40:54.998 --> 01:40:57.038
I was walking along the street and I pointed to it.
1331
01:40:57.078 --> 01:40:59.279
I like scoffed and rolled my eyes.
1332
01:40:59.319 --> 01:41:00.099
And she was like, what?
1333
01:41:01.385 --> 01:41:02.366
I said, the sign.
1334
01:41:02.386 --> 01:41:04.610
She was like, what do you mean?
1335
01:41:04.630 --> 01:41:06.813
Don't you oppose racism?
1336
01:41:06.833 --> 01:41:09.396
I was like, of course I oppose racism.
1337
01:41:09.437 --> 01:41:10.298
Why do we need a sign?
1338
01:41:11.733 --> 01:41:17.097
But yeah, so first comes the awakening, then comes the coming out, I guess.
1339
01:41:17.677 --> 01:41:32.428
Tim, I want to ask you first date questions, which is a way that I always just pepper the guest with some Rorschach questions to get the first thing that comes into their mind and allow the listener to understand them a little better.
1340
01:41:32.888 --> 01:41:35.390
What is the best meal that you've ever had?
1341
01:41:35.410 --> 01:41:39.033
Yeah.
1342
01:41:39.505 --> 01:41:44.108
Probably, I had Chinese, which is my favorite cuisine, Chinese food.
1343
01:41:44.168 --> 01:41:48.652
And then I had the best I've ever had was in Hong Kong.
1344
01:41:48.772 --> 01:41:50.353
And this like little side of the road thing.
1345
01:41:50.373 --> 01:41:53.595
And I just remember being like, this is the best that food could ever be.
1346
01:41:53.935 --> 01:41:54.155
Okay.
1347
01:41:54.175 --> 01:41:57.518
So actual Chinese, actual Cantonese food, not American Chinese.
1348
01:41:57.538 --> 01:41:57.878
No, no.
1349
01:41:57.898 --> 01:41:59.459
What about American Chinese?
1350
01:41:59.479 --> 01:42:01.421
No, it was pretty similar to the Americanized.
1351
01:42:01.441 --> 01:42:02.141
That's why I like it.
1352
01:42:02.161 --> 01:42:03.142
I actually prefer it.
1353
01:42:03.182 --> 01:42:04.943
But it was just so incredibly good.
1354
01:42:05.183 --> 01:42:05.583
Okay.
1355
01:42:05.704 --> 01:42:07.085
So the Kung Pao chicken and the...
1356
01:42:08.447 --> 01:42:09.953
oh my god yeah that's bullshit