প্রতিলিপি 🔗
1
00:00:54,390 --> 00:00:59,300
Welcome Paul Raffile to the
Smarticle Scams podcast.
2
00:00:59,360 --> 00:01:02,610
It is a true honor and
privilege to have you on here.
3
00:01:02,979 --> 00:01:08,460
Before we get started, I love for you,
and then I'll explain how I found you and
4
00:01:08,469 --> 00:01:11,510
what that's about, but I'd love for you
to give us a little bit of your background
5
00:01:11,809 --> 00:01:14,790
because we're doing the Smarticle Scams,
we're talking about scams, tell us a
6
00:01:14,790 --> 00:01:18,510
little bit about yourself, where you come
from and how you got into fighting scams.
7
00:01:20,009 --> 00:01:21,420
Hey, thanks so much for having me.
8
00:01:21,949 --> 00:01:26,380
Yeah, I've been an Intel analyst
for the past 10 years in my career.
9
00:01:26,410 --> 00:01:27,550
What is an Intel analyst?
10
00:01:27,710 --> 00:01:32,320
We are the folks who monitor things
online, threats against the nation,
11
00:01:32,320 --> 00:01:36,460
threats against corporations,
threats against regular people.
12
00:01:36,880 --> 00:01:41,169
I started out tracking ISIS on social
media for the government, early part
13
00:01:41,169 --> 00:01:45,029
of my career, and then moved over
to the corporate sector after that.
14
00:01:45,460 --> 00:01:50,760
Most recently, I've been focused on
combating a dangerous scam and pervasive
15
00:01:50,789 --> 00:01:52,490
scam called financial sextortion.
16
00:01:53,890 --> 00:01:57,720
That's the overarching basis of this
show is to talk about 6th Dorsian.
17
00:01:57,750 --> 00:02:00,660
So, Paul is, he's a little
bit humble, I think.
18
00:02:00,670 --> 00:02:04,380
He has incredible pedigree in
terms of this sort of work.
19
00:02:04,969 --> 00:02:09,470
I found Paul because as I started
doing research for this show, I started
20
00:02:09,480 --> 00:02:13,065
hearing these people, I like to call
them fraud warriors, but Paul is
21
00:02:13,065 --> 00:02:17,075
definitely a fraud warrior, has posted
prolifically about these different
22
00:02:17,105 --> 00:02:19,175
scams, specifically sextortion scams.
23
00:02:19,485 --> 00:02:23,135
So let's start there, and do me a favor,
there's, by the way, there's a great
24
00:02:23,175 --> 00:02:26,945
introduction or a great explanation
on the FBI website that I will post
25
00:02:26,945 --> 00:02:30,834
in the show notes, but tell us what is
sextortion, what is financial sextortion?
26
00:02:31,755 --> 00:02:37,035
Financial sextortion is a crime where
criminals are coercing young people,
27
00:02:37,065 --> 00:02:42,474
usually, into sharing intimate photos
or videos and then the criminals
28
00:02:42,474 --> 00:02:45,904
immediately blackmail their targets,
threatening to share those photos or
29
00:02:45,905 --> 00:02:50,634
videos and ruin their victims lives
unless they continue to pay money.
30
00:02:51,230 --> 00:02:52,950
Sextortion is not a new crime.
31
00:02:53,040 --> 00:02:57,670
It historically targeted females,
victims of intimate partner violence.
32
00:02:58,130 --> 00:03:03,269
But what we've seen rapidly growing
over the past two to three years is
33
00:03:03,319 --> 00:03:08,290
this financial version of sextortion,
where it is essentially a scam combined
34
00:03:08,290 --> 00:03:10,369
with child sexual exploitation.
35
00:03:11,109 --> 00:03:14,959
So in the past, it would be some,
somebody, maybe a boyfriend or a friend or
36
00:03:14,959 --> 00:03:20,450
whatever would ask for Uh, a young person,
typically a young lady, to send them
37
00:03:20,640 --> 00:03:22,730
naked photos or whatever of themselves.
38
00:03:22,760 --> 00:03:25,430
I was a teacher for a long time
and you'd see these bullying
39
00:03:25,470 --> 00:03:26,570
things come out around this.
40
00:03:26,870 --> 00:03:28,819
But that's not what we're seeing now.
41
00:03:28,960 --> 00:03:30,000
That's not typical anymore.
42
00:03:30,000 --> 00:03:30,540
Is that correct?
43
00:03:31,559 --> 00:03:34,849
What we're seeing with sex
torture is the script is flipped.
44
00:03:35,179 --> 00:03:40,839
Now the typical victim is a male,
typically 14 to 17 years old is
45
00:03:40,839 --> 00:03:43,490
the most common victim profile
according to the National Center
46
00:03:43,570 --> 00:03:44,779
for Missing and Exploited Children.
47
00:03:44,965 --> 00:03:48,695
The motive for the scam has changed.
48
00:03:48,934 --> 00:03:53,325
Now we're seeing an entirely new
criminal element, criminal enterprise,
49
00:03:53,405 --> 00:03:57,505
entering into the space of child
sexual exploitation for money.
50
00:03:58,195 --> 00:04:02,135
And these criminals have realized
that they can target young boys
51
00:04:02,135 --> 00:04:06,385
and young men with the scam
and get very rich very quickly.
52
00:04:07,024 --> 00:04:08,845
But why is it 14 to 17?
53
00:04:08,845 --> 00:04:11,385
Is that just like they're
particularly vulnerable?
54
00:04:11,584 --> 00:04:14,374
You think maybe a 21 year old kid,
I'm sure it happens to people older,
55
00:04:14,374 --> 00:04:16,045
but why is it that age in particular?
56
00:04:16,494 --> 00:04:16,954
Interesting.
57
00:04:17,024 --> 00:04:22,805
I would say that university age and kind
of young adult age is a very commonly
58
00:04:22,805 --> 00:04:26,945
targeted group as well, except we just
don't have good data on this age group.
59
00:04:26,965 --> 00:04:31,055
We have better data on minors simply
because these crimes are being reported by
60
00:04:31,055 --> 00:04:34,755
the social media platforms to the National
Center for Missing and Exploited Children.
61
00:04:35,320 --> 00:04:35,670
Got it.
62
00:04:35,670 --> 00:04:38,200
And that's going to lead me to a
question about social media later on.
63
00:04:38,200 --> 00:04:41,510
But before we get to that,
tell me what it looks like.
64
00:04:42,730 --> 00:04:46,470
How do they typically approach
or find or coerce their victims?
65
00:04:46,470 --> 00:04:49,850
I know that's three questions, but I'm
wondering how
Load full transcript
this even gets started.
66
00:04:50,419 --> 00:04:50,699
Yeah.
67
00:04:50,730 --> 00:04:52,160
So here's what the scam looks like.
68
00:04:52,755 --> 00:04:59,505
Imagine you are a young person on
Instagram and you receive a request from
69
00:04:59,505 --> 00:05:05,405
someone to follow you and that person
has 15 to 20 mutual friends in common.
70
00:05:06,285 --> 00:05:09,945
They appear like they're someone
potentially who goes to school with
71
00:05:09,945 --> 00:05:11,735
you or lives on the other side of town.
72
00:05:12,525 --> 00:05:15,665
Maybe someone that you don't know
personally but appears to be in your
73
00:05:15,675 --> 00:05:18,085
circle, outer circle of friends.
74
00:05:19,235 --> 00:05:21,145
The conversation starts out normal.
75
00:05:21,805 --> 00:05:26,355
They will ask you about your day, ask
what you're up to, and they will very
76
00:05:26,355 --> 00:05:28,215
quickly turn the conversation flirtatious.
77
00:05:28,545 --> 00:05:33,625
They'll ask for a selfie, a photo, and
then the criminal gets very deceiving.
78
00:05:33,685 --> 00:05:37,835
They actually send a nude photo
first, and then they demand and
79
00:05:37,914 --> 00:05:40,204
coerce their victim to reciprocate.
80
00:05:40,885 --> 00:05:43,735
The moment that happens, that's
when the blackmail begins.
81
00:05:44,165 --> 00:05:47,755
These criminals have scripts and it's
a verbatim, Hey, I have your nudes and
82
00:05:47,755 --> 00:05:49,205
everything needed to ruin your life.
83
00:05:49,715 --> 00:05:51,925
I'm going to send it to
your school, your family.
84
00:05:51,925 --> 00:05:55,105
You're going to get expelled
and lose your scholarships
85
00:05:55,415 --> 00:05:57,965
unless you pay me 500 right now.
86
00:05:58,780 --> 00:06:01,490
You've said something, they
usually have 20 friends in common.
87
00:06:01,730 --> 00:06:02,580
How does that happen?
88
00:06:03,050 --> 00:06:05,500
How do they get the 20 friends
in common on social media?
89
00:06:06,270 --> 00:06:06,559
Right.
90
00:06:06,580 --> 00:06:10,240
These criminals are very adept
at making themselves look like
91
00:06:10,319 --> 00:06:12,299
legitimate personas online.
92
00:06:13,390 --> 00:06:16,809
One of the tactics that these criminals
use is what they call bombing.
93
00:06:17,309 --> 00:06:21,190
And bombing is when they flood a whole
bunch of friend requests and follower
94
00:06:21,219 --> 00:06:23,210
requests into a specific community.
95
00:06:23,210 --> 00:06:24,369
It could be a high school.
96
00:06:24,729 --> 00:06:26,200
It could be a sports team.
97
00:06:26,684 --> 00:06:30,395
When numerous people, uh,
within that community accept
98
00:06:30,575 --> 00:06:32,284
that scammer's follow request.
99
00:06:32,809 --> 00:06:36,610
It makes their account seem more
authentic, more legitimate, that that
100
00:06:36,610 --> 00:06:39,270
is an actual person in the community.
101
00:06:39,390 --> 00:06:41,529
But nobody in the community
actually knows this person.
102
00:06:41,529 --> 00:06:45,949
This is just sort of part of the
con, is that they get one person to
103
00:06:45,949 --> 00:06:49,159
accept and then it's like, oh, so
and so accepted, they must be okay.
104
00:06:49,159 --> 00:06:51,179
Is that the psychology behind it?
105
00:06:51,770 --> 00:06:52,740
That's exactly right.
106
00:06:53,310 --> 00:06:53,710
Okay.
107
00:06:53,849 --> 00:06:57,609
Are these, maybe you don't have an
answer to this, but who are these people?
108
00:06:57,900 --> 00:06:59,989
Who is doing this extortion?
109
00:07:00,539 --> 00:07:01,789
Is it just across the board?
110
00:07:02,560 --> 00:07:04,430
Well, we actually have a
pretty good answer here.
111
00:07:04,460 --> 00:07:09,820
And most of the financial sextortion is
actually being driven by one particular
112
00:07:09,820 --> 00:07:13,889
threat group out of West Africa,
and they call themselves Yahoo Boys.
113
00:07:14,770 --> 00:07:15,780
Why the Yahoo boys?
114
00:07:16,760 --> 00:07:21,700
Yahoo boys are the Nigerian prince
scammers from about 20 years ago.
115
00:07:21,700 --> 00:07:24,460
They have moved on to the
romance scams on Facebook.
116
00:07:24,520 --> 00:07:26,989
They've moved on to the
crypto scams on Twitter.
117
00:07:27,470 --> 00:07:31,550
And now the scam that they are finding
to be very quick and very lucrative
118
00:07:31,580 --> 00:07:33,610
for them is financial sextortion.
119
00:07:33,639 --> 00:07:35,310
They call it the blackmail scam.
120
00:07:35,750 --> 00:07:39,640
What's funny, there's one theme that
I'm hearing over and over and over
121
00:07:40,120 --> 00:07:45,475
when we look at these digital online
scams is The creation of trust in the
122
00:07:45,475 --> 00:07:49,414
victim through things like what you
just said, bombing, getting people
123
00:07:49,435 --> 00:07:52,774
to accept requests, it's happening
on LinkedIn, it happens everywhere.
124
00:07:52,775 --> 00:07:55,865
So you're like, Oh, they must be
legit, even though they're not.
125
00:07:55,945 --> 00:07:57,284
Are there any hells?
126
00:07:58,044 --> 00:08:01,884
So if I was talking to my son or
daughter and I was saying, look,
127
00:08:01,904 --> 00:08:03,619
this is what you need to be aware of.
128
00:08:03,939 --> 00:08:08,890
What are the tells, what are the kind of
tricks that one might look for in this?
129
00:08:09,849 --> 00:08:10,780
Here's the scary thing.
130
00:08:11,260 --> 00:08:15,119
Some victims have sent me different
accounts that they know are being used
131
00:08:15,119 --> 00:08:19,149
in sextortion, the accounts that targeted
them, and I've looked at these accounts,
132
00:08:19,530 --> 00:08:22,349
and they are entirely indistinguishable.
133
00:08:22,655 --> 00:08:25,765
From real people, their
profile looks legitimate.
134
00:08:25,805 --> 00:08:27,695
It looks several years old.
135
00:08:28,025 --> 00:08:32,045
The criminals are purchasing or hacking
into accounts that have authentic
136
00:08:32,045 --> 00:08:33,965
activity
on the social media platform.
137
00:08:34,405 --> 00:08:35,215
So they look legit.
138
00:08:35,595 --> 00:08:40,054
And then once they have those 10, 15,
20 mutual friends in common, there's no
139
00:08:40,054 --> 00:08:41,774
telling just based on the account alone.
140
00:08:42,384 --> 00:08:44,269
Then I'll give some other red flags about.
141
00:08:44,510 --> 00:08:48,970
Ways that you can detect a sextortion
scam, hopefully before it happens.
142
00:08:49,699 --> 00:08:53,750
Number one, the criminal comes off
very flirtatious, very quickly.
143
00:08:54,370 --> 00:08:58,520
Nobody online with good intentions
is going to be asking or coercing
144
00:08:58,530 --> 00:09:02,809
you to send a compromising photo
within 48 hours of knowing them.
145
00:09:03,180 --> 00:09:06,319
And oftentimes that's all it
takes for this scam to execute.
146
00:09:06,780 --> 00:09:09,770
It could be as short as 30
minutes, or it could be extended
147
00:09:09,770 --> 00:09:10,640
out through a couple of days.
148
00:09:11,444 --> 00:09:13,355
But this is a very fast moving scam.
149
00:09:13,915 --> 00:09:18,314
Secondly, I think it's important to know
these criminals very often try to move
150
00:09:18,365 --> 00:09:20,375
the kids or the victims onto Snapchat.
151
00:09:21,245 --> 00:09:23,775
And the reason they do
that is for two reasons.
152
00:09:24,075 --> 00:09:27,025
Number one, young people
think that Snapchat is a less
153
00:09:27,025 --> 00:09:29,144
risky place to share photos.
154
00:09:29,794 --> 00:09:33,564
And the reason for that is Snapchat is
known for its disappearing photo feature.
155
00:09:34,185 --> 00:09:35,454
That's the main
characteristic of Snapchat.
156
00:09:36,140 --> 00:09:40,440
However, what these criminals have been
able to do is they are able to, number
157
00:09:40,440 --> 00:09:46,089
one, send pre recorded videos and live
and pre recorded photos to make it appear
158
00:09:46,089 --> 00:09:50,470
as though they are live photos and live
videos being sent to the victims using the
159
00:09:50,810 --> 00:09:55,700
platform's own features to make it seem
convincing, and number two, the criminals
160
00:09:55,700 --> 00:09:59,819
have been able to Screenshot and screen
record of things that are happening on
161
00:09:59,820 --> 00:10:05,240
Snapchat without that notification going
off, which typically notifies people
162
00:10:05,240 --> 00:10:06,910
that their Snapchats are being saved.
163
00:10:07,579 --> 00:10:08,420
How are they doing that?
164
00:10:08,599 --> 00:10:11,260
What's the, do you know what
the technology behind that is?
165
00:10:11,549 --> 00:10:12,739
We're not making that public.
166
00:10:13,300 --> 00:10:15,209
Okay, so it's, but it's a thing.
167
00:10:15,860 --> 00:10:19,480
It's a very rudimentary technology
around that they are using.
168
00:10:20,490 --> 00:10:24,610
And the reason I ask that is I often
wonder what is the responsibility
169
00:10:24,650 --> 00:10:29,469
of Snapchat to combating
this
or is Snapchat combating this?
170
00:10:30,760 --> 00:10:36,239
Snapchat has done a few things since this
has become a major topic on their radar.
171
00:10:36,829 --> 00:10:40,010
Number one, I do want to highlight
Snapchat's research that recently came
172
00:10:40,010 --> 00:10:44,580
out that showed 51 percent of Gen Z
have been targeted for sextortion.
173
00:10:45,280 --> 00:10:51,275
23% Have reported saying that they have
fallen victim to a sextortion and a
174
00:10:51,275 --> 00:10:53,575
large chunk of that financial sextortion.
175
00:10:53,835 --> 00:10:57,865
So that's not a small number then
there's millions of gen z ers online
176
00:10:58,205 --> 00:11:02,634
and on snapchat Do we have any idea
of the rough numbers when we say 23?
177
00:11:02,644 --> 00:11:03,365
What does that look like?
178
00:11:04,850 --> 00:11:08,100
That aligns with the huge spike we're
seeing out of the National Center
179
00:11:08,160 --> 00:11:09,990
for Missing and Exploited Children.
180
00:11:10,350 --> 00:11:14,589
Back in 2021, there were only 139
reported cases of financial sex
181
00:11:14,589 --> 00:11:16,249
torture in minors here in the U.
182
00:11:16,249 --> 00:11:21,449
S. Fast forward just two years to
2023, and instead of 139 cases,
183
00:11:21,970 --> 00:11:23,880
there were over 26, 000 cases.
184
00:11:24,585 --> 00:11:27,705
That's an 18, 000 percent
increase in the span of two years.
185
00:11:28,705 --> 00:11:31,995
139 cases they were reviewing on
an annual basis, and now they're
186
00:11:32,105 --> 00:11:33,775
reviewing 900 cases a week.
187
00:11:33,964 --> 00:11:34,685
Oh my goodness.
188
00:11:34,735 --> 00:11:36,204
They're completely inundated with this.
189
00:11:36,825 --> 00:11:40,115
Okay, you said it's one gang, the
Yahoo Boys or whatever out of Nigeria.
190
00:11:40,385 --> 00:11:43,805
Are they working similar to
what the pig butchering scams
191
00:11:43,805 --> 00:11:45,065
are working out of compounds?
192
00:11:45,495 --> 00:11:46,425
What does this look like?
193
00:11:47,319 --> 00:11:51,329
The Yalopoys have elements of
organized and disorganized crime.
194
00:11:51,800 --> 00:11:56,390
So no, they are not operating out of
a centralized scam center or compound.
195
00:11:56,440 --> 00:11:59,629
They're actually very geographically
distributed across West Africa,
196
00:12:00,009 --> 00:12:02,500
primarily in Nigeria and the Ivory Coast.
197
00:12:02,940 --> 00:12:05,810
These criminals operate in
small gangs, small groups.
198
00:12:06,030 --> 00:12:10,180
Often times one person is the money
person running the, the money accounts.
199
00:12:10,560 --> 00:12:14,579
Another person is the chatter who
sends all these friend requests
200
00:12:14,649 --> 00:12:16,180
and initial conversations out.
201
00:12:16,609 --> 00:12:21,009
And they work in groups in order to,
uh, extort as many people as they can.
202
00:12:22,209 --> 00:12:26,230
We know one criminal is responsible
for over a thousand victims.
203
00:12:26,560 --> 00:12:31,349
And I will say eight figures in
extorted payments from these victims.
204
00:12:31,779 --> 00:12:32,530
Just one person.
205
00:12:34,170 --> 00:12:34,990
Oh my goodness.
206
00:12:35,380 --> 00:12:38,330
I guess the question I would ask,
and then I really do want to get into
207
00:12:38,330 --> 00:12:42,590
the victims themselves, but is AI
playing a part in any of this now?
208
00:12:43,060 --> 00:12:47,600
I have been gone down an AI rabbit
hole, working on podcasts, working
209
00:12:47,610 --> 00:12:50,680
in technology, you just, it's
everywhere, it's prolific, but
210
00:12:50,680 --> 00:12:52,780
I am amazed at how good it is.
211
00:12:52,890 --> 00:12:55,200
I got to imagine there's
some level of this.
212
00:12:55,219 --> 00:12:57,020
Is this happening with AI at all?
213
00:12:57,870 --> 00:12:58,470
Yes.
214
00:12:58,539 --> 00:13:00,950
Right now it's a small
percentage, but it's growing.
215
00:13:01,680 --> 00:13:05,210
There's two ways that these criminals
are using AI to enhance their
216
00:13:05,260 --> 00:13:07,260
financial sextortion operations.
217
00:13:07,830 --> 00:13:12,855
The first one, for example, Let's say
we just met on social media, we are
218
00:13:12,855 --> 00:13:18,055
exchanging selfies, and some of these
victims do get a little suspicious,
219
00:13:18,395 --> 00:13:22,689
and they ask or request something
like They'll send me a photo of you
220
00:13:22,689 --> 00:13:27,050
touching your nose or with a thumbs
up or a peace sign, some sort of proof
221
00:13:27,050 --> 00:13:30,300
of life to make sure that that person
is actually who they say they are.
222
00:13:31,170 --> 00:13:36,030
And we are already seeing these
victims using AI tools to manipulate
223
00:13:36,060 --> 00:13:40,470
the models that they are catfishing
as in order to show us those poses
224
00:13:40,740 --> 00:13:43,589
to prove that they are that person.
225
00:13:44,160 --> 00:13:47,290
Before we get to the second part,
for my uncle Lou in Iowa, for
226
00:13:47,290 --> 00:13:50,519
people that aren't aware, define
catfishing really quickly for us.
227
00:13:50,955 --> 00:13:55,305
Yeah, catfishing is essentially pretending
to be someone that you are not online.
228
00:13:56,295 --> 00:13:59,494
Here's the other way that AI is
being used by these extortion
229
00:13:59,495 --> 00:14:04,055
criminals, and this part I think has
a big potential for abuse at scale.
230
00:14:05,045 --> 00:14:10,524
We are already seeing these criminals,
if they fail, at convincing a victim to
231
00:14:10,815 --> 00:14:13,475
send a nude photo, or a revealing photo.
232
00:14:13,920 --> 00:14:17,580
We're already seeing these
criminals artificially generate nude
233
00:14:17,580 --> 00:14:19,840
photos of their victims using AI.
234
00:14:20,430 --> 00:14:24,290
They are finding normal photos on
these victims Instagram accounts,
235
00:14:24,319 --> 00:14:29,710
for example, uploading these photos
to nudifying apps that are
readily
236
00:14:29,710 --> 00:14:34,650
available online these days, and then
using those photos, that material, to
237
00:14:34,650 --> 00:14:39,060
extort their victims, threatening to
send that material out unless they pay.
238
00:14:39,720 --> 00:14:43,560
So a person could do absolutely nothing
other than make contact with this.
239
00:14:43,910 --> 00:14:47,300
And it could be extorted to
pay for these fake photos.
240
00:14:47,750 --> 00:14:48,709
That's exactly right.
241
00:14:48,709 --> 00:14:49,869
You can do everything correct.
242
00:14:50,089 --> 00:14:52,689
You can decide not to send
the photo and you can still
243
00:14:52,689 --> 00:14:53,859
become a victim of this crime.
244
00:14:54,410 --> 00:14:56,599
All right, I'm about ready to
just shut down my computer.
245
00:14:57,699 --> 00:14:59,730
Lock my daughter in a bunker somewhere.
246
00:15:00,700 --> 00:15:02,479
The reality is obviously we can't.
247
00:15:03,345 --> 00:15:06,865
Let's talk a little bit
about the victims themselves.
248
00:15:06,935 --> 00:15:08,485
Is there a certain demographic?
249
00:15:08,485 --> 00:15:09,564
We said it's the age.
250
00:15:09,964 --> 00:15:13,095
I'd love to hear about what's
the fallout for the victims.
251
00:15:13,095 --> 00:15:16,125
I can imagine it's terrible and
things I've read from you and others.
252
00:15:16,444 --> 00:15:17,295
It looks horrific.
253
00:15:17,295 --> 00:15:21,655
So what's going on once the
scams start or they get hooked
254
00:15:21,655 --> 00:15:23,135
into it or catfished into it?
255
00:15:23,725 --> 00:15:27,394
So as I mentioned, these criminals
are using ruthless tactics,
256
00:15:27,665 --> 00:15:31,484
threats, manipulation in order
to get their victims to pay.
257
00:15:31,815 --> 00:15:35,275
They're legitimately threatening
to ruin these kids lives.
258
00:15:35,935 --> 00:15:39,775
I mentioned before, like, they are
threatening to leak these photos to,
259
00:15:40,435 --> 00:15:44,984
uh, the kids teachers, to their school,
to get them expelled, saying that their
260
00:15:44,985 --> 00:15:48,735
scholarships are going to get revoked
or they'll be taken off the sports team.
261
00:15:49,620 --> 00:15:53,820
In some instances, we even see these
criminals texting the kid from a
262
00:15:53,840 --> 00:15:58,230
different phone number, pretending to
be law enforcement, and that the kid
263
00:15:58,230 --> 00:16:02,530
is now under investigation for the
activity that they're involved in.
264
00:16:02,890 --> 00:16:05,470
Just really relentless
threats and blackmail.
265
00:16:05,765 --> 00:16:08,175
What's the fallout for
these kids themselves?
266
00:16:08,205 --> 00:16:09,345
What's happening to them?
267
00:16:10,185 --> 00:16:15,405
As of today, we are aware of at least
44 teen suicides of teenagers that
268
00:16:15,405 --> 00:16:20,065
were being victimized in a financial
sextortion scam who took their own lives.
269
00:16:20,065 --> 00:16:23,945
They had no other way out or they
thought that they had no other way out.
270
00:16:24,930 --> 00:16:28,430
I believe this is a
terribly low underestimate.
271
00:16:28,460 --> 00:16:32,860
Most of these cases have only been
discovered by happenstance, by chance.
272
00:16:33,329 --> 00:16:35,439
These victims are not leaving notes.
273
00:16:35,539 --> 00:16:38,080
They're taking this embarrassing
situation to the grave with them.
274
00:16:38,710 --> 00:16:42,140
I would not be surprised if the
actual casualty count was in the
275
00:16:42,540 --> 00:16:44,064
several hundreds at this point.
276
00:16:44,725 --> 00:16:49,194
We're only happening to discover
these cases when a friend just happens
277
00:16:49,194 --> 00:16:54,375
to remember the pin to the victim's
phone or police happen to crack
278
00:16:54,375 --> 00:16:57,625
into the phone three or four months
later after the, after the fact.
279
00:16:59,125 --> 00:17:02,275
As a parent, I can't
think of anything worse.
280
00:17:03,775 --> 00:17:05,914
I just can't think of
anything worse than this.
281
00:17:05,914 --> 00:17:08,214
Something happened to your child
that you can't protect them from.
282
00:17:08,615 --> 00:17:11,175
What is the landscape look
like for these families that
283
00:17:11,175 --> 00:17:12,425
are caught up in these scams?
284
00:17:13,040 --> 00:17:14,730
And is there anything
they can do about this?
285
00:17:14,730 --> 00:17:18,829
The scary thing is, all of
those, all the families.
286
00:17:19,694 --> 00:17:21,444
Have done everything correctly.
287
00:17:22,145 --> 00:17:24,845
The families that lost their kids
to this, they were loving families.
288
00:17:24,875 --> 00:17:25,984
They supported their kids.
289
00:17:26,025 --> 00:17:27,655
They talked about digital safety.
290
00:17:27,655 --> 00:17:31,904
They talked about not sending images
to people online, but these kids
291
00:17:31,904 --> 00:17:35,534
are victims and these criminals are
more manipulative than ever before.
292
00:17:35,595 --> 00:17:36,905
It is a rapid fire.
293
00:17:37,510 --> 00:17:41,940
Groaning and coercing the kids
into a terrible situation.
294
00:17:43,030 --> 00:17:45,330
Lots of parents, of course,
have the conversation.
295
00:17:45,490 --> 00:17:48,710
Do not send photos to
folks you just met online.
296
00:17:49,059 --> 00:17:49,159
Right.
297
00:17:49,580 --> 00:17:50,090
At all.
298
00:17:50,640 --> 00:17:53,390
I think there needs to be a
part two of that conversation.
299
00:17:53,760 --> 00:17:59,030
That sounds a little bit like, if this
does happen, There are things that we
300
00:17:59,070 --> 00:18:03,860
can do, resources that, that we can do
to make sure those photos are not leaked,
301
00:18:04,040 --> 00:18:10,149
posted, you will be okay, you'll be fine,
uh, come to us as a supportive parent,
302
00:18:10,150 --> 00:18:12,359
you know, be this off landing space.
303
00:18:12,940 --> 00:18:16,249
Um, let them know that you aren't going
to be mad and take away the phone and
304
00:18:16,250
--> 00:18:18,640
they're, they're going to be punished.
305
00:18:18,640 --> 00:18:22,400
Let them know that they can come to you
as the parent for those sorts of things.
306
00:18:22,950 --> 00:18:28,430
If you were talking to a room full of
kids, and I was a middle school principal
307
00:18:28,430 --> 00:18:32,659
and teacher, I always would say to
them, remember, even though it says
308
00:18:32,660 --> 00:18:35,799
that it's disappearing, once it's in
the digital space, it's there forever.
309
00:18:36,129 --> 00:18:40,670
What would you say, as somebody that's so
deeply embedded in this, to a room full
310
00:18:40,720 --> 00:18:42,990
of 14 to 17 year olds or college kids?
311
00:18:43,020 --> 00:18:44,180
What would you say to them about this?
312
00:18:45,020 --> 00:18:47,439
In other words, how do you
prepare them, is what I'm asking.
313
00:18:48,110 --> 00:18:51,620
Yeah, you might have to fact check me
on this, but I saw a statistic that
314
00:18:51,620 --> 00:18:55,979
if you know how a scam works, you're
80 percent less likely to fall for it.
315
00:18:56,220 --> 00:19:01,885
If I were to wave a magic wand, just In
the awareness element of letting teens
316
00:19:01,885 --> 00:19:07,954
know that, Hey, historically, you may
not have been a huge target or a victim
317
00:19:08,005 --> 00:19:13,704
of online exploitation, but the entire
demographic has shifted these criminals.
318
00:19:13,745 --> 00:19:19,045
Their target is everybody you will
be targeted by this crime, and you
319
00:19:19,235 --> 00:19:20,635
just have to recognize those signs.
320
00:19:20,635 --> 00:19:25,475
And if it happens to you, just there
are resources out there to help out.
321
00:19:26,185 --> 00:19:26,554
All right.
322
00:19:26,565 --> 00:19:28,684
So that leads us to the.
323
00:19:30,700 --> 00:19:33,760
What can or what are social
media, law enforcement, what
324
00:19:33,760 --> 00:19:35,380
are people doing to stop this?
325
00:19:35,420 --> 00:19:38,069
Or is anybody doing anything to stop this?
326
00:19:39,249 --> 00:19:43,159
The social media platforms
have taken some steps over the
327
00:19:43,219 --> 00:19:45,139
past year to try to curb this.
328
00:19:45,179 --> 00:19:48,879
We've seen some press releases and
feature updates from Meta, from
329
00:19:49,080 --> 00:19:53,710
Instagram, from Snapchat, and from
Cash App on this issue, and those
330
00:19:53,720 --> 00:19:57,500
three platforms are the most affected
by financial sextortion right now.
331
00:19:58,255 --> 00:20:01,105
On the law enforcement front,
we have seen some promise.
332
00:20:01,175 --> 00:20:04,615
It's very rare to have an
extradition of a scammer from
333
00:20:04,615 --> 00:20:06,125
Nigeria being brought to the U.
334
00:20:06,125 --> 00:20:06,985
S. for justice.
335
00:20:07,415 --> 00:20:11,935
Just a couple months ago, however, was
the very first extradition for financial
336
00:20:11,975 --> 00:20:14,904
extortion for a child who died by suicide.
337
00:20:15,550 --> 00:20:18,399
Those criminals are now in
federal prison serving 17 years.
338
00:20:18,810 --> 00:20:21,670
There are a couple other extraditions
pending out of West Africa
339
00:20:21,889 --> 00:20:23,320
from the Ivory Coast as well.
340
00:20:23,869 --> 00:20:28,499
And it's a problem where we can't
extradite our way out of it.
341
00:20:28,630 --> 00:20:31,360
There are thousands of
criminals doing this crime.
342
00:20:31,870 --> 00:20:34,789
So we really have to rely on the
social media platforms to ensure
343
00:20:34,790 --> 00:20:35,790
that they are safe by design.
344
00:20:37,070 --> 00:20:38,360
Are they safe by design?
345
00:20:39,180 --> 00:20:39,400
No.
346
00:20:40,679 --> 00:20:42,240
And that's what I'm seeing
over and over again.
347
00:20:42,580 --> 00:20:47,500
And I'm not trying to cast aspersions at
everybody's It uses social media, but I
348
00:20:47,540 --> 00:20:53,720
think that the one thing, theme that I'm
constantly hearing is social media needs
349
00:20:53,720 --> 00:20:55,679
to do more and it's across the board.
350
00:20:55,679 --> 00:20:58,000
It's every one of these types
of scams that are out there.
351
00:20:58,389 --> 00:21:01,559
So let's talk about one thing that when
you were saying that I was thinking, how
352
00:21:01,560 --> 00:21:03,240
do the kids get the money to pay for this?
353
00:21:04,389 --> 00:21:08,250
The number one payment platform
used by minors in financial sex
354
00:21:08,250 --> 00:21:09,500
tortion schemes is Cash App.
355
00:21:10,090 --> 00:21:14,389
Roughly 40 percent of payments being
remitted in financial sex tortion
356
00:21:14,389 --> 00:21:15,639
schemes are through Cash App now.
357
00:21:16,230 --> 00:21:21,460
Um, that has superseded gift cards, that
has superseded cryptocurrency, and that
358
00:21:21,460 --> 00:21:25,970
has superseded all the other peer to peer
payment platforms like Venmo and PayPal.
359
00:21:27,395 --> 00:21:31,335
So why CashApp, and why did
this crime spree actually
360
00:21:31,385 --> 00:21:33,585
start in quarter four of 2021?
361
00:21:35,385 --> 00:21:39,634
CashApp was the first of the peer
to peer payment platforms, uh,
362
00:21:39,654 --> 00:21:43,315
that allowed for teen accounts,
what they call sponsored accounts.
363
00:21:43,885 --> 00:21:47,095
Which rolled out in quarter four of 2021.
364
00:21:48,645 --> 00:21:54,335
At the very same time that these payment
platforms were extending their services
365
00:21:54,335 --> 00:22:01,145
now to minors aged 13 to 17, very quickly,
the scammers, uh, realized that they
366
00:22:01,155 --> 00:22:03,254
had new targets that were now connected.
367
00:22:03,495 --> 00:22:07,985
So the international payment system
when we say peer to peer, we mean
368
00:22:08,004 --> 00:22:12,004
things like Venmo or I have it attached
to my bank account and you and I go
369
00:22:12,004 --> 00:22:15,635
out for dinner and I say, I'm going
to Venmo you 40 bucks or cash app you
370
00:22:15,654 --> 00:22:19,615
40 bucks or whatever, should they,
and you don't have to answer this.
371
00:22:19,625 --> 00:22:23,594
You maybe you can't answer this,
but should cash app put the
372
00:22:23,594 --> 00:22:28,985
kibosh on the access for if we
see direct results of this should
373
00:22:28,985 --> 00:22:30,264
cash app do something about that.
374
00:22:31,605 --> 00:22:34,615
They certainly have the data
and the signals to act on this.
375
00:22:35,175 --> 00:22:40,145
They are seeing anomalous activity, they
are seeing money flowing out towards West
376
00:22:40,145 --> 00:22:45,145
Africa inexplicably from, uh, victims
who have never paid money there before.
377
00:22:45,604 --> 00:22:50,085
Uh, they are seeing teens empty their
entire accounts, uh, sending them to
378
00:22:50,085 --> 00:22:53,895
accounts that they have never interacted
with before, and accounts that have
379
00:22:53,895 --> 00:22:57,395
also received a whole lot of money
from a whole bunch of other teenagers
380
00:22:57,395 --> 00:22:58,845
in a very short period of time.
381
00:22:59,634 --> 00:23:06,840
Um, they are seeing The direct messages
that occur on Cash App, because you can
382
00:23:06,999 --> 00:23:12,189
send payment requests to people and these
criminals are sending payment requests
383
00:23:12,189 --> 00:23:14,679
to their victims with threats in them.
384
00:23:15,029 --> 00:23:18,784
So all this data is visible to Cash App.
385
00:23:18,784 --> 00:23:25,510
And you don't have to answer this if you
don't feel comfortable answering it, but
386
00:23:25,969 --> 00:23:27,939
why isn't Cash App doing something then?
387
00:23:29,260 --> 00:23:29,280
Ugh.
388
00:23:31,110 --> 00:23:32,060
It's complicated.
389
00:23:33,590 --> 00:23:35,770
I could go into the things
that they are doing, but they
390
00:23:35,770 --> 00:23:37,100
aren't particularly helpful.
391
00:23:38,200 --> 00:23:41,680
They committed to a White House
pledge to combat image based
392
00:23:41,730 --> 00:23:44,150
abuse and all these things that
don't really have teeth into them.
393
00:23:44,150 --> 00:23:46,360
I don't have a good answer
to that question, really.
394
00:23:46,849 --> 00:23:50,300
One of the things that I'm seeing
from people is people are genuinely
395
00:23:50,339 --> 00:23:55,039
and realistically worried about
litigation from companies because
396
00:23:55,669 --> 00:23:57,250
You can't prove some of this stuff.
397
00:23:57,280 --> 00:23:59,060
So I'm not saying that
cash app is doing this.
398
00:23:59,060 --> 00:24:01,840
I'm not saying that Instagram is
doing this, but it does feel like
399
00:24:01,840 --> 00:24:05,609
there's a lot of data out there
to support some of this work.
400
00:24:05,610 --> 00:24:10,769
So the next question I would ask them,
let's say that cash app is just a solace.
401
00:24:11,245 --> 00:24:13,905
Uh, machine, and they're not going
to do anything until they're forced.
402
00:24:14,295 --> 00:24:17,495
Who forces these companies
to make these changes?
403
00:24:17,495 --> 00:24:18,284
Is it Congress?
404
00:24:18,284 --> 00:24:19,324
Is it the president?
405
00:24:19,834 --> 00:24:21,024
Is it law enforcement?
406
00:24:21,084 --> 00:24:22,504
Where do these changes come from?
407
00:24:23,485 --> 00:24:27,825
At this point, I'll take anybody
because social media platforms have
408
00:24:27,825 --> 00:24:30,374
operated with impunity for 20 years.
409
00:24:30,804 --> 00:24:34,595
They are immune from any sort
of liability based on criminal
410
00:24:34,595 --> 00:24:36,054
activity on the platforms.
411
00:24:36,645 --> 00:24:40,544
COSA was just shot down in the House
of Representatives in December.
412
00:24:41,105 --> 00:24:41,625
What's COSA?
413
00:24:41,955 --> 00:24:46,705
The Kids Online Safety Act, and that
was the first significant online safety
414
00:24:46,705 --> 00:24:48,765
legislation for kids in 20 years.
415
00:24:49,365 --> 00:24:54,055
It passed in the Senate 91 to 3,
and when it moved over to the House
416
00:24:54,214 --> 00:24:59,424
for a vote, Speaker Johnson did not
even bring it up for a vote, despite
417
00:24:59,704 --> 00:25:04,155
the majority of attorney generals
urging him to do so, despite leaders
418
00:25:04,155 --> 00:25:05,985
of the Senate urging him to do so.
419
00:25:06,495 --> 00:25:09,775
Now he's been in a state that's
pushed for online protection,
420
00:25:09,814 --> 00:25:11,225
anti pornography, all this stuff.
421
00:25:11,729 --> 00:25:13,419
Louisiana has been at
the forefront of that.
422
00:25:13,429 --> 00:25:14,674
So what was his.
423
00:25:15,085 --> 00:25:19,095
Did he give any reasoning why he
killed the, killed it in committee?
424
00:25:20,435 --> 00:25:24,585
It actually passed through a committee and
it was due for a vote in the full house.
425
00:25:24,905 --> 00:25:26,635
It was just never raised for a vote.
426
00:25:27,365 --> 00:25:32,894
I don't suppose that has anything to do
with MEDA's decision, an announcement
427
00:25:32,895 --> 00:25:37,534
to invest a 10 billion data center
in Louisiana earlier in December.
428
00:25:38,695 --> 00:25:39,305
Interesting.
429
00:25:39,605 --> 00:25:42,285
We're not saying that Mike Johnson
did that because of that, but
430
00:25:42,675 --> 00:25:45,115
there does seem to be a monetary.
431
00:25:45,614 --> 00:25:47,435
Rationale for a lot of this stuff.
432
00:25:48,584 --> 00:25:50,144
I will editorialize.
433
00:25:50,154 --> 00:25:53,995
You don't have to Paul, but our kids
are more important than anything else.
434
00:25:53,995 --> 00:25:58,204
And they're certainly more important
than the shareholder stock price of meta.
435
00:25:59,014 --> 00:26:05,555
So what can the people listening today
do to push things like HOSA and bills to
436
00:26:05,555 --> 00:26:09,935
protect our kids, because the other crimes
we've talked about, they've affected older
437
00:26:09,935 --> 00:26:11,795
Americans, pig butchering is everywhere.
438
00:26:12,125 -->
00:26:13,775
This is attacking our children.
439
00:26:14,195 --> 00:26:16,094
This is a very serious.
440
00:26:16,545 --> 00:26:17,025
Issue.
441
00:26:17,565 --> 00:26:18,905
Children are dying.
442
00:26:19,165 --> 00:26:22,255
We talk about all sorts of things,
but here's an opportunity for us
443
00:26:22,255 --> 00:26:23,455
to actually do something about it.
444
00:26:23,655 --> 00:26:28,565
What can the average person listening
to this right now do to combat this?
445
00:26:29,264 --> 00:26:32,745
Number one, contact your
representatives, especially in the house.
446
00:26:33,300 --> 00:26:38,400
Make them know that this is a priority
in passing COSA in 2025's Congress.
447
00:26:38,500 --> 00:26:42,710
Number two, talk to families, talk
to kids, talk to teens in your life.
448
00:26:42,710 --> 00:26:47,040
Let them know that this crime
exists and hopefully they're less
449
00:26:47,040 --> 00:26:48,719
likely to become victim to it.
450
00:26:48,779 --> 00:26:52,750
And if they do, they know that you can be
a resource and help them get out of it.
451
00:26:53,375 --> 00:26:56,014
Is there any place you
would send families?
452
00:26:56,014 --> 00:26:58,225
I know you do a lot of this
work, but you're just one person.
453
00:26:58,575 --> 00:27:00,205
Is there, are there any resources?
454
00:27:00,255 --> 00:27:02,964
And I know there are, but
what are the basic resources
455
00:27:02,964 --> 00:27:04,495
that a family would look for?
456
00:27:04,515 --> 00:27:06,764
Yeah.
457
00:27:07,245 --> 00:27:10,715
So both for awareness, but also
reporting it if it happens.
458
00:27:11,145 --> 00:27:16,424
Great resources out of the National Center
for Missing and Exploited Children, NCMEC.
459
00:27:16,435 --> 00:27:16,735
org.
460
00:27:17,345 --> 00:27:20,805
There's also some great educational and
awareness material put out by THORN.
461
00:27:21,345 --> 00:27:24,915
And lastly, I would recommend the
awareness materials and education
462
00:27:24,925 --> 00:27:28,315
materials from the Canadian
Center for Child Protection.
463
00:27:28,395 --> 00:27:30,365
They've done a lot of great
work on the subject too.
464
00:27:30,985 --> 00:27:33,505
Because it's not just affecting
American kids, it's affecting
465
00:27:33,704 --> 00:27:34,995
kids worldwide, I'm assuming.
466
00:27:35,005 --> 00:27:35,065
Thank you.
467
00:27:35,625 --> 00:27:36,024
Absolutely.
468
00:27:36,675 --> 00:27:41,445
I am now depressed, thank you
Paul, but I am grateful that people
469
00:27:41,515 --> 00:27:43,275
such as yourself are out there.
470
00:27:44,415 --> 00:27:47,555
Doing battle for this last
question I have for you.
471
00:27:47,555 --> 00:27:51,385
And maybe it's an obvious question
to answer, but what motivated you to
472
00:27:51,395 --> 00:27:54,234
get involved in this battle and this
fight, you've got a job, you're doing
473
00:27:54,234 --> 00:27:56,595
your security stuff, why this topic?
474
00:27:57,565 --> 00:28:00,624
This is the worst scam
that I can think of.
475
00:28:01,280 --> 00:28:06,290
I have previously went head to head
with the Yahoo boys in previous roles
476
00:28:06,290 --> 00:28:11,739
where they were doing fake job scams
targeting my company and other cyber
477
00:28:11,739 --> 00:28:15,470
enabled fraud targeting one of the
financial institutions I work for.
478
00:28:15,999 --> 00:28:21,260
And when I saw them make this transition
over to committing child sexual
479
00:28:21,260 --> 00:28:28,189
exploitation and blackmail, resulting in
suicide at scale, I can't imagine a worse
480
00:28:28,625 --> 00:28:33,755
Financially motivated crime, and the fact
that nobody was really talking about it,
481
00:28:33,755 --> 00:28:38,005
like organized crime, we were looking at
these individualized cases, the individual
482
00:28:38,005 --> 00:28:42,794
tragedies, but nobody was saying,
Hey, these cases are all connected.
483
00:28:42,814 --> 00:28:46,135
It's by the same threat group, they're
using the same scripts, they're
484
00:28:46,135 --> 00:28:50,994
using the same images, and they are
deploying this at scale to target
485
00:28:51,064 --> 00:28:53,054
hundreds of thousands of teams.
486
00:28:53,474 --> 00:28:56,534
The gravity of the situation
wasn't lost on me, and I definitely
487
00:28:56,554 --> 00:28:57,924
felt a responsibility to.
488
00:28:59,135 --> 00:29:02,224
Step up and talk about it and,
and rally the groups to combat
489
00:29:02,225 --> 00:29:03,585
it in several different ways.
490
00:29:04,335 --> 00:29:09,044
I will be posting in the show notes some
of the material that you talked about,
491
00:29:09,045 --> 00:29:10,625
some of the resources for families.
492
00:29:11,055 --> 00:29:14,764
The one thing that we're, the whole reason
why we're doing these Barnacle Scams is
493
00:29:14,794 --> 00:29:17,244
to get the word out as much as possible.
494
00:29:17,515 --> 00:29:20,005
There is awareness, but
there's not enough awareness.
495
00:29:20,015 --> 00:29:22,675
So thank you, Paul, for doing
the work that you're doing.
496
00:29:22,915 --> 00:29:27,605
I appreciate you taking the time to talk
with us today and be part of this project.
497
00:29:28,205 --> 00:29:29,162
Thank you for having me.