প্রতিলিপি 🔗
1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:26,420
All right, all right, all right. Welcome back, everybody, to Bitcoin News Live. We are here with a great show ahead of us today. We are discussing Bitcoin as a store of value versus medium of exchange.
2
00:00:26,420 --> 00:00:41,020
Everybody's talking about Bitcoin, store value first, and then it goes through the different stages of money, but medium of exchange is essential, and I've got two guests today that are going to help us break it down as to why it is so important and what they are doing to help bring the vision of Bitcoin as a medium of exchange to the world.
3
00:00:41,020 --> 00:00:54,300
All right, let's dive right into it. Bitcoin has a chicken and an egg problem, and the fight is a lively one within the Bitcoin community at the moment. One camp says number go up comes first as it cements itself as a store of value.
4
00:00:54,300 --> 00:01:00,140
Seyfedeen Amous, the man who wrote the Bitcoin Standard, says it very bluntly. He came out and said,
5
00:01:00,140 --> 00:01:06,680
Bitcoin can't become money until its value rises enormously. Until then, pestering merchants to
6
00:01:06,680 --> 00:01:11,860
accept it is essentially a LARP. I think my two guests today will be very upset with that line
7
00:01:11,860 --> 00:01:17,420
and have a rebuttal because they're part of the other camp that says that's exactly how you lose.
8
00:01:17,720 --> 00:01:23,300
A Bitcoin that nobody spends is a Bitcoin that sits in ETFs and custodians. It eventually goes soft
9
00:01:23,300 --> 00:01:31,120
and becomes easily captured. So which is it? Do we hold our way to a Bitcoin standard or do we spend our way there?
10
00:01:31,780 --> 00:01:39,120
My two guests say there's no middle ground left. Kyle Huber and John McCabe argue Bitcoin goes to zero or it goes to a million.
11
00:01:39,560 --> 00:01:45,120
And the road between the two runs straight through using sats as a medium of exchange.
12
00:01:45,620 --> 00:01:50,660
But before we get into it, hit that share button. Let's get some more Bitcoiners in on the discussion in the chat,
13
00:01:50,660 --> 00:01:56,1000
telling us what they think about store value and medium of exchange. All right, boys, let's get up on stage.
14
00:01:57,400 --> 00:02:03,200
We got Mr. John and we got Mr. Kyle. Gentlemen, how are we doing? John, good to see you.
15
00:02:04,160 --> 00:02:09,760
Nice to see you guys. Yeah, happy to kick it off. Thanks for the intro, Rob. That was a very nice
16
00:02:09,760 --> 00:02:15,720
summary of where things are in the Bitcoin space as it applies to medium of exchange. Yeah, my name is
17
00:02:15,720 --> 00:02:44,120
John McCabe. One of my kind of points of interest maybe as it relates to medium of exchange is I worked at MasterCard for over 10 years. I was global director of product management in MasterCard's merchant loyalty team. And at the same time, I've been a Bitcoin maximalist for several years now. So as you might imagine, it's a sort
Load full transcript
of an interesting combination to be working at MasterCard while also being a Bitcoin maximalist.
18
00:02:44,120 --> 00:03:00,780
But one of the things I think I can bring to the discussion is my experience and expertise on merchant loyalty really uncovered what I think is a lot of insights that help us move forward as Bitcoin as medium of exchange.
19
00:03:01,180 --> 00:03:10,640
And right now, one of the startup I'm working on with my co-founder is Saturday Bitcoin, where we can get into that and talk a little bit about that.
20
00:03:10,640 --> 00:03:14,440
But I'll just kind of pause there if you want to introduce your other guests.
21
00:03:15,740 --> 00:03:17,120
Yeah, Kyle, say what's up. How are you doing?
22
00:03:17,920 --> 00:03:21,920
Yeah, John, great to meet you as well. I recognize your face probably from some conferences or something.
23
00:03:22,660 --> 00:03:26,740
Yeah, my name is Kyle Huber. We are Satoshi Podcast and make films.
24
00:03:27,780 --> 00:03:31,540
I'm very fortunate to travel to circular economies all over the world.
25
00:03:32,360 --> 00:03:38,780
And while I won't die on the hill, I may be used to a year ago that Bitcoin needs to be a medium of exchange at all costs.
26
00:03:38,780 --> 00:03:45,940
I think there's a lot of nuance here. We have to define things. We have to say, like, what does Bitcoin success really look like?
27
00:03:46,480 --> 00:03:52,200
But in my opinion, yeah, it's not about charity. It's not about building the world you want to see.
28
00:03:52,300 --> 00:04:00,560
I'm sure, I mean, there's something to that as well. But my main focus is really that it's in our economic and financial interest to use and spend Bitcoin.
29
00:04:00,760 --> 00:04:03,660
So that's where my journey has led me. Really excited for the conversation.
30
00:04:03,660 --> 00:04:22,440
All right, nice. Let's use this post from Seyfedeen that he wrote last week to really serve as a diving board into this conversation. I will bring it up right here. Pump up the size so you guys can see it at home. Beautiful. All right, so what did Seyfedeen say?
31
00:04:22,440 --> 00:04:28,120
Savity said, some Bitcoiners want Bitcoin as money and think price appreciation is counterproductive
32
00:04:28,120 --> 00:04:32,960
because it makes people hold Bitcoin instead of spending it. Other Bitcoiners want Bitcoin to keep
33
00:04:32,960 --> 00:04:38,040
appreciating as an asset without becoming money so it doesn't upset the government. In my view,
34
00:04:38,160 --> 00:04:42,920
Bitcoin can't become money without its value rising, and its value can't keep rising without
35
00:04:42,920 --> 00:04:48,320
it becoming money. If Bitcoin keeps working as designed, it keeps appreciating until it becomes
36
00:04:48,320 --> 00:04:54,000
Money is the general medium of exchange, the thing people are most likely to trade. What you are most
37
00:04:54,000 --> 00:04:59,280
likely to trade is the thing in which you have the largest cash balances. Bitcoin will only become
38
00:04:59,280 --> 00:05:04,540
money when its cash balances are large and held by a very large number of people. For that to happen,
39
00:05:04,540 --> 00:05:10,800
number must go up. If Bitcoin cash balances are tiny, it cannot be money. No matter how much we
40
00:05:10,800 --> 00:05:16,740
LARP circular economies and annoy merchants to accept it, it only converts, only to convert it to fiat to
41
00:05:16,740 --> 00:05:21,220
pay their rent and staff. If Bitcoin keeps appreciating until its cash balances are the
42
00:05:21,220 --> 00:05:26,400
largest of any cash in the world, people will use it for trade and it will be money. You won't have to
43
00:05:26,400 --> 00:05:32,420
pester merchants to accept it because his own cash balance and the cash balances of his landlord and
44
00:05:32,420 --> 00:05:38,760
staff are mostly in Bitcoin and they all want it. Bitcoin will have to appreciate enormously to work
45
00:05:38,760 --> 00:05:44,500
as money, whether you like it or not. And if Bitcoin keeps appreciating, people will use it as a money,
46
00:05:44,500 --> 00:05:46,380
whether you like it or not.
47
00:05:46,740 --> 00:05:54,860
Embrace the number, go up. So, John, what is your immediate reaction to that piece from Savity?
48
00:05:55,860 --> 00:06:11,440
Yeah, I think what I would say from my point of view, that the value of Bitcoin has actually nothing to do with the value propositions that I think we can bring to bear for Bitcoin as a medium of exchange.
49
00:06:11,440 --> 00:06:31,320
And just to get into it, you mentioned earlier that Bitcoin is a chicken and egg problem. And I think another way, and I think that's absolutely true, but I think another way to look at it from the medium of exchange standpoint is to consider Bitcoin as a two-sided market where you have consumers on one side and you have merchants on the other.
50
00:06:31,320 --> 00:06:56,880
and I think thinking of it with that sort of framework then makes you kind of stand back and think about well what value propositions can I bring to bear to both sides of that market to make it so that it's rational for people to not only be willing to exchange Bitcoin but actually prefer to use Bitcoin as a medium of exchange and that would be a very powerful goal to reach and I think we can absolutely get there.
51
00:06:56,880 --> 00:07:13,680
So starting with the merchant side, and this is where it may be something new or novel for many people talking about Bitcoin as medium of exchange, because I think in the Bitcoin space, we often talk about it as Bitcoin payments and merchants being willing to accept Bitcoin.
52
00:07:13,680 --> 00:07:36,920
But think of a scenario where, and this gets to my experience as MasterCard in merchant loyalty, what merchants are very much interested in, in fact, it's the very first conversation, the very first question that they have when we reach out to them to run a marketing program, a loyalty program, is
they're interested in new customers, new customer acquisition, demand generation.
53
00:07:36,920 --> 00:07:48,100
And what's very interesting is that it's actually very difficult to do that in the conventional fiat space in, say, MasterCard rewards and offers.
54
00:07:49,100 --> 00:07:57,300
I would say about 98% of the marketing budget that we spend is not on new customer acquisition.
55
00:07:57,300 --> 00:08:00,840
It's on what we call lapsed customers or general loyalty.
56
00:08:00,840 --> 00:08:11,280
So increasing frequency of spend, increasing basket size, reactivating users who are lapsed, like who used to shop with you but haven't recently.
57
00:08:11,680 --> 00:08:16,180
That's where all the marketing budget is spent because it's actually very difficult to activate new customers.
58
00:08:16,920 --> 00:08:26,800
But then think about the Bitcoin space and think about one of the most prominent examples of a success in the last year and a half was stake in shape.
59
00:08:26,800 --> 00:08:29,280
and many of us are familiar with what happened there.
60
00:08:30,080 --> 00:08:33,360
And if you go back and you look at the day that Steak and Shake went live,
61
00:08:34,160 --> 00:08:39,760
it was all they got. They had a massive success with Bitcoin and it was almost all essentially new
62
00:08:39,760 --> 00:08:44,080
customers. Whereas people saying that like, hey, I've never been to a Steak and Shake. Where's the
63
00:08:44,080 --> 00:08:49,200
nearest one to me? Oh my God, it's 10 miles away. I'm jumping in the car with my family or I haven't
64
00:08:49,200 --> 00:08:54,000
been to Steak and Shake in 25 years or I don't even like fast food, but they were still going there.
65
00:08:54,000 --> 00:09:06,820
and they're still not only going there but posting online. So it's undeniable that there is an energy there around a willingness to spend Bitcoin from Bitcoiners.
66
00:09:07,240 --> 00:09:22,280
There's another kind of layer of insight I would share is that, and actually just to add one more point there, I talked about new customer acquisition, even Steak and Shake and many merchants, when they think about why would I use Bitcoin,
67
00:09:22,280 --> 00:09:49,440
We talk about, well, you can save on credit card fees. And I think that's absolutely true. But I think it's the secondary benefit. Like if you really do the math on what is the impact to the merchant, I think it's new customer acquisition followed by what I would call recaptured margin. And that's the saving on credit card fees. And there's also essentially zero fraud and zero chargeback risk then as well.
68
00:09:49,440 --> 00:10:01,840
And then also I think there's an extra dimension where in the marketing space people often talk about how many customers do you have or how many users, what is the response rate on this campaign.
69
00:10:02,680 --> 00:10:09,200
But it sort of assumes that all these customers are the same type of customer, like one customer is the same as another.
70
00:10:09,200 --> 00:10:16,000
but I would argue that the vast majority of conventional fiat customers are actually what I
71
00:10:16,000 --> 00:10:22,100
would term mercenaries and where they're just discount hunters, bottom feeders, like think of
72
00:10:22,100 --> 00:10:26,980
people who actively use Groupon, like they're really not very loyal customers, they're not the best
73
00:10:26,980 --> 00:10:32,720
customer and I think Bitcoiners are the other end of the spectrum, like we can demonstrate maniacal
74
00:10:32,720 --> 00:10:40,180
loyalty, we have high integrity, we tend to skew wealthy, we tend to skew more traveled.
75
00:10:40,680 --> 00:10:47,740
We're arguably the best customer segment that a merchant could possibly want. So that's why I'm
76
00:10:47,740 --> 00:10:53,420
working on Saturday Bitcoin and I'm trying to tap into this and mobilize our very powerful Bitcoin
77
00:10:53,420 --> 00:11:01,020
segment to make the consumers very successful and the merchants very successful. So I just paused
78
00:11:01,020 --> 00:11:06,180
started to monopolize that bit of the conversation. Oh, good. That was great. Yeah. And I think it really
79
00:11:06,180 --> 00:11:11,520
does boil down to incentives, right? How do you get people to separate themselves with their Bitcoin?
80
00:11:11,700 --> 00:11:17,620
They need to be incentivized to do so. And merchants need to say, hey, I want it and give the people a
81
00:11:17,620 --> 00:11:24,180
reason to do so too, right? So Kyle, would love your input. Kyle is a Bitcoin filmmaker, been around the
82
00:11:24,180 --> 00:11:30,540
world spending sats. What has been your takeaway from your travels? Yeah, John, you covered a lot
83
00:11:30,540 --> 00:11:59,180
I agree. I'll say that the argument when I tell a restaurant or cafe, hey, you're going to get more customers, I think you made a good distinction there. It's more about building loyalty than actually attracting new customers. I see Bitcoin adoption or merchant adoption as like a supply-demand equation. So merchants being the supply side, customers willing to spend being the demand side. And in my opinion, the demand side is lacking.
84
00:11:59,180 --> 00:12:04,740
So there's merchants that I like, for example, I was just in Bulgaria making a documentary film there.
85
00:12:05,780 --> 00:12:11,340
And last year there was 21 merchants, restaurants accepting Bitcoin. There's 150, something like that
86
00:12:11,340 --> 00:12:15,760
across the country. And this year there was 10. And so I showed up, I was a little bit disappointed.
87
00:12:15,920 --> 00:12:19,980
I was like, guys, what's going on? And it's not because the merchants didn't want to accept Bitcoin.
88
00:12:20,080 --> 00:12:25,340
They're happy to. There's just no one spending. So is it in their actual interest to continue accepting
89
00:12:25,340 --> 00:12:32,240
if no one's spending? No, it's not. So that's why I'm really focused on like, hey guys, like
number one,
90
00:12:32,320 --> 00:12:38,340
you end up in the exact same place if you spend Bitcoin or fiat. It's not about which currency you
91
00:12:38,340 --> 00:12:44,080
use. It's more about are you making that purchase or not? So to me, the most important thing is just
92
00:12:44,080 --> 00:12:49,760
recognizing that every purchase you make in fiat could have been a purchase of Bitcoin. And if you
93
00:12:49,760 --> 00:13:06,602
and buy something with Bitcoin you can just buy the exact same amount of Bitcoin with fiat And then yeah beyond that it like if you just think a little bit forward into the future and where you know we thinking like okay I want to be able to use my Bitcoin with the maximum utility
94
00:13:06,942 --> 00:13:11,002
The best way that we can increase the utility of Bitcoin, forget price for a second.
95
00:13:11,122 --> 00:13:13,322
Obviously, the price goes up as more places accept it.
96
00:13:13,382 --> 00:13:13,802
That's obvious.
97
00:13:13,942 --> 00:13:18,522
So if you're a number go up guy like myself and probably many of us, spending Bitcoin is how we get there.
98
00:13:18,522 --> 00:13:27,422
Yeah, you're going to be able to actually use it versus having to convert and then pay the taxes and do the whole thing, the accounting.
99
00:13:27,422 --> 00:13:32,682
So yeah, those are sort of like the two first points I would make. I don't know. Back to you, Rob.
100
00:13:33,862 --> 00:13:48,482
Yeah, when it comes to me and this debate, I do sort of land in the camp that Bitcoin is going to go through the stages of money and that store value is the first one and that medium exchange becomes a whole lot easier.
101
00:13:48,522 --> 00:13:54,922
once, what's safe hitting said, the value goes up a lot. People who have some Bitcoin have a much larger
102
00:13:54,922 --> 00:13:59,142
percentage of their wealth in Bitcoin because of the value went up, and then it becomes much more
103
00:13:59,142 --> 00:14:04,802
natural to spend this. But at the same time, I think it is essential that people at least know
104
00:14:04,802 --> 00:14:11,022
how to spend Bitcoin. If you've never experimented with sending a transaction peer-to-peer from yourself
105
00:14:11,022 --> 00:14:15,522
to a merchant, you don't know the magic of Bitcoin. You have no idea what you're dealing with here. It's
106
00:14:15,522 --> 00:14:20,442
just a number on a screen, it might as well be any other financial asset. If you don't know how to spend
107
00:14:20,442 --> 00:14:25,402
it, if you don't know how to send it, you're essentially an amputee Bitcoiner. You're walking
108
00:14:25,402 --> 00:14:28,722
around without arms or legs here, not knowing the full power of what you truly possess.
109
00:14:29,362 --> 00:14:33,942
And it comes in handy, right? If you were caught in the cold card situation where you were fighting
110
00:14:33,942 --> 00:14:39,222
against the clock to move your Bitcoin and you had no idea how to spend or send, you were
in a very,
111
00:14:39,222 --> 00:14:43,482
very bad position because that's when fat fingers happen, right? You get scared, you get nervous,
112
00:14:43,482 --> 00:15:13,242
you press the wrong buttons but if you're practiced it's like a fire gun it's like a gun right it's a firearm you need to know what to do what procedures are in place and to smoothly calmly even in duress be able to spend send your bitcoin so yes I agree that bitcoin should and it's fun right it's so cool to be able to buy something send your bitcoin and give it to another person that you respect right especially if it's an institution or a merchant an artisan who is selling their goods for bitcoin there's it's really
113
00:15:13,242 --> 00:15:19,582
quite a special occasion to be able to do so. Yeah, let me add to that real quick. Is that right?
114
00:15:20,082 --> 00:15:27,122
Yeah. So yeah, it's fun. And the first time I did a Bitcoin transaction after following BTC sessions,
115
00:15:27,122 --> 00:15:31,682
running my own node, doing the whole thing, I actually had almost a spiritual experience. I cried.
116
00:15:31,842 --> 00:15:38,382
I was like, I can't believe that I just did what the banks do. I'm personally able to literally do
117
00:15:38,382 --> 00:15:42,462
the action of the banks. And because I had done the education and gone down the rabbit hole and
118
00:15:42,462 --> 00:15:48,702
learned it all myself as a non-technical person. Such a rewarding experience. I also think like Bitcoin,
119
00:15:49,082 --> 00:15:53,042
people will say, okay, we're going to wait for Bitcoin's price to go up to spend Bitcoin.
120
00:15:53,662 --> 00:15:59,082
There's kind of two sides to that. I think if you really want to support the businesses, like,
121
00:15:59,342 --> 00:16:03,862
okay, why do you spend money at a business? Because you get more value than you give them.
122
00:16:04,042 --> 00:16:08,822
So for example, my hair cutter, you know, I had long hair recently. Back in May, I paid her in Bitcoin.
123
00:16:08,822 --> 00:16:38,802
I guess the price just dropped so now my story is going to not be that good but the price went up 25% between my two haircuts and because I spent Bitcoin during the bear market and then the merchant my hairdresser experienced the upside of Bitcoin I was able to say to her hey isn't this interesting the haircut you gave me four months ago actually you have now 25% more purchasing power in the fiat world and then the last thing I'll say is that on your point of Bitcoin following this trend of you know starting as a store of value then medium of exchange then unit of exchange then unit of exchange then
124
00:16:38,822 --> 00:16:44,762
account. That's true, I would say, at the grand scale, but actually Bitcoin started as a medium of
125
00:16:44,762 --> 00:16:50,282
exchange. The first transaction was Laszlo buying pizza. The first use cases were Silk Road and
126
00:16:50,282 --> 00:16:56,322
WikiLeaks. And so the store of value is inextricably linked to the medium of exchange. And so the way I
127
00:16:56,322 --> 00:17:01,362
see it is that Bitcoin adoption happens one individual at a time. It's a permissionless
128
00:17:01,362 --> 00:17:05,782
network. You get to decide when you opt in. If you don't want to, I'm not going to go argue with you,
129
00:17:05,782 --> 00:17:11,842
You need to spend your sats, but just recognize that you are supporting the fiat system when you use their currency.
130
00:17:11,842 --> 00:17:18,422
And if you want to support this world of Bitcoin and freedom and prosperity, then you're more than welcome to do so when you're ready.
131
00:17:19,662 --> 00:17:20,862
Nice. Yeah, John, please.
132
00:17:21,522 --> 00:17:34,062
Yeah, just to build on what Kyle said, I mean, one other way I think about it is that the vast majority of us, if not all of us in the Bitcoin space who have spent Bitcoin and do try to make spending Bitcoin a habit,
133
00:17:34,062 --> 00:17:49,222
We do so essentially for ideological reasons, for mission-based reasons, and it's typically not economically rational for us to spend our Bitcoin because at the very least there is the friction that Kyle mentioned around taxes.
134
00:17:49,942 --> 00:17:59,842
And there's also an opportunity cost of sort of not getting your typical credit card rewards or consumer protections potentially if you really need them.
135
00:18:00,982 --> 00:18:02,562
And that's fine.
136
00:18:02,562 --> 00:18:19,062
So what I'm working on is the idea of to sort of channel that energy, that mission-based energy, but to add economic incentives so it actually becomes rational, like not just ideologically rational, but economically rational to spend Bitcoin.
137
00:18:19,062 --> 00:18:26,942
And that's sort of leveraging my background in rewards and offers at MasterCard. I'm essentially bringing that to the Bitcoin space.
138
00:18:26,942 --> 00:18:40,102
And then for the merchant standpoint, I think Kyle is absolutely right that it's sort of heartbreaking in the space where some merchants put a lot of effort into going to accept Bitcoin and then kind of nothing happens, you know.
139
00:18:40,102 --> 00:18:54,162
And that's the other problem I'm solving with SaturdayBitcoin.com is essentially a marketplace and discovery tool for Bitcoiners to find Bitcoin friendly merchants.
140
00:18:54,162 --> 00:19:04,762
And I think a very important concept here is the idea of redirecting our existing category spend to Bitcoin-friendly merchants.
141
00:19:04,762 --> 00:19:15,982
So in categories we already operate in, it's not so much asking people to go out and spend on things they would never typically spend on, but more to redirect their existing spend behavior to Bitcoin-friendly merchants.
142
00:19:15,982 --> 00:19:34,782
and that's how I'm actually we're actually running this we call a rally on the site right now where and this is where we kind of we can focus and channel our Bitcoin energy like our Bitcoin
Bitcoin or ethos on a single online merchant in the US.
143
00:19:34,782 --> 00:19:44,442
And this is how we sort of blow it up like a little bit like maybe what happened with that steak and shake so that if we can like if you have like 100 Bitcoiners and in the space of a year,
144
00:19:44,442 --> 00:19:51,582
each one of those Bitcoiners has one transaction at a single restaurant. Nobody's happy. It hasn't
145
00:19:51,582 --> 00:19:56,982
transformed any business. But if you get those 100 Bitcoiners and you direct them to spend at a single
146
00:19:56,982 --> 00:20:01,482
merchant in a single day, which is what we're doing in this rally, then it kind of like, wow,
147
00:20:01,722 --> 00:20:06,002
we hope to get a very good success there. And then that becomes a case study for the next merchant,
148
00:20:06,142 --> 00:20:10,662
the next merchant, in the next category, in the next category. Just one other final point I'll
149
00:20:10,662 --> 00:20:19,162
mentioned this concept is that for many categories, we actually don't need like hundreds or thousands of merchants.
150
00:20:19,882 --> 00:20:26,982
Like one of my hobbies, for example, is wine, right? And there's about like, depending on how you define it,
151
00:20:27,002 --> 00:20:33,162
there's about 4,000 stores in the United States, wine stores that have an online channel that sell online.
152
00:20:33,162 --> 00:20:38,202
And as you might imagine, that becomes a very long tail of merchants, some of which are relatively small.
153
00:20:38,202 --> 00:20:46,402
But my local wine store, I'd be happy to redirect my full category spend of wine to that store if they became Bitcoin friendly.
154
00:20:47,082 --> 00:20:52,482
And there are other there are there's an army of other Bitcoiners in the United States who would do likewise.
155
00:20:52,482 --> 00:20:58,382
And not only do we make that business like more successful, we could transform that that that business.
156
00:20:58,562 --> 00:21:02,042
And then and we only need one like for a category like wine.
157
00:21:02,042 --> 00:21:06,682
If we add like another three or four wine stores, it doesn't make as much of an impact.
158
00:21:06,682 --> 00:21:12,762
because if you have a single online store, it then becomes actionable for the whole U.S. audience.
159
00:21:13,442 --> 00:21:15,502
And then we move to the next category and the next category.
160
00:21:15,602 --> 00:21:18,982
And there are some categories like, say, clothing and that where one is not enough.
161
00:21:19,142 --> 00:21:20,122
You need a lot.
162
00:21:20,462 --> 00:21:23,062
You have like sportswear, formal wear, kids or whatever.
163
00:21:23,322 --> 00:21:26,822
But for many categories, one or two is actually sufficient.
164
00:21:27,022 --> 00:21:29,822
So I'll just pause there, but just wanted to get across some of those ideas.
165
00:21:31,782 --> 00:21:32,462
That's cool.
166
00:21:33,882 --> 00:21:35,122
Yeah, and I agree.
167
00:21:35,122 --> 00:21:39,242
I mean, it comes down to also the art of orange pilling, right?
168
00:21:39,322 --> 00:21:46,222
You got to be able to go to the merchant and pitch them on the idea of being able to accept Bitcoin and all the benefits it will give them.
169
00:21:46,742 --> 00:21:49,382
I've got a story, but I'll save mine for last.
170
00:21:49,822 --> 00:21:51,262
Let's go with Kyle first.
171
00:21:51,422 --> 00:21:55,242
What's an orange pilling merchant story that you got from your travels?
172
00:21:56,462 --> 00:21:57,362
Perfect, Rob.
173
00:21:57,422 --> 00:21:58,202
Thank you for the setup.
174
00:21:58,202 --> 00:22:26,282
I just have to say, John, that's a really smart take that I was going to make about local, using your local Bitcoin community to actually say, hey, if we can have our meetup here, I can bring you 20 customers a week. Like there's power in that. If all of us just go to random merchants, then maybe they see us all once per year. It's a super good point. And then on the Internet, we can do that at scale, right? So I think there's a huge opportunity there. Actually, a circular economy is not necessarily limited to a physical geographic space.
175
00:22:26,282 --> 00:22:54,042
If Rob pays me and I go, let's say I'm actually wearing two things in the screen that I pay with Bitcoin. One is this shirt and also these glasses, getchroma.co. And also this is an artist from Venezuela. I just have to show you guys the backside of the shirt real fast. You see that? It's one of my favorite Bitcoin shirts. So yeah, I think if you're like, I don't know where to spend Bitcoin, then go online. Like, John, I'm super excited about your product. And then where was I going to go with that?
176
00:22:54,042 --> 00:23:22,002
Oh, yeah. As far as like a story of merchant adoption or merchant like orange pilling, one of the biggest takeaways I had in Bulgaria, there's a restaurant services company called Order Moon, and they have done 95% of the orange pilling in Bulgaria. They don't walk in the front door and say, hey, guys, we're here. Like, are you ready to accept Bitcoin? Here's why you should accept Bitcoin. Like the fiat system is broken, the Federal Reserve. No, they don't do that. They're a restaurant services company first.
177
00:23:22,002 --> 00:23:51,302
So they come in and they say, hey, we noticed your website is out of date. We noticed you're using this table management service that's not optimized. Your takeouts are not optimized. So they just solve problems for the merchants, build trust. And then in the back end, like they're true Bitcoiners at heart. So in the back end, they have a lightning infrastructure where you can basically plug in any lightning wallet. They're not a custodian. They're non-custodial. And when the time is right and they've built the trust, then they say, hey, are you ready? And then boom. That's the number one takeaway I've had about orange pilling.
178
00:23:51,302 --> 00:23:55,902
anyone. Bitcoiners kind
of get this wrong, in my opinion, where it's like, we think we need to go
179
00:23:55,902 --> 00:24:03,682
pitch Bitcoin. Actually, the principles of business apply in Bitcoin or in fiat. Solve problems first,
180
00:24:04,262 --> 00:24:08,142
ask questions later. There you go. John, what's your take?
181
00:24:09,342 --> 00:24:17,542
Yeah, just as an orange-pilling example, well, just a kind of a transaction-related example that
182
00:24:17,542 --> 00:24:23,942
that might be interesting. And I was listening to one of the old podcasts from, I think it was Ibex,
183
00:24:24,862 --> 00:24:31,302
who on board some merchants, but they were saying that a very interesting category that they came
184
00:24:31,302 --> 00:24:39,022
across is tattoo parlors, where they actually have one of the highest chargebacks, where people
185
00:24:39,022 --> 00:24:43,322
actually go on vacation, they get a tattoo, they come home, and it's actually what's called friendly
186
00:24:43,322 --> 00:25:07,362
fraud where they say like, no, I didn't get any tattoo. That's not my transaction. So they get their money back having paid credit card. So my point here is that the point I guess I'm trying to make is that for certain categories of merchants, one of the selling points is Bitcoin because they essentially have zero fraud and chargebacks. So that's a potentially very, very powerful selling point.
187
00:25:07,362 --> 00:25:11,562
Yeah, I can't remember
188
00:25:11,562 --> 00:25:18,022
The processing fee, right? Like you're spending the merchants eating or you're eating a 2% to 3% processing fee
189
00:25:18,022 --> 00:25:24,202
Absolutely. I mean, that's actually a really good point is that for different merchants, I think
190
00:25:24,202 --> 00:25:27,262
and one of the things we're trying to do at Saturday Bitcoin, in fact, I've written
191
00:25:27,262 --> 00:25:33,662
like so far, I have like a 33 parts sort of strategy guide for merchants on our website.
192
00:25:33,662 --> 00:25:41,722
So it's all, I think there's about 28 pieces that are merchant facing and about six or seven that are Bitcoin facing.
193
00:25:43,262 --> 00:25:51,762
But we actually go into that a lot where it really depends, like the Bitcoin strategy will vary a little bit depending on the type of merchant.
194
00:25:51,762 --> 00:26:23,344
If they a long tail merchant if they in a very concentrated space if they high margin versus low margin if they geographically distributed versus single online store there nuance to that So for example what Kyle mentioned there about avoiding credit card fees that is absolutely huge for merchants who kind of satisfied two criteria where they have low margin like certain grocery stores just as an example like low margin and a very high rate of payment with credit card
195
00:26:23,344 --> 00:26:50,804
So when you bring Bitcoin in there and if we can start to get it to that, that's where the Bitcoin becomes 1% of the revenue, 2%, 3%, that could have a very
meaningful impact. Like I said earlier, when it's an online business, we can actually do that now. Like most of us, we think about our local grocery store reaching 5% Bitcoin. It's not going to happen anytime soon. It's not going to happen overnight. But my local wine store, I can tell you, we could potentially double their sales overnight.
196
00:26:50,804 --> 00:27:18,205
So on the margin side, then for other businesses that are already very high margin, there's a couple of things going on there. So their recaptured margin from avoiding credit card fees is then not necessarily a huge benefit. Like think of VPN providers, like sometimes you'll see very, you know, they actually have very high margin because it's just pure software. There's no incremental sale, just as an example.
197
00:27:18,205 --> 00:27:34,165
But one of the interesting dynamics there of the potential Bitcoin strategy is that a merchant like that can provide a significant Bitcoin cashback reward for attracting Bitcoiners
198
00:27:34,165 --> 00:28:02,624
So one other points I will make that maybe touches on some of my MasterCard experience is when we do new customer acquisition offers for a merchant, we typically have very high offers. It could be 20% off, even 30% off, because what the merchant is doing is they're attracting a new customer, some of whom will then have a lifetime value if they have repeat visit transaction. That's huge.
199
00:28:02,624 --> 00:28:11,945
And of course, that's another calculation that ultimately at Saturday Bitcoin, we're going to be making for merchants like, hey, here's your repeat spend from Bitcoiners.
200
00:28:12,005 --> 00:28:18,304
And by the way, it's much higher than your regular mercenary users to sort of sell them on the concept.
201
00:28:19,304 --> 00:28:32,245
But then once they have that first transaction, the opportunity is for us to give a residual ongoing reward from the merchants to that Bitcoiner over time.
202
00:28:32,624 --> 00:28:38,445
that would be higher than their credit card reward. And that's how we get to the point where it becomes
203
00:28:38,445 --> 00:28:43,665
economically rational for Bitcoiners to shop at Bitcoin-friendly merchants because they're not only
204
00:28:43,665 --> 00:28:48,344
being the change that they want to see in the world, but they're actually stacking sats every day.
205
00:28:48,945 --> 00:28:53,324
So think about it. Most of us Bitcoiners, we're just HODLers and we're just sitting around waiting
206
00:28:53,324 --> 00:29:00,344
for a number to go up and trying to orange pill normies. And it's not a very active, like we
207
00:29:00,344 --> 00:29:28,884
You listen to podcasts and stuff like that. But imagine where you're actually just engaging in your existing shopping behavior, but you're just redirecting that existing spend to Bitcoin-friendly merchants and you're stacking sats and you're being the change you want to see in the world. And that actually becomes a phenomenal orange-pilling opportunity for normies as well. Because think about right now for normies, if you want to orange-pill them, you have to tell them, set up an account at River or Coinbase or whatever it is and start buying Bitcoin every week.
208
00:29:28,884 --> 00:29:58,864
I mean it's not very interesting necessarily but imagine you say like okay imagine a scenario this is what we're working towards where you don't even have to have any bitcoin to begin with you have a wallet you you shop at a bitcoin friendly merchant you actually are able to convert in real time from from fiat to bitcoin so the merchant always receives bitcoin and you get a cashback reward in real time a bitcoin cashback reward in real time and so yeah
209
00:29:58,864 --> 00:30:18,044
I think we have a very interesting path ahead of us. And anybody who says Bitcoin as medium exchange is not important or it's not interesting, I mean, soon we'll be able to point to more merchants who have extraordinary success with this and fellow Bitcoiners who are stacking sats from spending.
210
00:30:18,044 --> 00:30:32,705
Yeah, orange peeling merchants is sort of like playing Pokemon, right? You're trying to collect them all, you know, get more notches in your belt and prove your ability to persuade in the name of Bitcoin.
211
00:30:32,705 --> 00:30:47,225
One story I have that I would love both of your input on. So I've got a local coffee guy in a van, right? He drives up every single morning early, parks his van there outside of a park, and he sells to people who are commuting to work.
212
00:30:48,044 --> 00:31:14,064
Good dude and a hardworking guy. He definitely puts in the hours to earn his money. And I convinced him he had a square terminal. And I said, hey, you can turn that on and accept Bitcoin. So last year he did that. And I sort of walked him through some of the settings. I showed him online how to do it. But yeah, he got it all going. He got the stickers. He put the stickers up on his van. And over the last year, it sounds like he was able to get some people to pay in Bitcoin, right?
213
00:31:14,064 --> 00:31:18,665
And I think he had worked his way up to around $1,000 worth of Bitcoin in sales, right?
214
00:31:18,745 --> 00:31:22,384
So around five bucks a cup of coffee is around 200 sales in Bitcoin.
215
00:31:23,245 --> 00:31:26,304
But then he got persuaded.
216
00:31:26,624 --> 00:31:27,284
I don't know.
217
00:31:27,725 --> 00:31:33,564
Somebody reached out to him in a WhatsApp group or he saw it online, but he downloaded a trading
218
00:31:33,564 --> 00:31:37,884
app and they said, we'll turn your Bitcoin, we'll 10X your Bitcoin, da-da-da-da.
219
00:31:38,225 --> 00:31:39,924
He put all $1,000 in.
220
00:31:39,925 --> 00:31:48,445
and then it showed me, it said that he had like eight Bitcoin, right? That he turned his $1,000 into eight Bitcoin.
221
00:31:48,745 --> 00:31:53,745
And then he's like, I'm trying to take my money out. And they say, you got to put in
another $3,000 to take
222
00:31:53,745 --> 00:32:00,384
out the $400,000 worth of Bitcoin that you've earned on this app, right? So just this space still is rife
223
00:32:00,384 --> 00:32:05,425
with scams. And if you don't go into it with the proper education or what to look out for, you could
224
00:32:05,425 --> 00:32:11,024
be a sitting target. So in terms of the education that needs to go into before a merchant turns on
225
00:32:11,024 --> 00:32:16,445
Bitcoin acceptance, what is the story there? Kyle, do you have any ideas?
226
00:32:17,364 --> 00:32:21,925
I do have some thoughts on this. It's actually where I wanted to go with the conversation because
227
00:32:21,925 --> 00:32:27,005
like I said at the beginning, I'm extremely a supporter of medium of exchange, but this year
228
00:32:27,005 --> 00:32:34,245
has been quite sobering as far as just me realizing I don't even understand Bitcoin well enough.
229
00:32:34,245 --> 00:32:40,104
for example, recommending a custodial wallet. I always tell them, look, like write down the words or
230
00:32:40,104 --> 00:32:43,905
in a custodial wallet, you wouldn't write down the words, but on wallet of Satoshi or something like
231
00:32:43,905 --> 00:32:49,084
that. And the reality is if they're not actually doing, it's an individual journey. If they're not
232
00:32:49,084 --> 00:32:53,684
actually doing the work to do the education, what are you going to show up to the coffee guy and pull
233
00:32:53,684 --> 00:32:58,645
him aside while he's in the middle of his business to try and educate him? There's a very real friction
234
00:32:58,645 --> 00:33:25,945
that we're facing. And not to get too conspiratorial, guys, but I think Bitcoin as a store of value does not threaten the fiat system at all. I think it can fit within the fiat system and it can just continue to be a store of value. That's fine. But the medium of exchange does threaten the current system. And so when I see these hacks, these attacks on BTC Pay Server, on LNBits, on all these lightning infrastructure providers, I just have a hard time believing that that's just coincidence.
235
00:33:25,945 --> 00:33:47,165
So whether it be like a high level nation state thing or a low level scam like that, I mean, that's brutal, right? Like the guy actually did it and he accepted the Bitcoin and he made the mistake. It can happen to anyone also, like even it can just happen, even someone who thinks that they're paranoid and aware, like this is only going to get harder.
236
00:33:47,165 --> 00:34:17,144
So my point here is that I've had to really look myself in the mirror and say, like, what am I doing out here traveling the world trying to onboard people if I don't even understand how to run my own lightning node and my own stuff at a sovereign level? Are we all going to be on running our own lightning nodes? Like, I just I don't see that happening anytime soon. Are we all going to have self-custody? Probably. I mean, mathematically, no,
right? Like at the base layer. So there's a really nuanced discussion here about, you know, what percentage of people will be using Bitcoin.
237
00:34:17,144 --> 00:34:22,725
in a sovereign way, even Hal Finney and Satoshi were talking about Bitcoin banks. So we're not getting
238
00:34:22,725 --> 00:34:28,905
out of custodians and certain things from the fiat world will continue to exist in the Bitcoin world.
239
00:34:29,425 --> 00:34:34,205
So that's just kind of some thoughts high level. There are legitimate challenges and I think Rob,
240
00:34:34,265 --> 00:34:41,445
your story highlights one of them and I don't have a great answer. John? Yeah, I think like Kyle
241
00:34:41,445 --> 00:35:08,944
I'll mention, I don't think there's any silver bullet here. I wish there were. I think from my standpoint, ultimately, I like the idea of as we onboard larger merchants, just as an example, marquee merchants, that we have a kind of a turnkey solution in place where as they gain a certain balance of Bitcoin, perhaps they move it to a trusted custodian or multi-sig.
242
00:35:08,944 --> 00:35:13,984
even a custodian like a river I would probably trust if I had to pick one.
243
00:35:14,784 --> 00:35:25,444
But I think maybe one of the learnings there is that we can't expect the newly minted Bitcoin-friendly
244
00:35:25,444 --> 00:35:30,365
merchant to be completely self-sovereign and understand everything about Bitcoin custody.
245
00:35:31,104 --> 00:35:36,685
All of us started somewhere and we kept learning. So I think just making it as turnkey and mitigating
246
00:35:36,685 --> 00:35:41,984
as much as possible is the best we can do. One of the points Kyle touched on is the idea that
247
00:35:42,624 --> 00:35:50,965
medium of exchange is more of a risk to the existing system. I think an interesting thought
248
00:35:50,965 --> 00:35:55,885
process to go through there, and it's one of the things that motivates me in the Bitcoin space,
249
00:35:55,885 --> 00:36:03,345
Bitcoin is medium of exchange, is that I think we have a significant opportunity to increase the
250
00:36:03,345 --> 00:36:16,865
I think it's going to be easier to bring normies into actually using Bitcoin as a medium of exchange if they're getting rewards and if they're having fun with it and they don't have to have Bitcoin to begin with.
251
00:36:16,865 --> 00:36:20,804
I think there's a framework there that we're working on to bring in more normies.
252
00:36:21,304 --> 00:36:29,185
And what I'm excited by is to get to the point where, think about when we move to 1% of the population, 2%, 3%.
253
00:36:29,185 --> 00:36:47,165
I think it's Nassim Taleb notes the idea of the intransigent minority, intransigent minority that we can potentially reach where imagine if we get to two or three percent of the population is likes, like owns some Bitcoin, is using Bitcoin every day, likes it.
254
00:36:47,165 --> 00:36:57,165
And you have similarly, you have merchants who are very successful with it. We then have a political constituency that becomes very difficult.
255
00:36:57,165 --> 00:37:12,504
It becomes increasingly more likely that politicians and the general system will need to support Bitcoin and Bitcoiners and Bitcoin-friendly merchants because that just becomes more politically rational as well.
256
00:37:12,504 --> 00:37:24,665
So, yeah, I do think it's a threat to the system, but I think the larger we can make the audience of the group of Bitcoiners, then we increasingly mitigate those threats.
257
00:37:27,165 --> 00:37:28,685
and Kyle.
258
00:37:29,345 --> 00:37:31,504
Oh, I just I'm curious, like how we do that.
259
00:37:31,584 --> 00:37:35,484
Like, I think it's a good idea, but I'm curious, like, I just don't see it happening.
260
00:37:35,484 --> 00:37:41,685
I see the interest in Bitcoin going down and I see more people interested in GTA and X money
261
00:37:41,685 --> 00:37:43,665
than Bitcoin as a medium of exchange.
262
00:37:43,825 --> 00:37:48,205
So I am I would like to hear, John, if you can share some of kind of the framework you
263
00:37:48,205 --> 00:37:51,385
mentioned and, you know, obviously rewards is part of it.
264
00:37:51,885 --> 00:37:56,544
Yeah, you know, like some of it I I'm wary of sharing because we haven't released it yet
265
00:37:56,544 --> 00:38:23,804
and we will be working, we are working on it. And so there is a little bit of like, but I would say that it does come down to, like right now, like we said, for the motivated segment of Bitcoiners, it is ideologically rational. But for, yeah, it's basically bringing the economic incentives so it becomes economically rational also.
266
00:38:23,804 --> 00:38:50,425
I think a lot of normies, like one way to think of it is like a lot of normies think that one of their criticisms of Bitcoin is like, oh, you can't spend it anywhere. You can't use it. It's not used as money. And I think the site like this that we're working on, Saturday Bitcoin, we tried to mitigate that concern that yes, yes, there are a lot of places like local places and online where you can spend your Bitcoin.
267
00:38:50,425 --> 00:39:13,047
Bitcoin And if we bring the rewards in and normally start to accumulate Bitcoin I mean one of the things I think about I got into Bitcoin around 2017 and the price is around And I was thinking like in that scenario I was thinking I even have like a slide where
268
00:39:13,047 --> 00:39:15,887
I have a picture of like groceries I was buying at Whole Foods.
269
00:39:15,887 --> 00:39:21,667
And if you buy like groceries at Whole Foods, say for $100 and say you got something like
270
00:39:21,667 --> 00:39:46,007
a 5% cashback in Bitcoin and sats in 2017, and you just left it there, then that would be worth maybe something like $100 now. You're basically getting free groceries if you just keep the sats. And no other award in fiat works like that. No other award increases in value over time. In fact, they decrease in
value over time.
271
00:39:46,007 --> 00:40:15,867
So it's another, I think once normally start to see that, and you touched on it earlier, like if you have an actual dashboard in your wallet, like imagine the scenario where they're spending Bitcoin, they see the reward come in, a couple of points here, they see the reward come in in real time, which is what we can do in the Bitcoin space, you cannot do that in the fiat world, like MasterCard and all the banks working with MasterCard,
272
00:40:15,867 --> 00:40:22,267
they cannot give a consumer award in real time. In fact, there's a long list of things that in the
273
00:40:22,267 --> 00:40:26,227
Fiat world don't work, whereas in the Bitcoin world they actually do work. I'll just give you
274
00:40:26,227 --> 00:40:34,707
one other example. One of the things that merchants are very frustrated with when they deal with a
275
00:40:34,707 --> 00:40:43,147
company like, say, MasterCard for card-linked offers, where the user spends, they make a qualifying spend
276
00:40:43,147 --> 00:40:47,807
and a merchant to take advantage of an offer that they were given, like say 20% off.
277
00:40:48,247 --> 00:40:54,127
And then a week later, they return that product and the merchant has to return the full price.
278
00:40:54,427 --> 00:40:56,167
They actually keep the reward.
279
00:40:56,587 --> 00:41:01,687
There's no mechanism for the merchant to even pinpoint that, oh, you also got a reward.
280
00:41:02,547 --> 00:41:05,187
So therefore, I'm only going to give you 80% of your money back.
281
00:41:05,247 --> 00:41:06,447
No, they give 100%.
282
00:41:06,447 --> 00:41:08,167
And merchants are very frustrated with that.
283
00:41:08,167 --> 00:41:21,827
There's no way to detect or to qualify that offer as being different from that cashback as being different to another.
284
00:41:21,827 --> 00:41:34,727
But in the Bitcoin space, we can absolutely do that so that the merchant gets, if they're giving money back to a customer based on their own return policy,
285
00:41:34,727 --> 00:41:41,707
they can remove the reward component so they're not paying twice essentially.
286
00:41:42,427 --> 00:41:46,027
But anyway, I'll just pause there.
287
00:41:46,107 --> 00:41:48,247
I know we're conversations drifted around a bit.
288
00:41:50,667 --> 00:41:51,687
No worries.
289
00:41:51,867 --> 00:41:59,267
I want to get into next Bitcoin as a medium of exchange around the world because Kyle has
290
00:41:59,267 --> 00:42:00,767
a lot of experience there.
291
00:42:00,767 --> 00:42:08,867
He's filming documentaries in places like Africa, Indonesia, Bulgaria. He really has an inside look as to what it is like.
292
00:42:09,427 --> 00:42:17,367
But first, we got to give a shout out to our good friends, the sponsors of this show, nobody else but Rhino Bitcoin.
293
00:42:17,887 --> 00:42:25,027
Getting access to Bitcoin financial services historically was slow, clunky, and scattered across all these different platforms, each with their own limitations.
294
00:42:25,027 --> 00:42:52,727
but Rhino is changing that. Rhino is a next generation Bitcoin banking app designed to handle all of your Bitcoin needs in one place. Buy Bitcoin with some of the lowest fees anywhere. That means more sats for every dollar you spend. Make payments over the Lightning Network instantly and again with near zero fees. Send cash globally fast and easy on Bitcoin rails to friends and family around the world. And of course, you can DCA, set up automatic savings so you stack sats on your schedule and build wealth over time.
295
00:42:52,727 --> 00:43:00,107
And this is just the beginning. Soon you'll be able to pay bills, direct deposit, even save for retirement right in the app there.
296
00:43:00,107 --> 00:43:14,247
And now with Arch, you can borrow against your Bitcoin in the Rhino app. If you're a Rhino user, you borrow against your Bitcoin using Arch before the end of this year, you get a whole percentage point off your APR. That's a huge savings.
297
00:43:14,247 --> 00:43:25,027
And now, Rhino protects your Bitcoin with the highest level of security, biometric verification, 24-7 fraud protection, and the confidence of knowing your Bitcoin is never, ever rehypothecated.
298
00:43:25,407 --> 00:43:38,667
Go to rhinobitcoin.com, download it today on iOS or Android, use the code BITCOINNEWS, that's one word, BITCOINNEWS, and Rhino will drop you $21 in free Bitcoin when you deposit your first hundred.
299
00:43:38,667 --> 00:43:42,847
it. If you're going to be using Bitcoin as a medium of exchange, you got to have some first.
300
00:43:43,287 --> 00:43:51,367
We highly recommend going over to Rhino and getting it over there. All right, boys, you got to get your
301
00:43:51,367 --> 00:43:59,667
Bitcoin. Buy it on Rhino. I know you're a fan of Rhino over there, Kyle. I'm sorry, you're muted, bro.
302
00:44:01,767 --> 00:44:07,467
You're muted, but yes. I've been on the speakers of my MacBook the whole time. Can you hear me?
303
00:44:07,467 --> 00:44:08,707
Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah
304
00:44:08,707 --> 00:44:18,147
Man, yeah, I love Rhino, huge fan of the team, specifically Hector, was one of the first Bitcoiners that just pointed me in the right direction as I was getting into the space
305
00:44:18,147 --> 00:44:24,247
I reached out to him on LinkedIn, I was like, hey man, I want to build on Bitcoin, he took some time out of his day, got on the phone with me
306
00:44:24,247 --> 00:44:28,707
So yeah, shout out to those guys, genuinely really good guys, and I support them 100%
307
00:44:28,707 --> 00:44:35,227
Nice, well, I want to give people a little preview of what you've been cooking up there, Kyle
308
00:44:35,227 --> 00:44:43,327
we're going to swatch the first little beginning here of your latest documentary filmed in Indonesia for my first Bitcoin.
309
00:44:44,007 --> 00:44:44,987
So let's check this out.
310
00:44:47,887 --> 00:44:51,887
People fly from all over the world to
discover our home.
311
00:44:58,187 --> 00:45:00,507
The light dancing across the water.
312
00:45:01,627 --> 00:45:03,727
The history at every turn.
313
00:45:05,227 --> 00:45:27,227
And with it, a sense that somehow life here is complete. Millions come each year to see our rainforests, cultures, and unique way of life. But behind the postcards and the Instagram stories, the locals here have been fighting a quiet war.
314
00:45:27,227 --> 00:45:35,147
Not with weapons, with money.
315
00:45:37,147 --> 00:45:42,467
The nature of money that we are living in, think of the worst in us.
316
00:45:44,987 --> 00:45:56,147
This is the story of how our small Indonesian community of teachers, builders, leaders, parents, entrepreneurs, and drivers
317
00:45:56,147 --> 00:46:06,047
decided to learn where our money really comes from and to prepare for a future that our government still says must be forbidden.
318
00:46:07,627 --> 00:46:13,587
Oh, there we have it. That's the quick intro to the latest documentary, The Bitcoin Revolution Indonesia.
319
00:46:14,027 --> 00:46:20,987
Try to stop a bigger than Bitcoin film for my first Bitcoin directed by our guest today, Kyle Huber.
320
00:46:20,987 --> 00:46:24,147
Great work. Watch that at the premiere of PubKey in New York City.
321
00:46:24,147 --> 00:46:32,587
had goosebumps throughout. Very touching story. Well done. Amazingly put together. Talk to us.
322
00:46:32,587 --> 00:46:39,507
What is Bitcoin as a medium of exchange like outside of America, outside of Europe, around the world?
323
00:46:41,107 --> 00:46:46,747
Yeah, Rob, thank you so much for bringing that up. And my first Bitcoin is the answer to the education
324
00:46:46,747 --> 00:46:53,187
problem, right? They are the only, there are multiple. They're the biggest, completely community
325
00:46:53,187 --> 00:46:58,187
and I'm a very wealthy funded nonprofit organization that's doing Bitcoin education.
326
00:46:58,187 --> 00:47:03,187
And as the founder John Dennehy says, whoever funds education will capture education.
327
00:47:03,187 --> 00:47:11,187
So if you're someone who's interested in supporting Bitcoin adoption around the world and actually improving people's lives, I can't imagine a better organization to support.
328
00:47:11,187 --> 00:47:16,187
I've been very blessed. It's just extremely aligned with what I already wanted to do.
329
00:47:16,187 --> 00:47:19,187
So, yeah, we traveled to four different circular economies this year.
330
00:47:19,187 --> 00:47:47,727
The first one being Kenya, Indonesia, we went to Prague, and then to Colombia in September. So I've seen Bitcoin on four different continents this year. And you know, they say Bitcoin is many different things to many different people. That's absolutely true. I won't rant too long right now, but in Kenya, Bitcoin is just better money, period. They had what's called M-Pesa in 2008, which is like a digital money. Many people there who cannot get access to traditional finance.
331
00:47:47,727 --> 00:47:52,127
They use M-Pesa on their phones. They have smartphones. And so when you come to them and say,
332
00:47:52,207 --> 00:47:58,247
hey, we have a different digital money and it has lower fees, non-KYC. It's like, oh, like dumb.
333
00:47:58,507 --> 00:48:04,927
Like it's so easy to, done, sorry. It's so easy for them to understand. I went there in March,
334
00:48:05,067 --> 00:48:09,747
April timeframe, kind of middle of the bear market thinking, oh man, the price is down. Everyone's
335
00:48:09,747 --> 00:48:14,447
going to be super bearish. Like, no, the opposite was the case. They had this organization called
336
00:48:14,447 --> 00:48:19,827
the core. And also, what's the other one? I can't remember. There's one for guys, one for girls,
337
00:48:20,027 --> 00:48:23,647
and they're doing great education. So they're just like, we're happy for cheaper sats.
338
00:48:23,647 --> 00:48:30,387
So in Kenya, Bitcoin adoption as payments, daily payments is booming. 150 plus merchants around
339
00:48:30,387 --> 00:48:36,267
Nairobi just in the last two years. There's a place called Kibera, which is the third largest slum in
340
00:48:36,267 --> 00:48:41,847
the world we visited. And some great organizations there, 60 something merchants, so many circular
341
00:48:41,847 --> 00:48:46,347
economies. I couldn't visit them all in that trip. And so, yeah, the first documentary was in Kenya.
342
00:48:47,527 --> 00:48:53,487
And then, yeah, Indonesia is the opposite. So in Indonesia, Bitcoin payments are illegal. It is not
343
00:48:53,487 --> 00:48:58,687
only illegal to accept Bitcoin payments, it's illegal to use any foreign currency. They work
344
00:48:58,687 --> 00:49:03,327
within the constraints that they have, and they're actually in the My First Bitcoin node network,
345
00:49:03,507 --> 00:49:10,567
the largest community. So they have 44 plus meetups around the country, and they do incredible
346
00:49:10,567 --> 00:49:15,987
education. They see it more as a store of value. They see it because their currency has not only been
347
00:49:15,987 --> 00:49:20,627
debased like ours has in the West, but even worse than some of the other Southeast Asian countries
348
00:49:20,627 --> 00:49:24,887
around them. So they're looking at it like, let's just solve our problem. We don't want to break the
349
00:49:24,887 --> 00:49:29,887
law. I don't want to break the law, but I do have to do what I have to do to protect myself, my future
350
00:49:29,887 --> 00:49:34,607
family and things like that. And that's how they see it. So they use FEDI, which is not technically
351
00:49:34,607 --> 00:49:39,987
Bitcoin, right? It's eCash. It's sort of a token from Bitcoin. That's their workaround. And they're
352
00:49:39,987 --> 00:49:46,007
still a few places accepting Bitcoin, but many people didn't know Bali was one of the first Bitcoin
353
00:49:46,007 --> 00:49:52,827
circular economies in the world. And in 2014, out of
the blue, completely unprepared for, the police
354
00:49:52,827 --> 00:49:56,287
showed up at a number of merchants' doors and just said, yeah, you guys are coming to jail.
355
00:49:56,867 --> 00:50:03,007
And multiple merchants spent years in jail, not short amount of time, like actually went to jail for
356
00:50:03,007 --> 00:50:08,827
multiple years. So very serious there. And yeah, like I said, they're working within the constraints
357
00:50:08,827 --> 00:50:38,747
You saw 80-plus students graduating. The energy was super high. But at the same time, they have real-world challenges ahead of them. I see potentially more challenges coming our way as far as using Bitcoin as well. So let's, yeah, just be aware that there are going to be challenging times ahead. And I saw it firsthand in Indonesia. And yeah, I'll pass it back to you guys. But those are sort of like the two documentaries that are out. The next one will be Columbia. And last thing I got to do is give a shout out to my editor.
358
00:50:38,747 --> 00:50:53,707
Ben Isaac, absolute beast of an editor. And, you know, they say a film is told three times, once when it's written, once when it's shot, and once when it's edited. The one that's actually seen by people is the one that's edited, and Ben deserves all the credit on the storytelling. He's an amazing editor.
359
00:50:54,787 --> 00:51:02,347
Let's go. Shout out Ben. And John, what is your take on Bitcoin as a medium of exchange outside of the West?
360
00:51:04,847 --> 00:51:06,167
Oh, sorry. I think you're muted.
361
00:51:06,167 --> 00:51:24,127
Sorry, back now. Yeah, I definitely think there are significant differences. I think most of us in the US are not worried about day-to-day inflation or debasement as they are in many other countries. So it's a different mindset.
362
00:51:24,127 --> 00:51:42,847
I think for better or for worse in what I'm working on right now in Saturday Bitcoin, there is more of a US focus because and the reason is that when recognizing or like the point I made at the very start that it's a way to think about it is a two-sided market.
363
00:51:43,267 --> 00:51:49,527
And when you think of the two-sided market and you're starting to build out a two-sided market, you have to start somewhere.
364
00:51:49,727 --> 00:51:52,647
You have to pick your sort of favorite market, if you will.
365
00:51:52,647 --> 00:52:04,967
and for better or for worse, that is the US for us because if we were to get say a single merchant in a particular category to accept Bitcoin, we can say,
366
00:52:04,992 --> 00:52:11,152
and mobilise the whole US market to direct their spend at that merchant and we can have a significant impact.
367
00:52:11,792 --> 00:52:21,512
So it's just easier for us to start to build a market in the US and it's also hopefully a stronger business, the potential business model over time as well.
368
00:52:22,512 --> 00:52:34,972
I think in, but you'll see in our website though, our website is global
in that we try to, we leverage as much data out there on businesses that accept Bitcoin
369
00:52:34,972 --> 00:52:44,152
so that even if a restaurant in some third world country starts accepting Bitcoin, we will show it in our website.
370
00:52:45,052 --> 00:52:47,852
We want to make sure that we cover the whole globe.
371
00:52:47,852 --> 00:52:59,912
But in terms of our outreach and our efforts for us to onboard merchants and to get them to do Bitcoin rewards, our focus is more on the U.S., at least right now.
372
00:52:59,912 --> 00:53:25,432
Yeah. And one big development in the US that happened last year this time was Square turning on their Bitcoin acceptance, right? And so there's been a slow rollout throughout the last 12 months. And the end goal is so that customers can go to the terminal and just toggle whether they want to pay in fiat or in Bitcoin. And we're still not seeing that everywhere.
373
00:53:25,432 --> 00:53:33,792
There was some talk that that rollout might have been finished by this month, a year after they launched, but it seems as if there's still some of that rollout still going.
374
00:53:33,792 --> 00:53:40,872
But do you think that that's an answer, giving the customers the option without the merchant even knowing that they're accepting Bitcoin?
375
00:53:41,532 --> 00:53:42,472
Kyle, what's your take?
376
00:53:43,372 --> 00:53:46,412
I had a complete change of perspective on this, Rob.
377
00:53:46,412 --> 00:54:21,052
I was under the perspective of like if the merchant is not actually storing the sats then by me spending I actually just selling Bitcoin straight to a centralized authority right Converting straight to fiat And that shift happened when I went into a merchant in Seattle as a coffee shop right near my dentist And I walked in and I saw the square terminal I was like ah let me just try this I haven done it before And I sparked a little conversation They asked like what We can accept Bitcoin on this thing Next thing you know the owner comes over she asking questions So the experience of being able
378
00:54:21,052 --> 00:54:26,612
to talk about Bitcoin for me is worth it. So now when I see those square terminals all over the US,
379
00:54:27,232 --> 00:54:30,792
I always choose. I always ask at least. And sometimes they say we can't figure it out,
380
00:54:30,832 --> 00:54:35,292
but it's as simple as clicking other payment options, lightning, QR code, done. It's that simple.
381
00:54:35,292 --> 00:54:44,212
And I think Jack Dorsey's decision and Block's decision to do that is maybe the most bullish thing I've seen since getting into Bitcoin in 2020
382
00:54:44,212 --> 00:54:49,352
Well, there you have it. Yeah, and John, what's your take on Square, what they've done?
383
00:54:49,712 --> 00:54:58,552
Yeah, I think it's up to 4 million merchants now, mostly small businesses in the US that can technically accept Bitcoin
384
00:54:58,552 --> 00:55:23,572
I think it's great in that it does remove a, it makes it much, if you look at the ultimate goal of getting the merchant up and running, accepting Bitcoin, welcoming Bitcoin, welcoming Bitcoiners, I think it's a great step because it makes it easier to make those merchants successful with Bitcoin than starting from scratch where you actually have to go in and do some implementation, they might have to run a node.
385
00:55:23,572 --> 00:55:29,872
That just seems like a lot of headache, a lot of work. So I think definitely it removes that point of friction.
386
00:55:30,252 --> 00:55:46,252
I think what I'd like to see, though, is that my expectation is that only a very small subsection of those merchants are likely primed to be enthusiastic about Bitcoin.
387
00:55:46,412 --> 00:55:50,632
I think many of them, as Kyle found, they don't even know that they can technically accept Bitcoin.
388
00:55:50,632 --> 00:56:20,612
and they're probably wary they're they probably have the typical hangups of like oh it's volatile or what am I supposed to do with the money when I somebody pays me or do I have to train my staff or whatever so um I think I'm still I'm still recognizing that in many cases when we start that conversation with the merchant we learn very quickly if they're if they're open-minded and they're they're bitcoin curious and I think those are the merchants to focus on that that are actually interested in like tell me more like tell me more and whereas many of them many of them if they're
389
00:56:20,632 --> 00:56:34,753
if they shut you down I think just move on to the next merchant in a way to look for the adoption there And all right gentlemen in closing here are we bullish or are we bearish on Bitcoin as a medium
390
00:56:34,753 --> 00:56:39,753
exchange? Let's just keep it contained within 2027. Are we going to see bullish developments
391
00:56:39,753 --> 00:56:42,993
as Bitcoin as a medium exchange in the next year? Kyle?
392
00:56:43,893 --> 00:56:48,573
If I have anything to say about it, Rob, yes, we're going to see it. If you listen to my podcast,
393
00:56:48,573 --> 00:56:52,853
If you see any of the stuff I post every single day, I think this is the most important thing.
394
00:56:52,933 --> 00:56:56,233
They say, you know, your vote in the political system doesn't really mean anything.
395
00:56:56,793 --> 00:56:57,293
I don't know.
396
00:56:57,593 --> 00:57:02,373
But when you vote with your money and your time and energy, that is the biggest impact that you can have.
397
00:57:02,373 --> 00:57:06,273
So when we realize that, I think that's going to be a big unlock.
398
00:57:06,413 --> 00:57:11,873
I think Bitcoiners should not underestimate the power of just small little daily transactions, little coffee payments.
399
00:57:12,153 --> 00:57:15,493
And back to your point of being ready to use Bitcoin when the time comes.
400
00:57:16,673 --> 00:57:17,613
Well, John.
401
00:57:18,573 --> 00:57:35,373
Yeah, I'm very excited about Bitcoin Medium of Exchange, not just next
year, but starting right now and starting potentially even this weekend or next weekend because we have our first merchant hopefully lined up to be part of our Saturday Bitcoin rally.
402
00:57:35,373 --> 00:57:42,053
We're throughout the United States. We want as many Bitcoiners to buy from this particular merchant on an upcoming Saturday.
403
00:57:42,053 --> 00:57:46,733
Just during this call, I got confirmation of the merchant.
404
00:57:47,133 --> 00:57:49,533
So it's going to be in the wine category.
405
00:57:51,193 --> 00:57:54,153
So, yeah, please come to the website.
406
00:57:54,413 --> 00:58:09,153
And, you know, if you are one of the few Bitcoiners who wants to see Bitcoin succeed as medium of exchange and you're willing to spend a bit of Bitcoin and actually get a get some get a discount as well, then please participate in this upcoming rally.
407
00:58:09,153 --> 00:58:13,413
and this is the mechanism we're going to be using to help drive Bitcoin medium of exchange.
408
00:58:14,213 --> 00:58:17,713
And check out the website and be part of the movement.
409
00:58:18,453 --> 00:58:22,713
Yeah, I love that idea of picking a day of the week and having a focus on one merchant.
410
00:58:22,913 --> 00:58:25,773
Everybody can rally behind. I think that's very, very powerful.
411
00:58:26,173 --> 00:58:29,833
All right. Nice. This was a very interesting conversation.
412
00:58:30,093 --> 00:58:43,233
I think one that was needed like medium of exchange gets lost in the sauce We talking about treasury companies and AI Jensen Huang yada yada yada Bitcoin is money Bitcoin should be spent You should know how to do it So gentlemen thank you so much for your time
413
00:58:43,353 --> 00:58:47,673
Let's just let you have a little bit of a shout out yourself. Where should people go if they want to find out more, Kyle?
414
00:58:48,973 --> 00:58:54,153
Thank you so much for having me on, Rob. And I just want to reiterate really quickly, I have no issue with the treasury companies.
415
00:58:54,153 --> 00:59:00,353
I have no issue with the people that want to just store it and HODL it. Actually, it's like protesting the sunrise.
416
00:59:00,353 --> 00:59:03,593
People are going to do it. I'm not going to protest the sunrise. You want to do what you want to do.
417
00:59:03,733 --> 00:59:08,993
But if you are aligned on this and you want to hear stories of people that are actually being impacted
418
00:59:08,993 --> 00:59:14,913
positively, Bitcoin's returns are not just monetary. For me, it's completely changed my life. I feel like
419
00:59:14,913 --> 00:59:20,053
I get to allocate my time as though I was like a billionaire. I spend my time how I want. And I
420
00:59:20,053 --> 00:59:25,173
highly encourage you to build on Bitcoin. So yeah, my podcast is called We Are Satoshi. Website is
421
00:59:25,173 --> 00:59:29,193
kylehuber.com. You can find all my links there. Thank you. Cool. And John?
422
00:59:29,193 --> 00:59:46,093
Yeah, thanks Rob for having me on. It was a really nice conversation. Yeah, like I hope as many Bitcoiners as possible can come to our website, SaturdayBitcoin.com and start to participate and be part of the movement at Bitcoin as Medium of Exchange.
423
00:59:46,093 --> 01:00:11,153
And also I have another personal project, LastCoinStanding.com, where I've created about 50 or 60 educational tools and calculators and experiences for Bitcoiners and the Bitcoin curious to learn more about Bitcoin and get more from Bitcoin. Things like Bitcoin versus real estate and planning Bitcoin retirement and things like that. Just a fun personal project.
424
01:00:11,153 --> 01:00:17,293
There you have it. Always stay learning, especially when it comes to Bitcoin. Thank you so much, guys.
425
01:00:17,513 --> 01:00:23,253
This has been Rob Wallace, your host with Bitcoin News Live. We'll be back every Wednesday,
426
01:00:23,413 --> 01:00:27,173
11 a.m. Eastern with some great guests like these two. All right. Until next time.
427
01:00:41,153 --> 01:00:42,153
.