প্রতিলিপি 🔗
Ben: Welcome to Incave and Presents, Readings from the Archive. I'm Ben, and ⁓ on this podcast I invite guests who write on the internet. They bring an essay, they read it, and we discuss it. My guest today is Avi, ⁓ who has ⁓ had an excellent career as a sound engineer and ⁓ also has a very interesting physics blog that I enjoy. ⁓ Avi, welcome to the podcast. Thank you, Ben. Good to be here. ⁓ what's the ⁓ essay that you've brought to share with us today? Today's essay is called World Building with Gravitational Slingshots. Excellent. ⁓ why did you select this one? I've always had interest in ⁓ gravity and gravity slingshots and this one has some interesting kind of sci fi ⁓ applications. Sure, sure. There are always ⁓ lots of interesting little physics models on your blog. ⁓ and then ⁓ this one I think ⁓ you said it also got turned into a story. Yes, it did. ⁓ by Max Harms. ⁓ that's nice. Did you come up through the idea did you discuss the idea together and then he wanted to do the fiction or how did that come back? I I I pitched the idea to him. I had had the idea for ⁓ a story around this because there's some very unintuitive things that would happen ⁓ to somebody in this situation and I thought it would make a good short story. Interesting. Yeah. ⁓ and so you this is a topic you've thought about for a long time. Yeah, it is. ⁓ but you finally got to writing about it in this one. Exactly. Great. Well ⁓ I look forward to hearing that. Let's give that a lesson. World building with gravity slingshots. One, burn fuel to get fast, burn fuel to get slow, zero sum. Artemis II successfully completed its mission two weeks ago. The Orion craft returned safely, screaming back to Earth at eleven kilometers per second, forty thousand kilometers an hour, or about thirty times the speed of sound. This insane velocity was hard won, yet life threatening on return. Set aside the effort it took Orion to reach such massive speeds, going to the moon and back. Now even throwing away that velocity for free would have been welcome. Indeed, throwing away kinetic energy is one of the most expensive and difficult challenges of the entire mission. What if a spaceship could return to Earth minus the inferno? Is physics hiding some kind of regenerative braking scheme like we have with EVs? Now imagine if kinetic energy were a tangible. Detachable thing, like a battery. And a craft in orbit could simply disconnect it and drop it in a bucket when it's ready to return. That craft would then fall gently, relatively speaking, back to the surface with no massive heat shield, no scrubbing off costly orbital speed, no 3,000 degree plasma bubble surrounding it. Not only that, this bucket would store that kinetic energy and donate it to the next rocket coming up. A large mass, which is used as a gravity slingshot, gives you just such a free boost, both going up to space and on returning. Now I've modeled an artificially placed mass in Earth orbit, and I in my attempt to design a kind of on-ramp and off-ramp for Earth orbit. And I can now report that such a gravity system is not possible at the orbital level. However, if scaled up to a solar system level, the physics becomes more friendly. And may hold an answer to much larger challenges. Now, if you had this bucket and it was full of rocket fuel for you, you would use rocket engines, which are an uncomfortable and stressful experience for airframes and humans alike. Those velocity buckets, if they were for of gravitational assist, well, a gravitational assist has a special comfort advantage that no rocket boost does, and we're going to get to that. two. The Gravity Slingshot. A large mass in orbit around another mass can accelerate and decelerate objects via the gravitational slingshot in the frame of the central mass. So let's talk about a gravity slingshot. A gravity slingshot is a three-body maneuver. A spacecraft passes close to a moving body, say Jupiter orbiting the sun, and it exits on a redirected path. In Jupiter's frame, the ship Arrives and leaves at the same speed. But in the sun's frame, it has gained or lost velocity by exchanging momentum with Jupiter's orbital motion. This is what's referred to as flybys, used in Voyager missions and other space missions that have enabled it to reach speeds to escape the solar system. Now, imagine an artificial slingshot mass in Earth orbit that could suck rop rockets up when they get near it and and and sling them to higher orbits, or out to the moon, or to other planets. And then craft returning from deep space would whip around this and slow down for free on their way back. It would have been a helping hand in and out of Earth's gravitational well. But as I said, physics has has dashed my hopes of this of this device. And I can I can explain why. If you consider the moon, now that's large and far away, three hundred eighty-four thousand kilometers away, and it's quite massive, but it has basically never been used as a ⁓ gravity assist in space missions, with with one exception. So why is that? You've got this huge ball out there. Why couldn't it suck the rockets up out into space for us? Well, if you're trying to attain Earth orbit, It's useless because it's far above the orbits that we'd want to use. And if you were using if you wanted to use it to sling objects deep out into the solar system, the velocity it can give you is is basically tiny. And that's and that's too small. That's just not very much. Reality check. How much influence does the moon have on current spacecraft reaching orbit? Not much. It doesn't provide any help and its influence is tiny. Now, consider the significant tides caused by the moon. For an object to offer significantly greater assistance than the moon, it would have to be nearer than the moon or more massive, or both. And those would prevent present even more disruptive tides than we have now. So the conclusion is I don't believe that there is a scenario where an artificial gravitational
Load full transcript
mass can help climbing in or out of the Earth's gravitational well. And it's important to report our null result here. In short, anything near enough to help on the way out is too disruptive. If you push it farther out in order to save the Earth, then by the time the rocket reaches it, it's already out of the out of the Earth's gravitational well. I experimented with scenarios where a moon could offer a slingshot effect to help ⁓ satellites reach orbit. Given an advanced civilization and and a slashing of the costs getting on and off world, I still don't see whether physics prefers a artificial slingshot mass in a planetary orbit. Stellar level artificial slingshot mass. I propose an artificial slingshot mass, an ASM, in a tight orbit around a star as the most plausible use case. Now the tidal effects are no longer a concern because the star is huge and who cares if you make it tight. A tide on the star, and its function would be to launch craft out to the deepest reaches of its system and to catch them effortlessly on their scorching returns. It could even be used to launch or receive interstellar missions. This would be the gateway hub of the inner planets. As an optimization, we could give the mass a highly elliptical orbit. That offers even greater orbital speeds at perihelion, albeit with more complex mission profiles. Well, I didn't see how a gravity assist at the orbital level Could save us from re-entry heating, like at 11 kilometers per second. That is, after all, a solved problem, albeit barely. But the heat shield limitations certainly drive the mission design, but but they do work. And ASM could help solve the future velocity scrubbing challenges. Nobody currently dares venture heat shield solutions for a 30 kilometer per second re-entry, let alone a hundred kilometer per second re-entry, say some mission returning from Neptune. They just buckled down with the rocket equation and presume we're stuck retro rocketing our way back down the well. If your heat shields are maxed out, add more rockets. But an artificial slingshot mass in a tight solar orbit could turn that 100 kilometer per second return into a solved 11 kilometer per second problem with zero fuel cost. And symmetrically, they can just as well accelerate a ship up to the same velocities, shoot them out to the outer reaches. Now, of course, manned missions in Neptune are not on anybody's roadmap. This is the this is the tech level of future centuries. We are we are world building. Yet we are world building based on a specific technical challenge challenge that we see on T V today. And as long as one is building such a capable civilization, they can also claim that the orbital reentry has long been solved with space elevators or or mass drivers or your your future tech of choice. The special sauce, where an ASM blows away a rocket. Having found a niche for an ASM, let's plan a mission. Suppose you have an ASM in a highly eccentric orbit, dipping well inside Mercury's orbit. If
you were to point your rocket to meet that mass at its low point as it's screaming past the sun around four times Mercury's speed, it will whip your rocket speed up by 20 kilometers per second in a short period of time. That acceleration would happen in minutes. You'd probably think you need to invest in some good crash couches, but don't bother. When you picture a ship completing a hairpin turn at speeds that would squash the pilot, then consider that an object in a gravity slingshot is actually in free fall. No matter how tight the turn, how fast they did a complete one hundred eighty, this is a form of orbit. And they would not feel any acceleration. Einstein would explain to you they merely traveled in a straight line. Through the curved space-time of the slingshot mass. Alright, welcome back. Well, thanks very much for reading that. I very much enjoyed listening to your recounting of that blog post, which didn't bear as much resemblance to the blog blog post as other people's recountings do. ⁓ you were ⁓ taking some liberties with the ⁓ text and improvising a little bit from ⁓ I I guess I do that when I repeat. ⁓ what did you notice ⁓ differently reading it out loud relative to when you had just ⁓ written it? Well, I try to relate it to ⁓ you know it It is a technical topic. So, you know, if I'm reading it I'm thinking about I'm reading it to a person and ⁓ and and suddenly I have someone I want you know, I'm I'm explaining something to and so I I just I I'm thinking about a person I'm I'm I'm bringing that to. Where' where's your interest in physics ⁓ stem from? How long has that been ⁓ something you've been fascinated by? I've pretty much always enjoyed phys like, you know, going back to high school and and college, ⁓ I liked my physic physics courses. ⁓ and ⁓ I didn't work with physics specifically in my career, although, you know, audio was applied physics. ⁓ so ⁓ it's just something I always had an interest in. And then when I started blogging, ⁓ the things I was most interested in exploring had to do with ⁓ gravity and orbits and and things like that. How did you start blogging? I ⁓ you've got lots of little physics models and things on your site. What was the impetus there? ⁓ well one of the things I really wanted to do, ⁓ in this next phase of my life was to do science explanations to do I actually was thinking I would be a a a YouTube science explainer and I just kept holding off and I, you know, I can too much of a perfectionist because I you know, I've been I've worked in audio a lot and I wanted the audio to be perfect and what letting be perfect and and it just never got off the ground. And then one day I said, Well why don't I just write the script? And then I started banging out articles. Yeah. I said, well this is seems to be where my momentum is. So I'm gonna write ⁓ I'm gonna write physics articles. That's great. ⁓ did you get any feedback on the ⁓ early ones or were you just ⁓ monologuing into the void? It is a lot of you
know, 'cause I'm I got my independent site. ⁓ it's it for the most part it feels like it's it's off into the void. I've, you know, reached out to some science writers and people I know and, you know, gotten a little bit of feedback. But, you know, I haven't quite got that, you know, hacker news hug of death, you know. yeah. ⁓ so yeah, it is ⁓ relevant that ⁓ none of the space rockets we send up are attempting to use the moon as a a slingshot in any particular way. ⁓ so it would I guess it would have to be much bigger and much nearer in order for it to have any effect. Exactly. ⁓ and or yes, I guess and then the tides would be destructive. ⁓ that the Right, that's yeah. So that's that's the problem is that if if you were to put something up there that would be a boost to rockets, it would be more of a gravitational influence on us than the moon is. Yes. Which would be bad. Uhhuh. We don't want that. Yeah, I don't quite know how big how quickly those tides would get bigger, but ⁓ they could I can imagine them getting quite Well if it had a if it had a greater ⁓ gravitational influence than the moon did. Because it would be pulling rockets up more than the moon does, right? The tides would from this thing would be bigger than the tides we have now from the moon. Mm-hmm. Let alone if the two were lined up and we had a combined tide of the two. Yep. So yeah, it's just it's just out of the question. That makes sense. And I so I did mention that, you know, I tried to sort of like, you know, go into my little world builder or kind of s some sim sandbox and said, Okay, well what if what if I had a a planet that was like really tide resistant, right? So what if it didn't you know, if it was like a rocky planet no s no oceans or if it didn't have tectonic plates, you know, maybe the tides wouldn't bother it as much. We wouldn't have volcanoes erupting in high tides. but just working the numbers through, I I kind of learned that ⁓ there's not a there's not a good hard science, you know, ⁓ case for that being. So I, you know if I ever see that come up in a sci-fi novel, I'm gonna really look at their numbers. but I you know I didn't give up on it so that's why I found the ⁓ I would would probably the the even more energetic ⁓ the more powerful ⁓ example which is not just getting off your planet, but like getting out of your star system. Yeah. and ⁓ did you suggest a Max B story idea or did you Yes. So the what happens ⁓ in the story is a reveal of the point I make at the very end, which is If you think of a gravity slingshot, which, you know, is a very evocative thing, like y it's a slingshot and you're the shot. Right. And you are the shot. you know, you think of a F one car going around a hairpin turn, right? Except you're, you know, at tens of thousands of kilometers per second. ⁓ and so you're thinking it would absolutely, you know, pure you. and then what physics tells us is that that's a form of orbit. And you would be weightless the entire time. ⁓ Interesting. Yeah. So I just I just spoiled Max's article. But but that was that was the that was the the vignette which I had thought up is like, ⁓ so what happens if, you know, so take somebody who knows their way who knows the ropes, right? You've got a a a crew, you know, who's done this slingshot maneuver a bunch of time, they've been in and out of the inner reaches, outer reaches, right? And then like a space reporter comes along. And you know, and they're like, Okay, get ready for the slingshot and they're all like, you strapping their couches and stuff. And then, you know, like one person like the cat's like drinking tea or something, you know? And and the then the reporters getting ready to get, you know, absolutely flattenative couch and then they they get into the slingshot and they're like, You know we're in orbit, right? That's very funny. Yeah. so ⁓ and just so I understand just let me ask noob physics questions. So is this specifically about a ⁓ a smaller planet orbiting ⁓ or a smaller body orbiting a larger body? ⁓ 'cause I think we do use like planets for a sling for ⁓ changing our speeds and changing our angles substantially. Yeah. But it's specifically about the smaller body around a larger body that we're talking about. Well it's it's it's about it's a three body thing. Well we're where one body is a spaceship. Yeah. So you have spaceship plus two other bodies. Yes. So the spaceship needs these two bodies. It could be the sun and a planet or the sun is artificial mass. ⁓ in Max's story the artificial mass is like many thousandth it's a black hole which is many thousandth times the mass of the sun. I mean he went he went all out with it. ⁓ but any any two ⁓ bodies where one is orbiting the other, you are using the orbital motion of one and and as a as a source of of of ⁓ velocity for your for your ship. Yeah. ⁓ And if I can explain the kind of the core idea behind a slingshot, which which is I think the the the thing that people don't often understand and I didn't understand the first few times I understood it, is if you think of doing a slingshot around Jupiter, Jupiter, right? We often think of ⁓ the gravitational field around ⁓ a planet as a gravitational well, right? It's you know, you you fall down into it, right? ⁓ and if you if you do a a near approach of a planet, you you kind of zoom in and then back out. So if you're going down a hill and back up the other side of a hill, like of a bowl, why would you come out faster? How do you gain energy there? The answer is the bowl is moving. In the bowl stream of reference, you didn't. So Jupiter sees you coming along. You come in at whatever whatever kilometers per second. You you exit at whatever kilometers per second. But the whole thing was moving relative to the sun. the other, I'll give you one more maybe more intuitive but more abstract example, which is it's sometimes described as a an elastic collision, something bouncing off of something. So imagine I take a rubber
ball that bounces perfectly and I throw it off that wall. It just comes back with the speed I I gave it. Minus a little friction energy. Yeah. Physics. Physics always ignores that stuff, you know. No friction, no no and no heat, right. Now, imagine the wall's moving toward me. Imagine I threw that ball off the front of a speeding freight train. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Much faster. This you it comes back faster than you threw it. Yes. It gains energy from the thing it bounces off That makes sense. that's how slingshots work is they gain energy from the thing they're slinging around. And and when I say gain energy, that can be in either direction. So you can be you can be coming back from Neptune and you fired your engines at some huge speed to get you know, so you didn't take ten years to come back and now you gotta slow down. And so you'd be able to do the same thing. You're you're you're basically throwing your your rubber ball off of a receding train. Yeah. ⁓ So it's a it's a free energy source. In either way. You ⁓ you seem to think a lot about ⁓ how to deal with ⁓ like three body issues ⁓ in space. You've also got your like ⁓ little simulator of trying to get something into orbit. Mm-hmm. ⁓ I guess that's just an interest of yours. Yeah, orbits are just so cool. Yeah. I you know, I'm just I haven't I haven't run out of cool things to do with orbits yet. and and and just gravity is just it's it's so simple. This pulls on this. It pulls the bigger the thing is, the more it pulls. The farther away they are. Were there any ⁓ books or anything in particular when you were younger that ⁓ got you interested in physics? I wish I could find I have no idea what this calculus book was. I must have been like maybe maybe middle school or early high school. When we got the Radio Shack T R S eighty model three with actual pixel graphics, not just text. Hm. Like one of the first things I wanted to do was so it's probably around when Star Wars came out. Star Wars Tatooine had two sons. Three bytes. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Well well not that was three by but I was thinking, I wonder if a planet would do like a figure eight between its two zones. Like what would the orbit look like? Answer is they don't do figure eights. But I was like, I wanna see like how like you know, I wanted to make a s like a space I wanna I want to make things orbit things on on my T R S 80. And and I had no idea I I had no business trying to create this. And I heard somewhere like you're supposed to use calculus. Mm-hmm. And I don't know where I found a calculus book. I looked all over for like how does a planet does a planet do figure eights around two suns. They nothing about that. I like, okay, calculus is useless. Okay. Forget calculus. And you know, I like I tried to figure out how to anyway, I tried to figure out how to how to do this thing and it I think at some point like like it moves like two pixels, you know. And I was like, ⁓ you know, I I got motion and I I forget what happened next. But Reading through like actually like digging in and and figuring out these equations from some calculus book when I was way, way over my head. was something I I remember doing. ⁓ so that's that that's not pr a particular author. ⁓ but ⁓ but that's that's a that's a book experience I remember ⁓ that, you know, goes as early as you can go. ⁓ how old were you at the time? ⁓ yeah, ⁓ like I said, it must have been, you know, young teen, fourteen or six thirteen or fourteen. Yeah, that's great. Yeah. ⁓ I have a sense that ⁓ Your goal coming in was to write a fair bit of physics stuff. ⁓ even though ⁓ I don't know that it has been the majority of your ⁓ app or it's been a a a tiny minority. I think it's my second physics article. Why did you ⁓ apply initially to why did you want to come to Ancaven? I wanted to write well, I wanna write more physics, but I wanted to write. and this was the s this was clearly the structure that would, you know, I I knew would work for me. ⁓ you know, it really was You know. I want someone to make it right. Remind how you heard about it? I I don't recall exactly. Yeah, I one of the blogs of ⁓ probably somebody off of ⁓ Less Wrong or Hacker News or something, I was just it just kind of s skittering my way across the internet and and and saw ⁓ a a blog entry which I don't remember what it was, but it referred back to this. I see. And then you put in that makes sense. ⁓ and yeah, how is it ⁓ so you had some goals to write more? Mm-hmm. Which you have done? I am still here, so you know I have. Yeah, it's day twenty seven or so. Three to go. That's right. ⁓ yeah, as ⁓ what surprised you about the writing that you've done here? ⁓ so my writing is a is a he has been a huge surprise. ⁓ as I said, I've written two or three science y articles and apparently what was really in my heart was to chronicle my my my life and and and career and so I've, you know, written a couple dozen memoirs. ⁓ recounting you know, interesting thing things that were interesting to me at least on on audio gigs and ⁓ you know, story of you know, building my company and shutting down in COVID and deciding what came next. And so it's been a ⁓ it's it's been a fabulous time for me to kind of get those memoirs out 'cause they are things I've been wanting to write about. ⁓ you know, I would I would come back from a gig and I would work with you know, very in very exciting situations that people say you really should write this up someday. And so it it had been on my on my list. ⁓ Yeah, yeah. I remember you showing me on the first call we had all your ⁓ map of all the pins of all the places you'd done gigs. Right, right. Which was a very ⁓ pin filled map of ⁓ the states and a few other spots. Yeah, yeah. When I first started working in audio, like probably right around two thousand and two or so. Mm-hmm. ⁓ that was just around when Google Maps had you know, like you could actually had Custom maps. That's fun. ⁓ yeah. And I started putting a pin wherever I
worked and I kept it up the entire time. Yeah, yeah, yeah. ⁓ yeah. which ⁓ which of the pe which piece of writing you've done in g here at Incaven ⁓ came the easiest? Which flowed out of you the ⁓ smoothest? Hmm. I had one which which really fit together well as a story and you know, I'm not gonna say I composed it like completely, you know, from scratch. ⁓ it's something I'd had some notes on before, which was a story called The Smell. ⁓ yeah, I love that one. Yeah, yeah. And and ⁓ I'd always you know, and I had a butt like I said, I had a bunch of stories like that where I was like, I I really need to write this up. And so that was one. ⁓ that ⁓ it was it involved you know, neurology and and audio and just kind of thinking from first principles and a little mystery. And a little mystery. It was it was a detective story. So yeah. I think I recall ⁓ you got some feedback from Scott Alexander on that. Scott Alexander, yeah. Yeah. I yeah, I put I put myself up, you know, on the on the big board but I think one of his first ⁓ feedback sessions. ⁓ so yeah and that was very helpful and I I I sold my notes from that session that I like, you know want to integrate back. ⁓ but You there w there I'm happy to say there was still some of the essay left when he was done. ⁓ so you know, we didn't have to delete all of it. ⁓ he loved he liked it as well. I think he had some Yeah, I mean we were we're all somehow being reminded of the basics by Scott. He's like yeah, sections should have a point and then they should end. And ⁓ you don't need to repeat this point three more times at the end. And what's ⁓ what's like amazing is like how why he didn't See that I was doing that? You know, you get so in into a piece. ⁓ and you know, I'll I'll confess I thought I'll put this one up there because this is the one that's got nothing no fat on it. This is the tightest. This is my tightest. I've gone over this one a million times. Like this is the one that this one's pot this one's ready to go. That's really funny. And he like found all his fat in it. And I was like, You're absolutely right. Why is that why is that paragraph in that? What was I thinking? Yeah. That's great. So it's great to get, you know, other eyeballs on What was the hottest piece to write during Ganghaven? Maybe this one. So what yeah, w one thing I've found, ⁓ just talking about Inkaven in general, is that it's hard to write every day. It is really hard. no individual piece, but ⁓ you know, there's a cognitive fatigue and I think that one reason I ended up doing more memoirs is they don't I'm not gonna say they're easier, because they're they're hard. But There's a particular kind of mental work that goes into the science piece. And, you know, that's not I may have written two science or three science pieces this month, but I tried I tried a few more. And they just don't kind of come together in the course of the day. And I I've tried to kind of get things, you know, going in the background while I get my daily thing done. but anyway, th this one, ⁓ you know, I I thought it was important to report the null result that I thought There could be a slingshot effect you could use to get off a planet. And, you know, I spent a lot of time working on that and I was like, okay, this is not gonna happen. ⁓ so you know, if I started with the successful case, it would have been less work and maybe the you know, may I think it is important to mention I didn't feel the essay was weaker for that. Okay. Yeah. But but the point the point is it took you asked what was the hardest thing to to write. Like you know, going down like rat holes and then saying, Okay, now I to find a different approach at what How long did you work on and think about this idea during Incaven? ⁓ so The day I wrote it I probably spent like ten hours on it. Like I didn't do anything. I just like completely I like, I'm gonna get this done and I I buckled down and did it. But you you in the morning were like, I would like to write a piece about slingshots? Like it's like today is look, today's the day I'm gonna do that slingshot piece. ⁓ had you already chatted with ⁓ no Max about it? Yeah, yeah, and it's something I've been like I have you know, I have a lot of threads in my you know, in my to you know, to write list and and things in various stages. So the the core I like the core idea has been around in my list for long time. I didn't that morning say I think I'll gee what you Yeah, yeah. So pretty much Yeah, any of the science stuff I've done did you have a long did you have a long list coming into Inkhaven? ⁓ God, like fifty. Yeah, I have a huge backlog of Yeah. I have a huge backlog of things I I I I still want to write. like I remember in my in my Inkhaven what do you want to write about? And I was like, I really wanna write about the acoustics on Mars, which are unique, and that if life like megafonic were were to evolve on Mars, their hearing would be so different from ours because there's this really weird acoustical property of the atmosphere on Mars. And I need to know one more detail about this. Well, so that was one I just couldn't get to. So the s okay. The speed of sound on Mars depends on Frequency. Now. The reason that is interesting is because But is it by something gas in the air that's very because of the CO two. It has this particular the molecules have this particular weird relaxing effect like in between the the way I'm not a I'm not a like a chemist person, so I don't really understand the the chemistry, but there's a particular quality to the CO two molecules in the Mars atmosphere that makes sound travel at different speeds depending on its frequency. Now I just want to clarify that because you know, we know that sound can travel, you know, the speed of sound isn't, you know, a super like ⁓ solid thing here. It's it's it can vary with temperature and humidity and all sorts of things. It travels different speeds in s in water, but it always travels like and in
a given place, the speed of sound is the same for all frequencies, all pitches, high and low. So you say different frequencies How what percent variation are we talking about? Are we talking like point one percent change in speed? Are we talking about a hundred percent change in speed? So it's enough that it was audible to and this is how it came up, to ⁓ one of the more I forget the name, one of the more recent Mars missions has actually has microphones. And this was like a a passing mention in a NASA paper where they they they used a laser to like pulverize a piece of rock. And they like videotaped it or whatever and they recorded the audio from this. And the sound when it traveled back so much fun. We're gonna send a rover to Mars and what are we gonna do? Just destroy rocks with lasers. Totally. Like w w why else? Like is that if you had a laser, is that not the first thing you would do? Come on. Send it to Mars, destroy things. Yeah, well, I mean, well, the helicopter. I mean they didn't shoot to the helicopter. So anyway. So there's this passing thing about, ⁓ yeah, and then the sound we the sound was recorded on our mics, and of it It travels differently at different frequencies. And I'm like, it what? What where is the YouTuber explainer about this? ⁓ so I looked into it a bit. It's not a huge effect, but it's it is kind of profound because you know, ⁓ I think the word is it's dispersive. It it disperses sound. So, you know, if if if you're to if you were to strum a a chord on your guitar ⁓ a hundred meters away, ⁓ the the low notes would arrive to me later than the high notes. and that would not happen here on Earth. Yeah, that'd be really annoying if I was trying to play like bark or something and the bass line arrived at like, you know, half beat later. ⁓ But and I I remember what I but I but I put in the application was the I think like something like Xeno acoustics. Imagine a creature that evolves in that atmosphere. Their hearing would have d would have evolved With that built in, and they would already reassemble. It would not sound smeared to them. They're just like how our eyes, we see two different images, right? But we don't see double. Our brain takes those two images and actually uses them to construct a 3D model. There's a rich I mean so now an ear that evolves in a dispersive atmosphere, when it hears a sound, it constructs a 3D model of how far away that thing was. We have we now have built-in range information in every sound. Ooh, that's crazy. Yeah. They might imagine coming to Earth and being like, I can't tell how far things are based on the notes that they're exactly. Another great sci-fi ⁓ scenario. How people go there and and then the sounds all smeary to them and like but the natives, you know, they they You've got to just do a constant partnership with Max Hound. I don't know how many sci fi authors do that where like the science ideas guy and then the writer guy. I don't I've not heard of it very much, but ⁓ perhaps you'll keep it going. Or perhaps you'll start writing the stories yourself. ⁓ I could try that. That'd be fun. That'd be fun. ⁓ What's ⁓ what in your writing are you ⁓ the proudest of that you've done here at Inkaven? Well as you know we need to reach five hundred words per day. And I think I did the most high labor intensive posting in that I decided to write when posting in haiku. And that is a terrible way to get yourself to five new words. It took me 39 verses. ⁓ dear. I think I really enjoyed that. I enjoyed it and I I posted them up ⁓ in a poster at our fair. but ⁓ by the cafe one of them was in Hebrew. Only halfway. That's true. I explained to you but that is that's it says I can't speak Hebrew but I can't I can't speak Hebrew, but I can say I can't speak Hebrew. But I did match the syllable account, of course. Certainly. ⁓ yeah. But yeah, they were lovely. ⁓ I was glad to print those off for the fair. Yeah. ⁓ So and and not just haha, I I you know, I got there. But It's it's like I'm the haiku guy, you know. I kind of carved that space out and and ⁓ you know, it's nice to have something that I do that's, you know, recognizable here, so Yeah, yeah, yeah. That was lovely. ⁓ I'm curious. ⁓ what was the best ⁓ writing feedback or advice that you got here at Inca? yeah. Scott gave me great ⁓ feedback on on the smell on my my medical mystery. and as I've kind of leaned in towards memoirs. when I arrived I I I immediately kinda connected up with ⁓ Steve Shu, our physics guy. And physics guy or genetics guy or startups guy or everything good. You know, I write physics and he certainly knows that stuff really well. and ⁓ you know, I was like, I'm gonna be coming to you with all my physics articles and you know at one point I said to Steve I I changed my major I work with Alexander Wales now in the in the memoir in the memoirs department. So Alexander's been been awesome. ⁓ give me feedback. ⁓ both you know ⁓ at at the Scott Alexander level of the you know of the sentence structure. But ⁓ often I would go to Alexander Wales about you know, where does where does this fit? You know, help me like in let me look at bigger questions. ⁓ Does this work or you know yeah, I can I can find sentence problems, but like I see like structural problems with this and you know, give me an example of someone who who solved this. And he does. So, you know, it helps that someone who's well read or or or you know, or read everything at the last ink, and then you can point me to the post from there. That's lovely. Yeah. That's great. Did anything surprise you about what it's like to be here? ⁓ over the course a month? Anything about the people or the environment or the the ⁓ structure of the event? Yeah. ⁓ it's a very surprising thing. Like it's just it's just very surprising. You can ask me what was surprised. Yeah, I you're gonna you want to know what was surprising, but it's just surprising. You didn't expect to see such a thing exist. No, but no, but it's
like okay. So So there there was there was an issue one time which which you helped resolved for me, ⁓ with some with some behavior. Right? And I remember you saying, that was not okay and me saying, Okay, I'm I'm glad that that wasn't okay, but I didn't really know. ⁓ that's probably too too vague. But ⁓ you know, s somebody had been off at a place they shouldn't have been and I was like, okay, I I guess and and ⁓ right. Right, right. And and And I was like kind of a mind of like, okay, I like I kinda don't know you know, what what what but you know, what is it anything goes or some things go, you right? So what doesn't go? ⁓ so it's been very hard to c you know, sometimes it's hard to calibrate. Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's a pretty high openness sort of place where people are crazy and so like you know, I come in, I think I'm the oldest person, the oldest ⁓ resident here, and like I know that I know that there's gonna be cultural things that I don't. I don't connect with. Yeah. Right. So I'm already, you know, trying to just be you know, I I I can't like Accepting impose things. Yeah, I'm very and I'm very accepting in general. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, just not a judgmental person. Yeah. No, it's fun having such a wide diversity of interesting, curious people at the same place. Yeah. At the same time. Yeah. ⁓ but yeah. You might be the oldest resident. You're not the oldest person here. We know we've had Mr. Friedman, Mr Scott Summoner, a couple other folks. Yeah. ⁓ and yeah, and that's been, you know Like, you know, meeting David Friedman and and chatting with him. I w we're I was making White Russians and we were talking about the White Russians. So that was that was cool. I'm sad I missed that. ⁓ Yeah. And ⁓ is there anyone else's writing here that you've enjoyed reading while you've been here in particular? ⁓ certainly you know, some of the residents. ⁓ you know, Natalie, Drew, ⁓ you know the the the stars. ⁓ yeah, I and it's It's really inspiring and so okay. Here's the surprise. One of those surprises which is like duh in retrospect. So I came here thinking, okay, I'm here to be around other writers. Well, I mean, we're not writing on the same thing, we're each writing our own thing, right? So it's kinda like going to a coffee shop, right? Either there's energy, you know, people are industrious and and but at a coffee shop I'm writing my thing and the guy over there is working on a spreadsheet, and I don't ever see a spreadsheet. But we're all kind of working in parallel. We're body doubling, whatever, co working. And then also reading each other's output. And I was like, ⁓ yeah, we're writing to each other. Like quickly, you know, and I as I mentioned, I didn't have a huge readership coming in here. So immediately my readership tripled because I was up to fifty people. I mean, you know, there were there were some eyeballs, right? And I'm reading theirs. And suddenly I think to myself, We're writing to each other. You know, and you know, that gets into the whole meta thing, which you don't, you know, ⁓ I never meta post-it, I'm happy to say. I I I am not a fan of meta posting. I didn't come here to hear your thoughts about Lighthaven. No. I mean, presumably you didn't have any before, so you were here because you had thoughts about something that was interesting and I want to hear what you think of the world. But you know, put it put it in a big post in the Slack, right? Yeah. Anyway, but that said, I I sense I'm writing with a sense of an audience now. Which is which is definitely different. ⁓ you know. and you know, I you know, occasionally dropped some, you know, Inkhaven reference. ⁓ so so that was just the the chemistry and the the audience and writing to each other and and the the you know the Exchange of ideas and exchange of of i you know, memes in in the Dawkins sense of a meme being an idea which is replicated and passed through as a society. so that was a that was a cool thing. Nice. Yeah. I'm glad to hear it. Yeah. Has this changed your ⁓ intentions or desires for blogging going forwards? Yes. Absolutely. ⁓ I don't say my intention. I over the intention. Yeah. Intention for several years and I got three, you know, six articles done. ⁓ It's it's changed my you know, belief that it can actually get done. ⁓ you know, nobody nobody claims they're gonna leave here and keep blogging every day. ⁓ one person did and they did for five months last time, but that was insane. Okay. Did you meet ⁓ I I won't say her non pseudominous name. Okay. But Margarita Lovelace is her blog, but she's a lovely lady. Okay. ⁓ anyway, the yeah, so nobody thinks that but I I believe there's a group that does w ⁓ community once a week. Yeah, for Underhaven. And I ⁓ and I think ⁓ Justice is like the the the last survivor of that, perhaps. There's a there's like four last survivors who've done it continuously. So I would absolutely a hundred percent be down for that. ⁓ I know some people from this group who are talking about staying in touch a lot are Bay Area, so I'm not Bay Area. ⁓ where are you based again, Boston? ⁓ Boston, East Coast in general. Yeah. That makes sense. Yeah. There's a couple of East Coast people here. I think Viv is from the East Coast, so you can ⁓ go hang out with her. Okay, I didn't realize it. Okay. ⁓ that's right. Yeah, we'd actually Let me talk about where she's moving to. but yeah, so does it change my my outlook on blogging going forward? Absolutely. I don't really call it blogging, you know. I I like I wanna yeah, yeah, but you know, developing this body of science articles and you know, and and yes, you know, putting together this this ⁓ history of, you know, cool things that that happened in my in my life. ⁓ I ended up w one of the article actually one of the articles, ⁓ which I think turned out rather well, but was very difficult to write. ⁓ was about ⁓ it's called Bad Backs and it's about ⁓ the history of scoliosis ⁓ through three generations, starting with my father and through me and and to my son. and that was a lot of ⁓ heartbreaking research. ⁓ not things I had ever known through my family, but reading about some of some of the realities of of orthopedic Treatments in my father's day. my father was treated at the hospital for ruptured and crippled children in New York. How's that for a name? The Hospital for Ruptured and Crippled Children. Yeah. How Dickensian, right? Anyway, ⁓ so that's something which I have brought a rupture child to your ruptured child, get the get the get the patches out. And that was not something I planned. So that was a real surprise. That was not something I planned to write. It just came out one of the That research you'd done that prior to write? No, that one was from scratch, actually. ⁓ Yeah. Yeah. Well, I don't know w what started that one. and that was yeah, and well, I wrote chapter one. I I I titled it chapter one. I don't know if there's gonna be a chapter two. Chapter two would be my story. ⁓ so which is a very different stor. I did not go through anything like my what my dad did. But ⁓ ⁓ my son also had ⁓ you know, significant ⁓ needed significant treatment for proscoliosis and so if I wanna get to chapter three, I'm gonna have to get through chapter two. Great. Yeah, yeah. Perfect timing. well I I look forward to ⁓ reading more of your writing, ⁓ both in the last three days and the preceding entire future ⁓ afterwards. ⁓ thanks so much for coming. ⁓ I enjoyed reading your stuff and good luck with the rest of it. It's been my pleasure. Thank you so much, Ben. All right, we'll wrap up there. Before we wrap up, I'd just like to thank our sponsor for this episode, WordPress dot com. As a teenager, many of the blogs I grew up reading were built using WordPress. Such as Slaystar Codex, Don't Worry About the Vars, and Stethel Optimized. The co-founder of WordPress, Matt Mullenweg, went on to build WordPress.com, a hosting service that supports bloggers. It provides an interface that allows you to design your website and to use the near infinite family of libraries and plugins that have been built for WordPress. If you're someone who cares to be able to design your own blog for your ideas, for your writing, and for your own aesthetic, then by far one of the best options on the internet today is WordPress.com.