ТРАНСКРИПЦИЯ 🔗
[0:00] Welcome to Ties That Bind, Law, Family, and Legacy.
[0:05] Welcome back to Ties That Bind, Law, Family, and Legacy
[0:09] with Patty Garner.
[0:11] Patty is a Tennessee attorney who focuses on a state
[0:13] planning and probate.
[0:15] Helping individuals and families make clear
[0:18] thoughtful decisions about the future
[0:20] and avoid unnecessary complications down the road.
[0:24] With over 20 years of legal experience,
[0:26] she brings a straightforward practical approach
[0:29] to these conversations.
[0:31] I'm Lisa Mosby, and today we're talking
[0:33] about the differences between revocable
[0:36] and irrevocable trusts in Tennessee
[0:39] and why the type of trust you choose matters.
[0:43] Welcome Patty, it's great to be back with you.
[0:45] Hey, Lacey, it's always good to see you.
[0:47] Yeah, I'm super excited about this conversation.
[0:50] I know, total nerd about the law,
[0:52] but it applies to so many of us,
[0:54] I can't wait to get into more of the nuances
[0:56] and the specifics of these kinds of trusts.
[0:58] But let's always start with the definition.
[1:02] What's the difference between revocable and irrevocable trusts?
[1:06] A irrevocable trust is a trust where you create it.
[1:10] It's a contract that you create
[1:12] and you have another third party who manages
[1:16] and runs and operates that trust.
[1:19] Whereas a revocable trust is a living breathing document
[1:24] that you can manage, you can maneuver,
[1:27] you can change and modify as you move along throughout life.
[1:33] The primary difference for an irrevocable trust
[1:37] would be the loss of control
[1:39] because if you can't control it,
[1:41] then the IRS and the debtors and the creditors
[1:43] can't get to it.
[1:44] And your inability to sell property
[1:48] without agreement of the beneficiaries
[1:51] or the trustees that are part of the trust.
[1:55] Whereas with a revocable trust,
[1:58] you can buy a sale, move, do whatever you want to do
[2:02] for as many times as you want to do it within that document.
[2:06] The thing that we have to look at
[2:09] with whether or not you need the revocable
[2:14] versus the irrevocable is kind of where you're at in life.
[2:18] So if we have a run-of-the-mill middle
[2:23] of the road family with a house and a mortgage
[2:26] and maybe they've got some securities
[2:29] and some stocks and bonds and that kind of thing
[2:32] and they're in good health and they're at age 40
[2:35] and they're just trying to take care of their kids
[2:37] and move along, they probably are okay
[2:40] with a revocable trust.
[2:43] But if we've got somebody that is say 50, 55,
[2:47] with a big business and by big business,
[2:52] I mean, doing more than $1 million worth of business a year
[2:55] and they've got a house and they've got some other entities
[2:58] and that kind of thing,
[2:59] then we may want to talk about an irrevocable trust
[3:03] because of the protections that it would offer.
[3:07] We always want to be aware of the Medicare, Medicaid,
[3:11] five-year lookback period when we get to an advanced age,
[3:15] when we may need to be looking for protections
[3:17] from the nursing home.
[3:19] And that's always a consideration
[3:21] when we're doing an estate plan.
[3:22] And I want to dive into kind of some case specific,
[3:26] using real life cases that you've worked on.
[3:29] But before we do that, I will put in
[3:31] a little kind of a public service announcement folks.
[3:34] All of these are specific to your situations.
[3:37] So definitely reach out, talk to Patty
[3:39] and discuss your situation.
[3:40] But we're going to give you some examples to start with
[3:42] so you can see how things work.
[3:44] So Patty, first one, let's take a case,
[3:48] a revocable trust case that you've worked on.
[3:52] Why did it make sense for those folks
[3:54] and how did it work to benefit them?
[3:57] So a revocable trust recently put one together
[4:00] for a couple in their late 30s.
[4:03] They had a young child.
[4:05] He has a business.
[4:07] She's employed somewhere else.
[4:10] And it makes sense for them to have a revocable trust
[4:13] because they're still building and they're still adding
[4:16] and they're still moving.
[4:17] And while they have a house,
[4:19] they may not be in their forever home.
[4:21] And if I put that into an irrevocable trust,
[4:23] then we have to get an agreement
[4:25] to sell that property.
[4:28] If they ever decided they wanted to move
[4:30] and do those kind of things.
[4:31] So the revocable trust made sense for that couple.
[4:35] In that revocable trust, they designated a guardian
[4:38] for their child.
[4:40] We designated who could buy and sell his business
[4:43] if the time came and it needed to be done.
[4:46] We could one, two, three.
[4:50] We set up the advanced healthcare directives
[4:54] and the power of attorneys
[4:55] and did all the things that we needed to do to protect them
[4:58] but move them along.
[5:00] And in 20 years, when we get down the road,
[5:04] we would do maybe a reconsideration
[5:06] and maybe you transfer that revocable
[5:08] into an irrevocable trust.
[5:10] Because at that time, it would probably make more sense.
[5:14] Creating that irrevocable trust requires
[5:17] the creation of another tax ID,
[5:19] which then requires a tax filing every year.
[5:24] And so there's some reasons too and reasons not too.
[5:27] And it really is fact specific.
[5:30] Back to that one, the case scenario
[5:31] that you're talking about.
[5:32] I heard you say that they had a small child.
[5:34] So perhaps there was life insurance
[5:36] and does life insurance go into a trust
[5:38] or not into a trust?
[5:40] So I would advise them to make the beneficiary the trust
[5:47] because if both of them have passed,
[5:50] then whoever's taking over the rearing of the child,
[5:53] they're going to need the funds to raise that child.
[5:57] So that needs to be
Load full transcript
controlled based on the terms
[6:00] that were set out in the trust.
[6:02] And in that particular one, we gave the trustee discretion
[6:06] to release funds to buy a car and to send them to college
[6:09] and to do the things that need to be done,
[6:12] to release funds to buy a house if needed.
[6:15] So when she's 21 or 25, she wanted to buy a house she could.
[6:19] But then there was a stair-step program
[6:21] so that she didn't get hit with all these funds
[6:25] and spend it like a young person will.
[6:28] Yeah, we're putting safety measures in place
[6:32] so that we create this legacy
[6:35] and that's what you're known for is building legacies with folks.
[6:38] Let's flip gears.
[6:39] Do you have a case within where an irrevocable trust was relevant?
[6:43] Maybe it was a couple that had children from,
[6:48] and this was the second marriage
[6:50] and they may have had children from their previous marriage.
[6:52] That's what I'm looking for on this one.
[6:53] So yes, irrevocable and second marriage
[6:58] and the first marriage for the wife
[7:03] for the wife ended in a death of her spouse
[7:06] and she inherited a lot of money.
[7:08] So and she had children of her own
[7:11] and they did the couple did not have children together.
[7:15] So the irrevocable trust made sense
[7:17] to protect her and her children
[7:19] because at the time that they got married,
[7:21] it was, they were later in life.
[7:24] I wanna say she was in her early 60s
[7:28] because of the amount of income that she had
[7:30] and because of the protections that she needed,
[7:36] it was appropriate for that irrevocable.
[7:38] We also took into consideration the fact
[7:40] because of her advanced age,
[7:42] we needed to be looking at that five-year lookback period.
[7:45] So we moved the real estate into the irrevocable trust.
[7:49] She was in what we called her forever home.
[7:51] There wasn't gonna be a need to sell that property
[7:54] until she passed if then.
[7:56] And so those are all things that have to be considered
[8:01] when you're making the decision
[8:03] to move into the irrevocable versus the irrevocable trust.
[8:07] And if she were to pass before her husband,
[8:09] could he stay living in the house
[8:10] and then all of the assets transferred to her child
[8:13] or children?
[8:14] Yes, and in fact, she made that provision
[8:16] because it was her home
[8:17] and she had had it before they got married.
[8:19] And he had not contributed
[8:21] and so there was no co-mingling of those funds
[8:24] and that kind of thing.
[8:25] But she designated it so long as he was living,
[8:28] he got to live in that house if he wanted.
[8:32] So there would have had to have been an agreement
[8:34] for him to move out if she passes first.
[8:36] Yeah, it's really interesting what we can do
[8:38] with these documents.
[8:39] They're incredibly powerful,
[8:40] but we have to sit down and have these discussions.
[8:44] I often think that people wonder
[8:46] how much control do they keep over their assets
[8:50] in each of these types of trusts?
[8:53] Do we lose control at any time?
[8:55] Do you lose control with an irrevocable trust?
[8:59] Because a third party fiduciary actually becomes
[9:02] the person operating the trust.
[9:08] So I refer to those at the trust,
[9:10] and the reason for the hesitation.
[9:12] I refer to those kind of like they become
[9:14] their own little entities.
[9:15] It's like you've created a little corporation
[9:17] and it's operated by a board of trustees
[9:20] and they manage and they take care of
[9:23] and then you have to have their agreement
[9:25] to move anything or do anything.
[9:27] And it's the same thing when you create
[9:29] a revocable trust,
[9:31] except you're the one controlling the entity.
[9:34] So the revocable trust you retain
[9:36] and keep total control.
[9:38] What it offers you is anonymity.
[9:40] So nobody knows who owns your house,
[9:43] nobody knows who owns the land down the street.
[9:47] Whatever it is,
[9:48] they don't know who owns it because it's your shielded.
[9:51] And I think that's a great thing,
[9:53] particularly in society these days,
[9:55] where everybody's so nosy.
[9:56] Everything is public with social media.
[9:59] So does either type of trust
[10:01] protect assets from creditors?
[10:03] How does that work?
[10:04] So the irrevocable would protect you from creditors.
[10:08] The irrevocable would.
[10:11] The revocable trust protects you from the stance
[10:14] that if they don't know that that's your trust,
[10:17] they wouldn't know to pierce it and go after it.
[10:21] So that's part of the help with the anonymity.
[10:23] But in the truest sense,
[10:25] if they know that you have that trust,
[10:28] it does not offer a credit protection.
[10:30] It does not offer protection from the IRS.
[10:32] It does not create any type of protection from that realm.
[10:36] Whereas the irrevocable trust
[10:39] absolutely shields you from creditors
[10:41] so long as you operate it correctly
[10:43] and you don't come in going,
[10:44] you don't pierce it yourself the way when you're operating it.
[10:48] Because again, you're operating a little company.
[10:50] And do you file a tax return for each of those types of trusts?
[10:53] You file a tax return for the irrevocable
[10:56] under its own tax ID number.
[10:59] Whereas the revocable trust operates on either
[11:04] your security, your husband's security, whatever,
[11:08] either one and you elect that in the setup.
[11:10] So there's not a separate tax return for a revocable trust,
[11:13] but there is for the irrevocable.
[11:15] And so if it's run under your social security,
[11:17] do you lose some of the anonymity for a revocable trust?
[11:20] If somebody got into your tax records,
[11:22] then they could see maybe, but not necessarily
[11:26] because you're not necessarily identifying.
[11:28] It's not an, it's not earning income.
[11:30] It's not doing the things that the irrevocable trust
[11:34] has the ability to do.
[11:35] So can an irrevocable trust ever be changed or terminated?
[11:39] It can, but it would typically require either court intervention
[11:44] or it would require agreement of the Board of Trustees.
[11:48] It's kind of like being on the hot seat with me today.
[11:49] It's like, I'm firing these questions,
[11:51] picking your brain, girl.
[11:52] I know, we'd want to brainwash.
[11:53] I'm just so curious and I imagine our listeners are too.
[11:57] Here's the next one.
[11:58] What should someone consider before creating
[12:01] an irrevocable trust?
[12:02] I think you consider the tax consequences,
[12:05] whether or not you're prepared and committed
[12:07] to the maintaining of that trust.
[12:11] And whether or not you're going to need to,
[12:14] within the next five years,
[12:16] sell real estate or do something
[12:19] that is impacted by that trust.
[12:21] So if you've got a piece of real estate
[12:24] and you're in your forever home and you're in your 60s
[12:28] and maybe we need to talk about moving that
[12:30] and getting that out of the Medicaid lookback period
[12:32] so we can escape that five year period,
[12:35] I think that's a great time to get serious
[12:37] about talking about an irrevocable trust.
[12:39] I think if you are running a large company
[12:42] and you've got personal exposure there,
[12:44] that's a time to talk about that
[12:46] because at that point you've got CPAs
[12:49] and you've got the people running and doing tax returns
[12:52] so that's not a reason not to have that company.
[12:55] You know, people are always, they struggle sometimes
[12:58] with having to do those tax reporting
[13:00] and that kind of thing so it's always a consideration.
[13:03] Have you seen someone come in thinking
[13:06] that they needed one type of trust
[13:07] when another option made more sense
[13:09] or how do you review people's assets
[13:12] and help them to make these decisions?
[13:14] So we have just a form, I mean we're old school
[13:18] we just have a form, you fill out,
[13:20] tell me kind of what you have
[13:21] and then we have a conversation
[13:24] and we talk about what are your goals,
[13:27] what are your plans, where are you headed
[13:30] and why do you think you need a trust
[13:32] because maybe they didn't, maybe they don't
[13:35] and if the last real investment would suffice
[13:37] then certainly I encourage people to do that.
[13:40] Now I will tell you that the older that I get,
[13:44] the more experienced that I have,
[13:48] I recognize the value in setting up a trust
[13:50] and doing those things earlier in life
[13:53] because of avoid in the chaos that probate core causes.
[13:59] So I'm more inclined these days to say,
[14:01] yeah, you at least need a revocable trust at a minimum.
[14:06] But everybody's case and facts are different
[14:09] and we sit down and have those conversations
[14:12] and really kind of get personal with you
[14:14] because I need to have a full understanding
[14:17] so I can design a plan, make recommendations,
[14:20] those type of things
[14:21] because if I don't know the full face value
[14:24] of what's going on, I can't direct you.
[14:26] So we sit down, we have the conversations,
[14:29] maybe we have two or three conversations,
[14:31] build the plan and figure out what works best for your family
[14:35] makes sense to me.
[14:37] Let's give folks another PSA, a public service announcement.
[14:40] If they do not have or have not done their estate plan,
[14:45] how would you like to warn them
[14:46] and maybe bring to light some of the risks
[14:51] of moving forward without an estate plan?
[14:53] A estate planning, it sounds really big and overwhelming
[14:58] but it is such from my perspective,
[15:02] it is, it's like your love language
[15:05] and the way that you tell the people that you care about,
[15:08] I've taken care of this, you don't have to worry about it.
[15:10] So from my perspective, when you sit down
[15:14] and do an estate plan and you prepare the documents
[15:17] so that they have what they need
[15:19] and let's say, you know, mom has a stroke
[15:22] or dad has a stroke, somebody needs to be able
[15:24] to handle the care, somebody needs to be able
[15:27] to run the business, it's so critical
[15:32] to have those documents on hand and in place
[15:35] because if not, let's say you've got dad, he's a business owner
[15:39] and he has a stroke on Wednesday, payrolls do on Friday,
[15:43] nobody else can sign checks, now what?
[15:48] And so when you think about those types of things,
[15:52] I think that's huge or dad has a stroke
[15:55] and he hasn't done a directive,
[15:58] we don't have a conservator.
[16:00] Now if he's married, the medical professionals
[16:03] are gonna listen to his wife probably,
[16:06] and Tennessee, there's a statute that says they can,
[16:09] but other states may be not,
[16:12] but if he's not married, that's critical.
[16:14] He needs somebody to be able to step in
[16:17] if he doesn't have that document
[16:18] and that estate plan set up.
[16:20] Now we've got to run to the courthouse,
[16:22] we've got to get a doctor signature,
[16:25] we've got to get an affidavit saying, you know,
[16:27] he needs this kind of care
[16:29] and then we have to get a judge as approval.
[16:31] Now we're back in court and now we've got chaos
[16:35] that could have all been avoided with a plan.
[16:38] So it may sound intimidating,
[16:40] but it really, when you find the right person
[16:42] to walk through this process with you
[16:44] and in your case, I can speak from my experience,
[16:49] you make it easy, you know, you just listen
[16:51] and you have such compassion for people.
[16:53] So we appreciate all that you do for us
[16:56] in the world of estate planning.
[16:58] You know, we try, we try really hard.
[17:01] Yeah, we try hard.
[17:02] Thank you so much for your time today, Patty.
[17:04] Hey, I appreciate you.
[17:05] That's it for today's episode of Ties That Bind,
[17:08] Law, Family and Legacy with Patty Garner.
[17:11] If you have questions about your own estate plan
[17:14] or you wanna make sure you're making
[17:16] the right decisions for your family,
[17:18] you can reach out to Patty Garner at Garner Law firm
[17:21] visiting pattybegarner.com.
[17:25] Thank you so much for listening and don't forget to like,
[17:27] leave a review and share this with someone
[17:29] who might need to do their estate plan today.
[17:32] Y'all give me a call and let's plan your legacy.
[17:39] Thanks for watching.
[17:41] Be sure to hit that like and subscribe button
[17:43] and leave us a review in the comments.