ТРАНСКРИПЦИЯ 🔗
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (01:56.866)
Hey y'all, this is Sam with the Roots of Change podcast, and I am very excited to have Laney Feingold and Josh Miele
is that how you say it, Josh? Okay, awesome. I'm so excited to have them both on the podcast. we are talking about dish digital accessibility ethics today. And there is a very timely book that both of you participated in. Lainey, you edited the book and really brought some amazing digital access experts to really talk about digital accessibility now.
Josh Miele (02:27.2)
Sure, yeah, that's great.
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (02:54.613)
And how we move forward with a more ethics-forward framework so that we can have that digital accessibility for all as a real concept in the real world. And so Lainey I'll kick it off with you. You are a globally recognized disability rights lawyer, author, and international speaker who has worked in the digital accessibility space since 1995.
You helped negotiate the first web accessibility agreement in the United States in 2000, and you've done a ton of other amazing work for the blind and disabled communities. I know you and I have talked about ATM accessibility and other types of digital access in the real world as well. So welcome, Lainey. I'm so happy that you're here. And is there anything else you want to share as we get started?
Lainey Feingold (03:49.848)
Thank you, Sam. I'm really glad to I'm really glad to be here and talk with you about this new book and the ideas. And yeah, so I think everything will come out as as we go along. So yeah, let's go over to Josh and hear from him.
Josh Miele (04:04.758)
So Josh, Josh Drace.
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (04:04.887)
Great. So Josh Josh Miele is a blind scientist, MacArthur Fellow, and Amazon design scholar. You have contributed to accessible technology ranging from audio description to tactile maps and graphics to screen readers and functions.
We touched the signal so we're gonna
Josh Miele (04:27.85)
You you're dropping out you're dropping out a bit, Sam. Sorry.
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (04:31.361)
Sorry about that. You have contributed to accessible technology ranging from audio description to tactile maps and graphics to screen readers and sonification. And I've like I said, I've only touched the surface of your work, so I'm really excited to dig into your perspective and how you build accessible technology. So welcome, Josh, and really happy to have you on.
Josh Miele (04:32.757)
Yeah.
Josh Miele (04:58.464)
Thank you so much. Yeah. So I mean, I'll just add that you know, all of the things that I do are part of why I'm thrilled to be can a contributor to the digital accessibility ethics book. I wrote a chapter on how to design and conduct accessibility hackathons and capstone projects ethically and outlined a number of
areas where educators and organizers of events like that can have opportunities to to really contribute to to make change in positive ways and to try to short circuit some of the less ethical behaviors that have that that are are pretty prevalent in today's or historical accessibility related hackathons and capstone projects.
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (05:54.188)
Yeah. Yeah, I'm I'm really excited to dig into that in a little bit because I think that you you do such a good job of kind of flipping the script on hackathons and other kind of project based work to make it to make accessibility sound easy because I think there is that kind of hurdle in a lot of people at a lot of organizations they feel like it's too big to handle. and and this entire book, but especially your chapter
Josh does a good job of making that feel accessible as we build new practices within the organization.
Josh Miele (06:35.606)
Great. You know, one thing that I hope we talk about like early on in our conversation is sort of what accessibility is. Some of your listeners may may you know, accessibility sounds like, you know, you should know what it is. it's like, you know, it means like understandable and you know, available, but it's it it actually has a much more specific meaning in this context. Accessibility is really about designing
technologies and institutions and landscapes and you know anything that gets designed and offered for people to use, whether it's a a program or a product, accessibility is about designing it so that people with disabilities are not inadvertently excluded. Or to turn that around a little bit, designing it so that it's usable, so that they are usable by people with disabilities in addition to
by everyone else. And so that's really what we mean when we say accessibility. And of course, digital accessibility means doing that in a in a digital world. So you know digital accessibility might include things like websites and ATMs and you know you know digital fancy watches that you know that big companies make to to you know help you track your health and stuff like that.
So anything that's digital, if you're not designing it thoughtfully and with the right ideas in mind, can easily be made to be inaccessible to people with disabilities. And obviously that's not the world Laney or I or probably any of us want to live in.
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (08:20.044)
Yeah.
Lainey Feingold (08:20.438)
I have to add one thing, one thing to Josh, who I agree with every word and half word you said. Also, design is is just the beginning because just as accessibility can be designed and must be designed into things, accessibility can be broken once the thing is built, once the thing is sent out into the world, once the thing is upgraded. So accessibility is a quality I like to think of it as.
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (08:27.296)
Yeah.
Josh Miele (08:27.69)
Yeah.
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (08:43.745)
Mm-hmm.
Lainey Feingold (08:48.46)
the quality of technology at every stage, you know, right from the first conception all the way to the very end, that makes it usable in a way, makes it usable for disabled people and meets all the
Load full transcript
values that we're going to talk about today that underscore that the ethics, the ethics book.
Josh Miele (09:10.944)
Yeah. We also like to say accessibility is not a a project, it's a process and a program. It is it is an ongoing practice of ensuring that everybody can use the things that you're that you're offering. And and if you you know you said I helped make it sound not that hard, you know, which I hope I I'm glad. Yeah, no, that's great. but you know,
Lainey Feingold (09:35.042)
I noticed that.
Josh Miele (09:39.16)
Accessibility is hardest when you've built something already and didn't think about it. Accessibility is easiest when you think about it the entire time, especially before you start. And that way you don't you don't have to fight against your own architecture and previous decisions. If you're thinking about it from the beginning, you can it's much easier. And you know, so this this book is really all about.
how to you know it's a framework it offers a framework and then lots of chapters that apply the framework it offers a framework for not only building accessible experiences and and programs and situations but but sort of a a set of values and questions and practices of
how to how to do that in an ethical way. And and maybe maybe ethics is another thing that we should sort of kind of say what we mean by that, Laney. What do you think?
Lainey Feingold (10:50.936)
Yeah, I'm gonna turn it back to Sam. You know, I want I want you to direct the conversation that you think will be most useful for your listeners, 'cause you know your listeners. So
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (10:59.307)
Yeah, I mean you're you guys are already right on track. I I really appreciate that bringing us down to what the true meaning of accessibility is because I know it can get very convoluted and especially now as we're seeing just more attacks on disabled people within certain federal governments and certain organizations. And so like bringing us down is really important. I did that is a
My next question. So just to show everyone, this is the beautiful book here: Digital Accessibility Ethics, Disability Inclusion in All Things Tech. And Lainey, you edited and compiled all of this. So I would love to hear from you kind of why frame it as ethics, why a digital accessibility ethics framework?
Lainey Feingold (11:52.546)
Yes, very good question. I there were three of us who are co editors, so it's me along with Regina Gilbert and Chansey Fleet. And we did bring together bes we all wrote chapters, the three of us, and there's a total of 39 authors that include us. so why ethics? good question. Many things I think led up to this. One was
I did a talk about five years ago at a conference that I called Digital Accessibility Ethics. And I asked people in the field, leaders like Josh, you know, do you have any ethics issues that come up in your work? And it was a lot of interesting things. And I had a little slide with people's picture and what they thought the ethics were. And it felt like I was only like s barely scratching the surface of what ethics could mean in our field. I mean
Generally, ethics at its most simple form is doing the right thing. But doing the right thing in all spaces requires the details. And so this framework that the book is based on is an actionable framework designed to disrupt patterns of disability exclusion in tech.
And I want to say right from the outset, I have to say this every time, this is not an academic book. It's an actionable framework that we want people to use. And you could say it's our book, the editors, our book, the authors, but I think of this book as our book, anybody who wants to make the digital world available to disabled people, because the framework fails if it sits on the pages.
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (13:33.407)
Mm.
Lainey Feingold (13:41.612)
The framework fails if we don't use it. It's three parts. One part is the values. We identify 10 values. People may want to add, modify these values. We identify ten, including things like inclusion, privacy, because if there's not accessibility, disabled people have to ask for help in systems designed to be used independently. Privacy, security, fairness, sustainability.
We have these 10 values, but to make the values real, the framework includes actions and questions. And the idea of these questions is for all the steps, the design, like Josh said, the building, the maintaining. All of us, we put out a social media post, we put a picture, we are at an inflection point of deciding.
Do we want to take the time and write an accurate description of the picture for people who don't see it? Or do we skip it because we're making an assumption about who's even going to read our post? So the idea of the questions is to say, you know, we call it the power of the pause. Let's stop and bring these values into our decision making. Do we want, who are we leaving out if we take this path? Do we even know how disabled people use?
technology so we can make an informed decision about what needs to be done. So that is a framework, like Josh said, the chapters in the book apply the framework in two basic categories. One, let's do accessibility work with ethics. You know, if we're designing, if we're developing, if we're creating speech to speech, I always forget that phrase, you know,
speech technology, are we considering people with various speech patterns or people with disabilities that impact their speech? You know, that first part is all about doing accessibility work with ethics. And the second part, which I kind of like, I don't want to say the best. I like every chapter. People say, What's your favorite chapter? I'm like, I'm not gonna identify my favorite child because truly I do love them all. the second part is like.
Lainey Feingold (16:00.674)
Digital accessibility needs to be in everybody else's ethics. So in that section, we have people writing about cybersecurity. There are cybersecurity
ethics. If cybersecurity systems aren't built for disabled people to use, they are broken. You know? So we have people writing about healthcare and gaming and robots and publishing and all the places where there are ethics frameworks that leave us out.
So that's that's the idea of the framework.
Josh Miele (16:33.535)
And I I just wanna you know, I think if, you know, a lot of the time when you're on a podcast, you you need to sort of, you know, people haven't read the book yet. I I would say to me, the most fundamental part of the framework is you mentioned inclusion, disability inclusion. Without that, like you cannot conduct ethical accessibility, right? I mean, it it it all kind of
Hinges on people with disabilities being included in whatever the process might be. If you begin from there, then a lot of the other stuff kind of comes along or is made so much easier. but you know, it kind of gets back to the you know, one of the one of the slogans of the disability rights movement is nothing about us without us. And it
it applies directly to digital accessibility. If you are designing digital accessibility and you are doing it without the involvement of people with disabilities who are going to be using the technology, you have already, you have already made things you know, ten times harder for yourself. it disability inclusion is sort of the foundation of of the I I think it's the foundation of
digital accessibility ethics.
Lainey Feingold (18:04.174)
Well, it's funny you say that because we have the 10 values, they are not numbered. But you know, writing a book is linear, so something has to come first. And the first chapter one really dives deep into what is this framework and offers, you know, sets out the values and gives examples of questions to ask to make sure the value is incorporated in our work, actions to take.
Josh Miele (18:26.199)
Six, five. Messages now. Plus one, six, five, zero, seven, zero, three, two, three, seven, six. To you in Lenny Fingold. Is this something I'm supposed to be on? Button. Actions available.
Lainey Feingold (18:29.606)
And the first one listed is, as Josh says, inclusion and non discrimination. Yeah. I'll say that is I agree with Josh, that's fundamental, foundational, and the rest flow from it. But the rest don't anyone think the rest are in some order that we think are both Yeah, I know. But I'm just saying, yes, that is the first one.
Josh Miele (18:46.163)
Yeah, yeah. I didn't mean to imply. Didn't you know, they're all important.
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (18:52.479)
Yeah. Having the the physical experience is incredibly important and I I appreciate too like the diversity of experiences, right? It's like you can't just have one, you know, disability expert who only has one niche understanding. So like having that full breadth of understanding I think is really important. And what I what I appreciated most actually was the
Josh Miele (19:14.304)
twenty eight AM.
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (19:21.045)
pause that you spoke of. Because I feel like especially within tech, the the tech ethos and big tech, I'm I'm recording this in the Bay Area in Silicon Valley, and their whole thing is move fast and break things. And they succeed at that because oftentimes access and dis disability access is not
when creating these products. And so I do like the idea of just like if we just slowed down and was a little bit more thoughtful about that process from the beginning, then it does become that process that that practice that you spoke to, Josh. Like think of like a yoga practice, you know, like they call it practice because you're not like trying to become an expert. You're trying to embed that into your everyday life.
so embedding it into the process a little bit more.
Josh Miele (20:18.741)
And the more something the more accessibility and disability awareness and knowledge are part of your thoughtful process, the less you need to slow down, right? I mean, that pause is really important to make sure that you're not building inaccessible things to think about accessibility, but the more the more, you know, accessibility is a muscle. It and it requires
Practice and the more you use that muscle, the stronger it becomes, and the more the more, you know, twitch the more twitch fibers you have. So the faster you can move. Those those those Silicon Valley folks that move fast and break things, they don't move so fast usually and break things so much that they forget about security. They don't forget about privacy. These are things that are, you know, essential. You
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (21:07.679)
Mm.
Josh Miele (21:13.801)
you know, to any any new product or or service, you you don't skip on the essentials. You you move fast, you break things, but there are some things that you don't move so fast as to not break. Security, privacy, and I would put accessibility in that same category, but you have to be used to thinking about it. You have to that has to be on your radar. And so what you know I think that part of what we're doing
with this disability ethics framework and book and and talking about it is to try to get more people who like to move fast and break things to recognize that accessibility is is not an option it is a requirement and and how to do it in an effective and ethical way is is just part of how you do business.
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (22:09.953)
Yeah, absolutely. and I you know what I really appreciated, I think Laney, I think this was your chapter, but I might be mixing it up. But you described the approach as like a harm prevention strategy. And I wanted to dig into that a little bit because, you know, on the one end, organizations are strapped very thin right now. They are you know, a lot of nonprofits specifically are have underfunding.
And so there's a lot of, I think, anxiety around wanting to have accessible technology, but not feeling like they have the ability to do that. So can you kind of explain the harm
prevention strategy, how that helps support folks kind of i even moving into the process of thinking about and starting to incorporate that into their everyday?
Lainey Feingold (23:04.78)
Yeah, that's a really good question. when we started thinking about ethics, a lot of people who knew more about ethics than I did were like, Yes, ethics are for inclusion and ethics are always about avoiding harm. That's like essential to doing the right thing. So, like for example, and we have in chapter one where we explain the framework and the goals of the framework, we do talk about different types of harms. One that
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (23:10.951)
Mm.
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (23:29.463)
Mm-hmm.
Lainey Feingold (23:34.804)
usually pops up is we have a chapter written by a woman in the Bahamas, who's a double amputee, and you know, they have a lot of hurricanes. So she writes about what happens if your information about natural disasters is not available to everyone. That is a life and death thing. And not just a hurricane's coming, but a hurricane came, here are the resources, here's what you need to rebuild.
So I've always sort of thought of it in connection with the book about like hurricanes in the Bahamas. And I did a talk and someone said, Well, yeah, our building has security procedures. What if there's a fire? What if there's a gunman, you know? And a lot of big tech companies work in buildings. I mean, I know. So just even taking that idea of health and safety and saying,
It's affecting everyone who has an emergency plan in any sort of building. How is that plan communicated and implemented to make sure 20% of the population isn't left out? So that's one kind of harm. And Utah Trevor Raynus, who wrote the AI chapter, she she's taught me a lot about sort of harm to the system as a whole. You know, when you are building things, creating things, and you are leaving people out.
Eventually, we are all going to need accessibility. You know, I turned 70 this year and I know that I am very happy when I can make my text larger on that's accessibility, you know. So it is bad for a system, it's bad for democracy. We have a chapter on voting. Like, what does it mean when people can't independently cast their vote? So these are some of the risks and harms besides.
Just pure exclusion. I mean, this is why the heart of the framework is disabled people, because one of the things we're trying to do here is say accessibility is not just a checklist. You know, it's not just legal compliance. We will not get the world we want if we leave it over there in legal compliance land. And I'm a lawyer. Legal compliance is one of the ten ethics values.
Lainey Feingold (25:59.788)
You know, we're not saying legal compliance doesn't matter, it's crucial. But there's way more than that.
Josh Miele (26:04.053)
And I think, you know, I think if you, you know, you can be you can design something from the checklist. You know, there are there are accessibility checklists out there, you know, there there are legal requirements, there are recommendations and guidelines for digital accessibility. You can follow all of them and be in one hundred percent compliance and still design something that sucks. And and so again this gets back to you know
intention is not enough. If you don't have people with disabilities in the loop, in the design loop, in the implementation loop, in the evaluation and iterative you know production, you you are likely to miss key things. You your building could have an emergency plan for people with disabilities intended to be accessible.
But if nobody with a disability has tested or given feedback on or been part of the design of that communication or or emergency plan, it is likely to fail. It is likely not to actually meet the needs of the people using it, even if it technically meets all of the requirements. And so that's why I think disability, you know, in addition to all of the other values of disability ethics, inclusion is
At the heart of all of it.
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (27:35.179)
Yeah. It's it's really it's bringing that checklist off the paper and into like three D. It's humanizing and that's yeah.
Josh Miele (27:42.646)
Yeah. I often sorry. just I I often talk about it like a like a recipe, like accessibility, like if if you don't know what that dish is supposed to taste like, you can read the recipe, you can make it, but if if you don't if you don't taste as you go, if you don't know what it's supposed to what you're shooting for, you might make something that doesn't really resemble that dish. and so so it's it's it's you know.
A recipe is nice, but but knowing what you're what you're after, knowing what you're supposed to be what it's supposed to taste like, that's the real key.
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (28:20.991)
Yeah, I I love that. That's a really great analogy. And it it reminds me a lot about like communications and marketing fundamentals as well. Of like we're not trying to like solve the like we're not trying to sell the product, we're trying to solve the problem, right? It's like taking it one step further of like what is the actual root of how we're trying to create tech versus
I want this product and then that whole outcome is already preordained because of the decisions that you made early on in the process.
I would love to like let's just get into your chapter, Josh, and talk a little bit about hackathons. so first of all, I really loved your chapter. it reminded me a lot of like I was having flashbacks of the movie The Social Network, where you know, Mark Zuckerberg and them are they're having their hackathons at night and they're staying up late or they're drinking their monster energy drinks.
And so I, you know, there is a bad reputation for hackathons within the disability community. and I would love for you to just kind of give us an understanding of that, the background of of why that is, and then how organizations and educators can
change their approach to hackathons and these larger project-based work.
Josh Miele (29:53.014)
Yeah, of course. And you know, what I I wrote several drafts of this chapter and the first one was very snarky and Laney was like, Okay, it's too snarky. You gotta like tone it down. And of course I I did. But I mean I I I love to use humor and and snarkiness as sort of a you know, and satire as a as a a a way of getting people to pay attention. And I but this is this is a real
Problem. And it's very easy to make fun of it. It's very easy to, you know, you say disability hackathon or accessibility hackathon to most disabled people in the know. And there will be a lot of eye rolling. Because the historical problem has been that you get a bunch of well-intentioned, sort of clueless people who are clueless about disability and accessibility, and they kind of substitute
a mixture of of you know pity and ableism and and sort of you know what they learned you know about disability from from cartoons and and tv for actual understanding of what the problem is and and very often there's shockingly little time spent on understanding what came before what solutions have already been tried what
what what worked, what didn't work, why it worked, why it didn't work. it's it's it's more again the move fast and break things approach of hey, I've got this great idea for a you know building a a a thing that I think I think blind people will will really need or I think deaf people really could use this or you know I think you know a stair climbing wheelchair would really help people who use wheelchairs and these are all just you know
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (31:26.967)
Yeah.
Josh Miele (31:50.356)
Again, it gets back to if you don't have people with disabilities in the loop of create, you know, ideation, problem identification, problem solving, and and sort of iterating on solutions, you will go down the wrong road of and you'll waste you'll waste your own time as a as a designer. You will learn the wrong lessons as a student.
And you will put you know, in collaboration with the equally clueless PR department of your university or or company, you will put harmful ideas out into the the public view about what solutions are needed by people with disabilities if you build the wrong thing or misidentify actual problems faced by people with disabilities. Again.
Disability inclusion is the very first step to solving this problem. And so that's that's really, you know, if if you're if you're designing a hackathon or a capstone project, you have to make sure that you have not just people with disabilities testing it at the end or giving you feedback at the end, but at the very beginning, helping you identify the what the problems are.
Helping you identify what viable solutions are to those problems, helping you understand what what has already been tried and why it did or didn't work and what we can do better. These are all things that that if you don't have people with disabilities in the room on the team as mentors, as professors, as judges of the the quality of the the hack or capstone, you you will you will do harm to yourself as a student.
and to the world. so that's that's what my chapter is about. And I I as you can tell, I I get worked up about it.
Lainey Feingold (33:52.672)
Yeah, one one of many things I loved about Josh's chapter and I learned is that it's a big responsibility to run a student project because these students are the workers of tomorrow. And if they get the wrong message, Josh writes about this, if they get the wrong message about disability accessibility, they're gonna carry that forth in the work they do. So it's not just like about a fun weekend or
Wouldn't this be cool? But this is like serious next generation foundational stuff, so
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (34:29.109)
Yeah. Yeah, that's a that's a really good point. I liked how you highlighted, you know, it's it there the dev the the losing my words, but for that student, the the problem is that then they go out and believe themselves to be accessibility experts without getting that that education. And go ahead, Josh.
Josh Miele (34:49.021)
Exactly.
Josh Miele (34:55.217)
well, no, exactly. And I'm sorry, I just I jump in, but I mean the the I've I realize that, you know, I've been I've framed this in sort of like this is what's wrong with hackathons, but hackathons are really cool, like they're amazing opportunities for learning. And and it is I think they're great. I I've run many hackathons and I have learned a great deal about how to how to set up a hackathon that is
That is ethical, that does help people learn the right lessons, that does sort of create new concepts in accessible technologies or build tools that people really, people with disabilities really, really can benefit from. And and this is this is what the chapter is is really about. It's not it's not just a critique of what we've got, but but a a set of signposts for moving forward and how to use the disability ethics.
framework that Laney and her co-editors propose for for really leveraging the amazing opportunities of you know hands-on learning and project-based learning such as hackathons and capstone projects for for the the real effective learning and building of accessibility and disability knowledge for the for the the tech the the tech
Builders of the future, the students that are participating.
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (36:24.181)
Yeah, absolutely. I I left reading that chapter feeling very helpful actually and I I wasn't expecting that for a hackathon chapter. But the like I said earlier, like the way you flipped it on its head of like, okay, these are these are statistically more harmful now. What if they were actually incredibly helpful and I could just see how empowering that would be for students to get that on-the-ground learning.
And then for an actual product or technology to then go out into the world, like that would be very
hopeful and amazing to see hackathons more like that in a in a regular a regular way.
Josh Miele (37:09.973)
Yeah, great. Thank you.
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (37:11.935)
Yeah. so I know we we have about 15 minutes left. so I did want to open it up to the audience. So if you guys have any questions who are watching the live podcast, definitely put them in the chat and we will make sure to cover them. I think, you know, Lainey, I I would love to kind of get back to the the law part of it, because what I did really appreciate about the entire book is
That balance of kind of the world as it is, knowing, you know, law can be an effective tool, but also the, like I said, the rehumanizing piece of it. Like how do we bring digital accessibility down to make it feel more like an on the ground daily type of task versus something that feels really out of reach for a lot of organizations?
so in the in your chapter you talked about law is the salt and the accessibility cookie. Can you explain that a little bit?
Lainey Feingold (38:18.938)
yeah, thanks for asking about that. I do have an article on my website called Accessibility is Delicious, where I collect food analogies or metaphors, not quite sure which is a correct word, about accessibility. And I depend on the community to send me those things. And I have a lot of them from a lot of people. One of them is the laws of salt in the cookie. And the idea there is that
If you're a baker, you know that a little bit of salt makes the sweetness of a cookie pop. But if you have no salt, you have a bad cookie. And I just did a talk in Iceland because they got their first digital accessibility law. And it was this sort of welcoming event, like, congratulations, and like what's next? Like, how are you gonna get this law implemented?
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (38:59.457)
Yeah.
Lainey Feingold (39:15.892)
And one of the organizers wanted the salt as a law and the cookie in the title of the talk, which meant I had to do research about what kind of cookies do they have in Iceland and do they actually use salt. And I was very happy to discover, yes, they do. And if they don't, they use salted butter. So, you know, it gets back to legal compliance isn't enough. And that's not just an idea that Josh and I have. It's we have had laws.
about digital accessibility, web accessibility for 30 years now. And it's growing and it's good. You know, I do a lot of talks around the world. People in countries that don't have the laws yet, they want the laws. And we need the laws.
Africa in Kenya just got their first accessibility standard in twenty twenty two and they're working to expand that across the African continent. And in the book, in I there's two legal chapters, one kind of a legal overview, one about we cannot have access to justice if there is no digital accessibility. Every aspect of access to justice, there's there's so much law stuff that happens online.
People do their mediations. Courts are starting to have online, you know, this online courts all over the world. So we want the law, we need the law, but too much law makes too much law is like too much salt, makes for bad
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (40:36.543)
Yeah.
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (40:46.805)
Yeah, I love that. As as a baker that that warmed my heart. 'cause I I know what that's like when you do not add salt. It does not taste good.
Lainey Feingold (40:57.41)
Well, it's funny because I live by the cheese board for those of you who are local and once I had a scone there and I said, This scone is like really bad and I asked the people, I said, I think you made a mistake. I think you forgot the sugar and they went back that, no, we forgot the salt. And we had sugar, but somehow it just the whole thing didn't work without the salt. So
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (41:18.399)
Yeah, it's it's magic. okay, so we've got some really great questions from the audience. Before I share them, I did want to to just note that the reason we're having this podcast today is because we are promoting an event that is gonna be on December third. so we're doing this in partnership with UC Berkeley's Disability Cultural Community Center. they will be hosting
some of the authors including Laney at we're we're unsure exactly the location just yet but it will be December 3rd 5 to 7 p.m on the UC Berkeley campus and there'll also be a zoom option. for those that are in the on the live I will share the RSVP link so if you do want to join for that we'll be digging into even more
fun conversations about this book. but let's get into some of the questions. so Josh we are Josh I didn't even know that. Josh, I'm so excited.
Lainey Feingold (42:23.495)
And Josh will be there too. You'd mention Josh. Yeah, Josh.
Josh Miele (42:29.889)
Yeah, no, that'll that'll I'm looking forward to it.
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (42:33.055)
Awesome. Josh, we do have a question for you. so it asks, Josh, you emphasize the importance of including accessibility experts in the design process from the beginning. How have you seen people do that successfully when they are the when there are no experts on the team?
Josh Miele (42:54.155)
Well, the first question I'll ask you is why are there no experts on the team? I think one of the most you know in designing hackathons, one of the you know, accessibility sorry, accessible accessibility hackathons, the the first thing to do is to make sure that people with disabilities are participants. and so
same thing with capstone projects. if if a team wants to do something effective in a disability and accessibility space, the first thing to try to do is to have people on the team who understand that space, understand that problem from a lived experience perspective. so that's that's number one. But let's say that didn't happen and you don't you know, you can't always you know, create
create that opportunity. But institutions should look out to try to make sure that you know, if I'm an engineering
department and I don't have any students with disabilities in my program and I am trying to run an effective accessibility hackathon, that's that's an issue for me as an institution, right? so but for on the team level, there are you know there are experts everywhere.
if you don't have if you don't if you have so if you are a team that doesn't have any accessibility or disability expertise, the first question is what what do you think as a as a team you really can be effective at working on? And maybe maybe somebody, maybe some people on the team do have some real knowledge of areas where
where they they can learn, you know, learn more or or contribute. But but you need to find a mentor who can help you even choose an appropriate question to hack on. So so finding a mentor if if you've identified a space that you already think you want to work on, do a little Googling, see if you can find somebody to advise you, the right person to advise you on the area that you've chosen.
Josh Miele (45:18.015)
If you've got a little extra time, like if it's a capstone project as opposed to a hackathon, then you you have the bandwidth and the ability to reach out to local organizations that are you know organizations supporting or of people with disabilities that are related to the the thing that you think you want to hack on. and don't just go to them at the end, go to them at the beginning.
and make sure they have input into the you know, give you feedback on the problem you are trying to solve, not just on the solution you have proposed. Because very often the the most important feedback comes in helping you identify an actual problem rather than what non-disabled people or people without lived experience imagine the problems to be so so yeah those are those are some some
Basic ideas.
Lainey Feingold (46:17.288)
one thing I'll add to that is totally agree with what you said, and the beginning can be more than the beginning of the hackathon. So awareness in education is in ethics value. And if you don't on your team and your community and your workplace, if you don't have involvement with disabled people, there are NGOs, there are nonprofits, you can invite people.
Always pay people, but you can invite people for casual, informal, I'd like to know better what you do. So then when it comes to starting the capstone or the hackathon, you know, here's an organization that works with blind people in my area or knows about cognitive accessibility issues. So I mean, yes, you can Google the only word of caution is the paid ads for accessibility are one, very expensive, and two, are always at the top.
And people don't always notice that. So maybe the first place they go is actually not that ethical a company. But
Josh Miele (47:22.859)
Yeah. And I think sorry, Laney.
Lainey Feingold (47:26.094)
Well, I was just gonna say, but like you could have student groups, you know, campuses have disability like disability community culture center who's sponsoring this
program on December third, which we're so grateful for. There's lots of ways to get in relationship with disabled people and hopefully it will lead to permanent employment so people are on the teams, but when you have a project coming up and you need someone, you won't be starting from total scratch.
Josh Miele (47:55.029)
I also want to mention you you mentioned organizations, Lainey, and one of the one of the organizations that I think very highly of is called Teach Access. and their mission is really to get more more classroom experience and knowledge of disability and accessibility into the you know the the college curriculum. And so teachaccess.org is a great place if you are
You know, if you are looking for ways to learn about accessibility and disability, and you're you know a college student or a a faculty or staff who who runs college and university programs, then teachaccess.org is an amazing resource. So many
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (49:04.439)
Amazing. and then the we have one last question which I think kind of dovetails really perfectly into both of y'all's responses, which is why is accessibility considered an extra or bonus when we all accommodate ourselves all the time?
Lainey Feingold (49:26.328)
You know, I love that question. I should say I'm on the board of Teach Access, so it really it's sorry that I didn't say, Yeah, Teach Access is a great resource. So thank you, Josh, for that. I believe in the word assistive technology, I think it's really important, but I read an article by Sarah Hendron who has a book called What Can a Body Do? And she wrote an article before she wrote that book, All Technology is assistive technology. And it
It really just shifted my whole perspective. I use a regular keyboard. Some people only have one hand, they use a half keyboard. The half keyboard call is called an accommodation, but the the full keyboard is just business as usual. And part of this is that disability is not front and center in people's minds. So there is no good there's no good answer. I think people are afraid.
afraid of disability. I think they don't understand it. They're afraid of themselves becoming disabled and they're scared of it. They don't know. I mean, I don't know, Josh, what do you think?
Lainey Feingold (53:30.838)
Yeah, and I I'll just I'll just end with saying and that's why ethics can be helpful, because people need to understand these are ethics issues. This is not just a technology issue, not just a legal issue. This is an ethics issue. And if you talk to people, which as a lawyer, I didn't do lawsuits, I did collaborations with big companies, and I'm here to tell you that when you big companies, the biggest companies in the country I did deals with.
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (53:53.639)
Mm-hmm.
Lainey Feingold (54:00.984)
Why? Because they met disabled people and they understood the issues. So yeah, we have a definition of ableism right at the beginning of the book because that is that is what it's all about. And we gotta get familiar and comfortable with saying these are ethics. And these are values of the Tim values in the book, they're values we all hold. So thank you, Sam. It was really fun to chat with you.
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (54:28.309)
Yes, I I really appreciate that. I'm like, we're we're we're launching a new podcast just as we're wrapping it up because we could keep going and going. I have so many more questions, but I am beyond grateful that Laney Feingold and Josh Miele were big able to join us today. if you have not picked up the book, it is Digital Accessibility Ethics. We will share all of the links in the show notes. And I think Laney, we might have a dis
Lainey Feingold (54:59.564)
Yes. If I haven't sent you that I will as soon as we hang up.
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (55:03.701)
Yeah, so if you are listening to the podcast, we will have a discount link for you to buy the book. if you would like to join us in person or online, we will be hosting an event on December 3rd, 5 to 7 p.m. Pacific Standard Time with the UC Berkeley Disability Cultural Community Center. we will announce when that where that location is, but it will be on the UC Berkeley campus, and we'll also have a Zoom.
and so of course all of that will be in the show notes.
Lainey Feingold (55:38.188)
And Sam, I'll just throw in we do have a website for the book which is accessibilityethics dot org and we're building resources, we have media, we have events, so you can check that out too.
Sam Chavez (he/they/she) (55:50.805)
Yeah, it's a great it's a great website. There's a lot of good resources on you can see all of the amazing co-authors, some really amazing experts on there, so definitely recommend you check that out. and with that I hope everyone stays rooted and we will see you again on another podcast. So thank you all for joining the Roots of Change podcast.
Lainey Feingold (56:16.024)
Thank you.