ТРАНСКРИПЦИЯ 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: Right now, it's time to talk some college football with Chip Patterson of CBSSports.com, CBS Sports Network, and the Cover 3 pod. He is with us on the FNZ Hotline. What's up, brother? How are you?
00:00:10
Speaker 2: I'm doing well. It's a fine time to be talking about college football, so good to be back with you doing it here on a Friday. No doubt.
00:00:16
Speaker 1: Do you feel like college football is healthy and in a good place right now? Ooh.
00:00:23
Speaker 2: College football is as fun as I can imagine it ever being. The health of the sport all depends on your purview. If the health of the sport is dictated by television ratings, things are good. If health of the sport is dictated by the mental well-being of our coaches, things are bad. If the health is dictated by the ability of players to capitalize on their talents, things are amazing. We're constantly dealing with the growing pains and making changes that were probably a little bit overdue. Kyle, I don't know if you've ever done this before, but have you ever let the honey-do list get too long and then you just get a real painful weekend to get it taken care of? Unfortunately for college football, it's probably going to take about three, four years But essentially what we're going through is knocking out the honeydew list because the game was built on a different economic reality because the way college football existed as a regional, not billion-dollar industry back in the 1990s and early 2000s, Simply is not the product that is negotiating with ESPN for a 2014 playoff and the money that would come with it.
00:01:34
Speaker 3: So I think that what we.
00:01:36
Speaker 2: Are doing is we are just upgrading our operating systems and it's painful and it's not going well for everybody. But I have confidence that we will eventually land. in a more tenable place for the coaches and hopefully still a sensible place for the players. But I'll come back to this. TV ratings are good. Fans love this stuff. I have a hard time saying that college football is in a bad place when so many people seem to enjoy the experience of watching on a Saturday.
00:02:03
Speaker 1: Okay, fair enough. The rankings came out earlier this week. Before I even ask you about the rankings themselves, what are your thoughts on both Kurt Cignetti and Kirk Ferentz this week going right at ESPN? for clearly perceived bias and the way they're covering this sport?
00:02:19
Speaker 2: Oh, I don't think that they would have even necessarily intended it as explicitly or viciously. I think they're participating in the conversation just like Steve Sarkeesian was when he was pre-explaining losses at SEC Media Day, right? If Texas' head football coach.
00:02:36
Speaker 3: who's sitting there with a national title contender, is.
00:02:39
Speaker 2: Already laying the groundwork for the argument for why the Longhorns should make it 9-3. I mean, I think I said at the time I thought that was a loser's mentality. But, hey, it might pay off because Texas might be on the cut line at 9-3. And thanks to politics, and it goes back to July, everybody's thinking about the Longhorns just a little bit differently. So look, I think they are just participating in the conversation. It's always been a part of it. We had split national championships. We had all kinds of people yelling about one play. They could have decided this or that throughout college football's history. I don't see a law. How about this? Kyle, I've seen a lot of lawsuits in college football over the last three, four years until I see coaches filing legal action against a media rights company. I'm still going to think they're just participating in the convo just like anybody else is. Okay.
00:03:29
Speaker 1: Did you have any real issue with what the committee did in those initial rankings a couple of nights ago?
00:03:36
Speaker 2: I think it exposed the way that the selection process has become a little overwrought. I think it's become a little bit too complicated. I think that with good intentions, the college football playoffs built the selection committee and the selection process to try to remove any bias. And they put in so many layers of bureaucracy within the process of what happens in that room that they... As a committee member, I think they can truly walk in and walk out feeling like I did not have any agenda. I just answered the small questions I was told to. And essentially what they're told to do is answer probably 150 small comparative questions over and over again.
00:04:17
Speaker 3: But to go through this, and really what.
00:04:19
Speaker 2: I'm talking about, for those who might not be aware, is the pod voting system.
00:04:23
Speaker 3: This was exposed last.
00:04:24
Speaker 2: Year when Notre Dame was ranked way ahead of Miami in the first committee rankings. And slowly but surely, as Miami rose, starting all the way down at number 18 in the committee's first ranking, getting closer and closer to that top 10 ranking, there were questions about Miami and Notre Dame. Why is Notre Dame so far ahead when Miami had the head-to-head win? And the committee kept explaining to fans that they just weren't close enough to be comparable for the head-to-head result to matter until the very final selection day. And that's because of this voting method where they just look at these little pods and head-to-head doesn't matter until teams are literally on the same screen together. And they tried to build in all of this complication so that no one can have any crooked, rigidness And I think what they've done is they've lost sensibility. I think that a selection committee should be able to use common sense and understand that if Tennessee didn't just beat Alabama, but beat them 26 to 10, there should not be that much difference between those two teams when they have an identical record.
00:05:29
Speaker 4: And while Ohio state does have one more loss than Indiana, Ohio state is you know, they
Load full transcript
do have a win against Indiana in Bloomington.
00:05:41
Speaker 2: And yet they find themselves eight spots behind the Hoosiers as well. And I see why it happens. Alabama gets bumped up.
00:05:48
Speaker 3: Because they're in with Kentucky, Kentucky.
00:05:51
Speaker 2: They're at number six, Alabama at number five.
00:05:53
Speaker 3: So I can say I take.
00:05:54
Speaker 2: Issue with Alabama at number five, for example, Kyle, but I'm trying to cut deeper than this because I'm telling you, we have made the process too complicated for the selection committee, and that's why it spits out these top 25s that just don't make sense. I think we should either trust the selection committee more to be able to not need this overcomplicated process, or... or forget the selection committee and let's go back to ones and zeros and build a BCS formula and we'll seed it from there because we're trying to do like half metrics, Half not metrics, half computers, half humans, and it's just leading to a complex final result. As we eye other changes that could be coming to the postseason, I surely hope that this process is revealed as well because it makes for great television. It makes for great radio because we find individual examples that don't make sense. But I'm telling you, Kyle, the reason they don't make sense is because they've made it too complicated with the good intentions of not being biased. But it's left them with the results that leave a lower, lower level of faith in the selection committee altogether.
00:07:01
Speaker 1: Chip Patterson, CBSSports.com, CBS Sports Network with us on the FNZ Hotline. Before I get to tomorrow, Virginia Tech SMU tonight, 7 o'clock ESPN, Gerald J. Ford Stadium down in Dallas, Texas. Both teams, 6-2. What are we thinking about this one? Because I'd still think the odds are long that either one of these teams ends up in the ACC title game, but the winner of tonight is still going to be in it while the loser, not so much.
00:07:26
Speaker 5: Oh, what a fun game between two untrustworthy teams. I have so much excitement to see who blows their big toe off with a shotgun on this hunting trip.
00:07:39
Speaker 2: I mean, this is just... Two teams with talent that have an unbelievable ability to come up with negative plays at the worst time or Virginia tech defensive breakdowns in the second half to, to see the way that Kevin Jennings, with all of his experience, still has really struggled with some costly turnovers and mistakes throughout this season. And yet all of it that we're sitting here, SMU, if they can beat Virginia tech, they can beat wake forest. shoot, they might be in Charlotte. I just don't trust them to do that.
00:08:12
Speaker 3: I have no idea who's going to end.
00:08:13
Speaker 2: Up winning this game, but both again, both teams have good quarterbacks. Both teams have talented offenses that can go out there and be really productive, but man, it has just been so many mistakes, blown leads while drives that have
been ruined by costly penalties. It's just two teams that are just not real buttoned up around the edges. But a lot of fun for me, Kyle.
00:08:37
Speaker 3: How are you feeling about the Hokies in this one?
00:08:39
Speaker 1: Well, honestly, as a man who not that long ago temporarily lost my big toe, that analogy hurts figuratively and literally that you made a minute ago. No, it's fine.
00:08:48
Speaker 2: It's fine.
00:08:49
Speaker 1: I won't take it personally. I'm nervous, but I'm also going to be on TV tonight doing a high school football game. So I'm just going to be checking the score. So in some way, I get to cop out and not really have to emotionally invest tonight, Chip.
00:09:00
Speaker 2: Yeah, exactly. Because it's a little bit of a house money situation for you because you don't have to watch with your eyes. The 17 point lead melt away slowly.
00:09:09
Speaker 3: Right.
00:09:10
Speaker 1: All right, moving on, because I'm already getting nervous and anxious about this. Miami-Notre Dame tomorrow night in primetime. Malachi Toney's going to be out, it seems like, for the next couple of weeks. I mean, Miami's still 8-0. They still have Mensah and Cooper Barcate and Mark Fletcher and Mallory. There's still a ton of talent out there. But this game's at Notre Dame Stadium, and Miami is a full seven-point underdog in this game. Should they be?
00:09:31
Speaker 2: Yeah, I don't, I think that this is a, and it got out to seven and a half, right? And even eight when the Malachi Tony stuff is really freaking out. So does the market. And I think that the issues for Miami against Notre Dame is how they were existing before the Malachi Tony entry. They're existing after the Malachi Tony entry and the issues for Miami against Notre Dame is they've got a past defense that has kind of been picked apart by Gio Lopez and by Bill Edwards. And I don't know if you knew this Kyle, but CJ car is projected to be selected higher in the NFL draft than Gio Lopez or Billy Edwards. And I liked, I liked Gio Lopez and Billy Edwards. I think this is a really good opportunity for Mike Denbrock, the offensive coordinator at Notre Dame, for C.J. Carr, who's in his second full year as a starter, and hasn't seen this Miami defense since the very first start of his college career all the way back in week one of last season. Reuben Bain ain't out there. Akeem Messidor ain't out there. I think that this is going to be a spot where C.J. Carr can have a lot of success. but I'm not ready to count out the canes. I still think that you've got Darien Mensah to your point, you know, bar Kate Mallory, you still got players out.
00:10:46
Speaker 3: There that can be able to, to maybe take advantage of a.
00:10:49
Speaker 2: Banged up Notre Dame defense that is missing some of its best players as well. I think it's going to be an awesome, awesome game. And I kind of think that if it's higher scoring, I'd give Miami a chance to go out there and pull out the outright upset. If Notre Dame can get the ground game going, I mean, go talk to the Tar Heels, right? North Carolina is a common opponent that played both Notre Dame and Miami, played both those teams competitively.
00:11:12
Speaker 3: What was the.
00:11:13
Speaker 2: One thing that really broke for the Tar Heels was when the Fighting Irish were running the ball in the rain all through that third quarter, just basically playing keep away after that kickoff return touchdown. Notre Dame would like to do that. you know, Notre Dame would like to be able to just possess this ball, limit the number of times Darien Mensah touches it, have CJ Carr hit a couple of explosive plays to make Miami, you know, a little bit panicky about how many defenders they can commit to stopping the run. But I am, I am definitely not going to count out Miami because If there's a year where Marcus Freeman can log a big win, boy, this one feels almost too easy. Doesn't it? Malakai, Tony going out, Freeman's going to have a lot of expectations from the Notre Dame fans to be able to win this. This goes from a coin flip all of a sudden to a, you need to win. And mentally that's a very different position for the home favorites to be for sure.
00:12:07
Speaker 1: Nc state won their first game post dave doran last week and now they're at home hosting duke tomorrow 12 30 on the cw our boy west bryant's going to be on the sideline on the cw but duke six and two states uh they're feeling good right now but duke's a four-point favorite here i expect them to win do you yes.
00:12:26
Speaker 2: I do i expect duke to win right correct yes yeah i i expect you to win this is um I am happy for the players on the NC state team that they were able to have a day that did look like, you know, you were out there in Carter Finley, scoring a touchdown early, pulling away late, just kind of like a good rhythm.
00:12:45
Speaker 3: It was Halloween, right?
00:12:46
Speaker 2: So my neighbors went to the game, came back. I saw him in the street later that day. And they, you know, they all said like, Hey, it was good. It was good to get in that stadium, get a win, be able to cheer, score touchdowns. Woo.
00:12:58
Speaker 3: Yay.
00:12:59
Speaker 2: But it is a team that, has mostly seen its preseason goals lost while Duke has the potential to really keep stringing this thing together and have another, you know, high wind count at the end of the season, which has basically become the new standard under first under Mike Elko and now under Manny Diaz.
00:13:17
Speaker 3: So they're a little bit more buttoned up.
00:13:19
Speaker 2: They're a little bit healthier as NC state has been dealing with health issues basically now for the last month.
00:13:24
Speaker 4: Yes.
00:13:24
Speaker 2: My expectation is that the blue devils win. And also, and I wanted to include this very, very last week, because I do think it was important for the health of the NC state fan base to get in there and have that win. Cal is an absolute mess. I mean, just a real dumpster fire right now. Our good, our good friend, Ron Rivera has got his hands full trying to help his first year head coach sort Get the screws tightened in because there has not been a lot of boxes.
00:13:49
Speaker 3: That have been checked.
00:13:51
Speaker 2: I know that they have wins. I've seen them win football games, Kyle. So have you. But the product and the quality of play from that team over the course of this season has really been disappointing.
00:14:01
Speaker 1: Chip Patterson, CBSSports.com, CBS Sports Network, and the Cover 3 podcast with us every Friday here on the show. Enjoy these games, brother. We'll talk to you next week.
00:14:11
Speaker 2: Sounds good.
00:14:11
Speaker 1: Y'all be well.